Evidence Lecture Notes
-
Upload
keerthan-manjunath -
Category
Documents
-
view
220 -
download
0
Transcript of Evidence Lecture Notes
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
1/65
"#$ $%&'$()$*+,-$..,+ '/%&' .)0,11
2(&%$+.&13 ,- '$(%$+ .12+" ),44$5$ ,- 4/6
)0/*1$+ 78 &(1+,'2)1&,( /(' *+$.$(1/1&,( ,- $%&'$()$/9 -/)12/4 .)$(/+&, 1, #$ 2.$' 10+,250,21 10$ 4$)12+$
"#$ %&&%&&'(%)'*( *+ ,-.%#%/ 0'(1*2( *( ,3.'2 456 4789:
;.$&' % 32%? 1%22$< !"# %&'#()*+ ,-".(+at Fords Theatre in@%'(>)*(6 ABCB
!He was accompanied by his wife, Mary Todd Lincoln, in the Presidents box, as well asD%E*.F$(.? G%)#-*($ %(< #'& +'%(1H$6 C2%.% F%..'&B
! F'&)*.? )$22& I& )#%) )#$ %&&%&&'( =%& J*#( @'2K$& L**)#B! L**)# *) 0'(1*2( '( )#$ -%1K *+ )#$ #$%< =')# % *($M*)6 -2I$M&/*K$ A$..'(>$.B
,+)$. L**)# *) )#$ ;.$&'$6 =#'1# =%& %-*I)49 *. OP +$$) -$2*=B
! He caught his spur on the bunting or draping of the Presidents box.! F$ #') )#$ &)%>$ *
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
2/65
O \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'3''+ *::-='> 1- 1'.1(
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
3/65
` \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN' (+1- 'D(>'+)'5
V33*&'(> 1*I(&$2 1%( =%') I()'2 1.*&&M$Q%/'(%)'*( )* -.'(> '( )#$ */'))$< 3*.)'*(B
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
4/65
5 \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'()*1(D' ()(*: +-1()' -< 19(. *N$.(/$() '& (*) % 3%.)?B
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
5/65
9 \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'&: "#$ &1*3$ *+ aI$&)'*(& ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ *( 1.*&&M$Q%/'(%)'*(
OB ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ cI$&)'*(&: G$aI'.$ /I2)'32$ %(&=$.&
!"#$%&' 7* Q#5 C--198 2-" were an actor, you were at Ford. J9'*1'# -+ 19'+(?91 -< %0#(: KL
198 2-" 9*> #'+1'> * 9-#.'8 *+> 2-" .9-1 U#'.(>'+1 V(+)-:+R
`B cI$&)'*(& )#%) ,&&I/$ ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ b*) '( UN'
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
6/65
8 \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN' 1*I(&$2 %&K& % &$.'$& *+ aI$&)'*(& *( ' 9*. *.@'> Q*4-# I*193-+' *3-"1 =9'#' 9' =*..(11(+? -+ >(#')1 'F*&(+*1(-+5 ; )*+ *.@8 Q*4-# I*193-+'8 2-" .*(> * &-&'+1
*?- 19*1 2-" ='#' .(11(+? (+ 19' D('=(+? 3-F =(19 19' V(+)-:+. *1 19' 1(&' -< 19'
*..*..(+*1(-+R
$FEJL=;
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
7/65
f \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN' % -%&'1 +%1)
!"#$%&' )-* J9' >' =(19 &"#>'#5 % 0#'."&01(-+ *#(.'. 19*119' D()1(& (. >'*> =9'+ 19' 0'#.-+ 9*. 3''+ &(..(+? *N$.(& )#$ $++$1) *+ 3.$&I/3)'*(& ';:LE>@A= AB $C@D;=E;
! G%'&$& 3.$&I/3)'*( )#%) ') =*I2< #%N$ -$$( I(+%N*.%-2$ )* )#$
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
8/65
7 \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN' 19' )*# #-::'> >-=+ 19' .1#''15 Q*23' 2-" 9*D' * KNH
2'*#H-:> @(> =9- >')(>'> 1- 3"2 Q-& *+> W*> >-+"1. *+> )-(> +-1 .'' A-9+ B(:@'.C--19 .9--1 U#'.(>'+1 V(+)-:+5 C"18 9' 9'*#> 19' .9-18 :--@'> "0 *1 19' D('=(+?
3-F8 *+> .*= A-9+ B(:@'. C--19 9-:>(+? * ?"+ =(19 .&-@' )-&(+? -"1 -< (15
! *,* W2&XC%( 1'.1I/&)%()'%2 $N'
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
9/65
g \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN' 3' &-#' 0'#."*.(D' 1- .9-= 19*1 * -+'H.9-18 3:"'H.&-@'W'##(+?'# =*. #$< -? )#$ $. *+:
! _(+%'. ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ[! C*(+I&'(> )#$ '&&I$&[! D'&2$%'+)' '0'+>'+1 "0-+ 19' -19'#
witness testimony.
@#%) '+ '..$2$N%() $N'
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
10/65
4P \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN''+)' 19*1 A-9+ B (:@'. C--19(. D(-:'+1 1- .9-= 19*1 9' *)1'> D(-:'+1:2 -+ 19' >*2 -< 19' *..*..(+*1(-+5
! EF)'01(-+G "#$
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
11/65
44 \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN';: $C@D;=E; OEA=>9R
Victims Character! A criminal defendant may introduce evidence of the victims character that is relevant to
*($ *+ )#$ ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ %&&$.)$
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
12/65
4O \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'")' 'D(>'+)' 19*1 A-9+ B(:@'.C--19 0#'D(-".:2 *11*)@'> * man in Fords Theater, in the viewing box whe#'
U#'.(>'+1 V(+)-:+ =*. .(11(+?5 J9' >''+)'5 J9' 0#-.')"1(-+ )*+ #'.0-+> 19*1 19' 'D(>'+)' (. -'+)' 19*1 C--19 0#'D(-".:2 *11*)@'> * &*+ (+ 19' D('=(+? 3-F5
J9(. (. *>&(..(3:' (< C--19 ):*(&'> :*)@ -< -00-#1"+(125
C.'/'(%2 C%&$&: R3$1'+'1 '(&)%(1$& *+ 1*( *)#$. )#%( 3.*3$(&')? XD^D^CY!"#$%&' ,6* A-9+ B(:@'. C--19s fiance testifies that Booth was a very
0'*)'")15 7-='D'#8 19'
0#-.')"1(-+ &*2 ".' 'D(>'+)' -< 19' 0#(-# *11*)@ $C@D;=E; O-+$ ZPVR Evidence of a persons habit isZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ )* 3.*N$ 1*(
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
13/65
4` \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
14/65
45 \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN';=E;
UN$.? 3$.&*( '& ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ 1*/3$)$()B XWGU 8P4Y! cI$&)'*(& %-*I) /$()%2 1*/3$)$(1$ >* )* )#$ ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ .%)#$. )#%(
)#$ % C--195
OB @')($&&$& /I&) )%K$ %( ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZB XWGU 8P`Y
JI$& %& @')($&&$&: XWGU 8P9Y! D%? (*) )$&)'+? '( ).'%2 *N$. =#'1# $ 3.$&'
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
15/65
49 \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN' %-*I)[! ^(%-'2')? )* )$&)'+? %11I.%)$2?[! ;.'*. '(1*(&'&)$() &)%)$/$()&[ *.! ,(*)#$. 1*().% % witness-'%& '& bV" %))%1K'(> #'& ).I)#+I2($&& UQ).'(&'1 $N' -+ 9(. 4-3 *00:()*1(-+5 !+ )#-..H'F*&(+*1(-+8 ; *& +-1 *::-='> 1- 3#(+? (+ 19' 4-3 *00:()*1(-+ 1- .9-= 19*1 9'
:('>5 7-='D'#8 ; )*+ *.@ 9(& *3-"1 19' 4-3 *00:()*1(-+ ]6-" 0#'D(-". :('> -+ *
4-3 *00:()*1(-+8 )-##')1R^5 ;< 9' >'+('. (18 ; )*++-1 3#(+? (+ 19' 'F1#(+.()
'D(>'+)'5
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
16/65
48 \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'#$< -? I(+%'. 3.$EI6 %.>I/$()%)'N$6 $)1B DI&) #%N$ % >** )9')k may be introduced to show George Atzerodts bias. L? )$&)'+?'(> *( %(*)#$. /%))$.6 % =')($&& ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ =%'N$ )#$ 3.'N'2$>$
%>%'(&) &$2+M'(1.'/'(%)'*( +*. )$&)'/*(? .$2%)'(> *(2? )* )#e witness character (FRE 608(b)).
):@G@=?J )A=C@E>@A= (.9-+'.125 Q"#>'#8 #*0'8 *+> *..*":1 *#' X!J )#(&'. -< >(.9-+'.125
!"#$%&' -7*\'-#?' %1['#->1 1'.1(&(..(3:'R YYYYYYYYYY5
C.'/$& )#%) #& )#$ 3.$EI
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
17/65
4f \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN''+)' -"1='(?9. (1. 0-..(3:' 0#'4">()(*:
'5 7' =*. )-+D()1'> *. *4"D'+(:'5 J9(. (. X!J *>&(..(3:'5
@')($&& (*)
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
18/65
47 \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'=;?>;G;=>8! ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ -$ I&$< )* '/3$%1#! ;.'*. &)%)$/$() ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ ($$< )* -$ &=*.(
!"#$%&' .,* \'-#?' %1['#->1 1'.1(' * 0#(-# .1*1'&'+1 19*1 9' =*+1'> 1- 9*#& V(+)-:+8 19*1
.1*1'&'+1 (. *>&(..(3:'5
! R)%)$/$() ($$< (*) -$ *=( )* =')($&& XWGU 84`Y! UQ).'(&'1 $N''N$( )#$ *33*.)I(')? )*
ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ )#$ 3.'*. '(1*(&'&)$() &)%)$/$()B
!"#$%&' .-*
\'-#?' %1['#->1 1'.1(1 )"1 * >'*: =(19 19' 0#-.')"1(-+ (+ 'F)9*+?'
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
19/65
4g \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'('+)' &'&3'# >(> +-1 9*D' 9'# ?:*..'. -+ =9'+ .9' .*= *?"2 4"&0
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
20/65
OP \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN' *+> )*++-1 #'&'&3'# =9*1 0:*2 .9'=*. =*1)9(+? -+ 19' +(?91 -< 19' *..*..(+*1(-+5 J9' *11-#+'2 )*+ .9-= 9'# 19'
0:*23(:: *+> *.@ (< 9'# &'&-#2 =*. #'5 J9' *11-#+'2 )*+ 19'+ 1*@' 19'
0:*23(:: ` 9' &".1 0"1 (1*=*2 *+> 19'+ 1'.1((*#2 *3-"1 =9*1 9*00'+'> #(?91 *8 B9*1 9*00'+'> +'F1R /9' >-'. +-1
#'&'&3'#8 .- .9' :--@. *1 9'# >(*#25 %-'. +-1
#'&'&3'#5 J9' *11-#+'2 -
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
21/65
O4 \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
22/65
OO \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
23/65
O` \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN' .*&0:'.8 >#"? .*&0:'.@')($&& /I&) N$.'+? =#$.$%-*I)& +.*/ )'/$ $N'I;=>@E?>@=M *IN@A= 3.*3$.2?[
'''B cI%2'+'$< ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ[ %(I;=>@E?>@=M 'AELG;=>?:N $C@D;=E;8! C*//*( /$)#* 7*#-:> 1#*D':'> =(19 A-9+ B(:@'. C--195 7' 1'.1((*#2 3':-+?. 1- C--198 *+> 9' .*= C--19 =#(1(+? (+ (15
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
24/65
O5 \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN' *:.- 1'.1(=#(1(+? :--@. :(@'8 *+> 19' 9*+>=#(1(+? (+ 19' >(*#2
3':-+?. 1- C--195
! 1NH;< AB 'AELG;=>?:N $C@D;=E;8 B592'5: ;A95
@('T$& )#$ #%(
b*(M$Q3$.) 1%((*) #%N$ -$1*/$ +%/'2'%. =')# )#$ #%( +*. 2')'>%)'*(
3I.3*&$&
!"#$%&' 0/* W*D(> 7*#-:> +''>. 1- 9*D' -#(?(+*: @+-=:'>?' -< =9*1 A-9+Wilkes Booths handwriting looked like before :(1(?*1(-+5
''B ,( ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ =')($&& *. )#$ EI.? 1*/3%.$& )#$ =.')'(> '(
aI$&)'*( =')# %(*)#$. =.')'(> )#%) #%& -$$( 3.*N$( )* -$ >$(I'($B
Z9 .;JB`/L>I;=>@E?>@=M 'AELG;=>. -"1.(>' 19' =(+>-= -< 9(. 4*(: )':: 1- 9'*# 9(& 1*:@5 7'# 1'.1(&-+2 (.
*>&(..(3:' *. (>'+1( )#%)1*(N$.&%)'*( -? )$&)'+?'(> )#%):
'B He recognized that speakers voice[
''B "#$ &3$%K$. ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ )#%) *(2? % 3%.)'1I2%. 3$.&*( =*I2< #%N$
K(*=([
!"#$%&' 06* A-9+ B(:@'. C--19 1-:> \'-#?' %1['#->1 19*1 9' @''0. 9(.W'##(+?'# 9(>>'+ "+>'# 9(. *#&-(#'5
'''B The caller dialed the number that was believed to be the speakers and the speaker
ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ #'/&$2+ I3*( %(&=$.'(>[ *.
'NB "#$ 1%22$. %.$ %) '&&I$
*. '+ % =')($&& '& .$2?'(> *( )#$ =.')'(> =#'2$ )$&)'+?'(>B L$=%.$ *+ % +%1) 3%))$.(
'( =#'1# )#$ =')($&& '& .$2?'(> *( % =.')'(> +*. %( @GG?>;:@?J/%))$.B
79 &= 5;=;:?J! ,332'$& )* =.')'(>&6 .$1*.
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
26/65
O8 \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
27/65
Of \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'.$$/$()
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
28/65
O7 \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'$ %332'$& %) ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ *+ % 1%&$ W*. % 3.'N'2$>$ )* %332?6 )#$.$ /I&) -$ % ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ
1*//I('1%)'*(
! VN$.#$%.< -? %( I(=%()$< )#'.< 3%.)? j 3.'N'2$>$ ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ! UQ1$3)'*(&:
U%N$&B6 ).%(&2%)*.Y
F*2
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
29/65
Og \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'?J )AGGL=@E?>@A= , 1*//I('1%)'*( /%$B ,332'$& )* -*)# ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ %(< 1.'/'(%2 1%&$&B
@#$( 1%( ') -$ %&&$.)$$ %332'$& '( 1%&$& =#$( *($ &3*I&$ '& ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ)#$ *)#$. &3*I&$B
C.'/$ '& %>%'(&) )#$ *)#$. &3*I&$ C.'/$ '& %>%'(&) )#$ ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ *+ $')#$. &3*I&$
(A>; U8 R3*I&%2 '//I(')? -$>'(& -$+*.$ /%..'%>$ -I) $($ -I) $Q)$(
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
30/65
`P \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'$/$()[ ^ ?'+'#*: )-"+.': -< * )-#0-#*1(-+5
! C*.3*.%)$ C2'$()&: R*/$ &)%)$& 2'/') )#$ 3.'N'2$>$ *(2? )* )#$ 1*().*2 >.*I3 /$/-$.& *+ )#$ 1*.3*.%)'*(
X'B$B6 $< '+ )#$? %.$1*//I('1%)'(>:
@')#'( )#$'. $/32*?/$() 2$>%2 %$
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
31/65
`4 \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN': A'&12*&I.$ '( % &)%)$ 3.*1$$ '+:
! @*I2< (*) #%N$ -$$( % =%'N$. '( +$>8 Fix my leg. Ive just shot the President and Im on the run.
J9(. .1*1'&'+1 (. +-1 0#(D(:'?'>5
'NB ,
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
32/65
`O \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'#) '( +$$ *. )#$ 3&?1#*)#$.%3'&)M3%)'$() 3.'N'2$>$d
"#$ 3&?1#*)#$.%3'&)M3%)'$() 3.'N'2$>$! W$('T$ )#'& 3.'N'2$>$B! D%'&)6 *. 2'1$(&$< &*1'%2 =*.K$. %(< % 3%)'$()! ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ #*2$6 -I) 3&?1#*)#$.%3'&) /I&) %&&$.)! "#'& 3.'N'2$>$
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
33/65
`` \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'&(*) ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ *. *)#$. *.>%('T%)'*(&! C.'/'(%2 1%&$: , 3.*&$1I)*. /%? (*) 1*//$() *( % defendants failure to take the stand.! C'N'2 1%&$: V33*&'(> 1*I(&$2 /%? 1*//$() *( defendants failure to testify! , =')($&& /%? -$ 1*/3$22$< )* 3.*N' )$&)'/*(? '+ )#$ >*N$.(/$() >.%()&
#'/ ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ +.*/ 3.*&$1I)'*(B
".%(&%1)'*(%2 '//I(')?: ;.*)$1)'*( .$>%. 32 19' 0#-.')"1(-+ 1- 1'.1(# ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ *. 1*(N'1)'*( *+ )#$ I($
Z9 *:AB;
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
34/65
`5 \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'?J *:@C@J;M; =*. +'?:(?'+1 -# 19*1 9'
=*. )":0*3:'5 7-='D'#8 19' 'D(>'+)' )-":> 3' -(> +-1 -=+ 19' 19'*1'#5
)AGH:AG@@?>@A=*)'%)'*(& =')# >*N$.(/$()%2 %>$(1'$& %.$ %.$$/$() '& (*) %A *?N ";D@E?J $FH;=
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
35/65
`9 \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'[ %(< e*2I()%.?
4@?S@J@>N &=$(1$ *. =.*(>+I2 1*($(1?6 ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ6 1*().*26 *. =')($&&-'%& %(< 3.$EI#)& *+
#& %(? I(+%'. 3.$EI
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
36/65
`8 \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
37/65
`f \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN' *.@'>8 B9*1 >(> 2-" .*2 2'.1'#>*2R
6-" #'.0-+>8 6'.1'#>*28 ; .*(> 19' .@2 =*. 3:"'5 J9(. (. *+ -"1H-*28 19'#' (. * ?--> )9*+)' (1 (. 9'*#.*25
"#.$$ C%)$>*.'$&:! A$%< XWGU 7POY[
F$%.&%? '& '(%-'. +-1 &*11'# (< A-9+ (. *D*(:*3:'5 7-='D'#8
(< 19' =(1+'.. =*+1. 1- T"-1' 9(& "+>'# MaL8 19*1 0*#12 &".1 &''1 -+' -< 19'
#'T"(#'&'+1. (+ 19' #":'5
! 0'N'(> XWGU 7P4Y[ R)%)$/$()& )#%) %.$ (*) *++$.$< +*. )#$ ).I)# *+ )#$ /%))$. %&&$.)$ *+> *.@'> =9*1 2-" .*(> 2'.1'#>*25 6-"#'.0-+>8 ; .*(> 19' .@2 =*. 3:"'5 ;< 19' .1*1'&'+1 (. -' 2'.1'#>*28 -# 19*1 2-" )*+ .0'*@ E+?:(.98 19' .1*1'&'+1 (. +-1
9'*#.*25
R)%)$/$()& )#%) %.$ bV" #$%.&%? X$Q12I&'*(&Y ^/3$%1#/$() ^
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
38/65
`7 \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN' 19'+ * ?"+ ='+1 -
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
39/65
`g \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN' #"+ *1 19' .*&' 1(&'8 (1 =-":> +-1 3' 9'*#.*2
3')*".' (1 =*. +-1 - %&&$.)$19' U#'.(>'+15 A-9+ B(:@'. C--19 )*+ 19'+ 1*@' 19' .1*+> *+> .*28 %1['#->1
1-:> &' -+ %0#(: 19' Kb19, I have * :-1 -< (:: will toward the President. J9(. (.
+-1 3'(+? -@HJ; 0;?:
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
40/65
5P \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
41/65
54 \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN' *. 5A5I'#4=#J*+> *#'
#H$2==2E&'R
"=* G$aI'.$/$()& +*. ;.'*. R)%)$/$()&:! "#$ %) ).'%2[ %(1 =*. 0#'D(-".:2 >'0-.'>5 7(. 1'.1(&-+2 *1 1#(*:)-+1#*>()1. 9(. .1*1'&'+1 *1 9(. >'0-.(1(-+5 J9' .1*1'&'+1 (. *>&(..(3:' 8 ; @(::'> %3#*9*& V(+)-:+5 ;< 19(. .1*1'&'+1 =*. &*>' (+ *
>'0-.(1(-+8 (1 )*+ 3' -1 @(::'> V(+)-:+5 ;< 19'
.1*1'&'+1 =*. +-1 &*>' "+>'# -*198 (1 )*+ 3' -15
^(1*(&'&)$() =')# )#$ )$&)'/*(? -$'(> >'N$( %) ).'%2$D@>A:\< (A>; Y8 The professor misspoke. The statement must be inconsistent=')# )#$ )$&)'/*(? *++$.$< %) ).'%2 )* aI%2'+? +*. )#'& $Q1$3)'*(B
U9 *:@A: )A= .>?>;G;=>
.$1$() /*)'N$ )* 2'$
! ^& %%.' *+ (+)-+.(.1'+1
.1*1'&'+15
Q9 *:@A: .>?>;G;=>< AB &D;=>@B@E?>@A=! , 3.$N'*I& *I)M*+M1*I.) '
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
42/65
5O \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN' (>'+1(&(..(3:' (< .9' 1'.1( %) )#'& 1I..$() ).'%2 X%(< '& )#$.$+*.$ (*)
&I-E$1) )* 1.*&&M$Q%/'(%)'*(YB "#'& $Q1$3)'*( 1%((*) %332? '+6 +*. '(&)%(1$6 )#$
=')($&& '& %)'*( )#%) '& I&$< %>%'(&) )#%)
3%.)? '& ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZB
"#'& %'(&) )#$ 3$.&*(s interest
!"#$%&' ))+*\'-#?' %1['#->1 1'.1(8 Im aV(3#*c J9(. .1*1'&'+1 (. *>&(..(3:', even though it is not against Booths
(+1'#'.15
! S 19' 9-".' *+> &2 .-+ said, A-9+ B(:@'. C--19 (. ?-(+?
to be the one to kill Abraham Lincoln. J9(. T"*:(&(..(-+8
*+> (. *>&(..(3:'
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
43/65
5` \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN' >-'. +-1 1'.1(&(..(3:' *. * )-Hconspirators admission.
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
44/65
55 \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'$($.%22? '(% &< 2=?C?@J?SJ; O-+$ bPZR
/ ';EJ?:?=> @< 2=?C?@J?SJ;@B 0;8! ^& $Q$/3) *( )#$ >.*I( @< ';;G;D /C?@J?SJ; @B8"#$ 3%.)? &$$K'(> )* '().* *1 * >'0-.(1(-+8 *+> A-9+
Wilkes Booths )-"+.': 9*> * )9*+)' 1- )#-..H'F*&(+' 9'#5 %>>(1(-+*::28 19'2
9*> * .(&(:*# &-1(D'5 J9' .1*1'&'+1 (. *>&(..(3:'5
!"#$%&' ))6*Q*#2 J->> V(+)-ln was deposed in a different case and Booths)-"+.': =*. +-1 0#'.'+15 J9' .1*1'&'+1 (. +-1 *>&(..(3:' 3')*".' C--19 >(>
+-1 9*D' *+ -00-#1"+(12 1- )#-..H'F*&(+' 9'#5
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
45/65
59 \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN' 7*#-:>8 9' 9*> * -+'H.9-18
3:"'H.&-@' W'##(+?'#5 J9(. (. )-##-3-#*1(+? 'D(>'+)'5 Booth can use Harolds
.1*1'&'+1 3')*".' (1 =*. *?*(+.1 9(. (+1'#'.1 *+> 19'#' (. )-##-3-#*1(+?
(+1'#'.15
Z9 .>?>;G;=> AB *;:A 6:A=MDA@=M O-A:B;@>L:; /M?@= 6:A=MDA@=MR
!"#$%&' )+)*A-9+ B(:@'. C--19 )*".'. W*D(> 7*#-:> 1- 3' "+*D*(:*3:'5 C--19)*++-1 -34')1 (< 19' 0#-.')"1(-+ attempts to use David Harolds outH-
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
46/65
58 \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'@A=< 6I;:; Declarants Availability I< &GG?>;:@?J O-+$ bPQR
*:; .;=2 #'.0-+>.8 A-9+ B(:@'. C--19 (. 4"&0(+? - T"-1' 19(. &*+ *+> - 1- T"-1' 19' &*+R
YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY5
!"#$%&' )+/*6-" *#' -+ 19' 09-+' =(19 2-"# ?(#:friend who is at Fords Theater./9' .*2.8 ; *& =*1)9(+? ABC .9--1 19' U#'.(>'+1 *+> #"+ *)#-.. 19' .1*?'5
J9(. (. * 0#'.'+1 .'+.' (&0#'..(-+5 ;< 2-"# ?(#: .*2.8 !9 &2 ?-.98 ; 4".1 .*= A-9+ B(:@'. C--19 .9--1 19'
U#'.(>'+1c J9(. (. *+ 'F)(1'> "11'#*+)' 3')*".' .9' =*. .1(:: "+>'# 19' .1#'.. - 1- @(:: U#'.(>'+1 V(+)-:+5
! b*) %@?Jevidence of the declarants state of mind (not hearsay). "* /$$) )#$ &)%)$ *+
/'(< $Q1$3)'*(6 )#$ &)%)$/$() /I&) -$ *++$.$< )* 3.*N$ )#%) )#$ 8! A statement that describes the declarants medical history6 3%&) *. 3.$&$()
ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ6 3%'(6 *. *)#$. &$(&%)'*(&
! ,2&* %*$& )* )#$ 1%I&$ *+ )#$ '(EI.?!"#$%&' ),8*J9' >-)1-# )-":> 1'.1((*&'&
A$3$(
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
48/65
57 \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'>5 John Wilkes Booth was so tired he couldnt talk. Mrs. Booth said,
A-9++2 4".1 3#-@' 9(. :'? when he jumped off the balcony at Fords J9'*1'# :*.1
+(?915 J9(. .1*1'&'+1
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
49/65
5g \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'@A=< Where Declarants Availability I< &GG?>;:@?J OEA=>9R O-+$ bPQR
+;EA:D;D +;EAJJ;E>@A=8! "#$ .$1*.< '& .$%< '()* $N'(*#2 '+1#25 J9(. =-":> 0-..(3:2 T"*:(&(..(3:' "+>'# 19' 3".(+'.. #')-#>. 'F)'01(-+5
! Distinguished from Recorded Recollection: Does not require witness& %-'2')? )* .$/$/-$.! ,I)#$()'1%)'(> G$1*.
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
50/65
9P \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN' 19'
#')-#>. &*2 9*D' =*+1'> 1- &(.)9*#*)1'#([' 19(+?.5
! UQ%/32$&: D$ -. &*>'
19'(# #-"+>. 19*1 +(?915
*LSJ@E +;EA:D
R$)& *I) %1)'N')'$& *+ *++'1$ *. %>$(1?[ V-&$.N%)'*( *+ % 3$.&*( =#* #%& % ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ )* .$3*.) )#%) *-&$.N%)'*(
UQ1$3)'*(&:
V-&$.N%)'*(& *+ % 2%= $(+*.1$/$() *++'1'%2 '( % ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ 1%&$
W%1)I%2 +'(*N$.(/$()
! D%? $Q12I
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
51/65
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
52/65
9O \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'' 1- 19' 0-:()' >"#(+? T"'.1(-+(+? 1- *.)'#1*(+0*.1 )#(&(+*: )-+>")1 (. )-+.(>'#'> 1'.1(&-+(*:5
_(%N%'2%-2$: ;.*&$1I)'*( /I&) *= )#$ ' =(1+'.. =9- (. * D()1(& -< * .'F- =-":> ."
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
53/65
9` \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN' *+ % +%1) %& ).I$ ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ .$aI'.'(> 3.**+
8B @#%) &*.)& *+ % aI$&)'*(d
V($ )#%) ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ =')#'( )#$ aI$&)'*(
OB @#$( %.$ 2$%$($.%22? 3$./'&&'-2$ *(
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
54/65
95 \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN' ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ )#%) ?*I *I2< ='( ?*I. 1%&$
9B @#%) '& % .$-I))%-2$ 3.$&I/3)'*(d
R#'+)& )#$ ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ %(< .$aI'.$& )#$
ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ )* *++$. 1*I()$.3.**+
)9 +$4$%/()$4B @#%) '& )#$ &)%(&(..(3:' 1- 0#-D' 19' >'
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
55/65
99 \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN' 19' >--#8 *::-=(+? 19' 0#-.')"1(-+ 1- (+1#->")'
'D(>'+)' -< 9(. )9*#*)1'#
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
56/65
98 \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN' % =')($&& =')# )#%) )#$ &)%)$/$()d
ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ
4PBD%? 3.'*. '(1*(&'&)$() &)%)$/$()& >$($.%22? -$ 3.*N$( =')# $Q).'(&'1 $N'
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
57/65
9f \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN' )#$ =')($&& &*/$)#'(> )* ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ
ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ &* #$ 1%( )$&)'+? +.*/ ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZB
;%&) .$1*22$1)'*( .$1*. +.*/ /$/*.? -$1%I&$ )#$
=')($&& ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ $(*I>#
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
58/65
97 \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN' *+ % 1%. %11'%. % 3#?&'1'%(M3%)'$() 3.'N'2$>$6 =#%) 2'/')%)'*(& %.$ 1*//*(d A*$& (*) $Q'&) '+ %1aI'.$< +*.
ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ[
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
59/65
9g \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'$ A*$& (*) %332? '+ 3%.) *+ % ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ *.
ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ
4PBD%? )#$ 3.'N'2$>$ %>%'(&) &$2+M'(1.'/'(%)'*( -$ '(N*K$< '( % 1'N'2 1%&$dZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ
&9 *2#4&) *,4&)3 $_)42.&,(.4B W*. =#%) 3I.3*&$ '& $N' 32$% -%.>%'( ($>*)'%)'*(& -$
%
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
60/65
8P \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'*28 (1 (. 9'*#.*25
OB D%? (*(N$.-%2 1*(#) )#$.$ -$ +*. % &)%)$/$() *)#$. )#%( )* 3.*N$ )#$ ).I)# *+ )#$ /%))$. %&&$.)$ % 1%.6L$ 1%.$+I26 /? -.%K$& %.$ -%$() *. #%< %&&I/$< )#$ .'&K6 =*I2< ') -$
#$%.&%?d
ZZZZZZZZZZZZZ
8B @#%) '& /I2)'32$ #$%.&%?%(< =#%) /I&) -$ *=( )* .$(18=9- =*. T"-1(+? A-9+ B(:@'. C--195 J9'#' *#' 1=- :'D':. -< 9'*#.*25 J9'
.1*1'&'+1. -< A-9+ B(:@'. C--19 *#' *+ *>&(..(-+ -< * 0*#12 -00-+'+15
Stantons testimony is admissible if Atzerodts statement fits within an exception
-# 'F):".(-+5
fB "#$ )#.$$ 1%)$>*.'$& *+ 3.'*. &)%)$/$()& )#%) %.$
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
61/65
84 \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
62/65
8O \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
63/65
8` \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'I2%.2?
1*(.8 09-+' :-? &*>' 32 * #')'01(-+(.18 '1)544B ^+ %( %11'%)'*(6
=*I2< ') aI%2'+? I(
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
64/65
85 \ ] OP45 "#$/'& L%. G$N'$=6 00C \ DLU UN'#) #$%.&%? $N'$%'(&)
#'/d
ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ
`B @#%) &*.)& *+ *I)M*+M1*I.) &)%)$/$()& ='22 N'*2%)$ )#$ 1*(+.*()%)'*( .'>#)& *+ %( %11I&$< '+
*++$.$< %>%'(&) #'/ '( % 1.'/'(%2 ).'%2d
ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ
5B @#%) /%K$& % &)%)$/$() )$&)'/*('%2I(
-
8/12/2019 Evidence Lecture Notes
65/65
A$+$(