G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... ·...
Transcript of G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... ·...
![Page 1: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
G.-G. ARSENEU.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara
2009
![Page 2: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Rel
igio
n
Science(Ecology) PhilosophyE.E.
![Page 3: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Ecology
- science(natural philosophy)
- objective
Ethics
-philosophy
subjective
![Page 4: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Science:
1. How things are.2. Repports and explains facts.3. Generates descriptions.
Ethics:
1. How things ought to be.2. Identifies values.3. Genetrate prescriptions.
![Page 5: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Ecological generalities• systems• relations• complexity
– emergent properties– non-linear behaviour– chaos
• scalar approaches: anorganic – biological - cultural• multi-, inter-, transdisciplinary field• ecology = (meta)science
– dimensions of the ecology• natural• socio-political• ideological
![Page 6: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
The “Holly Trinity” in Ecology:
Ecology ≈ Ecologism/Environmentalism
![Page 7: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Generalities about Philosophy
The Axial Age (V-VI BCE): the born of Philosophy
CHINA
Confucius
INDIASidharthaGautama
GREECE
Socrates
Con
tinui
ty
NowadaysC
ontin
uity
Dis
rupt
ion
Unchanged tradition Philosophy integrated inreligion
Natural philosophydissolved in science
(since 1850)
![Page 8: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Ethics: a re-entry story
![Page 9: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Ethics is about:
morality and human nature, choices, values, virtue, genetical determinism of the human behaviour, moral relativism, ethical absolutism, cynics, stoics, epicureans, social contract (HOBBES), utilitarianism, (BENTHAM, MILL), duty (KANT), meta-ethics (HUME), subjectivism, objectivism, prescriptivism, existentialism (SARTRE), postmodern neo-tribes, ...
![Page 10: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Moralagent
Moralobject
Responsibilities, Duties
![Page 11: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
from ROZZI, R., s.a. – The Dialectical Links Between Environmental Ethics and Sciences, PAIDEIA, http://www.bu.edu/wcp/Papers/Envi/EnviRozz.htm
![Page 12: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
“L’éthique recommande,la morale commande et le droit décide.”
![Page 13: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
ABSTRACTREAL
WORLDMETA-ETHICS
ETHICS MORAL CODES
![Page 14: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
... but, ...
“… moral statements are a puzzle because they don’t appear to fall into the standard categories of empirical or logical knowledge, which philosophers claim are the only ones.”
ROBINSON, D., GARRATT, C., 2003 – Introducing Ethics, Icon Books UK – Totem Books USA
![Page 15: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
The place of Bioethics:
Meta-ethics Ethics Bioethics Environmental ethics
![Page 16: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Beginnings of Bioethics
• 1969, “Patient as Person”Paul Ramsey
• 1970, “Bioethics, the Science of Survival”• 1971 “Bioethics: Bridge to the Future”
Van Rensselaer Potter• 1973, “Bioethics as a Discipline”
Dan Callahan(the first entry of the word “bioethics” in the catalogue of the National Library of Congress)
![Page 17: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
POST, S. G., 2004 – Encyclopedia of Bioethics, 3rd ed., Macmillan Reference USA – Thompson Gale
Issues in bioethics: abortion; adoption, aging, autoexperimentation; cancer, bioterorism, clinical ethics; chronic illness; cloning; conscience; death; dementia; disability; embryo and fetus; eugenics; fertility control; gender identity; genetic testing and screening; health insurance; infanticide; medical ethics; medical mistakes; neuroethics; nursing; organ and tissues transplant; patient rights; placebo; population policies; private ownership in invention; race and racism; reproductive technologies; right to die; sexism; suicide; warfare; xenotransplants; ...
![Page 18: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Conclusion:
The most issues in modern bioethics are humans - related
and, more specificallyhuman medicine - related .
This is a narrow view of Bioethics(Bioethics sensu stricto).
![Page 19: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Bioethics means also:
... agriculture and biotechnology; animal research; animal welfare and rights; bioethics in buddhism, christianity, daoism, ...; climate change; endangered species and biodiversity; environmental ethics; environmental policies and law; future generations; hazardous wastes and toxic substances; nanotechnology; profit and commercialism; sustainable development; veterinary ethics; ..
This is Bioethics sensu lato.
![Page 20: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
B IO E T H IC SE N V IR O N M E N T A L
E T H IC S
![Page 21: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Crisis
• Economic• Of energy• Moral• Institutional• Political• Religious• Environmental• ...
![Page 22: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
“Market capitalism has increased wealth beyond the imagination of previous generations, but cannot, in and of itself, distribute it equally or even equitably. These are problems that cannot be solved within the terms set by modernity, for the simple reason that they are not procedural, but rather valuational or, to use the simple word, moral. There is no way of bypassing difficult moral choices by way of a scientific decision-procedure that states ”Maximize X”. We first have to decide which X we wish to maximize, and how to weigh X against Y when the pursuit of one damages the fulfilment of the other. The human project is inescapably a moral project.”
Jonathan Sacks
![Page 23: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
“If we are to construct an alternative world-system to the one that is today in grievous crisis, we must treat simultaneously and inextricably the issues of the true and the good.”
http://www.panix.com/~lnp3/marxism.html
“The aim of education is knowledge, not of facts, but of values.”
W. R. INGE
![Page 24: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
![Page 25: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
NATURE(NON-HUMAN) HUMANS
![Page 26: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
General picture
• nature = ?– (nascilat.) = who give birth)
• environment = ?– things around (around who / what ?)
![Page 27: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
• nature– dynamic– complex, diverse– resources depot– living creatures + non-living objects– concrete and abstract– wilderness and artificial / anthropic (man made)– independent and dominated– autopoietic, resilient and damaged / fragile– divine (theatre of gods) and vulgar– disected and incomprehensible- limited (at the planet Earth)
![Page 28: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
“Engineering ecological systems is dangerous. Nature is neither predictable nor inert; rather it is evolutionary and self-modifying.
[...]Ecologists cannot hide behind “pure” science and divorce themselves from the dangerous application of ecology.
[...]Ecology is still a young science”PETERSON et al., 1997 – Ecology, Ethics and Advocacy, Conservation Ecology, 1, 1, URL: http://www.consecol.org/vol1/iss1/art17
![Page 29: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
• humans– individuals, grups, communities, humanity
(species)– increasing in number– dynamic– rational(bases ?) and impredictible– self consciousness– more and more powerfull (increasing impact)– the species that changed dramatycally its (our !)
environment (upgrading (?) the carrying capacity)– living only on Earth– emancipation from the environment ?
![Page 30: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
How Ethics began ?
Anorganic level
Biological level
Cultural level
Eth
ical
nativ
ism E
thic
alre
alis
m
![Page 31: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
• “humans and nature” = analitical approach– (anagr. =
– lysisgr. = )– schizophrenic ?
• “humans whitin nature” = holisitc / systemicapproach– holosgr. = whole, entity– species among species ?
Environmental determinism of the cultural level.
![Page 32: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
NATURE
HUMANS
![Page 33: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
Perspectives on nature:
Nature
Pragmatic Scientific
Emotional Ethical
![Page 34: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
• Human societies evolve;
• Environment / nature evolves;↓
CO-EVOLUTION
In which way ?
![Page 35: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
Major themes in the Environmental History• the history of impacts of natural changes—whether geological,
climatic, or biological—on human societies.• investigation of human impacts on the natural environment in
various places and in selected periods, as well as the ways in which changes caused by those impacts rebound and cause reciprocal changes in human societies
• the study of human thought about and attitudes toward nature, including the scientific study of nature, especially ecology, and the ways in which popular culture and systems of thought such as religions, philosophies, and political ideologies have influenced human relationships to the natural environment.
![Page 36: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
![Page 37: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
Scalar approach:• Y = f(time & space)• humanity
– nations• communities
– individuals
What level to apply ethics to ?
![Page 38: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
Scalar approach
![Page 39: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
![Page 40: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
Religious points of view
• animism• hinduism• budhism• taoism• mazdeism• judaism• christianism • islam• …
![Page 41: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
Animism
• animalat = soul• soul = spirit• everything is animated• stones, trees, animals, … are inhabited by
sprits• (→ Isis, Ishtar, Gaia, Ceres, …)• “Ecologically” correct• “Ethically” ?
![Page 42: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
“To us modern sophisticates, the great myths of the past appear quaint and fantastic, so straining credulity that we scarcely imagine how people took them seriously. […]
In an age in which human consciousness has long been conditioned by literacy, such tales seem ridiculous, but they reflect the fact that for most of history, humans felt located within a cosmos. The myths themselves were a fabulous expression of a profound intuition – that humans live in a richly layered and alive universe, full of meanings and portents and that their decisions and actions fit within the greater story of nature.”
R. FRODEMAN & J. B. CALLICOTT, 2009
![Page 43: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
“The truth of myths is not accuracy of description but adequacy of guidance. In those terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic value and biotic equality of all being is profoundly true.”
KOHA, E., s.a. – Truth of the Myths of Nature, PAIDEIA
![Page 44: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
Hinduism
• everything has a divine nature (Vishnu)
• karma
• transcendence: human condition →divine condition
• diversity of opinions:– bruthas– purush vs. prakriti (sattva, rajas, tamas)– paramanas– mayavada, …
![Page 45: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
“The one whose self is disciplined by yogaSee the self abiding in every beingAnd sees every being in the self;He sees the same in all beings.When one see pleasures and pain of othersTo be equal to one’s own, o Arjuna,He is considered the highest yogin.”
Bhagavad Gita, VI, 29, 32
![Page 46: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
Buddhism
• karma, samsara
• dukkha = pain• dharma = moral low
• non-agression• world = moral continuum
• non-attachment
![Page 47: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
The buddhist concepts rest on:
- a general principle of consequentialism;- a teleology;- a deontology – dharma
![Page 48: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
Daoism / Confucianism
• Dao = The Way
• Yin & Yang• Confucius: [sky – nature – man]
• pragmatism
![Page 49: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
Tao principles which should guide the relationship between humanity and nature:
• “Humanity follows the Earth, the Earth follows Heaven, Heaven follows Tao, and Tao follows what is natural.” (let the nature be
itself)
• Everything is composed of two opposite forces. (nature protectors vs. nature
exploiters)
• People should take into full consideration the limits of nature’s sustaining power, so that when they pursue their own development, they have a correct standard of success. (to be too
successful is to be on the path to defeat)
• Taoism has a unique sense of value in that it judges affluence by the number of different species. (verry special contribution to the conservation of nature)
PALMER, M., 2005, in COOPER, D. E. & PALMER, J. A. – Spirit of the Environment, Routledge
![Page 50: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
“When one hears cry of birds and animals, one will have compassion, because the jen is one with the birds and animals. If one says that animals have senses, then one will have compassion when one sees the grasses and trees faded and broken, because the jen is one with the grasses and animals. If you say that grasses and trees are animated beings, then one will regret when one sees tile-stones collapse, this is because the jen is one with tile-stone.”
Wang Yang-ming (Wang Shou-jen) (1472-1528)
Jen = the innate original knowledge and the principle of the universe at the same time.
(YAMAUCHI, T., 2003, in PALMER, J. A. – Fifty Key Thinkers on the Environment, Routledge )
![Page 51: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
Mazdeism
• 1000 b.C.
• good nature – bad nature• degradations of the environment
![Page 52: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
Judaism«The barrier between the western mode of consciousness and the natural world, and the consequent ethical deficiency in western conscience, began in some manner with the biblical emphasis on the perception of the divine in the historical events rather than within cosmological manifestation. The entire biblical experience could be described as a movement from the cosmological to the historical which began with the Exodus experience.»
BERRY, T, 1996 – Ethics and Ecology, URL: http://ecoethics.net/ops/eth&ecol.htm
![Page 53: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
Christianism
“God created man in his own image, in the image of God created he him; male and female created he them. And God blessed them, and God said unto them, Be fruitful, and multiply, and replenish the Earth, and subdue it: and have dominion over fish of the sea, and over fowl of the air, and over every living that moveth upon the eat.”
Genesis, 1:27-28
![Page 54: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
Islam
“The obligation of the Sharia’ah is to provide the well-being of all mankind, which lies in safeguarding their faith, their human self, their intellect, their progeny, and their wealth.”
Al-Gazali
![Page 55: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
(BECKER, C., Educating Humanity: From Western to Asian Environmental Ethics, PAIDEIA,at URL http://www.bu.edu/wcp/Papers/Comp/CompBeck.htm)
Western Asian
linear cyclical
divine salvation karmic necessity
human dominion human within nature
atomistic mechanistic individualism
organic interdependence
competition cooperation
glorification of wealth respect for humanhood
![Page 56: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/56.jpg)
Modern + postmodern perspectives
• world-machine• relativity• deep-ecology• ecofeminism• New Age• sustainability
![Page 57: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/57.jpg)
1543 - Copernicus
ptolemaic paradigm → heliocentrism
![Page 58: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/58.jpg)
Francis Bacon (1561-1626)
- doctrine of induction-reproductible experiments (empiricism)“Nature to be commanded must be obeyed …”- an Elizabethan scientist-magician who promised so much for the good of the human species, but was willing to destroy or distort at least as much to achieve this end
![Page 59: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/59.jpg)
1637 - Descartes
• res extensa (physicality ) vs. res cogitans (mentality )
![Page 60: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/60.jpg)
Social philosophy / Egocentric ethics
John LOCKE (1632-1704)
- mental corpuscles and forces (associationism)
Thomas HOBBES (1588-1679)
- the social contract (a way for wicked but rational human beings to avoid conflicts)
Maximization of Individual Self-Interest: What is good for the individuals is good for society as a whole
![Page 61: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/61.jpg)
1672 – Isaac Newton
![Page 62: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/62.jpg)
phisics → philosophy
David HUME
(1711-1776)
This doctrine was associated with a trust in the powers of human reason and insight into reality, which possessed God’s certification. -inventor of meta-ethics (the study of moral language, its meaning, function and certainity).- empiricist (all knowledge has to come trough our senses) and sceptic.
![Page 63: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/63.jpg)
Evolutionary biology
![Page 64: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/64.jpg)
• “loyalty to the earth”• man is not inherently superior to
any other animal• God is dead
Friedrich NITZCHE
(1844-1900)
![Page 65: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/65.jpg)
XVIth, XVIIth centuries:
- birth of capitalism
- the Reform (Martin LUTHER, 1483-1546), the call, The Protestant Ethic
- profound mutation from religious to laic / secular
WEBER, M., 1958 – The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism, Scribner, New York
![Page 66: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/66.jpg)
classical phisics → relativity
Albert EINSTEIN (1879-1955) Werner HEISENBERG (1901-1976)
![Page 67: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/67.jpg)
1935: ecosystem concept
Sir Arthur George TANSLEY (1871-1955)
![Page 68: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/68.jpg)
‘1960s
![Page 69: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/69.jpg)
“… a pale blue dot floating in the inky blackness of space …”
![Page 70: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/70.jpg)
ecology → ecologism / environmentalism
Rachel CARSON (1907-1964)
![Page 71: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/71.jpg)
About “Silent Spring” (1962)
• Time magazine (September, 28, 1962): CARSON’s argument is “unfair, one-sided, and hysterically overemphatic”
• Time magazine, three decades after: Rachel CARSON is one of the most important scientists of the twentieth century
!!!
![Page 72: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/72.jpg)
“What is the value of preserving and strengthening this sense of awe and wonder, this recognition of something beyond the boundaries of human existence ? Is the exploration of the natural world just a pleasant way to pass the golden hours of childhood or is there something deeper ?
I am sure there is something much deeper, something lasting and significant. Those who dwell, as scientists or laymen, among the beauties and mysteries of the earth are never alone or weary of live”
R. CARSON, The Sense of Wonder
![Page 73: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/73.jpg)
Lynn White jr. (1907-1987)
The Historical Roots of Our Ecological Crisis“What shall we do? No one yet knows. Unless
we think about fundamentals, our specific measures may produce new backlashes more serious than those they are designed to remedy.”
![Page 74: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/74.jpg)
1972 – Deep ecology“If you hear a phrase like “all life is fundamentally one !”, you must be open to tasting this, before asking immediately “what does it mean ?”. Being more precise does not necessarily create something that is more inspiring.”
Arne NAESS (1912-)
- Biospherical egalitariasm
- Self-realization (indian inspiration),
- SPINOZA influences
-The flourishing of life
![Page 75: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/75.jpg)
The Deep Ecology Platform• 1. The flourishing of human and non-human life on Earth has intrinsic value. The value of non-human life forms
is independent of the usefulness these may have for narrow human purposes. • 2. Richness and diversity of life forms are values in themselves and contribute to the flourishing of human and
non-human life on Earth. • 3. Humans have no right to reduce this richness and diversity except to satisfy vital needs. • 4. Present human interference with the non-human world is excessive, and the situation is rapidly worsening. • 5. The flourishing of human life and cultures is compatible with a substantial decrease of the human population.
The flourishing of non-human life requires such a decrease. • 6. Significant change of life conditions for the better requires change in policies. These affect basic economic,
technological, and ideological structures. • 7. The ideological change is mainly that of appreciating life quality (dwelling in situations of intrinsic value) rather
than adhering to a high standard of living. There will be a profound awareness of the difference between big and great.
• 8. Those who subscribe to the forgoing points have an obligation directly or indirectly to participate in the attempt to implement the necessary changes.
NAESS, A., 1989 - Ecology, Community and Lifestyle, Cambridge, CUP, p. 29.
![Page 76: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/76.jpg)
‘1970s - Ecofeminism
• since Bronze Era: androcentrism• woman assimilated to nature
Françoise d'EAUBONNE (1920-2005) (Val PLUMWWOD)
![Page 77: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/77.jpg)
1979 - Gaïa
James Ephraim LOVELOCK (1919-)
![Page 78: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/78.jpg)
New Age
Fritjof CAPRA (1939-) - ecolitteracy
![Page 79: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/79.jpg)
New Age life-spirituality (or self-spirituality) is characterized by three basic themes:First, life lived out of the ‘ego’ or ‘lower self’ does not work . Life at this level is mechanistic, distorted,
malfunctional. It is replete with neuroses, irritations, unsatisfactory accomplishments , bad habits, good habits which in fact do not work. Life at this level of existence is life lived in terms of what we all are by virtue of socialization, education, parenting—in sum, of what we are by virtue of what has been imposed on us since our birth.
Second, the experience of those involved with New Age spiritualities of life is that from birth (if not before) our true essence is of a spiritual nature . Our life, that is to say, is entirely bound up with, integral to, a spiritual realm which is entirely distinct from that which is acquired from the institutions, structures and values of society and culture. And life lived out of what lies within—the ‘higher self’, ‘source’ or goddess/god—is as perfect as this life can be.
And third, spiritual disciplines are experienced as providing the key to effecting a transformational ‘shift’ from the lower to the higher realm of being. The great cry is practice, engage, find ‘what works for you’, experience it.
WOODHEAD, L., FLETCHER, P., KAWANAMI, H., SMITH, D. (eds.), 2005 – Religions in the Modern World, Routledge, London, New-York
![Page 80: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/80.jpg)
1992 - Rio
• sustainability (roots in 1972)– weak sustainability
– strong sustainability– Environmental integrity
– Economic efficiency– Equity
• between individuals• between generations
![Page 81: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/81.jpg)
Environmental ethics
• applied ethics• ≠ bioethicsroots in ecosophy (Ist wave of enviromnetalism
):– H. D. Thoreau (1854)– J. Muir, T. H. Huxley (1911)
– A. Leopold (1949)– …
connections with the ecotheology, …
![Page 82: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/82.jpg)
- the land ethic
![Page 83: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/83.jpg)
Albert SCHWEITZER (1875-1965)
“The great fault of all ethics hitherto has been that they have believed themselves to have deal only with relation of man to man.”-the ethics of reverence for live-the mystical apprehension of the value of life
![Page 84: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/84.jpg)
Modern times
• 1962 - Silent Spring (R. Carson)• 1968 – The Population Bomb (P. Erlich)• 1972 – The Limits of Growth (D. H. Meadows
et al.)
![Page 85: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/85.jpg)
“ Nowhere to run, nowhere to hide.”“We are all the dinner of Tommorow.”
![Page 86: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/86.jpg)
Holmes ROLSTON III
• 1975 ‘‘Is There an Ecological Ethic ?’’
![Page 87: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/87.jpg)
Central issues in environmental ethics
• Does non-human entities have (intrinsic, inherent, per se) value ?
• Anthropocentrism (humanism) vs. biocentrism / ecocentrism
![Page 88: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/88.jpg)
Anthropocentrism (Humanism)
• Biological diversity exists for humans, has not value apart from humans, and need no exist apart from humans.
• The transformation of wild nature into nature resources adds value to nature, since nature possesses value only in human use(instrumental value ).
• The creation of just societies filled with flourishing individuals is the highest achievement of which humans ar capable.
![Page 89: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/89.jpg)
Rationality-based arguments against anthropocentrism• 1) Not all human beings are rational;• (2) Not all nonhuman animals lack rationality;• (3) There is no good reason to restrict
personhood to rational beings.
(if the personhood is based on rationality)
![Page 90: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/90.jpg)
Utilitarianism arguments against anthropocentrism• animal suffering should be included in the
utilitarian calculus (J. BENTHAM !)• utilitarianism, consistently applied, requires
people to take into account the interests of all sentient beings and to give equal interests equal weight in utilitarian calculations (P. SINGER).
![Page 91: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/91.jpg)
Biocentrism• the belief that all forms of life are equally
valuable and humanity is not the center of existence. Biocentric positions generally advocate a focus on the well-being of all life in the consideration of ecological , political, and economic issues.
• the philosophical position that the attributes of living things form the basis of perception , and thereby form the basis of observable reality itself.
![Page 92: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/92.jpg)
Most common objection to Biocentrism• all judgments of value, however nonanthropocentric in
content, are still anthropogenic (Callicott 1992) because they depend on human valuation, and there can be no value in the absence of valuers, (weak biocentrism )
• but … valuable does not mean ‘‘valued’’• normative biocentrism : to treat ethical judgements not as
mere expressions of human valuing but as having truth values of the kind widely recognized as belonging both to moral and to value discourse
![Page 93: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/93.jpg)
Anthropocentric critics to Biocentrism
Sophisticated (enlightened) anthropocentrism includes biocentrism !
![Page 94: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/94.jpg)
Ecocentrism
• a philosophy that recognizes that the ecosphere, rather than any individual organism, is the source and support of all life and as such advises a holistic and eco-centric approach to government, industry, and individual.
![Page 95: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/95.jpg)
Attention !
In many books and articles
Biocentrism = Ecocentrism
![Page 96: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/96.jpg)
Ecocentrism – Partnership Ethics (People and Nature)
• The greatest good for the human and nonhuman communities is their mutual living interdependence.
• Equity between the human and nonhuman communities.• Moral consideration for both humans and other species.• Respect for cultural diversity and biodiversity.• Inclusion of women, minorities, and nonhuman nature in the code
of ethical accountability.• Ecologically sound management is consistent with the continued
health of both the human and nonhuman communities.
![Page 97: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/97.jpg)
Arguments for intrinsic values and biocentrism / ecocentrism:• Religious authority• Expansion of the moral circle (rationality, sentience, …)
• Conativism (“will-to-live”)
• Identification (“We tend to see ourselves in everything alive” A. NAESS)
• Holistic rationalism (“”the diversity, integrity and other similar attributes of biotic communities (and larger units)
are intrinsically good and should be cherished” A. LEOPOLD)
• Interests (“living organisms have interest” telos)
• Bio-empathy (biophilia – E. O. WILLSON)SARKAR, S., 2005 – Biodiversity and Environmental Philosophy. An Introduction, Cambridge University Press
![Page 98: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/98.jpg)
Some defficiencies:
• 1. The weakness of the argument from the will to live
• 2. The impracticality of radical biological egalitarianism
• 3. The theory’s failure to provide practical guidance
• 4. The excessive guilt which the theory requires to bear.
![Page 99: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/99.jpg)
Extentionist approach in environmental ethics
Homocentric ethics
Bio-Ecocentric
ethics
(hapiness)
(unity,stability,diversity,
harmony of ecosystems)
![Page 100: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/100.jpg)
Anthropocentrisme Biocentrisme Ecocentrisme
caractérisation sommaire L’homme est au centre de tout.
L’environnement a une valeur instrumentale.
L’homme est le seul porteur de valeur
intrinsèque, parce qu’il est doué de
rationalité et de sensibilité.
Enraciné dans la culture occidentale et dans
le judéo-christianisme, il accorde beaucoup
d’attention aux notions de justice et droits.
Il existe en plusieurs variantes (dur - strong,
mou - weak, illuminné – enlightened, cinique
- cynical).
Uti, non abuti (utilisez, mais non abusez) –
principe de l’anthropocentrisme modéré (→
utilitarisme, pragmatisme)
Egalitarisme biotique: tout organisme
(pris individuellement !) a une valeur
inhérente, il est un centre de vie
téléologique[1] et un objet moral[2]. Les
organismes vivants possèdent de
manière égale ou dans différents degrés
(différences de nuance) conscience de
soi, rationalité, sensibilité, mémoire,
identité psychologique, désirs etc.
Egalitarisme biosphérique (biospheric
egalitarianism): les espèces, les
communautés (cénoses), les écosystèmes ont
une valeur intrinsèque, parce qu’ils sont les
matrices des organismes. Les communautés,
les écosystèmes doivent être protégés dans
leur intégrité (parfois cela exige de sacrifier
des individus). L’homme fait part de la
communauté biotique, les plantes et les
animaux sont ses compagnons. Idéologie du
partenariat (stweardship) avec la nature.
Promouvoir la beauté, la stabilité et l’intégrité
de la communauté biotique.
limitations / problèmes Egocentrisme. Optimisme exagéré vis-à-vis
des possibilités de la science et de la
technologie. Libéralisme débridé (idéologie
du «cow-boy»). Difficultés d’expliquer
pourquoi l’humanité seule, parmi les autres
créations, compte de point de vue moral.
N’apporte pas de solutions aux aspects
de la crises de l’environnement (érosion
des sols, pollutions diverses etc.).
Existe dans des variantes extrêmes, tournées
contre certains groups humains (kill yourself
to save the planet): fascisme
environnemental, impérialisme culturel
occidental etc. Difficulté d’expliquer les
intérêts des bactéries, montagnes, forêts etc.
de se maintenir, de se développer et d’être
donc des sujets moraux.
Des contradiction, parfois, avec la
démocratie.séparation de l’homme de la nature
quelques auteurs
représentatifs
B. Norton, 1991 – Toward Unity Among
Environmentalists, Oxford University Press,
New York
J. Passmore, 1974 – Man’s Responsibility for
Nature; Ecological Problems and Western
Traditions, Scribner's, New York
K. Shrader-Frechette, 1984 – Science Policy.
Ethics and Economic Methodology, D. Reidel,
Dordrecht
P. Taylor, 1986 – Respect for Nature: a
Theory of environmental Ethics, N.J.
Princeton University Press, Princeton
K. Goodpaster, Sayer, K. M. (eds.), 1979
– Ethics and Problems of the 21st
Century, University of Notre Dame Press,
Notre Dame
J. B. Callicott, 1989 – In Defense of the
Land Ethic: Essays in Environmental
Philosophy, SUNNY Press, Albany
A. Leopold, 1949 – A Sand County Almanac,
Oxford University Press
H. Rolston III, 1975 – Is There an Ecological
Ethics ?, Ethics, 85, : 93-109
A. Naess, 1973 – The Shallow and the Deep,
Long Range Ecology Movement, Inquiry, 16, :
95-100
C. Merchant, 1980 – The death of nature :
Women, ecology and the scientific revolution,
Harper & Row, San Francisco
![Page 101: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/101.jpg)
Environmental ethics: a man-to-man, not man-to-nature business
«Parce que le fait est, à l'évidence, que la sagesse écologique ne consiste pas à vivre en accord avec la nature, elle consiste à savoir comment les sujets se mettent d'accord sur la manière de vivre avec la nature.»
WILBER, K., Une brève histoire de tout,
![Page 102: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/102.jpg)
Organisations
• The International Society for Environmental Ethics -ISEE(1989)
• The International Association for Environmetal Philosophy (1997)
• Periodicals:– Environmental Ethics– Environmental Values
– Ethics and the Environment
![Page 103: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/103.jpg)
![Page 104: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/104.jpg)
The long, long way from theory to policy …
“As environmental ethics approaches its third decade it is faced with a curious problem. On the one hand, the discipline . . . has produced a wide variety of positions and theories in an attempt to derive morally justifiable and adequate environmental policies. On the other hand, it is difficult to see what practical effect the field of environmental ethics has had on the formation of environmental policy.”
in JENKINS (2008)
![Page 105: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/105.jpg)
Practical strategies in Environmental Ethics• The strategy of Ecojustice• The strategy of Christian Stewardship• The strategy of Ecological spirituality
JENKINS, W., 2008 – Ecologies of Grace, Oxford University Press
![Page 106: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/106.jpg)
Conclusions
• Ecologically, Homo sapiens is a social omnivore whit the bigest capacity to change its environment. This capacity increased / increases constantly.
• Firsts ethics that includes environment were religiously determined.
• Two types of ethical-religious approaches:– in-wordly (duality humans / nature)
– out-wordly (holistic)
![Page 107: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/107.jpg)
• Recent evolution: mecanicism → organicism.• Classical ethical frames are not reliable tools
to judge environmental problems.• New ethics appeared in the ‘1960:
environmental ethics.• Two clusters of general approaches in the field
of environmental ethics:– anthropocentrism– biocentrism / ecocentrism.
![Page 108: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/108.jpg)
• Sustainability is to be prouved.• Environmental ethics is a young field.
![Page 109: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/109.jpg)
“We must value nature from our point of view in a total context, which includes our cultural history and our natural history. Nature must be valued, from the ecological-evolutionary viewpoint of environmentalists, in its full contemporary complexity and in its largest temporal dynamic.”
NORTON, B., 1991 -Toward unity among environmentalists, Osford University Press, p. 250
![Page 110: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/110.jpg)
The Ten New Commandments(John PASSMORE)
1. Thou shalt not litter.2. Thou shalt no pollute thy air and water.3. Thou shalt not burn incadenscent light bulbs.4. Thou shalt not drive a Hummer.5. Thou shalt not waste resources.6. Thou shalt recycle.7. Thou shalt eat organic foods.8. Thou shalt reduce thy consumption.9. Thou shalt xeriscape thy lawn.10. Thou shalt install solar-energy panels on thy roof.
![Page 111: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/111.jpg)
“An important issue for scientists is ethics, and more specifically bioethics. The scientists has a general responsibility to the truth, and only there is their responsibility to the society an the world. Ethics is a function of time, location, and knowledge.
[...]We have to continue from the tree of knowledge to the
control of our destiny.”
LEHN, J.-M., 2004 – Science and Society: Some Reflections, in SERAGELDIN, I., PERSLEY, G. J. –Discovery to Delivery, Biovision 2004, Bibliotheca Alexandrina, The Doyle Foundation, p. 28
![Page 112: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/112.jpg)
“Discussion of foundational values, of why we practice agriculture as we do, should become a central, rather than peripheral, part of agricultural practice and education. If agricultural scientists do not venture forth to understand and shape the ethical base of the future, it will be imposed by others.”
Agriculture's Ethical Horizon, Robert Zimdahl, Academic Press, March 2006
![Page 113: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/113.jpg)
“The irony and tragedy of our situation make the stipulation of practical plans of action highly uncertain at best. Yet, it hardly seems moral or prudent to trust blindly in luck. We follow our bliss, in any case, but we do so in wisdom when we acknowledge the irony and tragedy inherent in our story, and when reflection upon these tropes is a perennial theme of our activity. […] We know enough about the environmental impacts of agriculture to make changes in practice, and we know too much about the philosophy of agriculture to remain sanguine about productionist biases. Stewardship, economics, and holism represent partial philosophies for reform, and the ideal of sustainability indicates the end of which reform should be directed. The tensions created when partial philosophies and unachievable ideals are combined only reveal the irony and incompleteness of any attempt at intelligent action. They do not excuse our indolence.”THOMPSON, P., 1995 – The spirit of the soil. Agriculture and environmental ethics, Routledge, London-New York, pp.
168-169
![Page 114: G.-G. ARSENE U.A.S.V.M.B. Timisoara 2009bioethics.agrocampus-ouest.eu/infoglueDeliverLive/... · terms, the theory of unending expansion is viciously false. The myth of intrinsic](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042103/5e80fedc9342a5081c3e2664/html5/thumbnails/114.jpg)
Agriculture – multifunctional
Space Services Production