First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in...

37
First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University The case for making human mouse chimeras to understand the function of human tissue stem cells from normal or genetically diseased donors

Transcript of First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in...

Page 1: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

First in human:Irv Weissman,

Stanford University

The case for making human

mouse chimeras to understand

the function of human tissue stem

cells from normal or genetically

diseased donors

Page 2: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

Blood-Forming Stem Cells

Ludwig Center at Stanford University

IN VIVO

VERITAS

1 Development

2 Maintenance

3 Malignant

transformation

Page 3: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

Engraftment of human fetal blood-forming

tissues in the SCID mouse

Bruno Peault

Ethics and politics in 1986-88

, Mike McCune, Reiko Namikawa, Ann Tsukamoto Irv Weissman

Page 4: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

Cancer Free Stem Cell Grafts

Improves Survival • Purified HSC show 3-fold higher survival vs non-purified MPB

• Stage 4 metastatic patients – failed all other therapies

~7%

~22%

~33%

Mueller,A. et al. 2011

ChemoRes

Stanford HSC

Stanford MPB

P< .02

P<.01

Page 5: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

• Donor blood-forming and immune system

• Induce permanent transplant tolerance

• Reverse genetic autoimmune disease

Healthy Donor Transplant

Healthy Donor

Recipient

MPB or bone marrow

Pure stem cells

• Dependent on

Immunosuppressants

• Risk of Infections

(fungus, bacteria)

Recipient

Recipient

Recipient

T cells

Graft vs Host Disease Healthy

RADIATION DAMAGE OR THERAPY

GvH No GvH

Shizuru, Beilhack, Weissman

Page 6: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

HSC Transplants In The Future

• Limited or no use of radiation or cytotoxic

drugs

• Targeted removal of host HSC, T cells,

and NK cells with Mabs

• In the far future [>5-10 years], ES or iPS

derived HSC will be cotransplanted with

other tissue stem cells from the same

donor line

Page 7: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

Print

02/16/99 1

Can Tissue Stem Cells Transdifferentiate?

Pluripotent stem cell

CNS-SC

Neurons Oligo-

dendrocytes

Astrocytes

HSC

Blood

PSC

Trans-differentiate

Differentiate

OR

Dedifferentiate

Cardiac

or

Skeletal

or

Lung

Trans-differentiate

NO! NO!

Page 8: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

Human CNS-SC Neurosphere Cells Engrafted, Migrated &

Differentiated Into Neurons, Astrocytes and Oligodendrocytes

In Vitro Expansion

Transplantation

Dopaminergic

Neuron

Astrocytes Neurons Oligodendrocytes

Cerebellum

Cerebral Cortex

Immunodeficient mouse brain

Uchida et al

x

Page 9: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

Human cells derived from HuCNS-SC transplant (brown)

RMS

Migrating as

chain of neuroblasts

b-tubulin III/ Human nuclei

Proliferation at neurogeneic site

SVZ

BrdU/Human Nuclei

Site appropriate differentiation

Into Granule Neurons in the olfactory bulb

HuCNS-SC Engraft, Migrate & Mature

Page 10: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

SC121

Olig2

MBP

Animal Studies: Production of Function Myelin

MBP

Oligodendrocyte

differentiation – new

functional myelin

Myelin enhanced nerve

conduction

MRI used to detect human

myelination in animals

Uchida, et al. 2012

16-20 dense lines

Page 11: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

• Progressive and fatal X-linked hypomyelination disorder due

to mutations of the proteolipid protein gene, PLP1

• No current therapy - regenerating oligodendrocyte

population alone could produce clinical benefit

• Recognized as appropriate human target for proof-of-

concept of donor-derived myelination in non-inflammatory

setting

• Diagnosis readily confirmed affording opportunity for early

intervention

• MRI measures of de novo myelination available as potential

surrogate markers of engraftment and function

Hypomyelination Disease:

Pelizaeus-Merzbacher Disease (PMD)

Page 12: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

Well-tolerated intervention with a favorable safety profile

Signs of clinical changes detected suggest a departure from

the natural history of disease

MRI findings consistent with de novo myelination in the

transplanted frontal lobe regions in all four subjects

Phase I strongly supports a controlled Phase II trial in PMD

MRI data in a human hypomyelination disorder suggests

potential applicability to other myelination disorders, such as

select forms of cerebral palsy, spinal cord injury, transverse

myelitis, and multiple sclerosis

Phase I PMD: Summary of results

Page 13: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

Pre 1 2 3 4 5 6 8 14 12

8

10

12

14

Weeks Post Injury

Open Field

BBB Score

(0-18)

* * * * *

HuCNS-SC (n=11)

Control (n=15)

Repeated Measures ANOVA p<0.01

* individual time points p<0.05

16

HuCNS-SC: Spinal Cord Injury Preclinical Efficacy

30day Delay DT

Treatment

Loss of

Gained

Function

Contusion site

A. Anderson UC, Irvine

Page 14: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

Extensive engraftment with CNS SC,

local deposit with MSC; both DT sens

Page 15: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

• Favorable interim safety and feasibility

• AIS A (n=3) cohort enrolled

• No adverse events attributed to HuCNS-SC

• Observed changes in light touch sensation support safety

• Quantitative Perception Testing shows segmental gains

• No evidence of electrophysiological loss

• AIS B cohort enrolling; AIS B dosed Sept 2012

Phase I/II SCI: Interim Results

Subject ASIA Grade ASIA Spinal

Level

Months Post

Txp

001 A T8 17

002 A T9 15

003 A T4 14

Page 16: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

normal

impaired

absent

Subject 3:

Light touch examination

Jun 28 12 (6m Post-TX) Dec 12 11 (Pre-TX)

© StemCells, Inc. 2012

Page 17: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

HuCNS-SC Clinical Trial Summary

Study N Cell Dose(s) Location Current Follow-up

Lysosomal

Storage

Disease (NCL) 6 500 to 1000 x 106

BRAIN:

Frontal lobe

Parietal lobe

Lateral ventricle

> 5 years

(n=3)

Myelin Disorder

(PMD) 4 300 x 106

BRAIN:

Frontal lobe > 2 years

(n=4)

Spinal Cord

Injury 4/12 20 x 106

SPINAL CORD

thoracic

intramedullary

AIS A > 1 year

(n=3)

AIS B 4 months (n=1)

Retinal

Degeneration

(dry AMD)

2/16 0.2 to 1 x 106 EYE:

subretinal space 2 to 4 months

(n=2)

Page 18: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

Lessons learned to date • Choice of animal models on target

• Animal models have been very good predictors; to date

recapitulating in humans what we have seen in animal models

• Safety profile show no concerns to date

• Metric for calculating dose choices seem to be working

• Small uncontrolled studies on patients

• Preliminary evidence of HuCNS-SC biological activity in

transplanted patients reflect what we have seen in animal models

to date

• Accumulating long-term safety (1-5yrs), sustained biological

effects

Page 19: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

It’s the cells, stu…

Page 20: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

The human neuron-murine brain

mouse • Several mutations allow early neural precursors,

perhaps radial glia, to proliferate, but neuron

lineage progeny die or disappear: ligase 4 dko,

xrcc4 dko, etc.

• Will same stage human neural stem/progenitors

engraft in fetal life and make mouse or human

nervous systems, if they work at all?

• Bioethics: The American Journal of Bioethics,

2007.Thinking About the Human Neuron

Mouse.Henry T. Greely; Mildred K. Cho; Linda

F. Hogle; Debra M. Satz

Page 21: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

WHICH OF THE FOLLOWING

NEURAL DISEASES DO YOU

NOT WANT TO CURE? • Lysosomal storage diseases(Battens,

Gauchers, etc)

• Brain cancers

• Spinal cord contusion with demyelination

• Stroke

• ALS

• Parkinsons

• Alzheimers

• Huntington’s

• Cerebral palsy

• Others I forgot since medical school

Page 22: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

Single –cell

embryo ~ Day 6 ~ Day 3-4

Embryonic

Stem Cell

Totipotent

Epiblast

Stem Cell

Pluripotent

First tissue stem

cells

Embryo – Fetal Transition

Somatic / adult stem

cell Multipotent

Cord blood &

placenta

Hematopoietic (HSC)

&

Mesenchymal (MSC)

Other tissue

stem cells

Reprogrammed iPS Pluripotent

Page 23: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

Phase I Study:

HuCNS-SC derived myelination

Diffusion MRI shows HuCNS-SC-derived myelination in all PMD subjects: 1

year post-transplant and 3 months post-withdrawal of immunosuppression

Gupta, et al. 2012

Control

ROIs

Transplant

ROI

Page 24: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

Subject 3: EPT and dSSEP (T7 Left)

Dec 12 ‘11

Pre-txp Jun 28 ‘12

6m post-txp

© StemCells, Inc. 2012

Page 25: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

• Purified, expandable & cryopreservable

• Self-renewing, non-tumorigenic

• Allogeneic – homologous use into

brain, spinal cord or eye

• In vivo – CNS restricted

• survive & migrate

• regulated by host

• differentiate site specific

• Mechanism-of-action: multi-faceted

• Cell replacement with proper type:

oligodendrocytes, neurons, astrocytes

• Neuroprotection of host cells: trophic

effects by secreted factors

HuCNS-SC cell attributes and clinical translation

Neurons Astrocytes Oligodendrocytes

Page 26: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

Subject 1

(16m)

Tracheostomy and gastrostomy at baseline. Remained neurologically stable, but was noted to have reduced nightly

continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) at 12 months. Increased FA by MRI.

Subject 2

(42m)

Developed improved truncal support and the ability to take steps with assistance.

Began speaking audible single words and the ability to follow two-step commands.

Increased FA by MRI.

Subject 3

(14m)

Tracheostomy and gastrostomy at baseline. Nightly CPAP dependency reduced.

Developed upper extremity antigravity strength and to take some solid foods by mouth.

Greatest increase in FA by MRI; but comparable to “control” regions.

Subject 4

(66m)

Developed improved truncal support; progressed from the use of a walker with significant support to walking with minimal assistance.

Developed the ability for self-feeding and to follow two-steps commands. Increased FA by MRI.

Clinical and Radiological Observations in PMD

Patients Post Transplant

Page 27: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

Study Outcome

Animal

(thoracic SCI mice)

Locomotor improvement dependent on

presence of human cells

Remyelination & new neurons

Human – Phase I/II

Thoracic injury

chronic

12 mo. interim results: AIS-A

No safety concerns to date

Observed changes in light touch sensation

supporting safety

No evidence of electrophysiological loss

Clinical signs of sensory gains

Spinal Cord Injury

Page 28: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

• Swissmedic authorized

• 12 patients with thoracic injury (tSCI)

• Injury level: T2-T11

• Chronic injury stage: 3-12 months post-injury

• Broad range of injuries: AIS A, B, C

• Significant cell dose: 20 million cells

• Safety and preliminary efficacy

• Clinical

• electrophysiological and

• QoL endpoints

Phase I/II Thoracic SCI Study

Page 29: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

Study Outcome

Animal

(RCS rat)

Preservation of visual acuity

Neuroprotection of host cone photoreceptors

Human

Phase I/II

Dry AMD

TBD

Enrolling patients

Case Study: Retinal

Degeneration

Page 30: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

Preservation of visual acuity

# c

on

es/1

00m

m

McGill et al,

2012

Page 31: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

• Geographic Atrophy (dry) age-related macular degeneration

• Open-label; dose-escalation (200,000 and 1 million cells)

• Cohort I: 8 subject ≤ 20/400 – dosing in progress

• Cohort II: 8 subjects 20/100- 20/200

• Objectives: Safety and preliminary efficacy

Phase I/II AMD Study ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT01632527

Dry AMD Wet AMD

Page 32: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

MRI: NCL Brain

Normal brain 6 year-old with NCL

Page 33: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

Mouse Model that Mimics Human NCL

PPT 1-/-

CA1

Normal (NOD-scid)

CA1

NCL mouse brain: CA1 region only 8% of neurons were detected compare to normal

Page 34: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

Neuroprotection Through Myelination

Oligodendrocyte Myelin sheath

with 20 continuous dense wrapping

Process

Myelinated Axons

Myelinating human MBP+

Olig2+ oligodendrocgtyes

in shiverer mouse brain

Olig2/SC121/MBP

Contused Spinal Cord Injury

Improved motor function

Remyelinated damaged axons

Axon

Axon

Immuno-EM: human myelin sheath

Human myelin sheath

with multi-layers dense wrapping

Oligodendrocyte death or

aberrant myelin

production leads to

myelin-associated

diseases

CNS-SC were

transplanted into: - oligodendroctye-mutant

shiverer mouse brain

- the injured spinal cord of

NOD-scid

Page 35: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

HuCNS-SC Protects Neurons in Batten Mouse

Hippocampus

Not transplanted Low Dose

Transplanted

High Dose

Transplanted

% o

f N

orm

al

0

20

40

60

8 %

33 %

57 %

p<0.001 p<0.001

n=6 n=9 n=6

Capela, Uchida

Page 36: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

HuCNS-SC Restores Motor

Function in Spinal Cord

Injured Mice

Pre 1 2 3 4 5 6 8 14 16 12 Post

DT

8

10

12

14

Weeks Post Injury

Open F

ield

BB

B S

core

(0

-18)

* * * * *

DT

Treatment

Restored

Motor

Function

Lost

HuCNS-SC (n=11)

Control (n=15)

Repeated Measures ANOVA p<0.01

* individual time points P<0.05

Aileen Anderson, Brian Cummings,Nobuko Uchida et al

Page 37: First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University/media/Files/Activity Files/Research... · First in human:Irv Weissman, Stanford University ... BBB Score (0-18) * * * * * HuCNS-SC

Testing Biological Activity of Human Cells in Animal Models: Xenogenic Transplant

Immunodeficient mice: NOD-scid