FINDING A BALANCE - Legislative Assembly of Alberta A BALANCE OH&S Programs in Alberta A Centennial...

24
whs.gov.ab.ca FINDING A BALANCE OH&S Programs in Alberta A Centennial Retrospective

Transcript of FINDING A BALANCE - Legislative Assembly of Alberta A BALANCE OH&S Programs in Alberta A Centennial...

Page 1: FINDING A BALANCE - Legislative Assembly of Alberta A BALANCE OH&S Programs in Alberta A Centennial Retrospective V OLUME 28 ¥ NUMBER 3 ¥ SEPTEMBER 2005 2 OCCUPA TIONAL HEALTH &

O C C U P A T I O N A L

M A G A Z I N E

whs.gov.ab.ca

FINDING A

BALANCEOH&S Programs in Alberta

A Centennial Retrospective

V O L U M E 2 8 • N U M B E R 3 • S E P T E M B E R 2 0 0 5

Page 2: FINDING A BALANCE - Legislative Assembly of Alberta A BALANCE OH&S Programs in Alberta A Centennial Retrospective V OLUME 28 ¥ NUMBER 3 ¥ SEPTEMBER 2005 2 OCCUPA TIONAL HEALTH &

O C C U P A T I O N A L H E A L T H & S A F E T Y M A G A Z I N E • S E P T E M B E R 2 0 0 52

P e r s p e c t i v e

P ositioning Norman* carefully in front of mybiomicroscope, I inwardly sigh. Obviously indiscomfort, Norman winces as I shine a bright light

to illuminate the large piece of metal embedded deep inhis cornea. In all my 17 years as a practicing optometrist,not one patient has come to me on the day of the incident,and Norman is no different.

He has left the iron filing for three days, somehow hoping itmight go away on its own. Instead, the iron has begun tooxidize, leaving a ring of rust around the now well-entrenchedforeign body. I’ll have to try to remove this ring as well.

Most eye injuries (70 per cent) are the result of flyingparticles, with 60 per cent of the objects being smaller thana pinhead. Twenty per cent of ocular injuries are chemical,the most devastating from alkaline. Most of the remainingincidents involve objects swinging from a fixed position,such as a tree branch, tool or chain.

It is believed that 90 per cent of eye injuries can beprevented through the use of properly fitted safety eyewear.An estimated three out of five workers injured are notwearing eye protection at the time of the incident.Unfortunately, most workers are hurt while doing theirregular job, and many believed the situation did not requiresafety eyewear. Not surprisingly, the vast majority of injuriesto workers who are wearing their eye protection result fromobjects or chemicals going around or under the protector.

The Canadian Standards Association certifies safetyeyewear through the use of markings on all approved safetylenses, frames and side shields. Safety frames are strongerthan street-wear frames and are designed to prevent lensesfrom being pushed into the eyes. The lenses must be madeof either plastic (CR-39) or polycarbonate, and must meetimpact resistance and thickness standards.

I manage to extricate Norman’s metal with a golf clubspud (named for the shape of the instrument – removinga foreign body is like hitting a golf ball out of a deepsand trap). Most foreign bodies can be removed in thisway, using magnification and a steady hand. But deeperor more embedded objects may require a surgeon’sevaluation, particularly if there is any chance they havepenetrated the entire thickness of the cornea.

With my Alger brush, a spinning instrument that gentlyabrades the cornea, I remove as much rust as I can reach

comfortably. This is delicate work so it’s imperative thatthe patient hold as still as possible. In a few days, morerust will come to the surface and if Norman returns I canremove it as well.

The cornea, with more pain receptors per square millimetrethan any other part of the body, scars easily. The next 24hours are going to be unpleasant, but there is little I can doto ease the pain. Although there are drugs to reduce cornealinflammation, they are generally not necessary followingsuperficial injuries like Norman’s. To encourage healing andminimize scarring, Norman will rely on oral painkillers. If hekeeps the eye well lubricated over the next several hours,he’ll feel much better by morning.

When a particle has penetrated the protective outer layerof the cornea, as in Norman’s case, there is always the riskof infection, which can result in significant vision loss in ashort period of time. He’ll need to watch for signs ofworsening redness or discharge.

Within a couple of days Norman will be back at workand will have forgotten all about his close call. And I’ll havelikely seen a few more injuries similar to or worse than his.

* Not his real name.

Dr. Jane Thrall has been a practicing optometrist in Alberta andManitoba. She is the past president of the Manitoba Association ofOptometrists, and currently practices in Leduc and Drayton Valley. For more information about eye safety in the workplace, contact theAlberta Association of Optometrists or visit www.optometrists.ab.ca.

by Jane ThrallCAN BE PREVENTED

Eye Injuries

An estimated three out of five workers injured are not

wearing eye protection at thetime of the incident.

Page 3: FINDING A BALANCE - Legislative Assembly of Alberta A BALANCE OH&S Programs in Alberta A Centennial Retrospective V OLUME 28 ¥ NUMBER 3 ¥ SEPTEMBER 2005 2 OCCUPA TIONAL HEALTH &

M A G A Z I N E

O C C U P A T I O N A L

An Alberta Human Resources and Employment publication

Managing Editor – Wally BaerEditor – Anita Jenkins

Occupational Health & Safety Magazine is published three times a year, in January, Mayand September. Magazine policy is guided by the Occupational Health & Safety MagazineAdvisory Board, which includes members representing both industry and government.

Membership on the Occupational Health & Safety Magazine Advisory Board is open to any resident of Alberta with knowledge and experience of health and safety, and aninterest in communicating health and safety information to the public. Any individualinterested in joining the Board should submit a letter of application to the managingeditor of the magazine. The Board meets three times a year in Edmonton. Board membersdo not receive remuneration or reimbursement for expenses related to meetings.

Occupational Health & Safety Magazine Advisory Board:Chris Chodan Alberta Human Resources and Employment

CommunicationsRick Ennis Christensen & McLean Roofing Co.

Lloyd Harman Alberta Forest Products Association Mike Joyce Manufacturers’ Health & Safety Association

Dianne Paulson Alberta Construction Safety AssociationKarl Pedersen Alberta Human Resources and Employment

Workplace Health & SafetyCorinne Pohlmann Canadian Federation of Independent Business

Kim Scott Salem Manor Nursing Home James Wilson Workers’ Compensation Board-Alberta

If there is a discrepancy between statements in this publication and the OccupationalHealth and Safety Act, or its Code or Regulation, the Act, Code or Regulation takesprecedence. Opinions expressed in this publication do not necessarily reflect the views orpolicy of Alberta Human Resources and Employment or the Government of Alberta.

Copyright is held by the Government of Alberta. Reproduction of articles in their entiretyis permitted. A reproduced article must include: the author’s name; title of the article; andthe full name of the magazine with its date, volume and issue number. For permission toreproduce excerpts of an article, please contact the magazine’s administration office.

Subscriptions are available without charge by calling 1-866-415-8690. When notifying us of a change of address, send an address label or subscription number with the new address. The magazine is also available as a PDF file on the Internet atwww.whs.gov.ab.ca/publications/ohsmag.asp.

Letters to the editor. We welcome response to articles or information published in thismagazine, as well as suggestions for future articles. We will print letters to the editor asspace permits. The editor reserves the right to edit letters.

Publication Mail Agreement No. 40062521

Return Undeliverable Canadian Addresses to:Circulation DepartmentAlberta Human Resources and EmploymentWorkplace Health & Safety and Employment Standards Compliance10th Floor, South Tower, Capital Health Centre 10030 - 107 Street, Edmonton AB T5J 3E4Email: [email protected]

Phone: 1-866-415-8690Fax: (780) 644-5424

Design and layout by McRobbie GroupPrinting by Quebecor World EdmontonISSN 0705-6052 © 2005

contents

O C C U P A T I O N A L H E A L T H & S A F E T Y M A G A Z I N E • S E P T E M B E R 2 0 0 5 3

P e r s p e c t i v e

2 Eye Injuries Can Be Preventedby Jane Thrall

Av o i d i n g I n j u r y i nL a b o u r - I n t e n s i v e J o b s

6 Alberta Oil Tool Has Got Your Back!by Naomi Côté

8 Weyerhaeuser Projectby Rebecca Dibbelt

S t o r i e s

10 What’s in Your Lunchbox?by Lee Craig

12 Finding a Balance: OH&S Centennial Retrospectiveby Anita Jenkins

16 Residential Construction CompaniesForm Safety Groupsby Bill Corbett

E r g o t i p s

18 Working in the Coldby Ray Cislo

P r o f i l e

20 GE Energy, Calgaryby Kerry Tremblay

M u c h M o r e

4 News & Notes

9 The Last Resort

9 From the Courtroom

19 Partnerships News

22 Web Watcher

22 Real World Solutions

23 Workplace Fatalities

Page 4: FINDING A BALANCE - Legislative Assembly of Alberta A BALANCE OH&S Programs in Alberta A Centennial Retrospective V OLUME 28 ¥ NUMBER 3 ¥ SEPTEMBER 2005 2 OCCUPA TIONAL HEALTH &

N e w s & N o t e s

O C C U P A T I O N A L H E A L T H & S A F E T Y M A G A Z I N E • S E P T E M B E R 2 0 0 54

A s of June 30, 2005, Suncor’s SAGD (Firebag)construction project had logged 4.5 million personhours worked. Despite the huge scale of this

undertaking, there have been only three lost time injuriessince the operation began in November 2001.

“At times our workforce exceeds 1,000 people, and since weare located on a remote site 150 kilometres northeast of FortMcMurray, the majority live in a camp and work a 10-day-on,four-day-off schedule,” says Sam Gibson, ConstructionEH&S/Site Services Manager. “However, our ‘dry’ site (noalcohol allowed), which offers extensive recreation andfitness resources, promotes a strong health and safetyculture for employees.”

The Firebag site boasts a new covered hockey rink thatdoubles as a multi-sport complex in the summer. “I believethis is a first for any remote construction camp,” Gibson says,adding that a full-time sports and fitness director organizesactivities and offers personal training. “We have a slow pitchleague with 16 teams, a boxing club, an archery club, anInternet cafe and several recreation centres where workerscan exercise, play pool or just relax,” Gibson says.

The planned eight-stage Firebag project involves drilling aseries of oil wells and pumping them full of steam. The steamheats up the heavy oil, which then flows to the surface.The work is expected to continue until the end of the currentdecade. Work is beginning on construction of an 80-megawattco-generation plant as well as added capacity.

For more information, visit www.suncor.com or call Brad Bellows,media relations, at (403) 269-8717.

Changes to the OH&S CodeAs promised, Alberta Human Resources andEmployment has committed to a much moretimely system for considering occupational healthand safety rule changes. In response to stakeholdersuggestions, a review will be conducted every twoyears, starting in 2005.

Current plans are as follows: n Stage 1 (completed by August 2005): Stakeholder

working groups consider suggested changes

n Stage 2 (Fall): Compilation of draft recommend-

ations and posting on AHRE website for comment

n Stage 3 (to be completed by December or

January): Working groups consider comments

received and finalize recommendations

n Stage 4 (late Winter and Spring 2006): OHS Council

reviews/approves and forwards suggested rule

changes to the minister for his consideration

For information, visit the WHS website, www.whs.gov.ab.ca/law/codereview or contact Kenn Hample, Safety SpecialistCoordinator, phone (780) 415-0648, [email protected].

KEEPING WORKERS SAFE & HEALTHYSAGD Project

Page 5: FINDING A BALANCE - Legislative Assembly of Alberta A BALANCE OH&S Programs in Alberta A Centennial Retrospective V OLUME 28 ¥ NUMBER 3 ¥ SEPTEMBER 2005 2 OCCUPA TIONAL HEALTH &

N e w s & N o t e s

5O C C U P A T I O N A L H E A L T H & S A F E T Y M A G A Z I N E • S E P T E M B E R 2 0 0 5

Title: AHRE Employers Ad Size: 4 x 7 Colours: BW plus 1 spot Publication: Run Date:

Created by: Kyle Loranger Design Contact: KylePhone: (780) 413-9237Email: [email protected]

EmployersWant to know more about increasing productivity and workplace effectiveness?

Check out the fl yer at www.alis.gov.ab.ca/employers

Alberta Human Resources and Employment has information resources on recruiting and retaining staff, balancing work and home, staff training, employment practices and talking through problems.

We also have reports on labour market statistics for information about employment growth, wages and salaries, productivity and economic trends.

And much, much more!

Video about Young Workers on WHS WebsiteA 19-minute video called Dying to Work examines the perilsof teen labour and discovers an astounding statistic – onaverage, one young worker in Canada dies on the job eachweek and 60,000 young workers are injured each year. Thisvideo is available on the WHS website, www.gov.ab.ca/hre/whs/workers/index.asp.

Product demo at 2004 HSCSA Trade Show.

4th Annual Alberta Health & SafetyConference and Trade Fair

November 7-9, 2005Calgary Stampede Round-Up CentreKeynote Speaker: Terry Bogyo

WCB-British Columbia

The Health & Safety Conference Society of Albertais a not-for-profit multi-purpose organization thatincludes industry safety organizations, professionalorganizations, government, Workers’ CompensationBoard-Alberta and other related groups.

For more information, visit the Society’s website at www.hsconference.com. Or send an e-mail [email protected].

Page 6: FINDING A BALANCE - Legislative Assembly of Alberta A BALANCE OH&S Programs in Alberta A Centennial Retrospective V OLUME 28 ¥ NUMBER 3 ¥ SEPTEMBER 2005 2 OCCUPA TIONAL HEALTH &

6

W hen the management ofAlberta Oil Tool saw thatsome of their workers were

having a tough time bending over andlifting all day, they sprang into action.

“We had couplings in baskets thatweighed about 4,000 pounds,” saysTerry Harnack, sucker rod manufac-turing manager. “We’d move thesebaskets into locations where employeessorted them into larger baskets forproduction.” The staff discussed howthis labour-intensive process could bemodified into a single step thatwouldn’t require heavy lifting andcame up with a handling system thatreduced back injuries from one or twoa month to zero.

Labour-saving solutionsThis initial success paved the way forother labour-saving solutions at thisEdmonton-based oilfield manufac-turing company. For instance, to forge

a sucker rod, two employees wouldswitch back and forth every 15minutes, forging the rods by hand.This process involved lifting a rodweighing anywhere from 44 to 72pounds and fitting it into a set of dies.Alberta Oil Tool commissioned thedesign of a robotic arm to automatethis process, which resolved all of theback and arm injuries associated withthe job.

“We found that the person doingthe forging was exhausted by the endof the day, so the production numbersdropped a little bit,” says Perry Harnack,general products manufacturingmanager. “Putting in the forge armactually increased production andwork in other areas.”

Years before the process wasautomated, Brent Draper, lead hand,suffered a back injury from lifting andmanually forging rod ends. “My back ismuch better now,” he says. “Having the

crane in the die preparation area hasbeen quite a back saver. Also, we havean improved transference system. Ourcarts have better rolling wheels so Ican easily bring them to and from thesetup area.”

“We probably rushed a lot of jobs anddidn’t lift properly because we didn’thave the right techniques and equipmentto assist us,” Perry Harnack says.

Keeping fitAlberta Oil Tool has also been proactivein teaching its employees about theproper way to stretch before theirshifts in order to avoid strain andinjury. “At a recent tool box meetingwe taught five or six exercises fordifferent body parts,” says MelonyErickson, director of quality, safetyand human resources. “For example,if you’re bent over, stand up and bendbackwards. Do the opposite motion.We’re hoping that as our population

O C C U P A T I O N A L H E A L T H & S A F E T Y M A G A Z I N E • S E P T E M B E R 2 0 0 5

by Naomi Côté

HAS GOT YOUR BACK!

AVOIDING INJURY in

LABOUR-INTENSIVE JOBS

Alberta Oil Tool

Page 7: FINDING A BALANCE - Legislative Assembly of Alberta A BALANCE OH&S Programs in Alberta A Centennial Retrospective V OLUME 28 ¥ NUMBER 3 ¥ SEPTEMBER 2005 2 OCCUPA TIONAL HEALTH &

and workforce ages, we’ll be able to usesome of these techniques to our benefit.”

When it comes to managing backpain, Draper and both of the Harnackbrothers agree that exercise and activityare the key.

“I’ve had back pain for over 10 years,and yes, it hurts a little bit,” says TerryHarnack. “But I find that if I sit aroundthe muscles tighten up more and it getsworse. When my back starts hurting, Istart doing exercises again and withindays the problem goes away. If I maintainthose exercises, which take all of about

R e s o u r c e s

WEB LINKSwww.wcb.ab.ca/back@it/default.asp2005 Back Education Campaign, a province-wide joint initiative

www.albertachiro.com Back health and chiropractic care in Alberta

www.wcb.ab.ca/news/2005/050223.asp Alberta Oil Tool receives Worksafe award

IN THE ALBERTA GOVERNMENT LIBRARY – LABOUR BUILDINGFor contact information, see page 23.

VideosBack Injury Prevention Through ExerciseImplementing an “exercise before working” program for all employees– includes back basics and why an exercise-before-work program isimportant. (VC 0255)

Back Safety: Lift Well, Live WellWorkers who pay attention to back basics stand a greater chance ofprotecting their backs from injury and avoiding lost days at work andwith their families. (VC 0377)

Lifting and CarryingTopics covered: the construction of the spine and its limitations; howand why injuries can occur if those limitations are not respectedthrough the use of correct lifting and carrying techniques. (VC 0350)

AOT’S BACK-SAVING INNOVATIONSINDEPENDENT CRANES FOR EACH FORGE Employeesused to pull out a set of dies (90 pounds per block)while bent over, which resulted in arm and back strain.The solution: cranes that allow the operator to pull outthe dies without any strain.

RACKING FOR GENERAL PRODUCTS Products used to bepiled up on A-frame racks that required loading andunloading to access the required material. The solution:creating crank-out racks with the products separated bysize and grade. It’s now fast and easy to access theneeded material without strain – and it has evencreated additional floor space.

PUP JOINTS Manually lifting these 100-pound joints wasvery strenuous work. The solution: designing a pup jointfeeder that feeds the pipe in and out of the machine,and a crane does the rest – no more lifting required.

two minutes per day, I don’t have back pain anymore. I cango out and golf and do all of the things that I like to do.”

Perry Harnack says that although it’s the company’sresponsibility to have the right equipment, it’s also theemployees’ responsibility to take care of themselves by doingexercises to prevent back pain. He finds it does wonders totake part in activities that strengthen your muscles – evenfor just 20 minutes.

Erickson sums up the current situation at Alberta Oil Tool:“We’re more productive, more efficient and there are morecost savings. And when your employees know you’re concernedabout their health, they’re happier. Everybody wins!”

Naomi Coté is a communications officer at WCB-Alberta.

O C C U P A T I O N A L H E A L T H & S A F E T Y M A G A Z I N E • S E P T E M B E R 2 0 0 5 7

Page 8: FINDING A BALANCE - Legislative Assembly of Alberta A BALANCE OH&S Programs in Alberta A Centennial Retrospective V OLUME 28 ¥ NUMBER 3 ¥ SEPTEMBER 2005 2 OCCUPA TIONAL HEALTH &

O C C U P A T I O N A L H E A L T H & S A F E T Y M A G A Z I N E • S E P T E M B E R 2 0 0 58

Weyerhaeuser is turning tosports science to create a saferworkplace for its tree planters.

The innovative project will help setthe bar for the health and safety oftree planters across Canada.

“Tree planting is a big part of ourbusiness, and until now the healthand safety of our workers in the fieldhasn’t received the attention it shouldhave,” says Weyerhaeuser silviculturistBruce Macmillan. “It’s very physicalwork; there’s a high level of exertionand a high potential for injuryassociated with the repetitive natureof the job. It caused us to questionwhat we could do to keep our treeplanters healthy.”

In 2002, Weyerhaeuser contactedSelkirk College’s sports physiologistDelia Roberts, a former Olympictrainer, who visited its planting sitesto devise ways to boost personalsafety. The eight-week pre-season Fitto Plant training regime was designedand is now supported by the B.C.Forest Industry Safety Association.All Weyerhaeuser tree planters in

Alberta will participate in 2005, thefirst full year of the program. Theprogram is designed to help plantersbuild strength, flexibility andaerobic capacity prior to plantingseason. In a typical eight-hour day, aplanter bends more than 1,600 timesand lifts a cumulative weight of morethan 1,000 kilograms. Coast RangeContracting supplies Weyerhaeuser’stree planters, and operations directorTroy Ferguson says he saw excellentresults from last season’s trial run.“Our Weyerhaeuser planters were ableto meet the goal of zero recordableinjuries last year, and that’s remarkablefor any reforestation business,”Ferguson says.

“We’re thrilled that industry hasevolved to this; it’s a real credit toWeyerhaeuser to get behind this,”says Ferguson. “It affords these youngpeople a better chance they willcomplete their summer as healthy as when they arrived.”

With pre-season training in place,Weyerhaeuser turned to ongoingmaintenance of health and safety.

It approached the Forest EngineeringResearch Institute of Canada (FERIC)to look at best practices dealing withtools and techniques of the trade.

Silvicultural operations supervisorErnst Stjernberg is in the midst of astudy involving 120 tree planters infour locations in various types ofterrain across B.C. and Alberta. “Weare seeking a better design in theequipment that planters use, andimproved understanding of practicesthey should avoid so they don’t over-extend their bodies in a harmful way.”

Rebecca Dibbelt is an Alberta freelance writer.This article is reprinted with permission fromthe May 2005 issue of The Edge forest businessmagazine, www.mediamatchwest.com.

AVOIDING INJURY in

LABOUR-INTENSIVE JOBS

WEYERHAEUSER PROJECT

by Rebecca Dibbelt

R e s o u r c e s

WEB LINKSwww.selkirk.ca/treeplantingFit to Plant program

Photo courtesy of FERICHelps Tree Planters Stay Healthy

Page 9: FINDING A BALANCE - Legislative Assembly of Alberta A BALANCE OH&S Programs in Alberta A Centennial Retrospective V OLUME 28 ¥ NUMBER 3 ¥ SEPTEMBER 2005 2 OCCUPA TIONAL HEALTH &

How Many OH&S Cases Go to Court?THE VAST MAJORITY of Alberta Workplace Health & Safetyinspections and investigations do not bring employers and primecontractors anywhere near the court system. Most times when an OHSofficer identifies a safety concern, he or she simply requests that thecompany address the issue. Sometimes there is a compliance orderthat basically says, “Here is a safety or health concern, and here’swhat we’d like you to do about it.” In more extreme situations astop-work order is required to ensure the worksite is safe. When adeficiency is noted, companies are generally cooperative – if notappreciative that a potential problem has been rectified.

In the unfortunate event of a fatality or a serious incident, OHSofficers have the challenging job of trying to find out what happened.Additionally, the investigation process involves working with thecompany to ensure that similar incidents do not occur again.

At the end of an investigation an internal review involving theofficer and senior staff at Workplace Health & Safety considerswhether there was a systemic failure to address safety concerns,a documented failure to perform required maintenance onequipment, an industry-wide problem in that area, and so on.Usually this internal review is the end of the process and no chargesare considered.

In a small percentage of investigations, however, all of the evidenceis sent to the Crown’s office, where an occupational health and safetyprosecutor reviews the investigation in detail, meets with the officerand makes a decision about whether to recommend charges. Often,the recommendation is that no charges be laid.

The Crown is bound by Alberta Justice policy to proceed only whenthe prosecutor believes there is a reasonable likelihood of conviction,and that it is in the public interest to prosecute. Even when chargesare laid, the Crown continually reviews the evidence with thesepolicies in mind. If at some point the Crown is no longer satisfied thatthe evidence supports a prosecution with a reasonable likelihood ofconviction, the charges can and will be stayed or withdrawn.

If a prosecution proceeds through the full trial process, neither theCrown nor defence counsel can predict exactly how the Courts willassess the credibility of various witnesses and interpret documents.Because there have been so few workplace health and safety trials inAlberta, unanswered questions remain. The Courts will ultimatelydetermine what is admissible in evidence and whether there hasbeen a violation of Alberta’s workplace health and safety legislation.

To suggest topics for future columns, please send a message [email protected] or [email protected].

Tamara Trull is a Crown Prosecutor at Alberta Justice.

F r o m t h e C o u r t r o o mby Tamara Trull

T h e L a s t R e s o r t

EMPLOYERAltapro Cleaning and Disaster Restoration Ltd.

INCIDENTOn November 30, 2001, a worker was seriouslyinjured when he fell approximately two metresfrom a scaffold.

VIOLATIONOn April 19, 2005, Altapro Cleaning and DisasterRestoration Ltd. was found guilty of:

• failing to ensure the health and safety of aworker [s. 2(1)(a)(i), Occupational Health andSafety Act]

• failing to ensure that a competent workerwas in charge of demolition while work wasin progress [s. 192(2)(a), General SafetyRegulation]

• failing to take all reasonable steps to ensurematerials were contained or restrained toeliminate potential danger [s. 67, GeneralSafety Regulation]

FINEAltapro Cleaning and Disaster Restoration Ltd.received a total penalty of $61,500: a fine of$10,000 plus a $1,500 victim fine surcharge;$25,000 to St. John Ambulance and $25,000 toSTARS Air Ambulance.

EMPLOYERSilver City/Famous Players Films Inc.

INCIDENTOn November 15, 2002, a worker received chemicalburns when a bottle of Drain Power spilled onhim. The product was 86.3% sulphuric acid.

VIOLATIONOn April 18, 2005, Silver City/Famous PlayersFilms Inc. pled guilty to failing to ensure thehealth and safety of a worker [s. 2(1)(a)(i),Occupational Health and Safety Act].

FINESilver City/Famous Players Inc. received a totalpenalty of $57,750: a fine of $5,000 plus a $750victim fine surcharge, and the remaining$52,000 to be donated to the Firefighters BurnTreatment Society.

For more information, go to www.whs.gov.ab.ca/prosecutions/releases.asp.

Reporting on Recent ConvictionsUnder the Occupational Health and Safety Act

O C C U P A T I O N A L H E A L T H & S A F E T Y M A G A Z I N E • S E P T E M B E R 2 0 0 5 9

Page 10: FINDING A BALANCE - Legislative Assembly of Alberta A BALANCE OH&S Programs in Alberta A Centennial Retrospective V OLUME 28 ¥ NUMBER 3 ¥ SEPTEMBER 2005 2 OCCUPA TIONAL HEALTH &

O C C U P A T I O N A L H E A L T H & S A F E T Y M A G A Z I N E • S E P T E M B E R 2 0 0 510

J im Weber was working a 14-hour shift on a hot Augustday, picking up insect traps on his way to Hudson Bay,and had missed lunch and dinner. Luckily, he had an

uneaten garlic sausage that had been sitting in his truckfrom lunch the day before.

“It was pushing 11 o’clock at night. I knew where I wasgoing, but I didn’t think there were a lot of options foreating and I was pretty tired,” says Weber, a forest healthtechnician for the Canadian Forest Service.

It was dark out and Weber’s dash light wasn’t working.He grabbed the bag with the sausage to eat it in the truckcab. Then he was struck with an inspiration. “I was going toget to the motel and relax and eat the sausage as a properdinner with some fruit that I had.”

When Weber arrived at his destination, he eagerly satdown at the table. “I pulled out the sausage and therewere maggots crawling on it, just wee little ones, almosttranslucent,” says Weber. Needless to say, he went to bedhungry that night.

Foodborne illnessesWhile Weber escaped illness from a lunch left in heat forfar too long, many people do risk getting sick from whatthey bring to work for lunch, particularly if they don’t haveaccess to a fridge. More than 3,000 confirmed cases offoodborne illnesses are reported in Alberta each year.

Shauna Dimock, a health inspector and educator for theCapital Health Region, says in Weber’s situation he wouldhave been at risk from the bacteria in the sausage, not themaggots. She says storing or preparing your lunchimproperly could lead to life-threatening illnesses or, at thevery least, extreme discomfort.

“People can suffer from diarrhea, vomiting, fever,headache or nausea. Depending on what the bacteria oragent is, in severe cases they could end up on dialysis orwith other kidney issues,” says Dimock. “For some people itcan be life-threatening, especially those in high-risk groups– the elderly, the very young and, of course, anyone who ison chemotherapy.” People often don’t report these types ofsymptoms because they don’t recognize that how they feelis a result of something they have eaten, Dimock adds.

Keep it coldThe most important step to follow in storing your lunch isto keep it cold. “If you leave a food out at room temperature,especially a high-protein food, bacteria can start to grow inanywhere from two to six hours,” says Dimock. She stressesthat cooling doesn’t kill bacteria once it starts to grow.“Once the bacteria is in the product, it’s in there. Evenfreezing won’t kill it.”

by Lee Craig

More than 3,000 confirmedcases of foodborne illnesses arereported in Alberta each year.

What’s in your

Page 11: FINDING A BALANCE - Legislative Assembly of Alberta A BALANCE OH&S Programs in Alberta A Centennial Retrospective V OLUME 28 ¥ NUMBER 3 ¥ SEPTEMBER 2005 2 OCCUPA TIONAL HEALTH &

O C C U P A T I O N A L H E A L T H & S A F E T Y M A G A Z I N E • S E P T E M B E R 2 0 0 5 11

You can prevent many foodborne illnesses by preparingyour food properly and storing it at the right temperature.Bacteria multiply quickly in the “danger zone” between4°C and 60°C.

PACKING SAFE LUNCHES

If a lunch is made the night before, Dimocksuggests you keep it in the fridge as long as possiblebefore transferring it to a work fridge. If your worksite has no fridge, freeze a bottle of water or ajuice box and pack perishable items close to thatfrozen item. Use an insulated lunch bag as well ascommon sense, such as not putting your lunch insunlight or against a heat register.

Important steps in food preparation includethawing food properly (do not leave meat, forexample, in the sink to thaw for several hours);hand washing between handling meat and otheritems; making sure your food is cooked quickly(for example, in barbecuing); and using athermometer to check for doneness.

As for Jim Weber, he is following the mostimportant step: he now has a fridge in a campertruck to keep his lunches cold.

Lee Craig is an Edmonton freelance writer and editor.

• Wash your hands well with soap and hot water beforemaking your lunch. Also, wash your hands when youswitch from one food to another and after you arefinished.

• Clean and sanitize your work surface and all yourcooking utensils with a mild bleach solution. Rinsethem with clean water and let them air dry or dry themwith paper towels.

• Clean and sanitize any reusable food containers andlunch bags or boxes.

• Wash all fruits and vegetables well before you prepare oreat them.

KEEP IT CLEAN WHEN PREPARING YOUR LUNCH

• An insulated lunch box is best for keeping food at theproper temperature. If you use paper bags, layer themto increase insulation.

• Keep cold food cold (at or below 4°C) – for example, allmeat (including chicken, fish and seafood), eggs,cheese and other dairy products, salads, cooked pasta,mayonnaise and butter.

• If you make your lunch the night before, freezewhatever you can, such as the bread and meat of asandwich. You can add the lettuce and tomato when youpack it in the morning.

• Put a frozen gel pack or a container of ice with yourcold food to keep it chilled.

• Keep hot food hot (above 60°C) – for example, soup,chili, stew and hot chocolate.

• Use an insulated container to store hot food. Preheat thecontainer with boiling water for a couple of minutes beforefilling it, and don’t open it until you are ready to eat lunch.

KEEP YOUR LUNCH AT THE RIGHT TEMPERATURE

R e s o u r c e s

WEB LINKSwww.inspection.gc.ca/english/corpaffr/foodfacts/campinge.shtmlCanadian Food Inspection Agency

www.canfightbac.org/english/indexe.shtml Canadian Partnership for Consumer Food Safety Education

www.hotlib.com/articles/show.php?t=Food_Safety_101Bag lunch safety tips

www.fsis.usda.gov/Fact_Sheets/Keeping_Bag_Lunches_Safe/index.asp USDA Fact Sheet

LUNCHBOX?

Page 12: FINDING A BALANCE - Legislative Assembly of Alberta A BALANCE OH&S Programs in Alberta A Centennial Retrospective V OLUME 28 ¥ NUMBER 3 ¥ SEPTEMBER 2005 2 OCCUPA TIONAL HEALTH &

O C C U P A T I O N A L H E A L T H & S A F E T Y M A G A Z I N E • S E P T E M B E R 2 0 0 512

FINDING A

BALANCEOH&S Programs in Alberta

A Centennial Retrospective

1906Coal Mines Act defines the government’sauthority for mines safety inspections

1913Coal Mines Act replacedby the Mines Act

1920WCB responsible for workplacesafety inspections

11111999991111188888Passage of Workmen’s Compensation Act and appointment of three-man Workmen’sCompensation Board

1941WCB’s First Aid Regulationspromote employee health,good housekeeping andpersonal protective equipment

8 8

T he province of Alberta was launched with high hopesand in high style. Most of the participants in the joyousinaugural festivities held in Edmonton on September 1,

1905, believed their new province would be a “can-do” kindof place with a very bright future.

Although this optimistic view eventually turned out tobe quite true, workplaces in Alberta in 1905 definitely hada dark side. The prevailing attitude was that a certainnumber of workers would inevitably be injured or killed atwork – primarily because people are accident prone and/orcareless. If a tree fell on a forestry worker or a mine shaftcollapsed, these tragic events were chalked up to “badluck.” In these situations, a “good” employer paid formedical or funeral expenses and provided some funds toworkers’ families.

The appointment of the Workmen’s Compensation Boardin 1918 was a major step forward. For the next five-plusdecades, the WCB gradually expanded and enhanced its rolein promoting health and safety in the workplace (seetimeline). Significant advancements occurred during thepost-World War II boom – injuries were increasing as theeconomy burgeoned, and workers and their employers wereno longer prepared to accept the same level of risk as theyhad in the past.

Occupational Health & Safety ActThe Occupational Health & Safety Act, passed in 1977,marked the beginning of a new era. “The OH&S Act wasunique in its focus on awareness and attitudes,” says Dr. Bob Orford, who was deputy minister of communityand occupational health from 1985 to 1987 and a seniorgovernment official from 1977 to 1987. “The approach wascooperative, not adversarial,” Orford adds. He notes thatfor the first time the regulations were performance-based

by Anita Jenkins

OOHHSS iinn AALLBBEERRTTAA

Page 13: FINDING A BALANCE - Legislative Assembly of Alberta A BALANCE OH&S Programs in Alberta A Centennial Retrospective V OLUME 28 ¥ NUMBER 3 ¥ SEPTEMBER 2005 2 OCCUPA TIONAL HEALTH &

O C C U P A T I O N A L H E A L T H & S A F E T Y M A G A Z I N E • S E P T E M B E R 2 0 0 5 13

8

11111999994444477777Discovery of oil at Leductransforms the Albertaeconomy and workforce

8 8

1945Maximum work hours: 8/day or48 in a six-day week

1948WCB enforcing legislative requirements for safe work conditions

1959WCB begins meeting withlabour representatives todiscuss compensation andsafety issues

1963Health and safety of workersstill the responsibility of WCB,within the mandate of theDepartment of Public Health

1966WCB institutes GeneralSafety regulations

(“This is what we want to accomplish”)as opposed to specifications-based(“The equipment has to look like this”).

Barry Munro, who was assistantdeputy minister of labour when heretired in 1996 after 16 years withthe Alberta government, recalls thatat first he and many other keyplayers felt the new centralizedlegislation was “diluted” and “toogeneric” because it replaced separatelaws governing various industriessuch as mining. However, Munrosoon became a convert and says, “Itwas the right thing to do.”

The decade after the passage ofthe OH&S legislation was a busytime, says Orford. Achievements ofthat period, he remembers, included

first aid and noise regulations, andextensive applied research into areassuch as the effects of coal dust andasbestos. Alberta was “very goodtechnically,” Orford notes. Munroconfirms this perception. “We hadone of the strongest industrialhygiene units in Canada, and a labthat was the envy of the rest ofCanada,” he says. “People listened tous at the national table because wehad such a strong research area.”

Alberta’s innovative culture Orford mentions his high regard forDr. Herb Buchwald, who came fromEngland in 1974 to set up Alberta’sindustrial hygiene service. Munroconcurs, and says it was valuable

to have a number of people like Dr. Buchwald come in from outsidethe traditional safety world. (Anothersuch person was Bill Rozel, an engineer.)Because of their backgrounds, Munrosays, these people were better equippedto “think outside the box.”

Orford and Rozel both remember amade-in-Alberta process in whichsenior people from various branchesand departments jointly reviewedevery fatal incident. The review teamlooked at the medical examiner’s dataand the safety inspector’s report, and“put the inspector on the hot seat,”says Rozel. Although the inspectorswere understandably anxious aboutthis approach, they soon learned thatit was an excellent training tool for

Page 14: FINDING A BALANCE - Legislative Assembly of Alberta A BALANCE OH&S Programs in Alberta A Centennial Retrospective V OLUME 28 ¥ NUMBER 3 ¥ SEPTEMBER 2005 2 OCCUPA TIONAL HEALTH &

O C C U P A T I O N A L H E A L T H & S A F E T Y M A G A Z I N E • S E P T E M B E R 2 0 0 514

them, Rozel comments. Also, Orfordnotes, “It produced some extremelyimportant insights.”

It was also during Orford’s (andBuchwald’s) tenure in Alberta thatthe current Labour library wasestablished. At the time it was oneof the largest OH&S collections inCanada. “The provincial governmentplayed a critical role in educationbefore the safety associations wereestablished,” says Wally Baer,current director of compliance forworkplace health and safety andemployment standards.

PartnershipsIn 1988 Rozel took on the job oflaunching the Partnerships program.This ground-breaking initiative bygovernment, labour and industryarose out of a realization that increas-ing the number of inspections wasnot the answer to every problem inoccupational health and safety, saysRozel. “It became apparent that theonly way to achieve our mutual

goals was to haveindustry take on agreater degree of responsibility.”

“Partnerships was ahome-grown concept,”says Brian Thomas,Partnerships consultant,“and it was reallyindustry’s idea.” The emphasis was onshared responsibility, consensusbuilding and collaboration amongmajor participants – about “bringingall our strengths to the table,” asMunro puts it.

“Partnerships put Alberta on themap,” Munro says. “It was such asuccess that we were asked by peoplearound the world to come and talk tothem about it.”

Baer notes that a couple of othergroups and sectors have also done a lotto keep Alberta workers safe andhealthy. One is the safety associations,which have voluntarily establishedstandards that are generally higherthan the legislated minimum and do

a lot of training in their industries.Another is the unions, which, Baersays, “do a tremendous job of trainingtheir members.”

The Work Safe Alberta strategylaunched in 2002 has also made majorstrides by encouraging everyoneinvolved to work together.

A balanced approachAll of these developments have cometogether very well, observes Baer.“We are fortunate that all of thecomponents are working right andcomplementing each other. It is not acase of ‘either-or’ but rather ‘inaddition to’. It’s all about finding abalance. All of the participants are

1973Industrial Health and Safety (Gale)Commission established to recommendpolicies for providing a coordinatedOHS program in Alberta

1975Gale Commission reportidentifies a number offundamental principles forthe prevention of illnessand injury

1979-86For the first time theAlberta Cabinet includesa Minister Responsiblefor Workers’ Health,Safety and Compensation(Hon. Bill Diachuk)

8 8

1978Alberta Labour takes over workplace safetyinspections (from WCB)11111999997777777777

Occupational Health and Safety Actapplies to all workers and employersin Alberta except federal employeesand workplaces, farmers anddomestic servants

“We are fortunate that all of thecomponents are working right andcomplementing each other.”

8

Page 15: FINDING A BALANCE - Legislative Assembly of Alberta A BALANCE OH&S Programs in Alberta A Centennial Retrospective V OLUME 28 ¥ NUMBER 3 ¥ SEPTEMBER 2005 2 OCCUPA TIONAL HEALTH &

O C C U P A T I O N A L H E A L T H & S A F E T Y M A G A Z I N E • S E P T E M B E R 2 0 0 5 15

11111999999999900000Partnerships in Health& Safety launched

8

1988Amendment to OccupationalHealth and Safety Act providesfor increases in the amounts of fines

Alberta Construction SafetyAssociation formed – thefirst of six such associationsthat would eventually befunded by WCB premiums

1989WCB sets up pilot project calledWork Injury Reduction Program(now Partners in Injury Reduction)

22222000000000022222-----0000044444New Occupational Health andSafety Act, Regulations and Code enacted

2002Work Safe Alberta strategy: commitmentby provincial industry, labour and safetygroups to jointly work towards furtherreductions in workplace injuries

Adam (Ab) Chervinski, 85, worked for AGT for just over 37 years, and in the period 1951 to 1978 he logged two million on-the-job miles in Southern Alberta, from Taber to theAmerican border. “The roads were not very good,” he says, “and the chinooks often changedminus 20 degree temperatures to above-zero in seconds. But I never had an accident.”

Chervinski’s “perfectionism,” as he describes it, extended beyond safe driving and carefullychecking over his vehicle each day. It included keeping the office spotless (he won manyClean Sweep awards for this in the 1970s) and making sure all the staff practiced safe workhabits. After hours, he taught safety to new Canadians for many years.

Ab Chervinski and others like him have made no small contribution to workplace healthand safety in Alberta.

A WORKER’S PERSPECTIVE

working together; people are nottrying to fix the blame or pointfingers when problems occur.”

Government establishes minimumstandards in legislation and imposespenalties for non-compliance.

WCB-Alberta provides financialincentives, and industry voluntarilyintroduces health and safetymanagement concepts. Employers are doing more OH&S training, and doing it very effectively.

And, says Baer, “Alberta has anextraordinary workforce thatincludes extraordinary employees.”

Anita Jenkins is the editor of theOccupational Health & Safety Magazine.

Page 16: FINDING A BALANCE - Legislative Assembly of Alberta A BALANCE OH&S Programs in Alberta A Centennial Retrospective V OLUME 28 ¥ NUMBER 3 ¥ SEPTEMBER 2005 2 OCCUPA TIONAL HEALTH &

O C C U P A T I O N A L H E A L T H & S A F E T Y M A G A Z I N E • S E P T E M B E R 2 0 0 516

A lberta’s residential housing construction industrydoesn’t have an enviable safety record. Indeed, in2004, residential construction – led by the roofing

and framing sectors – claimed the dubious distinction ofhaving the highest Workers’ Compensation Board premiumrates of all Alberta industries. This reflects a traditionallyhigh rate of injuries and fatalities, often the result ofunprotected falls from roofs or skeleton structures.

But things are getting better. WCB claims by residentialand general contractors dropped from 258 in 2003 to 228in 2004. Consequently, premium rates for the variousresidential sectors declined about 10 per cent in 2005and are scheduled to drop again in 2006 (see chart).

Reasons for the improvement include the province’snew Occupational Health and Safety Code, which includesmore stringent provisions for fall protection and personalprotective equipment. But much of the credit can go to theresidential construction industry itself, which has recentlyformed safety groups in Calgary and Edmonton.

“Even before the new code came in, a number of buildersin Calgary realized there were safety issues that needed to beaddressed,” says Allen Cayen, safety officer with Trico Homes

and chairman of the Calgary Residential Builders SafetyGroup. The Calgary safety group was formed in 2003 andnow has a membership of some 20 builders, representingabout 80 per cent of the city’s residential building permits.

“We decided it was important to implement basic safetyrequirements at the same time,” says John Tucker, health andsafety supervisor for Carma Developers’ Heartland/HawthorneHomes and former chairman of the Calgary safety group. “Ifonly one company said, for example, that their framers had totie off, some guys would just go down the street to a builderthat didn’t have that requirement.”

The safety group’s requirements are in line with safetycode regulations, which include having employers ensuretheir employees not only wear necessary personal protectiveequipment but also use it properly and are trained to do so.The code also stipulates that those working on flat roofs orcreating skeleton structures are no longer exempt fromusing fall protection.

“A lot of builders are afraid to require guys to wear fallprotection gear, because a lot of guys haven’t done it for20 years,” says Tucker. “Guys are still getting injured andkilled because their builders are not complying with thecode. But things are starting to change.”

The Calgary Residential Builders Safety Group hasregular meetings, where members discuss new trends,share ideas and listen to presentations from guestspeakers (such as Alberta Workplace Health & Safetyofficers) and safety equipment suppliers. “A lot ofcompanies are at different stages of developing theirsafety programs,” says Cayen. “The idea is to have anongoing dialogue so everyone’s speaking the samelanguage and is on the same page. I’ve found that safetypeople from different companies are all prepared toshare what they’ve learned. We want to help createstandardized programs and safe work practices.”

Edmonton’s Residential Safety Group was startedaround the same time as its Calgary counterpart.Edmonton group founder and president DuncanMatheson, safety officer with Sterling/Pacesetter Homes,went through the phone book and encouraged all the

by Bill Corbett

Workers’ Compensation Board-Alberta Premium Rates (per $100 insurable earnings)

11

10

9

8

7

FRAMING

ROOFING

10.811.09

9.71(-10%)

8.32(-14%)

9.88(-10.9%)

9.33(-5.6%)

2004 2005 2006 (forecast)

Residential Construction Companies

FORM SAFETY GROUPS

Page 17: FINDING A BALANCE - Legislative Assembly of Alberta A BALANCE OH&S Programs in Alberta A Centennial Retrospective V OLUME 28 ¥ NUMBER 3 ¥ SEPTEMBER 2005 2 OCCUPA TIONAL HEALTH &

O C C U P A T I O N A L H E A L T H & S A F E T Y M A G A Z I N E • S E P T E M B E R 2 0 0 5 17

city’s builders to join the fledgling group. The originalmembership of 32 has shrunk to a core of about 10companies, though they still represent the majority ofEdmonton houses being built.

“We felt we could accomplish a lot more as a group thanon an individual basis,” says Matheson. Besides monthlymeetings, the Edmonton group members conduct tours ofnew subdivisions to see what safety equipment and practicesare being used.

“When I started working as a safety officer, I was told (totake a hike) off the job site 15 times a day. It’s a slow process.We’re trying to change a culture, and it’s tough telling a 60-year-old he’s got to start wearing safety glasses and a hardhat,” says Matheson. “But it’s a heck of a lot better than it wastwo years ago. We’ve got a code, so we’ve got a rulebook, andour member companies have health and safety officers andthey’re all buying into it.”

Group organizers hope the positive results from their initialefforts are just the beginning and that their often-malignedindustry will soon have much safer work sites.

“There’s no doubt residential construction sites can behazardous places to work,” says Cayen. “But nobody shouldhave to go to work and worry about getting hurt or dying.Everybody deserves a healthy future.”

Bill Corbett is a Calgary writer. His latest book, The 11,000ers of theCanadian Rockies, is a climber’s guide to the 54 peaks in the CanadianRockies above 11,000 feet, all of which the author has climbed.

DARRELL LANDON, SAFETY MANAGER for the Qualico Groupof Companies, started developing a new fall protectionsystem and John Tucker, health and safety supervisor forHeartland/Hawthorne Homes, finished it in 2004. Whileprevious travel-restraint systems were either cumbersome orfailed to prevent all ground-striking falls, the new systemprotects residential workers at every stage of framing androofing a house. The open-truss system is reinforced by atwo-by-six stringer that runs from one gable to the otheralong the king post. Four or five straps are then attached tovarious points of the stringer, allowing workers – wearing aharness, rope and rope-grab system – to tie into the pointclosest to where they are working. When the house sheetingis completed, the straps still stick through the peak,allowing roofers, siding installers, shingle loaders, andeavestrough installers to also use the system.

“It provides full fall-arrest protection,” says Tucker. “If you go over the eave of the roof, or down through

the middle, or over the gable end, it will prevent youfrom hitting the ground.” The system meets all the coderequirements for fall protection and is certified by aprofessional engineer.

“Over the last two years, there have been 24 reportedfall incidents and four fatalities involving guys not usingany fall protection, even though it’s in violation of thecode,” says Tucker. “The good news is 10 home buildersin Edmonton and two or three in Calgary have alreadyadopted this system. I know of at least eight instancesalready where the system has arrested a fall and savedthe life of the worker involved.

“We spent a fair bit of time and money testing thesystem and getting it certified, but we didn’t patent it.We’re willing to share it with anyone who wants to use it.For about $225 in protective equipment, any worker canbuy everything he needs for full fall-arrest protection.”

NEW FALL PROTECTION SYSTEM

R e s o u r c e s

CONTACTSCalgary Group: Allen Cayen, (403) 287-9300Edmonton Group: Percy Pouliot, (780) 431-8812

WEB LINKSwww.calgarysun.com/cgi-bin/niveau2.cgi?s=generic&p=88768.html&a=1Calgary Sun article on the Calgary Group

ACSA BOOKLETSCopies of booklets on Siding and Eavestroughing Best Practices and WoodFraming Best Practices are available from Alberta Construction Safety Associationoffices in Edmonton, phone 1-800-661-2272 or Calgary, phone 1-800-661-6090.

IN THE ALBERTA GOVERNMENT LIBRARY – LABOUR BUILDINGFor contact information, see page 23.

VideosFalls in the Workplace (VC 0400) andHigh Impact Fall Protection (VC 0322)See descriptions in January 2005 issue of this magazine, page 8.

PPE: Don’t Start Work Without ItPersonal protective equipment includes eye and face protection, hearingprotection, head protection, hand protection and foot protection. (VC 0394)

PPE: The Right ChoiceIndustrial workers recall how the choices they made about personal protectiveequipment had an impact on their lives. Topics include hard hats, eye protection,earplugs and earmuffs, hand protection and safety footwear. (VC 0408)

Page 18: FINDING A BALANCE - Legislative Assembly of Alberta A BALANCE OH&S Programs in Alberta A Centennial Retrospective V OLUME 28 ¥ NUMBER 3 ¥ SEPTEMBER 2005 2 OCCUPA TIONAL HEALTH &

O C C U P A T I O N A L H E A L T H & S A F E T Y M A G A Z I N E • S E P T E M B E R 2 0 0 518

E r g o t i p s

I t’s important to realize that environmental conditionscan have a bearing on your personal safety and yourability to work effectively. Working in the cold can result

in hypothermia or frostbite – and even the heavy and bulkyclothing worn for protection from the cold can causeproblems on the work site.

Hypothermia, or below-normal body temperature, isgenerally the result of a combination of factors, includingcold and windy weather, fatigue and clothing that is poorlyinsulated or wet.

There is a range of outward signs of hypothermia,depending on the severity.

• Mild hypothermia: mild shivering, discomfort andmuddled thinking

• Moderate hypothermia: violent shivering, loss ofdexterity of the hands and feet, and an inability to thinkand pay attention

• Severe hypothermia: unconsciousness and death

Clearly, the lapses in judgment and attention span thatoccur even in mild cases of hypothermia can have seriousconsequences on the worksite.

Exposure to cold can reduce muscle power and gripstrength, thus limiting your ability to work for extended

periods. Reduced power and strength can make climbing aladder or similar structure very challenging.

Cold combined with vibration can reduce the flow ofblood to the hands and fingers and cause hand-arm vibrationsyndrome (HAVS), also know as “vibration-induced whitefinger” or “dead-finger.” Symptoms include numbness, lossof grip strength and clumsiness with the hands.

Many workers rely on their hands to operate equipmentcontrols, adjust process controls, sense surface temperaturesand finishes, and hold heavy or awkward tools. In coldweather, these workers may take longer to perform anaction and/or need to attempt an action repeatedly. In somecases they may be altogether unable to perform an actionuntil they get warmed up or alter their clothing.

In addition, exposed skin can be affected by the cold.Frostbite results from thick layers of tissue freezing solid.The affected area feels hard and cold, and turns white orgrey. Frostnip is a mild form of frostbite affecting only theskin’s outer layers. Either condition affects your health andcan influence your ability to work safely.

Clothing worn in the cold can also affect performance.Hats and hoods may interfere with hearing, vision andmovement. Bulky clothing layers may restrict movement,particularly in tight spaces, and increase the amount ofeffort required to move. Gloves, mittens and overmitts mayreduce dexterity and “feel,” while heavy and bulky footwearmay not fit into footholds or onto foot pedals. Clothing“systems” appropriate for the task and the temperature canovercome many of these limitations.

Ray Cislo, P.Eng., B.Sc.(H.K.), is a safety engineering specialist at WorkplacePolicy and Standards, Alberta Human Resources and Employment.

Working in the ColdPart TwoFocus on Human Performance

by Ray Cislo

R e s o u r c e s

WEB LINKwww.gov.ab.ca/hre/whs/publications/pdf/mg021.pdfWorking in the Cold, Alberta Health and Safety Bulletin

outside.away.com/outside/features/200212/200212_popsicle_splash.html#Video clips about hypothermia and cold water immersion

www.umanitoba.ca/faculties/physed/research/people/giesbrecht/Cold_Weather_Clothing.pdf Cold Weather Clothing

Page 19: FINDING A BALANCE - Legislative Assembly of Alberta A BALANCE OH&S Programs in Alberta A Centennial Retrospective V OLUME 28 ¥ NUMBER 3 ¥ SEPTEMBER 2005 2 OCCUPA TIONAL HEALTH &

19O C C U P A T I O N A L H E A L T H & S A F E T Y M A G A Z I N E • S E P T E M B E R 2 0 0 5

New Partners in Health and SafetyWelcome to three new Partners in Health and Safety:

■ Kawneer Company Canada■ Universal Compression Inc.■ Bird Construction Company Limited

First Youth Health and Safety Conference“What’s In It 4 U,” the first youth health and safety conferencesponsored by the Safe Communities Coalition of CentralAlberta, targeted youth who are new to the workforce orabout to enter the workforce. Held in Red Deer on April 23,2005, the conference featured several guest speakers,including Tammy Doyle and Barry Weatherall, who sufferedserious injuries at work, and Julie Hamilton, whose son diedin a workplace incident.

Partnerships Strategic PlanThe Partnerships Strategic Plan for 2005-06 describes theprogram’s growth and accomplishments, and outlinesmajor initiatives for the next year.

The current strategic directions have two majorsources. First, an evaluation of the Partnerships programcompleted in 2003 (the “Banister Report”) found thatPartnerships has many successes and enjoys industrysupport, but the report also made recommendations foraction to support continued program growth andimprovement. Secondly, the Work Safe Alberta Initiativehas helped to heighten awareness of health and safetyamong Albertans.

The Partnerships program continues to emphasizequality and credibility, and has begun to expand into newindustry sectors. The Alberta Restaurant and FoodservicesAssociation became a formal Partner in 2004, and in thatsame year the province’s first independent restaurant,Chili’s, achieved a Certificate of Recognition. During 2004employers in the retail, airline and newspaper industriesalso achieved CORs.

Partnerships has grown from 1,000 COR-holders in 1997 toover 5,000 at the end of 2004. This rapid growth has presentedmany challenges for the program and will continue to do so.

Retaining program quality and balancing stakeholders’business interests will be of primary importance. Improvingstandards without creating disincentives to participationwill also require attention.

The Strategic Plan has been sent to stakeholders andposted on the Partnerships website.

NEWSPartnerships

Partnerships in Health and Safety is a non-regulatory,province-wide injury prevention program sponsoredcooperatively by government, labour and industry. The program offers:

• tools to implement a health and safety management system

• guidance in applying for a Certificate of Recognition (COR)

• potential for premium refunds from the Workers’Compensation Board-Alberta

For more information, call 1-866-415-8690 toll free in Alberta or 415-8690 in Edmonton and area. Or visitwww.whs.gov.ab.ca/partners.

HIGHLIGHTS OF THE 2005-06 STRATEGIC PLAN INCLUDE:1 reviewing the small employer program and

identifying potential changes for improvement

2 increasing Partnerships participation in the retailand health care industries (The Continuing CareSafety Association’s new status as a funded safetyassociation will assist with program growth for its members.)

3 investigating the development of a program specificto owner/operators in order to provide tools bettersuited to employers of this size

4 investigating the need for and acceptance of a new“Gold Standard” or “Best Practices” level ofPartnerships for employers who wish to pursuecontinued improvement

5 negotiating the possibility of equivalency between the Partnerships standard and the InternationalStandards Organization, Occupational Health andSafety Assessment Series 18001 Standard (As thePartnerships program expands into otherjurisdictions such as British Columbia andSaskatchewan, Alberta will be challenged toremain a leader, address requests for equivalencyand respond to the potential for a western ornational standard.)

Page 20: FINDING A BALANCE - Legislative Assembly of Alberta A BALANCE OH&S Programs in Alberta A Centennial Retrospective V OLUME 28 ¥ NUMBER 3 ¥ SEPTEMBER 2005 2 OCCUPA TIONAL HEALTH &

O C C U P A T I O N A L H E A L T H & S A F E T Y M A G A Z I N E • S E P T E M B E R 2 0 0 520

GE Energy in Calgary, a major manufacturing facility,was awarded the Partnerships Certificate of Recognitionthree years ago. It was the first of the GE sites in Albertato receive the award.

S afety starts at the front door, the moment visitorsenter the lobby of the blue GE Energy building nearthe Calgary airport.

The security guard greets new arrivals with a smile andinvites them to sign in while awaiting their internal contact.At GE Energy the next few minutes of conversation aren’tabout the weather, the traffic or an offer for coffee – they areabout what happens if there is an emergency and the alarmsounds. Visitors are asked to turn and look toward the flagpoles in the parking lot, which is the gathering point forvisitors if they need to evacuate the building. There’s nomisunderstanding about where to go or what to do. Everyvisitor is also handed an information sheet that outlines whoto call in case of emergency and includes a map of the facility.

Precise, time-consuming workThis GE site designs, manufactures and assembles monitoringand control equipment that delivers reliable and quality power,

using real-time informationtechnology specificallydeveloped for electric powerapplications. It’s precise,time-consuming work.Technicians need steadyhands and keen eyes to puttogether and test the circuitboards, and assemble themto stringent specifications.

GE Energy technicians have exactly the right amount oflight and sit in ergonomic chairs, at benches that are oftenheight-adjustable. Depending on the job, sometimes eventhe floors are raised to ensure that people are at the rightangle to do the job effectively.

The manufacturing techs take mandatory stretchbreaks every morning and afternoon. “The area leadstands in the middle of the aisle where everyone can seeand leads a stretch that’s specific to the job,” says LynnBurns, environment, health and safety manager. “Sincewe put the stretch breaks in place about four years ago, a lot less people get stiff or have headaches or otherergonomic risk symptoms.”

Covering all the basesWithin the company, staff serve on various safety-relatedcommittees and teams, and receive extensive training thatis both computer-based (often offered in many languages)and face-to-face. The first aid team alone has 45 members.This is because the company’s goal is to train as manyemployees as possible in first aid. All personnel who visitfield sites are currently trained emergency first aiders.

Safety consciousness at this facility is part of the biggerframework for the Atlanta, Georgia-based company, saysBurns. “GE Energy Headquarters has a blanket EHS policythat all facilities have to comply with. It covers everythingfrom management practices to lockout/tagout practices.Individual sites modify these to accommodate local andregional differences in regulations.”

According to Ken Kan, GE Energy EHS manager for globalmanufacturing, “GE is, year after year, one of the world’smost admired companies. GE wants to be the best, andexpects to be the best.”

P r o f i l e

GE EnergyCALGARY

by Kerry Tremblay

Page 21: FINDING A BALANCE - Legislative Assembly of Alberta A BALANCE OH&S Programs in Alberta A Centennial Retrospective V OLUME 28 ¥ NUMBER 3 ¥ SEPTEMBER 2005 2 OCCUPA TIONAL HEALTH &

O C C U P A T I O N A L H E A L T H & S A F E T Y M A G A Z I N E • S E P T E M B E R 2 0 0 5 21

Kan says one of the advantages of working for this bigcorporation is the tools that have been designed to helpdrive EHS performance. For example, a computer programtracks EHS-related actions. “If during a site inspectionLynn (Burns) notices that a particular area of the(manufacturing) floor needs a new or different type ofpersonal protective equipment, this is entered andresponsibility tracked through the computer application.A due date is given by when it needs to be resolved. Theaction is tracked, and reminders are sent to the personresponsible for getting the jobdone. If it’s not done, then theperson’s supervisor gets anautomatically generated note.” Thesite’s responsiveness in completingactions is tracked and rolled up ina “closure rate” metric that thesite leadership is measured on.That way, he says, the requestdoesn’t get lost in the day-to-dayrush of business. People, including senior management,are held accountable for getting the tasks done.

Nina Novak, Alberta Workplace Health & Safety officer,says GE “seems to have covered all the bases, and thensome. They have a very comprehensive approach, and that’slabour-intensive.” Getting to that point, she says, takesmanagement commitment, effort and support for healthand safety.

Sharing best practicesPerry Scott, a Partnerships consultant who works with GEEnergy to set up internal goals for improvement, says thatin GE’s case most of the issues he helps with are finding

ways to increase their safety profile. “GE Energy is veryprogressive and dynamic.”

Mike Joyce, executive director of Manufacturers’ Healthand Safety Association, says, “The GE people’s enthusiasmpasses on to others. When GE people attend our meetings,it gives some of our other members the ideas andincentives they need to move forward. Sometimes GE doesthings that others just haven’t thought of.” And thecompany is willing to share what it has learned and itsbest practices from around the globe.

When the company received itsPartnerships Certificate of Recognition,senior management from the Atlantaheadquarters came to the beef-on-a-buncelebration. When recertification timecame this year, again senior managerscame, and the workers involved in theCOR were recognized. The program’ssuccess is also celebrated internationally

through the parent company’s website.

Kerry Tremblay is a Calgary freelance writer specializing in safetyand training.

“GE wants to be the best, and expects to be the best.”

R e s o u r c e s

WEB LINKwww.gepower.com/about/press/en/2003_press/012003.htmGE Energy press release

Stretch break at GE Energy, Calgary Photo courtesy of GE Energy

Page 22: FINDING A BALANCE - Legislative Assembly of Alberta A BALANCE OH&S Programs in Alberta A Centennial Retrospective V OLUME 28 ¥ NUMBER 3 ¥ SEPTEMBER 2005 2 OCCUPA TIONAL HEALTH &

O C C U P A T I O N A L H E A L T H & S A F E T Y M A G A Z I N E • S E P T E M B E R 2 0 0 522

We b W a t c h e rby Bob Christie

Running a good health and safety program in anorganization often presents two major difficulties:managing issues seemingly unrelated to H&S …

and the damnable paperwork. In Alberta many of those paperwork issues are about

to find an elegant solution. A new company called ForgeDynamics is releasing its first version of a reallyintriguing Internet application called OPTIC. OPTIC canstore your MSDSs as well as prompt you when they needto be updated. It can track incident investigations and,through an interface with WCB-Alberta computers, caneven file the necessary paperwork electronically. OPTICcan manage subcontractors records as well as companypersonnel records. It can track training requirements andupdate schedules for policies and other documents. Forgeis also working on a Quality module (to assist in theprocess leading to ISO certification) and an EquipmentMaintenance module. Both will be available soon.

What is particularly delicious is that the whole system(with the exception of a tiny notification kernel) runs noton your technology but on theirs. For those who arehypersensitive about data security, OPTIC can be mountedcompletely on your own system. However, the security atForge and the benefits of letting them handle thingsmake hosting your own site a less attractive option.

OPTIC costs from as little as $10,000 for a smallercompany to well over a quarter of a million dollars for a bigfacility, and there is also a nominal annual maintenancefee (in the order of $100 per employee). Of course, the issueis not what it costs but what it saves. The cost-benefit issueis easy to resolve once you compare the cost of somethinglike OPTIC to the total cost of just one incident.

If you are interested in taking a serious look at OPTIC,you will find Forge at www.forgedynamics.com/. Companyfounder and President Mat Matthews assures us that heand his people are only too willing to come to yourlocation to demonstrate OPTIC. Do call or fire off an e-mail to request a demo. I think you will be impressed,particularly in this day and age of manpower shortages.

Bob Christie is a partner at Christie Communications Ltd., amultimedia development company in Edmonton. Bob suppliesmost of the Web link resources for the articles in this magazine.

Real WorldSolutions

What improvements have you made at yourworkplace? If you’ve found a solution worthsharing, please send it to [email protected].

LIFTING HUNDREDS OF PLANT POTSTHE PROBLEMWorkers at garden centres may need to handlehundreds of small plant pots in a day – reaching,lifting, carrying and lowering them.

A SOLUTIONA light, length-adjustable potlifter can handle several pots atonce. The lifter could be adaptedfor use with other objects.

BENEFITBy greatly reducingrepetitive bending andlifting, the workeravoids overusing theback and arms.

WHEELBARROW CONVERTED TO DUMP CARTTHE PROBLEMWheelbarrows need tobe raised up by thehandles to ride on their single wheel.

A SOLUTIONConvert thewheelbarrow to a pushcart by adding two wheelsat the back. Various conversion kits are availablecommercially.

BENEFITSWorkers avoid unnecessary lifting, and whennecessary the wheelbarrow can still be used on its single front wheel.

Paperwork Can Make You Crazy

Page 23: FINDING A BALANCE - Legislative Assembly of Alberta A BALANCE OH&S Programs in Alberta A Centennial Retrospective V OLUME 28 ¥ NUMBER 3 ¥ SEPTEMBER 2005 2 OCCUPA TIONAL HEALTH &

Wo r k p l a c e H e a l t h& S a f e t y (WHS)

Contact Workplace Health & Safety any timeFor occupational health and safetyinformation and assistance, or to orderWorkplace Health & Safety publications,phone the Contact Centre at 1-866-415-8690toll free (415-8690 in Edmonton and area) or visit www.whs.gov.ab.ca/expert.

Sign up forWorkplace Health & Safety eNews

To be notified by e-mail of all new WorkplaceHealth & Safety Website postings, sign up for a FREE subscription service throughwww.whs.gov.ab.ca/subscribe.asp.

Alberta Government Library Labour Building SiteTo review the large selection of occupationalhealth and safety information materialsavailable through the Alberta government, go to www3.gov.ab.ca/hre/library/

To borrow materials, either contact your locallibrary and make your requests through theinter-library loan system or visit the AlbertaGovernment Library:

3rd floor, 10808 - 99 Avenue

Edmonton, AB T5K 0G5

Library phone (780) 427-8533

Audio-Visual Services phone (780) 427-4671

To reach either of the above numbers toll-freein Alberta, dial 310-0000 followed by the areacode and phone number.

Fax (780) 422-0084

Workplace Health & Safety is a division of AlbertaHuman Resources and Employment and falls under thejurisdiction of Minister Mike Cardinal.

The following information about deaths caused by work-related incidents or exposure ispublished to remind readers of the importance of workplace health and safety. In manycases the investigation into these fatalities is continuing. Final investigation reports arefiled at the Alberta Government Library – Labour Building Site and can be reviewed thereor at www.whs.gov.ab.ca/fatalities. To protect personal privacy, the fatalitydescriptions do not include the names of the deceased.

The following fatalities have been or are being investigated.A 28-year-old machinist with approximately one year of experience was operatinga vertical turret lathe. While the machine was still running, the worker attemptedto cut a long strand of metal shaving from the lathe. His foot got caught in themetal strand, and he was pulled into the lathe.

A 27-year-old logger parked a skidder on a hill. When the skidder began to rolldown the hill, the logger attempted to stop it and was crushed under the blade.

A 59-year-old equipment operator is presumed to have drowned but his body hasnot yet been recovered. As a member of a crew that was constructing an ice bridgeacross a river, the worker was operating a snowcat and the machine brokethrough thin ice.

A 60-year-old security guard was found dead in a parking lot, pinned under thewheels of his personal van. The worker started the vehicle to check the level oftransmission fluid. He shut off the engine and went to the rear of the vehicle toget some more fluid. The van then rolled back over the worker.

A 25-year-old apprentice welder was killed when struck by pieces ofstructural steel.

A 50-year-old company president was standing on top of a load of steel beams ona flat-bed trailer and directing a forklift operator who was placing two additionalsteel beams on the load. When the beams fell off the forklift onto the ground, theworker also fell to the ground and was crushed under one of the beams.

A 51-year-old surveyor was struck by a falling tree that he was cutting down.

A 55-year-old labourer was helping other crew members remove a piece ofsteel from a hole opener. A metal tong appears to have struck the worker inthe head area.

A 57-year-old planer mill technician tried to reposition a doubled-up board onthe planer infeed transfer table. When the board contacted the infeed mechanismit shot out and struck the worker in the abdomen. He died from his injuries inhospital a few days later.

A 58-year-old rig manager was working with a crew that was using a forklift totransfer compressed nitrogen accumulators and nitrogen cylinders from a tractortrailer to a pick-up truck. When one of the accumulators dislodged from thepallet, the worker went to stabilize it but it fell to the ground and ruptured,killing the worker.

A 43-year-old framer sustained fatal injuries when he fell 4.2 metres from a roof.He was not wearing fall protection.

A 21-year-old oilfield worker was found unconscious in a separator building thatcontained the piping controls for a horizontal pressure vessel. The cause of deathhas not been determined.

A 70-year-old worker was delivering flyers in a freezing rain storm when heslipped and fell on the ice. The worker later went to hospital, where he died ofhis injuries several days later.

Work-related incident fatalities January 2005 – April 2005

O C C U P A T I O N A L H E A L T H & S A F E T Y M A G A Z I N E • S E P T E M B E R 2 0 0 5 23

Wo r k p l a c e F a t a l i t i e s

Page 24: FINDING A BALANCE - Legislative Assembly of Alberta A BALANCE OH&S Programs in Alberta A Centennial Retrospective V OLUME 28 ¥ NUMBER 3 ¥ SEPTEMBER 2005 2 OCCUPA TIONAL HEALTH &

Return Undeliverable Canadian Addresses to:

CIRCULATION DEPARTMENTAlberta Human Resources and Employment

Workplace Health & Safety and Employment Standards Compliance

10th Floor, South Tower, Capital Health Centre 10030 - 107 Street, Edmonton, AB, T5J 3E4

E-mail: [email protected] Mail Agreement Number 40062521

ISSN 0705-6052 © 2005

www.alis.gov.ab.ca/centennialClick for highlights of Alberta’s labour market over the past 100 years

1905 to 2005 • Building on a Century of Growth, Prosperity and Success

Pho t

os c

ourt

esy

of: P

rovi

ncia

l Arc

hive

s of

Alb

erta

, The

Edm

onto

n Jo

urna

l, G

lenb

ow A

rchi

ves,

A

lber

ta E

cono

mic

Dev

elop

men

t, A

lber

ta In

nova

tion

and

Scie

nce,

and

Wom

en B

uild

ing

Futu

res