Eruptive potential of volcanoes in Marie Byrd Landvolcanoes can be used to refine the information...

3
enhanced image reveals the temperature of the surface and the brightness temperature of the crater area. The trace indicates that the brightness temperature is approximately 60°K above the background at the summit, which woud include the lava lake. Since this is a subresolution feature, cooler surfaces within the same picture element, or pixel, are also contributing to the pixel radiant temperature. The resulting pixel temperature is thus less than the true brightness temperature of the crater area. rhe installation of the high resolution picture transmission (HRPT) system at McMurdo Station makes it possible to monitor the thermal regime at Antarctica, including anomalous thermal areas such as Mount Erebus, in a way that was previously impossible. Its near-polar location allows many additional pass- es per day, greatly increasing the probability of receiving cloud- free imagery. We extend special thanks to Jann Knapp for her cartographic assistance, to Mike Matson for his help with the temperature plot, and to John Pritchard for the enhanced imagery. This work was funded by National Science Foundation grant DPP 77-27010. References Dozier, J. 1981. A method for satellite identification of surface tempera- ture fields of sub-pixel resolution. Remote Sensing of Environment, 11, 221-229. Hussey, W. J. 1979. The TIROS-N/NOAA operational satellite system. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Commerce/National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, National Earth Satellite Service. Kyle, P. R. 1979. Volcanic activity at Mount Erebus, 1978-79. Antarctic Journal of the U.S., 14(5), 35-36. Kyle, P. R., Dibble, R., Giggenbach, W., and Keys, J . 1982. Volcanic activity associated with the anorthoclase phonolite lava lake, Mount Erebus, Antarctica. In C. Craddock (Ed.), Antarctic geoscience. Madi- son: University of Wisconsin Press. Matson, M., and Dozier, J. 1981. Identification of subresolution high temperature sources using a thermal IR sensor. Photogrammetric Engi- neering and Remote Sensing, 47(9), 1311-1318. Eruptive potential of volcanoes in Marie Byrd Land WESLEY E. LEMASURIER Geology Department University of Colorado-Denver Denver, Colorado 80202 D. C. REX Department of Earth Sciences University of Leeds United Kingdom Those who study young volcanoes frequently are asked about the eruptive potential of these volcanoes, even when they are located in a region as remote as Marie Byrd Land. In Marie Byrd Land, human hazard is not a concern, but the possibility of climatic impact interests scientists beyond the immediate com- munity of antarctic geologists. Volcanologists commonly try to predict the future behavior of a volcano on the basis of its history, which in temperate regions often can be determined from historical records and carbon-14 dating of organic remains buried by volcanic deposits (see, for example, Crandall, Mullineaux, and Rubin 1975). In Marie Byrd Land, however, there is no history of human observation and no organic mate- rial for carbon-14 dating. Moreover, the rate of erosion of lava is so slow that even 10-million-year-old volcanoes are deceptively fresh in appearance. The methods available for inferring the eruptive potential of volcanoes in Marie Byrd Land are studying the emission of volcanic gasses, determining the potassium-argon (K-Ar) age of volcanic deposits, and examining ash layers in ice cores. Emis- sion of steam from volcanic vents has been observed in Marie Byrd Land (figure and table), and the intermittent emission of steam can be inferred where fumarolic ice towers (produced by condensation and freezing of water vapor) occur around a crater rim (LeMasurier and Wade 1968). The K-Ar method of dating is not nearly as useful as the carbon-14 method for determining the very recent behavior of a volcano, because the precision of the K-Ar method decreases rapidly in materials younger than 500,000 years, whereas the carbon-14 method is most precise when used on materials only a few thousand years old or younger. Thus, in the table, the materials in the columns labeled "Less than 200,000 years" were essentially too young to be dated by the K-Ar method. It is certainly possible to date some materials that are younger than 200,000 years by K-Ar, under favorable circumstances (Dalrym- ple and Lanphere 1969), but the materials from Marie Byrd Land could not be accurately dated if they were younger than 200,000 years old. On the other hand, the record provided by ash layers in the ice cores at Byrd Station and Dome C makes it clear that some volcano or volcanoes have been active in Marie Byrd Land within the past 75,000 years. Cow and Williamson (1971) record- ed 25 bands of ash in the Byrd Station core, with an especially large number of bands in the interval estimated to be 16,000 to 30,000 years old. Prevailing wind directions and the coarseness of the ash virtually require a source among the Marie Byrd Land volcanoes (Cow and Williamson 1971), and the petrographic characteristics of the ash support this inference (LeMasurier 1972). Similarly, Kyle and others (1981) analyzed ash estimated to be 25,000 years old from the Dome C core and inferred its source to be Mount Takahe. The new K-Ar data that provide the basis for this paper do not invalidate any of the earlier con- clusions; they simply provide a basis for a wider range of spec- ulation about which volcanoes have erupted in the recent past and which ones are likely to erupt in the future. 34 ANTARCTIC JOURNAL

Transcript of Eruptive potential of volcanoes in Marie Byrd Landvolcanoes can be used to refine the information...

Page 1: Eruptive potential of volcanoes in Marie Byrd Landvolcanoes can be used to refine the information available from K-Ar dating. Hawaiian volcanoes are known to have evolved through an

enhanced image reveals the temperature of the surface and thebrightness temperature of the crater area. The trace indicatesthat the brightness temperature is approximately 60°K abovethe background at the summit, which woud include the lavalake. Since this is a subresolution feature, cooler surfaces withinthe same picture element, or pixel, are also contributing to thepixel radiant temperature. The resulting pixel temperature isthus less than the true brightness temperature of the crater area.

rhe installation of the high resolution picture transmission(HRPT) system at McMurdo Station makes it possible to monitorthe thermal regime at Antarctica, including anomalous thermalareas such as Mount Erebus, in a way that was previouslyimpossible. Its near-polar location allows many additional pass-es per day, greatly increasing the probability of receiving cloud-free imagery.

We extend special thanks to Jann Knapp for her cartographicassistance, to Mike Matson for his help with the temperatureplot, and to John Pritchard for the enhanced imagery.

This work was funded by National Science Foundation grantDPP 77-27010.

References

Dozier, J. 1981. A method for satellite identification of surface tempera-ture fields of sub-pixel resolution. Remote Sensing of Environment, 11,221-229.

Hussey, W. J. 1979. The TIROS-N/NOAA operational satellite system.Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Commerce/National Oceanicand Atmospheric Administration, National Earth Satellite Service.

Kyle, P. R. 1979. Volcanic activity at Mount Erebus, 1978-79. AntarcticJournal of the U.S., 14(5), 35-36.

Kyle, P. R., Dibble, R., Giggenbach, W., and Keys, J . 1982. Volcanicactivity associated with the anorthoclase phonolite lava lake, MountErebus, Antarctica. In C. Craddock (Ed.), Antarctic geoscience. Madi-son: University of Wisconsin Press.

Matson, M., and Dozier, J. 1981. Identification of subresolution hightemperature sources using a thermal IR sensor. Photogrammetric Engi-neering and Remote Sensing, 47(9), 1311-1318.

Eruptive potential of volcanoes inMarie Byrd Land

WESLEY E. LEMASURIER

Geology DepartmentUniversity of Colorado-Denver

Denver, Colorado 80202

D. C. REX

Department of Earth SciencesUniversity of Leeds

United Kingdom

Those who study young volcanoes frequently are askedabout the eruptive potential of these volcanoes, even when theyare located in a region as remote as Marie Byrd Land. In MarieByrd Land, human hazard is not a concern, but the possibility ofclimatic impact interests scientists beyond the immediate com-munity of antarctic geologists. Volcanologists commonly try topredict the future behavior of a volcano on the basis of itshistory, which in temperate regions often can be determinedfrom historical records and carbon-14 dating of organic remainsburied by volcanic deposits (see, for example, Crandall,Mullineaux, and Rubin 1975). In Marie Byrd Land, however,there is no history of human observation and no organic mate-rial for carbon-14 dating. Moreover, the rate of erosion of lava isso slow that even 10-million-year-old volcanoes are deceptivelyfresh in appearance.

The methods available for inferring the eruptive potential ofvolcanoes in Marie Byrd Land are studying the emission ofvolcanic gasses, determining the potassium-argon (K-Ar) age of

volcanic deposits, and examining ash layers in ice cores. Emis-sion of steam from volcanic vents has been observed in MarieByrd Land (figure and table), and the intermittent emission ofsteam can be inferred where fumarolic ice towers (produced bycondensation and freezing of water vapor) occur around a craterrim (LeMasurier and Wade 1968).

The K-Ar method of dating is not nearly as useful as thecarbon-14 method for determining the very recent behavior of avolcano, because the precision of the K-Ar method decreasesrapidly in materials younger than 500,000 years, whereas thecarbon-14 method is most precise when used on materials only afew thousand years old or younger. Thus, in the table, thematerials in the columns labeled "Less than 200,000 years" wereessentially too young to be dated by the K-Ar method. It iscertainly possible to date some materials that are younger than200,000 years by K-Ar, under favorable circumstances (Dalrym-ple and Lanphere 1969), but the materials from Marie Byrd Landcould not be accurately dated if they were younger than 200,000years old.

On the other hand, the record provided by ash layers in theice cores at Byrd Station and Dome C makes it clear that somevolcano or volcanoes have been active in Marie Byrd Landwithin the past 75,000 years. Cow and Williamson (1971) record-ed 25 bands of ash in the Byrd Station core, with an especiallylarge number of bands in the interval estimated to be 16,000 to30,000 years old. Prevailing wind directions and the coarsenessof the ash virtually require a source among the Marie Byrd Landvolcanoes (Cow and Williamson 1971), and the petrographiccharacteristics of the ash support this inference (LeMasurier1972). Similarly, Kyle and others (1981) analyzed ash estimatedto be 25,000 years old from the Dome C core and inferred itssource to be Mount Takahe. The new K-Ar data that provide thebasis for this paper do not invalidate any of the earlier con-clusions; they simply provide a basis for a wider range of spec-ulation about which volcanoes have erupted in the recent pastand which ones are likely to erupt in the future.

34 ANTARCTIC JOURNAL

Page 2: Eruptive potential of volcanoes in Marie Byrd Landvolcanoes can be used to refine the information available from K-Ar dating. Hawaiian volcanoes are known to have evolved through an

Some characteristics of the evolutionary history of individualvolcanoes can be used to refine the information available fromK-Ar dating. Hawaiian volcanoes are known to have evolvedthrough an initial, relatively rapid, shield-building phase, fol-lowed by the development of a summit caldera and, in turn, bythe eruption of small cinder cones after the caldera formed(MacDonald 1972). A similar history seems to have charac-terized the development of volcanoes in Marie Byrd Land,though the time scale apparently is very much longer therethan for Hawaiian volcanoes. Recent K-Ar data (LeMasurier andRex in preparation) suggest that Marie Byrd Land volcanoes gothrough an initial trachytic, shield-building phase that may lastroughly 0.5-2.5 million years. This is followed by caldera forma-tion and then by a period of very infrequent basaltic cinder coneactivity that may last as long as 10 million years. Thus, if the pre-caldera lavas in these volcanoes are very young, the chances fora major eruption would seem to be relatively high, particularlyif the volcano displays fumarolic activity like that at MountBerlin. On the other hand, very recent cinder cone activity, likethat at Mount Andrus, is not especially suggestive of a highpotential for future activity, because cinder cone activity repre-sents the waning stage and possibly the termination of activityat a particular volcano. The pre-caldera lavas at Mount Andrus,for example, are more than 10 million years old. Mount Burseyhas a similar history.

The table summarizes the available information on relativelyrecent manifestations of volcanic activity in Marie Byrd Land. Inour estimation, the volcanoes that have very young pre-calderarocks have the highest potential for future eruptive behavior.Hence, the farther to the right a volcano is listed on the table,the greater its potential for future activity is presumed to be. Itshould be noted that even a major eruption here is not likely tohave much climatic impact. Very little subaerial ash has beenproduced by eruptions of these volcanoes in the past, and thepossibility of large volumes of ash being injected into the strat-osphere during future eruptions seems very slight (LeMasurier1972).

About 18 major volcanoes in Marie Byrd Land have formedwithin the past 10 million years. Small-scale cinder cone activity

-

Actively steaming fumarolic ice tower situated on the west rim ofBerlin Crater, Mount Berlin, December 1977.

is possible on any of these, if the eruptive histories of MountAndrus and Mount Bursey are reasonably representative, butthe next cinder cone eruption might take place on a volcano thathas been dormant for 2 to 5 million years. Therefore, it probably

Indications of potential activity in the volcanoes of Marie Byrd Land

Method Observation

Direct Fumarolic ice towers Actively steaming vents

observationMt. Berlin (135 050'W 76003'S). Observed in 1967 (LeMasurier and Mt. Berlin. On 22 Nov. 1977, 6 witnesses observed 4-6 vents.

Wade 1968) and again in 1977. Visited a second time within the following 2 weeks and observed 2steaming vents.

Mt. Hampton (1 25050'W 76050'S). Observed in 1967 (LeMasurier Mt. Kauffman (1 32 030'W 75035'S). On 11 Dec. 1977, 6 witnesses

and Wade 1968), but has not been revisited since, observed 3-4 steaming vents on the north flank of the volcano.

K-Ar dating Cinder cones<1 million yrs. <200,000 yrs.

Huff Peak, Mt. BurseyMt. Andrus (1 32020'W(132°40'W 76°0O'S) 7550'S)

Mt. Obiglio, Grant IslandMt. Waesche (1 27000'W(1 31 50'W 7428'S) 77°1 OS)

Pre-caldera rocks<1 million yrs. <200,000 yrs.

Shepard Island (1 32040'WMt. Takahe (11 2000'W7425'S) 76'15'S)

Mt. Murphy (111 000'WMt. Berlin75°20'S)Toney Mountain (1 16'00'W75°50'S)Mt. Waesche

351982 REVIEW

Page 3: Eruptive potential of volcanoes in Marie Byrd Landvolcanoes can be used to refine the information available from K-Ar dating. Hawaiian volcanoes are known to have evolved through an

is not unreasonable to represent the volcanoes that have pre-caldera lavas less than 1 million years old as active," and theremaining ones that are less than 10 million years old as dor-mant. A more conservative representation might show onlyMount Berlin as active, because of multiple evidences of recentactivity, and the remaining Plio-Pleistocene volcanoes as dor-mant. The only visit to the summit of Mount Takahe, wherefumarolic activity is most likely to be found, was described byAnderson (1960). No fumarolic activity was reported by Ander-son's party, nor by a reconnaissance survey of the lower flanksof the mountain in 1968. To our knowledge, the summit calderasof Mount Waesche, Toney Mountain, and Mount Murphy havenever been searched for evidence of fumarolic activity.

This research has been supported by National Science Foun-dation grants DPP 76-04396 and DPP 77-27546.

References

Anderson, V. H. 1960. The petrography of some rocks from Marie ByrdLand, Antarctica. USNC-IGY Antarctic Glaciological Data Report No.

2, Field Work 1958-59, Part 7, 1-27. Columbus: Ohio State UniversityResearch Foundation.

Crandell, D. R., Mullineaux, D. R., and Rubin, M. 1975. Mount St.Helens volcano: Recent and future behavior. Science, 187, 438-441.

Dalrymple, C. C., and Lanphere, M. A. 1969. Potassium-argon dating.San Francisco: W. H. Freeman.

Cow, A. J., and Williamson, T. 1971. Volcanic ash in the antarctic icesheet and its possible climatic implications. Earth and Planetary ScienceLetters, 13, 210-218.

Kyle, P. R., Jezek, P. A., Mosely-Thompson, E., and Thompson, L. C.1981. Tephra layers in the Byrd Station ice core and the Dome C icecore, Antarctica, and their climatic importance. Journal of Volcanologyand Geothermal Research, 11, 29-39.

LeMasurier, W. E. 1972. Marie Byrd Land Quaternary volcanism: Byrdice core correlations and possible climatic influences. Antarctic Journalof the U.S., 7(5), 139-141.

LeMasurier, W. E., and Rex, D. C. Rates of uplift and the scale of ice levelinstabilities recorded by volcanic rocks in Marie Byrd Land WestAntarctica. Submitted to the Fourth International Symposium on Antarc-tic Earth Sciences, University of Adelaide, South Australia.

LeMasurier, E. E., and Wade, F. A. 1968. Fumarolic activity in MarieByrd Land, Antarctica. Science, 162, 352.

MacDonald, C. A. 1972. Volcanoes. Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall, Inc.

Geology, paleontology, andbibliography of the Ellsworth

Mountains

GERALD F WEBERS

Macalester CollegeSt. Paul, Minnesota 55105

JOHN F. SPLETTSTOESSER

Minnesota Geological SurveyUniversity of Minnesota

St. Paul, Minnesota 55108

Considerable progress was made during the past year in theinvestigation of the large volume of information, rocks, miner-als, and fossils collected during the 1979-80 Ellsworth Moun-tains expedition. Data and material collected on earlier expedi-tions to this area also were examined. These studies,coordinated among more than 25 senior investigators, involvestructural, stratigraphic, paleomagnetic, paleontological, sedi-mentological, and geomorphic aspects of the Ellsworth Moun-tains. All of the 17 fossil localities sampled during the 1979-80season and all stratigraphic units are being studied. A notewor-thy recent accomplishment is the completion of a major revisionof the lower 7,800 meters of the stratigraphic column (that is,subdivision of the Heritage Group and overlying Minaret For-mation into formations and members).

Several significant publications have already resulted fromthe 1979-80 field project in the Ellsworth Mountains, and manyothers are in various stages of preparation. A bibliographycompiled for use in planning meetings prior to the field seasonhas been updated to include all known literature concerninggeologic investigations in the Ellsworth Mountains as well aspopular literature and literature on mountaineering.

Titles of papers for the Fourth International Symposium onAntarctic Earth Sciences (Adelaide, Australia, August 1982) areincluded, as are the citations for 13 papers given at a symposiumon the geology of the Ellsworth Mountains organized andchaired by C. Craddock, C. F Webers, J . F Splettstoesser, andM. D. Turner as a half-day session at the 1982 annual meeting ofthe Geological Society of America (GSA) (New Orleans, Loui-siana, October 1982). Only abstracts are printed for the GSApapers, but first drafts of complete manuscripts for most ofthem were submitted by the authors at the time of the NewOrleans meeting. These papers, and about 10 to 15 more, willmake up a volume on the geology and paleontology of theEllsworth Mountains, being edited by C. Craddock, J . F Splett-stoesser, and C. F. Webers for the Memoir Series of the Geo-logical Society of America. It is intended to include coloredgeologic maps of the entire range as plates.

An abridged version of the bibliography is presented here; anunabridged version, including more than 100 citations, somewith annotations, is also available (on request from C. F.Webers). In the unabridged version, annotations are includedfor some of the entries because their titles do not indicate rele-vance to the Ellsworth Mountains. For example, the Schopf andLong article (1966; see bibliography), which includes analyses ofthree samples of coal from the Polarstar Formation (the onlyknown published analyses of coal from the Ellsworth Moun-tains), would not have been indexed in Antarctic Bibliography to

36 ANTARCTIC JOURNAL