7/28/2019 EU Version: No Jobs Here: Why Industrial Fish Farming's Promise to Boost Local Economies Falls Flat

1/5

7/28/2019 EU Version: No Jobs Here: Why Industrial Fish Farming's Promise to Boost Local Economies Falls Flat

2/5

7/28/2019 EU Version: No Jobs Here: Why Industrial Fish Farming's Promise to Boost Local Economies Falls Flat

3/5

MHYTVYLQVIZLTWOHZPZHKKLKJV\SKILJYLH[LKI`[OLZHSTVUHX\HJ\S[\YLPUK\Z[Y`(KTP[[LKS`IL[^LLUHUK[OLTVZ[YLJLU[`LHYVMH]HPSHISLZ[H[PZ[PJZ[OLYLOHZILLUHUPTWYV]LTLU[PUQVIJYLH[PVUPU[OLZHSTVUWYVK\J[PVUPUK\Z[Y ^P[OHUV]LYHSSPUJYLHZLVMHYV\UKWLYJLU[VYQVIZ/V^L]LYP[PZPTWVY[HU[[VUV[L[^V[OPUNZ![OH[[OLZLQVIZHYLUV[ULJLZZHYPS`Z[HISLVYSVUN[LYTHUKHUHUHS ZPZ^P[OHSVUNLY[PTLOVYPaVUYL]LHSZV]LYHSSKLJYLHZLPUHX\HJ\S[\YLQVIZ

(ZLMJPLUJ OHZPUJYLHZLKHUK[OLPUK\Z[Y`OHZJVUZVSPKH[LKLTWSV`TLU[VWWVY[\UP[PLZOH]LZPNUPJHU[S`KYVWWLKOH[Z5L_[0M[OLPUK\Z[Y`JVU[PU\LZ[VL_WHUKHZP[WSHUZ[OPZ[YLUKPZSPRLS`[VJVU[PU\LHUKVWWVY[\UP[PLZMVYHS[LYUH[P]LY\YHSKL]LSVWTLU[Z\JOHZ[V\YPZTHUKYLJYLH[PVUHSZOPUNTH`ILPTWLKLKI`[OLULNH[P]LLU]PYVUTLU[HSPTWHJ[ZMYVTZOMHYTPUN(ZNV]LYUTLU[WYLZZYLSLHZLZHUK[OLTLKPHOHWWPS`OPNOSPNO[UL^QVIZJYLH[LKV]LY[OLWHZ[JV\WSL`LHYZ[OLSVUN[LYT[YLUKHUKSVZ[QVIZILJH\ZLVM[OLPUK\Z[Y`HYLPNUVYLK(JJVYKPUN[V[OL:HSTVU-HYT4VUP[VYZWVY[HUNSPUNHUK[V\YPZ[YLSH[LKQVIZOH]L

ILLUSVZ[PU[OL>LZ[/PNOSHUKZHUKPZSHUKZVM:JV[SHUKILJH\ZLVM[OLZHSTVUMHYTPUNPUK\Z[Y >OL[OLYL_JOHUNPUN[OLZLQVIZMVY[OVZLPU[OLZHSTVUPUK\Z[Y`PZ^VY[O^OPSLTPNO[ILKLIH[HISLPM[OLZHSTVUPUK\Z[Y`JV\SKWYV]PKLSVUN[LYTZ[HISLQVIZSPRLZWVY[HUNSPUNHUK[V\YPZTOH]L[OLWV[LU[PHS[VKV/V^L]LYSHJRVMLU]PYVUTLU[HSZ\Z[HPUHIPSP[`PUZHSTVUMHYTPUNJVTIPULK^P[O[OLHIZLUJLVMHN\HYHU[LL[OH[JVTWHUPLZ PSSYLTHPUPU:JV[SHUKPMV[OLYVWWVY[\UP[PLZHYPZLLSZL^OLYLTHRL[OLX\HSP[`VM[OLZLQVIZX\LZ[PVUHISL

4HYPUL/HY]LZ[P[ZLSMH[[LZ[Z[OH[PTWHJ[ZVUJVTT\UP[PLZHUK^VYRLYZHML[`HYLWYVISLTHYLHZ;OLJVTWHU`Z

JVYWVYH[LZVJPHSYLZWVUZPIPSP[`YLWVY[UV[LZ[OH[+PZY\W[PVUVMJVHZ[HSLJVUVTPLZIHZLKVUZOPUNHUK[V\YPZTHUKKHTHNL[VOLHS[OVMLTWSV`LLZYLZ\S[PUNMYVTPUHKLX\H[LOLHS[OHUKZHML[`WYLJH\[PVUZ^LYLIV[OWV[LU[PHSJVTT\UP[`PTWHJ[ZVM[OLJVTWHU`ZHJ[P]P[PLZ 0U[OLHUU\HSYLWVY[4HYPUL/HY]LZ[UV[LK[OH[;OLYL^LYLUVMH[HSHJJPKLU[ZVU[OLWYLTPZLZPUI\[[OLU\TILYVMTPUVYPUJPKLU[ZJ\[ZHUKZ[YHPUZYLTHPUZOPNOHUKYLX\PYLZM\Y[OLYH[[LU[PVUPU

0U6J[VILY4HYPUL/HY]LZ[HUUV\UJLKHTHZZP]LL_WHUZPVUPUP[ZVWLYH[PVUZ[OYV\NOVMMZOVYLZOMHYTZ^OPJO^V\SKJYLH[LUL QVIZH[LY-HYTZ2)>-YLHJOLKHTH_PT\TSL]LSVMLTWSV`TLU[PU6J[VILY^OLUP[LTWSV`LKWLVWSLUV[HSSSVJHS)`(WYPS[OLUL_[`LHYP[ZLTWSV`TLU[OHKKYVWWLK[V([[OLZHTL[PTL[OLJVTWHU`HWWSPLK[VTHRLTVKPJH[PVUZ[VP[ZZP[L0UMHJ[[OLTVKPJH[PVU^HZIHZLKPUWHY[[VLSPTPUH[L[OLULLKMVYZ[HMM!>LILSPL]L[OH[[OLVUS` H`MVY2VUH)S\L[VHJOPL]LWYV[HIPSP[`MVYV\Y2VUHVWLYH[PVUPZI`YLK\JPUNV\YYLSPHUJLVU:*

7/28/2019 EU Version: No Jobs Here: Why Industrial Fish Farming's Promise to Boost Local Economies Falls Flat

4/5

[VWYVMLZZPVUHSZLTPWYVMLZZPVUHSHUKSHIVYLYWVZP[PVUZHUV]LYHSSQVISVZZVMWLYJLU[3VVRPUNH[[OLLU[PYLPUK\Z[Y`PU/H HPPKVLZUV[WHPU[HIL[[LYWPJ[\YL/\RPSH\33*[OLV[OLYL_PZ[PUNVJLHUZOMHYTOHZHSZVYLJLU[S`HWWSPLK[VTHRLJOHUNLZ;OLJVTWHU WSHUZ[VKYHZ[PJHSS`L_WHUKWYVK\J[PVU/V^L]LYVUS`HYLSH[P]LS`ZTHSSU\TILYVMQVIZ^PSSILJYLH[LK)L[^LLU[OL[^VMHYTZ[OLPUK\Z[Y`LTWSV LKH[V[HSVMWLVWSLPU(M[LYTVKPJH[PVUZ[VIV[OMHYTZHYLJVTWSL[LV]LYHSSWYVK\J

[PVU^PSSOH]LPUJYLHZLKWLYJLU[MYVTHIV\[[VTPSSPVUWV\UKZI\[LTWSV`TLU[^PSSOH]LKLJYLHZLKI`WLYJLU[

-\Y[OLYTVYL[OLX\HSP[`HUKZHML[`VM[OLQVIZWYV]PKLKI`2)>-OH]LILLUJOHSSLUNLK)L[^LLUHUKMV\YMVYTLYLTWSV`LLZSLKSH^Z\P[ZHNHPUZ[2)>-;OLYZ[Z\P[ZL[[SLKV\[VMJV\Y[HSSLNLK[OH[2)>-KPKUV[WYV]PKLHZHMLWSHJL[V^VYRYLZ\S[PUNPUPUQ\YPLZJH\ZPUNVUNVPUNWO`ZPJHSHUKLTV[PVUHSWHPUHUKOHYT;OLZLJVUKHSZVZL[[SLKV\[VMJV\Y[HSZVHSSLNLK[OH[2)>-MHPSLK[VWYV]PKLHZHMLWSHJL[V^VYRVYWYVWLYLX\PWTLU[YLZ\S[PUNPUHKPZHISPUNIHJRPUQ\Y ;OL[OPYKJHZL^P[O

ZPTPSHYHSSLNH[PVUZ^HZ]VS\U[HYPS`KPZTPZZLK

;OLUHSJHZLUV[`L[YLZVS]LKHSSLNLKHTVUNV[OLY[OPUNZ[OH[2)>-^PSSM\SS`PNUVYLKHUK]PVSH[LK[OLTHUKH[VY`WYV]PZPVUZHUKVISPNH[PVUZZL[MVY[OPUP[ZV^U+P]L4HU\HSHUK[OH[[OLJVTWHU OHZ]PVSH[LKZ[H[LHUKMLKLYHSSH ZYLZ\S[PUNPUPUQ\YPLZ[V[OL^VYRLY

*OPSL!KPZLHZLV\[IYLHRHUK\ULTWSV`LK

0U*OPSL^OLYLKPZLHZLV\[IYLHRZHUKJOLTPJHS\ZLPUVWLU^H[LYZHSTVUMHYTZOH]LILJVTLUV[VYPV\ZHU\UZ\Z[HPUHISLPUK\Z[Y`OHZLX\H[LK[V\UZ\Z[HPUHISLLTWSV`TLU[VWWVY[\UP[PLZ(Z0UMLJ[PV\Z:HSTVU(ULTPHZ^LW[[OLPUK\Z[Y`ZHSTVUWYVK\J[PVU^HZKL]HZ[H[LK([P[ZWLHR[OLPUK\Z[Y`JYLH[LKKPYLJ[HUKPUKPYLJ[QVIZ I\[I`\UPVUSLHKLYZLZ[PTH[LK[OH[VM[OLZLQVIZ^LYLSVZ[1VIJ\[ZILNHUHZ0:(ZWYLHKIL[^LLUVWLYH[PVUZ0U-LIY\HY`VM:HSTVU*OPSLZHPK[OH[TVYLTH`SVZLQVIZIL[^LLU4HYJOHUK1\ULILJH\ZL[OLYL^PSSUV[ILHU`OHY]LZ[LKZHSTVU[VWYVJLZZ

*VUJS\ZPVUHUK9LJVTTLUKH[PVUZ!:HSTVUMHYTPUNTH`OH]LILJVTLVULVM[OLIPNNLZ[WSH`LYZPU:JV[SHUKZLJVUVT`JVU[YPI\[PUN[VV]LYOHSMVM:JV[SHUKZ[V[HSMVVKL_WVY[ZI\[P[ZJVU[YPI\[PVUZ[VY\YHSLJVUVTPLZHUK:JV[[PZOJP[PaLUZPZK^PUKSPUNHUK[OLVMMZOVYLQVIZ[OLPUK\Z[Y`PZTV]PUN[V^HYKTH ILSLZZKLZPYHISL[OHU[OL]LY`QVIZ[OLPUK\Z[Y`PZLSPTPUH[PUNPU[OLYLJYLH[PVUHSHUNSPUNHUK[V\YPZTZLJ[VYZ4VYLV]LY[OL

PUK\Z[Y`PZKVTPUH[LKI`H5VY^LPNHUJVTWHU HUK[OLYLHYLUVN\HYHU[LLZHIV\[^OH[^PSSOHWWLU[VQVIZVYZWLJPJHX\HJ\S[\YLZP[LZPU[OLM\[\YL OLUV[OLYSVJH[PVUZ^P[OSV^LYJVZ[VWWVY[\UP[PLZHYPZL

*V\UJPSZWSHUUPUNH\[OVYP[PLZHUKWVSP[PJPHUZHYL\UKLYWYLZZ\YL[VWYV]PKLQVIVWWVY[\UP[PLZHUK[OPZPZHKPMJ\S[JOHSSLUNLI\[P[PZPTWVY[HU[[VSVVRIL`VUK[OLMHSZLWYVTPZLZTHKLI ZOMHYTPUNJVYWVYH[PVUZHUKPU[V[OLM\[\YL0UZ[LHKVMZHJYPJPUN:JV[SHUKZY\YHSJVTT\UP[PLZMVY[OPZT\S[PUH[PVUHSPUK\Z[Y WVSP[PJPHUZZOV\SKZ\WWVY[TVYLZ\Z[HPUHISLSVJHSS`JVU[YVSSLKI\ZPULZZLZ>OLUVWLU^H[LYZOMHYTZMHPS[VKLSP]LYVU[OLPYWYVTPZLZVM

SVJHSLJVUVTPJNHPUJVTT\UP[PLZLJVUVTPLZHUK[OLLU]PYVUTLU[^V\SKILIL[[LYZLY]LK[OYV\NOPU]LZ[TLU[PUQVIZ^P[OSVUNL]P[ Z\JOHZ[V\YPZTZ\Z[HPUHISLZOPUNSHUKIHZLKYLJPYJ\SH[PUNHX\HJ\S[\YLZ`Z[LTZZTHSSZJHSLZOLSSZOHX\HJ\S[\YLHUK]HS\LHKKLKWYVJLZZPUN

(^PKL]HYPL[`VMZOLSSZOPUJS\KPUNT\ZZLSZV Z[LYZHUKZJHSSVWZHYLHSYLHK J\S[P]H[LKPU:JV[[PZO H[LYZHUK[OPZWYVK\J[PVUPZJ\YYLU[S KVTPUH[LKI`ZTHSSZJHSLWYVK\JLYZ9LJPYJ\SH[PUNSHUKIHZLKHX\HJ\S[\YLZ`Z[LTZ9(:HYLHUV[OLYVW[PVU[OH[HYLUV[VUS`TVYLLU]PYVUTLU[HSS`YLZWVUZPISLI\[OH]LILLUZOV^UPU[OLL\YNLWVSPJ`THRLYZUV[[VSL[ZOMHYTPUNJVYWVYH[PVUZ[HRLHK]HU[HNLVMZ[Y\NNSPUNJVTT\UP[PLZHUK^LYLJVTTLUK[OH[[OL,\YVWLHU-PZOLYPLZ-\UKZ\WWVY[PU]LZ[TLU[PUI\ZPULZZLZHUKYLZV\YJLZ[OH[JHUI\PSKSVUN[LYTLJVUVTPJWYVZWLYP[`HUKKL]LSVWTLU[PU:JV[SHUKHUKIL`VUK

(KKP[PVUHS,_HTWSLZ)YP[PZO*VS\TIPH!0U[OLZMHYTLKZHSTVUWYVK\J[PVU[YPWSLKPU)YP[PZO*VS\TIPHI\[UV[HZPUNSLUL QVI^HZJYLH[LK(ZHX\HJ\S[\YLPU[OPZ*HUHKPHUWYV]PUJLPUJYLHZLK^PSKZOSHUKPUNZKLJYLHZLKHUKLTWSV`TLU[PUWYVJLZZPUNKYVWWLKVMMHZ^LSS

5VY^H`!)L[^LLUHUK5VY^H`ZZOMHYTPUN

PUK\Z[Y`L_WHUKLK[LUMVSKI\[LTWSV`TLU[KYVWWLKI`WLYJLU[

$IDFWRU\VKIDUPRIIWKHFRDVWRI+DZDLL3KRWRE\12$$

7/28/2019 EU Version: No Jobs Here: Why Industrial Fish Farming's Promise to Boost Local Economies Falls Flat

5/5

,UKUV[LZ

4HYPUL/HY]LZ[/PZ[VY -LIY\HY`(]HPSHISLH[!^^ THYPULOHY]LZ[JVTLU(IV\[4HYPUL/HY]LZ[/PZ[VY`

4VYLQVIZJV\SKILJYLH[LKPU:JV[SHUKZH Z7HU-PZOJOPLM-PZO\WKH[LJVT5V](]HPSHISLH[!^^^ZO\WKH[LJVTUL^ZM\SSZ[VY WOWHPK4VYLFQVIZFJV\SKFILFJYLH[LKFPUF:JV[SHUKFZH`ZF7HUF-PZOFJOPLMO[TS

4VYLQVIZJV\SKILJYLH[LKPU:JV[SHUKZH Z7HU-PZOJOPLM-PZO\WKH[LJVT5V](]HPSHISLH[!^^^ZO\WKH[LJVTUL^ZM\SSZ[VY WOWHPK4VYLFQVIZFJV\SKFILFJYLH[LKFPUF:JV[SHUKFZH`ZF7HUF-PZOFJOPLMO[TS

4HYPUL:JV[SHUK:JPLUJL:JV[[PZO-PZO-HYTZ!(UU\HS7YVK\J[PVU:\Y]L`;OL:JV[[PZO.V]LYUTLU[H[

:HSTVU-HYT7YV[LZ[.YV\W HYUZVMM\Y[OLYQVISVZZLZ-PZO-HYTLY1\UL

-PZOLYPLZ9LZLHYJO:LY]PJLZ0UMLJ[PV\Z:HSTVU(UHLTPH;OL:JV[[PZO.V]LYUTLU[(]HPSHISLH[!^^^THYSHIHJ\R

*SV]LY*OHYSLZ 7VSS\[PVUMYVTZOMHYTZHZIHKHZZL HNL;LSLNYHWO3VUKVU:LW

:HSTVU-HYT7YV[LZ[.YV\W HYUZVMM\Y[OLYQVISVZZLZ-PZO-HYTLY1\UL 4HYPUL:JV[SHUK:JPLUJL:JV[[PZO-PZO-HYTZ!(UU\HS7YVK\J[PVU

:\Y]L`;OL:JV[[PZO.V]LYUTLU[H[ 4HYPUL:JV[SHUK:JPLUJL:JV[[PZO-PZO-HYTZ!(UU\HS7YVK\J[PVU

:\Y]L`;OL:JV[[PZO.V]LYUTLU[H[ :HSTVU-HYT7YV[LZ[.YV\W^HYUZVMM\Y[OLYQVISVZZLZ-PZO-HYTLY

1\UL :HSTVU-HYT7YV[LZ[.YV\W^HYUZVMM\Y[OLYQVISVZZLZ-PZO-HYTLY

1\UL"7HU-PZOB7YLZZ9LSLHZLD 7HU-PZOHJX\PYLZ4HYPUL/HY]LZ[[VMVYT[OL VYSKZSHYNLZ[ZOMHYTPUNJVTWHU 4HYJO"4HYPUL/HY]LZ[/PZ[VY`

4HYPUL:JV[SHUK:JPLUJL:JV[[PZO-PZO-HYTZ!(UU\HS7YVK\J[PVU:\Y]L`;OL:JV[[PZO.V]LYUTLU[H[

([[HJRVUWYV[MYVTZHSLVMZOMHYTPUNJVTWHU 7YLZZHUK1V\YUHS;OL(ILYKLLUH[LY-HYTZ33*-PUHS:\WWSLTLU[HS,U]PYVUTLU[HS

(ZZLZZTLU[MVYH4VKPJH[PVU[V5L[7LU+LZPNUZ>P[OPU[OL,_PZ[PUN7YVK\J[PVU*HWHJP[`HUK-HYT3LHZL(YLHMVY2VUH)S\LZ6MMZOVYL6WLU6JLHU-PZO-HYTVMMH[LY-HYTZ33*-PUHS:\WWSLTLU[HS,U]PYVUTLU[HS(ZZLZZTLU[MVYH4VKPJH[PVU[V5L[7LU+LZPNUZ>P[OPU[OL,_PZ[PUN7YVK\J[PVU*HWHJP[`HUK-HYT3LHZL(YLHMVY2VUH)S\LZ6MMZOVYL6WLU6JLHU-PZO-HYTVMMH[LY-HYTZ33*-PUHS:\WWSLTLU[HS,U]PYVUTLU[HS(ZZLZZTLU[MVYH4VKPJH[PVU[V5L[7LU+LZPNUZ>P[OPU[OL,_PZ[PUN7YVK\J[PVU*HWHJP[`HUK-HYT3LHZL(YLHMVY2VUH)S\LZ6MMZOVYL6WLU6JLHU-PZO-HYTVMMH[LY>H[JO*VTIPULK[V[HSWYVK\J[PVUHUKQVIZWYVQLJ[LKI JVTWHUPLZPU[OLPY-PUHS,U]PYVUTLU[HS(ZZLZZTLU[ZHM[LYHWWYV]LKTVKPJH[PVUZMYVT-PUHS,U]PYVUTLU[HS(ZZLZZTLU[7YVWVZLK,_WHUZPVUVM/\RPSH\-VVKZ6MMZOVYL-PZO-HYT4HTHSH)H 6HO\/H^HPGP7YLWHYLKMVY6MJLVM*VUZLY]H[PVUHUK*VHZ[HS3HUKZ/H HPGP+LWHY[TLU[VM3HUKHUK5H[\YHS9LZV\YJLZI`(X\HJ\S[\YL7SHUUPUN(K]VJHJ`33*1\S`HUK-PUHS:\WWSLTLU[HS,U]PYVUTLU[HS(ZZLZZTLU[MVYH4VKPJH[PVU[V5L[7LU+LZPNUZ^P[OPU[OL,_PZ[PUN*HWHJP[`HUK-HYT3LHZL(YLHMVY2VUH)S\LZ6MMZOVYL6WLU6JLHU-PZO-HYTVMMH[LY-HYTZ2HPS\H2VUH/0(WYPS

2HYSZZVU]2VUH)S\L>H[LY-HYTZH[LY-HYTZ33*H[LY-HYTZ33*H[LY-HYTZ33*HNULY]2VUH)S\L>H[LY-HYTZ33*