Forensic Accounting Fin
Transcript of Forensic Accounting Fin
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
1/33
Forensic Accounting:Forensic Accounting:
An IntroductionAn Introduction
AshwiniAshwini KumarKumar
Director, CBIDirector, CBI
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
2/33
22
OverviewOverview
What is Forensic Accounting?What is Forensic Accounting?
What is fraud?What is fraud?
Who commits fraud?Who commits fraud?
How do forensic accountants search forHow do forensic accountants search forfraud?fraud?
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
3/33
What is Forensic AccountingWhat is Forensic Accounting
Focus is:Focus is: the evidencethe evidence of economic transactions andof economic transactions and
reportingreporting
the legal framework which allows suchthe legal framework which allows suchevidence to be suitable to the purpose(s) ofevidence to be suitable to the purpose(s) ofestablishing accountability and/orvaluationestablishing accountability and/orvaluation
In other words:In other words: the identification, interpretation, andthe identification, interpretation, and
communication of the evidence ofcommunication of the evidence ofeconomic transaction and reporting eventseconomic transaction and reporting events
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
4/33
What is Forensic AccountingWhat is Forensic Accounting
often mistakenly assumed to beoften mistakenly assumed to beexclusively associated with "negative"exclusively associated with "negative"
applications, such as bankruptcy, fraud,applications, such as bankruptcy, fraud,business disputes, or matrimonial divorce.business disputes, or matrimonial divorce.
may also be applied in "positive"may also be applied in "positive"assurance engagements such as dueassurance engagements such as due
diligence reviews, business valuations,diligence reviews, business valuations,audit committee advisory services andaudit committee advisory services andenterprise risk management.enterprise risk management.
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
5/33
What is Forensic AccountingWhat is Forensic Accounting
Forensic accounting is applied to theForensic accounting is applied to theevidence of first order activities, notevidence of first order activities, notsecondary systems of controls.secondary systems of controls.
Analysis includes the crucial aspect ofAnalysis includes the crucial aspect ofrecognizing the implications of evidencerecognizing the implications of evidencethat has been obtained.that has been obtained.
Additional protocol extensions areAdditional protocol extensions areemployed to forecast or predict futureemployed to forecast or predict futureconditions based on known pastconditions based on known pasttransactions or events.transactions or events.
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
6/33
66
What is Forensic Accounting?What is Forensic Accounting?
Forensic accounting is the practice ofForensic accounting is the practice ofutilizing accounting, auditing, andutilizing accounting, auditing, and
inv
estigativ
e skills to determine whetherinv
estigativ
e skills to determine whetherfraud has occurred.fraud has occurred.
It encompasses two main areas:It encompasses two main areas:
Litigation supportLitigation support
InvestigationInvestigation
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
7/33
77
Litigation SupportLitigation Support
Is the factual presentation of economicIs the factual presentation of economicissues related to existing or pendingissues related to existing or pendinglitigation.litigation.
The forensic accountant quantifiesThe forensic accountant quantifiesdamages sustained by parties involved indamages sustained by parties involved in
legal disputes and assists in resolvinglegal disputes and assists in resolvingdisputes, even before they reach thedisputes, even before they reach thecourtroom.courtroom.
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
8/33
88
Litigation SupportLitigation Support
Arbitration assistanceArbitration assistance
Business valuation for divorce, stockholder disputesBusiness valuation for divorce, stockholder disputes
Computation of damages resulting from personalComputation of damages resulting from personal
injuries, wrongful death, breach of contract, casualty,injuries, wrongful death, breach of contract, casualty,and fidelity lossesand fidelity losses
Determination of lost profits due to business interruptionDetermination of lost profits due to business interruption
Testifying as an expert witnessTestifying as an expert witness
Financial review of contractual obligationsFinancial review of contractual obligationsInvestigative services related to fraud and other illegalInvestigative services related to fraud and other illegal
actsacts
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
9/33
99
InvestigationInvestigation
Is the act of determining whether criminalIs the act of determining whether criminalmatters such as employee theft, securitiesmatters such as employee theft, securitiesfraud (including falsification of financialfraud (including falsification of financialstatements), and insurance fraud havestatements), and insurance fraud haveoccurred.occurred.
Also includes searching for irregularitiesAlso includes searching for irregularities
associated with civil matters, such as aassociated with civil matters, such as asearch for hidden assets in divorce cases.search for hidden assets in divorce cases.
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
10/33
1010
What is Fraud?What is Fraud?
Fraud is an intentional misrepresentation
of a material point or issue on which avictim relies.
This reliance usually results in one or
more victims suffering damages.
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
11/33
1111
Types of FraudTypes of Fraud
OccupationalOccupational
Financial statement schemesFinancial statement schemes
Asset misappropriation (e.g., cash theft,Asset misappropriation (e.g., cash theft,fraudulent disbursements, inventory theft)fraudulent disbursements, inventory theft)
Bribery and corruptionBribery and corruption
Intellectual propertyIntellectual property
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
12/33
1212
Types of FraudTypes of Fraud
Other FraudsOther Frauds Financial institutionFinancial institution
Check and credit card fraudCheck and credit card fraud
Insurance fraudInsurance fraud
Health care fraudHealth care fraud
Bankruptcy fraudBankruptcy fraud
Tax fraudTax fraud
Securities fraudSecurities fraud
Money launderingMoney laundering
Consumer fraudConsumer fraud
Computer and Internet fraudComputer and Internet fraud
Governmental fraudGovernmental fraud
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
13/33
1313
Examples of FraudExamples of FraudFinancial Statement SchemesFinancial Statement Schemes
A publiclyA publicly--traded company engaged intraded company engaged insham transactions for more than sevensham transactions for more than sevenyears by using several shell companies.years by using several shell companies.The money transferred to the shellThe money transferred to the shellcompanies as payments for assets werecompanies as payments for assets werereturned as payments on accountsreturned as payments on accounts
receivable. The companys assets werereceivable. The companys assets wereinflated by as much as $80 million.inflated by as much as $80 million.
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
14/33
1414
Examples of FraudExamples of FraudAsset MisappropriationAsset Misappropriation
A CEO conspired with a former employeeA CEO conspired with a former employeeto sell a building to a company owned byto sell a building to a company owned bythe CEOs employer. The building wasthe CEOs employer. The building wassold for $1.2 million more than it had beensold for $1.2 million more than it had beenpurchased by the former employee. Allpurchased by the former employee. Alltransactions occurred on the same day.transactions occurred on the same day.
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
15/33
1515
Examples of FraudExamples of FraudHealth Care FraudHealth Care Fraud
Dr. X billed a patients insurance for the followingDr. X billed a patients insurance for the followingactivities:activities:
Knee arthroscopy with debridementKnee arthroscopy with debridement$1,650$1,650
Diagnostic knee arthroscopyDiagnostic knee arthroscopy 1,6251,625
Total billedTotal billed $3,275$3,275
The second procedure listed above isThe second procedure listed above is
included in the first procedure. Therefore, theincluded in the first procedure. Therefore, thecorrect amount of the bill is $1,650.correct amount of the bill is $1,650.
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
16/33
1616
Examples of FraudExamples of Fraud
Divorce FraudDivorce Fraud
John Dewey is the majority owner of a largeJohn Dewey is the majority owner of a largepublic relations firm. His wife, Mary, recentlypublic relations firm. His wife, Mary, recentlyfiled for divorce and is asking for half Johnsfiled for divorce and is asking for half Johns
assets. Prior to being served, John took someassets. Prior to being served, John took sometrips to the Cayman Islands and Switzerland.trips to the Cayman Islands and Switzerland.
During the divorce proceedings, Mary wasDuring the divorce proceedings, Mary wasshocked to learn that the value of the firm isshocked to learn that the value of the firm is$50,000. Prior to the divorce, John had given$50,000. Prior to the divorce, John had given
her $200,000 a year to cover their personalher $200,000 a year to cover their personalexpenses.expenses.
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
17/33
1717
Examples of FraudExamples of Fraud
Vendor Fraud: Defectiv
e Deliv
eryVendor Fraud: Defectiv
e Deliv
eryThe low bidder was awarded a contract toThe low bidder was awarded a contract topave a parking lot. Upon examination,pave a parking lot. Upon examination,several randomlyseveral randomly--taken core samplestaken core samplesrevealed 2 of paving whereas the contractrevealed 2 of paving whereas the contractspecified 4. Also, the parking lot had notspecified 4. Also, the parking lot had notbeen sealed as required by the contract.been sealed as required by the contract.
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
18/33
1818
Why is Fraud Committed?Why is Fraud Committed?
The Fraud TriangleThe Fraud Triangle
perceived pressure, perceived opportunities, andperceived pressure, perceived opportunities, and
rationalizationrationalization
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
19/33
1919
Perceived PressurePerceived Pressure
Employees, managers, and owners can feelEmployees, managers, and owners can feelpressure to commit fraud as a result ofpressure to commit fraud as a result of
Greed or preoccupation with being successfulGreed or preoccupation with being successful Living beyond meansLiving beyond means High personal debtsHigh personal debts Unexpected financial needsUnexpected financial needs
Expensive vicesExpensive vices FamilyFamily--imposed pressuresimposed pressures
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
20/33
2020
Perceived OpportunitiesPerceived Opportunities
Opportunities to commit fraud exist whenOpportunities to commit fraud exist whenlevels of trust in an organization are reachedlevels of trust in an organization are reachedor when controls are weak.or when controls are weak.
Inappropriate segregation of dutiesInappropriate segregation of duties Ineffective supervisionIneffective supervision Transaction authorization not requiredTransaction authorization not required
Lack of physical controlsLack of physical controls Lack of adequate audit trailLack of adequate audit trail
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
21/33
2121
RationalizationRationalization
Individuals usually dont commit fraud unlessIndividuals usually dont commit fraud unlessthey can justify their actions in relation tothey can justify their actions in relation totheir own code of ethics.their own code of ethics.
Feeling underpaid or overworkedFeeling underpaid or overworked Desire to seek revengeDesire to seek revenge Belief that taking the assets is a loanBelief that taking the assets is a loan
Belief they are helping others (family,Belief they are helping others (family,employees)employees)
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
22/33
2222
How do Forensic AccountantsHow do Forensic Accountants
Search for Fraud?Search for Fraud?
Proactive fraud detectionProactive fraud detection
Reactive fraud detectionReactive fraud detection
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
23/33
2323
Proactive Fraud DetectionProactive Fraud Detection
Inductive approachesInductive approaches
Use of DataUse of Data--mining softwaremining software
Digital analysis of company dataDigital analysis of company dataDeductive approachDeductive approach
Determine what kinds of frauds canDetermine what kinds of frauds can
occur. Search for symptoms ofoccur. Search for symptoms ofthese frauds.these frauds.
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
24/33
2424
DataData--mining Softwaremining Software
ExcelExcel
ACLACL
IDEAIDEAMicrosoft AccessMicrosoft Access
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
25/33
2525
Digital Analysis of Company DataDigital Analysis of Company DataBenfords Law (first digit frequency)Benfords Law (first digit frequency)
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Per ent
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
26/33
2626
Deductive ApproachDeductive Approachto Detecting Fraudto Detecting Fraud
Involves a 5Involves a 5--step process:step process:
Understanding the business environmentUnderstanding the business environment
Understanding the kinds of fraud that can occurUnderstanding the kinds of fraud that can occur
in this environmentin this environment Determining the most likely symptomsDetermining the most likely symptoms
Using databases and systems to search for theUsing databases and systems to search for thefraud symptomsfraud symptoms
Following up on discoveries to determineFollowing up on discoveries to determinelikelihood fraud existslikelihood fraud exists
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
27/33
2727
Reactive Fraud DetectionReactive Fraud Detection
Fraud accountants are often engaged afterFraud accountants are often engaged aftersomeone in the entity suspects that fraudsomeone in the entity suspects that fraudhas been committed.has been committed.
Usually the area in which fraud has beenUsually the area in which fraud has beencommitted is known. Often, the entirecommitted is known. Often, the entirearea is examined.area is examined.
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
28/33
2828
Evidence CategoriesEvidence Categories
TestimonialTestimonial
EvidenceEvidence
DocumentaryDocumentary
EvidenceEvidence
PhysicalPhysicalEvidenceEvidence PersonalPersonalObservationObservation
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
29/33
2929
Testimonial EvidenceTestimonial Evidence
InterviewingInterviewing
Interrogatories (written questions that identifyInterrogatories (written questions that identifyinformation needed from opposing party)information needed from opposing party)
Honesty tests (e.g., graphology, polygraph)Honesty tests (e.g., graphology, polygraph)
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
30/33
3030
Documentary EvidenceDocumentary Evidence
Document examinationDocument examination
Public records searchesPublic records searches
AuditsAuditsComputer searchesComputer searches
Net worth calculationsNet worth calculations
Financial statement analysisFinancial statement analysis
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
31/33
3131
Physical EvidencePhysical Evidence
FingerprintsFingerprints
Tire marksTire marks
WeaponsWeaponsStolen propertyStolen property
Identification numbers or markings onIdentification numbers or markings on
stolen objectsstolen objects
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
32/33
3232
Personal ObservationPersonal Observation
InvigilationInvigilation
SurveillanceSurveillanceCovert operationsCovert operations
-
8/8/2019 Forensic Accounting Fin
33/33
3333
Thank you!Thank you!