Europeanization Subverted? The European Union’s Promotion of Good Governance and the Fight against...

7/27/2019 Europeanization Subverted? The European Unions Promotion of Good Governance and the Fight against Corruptio

1/26

Europeanization Subverted?

Th E Us Pm f GGc h Fh s C hSh Ccss

Tj A. B Ysm Pm

N. 26 | A 2011

WORKING PAPER


2/26

2 | KFGWorking Paper No. 26| April 2011

KFG Working Paper Series

Edited by the Kolleg-Forschergruppe T T Pw E

Th KFG W P Ss ss ssm h sch ss f h K-Fsch y m

hm c. I ms hc cmc xch s w s sh

xs sc sch x s csss E h E U.

A KFG W Ps h KFG ws www.sfm. c

m sfm-@f-..

Cyh f hs ss: Tj A. B, Ysm Pm

E sssc c: C Bh, J S

B, Tj A./Pm, Ysm 2011: E S? Th E Us Pm f G G-

c h Fh s C h Sh Ccss, KFG W P Ss, N. 26, A 2011, K-

Fsch (KFG) Th Tsfm Pw f E F Us B.

ISSN 1868-6834 (P)

ISSN 1868-7601 (I)

Ths c hs f y h Gm Rsch F (DFG).

F Us B

K-Fsch

Th Tsfm Pw f E:

Th E U h Ds f Is

Ihs. 26

14195 B

Gmy

Ph: +49 (0)30- 838 57033

Fx: +49 (0)30- 838 57096

sfm-@f-.

www.sfm.


3/26

Europeanization Subverted? | 3

Europeanization Subverted?

The European Unions Promotion of Good Governance and the

Fight against Corruption in the Southern Caucasus

Tj A. Bl Y Pk

Abstract

I fs c, sy sy s , h E U hs h

E Nhh Pcy h ss sfm h msc scs f h Nwy I

Ss h s-S sc hs f fs h sh E ms cs f

mccy, f h w, m cmy, c. Emc c, hw, sss

h h EUs ccy h css s s s fm sms m. M,

ms hh cs sc s s fm ss ms f h

w s ccy fc mccy. Hc, EU s my s h f

cs h msc scs f ss, s s cs ss y mw

fm cs, h x h hy xs h s c, c s s h w f -

cm h c s. Ths s c hs s f E

(Schmmf 2007). I hs ccs ENP s c y sc h s -

s css h ss s f h E Us fm . Whch

f h w my mw s y h EUs ccy sh f fms s

h f msc cs.

T A

Tanja A. Brzel s Pfss f Pc Scc hs h ch f E

I h O Sh Is f Pc Scc, F Us B. H

sch ccs qss f Gc, s ch s s f

E s w s h s f s cs wh s f

h E U. Sc Oc 2008, sh cs h Rsch C Th

Tsfm Pw f E h wh Thms Rss.

Cc: @.f-.

Y Pk s Dc f h Sh Ccss Pjc f h Fch Nm

F f Fm hs s Ismc Ss Pc Scc

fm H Usy Tc Ss fm Us Mc Bch Ss.

Sh ws Rsch Assc h C Rsch C (SFB) 700

Gc As f Lm Sh mm f h sch jc

G Gc wh h Shw f Hchy? Th EU Nhh Pcy

A-C Mss h Sh Ccss. H PhD fcss h

f fm ss s f m sh h fm S U.

Cc: ysm.m@fs.


4/26


5/26


1. I1

Wh h s f h EU h m sws, ss f E h w

y h -w xm. As cs f h ccss cs, h EU ss sfm hmsc scs f h Nwy I Ss (NIS) h s f h S U

w fm h mm cy f h EU. I fs c, sy sy s

, h EU ss f fs (E Cmmss 2003) h sh h sm ms

cs f c s h EU s mm ss h msc ss

cs ccy. U h C Es E cs (CEEC), h Ws Bs

Ty, hw, h E hh cs (ENC) sc s sf-

f fm ss ms f h w s ccy fc mccy. M, hy h

mmsh sc, s h fs f.

Ss Nhh E (Gwch . 2009) h shw h h EUs ccy h

css s s hs m (Smh 2005; W . 2007; Sss 2008; Ky 2005; Lx 2004).

O s h h EU hs c sm fm s ch, whch, hw, hs h

s h h ch xs ms. Ths, w s h E f msc

scs f fmy S cs, whch, hw, s h s cs f wh h EU

s ch wh s E Nhh Pcy (ENP). I x hs hs

f E, w fcs h EUs ms m c, c h h

s c. Th s-S fs sm f h ms c cs h w, c-

h Sh Ccss . Hh css m cs Am, Aj

G s y css f E msc ch. O cm sy w shw

h s hh ms w ss f fm w, h h s

h EUs ms f c c sm fm s chs. Y, h h

sysmcy h c, cm ms h x h EU scy mm

-c cs c h w scs f h c s.

Th s f h s m- sc E () -

msc ch, fcs hw cm s h h fm cs h s h EU

c h ss, cs h h ch xs w scs. Th sc

cms hw Am, Aj G h s EU ms f msc ch

h c. W w shw hw h ms c sm fm ss s -

sm -c cs. Y, h msc chs w s ss y EU s-

s f . Rh, h cm ms h m x h h s c

cs h w. As s, E s s h h sfm c

scs h Sh Ccss.

1 W h T Fy, Ls Hh, J L, T S, Thms Rss f h hf

cmms ss f hs . Rsch sssc f Esh Amm s fy cw.

Ths ws s f h sch jc B2 - Gs R h Sch Hch?

Ksmf m sch Kss m Rhm EU-Nchschs, whch ws f h

C Rsch C Gc As f Lm Sh, f y h DFG (h://www.s-

c./j/j_hs_1/jch_/2/x.hm).


6/26


2. T Dk S E

Achs E msc ch h csy cc f h h -

w -w sc whch ccs h css y s -wy s s cs s ss cs f EU ms f ch (Os 2002; Kh-Kch 2003; Jcq/W

2003). Dmsc cs h h chcs s E h s ss EU

c fms; hy c sm EU cs ss c h w ss -

c hm fm h m cs. E chs h h

mwm f msc cs s y mchsm f msc ch (Cws 2001; B 2003). Y,

hy ssm h hs mw fm-m cs h ss f

f cmc wh EU qms (Schmmf 2005; Vch 2005). Wh ys c s

m msc ch f hy wf h, ss f E h y

h ssy h s f EU fms c s s h EU c h w s,

c sm msc ch, whch, hw, s h s c f h EUs s (

s Es 2009; Nch 2009).

I sh, E c h cs h msc scs f ss.

EU cs ss y mw fm cs, h x h hy xs

h s c, c s s h w f cm h c s. I

c hs s f E (Schmmf 2007), w w cc h ENP s -

c y sc h s s css h ss s

f h EUs fm . Whch f h w s my mw s y h EUs

sh f fms s h f msc cs. Th f c sh

f h cs y h EU h cc c h h EU sh h msc

hf m sc cs f h wys whch EU cs mw msc

cs.

2.1 The Power to Transform (EU Push)

A h EUs f c s sc css f cs. I , h

css f f cm ms f mcc ss wh m cms w

h f h ms, whch h m cmy scy. Sc h EU c y

cc my fc h cs c, h EUs w sfm h msc

sc f h cs s m ch h h f ms hh cs

sc.

Th ENP fs h ys f sms hs . Fsy, ccy- ms

chc c sssc ws ss ccs h cssy

fc fm. Th c sf f scs w-hw shs h ccy f

ms c wh h fm (sssc) c h cs y h

EU. Thy my s m cs h cssy fs / mcy ss s


7/26


sc cmc csqcs (Jcy 2006). Scy, h EU c s c w h

ms f m cs hh ss sc . Pc ms socializa-

on f h m h ms s h EU ss m. Fy, x incen-

ves w m h cs- ccs f ms. Whs s cs w m (f) h (s cy), x-s scs ms

s h whh ss s f cs ( cy).

Th EUs x s msy ws sh ms c msc fms. I s

ss s h h f msc -s cs hm wh c chc scs,

hm ccss s ws ss m hm h fm

css (B/Pm/Sh 2008).

Wh h ENP s -s-s fmw, EU sh hs css cs. Th cmc

c w f h EU s s x s wh h cs h symmc. I

c, h ENC h mch m wh cs s wh h EU, m

w. Hw, sm ss ssss scs (s, ) h EU s s , f sc mc,

h h c ss xs f h EU ( mm, css-

cm) h s ys h ss (Wy/Lsy 2007). Sc cmc

s c ssy m h csscy f h EU sh f msc ch, cy f h

cs ssss mmsh sc (M/Schmmf 2007; Schmmf/

Sch 2009). As w h shw swh, h mx f sms whch h EU s s hy -

c y h f sh f h cy. Th m mcc m

h m cs s sh, h m y h EU s s cs, s hs h

cs f G, wh Am Aj, whch m h whs sh s m

m h msy xs sc ccy- (B/Pm/Sh. 2008).

Th msc cx f h cs s y m fc m h EUs sh;

s s cs sh h ss f msc cs EU ms f ch.

2.2 The Disposion to Perform (Domesc Pull)

Th EUs x sh s sc c msc ch (Jcy 2006). S ss h m-

s h qs sc y msc cs, cy f ms c

fc h css f (Ky 2004; Z/P 2001; Vch 2005).

T ms ss cs f h EUs ms f ch. Th hh h css f

(ms), h m y hy ss cmc, cy f msc ys -

s msc ch. If, y cs, m s fm cs EU cs

ss w h msc , h ssc f ms ys my cm.

Hh sh ms E m y c s. I h css wh w sh

cms wh hh , chcs f E s . Hh sh w , y cs,


8/26


w s mch msc mc f h EU sc ms h s fc h xy

c css h ssc f msc ys.

If hs hc xcs f h E h, h scs f h EUs m m c h Sh Ccss h . Hm hs, mccy, h

f w h h s c q s fms h ch h c s

f sm-h ms whch y csc ws h h h ss

sy w. Th ssc s msc ch sh hf hh. G h c f

mmsh sc, h cmc c ss f h EU h sy f h

h ccss s y scs h cm wh Rss s cy, h EU hs hy

y sh f msc fms. Dmsc , y, s y qy w. Wh h

c f sc ss s ys mch f c, c scy s

w c s m s. Hh css cm wh w x sh msc

m h Sh Ccss s y cs f E. I, h sfm w f

h EU hs y m s h because ofh msc chs h h hh

cs h c ss h EUs m h c.

O cs ss w shw h w scs f E, whch h, hw, s

h h sfm msc scs. Th hs f E x y h

sccssf sy f cm m scy -c mss sh y h

EUs c c h w ss cs h w.

3. Exl P D Pll S C

3.1 High Mist, Prohibive Costs and Limited EU Push

Sc h ms f h S U 1991, h shs w h EU h ENC h

s ss, ch s fh sc f h c. Lws, h EUs

m f m c y ss msc fms hs cs scy

h s ys. Wh Es m c Am, Aj G h EUs

mm cy, h f f c sy, cm m c h EU

c y s sfm w hs m y h y s s. Th ENP ch

2004 ms fs c, sy sy h EUs w (E Cmmss

2004).

Th ENP s f fs (E Cmmss 2003: 4) h sh E ms

cs w h msc ss cs scy. Gy s,

h ENP fm cs h mj mss: mccy m, m

(y) scy c (W . 2007). G c css y css-c ss

h s msm h Ac Ps (AP) cc wh h cs 2006 hy h

c h ENP. I cs sss sch s m c s, cc f f


9/26


cs, s h s f w (cy wh h jcy), c h

m f c s c scy s, h c f m, -

c hm hs c s (cy my hs) h c (B/Sh/

Pm 2010).

I m hs ms fm , h E Cmmss hs hy h

-w mhs sms f s fm ccss cy wh h CEE cs (Ky

2006). Wh cms h cc c f h Ac Ps G, Am Aj,

h EU hs cy fcs hc h css f s ss c s

scs h h m mccy hm hs (B/Sh/Pm 2010). Is mh-

ss - fms cs fc f c sy mcc ch (B/

Pm/Sh 2009). S, m s ss m c ms s mhss h h

s c, whch ms h css f .

Th Sh Ccss cs h m h ms c cs h w, hh

sc fm f c . Wh G hs scy m s c sc h Rs

R, h s hs m m ss s Aj hs Am

(F 1). Ds h cs, c s s h cs, c G. Thy

ws m h c sh h ss s qm f f-

m ss hh c h c f c (Jhs 1999:

15). Th xs mss f sc ws f csc ss fs c c ss

xcs hs fm h s f c s (Dy . 2006; Ss 2007).

Fy, cs c f h cm m, h c f cmc s cm-

y w c scy fh h s f chc ms (Shf/Vshy

1993). C s y y h s s ws cm s c h c-

css w scs sc h yy f y msc cs (I Css G 2004).

Figure 1: Corrupon in the Southern Caucasus

Ty IlC P Ix Am G Aj

2004 ( f 146 cs) 3.1 (82.) 2.0 (133.) 1.9 (140.)

2006 ( f 163 cs) 2.9 (93.) 2.8 (99.) 2.4 (130.)

2008 ( f 180 cs) 2.9 (109.) 3.9 (67.) 1.9 (158.)

2010 ( f 178 cs) 2.6 (123.) 3.8 (68.) 2.4 (134.)

Th sc s fm 0 (hh c) 10 (w c).


10/26


Th EU Ac Ps q h h Ccs hh cs (CNC) cc, fy m-

m cs h h h s c, c h UN c-

C, h Cc f E Cm C Lw Cs h OECD C

cm y f F Pc Ocs I Bsss Tscs. G, Am Aj h j -c ws, sch s h G f Ss s

C (GRECO), mm h cmms. Fy, ch cy hs sm

ss h y cc m -c mss wh h ms /

h w fcm cs m h fmw f h sc f c-

cms. Th q cs q sm f h h Sh Ccss ss shy

y wh h sccy f c mss (cf. B/Pm/Sh 2008).

A h CNC h wh h EU h ms fm , whch css cm-

hs ms wh msc ss, cs c csss. Th ms

chs q y h EU ch h c s f cm s wh y cs-

c ws h h h ss sy w.

Y, h EU hs x sc x sh ss f h c

msc ch. Th ENP h Es Psh w xcy s

mmsh. Bscy, hy c cmc xch f c

cmc fms. Wh h EU c ccss cy sh f msc ch,

my (h ) ss ms, whh sssc ms c scs (..

s s). Lws, h EU c w ss y s (.. ssc -

ms), scs (.. cmhs m), smfy s ms

x h sc f sssc. Ths sss whs, h EU hs y c

s cy. Th CNC h f ss msc fms m ENP s

qms. I hs ms xcsy ccy c . Oy c hs h

EU cy, wh sc h s f chc c sssc

G 2003 c f ss h c (cf. B/Sh/Pm 2010).

Th sy f m fms hh s cs, , hs hm y y

fm s h sc f y chms f ms ss. M, h c f

c mmsh sc ms h scs f sc sc .

Ls s, h EUs m sy cmmc h cs f hm hs, mccy, h

f w c s sc s f h c sh hs sc h

CNC s hh c hs sss. Rh h ms -m

s f s (E Cmmss 2004: 8), h EUs xc s c m s

f hs cs y ms f sh, j cmmm wsh. B cc f h

ENP fm , c h h s c h hs f

h c h cs. Hw, s h cs f h h sms mx f

m, ss h c f EU h hm h css f h ch.

Ths, s h sy wh x c hs fs sc sc -

csss .


11/26


O, h s s y h EU s s fcs fm s scc

mss h csy s y h ss f h fm s, h c f m-

fms h sc f ss fm s (cf. B/Sh/Pm 2010). Cs -

s wh h EU sm h c f cs sch s h CNC h fc xmy hh css xm h EU.

M, h EU wh h h CNC s cy cmx, s G cs s Ws

ss h ss h mmsh NATO EU, Aj ssss s

() s cmms c ss scs, y Am s hcy

s ms cs s wh Rss. As s, h sc f EU ms s wh

h msc ss f h CNC hs f w h cs f h CEEC.

Ah cc fc s h h CEEC ccss css, h EU hs mw -

s cs h CNC. Sc 2004, h EU qs ENP ms cs c

wh -s cs c s h fm mm f h -

fm s. Y, h EU hs hy fc hs qm. U h f cy fmws,

hs s f fm h ss f -s cs wh h c (B/

Sh/Pm 2010). Th w Es Psh C Scy Fm, whch sh fc

w h CNC ms c c scy s (CSO), hs s f ch

hs (Bs/Sh 2010).

3.2 Weak Pull and Strategic Elites

Wh EU sh hs m, h s mch msc h. Th mc f c scy -

s h c s cs s wy c. CSO y m-

m cs m s h h fms sc h ws.

I c f s ccy, c scy s my s sc f w

xs h hcs h qy f h -c ms (cf. Dm/P 2001).

Ds ss h c s h Sh Ccss h fm x ccy

s s wh Ws NGOs, s y fs, h

c f cy s h w. Th f ms c scy s s y f cc

h s-S Sh Ccss. M, ms c s fc s -s

ccy cs fcs y f sss h c s m, fm mccy

hh y chc. I my css, hs hs s f xs

ss f scs. Fy, my f h c c scy s sm-sc s

wh m s h hy q wh ss chc s. As cs-

qc, ms msc -s cs h sc scs

m s f h scy. Ths c f ccy hs s s x f m cs

y c scy s ccss h cy css. Ay, h ch f scs

f c scy hs fqy s sh- mshm f NGOs h h ws


12/26


cs s x f s m y f cm (M 2008).

Nx m ccs, h w f c f h CNC ccmscs h c

my f c scy. A xc ws h mcc s f h Rs R Gh ws my chm y s sss s 2004. Th ms , hw,

mcc cs, s h c c f h 2008 w s (Ly

2008; T 2007). I Am Aj, h s s ws. R f w mccy

wy s, s h s m f c hs c s. Dmsc

css, wh cy cmcy ss s sch s h h s c,

cs ss sc h ss f fs ccss cs -

c. Fy, s h cm ch s, y sss cs c

scy s sf-ss cm s f hy fs c- h c-

sysm (Ly 2008; Kycy 2001).

Bsss s sc x c y csc ss h CNC. G cmc

fms -s csss cm cs f h cmc h

c sh. Dmsc cms c h cs ss f h c f s cmc

fmw h f w, csy cs hy fm m ss. Ahh m-

cms h sh ccss h CNC, cy h y sc Aj, hy h

s s h sh wh h cm m y sh f msc fms

(H/S 2004).

4. F C S C

Th EU hs fm sm ms f h h s c G, Am Aj,

cs sm ms. Lm sh mccy h y hs ms fm s

sysmc ss f fm fm w. Y, s hh css w s-

s, Am, Aj G h mm -c mss.

4.1 Introducing Instuonal Change

A h CNC h c h mj cs h h s c-

(cf. B/Sh/Pm 2010). I wh h s, h -

ms f G, Am Aj h c m f s chs. Thy h

-c ss -c c s, whch y A

C Cc whs mm s ss y sc Cmmsss. M, h s-

c cs ch wh h s sc f cms c. Fy,

G, Am Aj h c s s chs.


13/26


Figure 2: Domesc Instuonal Change in the Southern Caucasus

Azerbaijan Armenia Georgia

Pcy Fm I-Acy Cmmss

f Cm C

(2004), c h

C f Mss

I-Acy Cmmss

f Cm C

(2004), c h

C f Mss

A-C Cc

(2004)

Ex G (2008)

A-C Pcy

C Cc

(2001)

N Scy Cc

(2005)

Pcy Imm I-Acy Cmmss

f Cm C(2004)

A-C Sy

M Cmmss(2004)

Dm f

C A-C Pcs (2001)

S Ms f Rfm

(2005)

I-Acy C

Cc f Cm

C (2008)

Is

Psc

A-C

Dm Psc

Gs Oc (2005)

A-C

Dm Psc

Gs Oc (2004)

Psc Gs

Oc (2005)

I-Acy C

Cc f Cm

C (2008)

S Pm

Cm C,

c Imm

Ac P (2004-2006)

N Sy

Ics Tscy

Cm C,

c Imm

Ac P (2007-2011)

A-C Sy,

c Imm

Ac P

(2003-2007 2009-

2012)

N A-C

Sy (2005 2010),

c Ac P

f h A-C

Sy (2005-2006)

O, h h Sh Ccss Cs h c sm ss m h m f

h EU h cs h c. G h hh ms w ss f -

, h x f h msc chs w s s . W sh s s sm c,

A-C A

A-C S P S


14/26


whch w s x why c hs m s Aj cs Am

(F 1). Y, s h x sc w shw, h ms h mm -c m-

ss. Ths chs h c y EU cs sc s. Thy y

h mwm f cm s h h sm h h s c m h w f h c s. As s, E hs h c

h fm ss f csm . EU ms f h c h h

s h h sfm c h Sh Ccss.

4.2 Azerbaijan: Seling Internal Power Struggles

Aj hs q sm chs h c h E Cmmss s w s

h OECD h cw h ss h cy hs m (E Cmmss 2006: 4; OECD/

ACN 2010). Y, s s sm h mch c s f c (F 1). Smwh

xcy, hs s y c f fm ss h ccs s s-

s y h (Fch 2010; Bsm S 2010). Rh, h A m hs

q sc mm fc -c mss wy h css

h w y sc c s c h c h c sysm.

Ajs fm c sysm s chc y s cc f w h hs f h

xc ch c y h s hs s (F . 2009). I h shw f hs

fm ss, h s s fm s f w whch s ws h

y wf s cm wh ch h (I Css G 2010). Th s f hs

ws h h s-c w mss f , fs scy. Th

cc f h cq s m w w f s h sh w s sch -

c h c s f c cmc scs. I msy csss f sss-

m s-c chs h h m scy ss m (I

Css G 2010). Th s hs x fmy w c h cq f mss

h sc ws. Th s cs s w scs. Fhm,

h cs xchs wh h s ws ms css f cc m s

s. Th s ms, , s h y f hs ms wf s fcs

s h h s cs w h c sysm (Cs 2004; W 2003).

Th h s c hs cm y c hs fm sysm f c cs. Th

cm m hs x -c cs s w ss h hs

h xch f scs. L h mj cs, h s s s -

c mss y s c, h xcs fqy s mchsm f c

(Sh 2004: 29), whch s xm fm y ss jc s sh. Fhm, h

h f h s ms ccmy s chs h S C Sc Cmm s w

s h Cmmss f Cm C, whch s hm y w s (I Css

G 2010). I , cc s h c h fm mm f -c

cs, sch s h css, h s s, s


15/26


mchsms h c f h msm, my sjc s cmcs. Th

s jcy chs my cy h fc f cm s cs (Fm

Hs 2008).

Th w s ms hs ms h -c m-

s h cs ch wh h h s c (B/Mhy 2005). Th xcs

xcss c f h cys -c ws f sc mm f EU -

ms c h w f ss m cm s h c mw sf-ss-

cms y h ss hs css ys c. Lws, h A-C

Cmmss h Dm f Cm C h w cs s f

h s (I Css G 2010).

A m xm s h cs f A Is, wh ws f h fs f h Y

Ayc y c cs f Ajs ms c mms. H h

s-c Y w, sm f hc Ajs fm Am, Is h

y c h 1993 f h Ay fmy w. As m h Y w

cm j w m s ws hh ms. I 2005,

Is f fm c f sq f ccs wh fcs wh h cq. Sc

2003, h c f h Y w h y c s h sh ch fm Ay

S Ay J (S 2004; As 2007). Accs f c s f w, Is

ws s hs cs 2007. A sm cs xhs h m cmx s f h

w m. A s sh, x-ms f cmc m Fh Ay ( wh

h s) s ws cm y m h s-c ch f sss ss cs

h cc (cf. Es 2007). Ay ws s w f cs h w

c (msy y h Ws) s fm-m, Ws-c s f h y s. Sm

ss cm h Ay csh s ss wh fw ms f h

h y h chm f h s s (cf. Ismy 2006). Oh scs, hw,

cm h Ay ws sh f y c hs c ms. I y cs, Ay ws

ch wh c m, c s f c, mm f s y, sm

x s , h wh Is, cc s ys f msm (BBC Ww

M Sc 2008).2

I sm, h s f Ajs hs h c h fcs sh h s

s, x s c scy fs h w f h cms. As s, h

m f Aj hs my c h EUs ms f chc sssc w

jcs h m ccy f h xc c s cs. G c c

c sh, y cs, s f h schm. O h cy, h m hs s c

s c s w cm m c scy cs ss f h m

wh h cm cc f h hs (Fm Hs 2008). Ahh h f c

hs cs, s fms sc h ch. Nx ms c c h

m- c scs f x, c c hs mc

2 Th y f h x-mss ws csc c f f h sy 2009.


16/26


h wh -c hs cm f shsc c sysm c y h

cm s (I Css G 2010).

4.3 Armenia: Pleasing External Donors

Am hs s ss f s s Ds c h w-

c. Is m hs mm -c mss. Hw, c-

hs cs h h cs (F 1), whch s s y sm x

f h h s c s w s Aj, wh s. Rh h

m h w f c s, h Am m hs s h h s c-

c ccsm s x c f c sm.

Th cm m Am s m h h f Aj. Is cs f w my ss

wh h scy s, c h m fcs s sch s h

Yh (B/S 2006).3 Ams hsc sm h Kh cc h

c s ss f y h hs h h cys s fc-

s ms hm m c w ss. A h sm m, w c-

cs c sc sss (Kh Ty) h h s fs (Hs

2008), whch s h s f -c mss m c. Ms my, h w -

c wh m s y h Aj. A hy-xc wh w-ch

cmcs ms h s s (Shhy 2003). Hw, h m ys cm-

y s h fm w m h Aj. I c h

ssss fm h s f h cm wh h s s, h s-c chs h

csy ssm mmsh m (Fm Hs 2008). Fhm, c

s h jy s fm h Ds s h scc s-

h m (Dwc 1993). As csqc, Ams s s mch

f w s s w s s. H ss s c w

s wh h scy s, h xc ss x h m.

Sm Aj, c c-s s s sm f w s. Hw,

hs ccs mch w m , c s h jcy mm- s -

ccy. As h cs f h 1999 my sh mss, ss hh- h s s

y h ms (Hm 1999).

E m m h s w ss, h h s c ss h -

cm m c x scs. Am s mch m x c

h Aj (L 2004). I 1994, Am s cs cmc sc h

3 Th U f Vs Yh (G f h Cy) s my h ws f 1993

h Kh w. A h cs- 1994 Yh hs cm ss whs

mms h m ss h c my.


17/26


cs f s s wh Ty Aj. As csqc f hs s, sss -

s m Ams cmy s hy m y chc ms. A h sm

m, h sc Am Ds s q msc cs. Css f y s-

s, c s s s h U Ss, Fc h L,h Ds s cs c h scs h cy (Gs/Oh

1991; I O f M 2008). Y, c - f shs y h s

h mj mm f Ds ss. If sm hs y c s Am,

s h f m wh s f ss, wh y f , wh

y s c (Msy 2004: 20). Ths hs s , f cs, f f ss.

Wh h cys m m c (F 1), Ds s h s h

mm f msc fms f h c ms jcy, csms, x, c,

c hh h scs (Tscy I Am 2006; Ahjy 2010). U -

cs ss, h Am m ch sm cy s ms

cc w c, c h sc f c cs h x m, csms sc

c. G h c f sysmc c, sch chs s h cc f

my symc (Gy 2008).

I sm, -c cs h msy s s h cmmy

c f c sms cm h cmc s f h cy. Wh

c h w f s m c s, h Am m hs ss

c ms c y symcy s h sc f

s.

4.4 Georgia: Consolidang New Power Structures

I h s c s s, G h h h s c h c-

s s ss s cmy (Dchsh/ N 2003; K /Ls 2000). Oy

wh x s s c h sc h whw h s, Ps

Sh c sm fm chs. Mch h hs cs h , h -

c 1997 h y f h cs s c (McG Eh/Gm 2001: 12) h

m ch s s -c cm. A h sm m, hw, Sh m

s h h m h c . I m w,

h s s hs scs s h s f s w s ws. I x-

ch f h s, hs w s w h h c x c

scs, c m x, h sh f s. As s, s ss

cm csy m h s s (Why/Zch 2008). I Sm

2001, h ms f jsc, Mh Ssh, h m f s y, h

U N Mm, ss wh h Sh m c.

A Sh h s h h 2003 cs, mss ss


18/26


ss fc hm s fm c. Wh s my cs, Mh Ssh

hs y c sc s f h c s. H c h h s c

h c f hs m cs (Why 2005). Th w m mmy c

s c wh h w fcm cs, s h cm sm f h f-c c, whch h cs s f h ms c ss f h cy. 15.000 cs

s h js ccy h. I , sc fc f 30.000 m wm ch

h Msy f I ws ss mms . Rfms f h c fcs c wh

sms m qm, h c f w c cmy, my xms

f c cs, cs css h ss. A h sm m, c s f m

cs w . Py c ws s ss cm, w s ys f

msm (B/Kch 2005; Hscc 2005).

L hs css, Ssh c h h s c h c c f hs -

m. Sc 2006 2008, scy, h Ms f S Rfm h Ms f Jsc, wh

hs h I-Acy C Cc f Cm C, h ch wh h -

mm f -c cs. Wh s hs sy y c-

w s f ccy, Ssh hs ccs f y mj c-

s f w m hs css s h h y c my m ss.

Sm Aj, c hs c h sm c

(Chsh 2009). Nx w hs css sscs, Ssh hs s s h h s c-

s c s. Wh h fm ms f fs cs ssc f Ssh,

I Osh, h m 2006, fm s y ccs h Ps f

ms cms, h ws s c chs. A c f hm y f -sc x

sc hm ys s. Wh ws wy c s c sc s

mss ss c h s f m s 2008 (Fm Hs 2008c). Fy,

h c f ch c hs h s f c sms cmc

s. Th EU, h IMF h cs, whch h ss sssc f h

Rs R, s h c s f Gs w m. Th EU ms

s s (E Cmmss 2005); h c m sssc c cs

y m h ms w 2002 2007; s h f c sms (W B ;

Ix M).4 I 2006, h W B h I Fc C c G h

s fm h w s sss m (Fm Hs 2007). Th h s

c s f h cmc fms h Ssh m hs sh.

Wh h ms f s fms, Kh B, hs sh s mj s c-

, h cms h -c mss m cmc wh y sc c c

ss (E Sy I 2010).

I sm, h Ssh m hs sccssfy s -c mss c h

w scs ssh y h Sh m, cs hs w w scs,

4 Cf. Th W B D G h://.w./c Ix M FDI,

ws G 1997 - 2009 h://www.xm.cm/fcs/cs/BX.KLT.DINV.CD.DT/

cm?cy=#cy=.


19/26


s s c f c sm m hs fm

. Th f h -c h c fcs f h -

cms G s w s h cys cy f y x why hs mch

c h c h Aj Am.

5. Cl

Th Sh Ccss s s y cs f x E. Wh h ENP, h EU hs -

shsc fmw sfm h msc scs f fm S cs

y c. B ms s hh h sc f mmsh sc h EU hs

y- s sm f h css. N hs h EU x mch ss f ,

y sssc c h h () cy. Fy, h cm

ms h hy y fm cs h EU c mw, wh fm cs scy

c sc c. Wh cc xcs w sh s mch msc ch

ms f E, h ms f G, Am Aj h fc -

s h EUs m f c. G hs ms c h c. Th

EUs -c cs s wh h c f h Ssh m w

h css f . A h sm m, h EU h Ws s ms s h h

s c y c ms cs c. Am s s -

sssc s G. Is hs ss hssc h c s

c cs wh x ss s. E Aj, whch hs ms c s h

EUs c s s x scs, ssh sm ss

cs s s w hs. Fy, h ms h mm -c mss

h h sm cs. Ths, h EU s h mc cs h c mmsh

sc f css f hh, x ss s w h fm

cs EU cs w h msc . E s y h m-

wm f cm s h h fc f w cs wh h EUs m

f msc ch. C s fh wh hs s c s, c

ccsm c f sssc sms. D cs sh mccy,

E hs cs h h cs (F 3). Wh hs s sm-

s chs, h ccs h mc c . G, whch

s cy x s h ms sc f h h cs, hs s ms fm

ss ms f m sh. Thf, h G hs h s h

-c sh sh y m h ccy f s ss fc

c cs fs cmc wh. I Aj, h s mcc sc m,

h cm s h x h h s c s c s sc

sm. I Am, whch s sc s shws h hhs f sh, h m-

m f -c mss hs msy symc c ccsm

s h w f f sms, cy f s Ds. G h w h

EUs m f c h fcs f h Ssh m, G hs m


20/26


ss c c s h Aj cy Am, wh mc

c cs h cm ch f cmy. Y, h cs, h

cm s h my c h EUs -c h h c

h c f scs wh h c sysm c scs fm h s.E c msc s ch h cs h s fm w s f

sh mccy (hf) c ccss sc, f mws cm s.

Rh h sfm scs, hw, E hs s h c c-

mc scs f hh cs. Wh hy m h sh, h f mccy

hs m q s h w (F 3).

Figure 3: Democracy and Statehood in the Southern Caucasus5

Armenia Georgia Azerbaijan

Bsm

Tsfm Ix

Sh

8,8 (2010)

4,0 (2003)

6,3 (2010)

2,0 (2003)

7,0 (2010)

3,0 (2003)

Fm Hs

Fm h W

Ix Dmccy

5 (2010)

6 (2003)

4 (2010)

4 (2003)

5.5 (2010)

5.5 (2003)

Th sc f h Bsm Tsfm Ix Sh s fm1 (f s) 10 (cs s).Th sc f h Fm Hs - Fm h W Ix Dmccy s fm 1 (f) 7 ( f).

5 Cf. h Bsm Tsfm Ix (BTI) cy s Am, Aj, G, 2003

2010 h Fm Hs cy s Am, Aj, G 2003 2010.


21/26


L

Aghajanyan, Liana 2010: Ds Cfc Exms Isss f C Icm Iqs

Y, : Es, 6 Dcm, : h://www.s.//62513, 13 Dcm

2010.

Avioutskii, Viatcheslav2007: Ls Cs A j, : L C s Pys LEs 5: 1063, 67-79.

Badalov, Rahman/Mehdy, Niyazi 2005: Th Pc Iss f Aj: A Dchmy w

Tx Ry, : A, Amh/N, Gh (s.): Th Cs/Pc Rfm

Pcss G, Am Aj: Pc E Vcs f h P, Is f

Dmccy Ec Asssc, Ts.

BBC Worldwide Monitoring Service 2008: Ts Ccss U, 10 Sm.

Bedevian, Astghik/Stepanian, Ruzanna 2006: Ochc Py Us Mfs Am Mss Rc-

m f Mms, : Am Ly, 14 A, : h://www.my./c/

c/1581468.hm; 17 My 2009.

Bertelsmann Sung 2003: Bsm Tsfm Ix (BTI), : h://www.sm-s-

fm-x.///; 27 Nm 2010.

Bertelsmann Sung 2010: Bsm Tsfm Ix (BTI), : h://www.sm-s-

fm-x.///; 27 Nm 2010.

Bertelsmann Sung 2010: BTI 2010 Aj Cy R, Gsh, : h://www.s-

m-sfm-x./; 4 A 2010.

Boda, Jozsef/Kakachia, Kornely 2005: The Current Status of Police Reform in Georgia, in: Cole, Eden/Fluri,

Philip H. (eds.): From Revoluon to Reform: Georgias Struggle with Democrac Instuon Build-

ing and Security Sector Reform, Geneva.

Boonstra, Jos/Shapovalova, Natalia 2010: Th EUs Es Psh: O Y Bcws, : FRIDEW P 99, 1-14.

Brzel, Tanja A./Pamuk, Yasemin/Stahn, Andreas 2008: O S Fs A? Hw h E U P-

ms G Gc Is N A, : SFB 700 W Ps 18, Sfschs-

ch 700, F Us B.

Brzel, Tanja A./Pamuk, Yasemin/Stahn, Andreas 2009: Dmccy Sy? EU US Em

h Sh Ccss, : M, Amch/ Rss, Thms /McF, Mch (s.): Pm

Dmccy h R f Lw. Amc E Ss, Hms, 150-184.

Brzel, Tanja A./Stahn, Andreas/Pamuk, Yasemin 2010: Th E U Is Fh As C-

s N A. C M Dc?, : G Cm 11/2, 122-144.

Brzel, Tanja A./Risse, Thomas fhcm: Pc h Em - Hw Mch S Ds I T?,: SFB W Ps; Sfschsch 700, F Us B.

Chiabrishvili, Maria 2009: Th Dmcc Tsfm f G, : Cm, S (.): Fm F-

S Fc S. Phwys Dmcc Tsfm Cm Psc-

, B, 161-186.

Collins, Kathleen 2004: Th Lc f C Pcs. Ec fm h C As Tjcs, : W

Pcs 56/2, 224-261.

Darchiashvili, David/Nodia, Ghia 2003: Th W S Sym C, : IDEA Dscss

P 5: Pw Scs, Th W S Sym C G, Schm, 16-

22.

Demidov, Boris/Panlova, Elena 2001: R f C Scy C C Cs f Ts

Ecms, : www.scy../CENTER/DOC/c_CAF.c; 4 A 2010.

Drury, A. Cooper/Krieckhaus, Jonathan/Luszg, Michael 2006: C, Dmccy, Ecmc


22/26


Gwh, : I Pc Scc Rw 27/2, 121-136.

Dudwick, Nora 1993: Am: h N Aws, : Bmm, I/Ts, Ry (s.): N Pcs

h S Sccss Ss, Sf, 261-287.

Elbasani, Arolda 2009: EU Ams Cy Dmsc Dw. Th Lms f E-

Ch Cxs, : KFG W Ps 2, Jy 2009, F Us B.

Eurasianet2007: Aj: Ex-Mss T Cs Pc Ss, 5 Mch, : www.Es.

; 30 Sm 2010.

European Commission 2003: Cmmc fm h Cmmss h Cc h E P-

m. W E - Nhh: A Nw Fmw f Rs wh Es

Sh Nhs, (COM (2003)104 ), 11 Mch, Bsss.

European Commission 2004: E Nhh Pcy. Sy P (COM(2004) 373 ), 12

My, Bsss.

European Commission 2005: E Nhh Pcy - Cy R G, (COM (2005) 72

).

European Commission 2006: E Nhh Psh sm: Aj N I-c Pmm 2007-2010.

European Commission 2008: Imm f h E Nhh Pcy - Pss R

Aj, SEC(2008)391, Bsss, : h://c../w//f/ss2008/

sc08_391_.f, 3 Dcm 2010.

European Stability Iniave 2010: Gs L R. P III: Jcs Ts, B, T-

s, Is.

Franke, Anja/Gawrich, Andrea/Alakbarov, Gurban 2009: Khs Aj s Ps- S R

Ss: Rsc Icms Accy s D Cs Ps-S Rms, : E

As Ss 61/1, 109-140.

Freedom House 2003: Fm h W Ix: cy s Am, Aj, G, :h://www.fmhs./m.cfm?=15; 27 Nm 2010.

Freedom House 2005: Ns Ts Cy R G, : h://www.fmhs./

m.cfm?=47&=363&y=2005; 4 A 2011.

Freedom House 2006: Ns Ts - Cy R Am, : h://www.fmhs./

m.cfm?=47&=388&y=2006; 4 A 2011.

Freedom House 2007: Ns Ts; Cy R G, : h://www.fmhs./

m.cfm?=47&=423&y=2007; 27 Nm 2010.

Freedom House 2008: Ns Ts Cy R Aj, : h://www.fmhs./

m.cfm?=47&=445&y=2008; 4 A 2011.

Freedom House 2008: Ns Ts Cy R Am, : h://www.fmhs./m.cfm?=47&=445&y=2008; 27 Nm 2010.

Freedom House 2008c: Ns Ts; Cy R G, : h://www.fmhs./

m.cfm?=47&=452&y=2008; 4 A 2011.

Freedom House 2010: Fm h W Ix: cy s Am, Aj, G, :

h://www.fmhs./m.cfm?=15, 27 Nm 2010.

Frichova Grono, Magdalena 2010: Aj, : h://www.fmhs.; 4 A 2011.

Gawrich, Andrea/Melnykovska, Inna /Schweickert, Rainer2009: Nhh E hh

ENP - Th Cs f U, : KFG W Ps 3, As 2009, F Us B.

Gillespie, Kate/Okruhlik, Gwenn 1991: Th Pc Dmss f C Cs: A Fmw f

Ayss, : Cm Pcs 24/1, 77-95.

Group of States against Corrupon (GRECO) 2006: J s sc E R E

R Am, 10h Mch, 2006, GRECO E I-II R (2005)2E, : h://www.

c.//h/m/c/s/2/GcE1-2%282005%292_Am_


23/26


EN.f, 3 Dcm 2010; 4 A 2011.

Group of States against Corrupon (GRECO) 2008: Sc E R Cmc c f G-

, 15h My, 2009, Gc RC-II (2008) 9E, Ss, : h://www.jsc..

/s/Dcms//GcRC2%282008%299_G_EN_-_cmc__-

_2__.f6.f, 3 Dcm 2010 ; 4 A 2011.

Group of States against Corrupon (GRECO) 2010:: Th E R E R A-

j, 1s Oc 2010, Gc E III R (2010) 2E, Ss, : h://www.c.

//h/m/c/s/3/GcE3%282010%292_Aj_O_

EN.f; 4 A 2011.

Grigoryan, Marianna 2008: Am: G Ss C?, : h://www.s./

ms/sh/cs/071108.shm; 22 Nm 2010.

Hiscock, Duncan 2005: Th Cmmcs f Ps-s P Scy, : C, E/F, Ph

H. (s.): Fm R Rfm: Gs S wh Dmcc Is B

Scy Sc Rfm, G.

Ho, Karla/Sglitz, Joseph E. 2004: Th Ts fm Cmmsm: A Dmmc Exs f O-

scs h Dm f h R f Lw, W B Pcy Rsch W P 3352, 25J 2004, W B.

Homan, David1999: Pm c Am, : Th Wsh Ps, 28 Oc.

Hovannisian, Ra K. 2008: Fw h Ps: Rss, Ty, Ams F, Y, : h://

www.cs.m/cs/2008.hm; 4 A 2011.

Index Mundi2011: G - F c sm, ws cmy, : h://www.

xm.cm/fcs/cs/BX.KLT.DINV.CD.DT/cm?cy=#cy=; 13 A

2011.

Internaonal Crisis Group 2004: Aj: T O Nw Lf?, ICG E R, 13 My 2004,

Y; Ts; Bsss.

Internaonal Crisis Group 2010: Aj: V Sy, ICG E R, 3 Sm 2010.

Internaonal Organizaon for Migraon 2008: M Am. A Cy P 2008, G.

Ismavilov, Rovshan Ismayilov2006: Ajs Emcy Msy cms Pw Bs, : h://www.

s./ms/sh/cs/030906.shm; 30 Sm 2010.

Jacoby, Wade 2006: Is, C Ss. Ex Ics Pscmms Ts-

fms, : W Pcs 58, 623651.

Jacquot, Sophie/Woll, Cornelia 2003: Us f E I - Es fm Scc

Psc, : E I O Ps 7/12.

Johnston, Michael 1999: C Dmcc Cs, : Cfc Dmccy

C, Shy Cm Ds C f Hsc Ss, Mch 12 1999, Pc U-

sy, : h://www.4./cm//c-mcc-cs.f; 4

A 2011.

Karatnycky, Adrian 2001: Ns Ts: Em Dymcs f Ch.

Kelley, Judith 2004: I Acs h Dmsc Sc: Mmsh Cy Sc-

y I Iss, : I O 58/3, 425-457.

Kelley, Judith 2005: Nw W O Wss: Pcy L A h w E

Nhh Pcy, D.

Kelley, Judith G. 2006: Nw W O Wss: Pm Pc Rfms hh h Nw E-

Nhh Pcy, : J f Cmm M Ss 44/1, 29-55.

Kikabidze, Koba/Losaberidze, David2000: Issm Csm G, Ts.

Kohler-Koch, Beate 2003: L EU N Gc, Oxf.


24/26


Lavenex, Sandra 2004: EU Ex Gc W E, : J f E Pc Pcy

11/4, 680-700.

Laverty, Nicklaus 2008: Pms f Ls Ch: C Scy C Rs G

U, : Dmsy 16/2, 143-162.

Libaridian, Gerard J. 2004: M Am: P, N, S, Nw Bswc, NJ.

Maier, Sylvia/Schimmelfennig, Frank2007: Sh Vs: Dmccy Hm Rhs, : W, Kj/

Smh, Mch E./B, Mch (s.): G Es Nhh. Ps Ph-

y?, Mchs, 39-57.

Manaseryan, Tatoul2004: Ds Th Cm A f Am, : Am I

Pcy Rsch W P Ss 14/4, Am I Pcy Rsch G, :

h://www../UsFs/F/w/j2004/14.f; 27 Nm 2010.

Matveeva, Anna 2008: Ex C Scy: Th Ps-Cmms Exc, : Pms f Ps-Cm-

msm 55/2, 3-13.

McGiert Ekedahl, Carolyn/Goodman, Melvin A. 2001: Th Ws f E Sh, Ds.

Noutcheva, Gergana 2009: F, P Ims Cmc: Th Lms f h EUs Nm Pw h Ws Bs, : J f E Pc Pcy 16/7, 1065-1084.

OECD/ ACN 2010: Is A-C Ac P Sc R f M: Aj M-

R, Ps; 4 A 2011.

Olsen, Johan P. 2002: Th My Fcs f E, : J f Cmm M Ss 40/5,

921-950.

Sasse, Gwendolyn 2008: Th E Nhh Pcy: Cy Rs f h EUs Es-

Nhs, : E As Ss 60/2, 295-316.

Schimmelfennig, Frank2007: E y E, : L Rws E Gc

1/1, : h://www.ws./-2007-2001; 12 A 2011.

Schimmelfennig, Frank/Scholtz, Hanno 2009: EU Dmccy Pm h E Nhh.

Pc Cy, Ecmc Dm Ts Exch, : E U

Pcs 9/2, 187-215.

Shaer, Brenda 2004: Ic: Rc f Aj, : B, Vm/Vsm, Dm/Wss-

m, Ayh (s.): Pc O C As Aj: Scs Dcms,

L [..], 21-94.

Shahnazaryan, Nelson 2003: Ochs Am, Y.

Shleifer, Andrei/Vishny, Robert W. 1993: C (My), : h://s.c.///w/4372.

hm; 4 A 2011.

Sidikov, Bahodir2004: Nw T? Cs, R Gs, S Ps-S A-

j, : B Os If 21, 68-74.

Smith, Mitchell P. 2005: Th Ss f L. R h Pc Sc I E,

Nw Y.

Stokes, Susan C. 2007: Pc Csm, : Bx, Cs/Ss, Ss C. (s.): Th Oxf H

f Cm Pcs, 604-627.

Transparency Internaonal: C Pc Ix. Cy Rs, : h://www.scy.

; 23 Mch 2011.

Transparency Internaonal Armenia 2006: A-C Pcy Am, : h://www.s-

cy.m/c.h?=24; 27 Nm 2010.

Transparency Internaonal2009: G C R, Cm.

Tudoroiu, Theodor2007: Rs, O T: Th f s-S s, : Cmms

Ps-Cmms Ss 40/3, 315-342.


25/26


Vachudova, Milada Anna 2005: E U: Dmccy, L I A Cmm-

sm, Oxf.

Way, Lucan/Levitsky, Steven 2007: L, L, h Ps-Cmms D, : Es E

Pcs & Scs 21/1, 48-66.

Weber, Katja/Smith, Michael E./Baun, Michael(s.) 2007: G Es Nhh: Ps Phy?, Mchs.

Wedel, Janine R. 2003: Cs, Cqs C Ss: Rh Ts C Es

E h Fm S U, : J f I Dm 15, 427440.

Wheatley, Jonathan 2005: G Fm N Aw Rs R. Dy Ts h

Fm S U, Ash.

Wheatley, Jonathan/Zrcher, Christoph 2008: O h O Cs f Hy Rms: Th

S f Dmccy h Ccss, : Tw J f Dmccy 4/1, 1-31.

World Bank a: D Cy Sscs, : h://.w.//hm.; 3 Dcm

2010.

World Bank b: D Ics, : h://.w./c; 13 A 2011.

Zielonka, Jan/Pravda, Alex(s.) 2001: Dmcc Cs Es E, Oxf.


26/26

T Kll-F - E A Ex

I R

Th K-Fsch (KFG) s w f mm -

ch y h Gm Rsch F 2008. I s c-

c f h KFG sccy sm m

whch sch cs c wh y scs wh sm f s j schs.

Th K-Fsch Th Tsfm Pw f E

s h sch E s h B-B-

ss h c wh h -

ss sch ss. I xms h f h EU s -

m c f s, y h mchsms cs

f x s csss h sch s:

Iy h Pc Sh

Cmc, Cy By

Cm Rsm Es Ex Rs

Europeanization Subverted? The European Union’s Promotion of Good Governance and the Fight against...

Documents

Transcript of Europeanization Subverted? The European Union’s Promotion of Good Governance and the Fight against...