French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _...

31

Transcript of French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _...

Page 1: French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _ GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld Gu # [uxvt_cux Ga a Z l1m n o r xvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld` Gu

��������� � ����� ���������

�����

����� � � �"!$#&%('*)�+('-,

.*/1032 �546�7�8� / �9��:����7�

; <>= ?A@CBEDGFIHKJLBEM*DN@POQJRFI?&SITVU�WQDGF XY[Z\Y ]I^`_bac^[dGe�fg^h_cikjld�ZmZ1Z1ZmZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZnZ1ZmZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZ1ZmZnZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZ oY[Zpo ]I^Ae�q r&st_cacikuwvtuxdy_bac^[fku Z1ZmZ1Z1ZmZnZ1ZmZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZ1ZmZnZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZ oY[Z{z ]I^Aacjh_|^h_cikjld ZnZmZ1Z1ZmZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZnZ1ZmZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZ1ZmZnZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZ zY[Z~} ]I^Ae�q r&st_cacikun^��Nik^[fku�Z1ZmZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZnZ1ZmZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZ1ZmZnZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZ zY[Zp� ]>���Gjlr&j[_c�Gst_ciku ZmZ1Z1ZmZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZnZ1ZmZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZ1ZmZnZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZ zY[Z{� ]I^Aeci\r�i\fki�_b�G�Gu��Gi\acuxv�_bu Z1ZmZ1Z1ZmZnZ1ZmZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZ1ZmZnZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZ zY[Zp� �>a�jl�Gf\�xr&uxe�Z1ZnZmZ1Z1ZmZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZnZ1ZmZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZ1ZmZnZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZ }

X <>D��R��JRM*�y@PBEO�=�SIT��l=�Bh�yW�= �o Z\Y �>a�jl�Gf\�xr&uxe�Z1ZnZmZ1Z1ZmZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZnZ1ZmZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZ1ZmZnZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZ �

� <>D��R��JRM*�y@PBEO�=�SITV@PBEOQDGFI�RW�= ;��z�Z\Y �>a�jl�Gf\�xr&uxe�Z1ZnZmZ1Z1ZmZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZnZ1ZmZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZ1ZmZnZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZ1ZmZ1Z1ZmZ�YC�

� ��JRW T�@�O�JRFVS9=�?A=y¡�=�BE�yO �l= ? ;N¢

Y

Page 2: French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _ GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld Gu # [uxvt_cux Ga a Z l1m n o r xvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld` Gu

]9^��[sxjlr&st_caciku1uxe _w�Gd��h^[e _bu e�����ut_�� �Ni�j vxvt�� u��GdGu�Gfk^[vxumikr�� j[a�_|^hd�_cun� ^[dGe f\uxe u���uxa �vxikvtuxe��Gacj�� jle�sxem^[����� f\q r��Gig^h�Guxe�� dy_butacd ^h_cikjldG^[fkute���ecj[���lutd�_ �Gux����u ��uxacvtikvtuxe e��Game�i�� ZI]9^�lsxjlr&st_caci\u�_cuxfkf\u�� �Nu dGjl�Ge�^[fkf\jldGe>f ��st_c�G�Gikuta i\vxiR^��Gac^h_bi�� �Nuxr&uxdy_��Gi\e�� ^hac���Gute��Ga�j��lab^hr�r&uxe�Gu`f\q vxstu�Rjl�Ga fk^[ike�ecuxa��Gfg^[vtu����GdGu��[sxjlr&st_caciku �Gfk�New^[d ^[f�q�_bi!���Gu"� fk^�acstecjlf\�N_bi\jld(�Gutewu���uxa �vxikvtuxe#� ^heceb^hd�_1e�jl���lutdy_ �G^[a f ��uxr��Gf\jli��NuxewdGjlr��Gacutewvxjlr��Gfku ��uxexZ%$ ^[dGendGj[_cacu vtjl�Ga�e���dGjl�Ned �{^h� jla��Guxa�jldGe&� ^he�vxut_�_bu#� ^ha�_bi\u����Gi'���Gikutd(��� �~��_bikf\u ut_7u*)&vC^[vtu��+Q^[i�_�ecj[���lutd�_,�Gf\�Ge7^���Ruxf%��Gu7fg^ _butv|�GdGi!���Gu�vC^hfkvx�Nfg^h_cjlika�u���� �-�n�Gd�ab^[i\ecjldGdNuxr&uxdy_.�lsxj[r�s�_baci����Gu[Z0/�jl�Ge>dGjl�Ge1�Ga�i��lutacjldNe�GjldGvn�Gunf ���Gec^��luw� ���Gd2� �Nuxfkvtjld���Gu1acu3� �tacu[Z

]9^`�Gi4)�vt�Gf\_csw�Guwfg^�[sxjlr&st_caciku ^A�Nux���3j[aci!�[ikdGute�5G� ���GdGu�� ^[a _7fg^ �Gi4)�vt�Gf\_cs���� ��jld6�Rux��_^7�[jlika8� j[�Ga�9�:�;=<>vxu�� �Ni�ecu�� ^[ece�u ut_�� ^[a>+�j[ike r@?tr�uA� jl�Na _bac^[vxuta �GdNu�BC�l�Ga�u vxj[acacutvt_cu��Nu�_�fku_bac�te>fg^[a>�lu�s3�[uxdy_|^[i\f � ��jl�N_bi\fke u�_ �Nu7_c�Gsxj[ac�xr&uxe>r&ike.�wdGj[_cacu7�Gi\e��Rjleci�_bikj[d Zl�Ijl�Ga>acstecjl�G�Nacu��Gd�Gacjl�Nfk�xr&uw�Gu��lstjlr�s�_ba�iku��Njld �NjldGdGutab^��Nux��� vtjldGecutikf\exZCDIjl�N_�� �~^[� j[ac� ikf ute�_ ikr�� jla _|^[dy_��Nu_bab^hvxuxa>�GdNu �RjldGdGu�BC�l�Nacu��E�Rjl�Ga>vtuxfg^njld�� ut�N_ � �{^h� jla���f\ika�u�f ��sxdGj[dGvxs�uxd�+Q^[ikec^[dy_>�GdGu�BC�l�Ga�u��r-^hikd&fku3�[sxu��Rjl�Ga1�ljli\a f\uxe8� jli\dy_be i\dy_bacj �G�Gi�_be ut_8�ljli\a vxj[r�r&uxdy_�f\uxe �Gike>� j[ecuxa3�NutdGec�Gi�_bu jld_bab^hvxu��GdGu��lac^[dG�Gu&BC�[�Gacu��Ga�sxvxi\ecu,�wfg^ a����lf\u�ut_ ^[�&vxjlr�� ^[e,F�ec�Ga>�GdNu��Nuxr&i4�G�G^��lu��H�lj[ikacu7�GdNu� ^��lu utdy_bik�tacuJI�Z%$m�{^[��_bacu�� ^[a�_ ikfIuxe�_ � jld �Nu acu3� stacuxawe��Ga fk^@BC�l�Ga�u�� ut_n^J�h^[dy_w�Gu v|�Nuxacv|�Nuxafku,�Gacjl�Nfk�xr&u��Nacj��Ga�uxr&uxdy_��Ni\_J�0���Gutf!���Guxe�s3�y^[f\i\_bste ���{^[d��lfkute�� �Gu fkj[d�l�Gut�Gace8� �Ni jla�ikutd�_cuxa�jldy_fkuwab^hikecj[dGdGuxr&uxdy_xZ/�jl�Ge�^[fkf\jldGeK�ljli\a�e��Gvxvtikdy_butr�utdy_�_ba�jlike�^[e��Ruxv�_be��Gu fk^A�lstjlr�s�_ba�iku>�G��Gfk^[d�5P_cjl�N_����{^[�Rjla��

dGjl�GeL�lutacacj[dGe f\uxe3�Gi4M�stacuxdy_cuxe3_bab^hdGe>+�jla�r-^E_bikj[dGe6�G�N�Gfg^[dO�Rjl���h^[dy_6?t_ba�u �N_bi\fkuxeL�Rjl�Ga3fg^acsxe�jlfk��_bikj[d � ��u���uxa�vxikvtuxe3�&�G�Gike-fg^��lstjlr&st_ba�iku(�N��vxuxa�vxf\u ^7�[uxv �Gut����jl��_bikf\e-i\r@�Rjla�_b^[dy_be��eb^J�ljli\a3fg^QPSR�T�USU7VWT�X"YZT�[]\�^!VSU-ut_ fk^_�N�Gike�eb^[dGvtu � �~�Nd`�Rjlikdy_J� ut_3uxdaB d�fk^_�[sxjlr&st_caciku��G�_bacik^[d�lf\u7j�b6dGjl�Ge ab^���Ruxf\fkutacjldGe �Gd6vtuxa�_b^[ikd-dGjlr �Ga�u �GuA+�jlacr �Nfkuxe �N_bi\fkute u�_��Guxec�Gacj��Naciks�_bste�Gu�� jli\dy_be�acutr-^ha���� ^[�Gf\uxetZ

d e �7� ��� / f(g �1��� / �9��� f � 43� h 2t/�f

i j[r�r&uxdjtjldGe�G^[a�s�_b�G�Gi\uxamfkuxem_bab^hd�+�jlacr�^h_cikjldGe����Gi8�Gacstecuxak�lutd�_&f\uxe �Gi\e�_b^[dGvxute ut_�fkute^[d�lf\uxexZ

l1mkl noqp]ro.s�t]u ovp�w x.sy jli\_�z{ �Gd6�[uxvt_cux�Ga �G�2�Gfg^[d|�Gfg^ _bac^[dGe�fg^h_cikjld~} �Nu��[uxv�_bux�Na2z{ ^hececj vxi\u��A_cjl�N_,� j[ikdy_A�

�G���Gfk^[d fku2� jli\dy_~�O� _butf�� �Nu������ ����N�#� z{ Z ]9^ vtjlr@�Rjle�i\_bi\jld �Gu �Gux��� _cab^[dGe�fg^h_cikjldNe&�Nu�luxv�_but�Gace�z{ ut_z� uxe _ fk^n_cab^[dGe�fg^h_cikjldA�Gu��lutvt_cux�Ga�z{,� z� �yutfkf\u�dNu �Gs3� utdG�~� ^he �Gu�f ��jla��Gacu7� ^[dNefku����Gutf>jld u*M�utvt_c�Gu-f\uxen�Gux� � _bab^hdGecfk^h_bi\jldGexZ���dGuA_bab^hdGecfk^h_bi\jld uxdE�lj[iku&�GdGu&�Gacjli�_buAec�Nam�GdNu�Gacjli�_bu#� ^hab^[f\fk�xf\u[Z

l1m'� no�t0�����|p]rw ���|�Ks1par�o.uk�]9^6e�q r&st_caciku`vtuxdy_bac^[fku`ute�_1�GdGu&^[��_bacu _cab^[dNe>+�jla�r-^h_cikjld�ecikr��Gf\u[Z ]I^6e q�r&st_caci\u`vxuxdy_cab^[f\u

�Gu�vxutdy_bacuL� uxdE�ljli\uL� ec�Ga`f\u��Rjlikdy_�� � _butfc���Gu�������� � � � �3�>��� Z�� f ex�~^��li�_ s��l^[fkutr�utd�_� �~�NdGunacj[_b^h_bi\jld6� �~^[d�lf\u�� Z

]9^&vxjlr�� j[ecsxum� ���GdGu�_cab^[dGe�fg^h_cikjld3u�_ � ���GdGu e q r�s�_baci\umvtuxdy_bac^[fkumuxe _ �GdGu�e�q r�s�_ba�iku1vxuxd]�_bab^hfku[Z y jli�_L���NdGu e�q r&st_ba�iku(�Nu vxuxdy_cacuW� ut_6� � �GdNu e�q r�s�_ba�iku �Gu vtuxdy_ba�u�� � ��^[fkjla�e�fg^

o

Page 3: French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _ GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld Gu # [uxvt_cux Ga a Z l1m n o r xvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld` Gu

_bab^hd�+�jlacr�^h_cikjldL�����,�1ute�_ �GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld��Gu#�[uxvt_cux�Ga��a��� �������Z

l1m�� no�rxvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld`�Gu�vxutd�_cacuA� ut_ � �~^[d�lf\u�� ^[ece�j�vtiku,�n_cjl�N_1�Rjlikdy_8� �G���Gfk^[dA�Gd�� jli\dy_8� �

_buxf|� �Nu ��� �Q�� � u�_��`�� � �� FQ^[d�lf\uwjlaci\uxdy_bsJI�Z���_�_butd�_cikjld|�Geci j[d a�uxr��Gfg^hvxu � � ^[a� � jld�^����Gfki�� �Nu fg^�a�j[_|^h_cikjld�ikdE�lutacecuA�GuAfk^-acj[_b^h_bi\jld �lj[�Gfk�GuhZ y i�������� fg^�acj[_b^h_bi\jld uxe _f ��ik�Gutd�_ci\_cs[Z y i�� �N� �Gvh�~ute�_ �GdGune�q r&st_ba�ikuwvtuxdy_bac^[fkuhZ

l1m�� no�t0�����|p]rw ��o���w o.uk��Ijl�Ga&dGu2� ^[e&fg^ vxjlda+�jldG�Ga�u�^J�lutv fk^�e q r�s�_baci\u3vxuxdy_cab^[f\u j[dVf �~^���Ruxf\fku�s3�y^[f\uxr&uxdy_&acs*�

� u���ikj[d Z y jli�_�� �GdNu��Ga�jli\_cu�� fk^6acs � u���ikjld�� �~^E��u�� ^[e�ecj vxiku��6_bjl��_ �Rjli\d�_ � �G���Nfg^[d fku� jli\dy_�� � _butfv���Gu ���C� ���� � e�jli\_#�Ruxa>� utdG�Gi\vx�Gfk^[ika�u����ut_����Gu`f\u r&ikfki\ux� �Gu�� �`� ��� ^���� ^[ak�_bikutdGdGutd�_A�`fg^ �Nacjli�_bu ��Z

]9^wvxj[r@�Rjlecstu��Gu��Gut���Aacs � u���i\jldGe uxe _ �GdGu�_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld�e�i fkute ^E��uxe>ecj[d�_1� ^hab^[f\fk�xf\uxe3�h�GdNuacj[_b^h_bi\jld3ecikdNjld Z y i�� uxe _ f �~^[d�[fkuwuxdy_cacu1fkuxe ^E��uxe � u�_�� � �Nuxe a�s � u ��ikjldGe���ut_�� � �R^[f\jlace7fg^vxjlr�� j[ecsxu�� � � ��uxe _ �GdGu acj[_b^h_bi\jldm���{^[d��lfku!�"� u�_��Gjldy_�fku vtuxdy_ba�u�uxe _�fku8� j[ikdy_����~i\d�_cuxa�ecuxv�_bi\jld�Guxe7�Ga�jli\_cuxe#� ut_�� � Z

l1m%$ n�&�'�x1��xvp('A�|pawk�] ���Gjlr&j[_b�Nst_bi\uwuxe _ �NdGu1_cab^[dNe>+�jla�r-^h_cikjld(���Gi�dNumvtjldGecuta>�[u�� ^[e7f\uxe7�Gike _|^[dNvxuxetZR]>���Gjlr&j"�

_b�Gs�_biku �Gu�vxutd�_cacu���u�_ �Gu�ac^���Rjla�_*)&^[ece�j�vtiku&� _cjl�N_ �Rjli\d�_ � �G� �Gfg^[d�fku��Rjlikdy_ �N��_buxfa���Gu������� � ��) � �>����$Z y i+) � �-, jld a�ut_cacjl���[uAfg^-e q�r&st_caci\u vxutd�_cab^[f\u[ZK��dGu`�Gjlr&j[_c�Gst_ciku�utdE�ljli\u�GdGu �Gacjli�_bu6e��Ga��NdGu3�Gacjli�_buL���Gi7fk�Gi uxe�_@� ^[ac^[fkf\�xf\u[Z�]�ute�e�ux�Gf\uxeA�Gacj[i\_buteAikdE�h^[acik^[dy_buxeAe�jldy_vxuxf\fkute����GiK� ^[e�ecuxdy_,� ^[a�f\u vxutdy_bacun�Guwf �~�Njlr�jh_b�Gs�_bikuhZ���dGun�Gjlr&j[_b�Nst_bi\u vtjldGecuta>�[umf\uxe7^[d�[fkuxeut_`r �Nf\_bi��Gfki\uAfkuxe�fkjld�[�Gux�Ga�e�� ^ha/.0)�.pZ y i ���1 2 uxe�_A�Nd �luxv�_but�GaA�G�_�Gfg^[d|��e�jld ikr�^��lu6�����1 � 2 ��lsxa�i�B u �E�H�1 � 2 � �3) �E�1�2 Z���dGun�Gjlr&j[_b�Nst_bi\u vxj[dGecuta>�lum�GjldGvnf\uxe�ab^"�� j[a�_be7�Gunf\jld�l�Gut�GacetZ

]9^�vtjlr�� jle�sxu �Nu �Gux� �6�Gjlr&j[_c�Gst_cikuxe uxe _�ecjli�_��GdNu �Gjlr&j[_b�Nst_bi\u �Njldy_�fku ab^���Rjla _�uxe _�fku�Gacj �G�Gi�_��Guxe�ab^"�� j[a�_be3�Gecj[i\_7�GdGuw_cab^[dGe�fg^h_cikjld6e�i�fku#�Ga�j��N�Gi\_��Nuxe�ab^���Rjla _be��h^[�N_ , Z]�ute �Gj[r�j[_c�Gst_cikute�ecjldy_7_ba��xe��N_bi\fkuxe�f\jlace��Nu1fk^`acsxe�jlfk��_bikj[d ���~u �Nutacvtikvxute � ^hdGe7fku _ba�ig^[d��lfkuF �lj[ika�vxutacvtfkun� �54>�Nfkuxa�I�Z

l1m�6 no�t]w>��w u w p87 9��:9AwGr�K� pa�]9^&ecikr&ikf\i\_c�G�Gu �Nikacutvt_cum�Gu1vxutdy_bacu�@� �Gu1ab^���� jla _ ) u�_ ���{^[d��lfku�� uxe�_ fg^Avxj[r@�Rjlecstum�Nu

f ���Gjlr&j[_b�Gs�_bi\u �Gu vxuxdy_cacu��$u�_7�Gu ac^���Rjla�_;) ut_��Gu fg^macj[_b^h_bi\jld-�Guwvtuxdy_ba�u��$u�_�� �~^[d�lf\u<� Zi ut_c_cuw_bab^hdGe>+�jla�r-^E_bikj[d6vxjldGe�uxak�lu1fkuxe�^[d��lfkute�ut_7r �Gf�_bi��Gfki\u fkute�fkjld��l�Gux�Nace&� ^[a=. )�.{Z� d � ut�N_�vtjldGeci\�Gsxa�uxaA_bjl��_buxe�fkute&_cab^[dGek+�jlacr�^h_cikjldGe��Nacsxvtsx�Gutdy_buxeL��f ��u���vxu3�N_bi\jldV�Nu�fg^

e�q r�s�_ba�iku vtuxdy_bac^[fku vxjlr&r�u��Gute�eci\r�i\fki\_c�G�Gute,5 �GdGu _bab^hdGecfk^h_bi\jld-ute�_��GdNu eci\r�i\fki\_c�G�Gu��Gu ab^��a�� jla _ , �Gj[d�_ f\u�vtuxdy_ba�u ute�_ eci\_c�Gs,�1f �~i\d�B dGi �[�GdNu a�j[_|^h_cikjldAute�_ �GdGu�ecikr&ikf\i\_c�G�Gu �Nu ac^���Rjla�_ , �ut_7�GdGun�Gj[r�j[_c�Gst_ciku ute�_��GdGune�ikr&ikfki�_b�G�Nu � �~^[d�[fkuwd��Gf Z(� fkj[ace�fg^ vtjlr�� jle�sxun�Guw�Gut��� eci\r�i\fki �_b�G�Gute7�Gika�uxvt_cuxe�uxe _ �NdGunecikr&ikf\i\_c�G�Gu[Z

] ��ikr�^��luw� ���Gd�_cacik^[d�lf\u�� ^[a��GdGumecikr&ikf\i\_c�G�Gu ute�_ �Gd _cacig^hd�lfkuw�Njldy_ f\uxe ^[d�lf\uxe7ecjldy_ fkuter@?tr�ute�u�_�� ^[dGe7fkunr�?xr&uwjlac�Nacu1^[�N_cjl�Ga7�G� _cacik^[d�lf\u[Z�� f q ^ _cacjli\e�vtaci�_b�xa�uxe��Rjl�N_��Gika�u#���Gu

z

Page 4: French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _ GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld Gu # [uxvt_cux Ga a Z l1m n o r xvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld` Gu

�Gux��� _bacik^[d�lf\uxe ecjldy_9ecutr �Gfk^[�Gfkutev5Ce�jli\_�r&jldy_ba�uxa%���Gu>f\ux�Ga�e9^[d�lf\uxe e�jldy_�s3�y^[��� �Ce�jli\_ r�jldy_cacuxa� �Nu f\u ac^���Rjla�_I�Gute�f\jld�l�Gut�GaceI�Gute�v��h_bsxeIuxe _�f\u r�?xr&u��Pe�jli\_9_cacjl���[uxaI�GdGu ecikr&ikf\i\_c�G�Gu��Nikacutvt_cu� �Ni�uxdE�ljli\unfkuxe7e�jlr�r&ut_ce��Gunf ���Gd3ec�Ga7f\uxe�ecj[r�r&ut_ce��Gunf �~^[�N_ba�u[Z

l1m�� � rx���u������Kt ¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l= ;�y jlikutd�_ �V�Nd vtuxacvtfkuAut_ � �GdGu&�Gacj[i\_bu`�NjldGdGste��9vxjldNe�_ba��Gika�u��NdGuA�Gacjli�_bu�� ^hab^[f\fk�xf\u����

vxjl��G^[dy_ f\uwvxutacvxf\u�� uxd �Gut���2� j[ikdy_be�e�i\_b�Nsxe,�`�GdGu1�Gike _|^[dGvtu��-�GjldNdGsxuhZ

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=�X�4�_b^[dy_��Gj[dGdGs&�Gd��Rjlf\q]�lj[dGu ��� v��h_bsxe1jld�� ut�N_�vtjldGe�ik�Gstacuxanf\uxe1r�i\fkikut����������������� ���

�Guxe7v��h_bsxetZ� dE�lutacecutr�utdy_ e�i�fkuxec� jli\dy_be,�������������S���`ecj[d�_��Gj[dGdGsxe3�Gu���i\e�_bu �K_k� ikf �GdL� j[f\q]�ljldGu�Gjldy_ f\uxe��Rjli\d�_ce#����ecjldy_ f\uxe r&ikf\ikut���6�Gutewv��[_csxe F�st_c�G�Gikuta f\uxe vx^[e��W�! -ut_"�W�!#� �Rjl�GafkuwvC^he,�[sxdGstab^[f �G�Gike _bi\d�l�Guta�uxdy_ba�u � � ^hika�u�_ i\r@�G^[ika�I%$

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=���� d3vxj[dGeci\�G�xa�u _bacj[ike �Nacjli�_buxec� ^[ab^hfkfk�tfkute!�&�'� �)(�� �)*CZ i jldGe�_cac�Gi\acu �Nd3_cacik^[d�lf\u s����Gi\fg^h_cs*�

ab^[f 1 � 1 ( 1 *9_buxf�� �Nu fkuxeK�Rjli\d�_ce 1 ��� 1 (�� 1 *I^��� ^[a _bi\uxdGdGutdy_9acuxe>� utvt_ci��lutr�utdy_�^h���w�Ga�jli\_cuxe �&��� �)(�� �+*xZ

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l= �,y jlikutd�_-� u�_.� � �Gux� � vxuxa�vxf\uxe��Rr&jldy_bacuta�� ���~i\f�u���ike _bu1�Gux��� �Gj[r�j[_c�Gst_cikute�_bab^hdGe>+�jla�r-^hd�_

� uxd�� � Z�/ �Gun�Gi\acuweci�f\uxe7ab^Cq[jldGe7ecjldy_�s��l^[���0$ ¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=���y jli\_ 1 221 �Gd _cacig^hd�lfku"� vtjldGe�_cac�Gi\acu�� fk^ ac���[fku ut_�^[� vxjlr�� ^[e3�Gd vC^[a�acs �Gjldy_ �Gd

ecjlr&r�u�_�^���� ^[a�_cikutd�_�^[�6v��[_cs 1�2 �G�Gd6ecj[r�r&ut_�^[�6v��[_cs 1�1 ut_��Gut���3e�jlr�r&ut_ce�^[�H�c^[vxutd�_ce^��� ^[a _bi\uxdGdGutdy_ ^h� v��[_bs 221 Z

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=43�y jli\_ 1�221 �Gd�_ba�ig^[d��lfku�ike�j�vt�xfku�uxd 1 �Nf\uxec�Rjli\d�_ce&� ut_65 ecj[d�_��Gaci\e ec�Na�fkute�v��[_csxe 1 2

ut_ 1.1 a�uxe>� utvt_bi4�lutr�utd�_xZ ]�uxe �Gacjli�_bute"7 2 598 u�_�7 1 �:8>ecu vtjl��Ruxdy_�uxd<;&Z>= jldy_ba�uxa����Gu fkute�Gacjli�_bute�7'�?5487u�_ 7 221 8�ecjldy_,� ^[ac^[fkf\�xfkute�eci�u�_7ecut�Gfkutr�utd�_�e�iIj[d ^ �1 ;�� � � 1 ;�5 Z

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l= ¢@y jli\_ 1 � 1 ( 1 *��Gd _ba�ig^[d��lfku�u�_A;CB&�Gd �Rjli\d�_A�N� �Gfk^[d Z.� d �Gs3BGdGi\_ 1.D � 1�DFE *@�Rjl�Ga

��GH#GZ0� d-vtjldGe _bac�Ni\_>�GdGu�ec�Ni\_buI;����J;C(��K;C*��������l�Gu�_butfkf\u�ecjla _bu,� �Nu.;,��ecjli�_ f �~i\r-^"�lu �Gu-;C� E �� ^[a`fg^ acj[_b^h_bi\jld �Gu3vxutdy_bacu 1 �JLM�mut_A� �~^[d�lf\u (�N* ZO= jldy_bacuta����Gu3eci0;��QPFRFSL�T;CBJ��^[fkjla�e fku_bacik^[d�lf\u 1 � 1 ( 1 * uxe _�s����Gikfk^h_bstab^[f Z

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=4U�4�_b^[dy_ �GjldNdGsxe _cacjli\e vtuxacvtfkute �Gut��� �&�Gux�����Gi\e ��jli\d�_cexZ D�ac^[vxuta f\uxe _cacjli\eA�Rjli\d�_ce � ��ikdy_cuxak�

ecuxv�_bi\jld �Nuxe7_|^[d�[uxdy_bute u�� _csxaci\ux�Ga�uxe�vxjlr&r �GdNuxe,�&v|�G^����Gu�� ^hikacun�GunvtuxacvtfkutexZM= jldy_ba�uxa,���Guvxuxe�_cacjli\e&� jli\dy_be�ecj[d�_ ^[f\i!�ldNsxexZ

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=4V�

}

Page 5: French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _ GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld Gu # [uxvt_cux Ga a Z l1m n o r xvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld` Gu

y jli\_ 1�221 � u�_ 1 � 2 � 1 ����� �Gut��� vC^[a _buxe vC^[a�acsxute �Gumfg^&r@?tr�u1acs3�likjld3_bac^[vxstuxe#�&�Gi�M s*�acuxdy_cuxe�stv|�Guxf\fkutemu�_��Rjlecstuxe1f ���GdGu&ec�Ga1f �~^[�N_cacuhZ �wd�ec���� j[ecu����Gu�fg^(�Gf\�Ge �Rut_ci\_cu&�Nuxe1�Gux���uxe�_�uxdy_bi\�xacutr�utdy_���f ��ikdy_csxaci\ux�Ga �Gu fk^��lac^[dG�GuhZ = jldy_cacuxac� ���~i\f u �Ni\e�_cu �Gd6�GdGi����Gu��Rjlikdy_��Njldy_fkuxe acu3�Gacstecuxdy_b^h_bi\jldGewec�Na fkute �Gut��� vx^[a�_cuxe vtj � dGvtik�Gutdy_CZ 4 d �Gj[dGdGuxa �GdGu vtjldGe�_cac�Gv�_bi\jld���fg^ac���[fkuwut_ ^[�3vtjlr@�G^[exZ

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l= ; ��y jli\_ 1�2 1 �Nd�_ba�ig^[d��lfku�i\ecj vx�xf\u�uxd 1 u�_6�(e�jld-vtuxacvtfku�vxi\acvxj[dGecvtaci\_xZ]� d-dGj[_cu��3f\u7vxuxa�vxf\u

_|^[d�[uxdy_1^[���(�Gacjli�_bute 1�2 ut_ 1.1 ut_w_b^[d�lutdy_�� � ikdy_csxaci\ux�Ga�uxr&uxdy_CZK�wd dGjh_bu);0���+���fkute� jli\dy_be��Gu vxj[d�_b^[vt_ �Gu���^J�lutv 1�2 � 1�1 �J� acute��Ruxvt_ci��[uxr&uxdy_CZ 4 d�BGd%�� ute�_ fku�vtuxdy_ba�u �Gu� �� ute�_ fkuwr&ikfki\ux���Gu � ;� � u�_�� fkuwr&ikf\ikut�-�Gu � 221 � Z

� �Ne�_bi4B uxa6f �~s3�y^[f\i\_bs� �� �� � �� �� Z;4 d �Gsx�N�Gika�u�� �Nu�� uxe�_3f\u(vxutdy_bacu �G� vtuxacvtfku i\dGecvtaci\_� 1 221 Z

� e / � ���m� �������t� 4 � � ����� 2 �

i j[r�r&uxdjtjldGe�� ^[a��NdGu��Gacj��Naciks�_bswi\r@�Rjla�_b^[dy_bu �Nuxe�vxuxa�vxf\uxexZ

��� ��JRB�� M*=*;

!�"$#&%('*)�+-,.'0/1#324!�"5%*'$6 17�287 � #�' 5:9<; #�6=)�+-,.'0/1#324!�"5%*'$6>6?!�%('A@B!�@DC(@�E5"$).+�#&6F6D".#�'�6?#G+HE$#&IJ#&%('6K"�!�%L, 7'� 1 � � 2 81� 7Q5 1 �K5 2 8?9

i ut_c_cu��Gacj��Gaci\st_bs ecu(_cab^[�G�Ni\_6^hikdGe�i utd _cuxa�r�ute�� �~^[d�lf\uxe��Gu��Guxr&i4�K�Gacjli�_bute65 eci�� ut_ 5ecjldy_m�G� r�?xr&u&v��[_bs&�Gu&fg^3�Gacj[i\_bu�7 1�2 8 ��^hfkjla�e1f\uxe���� ^h_ba�u��Rjlikdy_ce 1 � 2 � � ut_ 5 e�jldy_vxj vtq vxf\i!���Guxe�e�i�ut_7e�ux�Gf\uxr&uxdy_7eci�jld3^ �1 � 2 � �1 5 2 �Neci � ut_I5 ecj[d�_7�Nu1v��[_bste7j���Rjlecste� ^[a�ab^���Rjla _��-fk^��Ga�jli\_cu<7 1�2 8 �R^[fkjla�e 1 � 2 �%� u�_"5 e�jldy_ vtj�v�q�vtfki�� �Nuxe e�i�u�_ ecut�Gfkutr�utdy_eci jld ^ �1 � 2 � � � �1 5 2 Z $ u~�Gf\�Gemutd ^���Ruxfk^[dy_�� f\u�vtuxdy_ba�u��G� vtuxa�vxfku�vxi\acvxj[dGecvtaci\_� 1 2 �?5W�Rj[d�^ 7 � 1 �S� 2 8v�3�>7'� 1 � � 2 8.�3�%7Q5 1 �J5 2 8 Zi u�_c_cu,�Nacj��Ga�iks�_bs�e�ikr��Gfku8� utacr&ut_>�GsG��� �Gu&+Q^[ika�u vxu���� ��jld&^���Ruxf\fku fk^ v|� ^[e�ecu ^[���A^hd�lfkute��

�-eb^J�lj[ikawv|�Gutacv|�Guta1e��Ga �GdNuBC�l�Ga�u���Guxf\ewecjldy_wf\uxew^[d��lfkute s��y^h��� ��ec����Gfkstr�utdy_|^[i\acuxe3� vxj[r ��Gfkstr�utd�_b^[ika�uxetZ\Z�ZC/ j[�Ge7f ��ikfkf\�Ge�_cacutacjldGe ^J�luxv1�GdGu��Ga�j��Ga�ikst_csw�Guxe7_ba�ig^[d��lfkutexZ

A

B

C

D

M

A

B C

T

P

QR

A

B

C

D

E

P

O

r

A

B

CD

E

LestrianglesM AB etM B Csontinversementsemblables.

Th´ eor eme deMiquel

Th´ eor eme dePtol em´ ee

PuissancedeP parrapport a :P A.PB = P C.PD = P E 2 = O P 2 − r2

D

D estl’axeradicalde 1 etG 2.

MN�O=PRQRSUTBVXWGYZN�O\[�]\^_N&P`[�acbdOfegVhPiSjVlk�N&QfOmN&noN&VlPpOfN&n�qXYUTBqXYZN�O

Page 6: French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _ GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld Gu # [uxvt_cux Ga a Z l1m n o r xvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld` Gu

��� ��JRB�� M*=(X���� O�� TI= W��

!�" ' 1 221 +H%_'$/K" ,h%�XE # #�' ; 7 � 7 � '0/1!�" 624!�" %('0686K" 'K+�&6 6B+H/8E$#�6 @ �<'��6 221 7 1�1o7 1 2/?#�6 2=# @�'$"���#&IJ#&%(' 9�� E !�/K6 E #�64@B#&/?@�E #�64@�"5/?@ !�%�6?@&/K" '06 ,.+��8'$/K" ,h%�XE #�6 1 � � 7�2 ;� 7 1 � ; 23,h6K61#�%('2 ,h/o+H% 2=!G" %('`@B!�I8I +H% 9

A

B

C

D

M

A

B C

T

P

QR

A

B

C

D

E

P

O

r

A

B

CD

E

LestrianglesM AB etM B Csontinversementsemblables.

Th´ eor eme deMiquel

Th´ eor eme dePtol em´ ee

PuissancedeP parrapport a :P A.PB = P C.PD = P E 2 = O P 2 − r2

D

D estl’axeradicalde 1 etG 2.

� <�V*X]9�V 5� y jli�_~}�f �~i\d�_cuxa�ecuxv�_bi\jld��Guxe3vtuxacvtfkute vtika�vxjldGe�vxa�i\_be3^h��� _cacig^hd�lfkute 1 � � ut_ 2 ;� Z���^havxjlf\ikdGsx^[aci�_bs �Nuxe,� jli\dy_be�jld ^

�} � 1 �N� ��1 �#}�� �} � 2 �N� �

�1 ��} � �}-; 1 �N� ��2 ;#}��

��^[a7vxj vtq vtfkikvti\_cs jld ^�} � 1 �O� �

�1 ��}�� �} � 2 �N� ��2 ;#}��

�wd �Gst�G�Gi�_ �}.; 1 � � ��1�� } ��� ^[a`vxj[dGecs3� �Nuxdy_�f\uxe���� ^h_cacu(�Rjlikdy_be 1 ��; ��}��4��e�jldy_

vxj vtq vxf\i!���Guxe3� �GjldGv#} ^��� ^[a _bi\uxdy_�^[� vxuxa�vxf\u1vtika�vxjldGe�vxa�i\_�^[�6_ba�ig^[d��lfku 1 ��;&Z �

� f uxe _ i\r@�Rjla�_b^[dy_1fkjla�e���� ��jld*vx^[fkvt�Gfku&�Guxe�^[d�lf\uxem�Gu@+Q^[i\acu&^h_�_buxdy_cikjld*^[��� eci��ldGuxemut_�f ��jlaci\uxdy_|^h_cikjld �Guxe1^[d��lfkutew^"B d �GuAdGu�� ^hewsxvxa�ika�u`�Guxenv|�Gjle�uxe�� ab^[i\uxewec�Nawvxuxa _|^[i\dGuxe#BC�[�Gacuter-^[i\e +Q^[�Nececute�e��Ga`� �~^[�N_cacuxe6F=�ljli\a u���uxa�vxi\vxu Y���I Z�4 d �[sxdGstab^[f ��jld sxvtaci�_Afkuxe�acuxfk^h_bi\jldGe���Giecjldy_,��ac^[ikute7ec�Ga�fg^BC�l�Nacu���� �~j[d(^A�Guxe�ecikdNsxu��Rut_�jld2�lstaci�BGu���� ��uxf\fkute a�uxe�_cuxdy_,��ac^[ikute e��Ga7fkute^[�N_ba�uxe&BC�l�Nacuxe3� jl� ^[�3r�jli\dGe&���Gun�Guxe�acutfg^h_cikjldNe�eci\r�i\fg^[i\acuxe acute�_cuxdy_A� ac^[ikutexZ��d�^h�N_ba�u1a�sxe��Gf\_b^h_7ikr�� j[a�_|^hd�_ ec�Ga7f\uxe7vxutacvxf\uxe7ut_�f\uxe&��� ^[�Ga�ikfk^h_b�tacuxe�ute�_ fkuwe��Gi��h^[dy_CZ

� � ��JLB���M = �����n@PJRW���M � =��

!�" ' 1�221 � +h% ).+X,��X/K" E ,.'��&/?# 9! % , E#" "5%$%��,lE " '&p6B+H"��?,h%('R#('

1�1 � 2 �*) 1 2 � 1 � � 221 �5� 1 �,��G#B@(���,hE5" '� 6K"=#�'`6?#�+hE$#�I #�%(' 6K"�E #�6\2=!�"5%('06 1 � 2 � 1 � � 6?!�%('�@ ! @mC(@�E " ).+�#�6+��,h%�6 @ #�' !G/,�</1#- @B#o).+H" 6D".�X%�"./*# ).+�# E$#&60�X/?!�" 'f#�6 7 1�1 8 #�' 7 2 � 8 6?#@B!�+B2=#&%*'21 E," " %('&�/K" #�+H/3�(+ @ #�/1@�E$#�4 9

Page 7: French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _ GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld Gu # [uxvt_cux Ga a Z l1m n o r xvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld` Gu

A

B

C

D

M

A

B C

T

P

QR

A

B

C

D

E

P

O

r

A

B

CD

E

LestrianglesM AB etM B Csontinversementsemblables.

Th´ eor eme deMiquel

Th´ eor eme dePtol em´ ee

PuissancedeP parrapport a :P A.PB = P C.PD = P E 2 = O P 2 − r2

D

D estl’axeradicalde 1 etG 2.

� <�V*X]9�V 5� y jli\_���f ���GdGi����Gu.� jli\dy_9�G���Gfk^[dw_butf]���Gu fkute�_bacik^[d�lf\uxe 1 2 ��ut_ 1 � 1 e�jlikutd�_I�Gi\acutvt_butr�utdy_ecuxr��Gfg^[�Nfkuxe&FQv[��uxe _>�G��� �Gi\acu&��� ��ikf�u���ike _bu7�GdGu7eci\r�i\fki�_b�G�Gu>�Gi\acutvt_bu�utdE�ljPqy^[dy_ 1�2 � e��Ga 1 � 1 I�Z�wd ^�� 2�� 1 � � 1�2�� 1 ����� ��j�b 2 � � 1 2 � 1 � � 1 ��Z $m�{^[��_bacuL� ^ha�_Ajld ^ �� 1�1 �� 2 1 � u�_ 1 � � 1�2 � 1.1�� 1 �6� �Gj[dGv fkute�_ba�ig^[d��lfkute 1�1 � u�_ 1 � 2 ecjldy_3ecutr �Gfk^[�Gfkute��� �~j�b 1 � � 1.1 � 2 � � 1 ��Za$��~^��Gac�te�f ��ikdGs3�y^[f\i\_bs�_cacig^hd�l�Gfk^[ika�u��G^[dGe�fku�_ba�ig^[d�[fku 2 1 � j[d3^1 � ) 1�2 � 2 �"^J�luxv1s��l^[fki�_bs e�i�ut_�ecut�Gfkutr�utd�_�e�i�fkuxe&�Rjli\d�_ce 1 � 2 ��� ecj[d�_ ^[f\i!�ldGste�� ^[dNevxut_ jlac�Ga�u[Z 4 d acuxr��Gfk^�jC^[dy_ 2 �8u�_ 1 � � ^[a fkuteA�h^[fkut�Gace jl�N_cuxd��Guxe3� jld�_cacjl�a�lu f �~i\dGs��y^hfki\_cs�Gumf �~stdGjldGvts[Z ] �~s3�y^[fki�_bsn^&fkikut� e�i9ut_ e�ux�Gf\uxr&uxdy_ eciIjld(^ �1�221 �`� �

�1�2 ���`� � � 1 � 1 ��GjldGvneci�u�_�ecux�Nfkuxr&uxdy_�eci�f\uxe&�Rjlikdy_ce 1 � 2 � 1 � � e�jldy_�vxj vtq vxf\i!���Guxe�� ^[dNe�vtut_�jla��GacuhZ �

��dGu`^[��_bacu �Gacj��Gaci\st_bsmikr�� j[a�_|^hd�_cu ���GiI�Gstvxjl�Gf\u �Gu fk^@�Ga�uxr&ik�tacu1uxe�_ vxu��� ��jld ^���Ruxf\fkufg^�G�Gi\ecec^[dGvxu1� ���Gd2� jli\dy_&� ^[a7ab^"�� j[a�_,�`�Gd vxuxa�vxf\u[Z

��� ��JLBl� M*= � ���mTIO ?C?tD F��l=�S��TIF U JRO F @&UIDGB�B�DGUIU JLB�@� T�F��l=�BE�yW�= �

!�" ' +H% @B#�/1@�E # � #G' +H% 24!�"5%*' ; 9 !�" ' +H%*# �</1!�" 'R#�2 ,h6D6�,h%('i2 ,h/ ; #�' @ !�+g2 ,h%(' E$#�@B#�/1@�E ##�% 1 #�' 2 - �G#�%('K+<#�E E #�I #�%('4@B!�% � !G%$�(+H6�4 9 � E !�/K6=E #F2A/1! �(+h" ' ; 1 � ; 2 %*# ��R2=#&%$� ).+�# ��# ;#�' ��# � 7 2 ,h6 ��# E , �X/?!�" 'f# 9

� <�V*X]9�V 5� y jli\_��GdGum^[�N_cacu1�Gacj[i\_bu�� ^heceb^hd�_A� ^[a-; ut_ vxj[�� ^[dy_ fku1vxuxa�vxf\umutd 1 ut_ � F=�ljli\a&BC�l�Ga�u7I�Z�wd ^

�; 1�1 � �2 1�1 � � 2 � 1 � � � ;-� 2 �]9ute�_ba�ig^[d�[fkuxe ; 1�1 u�_ ;�� 2 ecj[d�_7�NjldGv e�uxr �Gfk^[�Gf\uxe�F�ut_�� ��jla�ikuxdy_b^h_bi\jldGe j��� j[ecsxuteSI �G� ��j�b; 1�� ;-� � ; 1�� ; 2 �Gecjli�_I; 1 � ; 2 � ; 1 � ;���Z �

A

B

C

D

M

A

B C

T

P

QR

A

B

C

D

E

P

O

r

A

B

CD

E

LestrianglesM AB etM B Csontinversementsemblables.

Th´ eor eme deMiquel

Th´ eor eme dePtol em´ ee

PuissancedeP parrapport a :P A.PB = P C.PD = P E 2 = O P 2 − r2

D

D estl’axeradicalde 1 etG 2.

���&S�� ]���� ^���� b���� a������ ( ��� � ("!$# (

]�u(�Ga�j��N�Gi\_2; 1 � ; 2 uxe _&^���Ruxf\s% Xa;!USU�T�[|PSVV�Gu ; � ^[a ab^���� jla _ ^[�vxuxa�vxf\u:� Z y i�� uxe _ f\u vtuxdy_ba�u �G�vxuxa�vxf\u�ut_'& e�jldAab^Cqljld|�yjld � ut�N_>v|�Gjli �ecika 7 � ; 8�vtjlr&r�u>�Ga�jli\_cu u�_�u �a�Gaci\r�utafg^�G�Gi\ecec^[dGvxu1�Gu�; vtjlr�r&u

7 � ; � & 8�7 � ; � & 8 �Q� ;(� &

( �

Page 8: French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _ GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld Gu # [uxvt_cux Ga a Z l1m n o r xvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld` Gu

4>d �lstdGsxac^[fGjld`��_bikf\ike�u �Gute f\jld�l�Nux�Ga�e^[f!�lst�Gaci����Guxe3� vtu�� �Niw^��Rjl�Ga�vtjldGecs �� �NuxdGvtu����Gu�fk^��G�Gike�eb^[dNvxu�ute�_@� j[eci4�_bi��[u e�i ; uxe�_&��f ��u�� _bstaci\ux�Ga �Gu"� ut_�dGs��y^E_bi��[u e�i ; uxe�_&��f ��ikdy_bstaci\ux�GatZ�]�u vC^[e�f\ikr&i\_cu 1 � 2vxjla�acuxe>� j[dG�(^[�3vx^[e j�b fk^A�Nacjli�_bu 7 ; 1 8 ute�_�_|^[d��luxdy_bum^[� vxutacvxf\u��C� ^ha�f\u _b�Gstjlac�tr�u1�Gu1��qE�_b� ^��[jlacu"� jld a�ut_cacjl���[um�Nikacutvt_cuxr&uxdy_ fk^�[^hfkux�Na��Gumfk^��G�Gike�eb^[dNvxu�utd2+�j[dGvt_cikjld �Gu�� ; u�_ �Nu&�Z

]9^2�G�Gike�eb^[dNvxu-���~�Gd�� j[ikdy_�� ^[a1ab^���Rjla _�� �Gd*vtuxa�vxfku-^ �GdNu�a�sxvxi��Gacj]���Gu&�N_bi\fkuL59eci>fkute�Gacjli�_bute�7 1�2 8>ut_�7 1 � 8 ecu vxjl��Ruxdy_�utd��Gd(�Rjlikdy_ � ut_���� ��jld3^ ; 1 � ; 2 �?; 1 � ;-� F ^J�lutv�Guxe7fkj[d�l�Gut�Gace�^[f��lsx�Ga�i!���GuteSI*�G^[fkjla�e 1 � 2 � 1 ut_ � ecjldy_�vxj vtq vtfki!���GutexZ

A

B

C

D

M

A

B C

T

P

QR

A

B

C

D

E

P

O

r

A

B

CD

E

LestrianglesM AB etM B Csontinversementsemblables.

Th´ eor eme deMiquel

Th´ eor eme dePtol em´ ee

PuissancedeP parrapport a :P A.PB = P C.PD = P E 2 = O P 2 − r2

D

D estl’axeradicalde 1 etG 2.a N�ORP=Y�� T��XNpQmT��-S �1TBY��XN�O��XN�����N&Q �&YZN�O

y j[ikuxdy_ �Gut��� vxutacvtfkuxe � � ut_ ��(�Nu vtuxdy_ba�uxe-a�uxe>� utvt_bi4+�e�� � ut_@��(-�Nuac^CqljldGeIacute��Ruxv�_bi�+�e & � ut_�&�(J�P�GdGu1���Guxe �_cikjld8d ^h_c�Gacutfkfku uxe _��Gu e�u �Guxr�^[da��Nuxa�� �Nuxf>uxe _ f ��uxdNecuxr��GfkuA�Gute��Rjlikdy_be^Cql^[dy_ r�?xr&u&�G�Gi\ecec^[dGvxu,� ^[a ac^���Rjla�_� vtuxe7�Gut��� vxutacvxf\uxetZ�� d ec^[i\_��[a�[vtu��dNj[_ba�u&dNj[_ba�u +�j[acr �Gf\u`u��a�Gf\ikvxi�_bu��� ��ikfet�{^"�li\_&�Gu f ��uxdGe�uxr �Gf\u �Nuxe~�Rjlikdy_ce&;�[sxa�i�BL^[dy_4; � ( � � &

(� � ;�� (( � &(( �

e�jli\_.;�� (� � ;��(( � & ( � � &

(( Z���^[a fku_c�Gsxj[ac�xr&uw�Gu1��q�_b� ^��[jlacunjld3r&jldy_bacu���Gu*f ��uxdGe�uxr �Gf\u*�Gute(_butfke��Rjli\d�_ce9;ute�_ �GdGu �Ga�jli\_cuN�Ruxa>� utdG�Gi\vx�Gfk^[ika�uO�f �{^��Nu.7 � � ��('8�^���� utfks�TJYaV�<>T� �;'P�T�^C�Gute

�Gux����vxutacvtfkuxe�� ��ut_"��(PZ y iI�Gux����vxutacvtfkuxe ecu vtjl��Ruxdy_wuxd��Gux��� � j[ikdy_be 1 u�_ 2 � ^[fkjla�e f\ux�Ga^E��u-ab^h�Gikvx^[f uxe _ fg^3�Ga�jli\_cu97 1�2 8 Z y i �Gut���*vxuxa�vxf\uxe�e�jldy_�_b^[d�lutd�_ce�utd �Gd��Rjli\d�_ 1 �I^[f\jlacefkux�Na7^E��u1ac^[�Gi\vC^[f ute�_�fg^�_b^[d�lutdy_bunvxjlr&r �GdNu����Gi�f\uxe�e�s�� ^[a�u[Z� d ^`fku _b�Nsxjla��xr&uwec�Gi4�[^hd�_�e��Ga7fkuxe7^��Nute ac^[�Gi\vC^[��� Z

� � ��JLB�� M*= � � ��� � JLB�� M*= SI= ?ADN¡�= ?�B�D SIO �lDGT9¡ �

!�" ' � � 7 � � 7 ��* '0/?!G" 6@ #�/1@�E$#&6 9 � E$!G/K6 E #�+H/D6 '$/?!�"56 , �#�6 /�,��<" @?,.+ ��� � 7 � ( #G'�� * 6?!�%('\61!�" '@B!�% � !G%$�(+H6 7 6?!�" '`@B!�%*@ !�+H/&,h%('06 7 61!�" '323,h/�,hE5E��&E$#�6 9

� <�V*X]9�V 5� � dN� j[ikdy_3^���G^[a�_cuxd ^[dy_2� �Gut��� ^E��uxe3ac^[�Gikvx^[����^[� r�jli\dGe6^ r�?xr&u �G�Gi\ecec^[dGvxuW� ^[aab^���Rjla _1^[��� _cacjli\ewvxuxa�vxf\uxe����NjldGvAikf ^"�� ^[a _bikutdy_1^[��_cacjli\eci\�xr&u`^E��u[Z�$ j[dGv�e�jli\_ � � ut_ � (ecjldy_1vxjlda+�jldG�G�Genu�_nfku`ecj[d�_1�Gj[dGvA^J�luxv � *7� ecj[i\_wi\fke jldy_1�Gd ecut�Gf �Rjlikdy_n� ��ikdy_butace�uxvt_cikjld u�_ikfke�vtjl��Ruxdy_ �NjldGv � * uxd�vtut_ �GdGi�� �Nu��Rjlikdy_J� e�jli\_�i\fke�ecj[d�_�� ^[ac^[fkf\�xfkute�ut_ � * fkut�Ga7uxe _ �GjldNv� ^[ab^hfkfk�tfkuhZ �

��d acstec�Gf�_|^h_�ikr��Rjla�_b^[dy_ �Rjl�GaIfg^�acstecjlf\�N_bi\jldm���~u �Nutacvtikvxute uxe _�fku ec�Ni��h^[dy_�5Eecjli\uxdy_ 1�221 �ut_ 1 � ����Gux���6��� ^[�Nacikfk^h_b�tacute i\dGecvtaci\_ce7� ^[dGe �Gux����vxutacvtfkuxe3� e�i9fkuxe �Gacj[i\_bute 7 1�2 8*� 7 1 � 8*�7���� 8 ecj[d�_�vtjldGvxj[�Gab^[dy_cuxe ^[fkjla�e�fkute&� �G^h_ba�u��Rjli\d�_ce 1 � 2 ��� u�_�� ecjldy_�vxj vtq vtfki!���GutexZ

Page 9: French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _ GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld Gu # [uxvt_cux Ga a Z l1m n o r xvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld` Gu

�&mkl � rx���u������Kt ¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l= ;R; y jli\_ �(fku�vxutacvtfku vtika�vxjldGe�vxa�i\_ ^[��_cacik^[d�lf\u�s3���Gikfk^h_bstab^[f 1 221 Z y j[i\_�� �Gd��Rjli\d�_ �Gu f �~^[acv

� �~u � _bacstr�i�_bste 2 u�_ 1 dNu1vtjldy_butd ^[dy_,� ^[e 1 Z = j[d�_cacuta,��� ��jld ^ 1 � � 2 � � 1 ��Z

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l= ;�X y jli\_ 1 u�_ 2 f\uxe i\d�_cuxa�ecuxv�_bi\jldGe>�Gu��Gut���&vxutacvxf\uxe � ��ut_ ��(CZ y jli�_ 1 � �NdGu7vxjla��Gu7�GuI� ��u�_

� ut_���f\uxe ecutvxjldN�Guxe ikdy_butace�uxvt_cikjldNe acuxe>� utvt_ci��lute �Nuxe>�Gacj[i\_bute 1�1 u�_ 2 �"^J�luxvI��(PZ = j[d�_cacuta� �Nu1f\uxe7�Ga�jli\_cuxe�7 1 � 8 u�_27 ��� 8 ecjldy_,� ^[ac^[fkf\�xf\uxexZ

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l= ;�� ���6B�J O @P= SI= ��OQM*U�?xJRF � y jli\_ �(�Gd�vxutacvxf\u u�_ 1 � 2 � 1 _bacj[ike.� j[ikdy_be>�Gu-� Z y jli\_ � �Gd��Rjlikdy_ �G���Nfg^[d%� ; �J;����J;��ecuxe&�Nacj���utvt_bi\jldGe�e��Ga�fkute��Gacj[i\_bute�7 2 1 8'� 7 1 1 8'� 7 1 2 8�Z%= jldy_ba�uxa&���Guwfkute&� j[ikdy_be0; �J;����J;��ecjldy_ ^[fki��ldGste�eci�u�_ e�ux�Gf\uxr&uxdy_�eci ; ^"�� ^[a _bikutdy_,� � Z ¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l= ;�� y jli\_�� �wu�_ � (1�Gut��� vxuxa�vxf\uxe1ecu&vxjl��G^[dy_�^h���W� j[ikdy_be 1 ut_ 2 Z y j[i\_ � �GdGuA_|^hd�luxdy_cu

vxjlr&r �GdGu~� � �mu�_+��(7� 1 u�_ �5fkute� j[ikdy_be �Nu6vxjldy_|^hvt_beA�Gu � ^J�lutv�� �mut_)� (PZ y jli�_��f ��ikdy_butacecutvt_cikjld6�Gute �Nacjli�_buxe�7 1�2 8�u�_ 7 1 � 8*� r&jldy_ba�uxa&��� ��jld�^�� 1 �Q���Z

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l= ;�� y jli\_ 1�221 ���Gd ��� ^h�Gaci\fg^h_c�xacu1vxj[d0�[u���uAikdGe�vxa�i\_ �G^[dGe �Nd vxuxa�vxf\u �Gu�vtuxdy_ba�u ��Z y jli�_�;

fku��Rjli\d�_ � ��ikdy_butacecutvt_cikjld6�Gu)7 1�1 8 u�_�7 2 �<8�Z�]9ute�vxutacvxf\uxe�vtikacvtjldGe�vxaci�_be ^[����_bacik^[d�lf\uxe 1�2 ;ut_ 1 �<; ecuwa�uxvxj[�� utdy_7uxdJ�AZ y i|�A�J;0��� ecj[d�_��Gike _bikdNvt_be3���Ga�jl���[uxa����Gu 7 ��� 8 uxe _&�Ruxa��Ruxd]��Gikvt�Gfg^[i\acu��47Q; � 8�Z

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l= ; 3 y jli\_ 1 B 2 B 1 B �Gd�_ba�ig^[d�[fku�ut_ ; �Gd~�Rjlikdy_xZ� d6�Gs*B dGi\_ 1 �*� 2 �*� 1 � vxjlr&r�u fkutec�Ga�j���uxv �

_bikj[dGe j[a�_b�Nj��ljld ^hfkuxe �Gu � e��Ga f\uxe �Gacjli�_bute"7 2 B 1 B'8*�@7 1 B 1 B�8*�@7 1 B 2 B�8 Z�� d��Ns3B dGi�_��Gu r@?tr�ufkuxe�_cacig^hd�lfkute 1 ( 2 ( 1 ( ut_ 1 * 2 * 1 *PZ = jldy_cacuxa,���Gu�f\uxe�_ba�ig^[d��lfkute 1 B 2 B 1 B�ut_ 1 * 2 * 1 * e�jldy_ecuxr��Gfg^[�NfkuxetZ

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l= ;G¢My jli\_-� �*� � (��M��*7� ������� ^h_cacumvxuxa�vxf\uxexZ|� d�e����Rjlecu���Gu � ��ut_���( ecumvxjl��� utd�_ uxd ;���u�_

�)� �����GuA��(�ut_ ��*�e�u�vtjl��Ruxdy_muxd ;,(mu�_ ��(7�K���GuA� *mut_ ��� e�u�vtjl��Ruxdy_�utd ;,*�ut_ ��*�u�_� �Nu)���nut_�� ��ecu`vtjl��Ruxdy_wutd ;��nut_ ���Z = jldy_ba�uxa����Gu`e�i�fkute��Rjlikdy_ce";O� �@;C(J�@;C*J�@;��ne�jldy_vxj vtq vxf\i!���Guxe3�L^[fkj[ace�fkute&� j[ikdy_be �2�*����(7���*J��� fkuwecj[d�_�s3�y^[fkutr�utdy_CZ

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l= ; U y jli\_ 1 221 �Gd _cacig^hd�lfku ���Guxf\vxjld���Gu&ut_��5e�jld�jla�_c�Gj�vtuxdy_ba�u[Z y jlikutd�_n�Nux��� �Rjli\d�_ce��

ut_�5 �Ga�ike a�uxe>� utvt_bi4�lutr�utd�_1e��Gawfkutewv��[_csxe 1�2 u�_ 1�1 Z�]�uxewvtuxacvtfkutew�Gu`�Gig^hr���_bacute 2 55u�_1 � ecunvxj[�� utdy_ utd4; u�_ �&Z�= jldy_bacutaA���Gunf\uxe�� j[ikdy_be ;0���+� ��ecj[d�_ ^[f\i!�ldNsxexZ

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l= ; V ����� � ; V�VL� � y jli\_ 1 � 2 � 1 � � � �G^h_ba�u �Rjlikdy_ce �Gi\e�_cikdGv�_be��Gfg^hvxsxe�� ^[dNe vtut_ jlac�Ga�ume��Ga��GdGu��Nacjli�_bu[ZL]�ute

vxuxa�vxf\uxe��Gu �Nig^[r&�t_cacuxe 1�1 u�_ 2 � e�uwvxjl��Ruxdy_7utd�� ut_��-ZN]9^ �Gacjli�_bu27���� 8 vxjl��� u+7 221 8uxd��1Z y jli\_�; �Nd��Rjlikdy_1�Gike _bi\dGvt_n�Gu��ec�Ga1fg^3�Gacj[i\_bu 7����28 ZI]I^3�Ga�jli\_cu 7 1 ; 8 vxj[�� u&fku

Page 10: French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _ GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld Gu # [uxvt_cux Ga a Z l1m n o r xvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld` Gu

vxuxa�vxf\u��Nu��Nig^[r&�t_cacu 1�1 utd 1 u�_c� ��ut_ fg^w�Ga�jli\_cu�7 2 ; 8�vxjl��� u�fku�vtuxacvtfku7�Gu��Gig^hr���_bacu 2 �uxd 2 u�_-5 ZL� acjl�a�luxa,���Gu1fkuxe��Nacjli�_buxe 1 � � �<5�� � � ecjldy_�vxjldNvxjl�Gac^[dy_butexZ

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=�XL��� ��� ��JLBl� M*=�SI= � D ?C�lD W�� y jli\_ 1 221 � ��� �Gd �Gu��N^��lj[dGuAikdGe�vxaci�_w� ^[dNew�Gd vxuxa�vxf\u[Z y jli\uxdy_ � � ��� � f\uxewikdy_cuxace�uxv �

_bikj[dGe a�uxe��Ruxv�_bi4�luxe��Nuxe��Ga�jli\_cuxe"7 1�2 8 ut_�7�� �28 � 7 221 8>ut_�7 ��� 8*�@7 1 � 8 u�_�7 � 1 8 Z = j[d�_cacuta� �Nu&f\uxe#�Rjlikdy_ce � � � � � e�jldy_m^[fki��ldGsxetZ FQ��jl�Ganf\uxe#�Gf\�Gewvxjl�Nab^��lut��� ��r�j[d�_cacutawfku`r�?xr&u`acs*�ec�Gf�_|^h_��Rjl�Ga 1 � 2 � 1 � �4��� � � ec�Ga7�GdGunvtjldGi!���Gu����Gutfkvxj[d���Gu��-I

� e / � ���m� �������t� 4 � ����� /�fJ�12 �

i j[r�r&uxdjtjldGe#� ^ha����Guxf�� �Nuxenab^���� utfkexZ%� d�fk^[ike�ecutab^-fk^��Gsxr&jldGe _bab^E_bikj[d(�Guxe#�Nacuxr&ik�tacute+�jlacr �Nfkuxe jl�3�Gunf ��u���ike _buxdNvxun�Guxe��Rjlikdy_ce�vxi\_csxe�utd u �NutacvtikvxuhZ � d i\d�_cacj �G�Gi\ab^�u�_7�N_bi\fkike�uxac^�fkutedGj[_|^E_bikj[dGe��Ge��Guxf\fkuxetZ$ ^[dGe �Nd _ba�ig^[d��lfku 1 221 �Ljld dGj[_cu � ��� ���wfkute7fkjld�[�Gux�Ga�e �Nuxe v��[_bste j��� j[ecsxe ^[��� e�jlr �

r�u�_ben�Gjlr&jldyq r�ute1u�_ � ��O�K� f\uxe#�h^[fkut�Gacen�Gute�^hd�lfkutexZ � d*dNj[_bu � fku`vtuxdy_ba�u-�Gu��lab^J� i\_cs��� jli\dy_>�Gu vtjldGvtjl�Gace �Gute r&sx�Gik^[dGute��yfku��Rjlikdy_ � �Gi4� ikecu7v|� ^"� �Nu r&sx�Gik^[dGu�uxd��Gux� �&ecu��[r�utd�_ce�Gjldy_>fku�ac^���Rjla�_>�Nuxe fkj[d�l�Gut�Gacev�h^[�N_ � Z0� d&dNj[_bu���f\u�vxutdy_bacu7�G�&vxutacvtfku�vxi\acvtjldGecvtaci�_J���Rjli\d�_�Gu vxj[dGvxjl�Nace �Gutewr�st�Gig^E_baci\vxute�� � f ��jla _b�Gj vxutd�_cacu"�|�Rjlikdy_ �Gu vxj[dGvxjl�Nacew�Gute � ^[�N_cux�Ga�e�� u�_ �fku1vxuxdy_cacu �G��vxuxa�vxf\u�ikdNecvxa�i\_�� �Rjli\d�_ �GumvxjldGvtjl�Ga�e �Guxe �Gike�ecutvt_ba�ikvtuxe i\d�_csxa�ikux�NacuxetZ%� d(dNj[_bu�fku7�Guxr&i4� � staci\r���_bacu"�[e�jli\_.7 � � � � ��8 � �nu�_ y f �~^[ika�u��G��_cacik^[d�lf\u[Z0� d&dGj[_bu ��u�_ &wf\uxe>ab^Cqlj[dGeacuxe>� utvt_ci�+�e7�Guxe7vtuxacvtfkute vtikacvtjldGe�vxaci�_be�u�_ i\dGecvtaci�_bexZ� d ^`fkuxe�a�uxfk^h_bi\jldGe�e��Gi��h^[dy_bute 5

]9j[i �Guxe�eci\d��Ge ��� �� �

� ��� �� �

� ��� �� �

� �H��� ��������

� j[acr �Gf\u �Gu�� stacjld���� &���� ,7� � � 8�7� � ��8�7� � ��8

D��Gsxjla��xr&un� �5� f>�n^[ec�Gi� ( �?� ( � � ( � � ��� �"! � �

� j[acr �Gf\u � �54 �Gfkuta� � ( � � ( � �h��&

$ acjli�_buw� �54 �Gfkuta�'� �� � � �0�� �

Y$#

Page 11: French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _ GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld Gu # [uxvt_cux Ga a Z l1m n o r xvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld` Gu

O

A

B

C

H

GI

A

B

C

H

A

B

G

H

Un triangleAB C avecsesquatrepointscentrauxprincipaux

Le cercled’Eulerou cercledesneufpoints

A

B

C

H A

H B

H C

PA

PB

PC

O

H A

H B

H C

Q A

Q B

Q C

Le triangleorthique:lestrianglesAH B H C ,H A B H C ,H A H B Csontsemblablesentreeuxetinversementsemblablesau triangleAB C ,lespointsQ A ,Q B ,Q C sontlessym´ etriquesdeH parrapportauxcot es.

�`VcPRQRSUTBVXWGYZN�]\^ob T�k�N�� OfN�O�� �TBPRQfN��.egSjVhPfO��N&VlPRQmT ����XQRSjV �&S���T ��

� jPq[jldGe�r-^[i\dy_buxdG^[dy_�� �Nuxf!���GuteA�Nacj��Ga�iks�_bsxe��Nuxe,� jli\dy_be�acutr-^ha���� ^[�Gf\uxetZ

��� ��JRB�� M*=93

!�" ' � E$# 2A" # � �.#cE ,�h"56K61#B@�'$/K" @B#c"5%('��/D"$#G+H/?# " 6D6g+�# ��# 1 � ,l%�6 E # '$/K" ,h%�XE # 1�221 - @ " #&6g'�1���<"5/?# E#" "5%('f#�/D6?# @�'0" !�% ��# E , �h"56K6?# @�'$/K"$@ # ,��G#B@ E , �</1!�" 'R# 7 221 8 4J#�' 61!�" ' � E$# 2*"$# � ��# E ,�h" 6D6?#B@G'0/D"$@B#o#��3'&�/D"$#�+h/?# " 6D6g+�# ��# 17 !G% , ,hE !�/K6pE#" ���,hE5" '�p6g+H" �?,h%('f# '

� 2� 1 � � 2

� 1 � 1 21.1 �

� <�V*X]9�V 5� 4���utacvxi\vxuhZ �

YlY

Page 12: French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _ GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld Gu # [uxvt_cux Ga a Z l1m n o r xvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld` Gu

��� ��JRB�� M*= ¢

!�" ' 1�221 +H% '0/K" ,h%�XE #p"5%�6?@&/K" ' � ,h%.6 E$# @ #�/?@&E$# � ��# @B#&%('0/?# � 9 !�" ' � E$# @ #�%('0/1# �(+ @B#�/1@�E #" %�61@�/K" ' 7 � E , 6?# @B!�%$�.# " %('R#�/K61#B@G'0"$!G% �.# E , �l" 6K61#B@G'0/K" @B# " %('&�/K" #�+H/1# " 6K6B+�# ��# 1 , �G#B@ � 9� E$!G/K6

�H9 E$#&6 �</1!�" 'R#�6 7 � � 8 #�' 7 221 8 6?!G%*'�24#�/ 2=#&%$�<" @�+HE ,h" /1#�6 - ��!�%*@ � #&6g'3E$#4I "5E " #�+ ��# E," ,h/?@� ; 4 7

� 9 E$# @ #�/?@&E$# ��#o@B#&%('0/?# � 2 ,l6K6�,l%*'F2 ,h/ 2 #�' 1 23,h6K61#+���,hE$#&IJ#&%(' 2 ,h/ E$#`24!�"5%*' � 9

� <�V*X]9�V 5� 4���utacvxi\vxu �

��� � JLB�� M*= U � � BEO�D FI�RW�= JLBP@ � O ��TI=��

!�" ' � � ��� � ��� E$#&6\2A" # �<6 ��#�6��,.+�'R#�+H/D6 " 6D6g+�#&6 /?#&6 24#B@G'0"��G#�I #�%('3��#&6 6?!GI I #�'$6 1 � 2 � 1� " +h%�'0/D" ,h% �XE$# ,<@G+�' ,l%�XE$# - ��!�%(' 'R!�+H6�E$#&6 ,h% �XE$#&6�61!�%('\,l".�+H6�4 7 61!�" '�� E," !�/g'��*! @ #�%('0/1# ��#�@ #'0/K" ,h%�XE # 7 !�% ,8,lE$!�/D6

�H9 E$#�6 '$/K" ,l%�XE$#&6 1 ��� ��� 7 � 2 � � 7 � ��� 1 6?!�%('(�<" /1#B@G'f#�I #�%(' 6?#&I �hE , �hE$#&6 #�%('0/1##�+�� #G'=" %$�<"5/?# @�'f#&IJ#&%('46?#�I �hE , �lE$#�6�, + '$/K" ,h%�XE # 1�221 7

� 9 E$#&6�,.+�'R#�+H/D6 �(+o'0/K" ,h%�XE # 1 221 6?!G%*'�E #�6 �l" 6K61#B@G'0/K" @B#&6F"5%('��/D"$#G+H/?#&6 �(+o'0/K" ,h%�XE # � � � ��� 7,B2�24#�E� _cacik^[d�lf\u jla�_c�Gi!���Gu 7<9 E #�6 6fC.I �'$/K"$).+�#&6 ��# � 2 ,h/8/�,B2�24!�/B' , +�� '0/1!�" 6 @ �<'��6 �(+ '0/K" ,h%�XE # 1�221 ,B2.2 ,h/

'0"$#&%�%*#&%*' ,.+ @ #�/?@&E$#o@�"5/?@ !�%�6?@&/K" ' 1 1 221 9

O

A

B

C

H

GI

A

B

C

H

A

B

G

H

Un triangleAB C avecsesquatrepointscentrauxprincipaux

Le cercled’Eulerou cercledesneufpoints

A

B

C

H A

H B

H C

PA

PB

PC

O

H A

H B

H C

Q A

Q B

Q C

Le triangleorthique:lestrianglesAH B H C ,H A B H C ,H A H B Csontsemblablesentreeuxetinversementsemblablesau triangleAB C ,lespointsQ A ,Q B ,Q C sontlessym´ etriquesdeH parrapportauxcot es.

� <�V*X]9�V 5� 4���utacvxi\vxu �

Y�o

Page 13: French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _ GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld Gu # [uxvt_cux Ga a Z l1m n o r xvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld` Gu

� � ��JLB���M = V ���m=�BE�yWQ= S'� T�W�=�B � !�" ' 1 � � 2 � � 1 � E$#�6 I8" E5"$#�+ � /1#�6 2=# @�'0" � 6 �.#�6 @ ��'&�6 221 � 1�1 � 1�2 7 � � ��� � ��� E$#&6 2*"$# �X6��#�6 ��,.+�'f#G+H/K6\" 6K6B+�#�63��# 1 � 2 � 1 #�' ; �K;�� �J;�� E$#&6\I8" E " #�+��c/?#�6 2=# @�'$" � 63�.# � 1 � � 2 � � 1 9� E$!G/K6cE$#&6c%*#�+ �p24!�" %('06 1 � � 2 � � 1 � � � � ��� � ��� �J; �K;�� �J;�� ,B2.2 ,h/g'$"$#&%�%*#�%(' 1 +H%�I��&IJ#@B#�/1@�E # , 2�2=#&E� vtuxacvtfkun� �54 �Gfkuta 7 ��#o@B#&%('0/?#�� I8" E5"$#G+ �(+ 6?#��XIJ#&%(' � � � � #�' ��# /�,?C.!�% � � �.9

O

A

B

C

H

GI

A

B

C

H

A

B

G

H

Un triangleAB C avecsesquatrepointscentrauxprincipaux

Le cercled’Eulerou cercledesneufpoints

A

B

C

H A

H B

H C

PA

PB

PC

O

H A

H B

H C

Q A

Q B

Q C

Le triangleorthique:lestrianglesAH B H C ,H A B H C ,H A H B Csontsemblablesentreeuxetinversementsemblablesau triangleAB C ,lespointsQ A ,Q B ,Q C sontlessym´ etriquesdeH parrapportauxcot es.

� <�V*X]9�V 5� y jli�_ � f\u r&ikfki\ux���Gu � � � � �%� f\uwvxutacvxf\uw�Guwvxutdy_bacu � ut_7�Guwac^Pq[jld � � ��Z y jli\_��3f ���Gjlr&j"�_b�Gs�_biku��Gu vxuxdy_cacu � ut_ �Gu ac^���Rjla�_ �-, � ��Z 4 fkfku�uxdE�[jliku���utd � ���NjldGv f\u vtuxa�vxfku vxi\acvxj[dGecvtaci\_� 1�221 e��Ga � Z 4 fkfku uxdE�ljli\u 1 uxd 1 � � 2 utd 2 � � 1 utd 1 � �G�GjldGv 1 � � 2 � � 1 � ^��� ^[a _bi\uxdGdGutdy_� � Z y j[i\_�� � f ���Gjlr&j[_b�Nst_bi\u �GuAvxutdy_bacu � ut_1�GuAab^"�� j[a�_ , � �]� uxf\fku utd0�[jliku@� uxd � ���GjldNvfku&vxuxa�vxf\u�vtikacvtjldGe�vxaci�_� 1�221 ec�Na2� Z�4>f\fkuAuxdE�[jliku 1 uxd ; � 2 uxd ;�� � 1 uxd ;����I�GjldNv; �J;�� �J;�� ^��� ^[a _bi\uxdGdGutdy_�� � Z y j[i\_ � fg^��Nacjli�_bu� ^hab^[f\fk�xf\u��7 1 � 8�� ^heceb^hd�_ � ^[a � Z4>f\fku3uxe _��Ruxa>� utdG�Gi\vx�Gfk^[ika�u6� 7 221 8*�>�Gj[dGv6�G^[ab^[f\fk�tfkuL� 7 1 � �28�Z i jlr&r&u � uxe�_-fku3r&ikfki\ux��Gu�� � � � � fk^-�Gacj[i\_bu � ute�_nfk^�r�st�Gig^h_caci\vxu��Nu/� 1 � � � � �GjldNv`jld�^ � � � � 1 � � � � �a��GjldGv�� ^���G^[a�_cikuxdy_,�+� Z � d r&jldy_ba�uw�Gunr@?tr�u#���Gu���� u�_ ��� ^���G^[a�_cikuxdNdGuxdy_A�+�>Z0�

]�ute �Gut��� _b�Gstjlac�tr�ute ec�Ni��h^[dy_be ecjldy_ _cac�te �N_cikf\uxe,� jl�Na r&jldy_ba�uxa����Gu�_ba�jlike��Rjlikdy_ce e�jldy_^[fki��ldGsxe jl�L� �Nu1_cacjli\e��Gacjli�_bute�ecjldy_�vxjldNvxjl�Gac^[dy_bute jl�L� ^hab^[f\fk�xf\uxetZ

��� � JLB�� M*= ;�� ��� � F9� WQDI?��

!�" ' 1 221 +H% '0/K" ,h%�XE #4#�' ;0���+��� '$/?!�"56(2=!�"5%('06(2A/K"56>/?#�6 2=# @�'$"���#&IJ#&%('(6B+H/ E #�6 �</1!�" 'R#�6 7 221 8 77 1 1 8 7 7 1�2 8 9�� E !�/K6 E #�6i24!�" %('$6 ; �&� ��� 6?!G%*' ,hE5".�X% �6 6K"�#G'46?#G+HE$#&IJ#&%*'=6D"=!G% ,

2 ;; 1��

1 �� 1 �

1 �� 2 � �-,

YPz

Page 14: French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _ GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld Gu # [uxvt_cux Ga a Z l1m n o r xvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld` Gu

!��cE$#�6 E !�%�+�#G+H/K6 61!�%('\@B!�%�6D"���&/, #�6 ,hE.� �h/K" ).+�#�I #�%(' 9

A

B

C

P

Q

R

T

A

B

C

P

Q

R

T

Le th eor eme deMenela us

Le th eor eme deCeva.

� <�V*X]9�V 5� y jli\_ � f ��ikdy_butace�uxvt_cikjld �Gute��Nacjli�_buxe 7Q; � 8 ut_47 1 2 8*�v} f ��ikdy_butace�uxvt_cikjld �Gu3fk^ �G^[ab^[f\fk�tfku��7Q; � 8c� ^[e�eb^[dy_A� ^[a 1 u�_7�GuA7 1�2 8�ZL��^ha�f\u _b�Gstjlac�tr�uw�Nu D�� ^hfk�xe3�Gjld ^

2 ;; 1 � 2 �

��} �1 �� 1 �

} �� 1 �

� �~j�b 2 ;; 1 �

1 �� 1 �

1 �� 2 � 2 �

��} �} �� 1 �

1 �� 2 � ��,

��^[a�vtjldGecs3���Guxdy_ fkuxe&�Rjli\d�_ce0;0���+��� ecjldy_ ^[fki��ldGste eci�ut_7ecut�Gfkutr�utdy_ e�i jld ^ ��� � � ���� �Ge�jli\_

��� ��Z �

� � ��JLB���M = ;L; ���m=��GD �

!�" ' 1 221 +H% '0/K" ,h%�XE #4#�' ;0���+��� '$/?!�"56(2=!�"5%('06(2A/K"56>/?#�6 2=# @�'$"���#&IJ#&%('(6B+H/ E #�6 �</1!�" 'R#�6 7 221 8 77 1 1 8 7 7 1�2 8 9� E$!�/D6pE$#&6 �</?!G" 'f#&6 7 1 2 8 7 7 2 � 8 7 7 1 ��8 61!�%('`@B!�%*@ !�+H/&,h%('f#�6�6K"F#�'46?#G+HE$#&IJ#&%('6K"�!�%L, '

YC}

Page 15: French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _ GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld Gu # [uxvt_cux Ga a Z l1m n o r xvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld` Gu

2 ;; 1 �

1 �� 1 �

1 �� 2 � ,

!��cE$#�6 E !�%�+�#G+H/K6 61!�%('\@B!�%�6D"���&/, #�6 ,hE.� �h/K" ).+�#�I #�%(' 9

A

B

C

P

Q

R

T

A

B

C

P

Q

R

T

Le th eor eme deMenela us

Le th eor eme deCeva.� <�V*X]9�V 5� y jli\_.}�f\u,�Rjli\d�_ � ��ikdy_cuxace�uxv�_bikj[d-�Gute �Ga�jli\_cuxe-7 1 ; 8�ut_�7 2 � 8 � e�jli\_ �*f\u,�Rjli\d�_ � ��ikdy_cuxace�uxv �_bikj[d6�Guxe7�Ga�jli\_cuxe�7 1 }.8 ut_ 7 2 1 8 Z ]�u1ac^���Rjla�_��Guxe7fkj[d�l�Gut�Gace ���� � ute�_�s��l^[f%� ^[a�e�ikr&ikf\i\_b�N�Gu�Gu&_cacik^[d�lf\uxew^[� ab^���� jla _n�Guxe1�Gi\e�_|^hdGvxutem�Gu 2 u�_ 1 � fk^3�Nacjli�_bu�7 1 ; 8 ��fku����Gutf uxe _ ^[f\jlaces��y^[f ^[� ac^���Rjla�_��GuxeA^hikacute�� �� ���

� � � �F�vxute _bacik^[d�lf\uxe1jldy_�Rjl�Gam� ^[ecu 1 }8ut_�Rjl�Gam� ^[�N_cux�Ga�e

fkuxe��Gi\e�_|^hdGvxute �Gu 2 ut_ 1 �-fk^&�Nacjli�_bu&7 1 ; 8�I Z 4>d��N_bi\fkikec^[dy_�fku1r@?tr�um^[a��[�Gr�utdy_��Rjl�Ga�fkute^[�N_ba�uxe7ab^"�� j[a�_J�Njld3jl�N_bi\uxdy_

2 ;; 1��

1 �� 1 �

1 �� 2 � � 1 } 2 �

� 1 } 1 � �� 2 } 1 �� 1 } 2 � �

� 1 } 1 �� 2 } 1 � � , �

�wd ^����Gfki�� �Nu6^[fkj[ace f\u�r@?tr�u�^[a��l�Nr�utd�_ ���GuL�Rjl�Ga fk^(�Gsxr&jldGe _bac^h_bi\jld �G� _b�Gstjlac�tr�u6�Nu= uxdGutfg^�NexZ ]�uxe�_cacjli\eA�Gacjli�_bute47 1 ; 8�� 7 2 � 8�� 7 1 ��8 vxj[dGvxjl�Nacuxdy_-eci7ut_�ecut�Gfkutr�utd�_-eci7jldV^��� ���Ge�jli\_ ��� � � �

�� � �GjldGvneci�u�_�ecux�Nfkuxr&uxdy_�eci�j[d ^

2 ;; 1 �

1 �� 1 �

1 �� 2 � , �

� f[u���ike _bu>�GdGuv�h^[a�ig^[dy_bu�_baci��ljldGj[r�s�_baci����Gu��G�w_c�Gsxjla��xr&u �Gu i u3�h^7�Gjldy_9fg^��Nsxr&jldGe�_cab^h_cikjlduxe�_�e�ikr&ikfg^hikacuhZ

Y��

Page 16: French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _ GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld Gu # [uxvt_cux Ga a Z l1m n o r xvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld` Gu

��� ��JRB�� M*=*;�X ���m=��GD @PBEOQ�LJRFIJRM*�y@PBEO�� T9= �

!�" ' 1 221 +H% '0/K" ,h%�XE #4#�' ;0���+��� '$/?!�"56(2=!�"5%('06(2A/K"56>/?#�6 2=# @�'$"���#&IJ#&%('(6B+H/ E #�6 �</1!�" 'R#�6 7 221 8 77 1 1 8 7 7 1�2 8 9� E$!�/D6pE$#&6 �</?!G" 'f#&6 7 1 2 8 7 7 2 � 8 7 7 1 ��8 61!�%('`@B!�%*@ !�+H/&,h%('f#�6�6K"F#�'46?#G+HE$#&IJ#&%('6K"�!�%L,

�� �� �1�1 ;�� �� �; 1 2 �

�� �� �1�2 ��� �� � � 221 �

�� �� �221 ��� �� �� 1�1

� , �

�,mkl � rx���u������Kt ¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=�X9; $ sxr&jldy_bacuta7fkuxe�_cacjli\e�_b�Gstjlac�tr�ute7dGjld �Gsxr&jldy_ba�sxe7�G� vxjl�Ga�exZ

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=�XRX y jlikutd�_A� ��ut_&� (&�Gut��� vxutacvxf\uxe&�Gu ab^CqljldNe�a�uxe��Ruxv�_bi4+�e & ��ut_�&�(�ecu vxjl��� ^[dy_&uxd 1 u�_

2 � � �NdGu �Ga�jli\_cu����Gutfkvtjld���Gu� ^heceb^hd�_�� ^[a 1 Z y jlikutdy_ 1 ut_ � fkuteA�Rjli\d�_ce ���~i\d�_cuxa�ecuxv�_bi\jldacuxe>� utvt_ci�+�e��Gu � ^7�[uxv � � ut_.��(CZ i ^[fkvt�Gfkuta�fkunab^"�� j[a�_ 221��"2 � utd6+�jldGv�_bi\jld3�GdGi!���Gutr�utdy_�Gu & ��u�_�&�(PZ

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=�XR� y jli\_ 1�221 �Gd _bacik^[d�lf\unut_";0���+���$_cacjli\eA�Rjli\d�_ceA�Nacike�acute��Ruxv�_bi��[uxr&uxdy_we��Ga f\uxe �Nacjli�_buxe

7 221 8*�,7 1�1 8*�C7 1 2 8�Z � d�e����Rjlecu����Gu�f\uxe�_ba�jlike��Nacjli�_buxe 1 ; � 2 � � 1 ��ecu1vxjl��Ruxdy_ uxd6}��r�jldy_cacuxa&��� ��jld ^A^[fkjla�e

}-;1 ; �

} �2 � �

} �1 � � , �

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=�X � ���m=�Bh�yW�= S����U JRW W�JRF�OQTI?�� y jli\_ 1 u�_ 2 �Gux� � �Rjlikdy_ce u�_�� �Nd�acstuxfI�Gi�M sxa�uxdy_ �Gu , ZM= j[d�_cacuta����Gu�f �~utdGecutr �Gf\um�Gute

� jli\dy_be�� �N���Gfk^[d _butfke����Gu�f\u`ab^���� jla _ 1 � �"2 � ecj[i\_ns��l^[f.��� ute�_m�Gd vtuxa�vxfku&�Gjldy_1fkuvxuxdy_cacum^��� ^[a _bi\uxdy_,�`fg^ �Ga�jli\_cu 7 1�2 8�Z

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=�XR� ��� JROQF @�?`S9=�� DN�R= W =y@�S9=��6=�B��LJ FIF9= � y jli\_ 1 221 �Gd6_ba�ig^[d��lfku"�Necj[ikuxdy_I;0���+��� fkuxe&�Rjli\d�_ce��Gunvxjldy_b^[vt_7�G� vxutacvtfkunikdGe�vxa�i\_7^J�lutv

fkuxe�v��[_bste 221 � 1�1 � 1�2 �Necjli�_I; � f\u#� jli\dy_7�Gunvxjldy_|^hvt_��G�3vxutacvxf\unu���ikdGe�vxa�i\_7� ^[dNe f �{^[d��lfku 1^[��_ba�ig^[d��lfkum^J�luxv`f\u v��h_bs 221 FQf\u vxutacvtfku u �Ni\dGecvtaci�_ � ^[dNe f �~^[d�lf\u 1 uxe�_nf\u�vtuxacvtfku�_b^[d�lutdy_^[��� _bacj[ike�v��[_bste`�G� _ba�ig^[d�[fku��9r�^[ikemecu6e�i\_b�G^[dy_ �Gu6f �{^[��_bacu�v��[_cs6�Gu�fk^��Gacj[i\_bu 7 221 8 � ^[aab^���Rjla _�^[�6_bacik^[d�lf\u7I ZC� d3�Gs3B dNi\_��Gunr@?tr�u fkuxe��Rjlikdy_ce � � ut_ � � Z

;� = j[d�_cacuta#� �Nu`fkuxe �Gacjli�_bute+7 1 ; 8'� 7 2 � 8�� 7 1 ��8�ecj[d�_nvtjldGvtjl�Gab^hd�_cuxe@F �Rjli\d�_ �Guwuxak��ljldGdGuJI�Z

X$� = jldy_ba�uxa����Gu1fkuxe7�Ga�jli\_cuxe�7 1 ; � 8�� 7 2 � � 8'� 7 1 � � 8�ecj[d�_�vtjldGvxj[�Gab^[dy_cuxe�F � j[ikdy_7�Gu�/ ^���luxf �GdGj[_cs�5 I�Z

�$� = jldy_bacuta����Gu f\uxeA� jli\dy_be � � � �J5 ecjldy_ ^[fki��ldGsxe�� ^[dNe vxu�_wjla��Gacumut_���� ��jld ^A5 � �� � � � Z

�!� y jlikutd�_ 1 � � 2 � � 1 �lf\uxe�r&ikf\ikux� �n�Guxe v��[_bste �Gu 1 221 Z = jldy_ba�uxa ���Gu�f\u�vxutdy_bacu��N�`vxuxa�vxf\uikdGe�vxaci�_�� ^[dNe 1 � 2 � 1 � uxe _�fkuwr&ikfki\ux���N� e�u��lr&uxdy_ � � 5 � Z

YP�

Page 17: French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _ GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld Gu # [uxvt_cux Ga a Z l1m n o r xvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld` Gu

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=�X 3 y jli\_���� i $ �GdO� ^[ac^[fkf\sxf\j��lab^hr�r&u-_butf����Gu f �~^[d�[fku 1 uxe _ ^[i!�l��Z ]�u vxutacvtfku(�Gu �Nig^��

r���_bacu�� 1�1 � a�uxdGvtjldy_ba�u�fkute �Nacjli�_buxe 7 2 1 8�ut_)7 1 � 8�uxd �"ut_ � acuxe>� utvt_ci��lutr�utdy_CZ ]9^A_|^[da��luxdy_bu ^[��vxuxa�vxf\u uxd 1 vtjl��Ru fk^1�Nacjli�_bu 7 2 �<8>utd<;AZ = jldy_ba�uxac���Gu fkute8�Rjlikdy_ce ;0� �0��� e�jldy_^[fki��ldGsxetZ

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=�X�¢My jli\_�� �GdGu3�Gacj[i\_bu�� ^[ecec^[dy_��G^[a`f ��jla�_c�Gj vxuxdy_cacu6�G� _ba�ig^[d��lfku 1 221 ZO= jldy_ba�uxa ���Gu3fkute

e�q r�s�_ba�i!���Guxe-�Gu���� ^[a-ac^���Rjla�_�^[���Vv��[_csxe6�G� _bacik^[d�lf\u6�G^[ece�uxdy_L� ^[a��Nd r@?tr�u6� j[ikdy_J�r�jldy_cacuxa&���Gunvtu �Rjlikdy_7^"�� ^[a _bikutdy_�^[� vtuxa�vxfkunvtikacvtjldGe�vxaci�_,� 1�221 Z

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=�X U y jli\_ 1 221 �Nd3_cacik^[d�lf\u ^[vt�N_|^[d��lfku"��e�jlikutd�_�� ut_ 5�f\uxe�i\d�_cuxa�ecuxv�_bi\jldGe��Guwfk^��Gike�ecutvt_ba�ikvtu

ikdy_butacdGu �Nu`f �~^[d�lf\u 1 ^J�[uxv 7 2 1 8 u�_1^J�luxv`f\u vxutacvtfku vtikvxj[dGecvtaci\_�� 1�221 Z y jlikutd�_�� u�_ �fkuxe��Gacj���utvt_cikjldGew�Nu� e��Gawfkute v��[_csxe � 1�2 � ut_ � 1�1 � Z = jldy_bacuta#���Gu`f �~^[ika�u��G����� ^h�Gaci\fg^h_c�xacu1 � 5 � uxe _ s3�y^[f\u��Avtuxf\fkuw�G�3_ba�ig^[d�[fku 1 221 Z

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=�X V = jldy_bacuta ���Gu7fkuxe�e�q r�s�_ba�i!���Guxe �Nu�v|� ^����Gu7ecjlr&r&ut_ � ���Gd`_ba�ig^[d��lfku8� ^[a�ac^���Rjla�_>^h�`v��[_cs

j���Rjlecs7ecj[d�_ ^[f\i!�ldGste�eciLu�_ e�ux�Gf\uxr&uxdy_ eci fg^w�Gi\e�_b^[dGvxu7�Gu�f ��jla _b�Gj vxutd�_cacu7^[�&vxutdy_bacu �G�&vxuxa�vxf\uvxika�vxjldNecvxa�i\_7ute�_�s��y^hfku��`ecjld �Gik^[r���_ba�u[Z

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=��L��y jli\_ 1�221 �Gd�_ba�ig^[d�[fku���e�jli\_ 1 � 2 � 1 � �Gd�_ba�ig^[d��lfku��Gika�uxv�_buxr&uxdy_�e�uxr �Nfg^[�Gf\u�� 1 221 �Nu

_buxf\fku e�jla�_cu�� �Nu 1 ^���� ^[a�_cikutdGdGun^[�3v��h_bs 2 � 1 � � 2 ^[�3v��h_bs 1 � 1 � ut_ 1 ^h� v��[_bs 1 � 2 � Z y jli\_� f\umvtuxdy_ba�u �G� vxutacvtfku�vtika�vxjldGe�vxa�i\_�� 1�221 � � ecj[d jla�_c�Gj�vtuxdy_ba�u�u�_� � vxuxf\�GiI�Gu 1 � 2 � 1 � Z= jldy_ba�uxa���� �~j[d�^ � � �N� �6�kZ

� � 2 ���9��� f 46�7�8� �-����� �B� �7�

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l= ;�y jli\_�z{ fku.�lutvt_but�Gav�Rjla�_csc� ^ha �����Gu fkjld��l�Gux�Na ��FQu�_��Gu ecutdGe ^[a��Gi\_cab^[i\acu7I Z y jli�_ � � f ��ikr�^��lu

�Gu���� ^ha�fg^�_cab^[dGe�fg^h_cikjld��Gu��lutvt_cux�Ga(z{ ZC� d ^���Ruxfkf\u 1 u�_ 2 f\uxe�i\dy_buxa�ecutvt_bi\jldGe��Gu�� ut_I� � Z]I^w�Ga�jli\_cu � � ^hab^[f\fk�xf\u�� ��� ^[e�eb^[dy_1� ^[a 1 acs3� j[dG���wf �~stdGjldGvts[Z 4 dAu3M ut_ fg^ _cab^[dGe�fg^h_cikjld`�Nu�luxv�_but�Ga � z{ uxdE�ljli\uwfku��Rjli\d�_ 1 ec�Ga��GdL�Rjlikdy_ 1 ���Gi'��G^[a�vxj[dGe�_cac�Gv�_bikj[d �Nu 1 � ^���� ^[a�_cikutd�_� � ut_7uxe _ _cuxf%���Gu 1�1 � � Z

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=�X�� dy_cacj �G�Gike�jldGe����-fk^�e�q r&st_caciku-vxuxdy_cab^[f\u6�Gu6vxutd�_cacu2���hZ y i f ��jld ec���� j[ecuL��� �~i\f u �Ni\e�_cu

u3M uxvt_ci��[uxr&uxdy_&�Gd_� jlf�q]� �ldGu 1 �M����� 1 �(_butf&���Gu2���6ecj[i\_`f\u6r�i\fkikut�*�Gu 1 � 1 �JLM�~FQj�b_� ^[avxjldE�lutdy_bikj[d 1 � LM� � 1 �>I �L^[fkj[ace,�����h^AutdE�ljPqluta fku#�Rjli\d�_A���wec�Ga7fku#�Rjli\d�_A���JLM� Z� ikdGe�i]���K�h^�?t_ba�u �Nd��Rjlikdy_KBN��u �Nu fk^7vtjlr�� jle�sxu8�������8�M����� �� �|Z i ^[f\vx�Gf\jldGe9�GjldGv vxu�_c_cu

vxjlr�� j[ecsxuhZ���dGu e q�r&st_caci\u vxutd�_cab^[f\u ute�_��GdNu acj[_b^h_bi\jld-���{^[d��lfku,� ��fk^ma����lf\u �Gu vtjlr�� jle�i\_cikjld�Guxe1acj[_b^h_bi\jldGewdGj[�Gem�Ni\_n�GjldNv@���Gu�eci�� uxe�_ � ^[i\a����h^2?�_ba�u��GdNu&_cab^[dGe�fg^h_cikjld|� ut_1eciO� uxe _ikr�� ^[ika��1e�uxab^A�GdGune q�r&st_caci\u1vtuxdy_bac^[fkuhZ

� ikdGe�i�eci,�3uxe _Aikr�� ^[ika3��i\f8�h^ �Gikutd u���ike _buxa`�Nd �Rjlikdy_B��NsL� ^ha��E��uxd f ��j�vtvx�Ga�acutdGvxu3fkuvxuxdy_cacu��Numfk^Ae q r�s�_baci\unvxuxdy_cab^[f\u[Z � d��Gs*B dGi\_�r�^[ikdy_cuxd ^[dy_ 1 ��vxjlr&r&uwst_|^hd�_ vxu��Rjlikdy_J� 1 (

Y��

Page 18: French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _ GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld Gu # [uxvt_cux Ga a Z l1m n o r xvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld` Gu

vxjlr&r�u1st_b^[dy_wf ��ikr�^��luw�Nu 1 �,� ^ha#� � � 1 *wf ��ikr�^��lun�Gu 1 (#� ^ha#��(7� u�_w^[i\dGeciI�Gu e��Gi\_cu[Z�� fg^B d%�Nj[d6acut_cjlr �Ru �Gi\uxd6ec�Na 1 � LM� � 1 � ut_�f\u�� j[f\q]� �ldGu 1 �M����� 1 ��uxe�_�_cuxf � ���~jld3f\u��ljl�Nfg^[i�_CZ

��^[aAvxjldy_cacu eci � uxe�_@� ^[i\a���i\f�d ��u���ike _bu2� ^[e +�jlacvtsxr&uxdy_&�Gd _buxf��Rjlikdy_�BN��uhZ � f\�Ge �Gacs �vxike�sxr&uxdy_ e�i&�-ute�_`fk^ _bac^[dGe�fg^h_cikjld��Gu��[uxvt_cux�Ga�d �Nf'�9_bjl�Gemfkute��Rjlikdy_be��ljldy_`vtjldE�lutdGika�Rjl�Ga1 ���Gjld vxjldNe�_ba��Gi\_�utdGec�Gi�_bunfkute�^[�N_ba�uxe��Rjlikdy_be7�Gunr�?xr&u#���Gu �Nacsxvtsx�Gutr�r&uxdy_xZ $ ^[dGe�fkuwvC^hevxjldy_bac^[ika�u��Gi\f d � q3^[�Gac^�� ^[e7�Gunecjlf\�N_bi\jldGe�^h�6�Ga�jl�Gf\�xr&u[Z

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=���

A 1

A 2

A 3 = r(A 2)

D 1

D 2

D 3

r(D 1)

r(D 2)r(D 3)

A

B C

D

B C

DE

E

� i���jldGe7�Gd �Rjli\d�_ 1 ���Gu-�&��Z /�j[_bj[dGe &`fk^acj[_b^h_bi\jld��Gu�vxuxdy_cacu 1 ��ut_w� �~^[d�[fku � N * Z��Ijl�Ga� �Nu 1 � 1 ( 1 *�e�jli\_ �Gd-_cacik^[d�lf\u�s3���Gikfk^h_bstab^[fL�Gi �acuxv�_Iikf[e���)A_ � �Nu 1 *���&%7 1 (�8�Z7�wa�j[d��[ux�N_ ���Gufkuxe8� j[ikdy_be 1 (�ut_ 1 *7^���� ^[a�_cikutdGdGuxdy_�a�uxe>� utvt_bi ��luxr&uxdy_��#�+(�ut_ �)*J�P�GjldNv 1 *��Gj[i\_I^���G^[a�_cuxdGi\a� f ��ikdy_cuxace�uxv�_bikj[dm�Gute��Ga�jli\_cuxe &%7��+(J89u�_��)*CZ i uxe�Gacjli�_butewecu&vxjl��Ruxdy_1uxd �Gd��GdGi!���Gu �Rjlikdy_�� jld^(�GjldGv 1 *Aut_Ajld _cacjl���[u 1 (Auxd ^����Gfki�� �G^[dy_� 1 * fk^ acj[_b^h_bi\jld � &�Z

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l= �,� d eb^hi\_���� ���GdGuA�Gj[r�j[_c�Gst_cikum�Gu`ab^���� jla _�) r �Nf\_bi��Gfki\unfkuxe fkjld�[�Gux�Ga�e�� ^[a .0)�.pZ|� vti'� jld

�lux��_`uxdE�ljPq[uxa`�Gd vtuxa�vxfku��Gu-ac^Cqljld & �wec�Gam�Gd vxutacvtfku-�Nu�ab^Cqlj[d�&�(~5Ifku&ab^���� jla _=) �Gu*��ac^�GjldGv#�lstaci4B uxa=.0)�."�����

���Gvh�~ute�_>�G��� �Nikacu�)(����

���jl�/)~� � ������ Z4 d jl�N_cacu�� vtut_�_bu1�Gjlr&j[_b�Gs�_bi\u �Gu3� ac^�uxdE�[j�q[uxa fkuwvxutdy_bacu1�G�6�Gacutr�i\uxa�vtuxacvtfku"�R�Nikecj[dGe�� �

ec�Ga7fkuwvtuxdy_ba�un�G� e�uxvtjldG�%� ��(CZ�� ikdGe�i�jld3�Gjli�_7^J�ljli\a�fg^`acutfg^h_cikjld �3���� ��(c�3) �3���� � � ZC� f dGuna�uxe�_cu�Gfk�Ge&��� � �AvxjldGe _ba��Gika�u1f\uxe��Gut���2�Rjlikdy_be&���Gu1f ��jld6jl��_bikutdy_�^[ikdGe�i Z$ ^[dGe`fku�vC^[e`j�b & �� &�(7���GdGu6�Gute �Gux� � �Gjlr&j[_b�Nst_bi\uxe �Gacstvxsx�Nuxdy_bute�ute�_A�Gu�ac^���Rjla�_

, ut_�fku-vtuxdy_ba�u6vxjla�acute��RjldG� ^[dy_`ute�_`a�u ��u�_bs(��f �~i\d�B dGi Z i ut_c_cu��Gjlr&j[_c�Gst_ciku&uxe�_ uxd +Q^[i�_��GdNu_bab^hdGecfk^h_bi\jld Z�Z\Z

� � r�jli\dGe�� ^hdGe3fku(vx^[e3j�b�fkute6�Gux����vxuxa�vxf\uxe3dGu ex��ikdy_butace�uxvt_cuxdy_6� ^[e�� jld acuxr�^[a>� �Nu� �Nu fkute vtuxdy_ba�uxe��Gute��Gjlr&j[_c�Gst_cikuxe vxj[acacute��RjldG�Gutdy_7^[���@�Rjlikdy_be �Gu vxjldGvtjl�Ga�e��Guxe _|^[d��luxdy_butevxjlr&r �GdGute7^[���3�Nux��� vtuxacvtfkutexZ

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=���

A 1

A 2

A 3 = r(A 2)

D 1

D 2

D 3

r(D 1)

r(D 2)r(D 3)

A

B C

D

B C

DE

E

� d�vxjldNe�_ba��Gi\_1� �~^[�Rjlac���Gd vC^[a�acs 221 � �u�� _bstacikut�Gacutr�utdy_V^h� v��[_bs 2 1 �G�"_bacik^[d�lf\u[Zy jlikutdy_<� � u�_ � � fkuxe ikdy_butacecutvt_cikjldGe �Gu 1 ��u�_1 � ^J�lutv f\u6v��[_cs 2 1 Z y j[i\_ � f �~�Njlr�jh_b�Gs�_biku�Gu vxutdy_bacu 1 utdE�ljPqy^[dy_ � uxd �@�!��utfkfkumuxdE�lj[iku�Gu-r�?xr&u � uxd � � Z y jli\_ 2 � 1 � � � � � f ��ikr�^��lu�Gu 221 � � �G^[a � ZN��^[a�vtjldGe�_cac�Gv�_bi\jld6ikfRex�~^��li�_� �~�Nd vC^[a�acs[Z|� a f\uxe��Rjli\d�_ce 1 � 2 � 2 � ecjldy_w^hfki4��ldGsxe3�G_bjl��_7vxjlr&r�u fkuxe��Rjlikdy_ce 1 � 1 � 1 �!�G�NjldGvfkuwvC^hacacs 2 � 1 � �@� �ute�_�fkuwvx^[aca�s��[jl�Gf\� Z

Y �

Page 19: French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _ GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld Gu # [uxvt_cux Ga a Z l1m n o r xvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld` Gu

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=43��

� �

� �

���

]�u ecuxdNe��Gika�uxv�_ ute�_c+Q^hvxikf\u�5 e�i f\uxe �Gacj[i\_bute�7 �?598 ut_�7 221 8ecjldy_#� ^hab^[f\fk�xf\uxe3� ^hfkjla�e fk^@BC�l�Ga�u uxe _wikdE�h^[a�ig^[dy_bu � ^[a ab^���Rjla _��fg^�acs � u���i\jld � �~^E��u47 � 8*� � st_b^[dy_nfg^�� ^[��_bux�Nawikece��Gu`�Gu 1 Z�wd uxd �Gsx�N�Gi\_,���Gu1fku#�Rjlikdy_I;^���G^[a�_cikuxdy_A�Avxut_ ^E��u1ut_,���Gufkuxe7^hd�lfkute��1 ; � u�_#�1 ;�5 e�jldy_�s��y^[� ��Z

�Ijl�Ga fg^nacsxvti!�Ga�ja���Gu"��dNjl�Ge�^hfkfkj[dGe>ikdy_ba�j��G�Nikacu7fk^1a�s � u �Ni\jldvxjldGe�ik�Gstacstu��Gacstvxsx�Nuxr&r�utd�_�� vtuxfkf\u�� �~^E��u 7 � 8 Z ����� utfkjldGe � fk^�yZ�4 f\fku utd0�[jliku 2 ec�Ga 1 u�_ ;8ec�Gan�GdW� j[ikdy_�&Z9]�ute�^[d��lfkute��?; 2 ut_ � 54; 1 e�jldy_�s3�y^[���&vx^[a j���� jle�sxe8� ^[a fg^necjlr&r�u�_ �yikfuxdAacstec�Gf�_bu&���Gu7fkute>^[d�lf\uxe �1 ; 2 ut_ �1 ; 1 fku�e�jldy_ s��y^[f\uxr&uxdy_CZ� ikd ^hfkuxr&uxdy_��~jld�^ �1 ; 2 � �1 � 2 � � Z

= ^[ike1fg^3ecjlr&r&u&�Nuxem_cacjli\e�^hd�lfkutem���~�Gd�_ba�ig^[d�[fku�+Q^[i\_#��Z�wd3utd �Gst�G�Gi�_A���Gu 5

�1 2 ; � �2 1 ; � �1�2 � � �� 1 ; �N� � �

= ^[ike�r�^[dGi4+�uxe�_cuxr&uxdy_J��� ^[dGe7f\uxe�vxj[dG�Gi\_cikjldNe��Gunfg^�BC�[�Gacu"�Gjld ^`fkuxe�i\dGs��l^[fki�_bsxe �1�2 ; ��1�2 � ut_ �2-1 ; � �� 1 ;AZN]9^�a�uxfk^h_bi\jld@�Nacsxvtsx�Gutdy_bu#�Ga�jl���lu�� �Nu vxute�ikdGs3�y^[fki�_bste e�jldy_�utd~+Q^[i\_�Guxe7s��l^[fki�_bsxe3�Gut_�^hikdGe�iK� �Nu ;�� �&Z i utfg^��Ruxacr&ut_7�Nu1vtjldGvtfk�Ga�u[Z

YP�

Page 20: French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _ GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld Gu # [uxvt_cux Ga a Z l1m n o r xvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld` Gu

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l= ¢@]9^ vtjlr@�Rjle�sxu �Gu���a�j[_|^E_bikj[dGe � �~^[d�[fku (�N* ute�_7�GdNuwacj[_b^h_bi\jld�� �~^[d�lf\u �FN* �G�GjldGv fg^ vxj[r �

� jle�sxu �Nu+ -acj[_b^h_bi\jldGe � �{^hd�lfku (�N* uxe _wfg^�vxjlr�� j[ecsxu�� �~�NdGu acjh_|^h_cikjld � �{^hd�lfku �FN* ut_ � �~�NdGuacj[_b^h_bi\jld�� �~^[d�lf\u (�N* �N�GjldGvnv[��uxe _��GdGu _bac^[dGe�fg^h_cikjld Z84 d6�G^[a�_cikvx�Nfkikuta fk^�vxjlr��Rjlecstuw�Guxe�_ba�jlikeacj[_b^h_bi\jldGe�e��Gvxvtuxece�i��[uxe �Nsxvxa�i\_cuxe ^[�N_cjl�Ga �Gute1�Rjli\d�_ce 1 B � 1 �'� 1 ( ute�_ �GdGu�_cab^[dGe�fg^h_cikjld�Z y jli�_�z{fku~�lutvt_b^[�GaA�Gu3vxu�_c_bu6_cab^[dGe�fg^h_cikjld|��jld ^ ^[fkj[ace�z{ � �a���;,B';C*(� �]�E�;,*J;CSL� �����8� ���C�C���C�7�;O�QPFRF*';O�QPFRFSPZ$ jldGv eciI;CB2� ;O�QPFRFS7�>^hfkjla�e z{ uxe�_�fku~�[uxv�_bux�Na�d��Gf'� u�_��NjldGv f ��ikr�^��lu��Gu3_bj[�N_�� jli\dy_A�G��Gfg^[d�^��Ga��xe f\uxe7_bacj[ike��Nacuxr&ik�tacute a�j[_|^h_cikjldNe ute�_wvtu�r�?xr&u��Rjlikdy_CZ 4 d � ^ha�_bi\vx�Gf\ikuta,�Rjl�Ga 1 BJ�^��Gac�te-fk^��Ga�uxr&ik�xa�u a�j[_|^E_bikj[d i\f�ute�_-uxdE�ljPqls utd 1 BJ� ^��Ga��xe�fg^ e�uxvtjldG�Gu(i\f7uxe�_-uxdE�ljPq[s�utd�Gd�vxuta�_|^hikdZ�Rjlikdy_ 2 � u�_6^��Nac�xe6fk^�_cacjli\ecik�tr�u3a�j[_|^h_cikjld ikf�acu�_bjl�Ga�dGu(utd 1 BCZ i jlr�r&u jld^ �1 B 1 � 2 � �2 1 ( 1 B2� (�N* ut_ 1 B 1 ��� 1 � 2 � 2 1 (2� 1 ( 1 BJ�>^hfkjla�e`fkuxe���� ^E_bacu2�Rjlikdy_be1 B�� 1 ��� 2 � 1 (�+�jla�r�utd�_ �Gd(f\jleb^[d��lu��Gj[d�_ f �~^[d�lf\u1utd 1 ��u�_ 1 (��h^[��_ (�N* � �GjldGvmf �~^[d�lf\umutd1 B��[^h�N_ N * � u�_7fku _ba�ig^[d��lfku 1 B 1 � 1 ( ute�_�s����Gi\fg^h_csxac^[f Z

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=4U��A��Ruxfkj[dGe&� ^[a�u �Nutr@�Nfku�� � ����(7ut_I��* f\uxe _cacjli\e�vxutacvxf\uxe&���Gunf ��jld ^��`vxjldNecik�Nsxacuta7ut_�& � �

&�(�ut_ &�*�fkut�Ga ac^Cqljld6a�uxe��Ruxv�_bi4+ Z� d��h^�e����Rjlecuta�uxd�jl��_bacuA���Guwvxute _ba�jlike ab^Cqlj[dGe�ecj[d�_��Gux������Gux� �6�Gi\e�_bi\dGvt_ce�^"BGd(� �Nuwfkuxe _|^[d��luxdy_bute��Gjldy_�jld-�Gjli\_c�GacutdG�Ga�uwf ��ikdy_butacecutvt_cikjld-^[ikutd�_��Gikutd�Gd6�Rjli\d�_�vxjlr&r �Gd Z

�A��Ruxfkj[dGewr-^hikdy_butd ^[dy_ 1 �Q(1f\u�Rjlikdy_w� ��ikdy_cuxace�uxv�_bikj[d �Guxew_|^hd�luxdy_cuxewu�� _csxaci\ux�Ga�uxe�� � �ut_I��(CZ 4�_7�Gs3BGdGike�ecikj[dGe��Gunr@?tr�u 1 (F*�ut_ 1 * ��ZC�wd ^� �%� � ^[dNe�f ��u���uxa�vxikvtun}�����Gu 1 �Q(�st_b^[i\_fku vtuxdy_ba�um�Gunf �~�GdNi!���Guw�Gjlr&j[_c�Gst_ciku �Guwac^���Rjla�_ ���

�����Gi _bac^[dGe>+�j[acr�^[i\_6� � uxd���(CZ��A�� utfkjldNe

�@�Q(�vxu�_c_cum�Gj[r�j[_c�Gst_ciku u�_��Gs3B dNikece�jldGe7�Gu�+Q^�jxj[d ^hd ^[fkj��l�Gu �%(F* u�_ �%* ��Zi uA���Gu f �~jld�^m�Ni\_8�Gacstvxsx�Nuxr&r�utd�_c�Gacj[���lu �Gika�uxvt_cuxr&uxdy_����Gu��%(F* � �@�Q(�� � E �* � Z0� fLex�~^��li\_

�GjldGv utd~+Q^[i\_ �Gu��Nacjl���[uxa��Gd~+Q^hi\_ _bac�te��lstdGsxac^[f�5 fg^�vtjlr�� jle�sxu �Nuxe��Gj[r�j[_c�Gst_cikute �Gu vtuxdy_ba�u1 u�_ 2 ���Gi uxe _�utdGvxjla�u��GdGu �Gjlr&j[_b�Nst_bi\u ^ ecj[d vxutd�_cacu ec�Ga�fg^7�Gacjli�_bu.7 1 2 8�Z =�^[i\e �Rjl�GaIvxutfg^��jld a�u��y^hac�Gunf ��ikr�^��lu � �~�Nd��Rjlikdy_A� �Numfk^A�Nacjli�_bu 7 1 2 8��Likf�uxe�_ uxdE�[j�q[sxu�G^[a7fg^`vxjlr��Rjlecstuec�Ga �Gd��Rjlikdy_�� � ^"�� ^[a _buxdG^[dy_�uxdNvxjla�u��<7 1�2 8 Z8� ikdGe�iLfg^n�Gacjli�_bu 7 1 2 8>a�uxe _bu��[fkjl� ^hfkuxr&uxdy_ikdE�h^[acik^[dy_bu�� ^ha f �~�Njlr�jh_b�Gs�_biku vxjlr��Rjlecstu �yvxutfg^#�Gacj[���lu,���Gu7fku�vxutdy_bacu��Gu7vxu�_c_cu �Gj[r�j[_c�Gst_cikuuxe�_��Gi\uxd3eci�_b�Gsne��Ga7vxut_�_bun�Ga�jli\_cu[Z

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=4V�]�ute��Gut��� vC^[a _buxe ecj[d�_�ecutr �Gfg^h�Gfkute����GjldNv i\fwu���ike _bu*�NdGu e�ikr&ikf\i\_b�N�Gu��*utd0�[jPqy^[dy_ fg^

vC^[a _bu 1�2 1 � ec�Na6fg^ vC^ha�_bu 1 � 2 � 1 � �@�gZ y jli\_~�5fku(vtuxdy_ba�u��Nu vxut_�_bu eci\r�i\fki�_b�G�GuhZ1� uxe _fku e�ux�GfK�Rjlikdy_�i\dE�[^hacig^hd�_c� ^[a,���Gi\f�uxe _7�GjldGvnf\u ecut�GfK� j[ikdy_�vxj[r�r �Nd6uxdy_ba�u1f\uxe��Gut���3vx^[a�_cuxexZ��jl�Ganf\u vxjldNe�_ba��Gika�u���jld a�uxr�^[a����Gu ���GuAf �~^[d�lf\u�� �GuAfg^�e�ikr&ikfki�_b�G�Numute�_1f �~^[d�lf\u uxdy_cacuAfkute�Gacjli�_bute 7 1 2 8mu�_ 7 1 � 2 � 8����GjldNvL� ^���G^[a�_cikuxdy_ ^[� vxutacvxf\u~� ^[e�eb^[dy_ � ^ha fkute� j[ikdy_be 1 � 1 �ut_�� ^[a�f �~i\dy_buxa�ecutvt_bi\jld��Gute7�Gacjli�_bute�7 1�2 8 ut_ 7 1 � 2 � 8�FQvh�~ute�_>�G��� �Nikacuwf\u vxutacvtfkuwacu3�y^[a�� ^[dy_ 1 1 �ecjl�Ge f �~^[d�lf\u���I�Z�4 d�+Q^hikeb^hd�_ �Gu r�?xr&u ^J�[uxvwfkutec�Rjlikdy_ce 2 u�_ 2 � � 1 ut_ 1 � � ut_#�8ut_;� � � jldacut_cacjl�a�lu����&f �~i\dy_buxa�ecutvt_bi\jld6�Guw_bj[�Ge7fkuxe�vtuxa�vxfkutexZ

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l= ; �� �

� �

� �

� ��

��

� d a�uxr�^[a����Gu ���{^[�Rjla�� ��� �~i\f�q�^-�RuC^[�Gvtjl�� � �~^[d�[fkuxe�Gacjli�_be ec�Ga�fk^�BC�l�Nacu[Z�� f q6^mfkuxe�^[d�lf\uxe �1 ; ��� �1 � �,� �;c� 1ut_��2 � 1 Z =�^[i\e�i\f�qV^ ^[�Ge�eci�f �~^[d�lf\u �� 2-1 � fku6_ba�ig^[d�[fku

o #

Page 21: French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _ GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld Gu # [uxvt_cux Ga a Z l1m n o r xvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld` Gu

� 2 1 st_b^[dy_�i\dGecvtaci�_�� ^[dGe9�Gdn�Gutr�i � vtuxacvtfkuhZH� d1��_bikf\ike�u�^[f\jlace�Gux����+�jlike�f\u�_b�Gstjlac�tr�u �Gu.D�� ^hfk�xeK���GiE+�jl�NacdGi�_�fkute�s��y^[f\i\_csxev5

1 ;1�2 � 1 �

1 � � 1 �1 �

�wd3utd �Gst�G�Gi�_ �Nikacutvt_cuxr&uxdy_7f ��s��y^hfki\_cs �Gu1f ��sxdNjldGvxshZ�Ijl�Ga�fg^`ecutvxjldN�Gu ���Gute�_cikjld%�Ljld ikdy_cacj �G�Gi\_7f �~�Njlr�jh_b�Gs�_biku � �Gu1vxuxdy_cacu 1 ���Gi9utd0�[jliku �

ec�Ga � Z� d6dGj[_bu#� u�_ 5�fkute i\r-^��[uxe a�uxe>� utvt_bi4�lute��Nu 2 ut_��Nu 1 � ^[a � Z ]9^��Gacj[i\_bu27'�?548uxe�_��G^[ab^[f\fk�tfku�� 7 221 8 u�_w�GjldGv��Ruxa>� utdG�Gi\vx�Gfk^[ika�u�� 7 1 ��8�Z � i\dGeci�fku�vtuxa�vxfku � uxe _nfkumvxuxa�vxf\uikdGe�vxaci�_ �N��_ba�ig^[d�[fku 1 �?5�Z ��^ha � E � vxu vtuxa�vxfku�ecu�_cab^[dGek+�jlacr&u1uxd �Gd vtuxacvtfkum�Gu vxutdy_bacu �st_|^hd�_��Gj[dGdGsnf ��s��y^hfki\_cs �Gute ac^���Rjla�_ce��Gsxr&jldy_ba�sxu��Ga�sxvxst�Guxr&r&uxdy_J�����Gi�uxe _ s*� ik�Gutr�r&uxdy_7fkuvxuxa�vxf\u1i\dGecvtaci�_��G�3_bacik^[d�lf\u 1�2 1 Z

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l= ;R; A

B

C

M

M

A

B

C

D

E

F

]�uteW��� ^E_bacu_�Rjlikdy_ce 2 � 1 � 1 �S� s�_|^[dy_�vxj vtq vtfki!���Gute��wjld�^�2 � 1 � N * Z y jli\_6� � f ��ikr�^��lu �Gu � � ^[a3fg^ acjh_|^h_cikjld�& �Guvxuxdy_cacu 2 ut_ ���{^[d��lfku N * � vtut_c_cu�acj[_b^h_bi\jld utdE�ljli�_ � ec�Ga �Gd� jli\dy_w�Gu 1 � �9�Gj[dGvAjld�^ 1 � � 1 �O� � �`�N��Z9]�u _bacik^[d�lf\u2 ��� � ute�_6s3���Gikfk^h_bstab^[f ���GjldGv jld�^ 2 � � 2 � � � � � �$Z]I^ acjh_|^h_cikjld & uxdE�lj[iku 1 utd 1 � � ��j�b � 1 � � � 1 �>ut_��GjldGv1 � � 1 � � � ��� � � 1 � � 2 �$Z

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l= ;�X � d ^ �1 ��� ��� �

�1�2 � � � 1�2 � � � � � 1.1 �2���GjldGvAf\uxen�Gacj[i\_buteA7 1 � 8 ut_&7���� 8ecjldy_,� ^[ac^[fkf\�xfkutexZ

A

B

C

M

M

A

B

C

D

E

F

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l= ;�� � d�_cab^[i�_buxac^�fku vC^[e�j�b6fkuxe8� j[ikdy_be�e�jldy_7� ^[dGe fg^�vtjld�BC�l�Nab^h_cikjld��Nuwfg^�B�l�Gacu"�Gfkute�^[�N_cacute

ecuw_bac^[i\_cuxdy_7�Gu#+Q^�jxj[d e�ikr&ikfk^[ika�u[Z

o�Y

Page 22: French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _ GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld Gu # [uxvt_cux Ga a Z l1m n o r xvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld` Gu

A

B

C

P

PA

PB

PC

M

B

C

D

A 1

2

]�ute�� jli\dy_be2;0�J; � 2 �J;��V� ���GdGu(� ^[a _J� ; � 1 �J;�� �J;�� ���{^[��_bacu�� ^[a�_�ecjldy_Avtj�v�q�vtfki�� �Nuxe��� �~j�b �; ;��@; � �; 2 ; �� ; 221 u�_ �;�;�� ;�� � �; 1 ;���� �; 1�1 Z%� a f\uxe��Rjlikdy_ce�;0���+���ecjldy_ ^[fki��ldGsxe e�iLut_ ecux�Nfkuxr&uxdy_ eci �; ;��@;�� � ���yecjli�_ �; ;��@; � �; ;�� ;��v���Gj[dGv e�iLut_ ecut�Gfku �r�utd�_�eci � ; 221 � �; 1.1 �h�GjldGv�e�iNut_>e�ux�Gf\uxr&uxdy_ e�iGfkutev� j[ikdy_be 1 � 2 � 1 �J; ecj[d�_>vtj�v�q vxfki����GuxetZ

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l= ;�� ]9^2�G�Gike�eb^[dNvxu&�Gu(� � ^[a1ab^���Rjla _�� � �wet�~stvxaci�_�� 1 ( � � 1 �-� 2 ��vxuxf\fkuA�Gu�� � ^[a

ab^���Rjla _ ����( ex��sxvtaci�_1�� ( ��� 1 � � 2 �l�GjldGv jldA^#� 1 ( �Q�� ( �[�NjldGv�� ute�_ f\u r&ikfki\ux��Gu � 1 � � Z

A

B

C

P

PA

PB

PC

M

B

C

D

A 1

2

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l= ;��

��

��

� �

� d1^ � 1 ��� � �1 ��; � � ;�-� � �1 2 ; � � 1.1 � �� �1�2 ;�� � 1 �-��ZG��^[a�vtjldGecs3���Guxdy_ fkuxec� jli\dy_be 1 �C�@������ ecjldy_(vtj�v�q vxfki����Guxe3�����~j�b �����; � �� � 1 ��1 ��; � � �-� 1 � � 1�2 � � � �-� 1 � �( � 1 � � � N (vC^[a3fku(_cacik^[d�lf\u 1 � � ute�_ ikecj vx�tfku utd`����� �~j�b fk^vxjldGvtfk�Ge�ikjld�Z

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l= ; 3

olo

Page 23: French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _ GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld Gu # [uxvt_cux Ga a Z l1m n o r xvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld` Gu

�Ijl�GaA� �Numf\uxe ^[d�lf\uxe�dGum�Ns��RuxdG�Gutdy_#� ^[e��Gu�fk^�� jle�i\_cikjld3�G� �Rjli\d�_-; � jld�vtjldGe�ik�G�tacuxac^�Guxe�^[d�[fkuxe�j[acikutdy_bsxe7�Gun�Ga�jli\_cuxetZ

]�u � jli\dy_.;s�_|^[dy_A�Gacj���u�_bsmjla�_c�Gj��ljldG^[fkutr�utd�_�e��Ga f\uxe�v��[_csxe �N��_ba�ig^[d�[fku 1 B 2 B 1 BJ�Lfkute� jli\dy_be 1 B�� 2 �*� ; � 1 ��e�jldy_�vxj vtq vxf\i!���GuxetZ � d�^`�GjldNv�5

7 1 B 2 �'� 1 B 1 � 8 � 7 1 B 2 ��� 1 BJ; 8 � 7 1 BJ;0� 1 B 1 � 8.� 7 1 � 2 �'� 1 ��; 8 � 7 2 � ;0� 2 � 1 � 8��^[a7vxj vtq vtfkikvti\_cs �Guxe,�Rjlikdy_be 1 (J� 2 � � 1 (���; ut_7�GuteA�Rjli\d�_ce 1 (7� 1 �S� 2 (7� ; �Gjld ^L5

7 1 � 2 �'� 1 � ; 8 � 7 2 � ;0� 2 � 1 � 8.� 7 2 ( 1 ( � 2 (K; 8 � 7 1 (J;0� 1 ( 1 (�8��^[a7vxj vtq vtfkikvti\_cs �Guxe,�Rjlikdy_be 1 *J� 1 (J� 2 *���; ut_7�GuteA�Rjli\d�_ce 1 *7� 2 (7� 1 *7� ; �Gjld ^L5

7 2 ( 1 ( � 2 (J; 8 � 7 1 (J;0� 1 ( 1 (�81� 7 1 * 1 *�� 1 *K; 8 � 7 1 *K; � 1 * 2 *�8 � 7 1 * 1 *�� 1 * 2 *'84 dL+Q^[ikec^[dy_7�Gunr@?tr�u ^7�[uxv1fkute ^hd�lfkute�7 2 B 1 ��� 2 B 1 � 8�ut_ 7 1 B 1 �'� 1 B 2 � 8*�Gjld uxd3�Gst�G�Gi�_

� �Nu f\uxe ^[d�lf\uxe6�Gute _cacik^[d�lf\uxe 1 B 2 B 1 B u�_ 1 * 2 * 1 * ecj[d�_ s��l^[��� Z���^[a3vxj[dGecs3� �Nuxdy_J��fkute_bacik^[d�lf\uxe�e�jldy_�ecuxr��Gfg^[�NfkuxetZ

���

� �

� �

���

� �

� �

���

� �� �

���

� �� �

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l= ;G¢Mi j[r�r&uxdjtjldGe�� ^[a�+Q^hikacu �Gd �Nuxece�ikd�5

� �

� �

� �

���

� �

� �

� �

���

o[z

Page 24: French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _ GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld Gu # [uxvt_cux Ga a Z l1m n o r xvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld` Gu

�7_bi\fkike�jldGe��Nuxe�^[d�lf\uxe�jla�ikutd�_csxe7�Gun�Ga�jli\_cuxe�� j[�Ga&���GundGjle7acutfg^h_cikjldGe�dNu1�Ns��RuxdG�Gutdy_�� ^he�Gunf ��jlac�Ga�uw�Guxe��Rjlikdy_ce�ec�Ga7fkute7vxuxa�vxf\uxe�� �NjldGvn�Gunfg^BC�l�Nacu[Z

��^[a7vxj vtq vxf\ikvti\_bs"�Njld ^(5

7$�)�f��( ���2�m���8 � 70�2�D��(����)� ;�� 8 � 7$�)� ;��'���2�m���81� 7 ;,(1��(��K;C(J;�� 8 � 7 ; �';O�J�J;��1���8� 7 ;,(���( �K;C(J;,*'8 � 7Q;C(';C*��J;C(J;�� 8 � 7Q;���;��'�J;��J;C*'8 � 7 ;���;,*��J; �1���8

�wa�e�i�fkute,�Rjli\d�_ce ;O� ��;,(J� ;,*7� ;�� ecjldy_�vxj vtq vtfki!���Gute��Ljld ^(5

7 ;C(K;C* �J;,(J;O� 8 � 7 ; �';O���J; �';C*J81� �� �~j�bW5

70�2�D��(����)�D���8 � 7Q;C(1��(��J;C(K;C*�8 � 7Q;��';,*��J; �1���8� 7$��*1��( ����*J;C*'8 � 7$��*';C*��&��*1���8 � 70��*���( ����*����8

��^[a7vxj[dGecs3� �Nuxdy_J�Rfkute&� �G^h_ba�u��Rjli\d�_ce �)�*���(J���*7���� e�jldy_ vtj�v�q�vtfki�� �NuxexZ

oh}

Page 25: French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _ GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld Gu # [uxvt_cux Ga a Z l1m n o r xvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld` Gu

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l= ; U �

���

���

���

���

y jlikutd�_ ���(ut_ ��� fkuxe8�GacjH��ut_bste�acute��Ruxv �_bi�+�e �Gu �5e��Ga fkute v��h_bsxe � 1�1 � u�_ � 1�2 � ��u�_� ��ut_ � � ecute`e�q r�s�_ba�i!���Guxe`a�uxe>� utvt_bi4+�e� ^[aab^���Rjla _��-vtu r�?xr&umv��[_bshZK� d ^ �2 � � 1 �� 2 � 1 � � �

�221 1 ���GjldNv � � ^���� ^[a�_cikutd�_^[� vxuxa�vxf\u vtika�vxjldGe�vxa�i\_W� 1�221 F�uxd$vxfg^hikaec�Ga6fk^�BC�l�Ga�u7I�_cjl�N_3vxj[r�r&u � ��Z�$��{^h�N_ba�u� ^[a�_��lf �~^[d�[fku �� � � 1 st_|^hd�_>�Nacjli�_J� ���3^��a�� ^[a�_cikutd�_ ^[� vxutacvtfku`�Gu �Nig^[r&�t_cacu�� 1 ZK$ ur@?tr�u ���Vuxe _ e��Ga�f\u&vtuxa�vxfku&�Gu��Gig^[r&�t_cacu2 5 Zi ^hfkvx�NfkjldGe�fg^��G�Nikecec^[dGvtu��Gu�� � ^[a�ab^��a�

� jla _ ^[����_bacj[ike vxutacvtfkuxe>�Gu7fk^�BC�l�Ga�u[Z]� d-^�5� � � 7 � 8 � � 1

�� � �2� � 2

�� � �

� ����� 7 � 8 � � 1�� ���

� �� ���27 � 8 � � 2�� � �

� a&jld ^ � � � � � � ��� ut_�� � � � � � ���v� � �~j�b � �����27 �98~� �( � � �A7 � 8(�� �� ���27 � 8|Z��^[a�vxj[dGecs3� �Nuxdy_ � ^"�� ^[a _bikutdy_��`f �~^E��u ab^[�NikvC^hf��Gute�vtuxa�vxfkute�vxi\acvxj[dGecvtaci\_ce&� 1 � � � u�_

2 5 ��� � �GjldGv��Afg^ �Nacjli�_bu 7 ;� 8 Z ¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l= ; V 4 d vC^hfkvx�Nfg^[dy_ fk^6�G�Nikecec^[dGvtu6�Gu ; �G^[a ab^"�� j[a�_A^[� � �Gut��� vtuxa�vxfkute`jld ^ ; 2 � ;�5 �

;�4� ;�� � ; 1 � ; �$ZI��^[amvxjldGe�s����Gutd�_Af\u@��� ^h�Gaci\fg^h_c�xacu@� 2 1 5 ute�_`i\dGecvtaci��N_bi\�Gfku"� � ��j�b��?5 2 � �� 1-2 Z7]�ute _cacig^hd�lfkuteL� 1.1 u�_ 2 5/� ecjldy_ �Gacj[i\_be3��jld ^ �NjldGv �� 1�1 �N ( � �� 1 1 � � � ��?5 �(Z���^[a�vtjldGe�s����Guxdy_Af\u���� ^[�Ga�ikfk^h_b�tacu 1 �?5 �5uxe�_�ikdGe�vxa�i!�N_cik�Gf\u[Z]9ute7�Gacjli�_bute�7���� 8�� 7 1 �:8'� 7 �&598�ecjldy_7f\uxe7^E��uxe7ac^[�Gikvx^[�����Guxe7vxutacvtfkuxe7�Gun�Gik^[r&�t_ba�uxe 1.1 �2 ���Gu�_ �N� vtuxacvtfkunvxi\acvtjldGecvtaci�_,� 1 �?5/�6�R�NjldGvnuxf\fkuxe�e�jldy_�vxjldGvtjl�Ga�ab^[dy_butexZ

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=�XL���

���

y jlikutd�_4� �6f\u�vtuxa�vxfku vxi\acvxj[dGek�vxaci�_ � f ���Gu �G^"�ljldGu u�_�� ( f\u*_ba�i4�^[d�lf\u vxika�vxjldNecvxa�i\_ ^[� _ba�ig^[d�[fku1 � � ZV]9^ �Nacjli�_bu 7 1 � 8"st_|^hd�_fg^Vvtjlac�Gu*vxjlr&r �GdGu � vxuxe �Nux���vxuxa�vxf\uxe��y���{^��Nac�xe f ��u���utacvxi\vxunY�oa�[fkuxe�Gacjli�_bute<7R� � 8wut_ 7 2 �28wecj[d�_�� ^��ab^[f\fk�xf\uxe3� ^[ikdGe�i_� �Nu fkute �Ga�jli\_cuxe7f� � 87ut_+7 2(� 8�ut_����Gu fkute �Ga�jli\_cuxe7 � � 8�u�_+7 � �28 Z���^[a vtjldGe�s����Guxdy_��fkuxe7_ba�ig^[d��lfkute ��2 �"ut_ � � �5ecj[d�_ecuxr��Gfg^[�Nfkuxe@5�i\f u���i\e�_bu-�GdGu6eci\r�i �fki\_c�G�Gu�uxdE�ljPql^[dy_ f �~�Nd6ec�Ga�f �{^h�N_ba�u[Z

ol�

Page 26: French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _ GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld Gu # [uxvt_cux Ga a Z l1m n o r xvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld` Gu

]9u vxutdy_bacu �Gu vtut_c_cu e�ikr&ikfki�_b�G�Nu ^��a�� ^[a�_cikutd�_ ^[��� �Gut��� �Gacj[i\_bute27 2 � 8ut_&7�� � 8�Z���^[anvxjldGe�s����Gutd�_���i\f�ex�~^��li�_n�G�W� jli\dy_�� ���Gi>^"�� ^[a _bikutdy_n�GjldGvAs��l^[fkutr�utd�_��3fg^�Gacjli�_bu 7 � � 8 Z

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=�X9; � R��S:�<�����V��EZ]�u#�Rjlikdy_#� ^���� ^[a�_cuxd ^hd�_A� fk^ �Gike�ecuxv�_ba�ikvxun�Guwf �{^hd�lfku 1 �Gi\f�uxe _�s����Gik�Nike�_b^[dy_7�Guxe7v��[_bste

1�2 u�_ 1.1 �9�Gj[dGv-f\u&ac^���Rjla�_m�Gute�^[i\acutem�Gutem_cacig^hd�lfkute��h^[�N_ � � �� � � �

� � � �9� �~^[�N_cacu@� ^[a�_fku-ac^���Rjla�_ �GuxeA^[i\acute �Guxe _cacik^[d�lf\uxe �h^[��_ � � �N�Gike>� �Nu6fg^�� ^h�N_but�Ga`ike�ec�Gu6�Gu 1 fkux�Na uxe _vxjlr&r �GdGuhZ�� d r&jldy_ba�uwf ��s��y^hfki\_cs ^J�lutvmf\uwab^���� jla _�� �

� ��Gunfg^ r�?xr&uwr�^[dGik�tacuhZ

� R��S:�<�����V� CZi j[r�r&u�jld&^ �2 1 � � �� 1�1 �[fkuxe>^hacvxe 2 � ut_8� 1 ecj[d�_>s3�y^[���`�GjldGvA� ute�_ fku

r�i\fkikut�6�Gu1f �~^[acv 221 ZR��^[a�vxjldNecs����Gutdy_wfg^A�Gacj[i\_buA7 �� 8�uxe�_ fg^Ar&sx�Gik^h_ba�ikvxuw�N��v��h_bs 221 ��GjldGvnuxf\fku f\�Gi ute�_,� uta��RuxdG�Nikvx�Nfg^[i\acu[Zy jli\_���fk^c�h^[fkut�Ga��Gu f �~^[d�[fku 1 u�_ �&vxutfkf\u �Gu>f �~^[d�lf\u 2 �Cj[d�^ �2 � � � �2 1 � �

�1 2 � �� ( ��� ( Z$��{^h�N_ba�u��G^[a�_�j[d ^ �� 2 � �

�� 2 1 � �1-2 � ��� 221 � �1 1 � � � ( ��� ( Z$ jldGvnfku

_bacik^[d�lf\u 2 � � uxe _ i\ecj vx�tfku�uxd~� ut_8� ^[a>vtjldGecs3���Guxdy_�j[d�^ � � � 2 � 4 d +Q^[ikec^[dy_ �Nur@?tr�u�^J�[uxv�fku�_ba�ig^[d��lfku 1 � � j[d�utd&�Nsx�G�Gi�_1� �Nu�f\uxe�_cacjli\ev� j[ikdy_be 2 � 1 � � ^��� ^[a _bi\uxdGdGutdy_�A�Nd r�?xr&uwvxutacvxf\un�Gunvxuxdy_cacu � Z

� R��S:�<�����V��lZ]�ute�^[d�[fkuxe �2 ��� 1 ut_ �2 ��� 1 s�_|^[dy_��Gacjli�_beIfkute��Rjlikdy_be 2 � ��� � ����� 1 ecjldy_�vxjPq vxfki����Guxe3�

� �~j�b �1 ��� ��� � � � �2 ��� ��� � �1�1�2 �N�Nu r@?tr�u jld�r&jldy_ba�u �1 ��� ����� �1�221 �Nu�_&� ^[avxjldGe�s����Gutd�_&f\uxem_cacik^[d�lf\uxe 2 1�1 jldy_`fkut�Gace1_ba�jlike�^[d�lf\uxe�s3�y^[���*ut_ ecjldy_`�Gj[dGv-i\dG�Gika�uxv�_bu*�r�utd�_7e�uxr �Nfg^[�Gf\uxe�F=�ljli\acBC�l�Nacuw� ^[dNe�f\u vxj[�Gace�I�Z�� d3r�j[d�_cacuwfk^�eci\r�i\fki\_c�G�Gu ^J�luxvnf\uxe7^[�N_cacute_bacik^[d�lf\uxe��Nu1r�?xr&u[Zi j[r�r&u�jld ^ �2 � ��� �

�2 1�1 � �1 � ��� � fk^*�Ga�jli\_cu 7 2 1 8�ute�_3fk^*�Gike�ecutvt_ba�ikvtuu�� _bstacikut�Gacu �Gu f �{^[d��lfku ���� � ����u�_��GjldNv fg^1�Gacj[i\_bu 7 � 1 8 � �Ni�fk�NiRute�_&�Ruxa>� utdG�Gi\vx�Gfk^[ika�u�ec^�Gike�ecuxv�_ba�ikvxuni\d�_csxa�ikux�Nacu[Zy jli\_ � �h� � �l����fkute�e q r�s�_baci����Guxe��Gu � � ^[aIab^���� jla _�^h���n_ba�jlikeIv��[_csxe��G�m_cacig^hd�lfkuhZH� d

^ �2 � 1 ��2 � 1 � �� ��� 2 � �� 2 ���2� �1 � � 2 � ���� 2 1 �N� ��2 1.1 �7� ^[a9vtjldGecs3���Guxdy_

fku��Rjli\d�_ � ^��� ^ha�_bi\uxdy_w^h� vxuxa�vxf\u vxi\acvxj[dGecvtaci\_ ^[�(_ba�ig^[d��lfku 1�221 ZK� d r&jldy_ba�u�fkumr@?tr�uacsxe��Gf\_b^h_��Rjl�Ga�fkute�� jli\dy_be ��� ut_ ����Z

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=�XRX

M

B

C DA

1

2

B

C

T

A

P

Q

R

2r1

2r2

� d`^ 2 1 �3� & � �� �� �2 1.1 ut_ 2 � �� &�( �� �� � 2 1 ��Z�� a�jld`^ �2 1�1 � � 2-1 � �� ��� ��j�b �� �� �2 1.1 � �� �� � 2-1 ��ut_ �GjldGv� ��� ����

���Z

o[�

Page 27: French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _ GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld Gu # [uxvt_cux Ga a Z l1m n o r xvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld` Gu

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=�XR� ]�ute _bacik^[d�lf\uxe 221 }$ut_ 2 1�1 ^Cql^[dy_n�GdGu`� ^[e�u`vxjlr&r �GdNu���f\u ab^"�� j[a�_w�Gu`f\ux�Ga�ew^[i\acuxe

uxe�_,�Ga�j��Rjla�_cikjldGdNuxf�^[�3ac^���Rjla�_7�Gunf\ux�Ga�e�� ^[�N_cux�Ga�exZ � d�^`�GjldNv

� 2 1 } �� 221 1 � �

}-; �� �� �}-; 21 ; �� �� �1 ; 2

� }.;1 ; �

4>d_+Q^[i\eb^[dy_A�Gu3r�?xr&u6^J�luxv fkute _bacj[ike _ba�ig^[d��lfkute 221 } � 1�1 } � 1�2 } �Gjldy_&fg^ e�jlr�r&u��Gute^[ika�uxe��h^[�N_7vtuxfkf\uw�Gu 1�221 j[d j[�N_bi\uxdy_�5

}-;1 ; �

} �2 � �

} �1 � � � 221 } �

� 221 1 � �� 1�1 } �� 1�1 2 � �

� 1 2 } �� 1�221 � � , �

M

B

C DA

1

2

B

C

T

A

P

Q

R

2r1

2r2

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=�X � y �Ga6fg^*�Nacjli�_bu 7 1�2 8-i\f�q ^ �Gux� �O� j[ikdy_be�ec^h_bi\e>+Q^[i\eb^[dy_-fg^*vtjldG�Gi�_bikj[d Z 4 d u3M ut_3f\ux�Ga

vxj jlac�Gj[dGdGsxute�� ^[a q�vtuxdy_ba�i!���Gute�e�jldy_7acute��Ruxvt_ci��[uxdy_ 7 1 � ��� 2 � , 8 ut_�7 1 � � ��� 2 � , 8 Z y jli�_;� u�_� vxute�� jli\dy_bexZ y jli�_ � �Gd �Rjlikdy_�eb^h_cike>+Q^hikeb^hd�_ � �� � � ��vtjlr&r�u � �� � � ut_� �Nu �^��� ^[a _bi\uxdy_ ^h�*ecu3�lr&uxdy_ � 1�2 � jld utd �Gst�G�Gi\_ ���Gu(� � uxe _ fg^ �Gike�ecutvt_ba�ikvtu-ikdy_csxaci\ux�Ga�u��Nuf �~^[d�lf\u=�1 � 2 Z$ uwr�?xr&u j[d6�Gsx�G�Ni\_����Gu�� � uxe�_�fg^��Gi\ece�uxvt_caci\vxu u ��_csxa�ikux�Nacuw�Guwvtu r@?tr�u^[d�lf\u[ZR��^[a vxjldGe�s����Gutd�_1f\uxe �Nacjli�_buxe27'��<8 ut_ 7 � �28�ecjldy_#�Ruxa>� utdG�Gikvt�Gfg^hikacute u�_w�GjldNv �^��� ^[a _bi\uxdy_�^[�3vxutacvxf\un�Gun�Gig^[r&�t_cacu � �&Z

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=�XR� i j[r�r&uxdjtjldGe�� ^[a�+Q^hikacu �GdGu�BC�l�Ga�u�5

ol�

Page 28: French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _ GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld Gu # [uxvt_cux Ga a Z l1m n o r xvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld` Gu

B

C

GI N

x

y

z

P

Q

R

P

P

A

PC

A

D A

;� ��jle�jldGe��2� 1 � � 1 �2���� 2 �`� 2 ;0��� � 1 ; � 1 �&Za� d�^m^[fkj[ace ���� � ���� .�� � �� � � , ZL��^[a7fku _c�Gsxjla��xr&uw�Gu i u3�h^Ajld utd �Nsx�G�Gi�_7f ��u���ike _butdGvxu1�G�L� j[ikdy_7�Gu nuta��lj[dGdGu[Zi ^hfkvx�NfkjldGe�� ���M����� �NiGecjldy_>�Gute fkjld��l�Gux�Nace ikr��Rjla�_b^[dy_buxe � j[�Ga�fg^ ec�Gi�_bu��Gu�f �~u ��uxacvtikvtu��lu�_

uxd��lsxdGstab^[fN� ^[dGe>�RuC^[�Gvtjl��&� ��u���uxa�vxikvtuxetZ� d&^ 1�2 � 221 ��� � � � � � � ut_ 221 � � � ���� �~j�b��L� ��L � E � �( ZC$ u1r�?xr&uwjld vC^[f\vx�Gf\u�� � ��L � � E �( u�_��� E ��L � � L � ( Z

X$� = jldy_ba�jldGe���� ��jld6^ 1 ;#�a� 2 ; ��vxu����GiRec�a)�ac^��Rjl�Ga ��_bikf\ike�uxa fku7_b�Nsxjla��xr&u �Gu i u3�h^�Guwfg^ r�?xr&u r�^[dGik�tacu����Gu��Ga�sxvtsx�Gutr�r&uxdy_CZ y j[i\_ ;�� �J;�� fkute&� j[ikdy_be��Nu1vtjldy_|^[v�_��G�3vxuxa�vxf\uu���ikdGe�vxa�i\_ �G^[dGe`f �~^[d�[fku 1 ^J�luxv6f\uxe v��[_bsteLF �Nacjlf\jld�lsteSI 1 2 � 1.1 Zv�wd ^ 2 ;��Q� 2 ; � u�_1 ;�� � 1 ; � �>� �~j�b 2 ;�� � 1 ;�� � 221 Z1� a�jld ^ 1 ;��q� 1 ;�� ut_ 1 ;�� � 1 ;�� �1�2 � 221 � 1 1 � � ��j�b 1 ; � � ��L � � L � ( � 1�2 �

E ��L � � L � ( � 2 ;&Z�$� y jli�_ ��f ���Gjlr&j[_b�Nst_bi\u��Gu�vxutd�_cacu � ut_ �Gu�ab^���� jla _ � � Z���^[a �%�yfkuxe>r&ikf\ikux� � 1 � � 2 � � 1 �

�Guxe�v��[_bste��G�6_bacik^[d�lf\u e�jldy_7uxdE�ljPq[sxe�ec�Ga�f\uxe�e�jlr�r&ut_ce 1 � 2 � 1 Z y jli�_;� fk^��Gacj[i\_buA� ^[ac^[f4�fk�xf\u��<7 221 8�_|^hd�luxdy_cu ^[��vxutacvxf\u i\dGecvtaci�_ utd<; � � Z ] ���Gjlr&j[_b�Gs�_bi\u��Nu vtuxdy_ba�u 1 uxdE�ljPqy^hd�_;� ec�Ga 7 221 83utdE�ljli\u*fku vtuxacvtfku ikdGe�vxaci�_ ec�Ga fku�vxuxa�vxf\u u �Ni\dGecvtaci�_J�7�GjldGv ; � � e��Ga9; � �7ut_ fkute� jli\dy_be 1 �J; � � �J; � e�jldy_ ^[f\i!�ldGstexZ�� a jld ^ ;�; � � � � � ; � u�_ ;�; � � � � ; 1 � �7�GjldGv�fkute�Gacjli�_bute47 � 1 � 8`ut_97 ; � � ; � 8Ae�jldy_��G^[ab^[f\fk�tfkuxetZ ] �~i\r-^"�lu(� ^[a �V�Gu fg^ �Gacj[i\_bu�7 � 1 � 8 uxe _��GdNu�Gacjli�_bu�� ^[ac^[fkf\�xf\u#� ^[ecec^[dy_�� ^ha 1 �Lvh�~ute�_w�Gj[dGvmfk^&�Nacjli�_bu&7 1 ;#� 8 ZR]>��ikr�^��lun�Gu1f ��ikdy_cuxace�uxv�_bikj[d�Guxe��Nacjli�_buxe 7 � 1 � 8�� 7 � 2 � 8'� 7 � 1 � 89uxe�_��GjldGv f ��ikdy_butacecutvt_cikjldm�Guxe��Nacjli�_buxe 7 1 ;�� 8�� 7 2 �#� 8�� 7 1 ��� 8*��GjldGvnv[��uxe _�fku#�Rjlikdy_ 5�ZL��^[a7vxj[dGecs3� �Nuxdy_ f\uxe&�Rjlikdy_be � � � �J5�e�jldy_ ^hfki!�[dGsxe��G^[dGe7vxu�_ j[ac�Ga�uut_�jld ^+5 � �3� � � Z

�!� ] ���Gjlr&j[_b�Nst_bi\u��Gu�vxuxdy_cacu � u�_w�Gu ac^���Rjla�_ �-, � ��uxdE�[jliku � ec�Na fku r&ikf\ikut� �N� ecu����r�utd�_!� � 5 � �hjlaIuxfkf\u utdE�ljli\u 1�2 1 e��Ga 1 � 2 � 1 � �NjldGv utfkf\u utd0�[jliku fku vxuxa�vxf\u ikdNecvxa�i\_I�Gu�f �~�Nd�ec�Navxuxf\�Gi �Gunf �{^[��_bacu"�G�GjldNv1f\uwvxutd�_cacu1�G� vxuxa�vxf\u1i\dGecvtaci�_�� ^[dGe 1 � 2 � 1 � uxe _ f\uwr�i\fki\ux���Gu � � 5 � Z

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=�X 3 $m�{^��Nac�xe fkuw_b�Nsxjla>?xr&um�Gu = stdGsxfk^�Ge ^"��Gfki����Gs1^[� _cacik^[d�lf\u 221 � fkute,�Rjli\d�_ce.; ���@���

ecjldy_ ^[fki��ldGste eci ut_ e�ux�Gf\uxr&uxdy_ eci jld�^ � �� � �� ���� �� , Z y jli\_*�(fk^#�h^[f\ux�Ga �Nu�f �{^hd�lfku �221�1 u�_

�(fg^��h^[fkut�Ga>�Gu7f �~^[d�lf\u � � 1 1 Z y jli\uxdy_ � ut_ � f\uxe.�Ga�j���ut_csxe �Nuxe1� jli\dy_be 2 u�_ �"ec�Na 1.1 jld^`^[fkjla�e � �� � �� � ������� � ������ � ZC$m�{^[��_bacu�� ^ha�_�jld ^ � �

� �� ( � ����� �( � ����� �

� ����� �������Z i jlr&r�u 1�221 �

uxe�_ �Gd_� ^[ab^hfkfkstfkj��[ab^[r&r�u�jld ^ �� 2-1 � � ��� 1 � ^[amvxjldNecs����Gutdy_-f\uxe�_cacig^hd�lfkute 1 2 � u�_1 � � e�jldy_ ecutr �Gfk^[�Gfkute7� �~j�b � �� �

� � ZR]9u �Gacj �G�Gi�_��Gumvtuxe�_bacj[ike7ab^���� jla _be��h^[�N_ �GjldGv ,ut_�fkute&� jli\dy_be ; � �@� � e�jldy_ ^[fki��ldGsxetZ

o �

Page 29: French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _ GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld Gu # [uxvt_cux Ga a Z l1m n o r xvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld` Gu

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=�X�¢Mi j[r�r&uxdjtjldGe�� ^[a�+Q^hikacu �GdGu�BC�l�Ga�u�5

A

B

C

H

P

Q

R

P

Q

R

Ml

lA

lB

y jli\_2; �&� ��� f\uxe�Rjli\d�_ce � ��ikdy_butace�uxvt_cikjld �Nu�fg^��Nacjli�_bu ��^J�lutv6fkuxe�v��[_csxe 1�2 � 221 � 1�1�G� _cacik^[d�lf\u ut_�; � ��� � ��� � fkute e q r�s�_baci����Guxe �Gu � u�_ � � � � � � ��f\uxe3e�q r&st_caci!���Gute��Gu�fg^�Gacjli�_bu �A� ^[a�ab^���Rjla _��(vxute`r@?tr�u-v��[_csxexZ y jli\_�� f ��ikdy_butacecutvt_cikjld �Nuxe`�Ga�jli\_cuxe� ut_ � ��Z]9u6_cacig^hd�lfku<; � � � � � ute�_�f ��ikr�^��lu��G� _cacik^[d�lf\u�jla�_c�Gi!���Gu6�Nu 1 221 � ^[a`f �~�Gj[r�j[_c�Gst_ciku��Nuvxuxdy_cacu � u�_7�Gunab^���� jla _ ��Z � d ^&�Gj[dGv �� � ; � � � � � � ���1 Z�$��~^[�N_cacu�� ^[a _7jld ^

�� � � � � ���� � �� � � � � �� � � � � �� � � � � �

f �~^[d�lf\u �� � � � � st_b^[dy_7ikvxi�f �{^hd�lfku jl�N_c�%� jld ^&utd vtjldGe�ik�Gstab^[dy_�f �~^[d�lf\uw^[i��l�

�� � � � � � �� � � � � � �� � � � � �� � � � � �� � � � � � 7 � � �� � � � � 8'�

�wa&�G^[a�vxj vtq vxf\ikvti\_bswj[d ^�� � � � � �O� � �1 � � �~j�b

�� � � � � � � � � � � 7 � � �1 8.�O� � ���1 � �� � ; � � � ���^[a vxjldGe�s����Gutd�_1f\u �Rjlikdy_�� ^��� ^ha�_bi\uxdy_ ^[�(vxutacvtfku vtikacvtjldGe�vxaci�_��&; � � � � � � i\f9ex�~^��li\_ �GjldNv�Gu fk^�e�uxvtjldG�Gu(i\dy_buxa�ecutvt_bi\jldV�Nu � ^J�lutv(vxu vxutacvtfku[Zc� dVr&jldy_ba�u6��� ��ikf�utd uxe _��Gu r@?tr�u^7�[uxvmf ��ikdy_butacecutvt_cikjld �Guxe �Gacjli�_bute � u�_�� �v�L�Gj[dGv�vtuxe _cacjli\e7�Gacjli�_bute e�jldy_ vxj[dGvxjl�Nab^[dy_butexZ%�wafku1vxuxa�vxf\u vxi\acvxj[dGecvtaci\_��<;#� �#�Z��� ute�_wf\u�vtuxacvtfku vtika�vxjldGe�vxa�i\_�� 1�221 ���NjldGv�f\uxe�_bacj[ike �Nacjli�_buxe� � � � � � � ecunvxj[�� utdy_ e��Ga�fku vtuxacvtfkunvxi\acvtjldGecvtaci�_,� 1 221 Z

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=�X U y jli\_�� � ut_�� � fkuxe��Ga�j���uxv�_bi\jldGe��Gu�5 e��Ga 1 2 u�_ 1.1 acute��Ruxvt_ci��[uxr&uxdy_CZ i jlr&r�u � u�_

5 ecj[d�_ ec�Ga fg^n�Gike�ecuxv�_ba�ikvxu �Gu��1 ��jld�^ ��� � �1� u�_ � � 5 �?5�� � Z�� a jld6^ 2 5 � 1 5ut_ �� � 2 5 � �� � 1 5W���Gj[dGv�fkutem_cacig^hd�lfkute 2 5 � � u�_ 1 5�� � ecj[d�_ ec��Ruxa>� jlec^[�Gf\uxe���� ��j�b2 � � � 1 � � Zy jli\_�� f �{^[d��lfku r&jli�_biks �Gunf �~^[d�lf\u��1 �Njld�^

� 1�221 � � 1 2 � ��� � �� �� � � 1�1 � �1� �� �� � � 7 1�2 � 1�1 8�� ��� � �� �� � �

o[�

Page 30: French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _ GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld Gu # [uxvt_cux Ga a Z l1m n o r xvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld` Gu

�wa�j[d�^ 1�2 � 1�1 � 1 ��� � 1 �O��� ��j�b� 1 221 � � 7 1 � � � 1 � � 8�� ��� � �� �� �W� � 1 ���8� � � � ��� � � � � � �8�`� � � �

� �~j�b2�G^[a�� ^[ab^hfkfkstfki\ecr&u �GuA7 ��� 8�u�_27 ��� 548�u�_��GuA7 �1�:8�ut_ 7 5��N� 8� 1�2 1 � � � 1 ���1� � � � ���O5 � � � �1�?5 � � � 1 � 5 � � �

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=�X V

���

� �

� �

���

� �

����

� �

y jli\_ ��f ��jla�_c�Gj�vtuxdy_ba�u �G�6_cacig^hd�lfku 1�2 1 � � ecj[d6vxuxdy_cacun�Gu��lac^J��i�_bs u�_��$f\u vxutdy_bacuw�Nuecjld vxuxa�vxf\u�vxi\acvtjldGecvtaci�_CZ y jli�_ 1 � 2 � 1 � f ��ikr�^��luw�Gu 1�221 � ^ha f �~�Gj[r�j[_c�Gst_ciku ���Gumvxuxdy_cacu �ut_w�Gu�ab^���Rjla _�#� ecjli\uxdy_� � ut_�� � fkute ikr�^��lute �Gu � ut_�� � ^[a � Z y jli\_ � � ���.� ���*fkute�Gacj���utvt_cikjldGe��Nu � ec�Na�f\uxe��Ga�jli\_cuxe�7 2 � 1 � 8*��7 1 � 1 � 8*�,7 1 � 2 � 8�Z

]9^w�Gi\e�_|^hdGvxu7�Gu � �wfg^w�Ga�jli\_cu�7 2 � 1 � 8�uxe _ ##+�jli\e�fg^w�Gi\e�_|^hdGvxu��Gu � �wfg^ �Nacjli�_bu�7 2 1 8�u�_fg^n�Gike _|^[dGvtu �Nu 1 �<7 221 8 uxe _0 �+�jlike>vxu�_c_cu �Gi\e�_|^hdGvxu"�]�G^[a vtjldGe�s����Guxdy_�fk^1�Nike�_b^[dGvtu utd�_cacu 1ut_-7 2 1 8�ute�_ s��l^[fkuc�nfk^ �Gi\e�_|^hdGvxu�utd�_cacu7fkute��Ga�jli\_cuxeI7 2 1 8�u�_-7 2 � 1 � 8*�[�NjldGv�fkuc� jli\dy_ � uxe _fku�e�q r&st_caci!���Gu7�G���Rjlikdy_ 1 � ^[a>ac^���Rjla�_1� 221 ZE� f uxd&uxe _ �Nu�r�?xr&u&�Rjl�Ga fkute.� jli\dy_be ��� u�_� ��ZN��^[a vtjldGecs3���Guxdy_7fkutec�Rjlikdy_ce � � ��� ut_ � � ecjldy_�^hfki!�[dGsxe eciRut_ ecux�Nfkuxr&uxdy_�e�i f\uA�Rjli\d�_�5^��� ^ha�_bi\uxdy_w^h� vxuxa�vxf\u vxi\acvxj[dGecvtaci\_ ^[��_cacig^hd�lfku 1 � 2 � 1 � � �GjldGv e�i�u�_wecut�Gfkutr�utd�_ eci�j[d ^� � � � �+7 1 � 2 � 1 � 8��:#X�+7 1�221 87utd(dGj[_b^[dy_ �+7 1�221 87f\umac^Cqljld(�N��vxutacvtfku�vtika�vxjldGe�vxa�i\_��1�221 Z

] ��ikr�^��luw�Gu1fg^A�Ga�jli\_cu1��� 4 �Gf\uxa,� ^[a ��uxe�_ uxf\fku � r�?xr&uwvC^[a � �Rvtuxdy_ba�u��Gu �%�Rute�_ �Guxe�ec�GetZ�wd ^*�GjldGv � ����� � � � � ���#� � � � #E� � � ��� � � #E� � ����� � � ��� �*Z��^[a3vxj[dGecs3� �Nuxdy_ � uxe _ ec�Ga3fku vtuxa�vxfku vtikacvtjldGe�vxaci�_2� 1 � 2 � 1 � e�iwut_ ecut�Gfkutr�utdy_ e�iwjld ^� � �3�H�+7 1�221 8 ut_�fk^�Gacut���lumuxe�_�B dNiku[Z

¡�=�Bh�yOQ�l=��L��y jli\_�� � fku`vtuxdy_ba�u��G� vtuxacvtfkuAvxi\acvtjldGecvtaci�_�� 1 � 2 � 1 � ZK� dGu�BC�[�GacuAec�����l�xa�uA�GuAr�jldy_cacuxa

� �Nu`fkuxe�� jli\dy_be �5u�_�� � ecjldy_nvxj[d�+�jldG�G�Ne�FQ�Gi\uxd ��� ��jld dGu`eb^hv|�Gu�� ^[ewutdGvxjla�u��~���Gjli�vtuxfk^

z�#

Page 31: French National Centre for Scientific Research..._bab^hd + jlacr ^h_cikjld L , 1ute _ GdGuw_bac^[dGecfk^h_bi\jld Gu # [uxvt_cux Ga a Z l1m n o r xvpaovpawkx.s]9^nacj[_b^h_bi\jld` Gu

� ut�N_ e�uxa>� i\aSI�Z i jlr&r�umjld ^ �2 � 1 � � ��2 1�1 � � � �2 1 � 1 � f\uxeA� jli\dy_be 2 � ��� 1 � 1 �ecjldy_ vtj�v�q vxfki����GuxetZ|$ u��Gfk�Ge fku1ab^Cqlj[d(�G�(vtuxacvtfkumvxika�vxjldNecvxa�i\_��-vxute��Rjlikdy_be�uxe _ s3�y^[f ��vxutfk�Gi

�G��vxutacvtfku vtika�vxjldGe�vxa�i\_c� 1�221 �G�Gi\e���� ��ikfLex�~^��li�_ �N��vxutacvxf\u e�q r&st_caci!���GuA� ^[a ab^���Rjla _�� 221 Z$ u�r�?xr&unfkuxe,�Rjlikdy_be 1 � ��� 2 � 1 � e�jldy_ vtj�v�q�vtfki�� �Nuxe u�_ f\umac^Cqljld �G�(vxutacvtfku�� ^[ecec^[dy_#� ^[avxuxe.�Rjlikdy_ce uxe�_ s3�y^[fC�nvxutfk�GiG�N��vtuxacvtfku&� ^heceb^hd�_8� ^[a 2 � ��� 1 � 1 � ZE$��~^��Gac�te f �~u ��uxacvtikvtu o[oa�lfg^vxjla��Gu 1 � 1 � s�_|^[dy_7vtjlr�r��GdGuw^[� �6�Gut���6vtuxacvtfkute��Gjld3^ � 1 ��� � 1 � ���Guwr�?xr&u jld6r&jldy_bacu� 1 �a� � 2 �Lut_��GjldNv � ute�_�fkuwvtuxdy_ba�um�G� vxutacvtfkunvxi\acvxj[dGecvtaci\_,� 1 � 2 � 1 � � ���~j�b � �Q���gZ

� ��

���

� �

� �

��� �

� � �

� � �

= jldy_bacuta2� � � � � � a�u3� ikutdy_�� r&jldy_bacuta(���Gu f\u(_ba�ig^[d�[fku ��� � � ute�_ ike�j�vt�xfku utd��Z y jli�_A;�fg^ �Gacj���utvt_cikjld �Gu � e��Ga�� � � �>vxutfg^ acu*��i\uxdy_�utdGvxj[acu6� r&jldy_bacuta@���Gu�; uxe _fku r�i\fki\ux� �Gu � � � Z�]�uxe3_bacik^[d�lf\uxe 1 221 ut_ 1 � 2 � 1 � s�_|^[dy_ ecuxr��Gfg^[�Nfkuxe3��ikfwu �Ni\e�_cu �GdNuecikr&ikf\i\_c�G�Gu��&uxdE�[j�ql^[dy_ 1 221 ec�Ga 1 � 2 � 1 � Z y jli\_ � fku`ac^���Rjla�_ �Gu@��ut_-� ecj[d*^[d��lfkuhZK� d^ �9; � � � �"! � � ut_ � � � � � � � � � � � � �&Z�� d�v|�Gutacv|�Gu��GjldGv ��r&jldy_ba�uxa7fg^`acutfg^h_cikjld�@� � ��"! � � Z

�Ijl�Ga&r�j[d�_cacuta`vxut_�_bu acutfg^h_cikjld ���Gi�dGu �Gs3� utdG�����Gu �Gu3fg^ vxj[dGe�_cac�Gv�_bikj[d i\dGi\_cig^[f\u��Gute_bacik^[d�lf\uxe3�Gjld6�h^Avxjlr��Gf\�t_butr�utdy_ j[�G�Gfki\uxa7fkute�� jli\dy_be �����ut_ � � �Rjl�Ga7a�u3�lutdGika ^[��� e�ux�Gf\ev��[_csxe��Guxe7_ba�ig^[d�[fkuxetZ y j[i\_ 1 � � u�_ 1 � � fkute,�Nacj���u�_bsxe��Gu 1 ut_ 1 ec�Ga 1 � 1 � ZL] �{^[d��lfkuwutd�_cacu1fkute�Gacjli�_buteI7 1�1 8�ut_.7 1 � 1 � 8 �h^[fk^[dy_*�8�ljld�^ 1 � � 1 � �� 1�1 � ! � � Z0� a jld�^ 1 � 1 ��� �M� 1�1 �y�GjldNvikf�e���)A_ �Nu1r&jldy_ba�uxa�fk^ acuxfk^h_bi\jld�� 1 � � 1 � ��� 1 � 1 �gZy jli\_ 2 � � fg^ e�uxvxj[dG�Gu�ikdy_butacecutvt_cikjldA�G�Avxutacvtfku�vxi\acvtjldGecvtaci�_1� 1�221 ^J�[uxv�fg^ �Ga�jli\_cu�7 1 � 1 � 8�Z

��^[aIvxj vtq vxf\ikvti\_bs>�Gute��Rjlikdy_ce 1 � 2 � 1 � 2 � � jld ^�F �[jlika9ec�Na�fk^�BC�[�Gacu8� jl�NaIfk^,�Rjle�i\_bi\jldnacutfg^h_ci��lu�Guxe��Rjlikdy_be�I fg^ a�uxfk^h_bi\jld �1�2 � � 1 � � �1�1�2 � �1�1 � 2 � � �G�GjldGvwf\u _ba�ig^[d�[fku 1 2 � � 1 � uxe _7ike�j�vt�xfkuuxd 1 ZL��^[a�vxj[dGecs3� �Nuxdy_wjld�^ 1 � � 1 ��� 1 � � 2 � � ut_ jld r�j[d�_cacun�Gu1r@?tr�u 1 � � 1 ��� 1 � � 2 � �gZR]9^acuxfk^h_bi\jld�a�uxv|�Gutacv|�Gstu ex��jl�N_cikuxdy_,� ^[a�e�jlr&r�uw�Gunvtuxe7�Gux� � �Guxa�dGik�tacuxe7s3�y^[fki�_bstexZ

zNY