Geodesign: Challenges in Practice - Esri · GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE “Geodesign is a...
Transcript of Geodesign: Challenges in Practice - Esri · GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE “Geodesign is a...
![Page 1: Geodesign: Challenges in Practice - Esri · GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE “Geodesign is a design and planning method which tightly couples the creation of design proposals with](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022011902/5f0aafbd7e708231d42cd732/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Geodesign: Challenges in PracticeMelissa Alexander
![Page 2: Geodesign: Challenges in Practice - Esri · GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE “Geodesign is a design and planning method which tightly couples the creation of design proposals with](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022011902/5f0aafbd7e708231d42cd732/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE
![Page 3: Geodesign: Challenges in Practice - Esri · GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE “Geodesign is a design and planning method which tightly couples the creation of design proposals with](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022011902/5f0aafbd7e708231d42cd732/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
PROJECTDEFINITION1. Project Initiation2. Project Recon.3. Goals & Objectives4. Stakeholders5. Issues of Concern
Typical Geodesign Process
CONDITIONASSESSMENT9. Analyze Issues10. Suitabilities & Vulnerabilities11. Opportunities & Constraints
DATAMANAGEMENT6. Data Requirements7. Data Acquisition8. Project Database
GEO-RELATEDPLANNING12. Planning Strategies13. Create Alternate Plans
EVALUATION14. Evaluate Alternate Plans15. Select Preferred Plan
GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE
IMPLEMENTATION, DOCUMENTATION, ACCEPTANCE16. Implementation Plan17. Reports & Presentations18. Website19. Project Acceptance
Source: Miller, William, Geodesign Project Workflow, private papers, March 2016.
![Page 4: Geodesign: Challenges in Practice - Esri · GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE “Geodesign is a design and planning method which tightly couples the creation of design proposals with](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022011902/5f0aafbd7e708231d42cd732/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
• Scope & Contract• Scale & Expertise• Technology Ownership
Intra-Project Challenges Extra-Project Challenges
GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE
• Sequential & Cyclical Planning Processes• Market Demand for Stability• Client & Ownership• Designer Hubris• Ethics• Time
• To see trends• To construct buildings• To test, monitor, provide data
![Page 5: Geodesign: Challenges in Practice - Esri · GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE “Geodesign is a design and planning method which tightly couples the creation of design proposals with](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022011902/5f0aafbd7e708231d42cd732/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
To identify key challenges that present themselves in practice.
1.
To seed conversations about future development of technology to support the geodesign process.
2.
To provoke the project-based nature of geodesignprocess.
3.
Purpose of this talk
GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE
![Page 6: Geodesign: Challenges in Practice - Esri · GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE “Geodesign is a design and planning method which tightly couples the creation of design proposals with](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022011902/5f0aafbd7e708231d42cd732/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Primary Care, Urgent Care, X-Ray & Lab Feasibility StudyRight Service, Right Size,Right Location
GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE
![Page 7: Geodesign: Challenges in Practice - Esri · GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE “Geodesign is a design and planning method which tightly couples the creation of design proposals with](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022011902/5f0aafbd7e708231d42cd732/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
PROJECTDEFINITION1. Project Initiation2. Project Recon.3. Goals & Objectives4. Stakeholders5. Issues of Concern
Typical Geodesign Process
CONDITIONASSESSMENT9. Analyze Issues10. Suitabilities & Vulnerabilities11. Opportunities & Constraints
DATAMANAGEMENT6. Data Requirements7. Data Acquisition8. Project Database
GEO-RELATEDPLANNING12. Planning Strategies13. Create Alternate Plans
EVALUATION14. Evaluate Alternate Plans15. Select Preferred Plan
GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE
IMPLEMENTATION, DOCUMENTATION, ACCEPTANCE16. Implementation Plan17. Reports & Presentations18. Website19. Project Acceptance
Source: Miller, William, Geodesign Project Workflow, private papers, March 2016.
![Page 8: Geodesign: Challenges in Practice - Esri · GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE “Geodesign is a design and planning method which tightly couples the creation of design proposals with](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022011902/5f0aafbd7e708231d42cd732/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Project Definition
GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE
PROJECTDEFINITION1. Project Initiation2. Project Recon.3. Goals & Objectives4. Stakeholders5. Issues of Concern
![Page 9: Geodesign: Challenges in Practice - Esri · GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE “Geodesign is a design and planning method which tightly couples the creation of design proposals with](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022011902/5f0aafbd7e708231d42cd732/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Data Management
GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE
ESRI Data• Demographics (ACS, Census)• Zips, Counties, Census Boundaries• Transportation Data
Healthcare Forecasting Subscription Data• Service Line Growth
Hospital Data• Patient Locations (identity scrubbed)• Hospital and Competitor Service Locations
PROJECTDEFINITION1. Project Initiation2. Project Recon.3. Goals & Objectives4. Stakeholders5. Issues of Concern
DATAMANAGEMENT6. Data Requirements7. Data Acquisition8. Project Database
![Page 10: Geodesign: Challenges in Practice - Esri · GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE “Geodesign is a design and planning method which tightly couples the creation of design proposals with](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022011902/5f0aafbd7e708231d42cd732/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Condition Assessment
GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE
PROJECTDEFINITION1. Project Initiation2. Project Recon.3. Goals & Objectives4. Stakeholders5. Issues of Concern
CONDITIONASSESSMENT9. Analyze Issues10. Suitabilities & Vulnerabilities11. Opportunities & Constraints
DATAMANAGEMENT6. Data Requirements7. Data Acquisition8. Project Database
![Page 11: Geodesign: Challenges in Practice - Esri · GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE “Geodesign is a design and planning method which tightly couples the creation of design proposals with](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022011902/5f0aafbd7e708231d42cd732/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Condition Assessment
GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE
PROJECTDEFINITION1. Project Initiation2. Project Recon.3. Goals & Objectives4. Stakeholders5. Issues of Concern
CONDITIONASSESSMENT9. Analyze Issues10. Suitabilities & Vulnerabilities11. Opportunities & Constraints
DATAMANAGEMENT6. Data Requirements7. Data Acquisition8. Project Database
![Page 12: Geodesign: Challenges in Practice - Esri · GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE “Geodesign is a design and planning method which tightly couples the creation of design proposals with](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022011902/5f0aafbd7e708231d42cd732/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Condition Assessment
GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE
PROJECTDEFINITION1. Project Initiation2. Project Recon.3. Goals & Objectives4. Stakeholders5. Issues of Concern
CONDITIONASSESSMENT9. Analyze Issues10. Suitabilities & Vulnerabilities11. Opportunities & Constraints
DATAMANAGEMENT6. Data Requirements7. Data Acquisition8. Project Database
![Page 13: Geodesign: Challenges in Practice - Esri · GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE “Geodesign is a design and planning method which tightly couples the creation of design proposals with](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022011902/5f0aafbd7e708231d42cd732/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Condition Assessment
GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE
PROJECTDEFINITION1. Project Initiation2. Project Recon.3. Goals & Objectives4. Stakeholders5. Issues of Concern
CONDITIONASSESSMENT9. Analyze Issues10. Suitabilities & Vulnerabilities11. Opportunities & Constraints
DATAMANAGEMENT6. Data Requirements7. Data Acquisition8. Project Database
![Page 14: Geodesign: Challenges in Practice - Esri · GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE “Geodesign is a design and planning method which tightly couples the creation of design proposals with](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022011902/5f0aafbd7e708231d42cd732/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Geo-related Planning
GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE
PROJECTDEFINITION1. Project Initiation2. Project Recon.3. Goals & Objectives4. Stakeholders5. Issues of Concern
CONDITIONASSESSMENT9. Analyze Issues10. Suitabilities & Vulnerabilities11. Opportunities & Constraints
DATAMANAGEMENT6. Data Requirements7. Data Acquisition8. Project Database
GEO-RELATEDPLANNING12. Planning Strategies13. Create Alternate Plans
![Page 15: Geodesign: Challenges in Practice - Esri · GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE “Geodesign is a design and planning method which tightly couples the creation of design proposals with](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022011902/5f0aafbd7e708231d42cd732/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Geo-related Planning
GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE
PROJECTDEFINITION1. Project Initiation2. Project Recon.3. Goals & Objectives4. Stakeholders5. Issues of Concern
CONDITIONASSESSMENT9. Analyze Issues10. Suitabilities & Vulnerabilities11. Opportunities & Constraints
DATAMANAGEMENT6. Data Requirements7. Data Acquisition8. Project Database
GEO-RELATEDPLANNING12. Planning Strategies13. Create Alternate Plans
![Page 16: Geodesign: Challenges in Practice - Esri · GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE “Geodesign is a design and planning method which tightly couples the creation of design proposals with](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022011902/5f0aafbd7e708231d42cd732/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Implementation, Documentation, Acceptance
GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE
PROJECTDEFINITION1. Project Initiation2. Project Recon.3. Goals & Objectives4. Stakeholders5. Issues of Concern
CONDITIONASSESSMENT9. Analyze Issues10. Suitabilities & Vulnerabilities11. Opportunities & Constraints
DATAMANAGEMENT6. Data Requirements7. Data Acquisition8. Project Database
GEO-RELATEDPLANNING12. Planning Strategies13. Create Alternate Plans
EVALUATION14. Evaluate Alternate Plans15. Select Preferred Plan
IMPLEMENTATION, DOCUMENTATION, ACCEPTANCE16. Implementation Plan17. Reports & Presentations18. Website19. Project Acceptance
![Page 17: Geodesign: Challenges in Practice - Esri · GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE “Geodesign is a design and planning method which tightly couples the creation of design proposals with](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022011902/5f0aafbd7e708231d42cd732/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
PROJECTDEFINITION1. Project Initiation2. Project Recon.3. Goals & Objectives4. Stakeholders5. Issues of Concern
Typical Geodesign Process
CONDITIONASSESSMENT9. Analyze Issues10. Suitabilities & Vulnerabilities11. Opportunities & Constraints
DATAMANAGEMENT6. Data Requirements7. Data Acquisition8. Project Database
GEO-RELATEDPLANNING12. Planning Strategies13. Create Alternate Plans
EVALUATION14. Evaluate Alternate Plans15. Select Preferred Plan
GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE
IMPLEMENTATION, DOCUMENTATION, ACCEPTANCE16. Implementation Plan17. Reports & Presentations18. Website19. Project Acceptance
Scope & Contract• Scope specified we would deliver a variety of
options.• Final solution to be determined by others.
Scale & Expertise• NBBJ was the best choice to analyze a very large area
with specific healthcare expertise.• Local real-estate broker was the best choice to select
final locations.
Technology Ownership• Data may be transferred, but analytical tools and
processes rarely are.• No real way for future consultants to build into our
geodesign process.
![Page 18: Geodesign: Challenges in Practice - Esri · GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE “Geodesign is a design and planning method which tightly couples the creation of design proposals with](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022011902/5f0aafbd7e708231d42cd732/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE
1. Break the contract barrier.
GeoPlannerThought Experiment
Instead of offering finite solutions, we build a tool that can adjust to new forecast and suitability models.
What if?
2. Easy to use, and educational.NBBJ staffs all high-skill data management and tool update tasks.
3. New client relationship paradigm.
Shift from episodic planning, to an account mgmt./ retainer model.
![Page 19: Geodesign: Challenges in Practice - Esri · GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE “Geodesign is a design and planning method which tightly couples the creation of design proposals with](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022011902/5f0aafbd7e708231d42cd732/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
• Scope & Contract• Scale & Expertise• Technology Ownership• Time
• To see trends• To test, monitor, provide data
Intra-Project Challenges
• Sequential & Cyclical Planning Processes• Market Demand for Stability• Client & Ownership• Rejection of Outcomes• Ethics• Post-Occupancy Evaluations
Extra-Project Challenges
GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE
![Page 20: Geodesign: Challenges in Practice - Esri · GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE “Geodesign is a design and planning method which tightly couples the creation of design proposals with](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022011902/5f0aafbd7e708231d42cd732/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE
Visioning. Primary Planning. Secondary Planning. Development.
1. Process is sequential & cyclic
Civic Planning Template*
• Information travels downstream: feedback loops are difficult at best or simply non-existent.
2. Rejection of outcomes• Every project is an opportunity for the
next consultant to reject the findings of the previous study.
*Diagramming a process that is specific and idiosyncratic is nearly impossible. This diagram should be used for high-level speculation only.
Is this a Geodesign process?
Project Def.
Data Mgmt. Cond.Assess.
GeoPlanning
Eval. Imp./Doc./Accept.
![Page 21: Geodesign: Challenges in Practice - Esri · GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE “Geodesign is a design and planning method which tightly couples the creation of design proposals with](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022011902/5f0aafbd7e708231d42cd732/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE
1. One-off planning
Academic Planning Template*
• Client might a department or school, not the university.
• Insights and discoveries have little opportunity to have impact outside the project.
2. Each plan is uniquely authored.• Each plan is a combination of client
effort and consultant input.• Some information proceeds
downstream, but much can be lost in transmission.
Is this a Geodesign process?
*Diagramming a process that is specific and idiosyncratic is nearly impossible. This diagram should be used for high-level speculation only.
Project Def.
Data Mgmt. Cond.Assess.
GeoPlanning
Eval. Imp./Doc./Accept.
![Page 22: Geodesign: Challenges in Practice - Esri · GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE “Geodesign is a design and planning method which tightly couples the creation of design proposals with](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022011902/5f0aafbd7e708231d42cd732/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE
1. POE & testing are rare
Health Planning Template*
• Post-occupancy evals and true analytical testing of outcomes are rare.
• Data becomes anecdotal and opinion-based.
2. Ethics may limit continuity.• Consultant may be precluded from
continuing work through planning scales/phases due to ethical concern, such as oversizing buildings and spaces to take advantage of higher architectural fees later.
Is this a Geodesign process?
*Diagramming a process that is specific and idiosyncratic is nearly impossible. This diagram should be used for high-level speculation only.
Project Def.
Data Mgmt. Cond.Assess.
GeoPlanning
Eval. Imp./Doc./Accept.
![Page 23: Geodesign: Challenges in Practice - Esri · GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE “Geodesign is a design and planning method which tightly couples the creation of design proposals with](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022011902/5f0aafbd7e708231d42cd732/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
To identify key challenges that present themselves in practice.
1.
To seed conversations about future development of technology to support the geodesign process.
2.
To provoke the project-based nature of geodesignprocess.
3.
Purpose of this talk
GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE
![Page 24: Geodesign: Challenges in Practice - Esri · GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE “Geodesign is a design and planning method which tightly couples the creation of design proposals with](https://reader030.fdocuments.us/reader030/viewer/2022011902/5f0aafbd7e708231d42cd732/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
GEODESIGN: CHALLENGES IN PRACTICE
“Geodesign is a design and planning method which tightly couples the creation of design
proposals with impact simulations informed by geographic contexts.”
Project Def.
Data Mgmt. Cond.Assess.
GeoPlanning
Eval. Imp./Doc./Accept.
“Geodesign is persistent, collaborative planning armaturewhich tightly couples the creation of design proposals with impact
simulations informed by geographic contexts.”