Focusv21n3 a bio psycho social spiritual approach to hiv and homelessness

9
The ache for home lives in all of us, the safe place where we can go as we are and not be questioned. —Maya Angelou Over the past 25 years, homelessness and AIDS have formed intersecting epidemics, sharing roots in poverty and discrimina- tion, and physical health, mental health, and substance use disorders. Approximately one- third to one-half of people living with HIV in the United States are homeless or at imminent risk of homelessness. 1 HIV is more than three times as prevalent among homeless people than it is among those who are housed. 2 Suffering is prominent among homeless people. Physical health, mental health, and substance abuse problems are common, and death rates are high. 3 This article explores the experience of working with homeless cli- ents with HIV-related issues and proposes a bio-psycho-social-spiritual model to address multiple barriers to prevention and care. Medical Concerns HIV is only one among many conditions that affect homeless people differently than housed people. Homeless patients often pres- ent for care with advanced disease and acute conditions, including nutritional and dental problems, dehydration, hypothermia, and the physical consequences of traumatic assault. Infectious diseases such as lice, scabies, and viral hepatitis are common. Sexually transmitted diseases, skin infections, and respiratory infections, especially tuberculo- sis, are also common, and are facilitated by the overcrowded conditions many homeless people live in, such as shelters, as well as the exposure to the elements experienced by those living on the streets. Substance abuse, widespread in this population, can itself lead to a host of physical consequences. Among these are permanent cognitive impairment, and liver, lung, and heart disease. Psychological Issues Psychological disorders, which are com- monly undiagnosed and untreated in home- less people, are both a common cause of homelessness and are greatly exacerbated by it. Homeless people are five to six times more likely than the general U.S. popula- tion to have a serious mental illness such as schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, major depression, schizoaffective disorders, and severe personality disorders. 4 These psy- chological disorders, particularly personal- ity disorders, are also a cause of poor out- comes in the care of homeless people. They can interfere with the provider-client rela- tionship and create difficulties maintaining housing, which can undermine medication adherence and treatment planning. Research has documented the dispropor- tionate risk of HIV infection among home- less people with mental health disorders 5 and has implicated several factors. Among these factors are injection drug use with needle sharing, sex work, survival sex, and rape. Lack of privacy, as well as psycho- logical issues, contribute to more unstable sexual relationships, and inability to afford condoms and to negotiate their use add further barriers to HIV prevention. Cognitive impairment is a significant obsta- cle to both housing and prevention and care for many homeless people. Evidence suggests that homeless people are at greater risk than the general population for traumatic head injury. It is also common for these clients to experience cognitive impairment as a result of mental illness, chronic substance abuse, developmental delay, and HIV itself. 6 Substance abuse further complicates this mental health picture. While one in five Americans has a substance use problem, an estimated two out of three homeless people do, 7 and up to 50 percent of people who are homeless have co-occurring mental health and substance use disorders. 4 F OCU S A Guide to Research and Counseling March 2006 v21 n3 A Bio-Psycho-Social-Spiritual Approach to HIV and Homelessness Barry Zevin, MD

description

 

Transcript of Focusv21n3 a bio psycho social spiritual approach to hiv and homelessness

Page 1: Focusv21n3 a bio psycho social spiritual approach to hiv and homelessness

The ache for home lives in all of us, the safe place where we can go as we are and not be questioned. —MayaAngelou

Overthepast25years,homelessnessandAIDShaveformedintersectingepidemics,sharingrootsinpovertyanddiscrimina-tion,andphysicalhealth,mentalhealth,andsubstanceusedisorders.Approximatelyone-thirdtoone-halfofpeoplelivingwithHIVintheUnitedStates arehomelessoratimminentriskofhomelessness.1HIVismorethanthreetimesasprevalentamonghomelesspeoplethanitisamongthosewhoarehoused.2

Sufferingisprominentamonghomelesspeople. Physicalhealth,mentalhealth,andsubstanceabuseproblemsarecommon,anddeathratesarehigh.3Thisarticleexplorestheexperienceofworkingwithhomelesscli-entswithHIV-relatedissuesandproposesabio-psycho-social-spiritualmodeltoaddressmultiplebarrierstopreventionandcare.

Medical ConcernsHIVisonlyoneamongmanyconditions

thataffecthomelesspeopledifferentlythanhousedpeople.Homelesspatientsoftenpres-entforcarewithadvanceddiseaseandacuteconditions,includingnutritionalanddentalproblems,dehydration,hypothermia,andthephysicalconsequencesoftraumaticassault.

Infectiousdiseasessuchaslice,scabies,andviralhepatitisarecommon.Sexuallytransmitteddiseases,skininfections,andrespiratoryinfections,especiallytuberculo-sis,arealsocommon,andarefacilitatedbytheovercrowdedconditionsmanyhomelesspeoplelivein,suchasshelters,aswellastheexposuretotheelementsexperiencedbythoselivingonthestreets.Substanceabuse,widespreadinthispopulation,canitselfleadtoahostofphysicalconsequences.Among

thesearepermanentcognitiveimpairment,andliver,lung,andheartdisease.

Psychological IssuesPsychologicaldisorders,whicharecom-

monlyundiagnosedanduntreatedinhome-lesspeople,arebothacommoncauseofhomelessnessandaregreatlyexacerbatedbyit.HomelesspeoplearefivetosixtimesmorelikelythanthegeneralU.S.popula-tiontohaveaseriousmentalillnesssuchasschizophrenia,bipolardisorder,majordepression,schizoaffectivedisorders,andseverepersonalitydisorders.4Thesepsy-chologicaldisorders,particularlypersonal-itydisorders,arealsoacauseofpoorout-comesinthecareofhomelesspeople.Theycaninterferewiththeprovider-clientrela-tionshipandcreatedifficultiesmaintaininghousing,whichcanunderminemedicationadherenceandtreatmentplanning.

Researchhasdocumentedthedispropor-tionateriskofHIVinfectionamonghome-lesspeoplewithmentalhealthdisorders5andhasimplicatedseveralfactors.Amongthesefactorsareinjectiondrugusewithneedlesharing,sexwork,survivalsex,andrape.Lackofprivacy,aswellaspsycho-logicalissues,contributetomoreunstablesexualrelationships,andinabilitytoaffordcondomsandtonegotiatetheiruseaddfurtherbarrierstoHIVprevention.

Cognitiveimpairmentisasignificantobsta-cletobothhousingandpreventionandcareformanyhomelesspeople.Evidencesuggeststhathomelesspeopleareatgreaterriskthanthegeneralpopulationfortraumaticheadinjury.Itisalsocommonfortheseclientstoexperiencecognitiveimpairmentasaresultofmentalillness,chronicsubstanceabuse,developmentaldelay,andHIVitself.6

Substanceabusefurthercomplicatesthismentalhealthpicture.WhileoneinfiveAmericanshasasubstanceuseproblem,anestimatedtwooutofthreehomelesspeopledo,7andupto50percentofpeoplewhoarehomelesshaveco-occurringmentalhealthandsubstanceusedisorders.4

FOCUSAGuideto ResearchandCounselingMarch2006 v21n3

A Bio-Psycho-Social-Spiritual Approach to HIV and HomelessnessBarry Zevin, MD

Page 2: Focusv21n3 a bio psycho social spiritual approach to hiv and homelessness

Post-traumaticstressdisorderisanothercommon,yetoftenunrecognized,problem.Inonestudyofhomelesswomen,almost90percentreportedhavingbeenviolentlyvic-timizedatsomepointintheirlives.8Home-lessmen,especiallythosewithmentalhealthdisorders,havesimilarlyhighratesofvictim-ization.Despitebeingstereotypedasdanger-ousorviolent,homelesspeopleare,infact,amongthemostfrequentvictimsofviolence.

Experiencesoftrauma,loss,fear,andshameshapethebehaviorandqualityoflifeofmanyhomelesspeople,narrowingthescopeoflivingtomeresurvival.Yetprovid-ersoftenunderestimatetherolethatshameplaysinthebehaviorofhomelessclients,especiallyshamerelatedtoHIVorHIVrisk-relatedsubstanceuseorsexualbehaviors. Further,providersmaymistakeaclient’sshame-basedavoidanceofcareaspersonalrejectionoralackofconcernforhealth.

Social InfluencesStereotypesabouthomelesspeopleare

pervasiveandmayinterferewithprovidingappropriateservices.Amongthemostcom-monofthesestereotypesarejudgmentsthathomelesspeopleareisolated,violent,unapproachable,lazy,andasexual. Supportsystemsandsocialstructuresforhome-lesspeoplemaybeunconventional,butfewhomelesspeopleareentirelyisolated,andmostprioritizepersonalrelationshipsashighlyashousedpeopledo.Interventionsforhomelesspeoplethatdiscounttheserelationshipsarefrequentlyineffective.

Thesestereotypesalsocontributetotheassumptionthathomelesspeopleareunabletoadheretoantiviralregimens.9However,researchandexperienceattheTomWaddellHealthCenterinSanFranciscohasfoundthatadherenceratesandotheroutcomesarecomparabletohousedpopulations.

Homelesspeopleareoftenunabletoworkduetodiscriminationordisability.Becausethesedisabilitiesareoftenhidden,multiple,anddifficulttoclassify,claimsforbenefitsareofteninitiallyrejected,reinforcingthe

References1. Song JY. HIV/AIDSandHomelessness:RecommendationsforClinicalPracticeandPublicPolicy.Nash-ville: National Health Care for the Home-less Council, 1999.

2. Allen DM, Lehman JS, Green TA, et al. HIV infection among homeless adults and runaway youth, United States, 1989-1992. AIDS. 1994; 8(11): 1593–1598.

3. Cheung AM, Hwang SW. Risk of death among homeless women: A cohort study and review of the literature. Cana-dianMedicalAsso-ciationJournal. 2004; 170(8): 1243–1247.

FOCUS March 2006�

AsBarryZevinpointedoutwhenwefirstdiscussedhisarticleinthisissueofFOCUS, thepublicresponsetohome-lessnesshasparalleledthepub-licresponsetoHIV.Aninitialresponseofconcern,evenasenseofemergency,hasgivenwaytoatoleranceofsuffer-ing,asenseofhopelessness,and“compassionfatigue.”

Onereasonforthisisthefeel-ingthatwearepowerlesstohelp.TheepidemicsofhomelessnessandHIVhaveattimesseemedremarkablyresistanttochange.Anotherreasonisthatforthosestandingoutsidetheepidemics,itiseasytodrawfalsedistinc-tionsbetween“us”and“them.”Weknowthatmanyindividualsandfamiliesarejustapaycheckawayfromhomelessness,butprefertobelievethatthedividinglinebetween“us”and“them”willprotectusfromasimilarfate.

Thetruthisthatmuchofthetime,itdoes.Healthandhousing

domirrorpatternsofclass,race,andotherdemographics.Whileanyonecanbecomehomeless,justasanyonecancontractHIV,somegroupsaremuchmorevulnerabletotheseconditionsthanothers.

Twenty-fiveyearsafterfightingforthepublictorecognizethatAIDSisnotjusta“gay”disease,thetruthisthatnearlyhalfofallAIDScasesinthiscountrystilloccuramongmenwhohavesexwithmen.Many,likeMichaelCooley,theauthorofthesecondarticleinthisissue,areyoungmenatthetimeoftheirinfec-tion.PeopleofcolorarealsodisproportionatelyrepresentedamongboththosewithHIVandthosewhoarehomeless,withAfricanAmericanpeoplerep-resentingalmosthalfofbothhomelessAmericansandpeoplewithAIDSintheUnitedStates.

Inthemiddleclasscommu-nitiesoftherichercountriesoftheworld,HIVincidenceisstable—notdiminishingand

stilllarge,butstable.Agenera-tionofactivismwassuccessfulin“puttingaface”onHIV.Thesuccessledtoashiftfrommoralcondemnationtosocialsupport,fromassigningoutsiderstatustogaypeopleandpeoplewithHIVtoacceptingourcommonhumanity.Itledtomoremoneyforresearch,medicaltreatment,andpsychologicalcare,and,ulti-mately,totheantiviralregimenbreakthroughsofthemid-1990s.Yet,separationsbasedoneco-nomicclassseemmoreresistantthanevertochange,andHIVandhomelessnesscontinuetothriveinourpoorestcommunities.

BothZevin’sandCooley’sarti-clesgiveusachancetoconnectwiththeconcernshomelesspeo-plewithHIVface.Zevinremindsusofthechallengeshomelesspeopleface,andthesmallwayswecanexperienceourhomelessclients’—andourown—humanity.Cooleydescribeshistransforma-tivejourneyfromhomelessnessanddesperationtocommunityandfamilyreconnection.Eachremindsusthatlackingaroofoverourheadsshouldnotmeanlosingourplaceintheworld.

Editorial: A Place in the WorldMichelle Cataldo, Clinical Editor

Page 3: Focusv21n3 a bio psycho social spiritual approach to hiv and homelessness

judgmentthathomelessnessandinabilitytoworkrepresentamoralfailure.Benefits

andresourceadvocacyoffersastrongincentiveforhomelesspeopletoseekcaredespitethesebarriers.Obtainingben-efitsnotonlystabilizesaclient’sfinancialsitu-ation,ithelpstheclientovercomeshame,buildstrustwithproviders,andpromotesbetterhealth.10

Spiritual AspectsInthecourseofassist-

inghomelesspeopleobtainbasicresourcesforsurvival,itiseasytooverlookspiritualcon-cerns—thoseaspectsoflifethatoffermeaningandpurposeandenableapersontotranscendday-to-dayexistence.Home-lesspeoplefacemanyofthesameconflictsaroundidentityandmeaningashousedpeople,but

withaddedchallengesbecausehomelesspeoplearesoseldomtreatedbyothersasvaluable.Theseconflictsincludefindingasenseofpersonalpowerversusgivingupindespair,livinginsilenceandinvisibilityversusmakingconnectionandsharingone’sstory,andseeingoneselfasdependentver-susrecognizingone’scontributiontothecommunity.ReceivinganHIVdiagnosisoftenraisesthestakesoftheseconflicts,changingaperson’sperceptionoflifeandfurtherstimulatingasearchformeaning.

Someprovidersmaybesurprisedthatsomeoftheirclientsexperiencecrisesinthespiritualrealm“justwhenthingsweregoingsowell,”forexample,clientsmovefromhomelessnesstohousingorfromaddic-tiontorecovery.Thesetransitionsinvolvelossesaswellasbenefits,andtheydemandthathomelesspeoplerenegotiateidentityandmeaningastheyrelegateoldsocialnetworksandwaysofbeingtothepast.Again,uncom-fortableemotionsmaysurfaceforclientsjustwhenprovidersassumetheyarehavingtheirgreatestsuccesses.Forexample,aclientmayexperiencelonelinessafterleavinghisorherstreetfamilyforhousing,boredomwhenwithdrawingfromthedramaof“lifeontheedge,”oranxietyinresponsetomemoriesoftraumathatreturnasclientsachievesobriety.

Whenprovidersfailtoaddresstheseissues,clientsmaymanifestincreasingisolation,drugrelapse,inabilitytoadheretomedical

treatment,exacerbationofpsychiatricsymp-toms,hopelessness,andsuicidality.Atten-tiontotheseissues,ontheotherhandcanfosterengagementinthecommunity,greaterself-care,self-expression,andself-worth.

Comprehensive CareEffectiveengagementbeginswithcli-

ent-centeredattention,inanatmosphereofdignityandrespect.Simplyaddressingaclientrespectfullyandshakinghisorherhandmaymakethedifferencebetweenengagementandalienation.Sincemanypeoplehidetheirhomelessnessduetoshameorfear,thesimplequestion,“Whatisyourlivingsituation?”maybelessstig-matizingthanthequestion,“Areyouhome-less?”Attendingtoaclient’smosturgentneeds,includingemergencyhousing,food,andmedicalcare,createsanimmediatebondandthefoundationforaworkingrelationship.Supportivelisteningandfre-quentappointmentsbuildabridgebetweenproviderandclient—evenwhenitfeelsasifnothingconcreteis“accomplished.”

Earlyinthecourseofcare,providerandclientshouldcollaborativelydefinethecli-ent’shealthandlifegoals,andlaterreviewandrevisethesegoalsasnecessary.Thesegoalswillusuallyaddressmedicalandmentalhealthcare,housing,andchoicesaboutdruguse,work,andpossiblyspiri-tualpractices.Askingaclienttodescribehisorhergoalsandreasonsforthemcannaturallyleadtodiscussionsonavarietyofissues,rangingfromwhatsupportthecli-entcanreasonablyexpectfromtheagencytoinformationaboutspiritualvalues.

Talkingwithclientsabouthowtheyspendeachday—andaskingwhotheyhangoutwith,whotheymightaskforhelp,andwhotheycannotaskforhelp—fleshesouttheprofileoftheindividualandhisorhersocialsystem.Providersfrequentlyavoidopportunitiestodevelopafullerpic-turebecauseofinaccurateassumptionsorthefearof“openingacanofworms.”Forexample,providersmayoverlooksexualhistory,becausetheyassumehomelesspeoplearenotsexuallyactiveorsexuallyattractive.Thisisparticularlyproblematicwhenprovidersmissopportunitiesforunderstandingaclient’ssexwork,sur-vivalsex,orsexualdisempowerment.

Inhomelesssheltersandotherprogramsforhomelesspeoplethereisoftensignificantdiscriminationagainstmembersofsexualandgenderidentityminorities.Homelesspeopleoftenconcealtheirsexualorienta-tion,sexualpractices,ortransgenderiden-tityforfearofbeingharassedorassaulted.Manyservicesforhomelesspeopleare

4. Get the facts: Why are so many people with serious mental illnesses homeless? NationalResourceandTrainingCenteronHomelessnessandMentalIllness. 2005; http://www.nrchmi.samhsa.gov/facts/facts_question_3.asp.

5. Cournos F, McKin-non K. HIV Serop-revalence among people with severe mental illness in the United States: A criti-cal review. ClinicalPsychologyReview. 1997; 17(3): 259–269.

6. Spence S, Stevens R, Parks R. Cogni-tive dysfunction in homeless adults: A systematic review. JournaloftheRoyalSocietyofMedicine. 2004; 97(8): 375–379.

7. Burt MR, Aron LY, Douglas T, et al. Homelessness:Pro-gramsandthePeopleTheyServe:Find-ingsoftheNationalSurveyofHomelessAssistanceProvidersandClients. Washing-ton, D.C.: The Urban Institute, 1999.

FOCUS March 2006�

Social structures for homeless

people may be unconventional,

but few homeless people are entirely

isolated. Most prioritize personal

relationships as highly as housed

people do.

Page 4: Focusv21n3 a bio psycho social spiritual approach to hiv and homelessness

organizedorsupportedbyreligiousgroupswithexplicitprejudiceagainstgays,lesbi-ans,andtransgenderpeople.Asthesemaybetheonlyservicesinaparticulararea,individualsmayneedtosuppressidentityandneedsinordertoreceiveservices.

Traumahistoriesareoftenburiedaswell,andsomeprovidersmayavoidexploringtheseareas,concernedthateventalk-ingaboutviolencemaybringoutviolentbehaviorinaclientorrevealproblemsthattheproviderdoesnotfeelqualifiedtohan-dle.Providerscanbenefitfromdiscussingwithsupervisorsorconsultantstheircon-cernsabouttheprocess,timing,andextentofsexualandtraumahistorytaking.

Inevitably,someproblemswillariseforwhichprovidershavenoreadysolutions.Whenthisoccurs,providersstrengthentheircredibilitywithclientsandreducetheirownriskofburnoutbyadmittingtheirownlimitations.Thishonestyalsogivesclientspermissiontogeneratetheirownsuggestionsandmovetowardcollab-orativeproblemsolving.

Multidisciplinary CareMultidisciplinarycare—thecoordina-

tionofmedical,psychological,andsocialserviceproviders—iscriticaltoeffectivetreatmentofhomelesspeopleandcanbeachievedbycoordinatingwithlike-mindedproviderswithinanagencyoracommu-nity. Theinclusionofpeerstaff,consistingofcurrentlyorformerlyhomelesspeople,canalsobeveryeffective.Itisimportanttonotethatpeerworkers,inparticular,needextensivesupportandtrainingtodealwithissuesofboundaries,trauma,theirownpotentialtriggers,andharmreduction.

Agencypoliciesandprocedureshelpdeterminewhetherhomelesspeopleper-ceiveservicesasaccessibleorexclusionary.Forexample,flexibilityinschedulingand

drop-inavailabilitygreatlyreducesbarri-erstocareforhomelesspeople.Limitingthenumberofpersonnelwhointeractwithanindividual—forexample,byassigningeachclienttoacasemanagerandaprimarypointpersonineachareaofcare—canhelpcreateasupportivefamilyorcommunity-likemilieuthatincreasesaclient’scomfortandtrustandreducesconfusionandser-viceduplication.Clientswithsomementalillnessesandcognitiveimpairmentmayespeciallybenefitfromanintensive,long-lastingsupportivecasemanagementrela-tionshipinwhichdiscussionsandinstruc-tionsarekeptsimpleandarerepeated.6

Itiscriticaltomatchahomelessclient’spotentialhousingsituationtohisorherneedsandcapacitiesandplanforpos-siblesetbacks.Substancerecoverypro-gramoptionsandmoneymanagementandevictionpreventionservicescanhelpclientsmaintainhousing,althoughsomeclientsperceivetheseservicesasintru-sive.Inresponse,carefulredirectionbacktocollaborativelydevelopedgoalscanbehelpful,sincetheultimategoalisnotonlyhousing,butthecreationofastablehome.Thismayrequireservicesthatsupportlearninglifeskills,andprovidestructure,creativework,andanoppor-tunityto“giveback”tothecommunity.

ConclusionAcomprehensive,integratedapproach

addressesthemultiplephysical,logistical,andpsychologicalbarrierstoHIV-relatedhealthcare,mentalhealthcare,andpreven-tionforhomelesspeople.Whilethedivisionsbetweentheseaspectsofawholehumanbeingareultimatelyartificial,examiningeachaspectseparatelycreatesaframeworkforanintegratedapproach,onethatcanhelpprovidersprioritizetheoftenoverwhelmingproblemsintheirhomelessclients’lives.

8. Bassuk EL, Buckner JC, Perloff JN, et al. Prevalence of mental health and substance use disorders among homeless and low-income housed moth-ers. AmericanJournalofPsychiatry. 1998; 155(11): 1561–1564.

9. Moss AR, Hahn JA Perry S, et al. Adher-ence to highly active antiretroviral therapy in the homeless popu-lation in San Fran-cisco: A prospective study. ClinicalInfec-tiousDiseases. 2004; 39(8): 1190–1198.

10. Riley ED, Moss AR, Clark RA, et al. Cash benefits associ-ated with lower risk behavior among the homeless and margin-ally housed in San Francisco. JournalofUrbanHealth. 2005; 82(1): 142–150.

AuthorBarry Zevin, MD is Medical Director of Tom Waddell Health Center, the largest provider of homeless healthcare in San Francisco. He is a primary care physi-cian, credentialed as an HIV special-ist, and certified in addiction medicine.

FOCUS March 2006�

ReferencesConananB,LondonK,MartinezL,etal.Adapting Your Practice: Treatment and Recommendations for Homeless Patients with HIV/AIDS. Nashville,Tenn.:HealthCarefortheHomelessClinicians’Network,NationalHealthCarefortheHomelessCouncil,Inc.,2003;http://www.nhchc.org/Pub-lications/HIVguide52703.pdf.

ConnorA.EncouragingHIVrisk-reduc-tionbehaviorsandtestingwithpeople

experiencinghomelessness.Journal of Nursing Education. 2003;42(3):138–141.

CulhaneDP,GollubE,KuhnR,etal.Theco-occurrenceofAIDSandhomelessness:Resultsfromtheinte-grationofadministrativedatabasesforAIDSsurveillanceandpublicshelterutilizationinPhiladelphia.Journal of Epidemiology and Com-munity Health.2001;55(7):515–520.

DeRosaCJ,MontgomerySB,HydeJ,etal.HIVriskbehaviorandHIVtesting:A

comparisonofratesandassociatedfac-torsamonghomelessandrunawayado-lescentsintwocities.AIDS Education and Prevention.2001;13(2):131–148.

DouaihyAB,StowellKR,BuiT,etal.HIV/AIDSandhomelessness,Part1:Backgroundandbarrierstocare.AIDS Reader. 2005;15(10):516–520.

EbnerDL,LaviageMM.TheparalleluniverseofhomelessandHIV-posi-tiveyouth.Seminars in Pediatric Infec-tious Diseases. 2003;14(1):32–37.

HahnJA,BangsbergDR,McFarlandW,etal.HIVseroconversionamongthehomelessandmarginallyhousedinSanFrancisco:Aten-yearstudy.Jour-

Clearinghouse: Homelessness and HIV

Page 5: Focusv21n3 a bio psycho social spiritual approach to hiv and homelessness

AslongasIcanremember,myrelation-shipwithmydadwasstrained.PeoplealwaysaskifitisbecauseI’mgay,butitgoesbackfurther.In1973,whenIwasconceived,myfatherwas17andinthearmy,andmyhalfbrotherswerethreeandfour.MydadleftmymomsoonafterIwasborn.WhenIwasseven,rampantalcohol-ismfinallycaughtupwithmymother.Shebecameveryillandcouldnolongertakecareofme,soshesentmetolivewithmyfatherandhisnewwife.

In1991whenIwasalmost17,Iwaskickedoutofmyfather’shomeinPrunedale,aruraltownincen-tralCalifornia.Istayedwithvari-ousfriendsforayear,butkeptthinkingaboutSanFrancisco.ItwasthegayMecca;IhadseenthePrideParadeontelevision.Ihaddroppedoutofhighschoolaftermyjunioryear,soIcametothecitywithoutahighschooleducationandwithnoplacetostay.

Ihadneverlivedinacitybefore.Iwasusedtoroosterscrowing,horses,theslowerpaceofaquietcommunity.Nooneeverspoketomeabouthowto

findwork,howtofindfood,howtolive.Iwasonmyownwithoutahome.

Waiting for a PlaceIfoundaphoneboothandcalledthe

nationalrunawayhotline.TheytoldmetogotoasocialserviceprogramforyouthintheTenderloin,butwhenIgotthere,theprogramstaffsaidIhadtobeunder18togetaplace,andIhadjustturned18.TheTenderloinisintheheartofSanFrancisco’sredlightdistrict—aneighborhoodwhereyouhadtohave“streetsmarts”inordertomakeit.IfIhadhadstreetsmartsIwould

haveliedandsaidIwas17,becauseitwouldhavemeantIwouldhavehadaplacetostayforafewdays.Instead,Itoldthetruthandwasgiventwofoodvouchersandsentonmyway.Thiswasacriticalmomentwhenanintervention—likegettingintoayouthsheltereventhoughIwas18—wouldhavekeptmeoffofthestreets.

Iwasdevastatedandhungry,soIwalkedtoataqueriaonPolkStreet.Iwasfasci-natedbythestreetlifepassingby.Iwasn’tusedtoelectric-blueMohawks,thepunks,theskaters,thecrack-

heads,thequeerhustlerboys,twoorthreeofthemoneverycorner.

Iwenttoadrop-inspaceintheheartoftheTenderloin.Anow-defunctyouthpro-gramexistedintheirbasement.Thesmellcanonlybedescribedas“homeless”:acombinationofsweat,feet,dog,cigarettes,

FOCUS March 2006�

nal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome. 2004;37(5):1616–1619.

Healthcareforthehomelessresourcecenter.Bureau of Primary Health Care. Rockville,Md.:HealthResourcesandServicesAdministration,2006;http://www.bphc.hrsa.gov/hchirc/about/default.htm.

LevounisP,GalanterM,DermatisH,etal.CorrelatesofHIVtransmissionriskfactorsandconsiderationsforinterven-tionsinhomeless,chemicallyaddictedandmentallyillpatients.Journal of Addictive Diseases. 2002;21(3):61-72.

LinnJG,NeffJA,TheriotR,etal.Reach-ingimpairedpopulationswithHIV

preventionprograms:AclinicaltrialforhomelessmentallyillAfrican-Americanmen.Cellular and Molecu-lar Biology. 2003;49(7):1167-1175.

HCHResearchUpdates.National Health Care for the Homeless Council. Nash-ville,Tenn.:NationalHealthCarefortheHomelessCouncil,2006;http://www.nhchc.org/researchupdates.html.

RobertsonMJ,ClarkRA,CharleboisED,etal.HIVseroprevalenceamonghomelessandmarginallyhousedadultsinSanFrancisco.American Journal of Public Health.2004;94(7):1207-1217.

SurrattHL,InciardiJA.HIVrisk,sero-positivityandpredictorsofinfection

amonghomelessandnon-homelesswomensexworkersinMiami,Florida,USA.AIDS Care. 2004;16(5):594-604.

ContactsBarryZevin,MD,TomWaddellHealthCenter,50IvyStreet,SanFrancisco,CA94102,415-355-7400,[email protected](e-mail).

MichaelCooley,STOPAIDSProject,212815thStreet,SanFrancisco,CA94114,Telephone:415-575-0150,ext.225,[email protected](e-mail).

See also references cited in articles in this issue.

Homeless in the Age of AIDS Michael Cooley

I went to a hospitality house in the heart of the Tenderloin.

The smell can only be described as “homeless”: a

combination of sweat, feet, dog, cigarettes,

and alcohol.

Page 6: Focusv21n3 a bio psycho social spiritual approach to hiv and homelessness

andalcohol.Anne,acasemanager,saiditwouldbeamonthorsobeforeIcouldgetabedatahalfwayhouseforyouth.SinceIhadalreadystayedthemaximumnumberofnightsattheSalvationArmy,Iwasgoingtohavetostayonthestreets.

Iimmediatelybegantointegrateintostreet-life.ThefriendsImadequickly showedmehowtomakethebestofit.Isleptin“squats,”usuallyinaburned-outbuildingorconstructionsite,butIwasalwaysonthemove.Thepolicewouldchaseusout,andwewouldwaitafewdaysandcomeback.Wehadnowhereelsetogo.OnenightIcamedownwiththefluandwastooweaktogetoutofthe“squat”togetfood.Mynewfriendsbroughtmeabaggedlunchfromamis-sionarydoingoutreachonPolkStreetthatnight.Theytookcareofme.

Aftertwomonths,Igotaplaceinthehalfwayhouse.WhileIwasthere,thestaffencouragedmetotakemyhighschoolequivalencytest.Abouttwomonthslater,Iwenttoschoolforpracticetestsanddidsowellthattheinstructoraskedmetotaketheofficialtestrightthen.Ipassedthat,too.

Really Homeless ThenImetthemanofmydreams.

Randywasanewguyatthehouse,andwebegandating.Whenthehousecasemanag-ersfoundout,theysaidwe’dhavetostopseeingeachother—itwasahouserule—orwe’dhavetoleave.IfIhadtodoitalloveragain,Iwouldhavestayedinthehouse.Butrightthen,itfeltasifthisrelationshipwasthemostimportantthingintheworld.Ididn’tknowwhattherealityofbeingwithRandywouldmeanoncewewerebackonthestreetsagain.Randywasaveteranhustlerandspeedaddict.HehadacasemanageratahomelessyouthagencythatservedHIV-positiveclients.Hemanagedtotalkthecasemanagerintolettingmepaytheextra$5.00adaytostayinarat-infested,run-downhotelonSixthStreet.

IlearnedfromRandyhowtohustle,whattosaywhennegotiatingpaymenttokeepfromincriminatingmyselfincaseIwastalkingtoacop,and,oh,alsohowtoshootupcrystalmeth.Thiswasthebeginningofmytrulyhomelessdays,scratchingtosurviveanddreadingthethoughtofgivingmybodyuptolonely,needymenwhoweresodesperateforattentionthatIcouldn’teventrytorespectthem.Ihatedthem.

Ibeganusingspeedtogetmetothecor-neranditwasspeedthatkeptmethere.Randywasgoneafterafewmonths,andIwasstilllookingforwaystopaymyrentandgethigh.Ifoundsupportinanetwork

ofotherdrugaddicts;wewerealloutcasts.EverytimeIgottestedforHIV,Iknewthatifthetestcamebackpositive,Iwouldhave aplacetolive.Ididn’twanttobeHIV-posi-tive,buteveryonearoundmealreadyhadit.Itseemedlikeitwasonlyamatteroftime.

Myvisitstothetestsiteswereunre-markable.Idon’trememberreallyworkingonawaytoreducemyrisk.Itwouldn’thavematteredanyway,sinceIletthe“Johns”dictatewhatweweregoingtodo.IfIswallowedIcouldgetmoremoney;ifIgotfucked,itwasalotmoremoney.Weneverdiscussedcondoms,andIwasinnopositiontomakedemands.

Living with HIVImetBobbysometimeafterIturned19.

Hewas36andaspeeddealer.Bobbypaidforahotelroomformefortwomonths,andIwantedfornothing.IeventuallymovedinwithhiminasmallhomeintheEastBay.Wespentthenexttwoyears“play-inghouse.”

WhenIwas21,Bobbyreplacedmewithhisnextboy-toy.Iwasbackonthestreets.Itestedagain,andthistimeIwasHIV-positive.BecauseIhadHIV,newresourceswereavail-able,andI gotintoahotelroomthatverynight,happytohavearoofovermyhead.

IspentthenextfewyearsseeingRon,acasemanager.Ronalwaystolditlikeitwas:IwouldneedtostopthedrugsifIwantedtodoanythingbuthustletricksorselldope.Lookingback,Irealizethatalthoughitwashelpfultohaveaplacetostay,Iwasstillinthedrugenvironment.Usingtheclinicformedicalcareandfoodservicessavedmylife,butitalsoallowedmetospendallmyownmoneyondrugs.

A Moment of ClarityRonwasright.Thiswasnolifeforme.Twothingshappenedthatdrovemeinto

treatment.Thefirstthinghasscarredmeforlife.IwasrobbedandseverelybeatenbyalocaldrugdealerwhoknewIwasaneasytarget.Afterthat,Icouldn’tsleepor

FOCUS March 2006�

Comments and Submissions We invite readers to send letters

respondingtoarticlespublishedinFOCUSordealingwithcurrentAIDSresearchandcounselingissues.Wealsoencourageread-erstosubmitarticleproposals.Sendcor-respondencetorob.marks@ucsf.eduortoEditor,FOCUS,UCSFAIDSHealthProject,Box0884,SanFrancisco,CA94143-0884.

Page 7: Focusv21n3 a bio psycho social spiritual approach to hiv and homelessness

eatbecauseIwasafraidofgettingbeatenagain.IhidinmyhouseuntilnighttimesothatIcouldsneaktothestoretobuyfood.Iknewmylifehadtochange.IcalledRon,whowasabletogetmeintoaninpatientalcoholanddrugtreatment facilitythenextMonday.That’sright,treatment-on-demandwasoneofthereasonsI’malivetoday.

ThesecondthingwasthatIwashav-ingtroublebreathing.Iwasinthealco-holanddrugtreatment facilityfor10daysbeforeitwasclearthatIdidnothaveacold.Iwasdriventotheemer-gencyroom,andthedoctorsaidthat,ifIhadwaitedanotherday,I“wouldnothavecomethroughthefrontdoor.”

IhadPneumocystis carinii pneumonia,sotheyhookedmeuptoanoxygenmaskandputmeonantibioticsthatmademeverysick.Iwasshaking,throwingup,andsweatingthrougheverysheetandblan-ket.IthoughtIwasgoingtodie,andIwasn’tready.“It’snotfair,”Ithought.Iwas23yearsold,andIhadwhattheycallinthe 12-stepworld,a“momentofclarity.”Icallitanepiphany.IfIwasgoingtolive,Icouldn’tdoitandgethigh.

IspentEasterandmybirthdayontheAIDSwardatthecity’sgeneralhospital.Iwrotetomydadandstep-momforthefirsttimesincetheykickedmeout.Itseemedsolongago;Iwondered:whatwouldtheythink?Ididnotcare.Iwantedthemtounderstandtheconsequencesofkick-ingmeout,andIwantedthemtohurttoo.Ihopedtheywouldbeupsetandfeelguilty.Instead,theydroveupandtoldmethattheylovedmeverymuch.

Wedidnotspeakofthepastverymuch.Iwantedarelationshipwiththem—anyrelationship—evenifitmeantthatwewereindenialaboutourexperiencestogether.IknewIcouldn’tchangethepast,butIcouldliveinthepresent,andthatincludedanewrelationshipwithmyparents.Bobbyalsocametovisitmeinthehospital,andtoldmethathe,too,hadpneumoniaandhadbeenhospitalized.He

diedshortlyafterthat.Hejustcouldn’tputthedrugsdown.IhadanotherveryrealexampleoftheconsequencesofdruguseandAIDStokeepmeonmynewpath.

ConclusionIhaven’tusedsinceMarch21,1997.I

amgratefultobealive.IwouldnothavestoppedusingifIhadn’talmostdiedofAIDS,soIwelcomeHIVintomylife.

Iwenttoatradeschoolshortlyafterdrugtreatmenttolearnaboutcomput-ersandgeneralofficeskills,thengotajobatacreditcardcompanyansweringphones.Itwasthebeginningofareallife.Ayearintomynewjob,Igotsickandhad

totakefourdaysoff.IhadnevertoldmyemployeraboutmyHIVbecauseIdidn’twanttobetreateddif-ferently,butIneededadoctor’snoteforworkandhadtocomeoutaboutwhyIhadbeensick.Iwasveryupsetabouthavingtodisclosemystatus,andwenttoseeRonattheyouthcentertotalkaboutit.Hesaidmytimingwasgreat:theyhadanadminis-trativepositionopenandifIgotsick,theywouldunderstand.

WithinayearIwasthefirstpeeradvocateatayouthcenter.Ibegandoingstreetoutreach,HIVtesting,andgroupfacilitation.Overthe

lasteightyears,IhavebeenworkingtoimprovethequalityoflifeofotherHIV-positiveguyslikeme:Ihavewatchedsomeclientsgetoutof“thelife”andotherswhohavenotbeensolucky.

ThesedaysIspendmytimethink-ingaboutwhatdriveshumanbehaviorandhowwecanchangethecourseofHIVinourcommunity.Theonlyremark-ablethingaboutthisdiseaseisthatitistransmittedsexually,sowecarrythebaggageandstigmaaroundoursexualityintomakingsafersexdecisions.Today,myjobistotrytoreducethosestigmas,whichsoundssimple,butlikeallhumanbehaviorchange,itisincrediblychal-lenging.Ihavefoundmycallinginlife,Ihaveauniqueperspective,andI’mgladtohavethischancetomakeadifference.

AuthorMichael Cooley is the Prevention with Positives Program Manager at the STOP AIDS Project and a member of the San Francisco HIV Preven-tion Planning Council.

FOCUS March 2006�

I wanted them to understand the

consequences of kicking me out, and I wanted them to hurt

too. I hoped they would be upset and

feel guilty. Instead, they drove up and told me that they

loved me very much.

Page 8: Focusv21n3 a bio psycho social spiritual approach to hiv and homelessness

Homelessness and Antiretroviral AdherenceWaldrop-Valverde D, Valverde E. Homelessness and psychological distress as contributors to antiretroviral nonadherence in HIV-positive injecting drug users. AIDS Patient Care and STDs. 2005; 19(5): 326–334. (University of Miami.)

In his overview article, Barry Zevin identi-fies obstacles to HIV antiviral drug adherence among people who are homeless. But he also notes that there is evidence that appropri-ate medical care can lead to good medical outcomes, including high levels of adher-ence, within this population. This University of Miami study, which focuses on a variety of factors that may affect injection drug users’ adherence levels, did not find a connection between homelessness and nonadherence.

Depressionmaybeamorepotentindi-catorthanhomelessnessofHIVantiviralmedicationnonadherenceamonginjectiondrugusers.

Highlevelsofadherencetoantiretrovi-ralmedicationsarerequiredtomaximizetherapeuticbenefitsandviralsuppres-sion.Injectiondruguseisassociatedwithdecreasedadherencelevels,unstablelivingconditions,andmentalhealthproblems.

Despitetheprevalenceofthesenonadher-encerisksamongHIV-positiveinjectiondrugusers,therehasbeenlittlestudyassessingtheimpactofhomelessnessandpsychologi-caldistressonadherenceinthispopulation.Thisstudyevaluatedtheeffectsofhousingstatus(homelessandmarginallyhousedver-susnonhomeless)andpsychologicaldistress,measuredviadepression,anxiety,andper-ceivedstress,onself-reportedadherencein58HIV-positiveinjectiondrugusers.

HomelessandmarginallyhousedHIV-positiveinjectiondrugusersreportedhigherlevelsofanxietyandperceivedstressthantheirnonhomelesscounter-parts.Thegroupsreportedsimilarlevelsofdepression.However,onlydepressionwassignificantlyrelatedtoadherence.Housingstatus,drugoralcoholuse,andotherdemographicvariablesincludinggender,raceandethnicity,andyearsofeducation,werenotassociatedwithadher-ence.Thestudyalsofoundarelativelyhighrateofadherenceinhomelessandmarginallyhousedinjectiondrugusers,with63percentofthesesubjectsreportingperfect(100percent)adherencelevels.

Homeless Youth and HIV RiskWagner LS, Carlin L, Cauce AM, et al. A snapshot of homeless youth in Seattle: Their characteristics,

behaviors and beliefs about HIV protective strategies. Journal of Community Health. 2001; 26(3): 219–232. (University of San Francisco; University of Washing-ton, Seattle; and National Youth Advocacy Coalition.)

Homeless youth may have an especially high risk of contracting HIV. This Seattle-based study complements Michael Cooley’s memoir by reporting on the experiences and beliefs regarding the HIV risk of homeless youth.

KnowledgeofHIVprotectivestrategiesdifferedbysexualorientation,accord-ingtothislargeSeattlestudyofyoungpeople.Heterosexualyouthhadtheweak-estknowledgeofHIVprotectionstrategies,especiallycomparedwithyoungmenwhohavesexwithmen.

Researchersinterviewed272homelessyouthinordertodeterminehowinitialHIVpreventioneffortswerereceivedandtoassesswaysthattheyouth’sbeliefsandbehaviorscontinuedtoputthematriskforHIVinfection.Themeanageforthe169maleyouthwas18;themeanageforthe103femaleyouthwas16.Mostidentifiedashet-erosexual,but20percentidentifiedasgayorlesbianand17percentidentifiedasbisexual.

Youthreportedusingcondomswithcasualpartnersduringvaginalandanalsexand,amongthoseengagedinsexwork,withclientsduringoral,anal,andvaginalsex.Condomswereoftennotusedduringvaginalsexwithmainpartnersorduringoralsexwithcasualormainpartners.

FOCUS March 2006�

Next IssueResearchhasidentifiedtrauma,the

resultofeitherorbothsexualandphysi-calabuse,asakeyfactorinfluencingthebehaviorsmostlikelytoresultinHIVtransmission.Studieshavealsoidenti-fiedhighratesoftraumaandpost-trau-maticstressdisorder—thespecificcon-stellationofpsychologicalsymptomsthatcanresultfromtraumaticexperi-ences—amongpeoplewithHIV.IntheAprilissue,Deborah J. Brief, PhD, As-sistantProfessorofPsychiatryatBostonUniversity,reviewstheliteratureontheprevalenceandmanifestationsoftraumaandPTSDamongpeoplewithHIV.

AlsointheAprilissue,Nathan B. Han-sen, PhD,AssistantClinicalProfessorofPsychiatry,andKathleen J. Sikkema, PhD,AssociateProfessorofEpidemiol-ogy,bothatYaleUniversity,describetherangeofapproachesavailabletotreat PTSDandtheapplicationofthesestrat-egiestopeoplelivingwithHIV.

FOCUSFOCUSAGuidetoAIDSResearchandCounseling

Executive Editor; Director, AIDS Health Project James W. Dilley, MD

Editor Robert Marks

Clinical Editor Michelle Cataldo, LCSW

Recent Reports Rachel Billow

Founding Editor Michael Helquist

Medical Advisor Stephen Follansbee, MD

Design Saul Rosenfield

Production Suzy Brady Carrel Crawford Jennifer J. Regan Lisa Roth

Circulation Jennifer J. Regan

FOCUS, published 10 times a year, is a publication of the AIDS Health Project, affiliated with the University of California San Francisco.

Ten issues of FOCUS cost: Individual: Paper–$48; Paper Outside U.S.–$60; Electronic–$36 (inside and outside U.S.); Both Formats

–$58; Both Formats Outside U.S.–$70; Limited Income

–$24 for either format and $30 for both formats. Institutional: Paper–$105; Paper Outside U.S.–$125; Electronic–$90 (inside and outside U.S.); Both Formats–$120; Both Formats Outside the U.S.–$140. Make checks payable to “UC Regents.” Address subscription requests and correspondence to: FOCUS, UCSF AIDS Health Project, Box 0884, San Francisco, CA 94143-0884. For a list of back issues and information about cost, write to the above address, call (415) 502-4930, or e-mail [email protected].

To ensure uninterrupted delivery, send new address four weeks before you move.

Printed on recycled paper.

©2006 UC Regents: All rights reserved.

ISSN 1047-0719

Recent Reports

Page 9: Focusv21n3 a bio psycho social spiritual approach to hiv and homelessness

DID YOU KNOW?FREE searchable archive

You can access a FREE searchable archive of back issues of this publication online! Visit http://www.ucsf-ahp.org/HTML2/archivesearch.html.

You can also receive this and other AHP journals FREE, at the moment of publication, by becoming an e-subscriber. Visit http://ucsf-ahp.org/epubs_registration.php for more information and to register!

ABOUT UCSF AIDS HeAlTH PrOjeCT PUBlICATIOnS

The AIDS Health Project produces periodicals and books that blend research and practice to help front-line mental

health and health care providers deliver the highest quality HIV-related counseling and mental health care. For more

information about this program, visit http://ucsf-ahp.org/HTML2/services_providers_publications.html.