Wesley Snipes Cleared of Serious Tax Charges - New York Times http://www.nytimes.com/2008/02/02/business/02tax.html?_r=1&hp&ore...

1 of 3 2/3/2008 11:46 AM

SIGN IN TO E-MAILOR SAVE THIS

PRINT

SINGLE PAGE

REPRINTS

SHARE

RelatedLede Blog: In His Words - Wesley Snipes on Not Paying Taxes

Full Text of Anti-Tax Statement(pdf)

Text of Indictment

Wesley Snipes Cleared of Serious Tax ChargesBy DAVID CAY JOHNSTONPublished: February 2, 2008

OCALA, Fla. — A federal jury returned a mixed verdict against the

actor Wesley Snipes on Friday, acquitting him of the most serious tax

charges he faced, but convicting him on three of six lesser charges. The

case was the most prominent tax prosecution since the billionaire

hotelier Leona Helmsley was convicted of tax fraud in 1989.

Mr. Snipes, who has built a worldwide following acting in

films like the “Blade” vampire trilogy, must pay up to $17

million in back taxes plus penalties and interest.

He had become an unlikely public face for the tax denier

movement, whose members maintain that Americans are

not obligated to pay income taxes and that the government

extracts taxes from its citizens illegally.

The jury found Mr. Snipes not guilty on two felony charges of fraud and conspiracy. He

was also acquitted on three misdemeanor charges of failing to file tax returns or to pay

taxes from 2002 to 2004. But the jury found him guilty of failing to file returns or pay

taxes from 1999 through 2001. He faces up to three years in prison. If convicted of the

felonies, he would have faced up to 16 years.

JJ MacNab, a Maryland insurance analyst who attended the trial and is writing a book

about tax deniers, said “the verdict shows that promoters face serious jail time” but clients

who follow their advice will face a lesser but still serious risk of imprisonment.

Mr. Snipes’s two co-defendants — Eddie Ray Kahn, a promoter of tax denial, and Douglas

Rosile, a former accountant — were convicted on the fraud and conspiracy charges.

It was the fourth major case in which the Justice Department failed to win convictions in

cases against prominent tax deniers. The verdict drew whoops of joy outside the federal

courthouse here from fellow tax deniers who immediately proclaimed it another victory

that would draw more people to their cause.

The courts have declared the tax denier arguments are frivolous. Even Mr. Snipes’s

Next Article in Business (2 of

MOST POPULAR - BUSINESS

Go to Complete List »

China’s Inflation Hits Am1.

Exxon Mobil Profit Sets R2.

U.S. Economy Unexpecte3.

Wesley Snipes Is Acquitte4.

Small Law Firm’s Big Rol5.

Microsoft Bids $44.6 Bill6.

Starbucks to Close Stores7.

Age of Riches : At Elite PEndowments

8.

Financial Ties Are Cited a9.

Lilly Considers $1 Billion10.

Business All NYTBusinessWORLD U.S. N.Y. / REGION BUSINESS TECHNOLOGY SCIENCE HEALTH SPORTS OPINION ARTS STYLE TRAVEL J

MEDIA & ADVERTISING WORLD BUSINESS SMALL BUSINESS YOUR MONEY DEALBOOK MARKETS RESEARCH MUTUAL FUNDS

BLOGGEDE-MAILED

HOME PAGE MY TIMES TODAY'S PAPER VIDEO MOST POPULAR TIMES TOPICS Get Home

Sign up for finance news, sent beforSamplejames@omega-gold.com Change E-mail Address | Privacy

Get DealBook by E-Mail

Wesley Snipes Cleared of Serious Tax Charges - New York Times http://www.nytimes.com/2008/02/02/business/02tax.html?_r=1&hp&ore...

2 of 3 2/3/2008 11:46 AM

Next Article in Business (2 of 22) »

defense lawyers, who called the denier claims “dead wrong” in their closing arguments to

the jury, reiterated that statement after the verdict.

Mr. Snipes will pay all of his income taxes plus penalties and interest, said Robert E.

Barnes and Robert G. Bernhoft, who defended him.

“He will make full amends and pay everything,” Mr. Barnes said.

Mr. Bernhoft said Congress should repeal criminal tax laws and treat tax evasion as a civil

matter.

Robert E. O’Neill, the United States attorney here, said current law “is entirely subjective”

on criminal intent because juries must decide whether a defendant “sincerely believes” he

was not required to pay taxes.

The Justice Department has told Congress there is no need to revise the tax laws on intent.

But when Mr. O’Neill was asked whether the laws should be changed, he said,

“Absolutely.”

The defense, prosecution and Ms. MacNab all said the verdict showed that the jury

recognized the promoters as criminals and saw Mr. Snipes as their victim. They also

agreed that the reason the jury acquitted Mr. Snipes of not filing his tax returns in 2002

through 2004 was because he had been told he was the target of a criminal investigation

and jurors believed that he was exercising his right to remain silent. The jury convicted

him of failing to file his tax returns before he knew was a suspect.

Even as Congress has reduced income tax rates, the tax denier movement has spread,

fueled by high payroll taxes, political attacks on the Internal Revenue Service and anger

among people who have not benefited from strong overall economic growth.

Instead of prosecuting all offenders, the Justice Department brings cases against

well-known individuals, hoping that widespread news coverage will encourage

compliance, a policy known as general deterrence. The Snipes prosecution, like the three

earlier cases that resulted in full acquittals, appears to have backfired.

The Justice Department has for months declined requests to provide an official who would

discuss its tax prosecution policies on the record.

Tax deniers assert variously that the tax laws are valid but do not apply to them, that no

law makes anyone liable for taxes and that the government tricks people into paying.

Promoters of tax denial claim that people can legally stop paying income taxes by

executing certain documents, or by not signing others, like tax returns. Courts have

rejected all these arguments.

NEXT PAGE »

Donate to the Neediest Cases today!

Ads by Google what's this?

Full coverage of theAlso in Movies:

Photos of the nomineesWho should have been nominWhich movies will win this yea

ADVERTISEMENTS

Gershwin RBuy Now

Tips to run a successfuAlso in Business:

Getting paid, one way or anotHow to promote your businessFind new ways of custom-blen

All the news that's fit to personali

1 2

Wesley Snipes Cleared of Serious Tax Charges - New York Times http://www.nytimes.com/2008/02/02/business/02tax.html?_r=1&hp&ore...

3 of 3 2/3/2008 11:46 AM

Taxation Add AlertSnipes, Wesley Add AlertDecisions and Verdicts Add AlertFederal Taxes (US) Add Alert

Related Searches

Assault Family Violence?Experienced Former Prosecutors Knowledgeable, Discreet, Dedicatedwww.HinesRancHolub.com

10 Rules Losing Belly FatI Struggled for Years to Lose Belly Fat, Until I Found These 10 Rules.www.FatLoss4Idiots.com

Jaw Dropping Free VideosBe Afraid, Or Be Amused. Watch Free Instantly!BizarreByFar.com/AmazingVideo

TipsTo find reference information about the words used in this article, double-click on any word, phrase or name. Anew window will open with a dictionary definition or encyclopedia entry.

Past CoverageWesley Snipes To Go on Trial In Tax Case (January 14, 2008)Actor Pleads Not Guilty in Tax Fraud Case (December 9, 2006)No Deal Made With ActorIn Tax Case, Prosecutors Say (November 7, 2006)Arts, Briefly (October 21, 2006)

INSIDE NYTIMES.COM

ART & DESIGN » ESCAPES » ART & DESIGN » OPINION » ARTS »

Artistic Muscle, Flexed for Medicis

Winter, and Not a Ski on the Course.

Cradle for Serious Grooving Latest Twist in Comics:Captain America’s Back

Home World U.S. N.Y. / Region Business Technology Science Health Sports Opinion Arts Style Travel Jobs Real Esta

Copyright 2008 The New York Times Company Privacy Policy Search Corrections RSS First Look Help Contact Us Wor

Business & FinancialServices »

Computer»

Food & Beverage » FranchiseManufactu

Health & Beauty » Miscellane

Professional Services » Retail & SBusinesse

Travel & Real Estate » In partners

Browse Local Business ServicesFind businesses near you on The New York TServices Directory.

Wesley Snipes Cleared of Serious Tax Charges - New York Times http://www.nytimes.com/2008/02/02/business/02tax.html?pagewanted...

1 of 3 2/3/2008 11:47 AM

E-MAIL

PRINT

SINGLE PAGE

REPRINTS

SAVE

SHARE

RelatedLede Blog: In His Words - Wesley Snipes on Not Paying Taxes

Full Text of Anti-Tax Statement(pdf)

Text of Indictment

Wesley Snipes Cleared of Serious Tax ChargesPublished: February 2, 2008

(Page 2 of 2)

Mr. Snipes, 45, was indicted in October 2006 for filing a false claim

for a $7 million refund (of taxes paid in 1997, before he stoped paying

taxes), and conspiracy with his two co-defendants to defraud the

government through that claim, which was not paid.

Since 1986, Mr. Snipes has appeared in

more than 50 films, earning at least $103 million, court

papers showed, including more than $58 million in the

years covered by the indictment, 1999 through 2004.

Mr. Snipes has built a huge following, especially overseas,

with his portrayals of intrepid detectives and fearless

vampire slayers and his occasional comedic roles. In

addition to the “Blade” series, he starred in movies like the action film “Drop Zone,” the

political intrigue “The Art of War,” and, with Sean Connery, the corporate crime thriller

“Rising Sun.”

The defense rested on Monday without calling any witnesses. Mr. Snipes declined to

answer questions outside the courthouse on Friday, where a gaggle of reporters was

surrounded by dozens of fans from this central Florida city.

In closing arguments on Tuesday, lawyers for Mr. Snipes sought to portray him as a

well-intended victim of bad advice by his co-defendants. They called his tax theories

“kooky” and “crazy,” but said acting on these views did not make him a criminal because

he disclosed his actions.

The Supreme Court has ruled that tax deniers can demonstrate the absence of criminal

intent by asserting that they “sincerely believe” that they are not required to pay taxes,

although they cannot escape the levies.

Prosecutors argued that Mr. Snipes showed criminal intent when he sent the government

three bogus checks to pay $14 million in taxes and an amended tax return that was subtly

altered with software to insert the word “no” before “penalty of perjury.”

More Articles in Business »

MOST POPULAR - BUSINESS

Go to Complete List »

Unboxed: Eureka! It Rea1.

Progress Toward Ending 2.

Novelties: An Online Orgthe Dots

3.

A.I.G. Chief Can’t Stop Lo4.

Your Money: If It’s Tuesd5.

Massachusetts Accuses M6.

Wesley Snipes Cleared of7.

China’s Inflation Hits Am8.

Fair Game: Lenders Who9.

First Job Losses in 4 Year10.

Business All NYTBusinessWORLD U.S. N.Y. / REGION BUSINESS TECHNOLOGY SCIENCE HEALTH SPORTS OPINION ARTS STYLE TRAVEL J

MEDIA & ADVERTISING WORLD BUSINESS SMALL BUSINESS YOUR MONEY DEALBOOK MARKETS RESEARCH MUTUAL FUNDS

BLOGGEDE-MAILED

HOME PAGE MY TIMES TODAY'S PAPER VIDEO MOST POPULAR TIMES TOPICS My Account Welcom

Sign up for finance news, sent beforSamplejames@omega-gold.com Change E-mail Address | Privacy

Get DealBook by E-Mail

Wesley Snipes Cleared of Serious Tax Charges - New York Times http://www.nytimes.com/2008/02/02/business/02tax.html?pagewanted...

2 of 3 2/3/2008 11:47 AM

More Articles in Business »

Defense lawyers said Mr. Snipes did not file tax returns after his indictment because the

I.R.S., by making him the target of a criminal investigation, “forced” him to exercise his

right to remain silent.

After his indictment, however, Mr. Snipes sent the government a series of rambling letters

describing his tax theories and warning that “pursuit of such a high-profile target will

open the door to your increased collateral risk.”

Mr. O’Neill, the lead prosecutor, called the filings “gibberish” whose purpose was to thwart

law enforcement.

In one 600-page document, Mr. Snipes said he was legally a “nontaxpayer” and the tax

laws did not apply to him because he was not a resident of the District of Columbia, was

not a federal official and was not engaged in any trade or business, all common tax denier

arguments.

Mr. Snipes also complained that the I.R.S. violated his 14th Amendment rights to equal

protection because it would not help him establish what he said was his rightful status as a

legal nontaxpayer.

Mr. Snipes joined the tax denier movement after becoming upset when told that his 1999

income tax would be more than $2 million, Carmen Baker, his former assistant, testified.

A mutual acquaintance introduced Mr. Snipes to one of his co-defendants, Mr. Kahn. Mr.

Kahn operated a Christian ministry, the Guiding Light of God Ministries, and a central

Florida company called the American Rights Litigators that helped tax deniers avoid

paying.

Mr. Kahn, who was imprisoned for tax crimes in 1985 to 1987, fled to Panama after the

2006 indictment. He was extradited to stand trial on the latest charges but refused to

attend the proceedings, remaining in his jail cell, after telling Judge William T. Hodges

that the court had no authority over him.

Mr. Snipes and Mr. Rosile are free on bail.

« PREVIOUS PAGE

Donate to the Neediest Cases today!

Ads by Google what's this?

Church Background ChecksHave Piece Of Mind And Confidence In Your Volunteers And Leaders.www.ChurchVolunteerCentral.com

Cheap Background ChecksSearch multiple engines at once for cheap background checkswww.webcrawler.com

Private InvestigatorsMCS provides private investigators nationwide. Call today!www.expertsatmcs.com

Tips

How are people finAlso in Jobs:

Recruiting through professionAre you paying your employeeFind great candidates on NYT

ADVERTISEMENTS

On the GreBuy Now

All the news that's fit to personali

1 2

Business & FinancialServices »

Computer»

Food & Beverage » FranchiseManufactu

Health & Beauty » Miscellane

Professional Services » Retail & SBusinesse

Travel & Real Estate » In partners

Browse Local Business ServicesFind businesses near you on The New York TServices Directory.

Wesley Snipes Cleared of Serious Tax Charges - New York Times http://www.nytimes.com/2008/02/02/business/02tax.html?pagewanted...

3 of 3 2/3/2008 11:47 AM

Taxation Add AlertSnipes, Wesley Add AlertDecisions and Verdicts Add AlertFederal Taxes (US) Add Alert

Related Searches

To find reference information about the words used in this article, double-click on any word, phrase or name. Anew window will open with a dictionary definition or encyclopedia entry.

Past CoverageWesley Snipes To Go on Trial In Tax Case (January 14, 2008)Actor Pleads Not Guilty in Tax Fraud Case (December 9, 2006)No Deal Made With ActorIn Tax Case, Prosecutors Say (November 7, 2006)Arts, Briefly (October 21, 2006)

INSIDE NYTIMES.COM

ART & DESIGN » OPINION » THE CITY » OPINION » WEEK IN REVIEW »

The Gray Areas of Jasper Johns

Jimmy Carter and James A. Baker III: Voter ID

His City, Lost and Found The Party Animal Either Plays Well or Fights Well

Home World U.S. N.Y. / Region Business Technology Science Health Sports Opinion Arts Style Travel Jobs Real Esta

Copyright 2008 The New York Times Company Privacy Policy Search Corrections RSS First Look Help Contact Us Wor