GeoCAPE community workshop, NASA Ames Res. Center, 21-23 May 2013 European prospects for a...

GeoCAPE community workshop, NASA Ames Res. Center, 21-23 May 2013

European prospects for a geostationary ocean color sensor: the

“ocean color advanced permanent imager” (OCAPI)

David Antoine,on behalf of the OCAPI science team

Laboratoire d’Océanographie de Villefranche (LOV),

CNRS, Villefranche sur mer, France


From where OCAPI comes from …? (1/2)

• A first proposal was submitted to ESA in 2002 (“BIOGEOSAT”). Included a sensor on a geostationary platform plus a constellation of 3 micro-satellites…. (“Earth explorer call”)

• A number of studies were carried out to assess the feasibility and interest of ocean color observations from the geostationary orbit.

• We also conducted a study for the KORDI (GOCI preparation), in order to quantify the atmospheric signal measured by an ocean color sensor in the GEO configuration, and to analyze the geometry of the problem.

• In the meantime, several technical studies were carried out at CNES, ASTRIUM, and other companies in order to progressively discern and design the possible characteristics of such missions.

• A proposal was submitted to CNES in 2008 Selected as a high priority at the occasion of the 2009 quadrennial CNES “scientific prospective seminar”. Called “OCAPI”, which means Ocean Color Advanced Permanent Imager


From where OCAPI comes from …? (2/2)

• Proposal submitted to ESA (8th “Earth Explorer” opportunity mission) in June 2010

• Was not selected (budget and launcher), yet received an excellent scientific evaluation and a specific recommendation: “It is recommended that the OCAPI mission is further addressed in another programmatic framework”

• Phase 0.2 studies have been carried out at CNES to further define the concept (by Astrium and Thales). A phase A study might start in 2014

• Based on the ESAC recommendation, another proposal was submitted to ESA in summer 2011, called HOCI “Hosted Ocean Color Imager”. The logic was to embark a OCI-like instrument on a commercial telecommunication platform (the EDRS-C satellite). This proposal is unsuccessful for the moment. We watch out for other such opportunities to embark a mission on platform of opportunity

• Science studies are ongoing, for instance on the diurnal cycle of optical properties


Science focus of the OCAPI mission

Encompasses open ocean and the coastal environment.

Includes:

- The diurnal cycle of ocean optical properties, and its relation to physics and biogeochemistry

- Biological-physical coupling at (sub)meso scale- Data assimilation into coupled biological-physical models- Improved marine biogeochemistry and ecosystem models- Dynamics of coastal environments and ecosystems- Sediment transport- Aerosol transport- Land – ocean interactions- Operational services in the coastal zones


Coastal only versus “global” ?

Remember the « Coastal Zone Color Scanner » (CZCS)

From Acker et al. L&O bulletin, 2013:“Dick Barber noted that the first images from the CZCS demolished the commonly held misperception of alongshore continuity–“jets” and “squirts” and variability in current meandering indicated that the ocean was a much more complex place than point sampling had led many to believe.”

The step we’ll make with the advent of geostationary observations will likely be as important as the one we did after the CZCS launch

That’s why we think we should not only observe coastal areas


OCAPI: overarching objectives1. Within a range of conditions of observation (solar & view angles, clouds, …), the

diel dynamics of the ocean will be accessible. The 1st objective in this case is to study the ocean ecosystem functioning at the diurnal scale. The diurnal cycle of photosynthesis / respiration .. generates a diel cycle in the particulate pool, hence of the optical properties and of the recorded signal

2. In the above conditions and also when a little less observations will be available over a day, the 2nd group of objectives is related to observation & understanding of rapidly evolving phenomena (river outflows, aerosol plumes, phytoplankton blooms, (sub)meso-scale features ..). These phenomena are not necessarily linked to the biological functioning, and rather under the influence of physical forcings

3. When the conditions of observation do not allow the diel changes to be sampled, there is still the capability to dramatically improve coverage, with at least one observation of good quality per day in many areas. This is of tremendous importance for all operational uses, from data assimilation into coupled biological-physical 3D models to services in coastal zones


Diurnal cycle of optical properties

Can go from Dcp to DPOC.After integration over the productive zone, one gets either NCP or NPP

From Gernez, Antoine and Huot, 2011, L&O, 56, 17-36


Average diurnal variability at BOUSSOLE


Sediment transport in coastal zones :An example using SEVIRI on MSG

from: K. Ruddick & G. Neukermans, MUUM


COVERAGE

Mean(left) and max (right) number of daily available observations, for two LEOs complemented by OCAPI in March, June and December (top to bottom).

The observation area is here constrained by the MSG observation area (from which realistic cloud coverage was taken)


Data assimilation in Coupled physical-biological models

Current limitations: Spatial resolution, data frequency for assimilation, inadaptation of assimilation schemes for incorporation of biogeochemistryNeeded evolutions:○ Improving ocean-atmosphere coupling (air-sea interface)○ Extension to the coastal domain○ Adaptation of assimilation schemes to incorporate biogeochemistry

Sat

ellit

eN

emo-

Lobs

ter

R&D: NATL4 + LOBSTERDemo: ORCA025 + PISCES Source: P. Brasseur CNRS-LEGI, Grenoble


Operational services in the coastal zones

HABs

Front detection Images courtesy, ACRI-st

Such services exist as demonstration studies.Truly operational services are rare, however, because the availability of LEO observations is insufficient Very high potential of the GEO observations

The quality / reliability of these services is, again, much dependent on the significant improvements we’ll be able to bring to ocean color interpretation in optically-complex waters


Context

- Constrained by the ESA EE-8 call (2009-2010):

- Ceiling cost was ~100 M€ industrial cost for the space segment and mission specific ground segment (i.e. excluding launcher, operations, generic ground segment, level 2 processor and ESA internal costs) at 2009 economic conditions.

- We had to cover all mission objectives with 1 instrument only

- That’s why we don’t have, for instance, SWIR bands (would mean a second instrument) although we recognize their usefulness

- CNES alone cannot afford such a mission. International cooperation is mandatory (ongoing…)


Products & associated requirements (1/2)

Product types S: “standard” I: “intermediate” R:”research”


Products & associated requirements (2/2)


Band set

SNRs are for a 250m resolution

Grey cells indicate continuity /compatibility with MERIS and OLCI

Last column is priority for the mission


Other requirements (1/2)


Other requirements (2/2)


OCAPI: preliminary mission elements- Observation of all ocean areas (open + coastal) on the Earth disk at a ~1h temporal

resolution from a geostationary orbit (slightly inclined geosynchronous have been evaluated also)

- Step & stare concept- 250m GSD @ SSP- 18 bands from 395 to 1020 nm (OLCI compatibility)- High SNR required for ocean colour (>1000 @ 1-km resolution)- On-board calibration devices (solar diffusers)- Other characteristics typical of what’s required for ocean colour (see IOCCG#13)


Orbit


International context• One mission has been launched in 2010: COMS-1 / GOCI from KARI/KORDI

• NASA includes GEO observations as one of its priorities, in the “Advanced plan for NASA’s Ocean Biology and Biogeochemistry Research, NASA, 2007”, and has the GeoCAPE mission proposal under investigation

• ESA : Geo OCULUS (R&D stage). Very high resolution for risk assessment.

• ISRO also considers the GEO orbit for future Earth observations missions (GEO-HR mission for risk monitoring / assessment)

• CNES is investigating the OCAPI mission proposal

• IOCCG has set up a working group on ocean color observations from the GEO orbit. This group has prepared an IOCCG monograph (report), to be published by mid 2012.

• The EC Implementation Group of the Marine Core Service :“GMES should allow for research and technological developments. In particular, the possibility of embarking new instruments with the potential to meet GMES needs should be considered. Wide Swath altimetry and geostationary ocean color are the two most important new technology development

that will benefit the GMES MCS in the long run.”


Soon available


Areas where we need more work

• Atmospheric corrections (open ocean and coastal zones)Generic difficulties of atmospheric correction of ocean color

observation, plus some specific aspects (e.g., backscattering geometry)

• Diurnal cycles of IOPs and AOPs

• Radiative transfer for low solar elevations and grazing observation angles

• Calibration / validation (including vicarious calibration)

• Cloud “masks”

• Exploitation of the temporal / spatial coherency of the oceanic structures under observation by a GEO ocean color sensor

…


Ongoing studies

• Diurnal IOPs AOPs satellite signal inversion (based on in field measurements at BOUSSOLE) (D. Antoine, LOV)

• As above, but under the form of a “scene generator” (A. Roman, ISITV, Toulon)

• Exploitation of GOCI data for analyzing sediment transport in coastal areas (D. Doxaran, LOV)

• Assimilation of high frequency data into coupled BGC models (P. Brasseur, LGGE, Grenoble)

• Exploiting high-res (spatial & temporal) numerical simulations of phytoplankton distribution (M. Lévy, LOCEAN, Paris)

• Diurnal variability of fluorescence (M. Babin, Takuvik, Canada)

• MTF study starting from HICO data

• Extension of mission goals (aerosols, clouds, land vegetation)

• Cal/val studies

GeoCAPE community workshop, NASA Ames Res. Center, 21-23 May 2013 European prospects for a...

Documents

Transcript of GeoCAPE community workshop, NASA Ames Res. Center, 21-23 May 2013 European prospects for a...