Enrico Turrin - ARROW - Luxembourg - 062013
-
Upload
europeana-licensing -
Category
Business
-
view
873 -
download
2
Transcript of Enrico Turrin - ARROW - Luxembourg - 062013
www.arrow-net.euLuxembourg13/04/23
ARROW Plus is a Best Practice Network selected under the ICT Policy Support Programme (ICT
PSP)
Table of Contents
The ARROW system What is ARROW? How does ARROW work? Demo
ARROW and orphan works The search The registry of orphan works
ARROW Plus Including new countries Enhancing the system Piloting In the image field
What ARROW is
ARROW is a distributed system for facilitating rights information management in any digitisation programme, scalable to further applications A distributed system: a network of databases made interoperable through
use of standards Facilitating implies time saving
Data from validation survey: ARROW allows 90%+ time saving Rights information management: conceived as a separate function from
(though linked to) “rights management” (the RII = Rights Information Infrastructure)
Any digitisation programme: ARROW is conceived to be neutral to legal frameworks and business models
Future applications: Rights information may be crucial in new digital markets
You want to digitise a book but you are really asking for a work A request for permission to digitise and use a book refers to the
manifestation level a book in a specific edition and format (paperback, hardcover, large print) a book published by a specific publisher a book that may be still in print or out of print a book that may be still copyrighted or not
Rights clearance depends on information at work level The in print/out of print status of the work depends from the in print/out of print
status of all its manifestations published If the manifestation requested for digitisation is out of print but another
manifestation of the work is in print, then the work has to be considered in print As the chain of rights might be very complex and all rightholders must be
identified (authors, contributors, publishers)
Why ARROW is needed
Work and manifestation information the work (≈ Expression) of which the item the library wants to
digitise is a manifestation other manifestations of the same work (≈ Expression) Other works (Expressions) related to the work the item the library
wants to digitise is a manifestation A set of information on the rights status of the work
(aka ARROW Assertions) whether the work is copyrighted or in the public domain whether the work is In Print or Out of Print (as well as whether
each manifestation of the work is In Print or Out of Print) whether the work is considered Orphan or rightholders are
known and traceable A set of information on rights and rightsholder
who is the rightholder or rightholder representatives to be contacted to obtain the permission to digitise and use a work
how to get the licence to digitise and use the work, when appropriate
Library and TEL data
TEL and BIP data
Library and TEL data
Library, TEL and VIAF data
BIP data
RRO data
RRO data
RRO data
What ARROW rights information is
ARROW is a system to support libraries in increasing the dimension of their digital libraries and making them available to users supporting the search for the rights status and rightsholders in an automated,
streamlined and standardised way, thus reducing time and costs of the search process
facilitating the inclusion of copyrighted material, to overcome the black hole of the XXth century
building an alliance between libraries, publishers, authors and commercial players towards common services
What ARROW is for
A work becoming orphaned is essentially an issue of missing or incomplete information
ARROW system addresses the issue of Orphan Works but goes beyond it towards a comprehensive Rights Information Infrastructure
to search for information on all categories of books
ARROW facilitates the process of carrying out a search for the rights status and rightholders of a book by means of an easy to use system
What ARROW is for
START
The user submits a request to digitise a book and ARROW queries the existing sources of information connected to the system: The TEL database (The European Library: the single European library
catalogue), to identify the book and to cluster it with all other books containing the same work
The VIAF (Virtual International Authority File), to better identify the authors and support the identification of in copyright works
The BiP (Books-in-Print) in the country of publication, to know if any of the books concerned is in print (actively commercialised by any publisher)
The RRO (Reproduction Rights Organisation) database, to see if they know or can trace the rightholders
How ARROW works
The ARROW workflow LIBRARY
BOOKS IN PRINT
ORPHAN WORK REGISTRY
If NO rightholders is found, inclusion in OWR
All licensing activities are
performed by R
RO
according to business rules and national legal fram
ework
TEL CENTRAL INDEX
TEL performs a 1st clustering of the records
check authors authority files and adds information about the authors including date of death.
RRO
TEL matches the request with the TEL central Index
ARROW
feedback
feedback
VIAF
WORKFLOW option B
ARROW
WORKFLOW option A
Licensed BIP Same processing as BIP
ARROW
RRO matches the request against own repertoire (if applicable)
RRO validates the rights status of the cluster
RRO looks for rightholders
ISTC Agency
feedback
feedback
feedback
License issued by RRO
Request redirected to author/publisher
Request returned to the library for direct contact to publisher/authors
M1QM1A
M2R
M3QM3R
M5QM5R
M6Q
M6R
M7Q
M7RM7R
ONIX ISTC Registration message
M2QM4Q
ARROWM6Q/M6RM7Q/M7R
BIP retrieves in print/out of print status, new books and publisher information
LIBRARY
BOOKS IN PRINT
ORPHAN WORK REGISTRY
If NO rightsholder is found, inclusion in OWR
All lice
nsin
g activitie
s are
pe
rform
ed
by R
RO
accord
ing
to
busin
ess ru
les a
nd
natio
na
l le
gal fra
me
work
TEL CENTRAL INDEX
TEL performs a 1st clustering of the records
check authors authority files and adds information about the authors including date of death.
RRO
TEL matches the request with the TEL central Index
ARROW
feedback
feedback
VIAF
ARROW
ARROW
RRO matches the request against own repertoire (if applicable)
RRO validates the rights status of the cluster
RRO looks for rightholders
feedback
License issued by RRO
Request redirected to author/publisher
Request returned to the library for direct contact to publisher/authors
ARROW
BIP retrieves in print/out of print status, new books and publisher information
Simplified ARROW Workflow
ARROW collects the best available rights information from the different sources and delivers them at once
ARROW Results
END
Suitable for any model requiring a “diligent search” Supporting the diligent search process in an automated, streamlined and
standardised way Flexible to serve any diligent search model Neutral to the legal framework and licensing solution adopted
ARROW search = 5 % of Manual search time
Benefits in using ARROW for the search
National Pilots & Use Cases
National pilots German pilot up and running French pilot up and running Spanish pilot up and running UK pilot up and running
Identification of National Use Cases France: Collective agreement for Out-of-Commerce Works Germany: Collective agreement for Out-of-Commerce Works UK: collaboration with the UK RROs to support a digitisation project using ARROW
ARROW is a standard system that can be customised according to stakeholders’ requirements in the frame of national use cases
DEMO(www.arrow-net.eu)
orHow does ARROW look like
from the user perspective
Lessons learned
Effective rights information management requires the involvement and cooperation of the whole value chain: Libraries Authors Publishers Publishers’ and authors’ associations Books in print organisations Collective rights management organisations
The ARROW solution relies on networking, knowledge sharing and collaboration among stakeholders
To sum up
ARROW is a comprehensive system for facilitating rights information management in any digitisation programme supporting the diligent search process, scalable to further applications in the new digital markets
ARROW system addresses the issue of Orphan Works but goes beyond it towards a comprehensive Rights Information Infrastructure
to search for information on all categories of books
A work becoming orphaned is essentially an issue of missing or incomplete information
So… what about Orphan Works?
Orphan works are definable at the end of a search process and ARROW provides an environment and tools to facilitate the search for rightholders
ARROW approach to the search for Rights Information was worked out to be compliant with the HLG guidelines on diligent search the search is done prior to the use of the work the search is done title by title or work by work each step of the search is documented and results stored the workflow is executed on country-basis
according to country of the work’s origin
At the end we may have some unsuccessful searches: these works are “candidate orphans”
It is up to stakeholders, within a given legal framework, to decide whether a work is orphan or additional searches are required
ARROW approach to Orphan Works
The Registry of Orphan Works
In case of unsuccessful searches, information about “candidate orphans” form the Registry of Orphan Works
The ROW has been designed to be as neutral as possible to the evolution of the European and national legal frameworks concerning Orphan Works as well as operative solutions and business models that could emerge at national level
The Registry of Orphan Works will be available for searches and for rightsholder to claim their rights ownership individually or through a collective representative organisation or agent
ARROW Plus
ARROW plus Start date: 1st April 2011 End date: 30th September 2013 Full Partners: 26 Supporting partners: 10 Countries involved: 14
(Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, the Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, Spain)
About the project
Broadening the scope of ARROW through ARROW Plus
Pilot countries
Arrow
Arrow Plus
Main issues in new countries
The Arrow model works for countries where the book data infrastructure is quite advanced: The national library catalogue should be in TEL Books in print exists Reliable RRO database exists
How to move towards countries where one or more of these elements lack? We need to create the data infrastructure where it does not exist Or improve the existing data infrastructure where it is not able to fit
the requirements
Why ARROW Plus
Objective 1: inclusion of further countries Basing on the existing data sources in countries where BIP and RRO databases are in place
Creating a shared infrastructure of BIP and RRO databases in countries where they lack
Key element: setting up (or improving existing) BiPs and RROs, which will benefit the trade far beyond the project scope
Objective 2: enhancement of the system following use case requirements Customising the system when a use case emerges
Improving the system according to requirements of each new country included
Key element: specific requirements of one use case may be beneficial for the whole ARROW system
Objective 3: piloting the management of rights information on images embedded in books Including in the ARROW workflow visual artists’ CMO
Producing a feasibility study on diligent search in the image sector
Key element: this is a first step towards a broader scope for ARROW
Work Packages
Objective 1: inclusion of further countries Coordinating national initiatives (WP3) Creating conditions for inclusion - new registries (WP5)
Objective 2: enhancement of the system Enhancement (WP4) Infrastructure for registries (WP4) Technical inclusion of a new country (WP4) Validation (WP7)
Objective 3: piloting the inclusion of images Dedicated efforts (WP6)
Transversal Work Packages Project management (WP1) Dissemination and network building (WP2)
Associazione Italiana Editori (IT) (Coordinator) Int. Federation of Reproduction Rights Organisations (WP2 leader) Federation of European Publishers (WP3 leader) CINECA (IT) (WP4 leader) Marketing und Verlagsservice des Buchhandels (DE) (WP5 leader) European Visual Artists (WP6 leader) University Library of Innsbruck (AT) (WP7 leader)
ARROW Plus WHO’S WHO – WP leaders
The European Library - Koninklijke Bibliotheek (NL)Istituto Centrale per il Catalogo Unico (IT)EDItEURCoordination of European Picture AgenciesEuropean Writers CongressSociété des Auteurs et Compositeurs Dramatiques (BE)Latvian Book Guilds (LV)Hungarian Publishers and Booksellers Association (HU)
Portuguese Publishers Association (PT)
Lithuanian Publishers Association (LT)
Boek.be –Huis van het boek vzw (BE)
CIELA (BG)
Polska Ksiąŝka (PL)
The Irish Copyright Licensing Agency (IE)
Osdel (GR)
Centro Español de Derechos Reprográficos (ES)
DI-TECH (IT)
Bee Near (RO)
EKT-NHRF (GR)
Supporters: Europeana FoundationBibliothéque nationale de FranceCopydan WritingNational Library of LatviaLatvian Booksellers’ AssociationKopiostoSt. St. Cyril and Methodius National Library of BulgariaConference of European National LibrariesPolish Chamber of BooksPolish Association of Book Publishers
ARROW Plus WHO’S WHO - Partners
http://www.arrow-net.eu
ARROW Plus is a Best Practice Network selected under the ICT Policy Support
Programme (ICT PSP)
FURTHER INFORMATION
Enrico [email protected]
FEP – Federation of European Publishers(WP3 leader)