Georges Dossot, James H. Miller, Gopu R. Potty, Dept. of Ocean Engineering, URI

20
Georges Dossot, James H. Miller, Gopu R. Potty, Dept. of Ocean Engineering, URI James F. Lynch, Arthur E. Newhall, Ying Tsong Lin, WHOI Mohsen Badiey, University of Delaware Kevin Smith, D. Benjamin Reeder, Naval Postgraduate School 158 th Acoustical Society of America meeting San Antonio, Texas, October 2009 Modeling intensity fluctuations of acoustic transmissions from the R/V Sharp during SW06

description

Modeling intensity fluctuations of acoustic transmissions from the R/V Sharp during SW06. Georges Dossot, James H. Miller, Gopu R. Potty, Dept. of Ocean Engineering, URI James F. Lynch, Arthur E. Newhall, Ying Tsong Lin, WHOI Mohsen Badiey, University of Delaware - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Transcript of Georges Dossot, James H. Miller, Gopu R. Potty, Dept. of Ocean Engineering, URI

Page 1: Georges Dossot, James H. Miller,  Gopu  R. Potty, Dept. of Ocean Engineering, URI

Georges Dossot, James H. Miller, Gopu R. Potty, Dept. of Ocean Engineering, URIJames F. Lynch, Arthur E. Newhall, Ying Tsong Lin, WHOIMohsen Badiey, University of DelawareKevin Smith, D. Benjamin Reeder, Naval Postgraduate School

158th Acoustical Society of America meetingSan Antonio, Texas, October 2009

Modeling intensity fluctuations of acoustic transmissions from the R/V Sharp during SW06

Page 2: Georges Dossot, James H. Miller,  Gopu  R. Potty, Dept. of Ocean Engineering, URI

Outline

SW06 & R/V Sharp• 50+ events• Different locations

Specific internal wave events• Event 44 (past work)• Similar events (new work)

Modeling• Simplified model• Looking forward → Modeling real environment

Page 3: Georges Dossot, James H. Miller,  Gopu  R. Potty, Dept. of Ocean Engineering, URI

SW06 Test Site & R/V Sharp Locations

-73.35 -73.3 -73.25 -73.2 -73.15 -73.1 -73.05 -73 -72.95 -72.9 -72.85

39.05

39.1

39.15

39.2

39.25

SHARK

5 km

Longitude (degrees)

Latit

ude

(deg

rees

)SW06 Test Site & R/V Sharp Locations

A1A (4)

B1 (9)B1A (5)

B1B (5)

B5A (2)

C1A (3)C1B (4)

C3 (3)

C5A (4)

C1D (3)60

60

70

70

70

80

80

SW29

SW30SW31

SW32

SW33

SW34

Acoustic Transmission PathsSW06 Acoustic SourcesSHRUsShip PositionsEnvironmental Moorings

R/V Sharp & SW06: • 180 hours of acoustic

transmissions• Various ranges and bearings• 50+ internal wave events

witnessed

Interested in source-receiver path near parallel to approaching internal waves

M. Badiey, B. G. Katsnel’son, J. Lynch, S. Pereselkov, “Frequency dependence and intensity fluctuations due to shallowwater internal waves,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 122, 747-760 (2007)

Page 4: Georges Dossot, James H. Miller,  Gopu  R. Potty, Dept. of Ocean Engineering, URI

Objectives

SHARK Array

Research Vessel

Propagating Internal Wave

B. G. Katsnel’son, J. Lynch, A. V. Tshoidze, “Space-Frequency Distribution of Sound Field Intensity in the Vicinity of the Temperature Front in Shallow Water,” Acoustical Physics 53(5), 611-617 (2007)

Examine intensity fluctuations over time…→ before, during, and after internal wave events

Examine intensity fluctuations over space…→ depth and modal dependence

Statistically characterize intensity fluctuations…

FrequencyfTimetnumberarrivalChirpkNumberModeNorDepthz

),(

),,),||(( ftkNzI

Page 5: Georges Dossot, James H. Miller,  Gopu  R. Potty, Dept. of Ocean Engineering, URI

Intensity Measurements

Integrated Energy:

Temporally Integrated Energy:

Point Observations of Broadband Intensity:

Observations of Point Scintillations:

Point Observations of Peak Intensity:

Observations of Modal Amplitudes:

),,()( kzIddzkI z

),,(),( kzIdkzI

),,( kzI

12

2

I

ISI

)],,([max),( kzIkzIP

A. Fredericks, J. A. Colosi, J. Lynch, C. Chiu, and P. Abbot, “Analysis of multipath scintillation from long range acoustic transmissions on the New England continental slope and shelf,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 117, 1038–1057 (2005)

Duda, T.F., Lynch, J.F., Newhall, A.E., Lixin Wu, Ching-Sang Chiu, “Fluctuation of 400-Hz sound intensity in the 2001 ASIAEX South China Sea experiment,” Oceanic Engineering, IEEE Journal of, 29(4), 1264 – 1279 (2004)

),,( fkNI

Page 6: Georges Dossot, James H. Miller,  Gopu  R. Potty, Dept. of Ocean Engineering, URI

Outline

SW06 & R/V Sharp• 50+ events• Different locations

Specific events• Event 44 (past work)• Similar events (new work)

Modeling• Simplified model• Looking forward → Modeling real environment

Page 7: Georges Dossot, James H. Miller,  Gopu  R. Potty, Dept. of Ocean Engineering, URI

Event 44 “Point” Observations

‘ramping’ before arrival of internal wave

Note warm water bottom intrusion

Page 8: Georges Dossot, James H. Miller,  Gopu  R. Potty, Dept. of Ocean Engineering, URI

0

5

10

I (z,k)

Temporally Integrated Energy - Phone 1, z = 13.5 m

0

100

200

300Phone 1 Distribution

0

5

10

I (z,k)

Temporally Integrated Energy - Phone 4, z = 24.75 m

0

100

200

300Phone 4 Distribution

0

5

10

I (z,k)

Temporally Integrated Energy - Phone 10, z = 47.25 m

0

200

400

600Phone 10 Distribution

03:00 06:00 09:00 12:000

5

10

I (z,k)

Time Transmitted

Temporally Integrated Energy - Phone 14, z = 77.25 m

0

100

200Phone 14 Distribution

Event 44 depth dependance

Depth dependant variability

Page 9: Georges Dossot, James H. Miller,  Gopu  R. Potty, Dept. of Ocean Engineering, URI

Event 46 (new)Trapped sound between solitons?

Page 10: Georges Dossot, James H. Miller,  Gopu  R. Potty, Dept. of Ocean Engineering, URI

Event 47 (new)

Notice quiet conditions both before & after internal wave activity

Page 11: Georges Dossot, James H. Miller,  Gopu  R. Potty, Dept. of Ocean Engineering, URI

200 400 600 8000

2

4

6

8

10

I( ,z,k)

Transmission number

Intensity "Point" Observations

0 2 4 6 80

500

1000

1500Intensity "Point" Observations Distribution

I(,z,k)

Num

ber o

f arr

ival

s

Event 47 (new)Slight ‘ramping’ before arrival of internal wave

Page 12: Georges Dossot, James H. Miller,  Gopu  R. Potty, Dept. of Ocean Engineering, URI

Event 47 (new)

0

5

10

15

I (z,k)

Temporally Integrated Energy - Phone 1, z = 13.5 m

0

100

200

300Phone 1 Distribution

0

5

10

15

I (z,k)

Temporally Integrated Energy - Phone 4, z = 24.75 m

0

100

200

300Phone 4 Distribution

0

5

10

15

I (z,k)

Temporally Integrated Energy - Phone 10, z = 47.25 m

0

100

200

300Phone 10 Distribution

21:00 22:00 23:00 00:000

5

10

15

I (z,k)

Time Transmitted

Temporally Integrated Energy - Phone 14, z = 77.25 m

0

100

200

300Phone 14 Distribution

Lack of warm water intrusion near bottom → less depth dependant variability

Page 13: Georges Dossot, James H. Miller,  Gopu  R. Potty, Dept. of Ocean Engineering, URI

Outline

SW06 & R/V Sharp• 50+ events• Different locations

Specific events• Event 44 (past work)• Similar events (new work)

Modeling• Simplified model• Looking forward → Modeling real environment

Page 14: Georges Dossot, James H. Miller,  Gopu  R. Potty, Dept. of Ocean Engineering, URI

Assumptions: • 5km × 5km × 100m water

column• Flat bottom• Single layer soundspeed

properties for sediment• Source at 75 m depth• Single soliton marches

eastward• Same source-receiver angle

as in Event 44• Virtual VLA 4 km away from

source

Modeling

Using 3D PE model provided by NPS, start with a simple scenario

4 km range slice50 m depth slice

Page 15: Georges Dossot, James H. Miller,  Gopu  R. Potty, Dept. of Ocean Engineering, URI

Modeling

Cross-Range (km)

dept

h (m

) at 4

km R

ange

TL (dB re 1m), soliton 2500 m away

-2 0 2

0

20

40

60

80

100

50

60

70

80

90

100

Cross-Range (km)R

ange

(km

)

TL (dB re 1m), soliton 2500 m away

-2 0 20

1

2

3

4

5 50

60

70

80

90

100

Page 16: Georges Dossot, James H. Miller,  Gopu  R. Potty, Dept. of Ocean Engineering, URI

Modeling

0 5 10 150.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

I( ,z,k)

Transmission number

Intensity "Point" Observations

0.5 1 1.5 2 2.50

20

40

60

80

100Intensity "Point" Observations Distribution

I(,z,k)

Num

ber o

f arr

ival

s

Although not quite as dramatic, the same ramping trend is evident as soliton moves closer. Modeled distribution similar to that of measured data.

Page 17: Georges Dossot, James H. Miller,  Gopu  R. Potty, Dept. of Ocean Engineering, URI

Modeling: Next steps

G. R. Potty, J. H. Miller, P. S. Wilson, J. F. Lynch, A. Newhall, “Geoacoustic inversion using combustive sound source signals,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 124, EL150 (2008)

Y-M Jiang, N. R. Chapman, M. Badiey, “ Quantifying the uncertainty of geoacoustic parameter estimates for the New Jersey shelf by inverting air gun data,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 121, 1879-1894 (2007)

→ Modeling inputs for bathymetry and sediment properties to be taken from data and literature

Page 18: Georges Dossot, James H. Miller,  Gopu  R. Potty, Dept. of Ocean Engineering, URI

Modeling: Next steps→ Creating 3D soundspeed profile requires interpolation from various moorings and sensors and code modification

Page 19: Georges Dossot, James H. Miller,  Gopu  R. Potty, Dept. of Ocean Engineering, URI

Conclusions & Future Work

• Wealth of data from over 50 events across different bearings and ranges

R/V Sharp datasets

• Provide evidence of refraction – and ‘ramping’ of intensity measurements before arrival of IW

• Provide insight into depth dependence of intensity fluctuations associated with (or lack of) warm water bottom intrusions

Events 44, 46, 47

• Simple 3D model shows similar trends to measured data• Next steps to include measured data to better portray actual

environment

Modeling

Page 20: Georges Dossot, James H. Miller,  Gopu  R. Potty, Dept. of Ocean Engineering, URI

Thank you