Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

33
Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing Agnis Stibe Doctoral Candidate and Project Researcher [email protected] +358 401490499 @agsti Harri Oinas-Kukkonen Professor

description

How people located in airports can be socially influenced through information systems (social media) to change their behavior targeted to feedback sharing?

Transcript of Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

Page 1: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

Exploring the Effects of Social Influence

on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

Agnis StibeDoctoral Candidate and Project

Researcher

[email protected]+358 401490499

@agsti

Harri Oinas-KukkonenProfessor

Page 2: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

.oulu.fi

Agnis Stibe and Harri Oinas-Kukkonen “Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing”

Why did it?

What did?

Who are?

How did it?

What found?

What concluded?

WE

IADIS WWW/Internet ConferenceMadrid, October 19, 2012

Page 3: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

.oulu.fi

Agnis Stibe and Harri Oinas-Kukkonen “Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing”

Why did it?

What did?

Who are?

How did it?

What found?

What concluded?

WE

IADIS WWW/Internet ConferenceMadrid, October 19, 2012

Page 4: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

.oulu.fi

Agnis Stibe and Harri Oinas-Kukkonen “Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing”

PROJECT

Social Media Integrated in

Physical Space

(Airports)

IADIS WWW/Internet ConferenceMadrid, October 19, 2012

Page 5: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

.oulu.fi

Agnis Stibe and Harri Oinas-Kukkonen “Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing”

How social media can be used to

increase traveler’s participation in

feedback sharing while in airports

?IADIS WWW/Internet ConferenceMadrid, October 19, 2012

Page 6: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

.oulu.fi

Agnis Stibe and Harri Oinas-Kukkonen “Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing”

Why did it?

What did?

Who are?

How did it?

What found?

What concluded?

WE

IADIS WWW/Internet ConferenceMadrid, October 19, 2012

Page 7: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

.oulu.fi

Agnis Stibe and Harri Oinas-Kukkonen “Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing”

Persuasive 2012Linköping, Sweden: June 7, 2012

Page 8: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

.oulu.fi

Agnis Stibe and Harri Oinas-Kukkonen “Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing”

Persuasive 2012Linköping, Sweden: June 7, 2012

Page 9: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

.oulu.fi

Agnis Stibe and Harri Oinas-Kukkonen “Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing”

Why did it?

What did?

Who are?

How did it?

What found?

What concluded?

WE

IADIS WWW/Internet ConferenceMadrid, October 19, 2012

Page 10: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

.oulu.fi

Agnis Stibe and Harri Oinas-Kukkonen “Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing”

We are group

IADIS WWW/Internet ConferenceMadrid, October 19, 2012

Page 11: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

.oulu.fi

Agnis Stibe and Harri Oinas-Kukkonen “Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing”

Oulu Advanced Research on

Software and Information Systems

Socio-T

echnica

l Syst

ems

Human-Computer Interaction

Persuasive Technology

Behavior Change Support Systems

Persuasive Systems Design model

28 Features

IADIS WWW/Internet ConferenceMadrid, October 19, 2012

Page 12: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

.oulu.fi

Agnis Stibe and Harri Oinas-Kukkonen “Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing”

Persuasio

n

The influence of beliefs, attitudes, intentions, motivations, or behaviors.

A process aimed at changing people’s

attitude or behavior by using written or spoken words to convey information,

feelings, or reasoning, or a combination of them.

IADIS WWW/Internet ConferenceMadrid, October 19, 2012

Page 13: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

.oulu.fi

Agnis Stibe and Harri Oinas-Kukkonen “Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing”

Persuasive Technology

IADIS WWW/Internet ConferenceMadrid, October 19, 2012

Page 14: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

.oulu.fi

Agnis Stibe and Harri Oinas-Kukkonen “Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing”

Domains Health

Energy

Ecology

Business

Other

IADIS WWW/Internet ConferenceMadrid, October 19, 2012

Chatterjee, S. and Price, A. 2009 “Healthy Living with Persuasive Technologies: Framework, Issues, and

Challenges.”

Page 15: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

.oulu.fi

Agnis Stibe and Harri Oinas-Kukkonen “Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing”

Behavior Change

Support Syste

m

is a socio-technical information system with psychological and behavioral outcomes

designed to form, alter or reinforce

attitudes, behaviors or an act of complying

without using coercion or deception.

IADIS WWW/Internet ConferenceMadrid, October 19, 2012

Oinas-Kukkonen, H. 2012 “A Foundation for the Study of Behavior Change Support

Systems.”

Page 16: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

.oulu.fi

Agnis Stibe and Harri Oinas-Kukkonen “Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing”

Persuasiv

e Systems D

esign

model

28

featuresin 4 categories

Social Influence

IADIS WWW/Internet ConferenceMadrid, October 19, 2012

Oinas-Kukkonen, H. and Harjumaa, M. 2009 “Persuasive Systems Design: Key Issues, Process Model, and System

Features.”

Page 17: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

.oulu.fi

Agnis Stibe and Harri Oinas-Kukkonen “Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing”

How people located in airports can be

socially influenced through

information systems to change their

behavior targeted to feedback sharing

? R

IADIS WWW/Internet ConferenceMadrid, October 19, 2012

Page 18: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

.oulu.fi

Agnis Stibe and Harri Oinas-Kukkonen “Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing”

Why did it?

What did?

Who are?

How did it?

What found?

What concluded?

IADIS WWW/Internet ConferenceMadrid, October 19, 2012

Page 19: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

.oulu.fi

Agnis Stibe and Harri Oinas-Kukkonen “Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing”

IADIS WWW/Internet ConferenceMadrid, October 19, 2012

ResearchFramework

Page 20: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

.oulu.fi

Agnis Stibe and Harri Oinas-Kukkonen “Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing”

Persuasive 2012Linköping, Sweden: June 7, 2012

Implementation

Social Learning

Social Facilitation Cooperation

Recognition

Page 21: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

.oulu.fi

Agnis Stibe and Harri Oinas-Kukkonen “Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing”

Persuasive 2012Linköping, Sweden: June 7, 2012

Implementation

Social Learning

Social Facilitation

Competition

Cooperation

Page 22: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

.oulu.fi

Agnis Stibe and Harri Oinas-Kukkonen “Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing”

IADIS WWW/Internet ConferenceMadrid, October 19, 2012

37 18 19Participants Recognition Competition

35%

65%

Female Male

13%

57%

30%

20-24 years 25-29 years Over 30 years

Page 23: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

.oulu.fi

Agnis Stibe and Harri Oinas-Kukkonen “Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing”

Why did it?

What did?

Who are?

How did it?

What found?

What concluded?

IADIS WWW/Internet ConferenceMadrid, October 19, 2012

Page 24: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

.oulu.fi

Agnis Stibe and Harri Oinas-Kukkonen “Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing”

IADIS WWW/Internet ConferenceMadrid, October 19, 2012

92%Useful for feedback

collection

84%Encouraged users

to participate

Increase user Participation in developing or improving services provided by airports or airline companies

73%Believed, to some

degree, that the system would work well in a real airport

Feedback Participation Real Airport

Page 25: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

.oulu.fi

Agnis Stibe and Harri Oinas-Kukkonen “Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing”

IADIS WWW/Internet ConferenceMadrid, October 19, 2012

78%Tweets provided by

others on the big screen encouraged to come up with own tweets

81%The displayed number

of how many others were tweeting at the same time was as a positive motivator

70%The goal of 100 tweets

was perceived as a group task that requires cooperation

Social Learning Social Facilitation Cooperation

Page 26: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

.oulu.fi

Agnis Stibe and Harri Oinas-Kukkonen “Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing”

IADIS WWW/Internet ConferenceMadrid, October 19, 2012

70%Twitter is a powerful

tool to call for action outside the virtual world

73%Saw themselves in the

list of top responders or recognized with special titles

68%The displayed list of

top responders or public recognition motivated to improve performance

Influential Saw Themselves Competition/Recognition

Page 27: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

.oulu.fi

Agnis Stibe and Harri Oinas-Kukkonen “Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing”

IADIS WWW/Internet ConferenceMadrid, October 19, 2012

< 6 months

**The content tweeted by others encouraged me to create my own responses

Social Learning

> 6 months

**I tweet at least monthly on average

*I consider myself more than just a reader

Frequent/Contributors

Page 28: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

.oulu.fi

Agnis Stibe and Harri Oinas-Kukkonen “Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing”

IADIS WWW/Internet ConferenceMadrid, October 19, 2012

AT LEASTMONTHLY

Social Facilitation

NEVER OR SOMETHIM

ES

Cooperation Influential

Page 29: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

.oulu.fi

Agnis Stibe and Harri Oinas-Kukkonen “Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing”

IADIS WWW/Internet ConferenceMadrid, October 19, 2012

RECOGNITION

*I felt more willing to post additional tweets as the total number of tweets got closer to the goal of 100

COMPETITION

Cooperation

Page 30: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

.oulu.fi

Agnis Stibe and Harri Oinas-Kukkonen “Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing”

IADIS WWW/Internet ConferenceMadrid, October 19, 2012

HAVE SEEN BEING

RECOGNIZED

**Tweets provided by others on the big display encouraged me to come up with my tweets

*I felt more willing to post additional tweets as the total number of tweets got closer to the goal of 100

HAVE NOT SEEN BEING RECOGNIZED

Social Learning Cooperation

Page 31: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

.oulu.fi

Agnis Stibe and Harri Oinas-Kukkonen “Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing”

Why did it?

What did?

Who are?

How did it?

What found?

What concluded?

IADIS WWW/Internet ConferenceMadrid, October 19, 2012

Page 32: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

.oulu.fi

Agnis Stibe and Harri Oinas-Kukkonen “Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing”

IADIS WWW/Internet ConferenceMadrid, October 19, 2012

Frequent Tweeters

Influential70%

68%

68%

78%

81%

Less Experienced

Frequent Tweeters>

Page 33: Exploring the Effects of Social Influence on User Behavior Targeted to Feedback Sharing

[email protected]

@agsti

+358 401490499

Thanks to:

the Foundation of Nokia Corporation

the Finnish Funding Agency for Technology and Innovation

the Doctoral Program on Software and Systems Engineering