Eugenics and Education: Institutionalized Ideology Ann Gibson Winfield.

26
Eugenics and Education: Institutionalized Ideology Ann Gibson Winfield

Transcript of Eugenics and Education: Institutionalized Ideology Ann Gibson Winfield.

Page 1: Eugenics and Education: Institutionalized Ideology Ann Gibson Winfield.

Eugenics and Education:

Institutionalized Ideology

Ann Gibson Winfield

Page 2: Eugenics and Education: Institutionalized Ideology Ann Gibson Winfield.

Intellectual history:

• Plato and Aristotle

• Great Chain of Being - Every existing thing has its place – divinely inspired – in a hierarchical order.

• Social Darwinism – application of ‘survival of the fittest’ to human society.

• ‘Eugenics’ – coined by Sir Francis Galton in 1889.

Page 3: Eugenics and Education: Institutionalized Ideology Ann Gibson Winfield.
Page 4: Eugenics and Education: Institutionalized Ideology Ann Gibson Winfield.

Eugenics is …

“The science of improvement of the human germ plasm through better breeding” (Galton 1889).

“The application of human intelligence to human evolution” (Wiggam 1924).

Page 5: Eugenics and Education: Institutionalized Ideology Ann Gibson Winfield.
Page 6: Eugenics and Education: Institutionalized Ideology Ann Gibson Winfield.

Historical Contextearly twentieth century

• Immigration• Poverty• Jim Crow South• Industrial Revolution• Labor Unrest• FEAR

Page 7: Eugenics and Education: Institutionalized Ideology Ann Gibson Winfield.
Page 8: Eugenics and Education: Institutionalized Ideology Ann Gibson Winfield.

Eugenic Goals

• Positive Eugenics• Negative Eugenics• Sterilization• Immigration Restriction• Marriage Restriction

Eugenically undesirable persons included ‘blind, insane, feebleminded, epileptics, paupers, alcoholics, tramps, prostitutes, beggars, unmarried mothers, morons, imbecile, idiots, sexual deviants, children who masturbate, and criminals” Popenoe 1918 p. 42)

Page 9: Eugenics and Education: Institutionalized Ideology Ann Gibson Winfield.
Page 10: Eugenics and Education: Institutionalized Ideology Ann Gibson Winfield.

Use of:

• Scientific caché

• Progressive idealism – “making the world a better place” (through racial cleansing)

• Utopian narrative

Page 11: Eugenics and Education: Institutionalized Ideology Ann Gibson Winfield.
Page 12: Eugenics and Education: Institutionalized Ideology Ann Gibson Winfield.

Dissemination and Popular Culture

• Lecture Circuits• Plays• Pamphlets• Displays• Books• Curriculum• State Fairs• Contests

• Churches• Social Services• Health Groups• Philanthropy• Boy/Girl Scouts• Medicine• YMCA/YWCA• Carnegie/Rockefeller

Page 13: Eugenics and Education: Institutionalized Ideology Ann Gibson Winfield.
Page 14: Eugenics and Education: Institutionalized Ideology Ann Gibson Winfield.
Page 15: Eugenics and Education: Institutionalized Ideology Ann Gibson Winfield.
Page 16: Eugenics and Education: Institutionalized Ideology Ann Gibson Winfield.
Page 17: Eugenics and Education: Institutionalized Ideology Ann Gibson Winfield.

Eugenic Beliefs

• Heredity and Ability

• Race and Degeneracy

• Immigration, Crime and Poverty

• Sterilization and Marriage Restriction

Page 18: Eugenics and Education: Institutionalized Ideology Ann Gibson Winfield.
Page 19: Eugenics and Education: Institutionalized Ideology Ann Gibson Winfield.

Defining and Classifying

• Idiots – unable to develop full speech and have a mental age below age three

• Imbeciles – unable to master written language and range from three to seven in mental age

• Morons – the most dangerous to unsuspecting ‘normal’ people – a.k.a. “high grade defective”

• Feebleminded – anyone who didn’t fit into the long list of other classifications.

Page 20: Eugenics and Education: Institutionalized Ideology Ann Gibson Winfield.
Page 21: Eugenics and Education: Institutionalized Ideology Ann Gibson Winfield.

Education

• Focus shifts

• Compulsory education

• Education as a moral solution

Page 22: Eugenics and Education: Institutionalized Ideology Ann Gibson Winfield.

Early Curriculum

• Efficiency and Waste

• Child Study and Emotion

• Direct Dominant Ideals

• Control Indigents and Defectives

• Eugenic Worth

• Usefulness

Page 23: Eugenics and Education: Institutionalized Ideology Ann Gibson Winfield.

School Practices• Tracking• Ability Grouping• Vocational Education• Gifted and Talented Education• Health and Hygiene• Sex Ed• SAT/GRE

Page 24: Eugenics and Education: Institutionalized Ideology Ann Gibson Winfield.

IQ Test Recruits

Page 25: Eugenics and Education: Institutionalized Ideology Ann Gibson Winfield.
Page 26: Eugenics and Education: Institutionalized Ideology Ann Gibson Winfield.