FS surveys030911

download FS surveys030911

of 18

Transcript of FS surveys030911

  • 8/6/2019 FS surveys030911

    1/18

  • 8/6/2019 FS surveys030911

    2/18

    2011 Public Hearing

    12 financial quarterly

    13 you got it started Tuesday different

    14 monthly different

    15 nothing monthly evenings

    16 share opinions monthly different

    17 talked to everyone nothing none different

    Annual 2

    Monthly 7 g'ville 3

    Tuesday 1 local 1

    very well facilitated,started timely, stayedfocused on agenda

    weekdayevenings

    differentlocations- G'villetoo far

    have more usergroups at meeting

    twice ayear

    we drove for 1 1/2hour not sure what weaccomplished

    more specifictopics than"generalprincipals"

    need to be morespecific

    presidents of eachuser group

    weekdayevenings

    had the goal andprincipals alreadydeveloped, hadmultiple discussion

    groups w/ facilitators

    ensure thatresources arecommitted to finish

    this process

    In Tellico RangerDistrict horse riedrsand hikers workunselfishly on each

    others trails

    locallyorientedlike first

    meeting

    ask reps fromusers groups tospeak

    OHV use will bepushed to the side

    provide moreinformation aboutdates and times

    weekdayevenings

    put out lots ofnotice

    as oftenaspossible

    weekdayevenings

    wevenings

    13

    differentlocations

    10wafternoons2

    Quarterly6

    As oftenasPossible 1

    noanswer 2

  • 8/6/2019 FS surveys030911

    3/18

    2011 Public Hearing

    A. Survey

    1 smaller groups different

    2 you listened

    also mission approach such as school breaks, paying to work in our mtns - like parts of the west

    3 funds! Or lack therof

    4 different

    5 monthly different

    6 different

    What did we doright?

    What would youchange or add

    Concerns for future ofproject

    how can we make this

    process morecollaborative

    Howoftenshouldweschedulefuture

    meetings

    when

    shouldwe meet

    where

    shouldwe meet

    breakoutsessions

    timing to continue toconclusion

    imput from all usergroups

    quarterly

    evenings

    already determinedagenda - in this caseyour support willevaporate

    ask groups to go backand asnwer the questionsand formally answer forgroup

    asneeded

    weekdayevenings

    singlelocation

    ge user ypes

    to betterunderstandeach other

    slow down pace forpeople that do wantto stay longer

    organized,thought out

    microhone, breakoutby user groups,begin at 6:30 toallow for more time

    keep stakeholdersinformed and engaged

    mechanism for moreinteraction andrelationship buildingamong user groups -Team Conasauga

    dependson groupsize

    weekdayevenings

    condensed afterdiscussions

    contribute and ifthese aredesignated tocertain areas orinterests

    not allowing 1organization or groupto control

    weekdayevenings

    well organized,managed toavoid pettygriping, FS isreally listeningand wanting tomake

    improvements

    whether we canimplement proposedchanges, can the fundsbe raised for future

    projects

    FS needs to assignspecific personnel tospecific user groups/clubsto keep communication

    going

    quarterl

    y

    weekdayevening

    s

  • 8/6/2019 FS surveys030911

    4/18

    2011 Public Hearing

    volunteer hours should not be transferred into dollars/financial

    7 action

    8 somewhat right clean up the trails better monthly different

    9 everything nothing do not know time use monthly different

    10 kinda not much monthly different

    11 more time monthly

    12

    13 fair imput

    14 nothing

    15 monthly different

    16

    17 different

    greatlyorganized, funtoo

    only if we had moretime

    the same horse trailsopen

    evenings

    s

    losing access to moretrails

    make meetings availableto a specific discipline oftrail users

    yevenings

    formalizedprocess workedwell

    there are people whoare very contentouswith ea other. Theywere cool tonight, buteventually it may comeout.

    I can't think of one. Thiswas good

    weekdayevenings

    doesn'tmatter

    facilitatorsexcellent

    collaboration is goodbut ATVs still mess upthe trails

    yevenings

    groupparticipationwas very good

    keep goodcommunication open

    bringingeveryone

    together, lots ofFS staff there

    actually implementsome of the ideas

    that came up at themeeting

    nothing will be donedifferent - that you

    dont tap into the greatresource of people

    have an elected users

    council with reps fromeach user's group

    weekday

    evenings

    shared, I got alot of good ideas

    better facility forsize of group. Soundsystem

    to sift through all dataand focus on bestideas, solutions

    FS coordinate thru repsfrom different groups

    facilitators tokeep meetingon task

    groups too large,preview what groupsare for/expectations

    how to get the variousgroups to worktogether

    have multiuser volunteerdays/programs

    quarterly

    wee ayevenings

  • 8/6/2019 FS surveys030911

    5/18

    2011 Public Hearing

    18 money different

    19

    19 everything

    20 microphone please funds! Or lack therof annually different

    21 local

    22 aggressive people different

    Local 1

    Single 1

    blank 7 blank 7

    gathered imput,provide emailadedress topermit follow upsuggestions

    various groupsintroducethemselves

    establish advisory groupof reps from various clubs

    quarterly

    weekdayevenings

    good job, wellrun meeting.Thanks

    roads not trails, are not

    intended for use, LEappears to have freereignsee entirediscussion

    you guys did anauesome job

    good facilitation,discussionsbroad enough toavoid boggingdown in details

    work throughorganizations to educateusers

    weekdayevenings

    bringingeveryonetogether,

    too much time onmission statement

    closing trails - weshould come up with afuture plan from short -long term goals

    communication betweenall user groups

    quarterly

    weekdayevenings

    everything wasgood, and onthe right track

    we have volunteerswe just need an easyok to go out and domaintinance

    hoping things will getdone like what was saidby all users

    quarterly

    weekdayevenings

    evening13

    different11

  • 8/6/2019 FS surveys030911

    6/18

    2011 Public Hearing

    A. Survey

    1 monthly

    2 Guiding Principles quarterly

    3 bi-yearly different

    What did we doright?

    What would

    you change oradd Concerns for future ofproject

    how can we make this

    process morecollaborative

    How oftenshould weschedule

    futuremeetings

    when

    should wemeet

    where

    should wemeet

    bringing alldifferent groupstogether;Listening to whatwe had to say;clarification ofquestions andstaying on track

    more grouptime; moretime forindividuals tospeak ontopics

    educating, sustainability,maintenance, practicing"leave no trace," supportingall groups, clarifyingprinciples and missions, alot of people use sharedtrails

    more meetings,involving the people indecision regarding ournational forests, takingsuggestions to hears,being more open tosupport All groups

    haveoptions -peoplecan'talwaysmake it toone of theother

    differentlocations -everyoneis sospread out

    Questions forthe groupswere vagueand confusing

    long term funding thru gov'tand private; conflictresolution amoung groups

    ask the local forestlevel to involve usersin yearly projet plans

    afternoons

    never hold

    a meetingin this godawful hardto findplace

    giving everybodya chance to voiceopinions

    larger area -difficult tohear whilegroupsdiscussed

    weekendafternoons

  • 8/6/2019 FS surveys030911

    7/18

    2011 Public Hearing

    4 different

    5 g'ville

    6 hikers and forest watch social media vary different

    7 monthly weekends different

    by having themeeting itselfand lettingpeople talk

    it was toonarrowlyfocused, esp.with groupsquestions andtoo muchemphasis on

    volunteerconcernsinstead ofconcern ofdecreasedFederalfunding

    we need more detailedexperts and options like formore money to get thingsdone

    nothing is long-termabout funding andreemphasize thatNational parks belongto the people, notsubject to decreasedfunding

    reshedulemeetings

    whenthingscan bedone notjusttalkedabout

    either oralternate

    express interestin our needs andopinions; provideforum for publicopinion

    appoint FS repto each focusgroup to keepgroup onsubject

    that concerns expressed byuser groups are notregarded as same as FSobjectives and are notgiven importance

    communicate moreclosely to groupliasion/rep; meet sepwith different usergroups

    monthlyor bi-monthly

    afternoons

    interactive; gotuser groupstogether

    George'ssummaryprovided some

    closure; mixed,shuffled groupsvery good

    the paceseemed alittle frantic,but I know wemusn't askpeople to stay

    too long - 20min perquestion?

    can we see a specificmeasurable goal?

    I think you're bendingover backwardsalready

  • 8/6/2019 FS surveys030911

    8/18

    2011 Public Hearing

    8 nothing

    9

    thanks for allyour efforts;offered multiplemeetings somore couldattend, meetingwas veryorganized

    length of time to implementthe outcome, how long willit take?

    I amunable toparticipate due tosomemanypriorcommitments, iffuturemeetingsweredone onskype oras awebinarthat mayhelp withbusy folksand cutdown onfuel costsand time

    George's intro;move to a largerroom; friendlyattitude; it's goodfor us to be withother users likethis, even tho wedon't always likeit!

    don't put theon thing weneed to keepon the back of

    the one thingwe turn in;opportunityfor those whodo poorly inthis facilitatedstyle ofmeeting tooffer input -only theassertive win

    I see a real loss of valuableinput with this style ofmeeting, it is okay to useonce, but as an educator, Isee many whose input isleft out - I know them andknow what they say isvaluable

    USFSshouldsay

    weekdayevenings

    dependson howmanypeoplewant tocome andhow muchtime USFShas to dothis

  • 8/6/2019 FS surveys030911

    9/18

    2011 Public Hearing

    10 different

    11

    12 monthly weekends different

    13 clarity of purpose funds quarterly different

    14 by district

    15 different

    16 you have started! different

    17 bi-yearly different

    I would like tohear moreinformation fromyou

    example oftrails thatneed workand exampleof trails thatare good

    closure of the OHV trails isunacceptable

    I would like to seemore public cleanupsat Beaslie Knob

    semi-annually

    either oralternate

    that the plan truly protects

    the flore and fauna of theforest

    weekdayevenings

    holding openmeeting

    get the wordout about themeeting

    making trails only for onegroup

    one central hub forvolunteers

    ideas to discussbeforehand

    weekendafternoons

    facilitators -moving thru the

    process; location- comfortable.Engagingquestions

    trying to please all groupsat expense of forest

    use team conassaugaas an example forother groups andforest districts

    every 6weeks

    SaturdayAm

    conducted themeeting

    provide amethod tocapture allinputs fromusers to startthe process

    not sustainable b/c the FS isnot making long-termcommitments to provideaccess to every user group

    include all roads andtrails in the inventorywhich existed whenthe GA nat'l forestswere created (i.e.,leverage what alreadyexists)

    every 1-2months

    weekendsand someweeknights

    involving more people - getthe word out

    social networks;facebook/twitter

    asneeded -based onprogression

    weekendafternoons

    good leadershipand organizationof discussion

    could lead to moreregulation of trail use

    concentrate on usergroups to getinvolvement in this aswell as volunterism

    weekendafternoons

  • 8/6/2019 FS surveys030911

    10/18

    2011 Public Hearing

    18 monthly different

    19

    making effort tostart dialong;breakout groupsa good idea

    that it would not effectpositive change as intended

    more actively pursueparticipation

    weekdayevenings

    ask for input frompeople; give

    people change totalk

    instructionsfor 1st groupwere not

    clear; notenough time

    what will happen toinformaiton collected? Whatis next step? Need more

    clarification on definitions ofguiding principles

  • 8/6/2019 FS surveys030911

    11/18

    2011 Public Hearing

    Clarkesville

    8-Mar-11

    A. Survey

    1 different

    2 different

    3 organized quarterly different

    4

    What did we doright?

    What would youchange or add

    Concerns forfuture of project

    how can we makethis process morecollaborative

    Howoftenshouldweschedulefuturemeetings

    whenshouldwe meet

    whereshould wemeet

    small gp wasgreat

    collaboration oftrailmaintenance

    every 6-9months

    weekdayevenings

    good interaction

    b/t gps

    definingsustainabilityand getting buy-in from formal

    group

    bi-

    monthly

    weekday

    evenings

    time limit questionsand answers

    hope itcontinues

    different usergroups don'talways understandother group needsand concerns,maybe a shortsession on userneeds

    weekdayevenings

    interactivity andgroupcommunicationvia the miniprojects wasexcellent

    mission statement

    and principles werewritten great andcovered asatisfactory sert ofgoals and rules, letfolks know there arenot succinct laws sothat time isn'twasted with nonproductive questions

    any kind ofsegratationwithin the trailsystem. If itcannot beavoided, iet it beequal

    education on traildesign,construction andmaintenance

    monthlyandorganized specialeventsthroughyear

    weekdayevenings

    one centrallocation

  • 8/6/2019 FS surveys030911

    12/18

    2011 Public Hearing

    5 monthly clarkesville

    6 monthly either

    7

    8 good job! quarterly gainesville

    9 gainesville

    10 fine as it is quarterly gainesville

    good guidingprinciples

    participants shouldbe prepared beforemeeting so morethought can be putinto issues; domailout or useinternet

    look forward togetting greatresults, withmuchparticipation

    weekdayevenings

    opportunity foreveryone to havea voice

    thought this was agood first step

    money,collabortaion b/tall groups and FSunwillingness tocompromise

    good facilitation,ground rules, noagendas

    if evenings -centrallocation - ifweekend -different

    bettercommunication andeducation abouttrails

    web portal fortrail information

    need more trainingof volunteers,need bettercertification andtraining of

    contractors; putlimits oncommercials useof trals and betterregulate andmonitor

    included diverseusers and usedfacilitators

    continue to usefacilitators

    weekdayevenings

    great, very open

    and really careabout what wassaid

    more interactionwith FS person

    red tape - makeit faster

    more talking withFS persons; chrge

    $ to use trails(maybe not forthose that vol.)

    everycouple ofmonths

    weekdayevenings

    good discussionand had all usergroupsrepresented

    long time tocompletion

  • 8/6/2019 FS surveys030911

    13/18

    2011 Public Hearing

    11 internet monthly different

    12 $$$ monthly gainesville

    13

    14 quarterly gainesville

    15 monthly gainesville

    16 different

    17 different

    18 quarterly different

    small groups;smaller groupsyield moreproductivesuggestions

    moving it alongin a productivemanner

    weekdayevenings

    having these

    meetings

    smaller more

    focused groups

    break out groupswith FS personnel

    at each group

    weekday

    eveningsgreat opportunityto meet withother groups andthe FS

    failure toimplement

    asneeded

    weekdayevenings

    depends onneeds

    weekdayevenings

    you stayed onschedule andkept the

    conversation andcommentsmoving

    make it clear where

    to look for asummary of these 5meetings

    That it willwither away on a

    shelf. Please seethis initiative toconclusion

    have regularlyscheduled

    "listening"sessions forinterested groups

    weekdayevenings

    veryprofessionallydone but totallydifferent fromwhat I expected,was hoping formore localizedinformation

    maintainingenthusiasm

    lots ofcommunication -internet

    bi-monthly

    weekdayevenings

    Andrea was agreat mediator;enjoyed splittinginto groups

    limit of questions;statement perperson

    that follow upwill not be done

    more and bettercommunication

    3-6months

    weekdayevenings

    bringinginformation tothe public

    a greater definitionof terminology

    being able toTrack progressand follow theoutcome

    disseminate moreinformation aboutbuilding &maintaining whatis considered"sustainable"

    weekdayevenings

  • 8/6/2019 FS surveys030911

    14/18

    2011 Public Hearing

    19 different

    20 gainesville

    21 different

    22 monthly by district

    23 damn fish snacks quarterly gainesville

    24 monthly gainesville

    25 facilitators

    26 gainesville

    good effort tobring all usergroups togetherso we could heareeryone'sconcerns

    define next step b/tend of meeting

    make concertiveeffort to keepinterest alive

    by establishing acentralizedcommunicationprocess that allowsfeedback

    bi-monthly

    weekdayevenings

    very organized,everyone wasable to contribute

    trailhead parkingshould alsoaccommodatehorse trailers

    provide a secure

    section of yourwebsite wheredesignated usersfrom designatedorg. can post -

    weekdayevenings

    good job runningthe meeting withsuch a largegroup

    I do fit into agroup of usersbut not in asubgroup suchas CTRA orSORBA - pleasedo not leave outthe individualuser of trails

    every 2months

    weekdayevenings

    that it will lasttoo long

    smaller groups - bydistricts

    weekdayevenings

    weekdayevenings

    very well

    organized

    split people up into

    user groups

    keep it going, donot let theprogress get

    bogged down

    split people into

    user groups

    weekday

    eveningstoo many multi-use trails

    asking peoplewhat theythought

    changing groups soyou will have adifferent

    people becomingfrustrated andnot participating

    have work daysthat were plannedahed and assignpeople to workstations

    every 2months

    weekdayevenings

  • 8/6/2019 FS surveys030911

    15/18

    2011 Public Hearing

    27 monthly gainesville

    28 overall good

    29 good structure In time you did well quarterly Saturday in district

    30 yes x quarterly different

    31

    32 quarterly Saturday different

    33 different

    34 worked well loss of funding quarterly regional

    got multi-usegroups togetherand talking toeach other;

    providedstructure

    change groups foradditionaldiscussion; some

    groups had samepeople

    people becomingfrustrated andnot continuing toparticipate; wecame andparticipated but

    were not offereda Q & A time

    offer trainingcourses before thenext meeting;many people wantto get trained andbeat it to death

    during thismeeting

    weekdayevenings

    follow-upinformationaccess

    web accessfollowing

    weekdayevenings

    havingfacilitators keep users onseparate trails

    offer moremaintenancetraining to groups

    and individuals onthe GATC model

    sharing of ideasoutloud

    high clearanceneeds - maybeoverlook desires;not know how tostay involved

    continue thesetypes of meetings

    every thing wasgood

    professional leaderat group; wouldspeed up the process

    that user groupswould loosetrails and theusers hae

    already decidedwhat they aregoing to do

    monthly updates -email web -meeting

    bi-monthly

    weekdayevenings

    brought out a lotof ideas

    tell us how we canhelp

    weekdayevenings

  • 8/6/2019 FS surveys030911

    16/18

  • 8/6/2019 FS surveys030911

    17/18

    2011 Public Hearing

  • 8/6/2019 FS surveys030911

    18/18

    2011 Public Hearing

    Clarkesville