Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic...

38
MatWind2011 May 15-16, 2011, Cairo, Egypt Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performance Karam Y. Maalawi National research Centre Mechanical Engineering Department

Transcript of Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic...

Page 1: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced

MatWind2011

May 15-16, 2011, Cairo, Egypt

Functionally Graded Material Blades with

Enhanced Aeroelastic Performance

Karam Y. Maalawi

National research Centre

Mechanical Engineering Department

Page 2: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced

Main Aim of This PresentationImprovement of aeroelastic stability ofcomposite blades using FGM s concept.

Simplified model of a composite tapered bladeis analyzed, where the composition of thematerial of construction is optimized usingeither continuous or discrete variations ofvolume fractions along the blade length.

The major aim is to tailor the materialdistribution in the spanwise direction so as tomaximize the critical wind speed at which bladefailure might occur without the penalty ofincreasing structural mass.

Page 3: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced

What is FGM ?

FGMs may be defined as advancedcomposite materials that fabricated to havegraded variation of the relative volumefractions of the constituent materials.

Example: A composite material made from a

mixture of ceramic and metal. Ceramicprovides high temperature resistancebecause of its low thermal conductivitywhile metal secures the necessary strengthand stiffness.

Page 4: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced

Material Grading

Page 5: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced

Production of laminated Composites

The knowledge on processing methods forpolymer FGMs is limited.

Long-fiber reinforced polymers with gradedcomposition can be produced by laminationtechniques.

The resins are redistributed between theprepreg layers during molding.

Page 7: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced
Page 8: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced
Page 9: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced

Design variables

- Properties of fibers and resins

-No. of layers.

-Thickness of each layer.

-Fiber orientation in each layer.

-Fiber volume fraction in each layer.

o90

o60

o90

o0

o0

o0

o0

o60

o60

o60

Page 10: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced

12/07/1432 Lamination Theory 10

y

z

x

Exploded view of a [+60/0/-60] quasi-isotropic laminate

Page 11: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced

)x-1( p

Power-law model:

Vf(x)=Vfr

Page 12: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced

Material grading.The physical and mechanical properties areallowed to vary lengthwise, yielding to gradingof the material in the direction of the bladeaxis. Assuming no voids are present, we have:

Volume fractions : VA(x) + VB(x) =1

Mass density : (x) = VA(x) A + VB(x)

B

Young’s Modulus : E(x) = VA(x) EA+ VB(x) EB

Page 13: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced

Shear Modulus

+)G/G(

1-)G/G(= ,

V-1

V+1G=G

mf

mf

f

fm12

G=f1 G12

Page 14: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced

Advantages of Fabricating Blades from Composites

Higher stiffness-to-weight ratio.

Superior fatigue characteristics.

Corrosion resistant.

Material anisotropy provides direct bending-axial-torsion elastic coupling.

Use of aeroelastic tailoring to improve rotor blade design.

Page 15: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced

Optimization

is the art of obtaining best policies to satisfy

certain objectives, at the same time satisfying

fixed requirements.

Design Optimization is the process for the

selection of the best choice from among all

possible designs that are available.

Page 16: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced

General Statement of theOptimum Design Problem.

Find the set of design variables Xnx1 that will

Minimize Fi (X) , I=1,2,…k Subject to

Gj(X) 0 , j=1,2,………I

Gj(X) = 0 , j=I+1,I+2,….m

Integrated formulation (FEM)

[K]{U}={P} [K]{U}-{P}={0}

Page 17: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced

Design Optimization Packages

FE Software are developed including optimization capabilities.

CONMIN _ NASTRAN _ ANSYS

ASTROS _ GENESIS _ ABACUS

MATLAB Optimization Tool Box

Optimization routines are made available as MATLAB M-files.

The user supplies the Objective function and constraints information to the tool box as M-files.

www.mathworks.com/access/helpdesk/help/toolbox/optim

Page 18: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced

Multi-Objective Optimization

Design Objectives of an Advanced Blade

High Power

Coeff.

High

Stiffness/Weight

Low vibration

Long fatigue life

Page 19: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced

The Optimal Design Problem

Stiffness.wWeight.w)XF( .Min 2f1f

? w

? w

f2

1f

Weight minimization and Stiffness maximization

Page 20: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced

The Optimal Frequency Problem

ii

fiw)XF( .Max

XXX

MM

UL

0

Natural frequencies are the most representative of the overall Stiffness/Weight level of the blade structure

Subject to

Page 21: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced

Resonance avoidance

XXX

M Mto Subject

)(w)XF( .Min

UL

o

2*i

iifi

Page 22: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced

Aeroelastic Optimization

Aeroelasticity is the study of the effect ofaerodynamic loads on elastic bodies.

Aeroelasticity is one of the most importantconsiderations in aerospace industry.

When the energy of the flow is rapidlyabsorbed by the structure, violent vibrationswith rapidly increasing amplitude occur,which might cause structural dynamicinstability termed as Flutter.

Page 23: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced
Page 24: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced

An illustration: Blade divergence

Page 25: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced

The rotation of the airfoil, and theconsequent twisting of the blade, is afunction of the airspeed.

Structural failure Xe

UD

U

Elastic twist vs wind speed

Page 26: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced

Aeroelastic Phenomena

When the wind speed exceeds a certain value calleddivergence speed, Vdiv, the aerodynamic twist momentapplied to the blade exceeds the restoring elastic momentof its structure.

This causes static torsional instability of the blade, whichmay twist to failure.

Therefore, high divergence speed can be regarded as amajor aspect in designing an efficient blade with enhancedtorsional stability.

Page 27: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced

Max. Divergence Speed

•Maximization of the divergence speed can have other

desirable effects on the overall structural design.

•It helps in avoiding the occurrence of large displacements,

distortions and excessive vibrations, and may also reduce

fretting among structural parts, which is a major cause of

fatigue failure .

•A solution that can be promising to enhance aeroelastic

stability of composite blades is the use of the concept of

functionally graded materials , FGMs.

Page 28: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced
Page 29: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced

The associated Eigenvalue Problem

0=

Boundary Conditions

at x=b 0=x∂

∂GJ

at x=0

0=)x(eaCV2

1+)

xd

dGJ(

xd

d1

22

11

Page 30: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced

Considering tapered blade with thin-walled airfoil section

)x̂-1(C=C o

)x̂-1(h=h o

L

xx̂

)Δ-1(=

)x̂-1(hC∝J4

o3o

Page 31: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced

I-Continuous linear model

Power Series Solution

)x(λ∑C=)x(α m

2

1=mm

∑ )x(a=)x(λ∞

m=n

1-nn,mm

m=1, 2 (n m)

y

)ya2(YA-

y

)ya2(JA=)y(

k22

k21

II-Piecewise model

Bessel’s function method

Page 32: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced

Case Study

Page 33: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced

Linear distribution of V(x)

Page 34: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced

Piecewise model: 2-panel blade

Page 35: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced

Combined Material and Thickness Grading

Page 36: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced
Page 37: Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced Aeroelastic Performancecam.bue.edu.eg/Presentations/16 May 2011/01-Session... · Functionally Graded Material Blades with Enhanced

CONCLUSIONS

Efficient model for enhancing aeroelastic stability ofa wind turbine blade using FGM has been formulated.

Exact solutions have been given analytically usingBessel’s function method.

The model formulation is independent on the size ofthe rotor, blade geometry and type of material.

Extension of this work shall consider simultaneousgrading in both thickness and span directions.