Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United … · Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a...

28
Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United States Post Office Lilia Chen, MS Ayodele Adebayo, MD, MPH National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health Health Hazard Evaluation Report HETA 2007-0216-3056 United States Postal Ser vices Apply Valley, California Febuar y 2008 DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Workplace Safety and Health

Transcript of Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United … · Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a...

Page 1: Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United … · Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United ... RH Relative humidity ... Letter carriers leave the building to deliver

Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United States Post Office

Lilia Chen, MS

Ayodele Adebayo, MD, MPH

National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health

Health Hazard Evaluation Report HETA 2007-0216-3056 United States Postal Services Apply Valley, California Febuary 2008

DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES Centers for Disease Control and Prevention

Workplace Safety and Health

Page 2: Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United … · Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United ... RH Relative humidity ... Letter carriers leave the building to deliver

The employer shall post a copy of this report for a period of 30 calendar days at or near the workplace(s) of affected employees. The employer shall take steps to insure that the posted determinations are not altered, defaced, or covered by other material during such period. [37 FR 23640, November 7, 1972, as amended at 45 FR 2653, January 14, 1980].

Page 3: Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United … · Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United ... RH Relative humidity ... Letter carriers leave the building to deliver

Contents

RepoRt Abbreviations........................................................................ ii

Highlights.of.the.NIOSH.Health.Hazard.Evaluation............. iii

Summary............................................................................. iv

Introduction...........................................................................1

Assessment..........................................................................3

Results.and.Discussion........................................................4

Conclusions........................................................................10

Recommendations..............................................................10

References.........................................................................13

Appendix A Health.Effects.....................................................................16

Appendix B Additional.Information.on.IEQ.Issues.................................17

ACknowledgments Acknowledgements.and.Availability.of.Report....................19

Health Hazard Evaluation Report 2007-0216-3056 Page �

Page 4: Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United … · Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United ... RH Relative humidity ... Letter carriers leave the building to deliver

ABBReviAtions

ANSI AmericanNationalStandardsInstitute

APWU AmericanPostalWorkersUnion

ASHRAE AmericanSocietyofHeating,RefrigeratingandAirConditioningEngineers

AVPO AppleValleyPostOffice

cfm Cubicfeetperminute

CO Carbonmonoxide

CO2 Carbondioxide

EPA EnvironmentalProtectionAgency

ft2 Feetsquared

H. capsulatum Histoplasmacapsulatum

HEPA High-efficiencyparticulateair

HHE Healthhazardevaluation

HIV Humanimmunodeficiencyvirus

HVAC Heating,ventilating,andair-conditioning

IEQ Indoorenvironmentalquality

m3 Cubicmeter

MSDS Materialsafetydatasheet

NALC NationalAssociationofLetterCarriers

NIOSH NationalInstituteforOccupationalSafetyandHealth

PPE Personalprotectiveequipment

ppm Partspermillion

RH Relativehumidity

USPS UnitedStatesPostalService

Page �� Health Hazard Evaluation Report 2007-0216-3056

Page 5: Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United … · Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United ... RH Relative humidity ... Letter carriers leave the building to deliver

HigHligHts of tHe

niosH HeAltH

HAzARd evAluAtion

Health (NIOSH) received

(HHE) at the United

and air conditioning

2007.

The National Institute for Occupational Safety and

a union request for a health hazard evaluation

States Postal Service Office in Apple Valley, California. The request concerned workers at the post office potentially being exposed to pigeon droppings from pigeons roosting in the building’s heating, ventilating,

(HVAC) units. NIOSH investigators conducted an investigation in July

What NIOSH Did ● Weperformedconfidentialmedicalinterviewswithemployees

regardingtheirhealthsymptoms.

● Weinspectedthebuilding’sventilationsystemandreviewedthe system’sdesign.

● Wetookindoorenvironmentalqualitymeasurements (temperature,relativehumidity,andcarbondioxide[CO2

]).

● Wereviewedthebuildingventilationschematics,relevant healthandsafetyrecords,andpastsamplingreports.

What NIOSH Found ● Wefoundnospecificoccupationalorenvironmentalexposure

thatexplainsthehealthsymptomsthepostofficeemployees reported.

● Wefoundthatcomfortparametersatthepostofficewere withinacceptableguidelinesexceptforelevatedCO2

levels measuredinsomeworkareas,possiblyindicatinginadequate outdoorairintakeorunevenmixingofair.

● WefoundthattherooftopHVACunitshadbirdnettingin placetopreventpigeonentry.

● Wefoundnoevidenceofbirdsoranyotheranimalsinthe HVACunits.

What Managers Can Do ● Managersshouldmaintainnettingprotectionaroundthe

HVACunitstokeepbirdsout.

● Managersshouldensurethatoutdoorairdampersarenot completelyclosedtoallowadequateoutdoorairintake.

● Managersshouldensurethatregularhousekeepingactivities areperformedonaregularbasistoreducetheamountof particulatematterinthebuilding.

● Managersshouldhaveatestandbalanceoftheventilation systemdonetodeterminewhethertheHVACsystemis performingasdesigned.

What Employees Can Do ● Employeesshouldpromptlyreportanyconcernstheyhave

regardingbuildingconditionstomanagement.

● Employeesshouldtalkwiththeirphysiciansregardingany symptomstheybelievetobework-related.

Health Hazard Evaluation Report 2007-0216-3056 Page ���

Page 6: Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United … · Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United ... RH Relative humidity ... Letter carriers leave the building to deliver

summARy

The symptoms reported by employees can be caused by a variety of health conditions and illnesses and could not be attributed to a specific workplace exposure. After inspecting the

medical interviews, and taking into account the environmental requirements of H. capsulatum spores, we deemed that the potential for employees to contract histoplasmosis was

we do not recommend general testing for all

employees with persistent symptoms should contact their physician on a case-by-case basis to determine if individual testing is appropriate.

HVAC units, performing

very low. Therefore,

AVPO employees for histoplasmosis. However,

OnApril17,2007,NIOSHreceivedarequestfromNALCforan HHEonbehalfofworkersattheUSPSinAppleValley,California. NALCrepresentativesfiledtheHHErequestbecauseworkers atthepostofficewerepotentiallyexposedtopigeondroppings frompigeonsroostingontheroofandinthebuilding’sHVAC units.Someworkersreportedexperiencingdizziness,breathing difficulties,cough,andweakness,andwereconcernedthatthese symptomsresultedfromexposuretoH. capsulatum,afungusthat causeshistoplasmosis,afungallunginfection.Adead-animal odorinthebuildingwasreportedbyemployeesandadded totheirconcerns.TheNALCspecificallyaskedthatNIOSH conductorrecommendmedicaltestingforallAVPOemployeesto determinewhetherthesesymptomswererelatedtoexposuretoH. capsulatum,andconductanyadditionalsiteevaluationsdeemed necessarytoensurethehealthandsafetyofthepostalworkers.

OnJuly11-13,2007,NIOSHrepresentativesmadeasitevisit totheAVPO.NIOSHinvestigatorsheldopeningandclosing conferenceswithunionrepresentatives(NALC),managementof AVPO,thesafetymanager,representativesfromtheUSPSSan Diegodistrictoffice,andanindustrialhygienecontractorwho previouslyperformedenvironmentalsampling.WetookIEQ measurements(temperature,RH,andCO2

)andheldconfidential medicalinterviewswithUSPSemployees.Wealsoreviewed availableenvironmentaltestingreportsandmaintenancerecords.

Wefoundnodirectrelationshipbetweencurrenthealthsymptoms reportedbyAVPOemployeesandspecificoccupationalor environmentalexposures.Perceivedodorandbuildingventilation issueslikelycontributedtothesesymptoms.Wefoundthatthe potentialforemployeestocontracthistoplasmosiswaslowandthis potentialwasfurtherminimizedbycleaningandinstallingnets aroundtheHVACunits.WedonotrecommendtestingAVPO employeesforhistoplasmosis.However,ifindividualemployees feelthattheyshouldbetestedduetotheirsymptoms,theyshould discusstheirsymptomsandconcernswiththeirphysician.

Atthetimeofourinvestigation,wefoundcomfortparametersat thepostofficetobewithinacceptableguidelinesrecommended byASHRAEexceptforelevatedCO2

levelsinsomeworkareas, possiblyindicatinginadequateoutdoorairintakeorunevenmixing ofair.Allpigeonfecalmatterhadbeenclearedfromtheunitswe

Page �v Health Hazard Evaluation Report 2007-0216-3056

Page 7: Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United … · Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United ... RH Relative humidity ... Letter carriers leave the building to deliver

summARy (Continued) examinedand,overall,thebirdnettingappearedintact.Although wesawtwobirdfeathersinoneoftheHVACunits,wefoundno evidencethatbirdswereenteringorstilllivingintheunit.

Keywords: NAICS 491110 (Postal Service), histoplasmosis, pigeons, fecal matter, postal workers, indoor environmental quality, IEQ, ventilation, odors

Health Hazard Evaluation Report 2007-0216-3056 Page v

Page 8: Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United … · Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United ... RH Relative humidity ... Letter carriers leave the building to deliver

Thispageintentionallyleftblank.

Page 9: Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United … · Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United ... RH Relative humidity ... Letter carriers leave the building to deliver

intRoduCtionOnApril17,2007,NIOSHreceivedarequestfromtheNALC foranHHEonbehalfofworkersattheUSPSinAppleValley, California.NALCrepresentativesfiledtheHHErequestbecause workersatthepostofficewereconcernedaboutpigeondroppings frompigeonsroostingontheroofandinthebuilding’sHVAC units.Workersreportedexperiencingdizziness,breathing difficulties,cough,andweakness,andwereconcernedthatthese symptomsresultedfromexposuretoH. capsulatum,afungusthat causeshistoplasmosis,afungallunginfection.Adead-animalodor inthebuildingwasreportedbyemployeesandaddedtotheir concerns.TheNALCspecificallyaskedthatNIOSHconductor recommendmedicaltestingforallAVPOemployeestodetermine whetherthesesymptomswererelatedtoexposuretoH. capsulatum, andconductanyadditionalsiteevaluationsdeemednecessaryto ensurethehealthandsafetyofthepostalworkers.

TheAVPOislocatedinthedesertabout2hourseastofLos AngelesinSanBernardinoCounty.Thebuildingisaone-story 28,000ft2warehouse-likestructurebuiltin1988.AVPOemploys 96employees,67ofwhomarelettercarriersand29ofwhomare clerks,custodians,orsupervisors.Customerpostboxesandmail servicesarelocatedatthefrontofthebuilding.Thebackofthe buildinghousesthedistributioncenter,whereclerksandletter carrierssortincomingmail,andtruckdriverspickupoutgoing mail.

Typically,mailclerksstarttheirshiftat3:30a.m.andseparate incomingmailbyroutesforthelettercarriers.Lettercarriers begintheirshiftsat8:00a.m.andsortthemailfortheirroutes ina“case,”whichisathree-walledboothwithstanding-room onlyspace.Eachwallhasshelvesofholdingslotswheretheletter carriersorganizemail.Lettercarriersleavethebuildingtodeliver mailatapproximately10:30a.m.andreturnaround5:00p.m. Theyaverage3.5to4hoursinthebuildingand5or6hours ontheirroutes.Somelettercarriersalsoworkovertimetoa maximumof10hoursoftotalworkperday.Clerks,custodians, andsupervisorsspendthemajorityoftheirworkinghoursinthe building.

Managementreportedthatfacilitymaintenanceemployees dusthighareasonaquarterlybasis.However,theydonotkeep recordsofwhodusted,orwhen.TheAVPOusesanindependent contractorforpestcontrol,whosetstrapsandspraysforpests quarterly.

Health Hazard Evaluation Report 2007-0216-3056 Page �

Page 10: Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United … · Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United ... RH Relative humidity ... Letter carriers leave the building to deliver

intRoduCtion (Continued) AVPOemployeesarerepresentedbytwounions,theNALCand theAPWU.LettercarriersarerepresentedbytheNALC,and custodiansandclerksarerepresentedbytheAPWU.Complaints orconcernsofsafetyissuescanbebroughttotheattentionof theunionchiefstewards,whonotifymanagement;alternatively, employeescanfilloutaReportofHazard,UnsafeCondition orPractice(1767)formthattheymayanonymouslysubmitto management.Managementisrequiredtorespondtotheemployee onthecorrectiveactiontaken,eitherdirectlyorthroughameeting ofallemployees(inthecaseofanonymoussubmittal)withinthe sameworktour.

TheAVPOhasaSafetyandHealthCommitteecomposedof volunteeremployeesandmanagement.Managementandunion representativeshavestatedthattheyhavemissedsomemeetings andwouldliketoresumeregularcommitteemeetingsand activities.

InJanuary2006,agroupofAVPOemployeesperceivedadead-animalodorinandimmediatelyoutsidethebuilding.Thisodor wasreportedlyassociatedwithsymptomssuchasnausea,dizziness, headaches,light-headedness,cough,andbreathingdifficulty.Upon findingthatpigeonshadbeenlivingandnestingintherooftop HVACunits,managementprocuredaproposalfromacleaning andsanitizingcompanytoremovethepigeondebris,deadanimals, andnestingmaterial,andinstallbirdnettingforalloftheHVAC units.Thisproposalwasnotapprovedbecauseitwasdeemedtoo expensivebythepriorAVPOmanagement.

OnMarch6,2006,AVPOcontractedanHVACcontractorto eliminatetheodorproblem.Thecontractorfoundevidenceof nestinginoneoftheHVACunits;inaddition,filtersontwoof theunitsneededtobechanged.Thecontractorremovedthebird debrisandreplacedthefilters.However,employeesreportedthat theodorpersisted.

OnMay11,2006,theHVACcontractorreturnedtothepostoffice toservicethesupplyunitfortheemployeebreakroom,men’s lockerroom,andbathroom;areaswheretheodorwasreportedly worst.Theyfoundandfixedabrokenventpipe,whichwas thoughttobethesourceofthesmell.Theyalsoreportedclosing theoutdoorairdamper.Theodorwasreportedlylessnoticeable overtimeafterthesechangesweremade.

Page � Health Hazard Evaluation Report 2007-0216-3056

Page 11: Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United … · Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United ... RH Relative humidity ... Letter carriers leave the building to deliver

intRoduCtion (Continued) OnSeptember28,2006,thebudgetwasapprovedtocleanand removebirddebrisandinstallbirdnettingaroundtwoHVAC unitslocatedintherecessedareaontherooftop(proposalwas submittedinJanuary2006,bytheoriginalcleaningandsanitizing company).TwooftherooftopHVACunitsarecompletelyencased withnettinginacage-likestructure.Theothersevenunitshave nettingthatisattachedtothebottomoftheunitsandweighted totheroof,preventingbirdaccessintotheunitviatheoutdoor airdampers.Managementreportedthatthecompanytook severalweekstopressure-washthearea;removenests,birdfecal material,anddebris;andinstallthenetting.Althoughthecontract agreementwereviewedspecifiednettingforonlytwooftheHVAC rooftopunits,managementstatedthatalltheunitswerenettedat thattime.

InJanuary2007,severalemployeesraisedconcernsthathealth symptomstheyhadbeenexperiencingmaybeattributedto exposuretoH. capsulatuminthebirddroppings.Inresponse toemployeeconcerns,managementhiredanindependent environmentalconsultantonMarch6,2007,whotooktwo ambientairandonebulksample(fecalmatter)totestforavian-bornepathogens(H. capsulatum, Cryptococcus neoformans,and Chlamydophila psittaci).Airsampleswerecollectedonto37-millimeterpolycarbonatefiltersusinghigh-flowvacuumpumps calibratedat10litersperminuteandanalyzedbypolymerasechain reaction.Bothairsampleswerereportedbelowthedetectionlimit of100organisms/filteror<88organisms/m3,andnopathogens weredetectedinthebulksample.

OnMay23,2007,aUSPSbuildingengineerreportedthatone oftheHVACunitswasagaininfestedwithpigeons.OnMay30, 2007,theHVACcontractorremovedfeathers,pigeondebris,and deadpigeonsfrominsidetheHVACunit.Theotherunitshad nosignsofbirdactivityorroosting.Thecontractor’sworklog indicatedthattheycleanedtheeconomizersandcoolingcoils,and resealedanypossibleareasofpigeonentry.

Assessment OnJuly11-13,2007,wemadeasitevisittotheAVPO. NIOSHinvestigatorsheldanopeningconferencewithNALC representatives,AVPOmanagement,thesafetymanager, representativesfromtheUSPSSanDiegodistrictoffice,and anindustrialhygienecontractorwhoperformedtheprevious

Health Hazard Evaluation Report 2007-0216-3056 Page �

Page 12: Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United … · Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United ... RH Relative humidity ... Letter carriers leave the building to deliver

Assessment (Continued)

Results And disCussion

environmentalsampling.Wealsodirectlyaddressedallthe employeestoinformthemofthehazardevaluationandour proposedactivities.WetookIEQmeasurements(temperature,RH, andCO2)andheldconfidentialmedicalinterviewswithUSPS workers.Inadditiontoobservingtheworkarea,wereviewedthe buildingventilationschematics,anairsamplingreport,MSDSs, workorderspertainingtotheHVACunits,andReportofHazard Logs.WeheldaclosingconferenceonthemorningofJuly13to discusspreliminaryfindingsandrecommendations.

Medical Interviews

OnJuly11and12,2007,weinterviewedthirty-sevenemployees whowereinterestedinprivateandconfidentialinterviews.All interviewedemployeesreportedperceivingadead-animalodor thatwasworseontheeastsideofthebuilding.Nineemployees reportednosymptoms.Oftheremaining28employees,13 reportedfrequentheadaches,10reportedepisodictransient dizziness,and10reportedhavingfrequentepisodesofcommon cold,flu,orbronchitis.Othersymptomsreportedweresinus problemsbynineemployees;shortnessofbreathbyseven employees;musculoskeletalcomplaintssuchasneck,back,and shoulderpainandmusclespasmbysixemployees;andfatigue byfiveemployees.Nausea,hernia,andpalpitationswereeach reportedbytwoemployees.Abouthalfofthosewithsymptoms reportednoimprovementawayfromworkincludingduring vacation.Allbuttwoemployeesnotedthattheodorsubsidedwhen theareaaroundtheHVACunitswascleanedofpigeondroppings, andsomenotedconsiderableimprovementorresolutionof theirsymptomsaftertheHVACunitswerecleaned.Someofthe employeesinterviewednotedthattheirdeliveryroutesaredirt roadsandthoughtthatsomeoftheirsymptomsmaybedueto exposuretodust.

ThesymptomsreportedatAVPOcanbecausedbyavariety ofillnessesandenvironmentalconditions.Theseconditions andillnessescouldincludetheperceptionofunpleasantodors [Dalton1999;Shusterman1992;Bruvoldetal.1983;Amesand Stratton1991],poorindoorairquality[LindgrenandNorback 2005;ErdmannandApte2004;Skyberg2003;Nagdaand Hodgson2001;CrandallandSieber1996],thecommoncold,or histoplasmosis.Becausethesymptomsarefrequentlyassociated

Page � Health Hazard Evaluation Report 2007-0216-3056

Page 13: Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United … · Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United ... RH Relative humidity ... Letter carriers leave the building to deliver

Results And disCussion (Continued) withsomanytypesofillnesses,wecannotusesymptomsaloneto

pinpointtheexactcauseoftheworkers’concerns.Instead,we usesymptomsandtheotherfactorsdescribedinthisreportto determinetheprobabilityofawork-relatedexposure.

EmployeesmayhavebeenexposedtoH. capsulatumatAVPO,but thispossibilityisverylow,andwedonotrecommendtestingofall employeesforhistoplasmosisforthefollowingreasons:

● HistoplasmosisisnotendemicorprevalentinCalifornia. TheconditionsthatfavorthegrowthofH. capsulatumin soilareameantemperatureof71°Fto84°F,anannual precipitationof35to50inches,andarelativehumidityof 67%to87%[Deepe2004;Zeidbergetal.1955].Because theprevailingclimateinAppleValleyisnotfavorablefor thegrowthofH. capsulatum,thepotentialforexposureto H. capsulatumamongAVPOemployeesisverylow.

● Althoughsomeofthesymptomsreportedbyseveral employeeshavealsobeenreportedbypersonswith histoplasmosis,theconstellationofsymptomsreporteddid notsuggestthatemployeeshadactivehistoplasmosis.

● Becauseofinherentproblemsinthevariousclinicaltests forhistoplasmosissuchasfalsepositivity(positivetestresult intheabsenceofhistoplasmainfection),falsenegativity (negativetestresultinpersonswithhistoplasmainfection), andtheinabilityofsomeoftheteststodifferentiatepast fromcurrentinfection,areasonabledegreeofpretest probability(thelikelihoodofhavinghistoplasmosis)is neededtosupportcommunitytestinginordertoovercome inherenterrorsinthesetests.

Othermedicalconditionsthathavebeenassociatedwithexposure topigeonfecalmaterialandpigeonproteinsarepsittacosis, cryptococcosis,andhypersensitivitypneumonitis.Personswith psittacosis(infectionduetoChlamydophilia psittaci)usuallyhave symptomsofhighfeverwithchills,severecough,andnon-specific symptomssuchasheadache,joint,andmuscleaches[Schlossberg 2004].Personswithpsittacosismayhavechestpainwithshortness ofbreath[Schlossberg2004].Althoughlungsymptomsmayoccur inpersonswithcryptococcosis(diseasecausedbyCryptococcus neoformans),itisuncommonandpresentsasfever,cough,chest painandmalaise.Thecommonpresentationiscryptococcal meningitis,whosesymptomsarefever,confusion,headache,neck

Health Hazard Evaluation Report 2007-0216-3056 Page �

Page 14: Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United … · Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United ... RH Relative humidity ... Letter carriers leave the building to deliver

Results And disCussion (Continued) stiffness,andinseverecases,coma[Perfect2004].Basedonour

interviewsofemployees,wedonotthinkthatemployeesofAVPO currentlyhavetheseconditionsanddonotrecommendtesting ofallemployeesforthesediseases.Employeeswithpersistent symptomsshouldconsulttheirphysicianstodetermineiftestingis appropriateonacase-by-casebasis.

Hypersensitivitypneumonitisiscausedbythebody’simmune responsetoexposuretoorganicparticles,inthiscase,pigeon proteins(antigens).Acutediseaseusuallymanifestsasfluor atypicalpneumoniaandistypicallyself-limitingifexposure ceases[Rose2005].Subacuteandchronicdiseasesmaycause progressiveshortnessofbreath,cough,malaise,fatigue,weight lossanddecreasedlungfunction[Rose2005].Ourinterviewof employeesatAVPOdidnotsuggestthatemployeescurrentlyhave hypersensitivitypneumonitis.

Thepotentialforemployeestobeexposedtothecausativeagents ofthesemedicalconditionshasbeeneliminatedasaresultofthe cleaningandthenettinginstalledaroundtherooftopHVACunits. Thepotentialforexposureshouldnotoccuraslongastheintegrity ofthenetsismaintainedandpigeonroostingiseliminated.For moreinformationonhistoplasmosis,refertoAppendixAatthe endofthisreportandtheNIOSHdocument“Histoplasmosis: Protectingworkersatrisk,”[NIOSH2004],whichcanalsobe foundathttp://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2005-109/.

Facility Survey

TheAVPOhasnineHVACunitsontheroof.Untilrecently,the USPSSanBernadinomaintenanceemployeeswereresponsible forchangingairfiltersforseveraldifferentpostalofficebuildings inthearea.AVPOmanagementsaidthatthesemaintenance employeesreplacedairfiltersquarterlyattheirfacility,butdidnot keepwrittenrecordsoftheseactivities.OnMay30,2007,AVPO establishedamaintenanceagreementwithanindependentHVAC contractortomaintaintheirHVACunits,includingfouryearly preventivemaintenancecheck-ups,includingfilterchange-outs, althoughtheSanBernadinoFacilitiesDepartmentstillsupplies thereplacementairfilters.

Duringthebuildingwalk-through,weopenedandinspectedtwo oftheHVACunitsontheroofandexaminedthefilters,outdoor

Page � Health Hazard Evaluation Report 2007-0216-3056

Page 15: Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United … · Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United ... RH Relative humidity ... Letter carriers leave the building to deliver

Results And disCussion (Continued) airdampers,coolingcoils,andbirdnetting.Inoneoftheunits,

wefoundapigeonfeatherinthefrontoftheairfilterandanother featherbehindthefilteronthecoolingcoils.Giventheproper positioningofthefiltersatthetimeofinspection,thefeather shouldnothavebeeninthisarea.Wespeculatedthatthefeathers mayhavebeenleftafterthecleaningprocessorhadbeenknocked offtheairfiltersontothecoilduringfilterchange-out.Nopigeon fecalmatterwasfoundinanyoftheHVACunits,andbirdnetting lookedintactaroundalltheunits,althoughsomenettinglocated inareaswheretheunitandductworkjoinedhadsmallgapsbig enoughforapigeontoenter.Also,wefoundfreshbirddroppings neartwooftheexhaustvents.Managementsurmisedthatthe pigeonswereattractedtothewarmairexhaustingfromthosevents andiscurrentlylookingintoinstallingbirdspikestodiscourage pigeonsfromgatheringaroundthevents.

Whileinvestigatingthehistoplasmosisconcerns,NIOSH investigatorsperformedanIEQevaluationtoidentifyany potentialissuesbytakingthermalcomfortmeasurementsand lookingattheventilationsystem.Oneofthemostcommon deficienciesintheindoorenvironmentistheimproperoperation andmaintenanceofventilationsystemsandotherbuilding components[Rosenstock1996].NIOSHinvestigatorshavefound thatcorrectingHVACproblemsoftenreducesreportedsymptoms. Moststudiesofventilationratesandbuildingoccupantsymptoms haveshownthatventilationratesbelow20cubicfeetperminute perperson,areassociatedwithoneormorehealthsymptoms [Seppanenetal.1999].WhenconductinganIEQsurvey,NIOSH investigatorsoftenmeasurethermalcomfortindicators,such asCO2

,temperature,andRHtoprovideinformationrelative tothefunctioningandcontrolofHVACsystems.Maintaining theseparametersatrecommendedlevelshasoftenbeenshownto resultinresolutionorsymptomaticimprovementsinoccupants. Thus,improvedHVACoperationandmaintenance,higher ventilationrates,andcomfortabletemperatureandRHcanall potentiallyservetoimprovesymptomswithouteveridentifying anyspecificcause-effectrelationships.Wehaveincludedadditional informationonIEQparametersinAppendixB.

CO isanormalconstituentofexhaledbreathanditisnot 2

consideredabuildingairpollutant.Itisanindicatorofwhether sufficientquantitiesofoutdoorairarebeingintroducedinto anoccupiedspace.ANSIandASHRAErecommendthatthe indoorCO2

concentrationbewithin700ppmoftheoutdoor

Health Hazard Evaluation Report 2007-0216-3056 Page �

Page 16: Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United … · Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United ... RH Relative humidity ... Letter carriers leave the building to deliver

Results And disCussion (Continued) concentrationforcomfort(odor)reasons[ANSI/ASHRAE

2007].ElevatedCO2concentrationssuggestthatotherindoor

contaminantsmayalsobeincreased.IfCO2concentrationsare elevated,theamountofoutdoorairintroducedintotheventilated spacemayneedtobeincreased.ASHRAE’sventilationstandard, ANSI/ASHRAE62.1-2007:Ventilation for Acceptable Indoor Air Quality,recommendsacombinedoutdoorairrateof17cfm/ personforofficespaces,andareaoutdoorairratesof0.12cfm/ft2 forshipping/receivingareasand0.06cfm/ft2forwarehouses,as longasstoredmaterialshavenopotentiallyharmfulemissions [ANSI/ASHRAE2007].

Wemonitoredtheworkareafortemperature,RH,CO,andCO2

usingaQ-TRAKPlusIndoorAirQualityMonitor,Model8554 (TSIIncorporated,Shoreview,Minnesota).COwasmeasured becauseitisacommoncomponentofvehicleexhaust.Mail carriertrucksarelocatedinaparkinglotabout30feetfromaset ofdoubledoors.Trucksthatbringincomingmailunloadfour differenttimesataseparateloadingdockbetween3:30a.m.and 8:30a.m.andloadthreeseparatetimestoremoveoutgoingmail from1:30p.m.until6:00p.m.NoCOwasdetectedwhentrucks wereleavingorreturningfromtheirroutes.

WetookCO2measurementsonJuly11afterthebuildingwalk-

throughwhenthebuildingwasatlowoccupancy,andonthe morningofJuly12duringhighoccupancy.Onaverage,CO

2

measurementswereunder1064ppm(averagedailyoutsideCO2

measurement+theASHRAErecommendedguidelineof700 ppm).However,whenthefacilitywasathighoccupancy,wefound CO

2levelsthatexceeded1064ppminpocketsaroundthemain

workarea.RefertoTable1formeasurementrangesandaverages.

Table 1*. Environmental condition measurements taken at AVPO Date Location Temp. (°F) RH (%) CO2 (ppm) CO (ppm)

Outside 86.7 17.8 330 0 July 11, 2007 Mail sorting area (low occupancy)

PM Range 70-74 25.5-30.5 547-745 0 Average 72 28 611 0 Outside 78 23.4 364 0

July 12, 2007 Mail sorting area (high occupancy) AM Range 69-71 26.1-32.3 633-1215 0

Average 71 29 875 0 * See Table B1 in Appendix B for ANSI/ASHRAE recommended thermal environmental condition levels.

Page � Health Hazard Evaluation Report 2007-0216-3056

Page 17: Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United … · Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United ... RH Relative humidity ... Letter carriers leave the building to deliver

Results And disCussion (Continued) Weobservedtheuseof2-inchmedium-efficiencyfiltersinthe

HVACunits.Prefilters,whichpreservetheintegrityofthemain filter,wereobservedinonlysomeoftheunits.Duringour inspection,wewereunabletotellifallthefilterswereinstalled correctlybecausethedirectionalarrowsonthefilterframes werenotalwaysvisible.Duetothepositionoftheoutdoorair dampersandpanelsintheHVACunits,wecouldnottellifthe damperswerecompletelyclosed.Closedornearlyclosedoutdoor airdamperslimittheamountofoutdoorairbroughtintothe building.

Wereleasedsmallpuffsofsmokeintotheairandobservedthe directionsmokeflowedtodeterminethegeneralairmixingand flowdynamicsinthearea.Thissmoketestwasdoneatbreathing zonelevelthroughoutthebuildingandweobservedthat,overall, thebuildingwasunderpositivepressure,whichmeansairmoves frominsidetooutsidethebuilding.Severalareasappearedtohave lowairflow.Thewomen’srestroomwasdeterminedtobeunder negativepressure(airflowsfromworkareaintobathroom,thenis ventedthroughtheroof)whichisrecommendedbyASHRAE,but themen’srestroomwasunderpositivepressure(airinbathroom flowsouttotheworkarea).

Weinspectedtwoairsupplyductsanddiffusers,oneontheceiling ofthemainworkingarea,theotherinanoffice.Blackparticles hadcollectedaroundthediffuserdeflectorsinapatternoftheair flow.Wedidnotobserveanyblackparticlesinsidetheduct.The blackparticulatemaybegeneratedinsidetheworkareaordrift intotheworkareafromtheoutside,whereitisthenimpacted ontothediffusersbythesupplyair.Aslongasfiltersareinstalled correctlyandtheHVACsystemisworkingproperly,theamountof particlesenteringtheroomfromtheductworkshouldbereduced, becauseairispassedthroughfiltersbeforereenteringthesupply duct.

ItwasreportedthatAVPOmaintenanceemployeesmayhave removedandcleanedthepigeonfecalmatterthemselvesbeforethe cleaningandsanitizingcompanywashired.Ifanyinfectiousagents arepresentinthefeces,itwouldbepossibleforaerosolizationto occurduringcleaningactivities.

Duringourwalk-throughofthebuilding,weobservedseveral looselightfixturesandstainedorsaggingceilingtiles.Thesharps boxinthemen’sbathroomhadfallenoffthewallandhadbeen

Health Hazard Evaluation Report 2007-0216-3056 Page �

Page 18: Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United … · Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United ... RH Relative humidity ... Letter carriers leave the building to deliver

ReCommendAtions (Continued) insecurelyreaffixedwithtape.Wealsoobservednumerousinsects

(blackbugs)inthemen’sroom.Workersreportedthatinsectshad beenpresentinofficesandotherlocationsofthebuildingfora considerableperiodoftime.

ConClusionsBaseduponmedicalinterviewswithworkersandanassessment ofenvironmentalconditionsattheAVPO,weconcludethat nodirectrelationshipexistsbetweencurrenthealthsymptoms reportedbyAVPOemployeesandspecificoccupationalor environmentalexposures.Perceivedodorandbuildingventilation issueslikelycontributedtothesesymptoms.Wefoundthatthe potentialforemployeestocontracthistoplasmosiswaslowand thispotentialwasfurtherminimizedbycleaningandinstalling netsaroundtheHVACunits.WedonotrecommendthatAVPO employeesbetestedforhistoplasmosis.However,ifindividual employeesfeelthattheyshouldbetestedduetotheirsymptoms, theyshoulddiscussthiswiththeirphysician.

Wefoundcomfortparametersatthepostofficetobewithin acceptableASHRAEguidelinesexceptforelevatedCO2

levels insomeworkareasduringhighoccupancy,possiblyindicating inadequateoutdoorairintake(possiblyduetoclosedormostly closedoutdoorairdampers)orunevenmixingofair.Allpigeon fecalmatterhadbeenclearedfromtheunitsweexaminedand, overall,thebirdnettingappearedintact.Atthetimeofour investigation,wesawtwobirdfeathersinoneoftheHVACunits, butnoevidencethatbirdswereenteringorstilllivingintheunit.

ReCommendAtions Basedontheobservationsandfindingsofthisevaluation,the followingrecommendationsareprovidedintheinterestof enhancinghealthandsafetyconditionsattheAVPO.

1. TestingofallAVPOemployeesforhistoplasmosisis notnecessaryandneednotbeconductedbecausethe potentialforcontractingsuchisverylow.Employeeswith healthproblemsshouldseekcarewiththeirphysicianfor appropriatemanagement.

2. Evenintheabsenceofinfectiousagents,anyemployee whowillberemediatinganimalfecesshouldbeprovided withhazardcommunicationinformationandappropriate PPE.Hazardcommunicationinformationshould includeawarningthatindividualswithcompromised

Page �0 Health Hazard Evaluation Report 2007-0216-3056

Page 19: Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United … · Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United ... RH Relative humidity ... Letter carriers leave the building to deliver

ReCommendAtions (Continued) cell-mediatedimmunity(e.g.,anindividualwithHIV

infection,thelymphoma-leukemia-Hodgkin’sgroupof malignancies[cancers],orthoseonsteroidtherapyor otherimmunosuppressiveagents)areatgreaterriskof clinicaldiseaseshouldinfectionoccur.Individualswith compromisedcell-mediatedimmunityshouldbeadvised toconsulttheirpersonalphysicianconcerningtheneedto avoidexposuretomaterials(suchaslargeaccumulations ofoldpigeonfeces)possiblycontaminatedwithinfectious microorganisms.Onemethodofhazardcommunication includespostingsignsinappropriateareastoremind workersofthebirdfecesproblem.

3. Continuetomonitorthebirdnettingfordamageorholes toensurethatbirdsarenotabletonestintheHVACunits. Anygapsthatareidentifiedshouldbesealedimmediately.

4. TheHVACcontractor’sworkordernotedthattheyhad closedtheoutdoorairdampers.Toallowadequateintake ofoutdoorair,dampersshouldnotbecompletelyclosed. UseANSI/ASHRAEguidelinestodetermineminimum amountsofoutdoorairthatshouldbedeliveredintothe workareas[ANSI/ASHRAE2007].

5. SeveralhighCO2measurementsmayindicateinsufficient

outdoorairbeingbroughtintothebuilding,which mayimproveifdampersareopened.BasedontheCO

2

measurementsandsmoketuberesultsshowingareasof littleairmovement,atestandbalanceoftheventilation systemshouldbeperformed.Thecompanyperformingthe testingandbalancingshouldbecertifiedbytheNational EnvironmentalBalancingBureau(www.nebb.org)orother recognizedorganization.

6. Therestroomexhaustfansshouldbeevaluatedtoensure thatrestroomsareundernegativepressuresothatanyodors areexhaustedawayfromworkingareas.ANSI/ASHRAE standard62.1recommendsthatpublicrestroomshavea minimumexhaustrateof70cfmperunit(watercloset and/orurinal)whereperiodsofheavyuseareexpectedto occur,otherwisearateof50cfm/unitisacceptable[ANSI/ ASHRAE2007].

7. UseprefilterstoextendthelifeofthemainHVACair filters.Alsoensurethatthefiltersareplacedinthecorrect directioninrelationtoairflow.Filtersshouldbeplacedso thatflowdirectionarrowsareclearlyvisible,therebymaking iteasiertoobservewhetherfiltersareproperlyinstalled.

Health Hazard Evaluation Report 2007-0216-3056 Page ��

Page 20: Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United … · Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United ... RH Relative humidity ... Letter carriers leave the building to deliver

ReCommendAtions (Continued) 8. Duetothedustyandwindyconditionsofthedesert,

considerinstallingapressure-sensingdevice,suchasa manometerorMagnehelicgaugetoprovideanaccurate andobjectivewayofknowingwhentochangeairfilters. Bycomparingthereadingsofapressure-sensingdevice whenthefilterisnewversusheavilyloaded(readytobe changed),alongwiththefiltermanufacturer’sinformation onpressuredropcharacteristics,youwillbeabletoreplace thefilterswhenneeded[NIOSH2003].Moreinformation onFiltrationandAir-CleaningSystemscanbefoundin theNIOSHdocument,“GuidanceforFiltrationandAir-CleaningSystemstoProtectBuildingEnvironmentsfrom AirborneChemical,Biological,orRadiologicalAttacks” athttp://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2003-136/default. html#toc.

9. Performregularhousekeeping,includingdustingofsupply andexhaustventsandregulargeneraldustingtominimize particulatematter.Whenvacuuming,useanindustrial-typevacuumcleanerinstalledwithaHEPAfilter.We recommendfollowingthegreenorsustainablebuilding practice,whichaimstocreateahealthierandmoreresource-efficientmodelsofmaintenance.Additionalinformation onGreenBuildingscanbefoundattheEPAwebsite http://www.epa.gov/greenbuilding/.Informationon environmentalandhealth-friendlycleaningsuppliesand resourcesmaybefoundathttp://www.epa.gov/oppt/epp/ pubs/products/cleaner.htm.

10.Scheduleregularpestinspectionofthebuilding,andspray insecticideonlywhenneededandwhenthebuildingisnot occupied.Thiswillallowpesteliminationwhileminimizing employeeexposuretoinsecticides.

11.Continuetocommunicatewithbuildingoccupantsto discussissuesandsecureoccupants’cooperationwhen resolvingissuesorconcerns.Itisimportanttocontinue recording,respondingto,andresolvinghealthandsafety issuesinatimelymannertopreventthemfrombecoming majorhealthorcomfortproblems.TheHealthandSafety Committeememberscanhelpwiththisissue.

12.Replacestainedorsaggingceilingtilesandreaffixloose, hanginglightingfixtures.

13.Thesharpsboxinthemen’sroomshouldbesecurelyfixed tothewalltopreventaccidentalsharpinjuries.

Page �� Health Hazard Evaluation Report 2007-0216-3056

Page 21: Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United … · Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United ... RH Relative humidity ... Letter carriers leave the building to deliver

RefeRenCes AmesRG,StrattonJW[1991].Acutehealtheffectsfrom communityexposuretoN-propylmercaptanfromanethoprop (Mocap)-treatedpotatofieldinSiskiyouCounty,California.Arch EnvironHealth46(4):213–217.

ANSI/ASHRAE[2007].Ventilationforacceptableindoor airquality.AmericanNationalStandardsInstitute/ASHRAE standard62.1-2007.Atlanta,GA:AmericanSocietyofHeating, Refrigerating,andAir-ConditioningEngineers,Inc.

ANSI/ASHRAE[1999].Methodoftestinggeneralventilationair cleaningdevicesforremovalefficiencybyparticlesize.American NationalStandardsInstitute/ASHRAEstandard52.2.Atlanta, GA:AmericanSocietyforHeating,Refrigerating,andAir-ConditioningEngineers,Inc.

BruvoldWH,RappaportSM,WuTC,BulmerBE,DeGrange CE,KoolerJM[1983].Determinationofnuisanceodorina community.JWaterPollControlFed55:229–233.

CrandallMS,SieberWK[1996].TheNationalInstitutefor OccupationalSafetyandHealthindoorenvironmentalevaluation experience.Partone:buildingenvironmentalevaluations.Appl OccupEnvironHyg11(6):533–539.

DaltonP[1999].Cognitiveinfluencesonhealthsymptomsfrom acutechemicalexposure.HealthPsychol18:579–590.

DeepeGS[2004].Histoplasmacapsulatum.In:MandellGL, BennettJE,DolinR,eds.Principlesandpracticeofinfectious diseases.6thed.Vol.2.Philadelphia:ChurchillLivingstone Publisher,pp.3012–3025.

ErdmannCA,ApteMG[2004].Mucousmembraneandlower respiratorybuildingrelatedsymptomsinrelationtoindoorcarbon dioxideconcentrationsinthe100-buildingBASEdataset.Indoor Air14Suppl8:127–134.

LindgrenT,NorbackD[2005].Healthandperceptionofcabin airqualityamongSwedishcommercialairlinecrew.IndoorAir15 Suppl10:65–72.

NagdaNL,HodgsonM[2001]. Lowrelativehumidityandaircraft cabinairquality.IndoorAir 11(3):200–214.

Health Hazard Evaluation Report 2007-0216-3056 Page ��

Page 22: Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United … · Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United ... RH Relative humidity ... Letter carriers leave the building to deliver

RefeRenCes (Continued) NIOSH[2003].Guidanceforfiltrationandair-cleaningsystemsto protectbuildingenvironmentsfromairbornechemical,biological, orradiologicalattacks.Cincinnati,OH:U.S.Departmentof HealthandHumanServices,PublicHealthService,Centers forDiseaseControlandPrevention,NationalInstitutefor OccupationalSafetyandHealth,DHHS(NIOSH)PublicationNo. 2003-136.

NIOSH[2004].Histoplasmosis:Protectingworkersatrisk. Cincinnati,OH:U.S.DepartmentofHealthandHuman Services,PublicHealthService,CentersforDiseaseControland Prevention;NationalInstituteforOccupationalSafetyandHealth. DHHS(NIOSH)PublicationNo.2005-109.[http://www.cdc.gov/ niosh/docs/2005-109/]Dateaccessed:September5,2007.

PerfectJR[2004].Cryptococcusneoformans.In:MandellGL, BennettJE,DolinR,eds.Principlesandpracticeofinfectious diseases.6thed.Vol.2.Philadelphia:ChurchillLivingstone Publisher,pp.2997–3009.

RoseCS[2005].Hypersensitivitypneumonitis.In:MasonRJ, BroaddusVC,MurrayJF,NadelJA,eds.MurrayandNadel’s textbookofrespiratorymedicine.4thed.Philadelphia:Elsevier SaundersPublisher,pp1783–1794.

RosenstockL[1996].NIOSHTestimonytotheU.S.Department ofLaboronindoorairquality.ApplOccupEnvironHyg 11(12):1365–1370.

SchlossbergD[2004].Chlamydophilia(Chlamydia)psittaci (Psittacosis).In:MandellGL,BennettJE,DolinR,eds.Principles andpracticeofinfectiousdiseases.6thed.Vol.2.Philadelphia: ChurchillLivingstonePublisher,pp.2256–2258.

SeppanenOA,FiskWJ,MendellMJ[1999].Associationof ventilationratesandCO concentrationswithhealthandother

2

responsesincommercialandinstitutionalbuildings.IndoorAir 9:226–252.

SkybergK,SkulbergKR,EduardW,SkaretE,LevyF,Kjuus H[2003].Symptomsprevalenceamongofficeemployeesand associationstobuildingcharacteristics.IndoorAir13(3):246–252.

Page �� Health Hazard Evaluation Report 2007-0216-3056

Page 23: Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United … · Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United ... RH Relative humidity ... Letter carriers leave the building to deliver

RefeRenCes (Continued) ShustermanD[1992].Criticalreview:thehealthsignificanceof environmentalodorpollution.ArchEnvironHealth47(1):76–87.

ZeidbergLD,AjelloL,WebsterRH[1955].Physicaland chemicalfactorsinrelationtoHistoplasmacapsulatumin soil.Science122:33–34.

Health Hazard Evaluation Report 2007-0216-3056 Page ��

Page 24: Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United … · Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United ... RH Relative humidity ... Letter carriers leave the building to deliver

Appendix A: HeAltH effeCts

Histoplasmosis HistoplasmosisisaninfectiousdiseasecausedbyinhalingthesporesofafunguscalledHistoplasma capsulatum.Histoplasmosisisnotcontagious;itcannotbetransmittedfromaninfectedpersonoranimal tosomeoneelse.H. capsulatumgrowsinsoilsthroughouttheworld.Theproportionofpeopleinfectedby H. capsulatumishigherincentralandeasternstates(especiallyalongthevalleysoftheOhio,Mississippi, andSt.Lawrencerivers)andinanareaneartheRioGrande.Thefungusseemstogrowbestinsoils withhighnitrogencontent,especiallythoseenrichedwithbirdmanureorbatdroppings.Freshbird droppingsonsurfacessuchassidewalksandwindowsillshavenotbeenshowntopresentahealthrisk forhistoplasmosisbecausebirdsthemselvesdonotappeartobeinfectedbyH. capsulatum.Rather,bird manureisprimarilyanutrientsourceforthegrowthofH. capsulatumalreadypresentinsoil[NIOSH 2004].

Histoplasmosisprimarilyaffectsaperson’slungs,anditssymptomsvary.Thevastmajorityofinfected peopleareasymptomatic(havenoapparentilleffects),ortheyexperiencesymptomssomildtheydonot seekmedicalattentionandmaynotevenrealizethattheirillnesswashistoplasmosis.Ifsymptomsdo occur,theyusuallystartwithin3to17daysafterexposure,withanaverageof10days.Histoplasmosis canappearasamild,flu-likerespiratoryillnessandhasacombinationofsymptoms,includingmalaise(a generalillfeeling),fever,chestpain,dryornonproductivecough,headache,lossofappetite,shortnessof breath,jointandmusclepains,chills,andhoarseness.Rarely,amoreseveretypeofhistoplasmosisoccurs; personswhogetthemoreseveretypeofhistoplasmosisrequireantifungalmedicationstotreatthedisease [NIOSH2004].

Symptoms from Indoor Environmental Quality Thesymptomsreportedbybuildingoccupantsassociatedwithindoorenvironmentalconcernshave beendiverseandusuallyarenotsuggestiveofanyparticularmedicaldiagnosisorreadilyassociated withacausativeagent.Reportsdemonstratecloserassociationsofsymptomoccurrencewithoccupant perceptionsoftheindoorenvironmentratherthanwithanymeasurementofindoorcontaminantsor conditions[NIOSH1991;BerglundandCain1989].Atypicalspectrumofreportedsymptomsincludes headaches,fatigue,itchingorburningeyes,irritationoftheskin,nasalcongestion,dryorirritatedthroat, andotherrespiratorysymptoms.Thesesymptomsarealsooftenexperiencedbypeopleoutsideofthe workplaceandcouldberelatedtoanumberofdifferentcauses,suchasrespiratoryinfections,allergies, discomfortduetotemperatureandhumidity,andstress.Somestudieshaveshownthatpsychological, social,andorganizationalfactorsmaymodifyindividuals’andorganizations’responsestoconcernsin theofficeenvironment[Boxer1990;Ooi1997;Baker1989].Typically,workerssuspectaworkplacecause becausetheirsymptomsappeartobeworsewhileatworkandbetterwhenawayfromwork.

Lessoften,illnessesandreactionsmaybefoundtoberelatedtospecificexposuresincertainbuilding environments.Hypersensitivitypneumonitis,Legionnaires’disease,Pontiacfever,andCOpoisoningare allcausedbyspecificagent(s)thathavebeenfoundinsomebuildingenvironments.Thefirstthreeofthese conditionscanbecausedbymicroorganisms.

Page �� Health Hazard Evaluation Report 2007-0216-3056

Page 25: Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United … · Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United ... RH Relative humidity ... Letter carriers leave the building to deliver

Appendix B: AdditionAl infoRmAtion on ieQ issues

TemperatureandRHmeasurementsareoftencollectedaspartofanIEQinvestigationbecausethese parametersaffecttheperceptionofcomfort.TheANSI/ASHRAE Standard 55-2004:Thermal Environmental Conditions for Human Occupancy,specifiesconditionsinwhich80%ormoreoftheoccupantsareexpected tofindtheenvironmentthermallyacceptable[ANSI/ASHRAE2004].Temperaturesrecommendedby ANSI/ASHRAErangefrom68.5oFto77.0oFinthewinter,and75.0oFto81.5oFinthesummer(seeTable B1below).Thedifferenceislargelyduetoseasonalclothingselection.ANSI/ASHRAEalsorecommends thatRHbemaintainedatorbelow65%.TheUnitedStatesEPArecommendsmaintainingindoorRH between30%–50%.Valuesoutsidetheserangeshavebeenfoundtoproducesymptoms.RHbelow30% hasbeenshowntobeassociatedwithsymptoms[Wolkoffetal.2006;NagdaandHodgson2001],which maycontributetosomeofthesymptomsexperiencedbytheoccupants.Morespecificinformationon IEQissues,guidancetoolsformanagingIEQ,andventilationandcontrolstudiesoflarge,commercial buildingsmaybefoundattheEPAwebsite,http://www.epa.gov/iaq/largebldgs/index.html.

Table B1. ANSI/ASHRAE recommended thermal environmental conditions.

Relative Humidity (%) Winter Temperatures (oF) Summer Temperatures (oF)

30 69.5 to 77.0 75.5 to 81.5

40 69.0 to 76.5 75.5 to 81.0

50 68.5 to 76.0 75.0 to 80.5

References

ANSI/ASHRAE[2004].Thermalenvironmentalconditionsforhumanoccupancy.American NationalStandardsInstitute/ASHRAEstandard55-2004.Atlanta,GA:AmericanSocietyforHeating, Refrigerating,andAir-ConditioningEngineers,Inc.

BakerDB[1989].Socialandorganizationalfactorsinofficebuilding-associatedillness.OccupMed 4(4):607–624.

BerglundL,CainWS[1989].Perceivedairqualityandthethermalenvironment.In:Proceedings of IAQ ‘89: The Human Equation: Health and Comfort.Atlanta,GA:AmericanSocietyofHeating,Ventilating,andAir-ConditioningEngineers,pp.93–99.

BoxerPA[1990].Indoorairquality:apsychosocialperspective.JOccupMed32(5):425–428.

NagdaNL,HodgsonM[2001].Lowrelativehumidityandaircraftcabinairquality.IndoorAir11(3):200– 214.

NIOSH[2005].Histoplasmosis:Protectingworkersatrisk.Cincinnati,OH:U.S.DepartmentofHealth andHumanServices,PublicHealthService,CentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention;National

Health Hazard Evaluation Report 2007-0216-3056 Page ��

Page 26: Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United … · Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United ... RH Relative humidity ... Letter carriers leave the building to deliver

Appendix B: AdditionAl infoRmAtion on ieQ issues (Continued)

InstituteforOccupationalSafetyandHealth.DHHS(NIOSH)PublicationNo.2005-109.[http://www. cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2005-109/]Dateaccessed:September5,2007.

NIOSH[1991].Hazardevaluationandtechnicalassistancereport:LibraryofCongress,Washington.D. C.Cincinnati,OH:U.S.DepartmentofHealthandHumanServices,PublicHealthService,Centersfor DiseaseControl,NationalInstituteforOccupationalSafetyandHealth,NIOSHReportNo.HHE88-364-2104.

OoiPL,GohKT[1997].Sickbuildingsyndrome:anemergingstress-relateddisorder?IntJEpidemiol 26(6):1243–1249.

WolkoffP,NojgaardJK,FranckC,SkovP[2006].Themodernofficeenvironmentdesiccatestheeyes? IndoorAir16(4):258–265.

Page �� Health Hazard Evaluation Report 2007-0216-3056

Page 27: Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United … · Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United ... RH Relative humidity ... Letter carriers leave the building to deliver

ACknowledgements And

AvAilABility of RepoRt TheHazardEvaluationandTechnicalAssistanceBranch(HETAB) oftheNationalInstituteforOccupationalSafetyandHealth (NIOSH)conductsfieldinvestigationsofpossiblehealthhazards intheworkplace.Theseinvestigationsareconductedunderthe authorityofSection20(a)(6)oftheOccupationalSafetyand Health(OSHA)Actof1970,29U.S.C.669(a)(6)whichauthorizes theSecretaryofHealthandHumanServices,followingawritten requestfromanyemployersorauthorizedrepresentativeof employees,todeterminewhetheranysubstancenormallyfound intheplaceofemploymenthaspotentiallytoxiceffectsinsuch concentrationsasusedorfound.

HETABalsoprovides,uponrequest,technicalandconsultative assistancetofederal,state,andlocalagencies;labor;industry;and othergroupsorindividualstocontroloccupationalhealthhazards andtopreventrelatedtraumaanddisease.Mentionofcompany namesorproductsdoesnotconstituteendorsementbyNIOSH.

ThisreportwaspreparedbyLiliaChenandAyodeleAdebayoof HETAB,DivisionofSurveillance,HazardEvaluationsandField Studies(DSHEFS).DesktoppublishingwasperformedbyRobin Smith.EditorialassistancewasprovidedbyEllenGalloway.

Copiesofthisreporthavebeensenttoemployeeandmanagement representativesatAppleValleyPostOffice;andtheOSHA RegionalOffice.Thisreportisnotcopyrightedandmaybefreely reproduced.Thereportmaybeviewedandprintedfromthe followinginternetaddress:http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/hhe.Copies maybepurchasedfromtheNationalTechnicalInformationService (NTIS)at5825PortRoyalRoad,Springfield,Virginia22161.

Health Hazard Evaluation Report 2007-0216-3056 Page ��

Page 28: Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United … · Evaluation of Histoplasmosis Concerns at a United ... RH Relative humidity ... Letter carriers leave the building to deliver

Recommended Citation for this report. NIOSH [2008]. Health Hazard Evaluation Report: Evaluation of Histoplasmosis

U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Public Health Service, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and

occupational safety and health topics, contact NIOSH at: 1-800-CDC-INFO (1-800-232-4636)

E-mail: [email protected]

or visit the NIOSH web site at:

For a monthly update on news at NIOSH, subscribe to NIOSH eNews by visiting

Safety and health at work for all people through research and prevention.

National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health

Concerns at a United States Post Office, Apple Valley, California. Cincinnati, OH:

Health, NIOSH HETA No. 2007-0216-3056.

To receive NIOSH documents or information about

TTY: 1-888-232-6348

www.cdc.gov/niosh.

www.cdc.gov/niosh/eNews.

Delivering on the Nation’s promise: