Evidence2Success Community Selection Webinar
-
Upload
the-annie-e-casey-foundation -
Category
Government & Nonprofit
-
view
397 -
download
0
Transcript of Evidence2Success Community Selection Webinar
Today’s Presenters
Suzanne Barnard, Annie E. Casey
Foundation
Kevin Haggerty,
Social Development
Research Group
Margaret Flynn-Khan, Mainspring Consulting
Rebecca Boxx,
Providence Children and
Youth Cabinet
2
I. Evidence2Success and how it works
II. What we’re looking for in new Evidence2Success communities
III. The role of prevention science and proven programs
IV. How Evidence2Success helps communities invest in what works
V. Evidence2Success progress in Providence
VI. Your questions via the Q&A window
Webinar Overview
3
Communicate with us using the Q&A window at the right of the presentation window.
• Type questions for the panel at any time during the webinar.
• Use the box to let us know if you are having technical difficulties.
Communicating During the Webinar
4
The Annie E. Casey Foundation develops solutions to build a brighter future for children, families and communities.
6
Lessons from Research:What is Required for Young People to Be Successful?
Com
mun
ity School
Individual and Peer
Family
Child Well-being
Positive Relationships Behavior
EducationPhysical Health
Emotional Well-being
7
The Evidence2Success Framework
Governance structure
including public systems and community
Strategic use of data
Comprehensive financing strategies
Implementation of evidence-
based programs (EBPs)
Performance measures
8
Evidence2Success: Shared responsibility and shared accountability
Priority Outcome
AreasChild Welfare
Service Providers
Public Health
Community Representatives
Education System
Juvenile Justice System
Mental Health
Elected LeadersRisk and protective factors
9
Evidence2Success Communities
Designated site coordinator and implementation
oversight of evidence-based practices
Commitment to provide and shift public funding
and to share funding data
Commitment of school system to administer surveys
and provide data
Partnership of government systems, elected officials and
residents
• Locality with at least 100,000 residents
• Focus neighborhoods where significant financial resources are spent on children
Ability or willingness to use and share data
across systems
10
Governance Structure: Evidence2Success is Community-Owned
Evidence2Success Governance Structure
• Local site coordinator• Fiscal agent• Lasting local home
Ongoing local capacity
• Dedicated staff liaison to communities
• Tools and technical assistance
Community leaders ● System leaders ● Residents
11
Governance Structure
Their Charge:
• Select local site coordinator
• Review and understand data
• Set priorities
• Select programs
• Develop and review RFPs
• Monitor implementation progress and
outcomes
• Develop finance plan and scale plan12
The local site coordinator (100% FTE) is a senior-level executive in the Evidence2Success community who will ensure successful implementation of the Evidence2Success framework and build necessary capacities. May serve as finance lead.
Ongoing Local Capacity:Local Site Coordinator
13
Ongoing Local Capacity: System Partner Commitments
• Commit resources to support the work and commit to redirecting an increasing amount of public resources toward evidence-based programs over time
– Commit $150,000 cash at the outset for evidence-based programs, to be matched by the Foundation
• Designate a finance lead, along with finance experts from participating public departments
• Complete a fund map – an analysis of how key funding streams are invested
• Develop a collaborative strategic financing plan
• Pool a portion of resources dedicated to this effort that the partnership will determine how best to spend based on local needs
14
Annie E. Casey Foundation Support Structure
Evidence2Success Site ManagerWorks with local site coordinator
Tools and Technical AssistanceSurvey * Online tools * In-person
consulting * Financing toolkit * Program database * Evaluation dashboard
15
Evidence2Success Phases
Phase 1:
Build Partnership
Capacity
Phase 2:Select
Priorities and Proven
Programs
Phase 3;
Prepare to Install
Programs
Phase 4: Install Programs, Align
Practice, Evaluate, Adapt
• Fund and implement evidence-based programs city or state–wide
• Ongoing monitoring, tracking and adapting using survey data and dashboard
• Re-administer youth survey and continue to use fund-mapping tools
16
1. Use local data to prioritize underlying factors that contribute to well-being
2. Make decisions about which proven programs to use
3. Discuss decisions with confidence, knowing that they are grounded in solid research
The Role of Prevention Science in Evidence2Success
18
Why Proven (Evidence-Based) Programs?
• More consistent positive outcomes
• Strong ethical argument
• Cost savings to taxpayers
• Ability to address multiple risk, protective factors and outcomes
• Higher certainty of achieving the intended impact when implemented with fidelity
19
Essential Characteristics of Proven Programs
Impact Evaluation Quality
System Readiness
Intervention Specificity
Positive impact on child well-being outcomes
Absence of any negative effects
One randomized controlled trial OR two quasi-experimental trials without design flaws
Population of focus is clearly defined
Risk and protective factors that a program seeks to change are identifiable
Training materials are available
Information provided on the financial and human resources required
Cost-benefit analysis
• Achieving better outcomes from your investments
• Coordinating investments in shared priorities
• Reducing remedial spending by investing on front end
• Leveraging new public and private dollars to scale and
sustain programs and infrastructure
Investing Smarter for Greater Returns
22
How Do You Invest Smarter for Greater Returns?
$54,890,000 annual spending for children and families in one
community
Program Total Investment(per year)
Incredible Years BASIC
$127,386
Promoting Alternative Thinking Strategies
$50,773(for 3 years)
Life Skills Training $14,280
Functional Family Therapy (FFT)
$287,100
Nurse Family Partnership (NFP)
$103,631(for 2 years)
Total shift in spending $583,170
Redirect 1 percent to proven programs
23
Developing a Strategic Financing Plan
What are your financing goals?
What resources do you have?
What financial resources do you
need?
What financing strategies will you
implement?
What financing structures will you
implement?
Support for Strategic Financing in Evidence2Success
• Connection with national technical assistance consultants – Act as coach to the finance lead – Support the development of the fund map and strategic
financing plan• Access to online strategic financing toolkit • Participation in a peer technical assistance network
– In-person training– Ongoing information sharing and opportunities to connect
with peers
25
• Providence Children and Youth Cabinet serves as the convener of cross-sector and cross-system efforts in the city
• Early exploration of the Evidence2Success framework identified clear synergy with existing city priorities:
– Use strong data on well-being of children and youth
– Deploy resources more effectively for children and youth
– Implement the highest quality programs
– Collaborate across sectors and systems
• Public system executives provide ongoing leadership: education, child welfare, public health
Evidence2Success and Providence
27
• Outcomes chosen through community-driven process
• Six proven programs selected
Providence Progress to Date
• Finance plan: Public system dollars and Health Equity Zone grant
• Implementation underway, serving more than 2,000 children 29
How does a program earn the distinction of being proven?
Develop a strong
program design
Attain strong evidence of
positive program outcomes
• Carry out evaluation with a comparison group
• Conduct regression analysis (quasi-experimental design )
• Perform multiple pre-and post -evaluations
• Meta-analysis
Produce indicators
of positive
outcomes
• Conduct evaluation with random assignment (experimental design)
• Carry out multiple evaluations with strong comparison group (quasi-experimental design)
• Conduct pre- and post-intervention evaluation
• Evaluate program quality and process
• Establish continuous improvement system
Ensure fidelity of
Implement-ation
Obtain evidence of
positive program
outcomes
• Create logic model and replication materials
30
Projected Program Targets:First Year of Implementation in One Site
Program How Much? How Well? What difference will it make?
Incredible Years 503children
$107,572 Redirected 15% increase in social competence
Cognitive Behavioral Intervention for Trauma in Schools (CBITS)
40 children $ 32,825Redirected
10% decrease in depression
Positive Action 2,141 children $ 96,044Redirected
15% decrease in problem behavior
31
Please use the Q&A function on your screen tosubmit questions.
For additional information after the webinar: Mildred Johnson, [email protected]
Proposal due date: May 28, 2015
For supplemental materials and more information about Evidence2Success: www.aecf.org
Questions?
32