Anas Alam Faizli, Master of Proj Mgmt: Assignment Project Quality Management, EMQM5103
Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
-
Upload
stefanie-bayer -
Category
Documents
-
view
221 -
download
0
Transcript of Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 1/32
Assignment 2
Private Equity
Presented by:
Bayer, Stefanie
Cavaleri, Tobias
Díaz Palancar, Alfredo
Stoll, Jürgen
Stolz, Oliver
Lecturer: Dirk Zimmermann
Class: Financial Management
MBA GM06 (Spring 2010)
Due Date: 21.06.2010
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 2/32
ii
Financial Management Private Equity
Table of Contents
Index of Figures ............................................................................................................... iii Index of Tables ................................................................................................................. iii Index of Abbreviations ..................................................................................................... iv 1 Introduction and key definitions ................................................................................ 1
1.1 What is Private Equity? ...................................................................................... 1 1.2 Private Equity Firms ........................................................................................... 2 1.3 Private Equity Funds .......................................................................................... 3
2 Market size and major trends 2010 ............................................................................ 5 3 Types of Private Equity transactions ......................................................................... 9
3.1 Venture Capital ................................................................................................. 10 3.2 Growth (Expansion) Capital ............................................................................. 12 3.3 Acquisition / Buyout financing transactions .................................................... 12 3.4 Other types of transactions ............................................................................... 14
3.4.1 Secondary buyouts .................................................................................... 15 3.4.2 Mezzanine Financing ................................................................................ 15
4 A typical MBO process............................................................................................ 16 5 Private equity as a financing source ........................................................................ 19
5.1 Key findings on Productivity and Management performance .......................... 20 5.2 Key findings on Strategic Portfolio and continuity .......................................... 21 5.3 Key findings on employment ........................................................................... 21 5.4 Summary of Pros and Cons on the PE as financing activity: ........................... 23
Bibliography .................................................................................................................... 24 Appendix ......................................................................................................................... 27
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 3/32
iii
Financial Management Private Equity
Index of Figures
Figure 1: Private vs. Public Equity (own illustration based on (Bundesverband
Deutscher Kapitalbeteiligungsgesellschafen)) .................................................................. 2 Figure 2: Private Equity Fund Diagram (How do Private Equity Fund Investments
Work? 2010)...................................................................................................................... 4 Figure 3: Global LBO volume in US$billion by Region, January thru June 2009
(RREEF Research 2009) ................................................................................................... 5 Figure 4: Growth of primary and secondary PE market (RREEF Research 2009) .......... 7 Figure 5: Product Life Cycle (Fraser-Sampson 2010, 8) .................................................. 9 Figure 6: The MBO-Participants and their roles (own illustration based on (Manches
LLP)) ............................................................................................................................... 17 Figure 7: Organizational and financial flow of a MBA-process (own illustration based
on (Manches LLP) and (Hoffmann et al. 1992, 68))....................................................... 18 Figure 8: Private equity-owned firms have the best raw management practice scores on
average (The Global Economic Impact of Private Equity Report 2009, 11) .................. 20 Figure 9: Manufacturing employment under private equity targets: year and as
percentage of manufacturing sector employment (The Global Economic Impact of
Private Equity Report 2009, 39)...................................................................................... 22 Figure 10: Private Equity Landscape Chart (Tuck Center for Private Equity and
Entrepreneurship) ............................................................................................................ 28
Index of Tables
Table 1: Real GDP chance (RREEF Research 2009) ....................................................... 5 Table 2: Future trends within private equity (own illustration) ........................................ 8 Table 3: Comparison of the three main types of Private Equity transactions (own
illustration) ...................................................................................................................... 10 Table 4: Pros and cons of PE as an alternative financing source (own illustration) ....... 23
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 4/32
iv
Financial Management Private Equity
Index of Abbreviations
APAC
Asia-Pacfic
BRIC
Brasil, Russia, India, China
GP
General Partner
LBO
Leveraged Buyout
LP
Limited Partner
MBI
Management Buyin
MBO
Management Buyout
PE
Private Equity
SBIC
Small Business Investment Companies
VC
Venture Capital
WEF
World Economic Forum
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 5/32
1
Financial Management Private Equity
1 Introduction and key definitions
1.1 What is Private Equity?
“Private equity is money invested in companies that are not publicly traded on a stock
exchange or invested as part of buyouts of publicly traded companies in order to make
them private companies.” (Investopedia)
In general there are two different options to invest in a company.
If the company has gone public you can buy shares of that firm at the public capital
market (stock exchange market). This kind of investment is called “Public Equity”.
An investment in a company that is not listed at the public capital market is a “Private
Equity” investment. So the term “private” is related to the kind of the existing
ownership of the company’s equity. It doesn’t mean that the financing of the investment
itself is done by “private” money or cash.
There are some significant differences between the main characteristics of a “Public
Equity” and a “Private Equity” business.
In the form of Public Equity the investor has usually no limitation of the time frame of
his investment. He can handle his investments very flexible, which means adjusting his
business quite easy in a short term e.g. by buying and selling shares on a day to day
basis. Also it is a standard to put investments into different companies or industries. But
with this way of investment the investor does not have a big influence and power on the
company’s daily business and further strategic planning. A public company works like a
representative democracy. The designated board of directors monitors and discusses
with the Management the company’s future and development. The annual meeting is
more or less the only way to address an investor’s opinion to the board of directors.
In comparison the Private Equity investment is directly linked to a more entrepreneurial
attitude. With such an investment you can be part of the company’s management, if you
are have operational control, and you can play a part in decisions concerning the future
of the company’s business. On the other hand this kind of investment is less flexible to
rearrange or sell within a short time period. Only if the complete company value hasincreased it makes sense for the investor to sell his investment.
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 6/32
2
Financial Management Private Equity
Figure 1: Private vs. Public Equity (own illustration based on (Bundesverband DeutscherKapitalbeteiligungsgesellschafen))
1.2 Private Equity Firms
Especially start-up companies need to raise money for finance growth. Very often the
business plans and strategies do not give opportunities to make profit in the short terms
which stops banks from giving out necessary loans.
Also Private equity firms very often invest in troubled companies. Of course they have
to analyze the financial structure and potential of profits carefully upfront to determine
if the profit risk ratio makes the investment reasonable. Therefore Private Equity
companies are an important tool for driving growth and improving performance for
companies that struggle to survive.
That can work out, because Private equity owners and the managers of their acquired
companies can focus in an accurate way on what is required to improve long-term
performance. This structure also makes it far easier to align the interests of owners with
those of managers who also have a direct stake in the success of the company.
“Private equity firms typically hold companies for about five years, and then sell them,
hoping to realize a gain on the sale as a result of the increased value they have createdduring their period of ownership. The general partners cannot recover any of their
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 7/32
3
Financial Management Private Equity
money until and unless they return to investors their principal plus the first eight to 10
percent of partnership profits. If there are no profits, PE partners not only make no
money, they lose their own equity investment.” (Private Equity Council 2008)
The most important Private Equity Companies worldwide today:
• Apax Partners (www.apax.com)
• Apollo Global Management LLC
• Bain Capital Partners (www.baincapital.com)
• The Blackstone Group (www.blackstone.com)
• The Carlyle Group (www.carlyle.com)
• Hellman & Friedman LLC (www.hf.com)
• Kohlberg Kravis Roberts & Co. (www.kkr.com)
• Madison Dearborn Partners (www.mdcp.com)
• Permira (www.permira.com)
• Providence Equity Partners (www.provequity.com)
• Silver Lake (www.silverlake.com)
• TPG Capital (www.tpg.com)
1.3 Private Equity Funds
Private Equity investing can be divided into two main categories: fund investing and
company investing. A Private Equity fund is a portfolio of companies established by a
Private Equity firm where interested parties can invest in. It is one layer above company
investment and for this reason company investment is also called direct investment.
Private Equity firms establish funds that raise capital from investors, who are known as
limited partners (LP). The Private Equity firm (called: general partner = GP) finally
decides to invest this raised capital along with their own capital into companies that
they believe can achieve profitability with their infusion of skill and capital.
Because one fund is grouping different investments from different kind of investors, PE
fund are also called as “pooled investment vehicle”.
Private equity funds are typically limited partnerships with a fixed term of 10 years
(often with annual extensions).
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 8/32
4
Financial Management Private Equity
The Private Equity firm is the expert to manage and control each issued Private Equity
fund. Also it is there key competence to establish a certain reasonable and balanced
portfolio of different funds across certain industries that fit to their particular focus of
business.
Figure 2: Private Equity Fund Diagram (How do Private Equity Fund Investments Work? 2010)
The Private Equity target is to create value over the long-term, compared to e.g. hedge
funds. Private equity funds typically own and buy whole companies and help them to
realize profit growth over time. Typically Private Equity firms own companies in their
portfolios for about five years.
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 9/32
5
Financial Management Private Equity
2 Market size and major trends 2010
In the past few decades, the private equity (PE) industry has grown both in terms of size
and geographic reach. In fact, PE has evolved into a major force in global finance over
the last 10 years. Roughly US$2.5 trillion of assets are under PE management.
However, PE transactions outside North America and Western Europe are still relatively
few and only account for approximately 12% of the global LBO (Leveraged Buy-Out)
transactions in number and 9% in value over the period from 2001 to 2007. But this is
going to change now, recognizing growing PE investment activities into the emerging
markets. Without doubt, PE activities in emerging economies are expanding and
maturing, particularly for minority and growth capital investments, as stated in a
research report by the World Economic Forum in 2008. Taking the growth opportunities
within the regions Asia Pacific, Latin America and Middle East (Table 1), there is still
an investment backlog in emerging regions compared to the LBO levels in North
America and Europe (Figure 3).
Table 1: Real GDP chance (RREEF Research 2009)
Figure 3: Global LBO volume in US$billion by Region, January thru June 2009 (RREEF Research 2009)
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 10/32
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 11/32
7
Financial Management Private Equity
Figure 4: Growth of primary and secondary PE market (RREEF Research 2009)
What’s about the Private Equity industry trend in 2010? The Private Equity industry is
dominated by a small group of large firms whose core business is buyouts. With their
global reach, deep pockets, professional back office operations and sectorial expertise
they primarily drive the growth of this industry. Smaller players will be able to find
niches in specialist markets and industries, but they do not have a big impact on the
private equity industry. However, during the global economic downturn in the years
2008 and 2009, there have been a lot of speculations in the press that the private equity
model is dead. But after a phase of reflection and retrenchment there are signs that the
private equity industry is shaking off the credit crisis and the economic recession. Many
investors appear optimistic about the outlook for private equity again. Credit markets
are continuing to stabilize and the deal volume seems to be recovering during the year
2010. However, according to a research of Pricewaterhouse Coopers in late 2009
(Pricewaterhouse-Coopers 2009), over 80% of private equity funds expect the business
model to change in the future.
Expecting a more robust market for 2010, there will be opportunities for PE firms to
make smart acquisitions at bargain prices. However, the past experience of the
economic and financial crises has limited the financing options. The request for larger
equity contributions will lower the leverage of acquisitions. Politics and society demand
for greater transparency and more robust reporting within the private equity industry.
Table 2 illustrates a summary of some future trends for the private equity industry.
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 12/32
8
Financial Management Private Equity
IN OUT
Liquidity (e.g., liquidity events,
available capital)
Illiquidity (e.g., near complete
absence of capital for financing or
equity investment)
More equity in LBOs (e.g., co-
investment capital)
Excessive leverage
Registration, reporting and
transparency requirements
Megacap buyouts
Secondaries in private equity Shorter duration private equity funds
Emerging markets become more
important
Table 2: Future trends within private equity (own illustration)
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 13/32
9
Financial Management Private Equity
3 Types of Private Equity transactions
Private equity transactions can be categorized best by the type of company the
investment is made in. Therefore it is helpful to look at the Product Life Cycle, which
can be thought of as the hunting ground of each of the main types of Private Equity
activity.
Figure 5: Product Life Cycle (Fraser-Sampson 2010, 8)
In other words, the type of Private Equity investment depends on the development stage
the company is in. A new company still getting started (“Introduction” stage) has low
cash flows, it not yet well established and investing in it bears a relatively high risk. On
the other hand the size of the investment will be relatively low in comparison to
investments in grown companies. When a company is for example in the “Maturity
stage”, it is probably well know, already in a strong cash position and will attract and
need other investors than companies that are still trying to establish a strong market
position in the “Growth stage”. Keeping the type of company, respectively the stage of
development in mind, three main types of Private Equity transactions can be identified:
Venture Capital transactions
Growth (Expansion) financing transactions
Acquisition / Buyout financing transactions
In the following chapters we want to look at the different types in more detail. As a
short overview, the three main types are compared against each other based on a couple
of criteria in Table 3.
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 14/32
10
Financial Management Private Equity
Criterion Venture Capital Growth Acquisition / Buyout
Companiestargeted
Start-up companies,companies in earlystages of development
Establishedcompanies that needto at least stabilizetheir market position
and grow
Mature / establishedcompanies
Reason forinvesting
Build company,make a business outof ideas, getcompanies started
Make companiesmore profitable,bigger, morevaluable; growcompany e.g. to gopublic or be sold
Buy the company orbuy and resell it toother company; goingprivate
Operationalcontrol
More guidance thancontrol onmanagement /
operations
Little influence onmanagement,investors role is
mainly to providecash
Depends on type of investor: strategic orfinancial investor
Risk involved High due to “infantmortality”
Low risk Medium to low risk
Use of leverage Almost never Mostly not Almost always
Size of investment
US$50,000 - US$5m US$5m – US$50m US$2m – US$200m+
Table 3: Comparison of the three main types of Private Equity transactions (own illustration)
3.1
Venture Capital
Venture Capital investments target either start-ups that have just developed an business
idea and / or a business plan or young companies that are in their early stages of
development and are in need to get started. These companies usually bear strong
technological risks, have high R&D expenses or have important investments in
equipment, intellectual property and more generally in immobilizations. The main
industries VC investments were made in the last couple of years are information
technology (IT), life science (LS) and clean technologies. For example venture capital
investments in 2008 in Europe were done by 56.8% in the IT sector, by 16.5% in the LS
sector.
Funding to build a company from scratch with only ideas and a business plan in the
back are called seed funding. Seed funding is mostly done by the founders themselves -
often through securing bank loans against personal collateral, friends, family members
or business angels, who specialized in finance innovating start-ups. Business angels are
usually former entrepreneurs or executives who turned out to be high net worth
individuals. The goal of seed funding is the development of the first business structures
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 15/32
11
Financial Management Private Equity
from ideas and business plans, to gather the initial capital, acquire key human resources
and identify early business partners. Seed investing is one of the least favored areas of
investing because the death rate of the companies in these stages are relatively high and
returns are usually received after a period over more than five years.
Seed funding is crucial for businesses because it shapes the future company. To provide
innovative ideas and companies a platform for development, many countries try to
replicate the Silicon Valley idea by building “technoparks” (Switzerland) or “capuses”
(UK) where solid infrastructure, a pool of investment and human resources are gathered
together.
In addition to private investors we have venture capital funds which are “formal
business entities in which full-time professionals seek out and fund promisingventures”. (Megginson et al. 2008, 475) Megginson et al. identify four different types of
VC funds: small business investment companies (SBICs; federal charted corporations),
financial venture capital funds (subsidiaries of financial institutions), corporate venture
capital funds (subsidiaries or stand-alone firms of non-financial corporations, e.g. Intel
Capital, Siemens Ventures) and venture capital limited partnerships (funds established
by professional venture capital firms). For further details we refer to (Megginson et al.
2008).
To minimize the risks of venture capital investments many investors do not only
providing financial help but also soft capital. They help the company to find their first
customers for pilot projects, try to attract human resources in the company, provide for
example qualified lawyers and auditors and give guidance in general management
decisions. Investors often form venture syndicates because the different investors have
different expertise and know-how.
Normally several rounds of financing are needed to help a company to get to a stage
where it can survive on its own. Most of investors will provide at least 2 times of the
initial investment during the next periods. It depends on the speed of the development
and the outlook of the company’s future if a next round of funding will be granted or
given by the investors. If the company does not move forward as hope, investments will
be stopped and the company along with its business idea is very likely sentenced to
death.
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 16/32
12
Financial Management Private Equity
But not every start-up company needs venture capital to become successful. For
example Microsoft was not venture backed; it was financed through its first customer
(IBM). But also the amount / rounds of financing differs strongly between companies:
Google needed only 2 rounds of VC financing whereas FedEx needed 10 rounds of
financing. Therefore sometimes it is difficult to draw a straight line between VentureCapital investment and Growth Capital investment.
3.2 Growth (Expansion) Capital
Growth, Development or Expansion Capital is generally associated with companies that
are well established and already run a profitable business. These companies need capital
to expand their business and grow. For example they need to build new plants and
increase their level of production, develop new products, research new technologies orwant to enter new markets. Many companies in this stage are not granted sufficient bank
loans due to their size, their financial records or because banks associate still too high
risks with the company. This is where other players enter the game and provide these
companies with sufficient financing. In the past it was relatively difficult to identify
sources that were specialized on growth capital financing. Most of the time it was LBO
fund managers who decided to put money into companies. But over the last couple of
years some funds emerged out of industrial groups like 21 Investimenti (Italy) which
focused strongly on the mid-market. Also due to the development of the emerging
markets more and more companies need this kind of financing and the number of funds
specializing in this area of investment increases.
Investors of growth capital take minority as well as majority stakes in the investee
company. Normally no leverage is used because the target company needs a strong
financial position to finance its development. Depending on the success of the company
e.g. in gaining market share or enter a new market the revenues from growth capital
transactions can vary but will still be relatively low. But also the risk involved can be
categorized as low, because the company invested in is already an established company
and the chance of failure growth operations is not very high.
3.3 Acquisition / Buyout financing transactions
In general a buyout is considered as the “purchase of a company's shares in which the
acquiring party gains controlling interest of the targeted firm.” (Investopedia)Companies involved in buyouts are usually mature businesses which are able to
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 17/32
13
Financial Management Private Equity
generate sufficient profits to service the debt that is almost always issued in such a
transaction (see LBO, page 13). In former times the acquired companies were broken
up, sold in pieces and the cash generated was used to pay down the high leverage of the
transaction. Nowadays the focus lies more on adding value to the purchased company
and using the assets and the profit generated by the development of the company to paythe debt. The level of control taken by the Private Equity investor himself depends on
the reason behind the investment. Financial sponsors are only interested in securing the
profits and will most certainly not be involved in the management of the target company
personally. But to insure the success of their investments they will for example make a
deal with the management team to stay on board until the acquisition costs are leveled
out. On the other hand, a strategic investor will generally not be interested in keeping
the existing management team but will have “his” team to run operations after thetakeover to secure the success of the operation.
Buyouts happen for different reasons and in different forms. One main reason for a
company can be the wish to go private. Private companies don’t need to comply with
several restrictions and laws concerning reporting to government institutions and
stockholders. This is a way to save a lot of money. Also the management respectively
the owners can decide they want to focus more on running and growing the business
instead of complying with regulations.
We will now have a look at the different forms of buyouts.
In comparison to Venture Capital transactions, buyouts can’t be carried out without
issuing debt due to the size of the financial resources needed to acquire the target
company. This is actually one of the main ways in which one can distinguish Buyouts
from other forms of Private Equity transactions. Buyouts typically involve only a small
portion of Private Equity and a big portion of debt. This is the reason why the term LBO
(Leveraged Buyout) is often used for all buyouts. After the transaction, the investors
need to make sure that the company works profitable to be able to pay off the debt with
revenues generated out of the business. Therefore it is often the case that no matter what
special form of buyout happens, there are people involved who bring in their expertise
and advise the target company on how to generate sufficient profits. Actors in the LBO
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 18/32
14
Financial Management Private Equity
market are large Private Equity firms like the Blackstone Group1. Some of them have
also listed their funds like KKR2. The different players in the LBO market are merely
specialized either on the size of the target companies and / or on the industries the
companies are operating in.
A special form of an LBO is the Management Buyout (MBO) which will be discussed
in detail in Chapter 4. It basically means that the management team of a company or
parts of it, who have previously held a limited equity stake or no shareholding at all,
decide to acquire the company either from the parent company or from shareholders.
MBOs can arise out of a variety of reasons e.g. in case of a family business where there
are no obvious successors to take over the company. Another reason might be that the
company wants to restructure and get rid of a certain subsidiary which is then be
acquired by the management team. Historically these transactions were done by the new
owners themselves. However, in the last years it became more popular to involve
private equity firms to approach the target company and involve the new owners only at
the end of the acquisition process.
Another form of buyout is the Management Buy-in (MBI) which differs from the MBO
only in terms of the management team. The new owners were previous to the
transaction not a part of the management group and “bought their way in”. Individuals(mostly people who were involved in MBOs earlier on) interested in MBIs are most of
the time from the same industry as the target company and therefore have the necessary
expertise in the area the company operates in which reduces the risk of such a
transaction.
3.4 Other types of transactions
There are a lot of other types of private equity transactions and their categorization is
not consistent through literature. Nevertheless, the two types presented in this chapter
are the most relevant ones looking at the market.
1 http://www.blackstone.com2 http://www.kkr.com
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 19/32
15
Financial Management Private Equity
3.4.1 Secondary buyouts
“A ‘secondary buyout’ describes a transaction where an existing company created as a
consequence of a buyout backed by original private equity investors is sold to a new
buyer vehicle backed by new private equity investors.” (Yates et al. 2010)
Even though private equity funds are mostly considered an illiquid investment they can
be turned liquid through secondary buyouts. For example if a PE investor wants to sell
his part in the investee company there is significant number of secondary investors who
will take over this part. Of course this depends on the attractiveness of the investment
proposed. The market for secondary buyouts was not too strong a couple of years ago
but has increased over the last years.
3.4.2 Mezzanine Financing
Mezzanine finance got its name from its position on the balance sheet where it is
located between senior debt and equity. Another form of PE financing is Mezzanine
financing, which is strongly connected to buyouts. A “mezzanine investor will lend
money into a Buyout transaction, but with the right to convert all or part of it into shares
in the target company.” (Fraser-Sampson 2010) This type of financing can be used for
example to bridge the gap where senior creditors are reluctant to extend the debt and
stockholders are reluctant to accept the dilution of their equity position. There is a widearea of mezzanine lenders which include insurance companies, mezzanine funds,
venture capital firms or banks and other senior lenders.
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 20/32
16
Financial Management Private Equity
4 A typical MBO process
As defined in the previous chapter, MBO is a special form of a LBO in which the
existing Management team decides to acquire the company, usually in cooperation with
outside financiers. This acquisition process, which differs in some aspects from other
LBO-forms, will be described in the following by focusing on the participants as well as
on the organizational and financial flows.
Normally, the MBO is initiated by the Management Team3 who addresses its purchase
interest towards the current owner (letter of intent). The advantage of a MBO is the
existing knowledge of the Management about the company’s performance. This makes
the Due Diligence process less complicated and hence faster. The skills and the
knowledge of the management is one key success factor. The acquisition of thecompany (also called Target) is normally financed by a third party as it is highly
unlikely that the Management will have sufficient funds themselves to buy the Target
due to the high purchase price. In almost all buyouts, finance from external sources will
be required. Debt financing often covers only a small part of the investment, as MBOs
are considered too risky for a bank to give out loans. Thus, the management seeks for
private equity investors instead who invest for a proportion of the shares. For the
investors it is important to make sure that the Management is locked-in by its owninvestments. In this way, the risk of inappropriate management decisions can be
minimized. It is likely that the managements’ shares of the company increase in order to
maintain the management’s motivation to maximize the company value. The following
illustration visualizes the correlations between the participants in more detail.
3 In some cases, the initiation derives from the current owner who intends to sell the company.
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 21/32
17
Financial Management Private Equity
Figure 6: The MBO-Participants and their roles (own illustration based on (Manches LLP))
The MBO-process is not consistently described through literature. However, the most
important phases can be categorized as Preparation, Transaction and Completion phase.
As mentioned before the MBO is initiated by the announcement of the offer, normally
in an informal way. During this preparation phase, negotiations about purchase price
and contracts already between seller and buyer begin. The management team starts
elaborating the Financing-Structure in order to define the most suitable balance between
Debt and Equity Finance in consideration of expected cash flows and risk. The
preparation of a Business Plan is an important tool to catch the attention of potential
investors. The management sets up a MBO-Team with key players within the company
who leads the MBO-process.
After selecting equity advisors who are crucial as external experts for such a complex
topic regarding taxation, legislation and finance, the transaction process begins. During
this second phase, the Shareholders’ Agreement is signed. This is the deal between the
private equity provider and the management relating to their subscription for shares in,
and the managements' employment by the new company. The second deal is the Sales
Contract between Newco and the seller for the acquisition of Target. Third agreements,
so called Loan Agreements, are those between Newco and the providers of finance for
the acquisition of Target.
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 22/32
18
Financial Management Private Equity
In the completion phase the Due Diligence starts. This process, however, is likely to be
limited as buyers have already full knowledge of the company. Thus, there is no
Principal-Agent issue, which is typical of other LBO-transactions. This is also a reason
why the seller often prefers MBO as exit strategy as it is less time consuming.
The following illustration describes these 3 phases and each single step in more detail.
Figure 7: Organizational and financial flow of a MBA-process (own illustration based on (Manches LLP)and (Hoffmann et al. 1992, 68))
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 23/32
19
Financial Management Private Equity
5 Private equity as a financing source
The idea of Private Equity is relative simple and theoretically quite effective4: “buying
underperforming companies”, or companies that have found their critical mass to
continue growing, “turning them round and selling on at a profit” (Private equity
takeovers 2007), looks to be the right solution in order to eliminate inefficiency and
maximize value. By doing so, they create more financial wealth, and not only for their
own investors, but also (at least theoretically) for those companies that are being
acquired.
The central question raised by Private Equity as a financing source is: Do PE
investments aggregate growth and stability in terms of value creation or is it just a
financial tool to make short-term profit for the Private Equity firms’ point of view? Orin other words: Are Private Equity firms only concerned to secure a high and fast return
on their investment?
Private capital is now center in the on-going examination of the global financial system,
especially since the recent financial crisis5, with a consequent interest of policy-makers
to understand the impact of both traditional financial institutions, such as banks and
insurance companies, and alternative investment asset classes, such as private equity
and venture capital, on the global economy.
The World Economic Forum (WEF) publishes a report on the global economic impact
of the PE seeing it as a financing activity every year. They analyze the consequences of
this relative new financing source for those companies who decide to use it. The WEF
have defined the outcome of the overall PE activities in few fields to understand the
effects of it as investing activity: “Management Performance, Productivity, Strategically
portfolio, Risk sharing", etc. (The Global Economic Impact of Private Equity Report
2009)
As financing activity, we could also analyze the following points as well: the impact of
Private Equity on innovation, employment and corporate governance.
4 Venture capital financing is not considered in this paragraph.5 Here it is important to understand that several of these PE firms normally use traditional financingsources. They provide at the end only 15 or 20 per cent of the company capital and the rest is brought inby banks. The debts are then finally transferred traditionally to the acquired enterprises.
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 24/32
20
Financial Management Private Equity
5.1 Key findings on Productivity and Management performance
1. Firms acquired by private equity groups experience productivity growth in the two-
year period after the transaction.
2. The roughly 1,400 private equity transactions involving US manufacturing firms from1980 to 2005 raised output by somewhere between US$ 4 billion and US$ 15 billion per
year as of 2007
3. Both targets and controls tend to share productivity gains with workers in the form of
higher wages
4. Private equity-owned firms are associated with high scores on a wide range of
management practices, especially operational management practices.
(The Global Economic Impact of Private Equity Report 2009, VII)
Figure 8: Private equity-owned firms have the best raw management practice scores on average (TheGlobal Economic Impact of Private Equity Report 2009, 11)
As a critical counter argument, it could be said, that the difference in management
practice scores between Private Equity and dispersed shareholding firms (including
publicly quoted firms) is insignificant, and that normally PE firms select
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 25/32
21
Financial Management Private Equity
underperforming companies, so this incremental in productivity as well as in the
management performance should not be surprising but expectable.
5.2 Key findings on Strategic Portfolio and continuity
If we have a look at Patent quantity, we can see that it does not change after PEtransactions. The patent portfolios of firms become even more focused in the years after
PE investments. It is said that PE firms display no social responsibility; they have no
interest in investing in training or plants, since such investments are costly and rewards
are deferred and they do not have a long term view concerning their investments.
Empirically, if we look into the patent quantity from the companies before and after the
acquisition, it is clear that the portfolios of firms become even more focused in the years
after the PE investments. That would not be the case in short term strategies but more
for long term views.
It is true that many times PE firms generate profits by sacrificing necessary long-run
investments, but those are being compensated for the complete portfolio leverage.
Short-termism has been the curse of many. PE finance, being “geared to quick profits,
perpetuates this failing by discouraging long-term planning” (Private equity takeovers
2007). But the so called “quick flips” (i.e. exits within two years of investment by
private equity fund) account only for 12% of deals and have decreased in the last few
years. However, they could be a reason of the bad reputation of PE. The reality shows a
different tendency: “PE investors have a long-term ownership bias. 58% of the private
equity funds’ investments are exited more than five years after the initial transaction”
(The Global Economic Impact of Private Equity Report 2009).
5.3
Key findings on employment
While it is true that many of the PE acquisitions may include job destruction in the short
term, it is on the other hand also apparent that inefficiency damages the company’s
financial situation and finally leads to unemployment on a much greater scale (see
Figure 9).
PE firms display no social responsibility and they main task is to eager a profit in their
transactions; as financing activity, it must be clear that the governance of the company
gets diluted and many of strategically decisions, also regarding employment
management normally get out of the control of the former owner.
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 26/32
22
Financial Management Private Equity
Figure 9: Manufacturing employment under private equity targets: year and as percentage of manufacturing sector employment (The Global Economic Impact of Private Equity Report 2009, 39)
In general it can be said that there are certain inherent risks by using Private Equity as
an alternative financing source to the traditional debt acquisition as i.e. using loans from
banks.
On the one hand introducing an active partner who can share ownership, financial and
management responsibilities can lead to a better company performance and generation
of profits. On the other hand it has to be understand, that the majority of PE activities in
the past led to a total control of the management activities and to a dilution of the firm
control.
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 27/32
23
Financial Management Private Equity
5.4 Summary of Pros and Cons on the PE as financing activity:
Summarizing the previous chapters, the arguments for and against private equity as a
financing source are listed in the following table.
Pros Cons
Introducing an active partner who can
share ownership and management
responsibilities
You are accountable to other parties
Share financial responsibility with
other. Finance growth without
increasing personal debt
Control over the business and access
to the CF is diluted
Overcome the critical mass and
greater security for growth
Diluted control of your business
Inefficient companies damages the
financial situation on the company
and finally leads to unemployment
Restructuration may involve job
losses
PE investments make companies more
productive
PE firms display no social
responsibility
PE firms are significantly better
managed than government-owned,
family-owned and privately owned
firms
Normally PE firms seem to select
underperforming firms
Value-added implied by the
differential in productivity
Short-term financial goals at the
expense of operating performance.
PE investors have a long-term
ownership bias.
Main focus is to generate profits.
Some PE firms have only short term
focus
Table 4: Pros and cons of PE as an alternative financing source (own illustration)
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 28/32
24
Financial Management Private Equity
Bibliography
Bansal, A. (2006, August). An Overview of Private Equity Investments. Retrieved May
23, 2010, from IndianMBA.com:
http://www.indianmba.com/Occasional_Papers/OP154/op154.html
Bundesverband Deutscher Kapitalbeteiligungsgesellschafen . (n.d.). Retrieved May 20,
2010, from http://www.wir-investieren.de/was-ist-private-equity/private-
equity/definition-und-geschichte/
Company Partners. (2010). Retrieved May 9, 2010, from Company Partners:
http://www.companypartners.com/content/resource/types-of-private-equity-investment
Cruikshank, E. D. (2006). Adding Value in Private Equity: Lessons from Mature and
Emerging Markets.
Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu. (2007). Global Trends in Venture Capital 2007 Survey.
Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu.
Demaria, C. (2010). Introduction to private equity. The Atrium, Southern Gate,
Chichester, West Sussex.
Dumon, M. (n.d.). Why Public Companies Go Private. Retrieved May 09, 2010, from
Investopedia: http://www.investopedia.com/printable.asp?a=/articles/stocks/08/public-
companies-privatize-go-private.asp
Fraser-Sampson, G. (2010). Private equity as an asset class (2nd ed.). The Atrium,
Southern Gate, Chichester, West Sussex.
Hoffmann, P., Ramke, R. (1992). Management Buy-Out in der Bundesrepublik
Deutschland (2 ed.). Berlin.
How do Private Equity Fund Investments Work? (2010, January 12). Retrieved May 23,
2010, from Inside Trade LLC: http://insidetradellc.com/blog/how-private-equity-fund-
investments-work/comment-page-1/
Investopedia. (n.d.). Retrieved May 23, 2010, from http://www.investopedia.com/
Kaplan, S., Schoar, A. (2005, April). Private Equity Performance: Returns, persistance
and capital flows. Journal of Finance .
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 29/32
25
Financial Management Private Equity
Loiacono, S. (n.d.). Private Equity A Trendsetter For Stocks. Retrieved May 22, 2010,
from Investopedia: http://www.investopedia.com/printable.asp?a=/articles/07/private-
equity.asp
Lütjen, G. (1992). Management Buy-Out: Firmenübernahme durch Management und
Belegschaft. Wiesbaden.
Manches LLP. (n.d.). Retrieved June 04, 2010, from http://www.manches.com
Marks, K. H., Robbins, L. E., Fernández, G., Funkhouser, J. P. (2005). The Handbook
of Financing Growths: strategies and capital structure. Hoboken, New Jersey.
Megginson, W., Smart, S., Lucey, B. (2008). Introduction to Corporate Finance.
London.
Pricewaterhouse-Coopers. (2009). Private Equity Trend Report 2009. Frankfurt:
Pricewaterhouse Coopers.
Private Equity Council. (2008, July). Retrieved May 12, 2010, from
http://www.privateequitycouncil.org/
Private equity takeovers. (2007, February 26). Retrieved May 20, 2010, from The First
Post: http://www.thefirstpost.co.uk/5104,news-comment,news-politics,pros-and-cons-
of-private-equity-takeovers
RREEF Research. (2009). The Outlook for Private Equity Second Quarter 2009. San
Francisco, USA.
The Global Economic Impact of Private Equity Report 2009 - Globalization of
Alternative Investments, Working papers Vol.2. (2009, January). Retrieved May 21,
2010, from World Economic Forum:
http://www.weforum.org/pdf/cgi/pe/Full_Report2.pdf
Tuck Center for Private Equity and Entrepreneurship. (n.d.). Retrieved May 23, 2010,
from Tuck School of Business at Dartmouth:
http://mba.tuck.dartmouth.edu/pecenter/about/index.html
Value Based Management.net . (2010, March 29). Retrieved June 13, 2010, from
www.valuebasedmanagement.net
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 30/32
26
Financial Management Private Equity
World Economic Forum. (2008). The Global Economic Impact of Private Equity Report
2008. Geneva, Switzerland: World Economic Forum.
Yates, G., Hinchliffe, M. (2010). A practical guide to private equity transactions.
Cambridge.
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 31/32
27
Financial Management Private Equity
Appendix
8/2/2019 Financial Mgmt Assignment 2 - Private Equity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/financial-mgmt-assignment-2-private-equity 32/32
28
Figure 10: Private Equity Landscape Chart (Tuck Center for Private Equity and Entrepreneurship)