Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

67
Horst Horst Sievert Sievert , Nina , Nina Wunderlich Wunderlich CardioVascular CardioVascular Center Frankfurt Center Frankfurt Frankfurt, Germany Frankfurt, Germany Future Directions: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Structural Heart Disease Interventions Interventions 15th ANGIOPLASTY SUMMIT 15th ANGIOPLASTY SUMMIT- TCTAP 2010 TCTAP 2010 Seoul, Korea, Seoul, Korea, April 28 April 28- 30, 2010 30, 2010

Transcript of Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Page 1: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Horst Horst SievertSievert, Nina , Nina WunderlichWunderlichCardioVascularCardioVascular Center FrankfurtCenter Frankfurt

Frankfurt, GermanyFrankfurt, Germany

Future Directions: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Structural Heart Disease

InterventionsInterventions

15th ANGIOPLASTY SUMMIT15th ANGIOPLASTY SUMMIT--TCTAP 2010TCTAP 2010Seoul, Korea,Seoul, Korea, April 28April 28--30, 2010 30, 2010

Page 2: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Structural Heart InterventionsStructural Heart Interventions•• ShuntsShunts

-- ASD and PFO closureASD and PFO closure-- VSD closureVSD closure-- Fistula closure Fistula closure

•• ValvularValvular heart diseaseheart disease-- ValvuloplastyValvuloplasty-- ParavalvularParavalvular leak closureleak closure-- Valve repairValve repair-- Valve replacementValve replacement

•• CardiomyopathiesCardiomyopathies-- Dilatation and Dilatation and stentstent

implantation of subimplantation of sub-- and and supravalvularsupravalvular obstructionsobstructions

-- SeptalSeptal ablationablation•• Left Left atrialatrial appendage appendage

closureclosure

•• Heart failureHeart failure-- Catheter treatment of LV Catheter treatment of LV

aneurysmsaneurysms-- LV remodelingLV remodeling-- MonitoringMonitoring

•• Some Some extracardiacextracardiacdiseasesdiseases-- Patent Patent ductusductus closureclosure-- Angioplasty/Angioplasty/stentingstenting of of

coarctationcoarctation-- StentingStenting of pulmonary artery of pulmonary artery

stenosesstenoses-- StentingStenting of pulmonary vein of pulmonary vein

stenosesstenoses-- Pulmonary AV Fistula closurePulmonary AV Fistula closure

•• "Exotic interventions""Exotic interventions"

Page 3: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Structural Heart InterventionsStructural Heart Interventions•• ShuntsShunts

-- ASD and ASD and PFO closurePFO closure-- VSD closureVSD closure-- Fistula closure Fistula closure

•• Valvular heart diseaseValvular heart disease-- ValvuloplastyValvuloplasty-- Paravalvular leak closureParavalvular leak closure-- Valve repairValve repair-- Valve replacementValve replacement

•• Cardiomyopathies Cardiomyopathies -- Dilatation and stent Dilatation and stent

implantation of subimplantation of sub-- and and supravalvular obstructionssupravalvular obstructions

-- Septal ablationSeptal ablation•• Left atrial appendage Left atrial appendage

closureclosure

•• Heart failureHeart failure-- Catheter treatment of LV Catheter treatment of LV

aneurysmsaneurysms-- LV remodelingLV remodeling-- MonitoringMonitoring

•• Some extracardiac Some extracardiac diseasesdiseases-- Patent ductus closurePatent ductus closure-- Angioplasty/stenting of Angioplasty/stenting of

coarctationcoarctation-- Stenting of pulmonary artery Stenting of pulmonary artery

stenosesstenoses-- Stenting of pulmonary vein Stenting of pulmonary vein

stenoses stenoses -- Pulmonary AV Fistula closurePulmonary AV Fistula closure

•• "Exotic interventions""Exotic interventions"

Page 4: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Future Directions in PFO ClosureFuture Directions in PFO Closure•• Indications, reimbursement and use in daily Indications, reimbursement and use in daily

clinical practice will depend on the results of the clinical practice will depend on the results of the randomized trialsrandomized trials-- CLOSURE I to be presented at AHACLOSURE I to be presented at AHA-- PC Trial 2011PC Trial 2011-- If these trials are positive, PFO closure will become If these trials are positive, PFO closure will become

one of the most frequent structural heart interventionsone of the most frequent structural heart interventions-- If these trials are negative, the same will happenIf these trials are negative, the same will happen

•• Technically, there is a trend towards defect Technically, there is a trend towards defect anatomy specific closure techniquesanatomy specific closure techniques-- For example inFor example in--tunnel devicestunnel devices

•• Bioresorbable devices and closure techniques Bioresorbable devices and closure techniques without a device are under developmentwithout a device are under development

Page 5: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Paravalvular Leak ClosureParavalvular Leak Closure

Page 6: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

ParavalvularParavalvular leaks after surgical leaks after surgical valve replacementvalve replacement

•• Are frequentAre frequent-- 12% echo incidence for 12% echo incidence for mitralmitral prosthesesprostheses-- 5% aortic prostheses requiring replacement5% aortic prostheses requiring replacement

•• May cause severe symptomsMay cause severe symptoms-- HemolysisHemolysis, valve insufficiency, valve insufficiency

•• Difficult to treatDifficult to treat-- Mortality for 1Mortality for 1stst redo around 12%redo around 12%-- 22ndnd redo redo 15%15%-- 33rdrd redoredo 35%35%-- Freedom from recurrence less likely with Freedom from recurrence less likely with

each repeat redo operationeach repeat redo operation

Page 7: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

What about What about device closure?device closure?

Experience Experience is very limitedis very limited

Page 8: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

•• Clamshell, CardiosealClamshell, Cardioseal--/ / CardiosealCardioseal--StarflexStarflex

DevicesDevices

•• Difficult!Difficult!•• Not retrievableNot retrievable•• Bad results with Bad results with

Starflex due to the Starflex due to the micromicro--springssprings

Page 9: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

DevicesDevices•• Amplatzer Amplatzer

•• VSD OccluderVSD Occluder•• PDA OccluderPDA Occluder

Page 10: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

What are the Problems?What are the Problems?•• Difficulties to cross the defectDifficulties to cross the defect•• Difficulties to introduce the sheath due Difficulties to introduce the sheath due

to frictionto friction•• Device may cause valve leaflet Device may cause valve leaflet

obstructionobstruction•• Residual leak due to shape of defectResidual leak due to shape of defect•• HemolysisHemolysis•• Delayed tissue coveringDelayed tissue covering•• EndocarditisEndocarditis

Page 11: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

What are What are the future directions?the future directions?

Page 12: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

We now haveWe now have•• SteerableSteerable sheathssheaths

Agilis NxT

Page 13: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

We now haveWe now have•• SteerableSteerable sheathssheaths•• Improved imagingImproved imaging

-- intraintra--cardiac cardiac echocardiopgraphyechocardiopgraphy•• TransTrans--venous venous •• TransTrans--arterialarterial

-- the first generation of 3D TEEthe first generation of 3D TEE•• A dedicated device for A dedicated device for paravalvparavalv leaksleaks

-- and there are more new devices to and there are more new devices to followfollow

Page 14: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

With 3D TEE shape and size of defects With 3D TEE shape and size of defects can be visualized directlycan be visualized directly

Round oval crescentic

Slit-like Crescenticcutting edge

Page 15: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Amplatzer Vascular Plug III

•• OvalOval--shapedshaped•• Thinner wiresThinner wires•• More wiresMore wires•• Multiple layersMultiple layers

ØØ smaller pore sizesmaller pore size

ØØ improved surface improved surface contactcontact

ØØ faster occlusionfaster occlusion

Page 16: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Guiding of the ProcedureGuiding of the Procedure

Opening of LA disc… After rotation..still suboptimal

This could not be imaged with 2D TEE…

Page 17: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions
Page 18: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Even with these new technologies Even with these new technologies paravalvular leak closure is still a paravalvular leak closure is still a difficult and demanding proceduredifficult and demanding procedure

However, procedural However, procedural complications are rare complications are rare ……

…… they usually can be manged by they usually can be manged by catheter techniques catheter techniques ……

…… and reand re--do surgery can still be do surgery can still be performed if necessary performed if necessary ……

Page 19: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

For these reasons catheter For these reasons catheter closure will become the closure will become the primary treatment optionprimary treatment option

Page 20: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Transcatheter Valve RepairTranscatheter Valve Repair

•• Almost the past in the USAlmost the past in the US-- the FDA may need yearsthe FDA may need years

•• Present in EuropePresent in Europe-- Almost routine in selected centersAlmost routine in selected centers

•• Future in AsiaFuture in Asia

Page 21: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions
Page 22: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions
Page 23: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

1.1. GraspingGrasping

MR decreases during clip closure

Page 24: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

before after

Page 25: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

T. Feldman, ACC 2010

Page 26: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

T. Feldman, ACC 2010

Page 27: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

What does that mean?What does that mean?•• The catheter technique is as good as The catheter technique is as good as

surgerysurgery•• Complications are 5 x less frequent as Complications are 5 x less frequent as

with surgery and less severewith surgery and less severe•• This is true for surgical candidates, not This is true for surgical candidates, not

only for high surgical risk patientsonly for high surgical risk patients•• Without question high surgical risk Without question high surgical risk

patients will benefit even more from the patients will benefit even more from the catheter approachcatheter approach

Page 28: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Reduces Reduces diameter of diameter of

annulusannulus

Surgeons usually combine mitral valve leaflet Surgeons usually combine mitral valve leaflet repair with anuloplastyrepair with anuloplasty

Pushes posterior Pushes posterior leaflet forward for leaflet forward for better coaptationbetter coaptation

Page 29: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Percutaneous Mitral RepairPercutaneous Mitral Repair•• AnnuloplastyAnnuloplasty approachesapproaches

-- Coronary sinus Coronary sinus annuloplastyannuloplasty•• Edwards Edwards MonarcMonarc•• Cardiac Dimensions CarillonCardiac Dimensions Carillon•• ViacorViacor Shape Changing RodsShape Changing Rods•• NIHNIH--CerclageCerclage•• St. Jude MedicalSt. Jude Medical•• Ample PS3Ample PS3

-- Direct Direct annuloplastyannuloplasty•• MitralignMitralign SutureSuture--based based PlicationPlication•• Guided Delivery Guided Delivery AccuCinchAccuCinch•• CordisCordis Direct Direct PlicationPlication AnnuloplastyAnnuloplasty•• ReCorReCor Medical Medical •• QuantumCorQuantumCor RF Annulus RemodelingRF Annulus Remodeling•• MiCardiaMiCardia variable size ring (hybrid)variable size ring (hybrid)•• MitralMitral Solutions (hybrid)Solutions (hybrid)

Page 30: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Annuloplasty TechniquesAnnuloplasty Techniques•• Initially problems Initially problems

-- Low efficacyLow efficacy-- Complications due to compression of LCXComplications due to compression of LCX

•• Improved results withImproved results with-- better patient selectionbetter patient selection-- increased operator experienceincreased operator experience-- new devicesnew devices

Page 31: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

The PTMA Implant SystemThe PTMA Implant System

•• PPercutaneousercutaneous subclaviansubclavian accessaccess•• Permanent catheter in the coronary sinus Permanent catheter in the coronary sinus •• NitinolNitinol rods are progressively insertedrods are progressively inserted•• Treatment effect is induced by reTreatment effect is induced by re--shaping shaping

the coronary sinusthe coronary sinus•• Implant can be adjusted or removed Implant can be adjusted or removed •• DDeviceevice action is one of action is one of bendingbending rather rather

cinchingcinching between fixed anchors between fixed anchors

Page 32: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Procedural MR Reduction by TEEProcedural MR Reduction by TEE(PTOLEMY(PTOLEMY--1 Trial: n=13)1 Trial: n=13)

•• No adverse events No adverse events with sequelaewith sequelae

•• < 2 hours < 2 hours procedure timeprocedure time

•• MR reduction in MR reduction in 11/13 patients11/13 patients

Circulation Cardiovascular InterventionsCirculation Cardiovascular Interventions, 2009; 2:227, 2009; 2:227--284 (Sack et al)284 (Sack et al)

Page 33: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

ReCorReCorHigh Frequency UltrasoundHigh Frequency Ultrasound

Guidewire

US Balloon

Catheter

US Energy

•• A balloon catheter is advanced A balloon catheter is advanced via transseptal access into the via transseptal access into the left atriumleft atrium

•• Balloon is inflated with Balloon is inflated with contrastcontrast--water and positioned water and positioned at the mitral annulusat the mitral annulus

•• High Frequency Ultrasound High Frequency Ultrasound (HIFU) is delivered (HIFU) is delivered circumferentially to produce circumferentially to produce tissue heatingtissue heating

•• 5 applications with 805 applications with 80––130 W 130 W for 40for 40--60s60s

•• FIM 25. Feb 2010FIM 25. Feb 2010

Page 34: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

ReCorReCorBalloon position in 3DBalloon position in 3D

Page 35: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

BabicBabic•• Percutaneous Percutaneous

implantation of artificial implantation of artificial chordae tendineaechordae tendineae

Page 36: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

BabicBabic

PrePre--implantimplant PostPost--implantimplant

Page 37: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Lutter Mitral Valve ProsthesisLutter Mitral Valve Prosthesis•• Stent mounted valveStent mounted valve•• TransapicalTransapical•• Animal tests are ongoingAnimal tests are ongoing•• Current trial:Current trial:

-- Accurate positioning in 4/5 pigsAccurate positioning in 4/5 pigs-- 4 pigs completed 7 days follow4 pigs completed 7 days follow--upup-- After 7 days:After 7 days:

•• Correct valve positionCorrect valve position•• Only small transvalvular and LVOT Only small transvalvular and LVOT

gradientsgradients•• No migration or embolismNo migration or embolism•• No LVOT obstructionNo LVOT obstruction

Page 38: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

…… and the future of and the future of mitral valve interventions?mitral valve interventions?

•• We will have to find out which of the many We will have to find out which of the many different approaches do work bestdifferent approaches do work best

•• Those will need improvement and Those will need improvement and refinementrefinement

•• We will have to combine different We will have to combine different techniques like the surgeons dotechniques like the surgeons do

•• At the end, transcatheter techniques will At the end, transcatheter techniques will replace surgery as the primary approach replace surgery as the primary approach not in all but in many patientsnot in all but in many patients

Page 39: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Aortic Valve ImplantationAortic Valve Implantation

Page 40: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

CoreValve & EdwardsCoreValve & Edwards•• Already daily routine in EuropeAlready daily routine in Europe•• > 6000 patients> 6000 patients•• Completely percutaneouslyCompletely percutaneously•• Procedural mortality in many Procedural mortality in many

centers < 3%centers < 3%•• Excellent midExcellent mid--term resultsterm results

Page 41: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Next generation aortic valvesNext generation aortic valves

•• RepositionableRepositionable•• RetrievableRetrievable•• Low profile (< 18 F sheath)Low profile (< 18 F sheath)

Page 42: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Heart Leaflet Technologies

<16 Frretrievable

FIM 2009

Page 43: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Jena ValveJena ValveUnique design:Unique design:Prosthesis is "grabbing" Prosthesis is "grabbing" the native leafletsthe native leaflets

SelfSelf--expandingexpandingRepositionableRepositionablePorcine, equine or Porcine, equine or bovine bovine

Transapical human Transapical human implantations have been implantations have been performedperformed

Page 44: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

…… and the future of transcatheter and the future of transcatheter aortic valve implantation?aortic valve implantation?

We will be able to (almost) We will be able to (almost) completely replace completely replace

conventional surgery!conventional surgery!

And I hope very much that we can do this And I hope very much that we can do this together with and not against the surgeonstogether with and not against the surgeons

Page 45: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Structural Heart Interventions Structural Heart Interventions in Heart Failure Patientsin Heart Failure Patients

•• Acute heart failureAcute heart failure-- Assist devicesAssist devices

•• Chronic heart failureChronic heart failure-- MonitoringMonitoring-- Percutaneous treatment Percutaneous treatment

•• Cardiac assist devicesCardiac assist devices•• Epicardial techniquesEpicardial techniques•• Intraventricular approachesIntraventricular approaches

Page 46: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Structural Heart Interventions Structural Heart Interventions in Heart Failure Patientsin Heart Failure Patients

•• Acute heart failureAcute heart failure-- Assist devicesAssist devices

•• Chronic heart failureChronic heart failure-- MonitoringMonitoring-- Percutaneous treatment Percutaneous treatment

•• Cardiac assist devicesCardiac assist devices•• Epicardial techniquesEpicardial techniques•• Intraventricular approachesIntraventricular approaches

Page 47: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Heart Failure: Monitoring Can Heart Failure: Monitoring Can Reduce HospitalizationsReduce Hospitalizations

p(a) % DeclineMeasureMedtronic COMPASS Trial: 274 pts, Class 3 & 4

Reduction in heart failurehospitalizations and ER Visits

ê 21%p=0.33

Reduction in heart failure hospitalizations ê 36%p=0.03

Reduction in heart failure hospitalizations: Class 3 patients

p=0.06 ê 36%

-10

0

10

20

30

40

-7 -6 -5 -4 -3 -2 -1

Days Relative to EventRecoveryBaseline

HospitalizationPressure Change%

ChangePressure

Pressure in heart increases before adverse events

Source: Journal of the American College of Cardiology, Adamson PB et al. J Am Coll Cardiol.2003; 41: 565.

(a) p values less than 0.05 are considered statistically significant.

Page 48: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

CardioMEMSCardioMEMSDelivery System and Sensor DesignDelivery System and Sensor Design

• Implantable sensor• Measures the

pressure in the pulmonary artery

HF Sensor Design:Length: 15mmWidth: 3.5mmHeight: 2.0mmWire Loops: 1cm diameterTotal Length with Loops: 4.5cmWire Loop Function:

- Maintain alignment with vessel- Prevent distal embolization

TargetImplant

Site

Page 49: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Patient Home Electronics UnitPatient Home Electronics Unit

Page 50: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Trend Data

Discrete Data

Patient Data Viewed on Secure WebPatient Data Viewed on Secure Web

• Real-time• Daily access• Physician alerts• Home transmissions

Page 51: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Structural Heart Interventions Structural Heart Interventions in Heart Failure Patientsin Heart Failure Patients

•• Acute heart failureAcute heart failure-- Assist devicesAssist devices

•• Chronic heart failureChronic heart failure-- MonitoringMonitoring-- Percutaneous treatment Percutaneous treatment

•• Cardiac assist devicesCardiac assist devices•• Epicardial techniquesEpicardial techniques•• Intraventricular approachesIntraventricular approaches

Page 52: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

MardilMardil’’s BACE Systems BACE System•• Silicone band with inflatable Silicone band with inflatable

chambers placed around LVchambers placed around LV•• Surgically implanted (minimal Surgically implanted (minimal

invasive or open chest)invasive or open chest)•• Can be remotely adjusted after Can be remotely adjusted after

implantationimplantation•• Can be removedCan be removed•• FIM:FIM:

•• N = 11 N = 11 •• Mean reduction in MR > 2.5Mean reduction in MR > 2.5•• Improvement in heart failureImprovement in heart failure•• No device related AEsNo device related AEs

Page 53: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Dor ProcedureDor ProcedureAneurysm ResectionAneurysm Resection

•• Reduces the LV size Reduces the LV size -- reduces LV wall stressreduces LV wall stress

•• Improves contractility of remote myocardiumImproves contractility of remote myocardium

Athanasuleas CL et al, JACC 2004

Page 54: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

VPDVPD--ImplantImplant•• First device designed First device designed

to treat LV wall to treat LV wall abnormalities by abnormalities by catheter techniquescatheter techniques

•• UmbrellaUmbrella--like like occlusive membrane occlusive membrane with a nitinol framewith a nitinol frame

•• 2 mm long anchors2 mm long anchors•• Two sizes (75/85mm)Two sizes (75/85mm)•• Introduced through a Introduced through a

14 F sheath14 F sheath

16 struts with 2mmlong anchors

Page 55: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Case ExampleCase Example

BALLOON INFLATION TO EXPAND DEVICE

FULL DEPLOYMENT

Page 56: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

CAUTION: Investigational device. Limited by US law to Investigational Use.This Material Copyrighted and Confidential.

Efficacy: NYHA Class

2,4

1,3

0

1

2

3

4

before 6 months

P<0.01%

Page 57: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

CAUTION: Investigational device. Limited by US law to Investigational Use.This Material Copyrighted and Confidential.

Efficacy: Six-Minute Walk

367

394

340

360

380

400

before 6 months

P<0.02%

Page 58: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Left Atrial Appendage Left Atrial Appendage ClosureClosure

Page 59: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Watchman DeviceWatchman Device•• Nitinol frameNitinol frame•• PET membranePET membrane•• row of fixation row of fixation

barbs around the barbs around the mid perimeter mid perimeter

•• 21, 24, 27, 30, 33 21, 24, 27, 30, 33 mmmm

CE markCE mark

Page 60: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Protect AFProtect AF(System for Embolic (System for Embolic PROTECTPROTECTion ion in Patients in Patients with with AAtrial trial FFibrillation)ibrillation)

•• MulticenterMulticenter•• Prospective randomizedProspective randomized•• WATCHMAN vs coumadin 2:1WATCHMAN vs coumadin 2:1•• NonNon--inferiority trialinferiority trial•• 800 pts (enrollment closed June 2008)800 pts (enrollment closed June 2008)•• > 900 patient> 900 patient--yearsyears

Page 61: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

0,8

0,9

1,0

0 365 730 1.095

WATCHMANWATCHMANWATCHMAN

ControlControl

Primary Efficacy EndpointPrimary Efficacy EndpointFreedom from Stroke, Death, Systemic EmbolizationFreedom from Stroke, Death, Systemic Embolization

Event-free probabilityEvent-free probability DaysDays

LAA closure not inferior to anticoagulationLAA closure not inferior to anticoagulation

Page 62: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

All StrokeAll Stroke

2,3

3,2

0

1

2

3

4

Warfarin LAA Closure

P<0.05P<0.05Events/100 patient years

28%

Page 63: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Hemorrhagic StrokeHemorrhagic Stroke

0,1

1,6

0

1

2

Warfarin LAA Closure

P<0.05P<0.05

Events/100 patient years

94%

Page 64: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

MortalityMortality

3

4,8

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

Warfarin LAA Closure

P<0.05P<0.05Events/100 patient years

38%

Page 65: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

Future Directions?Future Directions?

Page 66: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

PROTECT AFPROTECT AFMost of us did not realize yet that Most of us did not realize yet that this was a trial with patients who this was a trial with patients who

can take anticoagulationcan take anticoagulation

Left atrial appendage closure will Left atrial appendage closure will become the primary treatment in become the primary treatment in

patients with atrial fibrillationpatients with atrial fibrillation

Page 67: Future Directions: Structural Heart Disease Interventions

70 Million worldwide70 Million worldwide