FS surveys030911
-
Upload
lisa-schnellinger -
Category
Documents
-
view
214 -
download
0
Transcript of FS surveys030911
-
8/6/2019 FS surveys030911
1/18
-
8/6/2019 FS surveys030911
2/18
2011 Public Hearing
12 financial quarterly
13 you got it started Tuesday different
14 monthly different
15 nothing monthly evenings
16 share opinions monthly different
17 talked to everyone nothing none different
Annual 2
Monthly 7 g'ville 3
Tuesday 1 local 1
very well facilitated,started timely, stayedfocused on agenda
weekdayevenings
differentlocations- G'villetoo far
have more usergroups at meeting
twice ayear
we drove for 1 1/2hour not sure what weaccomplished
more specifictopics than"generalprincipals"
need to be morespecific
presidents of eachuser group
weekdayevenings
had the goal andprincipals alreadydeveloped, hadmultiple discussion
groups w/ facilitators
ensure thatresources arecommitted to finish
this process
In Tellico RangerDistrict horse riedrsand hikers workunselfishly on each
others trails
locallyorientedlike first
meeting
ask reps fromusers groups tospeak
OHV use will bepushed to the side
provide moreinformation aboutdates and times
weekdayevenings
put out lots ofnotice
as oftenaspossible
weekdayevenings
wevenings
13
differentlocations
10wafternoons2
Quarterly6
As oftenasPossible 1
noanswer 2
-
8/6/2019 FS surveys030911
3/18
2011 Public Hearing
A. Survey
1 smaller groups different
2 you listened
also mission approach such as school breaks, paying to work in our mtns - like parts of the west
3 funds! Or lack therof
4 different
5 monthly different
6 different
What did we doright?
What would youchange or add
Concerns for future ofproject
how can we make this
process morecollaborative
Howoftenshouldweschedulefuture
meetings
when
shouldwe meet
where
shouldwe meet
breakoutsessions
timing to continue toconclusion
imput from all usergroups
quarterly
evenings
already determinedagenda - in this caseyour support willevaporate
ask groups to go backand asnwer the questionsand formally answer forgroup
asneeded
weekdayevenings
singlelocation
ge user ypes
to betterunderstandeach other
slow down pace forpeople that do wantto stay longer
organized,thought out
microhone, breakoutby user groups,begin at 6:30 toallow for more time
keep stakeholdersinformed and engaged
mechanism for moreinteraction andrelationship buildingamong user groups -Team Conasauga
dependson groupsize
weekdayevenings
condensed afterdiscussions
contribute and ifthese aredesignated tocertain areas orinterests
not allowing 1organization or groupto control
weekdayevenings
well organized,managed toavoid pettygriping, FS isreally listeningand wanting tomake
improvements
whether we canimplement proposedchanges, can the fundsbe raised for future
projects
FS needs to assignspecific personnel tospecific user groups/clubsto keep communication
going
quarterl
y
weekdayevening
s
-
8/6/2019 FS surveys030911
4/18
2011 Public Hearing
volunteer hours should not be transferred into dollars/financial
7 action
8 somewhat right clean up the trails better monthly different
9 everything nothing do not know time use monthly different
10 kinda not much monthly different
11 more time monthly
12
13 fair imput
14 nothing
15 monthly different
16
17 different
greatlyorganized, funtoo
only if we had moretime
the same horse trailsopen
evenings
s
losing access to moretrails
make meetings availableto a specific discipline oftrail users
yevenings
formalizedprocess workedwell
there are people whoare very contentouswith ea other. Theywere cool tonight, buteventually it may comeout.
I can't think of one. Thiswas good
weekdayevenings
doesn'tmatter
facilitatorsexcellent
collaboration is goodbut ATVs still mess upthe trails
yevenings
groupparticipationwas very good
keep goodcommunication open
bringingeveryone
together, lots ofFS staff there
actually implementsome of the ideas
that came up at themeeting
nothing will be donedifferent - that you
dont tap into the greatresource of people
have an elected users
council with reps fromeach user's group
weekday
evenings
shared, I got alot of good ideas
better facility forsize of group. Soundsystem
to sift through all dataand focus on bestideas, solutions
FS coordinate thru repsfrom different groups
facilitators tokeep meetingon task
groups too large,preview what groupsare for/expectations
how to get the variousgroups to worktogether
have multiuser volunteerdays/programs
quarterly
wee ayevenings
-
8/6/2019 FS surveys030911
5/18
2011 Public Hearing
18 money different
19
19 everything
20 microphone please funds! Or lack therof annually different
21 local
22 aggressive people different
Local 1
Single 1
blank 7 blank 7
gathered imput,provide emailadedress topermit follow upsuggestions
various groupsintroducethemselves
establish advisory groupof reps from various clubs
quarterly
weekdayevenings
good job, wellrun meeting.Thanks
roads not trails, are not
intended for use, LEappears to have freereignsee entirediscussion
you guys did anauesome job
good facilitation,discussionsbroad enough toavoid boggingdown in details
work throughorganizations to educateusers
weekdayevenings
bringingeveryonetogether,
too much time onmission statement
closing trails - weshould come up with afuture plan from short -long term goals
communication betweenall user groups
quarterly
weekdayevenings
everything wasgood, and onthe right track
we have volunteerswe just need an easyok to go out and domaintinance
hoping things will getdone like what was saidby all users
quarterly
weekdayevenings
evening13
different11
-
8/6/2019 FS surveys030911
6/18
2011 Public Hearing
A. Survey
1 monthly
2 Guiding Principles quarterly
3 bi-yearly different
What did we doright?
What would
you change oradd Concerns for future ofproject
how can we make this
process morecollaborative
How oftenshould weschedule
futuremeetings
when
should wemeet
where
should wemeet
bringing alldifferent groupstogether;Listening to whatwe had to say;clarification ofquestions andstaying on track
more grouptime; moretime forindividuals tospeak ontopics
educating, sustainability,maintenance, practicing"leave no trace," supportingall groups, clarifyingprinciples and missions, alot of people use sharedtrails
more meetings,involving the people indecision regarding ournational forests, takingsuggestions to hears,being more open tosupport All groups
haveoptions -peoplecan'talwaysmake it toone of theother
differentlocations -everyoneis sospread out
Questions forthe groupswere vagueand confusing
long term funding thru gov'tand private; conflictresolution amoung groups
ask the local forestlevel to involve usersin yearly projet plans
afternoons
never hold
a meetingin this godawful hardto findplace
giving everybodya chance to voiceopinions
larger area -difficult tohear whilegroupsdiscussed
weekendafternoons
-
8/6/2019 FS surveys030911
7/18
2011 Public Hearing
4 different
5 g'ville
6 hikers and forest watch social media vary different
7 monthly weekends different
by having themeeting itselfand lettingpeople talk
it was toonarrowlyfocused, esp.with groupsquestions andtoo muchemphasis on
volunteerconcernsinstead ofconcern ofdecreasedFederalfunding
we need more detailedexperts and options like formore money to get thingsdone
nothing is long-termabout funding andreemphasize thatNational parks belongto the people, notsubject to decreasedfunding
reshedulemeetings
whenthingscan bedone notjusttalkedabout
either oralternate
express interestin our needs andopinions; provideforum for publicopinion
appoint FS repto each focusgroup to keepgroup onsubject
that concerns expressed byuser groups are notregarded as same as FSobjectives and are notgiven importance
communicate moreclosely to groupliasion/rep; meet sepwith different usergroups
monthlyor bi-monthly
afternoons
interactive; gotuser groupstogether
George'ssummaryprovided some
closure; mixed,shuffled groupsvery good
the paceseemed alittle frantic,but I know wemusn't askpeople to stay
too long - 20min perquestion?
can we see a specificmeasurable goal?
I think you're bendingover backwardsalready
-
8/6/2019 FS surveys030911
8/18
2011 Public Hearing
8 nothing
9
thanks for allyour efforts;offered multiplemeetings somore couldattend, meetingwas veryorganized
length of time to implementthe outcome, how long willit take?
I amunable toparticipate due tosomemanypriorcommitments, iffuturemeetingsweredone onskype oras awebinarthat mayhelp withbusy folksand cutdown onfuel costsand time
George's intro;move to a largerroom; friendlyattitude; it's goodfor us to be withother users likethis, even tho wedon't always likeit!
don't put theon thing weneed to keepon the back of
the one thingwe turn in;opportunityfor those whodo poorly inthis facilitatedstyle ofmeeting tooffer input -only theassertive win
I see a real loss of valuableinput with this style ofmeeting, it is okay to useonce, but as an educator, Isee many whose input isleft out - I know them andknow what they say isvaluable
USFSshouldsay
weekdayevenings
dependson howmanypeoplewant tocome andhow muchtime USFShas to dothis
-
8/6/2019 FS surveys030911
9/18
2011 Public Hearing
10 different
11
12 monthly weekends different
13 clarity of purpose funds quarterly different
14 by district
15 different
16 you have started! different
17 bi-yearly different
I would like tohear moreinformation fromyou
example oftrails thatneed workand exampleof trails thatare good
closure of the OHV trails isunacceptable
I would like to seemore public cleanupsat Beaslie Knob
semi-annually
either oralternate
that the plan truly protects
the flore and fauna of theforest
weekdayevenings
holding openmeeting
get the wordout about themeeting
making trails only for onegroup
one central hub forvolunteers
ideas to discussbeforehand
weekendafternoons
facilitators -moving thru the
process; location- comfortable.Engagingquestions
trying to please all groupsat expense of forest
use team conassaugaas an example forother groups andforest districts
every 6weeks
SaturdayAm
conducted themeeting
provide amethod tocapture allinputs fromusers to startthe process
not sustainable b/c the FS isnot making long-termcommitments to provideaccess to every user group
include all roads andtrails in the inventorywhich existed whenthe GA nat'l forestswere created (i.e.,leverage what alreadyexists)
every 1-2months
weekendsand someweeknights
involving more people - getthe word out
social networks;facebook/twitter
asneeded -based onprogression
weekendafternoons
good leadershipand organizationof discussion
could lead to moreregulation of trail use
concentrate on usergroups to getinvolvement in this aswell as volunterism
weekendafternoons
-
8/6/2019 FS surveys030911
10/18
2011 Public Hearing
18 monthly different
19
making effort tostart dialong;breakout groupsa good idea
that it would not effectpositive change as intended
more actively pursueparticipation
weekdayevenings
ask for input frompeople; give
people change totalk
instructionsfor 1st groupwere not
clear; notenough time
what will happen toinformaiton collected? Whatis next step? Need more
clarification on definitions ofguiding principles
-
8/6/2019 FS surveys030911
11/18
2011 Public Hearing
Clarkesville
8-Mar-11
A. Survey
1 different
2 different
3 organized quarterly different
4
What did we doright?
What would youchange or add
Concerns forfuture of project
how can we makethis process morecollaborative
Howoftenshouldweschedulefuturemeetings
whenshouldwe meet
whereshould wemeet
small gp wasgreat
collaboration oftrailmaintenance
every 6-9months
weekdayevenings
good interaction
b/t gps
definingsustainabilityand getting buy-in from formal
group
bi-
monthly
weekday
evenings
time limit questionsand answers
hope itcontinues
different usergroups don'talways understandother group needsand concerns,maybe a shortsession on userneeds
weekdayevenings
interactivity andgroupcommunicationvia the miniprojects wasexcellent
mission statement
and principles werewritten great andcovered asatisfactory sert ofgoals and rules, letfolks know there arenot succinct laws sothat time isn'twasted with nonproductive questions
any kind ofsegratationwithin the trailsystem. If itcannot beavoided, iet it beequal
education on traildesign,construction andmaintenance
monthlyandorganized specialeventsthroughyear
weekdayevenings
one centrallocation
-
8/6/2019 FS surveys030911
12/18
2011 Public Hearing
5 monthly clarkesville
6 monthly either
7
8 good job! quarterly gainesville
9 gainesville
10 fine as it is quarterly gainesville
good guidingprinciples
participants shouldbe prepared beforemeeting so morethought can be putinto issues; domailout or useinternet
look forward togetting greatresults, withmuchparticipation
weekdayevenings
opportunity foreveryone to havea voice
thought this was agood first step
money,collabortaion b/tall groups and FSunwillingness tocompromise
good facilitation,ground rules, noagendas
if evenings -centrallocation - ifweekend -different
bettercommunication andeducation abouttrails
web portal fortrail information
need more trainingof volunteers,need bettercertification andtraining of
contractors; putlimits oncommercials useof trals and betterregulate andmonitor
included diverseusers and usedfacilitators
continue to usefacilitators
weekdayevenings
great, very open
and really careabout what wassaid
more interactionwith FS person
red tape - makeit faster
more talking withFS persons; chrge
$ to use trails(maybe not forthose that vol.)
everycouple ofmonths
weekdayevenings
good discussionand had all usergroupsrepresented
long time tocompletion
-
8/6/2019 FS surveys030911
13/18
2011 Public Hearing
11 internet monthly different
12 $$$ monthly gainesville
13
14 quarterly gainesville
15 monthly gainesville
16 different
17 different
18 quarterly different
small groups;smaller groupsyield moreproductivesuggestions
moving it alongin a productivemanner
weekdayevenings
having these
meetings
smaller more
focused groups
break out groupswith FS personnel
at each group
weekday
eveningsgreat opportunityto meet withother groups andthe FS
failure toimplement
asneeded
weekdayevenings
depends onneeds
weekdayevenings
you stayed onschedule andkept the
conversation andcommentsmoving
make it clear where
to look for asummary of these 5meetings
That it willwither away on a
shelf. Please seethis initiative toconclusion
have regularlyscheduled
"listening"sessions forinterested groups
weekdayevenings
veryprofessionallydone but totallydifferent fromwhat I expected,was hoping formore localizedinformation
maintainingenthusiasm
lots ofcommunication -internet
bi-monthly
weekdayevenings
Andrea was agreat mediator;enjoyed splittinginto groups
limit of questions;statement perperson
that follow upwill not be done
more and bettercommunication
3-6months
weekdayevenings
bringinginformation tothe public
a greater definitionof terminology
being able toTrack progressand follow theoutcome
disseminate moreinformation aboutbuilding &maintaining whatis considered"sustainable"
weekdayevenings
-
8/6/2019 FS surveys030911
14/18
2011 Public Hearing
19 different
20 gainesville
21 different
22 monthly by district
23 damn fish snacks quarterly gainesville
24 monthly gainesville
25 facilitators
26 gainesville
good effort tobring all usergroups togetherso we could heareeryone'sconcerns
define next step b/tend of meeting
make concertiveeffort to keepinterest alive
by establishing acentralizedcommunicationprocess that allowsfeedback
bi-monthly
weekdayevenings
very organized,everyone wasable to contribute
trailhead parkingshould alsoaccommodatehorse trailers
provide a secure
section of yourwebsite wheredesignated usersfrom designatedorg. can post -
weekdayevenings
good job runningthe meeting withsuch a largegroup
I do fit into agroup of usersbut not in asubgroup suchas CTRA orSORBA - pleasedo not leave outthe individualuser of trails
every 2months
weekdayevenings
that it will lasttoo long
smaller groups - bydistricts
weekdayevenings
weekdayevenings
very well
organized
split people up into
user groups
keep it going, donot let theprogress get
bogged down
split people into
user groups
weekday
eveningstoo many multi-use trails
asking peoplewhat theythought
changing groups soyou will have adifferent
people becomingfrustrated andnot participating
have work daysthat were plannedahed and assignpeople to workstations
every 2months
weekdayevenings
-
8/6/2019 FS surveys030911
15/18
2011 Public Hearing
27 monthly gainesville
28 overall good
29 good structure In time you did well quarterly Saturday in district
30 yes x quarterly different
31
32 quarterly Saturday different
33 different
34 worked well loss of funding quarterly regional
got multi-usegroups togetherand talking toeach other;
providedstructure
change groups foradditionaldiscussion; some
groups had samepeople
people becomingfrustrated andnot continuing toparticipate; wecame andparticipated but
were not offereda Q & A time
offer trainingcourses before thenext meeting;many people wantto get trained andbeat it to death
during thismeeting
weekdayevenings
follow-upinformationaccess
web accessfollowing
weekdayevenings
havingfacilitators keep users onseparate trails
offer moremaintenancetraining to groups
and individuals onthe GATC model
sharing of ideasoutloud
high clearanceneeds - maybeoverlook desires;not know how tostay involved
continue thesetypes of meetings
every thing wasgood
professional leaderat group; wouldspeed up the process
that user groupswould loosetrails and theusers hae
already decidedwhat they aregoing to do
monthly updates -email web -meeting
bi-monthly
weekdayevenings
brought out a lotof ideas
tell us how we canhelp
weekdayevenings
-
8/6/2019 FS surveys030911
16/18
-
8/6/2019 FS surveys030911
17/18
2011 Public Hearing
-
8/6/2019 FS surveys030911
18/18
2011 Public Hearing
Clarkesville