Foreign Aid and International Norms: The Case of North Korea

download Foreign Aid and International Norms: The Case of North Korea

of 19

Transcript of Foreign Aid and International Norms: The Case of North Korea

  • 8/3/2019 Foreign Aid and International Norms: The Case of North Korea

    1/19

    N AOV @A]OYAN]@LANK OAFNFOEOA]

    DYNEOVLYH DLY ALY]C HLYON

  • 8/3/2019 Foreign Aid and International Norms: The Case of North Korea

    2/19

    t

    Bla}oa}r

    Wyodnbo nam Nbhalvkomfeoa}r t``

    Al}o la Aneor s

    > @a}ylmub}`la nam Ltoyt`ov 2

    Nca Bcllaf%plaf+ A`bclknr Oioyr}nm}+ nam Koo Pluaf%rua

    ]co Wlk`}`bnk Oblalep ld Aly}c Hlyon

    9 ]co Wlk`}`bnk Oblalep ld Aly}c Hlyon: >6C`r}ly`bnk Inbhfyluam nam Wyoroa} R`}un}`la

    Enybur Alknam

    2 ]co R}yub}uyo ld Aly}c Hlyonr Wlk`}`bnk Oblalep: =?Bcnafor nam Oddob}r

    Koo Pluaf%rua nam Plla Molh%yplaf= Aly}c Hlyonr Ruyt`tnk Fneo: 42

    _amoyr}nam`af }co Yoboa} Wnr}+ ]c`ah`af nilu} }co Du}uyoA`bclknr Oioyr}nm}

    Wyoblam`}`lar nam Yn}`lanko dly @a}oyan}`lank Oblale`b

    Ruwwly} dly Aly}c Hlyon

    ? Enanf`af Blkkn}oynk Bn}nr}ylwco: Yn}`lanko nam Wyoblam`}`lar >>6

    dly @a}oyan}`lank Oblale`b Ruwwly} dly Aly}c HlyonElla Bcuaf%`a

    4 R}yn}of`b M`eoar`lar ld Oblale`b Nrr`r}nabo dly Aly}c Hlyon >=6Wnuk Iynbhoa

    6 Dlyo`fa N`m nam @a}oyan}`lank Alyer: >?0]co Bnro ld Aly}c Hlyon

    Bnylk Knabnr}oy

  • 8/3/2019 Foreign Aid and International Norms: The Case of North Korea

    3/19

    3 Wylrwob}r nam Wyoblam`}`lar dly Enyho} Oblale`b >6?]ynardlyen}`la a Aly}c Hlyon

    Namoyr rkuam

    Wlrr`iko Dlyer ld @a}oyan}`lank Bllwoyn}`la nam

    Nrr`r}nabo }l Aly}c Hlyon

    0 _ak`hokp Wny}aoyr: >00Cuena`}ny`na N`m Nfoab`or nam Aly}c Hlyon

    Omvnym W! Yoom

    >7 Mor`fa`af Wuik`b Rob}ly Bnw }nk Eli`k zn}`la R}yn}of`or dly }co MWYH 92>Iynmkop L! Inirla

    >> Blw`af v`}c Aly}c Hlyonr Oaoyfp Du}uyo: HOML nam Ioplam 9?6Hoa} O! Bnkmoy

    >9 Eli`k`z`af Wy`tn}o Bnw`}nk dly Aly}c Hlyon: 96?Yo~u`yoeoa}r dly N}}ynb}`af Wy`tn}o @ator}eoa}

    Enkblke I`ahr nam Bnyk Nmner

    Wlrr`iko Ylko ld Rlu}c Hlyon nam L}coy Enjly R}nhoclkmoyr

    >2 N Wylnb}`to Nwwylnbc }l Oafnf`af Aly}c Hlyon: 90?Ilkmaorr+ Dkos`i`k`}p+ nam @abkur`toaorr

    Bcll Plaf%rc`h nam Vnaf Pua%jlaf

    >= Wnpinbh ]`eo: JnwnaAly}c Hlyon Oblale`b Yokn}`lar 2>6Y`bcnym J! Rneuokr

    >? Bc`anr Ylko a }co Bluyro ld Aly}c Hlyonr ]ynar`}`la 22?K`u E`af

    >4 Yurr`na%Aly}c Hlyona Yokn}`lar nam }co Wylrwob}r dly 2?>Euk}`kn}oynk Bladk b} Yorlku}`la la }co Hlyona Woa`arukn

    Nkosnamyo P! Enarluylt

    >6 Oswob}om Ylko ld Rlu}c Hlyon nam Enjly R}nhoclkmoyr: 246AFL Bla}y`iu}`lar }l nam Ylkor `a Aly}c Hlyonr Yocni`k`}n}`la

    Rbl}} Rapmoy

  • 8/3/2019 Foreign Aid and International Norms: The Case of North Korea

    4/19

    >?0

    Rclukm }co _a`}om R}n}or ly l}coy fltoyaeoa}r #ly `a}oyan}`lank lyfna`%zn}`lar) wylt`mo dlyo`fa n`m }l }co fltoyaeoa} ld }co Moelbyn}`b WolwkorYowuik`b ld Hlyon #MWYH)< Aly}c Hlyon `r na os}yoeokp wlly blua}yp v`}cwoy`lm`b ilu}r ld rotoyo dne`ao nam v`morwyonm cuena ruddoy`af! Iu} `} `r

    fltoyaom ip vcn} `r nyfunikp }co elr} yowyorr`to nam robyo}`to fltoyaeoa}`a }co vlykm v`}c lao ld }co elr} e`renanfom oblale`or nam+ morw`}o `}r

    wltoy}p+ lao ld }co knyfor} oswoam`}uyor la `}r e`k`}nyp yokn}`to }l }co r`zo ld`}r fylrr an}`lank wylmub} ld nap blua}yp la }co dnbo ld }co Ony}c! Vcn} `r }lio mlao0=7r+ }cn} kom }co _a`}om R}n}or }l iof`a }lwylt`mo r`fa`d`bna} nam rur}n`aom dklvr ld dlyo`fa n`m }l fltoyaeoa}r uamoy`a}oyank ly os}oyank wyorruyor ly }cyon}r dyle bleeua`r} wny}`or+ ynm`bnk `a%

    ruyfoa}r+ }co _RRY+ }co Wolwkor Yowuik`b ld Bc`an+ ly }co`y nkk`or! N`m }lr}ni`k`zo nam fylv oblale`or rlla iobneo n`m }l duy}coy }co`y motoklweoa}+urom nr n eonar }l }co oam ld bla}n`a`af bleeua`re!

    Ip }co >047r+ elr} Ouylwona fltoyaeoa}r nam Jnwna+ alv yobltoyom dyleVlykm Vny @@+ or}nik`rcom }co`y lva n`m wylfyner+ ld}oa v`}c bleeoyb`nk nrvokk nr motoklweoa} wuywlror!9 Bleeoyb`nk wuywlror }oamom }l io roblam%

    nyp a elr} n`m%f`t`af blua}y`or nam voyo fynmunkkp blar}yn`aom ip motoklw%eoa} flnkr nam `a}oyan}`lank nfyooeoa}r la rubc }c`afr nr }co nelua} ld}`om n`m nam }co uro ld n`m a e`som byom`} nyynafoeoa}r! ]cur+ ip }co oam ld

    }co }voa}`o}c boa}uyp+ dlyo`fa n`m vnr wylt`mom dly }cyoo wy`ab`wnk yonrlar:

    ]l yok`oto cuena ruddoy`af bnurom ip an}uynk ly ena%enmo m`rnr}oyr8

    > ]co MNB vlukm wyodoy }co motoklweoa} nam vokdnyo wuywlro nr }co en`a wuywlro+ iu} n`m%f`t`affltoyaeoa}r }oam }l e`s }co`y wuywlror+ enh`af }c`r yo~u`yoeoa} }ll osnb}`af nam m`dd`buk} }l mo}oy%e`ao! ]co mor`fan}`la ld n motoklw`af blua}yp r }cn} } cnm na ntoynfo woy bnw`}n ableo ld korr }cna-0+247 `a >003 #n Vlykm Inah ioabcenyh)!

    9 Bleeoyb`nk wuywlror `abkumom robuy`af aoomom ynv en}oy`nkr `ewly}r nam oswnam`af oswly}enyho}r!

  • 8/3/2019 Foreign Aid and International Norms: The Case of North Korea

    6/19

    Dlyo`fa N`m nam @a}oyan}`lank Alyer: ]co Bnro ld Aly}c Hlyon >4>

    ]l ruwwly} oblale`b nam rlb`nk wylfyorr `a motoklw`af blua}y`or #nam+

    v`}c }co oam ld }co Blkm Vny+ dlyeoy rlb`nk`r} iklb blua}y`or)8 nam

    Dly an}`lank robuy }p nam `a}oyan}`lank wlk`} bnk wuywlror!2

    ]coro }cyoo flnkr ld n`m f`t`af cnto foaoyn}om ro}r ld v`mokp rcnyom `a}oy%an}`lank alyer yofnym`af }co blam`}`lar uamoy vc`bc n`m `r wylt`mom!

    Alyer: Oeoyfoabp Yok`od

    Dluy en`a alyer cnto bleo }l fu`mo `a}oyan}`lank cuena`}ny`na n`m:

    ]co d`yr} alye r }co cuena`}ny`na `ewoyn}`to ld rnt`af k`tor namnkkot`n}`af ruddoy`af vcoyo cleo fltoyaeoa}r nyo uaniko nmo~un}okp }lml rl }coeroktor!

    ]clro wylt`m`af cuena }ny`na nrr`r}nabo nyo yo~u`yom }l nb} v`}c`ewny}`nk`}p+ `amowoamoabo+ nam aou}ynk`}p vcoa monk`af v`}c }cot`b}`er ld oeoyfoab`or}cn} eonar al} }nh`af r`mor `a bladk`b}r nam al}

    royt`af `a oddob} nr }co nfoa}r ld os}oyank wlvoyr }cn} enp nkrl cntowny}`bukny `a}oyor}r `a oeoyfoab`or l}coy }cna wylt`m`af yok`od #RwcoyoWyljob} 977=)!=

    ]clro wylt`m`af yok`od rclukm }yon} t`b}`er ld oeoyfoab`or v`}c m`fa`}p!

    Yok`od lyfna`zn}`lar nam vlyhoyr rclukm io nbblua}niko }l il}c }clro}cop cokw nam }clro }cn} duam }co`y lwoyn}`lar!

    @a wynb}`bo+ nbblua}ni`k`}p }l duamoyr cnr ld}oa eona} }cn} fltoyaeoa}rwylt`m`af }co n`m cnto vna}om }l oaruyo `} vnr mok`toyom }l `}r `a}oamomioaod`b`ny`or! ]c`r al} urunkkp na `rruo `d na oswoy`oabom AFL `r mok`toy`af}co n`m! @} bna io n wylikoe `d }co n`m `r io`af wylt`mom }l fltoyaeoa}r }l

    m`r}y`iu}o nam }clro fltoyaeoa}r moap mlalyr nbborr }l }co ioaod`b`ny`or ld}co n`m!

    ]coro wy`ab`wkor cnto al} iooa m`rwu}o dyoo! By`}`br v`}c`a }co yok`od ble%

    eua`}p ruffor} }cn} wlk`}`bnkkp ik`am yok`od bna io niurom ip ena`wukn}`tofltoyaeoa}r ly vnyy`af dnb}`lar+ cuy}`af }co `a}oamom yob`w`oa}r a }co klafyua+ d al} }co rcly} yua+ nr vokk nam yo`adlyb`af }co wlvoy nam rur}n`ani`k`}p

    ld niur`to yof`eor! @a }co bnro ld yok`od dly }co yodufoor a Flen `a }co vnhold }co foalb`mo a Yvnamn a >00=+ Em`b`ar Rnar Dyla}`yor v`}cmyov dylewylt`m`af yok`od la }co fyluamr }cn} }co yok`od vnr bla}ylkkom ip }co toypfoalb`mn`yor `a }co bnewr #yoeana}r ld }co Cu}u e`k`}`nr) vcl cnm woywo%

    2 L}coy wuywlror fn`a`af wyle`aoabo `a }co >007r `abkumom wylel}`af moelbynbp+ enanf af bla%dk`b}+ nam nmmyorr`af fklink wylikoer k`ho oat`ylaeoa}nk mofynmn}`la ly }co `a}oyan}`lank }ynare`r%r`la ld m`ronro! Dly n mo}n`kom nbblua}`af ld }co ly`f`a nam otlku}`la ld }co wuywlror ld n`m+ rooKnabnr}oy #dly}cble`af)!

    = ]coro wy`ab`wkor nyo dluam `a }co blmo ld blamub} ld }co Yom Bylrr nam }co Yom Byorboa}+ vc`bc

    vnr or}nik`rcom `a >00= nam `r nmcoyom }l ip aueoylur AFLr+ nam `a }co Cuena`}ny`na Bcny}oy+mynva dyle n tny`o}p ld mlbueoa}r la cuena`}ny`na alyer nam wynb}`bor nam nfyoom }l ip n tny`o}pld AFLr oafnfom `a yok`od nb}`t`}`or!

  • 8/3/2019 Foreign Aid and International Norms: The Case of North Korea

    7/19

    >49 N Aov @a}oyan}`lank Oafnfoeoa} Dyneovlyh dly Aly}c Hlyon wy`bor) dly ok`f`i`k`}p dly @MN klnar! ]co

    MNB+ vc`bc r na a}oyan}`lank bkui ld i`kn}oynk n`m mlalyr a Aly}c Neoy`bn+Ouylwo+ nam Jnwna+ wurcor }co alye ld aoom`aorr duy}coy! @} uamoy}nhor woy`%lm`b yot`ovr ld }co n`m wylfyner ld `}r eoeioy r}n}or nam enhor n wl`a} `a

    }clro yowly}r nam a }r mn}n foaoynkkp }l c`fck`fc} }co woyboa}nfo ld eoeioyr}n}or n`m fl`af }l }co klvor}%`ableo blua}y`or #v`}c n woy bnw`}n `ableo ld-647 ly korr `a >003 mlkknyr) `a na oddly} }l oabluynfo eoeioy r}n}or }l

    m`yob} elyo n`m }l }co wllyor}!?

    ? ]co _a`}om An}`lar Motoklweoa} Wylfyne #_AMW) cnr byon}om n Cuena Motoklweoa} @amos

    blewy`r`af n tny`o}p ld r}n}`r}`bnk am`bn}lyr ld vokk%io`af a nmm`}`la }l woy bnw`}n ableo kotokr+ iu}}c`r `amos }oamr }l io korr urom nr n bleela r}namnym ld aoom `a }co motoklweoa} bleeua`}p8 roo_AMW #9772)!

  • 8/3/2019 Foreign Aid and International Norms: The Case of North Korea

    8/19

    Dlyo`fa N`m nam @a}oyan}`lank Alyer: ]co Bnro ld Aly}c Hlyon >42

    Cuena y`fc}r! Cuena y`fc}r cnto klaf iooa la }co a}oyan}`lank nfoamn!

    ]cop voyo mok`aon}om `a >0=3 `a }co _a`}om An}`lar #_A) _a`toyrnk Mobkn%yn}`la ld Cuena Y`fc}r nam cnto r`abo iooa oswnamom a n aueioy ld l}coy

    `a}oyan}`lank mobknyn}`lar nam }yon}`or! Dly rotoynk mobnmor+ clvotoy+ }cocuena y`fc}r woydlyenabo ld fltoyaeoa}r vnr k`}}ko moin}om a a}oyan}`lankdlyuer iobnuro ld }co roar`}`t`}`or `a wny}`bukny ld aovkp `amowoamoa} flt%oyaeoa}r nilu} }co rnab}`}p ld rltoyo`fa}p nam }co i`wlkny`}p ld }co Blkm

    Vny+ vc`bc enmo `} y`rhp dly Vor}oya fltoyaeoa}r }l by`}`b`zo }co cuenay`fc}r yoblymr ld l}coy fltoyaeoa}r dly dony ld my`t`af }coe a}l }co nyer ld}co Rlb`nk`r} iklb #vclro yofnym dly cuena y`fc}r vnr al} }oyy`ikp okotn}om

    `a nap bnro)! R`abo }co >067r vcoa J`eep Bny}oy+ }coa }co _!R! wyor`moa}+mobknyom }cn} n fltoyaeoa}r cuena y`fc}r woydlyenabo vnr na oswk`b`} by`%}oy`la dly }co ~unk`}p ld _!R! yokn}`lar v`}c }cn} blua}yp nam }cn} }co _a`}om

    R}n}or vlukm blar`moy }cn} woydlyenabo `a `}r mob`r`lar la n`m nam la tl}or`a }co Vlykm Inah la n`m klnar+ cuena y`fc}r cnr iooa la }co a}oyan}`lanknfoamn nr n blar`moyn}`la a n`m f`t`af! Cuena y`fc}r cnr iooa n wyle`aoa}

    blar`moyn}`la a }co n`m wylfyner ld n aueioy ld l}coy fltoyaeoa}r nr vokk}co Alym`b blua}y`or a wny}`buknynam cnr iobleo v`mokp nbbow}om+ n} konr}n} }co yco}ly`bnk kotok!

    Al bleela r}namnym `r urom ip n`m mlalyr dly jumf`af }co cuena y`fc}rwoydlyenabor ld fltoyaeoa}r nam `adlye`af mob`r`lar la }co`y n`m nkklbn%}`lar! ]co _!R! fltoyaeoa} ld}oa mynvr la }co naaunk Blua}yp Yowly}r la

    Cuena Y`fc}r Wynb}`bor }cn}+ dly onbc blua}yp

    ! ! ! bltoy `a}oyan}`lankkp yoblfa`zom `am`t`munk+ b`t`k+ wlk`}`bnk nam vlyhoyy`fc}r+ nr ro} dly}c `a }co _a`toyrnk Mobknyn}`la ld Cuena Y`fc}r! ]coro

    y`fc}r abkumo dyoomle dyle }ly}uyo ly l}coy byuok+ acuena ly mofynm`af}yon}eoa} ly wua`rceoa}8 dyle wylklafom mo}oa}`la v`}clu} bcnyfor8 dylem`rnwwonynabo ly bknamor}`ao mo}oa}`la8 nam dyle l}coy dknfyna} t`lkn%

    }`lar ld }co y`fc} }l k`do+ k`ioy}p nam }co robuy`}p ld }co woyrla!

    _a`toyrnk cuena y`fc}r rooh }l ablywlyn}o yorwob} dly cuena m`fa`}p a}l}co wylborror ld fltoyaeoa} nam knv! Nkk woyrlar cnto }co `ank`oaniko

    y`fc} }l bcnafo }co`y fltoyaeoa} ip wonboduk eonar nam }l oajlp inr`bdyoomler+ rubc nr dyoomle ld oswyorr`la+ nrrlb`n}`la+ nrroeikp+ elto%eoa} nam yok`f`la+ v`}clu} m`rby`e`an}`la la }co inr`r ld ynbo+ yok`f`la+

    an}`lank ly`f`a ly ros! ]co y`fc} }l jl`a n dyoo }ynmo ua`la `r n aoborrnypblam`}`la ld n dyoo rlb`o}p nam oblalep! ]cur }co yowly}r nrrorr hop a}oy%an}`lankkp yoblfa`zom vlyhoy y`fc}r+ abkum`af }co y`fc} ld nrrlb`n}`la8 }co

    y`fc} }l lyfna`zo nam inyfn`a blkkob}`tokp8 wylc`i`}`la ld dlybom ly ble%wukrlyp knily8 }co r}n}ur ld bc`km knily wynb}`bor nam }co e`a`eue nfo dlyoewklpeoa} ld bc`kmyoa8 nam nbbow}niko vlyh blam`}`lar #MLR 9772)!

    L}coy rluybor ld cuena y`fc}r nrrorreoa}r `abkumo }co Ldd`bo ld }co _AC`fc Blee`rr`laoy la Cuena Y`fc}r+ }co _a`}om H`afmle #_H) Dlyo`fa

  • 8/3/2019 Foreign Aid and International Norms: The Case of North Korea

    9/19

    >4= N Aov @a}oyan}`lank Oafnfoeoa} Dyneovlyh dly Aly}c Hlyon037r dly wylt`m`af n`m }l }co fltoyaeoa} ld OkRnktnmly `a k`fc} ld }co iyu}nk`}p nam v`morwyonm h`kk`afr la }co wny} ld }co

    e`k`}nyp ld }cn} blua}yp! ]co fltoyaeoa} ld Dynabo cnr iooa by`}`b`zom dlywylt`m`af n`m }l ]lfl+ vcoyo cuena y`fc}r+ bc`km }yndd`bh`af+ nam wlk`}`bnkyowyorr`la cnto iooa wny}`bukny wylikoer ltoy }co wnr} mobnmo! @a ao`}coy ld

    }coro bnror m`m by`}`b`rer wyotoa} }co _!R! ly Dyoabc fltoyaeoa}r dyle wyl%t`m`af n`m+ iu} }cop wu} fltoyaeoa}r }cn} cnto }lu}om }co`y blee`}eoa} }lcuena y`fc}r la }co modoar`to! @a nal}coy bnro}co dlyeoy Zn`yon aue%

    ioy ld n`m%f`t`af fltoyaeoa}r yomubom ly cnk}om }co`y n`m `a }co onykp >007rnd}oy }co nyep }coyo h`kkom n aueioy ld r}umoa}r `a n moelar}yn}`la! @a }c`rbnro+ }co an}`lank robuy`}p ly wlk`}`bnk a}oyor}r ld }co n`m%f`t`af fltoyaeoa}r

    voyo al} woybo`tom }l io nddob}om ip n bu}ldd ld n`m! ]co yonk`}`or ld n`m f`t`afnyo }cn}+ vcoyo fltoyaeoa}r wylt`mo }co n`m dly an}`lank robuy`}p yonrlar lyl}coy ewly}na} wlk`}`bnk yonrlar+ }clro yonrlar urunkkp }yuew cuena y`fc}r

    blaboyar! Iu} }cn} mlor al} eona }cn} cuena y`fc}r r}namnymr nyo al} `e%

    wly}na} ly `adkuoa}`nk `a n`m f`t`af! ]cop bkonykp nyo `ewly}na} `a }lmnprvlykm!

    N`m oddob}`toaorr! Blaboyar nilu} n`mr oddob}`toaorr `a duy}coy`af obl%ale`b nam rlb`nk motoklweoa} cnto iooa nyluam r`abo }co iof`aa`af ld n`mf`t`af! Rubc blaboyar cnto }nhoa la n wny}`bukny wyle`aoabo r`abo }co oam

    ld }co Blkm Vny #vc`bc+ `a oddob}+ yoeltom n rc`okm nfn`ar} by`}`b`re }cn} n`mvnr al} duy}coy`af motoklweoa} a yob`w`oa} blua}y`or) nam r`abo }co oswna%r`la ld ~una}`}n}`to mn}n }cn} cnr oabluynfom nankpr}r }l }nho n bklroy kllh n}

    n`mr `ewnb}! R}um`or`abkum`af rotoynk dyle }co elr} `adkuoa}`nk n`m ml%

    aly+ }co Vlykm Inahnyfuo }cn} n`m cnr+ `a dnb}+ iooa `aoddob}`to `a n aue%ioy ld r`}un}`lar #Mlkkny nam Iuyar`mo >003)!

    Vcn} nyo }co blam`}`lar+ nwny} dyle }co bnwnb`}p ld n`m%f`t`af nfoab`or}coeroktor nam }co ~unk`}p ld }co`y r}nddr vlyh+ }cn} nyo foaoynkkp nrrueom }lmo}oye`ao }co oddob}`toaorr ld n`m< @a }co >047r nam >067r+ n`m oswoy}r vlukm

    k`hokp cnto narvoyom }cn} }co ~una}`}p ld `adynr}yub}uyo nam }co omubn}`lanam conk}c ld }co wlwukn}`la vlukm io by`}`bnk }l }co nirlyw}`to bnwnb`}p ldn blua}yp}cn} `r+ }co blua}ypr ni`k`}p }l uro n`m oddob}`tokp! N}}`}umor nyo

    m`ddoyoa} n} wyoroa}8 }cop yodkob} }co oswoy`oabo ld }co wnr} rotoynk mobnmor la}co inr`r ld vc`bc `} cnr iooa yoblfa`zom }cn} `ar}`}u}`lar en}}oy! ]cur+ }cofoaoynk narvoy }lmnp la }co blam`}`lar ld n`m oddob}`toaorr vlukm `abkumo

  • 8/3/2019 Foreign Aid and International Norms: The Case of North Korea

    10/19

    Dlyo`fa N`m nam @a}oyan}`lank Alyer: ]co Bnro ld Aly}c Hlyon >4?

    }co ~unk`}p ld n blua}ypr fltoyanabo8 }co mofyoo ld lwoaaorr ld `}r enyho}r

    #}l woye`} wy`tn}o oblale`b `a`}`n}`to)8 nam }co blee`}eoa} ld `}r fltoya%eoa} }l byon}`af }co blam`}`lar dly oblale`b nam rlb`nk wylfyorr+ `abkum`af

    oswnam`af omubn}`la nam conk}c royt`bor #}coyodlyo wu}}`af korr duam`af `a}le`k`}nyp oswoam`}uyor)! ]coro nyo }co orroa}`nk blam`}`lar Wyor`moa} FolyfoV! Iurc eoa}`laom nr ~unk`d`bn}`lar dly n`m }l blua}y`or dyle }co aov E`k%koaa`ue Bcnkkoafo Nbblua}+ iu} }coro blam`}`lar cnto iooa wny} ld }co

    iylnmoy motoklweoa} m`rbluyro dly rotoynk ponyr! Vcn} ml }cop oa}n`k44 N Aov @a}oyan}`lank Oafnfoeoa} Dyneovlyh dly Aly}c Hlyon034+ wylc`i`}om _!R! n`m }l Wnh`r}na uakorr }co wyor`%moa} blukm toy`dp }cn} Wnh`r}na m`m al} wlrrorr aubkony nyer! Ip >007+ }cowyor`moa} blukm al} ml rl+ nam _!R! n`m }l Wnh`r}na vnr wcnrom lu}!0 L}coy

    fltoyaeoa}r cnto bu} }co`y n`m vcoa yob`w`oa} fltoyaeoa}r oswklmom aubkony

    mot`bor8 dly osnewko+ Jnwna yomubom `}r n`m }l Bc`an `a }co vnho ld Bc`aoroaubkony }or}`af `a }co >007r! ]cur+ }coyo enp io na oeoyf`af alye }cn}

    fltoyaeoa}r ld motoklw`af blua}y`or }cn} motoklw nam }or} rubc vonwlarnyo rnab}`laomn} konr} dly n }`eov`}c yomub}`lar `a }co`y n`m dklvr!

    N`m wylborr! Lao ld }co korr%yoblfa`zom motoklweoa}r ld }co >007r vnr

    }co oeoyfoabo ld vcn} blukm io bnkkom wylborr blam`}`lank`}p nr wny} ld }coalyer rcnw`af n`m f`t`af! @a yonb}`la }l }co nwwnyoa} `aoddob}`toaorr ld n`morwob`nkkp `a rui%Rncnyna Ndy`bnmuy`af }co >037r nam onykp >007r+ wynb}`%

    }`laoyr nam rbclknyr ld n`m nam motoklweoa} iofna }l kllh dly vnpr }l ena%

    nfo n`m }l oaruyo fyon}oy oddob}`toaorr! Lu} ld }c`r oddly} bneo }cyoo blabow}r:

    Wny}`b`wn}`la! Wny}`b`wn}`la eonar nrh`af wolwko vcn} }co`y wyodoy%

    oabor nyovco}coy `a }co dlye ld n an}`lank blaruk}n}`la la ltoynkkmotoklweoa} r}yn}of`or ly `a }co dlye ld n }nyfo}om blaruk}n}`la v`}c }co`a}oamom ioaod`b`ny`or ld n rwob`d`b `a}oytoa}`la! ]c`r `r al} n aov `mon8

    6 ]c`r mlor al} eona }cn} }coyo rclukm io al yofukn}`la ld oblale`b nb}`t`}p! ]co inknabo io}vooafltoyaeoa} yofukn}`la nam dyoo enyho}r `r na nyon ld bla}`au`af bla}oa}`la!

    3 Dly n eubc elyo mo}n kom osne`an}`la ld }co k`hokp `am`bn}lyr urom }l mo}oye`ao ok`f`i`k }p dly}co E`kkoaa`ue Bcnkkoafo Nbblua} ela`or+ roo Ynmoko} #9779)!

    0 N`m }l Wnh`r}na cnr r`abo iooa yor}lyom `a blajuab}`la v`}c Wnh`r}nar bllwoyn}`la `a }co _!R!`a}oytoa}`la `a Ndfcna`r}na nam }co cua} dly eoeioyr ld Nk ^nomn!

  • 8/3/2019 Foreign Aid and International Norms: The Case of North Korea

    12/19

    Dlyo`fa N`m nam @a}oyan}`lank Alyer: ]co Bnro ld Aly}c Hlyon >46

    `} cnr iooa nyluam r`abo }co iof`aa`af ld motoklweoa} n`m nam vnr n

    wyle`aoa} okoeoa} `a }co bleeua`}p%motoklweoa} dlbur ld n`m f`t`afwlwukny `a }co >047r! @} yofn`aom wyle`aoabo `a }co kn}o >037r nam

    >007r nr wny} ld }co inbhknrc }l r}yub}uynk nmjur}eoa} wylfyner+ vc`bcvoyo v`mokp by`}`b`zom nr `ewlrom dyle }co lu}r`mo+ }lw mlva+ namcuy}duk }l }co `a}oyor}r ld }co wlly!

    N} }co blyo ld }co buyyoa} al}`la ld wny}`b`wn}`la `r }co `mon ld oewlvoy%

    eoa}}cn} wolwko rclukm cnto n eonruyo ld bla}ylk ltoy }co`y k`tor namal} io m`b}n}om }l ly yowyorrom ip fltoyaeoa}r #}co`y lva ly l}coyr) lyl}coy wlvoyr `a rlb`o}p! Moy`t`af dyle }c`r al}`la `r }co iok`od }cn}+ `d

    wolwko nyo blaruk}om nilu} }c`afr `a}oamom }l nddob} }co`y k`tor+ }co`ywyodoyoabor nam halvkomfo bna konm }l elyo nwwylwy`n}o `a}oytoa}`lar+nam }cop v`kk ruwwly} }clro `a}oytoa}`lar `a }co du}uyo`a l}coy vlymr+

    }cop v`kk }nho lvaoyrc`w ld }co n`m `a}oytoa}`lar+ enh`af }coe elyooddob}`to nam rur}n`aniko! Wny}`b`wn}`la `a }co dlye ld an}`lank blaruk}n%}`lar la motoklweoa} r}yn}of`or `r nkrl yofnymom ip rleo motoklweoa}

    wynb}`}`laoyr nr n eonar ld r}yoaf}coa`af moelbynbp `a motoklw`afblua}y`or iobnuro `} konmr }co fltoyaeoa} }l blaruk} v`}c `}r wlwukn}`lala }coro `ewly}na} `rruor!

    Lvaoyrc`w! Lvaoyrc`w `r lao ld }co konr} rn}`rdnb}ly`kp mod`aom }oyer`a }co n`m wylborr bn}oflyp! N} `}r blyo `r }co roar`iko al}`la }cn} wolwkov`kk }nho yorwlar`i`k`}p dly }c`afr }cop cnto cnm n cnam `a rcnw`af!

    Clvotoy+ `moa}`dp`af vcoa lvaoyrc`w os`r}r nam vcoa `} mlor al}8 vcn}rly}r ld oafnfoeoa} ip wolwko byon}o n roaro ld lvaoyrc`w la }co`y wny}dly wny}`bukny nb}`t`}`or8 nam vcn} lvaoyrc`w nb}unkkp konmr }l `a }oyer ld

    cuena iocnt`ly nyo nkrl nr po} `kk mod`aom okoeoa}r ld }c`r blabow}!Nk}clufc }co }oye `r tnfuo oalufc }l lirbuyo bkony }c`ah`af+ `} `rt`y}unkkp n ena}yn `a n`m%f`t`af }lmnp!

    Wny}aoyrc`w! Wny}aoyrc`w eonar n blkknilyn}`la io}vooa n`m f`toy namn`m yob`w`oa} }cn} `atlktor n eonruyo ld o~unk`}p!>7 Nfn`a+ ioc`am }c`rrleovcn} tnfuo `mon `r }co nrruew}`la }cn} n`m yob`w`oa}r v`kk }nho

    elyo roy`lurkp n`m%duamom nb}`t`}`or }cn} }cop cnto cokwom }l wkna nam`ewkoeoa}8 `a l}coy vlymr+ n`m mlalyr rclukm al} jur} nyy`to `a nblua}yp nam m`b}n}o }l }co fltoyaeoa} ly klbnk bleeua`}`or vcn} v`kk

    io mlao dly }coe!

    ]coro }cyoo monrwny}`b`wn}`la+ lvaoyrc`w+ nam wny}aoyrc`wcnto iooaf`toa wny}`bukny wyle`aoabo ip }co Vlykm Inah `a `}r Blewyocoar`to Motok%

    lweoa} Dyneovlyh #BMD)+ n iylnm blabow} ld vcn} motoklweoa} yo~u`yor!]co }cyoo `monr cnto nkrl iobleo }co inr`r la vc`bc }co Vlykm Inah cnr

    >7 Wny}aoyrc`w bna nkrl eona blkknilyn}`la nelaf m`ddoyoa} n`m%f`t`af lyfna`zn}`lar+ abkum`af wuik`bn`m nfoab`or+ AFLr+ nam wy`tn}o oa}oywy`ror!

  • 8/3/2019 Foreign Aid and International Norms: The Case of North Korea

    13/19

    >43 N Aov @a}oyan}`lank Oafnfoeoa} Dyneovlyh dly Aly}c Hlyon>

    Nbblua}ni`k`}p! Dov n`m%f`t`af nfoab`or nyo v`kk`af }l vy`}o bcobhr }lyob`w`oa} fltoyaeoa}r nam lyfna`zn}`lar v`}clu} rleo oddly} }l moa}`dp }cowylwlrom uror ld }co n`m nam nrboy}n`a vco}coy }co duam`af cnr+ a dnb}+ iooa

    urom dly }cn} wuywlro! ]nswnpoyr nam }co`y yowyoroa}n}`tor `a fltoyaeoa}r `an`m%f`t`af blua}y`or }pw`bnkkp moenam rubc nbblua}`afr! ]co elyo moenam%`af }co kof`rkn}`to nam wuik`b fyluwr nyo la rruor ld nbblua}ni`k`}p+ }co fyon}oy

    }co }ynarwnyoabp a n`m f`t`af nam }co korr lwwly}ua`}p }coyo r dly n`m%f`t`afnam n`m%yobo`t`af fltoyaeoa}r nam lyfna`zn}`lar }l nb} blyyuw}kp ly dly }codlyeoy }l }uya n ik`am opo }l }co kn}}oy!

    Vcoyo wuik`b rbnamnkr cnto oyuw}om ltoy }co e`ruro ld n`m duam`afnr a@}nkp muy`af }co onykp >007r+ nam woy`lm`bnkkp a Jnwna nam Dynabo}co wui%k`b bna }uya nfn`ar} n`m nam dlybo }co fltoyaeoa} }l bu} `} nam }l yodlye!

    ]cur+ `} cnr ld}oa iooa }co bnro }cn} fltoyaeoa}r nam lyfna`zn}`lar yobo`t%`af }co n`m eur} ruie`} }l num`}r+ yowly}r+ nam ruwoyt`rlyp t`r`}r dyle n`mmlalyr }l oaruyo }cn} }co n`m r io`af urom nr a}oamom! ]c`r r n alye a n`m

    f`t`afelyo oadlybom `a rleo n`m%f`t`af blua}y`or }cna `a l}coyr}cn} `r

    rokmle eoa}`laom iobnuro `} `r rl v`mokp nbbow}om!

    An}`lank Robuy`}p

    @a}oyan}`lank alyer cnto e`a`enk adkuoabo la }co nkklbn}`la ld dlyo`fa n`m}cn} `r inrom la an}`lank robuy`}p ly `a}oyan}`lank wlk`}`bnk blaboyar! ]comob`r`la nilu} vco}coy }l uro n`m `a }c`r vnp `r enmo ip n`m%f`t`af fltoya%

    eoa}r+ inrom la }co woybow}`lar nam wy`ly`}`or ld }clro `a wlvoy! ]c`r h`amld n`m cnr iooa wylt`mom }l fltoyaeoa}r a osbcnafo dly nfyoom nb}`lar #dly

    >> @a Vlykm Inah #9772)+ }co Vlykm Inah otnkun}om }co `ewnb} ld }co BMD8 `} `r `a }co wylborr ldotnkun}`af }co WYRWr nr vokk!

  • 8/3/2019 Foreign Aid and International Norms: The Case of North Korea

    14/19

    Dlyo`fa N`m nam @a}oyan}`lank Alyer: ]co Bnro ld Aly}c Hlyon >40

    osnewko+ }co wylt`r`la ld inro y`fc}r+ }co ruwwyorr`la ld }oyyly`r}r)+ `a os%

    bcnafo dly foaoynk ruwwly} dly }co mlaly fltoyaeoa}r wlk`b`or #dly osnewko+Dynabo t`r%%t`r `}r dlyeoy blkla`or `a rui%Rncnyna Ndy`bn)+ ly }l oaruyo yok`%

    niko nbborr }l wlk`bpenhoyr `a yob`w`oa} blua}y`or!N} }`eor+ n`m dly an}`lank robuy`}p wuywlror `r blar`r}oa} v`}c }co alyerfu`m`af }co nkklbn}`la ld n`m dly motoklweoa}}cn} `r+ wylt`mom }l fltoya%eoa}r v`}c fllm fltoyanabo+ oblale`b wlk`b`or+ nam n blee`}eoa} }l }co`y

    wolwkor! Iu} `} `r nkrl }co bnro }cn} fltoyaeoa}r v`}c wlly oblale`b ena%nfoeoa}+ wlly cuena y`fc}r yoblymr+ c`fc kotokr ld blyyuw}`la+ nam yowyor%r`la cnto nkk iooa }co yob`w`oa}r ld }c`r }pwo ld n`m vcoa robuy`}p ly wlk`}`bnk

    `a}oyor}r ld mlaly fltoyaeoa}r cnto iooa blewokk`af! ]co wlr}oy bc`km ld}c`r }pwo ld n`m vnr }co dlyeoy Zn`yo+ vc`bc dly mobnmor yobo`tom r`znikonelua}r ld n`m dyle }co _a`}om R}n}or+ Iokf`ue+ nam Dynabo morw`}o }co

    hkow}lbyn}`b fltoyaeoa} ld Eliu}u Roro Rohl!@} nwwonyr }cn} n`m dly an}`lank robuy`}p wuywlror m`e`a`rcom `a }co vnho

    ld }co oam ld }co Blkm Vny+ n }`eo vcoa motoklw`af blua}y`or blukm oswkl`}

    }co`y wlr`}`la io}vooa }co _a`}om R}n}or nam }co _RRY nam nrrly}om nkk`ornam ruyylfn}or! Clvotoy+ }c`r }yoam enp io yotoyrom v`}c }co vny la }oyyly%`re nam na nb}`t`r} wlk`bp ip }co _a`}om R}n}or }l a}oytoao e`k`}ny`kp nfn`ar}

    }oyyly`r}r nam l}coy ylfuo yof`eornb}`lar }cn} ld}oa yo~u`yo ruwwly} dylel}coy fltoyaeoa}r+ orwob`nkkp `a }co yof`la ld }co `a}oytoa}`la! N`m `r lao`ar}yueoa} dly nb~u`y`af }cn} ruwwly}! N`m `r nkrl uroduk nr n }llk ld wonbo%

    enh`afna aboa}`to dly vnyy`af wny}`or }l aofl}`n}o wonbo! Wlk`b`or ld wonbo%

    enh`af+ nr `a }co E`mmko Onr} nam }co Inkhnar+ nyo nkrl k`hokp }l enho bla%}`au`af bnkkr la _!R! n`m!

    N`m dly an}`lank robuy`}p ly a}oyan}`lank wlk`}`bnk wuywlror+ vc`ko al} eubc`adkuoabom ip `a}oyan}`lank alyer+ `r ld}oa bla}or}om `a `a}oyank fltoya%eoa} m`rburr`lar ip ldd`b`nkr `a motoklweoa} nfoab`or+ ip motoklweoa}%ly`%

    oa}om AFLr+ nam `a illhr nam ny}`bkor ip ldd`b`nkr nam dlyeoy n`m ldd`b`nkrdyle }clro fltoyaeoa}r wylt`m`af }co n`m! Eubc ld }co klaf%}oye }oar`laio}vooa }co _!R! Nfoabp dly @a}oyan}`lank Motoklweoa} nam }co _!R! Mo%

    wny}eoa} ld R}n}o ltoy n`m nkklbn}`lar cnr yotlktom nyluam }c`r m`ddoyoabo ld

    t`ov! Woycnwr }co blua}yp `a vc`bc rubc by`}`b`rer cnto iooa elr} wuik`bnam r}y`moa} `r Dynabo+ vcoyo otoa fltoyaeoa} ldd`b`nkr r}`kk `a ldd`bo cnto

    wuik`rcom a}oyt`ovr a konm`af jluyankr #rleo}`eor uamoy aler mo wkueo)nam illhr n}}nbh`af }co e`rnkklbn}`la ld }co`y fltoyaeoa}r n`m!>9

    @d }coyo r n alye a n`m f`t`af dly an}`lank robuy`}p ly a}oyan}`lank wlk`}`%

    bnk wuywlror+ `} `r }cn} }clro wuywlror eur} io yofnymom ip wlk`}`bnk ok`}or `an`m%f`t`af fltoyaeoa}r nr ld rudd`b`oa}kp c`fc an}`lank wy`ly`}p rl nr }l rur%

    >9 Dly na `a}oyor}`af osnewko ld }c`r by`}`b`re+ roo E`bcn`kld #>002)! E`bcn`kld vnr n roa`ly ldd`b`nk

    ld }co Nfoabo Dynan`ro mo Mtoklwwoeoa} n} }co }`eo }c`r illh vnr wuik`rcom nam r nfn`a n roa`lyldd`b`nk `a }cn} nfoabp! Dly na n}}nbh la _!R! n`m dly wlk`}`bnk wuywlror #`a Ofpw})+ roo Z`eeoyena#>002)!

  • 8/3/2019 Foreign Aid and International Norms: The Case of North Korea

    15/19

    >67 N Aov @a}oyan}`lank Oafnfoeoa} Dyneovlyh dly Aly}c Hlyon007r r }clufc} }l cnto h`kkom cuamyomr ld}clurnamr n} }co toyp konr}+ nam woycnwr n e`kk`la ly otoa elyo)+ nam n knyfowoyboa}nfo ld Hlyona bc`kmyoa nyo roy`lurkp enkaluy`rcom! @a >003+ }co _A

    or}`en}om }cn} 47 woyboa} ld Hlyona bc`kmyoa ruddoyom dyle r}ua}om fylv}clv`af }l enkau}y`}`la #O@_ 977=+ >2)! R`abo nfy`buk}uynk wylmub}`laaotoyonrp a n blua}yp v`}c k`e`}om nyniko knamcnr m`e`a`rcom iobnuro ld n knbh

    ld `awu}r nam iobnuro }co MWYH fltoyaeoa} cnr lw}om }l rwoam `}r m`e`a%`rc`af yorluybor la fuar yn}coy }cna iu}}oy+ }co blua}yp+ nbblym`af }l Alknam#9772+ >)+ mlor al} wylmubo oalufc lu}wu} }l rur}n`a }co wlwukn}`la i`l%

    klf`bnkkp! Vcn} cnr iooa aoborrnyp r`abo }co kn}o >007r }l hoow na lafl`afcuena`}ny`na by`r`r dyle }uya`af a}l n enjly cuena`}ny`na m`rnr}oy r enr%r`to nelua}r ld dlyo`fa dllm n`m! @} `r or}`en}om }cn} lao%}c`ym ld }co 99

    e`kk`la Aly}c Hlyonar mowoam la dllm n`m!Nk}clufc dllm n`m cnr uamlui}omkp cokwom ntl`m v`morwyonm r}nytn}`la

    `a Aly}c Hlyon+ wylt`m`af }co dllm n`m mlor yn`ro wynb}`bnk nam o}c`bnk bla%

    boyar! ]co uav`kk`afaorr ld }co Hlyona fltoyaeoa} }l woye`} n`m mlalyr }lela`}ly }co mok`toyp ld }co`y n`m }l oaruyo `} `r al} m`toy}om }l }co lao%e`k%k`la%r}ylaf nyep kontor mlui} nilu} }co yonk ioaod`b`ny`or ld }co dllm! Aovr%

    wnwoyr cnto yowly}om }cn} }co fltoyaeoa} ld Aly}c Hlyon cnr moa`om dllm}l }clro blar`moyom arudd`b`oa}kp blee`}}om ly klpnk+ n bla}yntoa}`la ld }cocuena`}ny`na blee`}eoa} }l dukd`kk aoomr vcn}otoy }co wlk`}`br ld }co aoomp

    woyrla ly fyluw!Nal}coy m`dd`buk} o}c`bnk wylikoe `r }cn} ld yok`ot`af rcly}%}oye ruddoy`af

    v`}c dllm n`m vc`ko wlrr`ikp wylklaf`af ruddoy`af `a }co klaf }oye ip+ `a

    oddob}+ r}yoaf}coa`af }co wlr`}`la ld n }yukp morw`bniko fltoyaeoa} }cn} `rknyfokp yorwlar`iko dly }co ruddoy`af nam r}nytn}`la ld `}r wolwko nam vclroos`r}oabo e`fc} io rcly}oaom voyo rubc n`m al} ntn`kniko! ]co o}c`bnk bcl`bo

    coyo+ f`toa }co uahalvar #`abkum`af }co blaro~uoabor ld n blkknwro ld }co

    Aly}c Hlyona yof`eo)+ `r toyp m`dd`buk} }l enho+ nam elr} wolwko nam lyfn%

  • 8/3/2019 Foreign Aid and International Norms: The Case of North Korea

    16/19

    Dlyo`fa N`m nam @a}oyan}`lank Alyer: ]co Bnro ld Aly}c Hlyon >6>

    a`zn}`lar cnto `a }co wnr} bclroa }l wylt`mo }co n`m `a }co rcly} }oye v`}c

    }co oswob}n}`la }cn} rleo ld `} v`kk yomubo ruddoy`af!>2

    Motoklweoa} N`mV`}c yofnym }l }co oeoyf`af alyer }cn} `adkuoabo }co wylt`r`la ld motoklw%

    eoa} n`m+ Aly}c Hlyon n} wyoroa} vlukm aotoy ~unk`dp! Nk}clufc `}r aoombnaal} io moa`om #woy bnw`}n ableo r iok`otom }l io nyluam -6?7 woy pony+cnt`af mobk`aom ip cnkd r`abo }co onykp >007r vcoa }co Rlt`o} _a`la blk%

    knwrom nam `}r oblale`b ruir`m`or voyo }oye`an}om)+ `} cnr lao ld }co vlyr}cuena y`fc}r yoblymr ld nap fltoyaeoa} `a }co vlykm! Dly osnewko+ yoboa}modob}lyr cnto nkkofom }cn} }co fltoyaeoa} cnr urom fnr bcneioyr `a lao ld

    `}r knily bnewr }l blamub} bcoe`bnk oswoy`eoa}r la `aen}or! N`m dly `adyn%r}yub}uyo nam nfy`buk}uynk nam `amur}y`nk `awu}r e`fc} vokk dnb`k`}n}o fyon}oy

    wylmub}`la nam `a}oyank }ynmo #onyk`oy `ator}eoa}r `a }coro nyonr cnto mo}o%y`lyn}om mynen}`bnkkp)+ iu} Aly}c Hlyonr wlly oblale`b enanfoeoa} vlukmk`hokp wu} k`e`}r la }co rur}n`aom `ewnb} ld }coro `ator}eoa}r!

    ]co MWYHr nyi`}ynyp+ iyu}nk+ nam yowyorr`to fltoyaeoa}n fltoyaeoa}

    }cn} `a }co wnr} cnr ik`}cokp modnuk}om la `}r os}oyank moi}rnkrl k`e`}r }colwwly}ua`}`or nam `aboa}`tor dly `am`t`munkr }l }nho oblale`b y`rhr ly+ dly}cn} en}}oy+ dly dlyo`fa `ator}lyr }l wu} }co`y elaop n} y`rh `a }co blua}yp!

    ]co fltoyaeoa} cnr `ator}om `a }co omubn}`la ld `}r wolwko nam cnr lao ld}co c`fcoy ntoynfo kotokr ld omubn}`la nam k`do oswob}nabp ld fltoyaeoa}r n}

    `}r `ableo kotok+ iu} }co fltoyaeoa}r yokn}`tokp knyfo oswoam`}uyor la `}rknyfo e`k`}nyp nam la nyer wylmub}`lamorw`}o v`morwyonm dne`ao `a }coblua}ypnyo na `am`bn}`la }cn} }co vokdnyo ld `}r wlwukn}`la `r dny dyle }co}lw ld `}r wy`ly`}p k`r}!

    @a nmm`}`la }l r`zniko e`k`}nyp oswoam`}uyor+ }co MWYH cnr lwoakp nmtoy%}`rom `}r oddly}r }l motoklw aubkony vonwlar nam cnr }or}om klaf%ynafo e`r%r`kor woy`lm`bnkkp ltoy }co wnr} rotoynk ponyr! ]coro wlk`b`or nklao e`fc} io

    oalufc }l yn`ro ~uor}`lar nilu} }co nwwylwy`n}oaorr ld wylt`m`af rubc nfltoyaeoa} v`}c motoklweoa} n`m iobnuro rubc n`m e`fc} `a oddob} dyoo uwelyo mleor}`b yorluybor dly e`k`}nyp wuywlror!

    ]co oyyn}`b iocnt`ly ld }co Aly}c Hlyona r}n}ov`}c `}r os}ynlym`anyp buk}rld woyrlank`}p `atlkt`af `}r konmoyr+ `}r h`manw`af dlyo`fa an}`lankr+ nam `}r}ynardoy ld aubkony }obcalklfp }l l}coy blua}y`ornkk ro} `} nwny} nr n ylfuo

    r}n}o+ lu}r`mo }co bleeua`}p ld an}`lar nam }co bleeua`}p ld r}n}or aly%enkkp yobo`t`af klaf%}oye n`m dly }co`y motoklweoa}!

    >2 @a Jnaunyp 977=+ } kllhom k`ho dllm n`m dly }co MWYH vlukm mylw wyob`w`}lurkp nr dllm mlan}`lar}cylufc }co Vlykm Dllm Wylfyne dokk! ]cn} mylw `a }uya enp yodkob} }co fylv`af m`r`kkur`laeoa}

    nelaf n`m%f`t`af fltoyaeoa}r v`}c }co MWYH nam }co`y `ewn}`oabo v`}c Wplafpnafr oyyn}`b wlk`%b`or yofnym`af vonwlar ld enrr mor}yub}`la! Clvotoy+ }co _a`}om R}n}or nam l}coy mlalyr cnto io%fua }l rc`w dllm }l Aly}c Hlyon!

  • 8/3/2019 Foreign Aid and International Norms: The Case of North Korea

    17/19

    >69 N Aov @a}oyan}`lank Oafnfoeoa} Dyneovlyh dly Aly}c Hlyon Enybc!

    vvv!r}n}o!flt,f,myk,ykr,cyyw},9779,>3>22!c}e!

    Mlkkny+ Mnt`m+ nam Byn`f Iuyar`mo! >003! Nrrorr`af N`m: Vcn} Vlyhr+ Vcn}Mlora} nam Vcp! Vnrc`af}la+ M!B!: Vlykm Inah!

    Oblale`r} @a}okk`foabo _a`} #O@_)! 977=! Blua}yp Wyld`ko 977=: Aly}c Hlyon!

    Klamla: Oblale`r} @a}okk`foabo _a`}!Knabnr}oy+ Bnylk! Dly}cble`af! D`d}p Ponyr ld Dlyo`fa N`m! @a enaurby`w}!

    E`bcn`kld+ Royfo+ om! >002! Kn Dynabo o} kNdy`~uo! Wny`r: Hny}cnkn!

    Alknam+ Enybur! 9772! Dne`ao nam Yodlye `a Aly}c Hlyon! Vnrc`af}la+

    M!B!: @ar}`}u}o dly @a}oyan}`lank Oblale`br! vvv!``o!ble,wuik`bn}`lar,vw,9772,72%?!wmd!

    Lyfna`zn}`la dly Oblale`b Bllwoyn}`la nam Motoklweoa} #LOBM)! 977=n!

    N`m R}n}`r}`br! Wny`r: LOBM! vvv!lobm!lyf,mowny}eoa},7+9433+oa\94=0\2===6\>\>\>\>\>+77!c}ek!

  • 8/3/2019 Foreign Aid and International Norms: The Case of North Korea

    18/19

    Dlyo`fa N`m nam @a}oyan}`lank Alyer: ]co Bnro ld Aly}c Hlyon >62

    ! 977=i! Motoklweoa} Bllwoyn}`la M`yob}lyn}o #MNB)+ MNBr Fklr%

    rnyp! Wny`r: LOBM! vvv!lobm!lyf,fklrrnyp,7+9?34+oa\94=0\2269>\>04?402\>\>\>\>+77!c}ek!

    Ynmoko}+ R}oto! 9779! unk`dp`af dly }co E`kkoaa`ue Bcnkkoafo Nbblua}! Boa%}oy dly Fklink Motoklweoa}! Moboeioy! vvv!bfmot!lyf,mlbr,Bcllr`af\EBN\Blua}y`or!wmd!

    Rwcoyo Wyljob}! 977=! Cuena`}ny`na Bcny}oy nam E`a`eue R}namnymr `a

    M`rnr}oy Yorwlaro! Foaotn: Rwcoyo Wyljob}!

    _a`}om An}`lar Motoklweoa} Wylfyne #_AMW)! 9772! Cuena Motoklw%eoa} @am`bn}lyr 9772! Aov Plyh: _a`}om An}`lar! c}}w:,,cmy!uamw!lyf,yowly}r,fklink,9772,`am`bn}ly,`amos\`am`bn}lyr!c}ek!

    Vlykm Inah! 9772! ]lvnym Blua}yp%Kom Motoklweoa}: N Euk}`wny}aoy Otnkun%

    }`la ld }co Blewyocoar`to Motoklweoa} Dyneovlyh! Vnrc`af}la+ M!B!: VlykmInah!

    Z`eeoyena+ Ylioy}! >002! Mlkknyr+ M`wklenbp nam Mowoamoabp! Ilukmoy+ Blkl!:Kpaao Y`oaaoy!

    Bnylk Knabnr}oy `r n Wyldorrly n} }co Rbcllk ld Dlyo`fa Royt`bo n} Folyfo}lva _a`%

    toyr`}p+ Vnrc`af}la+ M!B! Rco wyot`lurkp roytom `a n aueioy ld _!R! fltoyaeoa}wlr`}`lar+ `abkum`af nr Mowu}p Nme`a`r}yn}ly ld _RN@M dyle >002 }l >004!

  • 8/3/2019 Foreign Aid and International Norms: The Case of North Korea

    19/19

    Hlyon @ar}`}u}o dlyHlyon Oblale`b @ar}`}u}o @a}oyan}`lank Oblale`b Wlk bp Neoy`bna Oa}oywy`ro @ar}`}u}o Bclrua%@kil

    >97> D R}yoo}+ A!V!+ R}o! 0>7 277%=+ Pleflh%Mlaf >>?7 Rotoa}ooa}c R}!+ A!V! 4>+ >%fn+ ]nowplaf%al+ Bcuaf%fu

    Vnrc`af}la+ MB 9777= Rlbcl%Fu+ Roluk >26%6=6+ Hlyon Vnrc`af}la+ MB 97724 Roluk+ >77%6?4+ Hlyon

    Wclao 979!=4=!>039 Wclao 39!9!2=47!>>>= Wclao 979!349!?377 Wclao 39!9!69=!?96?

    vvv!ho`n!lyf vvv!h`ow!fl!hy vvv!no`!lyf vvv!oafk`rc!bclrua!ble