FILED DUKE IP - South Carolina

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

1of317

DUKEIP ENERGY,

PROGRESS

CHARLOTTE, NORTH CAROLINA

2016 DEPRECIATION STUDY

CALCULATED ANNUAL DEPRECIATIONACCRUALS RELATED TO ELECTRIC PLANT

AS OF DECEMBER 31, 2016

Prepared by:

ItJtI GannettFlemingExcellence Delivered As Promised

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

2of317

DUKE ENERGY PROGRESS

Charlotte, North Carolina

2016 DEPRECIATION STUDY

CALCULATED ANNUAL DEPRECIATIONACCRUALS RELATED TO ELECTRIC PLANT

AS OF DECEMBER 31, 2016

GANNETT FLEMING VALUATION AND RATE CONSULTANTS, LLC

Camp Hill, Pennsylvania

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

3of317

g GannettFlemingExcellence Delivered As Promised

May 23, 2017

Duke Energy Progress550 S. Tryon StreetCharlotte, NC 28202

Attention: Cynthia LeeDirector, Asset Accounting

Ladies and Gentlemen:

Pursuant to your request, we have conducted a depreciation study related to the- electric plant of Duke Energy Progress as of December 31, 2016. The attached reportpresents a description of the methods used in the estimation of depreciation, thesummary of annual depreciation accrual rates, the statistical support for the life and netsalvage estimates and the detailed tabulations of annual depreciation.

Respecffully submitted,

GANNETT FLEMING VALUATIONAND RATE CONSULTANTS, LLC

Pv P.~JOHN J. SPANOSSr. Vice President

JJS:mlw

061918.000

Gannett Fleming Valuation and Rate Consultants, LLC

PO. Box 67100 Harnsburg, PA 17106-7100I207 Senate Avenue ~ Camp Hill, PA 17011

t: 717.763.7211 6 717,7634590

www.gfvrc.corn

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

4of317

TABLE OF CONTENTS

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

PART I. INTRODUCTION .

ScopePlan of ReportBasis of the Study.

DepreciationService Life and Net Salvage Estimates.

1-1

1-2

I-2I-3I-3I-4

PART II. ESTIMATION OF SURVIVOR CURVES.Survivor Curves.

Iowa Type Curves.Retirement Rate Method of Analysis .

Schedules of Annual Transactions in Plant Records ....Schedule of Plant Exposed to RetirementOriginal Life Table .

Smoothing the Original Survivor Curve

II-1

II-2II-3II-9

II-10II-13II-15II-17

PART III. SERVICE LIFE CONSIDERATIONS..Field TripsService Life Analysis

Life Span Estimates.

III-1

III-2III-3III-5

PART IV. NET SALVAGE CONSIDERATIONSSalvage Analysis.

Net Salvage Considerations .

IV-1IV-2IV-2

PART V. CALCULATION OF ANNUAL AND ACCRUED DEPRECIATION ....Group Depreciation Procedures................

Single Unit of Property.Remaining Life Annual Accruals.Average Service Life Procedure

Calculation of Annual and Accrued Amortization.

V-1V-2V-2V-3V-3V-4

PART VI. RESULTS OF STUDY .

Qualification of Results..Description of Statistical SupportDescription of Depreciation Tabulations..

gÃ GannettFleming

VI-1VI-2VI-2Vl-3

Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

5of317

TABLE OF CONTENTS, cont

Table 1. Summary of Estimated Survivor Curves, Net Salvage Percent,Original Cost, Book Depreciation Reserve and CalculatedAnnual Depreciation Rates as of December 31, 2016.................. VI-4

PART VII. SERVICE LIFE STATISTICS. VII-1

PART VIII. NET SALVAGE STATISTICS. VIII-1

Table 1. Calculation of Terminal and interim Retirements as aPercent of Total Retirements. VIII-2

Table 2. Calculation of Weighted Net Salvage Percent

Table 3. Calculation of Terminal Net Salvage Percent.

VIII-3

Vill-4

PART IX. DETAILED DEPRECIATION CALCULATIONS. IX-1

g Gannett Fleming Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

6of317


DEPRECIATION STUDY

EXECUTIVE SUMIIARY

Pursuant to Duke Energy Progress'"DEP" or "Company") request, Gannett

Fleming Valuation and Rate Consultants, LLC ("Gannett Fleming") conducted a

depreciation study related to the electric plant as of December 31, 2016. The purpose of

this study was to determine the annual depreciation accrual rates and amounts for book

and ratemaking purposes.

The depreciation rates are based on the straight line method using the average

service life ("ASL") procedure and were applied on a remaining life basis. The

calculations were based on attained ages and estimated average service life, and

forecasted net salvage characteristics for each depreciable group of assets.

The depreciation study results in an overall increase in depreciation expense.

This is primarily related to three factors, all of which affect production plant accounts.

There is a net decrease in depreciation expense for transmission, distribution and

general plant accounts, which is the result of longer service lives or less negative net

salvage estimates for certain accounts. The increase in depreciation expense for

production plant accounts is the result of capital additions and replacements of

components of many of the Company's power plants, shorter life span estimates for

some of the Company's production plant facilities, and a new decommissioning study

that provides an estimate of the future cost to retire the Company's production facilities.

These changes produce the most appropriate depreciation rates for the Company's

QX GannettFleming Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

7of317

production plant accounts, but result in a necessary increase in depreciation expense in

order to ensure the recovery of the Company's investments.

Gannett Fleming recommends the calculated annual depreciation accrual rates

set forth herein apply specifically to electric plant in service as of December 31, 2016 as

summarized by Table 1 of the study. Supporting analysis and calculations are provided

within the study.

The study results set forth an annual depreciation expense of $752.5 million

when applied to depreciable plant balances as of December 31, 2016. The results are

summarized at the functional level as follows:

SUMMARY OF ORIGINAL COST ACCRUAL RATES AND AMOUNTS

FUNCTION

Steam Production Plant

Nuclear Production Plant

Hydraulic Production Plant

Other Production Plant

Transmission Plant

Distribution Plant

General PlantLand Rights

General Plant Reserve Amortization

Total Depreciable Plant

ORIGINAL COSTAS OF

DECEMBER 31, 2016

$3,745,801,605.14

7,923,028,273.38

120,402,948.47

2,990,581,483,35

2,281,172,011.00

5,936,416,871 46

605,361,135.72256,897,911.43

PROPOSEDRATE

3.83

2.73

3.56

4.55

1.95

2.64

5.20

1.18

PROPOSEDEXPENSE

$143,281,064

216,283,468

4,288,852

135,955,459

44,407,785

156,653,365

31,454,329

3,025,334~1717 38

g GannettFleming IV Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

8of317

PART I. INTRODUCTION

$9gJ GannettFleming Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

9of317


DEPRECIATION STUDY

PART I. INTRODUCTION

SCOPE

This report sets forth the results of the depreciation study for Duke Energy

Progress ("Company"), as applied to specific electric plant in service as of December

31, 2016. The rates and amounts are based on the straight line remaining life method

of depreciation. This report also describes the concepts, methods and judgments which

underlie the recommended annual depreciation accrual rates related to current electric

plant in service.

The service life and net salvage estimates resulting from the study were based

on informed judgment which incorporated analyses of historical plant retirement data as

recorded through 2016; the net salvage analyses of historical plant retirement data

recorded through 2016; a review of Company practice and outlook as they relate to

plant operation and retirement; and consideration of current practice in the electric

industry, including knowledge of service lives and net salvage estimates used for other

electric companies.

PLAN OF REPORT

Part I, Introduction, contains statements with respect to the plan of the report,

and the basis of the study. Part II, Estimation of Survivor Curves, presents descriptions

of the considerations and the methods used in the service life study. Part III, Service

Life Considerations, presents the factors and judgment utilized in the average service

life analysis. Part IV, Net Salvage Considerations, presents the judgment utilized for the

net salvage study. Part V, Calculation of Annual and Accrued Depreciation, describes

the procedures used in the calculation of group depreciation. Part Vl, Results of Study,

QK GannettFleming I-2 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

10of317

presents a summary by depreciable group of annual depreciation accrual rates and

amounts, as well as composite remaining lives. Part Vll, Service Life Statistics presents

the statistical analysis of service life estimates, Part Vill, Net Salvage Statistics sets

forth the statistical indications of net salvage percents, and Part IX, Detailed

Depreciation Calculations presents the detailed tabulations of annual depreciation.

BASIS OF THE STUDY

~oe reaiation

Depreciation, in public utility regulation, is the loss in service value not restored

by current maintenance, incurred in connection with the consumption or prospective

retirement of utility plant in the course of service from causes which are known to be in

current operation and against which the utility is not protected by insurance. Among

causes to be given consideration are wear and tear, deterioration, action of the

elements, inadequacy, obsolescence, changes in the art, changes in demand, and the

requirements of public authorities.

Depreciation, as used in accounting, is a method of distributing fixed capital

costs, less net salvage, over a period of time by allocating annual amounts to expense.

Each annual amount of such depreciation expense is part of that year's total cost of

providing electric utility service. Normally, the period of time over which the fixed capital

cost is allocated to the cost of service is equal to the period of time over which an item

renders service, that is, the item's service life. The most prevalent method of allocation

is to distribute an equal amount of cost to each year of service life. This method is

known as the straight-line method of depreciation.

For all accounts, the annual depreciation was calculated by the straight line

method using the average service life procedure and the remaining life basis. The

calculated remaining lives and annual depreciation accrual rates were based on

[g, GannettFleming I-3 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

11of317

attained ages of plant in service and the estimated service life and salvage

characteristics of each depreciable group. Amortization accounting or vintage pooling is

proposed for most general plant accounts.

The straight line method, average service life procedure is a commonly used

depreciation calculation procedure that has been widely accepted in jurisdictions

throughout North America. Gannett Fleming recommends its continued use.

Service Life and Net Salva e Estimates

The service life and net salvage estimates used in the depreciation calculations

were based on informed judgment which incorporated a review of management's plans,

policies and outlook, a general knowledge of the electric utility industry, and

comparisons of the service life and net salvage estimates from our studies of other

electric utilities. The use of survivor curves to reflect the expected dispersion of

retirement provides a consistent method of estimating depreciation for utility property.

iowa type survivor curves were used to depict the estimated survivor curves for the

plant accounts. For steam and other production plants, the life span technique was

used. In this technique, the date of final retirement was estimated for each unit, and the

estimated survivor curves applied to each vintage were truncated at ages coinciding

with the date of final retirement.

The procedure for estimating service lives consisted of compiling historical data

for the plant accounts or depreciable groups, analyzing this history through the use of

widely accepted techniques, and forecasting the survivor characteristics for each

depreciable group on the basis of interpretations of the historical data analyses and the

probable future. The combination of the historical experience and the estimated future

yielded estimated survivor curves from which the average service lives were derived.

The estimates of net salvage by account incorporated a review of experienced

costs of removal and salvage related to plant retirements, and consideration of trends

~ GannettFleming I-4 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

12of317

exhibited by the historical data. Each component of net salvage, i.e., cost of removal

and salvage, was stated in dollars and as a percent of retirement.

An understanding of the function of the plant and information with respect to the

reasons for past retirements and the expected causes of future retirements was

obtained through discussions with operating and management personnel. The

supplemental information obtained in this manner was considered in the interpretation

and extrapolation of the statistical analyses.

QX Gannett Fleming 1-5 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

13of317

PART II. ESTIMATION OFSURVIVOR CURVES

~ GannettFleming Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

14of317

PART II. ESTIMATION OF SURVIVOR CURVES

The calculation of annual depreciation based on the straight line method requires

the estimation of survivor curves and the selection of group depreciation procedures.

The estimation of survivor curves is discussed below and the development of net

salvage is discussed in later sections of this report.

SURVIVOR CURVES

The use of an average service life for a property group implies that the various

units in the group have different lives. Thus, the average life may be obtained by

determining the separate lives of each of the units, or by constructing a survivor curve

by plotting the number of units which survive at successive ages.

The survivor curve graphically depicts the amount of property existing at each

age throughout the life of an original group. From the survivor curve, the average life of

the group, the remaining life expectancy, the probable life, and the frequency curve can

be calculated. In Figure 1, a typical smooth survivor curve and the derived curves are

illustrated. The average life is obtained by calculating the area under the survivor curve,

from age zero to the maximum age, and dividing this area by the ordinate at age zero.

The remaining life expectancy at any age can be calculated by obtaining the area under

the curve, from the observation age to the maximum age, and dividing this area by the

percent surviving at the observation age. For example, in Figure 1, the remaining life at

age 30 is equal to the crosshatched area under the survivor curve divided by 29.5

percent surviving at age 30. The probable life at any age is developed by adding the

age and remaining life. If the probable life of the property is calculated for each year of

age, the probable life curve shown in the chart can be developed. The frequency curve

presents the number of units retired in each age interval. It is derived by obtaining the

differences between the amount of property surviving at the beginning and at the end of

each interval.

QX GannettFleming Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

15of317

This study has incorporated the use of iowa curves developed from a retirement

rate analysis of historical retirement history. A discussion of the concepts of survivor

curves and of the development of survivor curves using the retirement rate method is

presented below.

iowa T e Curves

The range of survivor characteristics usually experienced by utility and industrial

properties is encompassed by a system of generalized survivor curves known as the

iowa type curves. There are four families in the iowa system, labeled in accordance

with the location of the modes of the retirements in relationship to the average life and

the relative height of the modes. The left moded curves, presented in Figure 2, are

those in which the greatest frequency of retirement occurs to the left of, or prior to,

average service life. The symmetrical moded curves, presented in Figure 3, are those

in which the greatest frequency of retirement occurs at average service life. The right

moded curves, presented in Figure 4, are those in which the greatest frequency occurs

to the right of, or after, average service life. The origin moded curves, presented in

Figure 5, are those in which the greatest frequency of retirement occurs at the origin, or

immediately after age zero. The letter designation of each family of curves (L, S, R or

0) represents the location of the mode of the associated frequency curve with respect

to the average service life. The numbers represent the relative heights of the modes of

the frequency curves within each family.

The iowa curves were developed at the iowa State College Engineering

Experiment Station through an extensive process of observation and classification of

the ages at which industrial property had been retired. A report of the study which

resulted in the classification of property survivor characteristics into 18 type curves,

gl GannettFleming II-3 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

16of317

lllde led Pallteu 'ldddled

QI

DOQy

IO

Irrce

NIIre

o ~

8OI

dC

Iflrll

oCV

Q)

DI

0

i

M

CQ

OCL

oT

oo o o o o o o oo Irl ce CV

6UIAIAJII$ $U80/8d

g GannettFleming 11-4 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

17of317

oore

oLON

0N

Cl

IgorII

0lsr

0S0

rrr I

N 8D

$0)o0

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 Ce CO h. CO u) W Crr CV

6UIAIAJR$ )UGOJBd


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

18of317

CI0

Io

N

0loN

LO

NN

00N D)

CD

CDCDLCD

0co

080

co 8N

ICD

00T

gy

0I

0

U)

gyCL

I-R

0

M

l0I0

8EE

(0

0Io

lrlN

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 ce co h co lo 'e co N

6UIAliUll$ )U8028d

lg GannettFleming 11-6 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2616

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

19of317

oo

lANN

ooN I

IA g)Ire

8

olAT

CSQ

rA 8Q.

80)o c(o

T

ryJII

0L0

I

MBy

I-C

0

LL'

B3'00

p!L

o o o o o o o o o oo Ar co 1 rA rA rt ro N

6UIAIAJII$ )UBOJBd


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

20of317

00

0IOCCC

IOCVN

O0 I

CoII

0C

0

M

Ir) Sce

I0

oI

0I0IOcu cb

Q

Cg0)

O C(O

00

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 cc C CO cO sr CIS CC

6UIAIAJns juaoJad

~ GannettFleming II-8 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

21of317

which constitute three of the four families, was published in 1935 in the form of the

Experiment Station's Bulletin 125. These curve types have also been presented in

subsequent Experiment Station bulletins and in the text, "Engineering Valuation and

Depreciation."'n 1957, Frank V. B. Couch, Jr., an Iowa State College graduate

student submitted a thesis presenting his development of the fourth family consisting of

the four 0 type survivor curves.

Retirement Rate Method of Anal sis

The retirement rate method is an actuarial method of deriving survivor curves

using the average rates at which property of each age group is retired. The method

relates to property groups for which aged accounting experience is available and is the

method used to develop the original stub survivor curves in this study. The method

(also known as the annual rate method) is illustrated through the use of an example in

the following text, and is also explained in several publications, including "Statistical

Analyses of Industrial Property Retirements," "Engineering Valuation and

Depreciation,"'nd "Depreciation Systems."

The average rate of retirement used in the calculation of the percent surviving for

the survivor curve (life table) requires two sets of data: first, the property retired during

a period of observation, identified by the property's age at retirement; and second, the

property exposed to retirement at the beginning of the age intervals during the same

period. The period ot observation is referred to as the ~ex science band, and the band

of years which represent the installation dates of the property exposed to retirement

during the experience band is referred to as the giacement band. An example oi the

calculations used in the development of a life table follows. The example includes

'Marston, Anson, Robley Winfrey and Jean C. Hempstead. Engineering Valuation andDepreciation, 2nd Edition. New York, McGraw-Hill Book Company, 1953.

'Winfrey, Robley, Statistical Anal ses of Industrial Pro ert Retirements. iowa State CollegeEngineering Experiment Station, Bulletin 125. 1935..

'Marston, Anson, Robley Winfrey, and Jean C. Hampstead, Supra Note 1.4Wolf, Frank K, and W. Chester Fitch. De reciation S stems. iowa State University Press. 1994.


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

22of317

schedules of annual aged property transactions, a schedule of plant exposed to

retirement, a life table and illustrations of smoothing the stub survivor curve.

Schedules of Annual Transactions in Plant Records

The property group used to illustrate the retirement rate method is observed for

the experience band 2007-2016 during which there were piacements during the years

2002-2016. In order to illustrate the summation of the aged data by age interval, the

data were compiled in the manner presented in Schedules 1 and 2 on pages II-11 and

II-12 In Schedule 1, the year of installation (year placed) and the year of retirement are

shown. The age interval during which a retirement occurred is determined from this

information. In the example which follows, $10,000 of the dollars invested in 2002 were

retired in 2007. The $ 10,000 retirement occurred during the age interval between 4/s

and 5/s years on the basis that approximately one-half of the amount of property was

installed prior to and subsequent to July 1 of each year. That is, on the average,

property installed during a year is placed in service at the midpoint of the year for the

purpose of the analysis. All retirements also are stated as occurring at the midpoint of a

one-year age interval of time, except the first age interval which encompasses only one-

half year.

The total retirements occurring in each age interval in a band are determined by

summing the amounts for each transaction year-installation year combination for that

age interval. For example, the total of $ 143,000 retired forage interval 4/s-5/s isthe

sum of the retirements entered on Schedule 1 immediately above the stair step line

drawn on the table beginning with the 2007 retirements of 2002 installations and

ending with the 2016 retirements of the 2011 installations. Thus, the total amount of

143 for age interval 4/s-5/s equals the sum of:

10 + 12 + 13 + 11 + 13 + 13 + 15 + 17 + 19 + 20.


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

23of317

IO

CI

CICICJ'0CIomCID

EIDDIo

CL

CD

Oel0

I—

le2ID co

Ctt

'IrT T T

g g gCJ

T

g gL- Q gCD

tg gQ CD CO CO IA

ggggIA

ID Q r CO QIA LA IA IXI

CLI IA LA 'tr CtlCtl CJ Ctt Ctt ~

IOCILD

CI

CICI

CL

UJ cC

Z CL'

LU

ZIL'JOUU- «C

crJ D-I- CDZ OUJ IU~ NUJ

I- gLU ~CX'. O'OUJ

OUJZOCo

toIo

0O0IO'0LIo0)

0

CO

CID

E0J

IDCL

IoID

CD

I

O

IA OO

O 0)

TO

O CD

CII

CD

O IA

CDQOCtt

PJOJ Ctl CLJ

O 0 L-C4 PJ

LXIDJ

LOTCI

CICICLJ

'0Cttl

CD

ID0CstID0.IC

LU

toID

XoID0el

CL

O

Ctt Ctl rl'A CD I IO OI Q L- Ctl CII & IA CD IoOOOQQOOOL-L-L-r t-OOOOOOOOQQQOQQO 0PJ CII PJ CJ PJ Ctl Ctt CJ OJ CLI Ctl AI Ctl CJ Ctl

g GannettFleming Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

24of317

Cl

00

UJ

Zo «(.

~ LU

0 I-UL

Z(D LUz (30 &

O (0& 0(D IJJz N

UJ ~Z (00

LLI

CILU

oI

CD

Cl

ClClNC'l

(D

LID

EGIOts(L

CD

0N0!0!

13CtoKlIDO0

,GI

IDC!.IC

LU

toIG

0CI

0N'0CGlIU

0

NID

ID(D

Gl

IU

N0G!

I-NC0Vl

0'G

ID

CU0

CI

ts

G!

CU0

0to0

CD

0N

0 Co

0N

0 CD

N

00 IAN

Co00 t«J

!00 NN

0ts 0

Oto(L

Ol

N 0 CD

«N

CO I CD ID

O(0

SI

N

0ID

ID (0 r Co 0! 0000000000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0NNNNNNNN

«t««t«IA

g N

N

U

N

NN

0 0 0 00 0NNNNN

0

G!

0

IGGl

0 0CI GlCC0 0Cl '0IUol ulGl IG

Gl N

Gl Gl0CL CL

LuCU CU

E0 0Gl Gl

G(

IG NC

IU IG

I-G

0E

IU loN Gl

Oll00tU

0 0(J Gl

GlGl0IE

IU 0IGN 0

o.

g GannettFleming ll-12 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

25of317

In Schedule 2, other transactions which affect the group are recorded in a similar

manner. The entries illustrated include transfers and sales. The entries which are

credits to the plant account are shown in parentheses. The items recorded on this

schedule are not totaled with the retirements, but are used in developing the exposures

at the beginning of each age interval.

Schedule of Plant Ex osed to Retirement

The development of the amount of plant exposed to retirement at the beginning

of each age interval is illustrated in Schedule 3 on page II-14. The surviving plant at the

beginning of each year from 2007 through 2016 is recorded by year in the portion of the

table headed "Annual Survivors at the Beginning of the Year." The last amount entered

in each column is the amount of new plant added to the group during the year. The

amounts entered in Schedule 3 for each successive year following the beginning

balance or additions are obtained by adding or subtracting the net entries shown on

Schedules 1 and 2. For the purpose of determining the plant exposed to retirement,

transfers-in are considered as being ~ex osed to retirement in this group at the

be innin of the ear in which they occurred, and the sales and transfers-out are

coneidered to be removed from the plant expoeed to retirement at the ~be innin oi

th f II'

Thus, the amounts of plant shown at the beginning of each year are

the amounts of plant from each placement year considered to be exposed to retirement

at the beginning of each successive transaction year. For example, the exposures for

the installation year 2012 are calculated in the following manner:

Exposures at age 0 = amount of additionExposures at age '/s = $750,000 - $ 8,000Exposures at age 1 "/s = $742,000 - $18,000Exposures at age 2"/s = $724,000 - $20,000 — $ 19,000Exposures at age 3"/s = $685,000 - $22,000

= $750,000= $742,000= $724,000= $685,000= $663,000


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

26of317

COT0NNCICI

Xl

(0mCSlEIDD(0

CL

mm 2cn m

c

0Dlm c

ID Cc00IID

CO

gN gN(0

T

gN gN

gN gNN

gN gN0T

gNCD IQ

g gN gg gT

CD IAgN«gl4

tgNN'«t (TJ N

gN gNT4

lg ggN

0

N IO Ol Ol CIITJ IO T- I Ol(TJ CD I LO

'lt IO CD

(TJ I ITJ N («I I CDCO N CD O IO (0 IO CoIO IQ CI IA CD «t 0 I

(T)

(00N

(0 T CO LO N N CDN CD T IO T" 00 0N («I IT) Tt Tt (0

CO CD (D Dl 0(0 CD N (0 C4(D I CD 0 C4

LU

UJ COT

— O UI- N «C

CC 0 mp O UJ

If.'ZCl «C-UJ LU UJN + CgP Z «C

CL O&-XLU p

Z LL UJgpNCL p «C

NUJ 5 2+ZNp ~LUZoN

ID

m

0p0IJI

10C(0ID

0

ID0ID0CLX

LLI

L(0S

050CDC2Aimmm

mID

0

2Nm

00

IA 0ON

0 CD

T0

0 (D

Cl

0 IO

CD Tt ID N I I 0 IQ 0 (TJ «t «- 0I 0 CO Ol «t Ol Tt ITJ N N «I (0

N T N N N Co ITJ Tt IO (D I Co Ol

Ol Tt 'lt CO I «- IAOl N I 0 (0 0

I«J ofLO Ol N O

CD 'lt ITJ Tt IO«t IA CD I IQ

IA N T CD T «I'D DI T N 0Dl Tt Co N I «- I CD ID IA

(TJ «t Tt IA LO I

CD (0 t 0 Tt (0 N N '«t O0 N IA O (TJ Co I«J Dl I CON N N (0 ITJ I«J Tt m'O CD

N (0 T T (D I 'll'll" 0f T- «t CD Tt 0 CoN N I«J 0) I«J Tt IO IA

I«) 'lt N 0 N Tt T- T- Co, LO T (D 0ID 00 Tt Co («I I (TJ C) N IQ N 'lt CoN N ITJ ITJ m ID (0 (0 Co 0& CI

(0TCI

ICICl

"0

mCQ

Cl0dlIIDCLX

UJ

Dl00N

00N

'0m 0

(0CL

(0 «t I I IA CILA Co N lrl 0 IA TN N (TJ (L) Tt Tt IA

IQ (0 0 t CO 0(D CD («I CD T- CDN N ITJ (T) 'll't

0) I CO (0 CII 0 (0 I NN ITJ (0 (T)

IA (0 I Co CD 0 T- N ITJ «t IA (00 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0N N N N N N N N N N N N

(00I-

ICCl

CI

CD

10N00"6

g GannettFleming II-14 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

27of317

For the entire experience band 2007-2016, the total exposures at the beginning

of an age interval are obtained by summing diagonally in a manner similar to the

summing of the retirements during an age interval (Schedule 1). For example, the

figure of 3,789, shown as the total exposures at the beginning of age interval 4/s-5%, is

obtained by summing:255+ 268+ 284+ 311 + 334+ 374+ 405+ 448+ 501+ 609.

Ori inal Life Table

The original life table, illustrated in Schedule 4 on page II-16, is developed from

the totals shown on the schedules of retirements and exposures, Schedules 1 and 3,

respectively. The exposures at the beginning of the age interval are obtained from the

corresponding age interval of the exposure schedule, and the retirements during the

age interval are obtained from the corresponding age interval of the retirement

schedule. The retirement ratio is the result of dividing the retirements during the age

interval by the exposures at the beginning of the age interval. The percent surviving at

the beginning of each age interval is derived from survivor ratios, each of which equals

one minus the retirement ratio. The percent surviving is developed by starting with

100% at age zero and successively multiplying the percent surviving at the beginning of

each interval by the survivor ratio, i.e., one minus the retirement ratio for that age

interval. The calculations necessary to determine the percent surviving at age 5"/s are

as follows:

Percent surviving at age 4%Exposures at age 4%Retirements from age 4% to 5%Retirement RatioSurvivor RatioPercent surviving at age 5%

88.15= 3,789,000

143,000143,000 —: 3,789,000 = 0.0377

1.000 - 0.0377 = 0.9623(88.15) x (0.9623) = 84.83

The totals of the exposures and retirements (columns 2 and 3) are shown for the

purpose of checking with the respective totals in Schedules 1 and 3. The ratio of the

total retirements to the total exposures, other than for each age interval, is meaningless.

g Gannet.t Flaming 11-15 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

28of317

SCHEDULE 4. ORIGINAL LIFE TABLECALCULATED BY THE RETIREMENT RATE METHOD

Experience Band 2007-2016 Placement Band 2002-2016

(Exposure and Retirement Amounts are in Thousands of Dollars)

Age at Exposures atBeginning of Beginning of

Interval Age Interval

(2)

RetirementsDuring Age

Interval

(3)

RetirementRatio

(4)

SurvlvolRatio

(5)

PercentSurviving atBeginning ofAge Interval

(6)

0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.59.5

10.511.512.513.5

Total

7,4906,5795,7194,9554,3323,7893,0572,4631,9521,5031,097

823531323167

44 780

801531511501461431311241131059383644426

1 606

0.01070.02330.02640.03030.03370.03770. 04290.05030.05790.06990.08480.10090.12050.13620.1557

0.98930.97670.97360.96970.96630.96230. 95710. 94970. 94210. 93010.91520.89910.87950.86380.8443

100.0098.9396.6294.0791.2288.1584.8381.1977.1172.6567.5761.8455.6048.9042.2435.66

Column 2 from Schedule 3, Column 12, Plant Exposed to Retirement.Column 3 from Schedule 1, Column 12, Retirements for Each Year.Column 4 = Column 3 Divided by Column 2.Column 5 = 1.0000 Minus Column 4.Column 6 = Column 5 Multiplied by Column 6 as of the Preceding Age Interval.


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

29of317

The original survivor curve is plotted from the original life table (column 6,

Schedule 4). When the curve terminates at a percent surviving greater than zero, it is

called a stub survivor curve. Survivor curves developed from retirement rate studies

generally are stub curves.

Smoothln the Ori inal Survivor Curve

The smoothing of the original survivor curve eliminates any irregularities and

serves as the basis for the preliminary extrapolation to zero percent surviving of the

original stub curve. Even if the original survivor curve is complete from 100% to zero

percent, it is desirable to eliminate any irregularities, as there is still an extrapolation for

the vintages which have not yet lived to the age at which the curve reaches zero

percent. In this study, the smoothing of the original curve with established type curves

was used to eliminate irregularities in the original curve.

The Iowa type curves are used in this study to smooth those original stub curves

which are expressed as percents surviving at ages in years. Each original survivor

curve was compared to the Iowa curves using visual and mathematical matching in

order to determine the better fitting smooth curves. In Figures 6, 7, and 8, the original

curve developed in Schedule 4 is compared with the L, S, and R Iowa type curves

which most nearly fit the original survivor curve. In Figure 6, the L1 curve with an

average life between 12 and 13 years appears to be the best fit. In Figure 7, the SO

type curve with a 12-year average life appears to be the best fit and appears to be

better than the L1 fitting. In Figure 8, the R1 type curve with a 12-year average life

appears to be the best fit and appears to be better than either the L1 or the SO.

In Figure 9, the three fittings, 12-L1, 12-SO and 12-R1 are drawn for comparison

purposes. It is probable that the 12-R1 Iowa curve would be selected as the most

representative of the plotted survivor characteristics of the group.

g GannettFlaming II-17 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

30of317

Q IOU

KQ Q

V

QQIO t-I

IC QZ ot

rIX QQ Q

ZR IO

QI RQ

tn o)N

LU

zlu

o rgN CC

R ICH ZU U

CI

Ct 8 Ct O O Ct OCt I ID IA

ONIRIRbIAS J.NEDb13d

IDN


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

31of317

O tttU

x ft:O

U

O

ttt

OO

O OZx ttt

Or. xO

Ll

Ur

Z O

x VlN ~ru

zul

o cgN C

x

OCt

CIO

BNIRIREIAS 1NdOE13d

Ct CtCt

Ct


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

32of317

Vlru

0 DU

DD

IYD

R Mt-iLl

fL'ro o

ZR ro

Q

0 cC

C!M

Ill (/JN ~lu

ZUJ

org

BNIAIAEIAS 1N30b13d

gl GannettFleming 11-20 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

33of317

D

0

H

tttttt

E

Ore

H

f HEO

ctE

Z

to EON

Eu

Ztu

c EgN E

ct

E

CtCf

Ct 8 R

BNIAIAblflS J.N3083d

CtN

CtCl

~ GannettFleming 11-21 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

34of317

PART III. SERVICE LIFE CONSIDERATIONS


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

35of317

PART III. SERVICE LIFE CONSIDERATIONS

FIELD TRIPS

In order to be familiar with the operation of the Company and observe

representative portions of the plant, field trips have been conducted. A general

understanding of the function of the plant and information with respect to the reasons for

past retirements and the expected future causes of retirements are obtained during field

trips. This knowledge and information were incorporated in the interpretation and

extrapolation of the statistical analyses.

The following is a list of the locations visited during the initial field trip.

December 6 2016Blewett Generating StationSmith Energy Complex

December 7 2016Roxboro Generating StationMayo Generating Station

Asheville Generating Station

SERVICE LIFE ANALYSIS

The service life estimates were based on judgment which considered a number

of factors. The primary factors were the statistical analyses of data, current Company

policies and outlook as determined during conversations with management; and the

survivor curve estimates from previous studies of this company and other electric utility

companies.

For 29 plant accounts and subaccounts for which survivor curves were

estimated, the statistical analyses using the retirement rate method resulted in good to

excellent indications of the survivor patterns experienced. These accounts represent 82


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

36of317

percent of depreciable plant. Generally, the information external to the statistics led to

minimal or no significant departure from the indicated survivor curves for the accounts

listed below. The statistical support for the service life estimates is presented in the

section beginning on page VII-2.

STEAM PRODUCTION PLANT311.00 Structures and Improvements312.00 Boiler Plant Equipment314.00 Turbogenerator Units315.00 Accessory Electric Equipment316.00 Miscellaneous Power Plant Equipment

NUCLEAR PRODUCTION PLANT321.00 Structures and Improvements322.00 Reactor Plant Equipment325.00 Miscellaneous Plant Equipment

HYDRAULIC PRODUCTION PLANT331.00 Structures and Improvements332.00 Reservoirs, Dams and Waterway333.00 Water Wheels, Turbines and Generators334.00 Accessory Electric Equipment

OTHER PRODUCTION PLANT342.00 Fuel Holders, Producers and Accessories343.00 Prime Movers343.10 Prime Movers — Rotable Parts345.00 Accessory Electric Equipment

TRANSMISSION PLANT353.00 Station Equipment354.00 Towers and Fixtures355.00 Poles and Fixtures

DISTRIBUTION362.00364.00365.00366.00367.00368.00369.00370.00371.00

PLANTStation EquipmentPoles, Towers and FixturesOverhead Conductors and DevicesUnderground ConduitUnderground Conductors and DevicesLine TransformersServicesMetering EquipmentInstallations on Customer Premises

g GannettFleming III-3 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

37of317

GENERAL PLANT392.00 Transportation Equipment

Account 365.00, Overhead Conductors and Devices, is used to illustrate the

manner in which the study was conducted for the groups in the preceding list. Aged

plant accounting data for the overhead conductors have been compiled for the years

1954 through 2016. These data have been coded in the course of the Company's

normal record keeping according to account or property group, type of transaction, year

in which the transaction took place, and year in which the electric plant was placed in

service. The retirements, other plant transactions, and plant additions were analyzed by

the retirement rate method.

The survivor curve estimate is based on the statistical indications for the period

1954 through 2016 and 1977 through 2016. The iowa 44-R1.5 is a reasonable fit of the

original survivor curve. The 44-year average service life is within the typical average

service life range of 40 to 55 years for overhead conductor. The 44-year average

service life reflects the Company's plans to replace conductor consistently in the future

as have been retired in the past.

For Account 364, Poles, Towers and Fixtures, the survivor curve estimate is the

45-R2.5. The statistical analysis for this account provides a good indication of service

life through age 66. The 45-R2.5 estimate is within the industry range and is consistent

with the outlook for this account. Based on these considerations, the 45-R2.5 survivor

curve is the most reasonable estimate for this account.

Similar studies were performed for the remaining plant accounts. Each of the

judgments represented a consideration of statistical analyses of aged plant activity,

~ GannettFleming III-4 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

38of317

management's outlook for the future, and the typical range of lives used by other

electric companies.

Life S an Estimates

Inasmuch as production plant consists of large generating units, the life span

technique was employed in conjunction with the use of interim survivor curves which

reflect interim retirements that occur prior to the ultimate retirement of the major unit.

An interim survivor curve was estimated for each plant account, inasmuch as the rate of

interim retirements differs from account to account. The interim survivor curves

estimated for steam, nuclear, hydraulic and other production plant were based on the

retirement rate method of life analysis which incorporated experienced aged retirements

for the period 1923 through 2016 for steam; 1971 through 2016 for nuclear; 1912

through 2016 for hydraulic; and 1968 through 2016 for other production.

The depreciable life span estimates for power generating stations were the result

of considering experienced life spans of similar generating units, the age of surviving

units, general operating characteristics of the units, major refurbishments, discussions

with management personnel concerning the probable long-term outlook for the units,

and the estimate of the operating partner, if applicable.

The depreciable life span estimate for most steam, base-load units is 52 to 63

years, which is within the typical range of life spans for such units. With the exception

of the Asheville units, these life spans represent the expected depreciable life of each

facility under their current configuration. The Company plans to retire the Asheville

steam units in 2019. The Company's proposal is to recover the costs of this facility over

a 10-year period. For the other facilities, future capital expenditures can extend a

facility's depreciable life, however, such changes to depreciable life would not be

prudent until the capital expenditures are actually put into plant in service. The life span

for nuclear units is approximately 60 years, and is consistent with the license dates for

g GannettFleming III-5 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

39of317

each unit. The depreciable life span for hydraulic units is 104 to 143 years which

corresponds to the license or relicense dates. A life span of 40-53 years was estimated

for the combustion turbines. These life span

turbines which are used primarily as peaking

estimates are typical for combustion

units. The combined cycle units are

relatively new units with a commonly used 40-year life span estimate. All solar facilities

have recently been constructed and will have a 25-year life span.

A summary of the major year in service, depreciable life span and depreciable

life date for each power production unit follows:

Major Depreciable DepreciableYear in Life LifeService Date ~San

Steam Production PlantAsheville Unit 1

Asheville Unit 2Mayo Unit 1

Roxboro Unit 1

Roxboro Unit 2Roxboro Unit 3Roxboro Unit 4

1964197119831966196819731980

2027202720352028202820332033

63565262606053

Nuclear Production PlantBrunswick Unit 1

Brunswick Unit 2Harris Unit 1

Robinson Unit 1

1977 20361975 20341987 20461971 2034

59595959

Hydraulic Production PlantBlewettMarshallTilleryWalters

1912 20551910 20351928 20551930 2034

143125127104

Other Production PlantAshevilleBlewettDarlington Units 1-11Darlington Units 12 and 13H.F. Lee (Wayne County) Units 10-13

1999 20391971 20241974 20201997 20372000 2040

4053464040


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

40of317

De reciable Grou

Major Depreciable DepreciableYear in Life LifeService Date ~San

H.F. Lee (Wayne County) Unit 14SuttonSutton CCSutton CTsWeatherspoonSmith CC (Richmond County) Block 4Smith CC (Richmond County) Block 5Smith CTsH.F. Lee CC (Wayne County)Camp Lejune SolarFayetteville SolarElm City SolarWarsaw Solar

2009196820131968197020022011200120122015201520162015

2049201720532017202420422051204120522040204020412040

40494049544040404025252525

The selected amortization periods for other General Plant accounts are

described in the section "Calculated Annual and Accrued Amortization."

ig GannettFleming III-7 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

41of317

PART IV. NET SALVAGE CONSIDERATIONS

QK GannettFleming IV-1 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

42of317

PART IV. NET SALVAGE CONSIDERATIONS

SALVAGE ANALYSIS

The estimates of net salvage by account were based in part on historical data

compiled through 2016. Cost of removal and salvage were expressed as percents of

the original cost of plant retired, both on annual and three-year moving average bases.

The most recent five-year average also was calculated for consideration. The net

salvage estimates by account are expressed as a percent of the original cost of plant

retired.

Net Salva e Considerations

The estimates of future net salvage are expressed as percentages of surviving

plant in service, i.e., all future retirements. In cases in which removal costs are

expected to exceed salvage receipts, a negative net salvage percentage is estimated.

The net salvage estimates were based on judgment which incorporated analyses of

historical cost of removal and salvage data, expectations with respect to future removal

requirements and markets for retired equipment and materials.

The analyses of historical cost of removal and salvage data are presented in the

section titled "Net Salvage Statistics" for the plant accounts for which the net salvage

estimate relied partially on those analyses.

Statistical analyses of historical data for the periods 1979 through 2016 for all

plant accounts were analyzed. The analyses contributed significantly toward the net

salvage estimates for 37 plant accounts, representing 88 percent of the depreciable

plant, as follows:

STEAM PRODUCTION PLANT311.00 Structures and Improvements312.00 Boiler Plant Equipment314.00 Turbogenerator Units315.00 Accessory Electric Equipment

~ GannettFleming IV-2 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

43of317

316.00 Miscellaneous Power Plant Equipment

NUCLEAR PRODUCTION PLANT321.00 Structures and Improvements322.00 Reactor Plant Equipment323.00 Turbogenerator Units324.00 Accessory Electric Equipment325.00 Miscellaneous Plant Equipment

HYDRAULIC PRODUCTION PLANT332.00 Reservoirs, Dams and Waterway334.00 Accessory Electric Equipment335.00 Miscellaneous Plant Equipment

OTHER PRODUCTION PLANT342.00 Fuel Holders, Producers and Accessories344.00 Generators345.00 Accessory Electric Equipment346.00 Accessory Electric Equipment

TRANSMISSION PLANT352.00 Structures and Improvements353.00 Station Equipment355.00 Poles and Fixtures356.00 Underground Conductor and Devices

DISTRIBUTION361.00362.00364.00365.00366.00367.00368.00369.00370.00371.00373.00

PLANTStructures and ImprovementsStation EquipmentPoles, Towers and FixturesOverhead Conductors and DevicesUnderground ConduitUnderground Conductors and DevicesLine TransformersServicesMetering EquipmentInstallations on Customer PremisesStreet Lighting and Signal Systems

GENERAL PLANT390.00 Structures and Improvements392.00 Transportation Equipment396.00 Stores Equipment

QÃ Gannett Fleming IV-3 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

44of317

Account 368.00, Line Transformers, is used to illustrate the manner in which the

study was conducted for the groups in the preceding list. Net salvage data for the

period 1979 through 2016 were analyzed for this account. The data include cost of

removal, gross salvage and net salvage amounts and each of these amounts is

expressed as a percent of the original cost of regular retirements. Three-year moving

averages for the 1979-1981 through 2014-2016 periods were computed to smooth the

annual amounts.

Cost of removal was relatively consistent during the 1980s and 1990s, then

fluctuated over the last 15 years. The primary cause of the high levels of cost of

removal in recent years was the required effort needed to replace transformers due to

various forces of retirement. Cost of removal for the most recent five years averaged 22

percent.

Gross salvage has varied throughout the period with high levels in 2011 and

2013 due to current practices of reuse. The most recent five-year average of 14

percent gross salvage reflects recent trends.

The net salvage percent based on the overall period 1979 through 2016 is 0

percent net salvage and based on the most recent five-year period is negative 8

percent. The typical range of estimates made by other electric companies for Line

Transformers is positive 5 to negative 15 percent. The net salvage estimate for line

transformers is negative 5 percent, is within the range of other estimates and reflects

the levels of net salvage experienced over the last ten years.

The net salvage estimate for Account 353, Station Equipment, is negative 15

percent. Net salvage data for the period 1979 through 2016 were analyzed for this

account. Cost of removal has been high in most years for the period studied. There

has been some gross salvage, but it has been less than cost of removal and has only

g GannettFleminti IV-4 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

45of317

averaged 1 percent since 2000 with the exception to 2006. For the period 1979 through

2016, net salvage has averaged negative 8 percent. More recent years have

experienced higher levels of retirements and have also experienced increased costs of

removal. The most recent five year average is negative 40 percent.

Estimates of negative 20 percent or less are common in the industry for this

account, although there has been a trend to more negative net salvage in this account

in recent years and some utilities do have estimates that are even more negative.

While the trend for this account does support a more negative net salvage estimate than

negative 15 percent, the negative 15 percent estimate reflects the expectations of the

Company for this account as well as the experience of others in the industry.

The overall net salvage estimates for the Company's production facilities, for

which the life span method is used, is based on estimates of both final net salvage and

interim net salvage. Final net salvage is the net salvage experienced at the end of a

production plant's life span. Interim net salvage is the net salvage experienced for

interim retirements that occur prior to the final retirement of the plant. The final net

salvage estimates in the study were based on a decommissioning study performed by

Burns 8 McDonnell. These studies excluded ash pond closure activities. The interim

net salvage estimates were based in part on an analysis of historical interim retirement

and net salvage data. Based on informed judgment that incorporated these interim net

salvage analyses for each plant account, an interim net salvage estimate of negative 16

percent was used for steam plant accounts; negative 10 percent for nuclear plant

accounts; negative 16 percent for hydraulic plant accounts; and a negative 4 percent

estimate was used for all other production plant accounts. The one exception is for

Account 343.10, Prime Movers — Rotable Parts units for the combined cycle units. This

account includes the hot gas path components of the combustion turbines for these

+99 GannettFleming IV-5 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

46of317

plants. An interim net salvage estimate of 40 percent is recommended, consistent with

the historical data and outlook for these assets.

The interim survivor curve estimates for each account and production facility

were used to calculate the percentage of plant expected to be retired as interim

retirements and final retirements. These are shown on Table 1 in the Net Salvage

Statistics section on page Vill-2. These percentages were used to determine the

weighted net salvage estimate for each account and production facility based on the

interim and final net salvage estimates. These calculations, as well as the estimated

final net salvage and interim net salvage percents, are shown on Table 2 of the Net

Salvage Statistics section on page Vill-3. Table 3 sets forth the calculation for

establishing the terminal net salvage percent for each location which is utilized in Table

The net salvage percents for the remaining accounts were based on judgment

incorporating factors such as the statistical net salvage analysis, general knowledge of

the property studied, and estimates of previous studies of this and other electric utilities.

Generally, the net salvage estimates for remaining general plant accounts were

zero percent, consistent with amortization accounting.

g GannettFleming IV-6 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

47of317

PART V. CALCULATION OF ANNUAL AND

ACCRUED DEPRECIATION

~ GannettFIeming V-1 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

48of317

PART V. CALCULATION OF ANNUAL ANDACCRUED DEPRECIATION

GROUP DEPRECIATION PROCEDURES

A group procedure for depreciation is appropriate when considering more than a

single item of property. Normally the items within a group do not have identical service

lives, but have lives that are dispersed over a range of time. There are two primary

group procedures, namely, average service life and equal life group. In the average

service life procedure, the rate of annual depreciation is based on the average life or

average remaining life of the group, and this rate is applied to the surviving balances of

the group's cost. A characteristic of this procedure is that the cost of plant retired prior

to average life is not fully recouped at the time of retirement, whereas the cost of plant

retired subsequent to average life is more than fully recouped. Over the entire life cycle,

the portion of cost not recouped prior to average life is balanced by the cost recouped

subsequent to average life.

Sin le Unit of Pro ert

The calculation of straight line depreciation for a single unit of property is

straightforward. For example, if a $ 1,000 unit of property attains an age of four years

and has a life expectancy of six years, the annual accrual over the total life is:

= $ 100 per year.$ 1,000

(4+ 6)

The accrued depreciation is:

$ 1,000 1 - —J

= $400.6i

10

g GannettFlaming V-2 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

49of317

Remainin Life Annual Accruals

For the purpose of calculating remaining life accruals as of December 31, 2016,

the depreciation reserve for each plant account is allocated among vintages in

proportion to the calculated accrued depreciation for the account. Explanations of

remaining life accruals and calculated accrued depreciation follow. The detailed

calculations as of December 31, 2016, are set forth in the Results of Study section of

the report.

Avera e Service Life Procedure

In the average service life procedure, the remaining life annual accrual for each

vintage is determined by dividing future book accruals (original cost less book reserve)

by the average remaining life of the vintage. The average remaining life is a directly

weighted average derived from the estimated future survivor curve in accordance with

the average service life procedure.

The calculated accrued depreciation for each depreciable property group

represents that portion of the depreciable cost of the group which would not be

allocated to expense through future depreciation accruals if current forecasts of life

characteristics are used as the basis for such accruals. The accrued depreciation

calculation consists of applying an appropriate ratio to the surviving original cost of each

vintage of each account based upon the attained age and service life. The straight line

accrued depreciation ratios are calculated as follows for the average service life

procedure:

7Average Remaining Life

Ratio = 1Average Service Life

~ GannettFleming V-3 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

50of317

CALCULATION OF ANNUAL AND ACCRUED AMORTIZATION

Amortization, as defined in the Uniform System of Accounts, is the gradual

extinguishment of an amount in an account by distributing such amount over a fixed

period, over the life of the asset or liability to which it applies, or over the period during

which it is anticipated the benefit will be realized. Normally, the distribution of the

amount is in equal amounts to each year of the amortization period.

The calculation of annual and accrued amortization requires the selection of an

amortization period. The amortization periods used in this report were based on

judgment which incorporated a consideration of the period during which the assets will

render most of their service, the amortization periods and service lives used by other

utilities, and the service life estimates previously used for the asset under depreciation

accounting.

Amortization accounting is appropriate for certain General Plant accounts that

represent numerous units of property, but a very small portion of total depreciable

electric plant in service. The accounts and their amortization periods are as follows:

Account

AmortizationPeriod,Years

391,

393,394,395,397,398,

Office Furniture and EquipmentFurniture and EquipmentEDP

Stores EquipmentTools, Shop and Garage EquipmentLaboratory EquipmentCommunication EquipmentMiscellaneous Equipment

158

2020151020

For the purpose of calculating annual amortization amounts as of December 31,

2016, the book depreciation reserve for each plant account or subaccount is assigned

or allocated to vintages. The book reserve assigned to vintages with an age greater

GannettFleming V-4 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

51of317

than the amortization period is equal to the vintage's original cost. The remaining book

reserve is allocated among vintages with an age less than the amortization period in

proportion to the calculated accrued amortization. The calculated accrued amortization

is equal to the original cost multiplied by the ratio of the vintage's age to its amortization

period. The annual amortization amount is determined by dividing the future

amortizations (original cost less allocated book reserve) by the remaining period of

amortization for the vintage.

~ GannettFleming V-5 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

52of317

PART VL RESULTS OF STUDY

g GannettFleming VI-1 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

53of317

PART VI. RESULTS OF STUDY

QUALIFICATION OF RESULTS

The calculated annual and accrued depreciation are the principal results of the

study. Continued surveillance and periodic revisions are normally required to maintain

continued use of appropriate annual depreciation accrual rates. An assumption that

accrual rates can remain unchanged over a long period of time implies a disregard for

the inherent variability in service lives and salvage and for the change of the

composition of property in service. The annual accrual rates were calculated in

accordance with the straight line remaining life method of depreciation, using the

average service life procedure based on estimates which reflect considerations of

current historical evidence and expected future conditions.

The annual depreciation accrual rates are applicable specifically to the electric

plant in service as of December 31, 2016. For most plant accounts, the application of

such rates to future balances that reflect additions subsequent to December 31, 2016, is

reasonable for a period of three to five years.

DESCRIPTION OF STATISTICAL SUPPORT

The service life and salvage estimates were based on judgment which

incorporated statistical analyses of retirement data, discussions with management and

consideration of estimates made for other electric utility companies. The results of the

statistical analyses of service life are presented in the section titled "Service Life

Statistics".

The estimated survivor curves for each account are presented in graphical form.

The charts depict the estimated smooth survivor curve and original survivor curve(s),

g GannettF)eming VI-2 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

54of317

when applicable, related to each specific group. For groups where the original survivor

curve was plotted, the calculation of the original life table is also presented.

The analyses of salvage data are presented in the section titled, "Net Salvage

Statistics". The tabulations present annual cost of removal and salvage data, three-year

moving averages and the most recent five-year average. Data are shown in dollars and

as percentages of original costs retired.

DESCRIPTION OF DEPRECIATION TABULATIONS

A summary of the results of the study, as applied to the original cost of electric

plant as of December 31, 2016, is presented on pages Vl-4 through Vl-12 of this report.

The schedule sets forth the original cost, the book reserve, future accruals, the

calculated annual depreciation rate and amount, and the composite remaining life

related to electric plant.

The tables of the calculated annual depreciation accruals are presented in

account sequence in the section titled "Detailed Depreciation Calculations." The tables

indicate the estimated survivor curve and net salvage percent for the account and set

forth, for each installation year, the original cost, the calculated accrued depreciation,

the allocated book reserve, future accruals, the remaining life and the calculated annual

accrual amount.

~ GannettFleming VI-3 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

55of317

00

SQUAB 88 BBSZ" ZS 8 8"8

0 ZN 5

R

N

R 8 Z8 8 i 8

BZR

i R

ZRSii-

02 R2 0

L %88

BBSz SR B

8 8i58RQ',RN: 8

88=ii(RRRQB 8 88

N

R

N

8

0 WZ

NioBwoK 0RKD

5

NBD

0 WIU

N00

U

8D 0

0

tU \0 ZN W

ii8855Zi

""8P,:"8RRB

8

Q ZA SR

BSQRZ"B

NBSB

8

88RZ"

NQ8

8 8SRS 88ZB Ri

884"

RRRR

8

55=8"8SZ

0 ~S

$ Z

UI

0IU

0

I

R

o 8ii

55

"-I88 DB

K IU K IU' K K IU

='='SSBSSS

8 NB BBBBODD D NOD RjR~j~RS

PiPR:RrtSBSSS

000

ZRR

Z

2 8 0 5 PU PU R R R

0

P

80-iRDR

Z0

iZZOOOOOKKKK

RRRK

I

8

U. PIN

2 R

LOKKZZZZDODDz0 0 0 0

8

0Ut

5

0 Z

UJ UI)0

Rz2 2

K 8

0KZKZiimo

KOOoooizz UIUII

S00 WIJ

W

sR

P

UIL 0

hog

LLLZizD0 0K000000K K K

S00

R0

0 N0 IU

0

2

CÃj GannettFleming Vl-4 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

56of317

5 0

0 8

ODQ8 U

580 Y

0Yh

0

8 8 8

to 8SZQZ SQ

ZZ 8 R

8 KS88 Z8

8 8 SQSR

8$ 88-8.6

8 Z

8 8ZRQDS-RQZ

QZ98 8$ "

9$ 5f8

0

0

00

OS

Z Zlr U

05Qh8Ul Itt ODZ0

ww

8UI

58

IU

0

8U

8

000

w0 0

hhIU 0 80)0

8

QQ

8

R $ 8 8

QQ RR RRR

$ 8 BQ888

R

88$' '8ZR

RR5 I H

8"8

$ $ 8 Q

$ 5zNIR

-fe.0

8

8

88 8

BQ"

SZ 8RRHR

888 8

QZ fs

Z ZS8 5

8S-QBZ

8 sfZ8

5 R-

88

SZIIRRR R'd

U.50IU

00 0Z80

UIUI

]5

Z0

55558j DZ D 0 0 D 0

0 Z 0 lt lt'

h

58

0O0 pw 8

5

I"

0 Z

OD-ZZZ0 I Y

0Df

h

0Z Z

IL $ g

Zo

5585 ozez

h

5

I 0 08

8 5 Ul 0

«III

h5

0 80 UI

O

tU PD0 z8 -'-0 U 0z 08

QU

IU 0QZ0 0

Q 8IU

-'5.8 5 0 5l

UZ z 0 8

h5

O

0

68

0 Y8 Iu

6

.m

uzs0 Owsw 05ZZ

550Ul

50U

5u

8Zrl0 p0

0


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

57of317

8 2 Ic80U Z

n s n

esse ss Rs s exs

ez$ O

0gs

assi

OÃ

0

e5

D0

0N05„s

8/0N

»ONgeegzzW»OY IC Q

5jCI

IC

0

OZOCl

IC

N0U

C0

0 Ic

58

cI z

p8

Cl

C. IC

"se ssSZ I-

se

ZZKZ

ohioR

8 sS

O'. IC ZK'OOO

R sss

Z tCN*

es- ss

"W

s-s ..ss

=e8 8 ', s ." o s ~: B 8

sss s ss e I: s s8 N S

f)4ee4)e45

8P.gsP,shed 8 IIII'

seg

:666::eeag:6:z

UUt

0

O

NIC

a

5$ PU

0

0cl a

0

N

0

O

DS p

s0Q

N

ph8 C.sa

6 s

h

8

N

6 8

88 5

It

6

0

0 W

D PY U

0s8

N

Z Z0 DC WZ Z

WNRZK K

yQD2eeZ Z-00

8

8popW I Z

OURCl lll 0

0UQZ0Z

8ecK

N850Ic 6

NeoC 0»Z Usz6KgzUN5Z 0ZWO0 tz Z

0DZ08

Y

tc YI cf6UUU»

ez5800pUU8 z)06N Z


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

58of317

02

8 80U

LS Z 8 see

2D0

ZZ Z 8"8"8 8 8

8 8Wn-N

8

VYU02

)IC

W

Y00Cl

X d888 U

U

8"IC

X

8 8 "88

"8SZRS

8

8" ZR8 8 ZZ 8SSR -SRS-"=

8588:8=

R" 8

8ZS 88 ZS-..8

RRR88 8 88 8

88888

0 8U

Z X880

VI Z

IC 0X U0 IC 00K

SKR5

P SN0U

0 XCZ Y C2

0 U

0

8 SZRSRR SRZR

ZS 8 "88

88 ns z

8

8

"SSR

888 SZ

SS8"H

8

Z

WUI X

52 S8 Nu0 X

0 WU 0

NEER:808 Se:8 SEFE:SR 8:Q ":See::RD8:8:: ApZ.

0 0

O

I8X

D

IC0 IC

5 X

0 U

Bw

lcg xD

X WX P

x 8 8 8 8 ic 8 8 8 8 8 8 88 d 8 d d 0 8 8 R d d 8 8

ARSPSSSS4SSSS8 8RRRZ 8 88 888 ""8

RR888

ggggXSd*d* '*

8

8448 ZZ88

IC

IC

D0VU

88O U0 O2 20 02 2* Z X

W N U UX IC

0 2 2 2

0 NNUUOW 2XZZZO Wpp

tx tl, W "'w«xI 8u 2258O JU88SSSKSS zuvvop8K F Sw zooKRK „N 2 ow zzNe~gzeexSCOI152Rooeeeewzzpoox ZZ ox ow

P' X 0 p U U&~osppggegwxuuzw

555$OCIXX Xwulz

X0NU

Cl

80

2WK

o0 Clu

8RX

D 8 &I

0 00 0V U

8 8d- 2 2v 2o2 2

o2/sf oo 8000 Cl I W

ZX XWW

v 2 2 8 8 x 8 c. 8 e 2 20 0UV SU 2 2 0DXoouu

ICI ZXUUZCI00 v cl

880 zzowQ8oR* x 8 N~I I 8 ~~ x

X

8W

8

0

QU0202V8UDC

85 0C.W W

8 Cl

0 8

2 88 NC.

00202U

U 00 UCl

I 8888HSuu

VDOpWW2 2zesC 22Z0Dtl U O

NNX

IC

0

NX

8 U

wz8 xU

0

88WN22

IC I IZX X

~w 8 8

dNLQ

II)8D8UvpCl Cl 22Z0

Z 2eez828K

UURwive2

8XZN

0 02 20 02 Z

Y YU 8 00 U

IC

X X

2 U tl U 0 Cl

I 2 2— 2CICI W

K8zz 88xmszz2200U lc Q cl o uz xwU o z 8

Clg

X 0

))8 p

woz«0

0

0

0

Ig GannettFleming VI-7 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

59of317

025 20zza

0U 2

"8 8 8" en 88 888

0) U

\U 2

Z p2 20

K" K

8

RR 8"8- "8 R8 8

I P.

888RK-K -8

8 .RK .

8

2 22 2

U

8 8 RK8 Ke

RR8 KS

8

C22

200IC

,8ow00

88888"8 RK

0 8U

2 22 20'

NOW0I

D0 IC'

2 I N

OZNCI '5

8"IC

U 02p 2IgNCI

NIC

0IC

N

N0UJOZ5

0

50 U

0

0 Z8 2

2N

0

0 0

IC 200 0I

K

Ksisgse-888

2 2 2 IC 2 2 IC'C' 2 2 2 2d 8 0 d d d 8 0 d 8 8 0 8

888888888808088

888

N NNJ NJ J

KKKK

Cl Cl N N Nddddddd N INNNddddd

88888088888808

8

8

8"

:gER

88K

0UU

50Cl N

O 28ugz5„2

d 98Z Z0 U

L-Z Z

Nk.5z2 2 0 zpp

2 I ICN OUUOO2 2 25 N z N i 0 0 I 8euzz — 288zeezz22202 NN»

UU2uzgozuu88zw"-— 55i022205CI0ZZN N NZ

glU

z V

8

0 UUu

2

O5

Ua

wzz55DN2N

N 0U

2

N0Z Z0 0WZ Z

2 2 I22

N DO

d

imf008UVOIC W 2220p p

NZZW5ez

W IUi22 2

0 00 QU U0 Q2 20 0Z 2u U

C C

88 8

866zz2 8D0

3

8p U

80C. 0

JI" P

00 0

2

awL 5Z CI2N 2 z

88

Nu8

Rao eK

N

0 8 0

002

8888888

20N5N2

2P0

20

8N0

a Ic

N 5I p

888

W 0

f N

DaQuz280Z CIZoz


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

60of317

2 0

0 2

0 "J

00~2 2

0 222 28

XXX S"ssx

X s.

0

0

CI2

00IC

IN0 S022e IOw

N I 0W 5 CI2 Ugfp& 0022)2

2 52 d2 IC0 0

U

256 5

N SI00

el 20w0

X

SX

xs

SX

XI

X g

2

XX

EX

o

gi

02Z0 2

IO ~

tC $2

0

0 2Iz

6 gcI2

Cl g 2200III

X g0 d

zz ee

2 2 2Ad NA

Id

5 O

& dU N

2

0

0 0N

0

UR

0CI

5 0U g

D 0

0 0

2

2000U

0

O 2$ 00

sg

Zhgg

90ZwD 0

g

0

I0

0

2 N

82

s0Id0

Wp

2 p

220

C.

O

e wpZw

262I0

0

0dlCl

wtd

g s2 gl2

Qw02 200 N d

IC u p

2

s0

hi

5 gu~j

I0

I h

zB

0 I" 2

Izl 2 I

50CI

D

N 00N tdN

N

0

0

:-I0

I0


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

61of317

8 0oiw0 eDU IC

NR

DB~fl Pc

88«Is

0

RQ-N

! I! I I!

IC

3

U

?0

80N0 SU

e z

8 U c.8800 Cc. 0 Z

cl 6

2 Pc

0 8

I

0UQ0Z588

8u00

R

p s

e

8RR 2"

8 'u8 5IC

Qb 8 Ic0 I!'

C

Z N0 0IZCN

0

I8

025 Z«U

Is ?I?2z 8C. z

RRR

2 Ic 2ddd

s s

0Uu

00

0Z

82

ZzZ Z««?00«ZZ0 0O2N

N ZuU 0 I

. jI

N

U8Z D0

Cl

8I

L LZ??I. ««Z

suu ?c. 2 2 0

sz?85 cl cl zZ

0N

0

O

0 0

d d

8 8E

0 0O U

PcZ Z

Ne Ne

0$

Z Oz

0U0

0I

5N5 5. Vs.ooooRNN

Z0

Z0e 0CI 0 0

Z8 0

0 CI

s

50

$I I8

CI 0?$ 8?s PI I-

8Nj8s?38

8 uw

8 U5

j I-:'

R

~ Gannett Fleming VI-10 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2616

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

62of317

8»l52O 82 20

U

»l?R8 2$ 8

I0

I8

?8

N0 8U

$ i

I" 0

IU 8I» 2280 5

UI

IU

8w

0U

0 2I 8w

w2w

R

:"59

5""

8 8

8

ss

86

88 8=.8'8

2

8 0.

2

8 8l2 6 I

N Ul

0Ig

8

U

0

I2

N

0 U

55Uj 2 28-"0

00V

»I88N

0

?0U

8Z

20

8888888P.R;=.8

IU

0

:j „.l»U 8

82520 0

0

08$ 2NW IU

)BI

W IU

IU I2 I»Z2 2888808',

828$ 2N

8888888888888=.58:8:8885:88

000

IR

0 0K

P-

282022

Z 2

8IJI

2028

22 ZZZ2280052208 UU

-:.'.'PPPI,I'K-888-I NN 800 K K K

III)


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

63of317

500 IU0 2500

0 UI0 Il

I"0

CI

8

5

8

8 s0 «

5q5I IU0

5IL'

NNNNU Ul25U )

I

tU $

NC

0 N5 5

e 0000

8

5

3 )'000 ZU 0

0 ~2»0IU 5

5

5

0

5

0 550

UJ 2

0" 0ZQIU

0 0

oUI 5

20

0tfI00

2 uu

0

Q0 Z

05I0

u5%

h5

~sZ

IU

(i;I o5

000N

00N0

00

0 0 0I I

E

f 5 52

2 joe

E

2 5

p 2

E

2 5

I

8

E

USE

2 2

2 E. 5

odd do


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

64of317

PART VII. SERVICE LIFE STATISTICS

g GannettFleming VII-1 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

65of317

55M ru rs

Z 0H

88) Is

re

rs u RM

H

0U 0

CI &IO p

UJ5

CIN

CII

BNIRIRHIIS J.N3383d

CIN

CICI

~ GannettFleming VII-2 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

66of317


ACCOUNT 311 STRUCTURES AND IMPROVEMENTS

ORIGlNAL LIFE TABLE

PLACEMENT BAND 1923 — 2016 EXPERlENCE BAND 1923-2016

AGE ATBEGIN OFINTERVAL

EXPOSURES ATBEGINNING OFAGE INTERVAL

RETIREMENTSDURING AGE

INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO

PCT SURVBEGIN OFINTERVAL

0. 0

0.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.59.5

10.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

556,526,636546,836,371520,769,252495,336,731489,972,566471,038,184479,189,487473,758,844413,032,907364,971,104

306,506,044289,088,594252,213,544235,512,442236,024,773227,004,055219,299,273215,807,703215,349,088214,470,462

212,592,951208,778,028198,852,048197, 521, 548196,622,834194,860,143193,535,390192,529,820187,240,411182,551,294

178,969,320176,737,941182,739,258179,092,99895,875,34192,294,56889, 761, 68082, 141, 11377,172,75776,609,050

57,1753,088

1,691,0386,988

971,5665,595

12,475216,14548,15130,168

31, 833711,383

3,555212,495102,237473,847134,039233,18642,089

444,882

272,4151,317,406

107,459479,943269,614184,07728,470

1,034,95699,289

181,689

497,74987,62651,38075,04339,676

283,2726,124

58,230120,50742,061

0.00010.00000.00320.00000.00200.00000.00000.00050.00010.0001

0.00010.00250.00000.00090.00040.00210.00060.00110.00020.0021

0.00130.00630.00050.00240.00140.00090.00010.00540.00050.0010

0.00280.00050.00030.00040.00040.00310.00010.00070.00160.0005

0.99991.00000.99681.00000.99801.00001.00000.99950.99990.9999

0.99990.99751.00000.99910.99960.99790.99940.99890.99980.9979

0.99870.99370.99950.99760.99860.99910.99990.99460.99950.9990

0.99720.99950.99970.99960.99960.99690.99990.99930.99840.9995

100.0099.9999.9999.6699.6699.4799.4699.4699.4299.40

99. 4099. 3999.1499.1499.0599.0198.8098.7498.6398. 61

98.4198.2897.6697.6197.3797.2497.1597.1396.6196.56

96.4696.2096.1596.1296.0896.0495.7595.7495.6795.52

g GannettFleminti VII-3 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

67of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE, CONT.

PLACEMENT BAND 1923-2016 EXPER1ENCE BAND 1923-2016




INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


39.540.541.542.543.544.545.546.547.548.5

49.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69. 5

70.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5

70,130,24668,389,34045, 812, 03145,048,68733,905,96433,824,39131,913,28331,793,83831,710,96130,811,18530,460,26721,568,96221,533,13515,773,37014,020,03613,111,93913,111,65511,165,02011,151,40810,538,520

8,185,7328,170,0074,869,8791,874,8531,855,3791,855,3791,758,0001,756,8421,755,5841,754,2971,753,089

969,792969,792969,792969,792969,792969,792969,792969,792969,792

91,203483,470238,85037,37947,20433,559

104,69274,74686, 196

108,760

12,3558,676

44,50617,68421,096

58113,232

23,840

0.00130.00710.00520.00080.00140.00100.00330.00240.00270.0035

0.00040,00040.00210.00110.00150.00000.00000.00120.00000.0000

0.00000.00290.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.99870.99290.99480.99920.99860.99900.99670.99760.99730.9965

0.99960.99960.99790.99890.99851.00001.00000.99881.00001.0000

1.00000.99711.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

95.4795.3594.6794.1894.1093.9793.8893.5793.3593.09

92.7792.7392.6992.5092.4092.2692.2692.2592.1492.14

92. 1492. 1491. 8791.8791.8791.8791.8791.8791.8791.87

91.8791.8791,8791.8791.8791.8791.8791. 8791.8791.87


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

68of317



ORIGINAL L1FE TABLE, CONT.

PLACEMENT BAND 1923-2016 EXPERIENCE BAND 1923-2016




INTERVALRETMTRATIO

5URVRATIO


79.580.581.582.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89. 5

969,792964,385964,385964,385964,385963,271959,030855,131855, 131507,067

5,407

1, 114

0.00560.00000.00000.00000.00120.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.99441.00001.00001.00000.99881.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

91.8791.3691.3691.3691.3691.2691.2691,2691.2691.26

91.26

QÃ GannettFleming VII-5 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

69of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE





INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.5

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29. 5

30.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

480,570,289474,256,722459,691,433435,969,638444,285,707439,080,756448, 531, 079443,482,937382,777,414336,556,030

278,104,942265,846,484228,993,155214,597,728215,374,294209,570,510201,912,844202,008,569201,636,252201, 648, 528

199,778,538197,446,953188,450,957188,446,186187,742,880187, 189, 855188,382,605187,433,022185,272,919180,583,803

177,101,207174,882,987180,885,561177,241,84894,033,49691,277,23788,763,95781,147,39076,179,03475,618,327

29,2372,297

1,690,9274,653

962, 881599

5,103216,070

9,26027,276

20,025697,449

3,340193,358101,879472,608132,339232,88641,039

437,792

267,5331,295,453

105,777473,030264,979183,36528,054

1,034,76599,289

179,689

485,74987,62650,12066,94633,676

263,6642,124

58,230117,50739,061

0.00010.00000.00370.00000.00220.00000.00000.00050.00000.0001

0.00010.00260.00000.00090.00050.00230.00070.00120.00020.0022

0.00130.00660.00060.00250.00140,00100.00010.00550.00050.0010

0.00270.00050.00030.00040.00040.00290.00000.00070.00150.0005

0.99991.00000.99631.00000.99781.00001.00000.99951.00000.9999

0.99990.99741.00000.99910.99950.99770.99930.99880.99980.9978

0.99870.99340.99940.99750.99860.99900.99990.99450.99950.9990

0.99730.99950.99970.99960.99960.99711.00000.99930.99850.9995

100.0099.9999.9999.6399.6299.4199.4199.4199.3699.36

99. 3599.3499.0899.0898.9998.9498.7298.6698.5498.52

98,3198.1897.5397.4897.2397.1097.0096.9996.4596.40

96. 3096.0495.9995.9695.9395.8995.6295.6195.5595.40


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

70of317






39. 5

40.541.542.543.544.545,546.547.548.549.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5


69,142,52367,406,96744,832,65844,074,41432,935,77232,854,59930,943,49130,824,04630,741,16929,841,393

29,495,83020,708,42420,672,59715,260,89614,020,03613,111,93913,111,65511,165,02011,151,40810,538,520

8, 185, 7328,170,0074,869,8791,874,8531,855,3791,855,3791,758,0001,756,8421,755,5841,754,2971,753,089

969,792969,792969,792969,792969,792969,792969,792969,792969,792


INTERVAL

85,853480,470233,75033,29846,80433 559

104,69274,74686,196

108,760

12,3558,676

44,50617,68421,096

58113,232

23,840

RETMTRATIO

0.00120.00710.00520.00080.00140.00100.00340.00240.00280.0036

0.00040.00040.00220.00120.00150.00000.00000.00120.00000.0000

0.00000.00290.00000.0000O.OOOO0.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

0.99880.99290.99480.99920.99860.99900.99660.99760.99720.9964

0.99960.99960.99780.99880.99851.00001.00000.99881.00001.0000

1.00000.99711.00001,00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000


95.3595.2394.5594.0693.9993.8593.7693.4493.2192.95

92.6192.5892.5492.3492.2392.0992.0992.0991.9891.98

91.9891.9891.7191.7191.7191.7191.7191.7191.7191.71

91.7191.7191.7191.7191.7191.7191.7191.7191.7191.71

g GannettFlaming VII-7 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

71of317




PLACEMENT BAND 1923-2016 EXPERIENCE BAND 1977 — 2016




INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


79.580.581.582.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89.5

969,792964,385964,385964,385964,385963,271959,030855,131855,131507,067

5,407

1, 114

0.00560.00000.00000.00000.00120.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.99441.00001.00001.00000.99881.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

91.7191.2091.2091.2091.2091.0991.0991.0991.0991.09

91.09


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

72of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE





INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO

PCT SURVBEG1N OFINTERVAL

0.00.51.52.53.54,55. 5

6.57.58.5

9.510.511.512.513.514.51516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

327,855,455320,643,997303,012,577279,664,643275,532,005268,858,985278,285,475276,736,545220,903,698173,468,787

119,855,978103,278,73879,381,56465,929,126

133,788,918128,737,499122,134,843126,547,149131,734,904133,575,155

134,991,040134,486,945137,247,506137,528,686150,173,758160,067,288161,046,944160,539,835155,401,110151,605,555

148,061,896151,866,911157,934,285156,500,40872,804,76272,404,60669,985,22867,847,34262,992,85563,336,462

615,4294,640

962,8785

2,270216,070

8,26027,200

20,001

3, 00393,77232,282

129,0S595,833

548407,206

267,1301,293,986

32,960320,744227,297148,56617,590

939,60695,020

160,089

432,66983,04449,02166,94633,676

228,3182,124

39,892103,04739,061

0.00000.00000.00200.00000.00350.00000.00000.00080.00000.0002

0.00020.00000.00000.00000.00070.00030.00110.00080.00000.0030

0,00200.00960.00020.00230.00150.00090.00010.00590.00060.0011

0.00290.00050.00030.00040.00050.00320.00000.00060.00160.0006

1.00001.00000.99801.00000.99651.00001.00000.99921.00000.9998

0.99981.00001.00001.00000.99930.99970.99890.99921.00000.9970

0.99800.99040.99980.99770.99850.99910.99990.99410.99940.9989

0.99710.99950.99970.99960.99950.99681.00000.99940.99840.9994

100.00100.00100.0099.8099.8099.4599.4599.4599.3799.36

99.3599.3399. 3399.3399.3399.2699.2399,1399.0599.05

98.7598.5697.6197.5897.3697.2197.1297.1196.5496.48

96.3896.1096.0496.0195.9795.9395.6395.6295.5795.41


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

73of317




PLACEMENT 1923 — 2016 EXPERIENCE BAND 1997-2016




INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


39.540.541.542.543.544.545.546.547.548.5

49.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59. 5

60.561.562,563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571. 5

72.573.574,575.576.577.578.5

56,861,08956,607,22634,953,41035,469,13124,533,47925,613,36826,942,89826,879,02329,853,10628,953,33028,699,79219,809,64419,775,07514,016,59712,264,47212,142,14712,141,86310,195,22810,181,6169,568,7287,215,9407,200,2153,900,087

905,061885,587885,587788,208787,050785,792784,505

788,652109,254109,254457, 318969,792969,792969,792969,792969,792969,792

80, 010468,008233,75018,80446,80433 559

104,69274,74686,196

108,760

12,3558,676

44,50617,68421,096

58113,232

23,840

0.0014 0.99860.00830.00670.00050.00190.00130.00390.00280.00290.0038

0.99170.99330.99950.99810.99870.99610.99720.99710.9962

0.0004 0.99960.00040.00230.00130.00170.00000.00000.00130.00000.0000

0.00000.00330.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.99960.99770.99870.99831.00001.00000.99871.00001.0000

1.00000.99671.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

0.00000.0000

1.00001.0000

0.0000 1.0000

95.3595.2294,4393, 8093.7593.5793.4593.0992.8392.56

92.2192.1792.1391.9291.8191.6591.6591.6491.5391.53

91.5391.5391.2291.2291.2291.2291.2291.2291.2291.22

91.2291.2291.2291.2291.2291.2291.2291.2291.2291.22

g~ GannettFlaming VII-10 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

74of317








INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


79. 5

80.581.582.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89.5

969, 792964,385964,385964,385964,385963,271959,030855,131855,131507,067

5,407

1, 114

0.00560.00000.00000.00000.00120.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.99441.00001.00001.00000.99881.00001. 00001.00001.00001.0000

91. 2290.7190.7190.7190.7190.6190.6190.6190.6190.61

90.61


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

75of317

M

z g

m8+M 0

v re o

5'-UH

o&ED p

UJ

CI o

BNIRIRBRS J.NBOBBd


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

76of317


ACCOUNT 312 BOILER PLANT EQUIPMENT

ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0.00.51.52.53. 5

4.55.56.57.58.5

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521,522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534,535.536.537.538.5


3,065,320,8703,040,569,9362,930,790,2082,672,950,7002,541,685,4302,496,701,5722,406,136,4412,341,239,6502, 108, 399, 7201,908,395,8761,551,672,5171, 448, 341, 4761,270,727,6191,220,936,0881,120,375,8801,076,972,5251 001I 311 643

923,676,294886,304,860848, 106,940

802,907,569772,622,728750,124,589727,767,404712,830,631705,195,490691,199,663674,275,481633,951,292625,473,884

617,461,656604,748,631629,766,737622,028,425374,421,447369,387,583363,690,361250,695,177231,261,837219,535,987


INTERVAL

4,236,2383,220,218

26,051,0947,019,7748,411, 6137,213,706

13,443,8209,723,477

13,683,7089,993,9087,211,0365,317,8884,968,9223,345,6235,904,3682,439,615

18, 175, 02110, 812, 83613,495,3854,138,0872,970,6053,610,4968,539,6882,682,5993,540,5225,686,7376,458,3324,948,9694,976,8915,903,8247,912,717

12,693,9344,893,0454,185,8516,768,4392,246,4121,828,9163,360,2331,325,3241,270,988

RETMTRATIO

0.00140.00110.00890.00260.00330.00290.00560.00420.00650.0052

0.00460.00370.00390.00270.00530.00230.01820.01170.01520.0049

0.00370.00470.01140.00370.00500.00810.00930.00730.00790.0094

0.01280.02100.00780.00670.01810.00610.00500.01340.00570.0058

SURVRATIO

0.99860.99890.99110.99740.99670.99710.99440.99580.99350.9948

0.99540.99630.99610.99730.99470.99770. 98180.98830.98480.9951

0.99630.99530.98860.99630.99500.99190.99070.99270.99210.9906

0.98720.97900.99220.99330.98190.99390.99500.98660.99430.9942


100.0099.8699.7698.8798.6198.2898.0097.4597.0596.42

95. 9195.4795.1294.7494.4893.9993.7792.0790.9989.61

89.1788.8488.4387.4287.1086.6685.9785.1684.5483.87

83. 0882.0280.3079.6779.1477.7177.2376.8475.8175.38


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

77of317






39.540.541.542.543.544.545.546.547,548.549.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5

EXPOSURES ATBEGINNING OFAGE 1NTERVAL

215,369,861207,618,234178,630,545168,577,865116,836,915114,417,33699,159,37696,444,94496,006,51479,130,33077,834,12154,743,79253,952,75839,281,59937,182,71132,740,07032,714,92926,113,92724,465,55419,591,405

11,954,9168,899, 1204,311,8601,642,0871,577,3561,575,3561,574,8901,574,8861,574,5261,573,626

864,151123,202123,202123,202123,202123,202123,202123,202123,202123,103


INTERVAL

3,179,890714,004

3,668,91411,022,4102,303,0081,878,6602,580,222

311,4521,533,5381, 285, 781

1,590,381756,251545,353210,973153,053294,663214,505

1,575,53040,80125,039

33,067110,293275,56560,577

226

99

RETMTRATIO

0.01480.00340.02050.06540.01970.01640.02600.00320.01600.0162

0.02040.01380.01010.00540.00410.00900.00660.06030.00170.0013

0.00280.01240.06390.03690.00000.00010.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00080.0000

SURVRATIO

0.98520.99660.97950.93460.98030.98360.97400.99680.98400.9838

0.97960.98620.98990.99460.99590.99100.99340.93970.99830.9987

0.99720.98760.93610.96311.00000.99991.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000.99921.0000


74. 9473.8473.5872.0767.3666.0364.9563.2663.0562.05

61. 0459.7958.9658.3758.0557.8257.3056.9253.4953.40

53.3353.1852.5249.1747.3547.3547.3447.3447.3447.34

47. 3447.3447.3447.3447.3447.3447.3447.3447.3447.31

gÃ GannettFleming VII-14 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 201 6

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

78of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE, CONT,





INTERVALRETMTRATIO

S URVRATIO


79. 580.581.582.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89.5

123,103123,103

56, 98356, 98356, 98349,24148,05848,05848,058

306

66,120

7,7421,183

47,658

0.00000.53710.00000.00000.13590.02400.00000.00000.99170.0000

1.00000.46291.00001.00000.86410.97601.00001.00000.00831.0000

47.3147.3121.9021.9021.9018.9218.4718.4718.470.15

0.15


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

79of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.5


2,768,046,5532,744,281,9412,653,939,9532,412,694,8702,352,983,2092,341,987,5022,270,278,3672,207,021,2191,974,649,1031,807,482,249


INTERVAL

4,235,8282,318,137

25,570,4626, 945, 5618,353,9577,199,261

12,083,3719,444,245

12,856,3939,935,102

RETMTRATIO

0.00150.00080.00960.00290.00360.00310.00530.00430.00650.0055

SURVRATIO

0.99850.99920.99040.99710.99640.99690,99470.99570.99350.9945


100.0099.8599.7698.8098.5298.1797.8797.3496.9396.30

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

1,451,1,365,1,188,1,149,1,049,1,018,

943,876,840,807,

020,986589,349142,904704,471392,211437,752068,227190,938513,524930,028

6,858,7675, 215, 0034,913,7993,329,1165,826,7622,207,501

18,173,25510,616,88713,310,1574,038,777

0.00470.00380.00410.00290.00560.00220.01930.01210.01580.0050

0.99530.99620.99590.99710.99440.99780.98070.98790,98420.9950

95.7795.3194.9594.5694.2893.7693.5691.7590.6489.21

19. 5

20.521.522.523.524.525,526.527.528.5

762740723706691690680665628620

842, 596121,409305,692035,840447,515804,996574,794737,470500,755029,613

2,743,4613,433,8088,504,8262,502,8313,466,8185,660,5046,380,6274,918,2264,972,6255,903,824

0.0036 0.99640.99540.9882

0.00460.01180.00350.0050

0.99650.9950

0.0082 0.99180.99060.9926

0.00940.00740.0079 0.99210.0095 0.9905

88.7688.4488.0387.0086.6986.2585.5584.7584.1283.45

29.530.531. 5

32.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

612599624616369365360247227215

017,797311,710330,177671,247923,118840,161142,940147,756714,416988,566

7,906,00912,693,9344,814,5634,162,2496,768,4392,246,4121, 828, 9163,360,2331,325,3241,270,988

0.01290.02120.00770.00670.01830.00610.00510.01360.00580.0059

0.98710.97880.99230.99330.98170.99390.99490.98640.99420.9941

82.6681.5979.8679.2578.7177.2776.8076.4175.3774.93


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

80of317






39. 540.541.542.543.544.545,546.547.548.549.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5


211,822,440204,070,813175, 083, 124165,030,443113,689,494111,269,91596,611,95595, 038, 94194,600,51077,724,32776,435,86053,346,81252,588,40937,917,34437,182,71132,740,07032,714,92926,113,92724,465,55419,591,40511,954,9168,899,1204,311,8601,642,0871,577,3561,575,3561,574,8901,574,8861,574,5261,573,626

864,151123,202123,202123,202123,202123,202123,202123,202123,202123,103


INTERVAL

3, 179, 890714,004

3,668,91410,622,4102,303,0081,278,6601,438,804

311,4521,533,5381,285,7811,590,381

723,621545,353210, 973153,053294,663214,505

1,575,53040,80125,039

33,067110,293275,56560,577

226

99

RETMTRATIO

0.01500.00350. 02100.06440.02030.01150.01490.00330.01620.0165

0.02080.01360.01040.00560.00410.00900.00660.06030.00170.0013

0.00280.01240.06390.03690.00000.00010.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00080.0000

SURVRATIO

0.98500.99650.97900.93560.97970.98850.98510.99670.98380.9835

0.97920.98640.98960.99440.99590.99100.99340.93970.99830.9987

0.99720,98760.93610.96311.00000.99991.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000.99921.0000

PCT SURVBEGIN OFINTERVAI

74.4973.3773.1171.5866.9765.6264.8663.9063.6962.66

61.6260.3459.5258.9058.5758.3357.8157.4353.9653.87

53. 8153.6652.9949.6047.7747.7747.7747.7747.7747.77

47.7747.7747.7747.7747.7747.7747.7747.7747.7747.73


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

81of317








INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


79. 5

80.581.582.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89.5

123,103123,10356,98356,98356,98349,24148,05848,05848,058

306

66,120

7,7421, 183

47,658

0.00000.53710.00000.00000.13590.02400.00000.00000.99170.0000

1.00000.46291.00001.00000.86410.97601.00001.00000.00831.0000

47.7347.7322.0922.0922.0919.0918.6318.6318.630.15

0.15


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

82of317

ro

0

0rsZ HOl

0 H

Ol+ Bro

0"gH

0

C &6) z

UJ0Cl;

Cl

CI

BNIAIABAS J.NBDBBd

ggg GannettFleming VII-19 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

83of317


ACCOUNT 312.1 BOILER PLANT EQUIPMENT — SCR CATALYST

ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.59.5

10.511.512.513.5


62,559,20462,559,20464,495,08865,310,32063,984,18160,147,63946,288,14435,068,54624,938,87116,209,0075,502,3865,502,3865,065,5385,065,538


INTERVAL

3,537,6856,128,2879,931,9794,685,4543,088,8265,526,1045,502,386

436,848

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00000.00000.05420.09580.16510.10120.08810.22160.3395

0.00000.07940.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

1.00001.00001.00000.94580.90420.83490.89880.91190,77840.6605

1.00000.92061.00001.0000


100.00100.00100.00100.0094.5885.5271.4064.1758.5245.55

30.0930.0927.7027.7027.70


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

84of317

g ro

K g

M rc0! re

CQ

0 0

pingMre00~0 00

8gH

0 UH

0

o &'O

~UJrg

C!

C)Cl

CI!

BNIAIABflS IN3083d


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

85of317


ACCOUNT 314 TURBOGENERATOR EQUIPMENT

ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE

PLACEMENT BAND 1923 — 2016 EXPERIENCE BAND 1923-2016


0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.59.5

10.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528,5

29. 5

30.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5


556,855,872549,688,056508,085,482472,909,297430,117,027414,992,561401,151,352394,166,829390,824,249378,804,953

371,713,070361,862,489360,901,132359,171,915350,644,689348,337,811345,939,364337,528,617334,268,267324,287,089

321,097,749304,666,963294,909,429288,559,852278,110,056260,541,644247,867,106239,233,041229,620,434225,159,338

222,635,233215, 286, 512221,824,303219,937,910144,434,648144,961,750143,809,691109,776,146105,910,371104,162,958

RETIREMENTSDUR1NG AGE

INTERVAL

6,357,23163,284

9,340,6421,757,429

759,1245,548

664,3631,577,752

503,138392,996

7,723,516184,485414,968

2,705,2871,722,892

10,4771,873,8681,753,6521,876,077

537,274

3,244,9413,256,2201,489,0488,140,3435,570,8392, 201, 588

875, 8015,544,3331,323,3992,141,400

1,872,2311, 990, 173

590,6742,591,604

598,082695,354287,024911,488

1,732,9371,691,143

RETMTRATIO

0.01140.00010.01840.00370.00180.00000.00170.00400.00130.0010

0.02080.00050.00110.00750,00490.00000.00540.00520.00560.0017

0.01010.01070.00500.02820.02000.00850.00350.02320.00580.0095

0.00840.00920.00270.01180.00410.00480.00200.00830.01640.0162

SURVRATIO

0.98860.99990.98160.99630.99821.00000.99830.99600.99870.9990

0.97920.99950.99890.99250.99511.00000.99460.99480.99440.9983

0.98990.98930.99500.97180.98000.99150.99650.97680.99420.9905

0.99160.99080.99730.98820.99590.99520.99800.99170.98360.9838


100.0098.8698.8597.0396.6796.5096.5096.3495.9595.83

95.7393.7493.6993.5892.8892.4292.4291.9291.4490.93

90.7889.8688.9088.4585.9684.2383.5283.2381.3080,83

80.0679.3978.6578.4477.5277.2076.8376.6876.0474.80


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

86of317




PLACEMENT 1923-2016 EXPERIENCE BAND 1923-2016


39.540.541.542.543 544.545.546. 547. 548.5

49. 5

50.551.552.553.554,555.556.557.558.5

59. 5

60.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69. 5

70.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5


102,172,15397,152,56686,255,42981,323,70965,617,58465,363,51658,223,71554,123,59753,189,29749,363,56246,927,70234,832,69334,813,30827,232,89924,850,21320,407,48720,372,10816,656,59116,532,21413,821,416

8, 871, 6346,516,7203,732,9512,275,3132, 273, 5182, 273, 5182,272,5862,272,5862,272,5862,272,586

1, 596, 222926,493926,493926,493926,493926,493926,493926,493926,493917,165


INTERVAL

1,287,812108,618

4,929,334214,740250,425

1,833,8424,093,918

927,102302,202

2,434,908369,30119,133

128,35737,03034,5031,032

90,48639, 704

1, 795

932

811

9, 328

RETMTRATIO

0.01260.00110.05710.00260.00380.02810.07030.01710.00570.0493

0.00790.00050.00000.00470.00150.00170.00010.00540.00240.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00080.00000.00040.00000.00000.00000.0004

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.01010.0000

SURVRATIO

0.98740.99890.94290.99740.99620.97190.92970.98290.99430.9507

0.99210.99951.00000.99530.99850.99830.99990.99460.99761.0000

1.00001.00001.00000.99921.00000.99961.00001.00001.00000.9996

1.OOOO1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000.98991.0000


73.5872.6572.5768.4268.2467.9866.0861.4360.3860.03

57.0756.6256.5956.5956.3356.2456.1556.1455.8455.71

55.7155.7155.7155.7155.6655.6655.6455.6455.6455.64

55.6255.6255.6255.6255.6255.6255.6255.6255.6255.06


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

87of317






79. 580.581.582.583.584.585,586.587.588.5

89.5


917,165917,165917,165917,165917,165915,933915,933914,549513,481

1,347


INTERVAL

1,232

401,068512,134

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00130.00000.00000.43850.99740.0000

SURVRATIO

1.00001.00001.00001.00000.99871.00001.00000.56150.00261.0000


55.0655.0655.0655.0655.0654.9954.9954.9930.870.08

0.08


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

88of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0.00.51.52.53.54,55.56.57.58.5

9.510.511.512.513. 5

14.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5


366,132,899368,264,428327,088,227343,745,465304,424,317289,369,697276,103,016274, 794, 185274,526,205262,515,551

278,400,869282, 809, 173289,838,288288,178,657279,655,151284,915,892282,574,309282,062,678278,814,234274,836,459271,670,974264,887,708255,153,486255,997,736250,869,985238,564,496225, 893, 115221,291,391214,967,209213,686,716

211,242,610208,541,292216,946,208216,106,533142,088,553142,615,654141,463,596107,430,983103,565,208101,817,795


1NTERVAL

14,60732,709

1,914,2321,757,429

759,1055,548

664,3631,577,752

503,138392,996

7,723,516184,485414,968

2,702,2871,717,025

6,4771,872,6681,750,3021,876,077

526,756

3,103,1413,235,1581,489,0488, 138, 4874,869,5402, 201, 588

875,8015,544,3331,272,3992,061,400

1,872,2311,990,173

590,6742,591,604

598,082695,354287,024911,488

1,732,9371,691,143

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00010.00590. 00510.00250.00000.00240.00570.00180.0015

0.02770.00070.00140.00940.00610.00000.00660.00620.00670.0019

0.01140.01220.00580.03180.01940.00920.00390.02510.00590.0096

0,00890.00950.00270.01200.00420.00490.00200.00850.01670.0166

SURVRATIO

1.00000.99990.99410.99490.99751.00000.99760.99430.99820.9985

0.97230.99930.99860.99060.99391.00000.99340.99380.99330.9981

0.98860.98780.99420.96820.98060.99080.99610.97490.99410.9904

0.99110.99050.99730.98800.99580.99510.99800.99150.98330.9834


100.00100.0099.9999.4098.8998.6598.6598.4197.8497.66

97.5294.8194.7594.6193.7393.1593.1592.5391.9691.34

91.1690.1289.0288.5085.6984.0383.2582.9380.8580.37

79.6078.8978.1477.9376.9976.6776.2976.1475.4974.23


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

89of317






39. 5

40.541. 542.543.544.545.546.547.548.5

49 . 550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5


100,502,54396, 154,48085,257,34380,325,62364,619,49764,365,43057,225,62953,125,51152,191,21148,365,47645,929,61633,834,60733,815,22226,234,81323,922,90919, 480, 18319,446,03615,731,90315,607,52613,307,935


INTERVAL

1, 287, 812108, 618

4,929,334214,740250,425

1,833,8424,093,918

927,102302,202

2,434,908369,301

19 133

57,57537,03034,5031,032

90,48639,704

RETMTRATIO

0.01280.00110.05780.00270.00390.02850.07150.01750.00580.0503

0.00800.00060.00000.00220.00150.00180.00010.00580.00250.0000

SURVRATIO

0.98720.99890.94220.99730.99610.97150.92850.98250.99420.9497

0.99200.99941.00000.99780.99850.99820.99990.99420.99751.0000


73.0072.0671. 9867.8267.6467.3765. 4560.7759.7159.37

56.3855.9255.8955.8955.7755.6855.5855.5855.2655.12

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69. 570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5

8,871,6346,516,7203,732,9512,275,3132,273,5182,273,5182,272,5862,272,5862,272,5862,272,586

1,596,222926,493926,493926,493926,493926,493926,493926,493926,493917,165

9320.00000.00040.00000.00000.0000

811 0.0004

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

9,328 0.01010.0000

0.00000.00000.0000

1,795 0.0008

1.00001.00001.00000.99921.00000.99961.00001.00001.00000.9996

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000.98991.0000

55.1255.1255.1255.1255.0855.0855.0655.0655.0655.06

55.0455.0455.0455.0455.0455.0455.0455.0455.0454.48


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

90of317



ORlGINAL LIFE TABLE, CONT.

PLACEMENT BAND 1923-2016 EXPERlENCE BAND 1983-2016




INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRAT10


79.580.581.582.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89.5

917,165917,165917,165917,165917,165915,933915,933914,549513,481

1,347

1,232

401,068512,134

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00130.00000.00000.43850.99740.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00000.99871.00001.00000.56150.00261.0000

54. 4854. 4854.4854.4854.4854.4154.4154.4130.550.08

0.08


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

91of317

CICI

R~~roK Ie

8 Iu

rc Utc Hro

rs rs ~rc o oro ro roZ ro ~

M

U

M gU

o&IO ~

UJIg

CI

CICl

BNIRIRbIAS j.N3083d

CI CI

Ig GannettFleming VII-28 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

92of317


ACCOUNT 315 ACCESSORY ELECTRIC EQUIPMENT

ORIGINAL LlFE TABLE





INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.59.5

10.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525. 5

26. 5

27.528.5

29. 530.531.532.533.534,535.536.537.538.5

307,867,140301,567,594284,208,511279,107,018276,244,174272,544,151262,889,140260,300,758226,053,166199,970,375

151,990,430141,384,198125,156,880122,542,548118,389,675117,209,526113,319,977112,230,863109,703,084107,835,007

106,494,56299,986,58394,429,94993,222,05690,988,03387,064,00081, 894, 04180,658,46875,795,11874,382,87071,865,21171,616,02375,250,51472,127,50547,259,43846,956,87846,113,20133,065,49831,346,99930,869,453

3,91525,6655,960

76,72675,2685,410

227,4113,343,809

4,2052,792,400

2,599,8341,068,247

142,13498,223

632,018102,403160,15232,847

862,836927,199

5,074,9262,126,5681,069,6672,318,3672,601,5081,049,579

38,5421,136,763

17,0906,601

50,461140,586760,448152,839398,82978,447

184,238202,951

9,34934,037

0.00000.00010.00000.00030.00030.00000.00090.01280.0000

1.00000.99991.00000.99970.99971.00000.99910.98721.0000

0.0140 0.9860

0.01710.00760.00110.0008

0.98290.99240.99890.9992

0.0053 0.99470.00090.00140.00030.00790.0086

0.04770.02130.01130.02490.02860.01210.00050.01410.00020.0001

0.99910.99860.99970.99210.9914

0.95230.97870.98870.97510.97140.98790.99950.98590.99980.9999

0.01010.00210.00840.00170.00400.00610.00030.0011

0.98990.99790.99160.99830.99600.99390.99970.9989

0.0007 0.99930.0020 0.9980

100.00100.0099.9999.9999.9699.9399.9399.8498.5698.56

97. 1895.5294.8094.6994.6294.1194.0393. 9093.8793.13

92. 3387. 9386.0685.0882.9780.6079.6379.5978.4778.45

78.4478.3978.2377.4477.2876.6376.5076.1975.7275.70


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

93of317








INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


39.540.541.542.543.544.545 5

46.547.548.549,550.551.552.553.554,555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5

29,157,33027,900,40723,982,01923,663,78017,519,14717,269,90614,349,68914,287,05014,255,59312,095,98111,962,1868,904,1428,824,7347,765,8096,580,0704,263,9814,199,4123,496,3963,473,5582,830,8181,803,8481,580,892

835,430483,392441,167441,167441,167441,167441,167441,167

286,630152,583152,583152,583152,583151,629151,629151,629151,629151,629

84,09620,866

296,199221,096175,717445,89062,59030,244

100,805132,823

41,77674,48163,4096,283

89,65863,207

20,03561,792

655

50,25342,225

35,068

13,675

33

0.00290.00070.01240.00930.01000.02580.00440.00210.00710.0110

0.00350.00840.00720.00080.01360.01480.00000.00570.01780.0002

0.00000.00000.06020.08740.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0795

0.04770.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0002

0.99710.99930.98760.99070.99000.97420.99560.99790.99290.9890

0.99650.99160.99280.99920.98640.98521.00000.99430.98220.9998

1.00001.00000.93980.91261.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000.9205

0.95231.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000.9998

75.6275.4075.3474.4173.7272.9871.0970.7870.6370.13

69.3669.1268.5468.0568.0067.0766.0866.0865.7064.53

64.5164.5164.5160.6355,3455.3455.3455,3455.3455,34

50. 9448.5148.5148.5148.5148.5148.5148.5148.5148.51


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

94of317





AGE ATBEG1N OFINTERVAL

79.580.581.582.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89.5


151,597150,223150,223150,223148,676140,385137,078137,07892,68716,640


INTERVAL

1,374

8,2913,307

44,39163,917

RETMTRATIO

0.00910.00000.00000.00000.05580.02360,00000.32380.68960.0000

SURVRATIO

0.99091.00001.00001.00000.94420.97641.00000.67620.31041.0000


48.5048.0648.0648.0648.0645.3844.3144.3129.969.30

9.30


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

95of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE





INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0.00.5

2.53.54.55.5

7.58.59.5

10.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523. 5

24. 525.526.527.528.5

29. 530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

246,218,538241,649,414224,668,140232,019,932230,349,773226,979,982220,418,793218, 875, 069185, 113, 486159,779,564

127,240,616120,900,896106,088,643103,491,65799,406,022

100,449,03997,061,21998,119,54095,617,09896,012,41195,326,44290,938,68785,420,85285,982,86583,882,53682,255,09377,092,88676,705,81372,423,83871, 848, 782

69,333,27969,697,08574,001,95971,119,12146,715,16146,420,55545,576,87832,529,83030,811,33130,333,785

1,0852

75,0718,6825,410

227,4113,343,359

4,205511,785

2,599,7841,067,388

135,30831 117

623,31925,377

134,2057,909

214,987272,723

4,415,1442,106,3691,069,6672,314,7722,601,5081,048,654

38,5421,136,763

17,0904,445

48,686140,586760,448151,949390,87578,447

184,238202,951

9,34934,037

0.0000 1.00000.0000 1.00000.00000.00030.00000.00000.00100.01530.00000.0032

0.02040.00880.0013

1.00000.99971.00001.00000.99900.98471.00000.9968

0. 97960.99120.9987

0.0003 0.99970.00630.00030.00140.00010.00220.0028

0.04630.02320.01250.02690.03100.01270.00050.01480.00020.0001

0.99370.99970.99860.99990.99780.9972

0.95370.97680.98750.97310.96900.98730.99950.98520.99980.9999

0.00210.00840.00170.0040

0.99790.99160.99830.9960

0.0062 0.99380.0003 0.99970.0011 0.9989

0.0007 0.99930.0020 0.99800. 0103 0. 9897

100.00100.00100.00100.0099.9799.9699.9699.8698.3398.33

98.0296.0195.1795.0495.0294.4294.4094.2694.2694. 05

93. 7889.4387.3686.2783.9581.3480.3180.2779.0879.06

79.0579.0078.8478.0377.8677.2177.0876.7776.2976.27


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

96of317






39. 540.541.542.543.544.545.546.547.548.5

49 . 550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69. 5

70.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5


28, 791, 38427,697,05823,778,67023,460,43017,315,79717,067,51114,147,29314,084,65514,053,19811,893,58511,759,7908,703,7708,624,3627,565,4376,381,2454,065,1564,008,8773,309,1693,286,3312,735,2121,803,8481,580,892

835,430483,392441,167441,167441,167441,167441,167441,167

286,630152,583152,583152,583152,583151,629151,629151,629151,629151,629


INTERVAL

84,09620,866

296,199221,096175,717445,890

62,59030,244

100,805132,823

39,75374,48163,4096,283

89,65863,207

20,03561,792

655

50,25342,225

35,068

13,675

33

RETMTRATIO

0.00290.00080.01250.00940.01010.02610.00440.00210.00720.0112

0.00340.00860.00740.00080.01410.01550.00000.00610.01880.0002

0.00000.00000.06020.08740.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000,0795

0.04770.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0002

SURVRATIO

0,99710.99920.98750.99060.98990.97390.99560.99790.99280.9888

0.99660.99140.99260.99920.98590.98451.00000.99390. 98120.9998

1.00001.00000.93980.91261.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000.9205

0.95231.00001. 00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000.9998


76.1875.9675.9074.9574.2573.5071.5871.2671.1170.60

69.8169.5768.9868.4768.4167.4566.4066.4066.0064.76

64.7464.7464.7460.8555.5355.5355.5355.5355.5355.53

51. 1248.6848.6848.6848.6848.6848.6848.6848.6848.68


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

97of317








INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO

PCT SURVBEGIN OF1NTERVAL

79. 580.581.582.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89. 5

151,597150,223150,223150,223148,676140,385137,078137,07892,68716,640

1,374

8, 2913,307

44,39163,917

0.00910.00000.00000.00000.05580.02360.00000.32380.68960.0000

0.99091.00001.00001.00000.94420.97641.00000.67620.31041.0000

48.6748.2348.2348.2348.2345.5444.4744.4730.079.33

9.33

gl GannettFleming VII-34 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2018

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

98of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABI E

PI ACEMENT BAND 1923-2016 EXPERIENCE BAND 1997 — 2016




INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0. 0

0.51,52.53.54.55.56.57.58.5

191,545,145187,766,153172,686,951167,785,264167,461,123166,264,148162,730,144161,662,504131,984,196106,809,339

74,6376,145

226,5713,308,711

0.00000.00000.00000.00040.00000.00000.00140.02050.0000

399,294 0.0037

1.00001.00001.00000.99961.00001.00000.99860.97951.00000.9963

100.00100.00100.00100.0099.9699.9599.9599.8197.7797.77

9.510.511.512.513.514,515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29. 5

30.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

61,993,13754,889,76839,931,17540,895,99759,562,40060,439,95956, 998, 18467,505,59366,596,03665,662,683

67,123,07465,775,46361,539,25959,953,63367,120,67668, 126, 54165,878,86564,647,56160, 333, 90860,927,167

58,427,56459,780,15063,415,02261,574,83136,723,44938,307,07237,482,00425,867,86924,282,46426,101,508

18, 105675,29287,46130,137

209,2544,728

107,6777,909

168,647272,705

955,3072,092,1731,036,400

39,0072,601,508

629,26338,542

587,5087,9124,445

48,686140,586760,448145,952378,77959,909

184,238185,011

9,34934,037

0.00030.01230.00220.00070.00350.00010.00190.00010.00250.0042

0.01420.03180. 01680.00070.03880.00920.00060.00910.00010.0001

0.00080.00240.01200.00240.01030.00160.00490.00720.00040.0013

0.99970.98770.99780.99930.99650.99990.99810.99990.99750.9958

0.98580.96820.98320.99930.96120.99080.99940.99090.99990.9999

0.99920.99760.98800.99760.98970.99840.99510.99280.99960.9987

97.4097.3896.1895.9795.9095.5695.5595.3795.3695.12

94. 7293.3890. 41BB.BS88.8385.3884.5984.5483.7883.77

83.7683.6983.4982.4982.3081.4581.3280.9280.3480.31


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

99of317






39. 540.541, 5

42.543,544.545.546.547.548.5


24,395,90823,993,31320,673,93721,240,29115,167,92015,491,70013,278,98313,392,63713,719,27011,559,658


INTERVAL

69,4023,230

248,797148,834116,394352,85827,43930,244

100,805132,823

RETMTRATIO

0.00280.00010.0120

SURVRATIO

0.99720.99990.9880

0.97720.02280.00210.0023

0.99790.99770.99270.0073

0.0115 0.9885

0.0070 0.99300.0077 0.9923


80.2179.9879.9779.0078.4577.8576.0875.9275.7575.19

49.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558,5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

11, 425, 8638,370,4978, 291, 0897,232,1646,216,1474,062,6553,998,0853,295,0703,272,2322,630,4451,603,4761,380,520

635,058283,020240,795240,795240,795240,795242,342242,342

39,75374,48163,409

6,28389,65863,207

20,03561,792

655

50,25342,225

0.00350.00890.00760.00090.01440.01560.00000.00610.01890.0002

0.00000.00000.07910.14920.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.99650.99110.99240.99910.98560.98441.00000.99390. 98110.9998

1.00001.00000.92090.85081.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

74.3374.0773.4172.8572.7871.7370.6270.6270.1968.86

68. 8568. 8568.8563.4053.9453.9453.9453.9453.9453.94

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5

131,16414,09914,09970,652

152,583151,629151,629151,629151,629151,629

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

33 0.0002 0.9998

53.9453. 9453. 9453. 9453.9453.9453.9453.9453.9453.94


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

100of317








INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRAT IO


79.580.581.582.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89.5

151,597150,223150,223150,223148,676140,385137,078137,07892,68716,640

1,374

8,2913,307

44,39163,917

0.00910.00000.00000.00000.05580,02360.00000.32380.68960.0000

0.99091.00001.00001.00000.94420.97641.00000.67620.31041.0000

53, 9353.4453.4453.4453.4450.4649.2749.2733.3110.34

10.34


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

101of317

CICcC

CIC

0 e0 5co

CQ

H

CD H

050

zUJ6I

CD Ct

BNIRIRblflS J.N3083d

QK GannettFleming VII-38 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

102of317


ACCOUNT 316 MISCELLANEOUS POWER PLANT EQUIPMENT

ORIGINAL L1FE TABLE



0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.59.5

10.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526. 527.528.5

29. 5

30.53132.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

EXPOSURES ATBEGlNNING OFAGE INTERVAL

92,062,84783,846,82379,067,68774,231,92571,781,35866,946,25262,486,18961,043,23157,914,07552,671,82542,830,69538,248,90732,435,13831,370,49628,191,81527,098,09426,516,75325,737,67925,083,10023,666,97622,897,81219,906,41819,019,37517,916,33516,994,97316,062,87215,800,00114,982,65913,921,13513,744,528

13,256,02812,671,06112,745,89312,282,8728,220,1428, 212, 9517,014,3595,093,8354,533,9324,347,681


INTERVAL

49,93532,261

366,029119,617205,970

1,024,930186,342430,860234,229505,541

423,866319,001147,823365,286188,96096,18642,89660,358

148,96246,691

1,906,703335,795661, 583544,507370,135242,508174,32789,49877,325

111,934

259,116134,03545,07889,72135,625

130,8916,583

395,73127,63755,598

RETMTRATIO

0.00050.0004

SURVRATIO

0.99950.9996

0.0046 0.99540.0016 0.99840.00290.01530.00300.0071

0.99710.98470.99700.9929

0.00990.00830.00460.01160.00670.00350.00160.00230.00590.0020

0.08330.01690.0348

0.99010.99170.99540.98840.99330.99650.99840.99770.99410.9980

0.91670.98310.9652

0.0304 0.96960.02180.01510.0110

0.97820.98490.9890

0.0060 0.99400.00560.0081

0.99440.9919

0.0195 0.98050.01060.00350.00730.00430.01590.0009

0. 98940.99650.99270.99570.98410.9991

0.0777 0.92230.00610.0128

0.99390.9872

0.0040 0.99600.0096 0.9904


100.0099.9599.9199.4499.2899.0097.4897.1996.5196.12

95.1994.2593.4793.0491.9691.3491.0290.8790.6690.12

89.9482.4581. 0678.2475.8674.2173.0972.2871.8571.45

70.8769.4968.7568.5168. 0167.7166.6366.5761.4061.02


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

103of317






39.540.541.542.543 . 544.545.546.547.548.549.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5


4,018,2623,965,7663,729,0863,656,8002,719,5442,696,9242,529,2562,524,5392,517,6322,091,2742,058,5681,600,8561,588,3521,323,0011,058,1281,039,617

949,666814,617813,593764,908

443,290326,667157,87215,43615,43615,39915,39915,39915 39915,399

15,39915,39915,39915,29915,29915,29915,29915,17212 77212,772


INTERVAL

7,72939,78154,30885,20615,08526,0221,1282, 183

80630,880

266,9267,407

233 337

14,97275,712

10233

282708

37

100

1272,400

RETMTRATIO

0.00190.01000.01460.02330.00550.00960.00040.00090.00030.0148

0.12970.00460.1469O.OO0O0.01410.07280.00000.00010.00000.0000

0.00060.00220.00000.00000.00240.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00650.00000.00000.00000.00830.15820.00000.0000

SURVRAT10

0.99810.99000.98540.97670.99'450.99040.99960.99910.99970.9852

0.87030.99540.85311.00000.98590.92721.00000.99991.00001.0000

0.99940.99781.00001.00000.99761.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00000.99351.00001.00001.00000.99170.84181.00001.0000


60.2460.1359.5258.665,7. 2956.9756.4256.4056.3556.33

55.5048.3048.0841.0241.0240.4437.4937.4937.4937.49

37.4937.4637.3837.3837.3837,2937.2937.2937,2937.29

37.2937.2937.2937.0537.0537.0537.0536.7430.9330.93

~ GannettFleming Vll-40 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

104of317






79.580.581.582.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89.5


12 77212 77212,77212,77212,77212 77212,77212,77212,77212,772


INTERVALRETMTRATIO

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000


30. 9330. 9330. 9330. 9330. 9330. 9330. 9330. 9330. 9330. 93

30.93


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

105of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE





INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.59.5

10.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

84,891,29976,828,93472,257,28167,761,08966,647,62961,991,19458,821,54957,409,13754,288,45749,532,27839,722,17035,566,85729,795,59429,102,39925,931,56625,061,03824,495,46024,140,59023,649,19622,357,019

32,91530,584

364, 996118, 312190, 180988,207185,292425,877232,078490,481

421,893302,925144,928363,375181,140

89,34635,73049,822

147,43845,949

0.0004 0.99960.0004 0.99960.00510.00170.00290.01590.00320.0074

0.99490.99830.99710.98410.99680.9926

0.01060.00850.00490,0125

0.98940.99150.99510.9875

0.0070 0.99300.0036 0.99640.00150.00210.0062

0.99850.99790.9938

0.0021 0.9979

0.0043 0,99570.0099 0.9901

100.0099.9699.9299.4299.2498.9697.3897.0896.3695.94

94,9993.9893.1892.7391,5790.9390.6190.4890.2989.73

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29. 5

30.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

21,590,52418,738,64817,902,89617,119,55916,207,99215,529,87215,528,32114,752,55113,883,47213,706,865

13,227,75412,643,19912,718,03112,256,2158,193,4848,194,9146,996,3225,075,7974,515,8954,329,644

1,902,873333,223651,416539,015369,502241,364174,22788,96677,325

104,045

258,703134,03545,07889,72135,598

130,8916,583

395,73127,63755,598

0.08810.01780.03640.03150.02280.01550.01120.00600.00560.0076

0.01960.01060.00350.00730.00430.01600.00090.07800.00610.0128

0.91190.98220.96360.96850.97720.98450.98880.99400.99440.9924

0.98040.98940.99650.99270.99570.98400.99910.92200.99390.9872

89.5481.6580.2077.2874.8573.1472.0071.2070.7770.37

69.8468.4767.7567.5167.0166.7265.6665.5960.4860.11


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

106of317






39.540.541.542.543.544.545.546.547.548.5

49, 5

50.551. 552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5


4,000,2253,947,8683,711,2913, 640, 0042,702,7492, 680, 1292,513,3612, 508, 6812,501,7742,075,4152,042,7091,587,5841,575,0801,309,7291,058,1281,039,617

949,666814,617813, 593764,908

443,290326,667157,87215,43615,43615,39915,39915,39915,39915,399

15,39915,39915,39915,29915,29915,29915,29915,17212,77212 772


INTERVAL

7, 58939,78153,30885,20615,08525,1221,1282, 183

80630,880

266,9267,407

233 337

14,97275,712

10233

282708

100

1272,400

RETMTRATIO

0.00190.01010.01440.02340.00560.00940.00040.00090.00030.0149

0.13070.00470.14810.00000.01410.07280.00000.00010.00000.0000

0.00060.00220.00000.00000.00240.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00650.00000.00000.00000.00830.15820.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

0. 99810.98990.98560.97660.99440.99060.99960.99910.99970.9851

0.86930.99530.85191.00000.98590.92721.00000.99991.00001.0000

0.99940.99781.00001.00000.99761.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00000.99351.00001.00001.00000.99170. 84181.00001.0000


59.3459.2358.6357.7956.4356.1255.5955.5755.5255.50

54.6847.5347.3140.3040.3039.7336.8436.8436.8336.83

36.8336.8136.7336.7336.7336.6436.6436.6436.6436.64

36.6436.6436.6436.4036,4036.4036.4036.1030.3930.39


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

107of317






79.580.581.582.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89.5


12,77212 77212,77212 77212,77212 77212 77212,77212,77212 772


INTERVALRETMTRATIO

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000


30.3930.3930.3930.3930.3930.3930.3930.3930.3930.39

30.39


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

108of317

ClCI

ro o rsZ 0H

O)gHNXrs 5 orsr 8ro u zg 0 ro

g 80U 0

o&IO ~

UJIg

o

CtO

BNIAIAH flS IN33b13d

oCV

C!


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

109of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE





INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.5

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29. 5

30.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

2,574,404,8832,436,987,8642,244,191,6902,214,492,2232,194,005,5992,136,908,5412,072,027,7121,995,017,3181,950,169,3021,930,464,1661,921,638,5851,911,142,1241,892,898,5241,868,950,0161,860,437,1191,850,959,7731,847,689,8361,834,567,7171,825,889,0461,824,454,0131,818,384,0251, 790, 651, 7801,754,522,6341,720,935,3361,705,083,5071, 661, 083, 0671,626,264,3291, 618, 932, 5741,907,909,7991,854,126,622

335,136,117297,664,221291,729,093264,022,444230,700,606229,184,548219,196,375202,945,472193,824,221190,596,143

1,294,4392,845,714

250,2011,266,4152,283,647

723,9991,406,7432, 189, 8002,544,246

640,276

2,266,3204, 031, 2784,161,0582,304,5773,259,9371,333,570

370,648924,179766,103

4,217,808

3,821,5422,697,1133,044,2248,419,0363,008,8811,326,0911,903,5644,235,5234,289,030

16,654,056

1,451,0712,559,7091,190,1461,026,2091, 444, 5181,341,359

931,0551,472,161

851,5562,165,996

0.0005 0.99950.00120.00010.00060.00100.00030.00070. 00110.00130.0003

0.00120.00210.00220.00120.00180.00070.0002

0.99880.99990.99940.99900.99970.99930.99890.99870.9997

0.99880.99790.99780.99880.99820.99930.9998

0.0005 0.99950.0004 0.99960.0023 0.9977

0.0021 0.99790.00150.00170.00490.00180.00080.00120.00260.0022

0.99850.99830.99510.99820.99920.99880.99740.9978

0.00860.00410.00390.00630.00590.00420.00730.00440.0114

0.99140.99590.99610.99370.99410.99580.99270.99560.9886

0.0090 0.9910

0.0043 0.9957

100.0099.9599.8399.8299.7699.6699.6399.5699.4599.32

99.2999.1798.9698.7498.6298.4598.3898.3698. 3198.27

98. 0497.8397.6997.5297.0496.8796.7996.6896.4396.21

95.3494,9394.1293.7393,3792.7892.2491.8591.1890.78


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

110of317






39.540.541.542.543 . 544.545. 5

46.547.548.5

49,550.551.552.553.554,555.556.5


146,215,956142,017,90318,721,81518,633,64117,868,73716,849,470

6202 2272,5492,177

5701, 4921, 429

3,584,8834,923,8354,923,8354,877,208


INTERVAL

816,20015,879,753

12,477745,04579,38142,643

46,6272,485

RETMTRATIO

0.00560.11180.00070.04000.00440.00250.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00950.0005

SURVRATIO

0.99440.88820.99930.96000.99560.99751.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000.99050.9995


89.7589.2579.2779.2276.0575.7175.5275.5275.5275.52

75.5275.5275.5275.5275.5275.5274.8074.77


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

111of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.5

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516. 517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523,524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5


495,959,273399,940,822397,447,055395,562,487351,830,181348,964,734301, 188, 994293,880,314320,914,258356,934,266

1, 535, 781, 9811,562,043,8501,565,377,1451,587,950,1271,607,607,7441,606,774,8541,603,200,7031,609,993,0241,628,271,6311,627,922,3311,654,644,4271,624,470,1361,695,771,8541,686,443,3741,640,031,2011,605,635,2301,611,269,4181,570,937,3351,853,214,987

339,870,061

296,174,202288,012,852264,815,813229,441,363228,491,377217,307,294203,326,006183,173,909190,909,779127,823,825


INTERVAL

1,357,305246,939

1,097,127960,663538,301

99,3641,773,488

880,828465,061

1,873,2602,613,8303,957,5262,000,4733,231,8631,222,802

370,439924,172764,897

3,966,513

3, 821, 5421, 583, 1192, 731, 8386,794,7682,212,3391,234,7011,492,2724,122,8753,128,5176,061,5301,324,9222,434,4841,177,335

998,3131,444,4241,230,947

724,459945,826849,958937,352

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00340.00060.00280.00270.00150.00030.00600.00270.0013

0.00120.00170.00250.00130.00200.00080.00020.00060.00050.0024

0.00230.00100.00160.00400.00130.00080.00090.00260.00170.0178

0.00450.00850.00440.00440.00630.00570.00360.00520.00450.0073

SURVRATIO

1.00000.99660.99940.99720.99730.99850.99970.99400.99730.9987

0.99880.99830.99750.99870.99800.99920.99980.99940.99950.9976

0.99770.99900.99840.99600.99870.99920.99910.99740.99830.9822

0,99550.99150.99560.99560.99370.99430.99640.99480.99550.9927


100.00100.0099.6699.6099.3299.0598.9098.8798.2798,00

97.8797.7597.5997.3497.2297.0296.9596.9396.8796.83

96.5996.3796.2796.1295.7395.6095.5395.4495.1995.03

93.3392.9292.1391.7291.3290.7590.2389.9189.4589.05


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

112of317






EXPOSURES ATBEG1NNING OFAGE INTERVAL


INTERVALRETMTRATIO

8URVRATIO


39. 5

40.541.542.543,544,545,546.547,548.5

49.550.551.552.553.554.555.5

142,822,54918,857,95218,645,88018, 613, 78216,928,666

185620

2,0422,114

570

631,4291, 429

3,583,4544,923,8354,923,835

816,200142,89712,477

745,04579,381

46,627

0.00570.00760.00070.04000.00470.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0095

0.99430.99240.99930.96000.99531.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000.9905

88.3987.8987.2287.1683.6883.2883.2883.2883.2883,28

83.2883.2883.2883.2883.2883.2882.49


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

113of317

ZH U

8 ol0

c4 ro

0rsr o+ cr o"szg or ro

550 UU

0

BNIAIABflS lN3083d

5Ã GannettFleming VII-50 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

114of317


ACCOUNT 322 REACTOR PLANT EQUIPMENT

ORIGINAL LlFE TABLE

PLACEMENT BAND 1959-2016 EXPERiENCE BAND 1971-2016




INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.5

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

2,537,180,3632,373,857,7782,226,544,8052, 190, 889, 8992,068,927,3821,986,330,2581,921,323,1851,827,799,0901,775,970,5731,747,923,0401,717,501,9701,704,374,9381, 611, 488, 9211,589,849,8641,596,038,3861,571,457,8931,410,497,7731,399,841,9151,361,710,6081,351,216,9791,303,512,0041,294,095,0561,265,285,8281,177,327,1861,167,260,6001,145,584,2501,109,249,1011,096,524,4911,198,421,6541,155,812,264

515, 854, 740518,345,098466,171,373282,705,837245,087,593239,170,588227,420,104215, 987, 976224,952,496216,793,560

426,762517,722

10,156,2194,017,9223,163,2467,870,2282,978,4914,957,8765,488,6209,682,893

9,192,80310,548,4113,177,1764,400,6377,573,0846,923,5112,125,8252,370,8625,563,313

12,281,532

6,699,5376,804,0177,946,2847,576,3162,032,129

10, 811, 8311,712,2823,652,8173,243,0477,643,283

796,6412,582,9734,181,5243,431,8793,438,3628,601,1414,607,4511,472,3953,754,3271,967,944

0.0002 0.99980.0002 0.99980.00460. 00180.00150.00400.00160.00270.00310.0055

0.99540.99820.99850.99600.99840.99730.99690.9945

0.0054 0.99460.00620.00200.00280.00470.00440.00150.00170.00410.0091

0.99380.99800.99720.99530.99560.99850.99830.99590,9909

0.00530.00630.00640.00170.00940.00150,00330.00270.0066

0.99470.99370.99360.99830.99060.99850.99670.99730.9934

0.0015 0.99850.00500.00900.0121

0.99500.99100.9879

0.01400.0360

0.98600.96400.97970.0203

0.00680.0167

0.99320.9833

0.0091 0.9909

0.0051 0.9949

100.0099.9899.9699.5199.3299.1798.7898.6398.3698.05

97.5196.9996.3996.2095.9395.4895.0694.9194.7594.36

93,5193.0392.5491.9691.3691.2190.3490.2189.9089.66

89.0788.9388.4987.6986.6385.4182.3480.6780.1278.79

Qgl GannettFleming VII-51 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 201 8

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

115of317






EXPOSURES ATBEGINN1NG OFAGE INTERVAL


INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


39. 540.541.542.543.544 5

45 5

46.547. 5

48.5

49.550.551.552.553.554,555.556.5

113,902,362107,298,04012,092,07811,355,59711,239,8399,958,579

4,667

58,52065,07865,07865,078

3,570,1081,386,079

375,92668, 611

726,925446,312

0.03130.01290.03110.00600.06470.04480.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.96870.98710.96890.99400.93530.95521.0000

78.0775.6274.6572.3371.8967.2464.2364.23


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

116of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0.00.51.52.53.54,55.56.57.58.5


941,569,567888,621,499771,847,184826,670,480716,999,205666,654,416659,497,069608,240,952613,274,436626,702,588


INTERVAL

426,762190,043

10,155,0813,845,0312,582,2287,076,2642,668,4141,307,1995,250,8307,384,613

RETMTRATIO

0.00050.00020.01320.00470.00360.01060.00400.00210.00860.0118

SURVRAT10

0.99950.99980.98680,99530.99640.98940.99600.99790.99140.9882


100.0099.9599.9398.6298.1697.8196.7796.3896.1795.35

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522,523.524.525.526.527.528.5

1,173,919,3591,167,012,0861,126,330,2081,278,568,4441,319,745,6871,303,974,5711,148,366,4651,146,044,0831,118,140,4991,113,970,6031, 181, 328, 4521,176,348,8031,247,050,2871,159,522,6351,149,787,9401,129,653,9231,109,155,9271,096,431,3171,198,328,4791,155,719,090

10,731,4688,329,7113,022,4232,174,2582,891,8386, 861, 3871,597,8382,029,9484,032,637

12,277,292

5,100,4656,421,9577,946,2847,298,9661,775,855

10,811,8311,712,2823,652,8173,243,0477,643,283

0.00710.00270.0017

0.99290.99730.9983

0.0022 0.99780.00530.00140.00180.0036

0.99470.99860.99820.9964

0. 0110 0. 9890

0.00430.00550.00640.00630.00150.00960.00150.0033

0.99570.99450.99360.99370.99850.99040.99850.9967

0.0027 0.99730.0066 0.9934

0.0091 0.9909 94.2293.3692.6992.4592.2992.0991.6091.4791.3190.98

89.9889.5989.1088.5487.9887.8487.0086.8786.5886.34

29. 5

30.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

515,854,740518,345,098466,171,373282,705,837245,087,593239,170,588227,420,104215,987,976224,952,496216,793,560

796, 6412,582,9734,181,5243,431,8793,438,3628,601,1414,607,4511,472,3953,754,3271,967,944

0.00150.00500.00900.01210.01400.03600.02030.00680.01670.0091

0.99850.99500.99100.98790.98600.96400.97970.99320.98330.9909

85.7785.6485.2184.4583.4282.2579.3077.6977.1675.87


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

117of317








INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


39. 5

40.541.542.543.544.545.546.547.548.5

49.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.5

113,902,362107,298,04012,092,07811,355,59711,239,8399,958,579

4,667

58,52065,07865,07865,078

3,570,1081,386,079

375,92668,611

726,925446,312

0. 03130.01290.03110.00600.06470.04480.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.96870.98710.96890.99400.93530.95521.0000

75.1872.8371.8969.6569.2364.7561.8561.85

QX GannettFleming VII-54 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

118of317

~~re5 gH

rnmrs +

g p H

M

re Ppao

g Hp p

Hp o

BNIAIRBflS J.N3383d


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

119of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE


AGE ATBEGIN OFiNTERVAL



INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.59.5

10.511.512.513 514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29. 5

30.53132.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

980,770,230939,633,511894,613,651867,153,546845,231,101714,806,225700,970,206603,586,750598,945,379569,220,670

560,365,966540,576,455518,091,643505, 834, 018492,249,695464,035,180438,007,278427,911,868421,155,495422,789,796418,790,180406,586,076372,467,474354,601,629319,490,420313,846,978308,822,764302,311,929320,233,302314,788,989

120,954,011117,016,340119,657,53297,512,51379,615,91372,045,95966,503,47865,633,10067,356,26064,986,589

103,33060,935

2,528,8241,244,192

387,261359,367

1 527 714161,219

5,621,14819,988,0977,350,448

682,6005,583,7904,004,4812,297,0771,686,0566,175,259

799,6878,851,704

306,969890,195

8,256,57033,460,4951,593,8494,762,2626,838,433

13,409,881651,881

11,044,845

1, 087, 313869, 017696,729

1,242,91556,932

174,536147,569804,431

1,109,3463, 182, 741

0.00000.00010.00010.00290.00150.00050.00050.00250.00030.0099

0.03570.01360.00130.01100. 00810.00500.00380.01440.00190.0209

0.00070.00220.02220.09440.00500.01520.02210.04440.00200.0351

0.00900.00740.00580.01270.00070.00240.00220.01230.01650.0490

1.00000.99990.99990.99710.99850.99950.99950.99750.99970.9901

0.96430,98640.99870.98900.99190.99500.99620.98560,99810.9791

0.99930.99780.97780.90560.99500.98480.97790.95560.99800.9649

0.99100.99260.99420,98730.99930.99760.99780.98770.98350.9510

100.00100.0099.9999.9899.6999.5499.4999.4499.1999.16

98.1894.6893.3993.2792. 2491. 4991.0490.6989.3889.21

87,3487.2887.0885.1577.1276.7375.5773.9070.6270.47

68.0067.3966.8966.5065.6565.6165.4565.3064.5063.44

~ GannettFlaming VII-56 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

120of317






39.540.541.542.543.544,545,546.547.548.5

49.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.5


40,064,47939,638,67511,780,33111,452,73111,429,793

9, 911, 488

146,163146,163146,163


INTERVAL

425,5912,571,954

114,63322,938

468,780

RETMTRATIO

0.01060.06490.00970.00200.04100.0000

0.00000.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

0.98940.93510.99030.99800.95901.0000


60.3359.6955.8255.2855.1652.9052.90


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

121of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.59.5

10,511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5


519,282,266477,594,718469,867,861451,533,377428,067,422299,535,909295,251,338202,602,549200,256,725189,422,258387,320,281373,462,027355,361,401363,791,782366,797,517348,049,278327,398,131318,611,258320,860,137325,109,407

359, 982, 169347,785,424355,264,944337,622,011302,510,803297,966,680308,822,764302,311,929320,233,302314, 788, 989

120,954,011117,016,340119,657,53297,512,51379,615,91372,045,95966,503,47865,633,10067,356,26064,986,589


INTERVAL

60,8582,527,0261,244,128

321,265294,045

1,432,82962,249

3,425,92419,603,9913,515,739

220,7213,306,4652,267,1942,001,4631,446,407

38,228246,088444,575

306,969890, 195

8,256,57033,460,4951,593,8494,762,2626,838,433

13,409,881651, 881

11, 044, 845

1,087,313869,017696,729

1,242,91556,932

174,536147,569804,431

1,109,3463, 182,741

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00000.00010.00560.00290.00110.00100.00710.00030. 0181

0.05060.00940.00060.00910.00620.00580.00440.00010.00080.0014

0.00090.00260.02320.09910.00530.01600.02210.04440.00200.0351

0.00900.00740.00580.01270.00070.00240.00220.01230.01650.0490

SURVRATIO

1.00001.00000.99990.99440.99710.99890.99900.99290.99970.9819

0.94940.99060.99940.99090.99380.99420.99560.99990.99920.9986

0.99910.99740.97680.90090.99470.98400.97790.95560.99800.9649

0.99100.99260.99420.98730.99930.99760.99780.98770.98350.9510


100.00100.00100.0099.9999,4399.1499.0398.9398.2398.20

96. 4391.5590.6890,6389,8089.2588.7488.3488.3388.27

88.1588.0787.8485.8077.3076.8975.6673.9970.7170.56

68.0967.4766.9766.5865.7365.6965.5365.3864.5863.52


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

122of317




PLACEMENT BAND 1960 — 2016 EXPERIENCE BAND 1997 — 2016




INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


39. 5

40.541.542.543,544.545.546.547.548.5

49.550.551,552.553.554,555.556.5

40,064,47939,638,67511,780,33111,452,73111,429,7939,911,488

146,163146,163146,163

425,5912,571,954

114,63322,938

468,780

0.01060,06490.00970.00200.04100.0000

0.00000.00000.0000

0.98940.93510.99030.99800.95901.0000

60.4159.7755.8955.3455.2352.9752.97

g GannettF!eming VII-59 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

123of317

g rn

H g

ro cr ™

M H

cs rurru o ore ro oz rc +

U

il

o&~zUJ(5

o

DNmmbrns &Nsoaad


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

124of317



ORIGINAL LlFE TABLE



0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.5

EXPOSURES ATSEGINNlNG OFAGE INTERVAL

1,350,144,6441,050,715,266

963,050,167881, 085, 135819,864,551785,500,250778,202,933705,224,268694,562,123687,653,141

RET1REMENTSDURING AGE

INTERVAL

721,007169,213254,086488,209

2,077,0301,169,7242,074,9703,782,3432,599,294

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00070.00020.00030.00060.00260.00150.00290.00540.0038

SURVRATIO

1.00000.99930.99980.99970.99940.99740.99850.99710.99460.9962


100.00100.00

99.9399.9199.8999.8399.5699.4199.1298.58

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521. 522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29. 530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

682,687,402680,727,556672,941,899671,288,948670,664,278668,612,149665,935,830663,460,756659,975,080656,752,359

654,051,940653,782,345643,676,606606,675,342604,853,257598,464,137578,772,057566,364,724678,522,566650,573,363

109,536,71894,180,62593,295,53085,704,26785,482,60684, 381, 68182,389,16380,428,47984,149,02280,281,751

466,4371,434,685

29,439223,445462,764338,485400,407

2,879,6402,923,3701,188,6794,711,0664,438,484

173,441871,876741,547

11,377,58516,168,9867,741,9681,105,0648,272,352

40,08160,060

247,166380,954

1,129,566982,012157,572

1,032,0413,413,6675,409,899

0.00070.00210.00000.0003

0.99930.99791.00000.9997

0.0007 0.99930.00050.00060.00430.0044

0.99950.99940.99570.9956

0.0018 0.9982

0,0072 0.99280.0068 0.99320.0003 0.99970.00140.00120.01900.0279

0.99860.99880.98100.9721

0.00060.0026

0.99940.99740.99560.98680.98840.99810.98720.9594

0.00440.01320.01160.00190.01280.04060.0674 0.9326

0.0137 0.98630. 0016 0. 99840. 0127 0. 9873

0.0004 0.9996

98.2198.1497.9397.9397.9097.8397.7897.7297.3096.87

96.6995,9995.3495.3295.1895.0693.2690.6589.4189.27

88.1388.1088.0487. 8187.4286.2685.2685.1084.0080.60


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

125of317






39.540.541.542.543,544.545.546.547.548.5

49.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.5


54,416,48353,750,2488,077,8406,971,7766,971,7766,707,304

1,1271 1271 127

213213

50,66050,44750,447


INTERVAL

534,277600,892920,041

264,472389,529

RETMTRATIO

0.00980.01120.11390.00000.03790.05810.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

0.99020.98880.88611.00000.96210.94191.00001.00001.0000

PCT SURVBEGlN OFINTERVAL

75. 1774, 4373.6065.2165.2162.7459.1059.1059.1059.10


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

126of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE





INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0.00.51.52.53.54,55.56.57.58.59.5

10.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.53132.533.534.535.536.537.538,5

1,223,143,342942,585,946855,959,829781,303,640720,144,177685,882,722680,371,922609,666,611608,343,931603,695,899

631, 509, 933630,047,557664,356,662662,896,277662,274,929660,651,468665,916,977663,441,902659,956,227656,733,506

654,033,087653,763,492643,657,753606,656,489604,834,403598,445,284578,753,204566,345,871678,522,566650,573,363

109,536,71894,180,62593,295,53085,704,26785,482,60684, 381, 68182,389,16380,428,47984,149,02280,281,751

721,007154,476254,086488,209

2,077,0301,169,7242,074,9703,782,3432,591,294

466,4371,434,685

29,439223,445462,764338,485400,407

2,879,6402,923,3701,188,6794,711,0664,438,484

173,441871,876741,547

11,377,58516,168,9867,741,9681,105,0648,272,352

40,08160,060

247,166380,954

1,129,566982,012157,572

1,032,0413,413,6675,409,899

0.00000.00080.00020.00030.00070.00300.00170.00340.00620.0043

0.00070.00230.00000.00030.00070.00050.00060.00430.00440.0018

0.00720.00680.00030.00140.00120.01900.02790.01370.00160.0127

0.00040.00060.00260.00440.01320.01160.00190.01280.04060.0674

1.00000.99920.99980.99970.99930.99700.99830.99660.99380.9957

0.99930.99771,00000.99970.99930.99950.99940.99570.99560.9982

0.99280.99320.99970.99860.99880.98100.97210.98630.99840.9873

0.99960.99940.99740.99560.98680.98840.99810.98720.95940.9326

100.00100.0099.9299.9199.8799.8199.5099.3398.9998.38

97.9697.8897.6697.6697.6297.5697.5197.4597.0296.59

96.4295.7295.0795.0594.9194.8092.9990.4089.1689.02

87,8887.8587,7987.5687.1786.0285.0284.8683.7780.37


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

127of317






EXPOSURES ATBEGINNlNG OFAGE INTERVAL


INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRAT IO


39. 540.541.542.543,544.545.546.547.548.5

49.550.551.552.553.554,555.556.5

54,416,48353,750,2488,077,8406,971,7766,971,7766,707,304

1 1271,1271,127

213213

50,66050,44750,447

534,277600,892920,041

264,472389,529

0.00980.01120.11390.00000.03790.05810.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.99020.98880.88611.00000.96210.94191.00001.00001.0000

74.9574.2273.3965.0365.0362.5658.9358.9358.9358.93


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

128of317

CICI

H5

g ru orq fy, H

Ho5ru CI rc

Mo0 0re 0

In HN O

H

o5YI,'&

~zlurg

CI

OCI

BNIRIRBAS INdD83d

tcN

CtCI

CI


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

129of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0.00.51.52.53.54,55.56.57.58.59,5

10,511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29. 5

30.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5


617,557,642528,091,821472,155,620463,303,041433,709,780364,388,658336,176,882325,737,843315,742,552294,288,835

279,589,970266,764,334254,049,219250, 818, 635243,718,042237,849,070232,660,240221,923,224219,535,827215,769,315

210,495,885201,945,819187,948,621170,849,486167,952,911163,397,057157,029,072150,122,915163,923,153147,971,302

51,587,11637,374,79821,733,84712,381,59811,078,66910,362,525

9, 168, 1108,656,3308,846,4838,434,636


INTERVAL

239,321715,521711,133

1,425,6902,120,0033,389,199',906,974

1,322,136965,083

2, 860, 74410,677,901

984,0572,202,4024,721,1942,023,414

645,917526,754

1,816,276584,694

3,057,7823,466, 1841,202,1821,186,9711,743,7862,759,1902,758,312

718,455593,396575,415

165,4618,825

260,97183,49311,16671,43692,33220,27729,00420,352

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00050.00150.00150.00330.00580.01010.01200.00420.0033

0.01020.04000.00390.00880.01940.00850.00280.00240.00830.0027

0.01450.01720.00640.00690.01040.01690.0176O.OO480.00360.0039

0.00320.00020.01200.00670.00100.00690.01010.00230.00330.0024

SURVRATIO

1.00000.99950.99850.99850.99670.99420,98990.98800.99580.9967

0.98980.96000.99610.99120.98060.99150.99720.99760.99170.9973

0.98550.98280.99360.99310.98960. 98310.98240.99520.99640.9961

0.99680.99980.98800.99330.99900.99310.98990.99770.99670.9976


100.00100.0099.9599.8099.6599.3298.7497.7596.5896.17

95.8694.8891.0890.7389.9388.1987.4487.1986.9986.27

86.0384.7883.3382.8082.2281.3779.9978.5978.2177.93

77.6377.3877.3676.4375.9175.8475.3174.5674.3874.14


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

130of317



ORIGINAL I IFE TABLE, CONT.



39.540.541,542.543.544.545,546.547.548.549. 550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59. 5

60.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5


5,328,4195,147,5911, 941, 8231,875,9971,875,9321,777,179

979797

111

111111111111

78,05478,05478,054

621414

14141414141414141414

14141414141414141414


INTERVAL

46,153458,602

661,403

25,552

49

48

RETMTRATIO

0.00870.08910.00000.00000.00070.01440.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.44270.00000.00000.00000.77760,00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

0.99130.91091.00001.00000.99930.98561.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00000.55731.00001.00001.00000.22241.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000


73.9673.3266.7966.7966.7866.7365.7765.7765.7765.77

65.7765.7765.7765.7736,6636.6636.6636.668.158.15

8.158.158.158.158.158.158.158.158.158.15

8.158.158.158.158.158.158.158.158.158.15


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

131of317



ORlGINAL LlFE TABLE, CONT.



79.580.581.5


1414


INTERVAL

14

RETMTRAT10

0.00001.0000

SURVRATIO

1.0000


8.158.15


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

132of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0.00.51. 5

2.53.54.55.56.57.58.59.5

10.511.512.513. 5

14.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5


335,517,043297,318,261248,933,248255,251,711230,197,021167,002,635145,642,387145,335,928144, 196, 801141, 846, 447

221,680,544222,774,215223,218,484232,519,432228,070,869224,276,654220,997,359211, 583, 007209,897,702206,895,177

205,537,807197,143,776185,985,298168,935,829166, 058, 312161,602,123157,025,625150,119,590163,920,676147, 968, 841

51,586,87637,374,55821,733,60612,381,35711, 078,42810,362,2849,167,8698,656,0898,846,2438,434,396


INTERVAL

113, 528432,978437,604

1,038,6351,655,9642,860,4562,840,1331,053,868

878,191

2,844,83810,605,020

897,2032,190,8094,686,9142,008,083

535,728465,405

1,490,083584,541

3,056,6203,449,6131,201,1761,168,6501,743,7862,759,1652,758,190

717,369593,396575,415

165,4618,825

260,97183,49311,16671,43692,33220,27729,00420,274

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00040.00170.00170.00450.00990.01960.01950.00730.0062

0.01280.04760.00400,00940.02060.00900.00240.00220.00710.0028

0.01490.01750.00650.00690.01050.01710.01760.00480.00360.0039

0.00320.00020.01200.00670.00100.00690.01010.00230.00330.0024

SURVRATIO

1.00000.99960.99830.99830.99550.99010.98040.98050.99270.9938

0.98720.95240.99600.99060,97940.99100.99760.99780.99290.9972

0.98510.98250.99350.99310.98950.98290.98240.99520.99640.9961

0.99680.99980.98800.99330.99900.99310.98990.99770.99670.9976


100.00100.0099.9699.7999.6299.1798.1896.2694.3793.68

93.1091.9187.5387.1886.3684.5983.8383.6383.4482.85

82.6281.3979.9679.4578.9078.0776.7475.3975.0374.76

74.4774.2374.2173.3272.8272.7572.2571.5271.3571.12


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

133of317








INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


39.540.541,542.543,544.545.546.547.548.5

49.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5

5,328,2575,147,4281,941,6601, 875, 8351,875,8351,777,082

494949

49979797

78,04078,04078,040

48

14141414

46,153458,602

1,40325,552

49

48

0.00870.08910.00000.00000.00070.0144

0.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.50530.00000.00000.00001.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.99130.91091.00001.00000.99930.9856

70,9570.3364.0764.0764.0764.0263.10

5Ã GannettFleming VII-70 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

134of317



ORIGINAL LlFE TABLE, CONT.



79.580.581.5


14


INTERVAL

14

RETMTRATIO

0.00001.0000

PCT SURVSURV BEGIN OF

RATIO INTERVAL


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

135of317

CICO

CIIO

Or

C!

550 c!

5K 0H

5

5re x"50

8re v zg D M

0cJ 0rY,

o o)K

ZUJ

o rgQ '4

CIN

OO

BNIAIABIIS J.NBOblgd

C!N O OCI


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

136of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE





1NTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0.00.51.52.53.54,55.56.57.58.5

12,242,18412,146,16711,950,45211,967,28411,495,43211,305,84011,300,49411,247,13311,555,86810,979,097

6,707

742, 813

12466227

0.00060.00000.00000.00020.00000.0000

0.99941.00001.00000.99981.00001.0000

0.0000 1.00000.0000 1.0000

0.0000 1.00000.0000 1.0000

100.00100.00100.0099.9499.9499.9499.9299.9299.9199.91

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

10,978,87110,963,73510,812,70110,812,63110,454,99210,456,50210,124,2269,940,0648,523,5767,800,267

8, 129498

70233,506

844

3731,861

7890

0.00070.00000.00000.02160.00010.00000.00000.00020.00010.0000

0.99931.00001.00000.97840.99991.00001.00000.99980.99991.0000

99.9199.8499.8399.8397.6897.6797.6797.6797.6597.64

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

6,986,1435,096,8055,068,9204,664,3264,656,1694,582,2914,563,4004,407,1234,389,5334,388,901

4,6220

3,2102,286

14216,8552,396

17,590632

24,986

0.99931.0000

0.00070.00000.0006 0.9994

0.99951.0000

0.00050.00000.0037 0.9963

0.99950.99600.9999

0.00050.00400.00010.0057 0.9943

97.6497.5797.5797,5197.4697.4697.1097,0596.6696.65

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

4,249,6864,199,8452,867,8722, 863, 9672,622,5842,600,0192,587,9942,530,0132,484,8692,340,828

2

30,4062,054

44,5908,8409,218

34,7419,409

61,9573,730

0.00000.00720.00070.01560.00340.00350,01340.00370.02490.0016

1.00000.99280.99930.98440.99660.99650.98660.99630.97510.9984

96.1096.1095.4095.3493.8593.5493.2091.9591,6189.33


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

137of317






39. 540.541.542.543.544,545.546.547.548.5

49.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59. 5

60.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5


2,199,7912,194,9142,177,0422,112,1052,088,4192,058,6702,057,6482,046,0032,044,6082,041,442

2,028,5322,020,9542,017,2142,011,6642,005,3622,004,5242,003,3301,847,3501,810,7341,796,510

1,793,2061,788,1891,782,2421, 781, 3421,678,8421,669,7051,666,9561,655,6951,655,6951,649,594

1,645,9051,642,6351,642,6351,642,5411,642,3191,612,3361,612,1211,612,1211,612,1211,612,121


INTERVAL

4,7228,2385,265

1,798

5471, 230

0

12,552

6,5371,3195,5506,137

0

4624, 391

35,8896,3871,726

3,4283,178

90094,6798,638

3,2803,689

2, 000

24,245215

RETMTRATIO

0.00210.00380.00240.00000.00090.00000.00030.00060.00000.0061

0.00320.00070.00280.00310.00000.00020.00220.01940.00350.0010

0.00190.00180.00050.05320.00510.00000.00000.00000.00200.0022

0.00120.00000.00010.00000.01480.00010.0000Q.QQQQ0.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

0.99790.99620.99761.00000.99911.00000.99970.99941.00000.9939

0.99680.99930.99720.99691.00000.99980.99780.98060.99650.9990

0.99810.99820,99950.94680.99491.00001.00001.00000.99800.9978

0.99881.00000.99991.00000.98520.99991.00001.00001.00001.0000


89. 1888.9988.6688.4488.4488.3788.3788.3488.2988.29

87.7587.4787.4187.1786.9086.9086.8886.6985.0184.71

84.6384.4684.3184.2779.7979.3879,3879.3879.3879.23

79.0578.9578.9578.9578.9577.7877.7777.7777.7777.77


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

138of317



ORIGlNAL LIFE TABLE, CONT.



79.580.581.582.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89.590.591.592.593.594.595.596.597.598.5

99.5100,5101.5102.5103.5104.5105.5


1,612,1211,595,6621,587,9351,587,6621,587,6621,587,6621,587,662

967,144967,130295,917

295,917295,917295,176277,136277,136277,136276,282276,282276,282276,135

252,136252,136251,783251,783250,387

6,298


INTERVAL

16,4597 727

272

480

74118,040

147

RETMTRAT10

0.01020.00480.00020.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00050.0000

0.00000.00250.06110.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00050.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

0. 98980.99520.99981.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000.99951.0000

1.00000.99750.93891.00001.00001.00001.00001,00000.99951.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000


77.7776.9876.6076.5976.5976.5976.5976.5976.5976.55

76.5576.5576.3671.6971.6971.6971.6971.6971.6971.66

71.6671.6671.6671.6671.6671.6671.66


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

139of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE





INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0.00.51. 52.53.54.55.56.57.58.59.5

10.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

9,815,3069,705,5759,519,7939,606,9059,151,4968,989,9288,986,2438,932,9669,242,5878,669,3308,669,4628,656,2638,511,0338, 518, 0148,160,5398,168,9987,839,1177,810,4296,450,7275,736,045

4,923,4993,037,0403,011,9242,611,1912,610,8562,537,5532,521,8582,379,2172,369,7092,372,276

2,260,1182,211,548

909,242905,845705,327700,518700,493675,683639,623504,057

6,707

2,180

8, 129

70233,506

1,861

3,3320

3,2102,286

14216,408

7609,509

2541,105

2738

1, 6547,051

0

1191,664

32554,459

0

0.00000.00000.00070.00000.00000.00020.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00090.00000.00000.02740.00000.00000.00000.00020.00000.0000

0.00070.00000.00110.00090.00010.00650.00030.00400.00010.0005

0.00000.00030.00180.00780.00000.00020.00240.00050.08510.0000

1.00001.00000.99931.00001.00000.99981.00001.00001.00001.0000

0.99911. 00001.00000.97261.00001.00001.00000.99981.00001.0000

0.99931.00000.99890.99910.99990.99350.99970.99600.99990.9995

1.00000.99970.99820.99221.00000.99980.99760.99950.91491.0000

100.00100.00100.0099.9399.9399.9399.9199.9199.9199.91

99.9199.8199.8199.8197.0797.0797.0797.0797.0597.05

97.0596.9996.9996.8896.8096.7996.1796.1495.7595.74

95.7095.7095.6795.4994.7594.7594.7394.5194.4686.42


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

140of317






39. 540.541.542.543.544 . 545, 5

46. 5

47.548.549. 550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558,5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5


366,750366,594355,979291,042267,356237,607236,585992,512991,131

1,667,0331,654,1241,648,9741,646,4751,646,0991,643,0331,642,1951,642,3171,490,7281,490,0011,482, 164

1,504,4761,500,5561,494,9621,495,1091,394,0051,655,6511,666,9561,655,6951,655,6951,649,5941,645,9051, 642, 6351,642,6351,642,5411,642,3191,612,3361,612,1211,612,1211,612,1211,612,121


INTERVAL

0982

5,265

1,798

2831,230

0

12,552

4,10977

3762,901

0

109

2,3313,178

94,6798,638

3,2803,689

2, 000

94

24,245215

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00270.01480.00000.00670.00000.00120.00120.00000.0075

0.00250.00000.00020.00180.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0001

0.00150.00210.00000.06330.00620.00000.00000.00000.00200.0022

0. 00120.00000.00010.00000.01480.00010.00000.00000.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

1.00000.99730.98521.00000.99331.00000.99880.99881.00000.9925

0.99751.00000.99980.99821.00001.00001.00001.00001. 00000.9999

0.99850.99791.00000.93670.99381.00001.00001.00000.99800.9978

0.99881.00000.99991. 00000.98520.99991.00001.00001.00001.0000


86.4286.4286.1984.9184.9184.3484.3484.2484.1484.14

83.5083.3083.2983.2783.1383.1383.1383.1383. 1383. 13

83. 1282. 9982.8282.8277.5777.0977.0977.0977,0976.94

76.7776.6776.6776.6776.6775.5475.5375.5375.5375.53

lg GannettFleming VII-77 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2018

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

141of317






79.580.581.582.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89.590.591.592.593.594.595.596.597.598.5

99.5100.5101.5102.5103.5104.5105.5


1,612,1211,595,6621,587,9351,587,6621,587,6621,587,6621,587,662

967,144967,130295,917

295,917295,917295,176277,136277,136277,136276,282276,282276,282276,135

252,136252,136251,783251,783250,387

6,298


INTERVAL

16,4597,727

272

480

74118,040

147

RETMTRATIO

0.01020.00480.00020.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00050.0000

0.00000.00250.06110.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00050.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

0.98980.99520.99981.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000.99951.0000

1.00000.99750.93891.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000.99951.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000


75.5374.7674.3974.3874,3874.3874.3874.3874.3874. 34

74.3474.3474.1669.6369.6369.6369.6369.6369.6369.59

69.5969.5969.5969.5969.5969.5969.59


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

142of317

CID

ra g

HU

rs A

MV XH

Hro o ocY,'ICm

rc

zIuIgID C

CICl

BNIRIRBIIS LN3083d


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

143of317


ACCOUNT 332 RESERVOIRS, DAMS AND WATERWAYS

ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.5

9.510.511.512.513.514.515,516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5


55,228,02753,913,66253,409,28453,260,95751,806,45751,807,88250,957,32250,137,95347,027,58546,860,214

46,697,75746,674,71746,572,19146,571,97546,571,93739,212,73331,571,69731,526,26030,956,50330,357,52228,363,13328, 014, 25725,721,31725,479,50023,965,96723,611,79823,561,48422,316,85622,292,94722,285,75722,149,59121,940,65618,704,25018,699,79918,228,27217,959,85817,959,85817,958,85817,958,85817,931,466


INTERVAL

2,253

6,8883,584

162,457

23,040

216

317

24110

15,910

50,3145,5747,851

123,442

162,922

4,245

1,000

18,3431,905

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00010.00010.0035

0.00050.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00060.00000,00210.00020.00040.00000.0055

0.00000.00740.00000.00020.00000.00000.00010.00000.00100.0001

SURVRATIO

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000.99990.99990.9965

0.99951.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00000.99941.00000.99790.99980.99961.00000.9945

1.00000.99261.00000.99981.00001.00000.99991.00000.99900.9999


100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.0099.9899.97

99.6399.5899.5899.5899.5899.5899.5899.5899.5899.58

99.5899.5899.5899.5899.5199.5199.3099.2899.2499.24

98.6998.6997.9697.9697.9497.9497.9497.9397.9397.83

gl GannettFleming 'jr'I I-80 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

144of317


ACCOUNT 332 RESERVOIRS, DANS AND NATERNAYS




39.540.541.542.543, 544 . 545.546.547.548.5

49.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.559.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5


17,618,94717,616,27017, 615, 68517,615,68517,413,34317,413,34317,413,34317,332,32217,331,51617,331,066

17,331,06617,331,06617,328,92717,326,68616,517,57216,517,57216,515,86016,340,92516,338,60516,338,60516,338,60516,338,60516,338,60516,338,60516,293,48616,293,48616,267,64216,267,64216,267,64216,138,497

16,138,49716,138,49716,137,22116, 135, 86716,135,86716,070,27416,069,23816,042,08016,035,13316,014,870


INTERVAL

2,677

202,342

41,928806

2,241809, 115

45,119

25,844

129,145

1, 2751,014

64,021

27,1586,948

20,2631,887

RETMTRATIO

0.00020.00000.00000.01150.00000.00000.00240.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00010.04670.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00280.00000.00160.00000.00000.00790.0000

0.00000.00010.00010.00000.00400.00000.00170.00040.00130.0001

SURVRATIO

0.99981.00001.00000.98851.00001.00000.99761.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00000.99990.95331.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00000.99721.00000.99841.00001.00000.99211.0000

1.00000.99990.99991.00000.99601.00000.99830.99960.99870.9999


97.8297.8197.8197.8196.6996.6996.6996.4596.4596.45

96.4596.4596.4596.4491.9391.9391.9391.9391.9391.93

91. 9391. 9391. 9391. 9391.6891.6891.5391.5391.5390.81

90.8190.8190.8090.7990.7990.4390.4390.2890.2490.13


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

145of317


ACCOUNT 332 RESERVOIRS, DANS AND WATERWAYS




79.580.581.582.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89. 5

90.591.592.593.594.595.596.597.598.5

99.5100.5101.5102.5103.5104.5105.5


16,012,98315,986,52514,710,21814,710,21814,676,37814,625,82014,619,4605,464,7785,460,1531,977,1781, 977, 1781,977,1781,977,1771,966,3611,957,1111,957,1111,957,1111,957,1111,957,1111,957,111

1, 943, 6611,943,6611,943,4511,943,4511,942,637

45,055


INTERVAL

26,4581,276,307

33,840

6,360130,292

4,6253,747

1340

RETNTRATIO

0.00170.07980.00000.00230.00000.00040.00890.00080.00070.0000

0.00000.00000.00020.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

0.99830.92021.00000.99771.00000.99960.99110.99920.99931.0000

1.00001.00000.99981.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001,00001.00001.00001.0000


90.1289.9782.7882.7882.5982.5982.5681. 8281.7581.70

81.7081. 7081.7081.6881.6881.6881.6881.6881.6881.68

81. 6881.6881.6881.6881.6881.6881.68


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

146of317

CtN

CtCt

g rrt

ra Ic

ct

M to ctIx1 rcg g H5 HoIg

E

ru ut 0z ro s:

M

ggH

H

ct

5

tc

o&itt

lur0

Ct

CICt

Ctt

BNIRIRbIAS LN30bI3d


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

147of317


ACCOUNT 333 WATERWHEELS, TURBINES AND GENERATORS

ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0.00.51 52. 5

3.54 55.56.57,58.59.5

10.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518,5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29. 530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5


33,514,66433,463,82433,755,89133,334,37328, 181, 19222, 764, 66718,425,14717,848,06318,880,22418,878,40918,878,40918, 827,41118, 816, 91618,816,91618,816,91618,509,23718,509,23718,367,96218,348,17018, 338, 192

17,993,13417,975,03317,974,47217,567,72216,602,27914,506,52214,174,12113, 568, 33113,322,91613,211,046

11,946,57811,626,6495,739,2134,929,6454, 154, 4894,140,6054,024,4963,980,1743,854,6043,716,419


INTERVAL

6, 919

296, 20387,285

650,642

1,815

32611, 9661,081

16,664561

1, 04232,098

293,08474,5901,051

111,86469,957

7796,574

13,558775,156

15737 2732,626

109,611138, 185

438

RETMTRATIO

0.00020.00000.00880.00260.00000.00000.03530.00000.00010.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00070.00010.0000

0.00090.00000.00000.00010.00190.02020.00530.00010.00840.0053

0. 00010.00060.00240.15720.00000.00900.00070.02750.03580.0001

SURVRATIO

0.99981.00000.99120.99741.00001.00000.96471.00000.99991.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000.99930.99991.0000

0.99911.00001.00000.99990.99810.97980.99470.99990.99160.9947

0.99990.99940.99760.84281.00000.99100.99930.97250.96420.9999


100.0099.9899.9899.1098.8498.8498.8495.3595.3595.34

95.3495.3495.3495.3495.3495.3495.3495.3495.2895.27

95.2795.1995.1895.1895.1894.9993.0792.5892.5891.80

91.3191.3191.2691.0476.7276.7276.0375.9873.8971.24

Qgl GannettFleming VII-84 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

148of317


ACCOUNT 333 NATERNHEELS, TURBINES AND GENERATORS




39.540.541.542.543.544.545.546.547.548.5

49. 5

50.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5


3,715,7923,715,7923,715,7923,714,9183, 714, 9183,714,9183, 714, 9183,704,3943, 698, 1283,698,0423,682,7153,680,9553,680,9283,667,4383,655,0393,619,4983,619,4982,694,2432,694,2432,694,007

2,694,0072,121,2872,121,2872, 121,2872, 121, 2872,089,2962,088,6122,084,2192,084,2192,083,079

2,034,7372,034,5621,937,8791,934,0881, 934, 0881,934,0881,934,0881,890,4901,890,4901,890,490


INTERVAL

6431, 456

872, 603

1,760

1, 24512,39914,827

4,462

236

572, 720

31,991684

1,14048,341

17596,6833,792

43,598

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00020.00040.00000.0007

0.00050.00000.00030.00340.00410.00000.00120.00000.00010.0000

0.21260.00000.00000.00000.01510.00030.00000.00000.00050.0232

0.00010.04750.00200.00000.00000.00000.02250.00000.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000.99980.99961.00000.9993

0.99951.00000.99970.99660.99591.00000.99881.00000.99991.0000

0.78741.00001.00001.00000.98490.99971.00001.00000.99950.9768

0.99990.95250.99801.00001.00001.00000.97751.00001.00001.0000


71.2371.2371. 2371.2371.2371.2371.2371.2271.1971.19

71. 1471.1171.1171.0870.8470.5570.5570.4770.4770.46

70.4655.4855.4855.4855.4854 6454.6354.6354.6354.60

53.3353.3350.7950.6950.6950.6950.6949.5549.5549.55


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

149of317


ACCOUNT 333 WATERWHEELS, TURBINES AND GENERATORS





RETiREMENTSDURING AGE

INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


79.580.581.582.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89.590.591.592.593,594,595.596.597.598.5

99.5100.5101.5102,5103.5104.5105.5106.5

1,890,4901,769,4361,767,5851,763,8871,583,0671,569,9671,190,2091,001,8191,001,819

568,146

532,298532,105532,105532,105499,346491,109491,109491,109491,109478,793

478,793478,793367,421364,339277,707277,707277,707

121,0541,8513,698

180,82013,100

374,68210,882

911958

193

111,3723,082

86,632

0.06400.00100.00210.10250.00830.23870.00910.00000.00090.0017

0.00040.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.23260.00840.23780.00000.00000.0000

0.93600.99900.99790.89750.99170.76130.99091.00000.99910.9983

0.99961.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00000.76740.99160.76221.00001.00001.0000

49, 5546. 3846. 3346. 2341.4941.1531. 3331. 0431. 0431. 01

30.9630.9530.9530.9530.9530.9530.9530.9530.9530.95

30.9530.9523.7523.5517.9517.9517.9517.95


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

150of317

CICt

g mK Io

H g

rtt ct +rrt I-Iro rcg p H0 cto ro g

U tu r't

N rtt Ortt rtr

«c

C &"IO ~

UJ5«r

CtCt

BNIRIRbIrIS 1.N30b13d


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

151of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE





INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0.00.51.52.53.54,55.56.57.58.5

9. 5

10. 5

11.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

25,650,0827,617,7277,750,2157,513,6157,579,5827,221,6165,926,9225,651,9596,344,0536,333,3626,342,7876,334,9616,334,9616,104,4145, 332, 8145,332,8145,272,5145,232,1505,192,7915,185,7235,163,6425,114,3014,688,5644,518,2854,512,3543,810,2523,775,6443,601,8763,503,0593,162,2553,019,5322,991,1421,176,069

778,119690,089671,640651,743649,365639,097639,097

10,69039

149, 219

2, 17910,50730,5117,068

21, 873

43,41862,0607,3022,0529,640

21,203141,13198,53222,37629,940

50212,306

138,19554 3559,827

1,775

7,831

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00170.0000

0.00000.00000.02360.00000.00000.00040.00200.00580.00140.0042

0.00840.01210.00160.00050.00210.00560.03740.02740.00640.0095

0.00020.00410.11750.06990.01420.00000.00000.00270.00000.0123

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000.99831.0000

1.00001.00000.97641.00001.00000.99960.99800.99420.99860.9958

0.99160.98790.99840.99950.99790.99440.96260.97260.99360.9905

0.99980.99590.88250.93010.98581.00001.00000.99731.00000.9877

100.00100.00100. 00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00

99.83

99.8399.8399.8397.4897.4897.4897.4497.2596.6896.55

96.1495.3394.1794.0393.9893.7893.2689.7887.3286.76

85. 9485. 9385.5775.5270.2469.2469.2469.2469.0569.05

GannettFleming 'rj'II-88 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

152of317






39.540.541.542.543.544,545.546.547.548.5

49. 5

50.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5

EXPOSURES ATBEGINNING OFAGE iNTERVAL

631,266631, 048631,004579,562576,115544,356544,356537,040533,544522,784

522,193519,407513,816503,472503,472503,472493, 181440,314439,566437,489

437,489437,489437,489436,787436,787436,689432,965432,879432,879430,985

430,985425,385425,385424,625421,981374,302373,601351,077351,077349,339


INTERVAL

217

3, 44716,096

6,8163,496

10,760238

5, 59156

156

2,077

702

981, 903

86

1,894

4,795

2,42247,679

70122,524

RETMTRATIO

0.00030.00000.00000.00590.02790.00000.01250.00650.02020.0005

0.00000.01080.00010.00000.00000.00030.00000.00000.00470.0000

0.00000.00000.00160.00000.00020.00440.00020.00000.00440.0000

0.01110.00000.00000.00570.11300.00190.06030.00000.00000.0000

S URVRATIO

0.99971.00001.00000.99410.97211.00000.98750.99350.97980.9995

1.00000.98920.99991.00001.00000.99971.00001.00000.99531.0000

1.00001.00000.99841.00000.99980.99560.99981.00000.99561.0000

0.98891.00001.00000.99430.88700.99810.93971.00001.00001.0000


68.2168. 1868,1868.1867.7865.8865.8865.0664.6463.33

63.3063.3062.6262.6262.6262.6262.6062.6062.6062.30

62.3062.3062.3062.2062.2062.1961.9261.9061.9061.63

61.6360.9560.9560.9560.6053.7553.6550.4250.4250.42


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

153of317








1NTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


79.580.581.582.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89.590.59192.593.594.595.596.597.598.5

99.5100.5101.5102.5103.5104.5

346,640346,640311,873311, 873306,054302,782299,511137,602136,64222,607

22,60722,60721,96320,70820,70820,70819,69419,69419,69419,694

19,21019,21019,21019,00116,729

34,767

5,8193,2713 271

1,254

0.00000.10030.00000.01870.01070. 01080.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.05710.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

1.00000.89971.00000.98130.98930.98921.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00000.94291.00001. 00001.00001,00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

50.4250.4245.3645.3644.5144.0443.5643.5643.5643.56

43.5643.5643.5641.0741.0741.0741.0741.0741.0741.07

41,0741.0741.0741.0741.0741.07


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

154of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0.00.51.52.53.54,55.56.57.58.5

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5


24,477,4996,449,1046,585,3486,455,0646,523,4206,196,7784,903,4074,633,0305,325,1245,318, 871

5,333,3275,454,0525,454,9465,269,2194,498,1424,498,1424,454,1514,494,0694,711,2004,705,6444,684,9184,639,0734,213,3374,043,0574,037,1263,335,0253,321,5293, 150, 8363,052,1182,711,314

RETiREMENTSDURING AGE

INTERVAL

7,01539

148,253

2,17910,50730,5115,556

20,518

43,41862,0607,3022,0529,6401,911

138,05698,53222,37629,940

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

0.00000.00000.00130.0000

0.00000.00000.02720.00000.0000

1,00001.00000.99871.0000

1.00001.00000.97281.00001.0000

0.0005 0.99950.0024O.OO680.00120.0044

0.99760.99320.99880.9956

0.0093 0.99070.01340.00170.00050.00240.00060.04160.03130.00730.0110

0.98660.99830.99950.99760.99940.95840.96870.99270.9890

0.0000 1.0000


100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.0099.87

99.8799.8799.8797.1597.1597.1597.1196.8896.2296.11

95.6994.8093.5393.3793,3293.1093.0589.1886.3985.76

29. 5

30.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

2,568,5912,541,007

726,102329,340241,827223,378203,482201,104192,611194,348

50212,224

138, 19554,0609,827

0.00020.00480.19030.16410.04060.00000.00000.00000.0000

7,831 0.0403

0.99980.99520.80970.83590.95941.00001.00001.00001.00000.9597

84.8184. 7984.3968.3257.1154.7954. 7954.7954.7954. 79


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

155of317






39. 5

40.541. 5

42.543. 544.545,546.547.548.5

49, 5

50.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.559.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5


189,217189,209189,165137,722137,722105,964105,964317,504315,669455,732

455,141452,355447,408437,119438,456438,456429,336376,469375,721375,721

376,205376,205376,205376,413378,685436,689432,965432,879432,879430,985

430,985425,385425,385424,625421,981374,302373,601351,077351,077349,339

RETIREMENTSDURlNG AGE

1NTERVAL

16,096

4713,496

10,760238

5,591

981,903

86

1, 894

4, 795

2,42247,679

70122,524

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.11690.00000.00440.01100.03410.0005

0.00000.01240.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00030.00440.00020.00000.00440.0000

0.01110,00000.00000.00570.11300.00190.06030.00000.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

1.00001.00001.00001.00000.88311.00000.99560.98900.96590.9995

1.00000,98761.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00000.99970.99560.99981.00000.99561.0000

0.98891.00001.00000.99430.88700. 99810.93971.00001.00001.0000


52.5852.5852.5852.5852.5846.4346.4346.2345.7244.16

44.1444.1443.5943.5943.5943.5943.5943,5943.5943.59

43.5943.5943,5943.5943,5943.5843.3943.3843.3843.19

43.1942.7142.7142.7142.4737.6737.6035.3335.3335.33


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

156of317





AGE ATBEGIN OF1NTERVAL

79. 5

80.581.582.583.584.585.586.587,588.5

89. 5

90.591.592.593.594.595.596.597.598.5

99.5100.5101.5102.5103.5104.5


346,640346,640311,873311,873306,054302,782299,511137,602136,64222,607

22,60722,60721,96320,70820,70820,70819,69419,69419,69419,694

19,21019,21019,21019,00116,729


INTERVAL

34,767

5,8193,2713 271

1,254

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.10030.00000.01870.01070.01080.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.05710.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

1.00000.89971.00000. 98130.98930.98921.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00000.94291.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000


35.3335.3331.7931.7931.2030,8630.5330.5330.5330.53

30.5330.5330.5328.7828.7828.7828.7828.7828.7828.78

28.7828.7828.7828.7828.7828.78


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

157of317

C&o

I

o s'fat'4 m

U3 Xooorc 0

rnHZ

Qm H

o50

o &'z

UJrg

BNIRIRBAS J.N3083d


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

158of317


ACCOUNT 335 MISCELLANEOUS PONER PLANT EQUIPMENT

ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0.00.51.52.53.54,55.56.57.58,5


4,598,2214,474,9974,452,4244,354,9604, 212, 8584,010,7793,885,2483,782,4533,610,9353,556,820


INTERVAL

1901,005

1,541

1,68712,6201,9786,2681, 998

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00020.00000.0004

SURVRATIO

1.00000.99981.00000.9996

0.00320.00050.0017

0.99680.99950.9983

0.0006 0.9994

0.0000 1.00000.0004 0.9996


100.00100.0099.9799.9799.9499.9499.9099.5799.5299.35

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516,517.518.5

3,471,3973,175,5152,988,7782,712,0271, 982, 0711,965,4051,898,9271,651,8821,477,9421,289,137

224,176

930

4,72821,3168,4061,284

50,73029,916

0.06460.00000.00030.00000.00240.01080.00440.00080.03430.0232

0.93541.00000.99971.00000.99760.98920.99560.99920.96570.9768

99.2992.8892.8892.8592.8592.6391.6291.2291,1588.02

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

1,036,9641,105,5681,058,168

914, 708858,847514,757503,627486,579464,643458,746

52,50143,18945,17510,8106,951

10,26911, 890

7, 6125, 8963,423

0.05060.03910.0427

0.94940.96090.9573

0.00810.01990.02360.01560,01270.0075

0.99190.98010.97640.98440.98730.9925

0.0118 0.9882

85.9881.6278.4375.0974.2073. 6072. 1370.4369.3368.45

29. 530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

402,557391,168358,571342,570335,257331,200328,631323,024320,744318, 348

11,1061,329

9185,894

118236

4,267678960396

0.02760.00340.00260.01720.00040.00070.01300.00210.00300.0012

0.97240.99660.99740.98280.99960.99930.98700.99790.99700.9988

67.9366.0665,8465.6764.5464.5264.4763.6363.5063,31


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

159of317








INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


39. 5

40.541. 542.543.544.545.546.547.548.5

49. 5

50.551.552.553.554,555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69. 5

70.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5

317,085315,613307,744151,508144,091142,932134,966132,505127,638125,448

120,069119, 683113,165112,646110,774107,607103,927101,488101,470100,601

98, 18397, 93696,53694,71794,64294,47193,58691,61589,50585,580

85,38667,18667,18667,15552,89152,17326,12526,12526,12526,125

1,4456,076

192748866

4,0121,6474,8671,0284,235

3866,060

5191 7223,1673,0581,413

11136

1, 623

2471, 3991, 819

75172885

1,9712,1103,925

194

18,200

3114,264

71826,048

724

0.00460.01930.00060.00490.00600.02810.01220.03670.00810.0338

0.00320.05060.00460.01530.02860.02840.01360.00010.00130.0161

0.00250.01430.01880.00080.00180.00940.02110.02300.04380.0023

0.21310.00000.00050.21240.01360.49930.00000.00000.00000.0277

0.99540.98070.99940.99510.99400.97190.98780.96330.99190.9662

0.99680. 94940.99540.98470.97140.97160.98640.99990.99870.9839

0.99750.98570.98120.99920.99820.99060.97890.97700.95620.9977

0.78691.00000.99950.78760.98640.50071.00001.00001.00000.9723

63.2362.9461.7361.6961.3961.0259.3158,5856.4355.97

54.0953.9151.1850.9550.1748.7347.3546.7146.7046.64

45.8945.7745.1244.2744.2344.1543.7442.8241.8340.00

39. 9031.4031.4031.3824.7224.3812.2112.2112.2112.21


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

160of317








INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


79.580.581.582.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89.590.591.592.593.594.595.596.597.598.5

99.5100.5101.5102.5103.5104.5

25,40125,40125,40125,40125,39425,35425,35412,12712,1271,686

1, 6861, 686

733733733733733733477477

477477477477477

7

40

13,227

10,441

953

256

477

0.00000.00000.00000.00030.00160.00000.52170.00000.86100.0000

0.00000.56520.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.34920.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00000.99970.99841.00000.47831.00000.13901.0000

1.00000.43481.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000.65081.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.0000

11.8711.8711.8711.8711.8711.8511.855.675.670.79

0.790.790,340.340.340.340.340,340.220.22

0.220.220.220,220.22


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

161of317

l-'l lnH

m g

N rs

Pg 00Z ln g

0

MH

5i

C &IO ~

uJr0

CIN

ClCl

O

ONinInb1nS j.NaOVad

Cl


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

162of317


ACCOUNT 336 ROADS, RAILROADS AND BRIDGES

ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0.00.512.53.54.55.56.57.58.5

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516. 5

17.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.53132.533.534.535.536.537.538.5


17,67117,67117,67117,67117,67117,67117,68617,90521,20521,205

21,20521,20521,20521,20521,20521,20521,20521,20521,20521,205

21,20521,20521,20521,20521,20521,20521,20521,20521,20521,205

21,16620,584

8,2588,2588,2588,2588,2588,2588,2588,258


INTERVALRETMTRATIO

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000


100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00

100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00

100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00

100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

163of317


ACCOUNT 336 ROADS, RAILROADS AND BRIDGES




39.540.541.542.543.544,545.546.547.548.5

49.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5


8,2588,2588,2588,2588,2588,2588,2588,2588,2588,258

8,2588,2588,2588,2588,2588,2588,2588,2588,2588,258

8,2588,2588,2588,2588,2588,2588,2588,2588,2588,258


INTERVALRETMTRATIO

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000


100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00

100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00

100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00

69.570.5

8,258 0.0000 1.0000 100.00100.00


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

164of317

CICI

l50 V

CI

m «H

&rexrs 5 o0

CI Zrc

80U CI

C &IO g

tu5

CInI

CICI

CIu1

BNIRIRBAS IN3383d


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

165of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.59.5

10.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29. 5

30.531.532.533.534.535.536.537,538.5


198, 861, 695193,531,067192,272,354191, 604, 502179,262,337159,256,320118, 789, 231118,690,473116,061,316115, 867, 520

115,729,706115,384,365115,161,947114, 607, 982113,060,09864,471,61653,777,14144,990,82315,122,37812,250,40613,062,53512, 881, 17310,763,26410,506,7308,539,8878,516,1118,275,7378,278,4338,418,2818,278,9378,153,1039,164,0929,152,1649, 128, 034

11,104,9868,550,3177,266,5097,606,6035,616,4055,324,676


1NTERVAL

11,62518,07252,50061,6705,1317,0002,074

30,000

99,6556,068

166,76762,8834,352

50,22576,027

1,332,443122,859

8,650

8,3012,357,997

5,3781,113,711

40,99710,268

12,441122,491

7,985

50,01249,389

38915,4756,5494,2874,872

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00010.00010.00030.00030.00000.00010.00000.00000.0003

0.00090.00010.00140.00050.00000.00080.00140.02960.00810.0007

0.00060. 18310.00050.10600.00480.00120.00000.00000.00150.0148

0.00100.00000.00550.00540.00000.00180.00090.00060.00090.0000

SURVRATIO

1.00000.99990.99990.99970.99971.00000.99991.00001.00000.9997

0.99910.99990.99860.99951.00000.99920.99860.97040.99190.9993

0.99940.81690.99950.89400.99520.99881.00001.00000.99850.9852

0.99901.00000.99450.99461.00000.99820.99910.99940.99911.0000


100.00100.0099.9999.9899.9699.9299.9299.9199.9199.91

99.8999.8099.7999.6599.6099.5999.5199.3796.4395.65

95.5895.5278.0377.9969.7369.3969.3169.3169.3169.21

68.1868. 1268.1267.7467.3867.3767.2567.1967.1567.10


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

166of317








INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


39. 540.541.542.543,544.545.546.547.548.5

49, 5

50.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558,5

59.560.561.562.563.564,565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5

5,244,2535,113,0304,177,6903,035,1772,851,9482,461,1511,177,147

325,35839,5355,707

233,0872,109,7952,109,7952,104,6561,876,708

71,045147

700,170474,879474,879

482,978488,109547,467747,755767,229734,378297,667200,288

21,358

133,89514,592

118,235

39,337

0.02550.00290.02830.00000.01380.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.0000

0.97450.99710.97171.00000.98621.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

67.1065.3865.2063.3563.3562.4862.4862.4862.4862.48

62.4862.4862.4862.4862.4862.4862.4862.4862.4862.48

62.4862.4862.4862.4862.4862.4862.4862.4862.48


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

167of317






79.580.581.582.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89.590.5


1, 348

15,004

16,753


INTERVALRETMTRATIO

0.0000

0.0000

0.0000

SURVRATIO


gÃ GannettFleming VII-104 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

168of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.5

9.510.511.512.513. 5

14. 5

15.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5


134,162,256139,722,598147,308,410175,177,996165,919,392145,932,060105,483,427105,387,657102,767,150102,588,949

102,451,134102,105,794101, 883, 376101,329,69299,782,98551,197,77340,566,98331,810,7663,267,982

585,244

4,200,5104,020,4534,289,6044,227,4633,392,7193,512,3343,271,9593,284,4954,871,5344,893,6804,773,6537,616,4528,362,4968,923,366

11,104,9868,550,3177,266,5097,606,6035,616,4055,324,676


INTERVAL

11,62518,072

61,6705, 1317,0002,074

30,000

99,6556,068

46,32662,8834,352

15,26545,92623,4212,9898,650

8,301

3,271

5,82610,268

12,441122,491

7, 985

50,01249,389

38915,4756,5494,2874,872

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00010.00010.00000.00040.00000.00010.00000.00000.0003

0.00100.00010.00050.00060.00000.00030.00110.00070.00090.0148

0.00200.00000.00080.00000.00170.00290.00000.00000.00260.0250

0.00170.00000.00600.00550.00000.00180.00090.00060.00090.0000

SURVRATIO

1.00000.99990.99991.00000.99961.00000.99991.00001.00000.9997

0.99900.99990.99950.99941.00000.99970.99890.99930.99910.9852

0.99801.00000.99921.00000.99830.99711.00001.00000.99740.9750

0.99831.00000.99400.99451.00000.99820.99910.99940.99911.0000


100.00100.0099.9999.9899.9899.9499.9499.9399.9399.93

99.9099.8099.8099.7599.6999.6999.6699.5499.4799.38

97.9197.7297.7297.6497.6497.4797.1997.1997.1996.94

94.5294.3694.3693.7993.2793.2793.1093.0292.9792.88


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

169of317






39.540.541. 5

42.543,544.545.546.547.548.5

49. 5

50.551.552.553.554,555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561,562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5


5,244,2535,113,0304,177,6903,035,1772, 851, 9482,461,1511,177,147

325,35839,5355,707

233,0872,109,7952,109,7952,104,6561,876,708

71,045147

700,170474,879474,879

482,978488, 109547,467747,755767,229734,378297,667200,288

21,358


INTERVAL

133,89514,592

118,235

39,337

RETMTRATIO

0.02550.00290.02830.00000.01380.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.0000

SURVRATIO

0.97450.99710.97171.00000.98621.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000


92.8890.5190.2587.7087.7086.4986.4986.4986.4986.49

86.4986.4986.4986.4986.4986.4986.4986.4986.4986.49

86.4986.4986.4986.4986.4986.4986.4986.4986.49


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

170of317








INTERVAL

PCT SURVRETMT SURV BEGIN OFRATIO RATIO 1NTERVAL

79.580.581.582.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89.590.5

1, 348

15,004

16,753

0.0000

0.0000

0.0000


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

171of317

0

rn Z +rn o og p Ho Uoo~

Ac omCu P6

rc rn 0

H

0

o&

lu5

BNIAIRBIIS j.N3083d

g GannettFleming VII-10B Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

172of317


ACCOUNT 342 FUEL HOLDERS, PRODUCTION AND ACCESSORIES

ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0.00.51.52.53.54,55.56.57.58.5

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19. 5

20.521.522.523.524.525.526.527,528.5

29.530.531.532,533.534,535.536.537,538.5


122,412,100121,182,502119, 143, 498118,838,14698,591,01073,129,36650,019,00549,875,03746,984,60946,972,09746,959,55646,945,05646,894,49544,461,76944,359,60930,458,94322,793,65717, 066, 18813,089,72611,880,93011,874,59510,724,16410,503,35110,418,93410,418,93410,435,46010,399,72510,400,85710,399,72510,393,671

10,392,65810,440,42510,440,42510,423,5733,483,0971,512,8611,414,8391,408,0261,380,8211,375,948


INTERVAL

106,128116,262363,178

12,51230,732

14,5001,1752,677

86,754

69,675369,650

30

1,150,43172 213

0

6, 0532,100

2620

770511,518

9,32248,595

1023,192

758100

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00000.00000.00090.00120.00500.00000.00000.00030.0007

0.00030.00000.00010.00000.00200.00000.00310.02170.00000.0000

0.09690.00670.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00060.0002

0.00000.00000.00010.04910.00270.03210.00000.01650.00050.0001

SURVRATIO

1.00001.00001.00000.99910.99880.99501.00001.00000.99970.9993

0.99971.00000.99991.00000.99801.00000.99690.97831.00001.0000

0.90310.99331.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000.99940.9998

1.00001.00000.99990.95090.99730.96791.00000.98350.99950.9999


100.00100.00100.00100.0099.9199.7999.3099.3099.3099.27

99.2199.1899.1799.1799.1798.9798. 9798.6796.5396.53

96.5387.1886.5986.5986.5986.5986.5986.5986.5986.54

86.5386.5286.5286.5282.2782.0579.4279,4278.1178,06


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

173of317






39.540.541.542.543.544,545.546.547.548.5

49.550.551.552,553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.5


1,355,2501,336,7071,007,485

954,565806,472631,006310,33195,85425,855

18,65318,65318,65318,65318,653


INTERVAL

18,31746,888

23,996

RETMTRATIO

0.01350.03510.00000.00000.02980.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000,00000.0000

SURVRATIO

0.98650.96491.00001.00000.97021.00001.00001.00001.0000


78.0677.0074.3074.3074.3072.0972.0972.0972.0972.09


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

174of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0.00. 5

1.52.53.54,55.56.57.58.5

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5


91,945,53998,386,386

102,224,340105,979,86686,951,90261,496,56738,395,58838,251,62035,361,19235,348,680

35,317,94835,318,31435,267,75332,835,02732,737,21018,836,54411,171,2585,443,7891,484,2098,346,395

10,394,9229,244,4929,030,4808,946,0648,949,6358,966,1618,930,6639,005,6459,061,5209,224,668

9,274, 1489,919,171

10,177,41010,330,5583,483,0971,512,8611,414, 8391,408,0261,380, 8211,375,948


INTERVAL

100,828116,262363,178

12,51230,732

14,5001,1752,677

86,754

69,675369,650

30

1,150,43172 213

0

6, 0532, 100

2620

770511,518

9,32248,595

1023,192

758100

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00000.00000.00100.00130.00590.00000.00000.00040.0009

0.00040.00000.00010.00000.00270.00000.00620.06790.00000.0000

0.11070.00780.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00070.0002

0.00000.00000.00010.04950.00270.03210.00000.01650.00050.0001

SURVRATIO

1.00001.00001.00000.99900.99870.99411.00001.00000.99960.9991

0.99961.00000.99991,00000.99731.00000.99380.93211.00001.0000

0,88930.99221.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000,99930.9998

1.00001.00000.99990.95050.99730.96791.00000.98350.99950.9999


100.00100.00100.00100.0099.9099.7799.1899. 1899.1899.15

99.0699.0299.0299.0199.0198.7598.7598.1391.4791.47

91.4781.3480.7180.7180.7180.7180.7180.7180.7180.66

80.6480.6380.6380.6376.6476.4373.9873.9872.7672.72

~ r2'rannettFleming VII-111 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

175of317






39.540,541.542.543,544.545.546.547,548.5

49.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566,567.5


1,355,2501,336,7071,007,485

954,565806,472631,006310,331

95,85425,855

18, 65318,65318,65318,65318,653


1NTERVAL

18,31746,888

23,996

RETMTRATIO

0.01350.03510.00000.00000.02980.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

0.98650.96491.00001.00000.97021.00001.00001.00001.0000


72. 7171.7369.2169.2169.2167.1567.1567.1567.1567.15


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

176of317

CICt

gK

H

~8gro I| grc 0

8 turo

M0

0 r

rc 0 0Z0Z

'n Hru

0 0

ZH

C &C'

UJ5

M

CIcr CI

r

DNInmznS iNaOaad

CIN O O

QÃ GannettFlaming VII-113 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

177of317


ACCOUNT 343 PRIME MOVERS ALL LOCATIONS EXCLUDING RICHMOND SIMPLE CYCLE

ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE

PLACEMENT BAND 1949-2016 EXPER1ENCE BAND 1968-2016AGE AT

BEGIN OFINTERVAL



1NTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.5

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

1,616,513,9761,599,522,2551,584,523,9951,541,369,6091,147,763,378

705,771,182395,732,962384,772,389322,025,053312,016,143

299,312,276285,168,215282,931,247267,967,627260,352,001189,241,139159,460,68980,960,95064,232,97155,812,33551,614,26339,935,96734,767,76032,949,90831,547,74630,976,14730,798,50228,149,38128, 149, 38125,552,95724,501,10724,428,55424,260,57324,151,81923,793,15423,198,48322,999,46123,167,83923,016,90422,962,847

512,981

14,2356,874,565

10,007,7526,674,0781,439,5058,829,9926,744,3676,460,702

12,550,2602,006,4239,742,5984,845,3187,660,0447,625,0751,108,193

200,961651,117

1,605,5571,145,3671,301,439

922,743571,599157,061525,883

2,596,424

55,183

366, 02211, 894

253,4774,794

0.00030.00000.00000.00450.00870.00950.00360.02290.02090.0207

0.04190.00700.03440.01810.02940.04030.00690.00250.01010.0288

0.02220.03260.00000.02800. 01810.00510.01710.00000.09220.0000

0.00230.00000.00000.00000.01540.00050.00000.00000.00230.0002

0.99971.00001.00000,99550.99130.99050.99640.97710.97910.9793

0.95810.99300.96560.98190.97060.95970.99310.99750.98990.9712

0.97780.96741.00000.97200.98190.99490.98291.00000.90781.0000

0.99771.00001.00001.00000.98460.99951.00001.00000.99770.9998

100.0099.9799.9799,9799.5298.6597.7297.3795.1393.14

91.2187.3986.7783.7882.2779.8576.6376.1075.9175.14

72. 9871.3669.0369.0367.1065.8865.5564.4364.4358.49

58.4958.3658.3658.3658.3657.4657.4357.4357.4357.30


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

178of317


ACCOUNT 343.01 PRIME MOVERS — ALL LOCATIONS EXCLUDING RICHMOND SIMPLE CYCLE






INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


39. 5

40.541.542.543.544.545.546.547.548.549.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562,563.564.565.566.567.5

22,477,74820,902,58019,211,59719,201,65719,159,75113,949,4097,606,8124,195,0101,097,911

1, 4751,4751,475

75,77175,771

106,869159,990159,99085,69485,69453,121

1,306,744

2, 9994,327

833,914

0.05810.00000.00020.00020.04350.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.94191.00000.99980.99980.95651.00001.00001.00001,0000

57.2853.9553.9553.9453.9351.5951.5951,5951.5951.59


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

179of317

BNlhlhBAS IN3083d


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

180of317


ACCOUNT 343.1 PRIME MOVERS - ROTABLE PARTS

ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0.00.51.52.53.54,55.56.57.58.59.5

10.511.512.513.514.5


284,501,464206,814,783173,958,365

98, 548, 61248,280,28790,119,42164,413,66156,463,79456,382,07456,382,074

51,066,51810,239,04610,239,04610,239,04610,239,046


INTERVAL

19,074,41749,221,59219,068,11432,539,95418,150,6317,949,867

81, 720

5,315,55540,827,472

10,239,046

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.09220.28300.19350.67400.20140.12340,00140.00000.0943

0.79950.00000.00000.00001.0000

SURVRATIO

1.00000.90780.71700.80650.32600.79860.87660.99861.00000.9057

0.20051.00001.00001.0000


100.00100.00

90.7865.0952.5017.1213.6711.9811.9611.96

10.842.172.172.172.17


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

181of317

CICI

mrs +ro o O

U

Krc ~ O

M

0

C &IO 2

UJ5

Ct

CICI

BNIRIRBIIS j.N3083d

cr CICI

C)


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

182of317


ACCOUNT 344 GENERATORS

ORIGINAL L1FE TABLE



0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.5

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5


307,750,565303, 184, 086301,012,381300,857,493253,796,965196,436,767164,922,041163,544,903150,239,461150,197,146

150,197,146147,780,547146,627,267145,655,097141,791,10598,345,67761,650,71134,356,60532,691,83121,449,729


INTERVAL

9,5178,587

1,978,967

15,355

1,773,249

934,07026,549

790,7862,469,726

80,70848,689

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00780.00000.00000.00010.00000.0000

0. 01180.00000.00640.00020.00560.02510.00130.00140.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

1.00001.00001.00001.00000.99221.00001.00000.99991.00001.0000

0.98821.00000.99360.99980.99440.97490.99870.99861.00001.0000


100.00100.00100.0099.9999.9999.2199.2199.2199.2099.20

99.2098.0398.0397.4197.3996.8594.4294.2994,1694.16

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

21,440,72911,615,80311,615,80311,615,80311, 615, 80311,615, 80311,615,80311,615,80311,615, 80311,615,803

968, 182 0. 04520.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.95481.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

94.1689.9189.9189.9189. 9189.9189.9189.9189.9189.91

29. 5

30.531.532.533,534,535.536.537.538.5

11, 615, 80311,615,80311,615,34011,602,12111,602,12111,601,39511,445,14511,445,14511,324,97011,319,469

46313,219

726156,250

0

120,1755, 501

22,140

0.00000.00000.00110.00000.00010.01350.00000.01050.00050.0020

1.00001.00000.99891.00000.99990.98651.00000.98950.99950.9980

89.9189.9189.9089.8089,8089.8088.5988.5987.6687.61


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

183of317






39. 540.541.542.543.544.545.546.547.548.5


11,297,32910,982,8509,430,5016,648,2045,476,5134,110,2652,143,1301,172,327

297,494


INTERVAL

314,478299,852

7,100265,347

RETNTRATIO

0.02780.02730.00000.00110.04850.00000.00000.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

0.97220.97271.00000.99890.95151.00001.00001.00001.0000


87.4485.0182.6982.6982.6078.6078.6078.6078.6078.60


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

184of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.59.5

10.511.512.513.514 515.516.517.518.5


207,548,892229,558,995254,803,357256,313,243231,234,455173,883,258153,018,532151,641,394138,335,952138,293,637

138,293,637136,164,744135,011,465134,039,295130,175,30386,729,87450,034,90822,740,80321,076,0289,833,926


INTERVAL

9, 5178, 587

1,978,967

15,355

1,485,543

934,07026,549

790,7862,469,726

80,70848,689

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00860.00000.00000.00010.00000.0000

0.01070,00000.00690.00020.00610.02850.00160.00210.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

1.00001.00001.00001.00000.99141.00001.00000.99991.00001.0000

0. 98931.00000.99310.99980.99390.97150.99840.99791.00001.0000


100.00100.00100.0099.9999.9999.1499.1499.1499.1399.13

99.1398.0698.0697.3897.3696.7794.0293.8793.6693.66

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

9,824,926

15, 648688,664

3,483,2684,639,621

968, 182 0. 0985 0. 9015

0.00000.00000.00000.0000

93.6684.43

29. 530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

4,639,6217,469,7578,458,301

10,167,22511, 602, 12111,601,39511,445,14511,445,14511,324,97011,319,469

46313,219

726156,250

0

120,1755,501

22,140

0.00000.00010.00160.00000.00010.01350.00000.01050.00050.0020


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

185of317








INTERVALRETMTRATIO

PCT SURVSURV BEGIN OF

RATIO INTERVAL

39.540.541.542.543,544.545.546.547.548.5

11,297,32910, 982, 8509,430,5016,648,2045,476,5134,110,2652,143,1301,172 327

297,494

314,478299,852

7,100265,347

0.02780.02730.00000.00110.04850.00000.00000.00000.0000


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

186of317

BNIRIRBIIS j.N3083d


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

187of317


ACCOUNT 344.1 GENERATORS - SOLAR

ORIG1NAL LIFE TABLE



EXPOSURES ATBEGINN1NG QFAGE INTERVAL


INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0.00.51. 5

179,194,342131, 513, 549

0.00000.0000

1.00001.0000

100.00100.00100.00


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

188of317

CD

CICD

g coK Io

cn v +CCC Hrog p Hrs vo ro g0, ro CO

prs cu o0CQ

m

5i

CD &IO ~

UJIg

CDC'C

CICD

CDID

cJNIRIRblflS J.N30b13d


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

189of317


ACCOUNT 345 ACCESSORY ELECTR1C EQUIPMENT

ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE

PLACEMENT HAND 1959 — 2016 EXPERIENCE HAND 1968 — 2016


EXPOSURES ATHEGINN1NG OFAGE INTERVAL


INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.5

317,638,545313,009,839301,713,924301, 197, 810237,447,823159,813,358108,388,317105,705,66794,342,64194,201,310

56,7721,014,6581,531,657

362,84761,843

491,17090,71049,594

0.00000.00020.00340.00650.00230.00060.00460.00100.0005

451,362 0.0014 0.99861.00000.99980.99660.99350.99770.99940.99540.99900.9995

100.0099.8699.8699.8499.5098.8698.6498,5898.1298.03

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

94,050,99392,627,45592,050,09691,646,42891,005,30068,809,67944,104,44418,991,45017,228,23614,295,424

116,59332,036

479,392493,229

1,111,9131,923,332

225,20260,784

130,7174,160

0.00120.00030.00520.00540.01220.02800.00510.00320.00760.0003

0.99880.99970.99480.99460.98780.97200.99490.99680.99240,9997

97. 9897.8597.8297.3196.7995.6192.9392.4692.1691.46

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

14,276,5287,873,2727,141,0595,084,5075,035,3234,984,6024, 947, 7764,908,7174,568,5254,565,0584,370,0134,349,9244,326,7304, 107, 8183,972,6823,961,2433,957,3873,957,3313,919,3823,919,382

745,40199,142

145,6676,389

16,5291,706

17,606

19,8454,634

173,38397,9735,5133,856

567,406

0.05220.01260.02040.00130.00000.00000.00000.00340.00040.0039

0.00450.00110.04010.02390.00140.00100.00000.00190.0000

1,710 0.0004

0.94780.98740.97960.99871.00001.00001.00000.99660.99960.9961

0.99550.99890.95990.97610.99860.99901.00000.99811.00000.9996

91.4486.6685.5783.8383.7283.7283.7283.7283.4483.41

83.0982.7182,6279.3177.4277.3177.2477.2377.0977.09


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

190of317






39. 540.541.542.543,544,545.546.547.548.5


3,912,9673,827,4002,821,5172,702,1192,591,8732,003,154

692,568477,947

84,807


INTERVAL

85,56752,861

119,398110,24680,862

RETMTRATIO

0.02190.01380.04230.04080.03120.00000.00000.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

0. 97810.98620.95770.95920.96881.00001.00001.00001.0000


77.0675.3774.3371.1868.2866.1566.1566.1566.1566.15


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

191of317



ORIGINAL L1FE TABLE



0.00.51.52.53.54,55.56.57.58.59.5

10.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530,531.532.533.534.535.536.537,538.5


246,752,100266,406,902281,971,145283,199,036222,848,851145,243,913100,490,080

97,934,35488, 591, 56288,503,558

88,482,38087,641,92387,103,96586,918,12186, 296, 81564,141,21539,451,80314,308,49712,749,4029,851,3629,838,4403,490,7172,761,452

796,377746,161702,460682,163722,428382,260406,080

212,9592,713,2503,119,9013,748,8963,972,6823,961,2433,957,3873,957,3313,919,3823,919,382


INTERVAL

15,424

14,2851,014,6581 531 657

362,84761,843

491,17090,71049,594

116,59332,036

479,392477,942

1,111,9131,923,332

219,20460,78415, 677

4, 112

707,05599,14254,1912,893

16,5298

16,250

19,1734,634

173,38397,9735,5133,856

567, 406

1,710

RETMTRATIO

0.00010.00000.00010.00360.00690.00250.00060.00500.00100.0006

0.00130.00040.00550.00550.01290.03000.00560.00420.00120.0004

0.07190.02840.01960.00360.00000.00000.00000.02290.00000.0400

0.09000.00170.05560.02610.00140.00100.00000.00190.00000.0004

SURVRATIO

0.99991.00000.99990.99640.99310.99750.99940.99500.99900.9994

0.99870.99960.99450.99450.98710.97000.99440.99580.99880.9996

0.92810.97160.98040.99641.00001.00001.00000.97711.00000.9600

0.91000.99830.94440.97390.99860.99901.00000.99811.00000.9996


100.0099.9999.9999.9999.6398.9598.7098,6498. 1498.04

97.9997.8697.8297.2896.7595.5092.6492.1291.7391.62

91.5885.0082.5980.9780.6780.6780.6780.6778.8378.82

75.6768.8668.7464.9263.2263.1463.0763.0762.9562.95


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

192of317








ZNTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


39.540.541. 542.543.544.545.546.547.548.5

3,912,9673,827,4002,821,5172,702,1192,591,8732,003,154

692,568477,947

84,807

85,56752, 861

119,398110,24680,862

0.02190. 01380.04230.04080.03120.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.97810.98620.95770.95920.96881.00001.00001.00001.0000

62. 9361.5560.7058.1355.7654.0254.0254.0254.0254.02


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

193of317

CD

z gH

co ro 0g CD

HCD HCD lu gOCD~

pCD le

CD

Ol H PW 0

Hui CD

HM

o&~zulCD«L

«I

CIO«I

BNlhlhBDS J.N3083d


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

194of317


ACCOUNT 345.1 ACCESSORY ELECTRIC EQUIPMENT - SOLAR

ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0.00.51.5


4,686,7154,047,631


INTERVALRETMTRATIO

0.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

1.00001.0000


100.00100.00100.00


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

195of317

o s'ursR ro

rn

rs 0 0re 0

H

IO H

05IY,'&

IO gUJ5

CIN

BNlhlhBAS j.NBDBBd

ION


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

196of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0. 0

0. 5

1.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.5


43,982,16540,422,44139,401,54138,573,76231,396,19922,702,04114,615,08712,699,97311,202,90311,223,697


INTERVAL

250

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00000.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

1.00001.00001.00001.0000

0.0000 1.00000.0007 0.9993

0.99840.9953

15,85423,23959,224

0.00160.00470.0000 1.0000

62,793 0.0056 0.9944


100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00

99.9399.7799.3199,31

9.510.511.512.513.514.515,516.517.518.5

10,668,32610,363,80310,227,25210,050,4789,853,2496,032,1674,159,9921,411,8111,141,879

971,518

18,60038,92444,463

430970,691

1,1095,242

32,9551, 892

0.00380.00430.00000.09850.00020.00130.00000.02890.0019

0.99620.99571.00000.90150.99980.99871.00000.97110. 9981

0.0017 0.9983 98.7598.5898.2197.7897.7888.14BB. 1388.0288.0285.48

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

1,242,4051,131,2811,064,778

896,845877,795729,793707,964696,233711,968720,934

658,775635,263659,253598,409608,885549,406503,996500,111491,521485,081

88,90344,64422,98611,4794,946

39,8545,2971,6575,978

49,922

12,2271,512

37,8598,989

45,27340,186

3,8915 5516,472

0.07160.03950.02160.01280.00560.05460.00750.00240.00840.0692

0.01860.00240.05740.01500.07440.07310.00770,01110.01320.0000

0.92840.96050.97840.98720.99440.94540.99250.99760.99160.9308

0.98140.99760.94260.98500.92560.92690.99230.98890.98681.0000

85.3179.2176.0874.4473.4873.0769.0868.5668.4067.83

63.1361.9661. 8158.2657.3953.1249.2348.8548.3147.67

~ GannettFleminti VII-133 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

197of317


ACCOUNT 346 MISCELLANEOUS PONER PLANT EQUIPMENT






INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


39. 5

40.541. 542.543,544.545,546.547.548.5

49.550.55152. 5

53. 5

54.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5

487,159480,634

81,45443,04339,97926,82214,0916,7742,774

306

2, 530392,31638,5932,882

75810,235

7 3174,0002,468

306

0.00520.81620.47380.06690.01900.38160.51930.59050.88961.0000

0.99480. 18380.52620.93310.98100.61840.48070.40950.1104

47.6747.43

8.714.594.284.202.601.250.510.06


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

198of317








INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


79.580.581.582.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89.590.5

4,590 0.0000

gx GannettFleming VII-135 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

199of317

BNIRIRBflS LN308'3d


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

200of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0.00.51 52.53. 5

4, 5

5.56.57.58.5

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5


93,690,57184,849,60774,453,16974,320,57174,497,39073,011,75271,884,94171,592,82960,978,22260,584,81759,625,02258,376,04657,041,67954,212,28252,879,26550,477,86048,082,62344,382,00542,010,80841,106,06839,498,87736,100,03532,851,28232,185,48730,494,96329,470,43128,927,88427,500,58322, 115, 95820,570,353

18, 136, 35317,543,12216,716,08415,888,11411,918,78910,570,2319,664,1169,392,7786,596,9675,524,881


INTERVAL

47,2894,6412,251

10,24630,3744,3493,944

53,95622,82824,063

20,719113,92923,37354,97184,378

174,83713,54815,210

225,472352,297

60,10864,52554,538

132,16149,742

234,74938,053

158,02320,415

112,081

13, 70816,98741,27010,11318,60451,0976,035

14,479961

14,903

RETMTRATIO

0.00050.00010.00000.00010.00040.00010.00010.00080.00040.0004

0.00030.00200.00040.00100.00160.00350.00030.00030.00540.0086

0.00150.00180.00170.00410.00160.00800.00130.00570.00090.0054

0.00080.00100.00250.00060.00160.00480.00060.00150.00010.0027

SURVRATIO

0.99950.99991.00000.99990.99960.99990.99990.99920.99960.9996

0.99970.99800.99960.99900.99840.99650.99970.99970.99460.9914

0.99850.99820.99830.99590.99840.99200.99870.99430.99910.9946

0.99920.99900.99750.99940.99840.99520.99940.99850.99990.9973


100.0099.9599.9499.9499,9399.8999.8899.8899.8099.76

99,7299.6999.4999.4599.3599.1998.8598.8298.7998.26

97. 4297.2797.0996.9396.5396.3895,6195.4894.9394.85

94.3394. 2694. 1793. 9493. 8893.7393.2893.2293.0793.06


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

201of317



OR1GINAL LIFE TABLE, CONT.



39. 540.541.542.543.544.545.546.547.548.549.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5


4,770,7064,271,5853,895,4042,657,1462,359,5061,874,1861,667,7761,642,7961,628,4851,451,4881,319,4781,217,7941,163,2711,139,5261,117,5941,091,7611,084,6321,075,6631,075,0601,058,4851,028,9031,002,403

998,114980,496964,259915,388911,992890,194789,167786,219

606,579602,025600,181598,283598,197596,390568,969567,288567,288556,512


INTERVAL

5, 25616,4805,5609,9607,1491,6324,1543,0661,0952,084

9,4738, 213

5504,530

13,3821,4043,825

9461

2,247

590667

5, 1504

18,13777

638177

172 232

26

1, 89886

1,2572,3151,640

1,884

RETMTRATIO

0.00110.00390.00140.00370.00300.00090.00250.00190.00070.0014

0.00720.00670.00050.00400.01200.00130.00350.00000.00040.0021

0.00060.00070.00520.00000.01880.00010.00070.00020.00000.0028

0.00000.00000.00320.00010.00210.00390.00290,00000.00330.0000

SURVRATIO

0.99890.99610.99860.99630.99700.99910.99750.99810.99930.9986

0,99280.99330.99950.99600.98800.99870.99651.00000.99960.9979

0.99940.99930.99481.00000.98120.99990.99930.99981.00000.9972

1.00001.00000.99680.99990.99790.99610.99711.00000.99671.0000

PCT SURVBEGIN OFiNTERVAL

92. 8192.7192.3592.2291. 8791.5991.5191.2991.1291.05

90. 9290.2789.6689.6289.2688.1988,0887.7787.7787.73

87.5587.5087.4486.9986.9985.3585.3485.2885.2785.26

85.0285.0285.0284.7584.7484.5684.2383.9983.9983.71


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

202of317






79.580.581.582.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89. 5

90.591.592.593.5


506,295263,776263,661263,661263,605263,059256,435228,772228,772151,589

107,120104,81160,49238,964


INTERVAL

292115

56546

97

RETMTRATIO

0.00060.00040.00000.00020.00210.00000.00040.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00010.00000.0001

8URVRATIO

0.99940.99961.00000.99980.99791.00000.99961.00001.00001.0000

1.00000.99991.00000.9999


83. 7183.6683.6283.6283.6183.4383.4383.4083.4083.40

83.4083.4083.4083.4083.39

g GannettFIeming VII-139 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

203of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE





INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0.00.51.52.53.54.55. 5

6.57.58.59.5

10.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518. 5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534,535.536.537.538.5

90,200,42281,798,56971, 857,23072,435,93272,960,14071,706,77370,848,45570,394,20159,792,77459,587,91758,771,79857,624,00356,355,22153,527,68552,212,62949, 814, 18947,417,95243,669,87341, 148, 88840,261,776

38,682,97935,313,75932,071,55231,413,25029,702,84128,728,30128,111,29226,663,39421,396,28619,806,83117,533,34016,904,25516,079,01415,258,29811,293,8229,946,4859,070,6898,799,3946,003,5274,940,608

45,2614,6412,251

10,13525,2443,7753,739

52,79118,95223,558

20, 158112,66922,09854,55184,378

174,55113,54815,210

225,246352,097

57,70662,25152,882

132,16149,741

234,34637,894

158,02320,41597,146

13,64816,98734,0206,654

18,60450,9976,035

14,479686

10,905

0.00050,00010.00000.00010.00030.00010.00010.00070.00030.0004

O.OQ030.00200.00040.00100.00160.00350.00030.00030.00550.0087

0.00150. 00180.00160.00420.00170.00820.00130.00590.00100.0049

0.00080.00100.00210.00040.00160.00510.00070,00160.00010.0022

0.99950.99991.00000.99990.99970.99990.99990.99930.99970.9996

0.99970.99800.99960.99900.99840.99650.99970.99970.99450.9913

0.99850.99820.99840.99580.99830.99180.99870.99410.99900.9951

0.99920.99900.99790.99960.99840.99490.99930.99840.99990.9978

100.0099.9599.9499.9499.9399.8999.8999.8899.8199.78

99.7499.7099.5199.4799.3799.2198.8698.8398.8098.25

97.4097.2597.0896.9296.5196.3595.5695.4394.8794.78

94.3194. 2494.1593.9593.9193.7593.2793.2193.0593.04


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

204of317




PLACEMENT SAND 1906-2016 EXPER1ENCE BAND 1977 — 2016


39. 540.541. 542.543.544.545.546.547.548.5

49.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5


4,241,6473,976,3193,605,7032,369,3292,071,9371,586,6191,382,9591,388,2231,376,8981,280,1741,193,5281,094,7331,088,2641,087,0931, 105, 8961,086,0641,078,9351,073,0051,072,4081,056,409

1,028,6651,002,221

997,932980,315964,174915,304911,983890, 185789, 159786,217

606,576602,025600, 181598,283598,197596,390568,969567,288567,288556,512


INTERVAL

5,25610,9163,6769,7127,149

9324,104

271, 0951, 908

8, 9787, 613

554,5307,3821,404

7869

409

590667

5,1504

18,1371

638177

172,232

262

1, 89886

1, 2572,3151,640

1, 8841

RETMTRATIO

0.00120.00270.00100.00410.00350.00060.00300.00000.00080.0015

0.00750.00700.00010,00420.00670.00130.00070.00000.00000.0004

0.00060.00070.00520.00000.01880.00000.00070.00020.00000.0028

0.00000.00000.00320.00010.00210.00390.00290.00000.00330.0000

SURVRATIO

0.99880.99730.99900.99590.99650.99940,99701.00000.99920.9985

0.99250.99300.99990.99580.99330.99870.99931.00001.00000.9996

0.99940.99930.99481.00000.98121.00000.99930.99981.00000.9972

1.00001.00000.99680.99990.99790.99610.99711.00000.99671.0000


92. 8492.7292.4792.3792.0091.6891.6291.3591.3591.28

91. 1490.4689.8389.8289.4588.8588.7488.6788.6788.67

88.6488.5988.5388.0788.0786.4186.4186.3586.3486.33

86.0986.0986.0885.8185.8085.6285.2985.0485.0484.76


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

205of317



ORIGINAL LiFE TABLE, CONT.





INTERVALRETMTRATIO

5URVRATIO


79.580.581.582.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89. 5

90,591.592.593.5

506,295263,776263,661263,661263,605263,059256,435228,772228,772151,589

107,120104, 81160,49238,964

292115

56546

97

0.00060.00040.00000.00020.00210.00000.00040,00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00010.00000.0001

0.99940.99961.00000.99980.99791.00000.99961.00001.00001.0000

1.00000.99991.00000.9999

84.7684.7184.6784.6784.6684.4884.4884.4584.4584.45

84.4584.4584.4484.4484.44


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

206of317

oN

o

rs UZC4'n ~ o

rs ot~ou rs v8 ~)o r o

g+ rc o

M

o&ED g

lur0

U HBH

0

CtO O

r

BNIRIRHAS J.N338gd

oN Ct o

gi GannettFleming VII-143 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

207of317


ACCOUNT 353 STATION EQUIPMENT

ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE





INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0.00.512.53.54.55.56.57.58.59.5

10.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.5

23.524,525.526.527.528.5

29,530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

1,101,031,7291,066,026,6511,023,825,258

997,827,689903,693,053838,273,018769,562,425724,055,842679,564,238625,931,298

590,810,804572,338,332554,697,697532,118,226506,652,214472,529,842443,980,903408,739,187392,865,934376,726,075

372,327,140358,958,956335,150,691325, 157, 278305,287,614284,775,656277,036,551260,306,491250,988,427237,523,031

209,836,672190,890,631178,956,051170,086,893125,531,697121,330,705110, 896, 24198,343,39484,792,23179,365,276

1,766,576394,612810,653

1,395,2421,848,4922,089,8042,620,2011,821,8232,791,3494,101,8842,169,2942,104,5192,919,0814,234,4193,866,1311,510,2701,486,8472, 291, 8812,246,9292,574,931

2,144,7416,920,5234,756,2574,575,6482,914,0821,813,9752,939,7843,051,4111,345,4372,447,3392,181,9492,391,9981,822,6182,056,181

637, 1982,308,5291,303,8191,111,9421,410,642

646,586

0.00160.00040.00080.00140.00200.00250.00340.00250.00410.0066

0.00370.00370.00530.00800.00760.00320.00330.00560.00570.0068

0.00580.01930.01420.01410.00950.00640.01060.01170.00540.0103

0.01040.01250.01020.01210.00510.01900. 01180.01130.01660.0081

0.99840.99960.99920.99860.99800.99750.99660.99750.99590.9934

0.99630.99630.99470.99200.99240.99680.99670.99440.99430.9932

0.99420.98070.98580.98590.99050.99360.98940.98830.99460.9897

0.98960.98750.98980.98790.99490.98100.98820.98870.98340.9919

100.0099.8499.8099.7299,5899.3899.1398.8098.5598.14

97.5097.1496.7896.2795.5194.7894.4894.1693.6393.10

92. 4691.9390.1688.8887.6386.7986.2485.3284.3283.87

83.0082.1481.1180.2979.3278. 9177.4176.5075.6474.38


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

208of317






39. 540.541. 5

42.543,544.545.546.547.548.549.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5


67,441,21462, 160, 08956,266,81149,791,42643,058,81235,732,62928,884,96224,591,75122,655,46118,809,07315,589,72713,394,59112,116,39511,634,35911,353,34610,140,73310,009,5398,894,3428,687,2458,056,474

7,925,8986,981,9996,829,6235,957,1125,852,6844,527,5753,509,5583,007,7762,152,9292,141,036

1, 813, 3731,809,1581,773,3081,760,8801,747,7291,497,0321,421,2651,264,4911,220,3391,185,557


INTERVAL

677,760920,051807,6585OO,96O

1,206,085536,038363,080386,068273,206332,121

164,046164,30091,50072,673

275,69484,234

122,018106,710

5,940111,159

25,78696,209

373,98212,61221,309

241,350157,98327,588

3011,230

2,34135,34312,1782,480

31,89213,842

129,64438,91313,12020,163

RETMTRATIO

0.01000. 01480.01440.01010.02800.01500.01260.01570.01210.0177

0.01050. 01230.00760.00620.02430 .00830.01220.01200.00070.0138

0.00330.01380.05480.00210.00360.05330.04500.00920.00000.0052

0.00130.01950.00690.00140.01820.00920.09120.03080.01080.0170

SURVRATIO

0.99000.98520.98560.98990.97200.98500.98740.98430.98790.9823

0.98950.98770.99240.99380.97570.99170.98780.98800.99930.9862

0.99670.98620.94520.99790.99640.94670.95500.99081,00000.9948

0.99870.98050.99310.99860.98180.99080.90880.96920.98920.9830


73.7773.0371.9570.9270.2068.2467.2166.3765.3364.54

63.4062.7361.9661.4961.1159.6359.1358.4157.7157.67

56. 8756.6955.9152.8552.7352 .5449. 7447.5047.0747.07

46. 8246. 7645. 8545,5345. 4744.6444.2240.1938.9538.53


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

209of317






79. 5

80.581.582.583,584.58S.S86.587.588.5

89.590,591.592.593.594.595.596.597.598.5

99.5100.5101.5102.5103.5104.5105.5106.5107.5

EXPOSURES ATBEGINNlNG OFAGE INTERVAL

1,154,707997,600979,903892,781808,582731,411636,697541,326527,983259,841

236,165220,914130,267127,956119,79332,06730,04730,04730,04729,238

29,23829,23828,76728,76728,76724,80524,80515,208


INTERVAL

21,894579

46,92483,85577,17192,52417,149

9026

1,258

33837

960

RETMTRATIO

0.01900.00060.04790.09390.09540.12650.02690.00020.00000.0048

0.00140.00020.00740.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

0.98100.99940.95210.90610.90460.87350.97310.99981.00000.9952

0,99860,99980.99261.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000


37.8837.1637.1435.3632.0428.9825.3224.6324.6324.63

24.5124.4724.4724.2924.2924.2924.2924.2924.2924.29

24. 2924.2924.2924.2924.2924.2924.2924.2924.29


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

210of317



ORlGINAL LIFE TABLE

PLACEMENT BAND 1908-2016 EXPERlENCE BAND 1977 — 2016


0. 0

0.51. 52.53.54,55.56.57.58.5

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520,521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5


1,014,012,199981,555,806950,059,828932,587,278847,005,484791,349,708730, 745, 817689,792,535647,708,732600,047,376

569,352,878554,479,206538,966,211517,270,512492,253,249459,393,943431,182,910397,853,983382,837,002367,729,076

363,523,193351,198,589327,809,996318, 644, 897298,684,491279,550,126271,586,297255,214,448247,029,071233,427,143

205,970,173186,978,981175,000,865166,192,237121,767,128118,082,248107,870,04095,459,77981, 931, 83376,557,726


lNTERVAL

895,137356,137708,997

1,269,353978,866

1,984,3772,470,8381,686,7212,634,8194,004,880

1,865,2341,984,9962,781,4134, 162, 9893,707,3491,486,4021,447,2832,125,2992,176,4352,525,4362,119,5666,853,2044,697,9264,568,0002,860,4771,792,8612,866,2092,985,7631,315,9802,410,3352,075,2112,317,3701,756,0902,015,340

381,4262,143,0621,216,0031,096,4441,387,607

595,211

RETMTRATIO

0.00090.00040.00070.00140.00120.00250.00340.00240.00410.0067

0.00330.00360.0052o.ooao0.00750.00320.00340.00530.00570.0069

0.00580.01950.01430.01430.00960.00640.01060.01170.00530.0103

0.01010.01240.01000.01210.00310.01810.01130.01150.01690.0078

SURVRATIO

0.99910.99960.99930.99860.99880.99750.99660.99760.99590.9933

0.99670.99640.99480.99200.99250.99680.99660.99470.99430.9931

0.99420.98050.98570.98570.99040.99360.98940.98830.99470.9897

0.98990.98760.99000.98790.99690.98190.98870.98850.98310.9922


100.0099.9199.8899.8099.6799.5599.3098.9698.7298,32

97.6697.3497.0096.5095.7295.0094.6994.3793.8793.34

92.6992.1590.3689.0687.7886.9486.3985.4784.4784.02

83.1682.3281.3080.4879.5179.2677.8276.9476.0674.77

/9'annettFleming VII-147 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

211of317






39.540.541,542.543.544.545.546.547,548.5

49.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59. 5

60.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574,575.576.577.578.5


64,723,03259,658,39653,842,46947,581,76940,900,46433,561,76426,728,68822,622,88820,872,64318,096,49015,033,41312,873,48011,786,41011,465,26411,212,68610,089,3079,960,7938,845,7168,652,6948,022,770

7,893,6756,949,8076,799,8245,927,8035,823,4254,502,3683,484,3772,992,1932,152,8922,141,036

1,813,3731,809,1581,773,3081,760,8801,747,7291,497,0321,421,2651,264,4911,220,3391,185,557


INTERVAL

627,836855,949684,245453, 818

1,205,167536,038362,869379,818270,233314,767

164,046164,30091,50072,088

275,69484,234

122,018106,710

5,940110,769

25,78696,209

373,98212,61221,309

241,350157,98327,588

3011,230

2, 34135,34312,1782,480

31,89213, 842

129,64438,91313,12020,163

RETMTRATIO

0.00970.01430.01270.00950.02950.01600.01360.01680.01290.0174

0.01090.01280.00780.00630.02460.00830.01220.01210.00070.0138

0.00330.01380.05500.00210.00370.05360.04530.00920.00000.0052

0.00130.01950.00690.00140.01820.00920.09120.03080. 01080.0170

SURVRATIO

0.99030.98570.98730.99050.97050.98400.98640.98320.98710.9826

0.98910.98720.99220.99370.97540.99170.98780.98790.99930.9862

0.99670.98620.94500.99790.99630.94640.95470.99081.00000.9948

0.99870.98050.99310.99860.98180.99080.90880.96920.98920.9830


74.1973.4772.4171.4970.8168.7367.6366.7165.5964.74

63.6262.9262.1261.6461.2559.7459.2458.5257.8157.77

56. 9756.7956.0052.9252.8152.6249.8047.5447.1047.10

46.8546.7945.8845.5645.5044.6744.2540.2238.9838.56


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

212of317


ACCOUNT 353 STATlON EQUIPMENT




79. 5

80.581.582.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89.590.591.592.593.594.595.596.597.598.5

99.5100,5101.5102.5103.5104.5105.5106.5107.5


1,154,707997,600979,903892,781808,582731,411636,697541,326527,983259,841

236,165220,914130,267127,956119,79332,06730,04730,04730,04729,238

29,23829,23828,76728,76728,76724,80524,80515, 208


INTERVAL

21, 894579

46,92483,85577,17192,52417,149

9026

1, 258

33837

960

RETMTRATIO

0.01900.00060.04790.09390.09540.12650.02690.00020.00000.0048

0.00140.00020.00740.00000.00000,00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

0. 98100.99940.95210.90610.90460.87350.97310.99981.00000.9952

0.99860.99980.99261.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000


37.9137.1937.1735.3932.0629.0025.3324.6524.6524.65

24.5324.4924.4924.3124.3124.3124.3124.3124.3124.31

24,3124.3124.3124.3124.3124.3124.3124.3124.31


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

213of317

gN

rQ H 0

D)go'o

hi Ptps;oro 0 0

I ZM

0

zUJI0

BNIhlhbIflS j.N3083d


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

214of317


ACCOUNT 354 TOWERS AND FIXTURES

ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE

PLACEMENT BAND 1908 — 2016 EXPER1ENCE BAND 1954 — 2016


0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.5

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5


65,175,62661,407,39261,097,75260,587,18158,847,92158, 678, 18258,632,17458,628,67258, 162, 61256,263,35956,154,22056,059,44756,109,32556,386,57656,253,91356,250,57556,421,55756,450,30156,561,78456,557,467

56,446,45856,218,89256,369,06656,334,39556,205,34752,306,14152,007,65452,274,13952, 655, 18952,864,065

52,874,45453,126,80240,567,49940,428,57329,663,47218,143,42117,964,72717,762,78317,745,27417,707,572


INTERVAL

982215,189

25,2863,528

19,49846,01339,008

24,55013,34642,334

1543,54713,38013,11320,50824,53938,417

29,95730,67930,93428,075

7,213298,043

7,72515,543

242990

3, 065126

18,78934,4234,921

153,77816,3504,347

18,303

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00350.00000.00000.00000.00040.00010.00030.00080.0007

0.00040.00020.00080.00000.00080.00020.00020.00040.00040.0007

0.00050.00050.00050.00050.00010.00570.00010.00030.00000.0000

0.00010.00000.00000.00050.00120.0003o.ooaa0.00090.00020.0010

SURVRATIO

1.00000.99651.00001.00001.00000.99960.99990.99970.99920.9993

0.99960.99980.99921.00000.99920.99980.99980.99960.99960.9993

0.99950.99950.99950.99950.99990.99430.99990.99971.00001.0000

0.99991.00001.00000.99950.99880.99970.99140.99910.99980.9990


100.00100.0099.6599.6599.6599.6599.6199.6099.5799.49

99.4299.3799.3599.2899.2899.2099.1899.1599.1299.07

99.0198.9598.9098.8598.8o98.7898.2298.2198.1898.18

98.1798.1798.1798.1798. 1298. 0197.9897.1497.0597.03


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

215of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE, CONT,





INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


39.540.541.542.543.544.545.546.547.548.5

49.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5

16,996,04916,545,28913,665,50813,789,70513,211,8789,514,3938,509,1768,490,2118,051,8887,454,6176,222,6433,843,0722,985,6592,867,3352,552,5642,426,5492,333,2902,185,9102,149,0782,033,0382,017,5591,977,4031,972,9501,972,4021,928,4481,851,9101,821,2781,819,2201,786,3271,785,512

1,785,0181,784,0641,784,0641,784,0591,780,8511, 780, 8511,780,8511,780,8511,683,5041,607,138

3,05998,94111,6304,206

14,07841,614

1,69313,36136,33915, 158

2,4991,124

42,211134,784103,956

93,420

16,27514,191

40,1564,453

54843,95456,000

586

32,893815494

954

63,207

97,34776,3661,907

0.00020.00600.00090.00030.00110.00440.00020.00160.00450.0020

0.00040.00030.01410.04700.04070.00000.04000.00000.00760.0070

0.01990.00230.00030.02230.02900.00030.00000.01810.00050.0003

0.00050.00000.00000.00180.00000.00000.00000.05470.04540.0012

0.99980.99400.99910.99970.99890.99560.99980.99840.99550.9980

0.99960.99970.98590.95300.95931.00000.96001.00000,99240.9930

0.98010.99770.99970.97770.97100.99971.00000.98190.99950.9997

0.99951.00001.00000.99821.00001.00001.00000.94530.95460.9988

96.9396.9196.3396.2596.2296.1295.7095.6895.5395,10

94.9194.8794.8493.5089.1085.4785.4782.0582.0581.43

80.8679.2579.0779.0577.2975.0575.0275.0273.6773.63

73.6173.5773.5773.5773.4473.4473.4473.4469.4366.28

lg 6annettFleming VII-152 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

216of317








INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


79.580.581.582.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89.590.591.592.593.594.595.596.597.598.5

99.5100.5101.5102.5103.5104.5105.5

1,556,4891,556,4891,542,5161,541,3691,541,3691,530,6621,509,6961,498,6181,161,0151,160,987

882,500793,652671,139663,564398,438115,132110,996110,99669,71169,711

69,71169,71113,84213,84213,65213,652

13,9731,147

10,70720,9667,9814,128

282,423

5,473379

2,329379189

4, 136

190

0.00000.00900.00070.00000.00690,01370.00530.00280.00000.0021

0.00620.00050.00350.00060.00050.03590.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.01370.00000.0000

1.00000.99100.99931.00000.99310.98630.99470.99721.00000.9979

0.99380.99950.99650.99940.99950.96411.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00000.98631.00001.0000

66.2066.2065.6065.5565.5565.1064.2163.8763.6963.69

63.5663.1663.1362.9162.8862.8560.5960.5960.5960.59

60.5960.5960.5960.5959.7659.7659.76


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

217of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.59.5

10.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29. 530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5


49,623,85146,656,29549,388,38148,853,80847,614,33850,883,75652,093,65552,103,32951,909,34850,851,54051,929,21554,267,42255,315,25955,838,20355,714,43255,740,18656,016,99656,049,95956,294,93956,396,222

56,298,07656,069,82656,220,00156,185,33056,068,67351,833,72451,578,59751,524,86051,507,14551,510,210

51,509,79951,461,92038,597,31538,457,00427,692,31416,051,97515,881,26815,669,34815,657,22315,563,310


INTERVAL

2,565

18,217

42,334

38,2012,380

13,11320,36818,77326,841

29,95730,67930,93413,0404,626

288,2157,725

15,543

411

3,06554

18,3781, 868

153,77810,9654,337

18,303

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0001

0.00040.00000.00080.00000.00070.00000.00020.00040.00030.0005

0.00050.00050.00060.00020.00010.00560.00010.00030.00000.0000

0.00010.00000.00000.00050.00010.00000.00970.00070.00030.0012

SURVRATIO

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000.9999

0.99961.00000.99921.00000.99931.00000.99980.99960.99970.9995

0.99950.99950.99940.99980.99990.99440.99990.99971.00001.0000

0.99991.00001.00000.99950.99991.00000.99030.99930.99970.9988


100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00

99.9999.9699.9699.8899.8899. Bl99.8199.7999.7599.72

99.6799.6299.5699.5199.4899.4898.9298. 9198.8898.88

98. 8898.8798.8798.8798.8298.8298.8297.8697.7997,77


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

218of317






39. 5

40.541. 542.543.544,545.546.547.548.5

49.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59,560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5


14,900,48614,451,94611,522,39211,493,16510,918,6597,195,5536, 198, 6866,185,3336,108,2605,472,493

4, 637, 9662,623,8971,975,6321,881,9061,835,4632,015,0171,921,7581,867,7981,876,3861,776,6211,775,3331,775,3331,828,6821, 828, 1341,824,1801, 815, 5361,821,2781,819,2201,786,3271,785,512

1, 785, 0181,784,0641,784,0641,784,0591,780,8511,780,8511,780,8511,780,8511,683,5041,607,138


INTERVAL

61495,24511,630

12,50925,328

10,4475,132

1, 066597

28,581134,464103,611

2,561548

3,954

32,893815494

954

63,207

97,34776,3661,907

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00660.00100 .00000.00110.00350.00000.00170.00080.0000

0.00020.00020. 01450.07150.05640.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00140.00030.00220,00000.00000.00000.01810.00050.0003

0.00050.00000.00000.00180.00000.00000.00000.05470.04540.0012

SURVRATIO

1.00000.99340.99901.00000.99890.99651.00000.99830.99921.0000

0.99980.99980.98550.92850.94361.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00000.99860.99970.99781.00001.00001.00000.98190.99950.9997

0.99951.00001.00000.99821.00001.00001.00000.94530.95460.9988


97.6597.6597.0096.9196.9196.7996.4596.4596.2996.21

96.2196.1996.1794.7788.0083.0483.0483.0483.0483.04

83.0483.0482.9282.8982.7182. 7182.7182.7181.2281.18

81. 1681.1181.1181.1180.9780.9780.9780.9776.5473.07


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

219of317






79. 5

80.581.582.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89.590.591.592.593.594.595.596.597.598.5

99.5100.5101.5102.5103.5104.5105.5


1,556,4891,556,4891,542,5161,541,3691,541,3691,530,6621,509,6961,498,6181,161,0151,160,987

882,500793,652671,139663,564398,438115,132110,996110,99669,71169,711

69,71169,71113,84213, 84213,65213,652


INTERVAL

13,9731,147

10,70720,9667,9814,128

282,423

5,473379

2,329379189

4,136

190

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00900.00070.00000.00690.01370.00530.00280.00000.0021

0.00620.00050.00350.00060.00050.03590,00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.01370.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

1.00000.99100.99931. 00000.99310.98630.99470.99721.00000.9979

0.99380.99950.99650.99940.99950.96411.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00000.98631.00001.0000


72. 9872.9872.3372.2772.2771.7770.7970.4170.2270.22

70.0769.6469.6069.3669.3269.2966.8066.8066.8066.80

66.8066.8066.8066.8065.8865.8865.88


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

220of317

BNIRIRBAS j.NBDBBd

OtV

o Cl


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

221of317


ACCOUNT 355 POLES AND FIXTURES

ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0. 0

0.51.52,53.54.55.56.57,58.5

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518,5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5


716,255,926679,028,630650,076,984578,010,359522,283,542454,582,633385,625,438354,403,327333,830,734307,118,341

280,155,991263,650,268255,724,049248, 571, 929240,263,621229,070,271214,602,616202,915,580192,012,310178,761,844

173,355,351163,821,262156,402,188153,961,088149,566,049144,237,791140,280,158131,060,975126, 088, 815114, 940, 896

103,674,34292,628,06985,768,97969,066,45562,689,63656,586,59849,130,43143, 201, 18838,678,16033,154,255


INTERVAL

1,648,8672,108,5202,376,0412,557,5691,052,9681,964,3621,826,1791,555,6634,683,8861,484,5671,479,3011,601,8301,005,4301,705,9841,820,0212,133,025

895,4231,156,6742,317,7761,166,9811,487,6011,034,8411,786,9781,347,5811,474,9951,314,7031,552,4331,323,3091,482,5611, 384, 251

1, 481, 9481,550,4831,127,275

877,8481,164,2201,165,380

808,154614,829754,387782,634

RETMTRATIO

0.00230.00310.00370.00440.00200.00430.00470.00440.01400.0048

0.00530.00610.00390.00690.00760.00930.00420.00570.01210.0065

0.00860.00630.01140.00880.00990,00910.01110.01010. 01180.0120

0.01430.01670.01310.01270.01860.02060.01640.01420.01950.0236

SURVRATIO

0.99770.99690.99630.99560.99800.99570.99530.99560.98600.9952

0.99470.99390.99610.99310.99240.99070,99580.99430.98790.9935

0.99140.99370.98860.99120.99010.99090.98890.98990.98820.9880

0.98570.98330.98690.98730. 98140.97940,98360.98580.98050.9764


100.0099.7799.4699.1098.6698.4698.0397.5797.1495.78

95.3294.8194.2493.8793.2292.5191.6591,2790.7589.66

89.0788.3187.7586.7585.9985.1484.3683.4382.5981.62

80.6379.4878.1577.1276.1474.7373.1971.9870.9669.58


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

222of317






39.540.541.542.543. 5

44 . 545.546. 5

47.548.549.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59,560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576,577.578.5


28,481, 86623,853,54220,915,50218,586,21613,392,3729,627,4588,660,3887, 382, 6016,139,1425,470,2553,954,3332, 841, 8792, 480, 1052,109,8122,069,7241,887,2671,494,6091,383,3481,280,1851,181,8811,167,4691,074,970

979,267879,375729,442542,519510,048485,223462,615404,899

398,752382,312380,701362,752300,398279,335215,587215,587203,727203,727


INTERVAL

546,555488,839376,087233,532278,060256,929193,98393,57660,478

199,220

144,85331,483

121,68539,17798,02014,62727,15237 1237,537

11,451

20,8646,1917,7205,831

10,5091,806

10,5942,0702,1275,091

3221,6111,0291,473

10,903

RETMTRATIO

0.01920.02050.01800.01260.02080.02670.02240.01270.00990.0364

0.03660.01110.04910.01860.04740.00780.01820.02680.00590.0097

0.01790.00580.00790.00660.01440.00330.02080.00430.00460.0126

0.00080.00420.00270.00410.03630.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

SURVRAT10

0.98080.97950.98200.98740.97920.97330.97760.98730.99010.9636

0.96340.98890.95090.98140.95260.99220. 98180.97320.99410.9903

0.98210.99420.99210.99340.98560.99670.97920.99570,99540.9874

0.99920.99580.99730.99590.96371.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000


67. 9366.6365.2664.0963.2961.9760.3258.9758.2257.65

55.5553.5152.9250.3249.3947.0546.6845.8444.6144.34

43. 9143.1342.8842.5442.2641.6541.5140.6540.4840.29

39.7839.7539.5939.4839.3237.8937.8937.8937.8937.89


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

223of317




PLACEMENT BAND 1909-2016 EXPER1ENCE BAND 1954 — 2016


79.580.581.582.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89.590.591.592.593.594.595.596.597.598.5

99.5100.5101.5


201,334199,852199,852199,852199,852199,852175,032171,900164,959152,843

106,50481,17080,69464,97758,27758,27719,99019,99019,81317,534

4, 8724,872


INTERVAL

237

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00000.00000.00000,00000.00120.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000.99881.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.0000


37.8937.8937.8937.8937.8937.8937.8537.8537.8537.85

37.8537.8537.8537.8537.8537.8537.8537.8537.8537.85

37.8537.8537.85


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

224of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0.0D.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.59.5

10.511.512,513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

EXPOSURES ATBEGlNNING OFAGE INTERVAL

671,754,019640,800,208616, 297, 398547,705,204499,703,542436,831,369369,048,440340,311,535321,500,962295,891,531271, 933, 847256,844,400249,677,015243,073,789234,873,146224,027,319210,510,034199,217,056189,283,543176,219,467

170,868,520161,607,803154,383,714152,109,155148, 035, 125143,138,298139,234,297129,868,924124,748,851113,686,526

102,294,54991,302,22684,451,35567,875,43861,621,29155,617,38048,357,76342,473,49537,967,28432,539,635


INTERVAL

1,002,0582,105,0852,359,7192,524,9141,005,5601, 935, 1281,776,1441,495,4514,593,2201,442,8831,349,4771,549,136

969,2581,673,8471,787,4372,082,541

838,642803,734

2,228,8701,129,198

1,437,643971,093

1,764,4011,294,8351,377,9231,229,8011, 538, 3511,316,0441,449,2721,370,6101,464,6621,542,0191,076,341

831,2501,077,2901,081,560

752,202609,999653,259754,467

RETMTRATIO

0.00150.00330.00380.00460.00200,00440.00480.00440.01430.0049

0.00500.00600.00390.00690.00760.00930.00400.00400. 01180.0064

0.00840.00600.01140.00850.00930.00860.0110D. 01010.01160.0121

0.01430.01690.01270.01220.01750.01940.01560.01440.01720.0232

SURVRATIO

0.99850.99670.99620.99540.99800.99560.99520.99560.98570.9951

0.99500.99400.99610.99310.99240.99070.99600.99600.98820.9936

0.99160.99400.98860.99150.99070.99140.98900.98990.98840.9879

0.98570.98310.98730.98780.98250.98060.98440.98560.98280.9768


100.0099.8599.5299.1498.6898.4998.0597.5897.1595.76

95. 2994.8294.2593 .8893.2492.5391.6791.3090.9389.86

89.2988. 5488.0087.0086.2685.4584.7283.7882.9481.97

80.9879.8278.4877.4876.5375.1973.7372.5871.5470.31

QW GannettFleming Vll-161 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

225of317








INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


39.540.541.542.543.544.545.546.547.548.5

49.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572,573.574.575.576.577.578.5

27,910,86123,308,63820,471,03118,145,06712,954,3239,201,8858,294,7307,032,2005, 812, 1835,156,4713,825,4022,752,6542,398,7972,044,2222,010,8341,828,8401,474,6191,363,3581,260,3721,164,3471,162,5971,070,098

979,267879,375729,442542,519510,048485,223462,615404,899

398,752382,312380,701362,752300,398279,335215,587215,587203,727203,727

521, 936387,762372,861230,431265,201254,975190,50391,44860,095

142, 188

144,80231,483

121,68539,17798,02014,47727,15237,1237,537

11,451

20,8646,1917,7205, 831

10,5091, 806

10,5942,0702,1275,091

3221, 6111, 0291,473

10,903

0.01870.01660.01820.01270.02050.02770.02300.01300.01030.0276

0.03790.01140.05070.01920.04870.00790.01840.02720.00600.0098

0. 01790.00580.00790.00660.01440.00330.02080.00430.00460.0126

0.00080.00420.00270.00410.03630.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.98130.98340. 98180.98730.97950.97230.97700.98700.98970.9724

0.96210.98860.94930.98080.95130.99210.98160.97280.99400.9902

0.98210.99420.99210.99340.98560.99670.97920.99570.99540.9874

0.99920.99580.99730.99590,96371.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

68.6867.3966.2765.0664.2462.9261. 1859.7759.0058.39

56.7854. 6354. 0051.2650.2847.8347.4546.5845.3145.04

44.6043.8043.5443.2042.9142.2942.1541.2841.1040.91

40.4040.3740.2040.0939.9238,4738.4738.4738.4738.47


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

226of317






79. 580.581.582.583.584.585.586,587,588.5

89. 5

90.591.592.593.594.595.596.597.598.5

99.5100.5101.5


201,334199,852199,852199,852199,852199,852175,032171,900164,959152,843

106,50481,17080,69464,97758,27758,27719,99019,99019, 81317,534

4,8724,872


INTERVAL

237

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00120.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000.99881.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.0000


38.4738.4738.4738.4738.4738.4738.4338.4338.4338.43

38.4338.4338.4338.4338.4338.4338.4338.4338.4338.43

38.4338.4338.43


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

227of317

c 5

+ rrr 0Mre 0 ~

f00Q rc

0 X00

0

o&~zUJr3«E

Ct o

BNIRIRbrflS J.N30brgd

QÃl GannettFleming VII-164 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

228of317


ACCOUNT 356 OVERHEAD CONDUCTORS AND DEVICES

ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE





INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.59.5

10.511.512.513. 5

14.51516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

481,340,175418,992,919409,026,799381,922,966365,525,668345,481,366296,067,701286,793,534276,583,312258,908,761245,106,052237,578,311231,782,209225,723,089218,634,587211,721,173203,205,804198,819,779195,086,349187,957,907

185,857,900182,780,632178,011,719175,656,630174,029,730168,341,451166,645,866162,690,030160,290,129153,899,700

148,854,144141,860,857128,762,223114,444,366102,512,46490,235,18082,512,16576,535,66571,761,87664,340,042

250,01272,985

472,004611,354417,606482, 710

1,509,355640,681581,693430,545

604,996655,643427,036330,736476,927697,587587,933297,147

2,072,157457, 158

396,373582,447543,634612, 188

1,071,652646,179496,478739,031401,866406,054

489,252449,001319,126356,449384,677251,374505,792519,570428,707302,099

0.00050.00020.00120.00160.00110.00140.00510.00220.00210.0017

0.00250.00280.00180.00150.00220.00330.00290.00150.01060.0024

0.00210.00320.00310.00350.00620.00380.00300.00450.00250.0026

0.00330.00320.00250.00310.00380.00280.0061o.oosa0,00600.0047

0.99950.99980.99880.99840.99890.99860.99490.99780.99790.9983

0.99750.99720.99820.99850.99780.99670.99710.99850.98940.9976

0.99790.99680.99690.99650.99380.99620.99700.99550.99750.9974

0.99670.99680.99750.99690.99620.99720.99390.99320.99400.9953

100.0099.9599.9399.8299.6699,5499.40aa.ao98.6798.47

98. 3098. 0697. 7997.6197.4797.2596.9396.6596.5195.48

95. 2595. 0594.7594.4694.1393.5593. 1992. 9192. 4992.26

92.0191.7191.4291.1990.9190.5790.3289.7689.1588.62


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

229of317






39.540.541.542.543.544.545.546.547.548.5

49.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5


56,477,31154,388,39550,275,03246,937,90441,629,49930,715,03528,646,15026,236,81222,461,87819,684,79814,304,40011,160,03610,297,4159,017,4298,719,7857,720,0695,911,2345,232,4124,844,6734,412,1914,376,7394,095,8453,648,1953,114,5502,698,8932,173,5192,000,1991,920,3311, 822, 1641,654,667

1,645,9311,596,7461,592,6581,573,7941,375,8851,367,1521,129,2201,129,2201,124,5291,122,706


INTERVAL

586,368769,62994,081

232,561421,979356,87593,496

172,98586,954

108,925

224,65052,689

139,990241,60299,18272,88360,56225,6464,681

30,950

88,83540,91014,050

109,73365,744

114,7314,296

31,7382,5588,736

24,9844,088

15,205104,753

1,870134,015

4,5351,824

19,021

RETMTRATIO

0. 01040.01420.00190.00500.01010.01160.00330.00660.00390.0055

0.01570.00470.01360.02680.01140.00940.01020.00490.00100.0070

0.02030.01000.00390.03520.02440.05280.00210.01650.00140.0053

0.01520.00260.00950.06660.00140.09800.00000.00400.00160.0169

SURVRATIO

0. 98960.98580. 99810.99500.98990.98840.99670.99340.99610.9945

0.98430.99530.98640.97320.98860.99060.98980.99510.99900.9930

0.97970.99000.99610.96480.97560.94720.99790.98350.99860.9947

0.98480.99740.99050.93340.99860.90201,00000.99600.99840. 9831


88.2187.2986.0585.8985.4784.6083.6283.3582.8082.48

82.0280.7380.3579.2677.1376.2675.5474.7674.4074.32

73. 8072.3171.5871.3168.7967.1263 .5863.4462. 3962.30

61.9761.0360.8860.3056.2856.2150.7050.7050.4950.41


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

230of317








INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


79. 580.581.582.583.584.585.586.587,588.5

89. 5

90.591.592.593.594.595.596.597.598.5

99.5100.5101.5102.5103.5104.5105.5106.5107,5108.5

1,093,3241,080,9731,080,4011,066,6571,061,0491,005,058

931,372914,513902,508880,510

677,150650,329640,087325,547130,356123,450114,173110,396110,39697,972

80,08674,88371,99165,69564,02656,81021,82519,16419,164

12,351571187

5,6OS55 991

0

16,7337,741

9519

0

0

3,462

1, 744

0.01130.00050.00020.00530.05280.00000.01800.00850.00000.0000

0.0000O.OOO80.00000,00000.02660.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0910

0.98870.99950.99980.99470.94721.00000.98200.99151. 00001.0000

1.00000.99921.00001.00000.97341.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000.9090

49.5649.0048.9748.9648.7146.1446.1445.3144.9244.92

44.9244.9244.8944,8944,8943.6943.6943.6943.6943.69

43.6943.6943.6943.6943.6943.6943.6943.6943.6939.72


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

231of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE





INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0. 0

0.51,52.53.54.55.56.57.58.5

9.510.511.512.513,514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524,525.526.527.528.5

29. 5

30.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

420,092,652359,624,717352,254,130328,902,739318,592,366309,906,591261,983,325255,584,021249,325,241234,592,194

227,923,100223,630,519219,794,749214,657,960207,800,006201,S98,332195,274,174192,236,527189,279,073183,068,505

180,991,509178,302,865174, 157, 488172,319,049170,929,912165,696,436164,344,248159,169,872156,781,552150,616,021145,011,723137,967,011124,827,731110,577,06598,908,32986,747,19679,233,46273,059,60168,360,63561,120,308

141,33969,031

371,785583,318382,652322,954947,700505,410454,142364,720

399,902540,778408,281257,936419,141662,256239,555204,937

1,952,279421,148

361,325428,772475,728521,036

1,019,407505,566440,697653,561359,491282,802

447,536415,135271,752186,346265,261191,453504,282435,964244,292268,584

0.00030.00020.00110.00180.00120.00100.00360.00200.00180.0016

0.00180.00240.00190.00120.00200.00330.00120.00110.01030.0023

0.00200.00240.00270.00300.00600.00310.00270.00410.00230.0019

0.00310.00300.00220.00170.00270.00220.00640.00600.00360.0044

0.99970.99980.99890.99820.99880.99900.99640.99800.99820.9984

0.99820.99760.99810.99880.99800.99670.99880.99890.98970.9977

0,99800.99760.99730.99700.99400,99690.99730.99590.99770.9981

0.99690.99700.99780.99830.99730.99780.99360.99400.99640,9956

100.0099.9799.9599.8499.6699.5499.4499.0898.8998.71

98.5598.3898.1497.9697.8497.6497.3297.2097.1096.10

95.8895.6995.4695.2094.9194.3494.0593.8093.4293.20

93. 0392.7492.4692.2692.1091.8691.6591.0790.5390.20


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

232of317








INTERVALRETr4TRATIO

SURVRATIO


39.540.541.542.543.544.545,546.547.548.5

49.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565,566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572,573.574.575.576.577.578.5

53,403,98751,484,18247,498,73643, 964, 87238,676,94928,083,95426,287,69123,902,18020,136,39517, 462, 185

12,938,48210,040,6029,208,2878,429,2188,341,9497,350,3975,564,9784,890,0404,507,3214,112,5124,096,6383,904,6193,459,9202,944,1772,575,3632,067,8721,971,9331,897,3871,799,2191,654,6421,645,9061,596,7211,592,6331,573,7691,375,8601,367,1271,129,1951,129,2201,124,5291,122,706

401,047584,88891,293

206,15167,132

185,49272,510

171,63823,474

108,888

26,53248,615

139,636240,323

94,46271,96560,45620,6254,593

29,259

5, 63540,8512,444

64,55958,05487,2881,635

31,7382,5588,736

24,9844,088

15,205104,753

1,870134,015

4, 5351, 824

19,021

0.00750.01140.00190.00470.00170.00660.00280.00720.00120.0062

0.00210.00480.01520.02850.01130.00980.01090.00420.00100.0071

0.00140.01050.00070.02190.02250.04220.00080.01670.00140.0053

0.01520.00260.00950.06660.00140.09800.00000.00400.00160.0169

0.99250,98860. 99810.99530.99830.99340.99720.99280.99880.9938

0.99790.99520.98480.97150.98870.99020.98910.99580.99900.9929

0.99860.98950.99930.97810.97750.95780.99920.98330.99860.9947

0.98480.99740.99050.93340.99860.90201.00000.99600.99840.9831

89.8189.1388.1287.9587.5487.3986.8186.5785.9585.85

85.3185.1484.7383.4481.0680,1479.3678.5078.1778.09

77.5377.4276.6176.5674.8873.1970.1070.0568.8768.78

68.4167.3767.2066.5662.1362.0555.9655.9655.7455.65

~ GannettFleming VII-'t 69 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

233of317




PLACEMENT SAND 1900 — 2016 EXPERIENCE BAND 1977-2016




INTERVALRETMTRATIO

5URVRATIO


79.580.581. 5

82.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89.590.59192.593.594.595.596.597.598.5

99.5100.5101.5102.5103.5104.5105.5106.5107.5108.5

1,093,3241,080,9731,080,4011,066,6571,061,0491,005,058

931,372914,513902,508880,510

677,150650,329640,087325,547130,356123,450114,173110,396110,39697,972

80,08674,88371,99165,69564,02656,81021,82519,16419,164

12,351571187

5,60855,991

0

16,7337,741

9

5190

0

3, 462

1, 744

0.01130.00050.00020.00530.05280.00000.01800.00850.00000.0000

0.00000.00080.00000.00000.02660.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0910

0.98870.99950.99980.99470.94721.00000.98200.99151.00001.0000

1.00000.99921.00001.00000.97341.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000.9090

54.7154.0954.0654.0553,7750.9350.9350.0149.5949,59

49.5949.5949.5549.5549,5548.2348.2348.2348.2348.23

48.2348.2348.2348.2348.2348.2348.2348.2348.2343.85

gi GannettFleming VII-170 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

234of317

ClC

j g

In rs +In o c'o

rC:u~Uo g

Iu

IS

U15

5

O &"ID ~

lu5

CI

CtI

BNIRIRBAS j.NBDBBd

OPl

OCI

O


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

235of317


ACCOUNT 358 UNDERGROUND CONDUCTORS AND DEVICES

ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE


AGE ATBEGlN OFINTERVAL



INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.59.5

10.511.512.51314.515.516,517.5

21,603,99921,603,99921,603,99921,603,999

11,427713

12,62212,62212,62212,622

11,427713

12,622

0.00000.00000.00000.0000

1.00001.00000.00000.00000.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.0000

100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

236of317

CICI

rn In

rn I« ~rn s Cl

8 ) Is

fl, rn tn

~RXUO~0

g CI &rn In 'n

m A

OCl 5

H

0

C &IO ~

UJ5«(

CIC«

CICI

BNIRIRBAS 1N3DbI3d

Cl CI««

CI CI


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

237of317


ACCOUNT 359 ROADS AND TRAILS

ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE





INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0.00.51.52.53.54,55.56.57.58.5

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

319,186312,823312,823312, 823313,751313,751313,751313,751313,451313,451

313,451313,451313,451313,451313,45115,92315,92315,92315,94315, 989

16, 19416, 19416,19416,19416,19416,15316,19416,19416,19416,194

15,26615,26615,26615,26615,26615,26615,26615,26615,26615,266

300

928

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00100.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0573

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000.99901. ODDD

1.0000

1.00001.00001. DODO

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001. DODO

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000.9427

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

100.00100.001DO. 00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.0099.9099.90

99.9099.9099.9099.9099.9099.9099.9099.9099.9099.90

99.9099.9099.9099.9099.9099.9099.9099.9099.9099.90

94. 1894. 1894. 1894. 1894.1894. 1894.1894.1894. 1894. 18


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

238of317






39,540,541.542.543 5

44. 5

45 5

46.547.548.5

49. 550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5


15,26615,26615,26615,2669,9829,9369,7319,7319,7319,731

9, 7319, 7319, 7319, 7319, 7319, 7319,7319, 7318,556


INTERVAL

2046

205

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00000.00000.00130.00460.02060.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

5URVRATIO

1.00001.00001,00000.99870.99540.97941,00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000


94.1894.1894.1894.1894.0593.6291.6991.6991.6991.69

91.6991.6991.6991.6991.6991.6991.6991.6991.6991.69

QA GannettFleming VII-175 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

239of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0.00.51. 5

2.53.54.55.56.57.58.59.5

10.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518. 5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531 532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5


303,891297,528297,528297,528303,092303,092303,092303,092302,792302,792

302,792302,792302,792302,792302,792

5,2645,2645,3056,439

14,995

14,99514,99514,99514,99514,99514,95414,99515,92315,92315,923

14,99514,99514,99514,99514,99514,99514,99514,99514,99514,995


INTERVAL

300

928

RETMTRAT10

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00100.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0583

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001,00001.00000.99901.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001,00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000.9417

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000


100.00100.00100.00100,00100.00100.00100.00100.00

99.9099.90

99.9099.9099.9099.9099.9099.9099.9099.9099.9099.90

99.9099.9099.9099.9099.9099.9099.9099.9099.9099.90

94.0894.0894.0894.0894.0894.0894.0894.0894.0894.08


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

240of317








INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


39.540.541.542.543.544.545.546.547,548.5

49,550.551.552.553.554,555.556.557.558.5

14,99515,01515,06115,2669,9829, 9369, 7319, 7319, 7319, 731

9, 7319,7319,7319, 7319, 7319, 7319, 7319, 7318,556

2046

205

0.00000.00000.00000.00130.00460.02060.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000,00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

1.00001.00001.00000.99870.99540.97941.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

94. 0894. 0894. 0894. 0893. 9593. 5291.5991.5991.5991.59

91.5991.5991.5991.5991.5991.5991.5991.5991.5991.59


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

241of317

W

55~so

o)go'o

ro u Rre 0 cc

5U

0U 0

o&~zUJr0

o o

BNIRIRBflS J.Nd083d


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

242of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE





INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0.00.51

2.53.54.55.56,57.58.5

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528,5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

123,232,720111,604,378108,580,059108,843,798106,066,540104,973,280100,734,63497,888,02096,535,37390,229,704

87,347,87981, 586, 21476,802,31574,236,13366,420,30561,452,56451,123,87046,715,95242,136,43740,256,806

39,112,46934,209, 18332,135,80228,168,35226,107,64723,267,13121,854,61018,467,86816,857,00613,020,364

12,069,76310,876,15110,001,4869,388,8308,438,6587,696,4466, 871, 8675,893,3485,453,0324,714,946

1,629,530159,44655,676

269,475162,126309,521110,732109,437308,256464,507

252, 180694,366294,041128,623219,697480,051299,50591,157

194,788206,328

272,405122,201164,303117,022208, 516848,649248,009110,428104,80571,934

48,56142,44973,48844,77520,88445,15032,87820,63888,68223,241

0.01320.00140.00050.00250.00150.00290,00110.00110.00320.0051

0.00290.00850.00380.00170.00330.00780.00590.00200.00460.0051

0.00700.00360.00510.00420.00800.03650.01130.00600.00620.0055

0.00400.00390.00730.00480.00250.00590.00480.00350.01630.0049

0.98680.99860.99950.99750.99850.99710.99890.99890.99680.9949

0.99710.99150.99620.99830.99670.99220.99410.99800.99540.9949

0.99300.99640.99490.99580.99200.96350.98870.99400.99380.9945

0.99600.99610.99270.99520.99750.99410.99520.99650.98370.9951

100.0098.6898.5498.4998.2498.0997.8097.7097.5997.27

96.7796.4995.6795.3195.1494.8394.0993.5493.3592.92

92.4491.8091.4791.0190.6389.9086.6285.6485. 1384.60

84.1383.7983.4782.8582.4682.2581.7781.3881.1079.78


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

243of317






39. 540.541,542.543.544.545.546,547.548.549.550.551.552.553.554,555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5

EXPOSURES ATBEGINNING OFAGE INTERVAI

4,124,4473,493,9293,206,4392,776,0432,167,6201,963,2511,706,5471,550,3751,218,9501,085,560

915,115858,787806,563718,254705,099688, 719658,148648,506644,480618,256

603,970586,031580,036557,710444,685351,652321,634282,462225,369197,818

197, 818197,668195,428193,132182,333176,915167,392127,533122,988118,150


INTERVAL

23,42812,99711,6948,560

15,3296,8429,031

36,8493,611

11,458

6, 1978,0541,7421,516

490

4,9872,662

11,5867,598

313553

1, 57255,08949,018

898

14,912

1502,2402,1071,7461, 9824, 165

33,8524,4194,818

20,126

RETMTRATIO

0.00570.00370.00360.00310.00710.00350.00530.02380.00300.0106

0.00680.00940.00220.00210.00070.00000.00760.00410.01800.0123

0.00050.00090.00270.09880.11020.00260.00000.00000.06620.0000

0.00080.01130.01080.00900.01090.02350.20220.03470.03920.1703

SURVRATIO

0.99430.99630.99640.99690.99290.99650.99470.97620.99700.9894

0.99320.99060.99780.99790.99931.00000.99240.99590.98200.9877

0.99950.99910.99730.90120.88980.99741.00001.00000.93381.0000

0.99920.98870.98920.99100.98910.97650.79780.96530.96080.8297


79.3878.9378.6478.3578.1177.5677.2976.8875.0574.83

74.0473.5472.8572.6972.5472.4972.4971.9471.6470.36

69.4969.4569.3969.2062.3755.4955.3555.3555.3551.69

51.6951.6551.0650.5150.0549.5148.3538.5737.2335.77


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

244of317






79.580.581.582.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89.590.591.592.593. 5


97,99796,80776,07674,58271,19871,00970,94258,28958, 12857,554

57,55418,6162,363

91


INTERVAL

1,19020,731

9423,385

18868

1, 204161574

14,23928

RETMTRATIO

0.01210.21410.01240.04540.00260.00100.01700.00280.00990.0000

0.24740.00150.00000.0000

5URVRATIO

0,98790.78590.98760.95460.99740.99900.98300.99720.99011.0000

0.75260.99851.00001.0008


29. 6829.3223.0422.7621.7221.6721.6421.2821.2221.01

21. 0115.8115.7915.7915.79


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

245of317

CICI

K"rn ~ &

H 0re 0~ru

H&g+ 0 rn

0ro 0

g N Ms:

880 H

0H

0

C &ID

UJ0

CICI

BNIRIRBAS J.N30bI3d

I


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

246of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE





INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0.00.51.5

3.54.55.56.57.58.59. 5

10.511.512.513.514.51516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

689,708,060649,926,738627,094,362609,693,865591, 074, 842562,534,460514,468,742483,729,569454,926,771423,541,826

403, 785, 155388,541,343377,073,048363,914,087347,634,924324, 783, 813293,767,596267,230,287247,873,176230,369,750

218,287,406208,947,698201,257,479190,084,689178,840,378166,485,967157,609,545144,132,042132,434,051115,814,903

104,685,13694,758,66688,793,28282,001,43571,777,52465,279,06962,585,86658,077,69452,616,58548,523,684

7,920,804390,280

1,297,2333,461,2762,599,8293,597,1912,907,6113,394,3292,718,4344,043,3953,905,2402,910,3643,496,8291,876,7023,666,7152,959,6691,660,9482,742,9714,022,8394,739,667

3,020,6932,408,6933,433,7522,270,6862,068,4182,239,1202,456,7341,881,7941,936,0731,651,563

1,607,4241,023,3031,484,5591,368,3051,098,511

881,3281,190,7161,066,356

798,659740,199

0.01150.00060.00210.00570.00440.00640.00570.00700.00600.0095

0.00970.00750.00930.00520.01050.00910.00570.01030.01620.0206

0. 01380.01150.01710.01190.01160.01340.01560.01310.01460.0143

0.01540.01080.01670.01670.01530.01350.01900. 01840.01520.0153

0.98850.99940.99790.99430.99560.99360.99430.99300.99400.9905

0.99030.99250.99070.99480.98950.99090.99430.98970.98380.9794

0.98620.98850.98290.98810.98840.98660.98440.98690.98540.9857

0.98460.98920.98330.98330.98470.98650. 98100.98160.98480.9847

100.0098.8598.7998.5998.0397.6096.9796.4295.7595. 18

94.2793. 3692.6691.8091.3290.3689.5489.0388.1286.69

84. 9083.7382.7681.3580.3879.4578.3877.1676.1575.04

73.9772.8372.0570.8469.6668.5967.6766.3865.1664.17


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

247of317






39.540.541,542.543.544.545.546,547.548.5

49.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578,5


44,007,37739,043,08435,173,17930,538,33726,716,72923, 122, 80420,280,84817,367,17715, 001, 52812,985,168

11,363,5389,575,4388,562,7817,342,4596,923,0936,468,2305,342,1614,792,4844,368,0234,031,1863,423, 8712,845,7972,700,6562,482,5982,089,1771,861,8281,641,8251,319,664

782,357597,710

583,772566,268528,521522,447431,934388,120312,320291,121274,604274,333


INTERVAL

758,740932,463597,280730,562389,551462,117727 127338,043520,569280,938

500,602425,650536,15899,496

173,596516,342371,710239,785146,883112,860

75,65597, 28141,16052,49349,32030,04369,374

135,2408,7257,764

7,69927,1205,736

79,53920,75616, 348

388532142

29,471

RETMTRATIO

0.01720.02390.01700.02390.01460.02000.03590.01950.03470.0216

0.04410.04450.06260.01360.02510.07980.06960.05000.03360.0280

0.02210.03420.01520.02110.02360.01610.04230.10250.01120.0130

0.01320.04790.01090.15220.04810.04210.00120.00180.00050.1074

SURVRAT I0

0.98280.97610.98300.97610.98540.98000.96410.98050.96530.9784

0.95590.95550.93740.98640.97490.92020.93040.95000.96640.9720

0.97790.96580.98480.97890.97640.98390.95770.89750.98880.9870

0.98680.95210.98910.84780.95190.95790.99880.99820.99950.8926


63.1962.1060.6259.5958.1757.3256.1754.1653.1051.26

50.1547.9445.8142.9442.3641,3038.0035.3633.5932.46

31. 5530.8529.8029.3428.7228.0527.5926.4323,7223.45

23.1522.8421.7521.5118.2417.3616.6316.6116.5816.57


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

248of317






79.580.581.582.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89.590.591.592.593.594, 5

95.596.597.598.5

99.5100.5101.5102.5103.5104.5105.5106.5107.5


238,428161,867152,980136,967127,575125,598116,938105,029101,95194,847

75,87372,53935,72026,07224,83520,9252,0572,0572,0572,057

2, 0572,0572,0572,0572,0572,0572,0572,057


INTERVAL

2451, 140

11,7109,2771,9388,212

87621

2,243

213

17,943

RETMTRATIO

0.00100.00700.07650.06770.01520.06540.00070.00590.02200.0000

0.00280.00000.00000.00000.00000.85750.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.0000'.0000

0.00000.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

0.99900.99300.92350.93230.98480.93460.99930.99410.97801.0000

0.99721.00001.00001.00001.00000.14251.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000


14. 7914 .7814.6713.5512.6312.4411.6311.6211.5511.29

11.2911.2611.2611.2611.2611.261.611.611.611.61

1.611.611.611.611.611.611.611.611.61


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

249of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0. 0

0,51.52.53.54,55.56.57.58.59.5

10.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5


621,125,850586,736,195567,239,265555,107,227541, 850, 158516,983,768473,348,401446,873,287423,035,307395,056,567

378,877,477366,411,536356,432,110344,547,667328,853,463307,037,075277,772,703252,362,170233,970,370217,297,612

206,895,572198,912,605191,966,499181, 684, 747171,966,960160,300,258152,243,672139,697,336129,059,973112,852,680

101,730,36191,703,76485,826,31079,153,83269,182,18562,909,32060,312,09055,950,42750,655,23746,585,503


INTERVAL

7,911,144241,071739,359

2,689,9341,710,6972,476,1872,063,6642,209,8172,070,3703,528,9583,193,7092,455,6803,189,0131,566,1923,240,4262,310,9861,306,8592,399,0023,512,9463,929,1892,640,0532,008,7393,002,9741,690,3751,650,0731,904,9911,917,2501,670,6211, 708, 1271,590,0641,494,503

845,1811,315,3521,116,038

909,688750,834

1,024,043957,017715,801672,603

RETMTRATIO

0.01270,00040.00130.00480.00320.00480.00440.00490.00490.0089

0.00840.00670.00890.00450.00990.00750.00470.00950.01500. 0181

0.01280.01010.01560.00930.00960.01190.01260.01200.01320.0141

0.01470.00920.01530.01410.01310.01190.01700.01710.01410.0144

SURVRATI0

0.98730.99960.99870.99520.99680.99520.99560.99510.99510.9911

0.99160.99330.99110.99550.99010.99250.99530.99050.98500.9819

0.98720.98990.98440.99070.99040.98810.98740.98800.98680.9859

0.98530.99080.98470.98590.98690. 98810. 98300.98290.98590.9856

PCT SURVBEGIN OFlNTERVAL

100.0098.7398.6998.5698.0897.7797.3096.8896.4095.93

95. 0794.2793.6492.8092.3891.4790.7890.3589.4988.15

86.5585.4584.5983.2682.4981.7080.7379.7178.7677.71

76.6275.4974.8073.6572.6171.6670.8069.6068.4167.44


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

250of317






39. 5

40.541.542.543.544.545.546.547.548.5

49.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59. 5

60.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5

EXPOSURES ATSEGINN1NG OFAGE INTERVAL

42,140,70737,345,30433,516,19829,041,93325,365,35221,821,55319,106,96416,331,39214,098,55712,213,834

10,700,1218,934,9058,062,0406,908,8716,533,5276,148,7585,068,7914, 521, 5834,101,7023,841,2693,244,8422, 690, 1812,551,3812,336,8471,952,1531,754,7631,538,6511,216,877

755,587573,458

563,002551,090523,084520,410431,899388,120312,320291,121274,604274,333


INTERVAL

690,644845,889452,404583,857268,393332,934598,398219,097389,087190,989

485,994327,050487,73993,127

155,461498,371369,317235,907101,516102,266

54,66192,87937,76743,76649,32026,15269,37469,9996,2074,282

2, 10717,3792,336

77,53720,72116, 348

388532142

29,471

RETMTRATIO

0.01640.02270.01350.02010.01060.01530.03130.01340.02760.0156

0.04540.03660.06050.01350.02380.08110.07290.05220.02470.0266

0.01680.03450.01480. 01870.02530.01490.04510.05750.00820.0075

0.00370.03150.00450.14900.04800.04210.00120.00180.00050.1074

SURVRATIO

0.98360.97730.98650.97990.98940.98470.96870.98660.97240.9844

0.95460.96340.93950.98650.97620.91890.92710.94780.97530.9734

0.98320.96550.98520.98130.97470. 98510,95490.94250.99180.9925

0.99630.96850.99550. 85100.95200.95790.99880.99820.99950.8926

PCT SURVBEGIN OFINTERVAI

66.4765.3863.9063.0461.7761.1260.1858.3057.5255.93

55.0652.5550.6347.5746.9345.8142.1039.0336.9936.08

35. 1234.5333.3332.8432.2331.4130.9429.5527.8527.62

27.4127.3126.4526.3322.4121.3320.4320.4120.3720.36


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

251of317


ACCOUNT 362 STAT1ON EQUIPMENT




79.580.581. 5

82.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89,590.591.592.593.594.595.596.597.598.5

99.5100.5101.5102.5103.5104.5105.5106.5107.5


238,428161,867152,980136,967127,575125,598116,938105,029101,95194,847

75,87372,53935,72026,07224,83520,9252,0572,0572,0572,057

2, 0572,0572,0572,0572,0572,0572,0572,057


INTERVAL

2451, 140

11,7109,2771,9388,212

87621

2,243

213

17, 943

RETMTRATIO

0.00100.00700.07650.06770.01520.06540.00070.00590.02200.0000

0.00280.00000.00000.00000.00000.85750.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

0.99900.99300.92350.93230.98480.93460.99930.99410.97801.0000

0.99721.00001.00001.00001.00000.14251.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000


18.1718.1618.0316.6515.5215.2814.2814.2714.1913.88

13. 8813,8413.8413.8413. 8413.841.971.971.971.97

1.971.971.971.971.971.971.971.971.97


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

252of317

CICl

m III

E

'C Dr

III ro ™(o z c'o

EE IIICIIL'E

OE

E

Grc Ill c'E

a ~uE a, CE0

z

In

~zz

H0U~ o

ZUJEg

CICI CI

InCI

BNIAIABRS J.N30kI3d


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

253of317

ENERGY PROGRESS

ACCOUNT 364 POLES, TOWERS AND FIXTURES

ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE

PIACEMENT BAND 1908-2016 EXPERIENCE BAND 1954-2016


0.00.51.52.5

4.55.56.57.58.5

10.511.512.513.514 .515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5


795, 179, 951759, 853, 923754, 821, 361703,289,887696,331,239670, 408, 887639,230,899601,300,462582,418,823565,627,613

550, 864, 581533, 473, 370514,775,203494,213,401471,318,603455,357,801426, 641, 457411,720,715367, 033, 319360, 905, 100

344,985,284295, 771, 588281, 062, 329268, 066, 624254, 967, 120239, 977, 485220, 846, 040204,523,311187, 505, 365170,310,780

152,436, 907137,600,609124, 061, 964112,525,329101,586,711

91, 281, 97580,443,69273,246,69666, 588, 75859, 963, 166


INTERVAL

472, 6563, 871, 1392, 750, 9032,361,7112,898,7132,334,4892, 347, 9622, 034, 822I, 874, 5601,819,887

1, 894, 4512, 097, 7842, 033, 9141, 960, 2772,259,7952, 321, 9032,206,0051, 918, 047I, 793, 7132,098,760

2, 325, 718I, 790, 3481, 790, 1651,794,7412, 089, 2742I272,1802,047,5741,874,3091, 731, 1831,687,416

1, 068, 007941, 467859,893771,552671, 586

I, 947, 515800,483

1, 184, 329581,703

3,210,562

RETMTRATIO

0.00060.00510.00360.00340.00420.00350.00370.00340.00320.0032

0.00340.00390.00400.00400.00480.00510.00520.00470.00490.0058

0.00670.00610.00640.00670,00820.00950.00930.00920.00920.0099

0.00700.00680.00690.00690.00660.02130.01000.01620.00870.0535

SU RV

RATIO

0.99940.99490.99640.99660.99580.99650.99630.99660.99680.9968

0.99660.99610.99600.99600.99520.99490.99480.99530.99510.9942

0.99330.99390.99360.99330.99180.99050.99070.99080.99080.9901

0.99300,99320.99310.99310.99340.97870.99000.98380.99130.9465


100.0099.9499.4399.0798.7498.3397.9897.6297.2996.98

96. 6796. 3495. 9695. 5895.2094.7494.2693.7793.3392.88

92. 3491.7291.1690.5889.9789.2488.3987.5786.7785.97

85.1284.5283.9483.3682.7982.2480.4979.6978.4077.71

g GannettFleming Vll-190 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

254of317






39.540.541.542.543.5

45,546.547.548

50.5

52.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.5

64.565.566.567.568.5

69.570,571.572.573.574,575.576.577.578.5

79. 5

80.581.582.5


51,898,59044,065,92838,583,25630,433,80022,737,38117,857,06913,556,81310,217,6367,881,6274, 853, 611

3,101,2312,247,8241,715, 6331, 132, 374

994, 132954, 097901,497880,876879, 816870,296

769, 120717, 054715, 824710,400710,010526, 900344, 992211, 336123, 903

61, 041

2, 4152, 2382, 238

101010

9

9

99


INTERVAL

2, 732, 6502I 011 I 9513, 271, 6661,542,706

699, 942473, 548565, 56S

1, 587, 3422,279,105

950,402

169, 330126, S95274,057

67, 10140, 03652, 60020, 621

1, 0609, 520

101, 175

52,0661, 2302, 769

390181,266181, 908133,57487I40262,86258, 625

2, 22800

0

RETMTRATIO

0.05270.04570.08480.05070.03080.02650.04170.15540.28920.1958

0.05460.05650.15970.05930.04030.05510.02290.00120.01080.1163

0.06770.00170.00390.00050.25530.34520.38720.41360.50740.9604

0.00000.00000.99570.00100.00520.00630.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00001.0000

SURVRATIO

0.9473

0.91520.94930.96920.97350.95830.84460.71080.8042

0.94540.94350.84030.94070.95970.94490.97710.99880.98920.8837

0.93230.99830.99610.99950.74470.65480.61280.58640.49260.0396

1.00001.00000.00430.99900.99480.99371.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.0000


73.5569.6866.5060.8657.7756.0054.5152.2444.1231.36

25.2223.8422.5018.9017.7817.0716.1315.7615.7415.57

13.7612.8312.8112.7612.759.496.223.812.231.10

0. 040.040.040.000.000.000.000.000.000.00

0.000.000.00


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

255of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0.00.51.5

3.54.55.56.57.58.5

10.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.51S.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29. 5

30.531.532.533.534.5

36.537.538.5


716, 686, 722685,355,449684,278,768637,210,707633, 573, 130612, 910, 517586, 249, 132552, 855, 865537,426,110524,115,050

512, 831, 368498,733,784482,677,459464,890,279443,875,764429, 923, S94403, 036, 814389, 223, 286348,408,169343, 534, 972

329, 147, 667281, 129, 643267,816,810256, 290, 775244,544,328230,895,043213,374,731200,829,642183,813,549166,858,042

149, 391, 811134, 931, 600121, 555, 002110, 112 I 013

99, 302, 54589, 135, 91278, 526, 36771,540,19764,940,89958,470, 929


INTERVAL

385,8073,686,4362,551,3992, 092, 9182, 679, 5902, 094, 7442, 091, 8081,766,7521, 549, 4031, 546, 579

1, 561, 9491, 756, 7621, 662, 6161,560, 8551, 811, 4981,871,2991,763,2371,534,0151,406,1911, 664, 421

1, 945, 7471,414,4421, 416, 6701,408,3341,722,4611, 893, 8611,711,4781, 606, 8321, 503, 8241, 452, 678

847,055767,014705,853628,438554,291

1,763,13569S,035

1, 133, 642497, 919

3, 153, 919

RETMTRATIO

0.00050.00540.00370.00330.00420.00340.00360.00320.00290.0030

0.00300.00350.00340.00340.00410.00440.00440.00390.00400.0048

0.00590.00500.00530.00550.00700.00820.00800.00800.00820.0087

0.00570.00570.00580.00570.00560.01980.00890.01580.00770.0539

SURVRATIO

0.99950.99460.99630.99670.99580.99660.99640.99680.99710.9970

0.99700.99650.99660.99660.99590.99560.99560.99610.99600.9952

0.99410.99500.99470.99450.99300.99180.99200.99200.99180.9913

0.99430.99430.99420.99430.99440.98020.99110.98420.99230.9461


100.0099.9599.4199.0498.7198.3097.9697.6197.3097.02

96.7396.4496.1095.7795.4495.0594.6494.2393.8693.48

93.0292.4792.0191.5291.0290.3889.6488.9288.2187.48

86. 7286.2385.7485.2484.7684.2882.6281. 8880.5879.97

QX GannettFleming VII-192 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

256of317






39.540.541.542.543.544.5

46.547.548.5

49.550.551.552.553.554.555.5

57.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.5

67.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5

79. 5

80. 581.582.5


50, 581, 15742,788,58437, 332, 63829,212,71921, 538, 90216, 711, 94212,454,488

9, 162, 4616, 874, 1543, 872, 537

2, 137, 5961,715,5101, 432, 953

896, 371812,795846, 571875, 912880,834879, 774870,286

769, ill717, 044715,814710, 391710, 001526, 890344, 992211, 336123I 90361,041

2, 4152, 2382, 238

101010

9

99

9


INTERVAL

2,708, 8591, 986, 8383,243, 9171,521,176

648,235455,437542,796

1,572,3052,272,745

944, 609

166, 248126, 037268, 932

62, 21919, 66212, 20610, 290

1, 0609, 487

101,175

52, 0661, 2302, 769

390181,266181,908133, 57487,40262,86258, 625

2, 2280

0

0

RETMTRATIO

0.05360.04640.08690.05210.03010.02730.04360.17160.33060.2439

0.07780.07350.18770.06940.02420,01440.01170.00120.01080.1163

0.06770.00170.00390.00050.25530.34520.38720.41360.50740.9604

0.00000.00000.99570.00100.00520.00630.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00001.0000

SURVRATIO

0. 94640.95360,91310.94790.96990.97270.95640.82840.66940,7561

0.92220.92650.81230.93060.97580.98560.98830.99880.98920.8837

0.93230.99830.99610.99950.74470.65480.61280.58640.49260.0396

1.00001.00000.00430.99900.99480.99371.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.0000


75.6571.6068.2862.3459.1057.3255.7653.3344.1829.57

22.3620.6219.1015.5214.4414.0913.8913.7313.7113.56

ll. 9811. 1711.1511.1111.108.275.413.321,950.96

0.040.040.040.000.000.000.000.000.000.00

0.000.000.00


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

257of317

ClC

MCQ

ro ct t-t

8 c'uf, Q M

0g ct~ ct r.

rq rl ct

g ro M

5 0

C &Itt ~

rur0

CI

BNIRIRBIIS J.N9389d

Cl Ct Ct


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

258of317



ORIGINAL LlFE TABLE



0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.5

1, 1071, 004

942881854828793736710687

772,510929,863316,200392,839731 137106,490344,088445,351045,356183,554



INTERVAL

9, 179, 16312,729,0969,370,2893,252,8874,524,9247,878,1988,428,9233,992,5713, 115, 1884,391,121

RETMTRATIO

0.00830.01270.00990.00370.00530.00950.01060.00540.00440.0064

SURVRATIO

0.99170.98730.99010.99630.99470.99050.98940.99460.99560.9936


100.0099.1797.9296.9496.5896.0795.1694.1593.6493.23

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

1920.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29. 5

30.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

665648623599565533487465389378

361305289276266251234213191175

161149139130121113106

978881

864,548354,336105,212374,137731,090942,443377,690804,392155,942255,294

428,684965,353674,765270,050576,182512,054784,861530,343263,713196,081

205,627775,078153,826269,097640,520645,581111,303851,431608,310814,953

3,090,6885,652,9645,287,6335,685,8086,924,7114,629,8724,105,9283,591,9914,005,6773,936,3185,085,5863,444,7532,325,9602,702,2133,525,0053,027,8512,096,1172,075,3032,160,4561,684,4762,312,4801,371,9751,096,0601,730,664

855,4071,053,827

772,047836,574588,208436,602

0.00460.00870.00850.00950.01220.00870.00840.00770.01030.0104

0.01410.01130.00800.00980.01320.01200.00890.00970.01130.0096

0.01430.00920.00790,01330.00700.00930.00730.00850.00660.0053

0.99540.99130.99150.99050.98780.99130.99160.99230.98970.9896

0.98590.98870.99200.99020.98680.98800.99110.99030.98870.9904

0.98570.99080.99210.98670.99300.99070.99270.99150.99340.9947

92. 6392.2091.4090.6289.7688.6687.8987.1586.4885.59

84.7083.5182.5781.9181.1080.0379.0778.3677.6076.72

75.9974.9074.2173.6372.6572.1471.4770.9570.3469.87


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

259of317






39,540.541.542.543.544.545.546.547.548.5

49.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.5'7.5

68.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5


77,871,77475,341,79571,184,14762,914,92257,529,56851,066,44238,337,04630,053,73121,646,67517,172,779

12,622,4919,239,2087,134,1045,605,3175,100,8774,828,2734,554,4144,391,8234,253,7874,133,0404,047,3413,965,2433,915,7793,707,8263,617,9303,264,2103,096,3262,924,7862,890,5621,848,014

1, 811, 7061,792,6441,333,6861,333,686

228,0931111

1


INTERVAL

768,713615,951631,916

1,193,1591,269,3713,285, 1994,694,8784,817,1132,071,4341,165,425

735,490506,846364,288293,72976,92464,30731, 99868,474

105,37658,311

59,71543,248

207,95489,895

353,720167,884171,54034,224

1,042,54836,308

19,063458,957

1,105,593228,092

RETMTRATIO

0.00990.00820.00890.01900.02210.06430.12250.16030.09570.0679

0.05830.05490.05110.05240.01510.01330.00700.01560.02480.0141

0.01480.01090.05310.02420.09780.05140.05540.01170.36070.0196

0.01050.25600.00000.82901.00000.00000.00000.00000.65520.0000

SURVRATIO

0.99010.99180.99110. 98100.97790.93570.87750.83970.90430.9321

0.94170.94510.94890.94760.98490.98670.99300.98440.97520.9859

0.98520.98910.94690.97580.90220.94860.94460.98830.63930.9804

0.98950.74401.00000.17100.00001.00001.00001.00000.34481.0000


69.5068.8268.2567.6566.3664.9060.7253.2944.7540.47

37.7235.5233.5731.8630.1929.7329.3429.1328.6827.97

27.5727.1726.8725.4424.8322.4021.2520.0719.8312. 68

12.4312.309.159.151.570.000.000.000.000.00

79.580.5

1 1.0000 0.00


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

260of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0.00.51.52. 5

3.54.55.56.57.58.5

9.510.511.512.51314.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29. 5

30.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5


1,015,007,666913,647,846854,902,777801,025,723776,706,035756,910,127733,649,743681, 847, 851659,870,851641, 408, 854

624,604,171612,244,658590,114,452571,294,502541,220,645511,460,655467,155,928446,803,618372,245,031362,547,920

347,882,119293,747,295279,104,858267,515,424258,284,502243,954,151227,729,134207,159,065185,376,736169,639,658

154,934,841143,943,773133,668,394125,304,677116,328,174108,495,118101,158,606

92, 837, 31583,768,87377,266,785


INTERVAL

9,046,61812,587,885

9, 189, 9683,046,2144,271,5117,610,0588,095,8773,645,9302,790,8064,029,2432,688,9215,198,3474,793,7865,154,4266,292,3584,053,4463,540,5263,172,0173,550,8793,473,6724,680,3693,064,9591,970,1882,314,9083,156,8262,666,6451,766,6171,826,6691,985,4451,444,8312,147,4121, 198,413

952,5301,628,668

742,166921,470710,979780,058505,837397,296

RETMTRATIO

0.00890.01380.01070.00380.00550.01010.01100.00530.00420.0063

0.00430.00850.00810.00900.01160.00790.00760.00710.00950.0096

0.01350.01040.00710.00870.01220.01090.00780.00880.01070.0085

0.01390.00830.00710.01300.00640.00850.00700.00840.00600.0051

SURVRATIO

0.9911Q.98620.98930.99620.99450.98990.98900.99470.99580.9937

0.99570.99150.99190.99100.98840.99210.99240.99290.99050.9904

0.98650.98960.99290.99130.98780.98910.99220.99120.98930.9915

0.98610.99170.99290.98700.99360.99150.99300.99160.99400.9949


100.0099.1197.7496.6996.3295.8094.8393.7993.2892.89

92.3191.9191.1390.3989.5788.5387.8387.1686.5485.72

84.9083.7682.8882.3081.5880.5979.7179.0978.3977.55

76.8975,8375.1974.6673.6973.2272.6072.0971.4871.05


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

261of317






39. 540.541.542.543.544.545.546.547.548.5

49.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5


73,553,59371,100,94067,001,80058,803,17553,547,74247,174,13834,508,80827,371,18618,990,26514, 714, 086

10,301,2737,054,2805,110,3134,785,0434,280,6094,008,0523,752,7364,049,3693,911,3533,790,6063,932,9993,857,7963,813,3853,605,4313,515,5363,263,6623,095,7782,924,2382,890,0141, 848, 014

1,811,7061,792,6441,333,6861,333,686

228,09311111


INTERVAL

743,726593,193596,872

1,175,9751,259,2303,260,8654,658,0254, 806, 3132,068,6431,138,097

734,953505,727364,260293,72376,87764,30731,99868,474

105,37658,311

59,71543,248

207,95489,895

289,327167,884171,54034,224

1,042,54836,308

19,063458,957

1,105,593228,092

RETMTRATIO

0.01010.00830.00890.02000.02350.06910,13500.17560.10890.0773

0.07130.07170.07130.06140.01800.01600.00850,01690.02690.0154

0.01520.01120.05450.02490.08230.05140.05540.01170.36070.0196

0.01050.25600.00000.82901.00000.00000.00000.00000,65520.0000

SURVRATIO

0.98990.99170.99110.98000.97650.93090.86500.82440.89110.9227

0.92870.92830.92870.93860.98200.98400.99150.98310.97310.9846

0.98480.98880.94550.97510.91770.94860.94460.98830.63930.9804

0.98950.74401.00000.17100.00001.00001.00001.00000.34481.0000


70.6869.9769.3868.7767.3965.8161.2652.9943.6838.93

35.9133.3530.9628.7526.9926.5026.0825.8625.4224.73

24.3523. 9823.7222.4221.8620.0619.0317. 9817. 7711.36

11. 1311.028.208.201,400.000.000.000.000.00

79.580.5

1 1.0000 0.00


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

262of317

B5g U

0U 0

U

ruf42 rn

re

I

i0

0

o&~zru5

o o

ONWr ans &NaOVad

QÃ GannettFleming Vll-199 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

263of317


ACCOUNT 366 UNDERGROUND CONDUIT

ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE





INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0. 0

0.51.52.53.54,55.56.57.58.5

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521,522.523.524,525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

193,050,105187,145,127181,202,745167,087,074150,202,931133,116,648123,642,423120,676,211117,849,846113,691,147

108,555,538103,690,33596,233,93589,124,77382,993,62780,078,27970,856,07067,303,65453,191,54353,041,297

49,479,82338,138,52534,151,80231,761,25529,740,70525,100,22922,589,79819, 180, 82811,549,9058,369,0615,834,7004,710,8213,928,4973,303,8323,051,6342, 671, 6862,253,7672,113,5991,788,2941,701,023

294, 414114,972

81,78341,40627,35634,31521,08017,97122,52423,385

24,11524,35617,94510,85323,76791,82555,44094,33041,26070,832

446,111139,787186,728366,356259,406333,169179,683303,693133,02251,099

95 191100,576192,068134,35357,169

173,303114,638270,84120,61216,763

0.00150.00060.00050.00020.00020.00030.00020.00010.00020.0002

0.00020.00020.00020.00010.00030.00110.00080.00140.00080.0013

0.00900.00370.00550.01150.00870.01330.00800.01580.01150.0061

0.01630.02130.04890.04070.01870.06490.05090.12810.01150.0099

0.99850.99940.99950.99980.99980.99970.99980,99990.99980.9998

0.99980.99980.99980.99990.99970.99890.99920.99860.99920.9987

0.99100.99630.99450.98850.99130.98670.99200.98420.98850.9939

0.98370.97870.95110.95930.98130.93510.94910. 87190.98850.9901

100.0099.8599.7999.7499.7299.7099.6799.6699.6499.62

99.6099.5899.5699,5499.5299.5099.3899.3099.1799.09

98.9698.0697.7097.1796.0595.2193.9593.2091.7390.67

90. 1288.6486.7582. 5179.1677.6772.6368.9460.1159.41


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

264of317








INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


39.540.541.542.543.544,545,546.547.548.5

49.550.551,552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59. 5

60.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571,572.5

1,296,6281,278,6471,235,573

973,743498,402223,574176,021140,84022,83016,582

1,8001,325

144144144144144144144144

144144

3

3

3

3

3

3

3

3

14,6039,770

11,9448,8595,8241,8565,3141,7804,825

109

1, 106

74

0.01130.00760.00970.00910.01170.00830.03020.01260.21140.0066

0.00000.83470.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.51380.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00001.0000

0.98870.99240.99030.99090.98830.99170.96980.98740.78860.9934

1.00000.16531.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00000.48621.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.0000

58,8358.1657.7257.1656.6455.9855.5253.8453.1641.92

41. 6541. 656.896.896.896.896.896.896.896.89

6.896.893.353.353.353.353.353.353.353.35

3.353.353.35


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

265of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE





INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.5

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

190,061,042184,408,428178,641,890164,824,637148,515,071131, 762, 897122,529,496119,734,649117,180,073113,166,212

108,161,542103,345,13495,943,19488,840,44282,713,47079,802,71470,589,05767,047,46153,176,13753,026,051

49,464,77138,123,50934,149,89931,760,34729,737,49425,094,82822,584,56619,176,05411,546,5398,365,702

5,831,3694,707,5013,925,1773,300,5123,048,3142,668,2892,250,3702,110,2021,784,8971,697,626

292,793113,68580,05340,95126,42234,05820,34017,82922,43123 312

24,02822,71917,86710,41823,32191,51755,30394,27241,26070,639

446,111139,447186,075366,328259,154333,151179,552301,194133,01551,071

95,180100,576192,068134,35357,169

173,303114,638270,84120,61216,763

0.00150.00060.00040.00020.00020.00030.00020.00010.00020.0002

0.00020.00020.00020.00010.00030.0011o.oooa0.00140.00080.0013

0.00900.00370.00540.01150.00870.01330.00800.01570.01150.0061

0. 01630.02140.04890.04070.01880.06490.05090.12830.01150.0099

0.99850.99940.99960.99980.99980.99970.99980.99990.9998o.9998

0.99980.99980.99980.99990.99970.99890.99920.99860.99920.9987

0.99100.99630.99460.98850.99130.98670.99200.98430.98850.9939

0.98370.97860.95110.95930.98120.93510.94910.87170.98850.9901

100.0099.8599,7899.7499.7199.7099.6799.6599.6499.62

99.6099.5899.5699.5499.5399.5099.3899.3199.1799.09

98.9698.0797.7197.1796.0595.2293.9593.2191.7490.68

90.1388.6686.7782.5279.1677,6872.6368.9360.0859.39


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

266of317






39. 5

40.541. 5

42.543.544.545 546. 547.548.5

49.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.5


1,293,2311,275,2501,232,176

970,346495,005220,177172,624139,65721,64715,399

6171, 248

676767676767

144144

144144

3

3

3

3

3

3

3

3


1NTERVAL

14,6039,770

11,9448,8595,8241,8563,1001,7804,825

109

1, 106

RETMTRATIO

0.01130.00770.00970.00910.01180.00840.01800.01270.22290.0071

0,00000.88620.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.51380.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00001.0000

5URVRATIO

0.98870.99230.99030.99090.98820.99160.98200.98730.77710.9929

1.00000.11381.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00000.48621.00001,00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.0000


58.8058. 1457.6957.1356.6155.9555.4854.4853.7841.80

41.5041.504.724.724.724.724.724.724.724.72

4. 724. 722.302.302.302.302.302.302.302.30

2.302.302.30


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

267of317

rnMro 0

UU D

g

RH

H

5'&~zIll5

BNIRIRBAS J.N3383d


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

268of317



OR1GINAL LIFE TABLE



0,00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.59.5

10.51112.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5


1,174,100,2011, 149, 928, 8401,117,276,0851,059,619,2571,041,379,152

996,852,684969,311,518924,000,762889,604,917846,721,479

802,900,573763,342,012705,658,320652,397,985597,165,209567,800,521502,401,315480,594,285387,330,770375,761,365

350,503,510271,092,506248,589,208232,441,393208,535,962183,069,672152,904,989125,868,69986,825,56959,310,257

31,807,90116,024,7116,919,0955,879,5644,857,5024,093,3223,566,0693,059,1232,532,4982,251,217


INTERVAL

1,403,2315,353,7462,453,8241,836,3861,783,0401,152,5121,239,1401,256,248

638,6831,006,620

740,3311,272,0102,017,4802,618,0903,234,7842,932,2972,767,5571,697,962

861,6401,040,2261,134,787

642,004905,761

3,827,5835,497,9764,250,2353,624,2042,472,1641,971,2671,342,478

1,342,3211,510,587

361,399199,221109, 18264,38825, 81851,40310,4869,257

RETMTRATIO

0.00120.00470.00220.00170.00170.00120.00130.00140.00070.0012

0.00090.00170.00290.00400.00540.00520.00550.00350.00220.0028

0.00320.00240.00360.01650.02640.02320.02370.01960.02270.0226

0.04220.09430.05220.03390.02250.01570.00720.01680.00410.0041

SURVRATIO

0.99880.99530.99780.99830.99830.99880.99870.99860.99930.9988

0.99910.99830.99710.99600.99460.99480.99450.99650.99780.9972

0.99680.99760.99640.98350.97360.97680.97630.98040.97730.9774

0,95780.90570.94780.96610.97750.98430.99280.98320.99590.9959


100.0099.8899.4299.2099.0398.8698.7498.6298.4898.41

98. 2998.2098.0497.7697.3796.8496.3495. Bl95.4795.26

94. 9994. 6994.4694. 1292.5790.1388.0385.9584.2682.35

80.4877.0969.8266.1763.9362.4961.5161.0760.0459.79


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

269of317








INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


39.540.541.542.543.544.545,546.547.548.5

49.550.551.552.553,554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.5

1,829,5791,629,9051,502,8651, 257, 0811,142,7931,064,7871,085,495

991,972893,341717,296

588,350527,859506,349486,718467,815414,584230,093230,082164,02052,903

161211

53

3

3

9, 792143

13,459

3

13,7402,8851, 004

45,20828,308

17,1763,3986,038

11,8964,885

30111

10551

0.00540.00010.00900.00000.00000.01290.00270.00100.05060.0395

0.02920.00640.01190.02440.01040.00070.00000.00050.00000.0000

0.24080.06940.56430.29330.00000.00001.0000

0.99460.99990.99101.00001.00000.98710.99730.99900.94940.9605

0.97080.99360. 98810.97560.98960.99931.00000.99951.00001.0000

0.75920.93060.43570.70671.00001.0000

59.5559.2359.2258.6958.6958.6957.9357.7857.7254.80

52.6451.1050.7750.1748.9448.4348.3948.3948.3748.37

48.3736. 7234.1814.8910.5210.5210.52


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

270of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



EXPOSURES ATBEG1NNING OFAGE INTERVAL


INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0.00.51.52.53.54,55.56.57.58.5

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

1920.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534,535.536.537.538.5

1, 154, 293, 1671,131,315,5591,100,707,2931,046,148,1611,030,420,991

987,708,945961,192,746917,749,962884,788,528842,957,437

799,963,226760,920,324703,616,575650,613,874595,579,203566,410,775501,208,487479,548,467386,503,282375,009,736

349,900,594270,595,130248, 271, 139232,232,244208,422,755182,967,560152,836,793125,813,19986,778,35159,264,479

31,762,35415,980,0196,875,1035,835,8384,815,5054,051,3323,524,3413,017,3952,490,7702,214,072

1,385,2535,338,0082,439,2961,830,6471,774,1741,141,3301,228,5591,227,185

632,7471,004,577

733,8181,261,9892,001,1382,613,8313,228,7882, 928, 1652,759,8291,696,147

860,1701,039,4811,131,579

637,301902,872

3,826,4695,496,5054,246,6523,623,4962,471,0731,969,8271,342,139

1,341,5571,509,887

361,160199,221109,18264,12625,81851,40310,4869,257

0.00120.00470.00220.00170.00170.00120.00130.00130.00070.0012

0.00090.00170.00280.00400.00540.00520.00550.00350.00220.0028

0.00320.00240.00360.01650.02640.02320.02370.01960.02270.0226

0.04220.09450.05250.03410.02270.01580.00730.01700.00420.0042

0.99880.99530.99780.99830.99830.99880.99870.99870.99930.9988

0.99910.99830.99720.99600.99460.99480.99450.99650.99780.9972

0.99680.99760.99640.98350.97360.97680.97630.98040.97730.9774

0.95780.90550.94750.96590.97730.98420.99270.98300.99580.9958

100.0099.8899.4199.1999.0198.8498.7398.6098.4798.40

98.2898.1998.0397.7597.3696.8396.3395.8095.4695.25

94.9994.6894.4694.1192.5690.1288.0385.9484.2582.34

80.4877.0869.7966.1363.8762.4261.4360.9859.9559.69


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

271of317








INTERVALRETMTRATIO

S URVRATIO


39.540.541.542.543,544.545.546.547.548.5

49.550.551.552.553.554,555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.5

1,803,1281,605,3301,478,2901,232,5061, 118,2181,040,2121,062,821

974,926882,323716,045

588,145527,751506,242486,718467,815414,584230,093230,082164,02052,903

161211

53

3

3

9, 614143

13,459

3

13,2642,885

71245,20828,308

17,1763,3986,038

11,8964,885

30111

10551

0.00530.00010.00910.00000.00000.01280.00270.00070.05120.0395

0.02920.00640.01190.02440.01040.00070.00000.00050.00000.0000

0.24080.06940.56430.29330.00000.00001.0000

0.99470.99990.99091.00001.00000.98720.99730.99930.94880.9605

0.97080.99360.98810.97560.98960.99931.00000.99951.00001.0000

0,75920.93060.43570.70671.00001.0000

59. 4459. 1359.1258.5858.5858.5857.8457.6857.6454.68

52.5250.9950.6650.0648.8348.3248.2948.2848.2648.26

48.2636.6434,1014.8610.5010.5010.50


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

272of317

ClCI

Z0 0M H

rs

g H 00g Ct M

Z

tYl 0H

0

o&tD p

lucg

CtO

BNIAIRBrIS LN3083d

Ct Ct


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

273of317


ACCOUNT 368 LINE TRANSFORMERS

ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE





INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0.00.51. 5

2.53.54.55.56.57.58.5

9.510.511.512.513.514.51516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

1, 1621,090

909889874861844815776720

714686636615612574542533514486

457414407386351333312284250210

177150129112

988883776962

692,340396,690202,397840,069945,266978,668899,260681,489816,505221,756

062,886052,371109,703810,603517,194421,938217,051476,666116,086783,484

689, 149063,524965,423852,902787,676032,118591,678125,789302,646520,152

255,969531,837015,006250,852946,857930,432969,363625,731638,821734,113

276,4772,231,7892,418,6102,180,9052,656,9982,650,8522,700,7193,578,0443,648,8472,588,3892,831,2462,880,4572,203,7192,550,7012,855,9993,728,8143, 878, 1285,313,9036,555,6209,299,5508,130,0305,346,4355,413,6795,063,0216,064,4268,063,6916,324,3247, 861,5114,754,9234,591,5362,917,1383,277,5863,395,9674,485,9221,268,9001,001,9091,529,3872,082,3891,557,3553,079,305

0.00020.00200.00270.00250.00300.00310.00320.00440.00470.0036

0.00400.00420.00350.00410.00470.00650.00720.01000. 01280.0191

0.01780.01290.01330.01310.01720.02420.02020.02770.01900. 0218

0.01650.02180.02630.04000.01280.01130. 01820.02680,02240.0491

0.99980.99800.99730.99750.99700.99690.99680.99560.99530.9964

0.99600.99580.99650.99590,99530.99350.99280.99000.98720.9809

0.98220.98710.98670.98690.98280.97580.97980.97230. 98100.9782

0.98350.97820.97370.96000.98720.98870.98180.97320.97760.9509

100.0099.9899.7799.5199.2698.9698.6698.3497.9197.45

97.1096,7196.3195.9795.5895.1394.5193.8492.9091.72

89.9788.3787.2386.0784.9483.4881.4679.8177.6076.13

74.4773. 2471. 6569.7666.9766.1165.3764.1862.4661.06


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

274of317



ORIGINAI LIFE TABLE, CONT.





INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


39. 540.541.542.543.544.545,546.547.548.549, 5

50.551.552.553.554,555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5

55,620,51651,852,90448,398,40241,565,50933,816,59626,940,12421,486,36915,521,57911,084,6309,101,1467,371,2895,446,6044,412,0023,557,1412,977,4552,590,2912,203,6991,930,8301,580,9801,401,3951,139,845

927,410661,337475,092286,773228,452178,601131,491117,73783,790

73,55664,01354,49554,49554,49554,49544,78925,14125,14123,997

3,073,7623,206,6892,669,4242, 892, 5153,745,6843,292,7601,941,1651,358,416

545,599577,231

1,010,699247,438101,10070,15368,51461,22168,41798,92744,61912,937

39,02636,96610,3539,050

16,8777,1507,8637,678

25,18610,234

9, 5449, 518

9,70619,648

1,144

0.05530.06180.05520.06960.11080.12220.09030.08750.04920.0634

0.13710.04540.02290.01970.02300.02360.03100.05120.02820.0092

0.03420.03990.01570.01900.05890.03130.04400.05840.21390.1221

0.12970.14870.00000.00000.00000.17810.43870.00000.04550.0000

0.94470.93820.94480.93040.88920.87780.90970.91250.95080.9366

0.86290.95460.97710.98030.97700.97640.96900.94880.97180.9908

0.96580.96010.98430.98100.94110.96870.95600.94160.78610.8779

0.87030.85131.00001.00001.00000.82190.56131.00000.95451.0000

58.0654.8551.4648.6245.2440.2335.3132.1229.3127.87

26.1022.5221.5021.0120.5920.1219.6419.0318.0617.55

17. 3916.7916.1215. 8715.5714.6514.1913.5712.7710.04

8.827.676.536.536.536.535.373.013.012.88


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

275of317






79.580.581.582.583.584. 585.586.587.588.5

89.590.591,592.593.594.595.596.597.5


23,99723,99723,99722,97122,97121,87921,87921,879

0

0


INTERVAL

1, 026

1, 092

21,879

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00000.04280.00000.04750.00000.00001.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00001.0000

SURVRATIO

1.00001.00000.95721.00000.95251,00001.00000.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000


2.882.882.882.752.752.622.622.620.000.00

0.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.00


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

276of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE





1NTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0.00. 5

1.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.5

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

1,047,224,648980,929,891802, 234, 841789,104,315781,747,194776,079,426763,718,653743,022,540712,088,021661,656,347

662,099,052639,131,641593,608,554576,742,013576,391,529541,038,174511,592,950505,074,145492,020,597466,252,283

439,504,577398,090,889394,420,382375,520,727342,669,311325,662,525307,605,817280,251,013246,897,101208,229,325

175,175,691148,550,328127,456,948110,771,28797,567,43287,649,77882,765,64576,437,80468,484,24861,649,207

121,1421,567,9471,583,1101,407,4281,886,3951,929,0132,080,2592,984,1813,024,4222,006,4932,260,2272,276,9221,619,0151,992,1682,220,7543,093,1563,333,5284,709,8435,847,0488,521,9007,280,8584,468,9774,492,1714,155,7254, 854, 4156,938,1616,008,6677,527,1624,395,2874,352,9972,747,2372,808,6523,294,6134,326,8201,124,832

918,4761,476,4382,022,6731,476,5533,021,507

0.00010.00160.00200. 00180.00240.00250.00270.00400.00420.0030

0.00340.00360.00270.00350.00390.00570.00650.00930.01190. 0183

0.01660.01120.01140.01110.01420.02130.01950.02690.01780.0209

0.01570.01890.02580.03910.01150.01050.01780.02650.02160.0490

0.99990.99840.99800.99820.99760.99750.99730.99600.99580.9970

0.99660.99640.99730.99650.99610.99430.99350.99070. 98810.9817

0.98340.98880.98860.98890.98580.97870.98050.97310.98220.9791

0.98430.98110.97420.96090.98850.98950.98220.97350.97840.9510

100.0099.9999.8399.6399.4599.2198.9798.7098.3097.88

97.5997.2596.9196.6496.3195.9495.3994.7793.8892.77

91.0789.5688.5687.5586.5885.3583.5481. 9079.7078.29

76. 6575.4574.0272.1169.2968.4967.7766.5764.8063.41

le% GannettFleming VII-213 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

277of317








INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


39. 5

40. 5

41.542.543.544.545.546. 547. 5

48.549.550.551. 552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5

54,658,65251,042,56747,705,69640,950,50533,273,28426,464,72921,070,28115,146,37010,801,7818,860,9487,171,3225,285,0264, 286, 1833,451,6702,917,5322,532,3172,155,0521,884,8061,537,3261,357,8821,102,529

919,481655,537474,764286,446228,124178,601131,491117,73783,790

73,55664,01354,49554,49554,49554,49544,78925,14125,14123,997

2,986,1523,134,0042,597,6992,821,2903,681,8463,243,5331,915,9141,333,463

519,418559,610

985,633226,471

BB, 04163,42366,92060,32867,10398,66844,53312,726

38,76436,96610,3539,050

16,8776,8237,8637,678

25,18610,234

9,5449,518

9, 70619, 648

1,144

0.05460.06140.05450.06890.11070.12260.09090.08800. 04810.0632

0.13740.04290.02050.01840.02290.02380.03110.05230.02900.0094

0.03520.04020. 01580.01910.05890.02990.04400.05840.21390.1221

0.12970. 14870.00000.00000.00000.17810.43870.00000.04550.0000

0.94540.93860.94550.93110.88930.87740.90910.91200.95190.9368

0.86260.95710.97950.98160.97710.97620.96890.94770.97100.9906

0.96480.95980.98420.98090.94110.97010.95600.94160.78610.8779

0.87030.85131.00001.00001.00000. 82190.56131.00000.95451.0000

60.3057.0053.5050.5947.1141.8936.7633.4230.4729.01

27. 1823.4422.4421.9821.5721.0820.5819.9318.8918.34

18.1717.5316.8316.5616.2515.2914.8314 . 1813.3510.50

9.218.026.836.836.836.835.613.153.153.01


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

278of317






79.580.581.582.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89.590.591.592.593.594.595.596.597.5


23,99723,99723,99722,97122,97121,87921,87921,879

0

0


INTERVAL

1,026

1, 092

21,879

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00000.04280.00000.04750.00000.00001.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00001.0000

SURVRATIO

1.00001.00000.95721.00000.95251.00001.00000.00001. 00001.0000

1,00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000


3.013.013. 012.882.882.742.742.740.000.00

0.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.00


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

279of317

CICI

)

Ul Mro roro U

H

o re~CI Prs ~ o

Ã r

0

H

H

0

C &IO ~

UJ5

BNIRIRBAS J.N3383d

CICV

CI


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

280of317


ACCOUNT 369 SERVICES

ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.5

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525,526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5


680,359,136639,708,190610,847,824577,191,469574, 832, 179564,084,402550,960,958537,788,380531,204,053512,258,106

488,300,122467,861,007444,056,932418,723,104392, 089, 133382,416,315344,883,365338,402,852289,586,936286,817,706

272,608,633221,440,536202,403,650184,232,719167,983,983151,970,166137, 168, 224121,356,309104,989,49989,862,053

77,555,98968,086,78859,123,25150,332,42743, 131, 48638,083,54432,983,44331,756,44130,143,65528,171,249


INTERVAL

745,3493,315,7381,962,8381,920,3561,520,4631,084,752

890, 147881,459867,129867,203

1,013,078861,629859,058924,531

1,240,009761,772653,432542,078628,772693,523

682,492529,187586,461834,406

1,197,7961,305,410

894, 081776,091495,374541,169

588,8892,429,2242,555,3012,155,1053,570,1673,734,080

699,419767,284

1,092,8901,466,072

RETMTRATIO

0.00110.00520.00320.00330.00260.00190.00160.00160.00160.0017

0.00210.00180.00190.00220.00320.00200.00190.00160.00220.0024

0.00250.00240.00290.00450.00710.00860.00650.00640.00470.0060

0.00760.03570.04320.04280.08280.09800.02120.02420.03630.0520

SURVRATIO

0.99890.99480.99680.99670.99740.99810.99840.99840.99840.9983

0.99790.99820. 99810.99780.99680.99800.99810.99840.99780.9976

0.99750.99760.99710.99550.99290.99140.99350.99360.99530.9940

0.99240.96430.95680.95720,91720.90200.97880.97580.96370.9480


100.0099.8999.3799.0598.7298.4698.2798.1197.9597.79

97.6397.4397.2597.0696.8496.5496.3596.1696.0195.80

95.5795.3395.1094.8394.4093.7292.9292.3191.7291.29

90.7490.0586.8483.0879.5372.9465.7964.4062.8460.56


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

281of317






39.540.541.542.543.544,545.546.547.548.5

49. 5

50.551.552,553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5


21,848,95220,529,45719, 182, 56617,258,80414,966,07813,292,56511,717,12510,562,1038,839,2967,376,3266,004,3644,927,0414,091,4803,489,4842,991,0892,647,6332,347,1041, 918, 3051,103,589

560, 871

248, 3 1491,15785,77683,44665,06354,76334,95923,3057,4632,233

503503

56565656565656


INTERVAL

808,096881, 377960,491

1,192,966815,799841,309838,408

1,073,8551,074,629

985,889

740,391654,326413,581348,518249,302204,885420,986768,968517,384255,945

144,3812,7782,330

18, 38210,30119,80411,65415,8415,2301,730

447

56

RETMTRATIO

0.03700.04290.05010.06910.05450.06330.07160.10170.12160.1337

0.12330.13280.10110.09990.08330.07740.17940.40090.46880.4563

0.58140.03050.02720.22030.15830.36160.33340.67980.70080.7746

0.00000.88780.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00001.0000

SURVRATIO

0.96300.95710.94990.93090.94550.93670.92840.89830.87840.8663

0.87670.86720.89890.90010.91670.92260.82060.59910.53120.5437

0.41860.96950.97280.77970.84170.63840.66660.32020.29920.2254

1.00000.11221.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000


57.4155.2952.9150.2646.7944.2441.4438.4734.5630.36

26.3023. 0620.0017. 9816. 1814. 8313.6811.236.733.57

1. 940. 810.790.770.600.500.320.210.070.02

0.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.00


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

282of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE

PLACEMENT BAND 1920-2016 EXPERlENCE BAND 1977 — 2016


0.00.51.52.53.54,55.56.57.58.59.5

10.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5


644,423,083606,136,738579,017,785548,203,819548,603,582540,951,784530,432,623519,179,832514,835,995497,541,767

475,152,709456,142,632433,315,522408,929,165383,072,318374,038,995337,193,739331,037,707282,954,125280, 518, 877

266,830,214216,201,054197,719,835180,029,147164,332,705148,741,115134,456,569119,554,541103,264,32488,205,958

75,957,77766,512,57657,599,34648,909,05641,837,26036,921,74331,937,36230,820,87029,309,13027,428,534


INTERVAL

720,7113,234,9041,883,6341,835,5061,420,772

965,459757,169747,794719,593709,023

856,706678,441698,442758,817

1,066,396590,957494,837414,654488,662559,046

557,598413,743491,574734,803

1,072,2651, 195, 826

825,390700,357456,931505,886

554,7032,374,8012,522,0902,135,2113,548,1713,718,853

684,618753,876

1, 082, 8151,457,632

RETMTRATIO

0.00110.00530.00330.00330.00260. 00180.00140.00140.00140.0014

0.00180.00150.00160.00190.00280.00160.00150.00130.00170.0020

0.00210.00190.00250.00410.00650.00800.00610.00590.00440.0057

0.00730.03570.04380.04370.08480.10070.02140.02450.03690.0531

SURVRATIO

0.99890.99470.99670.99670.99740.99820.99860.99860.99860.9986

0.99820.99850.99840.99810.99720.99840.99850.99870.99830.9980

0.99790.99810.99750.99590.99350.99200.99390.99410.99560.9943

0.99270.96430.95620.95630.91520.89930.97860.97550.96310.9469


100.0099.8999.3699.0398.7098.4498.2798. 1397.9997.85

97.7197.5397.3997.2397.0596.7896.63

96.3796.20

96. 0195. Bl95. 6295.3995.0094.3893.6293.0492.5092.09

91.5690.8987.6583.8180.1573.3565.9764.5562.9760.65


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

283of317








INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


39. 540.541. 542.543.544.545.546.547.548.5

49. 550.551.552.553.554,555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563,564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5

21,187,80819,934,65618,642,86316,769,30714,521,32012,890,59411,355,64410,244,0838,567,8967, 148, 283

5,823,7404,798,5193,993,6983,417,4772,939,8372,622,2632,342,0311,918,3051,103,589

560,871

248,31491,15785,77683,44665,06354,76334,95923,3057,4632,233

503503

56565656565656

803,400878,623959,039

1,190,692814,75384Q,380837,022

1,067,3351,069,893

977,413

740,230651, 928413,525346,093234,379189, 174418,440768,968517,384255,945

144,3812,7782,330

18,38210,30119,80411,65415,8415,2301,730

447

56

0.03790.04410.05140.07100.05610.06520.07370.10420.12490.1367

0.12710.13590.10350.10130.07970.07210.17870.40090.46880.4563

0.58140.03050.02720.22030.15830.36160.33340.67980.70080.7746

0.00000,88780.00000.00000.00000.0000O.OOQO0.00001.0000

0.96210.95590.94860.92900.94390.93480.92630.89580.87510.8633

0.87290.86410.89650.89870.92030.92790.82130.59910.53120.5437

0.41860.96950.97280.77970.84170.63840.66660.32020.29920.2254

1.00000.11221.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

57.4255.2552.8150.0946.5443.9341.0638.0434.0729.82

25.7422.4719.4217.4115.6414.4013.3610.976.573.49

1.900.790.770.750.580.490.310.210.070.02

0.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.00


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

284of317

B 0H

Hro

Ow5p Z M

c' 0

fu M

How!

m gH(3H

0 ™0

o&~ZUJ5

CI

C!

CICI

BNIRIRBflS INSD83d

CIf4

CI O


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

285of317


ACCOUNT 370 METERS AND METERING EQUIPMENT

ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE





INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0. 0

0.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.5

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29. 5

30.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

284,586,262283,616,227283,925,924281,466,531281,173,518275,361,805269,411,707264,572,017261,042,988252,502,854

247,482,980245,767,325178,301,043174,235,652170,933,888165,125,751164,554,678160,992,190156,725,824141,422,634

136,741,713129,214,461126,694,476120,103,540111,071,41498,387,58388,466,35476,311,86463,993,85945,380,77031,616,63020,360,70319,958,96319,176,31917,270,84415,574,12114,735,04413, 148, 67011,842,29810,574,170

1,099,631202,024579,326

1,032,981932,893

1,041,857631,044571,843590,204579,144

476,2931,615,757

405,490358,922519,901370,591508,073501,111

1,295,617683,523

1,209,1801,144,0431,424,7795,734,6748,883,7486,900,1297,303,9077,354,698

10,115,4266,759,8765,001,880

331,716609,782

1,838,9441,708,754

777,3431,579,4521,265,3111,174,632

954,570

0.00390.00070.00200.00370.00330.00380.00230.00220.00230.0023

0.00190.00660.00230.00210.00300.00220.00310.00310.00830.0048

0.00880.00890.01120.04770.08000.07010.08260.09640.15810.1490

0.15820.01630.03060.09590.09890,04990.10720.09620.09920.0903

0.99610.99930.99800.99630.99670.99620.99770.99780.99770.9977

0,99810.99340.99770.99790.99700.99780.99690.99690.99170.9952

0.99120.99110.98880.95230.92000.92990.91740.90360.84190.8510

0. 84180.98370.96940.90410.90110.95010.89280.90380.90080.9097

100.0099.6199.5499.3498.9798.6598.2798.0497.8397.61

97. 3997. 2096.5696.3496.1495.8595.6395.3495.0494.26

93. 8092. 9792. 1591.1186.7679.8274.2268.1061.5351.81

44.0937.1136.5135.3932.0028.8327.3924.4622.1019.91


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

286of317








INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO

PCT SURVBEGIN OFlNTERVAL

39.540.541.542.543.544.545,546.547.548.5

49.550.551.552.553.554,555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5

9,572,3668,633,1957,450,0445,876,0635, 090, 8184,469,3393,672,1922,930,8092,196,3421,426,742

820,681661,780465,569334,10992,92627 72127,37526,06226,02825,863

25,86324,99824,1499,8679,6992,1682,1681,9691,9691,969

1, 9461, 0121, 012

76766356433622

920,8041,178,0791,574,220

767,031621,700797, 381741,552732,857769,671606,091

158,908196,235131,477241,18365,205

3461,313

34165

872849

14,283168

7,531

199

23

935

935

147

137

13

0.09620.13650.21130.13050.12210.17840.20190.25010.35040.4248

0.19360.29650.28240.72190.70170.01250.04800.00130.00630.0000

0.03370.03390.59140.01700.77650.00000.09190.00000.00000.0114

0.48020.00000.92440.00000.17880.10690.23970.15740.37410.0000

0.90380.86350.78870.86950.87790. 82160.79810.74990.64960.5752

o.eoe40.70350.71760.27810.29830.98750.95200.99870.99371.0000

0.96630.96610.40860.98300.22351.00000. 90811.00001.00000.9886

0.51981.00000.07561.00000.82120.89310.76030.84260.62591.0000

18.1116.3714.1411.159.708.516.995.584.192.72

1.561.260.890.640.180.050.050.050.050.05

0.050.050.050.020.020.000.000.000.000.00

0.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.00

g GannettFleming Vll-223 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

287of317






79.580.581.582.583.584,585.586.587.588.5

89.590.591.592.593.5


222215151515151510

5


INTERVALRETMTRATIO

0.00000.32900.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.33130.49550.0000

0.00000.00000.00001.0000

8URVRATIO

1.00000.67101.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000.66870,50451.0000

1.00001.00001.0000


0.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.00

0.000.000.000.00


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

288of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



EXPOSURES ATBEGINNING QFAGE 1NTERVAL


INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0.00.51.52.53.54,55.56.57.58.5

9.510.511.512,51314. 5

15.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536,537.538.5

144,224,569149,864,559151,199,050154,294,928157,450,546156,579,121154,747,977155,961,220157,161,186159,971,456

165,053,834173,501,225113,957,033118, 583, 232119,849,731117,869,446121,389,238121, 481, 517120,581,316108,413,757

108,648,631104,690,851102,752,87296,961,96490,082,94579,523,41870,618,30060,206,99849,328,73932,070,113

19,860,8559,476,5749,831,041

10,221,2219,275,6858, 407, 8158,332,4527,446,9766,957,7606,298,717

378,348

10,96257,690

55,51183,9932,411

821,251,638

116,19984,189

192,52113, 889

165, 846182,326757,469229,804

844,481683,367980,759

5,256,0328,218,0356,433,7176,784,6996,780,5699,662,6065,921,611

4,822,857162,197372,134

1,610,0701,479,328

557,9041,322,101

858,009950,618746,289

0.00260.00000.00000.00010.00040.00000.00000.00040.00050.0000

0.00000.00720.00100.00070.00160.00010.00140.00150.00630.0021

0.00780.00650.00950.05420.09120.08090.09610.11260.19590.1846

0.24280.01710.03790.15750.15950.06640.15870.11520.13660.1185

0.99741.00001.00000.99990.99961.00001.00000.99960.99951.0000

1.00000.99280.99900.99930.99840.99990.99860.99850.99370.9979

0.99220.99350.99050.94580.90880.91910.90390.88740.80410.8154

0.75720.98290.96210.84250.84050.93360.84130.88480.86340.8815

100.0099.7499.7499.7499.7399.6999.6999.6999.6699.61

99.6099.6098.8998.7898.7198.5698.5498.4198,2697.64

97.4496.6896.0595.1389.9881.7775.1567.9360.2848.47

39.5229.9329.4128.3023.8420.0418.7115.7413.9312.02


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

289of317








INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


39. 540. 541. 542.543.544.545.546.547.548.5

49. 550,551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571,572.573.574.575.576,577.578.5

5,877,9645,505,3264, 811, 0763,632,4343,213,7272,924,9662,539,7712,799,5902,078,3961,322,863

732,419591,182405,714290,04164,6407,711

18,73018,49119,43919,302

21,31024,86124,0269,7669,6222,0922,0921,8921, 9061, 913

1, 904976989

545448412821

7

723,104999,187

1, 418, 698617,808523,767740,716709,082721,360755,590590,963

141,462185,605115,672232,90156,937

57389

9

137

872834

14,283151

7,531

199

23

935

935

147

137

13

0.12300. 18150.29490.17010.16300.25320.27920.25770.36350.4467

0.19310.31400.28510.80300.88080.00750.02080.00050.00700.0000

0.04090.03360.59450.01540.78260.00000.09520.00000.00000.0118

0.49090.00000.94540.00000.25330.14070.32790.24360.64490.0000

0.87700.81850.70510.82990.83700.74680.72080.74230.63650.5533

0.80690.68600.71490.19700.11920.99250.97920.99950.99301.0000

0.95910.96640.40550.98460.21741.00000.90481.00001.00000.9882

0.50911.00000.05461.00000.74670.85930.67210.75640.35511.0000

10.609. 307.615.374.453.732.782.011.490.95

0.520.420.290.210.040.000.000.000.000.00

0.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.00

0. 000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.00


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

290of317






79.580.581.582,583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89.590.591.592.593.5


7

1210101010101510

5


INTERVALRETMTRATIO

0.00000.59680.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.33130.49550.0000

0.00000.00000.00001.0000

SURVRATIO

1.00000.40321.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000.66870.50451.0000

1.00001.00001.0000


0.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.00

0.000.000.000.00


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

291of317

r 50 0

OI'0

reMHg tu v0 N tu+ fe III

rf5 ~ ppro

fe I Ill

l5)0Lt

0

o&

UJI0

oO

BNIRIRBAS j.N3083d

oND

CI


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

292of317


ACCOUNT 370.02 METERS - UOF

ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0.00.51.52.53,54.55.5


4,601,4964,571,6714,570,5804,544,5284,544,130

297,662


INTERVALRETMTRATIO

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000


100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00100.00


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

293of317

ro 0 ra0CQ

H

0+)0 VJ

rcH0 0H 0

Zro

8H0H

H 050

o&~zUJ5

BNIRIRBIIS IN3083d


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

294of317


ACCOUNT 371 1NSTALLATIONS ON CUSTOMERS PREMISES

ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE





INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0,00.51.52.53.54,55.56.57.58.5

347,533,516335,961,970327,420,990314,139,964309,123,357296,150,035282,463,252270,694,194261,006,972245,732,655

2,153,6862,213,8081,472,7291,408,5833,005,8066,593,3724,638,7612, 857, 8193,018,2403,559,702

0.00660.00450.00450.00970.02230.01640.01060.01160.0145

0.99340.99550.99550.99030.97770.98360.98940.98840.9855

0.0062 0.9938 100.0099.3898.7398.2897.8496.8994.7393.1892.1991.13

9.510.511.512.513. 5

14.515.516.517.518.5

231, 738, 888216,653,563198,446,708184,314,347169,076,955156,758,285127,652,444115,032,16384,588,54778,572,759

2,943,8926, 882,5162,776,3932,743,2863,577,3259,208,8885,828,3885,300,4295,059,5923,664,274

0.01270. 03180.01400.01490.02120.05870.04570.04610.05980.0466

0.98730.96820.98600.98510.97880.94130.95430.95390.94020.9534

89.8188.6785.8584.6583.3981.6276.8373.3269.9465.76

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534,535.536.537.538.5

66,641,90732,851,54226,963,16513,603,8198,270,1295,489,3183,676,7962,928,4072,289,0741,905,676

1,605,451140,560139,819139,346138,533138,184137,859137,697137,518137,518

1,854,4661,558,216

984,282358,984235,535301,196250,335117,06047,51850,769

239,201637473804349325162178

81

0.04740.03650.02640.0285

0.95260.96350.97360.9715

0.0549 0.94510.06810.04000.02080.0266

0. 14900.0045

0.93190.96000.97920.9734

0.85100.9955

0.0034 0.99660.00580.00250.0024

0.99420,99750.9976

0.0012 0.99880.00130.00000.0006

0.99871.00000.9994

0.0278 0.9722 62.6960.9558.0655.9454.4652.9150.0146.6044.7443.81

42. 6436.2936. 1336.0035.8035.7135.6235.5835.5335.53


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

295of317


ACCOUNT 371 INSTALLATIONS ON CUSTOMERS PREMISES






INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRAT I0


39.540.541.542.543.544,545,546.547.548.549.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.5

137,437137,356113,10099,53887,20469,62153,59440,26830,41922,658

15,91010,5635,8731,984

511111

8124,25613,56212,33417,58316,02713,3269,8497,7616,748

5,3474,6903,8891,979

4

0.00060.17660.11990.12390.20160.23020.24860.24460.25510.2978

0.33610.44400.66210.99730.74770.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00001.0000

0.99940.82340. 88010.87610.79840.76980.75140.75540.74490.7022

0.66390.55600.33790.00270.25231.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.0000

35.5135.4929.2225.7222.5317.9913.8510.407.865.85

4.112.731.520.510.000.000.000.000.000.00

0.000.00


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

296of317


ACCOUNT 371 INSTALLATIONS ON CUSTOMERS PREMISES

ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE





INTERVALRETMTRATIO

8URVRATIO


0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.59. 5

10.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29. 530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

340,061,038329,159,260320,857,970308, 261, 906303,826,951291,424,172278,141,943266,785,709257,627,288242,773,152

229,282,420214,637,879196,834,953183,191,132168,346,113156,261,341127,346,486114,756,27884,328,23678,332,21466,421,62632,647,92126,771,00513,421,3028,096,8685,325,1343,523,5592,564,7431,928,1121,546,1251,247,266

1,217891740359335

24,51137,91350,06959,715

1,908,6502,070,6771,299,0831,195,4152,778,3716,353,7954,435,2222,687,3582,879,3023,421,1422,821,2646,702,1422,518,3602,554,1043,514,9719,163,6725,825,0555,297,0225,058,2643,658,2861,849,6211,556,029

982,926358,279234,705300,741248,297116,81146,99750,002

20,842563473638266242162178

81

0.00560.00630.00400.00390.00910.02180.01590.01010.01120.0141

0.01230.03120.01280.01390.02090.05860.04570.04620.06000.0467

0.02780.04770.03670.02670.02900.05650.07050.04550.02440.0323

0.01670.46280.53160. 86180,74000.72140.00660.00470.00000.0014

0.99440.99370.99600.99610.99090.97820.98410.98990.9888O. &59

0.98770.96880.98720,98610.97910.94140.95430.95380.94000.9533

0.97220.95230.96330.97330.97100.94350.92950.95450.97560.9677

0.98330.53720.46840.13820.26000.27860.99340.99531.00000.9986

100.0099.4498.8198.4198.0397.1495.0293.5092.5691.53

90.2489.1386.3485.2484.0582.2977.4773.9370.5166.28

63.1961.4358.5056.3554.8553.2650.2546.7144.5843.50

42.0941.3922.2310.411.440.370.100.100.100.10


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

297of317


ACCOUNT 371 INSTALLAT1ONS ON CUSTOMERS PREMISES






INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


39. 540.541.542.543 5

44.545, 5

46. 5

47.548.5

49.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.559.560.561.5

76,45791,40478,00673,71768,28056,59645,81437,05730,34322,658

15,91010,5635,8731, 984

51111

1

8124,25613,47912,33417,34116,02713,3269,8497,7616,748

5,3474,6903,8891,979

4

0.00110.26540.17280.16730.25400.28320.29090.26580.25580.2978

0.33610.44400.66210.99730.74770.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00001.0000

0.99890.73460.82720.83270.74600.71680.70910.73420.74420.7022

0.66390.55600.33790.00270.25231.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.0000

0.100.100.080.060.050.040.030.020.010.01

0. 010. 010.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.00

0.000.00


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

298of317

CICI

ro

8 (JH

rn ro +ro

g )H

g roH

rs x HoU 8ro H

M Ht5'Y,'&

IO ~luU«C

OO

«JNIRIRHAS IN33bI3d

OI«

O O


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

299of317


ACCOUNT 373 STREET LIGHTING AND SIGNAL SYSTEMS

ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE





INTERVALRETMTRAT10

SURVRATIO


0.00,51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.5

9.510.511.512.513,514.51516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

287,443,261196,112,977142,966,533123,939,420118,326,559107,805,068104,612,695100,759,78691,003,92685,329,88480,079,43374,853,09269,528,65964,554,57258,963,71053,995,17148,286,37741,931,08134,552,57531,188,938

28,810,70723,673,29420,249,74717,407,07014,586,43511,427,0599,020,8287,635,3026,356,9385,343,888

4,176,2703,104,3332,654,0182,486,5372,465,2172,220,9482,167,8331,921,6181,468,2951,302,100

3,793,9884,322,7171,962,9922,442,4451,922,5901,210,7511,135,1921,089,6701,185,9401,384,9601,305,6231,216,4231,278,2861,463,3281,406,0281, 702, 8183,843,4361, 801, 2322,658,8341,465,896

1,815,0672,292,5591,910,6671,937,3522,072,7391,588,655

806,184590,881365,154207,805

132,44533,85948,47620,76422,54026,86431,282

170,97866,03573,923

0.01320.02200.01370.01970.01620.01120.01090.01080.01300.0162

0.01630.01630.01840.02270.02380.03150.07960.04300.07700.0470

0.06300.09680.09440.11130.14210.13900.08940.07740.05740.0389

0.03170.01090.01830.00840.00910.01210.01440.08900.04500.0568

0.98680.97800.98630.98030.98380.98880.98910.98920.98700.9838

0.98370.98370. 98160.97730.97620,96850.92040.95700.92300.9530

0.93700.90320.90560.88870.85790.86100.91060.92260.94260.9611

0.96830.98910.98170.99160.99090.98790.98560.91100.95500.9432

100.0098.6896.5095. 1893.3091. 7990.7689.7788.8087.64

86.2284.8283.4481.9080.0578.1475.6769.6566.6661.53

58.6454.9449.6244.9439.9434.2629.5026.8624.7823.36

22.4521.7421.5021.1120.9320.7420.4920.2018.4017.57


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

300of317






39.540.541.542.543.544.545,546.547.548.5

49. 550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.5


1,060,322899, 140835,990549,502285,495204,21893,59932,55432,66030,864

32,31325,34319,23014,66411,10810,52510,1669,9146,8116,659

8, 1806, 025


INTERVAL

49,67732,039

124,630276,68228,86217,67514, 1889, 494

11,39111,946

17,80215,14013,23411,7308,2057,6557,3177,7496,7204,563

6,2036, 025

RETMTRATIO

0.04690.03560.14910.50350.10110.08650.15160.29160.34880.3870

0.55090.59740.68820.79990.73860.72730.71980.78160.98660.6853

0.75831.0000

SURVRATIO

0.95310.96440.85090.49650.89890.91350.84840.70840.65120.6130

0.44910.40260.31180.20010.26140.27270.28020.21840.01340.3147

0.2417


16.5715.8015.2312.966.445.795.284.483.182.07

1.270.570.230.070.010.000.000.000.000.00

0.000.00


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

301of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.5

9.510.51112.51314.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29. 5

30.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5


213,323,523139,260,08591,078,27075,425,31773,434,79266,971,00367,355,92567,438,88061, 856, 08359,710,347

58,412,32757,881,57654,432,66450,946,50346,572,78342,752,38637,926,69232,352,49926, 081, 26823,718,68822,083,91017,239,49514,385,18412,574,39910,688,1528,054,0915, 981,4184,728,4373,770,7902,909,6172,068,9611,355,0211,043,2541,095,5441,224,5841,031,2111,192,578

945,975706,744705,778


INTERVAL

100,8332,970,4711,122,5001,683,1531,048,689

257,212177,497290,438463,332547,268

615,844665,331761,576894,284886,454

1,165,9473,265,3951,302,2612,208,8181,107,3761,550,3911,970,2451,664,2351,680,7001,924,3891,366,016

659,381507,169231,499102,747

71,1294,1928,432

11,1664,3256,701

21,19924,27417,61615,443

RETMTRATIO

0.00050.02130.01230.02230.01430.00380.00260.00430.00750.0092

0.01050.01150.01400.01760.01900.02730.08610,04030.08470.0467

0.07020.11430.11570.13370. 18000.16960.11020.10730.06140.0353

0.03440.00310. 00810.01020.00350.00650.01780.02570.02490.0219

SURVRATIO

0.99950.97870.98770.97770,98570.99620.99740.99570.99250.9908

0.98950.98850.98600.98240.98100.97270.91390.95970.91530.9533

0.92980.88570.88430.86630.82000.83040.88980.89270.93860.9647

0.96560.99690.99190.98980.99650.99350.98220.97430.97510.9781


100.0099.9597.8296.6294.4693.1192.7592.5192.1191.42

90.5889.6388.6087.3685.8284.1981. 8974. 8471. 8365.75

62.6858.2851.6245.6539,5432.4226.9323.9621.3920.07

19.3718.7018.6418.4918.3018.2418.1217.8017.3416.91


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

302of317






39.540.541.542.543.544.545.546.5


658,520572,613627,383508,196244,337167,33856,534


INTERVAL

19,3702,880

94,427263,86015,3106,9592,127

RETMTRATIO

0.02940.00500.15050.51920.06270.04160,0376

SURVRATIO

0,97060.99500.8495O.48O80.93730.95840.9624


16.5416.0515.9713.576.526.115.865.64


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

303of317

BNIRIRBflS J.N3083d

g& GannettFleming VII-240 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

304of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE



0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.5

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5


158,473,893149,116,157142,675,608126,707,964122,176,164115,200,917108,379,949106,200,001100,839,45096,398,613

95,172,44191,546,36891,118,35389, 014, 91685,982,44782,590,45773,263,75168,336,93856,707,42050,477,653

49,655,62635,854,55134,671,87533,054,50832,342,39431,792,35430,078,41529,717,29628,776,19425, 671, 338

23,691,82414,858,93814,529,11011,406,9179,746,2868,158,5956,821,5365,441,6063,919,3063,824,002


INTERVAL

1,200264,516185,81685,51523,203

195,23745,608

929,390167,460315,346

1,339,925275,090784,696640,244

1,058,143373,048434,832

3,737,761311,474365,304

456,658126,836234,97951,577

319,763804,561139,864450,017

1,094,81897,182

63,54568,258

684,82769,769

122, 09133,49776,61946,99755,5768,125

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00180.00130.00070.00020.00170.00040.00880.00170.0033

0.01410.00300.00860.00720.01230.00450.00590.05470.00550.0072

0.00920.00350.00680.00160.00990.02530.00460.01510.03800.0038

0.00270.00460.04710.00610.01250.00410.0112O.O0860.01420.0021

SURVRATIO

1.00000.99820.99870.99930.99980.99830.99960.99120.99830.9967

0.98590.99700.99140.99280.98770.99550.99410.94530.99450.9928

0.99080.99650.99320.99840.99010.97470.99540.98490.96200.9962

0,99730.99540.95290.99390.98750.99590.98880.99140.98580.9979


100.00100.0099.8299.6999.6299.6199.4499.3998.5398.36

98. 0496.6696.3795.5494.8593.6893.2692.7187.6487.16

86.5385.7385.4384.8584,7183.8881.7581.3780.1477.09

76.8076.6076.2472.6572.2171.3071.0170.2169.6068.62


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

305of317






39.540. 541.542.543.544.545.546.547.548.5

49.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578,5


2, 973, 8192,926,0282,141,5241,919,6751,766,0111,129,7441,017,0801,005,985

995, 648954, 209

959,518910,152756,764620,650614,944183,809175,159176,281176,281164,621

164,521164,521150,256150,256155,412112,130109,578107,086107,086100, 947

100,947100, 947100,94731,78031,78031,78031,78031,78031,78031,780


INTERVAL

662274,17623,390

117,540319,97643,8941,6906, 994

41,4401,085

34,1143,529

136,1145,706

968

100

14,265

26,7771,1222,492

6,139

69,166

RETMTRATIO

0.00020.09370.01090.06120.18120.03890.00170.00700.04160.0011

0.03560.00390.17990.00920.00160.00000.00000.00000.00000.0006

0.00000.08670.00000.00000.17230.01000.02270.00000.05730.0000

0.00000.00000.68520.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

SURVRATIO

0.99980.90630.98910.93880.81880.96110.99830.99300.95840.9989

0.96440.99610. 82010.99080.99841.00001.00001.00001.00000,9994

1.00000.91331.00001.00000.82770.99000.97731.00000.94271.0000

1.00001.00000.31481.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000


68.4768.4662.0461.3657.6147.1745.3445.2644.9543.08

43. 0341. 5041.3433.9033. 5933.5433.5433.5433.5433. 54

33.5233.5230.6130.6130.6125.3425.0824.5124.5123.11

23.1123.1123.117.277.277.277.277.277.277.27


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

306of317








INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


79.580.581.582.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89.590.591.592.593.594.595.596.597.598.5

99.5100.5101.5102.5103.5104.5105.5106.5107.5108.5

31,78031,78031,78027,78427,78427,78427,78427,78427,78427,784

27,78427,78427,7843,7653,7653,7653,7653,7653,7653,765

3,7653,7653,7653,7653,7653,7653,2002,6392,187

565

452

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.15000.00000.17120.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000.85001.00000.82881.0000

7.277.277.277.277.277.277.277.277.277.27

7.277.277.277.277.277.277.277.277.277.27

7.277.277.277.277.277.276.186.185.125.12


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

307of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE





INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.59.5

10.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29.530.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

153,460,182144,249,026139,777,754124,330,704119,849,611113,377,514106,664,871104,460,57299,135,72594,715,024

93,511,59589,945,08289,692,58287,608,32884,582,75981,764,69972,468,92367,562,04056,093,04549,873,42849,051,64535,251,57034,134,56032,815,72632,104,88231,582,38129,885,97129,555,56028,534,64025,422,70423,361,65414,536,35114,207,80011,086,0429,423,8067,841,7896,515,3725,129,5703,616,2053,525,577

1, 200258,925184,04477,38822,725

186,38543,520

908, 945150,244314,927

1,339,223274,233765,870636, 949

1,051,104356,144427,019

3,731,165308,474365,304

455,65863,024

224,46748,629

316,923797, 681138,327425,918

1,094,49687,581

57,50466,981

684,39269,769

116,41722,85574,48036,53950,3337,368

0.00000.00180.00130.00060.00020.00160.00040.00870.00150.0033

0.01430.00300.00850.00730.01240.00440.00590.05520.00550.0073

0.00930.00180.00660.00150.00990.02530.00460.01440.03840.0034

0.00250.00460.04820.00630.01240.00290.01140.00710.01390.0021

1.00000.99820.99870.99940.99980.99840.99960.99130.99850.9967

0.98570.99700.99150.99270.98760.99560.99410.94480.99450.9927

0.99070.99820.99340.99850.99010.97470.99540.98560.96160.9966

0.99750.99540.95180.99370.98760.99710.98860.99290.98610.9979

100.00100.0099.8299.6999.6399.6199.4499.4098.5498.39

98.0696.6696.3695.5494.8593.6793.2692.7187.5987.11

86.4785.6785.5184.9584.8283.9981. 8781.4980.3177.23

76.9776.7876.4272.7472.2871.3971.1870.3769.8768.90


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

308of317








INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


39.540.541. 542.543,544.545.546.547.548.5

49.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565,566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.577.578.5

2,676,1512,628,5511,850,6201,632,7691,475,687

843,325719,907710,588700, 251686,200

677,810721,586568, 198590,389584,683153,548144,898144,898144,898133,239

133,239133,239133,239133,239133,23989,95688,52689,65289,65295,791

95,79195,79195,79131,78031,78031,78031,78031,78031,78031,780

662272,11123,389

117,340315,58742,270

1,2076,994

14,0521,085

1,4833, 5291, 8285,706

968

26,777

64,010

0.00020.10350.01260.07190.21390.05010.00170.00980.02010.0016

0.00220.00490.00320.00970.00170.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.20100.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.66820.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.99980.89650.98740.92810.78610.94990.99830.99020.97990.9984

0.99780.99510.99680.99030.99831.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00000.79901.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00000.33181.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

68.7568.7361.6260.8456.4744.3942.1742.1041.6840.85

40.7840.6940.4940.3639.9739.9139.9139.9139.9139.91

39.9139.9139.9139.9139.9131.8931.8931.8931.8931.89

31.8931.8931.8910.5810.5810.5810.5810.5810.5810.58


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

309of317








INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


79. 5

80.581.582.583.584.585.586.587.588.5

89. 5

90.591.592.593.594.595.596.597.598.5

99.5100.5101.5102.5103.5104.5105.5106.5107.5108.5

31,78031,78031,78027,78427,78427,78427,78427,78427,78427,784

27,78427,78427,7843,7653,7653,7653,7653,7653,7653,765

3,7653,7653,7653,7653,7653,7653,2002,6392, 187

565

452

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.00000.00000.00000.15000.00000.17120.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00001.00001.00001.00000.85001.00000.82881.0000

10.5810.5810.5810.5810.5810.5810.5810.5810.5810.58

10.5810.5810.5810.5810.5810.5810.5810.5810.5810.58

10.5810.5810. 5810.5810.5810.588.998.997.457.45


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

310of317

o&P)

UJ5

Cf C& o

BNIRIRH fig j.N3083d


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

311of317


ACCOUNT 392 TRANSPORTATION EQUIPMENT

ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE





INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


0. 0

0.51.52.53.54,55.56.57.58.5

282,176,182280,225,127279,388,982278,746,174255,788,659232, 381, 950217,277,974173,385,932155,223,727125, 948, 931

43,013219,041885,038

1,990,3776,737,160

15,155,04515,288,24712,391,06719,936,64915,118,948

0.00020.00080.00320.00710.02630.06520.07040.07150.12840.1200

0.99980.99920.99680.99290.97370.93480.92960.92850.87160.8800

100.0099.9899.9199.5998.8896.2790.0083.6677.6867.71

9.510.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520,521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29. 5

30.531.532.533.534.535.536.537.538.5

108,532,59785, 123, 32970,089,88156,629,24441,138,68928,408,75724,382,83920,584,32213,141,1249,842,167

6,065,0695,073,6534,041,9423,464,7213,329,4503,090,0692,679,3922,070,4231,969,5651,664,252

1,523,110958,501882,455756,569391,790227,020181,566110,48470,49954,814

17,759,37314,956,94813,272,13213,190,96311,385,6723,996,8193,291,1345,909,9173,083,2672,512,670

822,474985,834511, 858132,382181,776233,759550,86494,549

293,673132,768

465,31659,97347,22571,44975,0297,594

33,01428,85615,6851,336

0.16360.17570.18940.23290.27680.14070.13500.28710.23460.2553

0.13560.19430.12660.03820.0546

0.83640.82430. 81060.76710.72320.85930.86500.71290.76540.7447

0.86440.80570.87340.96180.9454

0.04570.14910.0798

0.30550.06260.05350.09440.19150.03350.18180.26120.22250.0244

0.95430.85090.9202

0.69450.93740.94650.90560.80850.96650.81820.73880.77750.9756

0.0756 0.92440.2056 0.7944

59.5849.8341.0733.3025.5418.4715.8713.739.797.49

5.584.823.893.393.263.092.852.272.161.84

1.691. 181.101.040.940.760.740.600.450.35


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

312of317


ACCOUNT 392 TRANSPORTAT1ON EQUIPMENT




39.540.541.542.543.544,545.546.547.548.5


52,24052,24049,76645,09439,49334,28529,27627,21425,91821,620


INTERVAL

1, 5982, 6253 3211, 3285,0092,0631,2964,298

389

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.03060.05270.07360.03360.14610.07050.04760. 16580. 0180

SURVRATIO

1.00000.96940.94730.92640.96640.85390.92950.95240.83420.9820


0.340.340.330. 310.290.280.240.220.210.18

49.550.551.552.553. 5

54. 5

55.556.557.558.5

21,23015,25014,62013,69712,17412,17412,17412,1748,5306,533

5, 981630923

1, 523

3,6441,997

994

0.04130.06310.11120.00000.00000.00000.29930.23410.1522

0.95870.93690.88881. 00001.00001.00000.70070.76590.8478

0.2817 0.7183 0.170.120.120.110.100.100.100.100.070.05

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571. 5

72.573.574. 5

75.576.5

5,5395,5395,3375,3373 3172,5042,5042,5042,5042,504

1,3681,3681,368

683683683683

202

2, 020812

685

0.00000.03640.00000.37860.24490.00000.00000,00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.50070.00000.00000.00000.0000

1.00000.96361.00000.62140.75511.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00000.49931.00001.00001.00001.0000

0.040.040.040.040.030.020.020.020.020.02

0.020.020.020.010. 010,010.010.01


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

313of317



ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE


AGE ATBEGIN OFiNTERVAL

0.00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.59.5

10.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.522.523.524.525.526.527.528.5

29,530.53132.533.534.535.536.537.538.5


266,560,025265,552,214265,622,298266,940,258245,298,973223,469,949210,100,633167, 614, 498150,428,099122,295,172

105,905,36283,823,00569,484,98756,304,39640,870,97828,176,52024,190,38320,465,47313,037,2499,745,6195,971,5084,983,4373,956,1113,386,2523,253,6893,024,5362,621,6912,019,4991, 921, 8801,622,6481,494,141

930,162855,022730,638368,229205,986160,53291,07153,52339,093


INTERVAL

35,385211,281833,480

1,892,7096,297,358

14,241,95114,315,88711,744,11619,303,39614,485,617

16,836,52614,582,76613,137,37813,135,44911,353,3213,959,7573,210,2615,899,8913,078,4502,510,198

819,067985,834504,793132,040175,570222,706550,664

92,176289,611126,526

464,88459,93745,72371,44973,0187, 594

32,81128,85614,430

988

RETMTRATIO

0.00010.00080.00310.00710.02570.06370. 06810.07010.12830.1184

0.15900.17400.18910.23330.27780.14050.13270.28830.23610.2576

0.13720.19780.12760.03900.05400.07360.21000.04560.15070.0780

0.31110.06440.05350.09780. 19830.03690.20440.31690.26960.0253

SURVRATIO

0.99990.99920.99690.99290.97430.93630.93190.92990.87170.8816

0.84100.82600.81090.76670.72220.85950.86730.71170.76390.7424

0,86280.80220.87240.96100.94600.92640.79000.95440.84930.9220

0.68890.93560.94650.90220.80170.96310.79560.68310.73040.9747


100.0099.9999.9199.5998.8996.3590.2184.0678. 1768. 14

60.0750.5241.7333.8425.9518.7416.1113.979.947.59

5.644.863.903.403.273.102.872.262.161.84

1.691.171.091.030.930.750.720.570.390.29


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

314of317








INTERVALRETMTRATIO

SURVRATIO


39. 5

40.541.542.543.544.545.546.547.548.549.550.551.552.553.554.555.556.557.558.5

59.560.561.562.563.564.565.566.567.568.5

69.570.571.572.573.574.575.576.5

43,28245,64743,17338,50132,90028,50523,49622,23520,93821,620

21,23015,25014,62013,69712, 17412,17412, 17412, 174

8, 5306, 533

5, 5395, 5395,3375,3373,3172, 5042, 5042, 5042, 5042, 504

1, 3681, 3681,368

683683683683

1, 5982, 6253,321

5155,0091,2621,296

685389

5, 981630923

1,523

3, 6441, 997

994

202

2,020812

685

0.00000.03500.06080.08630.01570.17570.05370.05830.03270.0180

0. 28170.04130.06310.11120.00000.00000.00000.29930.23410.1522

0.00000,03640.00000.37860.24490.00000.00000.00000.00000.0000

0.00000.00000.50070.00000.00000.00000.0000

1.00000.96500.93920.91370.98430.82430.94630.94170.96730.9820

0.71830.95870.93690.88881.00001.00001.00000.70070.76590.8478

1.00000.96361.00000.62140.75511.00001.00001.00001.00001.0000

1.00001.00000,49931.00001.00001.00001.0000

0.280.280.270.250.230.230.190. 180.170.16

0.160.110.110.100.090.090.090.090.060.05

0.040.040.040.040.020.020.020.020.020.02

0.020.020.020.010.010.010.010.01


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

315of317

CQ

K IuH

Mrs ccpCl

rs

o, rs Ul

p

ro ro pCQ

o

IQ R

R~~H

p pM

p

o &'9 zLuIg

o CI

BNIAIAbIrIS J.N3383d


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

316of317


ACCOUNT 396 POWER OPERATED EQUIPMENT

ORIGlNAL LIFE TABLE



0. 00.51.52.53.54.55.56.57.58.59.5

10.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.518.5

19.520.521.5


10,258,4729,747,9229,664,3739,479,1109,460,0858,473,1338,387,0097,796,0047,774,3597,330,3497,263,2066,594,3506,415,2041,485,141

416,246188,29487,96347,576

938938

938938


INTERVAL

4, 1028,074

16,40119,900

41540,45814,951

152,23067,143

42,787129,262

4,930,0631,068,895

227,952100,33240,38746,638

938

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00040.00080.00170.00210.00060.00480.00190.01960.0092

0.00590.01960.76850.71970.54760.53280.45910.98030.00000.0000

0.00001.0000

SURVRATIO

1.00000.99960.99920.99830.99790.99940.99520.99810.98040.9908

0.99410.98040.23150.28030.45240.46720.54090.01971.00001.0000

1.0000


100.00100.0099.9699.8799.7099.4999.4398.9598.7696.83

95.9495.3793.5021.656.072.741.280.690.010.01

0.010.01


Exhibit A

ELECTR

ONICALLY

FILED-2018

June22

1:41PM

-SCPSC

-Docket#

2018-204-E-Page

317of317


ACCOUNT 396 POWER OPERATED EQUIPMENT

ORIGINAL LIFE TABLE


AGE ATBEGiN OFINTERVAL

0. 0

0.51.52.53.54 5

5.56.57.58.59.5

10.511.512.513.514.515.516.517.5


9,900,6909,330,3409,250,8939,167,0479,159,7958,207,1478,110,7537,521,3337,506,9647,266,3047,238,6996,571,5546,397,6481,468,252

415,122187,35687,02546,638


INTERVAL

15,58516,2805,415

37,50714,369

136,90927,605

41,075124,022

4,929,3961,053,130

227,766100,33240,38746,638

RETMTRATIO

0.00000.00000.00000.00170.00180.00070.00460.00190.01820.0038

0.00570.01890,77050.71730.54870.53550.46411.0000

8URVRATIO

1.00001.00001.00000.99830.99820.99930.99540.99810.98180.9962

0.99430.98110.22950.28270.45130.46450.5359


100.00100.00100.00100.00

99.8399.6599.5999.1398.9497.13

96.7696.2194.4021.666.132.761.280.69

g~. GannettFleming VII-254 Duke Energy ProgressDecember 31, 2016

FILED DUKE IP - South Carolina

Documents

Transcript of FILED DUKE IP - South Carolina