fv £ i C'hiwatari/lecture/kokusai/... · m t'^B L ^.i i< ^ tSIm-^ 5 L.4^^£V^)o o^i, ^ ^ 7"©^...
17
aSBEl CJ1 ^ CO ts3 I—' ^ ^ ia 9 S 5 M fi e>; ^ fv o qU r\ ^ ifi rY S » -B- i2 -B- fv £ i C' S" ® » ffl a> ^ @§ •# /V -0- nn
Transcript of fv £ i C'hiwatari/lecture/kokusai/... · m t'^B L ^.i i< ^ tSIm-^ 5 L.4^^£V^)o o^i, ^ ^ 7"©^...
aSBEl
CJ1 ^ CO ts3 I—'
^
ia 9S5 M fie>; ^ fvo qU
r\ ^
ifi rYS
» -B- i2 -B-fv £ i C'
S" ® » ffla> ^ @§•# /V
-0- nn
r^f3t°D'J^ h£7)5S
feX-^ct^-po
i:SfflSPiSM® 2
;b^bJS:^o
^i:ic®(crom^^orci:UTt). i:z<Dn>^m^mwti\
(1) @W (the purpose/character of the paper)
(2) 43,(the centra! thesis)
(3) rPo^Si:f!SaiJ (research design)
(4) (implications)
i^-f, |Sl}JLXlK3tJ^. ■^®^^lct>t':>>iSUXl^?c7c^7cl^®l4;.
ntxi^S:®
^iftLTi^<if,
05;®fi^75■^■©fe® {TcHXit, li5£;®i^®®^^^5felc®l''Xl/M:tlSJ;l^®S^t:i^-:37ci_H) lSlii^U^l-\i:V,\0>SX^So ^©J;^J5:y-AO
I3^4*lClEU;c®X-0f^$
n7
ci^o
:2m
lilS
:o#
IS«
o<
5
1 a
g6
5®
ii^a
Jti^
^fl5
l-td;o
^'®
40
. • S
SJ T
iglft
^liE
j r»
]|iji9:j m
mm
.(om
^}
x^S
o
lOo
/s-tf 1
^-ru
^Ji^
rL^-ttn
tf^i:
(tmlS
c-e® fc
®(c
{i. cog&
^J^tB1-ik^^g(i^):^'■
')o M
^&
5i-^
gg
65 • Si](!)^65g&
5i|!gJg-::i"t^.Sili
J;-^
{Jf®
M#
(CfcO
Xtio
±i^
^iftz
4'D
0M
^<
^h
(O,
O^ i9ie£^®
1^t5 • Mti,
•en
txic
^?
^
i®X
i-So
C
CX
^<^^^:^,li^a
J£l-^:^B
^^}#-^^>
ox,
l-^®
ti^ll:^
(±^j<
!:J;
i3, m
Wa,
.m
^
tzt
Xl-£,
D
i (i <- L y;: 19 -t
t'(D
iU\
^
Sc ®
a
i0[^!^{c
fc(,^T
(iE.
(ErnstH
aas) ®
^:5
1^iil-^
-r 5-i-|H65lra5^ii
(Haasl953)o
^
m^m
i i.^ r.
j; 9 ic, fe o
c:o
a®
t«,
ot
^ tz^
C®
:5:li((cfc{5
1978 ^{C y -
-: L fc H
. ih -f X y
(Herbert Sim
on) (D
M^
(bounded rationality) fc®
Xib
So
m
t'^B L .i i< t
SIm
-^■5 L.4^^£V^)o
o^i,
^ ^ 7"©
^
Trachtenberg2006)o ^ C'V
it, -?:tl^
T ^ ^i:
o^
L ft cb I-^-P (C m
i tl-^ ^ t-t £ S o
cti^ 2 o
©f^W
tcti$
nft=6^ftt-
S©;6s®^1^!iEtISU^IiJiS® 2
(ab5V^ti^*^d:i'©iiEm
) ftM-i
ccTH^■9^gIS
I^IiE'eab'S
o
L(±C4^>■5i,
■s)o■(SIS1^SE©W
^^^J^ 1 "^o 1980^-fti^JSii^l^.
r^£-lf I960 ^ft©
Liilf $ C <h
^ ft ©tIi^Jil,^-5Fp^VM
C^-r-5lra^A^i^C ofto ^B#®®
i®gim
^ (il0^)
^■fW • I^Sfetft©
A^"^©W
R£^®
)^®.
C. yy y CChalmers
Johnsonl982) il
fto;6^:$:^ (c
# 5 © ^ i'9
^ ^ ^ B :$: © X - 'T? t) o T L T
$tlft©
T"fe
So
^^L
ft^^^jg
O'.
;f)^-:.ft^^®0
f9^^'^,
ifcttd^i-^fto
3 y
v(its 30 ^
ft ftm
^£Ttiigf©iS
I5Stifefe-»^ft t>©
LA>L. c:n^T©
iKiS
1^iiE®
i^m,
a^®
i^S
^«
^®
i^0
■& t)nt) n
©«
(i ft I-^^
® s--s o
;£.i|^^®^^-^x —
^ V^fifE&tlj't'S i
9fF^'Ci»'So ft?
y7^-f=
''7.^^©
ii|!t^ft'&©
iiS&
9:^^'t^^9
-f-^'^^T.
•I" 7 (C
harles Darw
in) L
ft i l"';t S tri>
-S 9©
i'©
<k 9 l^i'^tl
{mm
f-^'^
<o
mm
m^^^W
tm'th
ct¥
X'^
ho
i)\ i.^t>
(f^^)ii?<
®i^T
"
t±-t ©
J: 9 ^C ®tiS
ft i'<9 #
V ^ ft © T
-^ft o
@[J
®^J
^^{fn(f,
E. CEm
ile Durkheim
) ©
g^©
ff5^3
!)^fg
j^T
'^S
o
191SJE
?^^. 3
-a .y
y^°^
gT
"©g
^^®
±#
^@
©^ft^
^;:L
T,
ft:-y:'@
^t±^c
:.S®
A^<
!:^ii:y:^^®
5:lt^>
iiP=
l9ft®
T'fe
-5o
g^(i®
At^
'<^k®
^^ft"i,®
^n
Tl<
^fto
L
^^L.
©)^
0{±
l|{itl:^-t©
t) ©,
-9^ 1
9|@
A©
^i-®fi^^S
ti^hS
(±f"ft"ft©
Tfe
So
C
©^i®
®$
E^^-€
-;6^y
;^^^x^^k
-ir-A©
^-tJg
T'£
b-:>
fto ^9
LT
^;i^
±lL
ft^^l^
®«
^®
^±^^H
L,
-J3SA
J; 19 fe¥A®
gi^^pf)>'iiS
>-^-
i. h 0-y ^
^^3
:(9
y h|{[t^
®{i9
^^S
W«
i.^;: t,
^
t. ft (i;f;?£U^J; 19 t)J
?W
® (i 9
d i
£ L ft®
T^ 6©
x^;k
':r-A©
iS|J
&|IJ
^{i@^^ftijO
T!ilfH
-^13
F5
^©it^®
i9rj^l.^ft®
r'fe
-:>fto 1i^^4
^ftfcH^T
Ii^Mi^^«
l^:s:ti^gi^^^^l^E
l^:^:ft<y©
<j®
-eib
S;()i,
jC,^ftii'J
6T
fe^ftl.^o
2 4" 'C.^ ^
o -5 ©
(ii^ijll^^MT
ib ^So
C4
T.li^l§
7?
the central thesis ft"?
(±'n
Si®
T%
B
^^fts
RL
ft<t^
o
fti9
&;i#
' r^iHJ
tLft;!)^,
t^m
^T
t^9
iil6®
^t&
^£
fc®
^m
i5^-rs
®-e
{±ft'<
,
^)o
c!:^
ft< t^
^{f r'B
'.^fti-^ilchJ i
^>®
T
(BO
X 2-1 fc#
»c:i)o
ft. K
;&m
t^ftt^©?
J t^
#ti,®
9o
ti9
^j:n{^l^3
i:©W
#^^?
l^tSfo
®-c,
cn^^^i:(j-n(fiSp:$:@
fj(i:>{»^fiJci9j5:ft'j:i.^—
3;9
^j:fc©
"e&
So
^s^^^^t^
9'<
i^J®
7)^
, i^:$:ft-©
T-^S
o m ^m
^©
A^ (^
) ^
55 S531
. ow 1^.i 0-. -
r-
-rl". It'-; v^ 9;in 3--
: 5'i>h
'■ ^. En,-
Si;5{t m: 4 ^;: dt ■ r< -'
w■■ ■ ■:'■ «4-
-O. PP-■ ; Mh
• dt- ■ -^V<s:. r<:s, o« n ;
Jg 0^ d
-c- c. .
• c: -tv. <?.
^s- ; 8^-d* fi
-It-Q.Q 5.
■M © W-"iv liS. *•
-1: n>'. cSl,vJ. •:' -^S-?^- ft- ts;
, h-. .rv © -Or-^'' tr -
55. d '-55,-
•«> ^•:-S'Q C''-5? '®
W"■^:- Sv -.jvvM. in ^^ ^ ©•-^ - 55:©. >. ?i.'m-ffi o-'.-
^t^=< © «:•■,vn- - ,:r..-'Cv':'® • ■-©k' ft/.■' ^'n04" il' »■ 04 rr-' mnu d
,
fV '•r':^•■55 ■ft . ■<^ ■ -.4' .^ m . -O' • \> ^0k-0 ^ * m 0" -:f?
■it- -II I®-. - '0 ,0- .:.?t-n :d '•4:-
■•M' -•©k ,-n.
0 'I-'€N: 0v
- 54:'S 8d •' © .-.Hir
• i: o, -ij:::" -d . -
.9-iz - K in.:Z. r' IS •T , £f 01^:,d it' — TT--.iW ■ M- i'.
i: 3in n0 g-
?r 0fv d
"
5k "fr5R T'
e- M55
m ^
N de HSi dS sv55
3S 0::i Si^ mSV 7t04 "—^ fVrt T
s w-(V ^c- m
<xs H¥-§ ^ (M-■fftn 4ff ^;S 0 J5f ci I
J3- Cf d
S
, w-d -e-ra n.
■ls>1 ss3- rr
' ><t
• ^
s ^i f4 min 5r< 4H
fv ffli: pjvo« 2cS^ n
0 fl.-fr& d 4
d Sv 04
^ ' 531d rt Ii:
^?3! 1^- w1"^ 55. 04d —; ?T!»- 0 O.in M ^
-B- m 110 p?v
^ ^# q: 0n 04 ^^ rr ml04 C ii5? O' d
^^
5? 0404 ^ fM.
/s. *
44 1' -B-£g rt5
^ "f" ^^ ©v- f.lof ^ ^■s © w-
v^ 04X I mP?v d; affli ^ r^v^ -r ^rr (^vt: ^o. m ^r4 drv qi 551
d>1' Sv^ 04CT ®^ cf
o-
^ 5k
2 ^
% ^
IS svoj. 404 04r4 ^fV ^'
vs 41*
^'n
# c4 o«04 -e- ^ail0 nd t5^©v ^ S^ i4 d* ^ *-B- rr ig
4 ^^ 04 0
C5^ 0n ^
w r«
'S: ^ 0'W 1^ C^ >4 d3 0^
t4 ^M M na P °4 n r<04 K r<0 ^ d
^ (Vi4 (?-rd> 8tSI ^n O'cfr 04^ OM-^ ftrv fvc ^•0< 9+.
^ ' ,0 nd »SkS m
^ •¥). m1 m ^"P" n ©V
^ 55m $r ZH- O' 04^ sCt ®^ {Jt14 ^ 04 n (V^ 55
I t-' ✓%
^ 0 r4 0
5 f- H^ r4
2 Q^ SI^ rv S3 - S
® c?^ 5f^ 0 _,vT' d ^^-©^ 4J^^ 04 ^1=:^ ^0 gnd r 04 ii^04 ^ >4
04 trt-1
0 js-k/
04 804 04
d fg 04<~
V FT
o« d }> ?fr
IS St-<•
m 04 <- dV
0
IS
0 ft
ft33^ '-^4
0 Ss p^ illd
/Pf3
fS£J-
FT
4 4ft
4
04
04 414
o- VI
4ill
ft FT 3—1 4
SI4X
40 4
Ell d-e-
-B-
V
© ■Ifm
(V
ftF»' ti- H
04 mr
mIS d4 0
—1
V ISdst- f«- fV 3
O' S
O"
m ^m 2^
a^ nIS 5^4 c-
C r4 ?tJt, 0fV0 St-
O'
S 41 d
k; sva <>>Vjm ®g p-J-
□)! ^■
iti h-
?t>4 ^^ i\
kX14 ^i-rt
z Stf
fl- ffi-0 9+d 0QV Otiji>* 0® fV
d'
c5^^ 0
7fl-g s->4 0Hii e-^ Q
0-* 9+W-
d m0 dH St-a
r< ■*
\y 00 m
:Sla W-1^ 1\c O.Or r
0 ?tC? vy-rv £l
p^V ^r- ^d ^ ^^ r %^ ■ P?VM X mM M vsrrl lai (^M ^ 4ii -d ?v
^ ©St- -B-
d §S'
14nfe m
40 o*531 n
bf Ci^ n-© ^
^ <-d 'CO
n 0St- h-ft- o-«>» f?c^ fV© nit-
r\ fi; m> ^c f>; ^^ Or ^ ©f-< Cf- H(V O' ^^ S: 2t 1C^' ^ ^ ^
m} © 4SS ^ 5S )i^(^ S ^0 n ^ ^^ w n ^ri ^ IS yiiiC a id- ^
r\ ^
.7.
5S P?v4 gIV
n
^ CQ0 d
-6-4 fS■S H
>4 ii0 SSi SIf
1 A Md B
1 S!»• n
Sef
0 (^ft- C?^V 0fw- fSiX- <r-1 d
St- n
>-
14 d-ih-
0 O-m n
hpr S£h g:
bi 4S^ iivoL
Iff st-0 0*rS "5 ^
0 Iff0+
^ BS r*
>4 S^0 (Hm ^I&ft CrW- U- O-C< <h^ O.iT' 9?0 ($^531 ©
No< I4«>4 M
rv 1n
0 mdt""$■'
4 IS04 ^04 ^V ^V ^ft 404 04© 11:
d*'W'^r'n cS- rS ^n -r tJ-* 04 ^ft» 04 vj-'0 V 5^iti rv "Sijg Jjw fVnl 04^ ?Or r ^Ot £3- ^^ S sC d ^.r. ^ St-
r- ^
^ ^ 04S 0CS3 ^
© s gM ^ gS V 23S - S^ O' 4W 4 A4 ^ nit-04 ^o. K- ®
PS•S 4 ii
ii w-ft X ?t-^ ri (V
E
® » 8a 04 ^
5B o< ©r- -e- ^d r-' □>C 4 P?V?i ® V^ P?V vG-
^ St-St- ^
fSXw- 0 h-N ^ o«0 D> ®M d 0a St- >«-^ 04 »,3r^ O
W- ViJj Nft ^ 004 © Ms lli 0
04 m© ^ffl& o.n wt-4 ^04 M0 uHD
3flld
ft© ft ^tl> ©IS iii ^w- ^ S|
4m t{¥ ufS pH \'Sv >404 S "7"® 4 vji<■^4 04 ^o< n K'(S {^ usS K Vm: * 43 Em B¥5; p^^ ^ IRiIS ^ a^ B c-Or 4 fS^ 04 1:
04
0 04^ ii3
0 4
ilf r^ 9ti^tl J O'^ OV ftp^v dt- n>&-v ft- 304 C?-
^ 0 ^
i w K-# iT'
ft Ml4^? 0 Hn> )itff <5r® ^ o3 0 4^ ^^ :5i 4© w- 'at? 35 M)ta i) ^n S 514 It
S ©fv nC ^ ii^ 0-4 Itfii:Or ftC 04 ^o< \>4 nt*9t ^ 4o« ^ ^
04 P^0< ® 0rv- <Sp^v dnn 1: D>3 rt liV ^ 3(T ® ftd OrC 5i04 ft 4® ^ 3ft pSV il c;^. 04E p?v i¥
K>;;2 ^f 1 d #»f 5 0
04 Q>^ Or ig§M <r m
i ^>3f o< vs-^ fv ^0 4M d^ )ii& «^ M
m ^0 m 4ift 4 ffiH
Or ^ 1^
o< 4 nivh- ^ m0< v3- V3r
fv St- n(S^ ^ r-0 • h" yi O.^ F# OrSf 4' m 04Si ^ 04A . V
u m nV ^ SVyi 4 Oi•7* 04Ml 4^ o. ftV- ft VU1 pf f4.V k> HU 3 '^ aiiF mttSS 5fll!i 0
P^ iH:V S 25
iT' 0t: ^ >44 FT' fv;3 r- 104 d St
4 rR?
5f1- FT3 ^d U'
3
SB -6
^ viin ^
^ U1d V
04 ^t¥ OrH> 1:3 0ft Ftii iCi©
1 iityi fs-
ft'W ©St- H04 ^5 P?v
V ^^ 4
I 04^ fv
1:FT O'^ 4H
9t(- p^t-
K my\ d-M 04S fvCih z3 o.04 bf^ tl?04 ^
U'
m 040 °^ mm FtV 'ft >404
» >
-ii
ti> 0'W h-dft ft^ iiiW ^m 4Hs ^^ ft
i^-Tit
^ h-
tf? d
Ml St-^ 043 o.ft °>4 Ftml V^ F^')^ Wl
pffl n^
IS VfM- T
ri 2\
> ?—
°c-Tf
°(n =^
i|<5
'W^3
jo•SMaiA0JlBnUUB-MMM ®
f/ :>
} Il
U 1 ¥
^ 3V
^ -f
' 5 i
12
oa
?vian
mauaHlenuuV —5-9^^7:?G3^Ssl5-oa
°5'M:?^j'?^I9Hig9^i'?..> 9-^-1;^? rc^ty/oanw)
onHIf)^&lEQ'::?5-^g||::n=/q=J 'j
p)^
TV
'^i
MIE^? for; >'1
3r¥l
MIS;
(^::
^®#;
J,>o
::j
?ilM:!i^®:? 'f)::|??94-::i#iC-i:?:^:!i^^
'?10vtfvc^Hl?or/^)c.^^-j—^ °9$^:?(^^vi79-^lfa^::)
*>3V^a¥C0fm::? '5
<;f9
"¥a (v) J-¥
° 9 •$ a
9r O ?
;^jf-'oc-e<5v:?ac.c^^^|5gy;CT®.7 'an?
^J
'C(¥c.
^ fi
^^^G!):?
'<^:!j
-hlY^-Jf 7 54-1
'G¥1
4;
^ ip:;}c^s
ip:; (o)
(9) (V) fJW^H
°9 9pain? 'dw-iH
• .q
u:}—9 9paniHi^?rviy^ci3!/jpm-pjy^^ia3ic:-^Q«Q^if5'? r(®^9 4M
K'l
(0) (H) (V)
¥1^
5? ' Ci
o9
U'^>
'94figl^-3;^-^^^5?5¥WIi3j:!l®
■'9
viii^
?yi
f>n
3r^
'?
CO)
°9\ii
n^®
F:?
):gy
^^J'
? CS
+i¥f
4l)
(9)
°vin
Hi5
?^«^
(o
^Bd
) (V
)
"v-i
5v
r/u
e ^S
S5^;^
o-
Era-
3^Ep
sc.^i
? r^
¥®
>y;j
mETay
)¥
o :? t
)"^®
9 '?
:? 9
^5
4i|)S
&-3r
:2^^
y/^T®
-^
^^giy
-—-f
ryK
l5?
) °9
T^?d
_[l¥
(4T:
:)P
i-/O
'Y
~T
J f
h'^
'a. ^
■i'5
'?3?
:il9
Y-5
:=l ^
T 9
3; >
c.:
!}g
"-I ?
OS
^Oill
•'3
f®^^
■SivG
3^^M
' >
T®
¥¥
Ci ^
^■pl
'^lii
#^-^
1?
^l-P
)S-l'
rT®
3?
'::)C
T®:?
°9'
?a.4
^)5'
-1in
^2lf^
^liW
^^¥^
i:i^■
C^
(y/D
^iF
9>
c.5
Si«
co
x9
J
mzm
s4
.-if^^
3fc
rsj
Ki;
24
sias
raj
yhtti^o
^cD<fc a nj:r«^^®motj-::i5cDM[±^
IC, 0FIStc i
o
"C4>-5o C
:5'—L < ,
JilT.
{c-^-oT2oo^-■<ctT
.t>{irim
^7° D
- f-
i T
7° O -
T
-5 o
1^ 1 ¥ T"t^M
L fc i f:j,
^ o T
;!)^ ^j: tj- n tdf E
li it 8
io'<
fc®j&
^2oT^-&
(—
Sg
T^5
^t±#
il2^#
m^tL
fcL
)„-eti,
n^^m
ML
x^^co
o -e
oit,
CStfiR
^^'W rrf-^
-i-
cnti$fe^f5F5^
(Jew
ij ■^ —f- . -f'-y-M
-S D
esigning Social Inquiry: Scientific In
ference in Qualitative Research (King, Keohane, and Verba 1994: 16-17) {C (i
oi'®
(a:$:|g!??S
(i+
2004. 18-19^),, tlX
h
^n
^m
^I-^
SE
LT
^T
,
2. i®
®,
X\^^6
^0^s.
fc"(c+5)-5tliE
^nTi.^^£l<
0 ^
Lr.
^{±SiJ®
Sf^®
t5
3. 3<:^i::-^t>n-5l^%
l-#SnLT
, "to
m^ (o
^ f9 t>®
ffly^^iEH.^
a3
t®#
IS«
o<
5
25
4. L
/c^,ife ^
I. ■« {±-5: ® iii®
IE L ^
-S 0f5
S^#
^ o
t^o
(C®
^ 6 fPiS
lcoi,>T
{i BOX 2-2 ^#
m)o
l>®
®B
^^'fl:^tiTO
^j:i;^^ii—o
t <0 T^ti^'M
U±
h OTIIP
8^{C J; -:>
t\.^ofIJtl—
®iE
L<h07©
A^.
tf^,
(ic.
yV
-€-n^m^5F
5^^^tMt^i®
;&^'±®
m2«T
-^^/;:o Ii> a yyyK
i
(WJ't^'C
.O rx
u~
^- f- t>
f41
itCl5
:oO
Ai'#
^ia6
^Ty a
5o c tl
[± ()5;®;r"(±/j:<) ^^®
tl^^t±i^;^^-4
-So
L^>L.
J; o Tti L;»^>T.
empirical puzzle 1
;6^ J: < ^ t) n
-5 i}m
#±A^oT
<-5®
iJ^^MX
5 o ■€■ O J: 7 /J:
ti
m<D
txi)^xh, 1)1.^7'^^^
<DX$>i>o
C CT
O
7 anomaly O
<1
rs!j
IS 2*
BOX.2-2
(. > -5#^—
6«—
c
pi^,'? ft(D'C^5o
1\.}oX<D-:^mt (iS'K-. 1^
^0^^-S{aa^t!36i*5^i'V-'o '
,v, , .
;/;
3 o®®|^^5i:^;6i-rT-(;::S:iS^1^7f5|i,^ n
TV>S i bJ: •?„
■ ^^p: ±K©;3 -^©a^® 9 xr
2-9 (£?>•£v>Ji t-p) ;Vii>fs.v^XW^Xtct px-1- y
XT~t& So , .;^\;
tx
s:6?:&p
ffi?gM^^jfe®i>i-9;6J-r^8S&^J«^ ra-Ca^SJ <i:Vv^fc^i®i:^,^^J;Oo
■ >i^^4^(c:fon^-C(±gi^ic 3o®a^'^^^
5p (IS) :
f]^m¥=^nutx:^m,
i±W^)-W(=J;-3T^/^S^j®®. yi^i^^-citc®3-9;6sA®^^i&®So *e:-
■ c.te''3'-9©aaS6^tyi5&if
rra^ni::i.Vs;()^f-x y ift^<bx^x^ Mm'^tix\^tH:^tii£, ^
■f^ ic%
s c S
A;
'en
{iA^^a
ncci:ii<
>;tJ
;9o
4'-tf^£t),
W-oM
H
a^0F5^{c
—/J—
^fftlY
t®P
jaaAO
HTiE
^2
-1
»0
IJX
i:®-a
- rA
lliSX
OU
iWJ
BItg
-a
-y9-
rAf-iS
Yw
sftiJaj
g] 2-2 b
-^ h (C
<t
y_
;K7
5_
^_»
UXflW
fiRait J.«nK'W
HJH
6
^m
Ei$
iflS—
/?-
77
>7
/? -
TcW
SiS
iJKU
—j9 -
t t S
t^u
>f 7/v
u h
$-o
Jtfc*0iJ
(5tirWfS
{=(±&
'5'^fc)
Ln
^j:t^o
11
2-1
7'
it 7
E^
Hii.
(-9^ i9fra
!^®^li)
t±,-^itti&
tl^J^Ji LT
(± A
. i/'f
Xy^jUV
CArend Lijphart) tf
tL J; 9 o^tltX
itR. /-^L
- CR
obertDahl) ®|J& <
^mM
mm
^X^-^tz-o
LtS
^L,S
i- ^-r.
9 t < ^B^7
tic
i.^/;®7
£b
So
-e
cT
'^^y
®
b r
Si$
i]<tl.^9
|gt:^^n
't.t±it/c0
7a
bo
/^o
c:©c<
!:(cj;i9,
p-rSi0J/&
aB^{±A
i'^t-Miitfc®
7feSo
h oSt^(±.
[12-2®
ISC
rsij
SI 2-3 -i^V ::^CD^0iJA<t)fc6Ufc-7;P5^^^li(O<gEIE
e5fesaw*iilism
v;i.i';^±jSI±v^S;^SC0^-p
a^mz6t
a-* s 5 tm&
±»
^ :; toassTb' fc o
rk t
/8 3a^<o^«d*- /? - si&<o§i^<o
STJiS Sli-f^a.
<±-fti5
»S4P.t>'{c
■i^'):^
$ h^M
ido
mz 5
S'S
^UX
IC.
•f(Oflk<D
S^H
UA
'fe^ktST
1
K-<
i±-f-e<fe5
-p -* mu
^—
^HiJ(if3
®-P
S 5
-a —
li-f-CA
5
-p -* K
-f-vtttS
i^-e
^tL
in^(o
m\iz
i>
-Skm
t
LT r^5-3 i
(most likely case m
eth-^od)J,
rt
<t t) S
(least likely casem
ethod)J (D2'0^^$>6o
^^liE L t) o i a
■So -:j4
0 locr,W
Jfc"(^T.
/j: J' -
-S C
<h i/.£ S
o
itiSat^fc
-6 ti -f 4^* iJ X
7!)S^$fejigT fe ^ fco
jgc S
o fc®-C"-cb-So
d' +' 'J Xfc o i
fci ■
t^xJ;9o
LA
^L. Ii^lc
(i-7;u
^xi^^®
1^?
|iJlc
SL
r, ^®
J;9
4-?i^:-4-*'j x
-eti^
c ^/d:;&
^-:.fc®Tafei9.
c:®l^t±-7-'t/^ x
^^#
ic
^t^LT:2^tS
&i]^£B
il^6^H^iE
^ieofc®T
£bofco ^
'J x
Z.ih
Ui)^'^tz0
tz, ti,\^^i^T
"^>o
TC
®^{ijlS
A^n
fco
t^^L
,
El^-z?^-ii-O
T2-3 ®
«t -5 {c/d;.S;i)i, x^^®
igjE
{cMo
rh-5
t^Tfe'S-P
o c®
^'fr®^^6
^1
t±.r3S
M0J®
MJJ
K-f
C^'N
JUX (Robert M
ichels) ®ffl-^"C
^S ( H •<
1911 ^ti^tljfiS)o 1$P>iJt3^g2®i;^M
iJJ cb4>WnS
a -^^*9, i'®
m^S
fcfcl,^TK
-f-yy:
^^*5
.
f>iS
fiSg^iS
t)tlTt^fco
L^^L
. 5
^JUX
{i-^®K
^ o ^®
^-m.
e:® 5 '^^u
x1^ 2-4 o
^®
cfc o t-1:So
^m
ntr^
fzo
E!2-5®
J:^lc/^So
^X-T^^tiizMU
^^
(b) $^JF^4^-i":/7'^ct-?-®''<U
x-i/3 :/ C
LT
^^{±. m
.'^tmW
i^m
i®^t^/c
®+
'-f-y^c
iigts
i®
12-5
a
mi6A<o
—0
3
i i
Ad'tott
^T{i45i:
AJ55X
Sbil^VMX —a - S-CJ:
i=<tSiSatittgiE Zti
Ai)^X\Zfi
A;4^aTI±S5
^ ~*
z;i:7»*iajfig —
©iatiSWJY
a:<D(S$i4%giE
T t
cncoi-5 4 WJ«'*SBSe5<::S^
mmAOi^jE
t
t\^^mdSi
^mTux^^x-
W{-4STi±is
li-fi: v»9«I86
aiaA»f3)iK14;S'
i''q±
(method of difference i 1;^ 9
)
^(Dj^iZ, :^ <
^
mm)
(method of agreement i
t^^)
lif-'^iC-li-ck, "j-f
{c:a@L, U-^, -?■©=»; *5
y -e
h 4-V^
/j:e,{f,
lt. y ^
h'y
tmm
<D
mm
^M^t^i>
if^^, u
t
y-<
jL'X
i>^ti
mity
^ ';
7 >f
'J t'y
W:)-tz(D
i)\ d
© 2 i3
mf^<
0¥
x -y
y h tfi^
o
T'{±,
iifi(c.
^c-tfK
^6
i.>(i.
y ^ t'y
try ') ijm
m,
d©
J:7
lc^E^fcJ;9
^£^^m
lc^@L
fc9;iT
^ C t tU
^o
xh
o^(c
, ♦M
Fa
i+*+
'vy^®
-»^)ij?
ij&L
j;9o
±.x
^^tifz^^fx
mm
m
^'x
-yzri}i$
>;h
t^K
, -S
15
®W
Jf-t±
WM
^=ii^^T
{i^S
(■e®
WJ^^tiS
mx^?
>)
>iig
iJ®
WJi-{ife
T(±
^
c0
^t}M
^u
, nf
CD ♦M
i-Tti
e. net !©;{)»?
cor«
^^
tc/j:^ 0 Ja
flfc/c
^|^lii^®|!S
^^Jg
§ c i i
cn
iij:iB®
^M
^M
,;S®
;£:fflJ
f$"e
iSo
7^ 'J t°y
i$^g
®M
^^^rd
:i?^f$
&^jfc
)5?
^L
<t9
o
y ^ V t°y©
^M
S.T
iy
(Sam
irAm
in) ^ A
. G. 7
yy^
(Andre G
under Frank)
/j! L fc d
©gfm
tc; J;tl(i',
■a
^iA
ti-|t|^g
:$;ia
i^g
j{i 1 o©
-> X r A
L T
0
^ d
(iSfe
iiS
;!?^^^g
ic^-rn
tdr^M
i^±a
©^^^g
{d:ig
<
t^-5
it^9
o
9-f
•) S
^{c
d©
lt&^;^
^®
g:^
iaf^^J
T{-tJ
V^T
^^®(^n
Tl^S
7&
^t>it^9
di{;:/j:.5
o
LA^L.
< ^X
ltt >^£t^o
19
50
^ft®
M^j:&
(f
7-r 'J
ri^®ij
Ln7d:t^;^)^, ■?■©
r^^J
{±i'9
LT
iin^ d i;6
^'T
-i/c©
K
7j:-tf7
^ 'J fyti
fSS
tiiJ X
^U^^-o
fz
©;6>o ^S
i:7'f '; t°y
©:tl.^
^M
t^{c
{±m
W^^iig
#:$
ijm©
a[b
:6i
111^. d
©M
^s?t^fc©
^^. m
w.<
om
msm
\^'&u
t^m%
xh
'yiz
, x>
t
"9, B
tfcfi-e
©J:9
^ fnv 3n
^ 3 S
ri '^ Q «•
-B- S Jitla fV W;W- ^
\ Ti ' ^X fi Ci ^
V rv rv- r4i ^U X A- .CH St- w
0« 9+ X n°
i s i o ^ H r n?v
^ L\ 7t ^g (V d q:
iN ^ tt 3 rj-^ ° ^ r^ CiO (V
^ O Q ^ CN (V> O n ^<5 o si:vO --N Q <j^ (><n O o.
rt fc O e-rr 4tt £ O (T fT
w- O fvd tJ-
• e (ffi r Hh- ^ X r< ^ rt.d 3 0 C 3^ 5C 1 ft ^tt 9- V 3 nrt • ^ - a^ r< c~A ^ r< 3d^ ' e>^ Jt 4H ig^ r<
CN
M B^ ^ Zv-^ Hi ®
a- 1 ^ OT0 q: p^ d ^0-i c^ w- _,
li ^ A Sd 3 tt
(S^ o<
3
^ 0St- 3
°' W-7^ m
<r fia
^ §S0 ^fV ^&■ da H^ n3 19t^ i^
W S
^ ?■Q S
-' e»rr '?
o* ?fD i^c?*" 3e c (y^d St- iH IS£n ?^' r<
^ 0 ft0 «v ^^ ^ 3vy- ^ '9-9? S •-
® Ss ^^ "□
I ^H» h-
3
■* (^VM ^^ Jit
St- n ^cj^ ^ r<
' (Vr< 0, d ^?• i: k; 'W- d d w-d Pt 3 w-3 ^ ^ rlm ^ M ^n d H H
r» W ^0 ^ ^|i- ^^ S dM 0 US • ?t3 D> ^m M d^ " St-5j: 0'W m n
H fw ^ d- 9J ntl^ 0H rt t!¥ ? 4j) if ?ta ® rv H ^ ' °
1 r< -M E d Kr^ ^ tf ^ V r-
q S d; c« & il; d* 3 c- ^ '
n ^ 9t d 1
3 atlt
d;-t 3^ 9tH O'
r<
3 mh-o« 39? l¥
5lr ^
-j: vy«fit in>3 #o 3... 9?
-rrT jj.JS- ^
»OP CJ.w- ^
d ^St
ft rvo
0 9V9U- f«-o- «V
* f«;n «tM 9ts m<a- :fiW'. ^T
^ d/V InJ
S H3 m)B}- ctm 3^ ?tvyCD- n
?S- i:' O'm ^® qI# d
St-^ 04d ®9t ^i: y--5-)fr m^ m
^ m4ff 1^0 md ftA 0+^ rift, ?Td 5d 94?q
fV 9?
vy q m1 m §, Si 4jt2 9? ^ ^ S 3" 3 ott d ^ i¥r4 d ^ St ^B4 «>3 St 0 04 30 04 ?t K Xj-
3^n ^9+
^B4 «>3 itW ^o< r«
9t ®i?t 3 0
S^B d MSHk;»«»is r^
9
d^34r»S!^^i$ssr dS8
m i^@im»; »93 amh^ i:=SUK rr fSP$ 9t n>a nus a-4£§ «>•
hr fX _@ V S
, i ft; e>
i m
firs 5SIa 04
«
ss dm ^
0 St d;«t 04 I
C- sW o. ^i^ 04 ng I I
SI d;
I Xs5 fW-S -^t:
^-•^■•"'15 9?t= 04 ^
" 5!^ Stim 4^) d-iiJ d 04^ q ■-a ^ ;5p
fM;fV V
i: dIK d
I 94- HQ
d ^ A\ ^Pf S 04m 'n ^ m^ 0 ^Ml «t St^0- 04
H ?a ?fr04 ?t
n ^-1 w- ffl>4 ft m
d ^ ir>^^ ^ ^^ %^S- )«■ 3
d ^(V Sm r-
td w-m ft3 fvd JjJd ^
dda StI 04
i4 o.
(V ?tn Ot?i- 3
9t tsJd- W ^01 ^ fVi; 3 0-'m d prd d 043 a n3 a n
d -0 ttr SI vy?t o^ 3
C 33 3
^ St
Jit 0q ?t
^ d Mtt 3 ^& ot c^H 9u StVji fV C
d-04 ri
?t ri 3 ' Stn ?ti^ I fv
^ d ^9+ ^
«t fVd ?t 3d 04 Kta n if
1 rr 3d fT dd 9t dSt 04 avs- ° 1
C< 99rv (¥3- d d d ®
fV
St ^?>4 d*° 04
?tfv ts-d- mq iiiii' 3
^ ^ d-S c- ?tw- d *^ C r4d tS-s ^ ly{H o< ^r4 nfv ° 3
iffl d "W-3§ <5*- o-'r- itffi nd ^ 94-tf d--A ^ dr< nrr ^ ^
«i Ftd- 304 ^
(V 0
f>4' 9tt^ m Kt^ Kt iffv if 3C?- 3 d"S d do. d nA a 1fut 1 d5ir d ^1^ 3 (V
SI vyq tt• d ^ ot^ ' d
c?^ r*Ijt 9904 >1-
wt54-
i: dO.
9^ I®i£fk m3
Kt ?S- a^
3 ^ 04d ® fvd W c-a if d
0 fffd ^
04 9fr
m ^M 04d m99 3
n n
i:wt 0
d d3 ^
SI 3 ®0. 99 ^C
^ ^ c-c- ^ ft?t ® tvri JjtfV Dr ^99 '9? d S:
nt ^
it 3OB -
Ot 0(V «t 5}tc ^^ m
^ Ft04 nn
35
x'.
eh g jIHTC J; 9
o
vx 5' y
h ^ o f^f-S
I-—ab S (< (cMo (tt)n-5J;-?{c^S
I* C t
<tSt)tl'5o
.^sEbim^nmoi'M^
I ^T, LJ;oo mtcctr-r-
piffl:SC (r^^xt>ti®55-^(±^ c^tr^ijiiLfc^^, C^Cti©^jli75^^oTt-^-2>Ji le o
J; -9 t^:S: ©
i ) © @ (± C © J;
(a
4' & 4 t> 4
i^o Lt&^l, ^3S©^i'l5lm:S:icfci,^-r(arp^^®f^Mt±di^,'^-c^abi9.
;(i4i^o yifi?^$n4(an{dr, ira3i:ti^<
f>4
^''©"trcb loI C©g?^^f^^©itiii-C(i,
—)l56^(iiV^oro^©a:-p44o©^M^®i9lS
HI®Pa1©Kl^v^
^^6^-^4{an{df4 b4Uo
• T'-^'
. c:nii4^i^oi. (ai;i6©2^(cMLrti|S0^(i;f^gTi59 C^UFI:^
lf(c3^g©M^.'^-.'u4i-j!)^ab5©-eaSc)o 3#g© m^Wc.t>ti^Um.
;(ft?lK)j c^^(it^a,|:^^^lc^tn■
5i©oia3!)^
^■Ocfc9 4^4tn:iS
ISS
(±^^fe-5:i>^t>Ln4ie^ ©
2g
m®
^>.
Mljt^
(<h < ic
l^i 4-2.^:^:60
4^fe
©T
•4^ttl{^4
^>4
l^o
iii
(V
o. 53F«v
d 3c?- •
^I -
^ tH
1§SS 4H^ 5ff
^ Q t=H S^ c M
if 53f Mil yim 3fi
3 r 4if rur
-e- ?3 © f-'
m d C"
St- ga ✓-V 94,
9+ \M ©
y? o« nuR rt
?0 s»
-fRa
n CMmu
4J- 53- rt53- m Ittt 14 d 53-
CM (Vc
^3-St-CM
#
CM0
30
-9- fi fT
7' © d
sa y?(S^ D>C
3 94 d d
3<-
—,<'
<s^ 6- IS (M
3 Wi Pr
(S^ (V
wv ;j^ ?S
^ m mTi T<M 'h <$^o- 0 3
A H ^fw-
dV 3 Q
0^ S hio« ma '
' d<s^
<r d*
o< W-
^ O'p?v m
^ 4w> C |!!ltn
St Pr>4 -
CN O'
m s
S4H :ttl¥ ^1^ mm «a
rv ^•Ott" CM
r< 5?
3 a§9r HO. f? 0
vl' rlIS "S^ CM
n ° fVnH h- :t?^' 4 mCM -r 1^r< Oh <hfV ■!§ CM^ ^ ^d »t ^'utt" "liS i?CM ^ C® S Q
40 -3 o-
^ ^r n(^ O' 0
ts-iffl c?^ r*r Q ^rl d jit^ dv n^ ? D^3 H i^'
Spj ^§t?)IS ©^ (5^a ©rt ©
vi' 32H ifIE ^
3 ^-B- sCS-f-' CM
W- ^
iVr ^tS- CMrl h-S O-CM n
M Mi^ m3 3au[i^ -fl"^ e-
^ m
CM ^^ 4■IS A^ w
# ^nl CM&r °0
rto-
© l-g»t d■i fW"d Cm5v isrt n>» (5*-d Sv
CM0 o<
iS d^ 94-CM nuR
© 1^M Xm ©m m^ mtd 54
d 3^ rt
^ O'A ^d M© 1^^ r<D> o-d-B- CM?■' r<
(V
& fv3 9fnRji v>^ o«
^ (5^S14 vM
m St-# 0^ dSs 5+^ 5??t v3"'
m ss
S asl-sS BP"<n .-H.
0^ -B3 {Vd c-^ do-» -e-O- 17'
Pr ^
O. ^
t«A 53-
d ^St- sfCM j
1 -
O'
d 35? o-ct VJV^ --5^ ^
mCY »OV ^? ^5^ S^vjt "-t;d8»
£i C7-n Duji2t 'm^ t#
^ St-liiit CM3 Prm #1jM. lilt
m w-
dm Mlift w.w- ft-B-<7' Aa> ^
^ St QI IS Ig >4 S^ -Hf^ m i® H1^ Pr eM^ ^ ^^ \ BVi m ^p?v lifk w-
vs- CM
^ fVfV <5^
n 0h- l>vs c?^
m m^ w>m ■—?F 5^n *>t ^fW- n5? tf
Oh isn^ >5f(i ^3 ^n M- as
Cm ^^ g{9t(- ^^ 14pjt- 0im d
>4 C?c r<m fvs p^t-r- 911d 47 n
r^ imSI ^
m^ X^ ©-fCM
r< m4 s" ©
-A rn (VcSv p?vMl ^rt ^h- &•o. rt5? m
IS )mp?v 51;
Pt ^'©© ^ Sil
CM ^>4 0 dg >4 St-4^ d ^s"^ St- "3 •3'n • Q? ®5 © ^5^4
I^? ^
X ^ M
^ n^ ©
1 w-
8 2
I [4d ^St- ^CM ^
© 2rr
sv ri9? 52
,Q w© ia-
O Bllll
>13 ©11^d mKj 1—
M ^a ^m CM^ °14 ilm fd p*w- >t
W; n- ^
Oh a ?$® .<; a
n wPr ^0
d Ss3
l_
r<-4 PrA n
fW- C-5S rt
^ PreM
53 PrC^/ -
pffl 00 wd vs*r-
h- ^d
5? life
?l« o.
t Qp?v ja-41?
Pr ^C
-B-Oh C'
" -S^
d&■ St-^ CM
3^ ft4
d d X^lpTTO
<— -f94 St- V p^v 0 y>
<M © <-*
m wv FTr< QCT s rt I§
~m.-IS IV 11 m FT ■* m
FTR¥
p^ VJm911Vr
0\itnTP
ifn
d if s VIS p^ FT ✓N. p^ 2ffi
vGQSi d p?v
TO
Kj
vT" Oh iil r-94
if
41^3- A S d vS- H R
d w- FT 94 Vj' CMOP
)4d if
o« r< 9
sv VS- Si if V 41
i»}(BP \M r< a vT' d
»
1^o< cj- d St- 0
"k0 l^'m
St-CM
rtPr
CM0
✓s
CH
5F
94,
0K 3 -& mA fj- On © S!? 53-
V;v»
V y^0 -Vt«
mp'VJlTT
FT P^
4H a-Oh if if :S© © V vT' nk hi 91194 Si © 3 Vj' ?s- 5T' m FT if 91! FTO' ii m Sf CM 4 ?f(l
m«v NJ ^4 tHiM
ra )tiiii w
C rt 5: h- vJ ^ 5+; cS' O' ^ ^ iit J ^ ^Ti n rv « fv "(V ai ^ 1: ftn gK n 4 S3= S pi- tV ^ &i i^S 1 ct c 7 IS X^^ o ;i nrr 3 /V 0^- ^ (Vfv ^■ \ -r-c Uk ~ i& ii Hr^" -£j. IS ^ (5^^ S 7 ts ^ jJ' >f ^ S ^ (V° C ? >-5 2! CJ-
ft . K~ ^ ^^ rr ^ n>It ^ ^f>>v ' '- »? ^
St- fv^ Vi
dcO
4.s : ,✓ *• t:
- tfiL mOt ?n d rwj0 25-
i/ft ■ pE
n ft s Or At HtS
■ liiniTjtir n S Q.
i> rt »■ &; tSjJi
>4 nT' d Ot £lil!
;-t-0
i4 54-ft Bi At —,
vyt 2 IS 8 q' X
f f -J 5r^ O ^ ^ m f^ O ^ r^ ^ri O ^ ^^ fii M r^ M^ c S g? s ?L- ^ m s ^ 11- xN 9? n "^ rS f- /tir -w ^j. t> ° » 1 iJ. [> E ^ S;t- > ^ ^^ l> ^ r] ^ ■£^ C f,! Jli
; fT^ ? f S Iri fs . . •■^" ?!! S r- as ^ tl^' j-v ms ^ J1 ^ ^ s i .?I -31 - -5 C ^, J7J 3 -f; ft t>t; tr S? ^ ^ Sj 4 C SBU - A m £:>3. — 4 SI & S n s ^h-- I tt- A} ^' -Si «- -4 *3i rS *5: ' ^^ $ 4 c- =Li; ^ ^1 ^ 5! f X I s ^
z^ Quitft foc 5?Si 5cu(t ^r; OtS ffi^ ^ rrSMik JL! 94-^ 2i? - a-^ 'i . :o
^ ?tCN as:
fv rv
cf^ (?*• 0J>fV C ^sit o.m A runC~ fWr 0r\ ^ Q.
^ r^v ^^ ^ 4
fll8 W- n
^ P
(N Sf "fr
P?1 (N ^iE ft ^f^' l> feifr ^ 4
E^ tXm ^
H ®9>. f? "xT' 0
® w-s c ^
® O. _,Sf 5^ fiiH> ^ ^52 H S
^^ cr- ■-
t sd. ?>45+ S
S S
f\^ rr4
mk +>n IffiH Srr. M
Si's 5+^ -
S>4 15+ ^Ata A^'4 r\
^
# ^ >4
(4 154 g
32:=> -rt-
g ^1 X
S Iar: E5.'^ m
^ ft
4 0rv
A'* rAH air
f S SDiOr d 0ca. SV a^v
^ At W-# C ^f\A d -g-^ ;n r-0
,>t 4St m
~ ^ -2-
- S S■< > ^^ rT g
^ «sK n p!4: 4 1fL ' ^r- ■< N
SS- 13 >44 ^ ^
o
n [5 "s m td.ins a-Jcn ss- cs ri- (4
o
ot ^S »
CiJ- 0*
?t -s-
^ a>4 ^-7-
o"3 512
ft sS Ot>4 0-
d' ^55P Ott^ ^SS- 'Cn A»01 a
^ &
# dt' c4■§> 0^ d4: [4^ m0 riiciji> ^
9-r c.
S l=i-^ 0
fv™ tj.
LW «
^ P-i^^ fM- a^ 1^ r^" ^# ft<^1
g fv^ -ffl
auii
^ mQ
a- w>M Q n
^ dt^
n w-^ «vft
ff ^^ (?^^ c-
r4 °0* s*-
d «>*41
OH a'o. M
m d
a ISft
CN ^^ 4^ o*a §;c^ m0 P
(H
■* n>» -m (VrvS «v
^ wv
m ©3ft a1^ ^(i St-dv \>(i>4 0<
^ Stft r
ft04 04
r4 r<fV fV
^ fVSv >t04 04
a ^
0t_
0 nfS^ a?i- canH 0□llUW M-ft ai4tD rii: dt-
0 ah-
n 0«n
O- *nl ms^^ ISfV ^ft m
^3-' »:ft 4^i: ^ari
r:
a 0?T ftO'
^ ^ 0g t aS ^ ^
m (Vrw-
mr« djj. <-
r4 afV I®:^ ato it
d(H a" m
m am
liiit #d
m '
&■ ^
ft
04 ^° d
otif
4 d ft^ ' &•
n ® ®5 »»■^ ^ 04fH2 ^ ^^ a OH^ d ^
w ts-TO ^ ^
^^ r< tt2; a a^ ^ ®I 1 ^s 4ffit a
^ ftg 4) 4)^ ^ ISd -t!? 3St- ® ii5^ ^ ^
32w- 4$ aft f; (?^^ ^ a^ 0^ n^ 1^ St-
<5^ 4 ft0 d4 B> r4 ft> fV 04> IV r<@ ft V
S ft)[ffl ^i-^ ftSv ^^ mft* s
3 nft V•« 0^ n
• •^ o.n ft
■ C?-
pj> ft^ sV a-
aili ttvl'
^ V
r< D?i
^ 35 d^ K';h. n lud ><^ dWf cv "—rt n Ha ft >d ^ -&t- ft 3504 ^ m® HI ^c ^ -4rt t~ ®J5- ft Vr i: 35d ^- m II1^ ^ V
jf3 m^ 4fV 1^A ^4 ^a 4\S 04
11
5W sva 04
n ftV
>
^ m ^-, ;>4. (w-11^ <H ftU > ^li: Qt rX- V d
v Kf o.m H+"# m ?t■4 ^ V
1$ ^ 5W^ ^s- W>1- X Kfm ^ m^ d ^»r' 04 ftn ° mft 70$ -4
1 1 am BV 1$ FdC ^ Hf0 >!■ m
e ^ Q^ a ft
ft %d ' wt-!¥ d ftW> IIS V a^ d JH!
V ftfl 04
0 r* °ft d
gt ^V3
0 ■—d TCT
i sfi
? ®
4hr OH>St ^^ aft Va fit-d
H ON®
^ ?t0 W-
d ftt: «v04 n
S «- TO?4 r* i<«>4 D a ^c?^ 2 ^ si:a ^ o« lititV ^ ft ac ^ 1^ ^
9+
n 4i^ Ohfu^ r*ft Vr <5^° dr* w-
^ h-O' O'
^ °a Vrtt vT'a na ftA 'd 35n JWtJt ft
UK i: SD4 ft W-ON ^ w" [ 1 mm ^ m^ na n^ >h V^ ^ 0li rt dtil> 0 w-n c jHitfr d Hf■tt ft 4«>4 M ^+ ^ M^ ^ m>i ^ 1
^ m "S:ti> ^ Ka s ^
o. ^Bi ^ ^ft ® 3- 5Ct^ o- ^ ^
[ B d^ ^ sv3 3 *>ft ^ o.t¥ ^ °
n S^5 <>4
^m [r (}*^ a r<
k; fv
5 a 'jrt; H ftr 0 o®*
>w n ^S s n
tr+) n ^IS f5t^ >■■ f.M vT- °>^ ^s- n
^ ll' Hfi 1
«v ™
^ r ^
^ m ^^ m m^ ?V -HH ><• ^ 0a 4^ St-
^ IU> CNX c: ^ ®
0 W-S?: >4 ?t& i:r\ s r\Hi & £
✓V ^
^ ig0 d< >4«v ?t ©& 3t?
^ fT 1-^r- St- ^i: «>< ©
© »
>4 'iSt- ®
B & ' ot-d ^ jt r< 0^
d (5*-^ ©
h" c- dQ C St-^ —, CN^ ISr« ^
fV nff
h- Qo< ^m
c^ tJt■»
g&m: ©(H '-A fvw- Tr4 0«St- ^-^ O'
°
Ci -S© n
^ m© m^ JBn3 >+•
-, 0IH> ^ftfe tf-
^ 9?
^ o
©
-B- ^i' IS1^^ Cm rS
tt- 3^
fv n®
fv null ggff 55^ ©_, 4 IJl>r. ^ ^^ W; C?^>4 C IS'n i: WM- © r«^ d ^-B- St- v)
0-* fS5)> o. Sna ^ S
AL.
d -
0?«. ft 0^:: © ft
0 W da 1^^ HIS ^ ^^ (\ ij
^ H© a-fl- ti-C' >1
X £ ^C ^ r<•- ^' ^8 iCf vT'^ f n
^ C ©CN ° ^^ D>
oV 3c \>« H^ ^ O.
«s © n?v (i—I ®ri d ^^
^ ^St- :5i 4lt?t s m
^ r^ ^ dfV W> C^ O-i^ 9? ftr *: %fS ft IS^ ^ §s
ISO. ^ ^ft P^t-ft ^ s^SS ^ o«
S- 5+d h-
n fV
M
\y« r^'
r
^ ^ -4^ life 01
n ®?i- 3tfl ^Oi ^ Q9t 4" Kj
^o< g^in «3- S
^ tt^ &•— 0-4Q nr< (V(V d
Si-
# 'r<
o< r<
1
SI --3M H
m ^>4 ^
^5-riffe ©© ^-B- m$■' n5> S5gS r
"W-
ftk i:
ft^ m
m afeIS ^gs ^> 3
o. L2H- IS ^
^ 1 i>?• iffi i
r\ ti >(?^ n P*CO QV 00 ?t t:>> 0* d\y ® life'Z ^WV Q ^d ^
O'
^ ft dr< w
rr V ft
© d1 (S^^ ^t
© ^
^ ^
r4
(S^ ftrt ^vy ^-4 dA c•< 0^X ^
^ Ap?v o<^ ©w- rr
A Wd fM-
^ diW 'pP
^ ^ r<0 nl ^3-d fitt- deft- rt 1-^>^ k >4<+ ?s ^&* o-fV ° ©2 :i It^ 2 ®^ i m
O 5aSr ^-fFH soL
^ ^2® S S^ ^ t,il w- '^,1 ?•. 4-4 d T^ - 0
mk CA ^
d* ^o. >. txn ott ^
SdJ ^ IPo <4 S
h- 3D)^ )t$l5: 4H($*• ®
i ?>I i
mr r-*
iii ft
k ©
^ m ^© s n^ ^ ^O' 0
ft m dmi © .^m St- 04ft fv aEJ> n dm ^ u^ ^ ftm^ri
tr '
t ^ ^^ ^ >4tx ^ Xr< ^ Zrv 4 5n ^ 5h- r< Io- fv r
[fife 9tV r4© r- 5^
S: * V04 ^ U1r( ht V(V ^(5*- d
m n e^ © St14 # 1m 3 ^© ^ dDJ> © St-§1 St- 04
03
^ rt ^2 d ^f-J fv ^
4 ft■> d ^
rl4 ^ 7^© ^ n^ st-n> iN- d rrI]J^ Oi ^^ d o>© St- gg-^ 1^iji JS-1^ * •a? ^ ESI
1: 4 ^iSB >-3^ ®M -n ^Q ©sj 0 M
"• jni
A ^ ns © ^sj -e- ^s. ^d §t- ^ C04 Qo 4 S?t ^ df; 3 H>4. 14 ^K - P?v S
k ^ ^5 d2 vy 42 €N^ o« r<0 Q fV&•—(?*•© (V •>!^ ^ ^
^ rt M-
d ^ ft* tl- C
>4 ft 0
m m
n Q
Jit Sn 9 h"0 d
r\ ^^ °0 <?^
il OV© ' \>» d )4 'm ' CiA 31? ?^ ii ff' m m
fv X
o. nh- ^O'
a
<s^ ^© m
n S I 9rv t n^ n^ S i•- r ^ ""
^ M S* a IQ 0^- J^ 5
^ 35B S j::^rVr ri^- »
^ rt n %^ J® M^ f^ ■ fe'g S! ^% 1 at^ js-^ d £g UK8^ ffi is n?v at
ii ss."W 1>
OB Pm mw sg ^M Hiol^ h" ^© M, iJ'VI ©□ OD Sft S fX>J w imn c?
C ©tO' e>J
iT' 9tt °>i< d^ ct«i—, A
CO CO I—•
w- ^ -B-fV ^& d ®
©
ij- ^
-V M-^ ?
n
CN
