Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k'...

60
Philosophiae Doctor (PhD) Thesis 2018:1 Walid Fayez Mustapha Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials and interactions with the forest industries and the energy sector Skogsbasert biodrivstoff i Norden: Potensialer og samspill med skogindustrien og energisektoren Norwegian University of Life Sciences Faculty of Environmental Sciences and Natural Resource Management

Transcript of Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k'...

Page 1: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo

Philosophiae Doctor (PhD)Thesis 2018:1

Walid Fayez Mustapha

Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries:Potentials and interactions with the forest industries andthe energy sector

Skogsbasert biodrivstoff i Norden:Potensialer og samspill med skogindustrien og energisektoren

Norwegian University of Life Sciences Faculty of Environmental Sciences and Natural Resource Management

Page 2: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 3: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 4: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 5: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo

They say a PhD teaches you how to think. It turns out they were right.

Only now, in retrospect, am I able to appreciate their saying. Because up until this very moment, I was busy thinking about my PhD.

Walid Fayez Mustapha

Page 6: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 7: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 8: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 9: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo

Journal of Environmental Management

Energy Conversion and Management

Forest Policy and Economics

Energy

Page 10: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 11: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 12: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 13: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo

Synopsis

Page 14: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 15: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 16: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 17: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 18: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 19: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 20: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 21: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo

1. Is it best to store biomass in the biosphere or substitute fossil fuels and fossil intensive

materials for climate change mitigation in the short and long-term?

2. Are future forest-based conversion pathways for biofuel production cost-competitive?

3. Which Nordic countries and regions are most attractive for large-scale forest-based biofuel

facility deployment and how does regional deployment change with changing

technologies?

Page 22: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo

4. How will biofuel facilities interact with the existing forest dependent industries given large-

scale deployment?

5. How will large-scale biofuel facility deployment affect the heat and power technology mix?

question one

question two question four question three

question four question five

Page 23: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 24: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 25: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 26: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo

Biomass Products

Page 27: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 28: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 29: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 30: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 31: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo

P. maximowiczii P. trichocarpa

Page 32: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 33: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 34: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 35: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 36: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 37: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 38: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 39: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 40: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 41: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 42: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 43: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 44: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 45: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 46: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 47: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo

spatial partial

Page 48: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 49: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 50: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 51: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 52: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 53: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 54: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 55: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 56: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 57: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo

Paper I Taeroe, A., Mustapha, W.F., Stupak, I. & Raulund-Rasmussen, K. 2017. Do forests best mitigate CO2 emissions to the atmosphere by setting them aside for maximization of carbon storage or by management for fossil fuel substitution? - Journal of Environmental Management 197: 117-129. DOI: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2017.03.051

Paper II Mustapha, W.F., Bolkesjø, T.F., Martinsen, T. & Trømborg, E. 2017. Techno-economic comparison of promising biofuel conversion pathways in a Nordic context – Effects of feedstock costs and technology learning. - Energy Conversion and Management 149: 368-380. DOI: 10.1016/j.enconman.2017.07.004

Paper III Mustapha, W.F., Trømborg, E. & Bolkesjø, T.F. (Online first 2017) Forest-based biofuel production in the Nordic countries: Modelling of optimal allocation. - Forest Policy and Economics. DOI: 10.1016/j.forpol.2017.07.004

Paper IV Mustapha, W.F., Kirkerud, J.G., Trømborg, E. & Bolkesjø, T.F. Hard-Linking of a Forest Sector Model to an Energy Systems Model - Effects of Large-Scale Forest-Based Biofuel Facility Deployment and Carbon Prices on the Technology Mix in the Nordic Energy Sector.- Energy. (Submitted)

Page 58: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 59: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo
Page 60: Forest-based biofuels in the Nordic countries: Potentials ... · cv 7khvlv qxpehu ,661 ,6%1 ll 3k' vxshuylvruv 3urihvvru (uln 7u¡peruj )dfxow\ ri (qylurqphqwdo 6flhqfhv dqg 1dwxudo

ISBN: 978-82-575-1477-8 ISSN: 1894-6402

Postboks 5003 NO-1432 Ås, Norway+47 67 23 00 00www.nmbu.no