Failure Analysis Behind the Scene - ASPRI · 2015. 1. 30. · (Ref: Understanding How Components...
Transcript of Failure Analysis Behind the Scene - ASPRI · 2015. 1. 30. · (Ref: Understanding How Components...
Advancing Towards New FrontiersSingapore Test Services
Failure Analysis – Behind the Scene
1. Some thoughts on Failure Analysis
2. Preparing the Quotation – look before you leap!
3. Lab Investigations – from Visual to Metallurgical examination
4. Preparing the Report
a. Review of background information
b. Analysis of lab investigation findings
c. Evaluating the cause of failure
d. Recommendations
Advancing Towards New FrontiersSingapore Test Services
1. Incident occurred on 20
April 2004.
2. Think about it: if both the
Prosecution and Main
Con said they were right
and the other party was
wrong, who then was
right?!
3. Can it be that both parties
are right, or both wrong,
or one right and one
wrong???
2
Source: Wikipedia
Advancing Towards New FrontiersSingapore Test Services
3
1. The term “failure,” means the inability of a part or an
assembly to perform its intended function for any
reason.
2. We usually think of failure in terms of fracture, wear,
or corrosion.
(Ref: Understanding How Components Fail, D J Wulpi, ASM)
3. Think about it: the senior manager of a hotel stepped
on a small piece of hard debris on the carpeted hotel
room and sent it for examination – in what ways can
this be considered a “failure” ?
Advancing Towards New FrontiersSingapore Test Services
Failure Analysis
1. In the study of any failure, the analyst must consider a broad spectrum
of possibilities for the occurrence.
2. Often a large number of factors, frequently interrelated, must be
understood to determine the cause of the original, or primary, failure.
3. Like a police detective attempting to solve a baffling case, the analyst
must carefully examine and evaluate all evidence available, then
prepare a hypothesis that can explain the “crime.”
(Ref: Understanding How Components Fail, D J Wulpi, ASM)
Advancing Towards New FrontiersSingapore Test Services
5
(Ref: Incident Investigation and Accident Prevention in Process and Allied Industries, Ch 7, Dyadem Engineering Corp.)
Hypothesis . . .
At the beginning one does not know precisely and exactly what happened in the
incident. Therefore any theories are hypothetical (i.e., they may be right, wrong or
partly correct). The objective is to create a single working hypothesis to be analyzed
further to verify the true version of what has occurred. Hypotheses are basically
unproven explanations.
What is meant by the term hypothesis? A hypothesis is a proposed explanation for a
phenomenon or observation. It is a tentative theory, explanation or supposition
provisionally adopted to explain certain facts, and to guide in the investigation of
others; hence it is often called a working hypothesis. A hypothesis is a basis for
reasoning without having to assume it must be true.
Advancing Towards New FrontiersSingapore Test Services
6
(Ref: Incident Investigation and Accident Prevention in Process and Allied Industries, Ch 7, Dyadem Engineering Corp.)
Hypothesis . . .
At the outset the focus will be on one or two dominant hypotheses. The remainder, less
probable hypotheses, are canceled out by a process of elimination through reasoning.
Advancing Towards New FrontiersSingapore Test Services
7
Case Study
Advancing Towards New FrontiersSingapore Test Services
8
Case Study(continued)
Remember:
1. Consider ALL possibilities and ALL evidence, and
2. NEVER be too quick to jump to conclusions.
Advancing Towards New FrontiersSingapore Test Services
9
Advancing Towards New FrontiersSingapore Test Services
10
Advancing Towards New FrontiersSingapore Test Services
11
Advancing Towards New FrontiersSingapore Test Services
12
Advancing Towards New FrontiersSingapore Test Services
13
Accredited Test Labs
1. The importance of accreditation to commercial test laboratories
2. The importance of using accredited labs to customers
Advancing Towards New FrontiersSingapore Test Services
14
STS’ Accreditations and Approvals
Advancing Towards New FrontiersSingapore Test Services
15
Term MeaningAccredit 1 : to give official authorization to or approval of: a : to provide with credentials; especially :
to send (an envoy) with letters of authorization b : to recognize or vouch for as conforming
with a standard.
Certify 1 : to attest authoritatively: as a : CONFIRM b : to present in formal communication c : to
attest as being true or as represented or as meeting a standard.
2 : to inform with certainty : ASSURE
4 : to recognize as having met special qualifications (as of a governmental agency or
professional board) within a field <agencies that certify teachers>
Conform 2 a : to be obedient or compliant —usually used with to <conform to another's wishes> b : to act in accordance with prevailing standards or customs <the pressure to conform>
Comply 2 : to conform, submit, or adapt (as to a regulation or to another's wishes) as required or requested <comply with federal law> <the devices comply with industry standards>
Qualify 3 a : to fit by training, skill, or ability for a special purpose b (1) : to declare competent or adequate : CERTIFY (2) : to invest with legal capacity : LICENSE
intransitive verb
1 : to be or become fit (as for an office) : meet the required standard
Verify 1 : to confirm or substantiate in law by oath
2 : to establish the truth, accuracy, or reality of <verify the claim>
Advancing Towards New FrontiersSingapore Test Services
16
Term Meaning
Technical
standard
1. An established norm or requirement. It is usually a formal document that establishes uniform engineering or technical criteria, methods, processes and practices.
2. A technical standard can also be a controlled artifact or similar formal means used for calibration. Reference Standards and certified reference materials have an assigned value by direct comparison with a reference base. A primary standard is usually under the jurisdiction of a national standards body. Secondary, tertiary, check standards and standard materials may be used for reference in a metrology system. A key requirement in this case is (metrological) traceability, an unbroken paper trail of calibrations back to the primary standard.
3. This article discusses formal technical standards. In contrast, a custom, convention, company product, corporate standard, etc which becomes generally accepted and dominant is often called a de facto standard.
4. A technical standard may be developed privately or unilaterally, for example by a corporation, regulatory body, military, etc. Standards can also be developed by groups such as trade unions, and trade associations. Standards organizations often have more diverse input and usually develop voluntary standards: these might become mandatory if adopted by a government, business contract, etc.
5. The standardization process may be by edict or may involve the formal consensus of technical experts.
Advancing Towards New FrontiersSingapore Test Services
17
Term Meaning
Types of standards
The primary types of technical standards are:
1. A standard specification is an explicit set of requirements for an item, material, component, system or service. It is often used to formalize the technical aspects of a procurement agreement or contract. For example, there may be a specification for a turbine blade for a jet engine which defines the exact material and performance requirements.
2. A standard test method describes a definitive procedure which produces a test result. It may involve making a careful personal observation or conducting a highly technical measurement. For example, a physical property of a material is often affected by the precise method of testing: any reference to the property should therefore reference the test method used.
3. A standard practice or procedure gives a set of instructions for performing operations or functions. For example, there are detailed standard operating procedures for operation of a nuclear power plant.
4. A standard guide is general information or options which do not require a specific course of action. 5. A standard definition is formally established terminology. 6. Standard units, in physics and applied mathematics, are commonly accepted measurements of physical
quantities.
Standard
vs. Code
1. A Standard can be defined as a set of technical definitions and guidelines that function as instructions
for designers, manufacturers, operators, or users of equipment.
2. A standard becomes a Code when it has been adopted by one or more governmental bodies and is
enforceable by law, or when it has been incorporated into a business contract.
Advancing Towards New FrontiersSingapore Test Services
18
Enquiry and Quotation Stage
1. Look before you leap!
2. View the failed item. (An item that’s lightweight to a
weight-lifter may be heavy to a sprinter.)
3. Obtain item description and brief background of the
failure.
4. Guiding keywords:
a. 5Ws 1H – Who, What, When, Where, Why & How?
b. 3Ms – Man, Material & Machine.
5. Establish scope of work and any requirement to out-
source (to factor in such cost, may be expensive).
Advancing Towards New FrontiersSingapore Test Services
19
Typical Quotation for
Failure Analysis of a Fractured Tube
Thank you for your interest in the services provided by STS. We are pleased to quote
you a lump sum price of S$xxxx.00 for the following scope of work:
1. Visual inspection and photo documentation of the fractured tube.
2. Examination of the fracture surface with a stereo-microscope to identify macro-
features as well as identify areas for further analysis.
3. Examination of the fracture surface using a scanning electron microscope (SEM) to
establish the origin of failure, mode of failure, e.g. whether it was due to fatigue,
overload, etc.
4. Energy dispersive x-ray (EDX) elemental analysis will be conducted on the fracture
surface to establish the elemental constituents.
5. Quantitative chemical composition analysis.
6. Mechanical testing - tensile test, impact test, etc.
7. Metallurgical examination of the fracture surface to establish any microstructural
factors that could have contributed to the failure.
8. Microindentation hardness test.
9. Interpretation of results, evaluation of the possible cause(s) of failure, and reporting.
Advancing Towards New FrontiersSingapore Test Services
20
FAILURE ANALYSIS
(2) Visual/NDT/
Dimensional
measurement
(3) SEM/EDX
Analysis
(5) Metallographic
Examination
(4) Mechanical
Testing
(6) Chemical
Analysis
(7) Product
Reliability
Evaluation(8) Specialized
Tests, e.g.,
H2
content . . .
(1) Background
information
Advancing Towards New FrontiersSingapore Test Services
21
Coordinate Measuring
Machine (CMM)
Fluorescent
Particle Inspection
Radiographic
Inspection
Some Preliminary
Inspections
Advancing Towards New FrontiersSingapore Test Services
22
Stereo-microscope
(7.5 – 50X)
How big
or
how small?
Advancing Towards New FrontiersSingapore Test Services
23
Fracture
started here
Fracture
started
here
Advancing Towards New FrontiersSingapore Test Services
24
Which cutting machine/tool to use???
Horizontal Bandsaw
Hacksaw