Ethical Organizational Management
-
Upload
bashir-jaman -
Category
Documents
-
view
143 -
download
0
description
Transcript of Ethical Organizational Management
Prepared by
Bashir Jaman
Word Count: 3,004
Ethical Organisational Management
Ethical Organizational Management
Table of Contents
Introduction................................................................................................................................4
TASK 1: Motives to Install New Technology...........................................................................4
Right Thing at Right Time.....................................................................................................4
Definition of Profession.........................................................................................................4
Unity of Command.................................................................................................................5
Commitment from Board of Directors...................................................................................5
Modification Concept.............................................................................................................5
Universality............................................................................................................................5
Communication......................................................................................................................5
Recommendation....................................................................................................................6
Awareness...............................................................................................................................6
Culture....................................................................................................................................6
Religion..................................................................................................................................7
Beliefs.....................................................................................................................................7
Societal Norms.......................................................................................................................7
Image......................................................................................................................................7
Diversity.................................................................................................................................8
Motives to Delay New Installation.........................................................................................8
Abiding by the Law................................................................................................................9
Financial Situation..................................................................................................................9
Imposition of New Regulations..............................................................................................9
Need to Update Regulations...................................................................................................9
Mission Statement................................................................................................................10
Board of Directors................................................................................................................10
Managers..............................................................................................................................10
Bashir Jaman Page 2
Ethical Organizational Management
Stakeholders.........................................................................................................................10
Ethics of Accounting............................................................................................................10
Ethics of Marketing..............................................................................................................11
Ethics of Human Resource Management.............................................................................11
Ethics of Production.............................................................................................................11
Impact of Updated Regulation on the Region......................................................................11
Accounting Legislations.......................................................................................................12
Diversity Related Legislations.............................................................................................12
Production.............................................................................................................................12
Social Responsiveness..........................................................................................................12
TASK 2: Explanation to the Given Scenarios..........................................................................13
Receiving a Holiday Gift:...................................................................................................13
Sales Expense:.....................................................................................................................13
Conflict of Interest:............................................................................................................13
More Competition:.............................................................................................................14
TASK 3: Critical Evaluation of Ethical and CSR Practices..............................................15
Organisational Approach......................................................................................................15
Values, Beliefs and Ethical Decision Making......................................................................15
Community Orientation........................................................................................................16
Organisational Practices.......................................................................................................16
Value Statement....................................................................................................................16
Corporate Social Responsibility...........................................................................................16
Employment.........................................................................................................................17
Cultural Products and Services.............................................................................................17
Local Adaptation..................................................................................................................17
Conclusion:.............................................................................................................................18
References................................................................................................................................19
Bashir Jaman Page 3
Ethical Organizational Management
Introduction
Code of conduct is a certain framework that states the way to accomplish a task and such a
framework is commonly called ethical standards or ethical standards in the business
language. Like dress code is a part of code of conduct which is to be followed by the
professionals in an organisation. For instance, doctors have to wear white overcoat at work,
lawyers have to wear black collar coat as part of their outfit. Similarly code of ethics exists
for the behaviour, manners and attitudes of employees (Anand, 2002). This piece of work
will provide reader with different angles related to the topic in the light of case study that has
been provided in order answer a certain set of questions in thorough detail.
TASK 1: Motives to Install New Technology
Jonica Gunson has to maintain certain code of ethics in the company in order to enable the
employees to work in orderly manner. The code of ethics made by an organisation is based
upon certain principles of ethics. Those principles and norms are important for the decision
and policy makers of the organisation to create such a universal code of ethics which is
acceptable to each member of the organisation. Due to following reason the company is
motivated to install new technologies:
Right Thing at Right Time
The concept is about providing convenience to the people and decision makers to have right
decision at the right time so that the organisational objectives may be achieved (Moon et al.,
2001).
Bashir Jaman Page 4
Ethical Organizational Management
Definition of Profession
The code of ethics clearly states about the nature of the business and it should help to attain
the physical, financial and other resources of the business by giving a returned value to the
society (Biggs et al., 2004).
Unity of Command
In the situation of overlapping interests and workload, the ethical standard demand to follow
the command of law (Anand, 2002).
Commitment from Board of Directors
The ethical standards are made such that they conform, the commitment with board of
directors as the board finally approves or disregards the code of ethics (Mallor et al,. 2007).
Modification Concept
Jonica Gunson keeps flexible code of conduct so the terms can be modified as per the need of
the time and situation and in the given case study the firm needs to raise its ethical standard to
retain its goodwill.
Universality
The code of conduct is made with intention to address environmental and other factors so that
the code may not seem culturally or socially partial (Moon et al. 2001). Thus the company
needs to follow the universal standard for safety and should decide to go for new installation
(Bansal & Kandola, 2003).
Bashir Jaman Page 5
Ethical Organizational Management
Communication
The code of conduct about the communication in the company for which Jonica Gunson
performs as an environmental compliance manager is stated so miscommunications on any
level shall be avoided. Once the need for the new installation has been triggered and
communicated to the company, then it must be put in action (Murphy, 2011).
Recommendation
The ethical standards of the case study company also mention the norms to recommend the
actions for specific tasks or rewards or to tackle the recurring event.
Awareness
Anand (2002) states that in order to creating awareness about the ethical practices within the
organisation is a must, as it is important concept in the organisational ethics and the
developed code of ethics is circulated and made known to all members of a company. Similar
is the case with the company for which Jonica Gunson works as it in turn has created the
pressure to abide by the environmental safety standards.
There are numerous factors despite the principles of organisational ethics which keep a deep
influence upon the ethics of the organisation. The reason of existence of influencing factors is
the strength of individuals keeping different beliefs and mindsets and the traditions that
collectively form a prominent difference from other strata. Following factors could be most
influencing in the context of organisational ethics that are the key motives for the company to
consider new technology adaptation with gravity:
Culture
The culture of the origin of the company where Jonica Gunson works could be different from
the culture in which the organisation currently operates and hence the organisation needs to
Bashir Jaman Page 6
Ethical Organizational Management
adopt the altered code of ethics to meet the feelings of local workforce and the customers. If
the demand to install new technology is raised in the current culture which might be
apprehended as sensitive and cautious to the environment, then the company has to follow it
despite other factors (Fombrum, 2005).
Religion
Religion is another highly influencing factor for the organisational ethics because people
within the organisation and the community hold certain associations with the religion. Thus
Jonica Gunson may not keep such code of ethics that are tilted to one religion. The company,
if belongs to people of another religious group, then the issue of safety can be raised on
partial basis and resultantly the company can come under controversy (Bansal & Kandola,
2003).
Beliefs
Common beliefs of the people may influence Jonica Gunson to alter the ethical standards if
any practice found against certain beliefs. The company has to ensure the society that all
measures will be taken to control the loss of the environment (Biggs et al 2004).
Societal Norms
The norm of the society in which the company operates seems to be influencing Jonica
Gunson to mould the company codes and practices. The company has to reconcile with the
needs of the society and it should compensate the community by altering its ways of
manufacturing.
Bashir Jaman Page 7
Ethical Organizational Management
Image
The positive image of Jonica Gunson also influences the organisation to retain its image by
practicing universally accepted ethical practices.
Diversity
Diverse environment and workforce can influence Jonica Gunson to develop the ethical
norms, eradicating biasness and discrimination and thus she must ensure that the company
respects the opinions of diverse people to install advanced technology to reduce the wastage
poured to the lake (Fombrum, 2005).
Motives to Delay New Installation
Business ethics exists at three different levels which are individual level, corporate level and
macro level. At corporation level, the code of ethic, rules and standards are collectively called
business ethics and they are affected by certain situations and socio-cultural context where
public or private sector organisation operates. Theories suggest that ethics and personal
morality directly influence the corporations while the gap still remains in the practice of
individuals inside the organisation and outside. It can be argued that it is a significant factor
that creates distrust of giant businesses where separate entity concept of the organisation is
open to abuse. If the executives and top management act ethically, yet their act would be
different they were taking decisions on the business and money of their own (Borgerson &
Schroeder, 2008).
Bashir Jaman Page 8
Ethical Organizational Management
Jonica Gunson has got few genuine and valid reasons to delay the installation of the new
machinery and technology. The reasons are based on the prior continuity of the company in
the same scenario. Such motives of the company are discussed as follows:
Abiding by the Law
The company has been, though pouring the waste to the lake but the level of the waste is in
accordance with the provision of the law and hence if the public sentiment or the competitors
raise their voice, yet the company has the reason to defend in the context of law.
Financial Situation
The company has been going through hard financial situations and the company has a
nominal budget of environment and social responsibility. Thus the company cannot afford to
have the expensive technological installation.
Imposition of New Regulations
Ethics and the law are closely related to each other as the law enforces the organisations to
develop certain code of ethics. Like 406 section of Sarbanes Oxley Act requires the public
limited companies to disclose that they have a code of ethics and it also reveals the utility of
provided rules. The provision does not ask the companies to keep any code of ethics but it
demands the organisations to disclose whether their code of ethics covers the positions of
controllers, accountants and financial managers (Sarbanes Oxley Act, 2002).
Bashir Jaman Page 9
Ethical Organizational Management
Need to Update Regulations
Different organisations keep a different set of standards for their people and the difference
may occur due to perceptions, values or cultures. However, according to Friedman (1984),
the crux of all ethical codes is to show compliance by the law. The region where the case
study company operates should have an updated version of imposed regulations because the
current regulations seem misfit and outdated and the companies should be obliged to practice
under new regulations especially in the context of ethics and social responsibility for the
following reasons:
Mission Statement
The mission statement of the organisation does not reveal anything about ethics which
reveals lack of gravity of the organisation towards ethics (Murphy 2011).
Board of Directors
The clarity about the ethical role of board of directors of the organisation does not exist and
hence the organisation should have a comprehensive code of ethics (Asaecenter 2011).
Managers
According to the law of Principle – Agent relationship, the managers should be provided the
ethical norms with comprehensive guideline to act in favour of the owners and comply by the
law (Bansal & Kandola, 2003).
Bashir Jaman Page 10
Ethical Organizational Management
Stakeholders
The stakeholders must also be provided code of ethics to remain compliant to the law and to
act in favour of other stakeholders (Asaecenter 2011).
Ethics of Accounting
The code of ethics obliges the employees to follow the ethics of accounting by avoiding
accounting fraud, bribery and by giving just compensation so the companies may not find
excuse to continue practicing anything hazardous for environment (Sarbanes-Oxley Act,
2002).
Ethics of Marketing
The code of ethics should also be clear about the practices in promotion, sales and
advertisements of the organisation and not to use any unfair means or misstatements (Mallor
et al. 2007).
Ethics of Human Resource Management
The most important part of the code of ethics is provided for the HR department to eradicate
any kind of discrimination or sexual harassment and to ensure the provision of safe and
healthy working environment (Asaecenter 2011).
Bashir Jaman Page 11
Ethical Organizational Management
Ethics of Production
The code of ethics also states that the production functions of the organisation must not
distort environment and the products should be assured to be of quality by pretesting (Biggs
et al. 2004).
Impact of Updated Regulation on the Region
The aforementioned evaluation of the code of ethics clearly reveals that the accounting, HR,
marketing and production personnel of the region needs to be provided with the code of
conduct and ethical standards which makes them logically and morally bound to obey the
code of practices and also makes them accountable for not following or breaching the code.
Most researches show that practicing ethics in the organisation has a positive relation with the
accountability of the key players of the organisation (Bansal & Kandola, 2003).
Accounting Legislations
International Accounting Standards (IAS), Sarbanes Oxley Act and other provisions for the
accounting and financial standards have made the accountants and financial managers legally
liable to abide by the principles of law and this can reduced the financial scams in the
corporations.
Diversity Related Legislations
Legal provisions about diversity like Race Act, Sexual Harassment Act, etc ensure the
organisations to develop the code of conduct in view of those laws and this can also make the
members of the organisation accountable to show respect for the diversity (Mallor et al,
2007).
Bashir Jaman Page 12
Ethical Organizational Management
Production
Certain regulations about the safety of the workers and the environment ensure that the
production norms of the organisation must not be compromised and hence the production
department also becomes accountable due to the legislation (Anand, 2002).
Social Responsiveness
Organisations will be bound to show their concerns for the society by activating initiatives of
social responsibility and the organisation as a whole is responsible and accountable to
contribute to the environment and the society in which it operates (Biggs et al 2004).
Bashir Jaman Page 13
Ethical Organizational Management
TASK 2: Explanation to the Given Scenarios
Receiving a Holiday Gift:
It primarily depends upon the nature of relationship; if relation is purely professional and the
supplier wants to liaison for better understanding then the gift should be accepted with
appreciation. However if the supplier wants to get out of bound benefits, then the thing must
be discouraged/rejected.
Sales Expense:
There is no harm in accepting such an offer because the social responsibility department of
the company has to contribute to charity, no matter if the organisation is of other’s choice
because this would fulfil the aim of CSR and would get another benefit in shape of a large
order. But management should try to find out any controversy in that charity organizations
accountability. Also, management should be convinced with the cause of the charity
organization. Donating on charity just for financial gain should not be encouraged in
organization. If the motives of the stakeholders is to encourage people in charity, then it
should be taken positively.
References:
As per code of ethics, no confidential information will be shared but the client will be
diplomatically dealt and will be told what the entire market already knows about the
competitor (Borgerson & Schroeder 2008).
Conflict of Interest:
The new business owner will be contacted and asked for the quality and range of items and
then will be decided if the new business owner provides extra benefits. She can further act as
Bashir Jaman Page 14
Ethical Organizational Management
useful contact for the company for future orders.
More Competition:
It seems attractive offer at an instance but the consequences can be dangerous and can bring
in escalated conflict if the competitor comes to know about the leakage of confidential
information and files a lawsuit against the individual or the company. The offer will be
denied but the personnel will be asked to share learning experience and suggestions to bring
improvement in the performance of the company.
Bashir Jaman Page 15
Ethical Organizational Management
TASK 3: Critical Evaluation of Ethical and CSR Practices
Corporate social responsibility and ethics are important in the decision making process of an
organisation and their contribution cannot be denied in the progress and development of the
nation. Reaping profit is not the only aim of the business but the organisation also needs to
perform the social actions. Corporate social responsibility and the business ethics are two
separate concepts but their overlapping and inter-dependence is a proven fact. Thus many
organisations in present era have adopted the integration approach to business ethics and
corporate social responsibility (Mallor et al. 2007). The company (Wolse Inc.) has following
ethical and corporate social responsibility practices with critical analysis:
Organisational Approach
Organisations keep the following approach in relation with ethics and CSR:
Values, Beliefs and Ethical Decision Making
Organisations show their commitment to the community and value the responsibility to
contribute to its customers and employees. Senior managers and executives are the decision
makers for an organisation and their decisions are based upon the values and beliefs in
context of social responsibility and business ethics. Like, they make all decisions keeping in
view the interests of all stakeholders and shareholders of the company. Similarly they decide
to develop code of ethics and policies based on the common beliefs and values of the
organisation and the society (Anand 2002).
Usually, the company attempts to form diverse groups in the organisation, hence the
decisions of the groups are restrained from biasness or discrimination and they form a
balance view in decision making process. Their ethical responsibility is to safeguard the
interests of shareholders and to be loyal to the community and the organisation. Similarly
Bashir Jaman Page 16
Ethical Organizational Management
individuals base their decisions in conformity to ethics, beliefs, values and society and show
urge to deliver their roles and responsibilities efficiently (Fombrum 2005).
Community Orientation
The multinational organisation pays special attention to the matter of cultural and societal
differences with the operating environment and within the organisation. That’s why it hires
local people and adopts local slogans, tag lines and services to mix up with the prevailing
culture and to reduce the effect of the difference of values and beliefs. The top management,
executives and the individuals go through a devised procedure to approach a decision and the
procedure ensures minimised conflict with the cultural values. The effects of values and
beliefs strategy is positive on the performance of the organisation because it tends to reduce
the conflict with internal and external environment by giving respect to the values and beliefs
of the individuals and the community and allows the organisation to mould its values
accordingly if found in contradiction to the cultural or societal norms (Moon et al. 2001).
Organisational Practices
The organisational practices pertaining to CSR and business ethics are:
Value Statement
The organisation has developed a value statement stating the respect and consideration for the
employees and community (Borgerson & Schroeder. 2008).
Corporate Social Responsibility
The organisation does not actively participate in the social responsiveness programs like
charity, promoting local traditions, etc which can develop an air of respect for the society and
their basic standards and values (Mallor et al. 2007).
Bashir Jaman Page 17
Ethical Organizational Management
Employment
Provision of equal opportunity is not highlighted which can intake the people of any
demographic or society on merit and can generate feeling ownership for the organisation
(Fombrum 2005).
Cultural Products and Services
The organisation has developed the products and services that are fit in the cultural context of
the society and it advertises and promotes accordingly by using local slogans and slangs
(Borgerson & Schroeder 2008).
Local Adaptation
The organisation attempts to adapt the local environment and it endeavours to alter its
policies, procedures or the products and affiliations if they are in contradiction to the
common beliefs and values (Moon et al. 2001).
Bashir Jaman Page 18
Ethical Organizational Management
Conclusion:
On a concluding note it would not be wrong to say that it is very imperative for an
organization to stick to the basics especially when it comes to complying the rules and
regulations of the state in which it is operating. Public are becoming more and more aware
regarding the importance of environmental safety and security and to show the customers and
make the potential this factor can be used as key trigger by making the customers and or
service renderers to realize that the organization is serious about the environment safety and
strictly complies with the set regulations.
Bashir Jaman Page 19
Ethical Organizational Management
References
Anand, V. (2002) Building Blocks of Corporate reputation- Social Responsibility Imitative,
Corporate Reputation Review, vol.5, No.1 (spring), pp.71-74.
Bansal, P & Kandola, S. (2003). Corporate Social responsibility, Why Good People Behave
Badly in organisations, Ivey Business Journal (March/April)
Borgerson, J. L. and J. E. Schroeder (2008) Building an Ethics of Visual Representation:
Contesting Epistemic Closure in Marketing Communication in Cutting Edge Issues in
Business Ethics. M. P. Morland and P. Werhane Boston, Springer pp. 87–108 ISBN 1-4020-
8400-5
Biggs, Tom & Halina, W. (2004) Linking Social Responsibility, Good Governance and
Corporate Accountability through Dialogue Discussion Paper of International Institute for
Environment and Development, www.iied.org
Building Corporate Reputation through CSR Initiatives: Evolving Standards, Corporate
Reputation Review, vol.8, No.1 (spring) pp.7-12.
Fombrum, C. J. (2005). A World of Reputation Research Analysis and Thinking
Friedman, M. (1984) Milton Friedman responds—an interview with Friedman. Business and
Society 84(5)
Bashir Jaman Page 20
Ethical Organizational Management
Mallor, J. P., Barnes, A. J., Bowers, T., & Langvardt, A. W. (2007) Business law: The
ethical, global, and e-commerce environment (14th edition). New York: McGraw-Hill.
Moon, C Et al. (2001) Business Ethics London: The Economist: 119–132
Murphy, J. (2011). The Concepts of Vision & Mission Revisited. Retrieved from:
http://www.calumcoburn.co.uk/articles/articles-vision-mission
Bashir Jaman Page 21