frsbog_mim_v14_0096.pdf

5
7/17/2019 frsbog_mim_v14_0096.pdf http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/frsbogmimv140096pdf 1/5 FEDER L RESERVE BO RD WASHINGTON January 4, 1921. x 3014 Subject: Comments by the Federal Reserve Board  on  recommendations made by  Governors  of  Federal Reserve Banks  at  their conference with  the  Federal Reserve Board October  14 and 15» 1920. Dear Sir:- The  Federal Reserve Board  has  examined  the  record  of  voids taken by the  Governors  of the Federal Reserve Banks  on the  several topics  sub- mitted  for  consideration  at the conference held  in  Washington October  14 and 15, 1920.  With  a few exceptions,  the  Board concurs  in the  recommend- ations made.  The  cases where  the  Board  is not  prepared  to  accept  the re- commendations,  or  which seem  to  call  for  special comment,  are  discussed below:  Check Clearing  and  Collection (Steno. report page 18.) ACTION: Voted that  the  confusion existing  at  present  in  connect- ion  with transactions  of  this character  is due to the  difference  of  opin- ion as to  what constitutes  a  proper telegraphic transfer  of  funds,  and that it is recommended that  the  Federal Reserve Board issue  a  mandatory ruling to the effect that  no  Inderal Reserve Bank should accept telegraphic transfers from  any  except member  and  non-member clearing banks. COMMENT:  The  Board rules that telegraphic transfers shall  not be  made  by a  Federal Reserve Bank except upon request  of a  member  or non- member clearing bank. II.  (Steno. report •page  27.) The  propriety  of  Federal Reserve Banks sending collection items to  member  and  non-member banks  in  other districts, with instructions  to remit  to the  nearest Federal Reserve Banks  for the  credit  of the  sending Federal Reserve Bank. ACTION:  The  Conference voted that this privilege should  not be permitted, unless  the  time involved  in the  collection  is  such that  the Federal Reserve Bank must necessarily send  the  items direct,  in  order  for collection to be made before  the  maturity  of the  items. Reference  is in- vited to the recent ruling  of the  Federal Reserve Board permitting Federal Reserve Banks  to  receive collection items direct from member banks  of other districts,  and  allowing them  to  permit their member banks  to  route collections direct  to  other Federal Reserve Banks, after  the  permission  of such other Federal Reserve Banks  has  been obtained  by the Federal Reserve Bank  of the  district  in  which  the  member bank requesting  the  privilege  is

Transcript of frsbog_mim_v14_0096.pdf

Page 1: frsbog_mim_v14_0096.pdf

7/17/2019 frsbog_mim_v14_0096.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/frsbogmimv140096pdf 1/5

FEDER L RESERVE BO RD

WASHINGTON

January  4 , 1921 .

x 3014

Subject: Comments  b y t h e  Federal Reserve Board  on  recommendations made

b y  Governors  of  Federal Reserve Banks  a t  the i r conference

with  t h e  Federal Reserve Board October  14 and 15» 1 92 0.

Dear  S i r : -

The

  Federal Reserve Board

  h a s

  examined

  th e

  record

  of

  voids taken

b y t h e  Governors  o f t h e  Federal Reserve Banks  o n t h e  s eve r a l t op i cs  s u b -

mit ted  f o r  cons i de r a t i on  a t t h e  conference held  i n  Washington October  1 4

and 15 , 1 920 .

  With

  a few

  except ions ,

  t h e

  Board concurs

  i n t h e

  recommend-

ations made.

  The

  cases where

  t h e

  Board

  i s n o t

  prepared

  t o

  accept

  t h e r e -

commendations,  o r  which seem  t o  c a l l  f o r  special comment,  a r e  discussed

below:

•  Check Cle ari ng  an d  Col lec t ion

(Steno. report page  1 8 . )

ACTION: Voted t h a t

  t h e

  conf us i on ex i s t i ng

  a t

  p r e s e n t

  i n

  connect -

i o n

  wi th t r ansac t ions

  of

  t h i s cha r ac t e r

  i s d u e t o t h e

  d i f f e r e n c e

  of

  opin-

i o n a s t o  what cons t i tu tes  a  pr oper t e l eg r aph i c t r an s f e r  of  f unds ,  and

t ha t

  i t i s

  recommended that

  t h e

  Federal Reserve Board issue

  a

  mandatory

r u l i ng  t o t h e  e f f e c t t h a t  no  Inderal Reserve Bank should accept telegraphic

t rans fer s f rom  any  except member  and  non-member cl e ar in g ba nk s.

COMMENT:

  The

  Board rule s th at teleg raph ic t ra ns fe rs sh al l

  n o t

b e

  made

  b y a

  Federal Reserve Bank except upon request

  of a

  member

  o r n o n -

member clearing bank.

I I .

  (St eno . re po rt •page

  2 7 . )

The  p r o p r i e t y  of  Federal Reserve Banks sending collection items

t o

  member

  and

  non-member banks

  i n

  o t he r d i s t r i c t s , w it h i n s t r u c t i o n s

  t o

remit

  t o t h e

  nearest Federal Reserve Banks

  f o r th e

  c r e d i t

  o f t h e

  sending

Federal Reserve Bank.

ACTION:

  The

  Conference voted th at th is p ri vi le ge should

  n o t b e

permi t t ed , unless

  t h e

  time involved

  i n t h e

  c o l l e c t i o n

  i s

  such th at

  t h e

Fed era l Reserve Bank must ne c es sa ri ly send  t h e  i t ems d i rec t ,  i n  order  f o r

c o l l e c t i o n  t o b e  made before  th e  matur i ty  of the  i tem s. Reference  i s i n -

v i t e d

  t o t h e

  recent ru l ing

  of the

  F ede ral Reserve Board pe rm it t i ng Fe deral

Reserve Banks

  t o

  r ece ive co ll e c t i o n i tems d i re c t from member banks

  of

o t h e r d i s t r i c t s ,

  a n d

  allowing them

  t o

  p erm it t h e i r member banks

  t o

  route

c o l l e c t i o n s d i r e c t

  t o

  other Federal Reserve Banks, af ter

  t h e

  permiss ion

  of

such other Federal Reserve Banks

  h a s

  been obtained

  b y t h e

  Federal Reserve

Bank

  o f t h e

  d i s t r i c t

  i n

  which

  t h e

  member bank requesting

  t h e

  p r i v i l e g e

  i s

Page 2: frsbog_mim_v14_0096.pdf

7/17/2019 frsbog_mim_v14_0096.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/frsbogmimv140096pdf 2/5

  2

X-3014

lo c a t e d .  I t i s  recommended that member banks  b e  permi t ted  t o  se n d c o l l e c t -

i o n

  i tems d i rec t

  t o

  Federal Reserve Banks

  of

  o t h er d i s t r i c t s ,

  and

  t h a t

  a l l

Federal Reserve Banks

  b e

  requ i red

  t o

  accept non-cash items

  f o r

  c o l l e c t i o n

when received from member banks

  of

  o th er d i s t r i c t s ;

  i t i s

  also recommended

th a t

  t h e

  Federal Reserve Board make

  a

  mandatory ruling

  t o

  t h a t e f f e c t .

  I t

i s

  further recommended that

  t h e

  Board direct each Federal Reserve Bank

  t o

i s sue uni fo rm c i rc u l a r s

  o n th e

  d i r e c t r o u t in g

  of

  collection items, embody-

i n g  c e r t a i n e s s e n t i a l p o i n t s ,  an d i f  th is ac ti on meets with  t h e  approval

o f t h e  Federal Reserve Board,  t h e  Committee  on  Forms appointed  a t t h e  l a s t

Governors' Conference

  b e

  i n s t r u c t e d

  t o

  design forms necessary

  t o

  take care

o f a l l

  t ran sac t ions a r i s i ng f rom

  t h e

  operat ions mentioned therein .

COMMENT:  The  Board concurs  i n t h e  above,  an d  makes  t h e  mandatory

rul ing requested through

  t h e

  medium

  of

  t h i s l e t t e r .

I I I .

  Currency

  a n d

  Circu la t ion

(Steno. report page

  6 9 . )

I n

  view

  o f t h e

  p re se n t i n su f f i c i e n t su p p l i e s

  of new

  cur rency ,

  i s

i t  des i rab le tha t  t h e  Federal Reserve Banks  and  Branches adopt  t h e  uniform

p o l i c y

  o f

  pay ing

  ou t new and

  redeeming unfit currency?

ACTION;

  The

  Governors presented

  a n

  u rg e n t p e t i t i o n

  t o t h e

  Board

t o  take  u p  wi th  t h e  Secre ta ry  o f t h e  Treasury  t h e  ques t ion  of  providing

t h e

  necessary notes through contract with pr ivate concerns .

COMMENT: Reports

  of

  currency operations (form

  1 6 0 )

  rece ived

  by the

Board since August 27th have shown that currency operations

  i n t h e

  severa l

Federal Reserve Di st r i c t s vary

  t o

  such

  a n

  ex te n t tha t

  i t i s n o t

  des i rab le

f o r

  Federal Reserve Banks

  and

  branches

  t o

  adopt

  a

  un i fo rm ra t io

  of

  payments

of new  currency  t o  total payments  of  c u r r e n c y .  The  Board, however, desires

t o

  d i r e c t

  t h e

  a t t e n t i o n

  o f t h e

  banks

  t o t h e

  fac t tha t p resen t supp l ies

  of

ne w

  cur rency p r in ted

  b y t h e

  Bureau

  of

  Engraving

  and

  P r i n t i n g

  a r e n o t

s u f f i c i e n t

  t o

  meet payments

  f o r

  normal replacements

  a n d

  r e q u e s t s

  a l l

  banks

t o  continue  t o  conserve their supplies  of new  currency.

I n  accordance with  t h e  vote  o f t h e  Governors,  t h e  Board  h a s . submi tted

t o t h e

  Secre ta ry

  o f t h e

  Treasury

  t h e

  r e p o r t

  of the new

  Currency Committee

together with

  t h e

  resolut ion adopted

  "by t h e

  Governors

  i n

  conference,

po in t ing

  o u t t h e

  inadequacy

  of the

  supply

  of new

  cur rency

  a n d

  urging that

immediate steps

  b e

  taken

  t o

  increase

  t h e

  Bureau ' s ou tpu t .

  As th e

  Federal

Reserve Banks have been advised, arrangements have been made  f o r t h e

purchase  of new  equipment  b y t h e  Bureau  of  Engraving  a n d  P r i n t i n g  t o b e

paid

  f o r b y

  Federal Reserve Banks

  and to be

  used exc lus ive ly

  f o r

  p r in t in g

Federal Reserve Notes.

The

  S e c re t a ry

  o f t h e

  Treasury advises

  t h e

  Board that

  h e

  hopes that

with  t h e  complet ion  of the  Lib ert y Bond p r i n t i n g program  a t t h e  Bureau,  t h e

output  of new  currency  may be  in c re a se d ,  a n d  t h a t  i t  w i l l  b e  s u f f i c i e n t  t o

provide

  f o r

  normal replacements.

Page 3: frsbog_mim_v14_0096.pdf

7/17/2019 frsbog_mim_v14_0096.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/frsbogmimv140096pdf 3/5

>

X-3014

17. Ope rat io n-( S teno. repo rt pages  129 & 155 )

Ad v i sa b i l i t y

  o f

  standardizing methods

  o f

  a u d i t i n g

  a n d

  accounting,

inc lud ing rea l es ta te account ing ,

  and

  a l s o a d v i s a b i l i t y

  of

  prov id ing

  a

method,

  a

  cl ea r i ng house

s o t o

  speak,

  f o r t h e

  exchange

  of

  d e t a i l s

  c o n -

cerning methods

  o r

  devices which

  a n y

  Federal Reserve Bank

  h a s

  fo u n d e f f i -

c i e n t

  i n

  opera t ion .

ACTION:

  I t w a s t h e

  sense

  o f t h e

  Conference that th is topic ,

  t o -

ge the r wi th o thers r e la ted

  t o

  operat ion, should

  b e

  r e f e r r e d

  t o a

  c o n fe r -

ence

  of

  o p e r a t i n g o f f i c i a l s

  o f t h e

  twelve banks

  t o b e

  c a l l e d

  i n t h e

  near

f u t u r e .

COW®NT:  The  Board does  n o t  approve,  a t  th is t ime ,  t h e  c a l l i n g

of a  conference  of  o pe ra ti ng o f f i c i a l s .  A  reg u la r confe rence  of  auditors

h a s  been authorized  a n d ,  with  t h e  Group Conferences already provided  f o r ,

i t  would appear that  t h e  o b j e c t s  t o b e  a t t a i n e d  in the way of  s t a n d a rd iz a -

t i o n  of  accounting through  a n  exchange  of  ideas might  b e  taken care  of

through machinery already provided.

7 .

  Circuit ous Routing

  of

  Checks.

(Steno. report pages

  1 5 8 t o 1 6 7 . )

ACTION:  I t was  moved  and  c a r r i e d th a t  t h e  Governors request  t h e

Federal Reserve Board  t o  recons ider  t h e  B o a r d ' s l e t t e r  N o.  X-1944, dated

Apri l

  7 , 1 9 2 0 ,

  r e l a t i n g

  t o t h e

  c i r c u i to u s ro u t in g

  of

  checks

  a n d , i f c o n -

s i s t e n t ,

  t o

  i s su e

  a

  ru l in g

  i n

  accordance with

  t h e

  recommendations

  of the

last Governors ' Conference.

COMMENT:

  The

  Board reaff i rms

  i t s

  opinion

  i n

  th i s ma t t e r

  a s s e t

f o r t h

  i n

  le t ter X-1944, dated Apri l

  7, 1920%

7 1 .

  Check Clearings

  a n d

  Collections*

(Steno. report pages

  1 7 9 to 1 9 3 - )

Exchange

  of

  letters between Federal Reserve Banks covering

  i n -

dorsement  of  i tems sent d irect  t o  other Federal Reserve Banks  b y  Member

Banks.

ACTION:  The  Conference recommended that this matter  b e  r e f e r r e d

t o t h e

  Fed era l Reserve Board, wi th requ est t ha t Counsel

  f o r th e

  Board

  p r e -

pare

  a

  u ni fo rm l e t t e r

  o f

  in s t ru c t io n s ;

  o r a

  regu la t ion cover ing these

  i n -

dorsements

  t o b e

  exchanged

  b y t h e

  twelve banks.

COMMENT:

  The

  Board con&urs,

  and

  w i l l d i r e c t

  i t s

  General Counsel

t o

  prepare

  t h e

  form re que st ed.

Page 4: frsbog_mim_v14_0096.pdf

7/17/2019 frsbog_mim_v14_0096.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/frsbogmimv140096pdf 4/5

9 9

- 4 -  X-301U

VII• Inter Federal Reserve Bark Transactions.

(Steno. repor t pages

  194 to 201)

The

  d e v i s i n g

  of a

  method

  t o

  avoid pre sen t f r equ ent hold ing

  up of

books  i n  connect ion wi th in te r -ban k redi sc ount opera t i ons . Also

t

  a  b e t t e r

method  of  prepayment  b y  Federal Reserve Banks  of  paper under rediscount

b y

  other Federal Reserve Banks.

ACTION:

  The

  f o l l o w i n g r e s o l u t i o n c a r r i e d :

  ( l )

  That rediscounts

made  by one  Federal Reserve Bank  f o r  another  Federal Reserve Bank  b e  made

as of the day

  when

  t h e

  reques t

  i s

  made, except

  on

  Friday when

  t h e

  reserve

p o s i t i o n  of  each Bank  i s  made public.  ( 2 )  That each Federal Reserve Bank

r ed i s coun t i ng

  f o r

  anot her Fe der al Reserve Bank pre pa re

  and

  forward promptly

t h e  schedule  of  papers  i t h a s  been redi scount ing .  ( 3 )  That Requests  f o r

a n t i c i p a t i o n  of  paper under rediscount  be  Combined  in one  wire each  d a y ,

and  tha t such t r ansac t ion  be  ef fec ted upon  the day o f  r e c e i p t  o f t h e r e -

ques t ,  i f  rece ived bef ore  th e  c l o s e  o f  bus i nes s ;  i f n o t ,  upon  t h e  f o l l ow-

i n g d a y .

COMMENT:

  The

  Bo a rd ' s l e t t e r

  of

  February

  1 7 , 1 9 2 0 ,

  X-1835>

  s u b -

je c t Gold Se ttl em en t Fund Dai ly Clear ing ,  paragraph  2 of  page  2 ,  s t a t e s

tha t ,

"The

  Fe de ra l Reserve Banks w i l l

  b e

  expected

  t o

  a n t i c i p a t e

  i n

s o f a r a s  pos s i b l e t he i r  n e t  debi t ba lances  o r n e t  c r ed i t ba l ances

i n t h e

  s e t t l e m e n t ,

  and

  wherever necessary reques t

  t h e

  Board

  t o a r -

range rediscounts with other Federal Reserve Banks  i n t h e  a f t e r -

noon  a s a t  p r e s e n t ,  i n  order  t o  mai n ta i n t h e i r r e s e r ve po s i t i on  a t

about  4C%  a f t e r f i n a l c l o s in g  o f the  books  f o r t h e d a y .  Whenever

a

  Federal Reserve Bank receives

  a

  heavy debit

  i n t h e

  s e t t l emen t

  ( a d -

v i ce  of  which wil l  n o t b e  received under  the new  pl a n u n t i l  t h e f o l -

lowing morning) which

  w a s n o t

  a n t i c i p a t e d

  and

  which w i l l reduce

  i t s

reserve below  t h e  required minimum, notice  of  this should  b e  prompt-

l y

  communicated

  t o t h e

  Board with

  t h e

  reques t tha t r edi sc ount s

  b e a r -

ranged  i n  suf f i c i ent amount  t o  b r i n g  t h e  r es e r ve  t o t h e  required

minimum. Entries,

  of

  course ,

  i n

  connect ion wi th th i s t r a nsa c t i on

w i l l  b e  made  o n t h e  books  of  bo t h  t h e  r ed i s coun t i ng  and  lending  F e d -

eral Reserve Banks before

  t h e

  f i n a l c l o s i n g

  of

  books

  a s o f t h e p r e -

vious

  d a y . "

I n  order  t o  avoid  t h e  f r e q u e n t n e c e s s i t y  of  consummating rediscount

t r a n s a c t i o n s  t h e  fol low ing morning  as o f the  previous day ' s da te  due to

red isco unt i ng banks sending th e i r reque s ts  f o r  rediscount accommodations  t o

t h e  Board  t o o  l a t e  i n t h e  a f t e r noon  f o r  d e t a i l s  t o b e  ar ranged tha t  d a y , t h e

Board reques ts that rediscount ing Federal Resewe tanks ar range

  to r s thd

Board  n o t  l a t e r t h a n  2 : 3 0 p . m . ,  Washington time (11:00  a . m .  Washington time

on

  Saturdays)

  t h e

  amount

  i t i s

  then es t ima ted

  i t

  w i l l

  b e

  neces s a r y

  t o

  r e d i s -

count  t o  maintain their combined reserve posit ion above  40 ^  a f t e r f i n a l

c l o s i n g

  of the

  books

  f o r t h e d a y .

  Under such

  a n

  arrangement

  t h e

  bank ' s

excess reserve should  b e  s u f f i c i e n t  t o  provide  a  reasonable margin  f o r

con t i ngenc i es .

Page 5: frsbog_mim_v14_0096.pdf

7/17/2019 frsbog_mim_v14_0096.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/frsbogmimv140096pdf 5/5

A »

I C O

- 5 -  x-3014

The  Board, requests that advance payments  an d  r e b a te s  of  r e d i s -

counts with other Federal Reserve Banks  b e  handled  i n  accordance with  t h e

B o a rd ' s l e t t e r

  of

  October

  1 8 , 1 9 2 0 ,

  X-2030, su bj ec t Unifor mity

  i n

  method

of

  handling inter-Reserve Bank transactions through

  t h e

  Gold Settlement

Fund , excep t th a t

  a s

  provided

  f o r i n t h e

  above resolut ion requests

  f o r

a n t i c i p a t i o n  of  paper under rediscount  b e  combined,  i n s o f a r a s  poss ib le ,

in one  wire  t o t h e  Board each  d a y .

Very truly yours,

G o v e r n o r .

L e t t e r

  t o

  Governors

  of a l l

  Federal Reserve Banks.