Faculty & Administration Pension Plan and Support Staff Pension Plan Annual General Meeting June...

17
Faculty & Administration Pension Plan and Support Staff Pension Plan Annual General Meeting June 2006

Transcript of Faculty & Administration Pension Plan and Support Staff Pension Plan Annual General Meeting June...

Page 1: Faculty & Administration Pension Plan and Support Staff Pension Plan Annual General Meeting June 2006.

Faculty & Administration Pension PlanandSupport Staff Pension Plan

Annual General Meeting

June 2006

Page 2: Faculty & Administration Pension Plan and Support Staff Pension Plan Annual General Meeting June 2006.

2

Governance Overview and Financial Report – Chair, Pension Committees

Pension Plan Investments – Mercer

Report from Custodian and Record keeper – Sun Life Financial

Open Forum- Member comments and questions

Members’ Luncheon

Agenda

Page 3: Faculty & Administration Pension Plan and Support Staff Pension Plan Annual General Meeting June 2006.

3

Pension Assets $96.5 million - March 31, 2006

Saint Mary's University

$77.1

$19.4

$67.8

$16.1

Faculty andAdministration(477 members)

Support Staff(358 members)

2005

2006

Page 4: Faculty & Administration Pension Plan and Support Staff Pension Plan Annual General Meeting June 2006.

4

Both plans have a substantial portion of membership in mid-career (age 35 to 54: F&A 60%, SS 67%). At the extremes of the distribution – the F&A group has more older members (F&A 29%, SS 16%) and the SS group has more younger members (F&A 11%, SS 17%).

Member Age Distribution - March 31, 2006

Saint Mary's University

Faculty & Administration Pension Plan Support Staff Pension Plan

0%

3%

8%

13%

16% 16%15%

13%13%

3%

20 -

24

25 -

29

30 -

34

35 -

39

40 -

44

45 -

49

50 -

54

55 -

59

60 -

64

65 -

69

2%

5%

10%

13%

19% 18%17%

11%

3%2%

20 -

24

25 -

29

30 -

34

35 -

39

40 -

44

45 -

49

50 -

54

55 -

59

60 -

64

65 -

69

Page 5: Faculty & Administration Pension Plan and Support Staff Pension Plan Annual General Meeting June 2006.

5

Investment Style Distribution - March 31, 2006

Saint Mary's University

Faculty & Administration Pension Plan Support Staff Pension Plan

2%

12%

56%

28%

2%

Conservative Moderate Balanced Growth Aggressive

3%

10%

64%

19%

4%

Conservative Moderate Balanced Growth Aggressive

The above distributions show the proportion of members in the various asset allocation portfolios (86% of plan members at SMU use the portfolios).

Page 6: Faculty & Administration Pension Plan and Support Staff Pension Plan Annual General Meeting June 2006.

6

The above charts show the proportion of pension assets in the various investment funds (100% of plan assets – includes the SMU portfolios and other investment choices)

Investment Style Distribution - Asset Mix - March 31, 2006

Saint Mary's University

Faculty & Administration Pension Plan Support Staff Pension Plan

Cdn Equity35%

ForeignEquity23%

Fixed Income27% Guar/Money

Mrkt15%

Cdn Equity36%

ForeignEquity24%

Fixed Income29%

Guar/MoneyMrkt11%

Page 7: Faculty & Administration Pension Plan and Support Staff Pension Plan Annual General Meeting June 2006.

7

CAP Guidelines AssessmentBenchmarking the current practices of the SMU Pension Plans

The Joint Forum of Financial Market Regulators, on May 28th, 2004, released the Capital Accumulation Plan (CAP) Guidelines.

The CAP Guidelines are intended to outline and clarify the rights and responsibilities of sponsors, service providers and members; and to ensure that members are provided the information and assistance that they need to make investment decisions in a capital accumulation plan.

The CAP Guidelines were developed by the pension industry to represent best practices.

The SMU pension plans were 100% compliant with the guidelines by the deadline on December 31, 2005.

Page 8: Faculty & Administration Pension Plan and Support Staff Pension Plan Annual General Meeting June 2006.

8

CAP Guidelines Assessment – Plan Governance

governance statement formalized organizational structure approved retirement committees established insurance and indemnification in place mission and goals documented terms of reference established pension benefit adequacy assessed - need to do analysis to confirm committee meetings occur regularly minutes documented and approved plan text updated and filed with regulator professional agents employed sufficient operating funds provided periodic reporting to Finance Committee member communication policy established delegation and monitoring of functions carried out internally formally documented

Plan governance is the process of implementing an effective control system to oversee the proper operation of the CAP. Key elements include defining the purpose of the CAP, ensuring effective documentation of all roles and responsibilities, legal requirements and support materials. Where key functions are to be delegated, the terms of the delegation should be documented and an effective monitoring system should be in place.

Page 9: Faculty & Administration Pension Plan and Support Staff Pension Plan Annual General Meeting June 2006.

9

The structuring and on-going assessment of an appropriate investment offering is critical to the success of a CAP. The investment structure should consider the nature of the CAP and the membership base. The structure should offer sufficient choice to enable members with different tolerances to risk and different return requirements to structure an optimal portfolio. The complexity of the investment structure should be managed so as to ensure that it can be communicated effectively to CAP members.

CAP Guidelines Assessment – Investment

comprehensive investment policy approved, annual review established investment policy and performance benchmarks regularly reviewed independent performance monitor engaged, Mercer HR Consulting qualitative assessment of investment managers reviewed range of investment choices is offered investment choices aligned with purpose of the CAP members control investment of employee and employer contributions members can easily make changes to investment choices investment decision-making tools provided to members default investment option has been established regular meetings with the investment alliance manager, Sun Life

Page 10: Faculty & Administration Pension Plan and Support Staff Pension Plan Annual General Meeting June 2006.

10

It is necessary to perform a periodic re-assessment of the recordkeeper to ensure that it continues to meet the original selection criteria and the standards outlined in the fees and services agreement. In the event that the recordkeeper no longer meets the needs of the CAP, quick action should be taken to remedy the situation. The level of fees borne by members will have a significant impact on member balances, and members should understand the level and what is included in the fees paid by them.

CAP Guidelines Assessment – Administration

engaged Sun Life Financial as recordkeeper Management services Plan member records and statements Customer service helpline Internet site Interactive software

recordkeeper service level established fees and service agreement in place fees compliance monitored formal system for monitoring the recordkeeper established full fee disclosure review member termination documentation periodically document retention policy adopted

Page 11: Faculty & Administration Pension Plan and Support Staff Pension Plan Annual General Meeting June 2006.

11

Having a clearly documented communication strategy helps to ensure that members receive accurate and timely communication. CAP members must be provided with information on their CAP account and the performance of the investment funds available in the CAP, as well as access to additional information upon request. All communication materials must be adequate and understandable, and provide CAP members with sufficient detail about available investment options so they can make informed investment decisions, using the tools available to them.

CAP Guidelines Assessment – Communication

member sign-up process new member orientation sessions periodic updates from Chair annual general meeting of members quarterly statements mailed directly to members pension plan website and information call centre regular written materials tools provided for decision-making communication strategy established for the CAP member booklet revised formal process for assessment of member information needs review process documented for communication materials in the communication policy

Page 12: Faculty & Administration Pension Plan and Support Staff Pension Plan Annual General Meeting June 2006.

12

Investment Performance Comparison - Canadian Equity Fund

Saint Mary's University

Year ended April 2005

25.7%

18.4%

Jarislowsky Fraser BGI

Page 13: Faculty & Administration Pension Plan and Support Staff Pension Plan Annual General Meeting June 2006.

13

Investment Performance Comparison - Canadian Equity Fund

Saint Mary's University

Year ended April 2005 Year ended April 2006

25.7%

18.4%

Jarislowsky Fraser BGI

23.7%

35.5%

Jarislowsky Fraser BGI

BGI information from Mercer monitor report 3-yr. average Mar. 31, 2006 = 28.9% top quartile performance compared to Mercer Pooled Fund Universe Strategy has above-average prospects to outperform Investment process, research, and professionals provide a competitive advantage

BGI fees are relatively low

Page 14: Faculty & Administration Pension Plan and Support Staff Pension Plan Annual General Meeting June 2006.

14

Pension Plan – education opportunities for plan members

Sun Life Information Sessions Plan member website training Retirement planning tool training

Financial Partners Information Sessions RBC – Estate Planning Scotia Private Client Group – Planning for Retirement

Information tailored to members nearing retirement Two small group sessions specific to SMU (Mercer) One-on-one consulting – first session paid by SMU Book purchase on retirement lifestyle

HR Department orientation sessions for new members

Canada Pension Plan session

Pension Website (SLF and SMU)

Quarterly statement inserts

Annual General Meeting

Page 15: Faculty & Administration Pension Plan and Support Staff Pension Plan Annual General Meeting June 2006.

15

Pension Plan – financial/budget report

The pension committees have adequate funding to operate effectively:

Operating funding $65,000 annual budget provided by SMU 2005/06 expenses $67,000 ($2,000 deficit)

(pension consulting, member meetings and training, investment monitoring, information return to pension superintendent, member communication)

Accumulated reserve for pension administration

increased from $71,000 to $72,000

($71,000 - $2,000 deficit + $3,000 interest)

Page 16: Faculty & Administration Pension Plan and Support Staff Pension Plan Annual General Meeting June 2006.

16

Committee Support Services (non-voting):

Advisor, Internal - Ron Cochrane (Director of Finance)Committee Secretary - Janine Rose (Pension & Benefits Officer)Pension Consultant - Karen Henderson (Mercer HR Consulting)

Support Staff Pension CommitteePension Plan #1395-02: 358 members, $19.4 million assets

Nova Scotia Government Employees Union (1)

appointed by NSGEU- David Lane (Astronomy & Physics)

International Union of Operating Engineers (1)

appointed by IUOE- Robert MacDonald (Facilities Management)

University, ex officio (2)

Vice-President, Finance & Director of HR- Larry Corrigan (Financial Services)- Kim Squires (Human Resources)

Senior Administrator (1)

appointed by President- Keith Hotchkiss (Student Services)

Page 17: Faculty & Administration Pension Plan and Support Staff Pension Plan Annual General Meeting June 2006.

17

Committee Support Services (non-voting):

Advisor, Internal - Ron Cochrane (Director of Finance)Committee Secretary - Janine Rose (Pension & Benefits Officer)Pension Consultant - Karen Henderson (Mercer HR Consulting)

Faculty & Administration Pension CommitteePension Plan #1395-01: 477 members, $77.1 million

Saint Mary's University Faculty Union (5)appointed by SMUFU- Darryl Bruce (Psychology)- Walt Finden (Mathematics)- Lori Francis (Psychology)- J eff Power (Accounting)- Nicola Young (Accounting)

Administrative/Professional Group (1)elected- Kevin Webb (Manager, Financial Planning)

University, ex officio (2)VP Finance & Director of HR- Larry Corrigan (Vice-President, Finance)- Kim Squires (Director, Human Resources)

Senior Administrator (1)appointed by President- Keith Hotchkiss (Director, Student Services)