~~fi - Max Planck Societyloops05.aei.mpg.de/index_files/PDF_Files/reuter.pdf · - Q~-bOvt. ~~~'tt;...
Transcript of ~~fi - Max Planck Societyloops05.aei.mpg.de/index_files/PDF_Files/reuter.pdf · - Q~-bOvt. ~~~'tt;...
C Lo..s$ ic.a.l
5u...c.c..e" S' ~L pheV\oW\.e""oLo3&'c..-a..( -b-h. eory ~l
LQ.bO~bo.,.y, SoLQ.Y" sysl.elh1} dQ.,lct.c...It'c..)'"C?J
Le~S~h. sca..Le.s -R » ..e'P.t.'" 1(f 'I< 10- ~~ Cttt
re'(kvb~l:Lvel1 V\oLl\re~~L; ~Le
wi.olesrrea.ct beLief -t~Q..-t: Q~~~ E,~s4ei~ G~vi{1
is ~erely C4~ ef{'ecf\ve -theory} Q.~'c.~"(e for,.£ »21L} v~~eY' ~"" ~ ~e~:~~l (\1tI\'c..'t'~sCopa'C )
t:heor'y ~lt'ol a.~ Q.~t-b~~ilt s~G.ll dist/G.llfc.es.
US<.tA.LLyCl. iheoV''y..Cotl Gt' o!e"('e. d.II ~ l (f
• l.S"oia.I4It bL; Q.l
i.f it: 1$
?e~'('bo....h'v e.l 'ire~~r~; ?:Q...ble )•
zffi:sI.e.~~fi",i fie s
CQ.nbe.C&.b sorbe d.byre d.ef.,",·fIt(jo"-L)'
%~i{eli.W\Q.~,Y
~'f"Q.IM.e.ie.rS(\'\It, ~ ) ... ).
iKC. VeQ..4iKd
Lo0r 0 '(rk '('
~\(A ••~ber of -lerMlt. S
~ i~·";~e.Li !MCbay -rrQ~ fQ,YQ..""'e.i~rs
~ V\() 'PY'edic.ckve ~er
Howev<9-Y' •---- .~eV'e eX-tst ~nct~~e"--t:-CLl i-heorLes Wk.,'c...k.
Cl V'e \l\.ot peY'.(;~rbOL.~veL>, reV\OOka..Lc' ~o.bLe :
• "no~peY~Y'b~.&.\vel.>' ~evtoY'*~l~cQ..bLe (f
0t k. WiLso~ (s 3evaeY'~.l \>ri.\AC4~ s
0..£0 Vij -I:It e ltit esof re\1.O~\M.al.t~CL~'O"L
• co h S ~Yc..t.C.iQ.o(
Li_.i: Q.i Qby peY'foV'~~~~ -I::he iIIIf,·Mik. - c.u..l::ofr
V\O~- ua.u.ssiQ.tt R6 -Rltecl fo~-I: (u.* =1=0)
II tt.(.V1.cJQ.Wt.e\'1.~Ol.L If : =: iVlf.iAiie - c.~Ot{ LfM4it
UlMi-l:) eK1'si S
l'~~ps Qt.c.Q."'~ Eiv.s-bein 6'tCLvi.ty CCb\. be. de~""ecl.
-n.o""reviu.,.bQ.. *,veo/ Q! 0- V\o~- Gcu..LS.riC\.~ ~xeo( foLVL-#:.
pY'O~ 'fess
Q.~fvor.•..io•.:l:e
ha..'Mfeye cl by {c..c.k °rCG.l.~lA.J., Mo.l sckMlfe
U I( f. I I'Se ~ec.4'iv e Q.veyQ..~e ctc."'o"",,,
~~,c.lseems iha.,Uy suiteol...
£ffec-~ve Q.vev~~ e 0.,+''0",- foY' 1~"i~ 7:
r [~~ ...]0-i i)
____________________________________________"'_r-_-------------...
• r'R cc.<.!Q.f~ ~t i, : r;. CoK.iQ.ilots
~\I\.b\IK t~c.~tio~s ~ith MOw..e"'-tQ.
Y\O-t. (ye!) o~ -!:ho&e wi!h. p <. i .• 'M. oa{e S "-'i 1-h. P ~ i $"«fIOre 4$ se ol itot.
b~ (w\Q.ss / = 'R i.Cpj
• =--s)r
/1
su.b SpQ..c.e
M.R. 11~6
I 5 ~ - s [r~"]• S taT h\1..~ ~oi",,"-\:: tV '6/,~ e . I .
• clec.oW\fo.re « ="8 + h.i~ /., tv~xeoC bo..c.k,vot.
\M. e~vi~
• eKfQ.vo.ol. h.,.." i."l
I"R c~-toH -i~ ••
• de,. i.ve e J(Q.d 7(G eyuo..J·,o",- .g.OIM- po<!k ik teJ Ifo.l :
~ ~ r-9z [ 3, 3, ...] = 11= (u-)
spo..c:.. e
-
9n.: ~eV'Q_U'!-eot COc....f'I'·kj S
lTn.. J : l'bQS'isfl 0t diHeoWt. i~". -V""'\ltc~'~IA-~lJ'
'3 J~, S ry R ) S fj 1(. •••.1 ... J \'to'" Loc.~l teyV"t S
lheovy S'f'G-c.e ;$ coo.,c1,tMQ.~'!-ect b;J e Sol eYLh'~l ,
oti\M.eVJd",·e)k..le IS c.o~p(,'k.qS
rr = (~n.) : vec..-to"f ~'eLJ. o~ theOY'l Sf'Q.ce (If R6 fLo~ ff )
~
o (r,f) ::::0) is
('(Q.S'Y~p~J"Ic.~{(r s~fe..It) •
Wein.bey~ (~l-'
QL.t.~V\.k\M.. theov'1 is
~(A",,,,i,,,,j ihrio(e bk e-l:-~ "F 'P ) wi.tk
c1ef,'kect byUV - C'YiHcQ..l
"" 1<..6 1:Y~iec..h>vt
hyfev StA.yfc..c..e. of
- Q~-bOvt. ~~~'tt; -/;e& iMA.~ll Y dole~ r*.
No!.e : r* hcts no ~eQ.SO~ .fz> be of
Ei\"ts-lein - t-til\oev t torM:
0..\11 S Q-l2 :-
b.vo
f) d- 'l.di~enS'''oM Less: (J{ -i.) = R" ~~
c ~ tcl~W\e~""OkLe rr: ;( (iJ : 11. / iIt
~ dt 9 (~) = 03 (3,'\)
{ ~Il A Ci) == ~ ~ (3l~)
c:.
(1) G.&ft ~ctc.eWte clepevtt>levtce
wii:hi"" -th.e E;~&-le.iVL-lliLber./;.
(CY'ih·c.~( exro",e""i.s) S-",.:l"'i ) ....
sch.elM.e --i~o(epeJo1.o(ek:b ,'tt.-/J,e
C:; :Kt(.) - defe>UJl~ )·b·~V\c.~-In'o Vl
o. La.c..c..sc..ket) H.1<.) h.e,- ~h-/ 010~O t.t-O
M. 12.) T S~eY'erl';~ J he.p - -th.. /011 00 5"'f
hep - ih, /OJ. 06 'lf~
'PT- E'RG E': A. Oo"'Q.\I\II\O J M.~.) hep- *'-. 10 <.t to I ~ I
(2) GleV\eY'~li~ecl i~~CCL ~'OVl c.Ji-i.1-a.. 1( 2._ (~vG.1't~~t
Q. La.u.s-c..ker J M. 'Q.) keF - & 1011 00.2 1
l.1.e.p - i:h- /OlOS062
~ IJG T? See.tHS ~ be very
--NoV\,..J:Y'i vl'o..l ev'de~c.e sc..c..ppo-t -b".., *heh '1po .f:~esis 0+ Q.. AI6 -,:? .•..""~he e~a.c..f: ~ eo,,! .
The 1<G ~~(l.Le~~ovy Jenl.i ~eol it1. Na.luye~ ---~-- - -- -- -- - ---- ~ ~~-- ~~--- -- ~
IO-60+-~ ~-I ~ ~
~ 10-c,., so l6."~,'es/'
sr N.~\I\1. . to '/&O$hto 'Y '/-fO+
~~ L'P,-_~____1_ ~10
10- 60
« .L~~
2- Z
0(")
clAsrit:.Q.1. G R ve3i...e:G) A ~ CD~S-l:
\ = 0(1)~ H. 2o
I ( I•••
• I ••• PQ~~~••.lo.r: 8r~ [<cr) 1 = 0cSCP()() ~
'<fielcls •••~ •.• Jielcl <c:P ~ =- foelot ,.seen.·· b:;~;c.ro Sc.0fE (.Ji~h reSolvit1.3 'Poc.u~ R.
r~ clyQ.vi~y :,• Q v~ ~ i"'j y eplor.c.ecl 1o:J ~ 'Ih""j - 0 ff
-2of J) - eiJQ~vct.Lc..c..e s
• .,eLQ..J.a't)l'l s-/'uf .R = R.(il) ~O"e co"'"'"/',eq.:lecJ
1\1. 3ene1"q,.t
I
• T"ix a.. FVl.{UIM.. tkeo.,y ~1 p1.ck-akJ Q. $fecz'A'c
1<.6 -k~Jec..ky ~ ~ r~[.1 .
C4.i 0..'7 -fi.:• Solve e +to ~e Lel e!f .
sr~ [<~>~]8Sr~
(. scQ.le
=0
• Me~ s-b-"c..~ve of "Q£6 sFcef;~ " {s descYibQol "d
~"",tel,/ INlCr"'.'1 c(Q.s-S",·cQ.l 1(,'e~",,(Ot.\fl \M.e-bn'c ~ .
~~_-leytve!Q.."'~O~_: Obse"v1'~d sFe-bilMe c..tvtelev Oc. ~icroscore
o{ resoLviKj f0c.ve'( RI o~e sees Q..
~(Q.~'ZCr:t.l Wleu,ifolJ c..:>ith lIkef:.t-t'c.
The le~J!h. of tk.e COCtsi &He of £'It~(QkrJ.
depeVlols 0\;1.. the ~i ~e of tl-z ~ YOLvots.l:,'c..k
u- se.rL -I::b 1Nle.Oc. rCAy e i!.
veca.LL :
-7.
-:D ei~~~S'
c.~-l off Q..-\; ~ '2.
[~ j a =:3 j 'J"0sol$ :=. 0 ]
L> j) 1.. =- :J)1..
Al~OYi!h~ :~~ -~-~~~
• G~veVl 1<~r"~ 1 ) UJvrrtY'Woc.i "ov.- sheLL Lo..plQl'iQVl.S' tt
A C-{) := .])2 «j')~ )
• ii\llol e.iJ e.'tl~Vlc.1:,'o""-<f ()()of- ~c-&.)w~'~k
eije-n.vo..l,--e. ~ '2\
w~,p Srec.-4 (-12./
0
¥t2
()o_..-(..- {7P1'cQ.L LeV1.~ih Sc.oJ.e dt'$('LQ.yeol.. hi '1f(KI
(e. <j. pe-rz.'oe{);
.pYOpeY Levt~t-h. wi-u, res-fecI:- b "~iv~ tOt seLf .
3
••• OV\ S'co..Les Q..i Whl'c:...k fhe 1<..(;. i::r~iec.fo"'7
is' ~eQ.v I:-he T 'P ~z ~-d!\(i.) = ~ i. G(~J =Q ~ •••*") .J*)
O. I...aMscket )
M. "R.. ) 2.0 0.2..
• Vto c(i~. ~L COV1S~""'+.r of 1'~ te.jro..holA.
~ SOl(.(...hb~ hGlS rctc(1·"'.r of c~yvo..k1e- 1. _ 1
'"c. (~) 0(. A (ft.) Z c<. i,
re~~~e.
> 1{~O(i(..(s of CCA.yvC4.tv.re d.e!ec.ie.ol.
b II , , I? IIY INtlc'(o&c°fe of 'IeSoker\ok N :
II 2oolNt;lIt.j II dee-fey ~k.fo -the s~e.J,~ s-l:.~~&"'e.( Low en'~j JL) do es &-to! ~ \<t.j e -the ilMQ.~ See I;f.
by -the Mic.yo.f'COre ·
-O. LQ.fA.S~Y.
K.'R. ) .2002.
Cfj ( pJ '"
-~ - -- - --~~ - ----- -- -
EXQ.\M.f le. :T'P.
y ed L"""-e
2-0(G CiJ = 3:* ~
=> I '7 •.. "1-1f. = 2.. _. rl I ...consi
At tke- T1>.- ----~- .
-7> I D;:rk~k1ic~LCh.Oa.Vl~Q o~ di.~e~sio~t"' .:l ~ oL ,
~"£cl ihe 1< G evou......h'"",- f.,o","-- -Ht.~ -R'keo{ fot,\.c..t
.to -tl.e. do- S S''Z'C f4..l ~e~i.\M.e.. •
0T k" (x,x';r) = 43 k:t (x,J<.'j T ),L).:J t = 3- I (),.(f'l ~~" ~" cp)
- ,- -V -,- T~11' e. d
ol= -.2. at ~ 11CT)rl ~T
100 tivo..te s He ioLLoG.J/.«j def,' ••;J.." ••. fo. ~"e sr-=lro..lcti,-eCl\l't'o~ 0t CL Q E6\ s{"tc.e.~~~ :
'P CT) :; < 'j)~ (T)>=: !iJo/-oJ ;)c,;)E ref (T)
- s [~,C, CJe
7
":"\ . o.L~Evo..!.u.Q...h"Oh.. 0+ oUs iK !I,e 1(6 {"".•.el.i>O'C k K.R 2/)05
h.e p - ·HL /050 e2.02.
(1) golLoe-~o"," of 'Ri~« ~>.•.) = 1\ (-i) < ~r~>i< s~s~'(p'~
Acio)<: <3J'o1 ~ = . < ~rv>11.Jl I\(~) T(o
•AppLy Cl> ({J = ~ C P<. ) k (··e )
Hocu to c..hooJ'e ~ 2•
)
l?J) It -tke c!i {{CAh'c)\;\. Pyoc.e.ss involve ~ o~L,/ lIkov-e~
~eQv C\.. .n,'-t~(e.,~")(ect -i:
- ~ ( ~o ) cp~ = E..v.. <Pn
t (~t.) :: A (~) IA(io)
(If) Tfhte evoL....J.'o"1. of ;It iI•.••.L proha..bili i7 cJ.js{yilo •.•.f,0•• P (x j 0 J :
P (X'j T) :: J'0(1 ( f~O(~I) k (J(,)(' iT) p(J(lj 0 )
If
Tf' c!rt i=:- 0 ol'\.ly fay Ot. Si••.~Le. cEN:
5 i••.~le - s<;oJ.e ~YOIoLe.••••..J 0 bvioLLS ckcn'c.e is -R. == -{ E'11/'
(5) If
Vh<..LLb i - scn..le. pvo~ le."",,- )
Choose ~ 0de - olep~t SCCkLe.
Kocle <R h~sp
q ff
'te soLv~lIt:J pOW~'('
I( I' -.l _'de e.E' ""'-e. "t:nc
P.' , ,~ ;p; : ~€~ =t
< ~I'V>•.... iH•. P<. = f£t .
• Co YV ec.i
Cuts off
,&'(A-ce ..s-'l.'-'tc.e}
the. StedvG< ~ of j) < ~
to
Let ~o = 'N\~c.Y't)~O~'c. {'c~le Iwith. ACf<.o)« 'tt,(p: IQ.~
<c;)i'f >~o~ fLQ.-t lM.e tnc.••
~ CT)
S ol~- pt tcp2J r-. ~- e.
T~oo:
T-+O
lcVlj YQ.~olowt evoJ.kg) pY'obe SFc.e.·!'"",e st.vc.<.c.l:v..ye
~-b ~~e ctisiQ.~c.es) dO\leY'i'leo( b:J T cpt)
'-Vi!~ PL --. 0: c./.Q. f$sico..l re3i~e
sho'l'! ~~~ ~u< ..s ) fYobe Srceh'lM.e J'frCA.~ie.
~t S~Q.tl cJ.;sk",,-c.eS' j d0V'eyllteo( 1:1;; rCf'l}wi!"'--f 2-+ 00: ..fi)(eot poi",--c re.;} i~e
II
\'to 'V(A"'\I\'~'j) A (~) ~.A( -80)
=> 'P CT) 0<.. T - 01/1
~ \ -Us = d. \
• _!i)(e.c{ ?OL\I\...t ve ~ tWle~ -- - - -
=F ~ 1)
1\ (~) ~ ilZ , ~ (p t) 0(. f <-
~ P CT) e(. T - d./If
I 2)S = 1ct I
Q E"" 6 ) b(A~eol «4>0\1'\. Ot~~ 1<.6 -i~,jec."'o~y, precl1'c.:{. S'
G. Co","\:i",CA.ou..s C.ho."'3e 0 f ~he tYc..~-L~t oliMe~h()l;\o..l':~y
o~ spQ.ce.s..·~ f,o~ -Us = 't o..-/; ~o..CYO&&JP)·c bi)r '= .2 ~'" t/tIt'·C.YOS~Qf)'c c/i,,-&o..M<.e s .
12
....••• -- -~~--A1'~ _,
• Resc.c..Lt.- tc>'(
of Q.S y~p J-oh'c.
-\:v-,", Vl c~ '0'" •
Q.c.ic....o.J.Ly ~k. exa.c.i COh.re 1uelllc...e.
u ~ ol cI.oes a.-t 0 t re.ly 0 &.1... <.c..V\y
• d.=. 4-.
sfecz'Q..l :LS
d..-t-r
IZJs
~~c.Y"O $CO, ,'c
I~ cL
I
2 d.'M,' f.YO ~eof'l'c
-~.
~
~
Cl~tees
~itcJ...=Lfr
•
• 1<6pye 0( 'l'e J,:o~of2 otillK e\-tcf'1 '0 K. Cl Lfra..c.f~L(rJ.=4)
S'~ppo"( toQ 0{
cbcJMOlit..ie.. CAy-Lo'fe r~Li S' :
,,()s (r-. O())
:: If. 02 z O. (
~~(r --+ 0 J
-f. ~O :t O. 2.S--
13
.,... ~~~~ .....--.-..
A QEGspo.. c.e+,'..,e" 'f lel. "CClT1t'e S1Nt~1 b
i.,. f;",i -t:ely
MOt "'Y~e-l:fic. s< <3f~'1l(..,)k.'c.-t-.
ole sc..n ~e
i!S~e~n'~s!y~ C. teA. '#e0"'-ol\ f{eye ,,:#;
,tl1.5 fo..~e.h'~e he.. s
CLlL Ye~ik.-\es ~,f;~
o~ -l~e ~ya.vikko~••{
f'~~Cl.l p~fe.,kes
~o~-t:n"iCl.l RQ Yc.c."-t4"",,~
As Cl. ol;v QC.-4:: ~""C.C. ekQ.~ ~ Co." se ,,,,etA. c.e 0 fOlrY~f'fvh'c sclfety (eJ(i.rle~c.e 0+ q, 1="P )
owe f;~o(s CA. Co~ .t-,'''''CA..ou$ c.(,.Qk~e of i/; s~~c..~~l ot;CA.te\lt4'io\l\.) f'~o"" 4- Q.i ~o..c:rosCof"c
ciis-Lo..",-c.es io .2, OM "'u'c:roscof)'C sc-q,les ..