Envisioning the Vacuum David Vronay Research Manager Windows UI Strategy Microsoft, Inc.

Envisioning the Vacuum

David VronayResearch ManagerWindows UI StrategyMicrosoft, Inc.

© 2005 Microsoft, Inc.

Doing design

• How do you feel so far?

• Is it hard?

• Is it easy?


Challenges to doing design

• Coming in too late– Do it the old comfortable way

• Jumping to a solution– Working backwards to “the design” to prove you

are right

• Committing too early to a solution– Avoiding hard work

• Becoming emotionally involved with a design– Clouds critique

• Not being self-critical– It feels bad


Observation

• All of these challenges are emotional, not practical

• In doing design, often the biggest obstacle to your work is you

• But how can you get yourself out of the picture?


Other disciplines can help

• Most problems have already been solved at some point in the past– If you are stuck in your discipline, look to other d

isciplines for an answer

• We already used psychology and story telling

• We talked about aesethics– “The Art of Tea” by Kakuzo Okakura

• Now we can turn to philosophy– “An Enquiry into The Good” (Zen no Kenkyu) by

Nishida Kitaro– “The Art of War” by Sun Tzu


Envision the Vacuum

• In philosophy, we speak of “being” and “nothingness”

• Nothingness what we are after as a starting point in design

• Negate the self (zen)

• Start with nothingness as your background


What do we mean by vacuum?

• The nothingness that allows things to exist within it– No nothingness means no something

later

• The vacuum is what is essential about object– The emptiness of the room allows

objects to placed within it– The emptiness of a pitcher allows it to

be filled with tea


Why Vacuum is important

• With no space, there is nothing to fill

• No room for a proper design

• No room to see the problem

• No room for the solution to materialize


How do you do it?

• Clear your mind

• Put your emotion towards your users, not your work in progress

• Reject desire

• Instead, Focus on critique

Critique


The Three “C”s of design

• Critique• Critique• And Critique

• Being able to criticize a design is the most important skill of a designer

• Sadly, there is no way to teach this in a few minutes


Two Sides of Criticism

• Learning how to criticize others

• Learning how to accept criticism yourself

• The goal: learn to love criticism!

• Develop confidence that strong criticism is the only way you will get better


Learning how to Critique

• Insist on perfections

• Don’t rest after the obvious

• Use your design tools– Missed emotional moments– Heaven & earth– Personas & scenarios


Critique starts at home

• Be your own harshest critic– “Is that the best you can do?”

• Go back over your old work– Critic is easier if you have some

emotional distance

• Stop selling yourself on you– Save it for marketing

• Keep a notebook– Excellent way of reviewing your

thoughts


A story of critique

• “Fear of the Red Pen”

• Moral: the class made students highly motivated to find their own flaws before the instructor


Critique and the Vacuum

• Critique is like a form of destruction– A negation of bad ideas

• Each bad idea you eliminate opens more space– You create the vacuum

• Then you are free to design


Critique and Nothingness

• Critique feels bad when you first start doing it

• This is where self-negation comes in handy– Remove your self from the critique

• Think of it in terms of reaching towards enlightenment

Assignment 4 Review

The dating phone!


Review of Assignments

• Did you create a story?– Characters– Settings– Arcs– Emotional moments

• Was your product desirable?• How much was new technology vs.

repurposing existing technology?• How would you critique your work?

Design & Research


Careers in design

• Interaction Designers• Visual Designers• Production Folks• Usability Testers• Rapid Prototypers• Production managers

• Research!– HCI (Human Computer Interaction)


Human-Computer Interaction Research

• As people trained in research, you will most likely be involved in research related to HCI

• There are several broad areas of research– Novel Interaction Techniques– Frameworks– Design solutions– Usability Studies


Broad types of HCI research

• Novel Interaction Techniques– Camera-based input

• Frameworks– XML/XSL, model/view/controller

• Design solutions– Web browser for a cell phone

• Usability Studies– Do automobile navigation systems help

drivers?


Some HCI conferences

• ACM SIGCHI– Computer/Human Interaction

• ACM UIST– User Interface and System Technology

• Many others– CSCW– ACM Multimedia– DUX– Mobility– etc


Incorporating design into your own research

• Most of us will not be focusing on HCI, but are working in another computer research area

• However, it is useful to incorporate design thinking into your work

• You might already be doing an HCI project!

• Are you inventing a new technology or coming up with a new use for an existing technology?– If it is the latter, you are doing HCI


Design can help your current research

• Design can help direct your solutions– Example: tonguing UI– What is the context where this would be

appropriate?

• Design can help lead you to new solutions– Example: Lazy Snapping– Thinking of the heaven solution actually results

in a design

• Design can change the way you think about your technology, and lead you to new applications– Example: Keyword clustering


Learning more about design

• Books– Lots of “cookbooks”, not many good bo

oks on design theory

• Web sites– Many good discussion boards & blogs

• Classes• Internships– MSR Asia– MSR Redmond– MSX

Assignment #5

The Critique


Critiquing User Interface

• Pick an application– Better to start with a small one rather than,

say, all of Windows

• Critique it, finding its flaws• Try to find specific ways in which it

violates the things you have learned in class– Who are the personas?– What is the perfect solution?

• For extra effort, propose new solutions


Two levels of assignment

• For most students– Short paper, about the length of the past

assignments– Try to focus on one or two significant

design flaws

• For Content Science Students– Longer report– More in-depth analysis– Show your redesign

Envisioning the Vacuum David Vronay Research Manager Windows UI Strategy Microsoft, Inc.

Documents

Transcript of Envisioning the Vacuum David Vronay Research Manager Windows UI Strategy Microsoft, Inc.