Franchise Succession Planning and Transfers...Franchise Succession Planning and Transfers A Best...
Transcript of Franchise Succession Planning and Transfers...Franchise Succession Planning and Transfers A Best...
FranchiseSuccession Planning and TransfersA Best Practices Handbook
Published by the
International Franchise Association1501 K St., NW, Suite 350Washington, DC 20005 USATel: +1 202 628 8000www.franchise.org
Franchise Relations CommitteeBarb Moran, ChairSuccession Planning And Transfers Task ForceWilliam Slater Vincent, Co-ChairKeith Miller, Co-Chair
Revised Spring 2010
IFA Franchise Succession Planning & Transfers Handbook
FOREWARD ...................................................................................................................................................IABOUT IFA ....................................................................................................................................................IIIFA FRANCHISE RELATIONS COMMITTEE .................................................................................................. III
I. SUCCESSION PLANNING
A. INTRODUCTION................................................................................................................................................................. 1B. WHYASUCCESSIONPLANISNEEDED............................................................................................................................... 2C. THESUCCESSIONPLAN..................................................................................................................................................... 3
i. DevelopTeamofAdvisors...................................................................................................................................... 3ii. IdentifyQualitiesSuccessorMustPossess................................................................................................................. 3iii. IdentifytheSuccessor............................................................................................................................................ 3iv. TraintheSuccessor................................................................................................................................................ 4v. FinalThoughts–Legal&TaxIssues.......................................................................................................................... 5
D. CONCLUSION................................................................................................................................................................... 5
II. THE SALE AND TRANSFER OF THE FRANCHISE
A. INTRODUCTION................................................................................................................................................................. 6B. EXITSTRATEGY................................................................................................................................................................... 6
i. SellingtoanOutsider............................................................................................................................................. 7ii. MarketabilityoftheFranchiseBusiness...................................................................................................................... 7iii. ValuationoftheBusiness......................................................................................................................................... 8iv. ValuationMethods.................................................................................................................................................. 8v. SellingtoanEmployee............................................................................................................................................ 8
C. THETRANSFERPROCESS.................................................................................................................................................... 9i. LocatingProspectiveBuyers................................................................................................................................... 10ii. Approval/DisapprovalProcess............................................................................................................................... 11iii. TheImportanceofEstablishingaTransferPolicy....................................................................................................... 11iv. APerfectWorldTransferScenario.......................................................................................................................... 12v. WhatNormallyHappensintheTransferScenario.................................................................................................... 13vi. LocatingBuyers.................................................................................................................................................... 13vii. UnqualifiedCandidatesinTransfers........................................................................................................................ 14viii. TransferFees........................................................................................................................................................ 14
D. TRANSFERDOCUMENTATION........................................................................................................................................... 15i. Documentation..................................................................................................................................................... 15ii. ConsenttoTransfer............................................................................................................................................... 16iii. ApplicableStateLaws........................................................................................................................................... 16iv. Disclosure............................................................................................................................................................ 17v. TransferProcedures............................................................................................................................................... 17
E. TRAININGANDOPERATIONALSUPPORTFORTRANSFEREES............................................................................................... 18i. DifferencesComparedtoaNewFranchisee............................................................................................................ 18ii. ComplianceReviewatTransfer.............................................................................................................................. 18iii. InitialTrainingPrograms........................................................................................................................................ 18iv. On-SiteVisitations................................................................................................................................................. 19v. HowtoGetNewTransfereesUp-To-SpeedOperationally.......................................................................................... 19vi. MentorPrograms.................................................................................................................................................. 20
F. CONCLUSION................................................................................................................................................................ 21
Table of Contents
I
II
IFA Franchise Succession Planning & Transfers Handbook
Foreword
Sellingandtransferringownershipofafranchisedbusinessissomethingthatmanyfranchiseesdonotthinkaboutuntiltheyareatthepointwheretheyareretiringorreadytoselltheirbusinesses.Manypeoplemistakenlyassumethisisasimpleprocess,buttherearemyriaddecisionstomakebeforeafranchisedbusinesscanbesoldandownershiptransferred.
Perhapsthebestwaytoprepareistocreateasuccessionplan–anadvancestrategythatmapsouthowafranchiseeplanstoremovehimselffromthebusinessinthefutureandtransferittoanewfranchiseeowner,whocouldbeafamilymemberorathirdpartybuyer.
Thishandbookprovidesablueprintforestablishingasuccessionplanalongwithalistofdecisionstobemadeintheplanningprocess.
Sellingandtransferringownershipofthebusinessnotonlyaffectsthefranchisee,butalsothefranchisor.Onesectiondiscusseshowfranchisorscanworkwiththeirfranchiseestofindasuitablebuyerfortheirfranchise.Havingaplaninadvancewillmakethissometimesemotionallydifficultprocesseasiertoexecute.
Franchise Succession Planning and Transfers
I
IFA Franchise Succession Planning & Transfers Handbook
About the International Franchise Association
II
TheInternationalFranchiseAssociation,theworld’soldestandlargestorganizationrepresentingfranchising,isthepreeminentvoiceandacknowledgedleaderfortheindustryworldwide.Currentlycelebratingahalf-centuryofservicewithagrowingmembershipofmorethan1,100franchisesystems,10,000-plusfranchiseesandmorethan500firmsthatsupplygoodsandservicestotheindustry,IFAprotects,enhancesandpromotesfranchisingbyadvancingthevaluesofintegrity,respect,trust,commitmenttoexcellence,honestyanddiversity.
IFA Mission
Protect,enhanceandpromotefranchising
IFA Vision
Thepreeminentvoiceandacknowledgedleaderforfranchisingworldwide
IFA Strategic Priorities
• Governmentrelations• Publicrelations• Educationandprofessionaldevelopment
IFA Values
Integrity• Infusinghighethicalstandardsintoallefforts
Respect• Showingthoughtfulconsiderationforallmembers,staffandotherswithwhomwework
Trust• Faithfullyfulfillingourresponsibilitiestomembers
Excellence• Deliveringhighqualitycontentandprogramsthatpropelfranchisingforward
Diversity• Embracingthediversityofindividuals,ideasandperspectives
Formoreinformation,visittheIFAWebsiteatwww.franchise.org.
IFA Franchise Succession Planning & Transfers Handbook
TheIFA’sFranchiseRelationsCommitteeisdedicatedtodevelopinginformationandprogramsthatpromotepositiverelationsandencouragedialogueandcooperationbetweenfranchiseesandfranchisors.ForadditionalcontentproducedbytheFranchiseRelationsCommittee,pleasevisitwww.franchise.org/franchiserelations.aspx.BarbMoran,MoranIndustries,Inc.Chairman
BarryMiller,SylvanLearningCenterofGirard,OhioVice-Chair
KeithMiller,SubwayFranchiseeVice-Chair
Michael Bamrick, CFE,JackInTheBox,Inc.Bruce Bloom, CFE,Bloom&Associates,LLCJoe Bourdow, CFE,ValpakSteve Bridge,CaliforniaFreshofLompoc,CAMary Beth Brody, CFE,Faegre&BensonLLPJanice Dwyer, CFE,Luce,SmithandScott,Inc.Paul Eckert,FamilyFinancialCenters,LLCDonald Higginson,MBE,aUPSCompanyHarvey Homsey,ExpressEmploymentProfessionalsKen Houck, CFE,GoldenCorralBuffet&GrillChuck Jones, CFE,HouseMasterHomeInspectionServicesJohn Kujawa,McDonald’sCorporationPaul Mangiamele, CFE,Salsarita’sLisa McCarthy,OutOfTheBoxTechnologyCatherine Monson,FASTSIGNSInternationalRay Moore, CFE,BrightStarFranchising,LLCJack Pearce, CFE,AnnexBrands,Inc.Andrew Perrin,LarkinHoffmanDaly&LindgrenSteven Rafsky,PadgettBusinessServicesRobert Sells, CFE,SellsDevelopment,Inc.Linda Shunk, CFE,OreckFranchiseServices,LLCTim Shuy,ChoiceHotelsInternationalKeith Singletary,Chick-fil-ACapitalCentreJim Squire, CFE,HoneyBakedHamCompanyandCaféEric Stites, CFE,FranchiseBusinessReviewLarry Tate,GoldenCorralBuffet&GrillWilliam Vincent,LifeUniversity;FootSolutions,Inc.David Wells, CFE,Snap-on-ToolsCompany,LLC
IFA Franchise relations Committee
III
IFA Franchise Succession Planning & Transfers Handbook
A. INTrodUCTIoN
America’sbusinesscommunityisbuiltuponfamily-ownedbusinesseswhichincludesfranchises.Morethan90%ofallbusinessesintheUnitedStatesarefamily-ownedandemploy62%oftheprivatesectorworkforce.Two-thirdsofthenation’sGrossDomesticProductisproducedbyfamily-ownedbusinesses.Further,overthelast20years,morethan80%ofthenetnewjobscreatedintheUnitedStatedwerecreatedbyfamily-ownedbusinesses.Alargenumberoffamily-ownedbusinessesarefranchisebusinessesofwhichover900,000existtoday.
Unfortunately,statisticsarenotverygoodaspertainstothecontinuationoffamily-ownedandfranchisebusinesses.Almost70%ofallbusinessesfailtosurvivetothesecondgeneration.Ofthosethatdosurvive,only12%makeittothethirdgeneration.Aconsiderablenumberoffranchisedbusinessownerswouldliketomaintainownershipoftheirfranchisesafterretirement.However,forseveralreasonsthisdoesnothappenin70%ofbusinesses.Oneoftheprimarycausesofafamilybusinessnotstayinginthefamilyisthefailuretocreateandexecuteamanagementsuccessionplan.Othermajorreasonsincludeinadequateestateplanning,andthesubsequentlackoffundstopayestatetaxes.
Mostbusinessownerswanttheirbusinessestosurvivethemandthevastmajority,exceeding80%,wanttopasstheirbusiness,orfranchises,ontotheirchildrenorotherfamilymembers.However,thenumberonereasonthisdoesnotoccurisduetothelackofaviablesuccessionplan.Therefore,inordertoensurethecontinuityofownershipbythefamilyofafranchise,asuccessionplanmustbedevelopedandimplemented.
I. SUCCeSSIoN PLANNING
1
In order to ensure the continuity of ownership by the family of a franchise,
a succession plan must be developed and
implemented.
IFA Franchise Succession Planning & Transfers Handbook
B. wHY A SUCCeSSIoN PLAN IS Needed
Approximately70%offamily-ownedfranchiseswillnotsurvivetheretirementoftheoriginalownerwithoutasuccessionplaninplace.Therearemanyreasonswhytheownermaynotbeabletocontinuetooperatethefranchiseandneedstohaveareplacementwaitingtotakeover.Forexample,oneneverknowswhenhemaydieorbecomephysicallyincapacitatedduetoanillness.Also,therearelegalandfinancialproblemsthatcanariseinwhichtheownerneedstobeimmediatelyreplacedbyasuccessor.Therehaveevenbeencaseswheretheownerhas,withoutnotice,walkedawaybecausehehadhadenoughandwantedtogointoimmediateretirement.However,atsomepointintimeasuccessorwilltakeoverfortheoriginalownerofthefranchise.Andthepointis,oneneverknowswhenthatsuccessorwillneedtotakeover.Aswehavealwaysbeentaught,anounceofpreventionisworthapoundofcureandthereforeitisofextremeimportancetohaveasuccessionplaninplaceiftheownerofthefranchisewantstomaintainownershipasopposedtotransferringittoanother.
Thereareseveralcompetinginterestswhentheownerdoesneedtoretire.Ifmembersofhisfamilyarealsoemployeestheymightfeelliketheyshouldbethesuccessor.Also,iftheownerhasseveralchildreneachofthemmayfeelthattheyshouldbeputinchargeofthefranchise.Additionally,therearenon-familyemployeesthat,becauseoftheirlengthofserviceorimportancetothefranchise,wanttobecomethesuccessortotheowner,oratleastobtainastakeinthefranchise.Evenwhentherearenofamilymembersoftheowneractivelyinvolvedinthefranchise,therecanstillbepressureappliedbecausethesefamilymemberswanttoensurethattheywillendupowningthebusinessifsomethingshouldhappentotheowner.Forthesereasonsandothers,aneffectiveandcompletesuccessionplanneedstobeimplementedbyeachfranchiseownertoensurethecontinuedsuccessofthefranchiseintheeventtheoriginalfranchiseownerisnolongerabletoorwillingtoleadandoperatethefranchise.
2
Approximately 70% of family-owned
franchises will not survive the retirement of the original owner without a succession
plan in place.
IFA Franchise Succession Planning & Transfers Handbook
C. THe SUCCeSSIoN PLAN
(i) DEVELOP TEAM OF ADVISORS
Thefranchiseownerneedstocontrolthesuccessionplanfrombeginningtoend.Afterall,itishiscompanyandthereforeneedstocontrolthemanagementcontinuitystrategy.Theownercanselecttodothisinoneoftwoways.First,theownermightdecidejusttoworkwithselectedmembersofhisorherfamilyandallowimmediatefamilymemberstoactivelyparticipateinhelpingtheownerdecideuponasuccessor.Second,theownermightdecideitisadvisabletobringinprofessionaladvisorssuchasanattorneyorbusinessexpertsinhisindustrythatknowwhatqualitiesareimperativeforasuccessortohavetobeasuccessfulreplacementoftheowner.Regardlessofwhatapproachistaken,itisadvisabletocontactthefranchisoranddeterminewhathelpthefranchisorofferswithregardtotransfers.Oftentimestheownerwillfinditbeneficialtocombinebothstrategiesandselectasuccessorbaseduponinputfrombothhisimmediatefamilymembersandprofessionaladvisors.
(ii) IDENTIFY QUALITIES SUCCESSOR MUST POSSESS
Oncethefranchiseehashisteamofadvisorsinplacehemustidentifythosequalitiesthathissuccessormustpossessinordertosuccessfullyrunandoperatethefranchise.Manyfranchisorsrequirecertainqualificationsofasuccessortotheexistingfranchisee.Dependinguponthetypeoffranchise,therecouldbesomeveryspecificandhighlytechnicalqualitiesthatmustbepossessedbyapotentialsuccessor.Suchqualitieswouldbeascertainedbythefranchisee,hisadvisors,andthefranchisoraspartofhissuccessionplan.However,therearemanyqualitiesthatthesuccessormustpossessthatarecommontoallfranchises.Forexample,thesuccessormustqualifyasafranchiseeandhaveacompleteknowledgeofthebusinessheorsheistorunandoperate,oratleasttheabilitytoacquirethisknowledgewithinanacceptabletimeframe.Further,thesuccessormustpossessthetraitsofenthusiasm,persistence,determination,willingnesstolearn,andbasicintellectualcapacity.Otherqualitieswouldincludetheabilitytoplanandorganize,abletosolveproblems,aneyefordetail,alongwithgoodhealth,plentyofenergy,andagung-hoattitude.
(iii) IDENTIFY THE SUCCESSOR
Oncethefirstandsecondstepsofthesuccessionplanhavebeencompleted,itisnowtimetoidentifypotentialsuccessors.Oftentimes,thefranchiseewillassumethathischildrenwillwanttotakeoverthebusinessandbethesuccessor.However,theownerofthefranchisemustidentifytherightsuccessorforhisbusinesswhetherornotitisoneofhischildrenoranotherfamilymember.
Thefranchiseeshouldmakeitcleartoeachofhischildrenandotherfamilymemberswhetherornotheorsheisrequiredtojointhebusinessonafulltimebasis.Also,itmightbeappropriatetogivethepotentialfamilymembersuccessortheopportunitytoworkoutsidethebusinessfirsttogainvaluableskillsinotherbusinesssettings.ThisisdonebyChick-fil-Awiththegrandchildrenofthefounder.Thefranchiseemustrealizethatthesuccessormayormaynotcomefromwithinhisorherfamily.Further,itispossiblethat,iftherearetwostrongcontendersforsuccessors,thefranchiseemayworkwithbothofthemtobehissuccessorandbothmayberesponsiblefortheeffectiveoperationofthebusinessuponhisretirement.
3
IFA Franchise Succession Planning & Transfers Handbook
Thetwomainreasonsfranchiseesdonotputasuccessionplanintoplaceorgiveitmuchthoughtisbecauseone,theyfeelliketheyhaveplentyoftimetodosoandtwo,thattheymightoffendfamilymembersiftheypickoneoveranother.However,itisinterestingtonotethattheaveragelifespanofafamily-ownedbusinessis24yearsandthatisalsotheaveragetimetheoriginalownerisatthehelmofthefranchise.However,neverknowingwhatwillhappentomorrow,itisalwaysimportantearlyoninthelifeofafranchisebusinesstohaveasuccessionplaninplacesothatsuccessorscanbegroomedbecausetheymaybeneededsoonerthanlater.
(iv) TRAIN THE SUCCESSOR
Nowthatthesuccessorhasbeenpicked,andassuminganylegalmattersaretakencareof,thefranchiseemusttrainthesuccessorbytransferringhisknowledgetohimgraduallyovertime.Dependinguponthefranchise,theownerwillneedatransitionperiodofonetothreeyearstoadequatelytrainhissuccessor.Thesuccessormustfollowasuccessionplanthatincludeseducationaboutthebusiness.Thismayincludeattendingtherequiredfranchisortrainingcourse(s)andworkingwiththecurrentownertolearneverythingthereisaboutthebusiness.Thesuccessormustgettoknowthefranchise’smostimportantcustomersalongwithitskeysuppliers,vendors,andotherpeopleinbusinessesthathavecontributedtothesuccessofthefranchise.Thefranchiseemustconveythekeyfactorsthathefeelshasledtohissuccessandthosekeyfactorsthathefeelswillleadtosuccessinthefuture.Asmuchaspossible,thefranchiseemustdocumentallofhisknowledgeandprocessessothatthesuccessorwillknowhowthingsaredoneandwhy.Muchofthisknowledgeisalreadycontainedintheoperationsmanualprovidedbythefranchisor.However,theownerwillstillcontributemuchknowledgeinthesuccessfuloperationofthefranchisethatisnotcontainedintheoperationsmanualandothermaterialsprovidedbythefranchisor.
Graduallythefranchiseemustshowhistrustinhissuccessorbydelegatingmoreandmoreresponsibilitiestohim.Theownermustrealizethatthesuccessormaymakemistakesfromtimetotimeandneedstobetheretoassistincorrectingthemistakesandturnthemintolearningexperiences.Further,theownerneedstoprovidehisorhersuccessorwiththeappropriatedocumentsthatarerequiredtoefficientlyoperatethefranchise.Thesedocumentsincludesuchitemsasfinancialstatements,insurancepolicies,keycontracts,corporateand/orotherbusinessdocumentsthatdictatehowthebusinessistoberun,alongwithsharingallfranchisormaterialswiththesuccessor.
Initiallythesuccessorwillshadowthefranchiseeandjustwatchthefranchisee.Graduallytheownerwilldelegatemoreandmoreresponsibilitiestohissuccessorsothathecaneffectivelytrainhim.Also,thistransitionperiodallowsfornotonlytheotheremployeesofthefranchisebutalsoforthefranchisee’scustomers,suppliers,andvendorstodevelopconfidenceinthesuccessoraswell.Theendresultisthatallpartiescometoidentifythefranchisewiththesuccessorasopposedtotheoriginalowner.
4
IFA Franchise Succession Planning & Transfers Handbook
(v) FINAL THOUGHTS – LEGAL AND TAX ISSUES
Finally,thesuccessionplan,aspartofthefranchisee’sestateplanning,mustbestructuredinsuchawayastominimizetheimpactofestate,gift,andinheritancetaxesonfamilymembersandthebusiness.Franchiseownerswhofailtoconsiderthepotentialimpactofestateandinheritancetaxescouldeasilyforce,upontheirpassing,theirremainingfamilymemberstosellthebusinessinordertopaytheestate’staxbill.AtthispointitiscriticaltohaveataxattorneyandaCPAwhospecializesintaxestodeterminewhichvehiclesarebestinordertominimizethesetaxes.Severalitemsthatcanbeutilizedinordertodothisareitemssuchasfamilylimitedpartnerships,anestatefreeze,varioustypesoftrusts,lifetimegifting,andbuy-sellagreements.Thefranchiseemustcovertheseissueswithcompetentlegalandtaxcounselandanyfurtherdiscussionofthesetypesoflegaloptionsisbeyondthescopeofthishandbook.However,beforetheowneroffranchisecandeterminewhichoptionstoutilizefromalegalandtaxperspective,hemustfirstcheckwithhisfranchisorinordertodetermineifwrittenpermissionisneededfromthefranchisorinorderfortheownertoparticipateinoneoftheselegalstrategies.Afterall,thefranchisorwillwanttoknowwhatisgoingonandwillwanttoreviewwhateverisdonebeforeitisdoneconcerningtheseitems.
d. CoNCLUSIoN
Afranchiseowner,uponpurchaseofafranchise,shouldalreadybeimplementingasuccessionplan.Oneneverknowswhenasuccessorwillhavetotakeoverlongbeforeexpected.Therefore,itisalwaysbettertobeproactivethanreactive.However,notallfranchiseownersarelookingtodevelopasuccessionplanbecauseforwhateverreasontheyhavealreadydecidedtheywillsellthefranchisetoathirdparty,whichcouldincludeafamilymember.Therefore,forthosesituations,thesecondpartofthishandbookcoversthesaleofabusiness,whichunderfranchisingisreferredtoastransfers.
5
one never knows when a successor will have to take over long before expected.
It is always better to be proactive than reactive.
IFA Franchise Succession Planning & Transfers Handbook
A. INTrodUCTIoN
Entrepreneursrarelytakethetimetoconsiderhowtheyaregoingtohandle‘theend’atthestart-uporduringthelifeofabusiness.Littlethoughtisgiventotheimplicationsofatransferorsuccessionofafranchisedbusinesswithathoroughreviewoftheapplicablefranchisedocuments.
Formanyentrepreneurs,itisdifficulttoconsiderthedissolutionofthefranchiseattheonset.Manychoosetooptimisticallyfocusonthebenefitsandpotential.Evenifaclearunderstandingexistsinitiallyabouttheprocessandproceduresforatransferorsuccessionofthefranchise,itisrarelyrevisitedorreconsideredduringthelifeofthebusiness.
Onlyontheoccasionofasignificanteventlikeanillnessorretirementdoestheissuegettheattentionitdeserves.Andtheresultisalltoooftenlesssatisfyingthanitmighthavebeenifaprocesstoexitthesystemhadbeenclearlydocumentedandagreeduponatthebeginningofthefranchiserelationship.B. eXIT STrATeGY
Animportantpartofanysuccessionplanistheexitstrategyforthefranchiseowner.Disability,retirement,death–theseareallissuesthatmustbeplannedforandaddressed.Thetimingofatransitiondependsonanumberoffactors,suchasthefranchisee’sage,health,retirementgoals,andthereadinessofabuyer/successor.Thefranchiseemustconsiderwhethertomaintainsomeinvolvementwiththebusinessormakeacleanbreak.
Thefollowingarepotentialnon-familysuccessorsinthesaleofyourbusiness:
a. anoutsiderb. anexistingemployeeandpossiblyretainingpartial ownershipc. aselectgrouportoallofyouremployees
II. THe SALe ANd TrANSFer oF THe FrANCHISe
6
For many entrepreneurs, it is difficult to
consider the dissolution of the
franchise at the onset.
IFA Franchise Succession Planning & Transfers Handbook
Ofcourse,allthreeofthesearesubjecttothefranchiseagreementtermsandprovisionsconcerningrenewal,termination,repurchase,modificationandassignmentofthefranchise.Therearecontractrestrictionsonthefranchisee’srighttofreelytransferthefranchise.Thesecontractlimitationsaresometimesalsosubjecttoseparatestatelegislation.
Thesestandardfranchiseagreementprovisionsenablefranchisesystemstoenforcehighqualitystandardsandensureuniformity.Failuretocomplywiththeserestrictionsgenerallybecomescausefordefaultandterminationoftheagreementandexposesthefranchiseetotheriskofendingupwithnofranchiseatall.Soitisofutmostimportancetomakeallplanswithinthescopeoftheappropriateprovisionsofthefranchiseagreement.
(i) SELLING TO AN OUTSIDER
Theoutsiderchallengeisidentifyingsomeoneinterestedinandfamiliarwithyourbusiness,thenqualifyingthembothoperationallyandfinancially,andmatchingtheirpersonalityandskillsettothefranchiseconcept.
Oneexampleisavendororsupplierpreparedtomoveintobusinessownership.Akeysupplieroficemachineswithalongworkingrelationshipwitharegionaldistributorenjoyedtheend-usercustomercontactsomuchthathepurchasedthebusinesswhenthedistributor/sellerlefttobeginhisnextcareer.However,thefirstplacetolookistothefranchisor.Manyfranchisesystemsassistfranchiseeswithlocatingasuccessorandhandlingtheresultanttransfer.
Anothersourceofinterestedpartiesmaybeaclientthatissubjecttodownsizingand/orconsolidationofalargecorporationwhoispreparedtosecuretheirfuturebypurchasingabusiness.Athirdpartyreferral,suchasabusinessbrokerorabroker’sreferralnetworkmayspeedtheprocessofqualifyingandmatchingpossibleprospects.
(ii) MARKETABILITY OF THE FRANCHISE BUSINESS
Buylowandsellhighisalwaysagreatidea,whetheritisastockorabusiness.Sellthestorewhensalesareclimbing,placingthebuyerinapositivestateofmindandpsychologicallypreparedtomakethepurchase.Thefollowingareimportanttothebuyer.
• Afullytrainedstaffisanattractiveasset• Allkeymanagementpositionsarefilled• Thelowerthedebtloadofabusinessthehighertheliquidityandcashflow• Severabilityofrealestatefromthebusiness• Completeanddetailedcorporatebooksandrecords• ApositiveEBITDA(EarningsBeforeInterest,Taxes,Depreciation,&Amortization)trendline• Afranchisethatisnotoverlydependentontheownerforitsoperationalsuccessand
profitability• Theageandconditionoftheequipmentandfacilities
7
IFA Franchise Succession Planning & Transfers Handbook
(iii) VALUATION OF THE BUSINESS
Therearevaluationissuesintheeventofdeathforfranchiseeswithasubstantialnetworth.Theestatetax–evenasmodifiedbytheEconomicGrowthandTaxReliefReconciliationActof2001–isaprincipalconsiderationindevelopingthesuccessionplan.TheInternalRevenueCoderequirestheestatetaxtobeimposeduponthefairmarketvalueoftheestateofthedeceasedatthetimeofdeath.Franchisescanpresentuniqueproblemsintheareaofvaluation.Amajorreasonforpreparingasuccessionplanistoavoidtheprospectofaforcedsalethatwoulddiminishthevalueofthefranchisebusiness.
(iv) VALUATION METHODS
TherearethreebasicmethodsofvaluationacceptedbythecourtsandtheIRS:bookvalueornetworth,capitalizationofearnings,andcomparablesalesofsimilarfranchisebusinesses.Themostpersuasive,whenavailable,iscomparablesales.Asarule,theinformationoncomparablesalesoffranchisebusinessesisinthepossessionofthefranchisor.Ideally,thefranchisesystemshouldprovideitsfranchiseeswithalltheinformationitcanaboutcomparablesaleswithoutdivulgingconfidentialinformation.
Abusinessisworthwhatanotherpartywillpayforit.Afranchiseemayhaveinvested24hoursaday,7daysaweekforyearsinabusiness,whichmaybeworthmillionstothem.Butthebuyerhasnoemotionalinvestmentandwillonlypurchaseifthebusinessoffersabetterreturnthananotherbusinessofferedinthemarketplace.
Tosetamarketableprice,onesourceofinformationistheresalelistofthefranchisor.Askhowmanytransactionswereresales.Whatpercentoftheiraskingpricedidtheysellfor?Whatmultipleofgrosssales,netsalesorprofitabilityiscommonlyusedtosetthesellingprice?Themarketsetsthepriceandifthepriceistoohigh,theprospecthastheoptionofinvestinginanewstart-uplocationifterritoryisavailable.Theadvantageofbuyinganexistingstoreisgenerationsofcashflowsandanestablishedclientbase,aslongastheaskingpricefortheseisreasonable.Finally,anytransferandfranchisefeesthatmayapplytothistransactionmustbediscussedwiththefranchisor.Thisshouldbeconsideredindetermininganytransferpriceofferedtoaprospectivesuccessor.
Thereareanumberofwaysofvaluingabusiness.Gotowww.smallbusinessnotes.comforacomprehensivelistofthedifferentwaysabusinesscanbevaluedindeterminingthepriceatwhichtosellthebusiness.
(v) SELLING TO AN EMPLOYEE
EmployeeStockOwnershipPlans,whichinvolvetransferringownershipofthecompanybothtofamilymembersandtoemployees,cannotbeusedontheirowntotransferownershipwhollytofamilymembers,buttheycanbeusedincombinationwithothermethodsoftransfer–suchasgiftingorrecapitalization–tokeepmajorityownershipinafamily.
Onescenarioofakeyemployeepurchasingthebusinessmightbe,“IfIdieoramdisabled,thecontractsthatIhavewithmytwotrustedexecutivesrequirethemtorunthecompanyforat
8
IFA Franchise Succession Planning & Transfers Handbook
leasttwoyears.Theyhaveanoptiontobuythecompanyatanytimefor$7millionor,iftheydecline,theywillbepaidasubstantialperformancebonusifthecompanyisultimatelysoldformorethan$8million.”
Onemethodforkeepinggoodemployeesinterestedingrowingthebusinessis‘keyman’insurance.Thisisapolicyinthenameoftheemployee,wherethecompanypaysthepremiumandtheemployeeaccruesthecashvalueofthepolicy.
Withsomanydecisionsandchoices,everysuccessionplanshouldbereviewedandapprovedbythesellingbusinessowners,theiraccountant,attorneyandfranchisor.Onemustplanaheadforasuccessfulandsmoothexitstrategy.
C. THe TrANSFer ProCeSS
Mostfranchisorshavedeterminedhowtheyaregoingtohandlethetransferprocess.ThisisreflectedintheFDDandmorespecificallydetailedinthefranchiseagreement.Atypicalprocesswouldbeasfollows:
1. Notification: Thefranchiseemustgivenoticetothefranchisorofhisintenttotransferthebusiness,whethertoanotherfranchiseoperatororfamilymember.Theperiodfornotification,ifnotregulatedbyStatelaw,isgenerally30to90daysbeforetheproposedtransfer.
Thefranchisormostlikelywillrequirethepaymentofatransferfeeatthetimetherequestfortransferisreceivedorlater,whendocumentsaresignedgivingthefranchisor’sapproval.Mostfranchiseagreementsrequirethefranchiseetonotifythefranchisorintheeventofthedeathordisabilityofthefranchisee.Therearegenerallyspecifiedtimeframesforaqualifiedsuccessortobenamedandmeetthefranchisor’sapprovalcriteria.
Itwouldbeprudentforeveryfranchiseetohaveaprospectivesuccessoridentifiedshouldtheybeneeded.However,veryfewfranchiseeshaveconsideredidentifyingaprospectinadvance.
2. Approval:Thefranchisorwillhavetherighttoapprovethetransfereethefranchiseedesignates,whetheritisanotherbusinessperson,arelative,oranotherfranchisee.Theprospectivefranchiseewillhavetomeetthefranchisor’scurrentrequirementsforanewprospectivefranchisee,includingfinancialqualifications,experience,businessacumenandcommitmenttooperatethefranchise.
Forthefranchisee’sfamilymembers,sometimestheapprovalrequirementsarelessstringent.Careshouldbetakentounderstandthenatureofthetransferorsliabilityafterthetransfer,asmanyfranchisorsdoNOTreleasetheoriginalfranchiseefromallorpartoftheirliabilityunderthefranchiseagreement,whenitisassignedtoasuccessor.
9
IFA Franchise Succession Planning & Transfers Handbook
3. Right of First Refusal:Manyfranchisorshavearightoffirstrefusaltopurchasethefranchisedbusinessatthepointofaproposedtransferifcertainfactorsexist.Thesemayincludeinstanceswhentheprospectivesuccessorisabusinesspersonfromoutsidethesystem,afamilymemberthatisdeemednotqualifiedtooperatethefranchisedbusiness,orothersimilarsituations.
Somefranchisorswillnegotiatethisprovisionoutofthefranchiseagreement,especiallyinanewfranchisesystem.However,asthefranchisorandtheirsystemgrows,afranchisorwillbeincreasinglyreluctanttoremoveordilutethisprovision.
4. Training: Ifthefranchisorapprovesthetransfer,therewillberequiredtrainingtofurtherqualifythetransfereetooperatethefranchisedbusiness.Thistrainingmayrequirethetransfereetoattainsomelevelofcompetencytosatisfythequalificationprocess.Theremaybetrainingfeestobepaidbythetransferee,alongwithtravelandlivingexpensesincurredduringthetrainingperiod.
5. Effective Dates for Transfer of the Franchise:Dependingonthetypeofbusiness,therewillbeapointintimewhenthetransferofficiallyoccurs.Ifthebusinesshastangibleassets,itwillgenerallybeonthedayanddatewhenthoseassetshavebeenofficiallyconveyedtothetransferee.Ifitisaservicebusiness,itisgenerallywhentheaccountshavebeenpresentedandtherevenuegeneratedafterthatdateaccruestothetransferee.
(i) LOCATING PROSPECTIVE BUYERS
Oneofthebenefitsofowningafranchisedbusinessistheavailablepoolofprospectivebuyers.Thepoolofcandidatesmayinclude:
• Existingfranchiseesinthesamesystem.• Ifallowed,franchiseesofotherconceptsinthesamevicinitywhoarelookingfor
expansionopportunities,butarelimitedwithintheirpresentconcept.• Forexample,aBaskin-Robbinsfranchiseewithnoaccesstoanother31Flavors
franchiseintheirareamayseekanotherfranchisebrand,suchasacoffeeshoporsandwichshop,inthesamearea.
• Franchiseprospectsthatareinterestedinbuyinga‘goingconcern’withimmediatecashflowversusastart-upsituation,whichcouldtake6to12monthstoopen.
Oneofthekeystosuccessinlocatingabuyerforafranchisedbusinessistounderstandtherolethefranchiseeandthefranchisorcanplayinthetransferprocess.However,almostalwaystheprospectivefranchiseemustmeetthequalificationsassetforthbythefranchisorandbeapprovedbythefranchisor.Franchisor’srole:Thefranchisorwillgenerallytakea‘handsoff’approachinthepreparationofthelegalsaledocuments,butexperienceindicatesthatmanyareeagertosupportafranchiseeinthetransferprocess.Thefranchisorwantstoensureaqualifiedoperatorendsupwiththebusinessandmanyfranchisorswillactivelymarkettheopportunitywithintheirorganizationandtonewfranchiseprospects.Franchisee’srole:Thebottomlineisthatafranchiseeisresponsibleformakingthedecisiontheywanttoaffectatransferandlocatinganappropriatetransferee.Therearenumerousavenuesandresourcesforreachingthatdecisionthatatransferisappropriateandforlocatingpotentialtransferees:
10
IFA Franchise Succession Planning & Transfers Handbook
• Franchisee’snetwork–Oneplacetolookiswithinthefranchisee’sownsphereofinfluence,suchasbusinesscontacts,vendors,otherfranchiseesinthearea,friendsandrelatives.Manytransfersresultfrominterestshowninafranchisedbusinessbysomeonewithpersonalinvolvementinthebusinessand/orthefranchisee.
• Franchisor’snetwork–Ifthefranchisoriswillingtoprovideaccessto,orstimulateinterestfrom,theirnetworkoffranchisees,prospectsandvendors,itisthefranchisee’sresponsibilitytoindependentlyinvestigateeachleadanddetermineifitrepresentsatrueprospect.Becausetheprospectreferralcamethroughthefranchisordoesn’tnecessarilymeantheywillmeetthefranchisor’scriteriaforapprovaltoacquirethefranchisedbusiness.
• BusinessBrokers–ThereisanactivebusinessbrokernetworkintheU.S.andabroadthatrepresentbuyersandsellersofbusinesses,bothfranchisedandindependent.Onemustbecertainthatthebrokerworkswithfranchisedbusinessesandunderstandsthatthebuyermustultimatelybequalifiedandapprovedbythefranchisorpriortothebuyeracquiringthefranchise.Manyprospectsinitiallyseekinganon-franchisedbusinessthroughabusinessbrokerbecomeinterestedinafranchisedbusinessduringtheprocess.
• Thebasisforusingabusinessbroker,whethertorepresentthesaleofyourbusinessortoprovideprospectivebuyersforyourbusiness,isthecontractyousignwiththem.Itwillidentifytheservicesthebrokerwillprovideandfeesthatwillbeincurredshouldasaleresult.Thesefeescanvarysubstantiallybetweenbrokers.Beforeemployingabroker,thesellershouldrequestaclientlistfromthebroker,withcontactinformation,togetrecommendationsregardingthebroker’spastservicestohisclients.
(ii) APPROVAL/DISAPPROVAL PROCESS
Oncethedecisionhasbeenmadebyafranchiseetosellafranchisebusiness,thetransfereehasbeenidentifiedandthepriceandtermshavebeenagreedupon,thefranchisorwillhavetherighttograntordenytherequestforapprovalofthetransfereewithinaspecifiedtimeframe.Thefranchisormayalsorequirefranchiseand/orbackgroundcheckdocumentsbecompletedbeforeitwillconsideranapplicationforapproval.
• Approval–Thefranchisor’sapprovalofthebuyershouldbeinwritingtoensurenomisunderstandings.Theapprovalwillgenerallystatewhetheritiscontingentonanyotherfactors,suchasobtainingfinancing,successfullycompletingtrainingandapprovalofdocumentssuchasanAssetSaleAgreementorPurchaseAgreement.
• Disapproval–Oneofthemostchallengingaspectsofthefranchiserelationshipcanbethedisapprovalofarequesttotransferafranchisedbusiness,whethertoaanotherfranchisee,athirdpartybuyerortoafamilymember.Therearesometimesrightsprovidedinthefranchiseagreementtoappealthedisapprovalofatransferrequest.However,atbest,thisresultsinadelayinthetransfertimetable.
(iii) THE IMPORTANCE OF ESTABLISHING A TRANSFER POLICY
Thereareseveralreasonswhyafranchiseemaychoosetoexitthefranchisesystemandtransferhisbusinessandfranchisetoanotherparty.Afranchiseemaychoosetotransferbecauseheisretiring,notexperiencingthelevelofsuccessorsatisfactionhewasexpecting,orbecausethebusinesswasverysuccessfulandnowthefranchiseewantstosellatafavorablepriceand
11
IFA Franchise Succession Planning & Transfers Handbook
pursueotheropportunities.Regardlessofthereasonfortransfer,everyfranchisorshouldhaveestablishedatransferpolicy/processsothatallfranchiseescanunderstanditandtransferscanmoveforwardassmoothlyaspossible.
Thetransferpolicyshouldtakeintoconsiderationtheinterestsofallthepartiesinvolved.Thethreepartiesalwaysinvolvedintransfersare:thefranchisor,thefranchisee(transferor)andthetransferee(prospectivenewfranchisee).
Thefranchisor’sinterestintransfersiswantingtomakesurethetransfereemeetsitscurrentcriteriaforqualifyingasafranchisee,thatthetransfereewillbeagoodfitwithinthesystemandthatthebusinessisbeingsold/purchasedforareasonablepricetoaffordthetransfereeagoodchanceforfinancialsuccess.Thefranchisee’sinterestintransfersboilsdowntowantingtoexitthefranchisesysteminatimelymanner,whilegettingthehighestpricefortheirfranchisedbusiness.
Thetransferee’sinterestisdifferent.Thetransfereeneedstobesurethesystemtheyareenteringisonetheywanttobeactiveinforthelifeofthefranchiseagreement.Thetransfereeneedstomakesuretheyarepayingafairpriceforthebusinessandneedtobeawareofthechallengesthatmayoccurfromassumingownershipofanexistingbusiness,regardlessofwhetherthebusinessissuccessfulornot.
(iv) A PERFECT WORLD TRANSFER SCENARIO
Inaperfectworld,alltransferswouldbecookie-cuttercasesandtheprocessthefranchisorhasestablishedwouldbefollowedquicklyandsmoothlyeverytime.Unfortunatelythisisnotaperfectworld.Butthatdoesn’tmeanfranchisorsshouldn’testablishtransferpoliciesasifitwere.Hereisasample“perfectworld”transferscenario:
1). ThefranchiseecommunicateshisdesiretosellhisbusinessandexitthesystemtohisFieldRepresentativeorhiscontactatthefranchiseheadquarters.
2). Oncetheinitialcommunicationhasbeenmade,thefranchisorrepresentativeandthefranchiseediscusswhetherthefranchisormayhaveaqualifiedprospectfortheunit.However,inmostcases,thefranchiseemustlookforhisownbuyer.
3). Onceacandidateislocated,thefranchisorwillinterviewandqualifythecandidateinasimilarfashionasanewprospect.Oneofthemostfrequentcomplaintsfromfranchiseesregardingtransfersisthatthefranchisorismuchmorestringentinestablishingitsqualificationsforatransfereethantheyseemtobeforanewfranchiseecomingintothesystem.Thisseemsunfairtothefranchiseebecausesuchpracticesmakeexitingthesystemforthemmoredifficult.Ifthesameapprovalcriteriaareusedfortransfersasfornewsales,therewouldbelessroomfordispute.
4). Whileaqualifiedtransfereeisbeingsought,apriceforthebusinessshouldbeestablished.Regardlessofwhenthesalepriceisarrivedatbythetransferor,theyshouldbeawarethatundermostfranchiseagreements,thefranchisorhastherighttoknowtheaskingpriceandothertermsofthetransferofthebusiness,forpossibleexerciseofitsrightoffirstrefusalorcompliancewiththefranchiseagreement,andtoapprovetheterms.
12
IFA Franchise Succession Planning & Transfers Handbook
Itisthefranchisor’sresponsibilitytoprotectthetransfereeandthesystem.Ifthetransferee’sdebt/equityratioistoohighbasedonthepurchasepriceandtheamountofdebtowedtothetransferororthelender,thetransfereemaynotsuccessfullygrowthebusinessandmayjeopardizeitssuccess.
5). Onceaqualifiedcandidateisfoundandapprovedandafairpriceisagreeduponbyallparties,aclosingandtransitiontimelineshouldbeset.Thistimelineshouldoutlinesuchthingsas:trainingforthetransfereewiththefranchisor,on-sitetrainingforthetransfereeeitherbythetransferororthefranchisor,aclosingdate,signingoflegaldocumentsinvolvedandpaymentofthepurchasepriceandtransferfee.
6). Whenalloftheitemsonthetransitiontimelinehavebeencompleted,thetransfereewilltakeoverthebusiness.Fromthispointforward,theinvolvementofthetransferor(originalfranchisee)willvaryfromsystemtosystem.Insomefranchisesystems,itislikelytheoriginalfranchiseewillhavenofurthercontactwiththetransfereeorthefranchisor,afterthetransferiscomplete.Itisusuallyeasierforthetransfereeandfranchisortohaveabetterworkingrelationshipifthetransferorisn’tcontinually“inthemiddle”ofthenewrelationshipofferingtheiropinions.Insomecases,somefranchisorsmayencouragethetransferortostayinvolvedforafewmonthsafterthetransferoccurs,becausetheoriginalfranchisee’scontinuedinvolvementmayhelpthetransfereemorequicklygetontheirfeet.
(v) WHAT NORMALLY HAPPENS IN THE TRANSFER SCENARIO
Mostfranchisorswilltellyouthatmosttransfersdonotgoexactlyliketheirtransferpolicyprovides.Therearecircumstancesthataffecteverytransfer,makingitdifficulttofollowtherulesattimes.
Sometimesthefranchisoristhelasttoknowwhenatransferisabouttooccurorhasalreadytakenplace.Thefranchisorgetscontactedafterthefranchiseehasfoundsomeonelocallywhoisinterestedinpurchasingthebusinessandthentheyreporttheclosingisalreadyscheduled.
Asafranchisorinthisscenario,firststartsortingthroughthepiecesofthepuzzle,becauseafranchisorcannotstickitsheadinthesandandrefusetoworkwiththefranchiseetocorrectthesituation.Onceyoudeterminehowfarintothetransferprocessthefranchiseealreadyis,afranchisorneedstodoitsbesttoproceedfromthere.
(vi) LOCATING BUYERS
Locatingbuyersfortransferunitsistheprimarytask.Franchiseesoftenlookfirsttointerestedpartieswithintheirregion.
Perhapsalocalmulti-unitoperatorisinterestedingrowthbyacquisitionormaybeanacquaintancehasalwaysbeeninterestedingettinginvolvedwiththesystemandthisisaconvenientlocationtoavoidrelocating.Howeverpotentialbuyersarelocatedforthepurchaseofthistransferunit,afranchiseeshouldfollowthesystem’stransferpolicytoavoidconfusionanddelays.
13
IFA Franchise Succession Planning & Transfers Handbook
(vii) UNQUALIFIED CANDIDATES IN TRANSFERS
Oneofthemostchallengingcircumstancesintransfersituationsiswhenthefranchiseepresentsapotentialbuyerandthebuyerdoesnotmeetfranchisor’squalificationstobeafranchisee.Thissituationcanbecomemorecomplicatedifthefranchiseeandprospectivetransfereehavealreadyagreeduponaprice,scheduledtheclosingandaremovingforwardwiththetransferbeforecontactingthefranchisor.
Itisworthwhiletomentionthatwhilemostfranchisorswillnotunreasonablywithholditsapprovalofatransfer,thereisstillaqualificationprocesswhichmustbefollowed.Thefranchisee(whoprobablywentthroughasimilarfranchiseecriteriaandqualificationprocesswhentheyenteredthesystem)shouldbeawaretheyneedtohelpthetransfereegetapprovediftheywanttoexitthesysteminatimely,cost-effectivemanner.
Whenasituationariseswherethefranchiseehasbroughtatrulyunqualifiedcandidatetothefranchisorforapproval,thefranchisorshouldbeconciseandstraightforwardwiththefranchiseeintheirassessment.Clearlyoutlinewhythecandidatedoesnotqualify,butdonotleavetheconversationopenforfurtherdiscussion.Ifthefranchisorcanclearlyidentifytothefranchiseewhyaparticularcandidatedidnotqualify,thenthefranchiseeshouldbewillingtogooutandsearchforacandidatewhodoesmeetthecriteria.
Ifthefranchiseebringsmultiplecandidatestothefranchisorforreview,butisrepeatedlytoldtheprospectsdonotqualify,thefranchisorshouldbepreparedforstrongresistancefromafranchisee.Ifthefranchisoriscontinuallyrejectingthefranchisee’scandidates,perhapsthefranchisorshouldstepbackandconsiderwhethertheyarefairlyevaluatingthecandidatesorifthereissomeotherreasonwhytheprospectsarenotmeetingthefranchisor’scurrentstandards.
(viii) TRANSFER FEES
Somefranchisorshavefeesassociatedwiththerequesttohaveabuyerapprovedwhileothershavefeesassociatedwiththesubsequenttransferofafranchisedbusiness.Thefranchisordoesnotwantfranchiseestocapriciouslysubmitprospectsforreviewwithoutremunerationforthetimeandresourcesitwilltaketoadequatelyreviewandapproveeachprospect.Sometimes,thefeesareconnectedtovariouselementsoftheprocess,withseparatefeesforreviewingtherequest,qualifyingprospects,approvingtherequestandfinallydocumentingtherequest.
Insomecircumstances,thefranchisormaysetthefeeasapercentageofthesaleprice,whichcanresultinsignificantfees.Generally,thefeeschargedbyfranchisorsforapprovingthesaleofabusinessandthetransferofanexistingfranchiseagreementarespelledoutinthefranchiseagreement.Thefeescanbesignificant,whichiswhyitisimportanttoaddressthemclearlyinthefranchiseagreementandforafranchiseetothoroughlyreviewandunderstandthetransferprocess.
Mostfranchisorscontendthetransferfee,payableatthetimeofclosingbyeitherthetransferor(franchisee)ortransferee,isneededtocoverthefranchisor’sexpensesofbeinginvolvedinthetransferprocess,whichoftencanbelengthyandtime-consumingforthefranchisortoapprovethebuyer.Thetransferormayfeeltheyshouldn’thavetopaythetransferfeebecausetheypaidthefranchisefeewhentheyjoinedthesystem.
14
IFA Franchise Succession Planning & Transfers Handbook
Itisimportanttoboththefranchisorandfranchiseethatarequirementtopaytheamountofsuchfeebeclearlyspecifiedinthefranchiseagreement,includingpaymentofthetransferfeeasaconditionoftheclosingandtransferofthefranchise.
d. TrANSFer doCUMeNTATIoN
Thereareprimarilytwowaystotransferafranchisedbusiness,withaccompanyingdocumentation.Thefirstmethodisforthefranchisorandtransfereetosignanewfranchiseagreementunderwhichthetransfereewillbeawardedafullnewtermof5,10,15or20years.Thesecondmethodisforthetransferor,transfereeandfranchisortoexecutean“AssignmentofFranchiseAgreement”.
Theassignmentmethodisoftenusedwhentherearemultipleyearsleftontheoriginalfranchiseagreementorwhenthetransferornegotiatedfavorabletermsinitiallyforhimself,whichwouldcontinuetobeabenefittothetransferee.Afranchisormaysometimespreferthismethodifitdoesnothaveacurrentfranchisedisclosuredocumentorisnotregisteredtosellfranchisesinthestatewherethetransferistakingplace.
Ifthesellingfranchiseehasanoldoroutdatedfranchiseagreement,thefranchisormaywanttohavethetransfereeexecuteacurrentformofagreementtobeconsistentwithnewfranchisesales.Itisimportanttothefranchisortohavethetransferorsignageneralreleasestatingthatnoclaimsordisputesexistfortheperiodthefranchiseagreementwasineffect.Thisbringsclosuretothebusinessrelationshipforbothparties.Onceabuyerisidentifiedandthebusinessterms(e.g.,personalandrealpropertytobetransferred,purchaseprice,financing)arefullynegotiated,thelegalprocess–asbrieflydescribedbelow–canbegin.
(i) DOCUMENTATION
Abuy-sellagreementwillneedtobedraftedbylegalcounsel,whetherthetransferisoftheassetsofthebusiness(includingthefranchiserights)orthestockorpartnershipinterestinthefranchisee.Ifassetswillbesold,itmaybecalledan“AssetPurchaseAgreement.”Ifstockwillbesold,itmightbedescribedasa“StockPurchaseAgreement.”Ineithercase,tomakethedraftingprocessmoreefficient,a“letterofintent”ora“termsheet”initiallywillbepreparedandexecuted,outliningthemainprovisionsoftheparties’agreement.Ineithercase,thedocumentsmustbeincompliancewiththefranchiseagreement.Thetransferorneedstoconfirmwhatisownedbythefranchiseeandwhatisownedbythefranchisorandonlyincludeassetsthataretrulytransferable.
Thebuy-sellagreementwilldescribethepartiestothesale;thespecificassets,stock,orpartnershipintereststobesold;thetimingofthesale;thepurchasepriceandhowandwhenitwillbepaid;anyfinancing;indicationsofwhoisresponsiblefordebtsandliabilities;andothersuchtermsparticulartothesale.Thisisanegotiateddocumentandlegalcounselisusuallyinvolvedinitspreparation.
Franchisetransfersalsotakeplacewhenthereisatransferofassetsfromtheestateofadeceasedorincapacitatedfranchisee.Transfersmayalsooccurwhenanindividualfranchiseepersonallytransferstoanotherlegalentity(e.g.,corporationorlimitedliabilitycompany)whichthefranchiseehasformedforconvenienceofownershiportaxpurposes.Typicallysimplerdocumentationisrequiredininstanceswhereathirdpartyisnotinvolved.
15
IFA Franchise Succession Planning & Transfers Handbook
(ii) CONSENT TO TRANSFER
Thefranchiseagreementwilladdresstransfersbyboththefranchisorandthefranchisee.Forfranchisortransfers,theagreementtypicallywillstatethatthefranchisorisfreetotransferthefranchiseagreementandthatitneednotobtainanyconsentorapprovaltodosofromfranchisees.However,franchiseesarepermittedtotransferonlyiftheyobtainpriorwrittenapprovalfromthefranchisor.Typically,thefranchiseagreementwillstatethatapproval“willnotbeunreasonablywithheld”.Itwouldbeconsideredreasonableforthefranchisortowithholdconsentundercircumstances,suchas:• thesellingfranchiseehasnotpaidalloutstandingmonetaryobligationstothefranchisorand,
insomecases,outsidesuppliers;• thesellingfranchiseeisindefaultunderthefranchiseagreement;• thesellingfranchiseehasnotsignedageneralreleaseofclaims;• thesellingfranchiseehasnotpaidatransferfeetocoverthefranchisor’scostsofthetransfer;• thesellingfranchiseerefusestoacknowledgeitspost-terminationobligationsregarding
confidentialityandnon-competitionandtoremainliableforallpre-transferobligations;• thetermsofthebuy-sellagreementwouldcreateanunduefinancialstrainonthefranchised
businessandplacethebusinessinjeopardy;• thebuyerdoesnotmeetthefranchisor’sfinancial,educational,managerialorother
qualifications;• thebuyerfailstocompletethefranchisor’sinitialtrainingprogram;• ifrequiredbythefranchiseagreement,thebuyerrefusestoupgrade/renovatethepremises
tomeetstandards;• ifrequiredbythefranchiseagreement,thebuyerrefusestosignthecurrentfranchise
agreementortohaveitsprincipal’sguaranteeperformancepersonally.
(iii) APPLICABLE STATE LAWS
Therearesomestatelawsthatapplytotheprocessofobtainingapprovalfromafranchisortotransfer.Theselawsmayrestrictfranchisorsfromwithholdingapprovalofafranchisee’stransferrequest,exceptfor“goodcause.”Thedefinitionof“goodcause”variesfromstatetostate,butgenerallyrequiresfranchisorstoaccepttransfereesthatmeet“reasonable”qualifications.Permissiblegroundsfordisapprovalofatransferundersuchastatelawmayincludesituationswherethetransferee:(1)isacompetitortothefranchisor;(2)refusestoagreetothetermsofthefranchiseagreement;(3)failstocureadefaultbythecurrentfranchiseeundertheexistingfranchiseagreement;(4)wouldhaveanoverly-largeterritoryasaresultofthetransfer;or(5)wouldpayapurchasepricesohighthefranchisorreasonablybelievesitwouldimpairthetransferee’sabilitytogeneratesufficientcashflowtooperatethefranchisedbusinesssuccessfully.Afewstatelawsalsorequireafranchiseetoprovidethefranchisorwithwrittennotice,aswellasinformationconcerningtheproposedtransferee,beforemakingatransfer.
Afranchisors’refusaltoconsenttoatransfercanbechallengedbyafranchiseebaseduponcommonlaw,asdecidedincourtcasesbyjudgesinthejurisdictionprovidedforinthefranchiseagreement.Theprovisionmosttypicallyreferredtoisknownasthe“covenantofgoodfaithandfairdealing.”
16
IFA Franchise Succession Planning & Transfers Handbook
Applicationofacovenantofgoodfaithandfairdealingrequiresacourttodeterminewhetherthefranchisor’swithholdingofconsenttotransferunderthecircumstancespresentedwouldhavebeenreasonablyexpectedbythepartiesatthetimetheyenteredintothefranchiseagreement,regardlessofwhethertheissueisdirectlyaddressedinthefranchiseagreement.Thisfollowstheassumptionthatafranchisormaynotperformactsthatnegativelyaffecttheirfranchisee’sinterest.However,mostcourtshavenotimpliedacovenantofgoodfaithandfairdealingonissuesnotspecificallyreferredtointhefranchiseagreement.
(iv) DISCLOSURE
Whilefranchisesaleslawsrequirefranchisorstoprovidefranchisedisclosuredocuments(FDDs)toprospectivebuyers,inthecaseoftransfersthisobligationcontinuestobetheresponsibilityofthefranchisorandnotthesellingfranchisee.Franchisorsareoftenlegallyobligatedtoprovidesuchdisclosuredocumentstothebuyer,especiallytobuyerswhosignanewfranchiseagreementanddonotassumebyassignmenttheseller’sexistingfranchiseagreement.Tobeabletoprovidesuchdisclosure,thefranchisorneedstohaveacurrentFDDineffect,andalsoinsomestatesmustbecurrentlyregisteredtoofferandsellitsfranchises.
(v) TRANSFER PROCEDURES
Manyfranchisorsdistributetosellingfranchisees“transferpackages,”whichcontaininstructionsontheprocedurestofollowinsellingtheirfranchisebusiness.Thesepackagesprovidestep-by-stepinstructionsandmayincludeformsandstandarddocumentstobeexecuted,suchasanumbrelladocumentcalleda“ConsenttoTransferandReleaseAgreement”.Thisaddressesallofthepresentandfutureobligationsofthepartiesinconnectionwiththetransferandistobesignedbythefranchisor,thetransferor,andthebuyingfranchisees.
Eventhemostdetailedtransferpackages,however,willnotcovereverytypeoftransfer.Transferscanincludeacompletesale,asaleofapartialinterestinthefranchise,atransferondeath,atransfertotheirowncorporationorLLCforconvenience,apublicoffering,orotherwise.Eachwillpresentuniquefeaturestobeaddressedintheprocessanddocumentation.
Thedescriptionsaboveprovideageneralsenseofwhatwillberequiredformanytransfers.Thereisno“one-size-fits-all,”andeachtransactionisdifferent,sothat–fromboththebusinessandlegalperspectives–carefulplanningandacustomizedapproachwilloftenbenecessary.Forlegalissues,theadviceofanattorneywhohasexperiencewithfranchisetransferswillbevaluable.
17
IFA Franchise Succession Planning & Transfers Handbook
e. TrAINING ANd oPerATIoNAL SUPPorT For TrANSFereeS
(i) DIFFERENCES COMPARED TO A NEW FRANCHISEE
Insomerespects,thefranchisor’sjobissignificantlyeasierwithatransferee.Muchofthestart-upsupportthatwouldbeprovidedtoanewfranchiseemaybeunnecessary,asthetransfereewillbetakingoverafullystaffedandoperationalbusiness.Insite-specificbusinesses,forexample,thefranchisorisrelievedofprovidingtrainingandsupportintheareasofsiteselection,leasenegotiation,architecturalplanning,interiordesign,andconstruction.Typically,transfereesareenteringanestablishedbusinessoperation,whichwilloftenhaveexistingmanagementandstaffinplace,thehiringprocesswillhavebeencompletedandtheemployeestrained.
Thefranchisordoesfacesomeuniqueopportunitiesandchallengeswhenprovidingtrainingandoperationalsupporttotransfereeswhoarebecomingfranchisees.
Ifthetransferredfranchisewaswellrunpriortothetransfer,thegoalofasuccessfultransfermaybetoprovideaseamlesstransitionbetweenfranchiseeandtransferee,maintainingthehighstandardssetbytheoriginalfranchisee.Thismayhaveimplicationsrelativetothenewfranchiseeadjustingtoanestablishedcultureamongtheemployeesattheunitlevel.Theremaybeaneedtohelptheemployeesadapttochangesinownershipandadifferentcultureandenvironment.
Conversely,whenthepreviousfranchiseewasaless-than-stellarorunsuccessfuloperator,thechallengebecomesoneofinstitutingincrementalimprovementtotheexistingoperation.Insomecases,improvementcanbeattainedgraduallyuntilanoperationisoperatingatorabovesystemstandards.Inothercases,moreradicalchangesmaybenecessary.
(ii) COMPLIANCE REVIEW AT TRANSFER
Atthesametime,manyfranchisorslookatatransitionwithanewfranchiseeasanopportunitytoimproveaunittomeetcurrentsystemstandards.AchangeoffranchiseeownershipmayinvokeprovisionsintheFranchiseAgreementforremodelingandupgradesindécor,equipment,signage,newPOSsystems,orinstitutingchangesinoperatingprocedurestothecurrentsystemstandards.
Inthiscase,thefranchisorandthetransfereecanlookatatransferasanopportunitytoimproveboththeirlocationandthesystemasawhole.(iii) INITIAL TRAINING PROGRAMS
Whenanestablishedunitisupandoperatingwithexperiencedpersonnel,theremaybeatemptationonthepartofsomefranchisorsandfranchiseestoskiportominimizethetransferee’sneedforinitialtraining.Andwhileshorteningoreliminatingtrainingmightbepossible,thereareanumberofreasonswhythetransfereeshouldberequiredtoandwanttocompletethesametrainingprogramasanewstart-upfranchisee.
18
IFA Franchise Succession Planning & Transfers Handbook
Thefirstreasonisimprovedqualitycontroltomeetcurrentoperatingstandards.Thetransferprocessallowsthefranchisortheopportunitytoidentifyandbreakbadhabitsandtocorrectnon-standardactivitiesthatunit-levelpersonnelmayhavedevelopedunderthepreviousfranchisee.Thistrainingwillhelpstrengthenthesystemforboththefranchisorandfranchisee.Thereisalsothepossibilitythatthenewfranchiseewillnotpasstraining–anditwillbebettertodeterminethisinadvancebeforethenewfranchiseeisintheunitoperatingit.
Asecondreasonrelatestolegalissues.Oneadvantagetothefranchiserelationshipisthatthefranchisorcanreducetheriskofliabilityfortheactsoftheirfranchisees.Ifafranchisorfailstoprovideadequatetrainingonanissuerelativetosafetyorotheroperatingpolicies,afranchisee’sactionsmaycreatethistypeofliabilityforafranchisor.
Forexample,afranchiseethatisnottrainedintheareaofsexualharassmentmightunwittinglycreateliabilitybothforitselfandforthefranchisorbysteppingoverthelinewithanemployeetocreateaharassmentcharge.Ifproperlytrainedandtestedbythefranchisorconcerningsexualharassmentissues,thatfranchiseeinthesamesituationmightavoidcreatingaproblemwithsignificantliabilitypotential.
Onefinalreasonforfullandcompletetrainingofatransferfranchiseeisthatthisprocessprovidesanopportunityforthefranchisoranditsstafftodeveloparelationshipwiththenewfranchisee.Asidefromtheabilitytomakeadeterminationastothefranchisee’scompetenceinoperations,thetrainingexperienceisa“once-in-a-relationship”opportunityforbondingwiththefranchisorandisanopportunityforthefranchisortoexplain“whywedoitlikethat.”
(iv) ON-SITE VISITATIONS
Inmanyfranchisesystems,thefrequencyofon-sitevisitationsbyfranchiseserviceconsultantsinthefielddecreasesovertime,asthefranchiseegrowsmoreandmorecompetentandexperiencedintheoperationofthefranchise.Whenanewfranchisetransfereetakesoveranestablishedoperation,thefranchisormaycontinuewiththepreviouslyestablishedfieldvisitfrequencyappropriateforanexperiencedfranchisee,insteadofthevisitfrequencyofanewfranchisee.
Itismoreappropriateinthefirstweeksfollowingatransfertovisitatransfereeatleastasfrequentlyasthefranchisorwouldvisitanewstart-upoperator.Insomecases,thevisitsshouldbemorefrequent.Whilethetransfereemayhaveanumberofadvantagesoverthestart-upoperatorfromthestandpointofexistingtrainedstaffandanestablishedcustomerbase,inthefirstweeksofoperationtheinexperiencedtransfereewithlittleornotrainingcanpermanentlydamageyearsofgoodwillbuiltupbythepreviousfranchiseethroughtheirerrorsandoperatingmistakes.Theinitialvisitsbyfranchisorfieldrepresentativesoftenfocusonpersonnelandmoraleissues,aswellasonoperationalissues.
(v) HOW TO GET NEW TRANSFEREES UP-TO-SPEED OPERATIONALLY
Manyfranchisesystemsrequirethetransferee’sinitialtrainingtobecompletedbeforethetransferisfinalizedasitisthecriticalelementinbringingtransfereesup-to-speedintheirnewbusiness.Asindicatedabove,itisstronglyadvisedthattransfereesattendthefulltrainingprogramofferedtonewstart-upoperators.
19
IFA Franchise Succession Planning & Transfers Handbook
Ifthetransfereeisbringinginanewmanagertooverseeday-to-dayoperations,thatindividualshouldalsocompletethefranchisor’sentirepre-openinginitialtrainingprogram.Ifthepriorfranchisee’smanagementstaffisgoingtoremaininthebusinessandreporttothenewfranchisee,itisoftenusefultohavethesekeymanagersalsoattendrefreshertrainingconductedbythefranchisor.
Thisisparticularlyimportantiftheoperationsoftheoriginalownerwerenotmaintainedaccordingtothefranchisor’ssystemstandards.Suchtrainingwillnotonlyensurethemanagersarefamiliarwithcurrentproceduresinusethroughoutthesystem,butitwillalsohelptocreatenewenthusiasmfortheirroleinthebusiness.Anaddedbenefitofthenewfranchiseeandtheformerfranchisee’smanagersattendingtrainingtogetheristhattheywillbegindevelopingtheirownpersonalnetworkingrelationshipinapositiveenvironmentawayfromthebusinesslocation.
Anotherstrategytohelpimprovethetransferee’soperationalperformanceandresults,whenappropriate,istoconducton-sitetrainingattheirlocationimmediatelyfollowingtheirsuccessfulcompletionofheadquarterstraining.Althoughmostfranchisesystemsprovideon-sitetrainingtonewstart-upoperators,manydonotprovidesimilar(orasextensive)trainingtotransfereesattheirlocation.Athoroughon-sitetrainingcomponentfortransfereeswillenablethefranchisorto:• Observetheperformanceofthetransfereeintheirnewbusinessandidentifyanyissueswhich
needfurtherattention;• Assistthetransfereeandtheirstafftoimplementcurrentoperationsstandards,introducedat
thetimeofthetransfer;• Identifyandcorrectanyoperationaldeficienciesthatmightexistatthelocation;• Providetrainingasneededforunitco-workersandemployees;and• Followingon-sitetrainingatthetransferee’slocation,thefranchisorcanidentifyanyremaining
operationsissuesthatneedtobeaddressed,anddevelopanactionplanwiththetransfereeforresolvingthem.
(vi) MENTOR PROGRAMS
Manyfranchisesystemshaveestablishedmentorprogramstofacilitatethesuccessfultransitionofanexistingfranchisedlocationtoanewoperator.Additionally,amentorshipprogramisavailablethroughtheFranchiseRelationsCommitteeoftheInternationalFranchiseAssociation.Inatypicalmentorprogram,atransfereewillbeassignedtoanexistingexperiencedoperatorpriortotheirassumingday-to-daymanagementresponsibilitiesoftheirnewbusiness.Theextentofthementoringprocesscanrangefromanexperiencedoperatorsimplybeingavailableasneededtoanswerquestionsonthetelephone,toamoredirectroleofmeetingwiththetransfereeorhelpingthemwithoperationsissuesattheirfranchisedlocation.
Keyelementsofasuccessfulmentoringprogramincludethefollowing:• Onlyfranchiseesthatareoperatingatorabovethefranchisor’sstandardsshouldbepermitted
tofulfillamentoringrole;• Ideally,mentorswillbelocatedwithinthesamecityorregionasthetransferee.Thislocal
connectionwillenablethementortobestunderstandtheneedsofthetransferee,andbeavailableifneededtomeetwiththefranchisee;and
• Althoughthefranchisorshouldhavesomeinputintothementoringprogram(e.g.,whichfranchiseesareapprovedtobementors),franchiseesshouldbeverymuchinvolvedindevelopingandmanagingthementoringprocess.Amentoringprogrammusthavethefullsupportoffranchiseestosucceed.
20
IFA Franchise Succession Planning & Transfers Handbook
Successfulmentorprogramswillnotonlybenefitthetransferee,butwillalsobenefittheexistingfranchiseesthatparticipateasmentors.Throughthementoringprocess,existingfranchiseeswilldeveloprelationshipswithnewoperatorsinthesystemmorequickly.Theybegintodevelopdialoguewithintheirregiononissuessuchasbestpractices,cooperativemarketingandothertopicsrelatedtothegrowthoftheirrespectivebusinesses.
F. CoNCLUSIoN
Whiletransfersarenotalwaysgoingtobecookie-cuttercasesorfollowthetransferpolicyperfectly,itiscriticaltothefranchisesystemforthefranchisortohaveadetailedtransferpolicyineffectsothatallpartiesareonanevenplayingfieldandfewerdisputeswillresult.
Formanysuccessfulbusinesspersons,fromdayonetheirbusinessis“ForSale”.Thisdoesn’tmeanthatmillionairebusinessownershangupa“ForSale’signnexttothe“GrandOpening”sign.Itdoesmeanthatmanysuccessfulbusinessownershavetwobusinessplansintheirheads,ifnotonpaper.
Thefirstbusinessplancovershowtobuildasuccessfulbusiness.Thesecondplanshowsthebusinessownerhowtomaximizehisreturnoninvestmentwhenhewantstosellhissuccessfulbusiness.Theirsecondtypeofbusinessplanisconsideredanexitstrategy.n
21
INTerNATIoNAL FrANCHISe ASSoCIATIoN
1501KStreet,NW,Suite350Washington,DC20005USATel:+12026288000www.franchise.org