The Return of Religion in the 21st Century, Towards Post-Secular
English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
Transcript of English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
1/54
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
2/54
2
ABSTRACT
Author: Benji Hill
Title: English Football: The Rise of Secular Religion
Supervising Professor: Ben Carrington
I recently had the privilege to travel to England for two weeks to observe
and analyze the comparisons between football and religion. I attended multiple
games and interviewed many fans, players, and academic scholars; byimmersing myself in football culture I was able to fully grasp the importance of
the sport in English society. I also witnessed the declining presence of religion
in English peoples lives.
Interlacing my own observations with academic sources I intend to show
that the institution of football is rapidly replacing the institution of religion in
England. I believe that the frenzied football fan base has essentially discovered
an alternate form of spirituality, whether they realize it or not. Further, I will
use England as my case study to demonstrate how secular institutions have
the potential to serve as cultural, social, and ultimately religious entities.
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
3/54
3
Outline
1)Introduction ...5
2) History ..73) Social Construct..10
a. Alternate Universe.....10b. Conflict Perspective11c. Delirium Theory..12
4) Identity.........14a. Material Symbolism14b. Money Matters.15
5) Community...176)Tribal............187) Sanctuary.....218) Crowd...........23
a.Transformative Misconduct.23b. Unity24
9) Music...........26a. A Temptress Muse..26b. Siren from Afar27c. Beatlemania.29
10) Idolization..3011) Afterlife......34
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
4/54
4
a. Life and Death.3512) Heredity.....3613) Catharsis......38
a. Everton vs. Tottenham: The Climax3814) Secularization..41
a. Secularization Theory at Large..41b. Secularization in England43c.The Rise of Football...45
15) The Changing of the Guard.....4716) Conclusion: The Final Whistle50
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
5/54
5
For many of us in this secular age it is stating the obvious to acknowledge
that religion, certainly in any organized sense, has lost its grip. We appear
to have fallen out of love with it. As an effect of this there is an enormous
vacuum, a God shaped hole in our lives. A situation vacant. And it looks as
if football has become that which for so many fills that vacuum.
(Oakley 148)
1. Introduction
I walked into that majestic football stadium and all of lifes troubles melted
away. With my teams scarf warming my neck, my identity was clear. I was
one with the fans, this was my community. We sang in unison and our
solidarity shook the earth. Running before me were my heroes and idols, my
prophets. This was the key to immortality. Goal, catharsis, God?
In an interview with Ian Mcdonald, a sociology professor at the University
of Brighton, I uncovered a piece of sociological insight that will serve as a
catapult for the rest of my thesis. He said the following:
Thefunctionalistperspectivesays that institutions in society exist in
order to meet certain needs of society. So in society we have a need for
some kind of spiritual meaning or some kind of relationship to
spirituality. Obviously churches have historically fulfilled that role for
some sense of meaning, but now sport is fulfilling that role, and football
clubs in particular are meeting this need for some kind of
religiosity/spirituality in society.
(Ian Mcdonald)
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
6/54
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
7/54
7
2. History
Throughout history religion and sports have shared close ties. There are
numerous examples of ancient sports originating in the form of religious ritual.
In ancient Central America, the Mayans and Aztecs played a sport
outside of their temples which in many senses was viewed as a cultic ritual.
Using only their hips they would try to shoot a rubber ball through wooden
hoops on opposing sides. This was representative of the arc and descent of the
sun into the underworld, which would lead to the resurrection of new strength
and warmth. Many times players would be beheaded after games and used as
sacrifices to the gods. This sport obviously held more significance to this
culture than the simple act of putting a ball through a hoop. It was utilized as
a highly symbolic ritual which in turn reminds us of a day when religion and
athleticism enjoyed an intimate, if gory, relationship (Baker 7).
An even more recognized example would be that of the Greek Olympics.
In 776 B.C. the ancient Hellenes created this sports festival in order to honor
the gods through the pursuit of athletic perfection. The games played
included: foot races, chariot races, boxing, wrestling, discus, and javelin
throwing. However, to the Greeks, a sport meant so much more than just a
game. Athletes were venerated and rewarded abundantly for victories; statues
were erected and legends were born; poetry and art solidified heroes in Greek
lore. In many ways, sports replaced the glory of war.
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
8/54
8
In Ancient times, all successes and all defeats were attributed to the
gods.
According to Homer, the gods took an active interest in the events. Like
modern athletes who chalk up wins or losses to the will of God, young
Greeks blamed or praised the gods according to the contests outcome.
An archer was said to have missed his target because he had failed to
promise Apollo a sacrificial offering. Presumably Apollo begrudged him
victory. When a chariot driver momentarily dropped his whip in the
midst of a race, he blamed Apollo for knocking it out of his hand but
thanked the goddess Athena for helping him retrieve it. These early
athletes looked to the heavens for assistance. Eager to win the prize for
the footrace, Odysseus charged down the stretch praying to Athena,
Hear me, goddess: come, bless mewith speed!
(Baker 9)
Considering this passage, the Greeks viewed sports and religion as extremely
complementary to one another. They had effectively developed a stage on
which to showcase the capabilities of the gods through human talent.
We must keep in mind that the Olympics have survived to this day and
reoccur every four years. Not only do they remain active, but they have
retained many of the rituals, traditions, and morals which originally defined
them. Nevertheless, we no longer worship Zeus, Apollo, and Athena, so how
could this be? Has the institution of sports outlasted and evolved beyond its
counterpart of religion?
The meaning driven nature of the modern Olympics can harbor immense
significance for people, even in the absence of omnipresent gods. Though the
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
9/54
9
gods may have initially appeared as the primary element of the ancient
Olympics, they may have in fact been a superfluous byproduct. In the past,
many cultures exploited the notion of the supernatural as a means to bring
people together. But what is often overlooked is the pure importance of the
customs involved. The Olympics serve as a prime example that sports can still
fulfill social needs without the mention of gods.
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
10/54
10
3. A Social Construct
a.Alternate Universe
I landed in London on a cold and misty night in late December filled with
latent anxiety and bubbling anticipation. Fortunately the son of my host
family, Joseph, was a diehard Arsenal fan and he invited me to watch the
Arsenal fixture with him and his friends. They did not have Sky TV (the
English cable service which airs most Premier League games), so we set up a
laptop and scoured the internet for live streams of the match. Luckily we
found a pixilated channel which would suffice, but who knew how impactful
these pixels would be. The game began.
Huddled around that tiny screen we were transported into another world,
one filled with enchantment, enshrouded by faith, and teeming with emotion.
They passed around little bits of knowledge like cocaine, snorting in the
essence of fandom. Each sports fact, each player reference, each pass, each
shot, each success, each failure they shared this drug commonly known as
football. I watched as their thoughts and passions metamorphosed alongside
the erratic game; if this was not an alternate state of mind, I am not sure what
is.
Football and sports in general serve as an escape from the troubles of
reality. Like a drug, football can provoke a legal altered consciousness, one
outside the realm of everyday life. In my interview with Ian Mcdonald he
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
11/54
11
mentioned that football can act as a form of distraction and a form of
pleasurable meaning in an otherwise fairly hostile meaningless world. Chris
Oakley goes as far as calling football a dream spacea place apart, something
other. This we seek to sustain as bright, as luminous even, whilst
simultaneously we can find ourselves cornered in some other reality:football
becoming the taste of colour in a wash of grey (Oakley 4).
Football unveils a portal into another universe, one in which anything is
possible, miracles do happen, and success is within reach. Alas the real world
is difficult and influence is hard to come by. Thus many people resort to an
imaginary existence in which their goals and aspirations are interlaced with
their football club, their escape.
b. Conflict perspectiveKarl Marx believed that institutions were often utilized in order to mold
ideological roles, namely to placate citizens, especially in downtrodden working
class communities. In the past, religion was the primary instigator of such a
model. Christianity promised the ultimate reward of eternal life in heaven for
those who would abide by a specific moral code. Hence, the institution of
religion was largely set in place to maintain the social order and the proper
behavior of a nations citizens.
From a Marxist perspective, sports can be seen as a surrogate means of
preserving social control. Sports harness the ability to distract attention from
important social, political, and economic issues and thereby become opiates of
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
12/54
12
the masses (Coakley 519). Running with this notion of distraction, sports (and
any source of entertainment for that matter) are often beneficial to society in
that they provide enjoyment even in times of despair. While citizens once
exclusively turned to their church for comfort, people now have secular options
which they can fall back on.
c. Delirium theoryIn the book Football Delirium Chris Oakley poses that football offers a
madness that is essential for a sane life (Oakley 5). This concept of
therapeutic delirium as he puts it unveils avery interesting take on English
football fans, especially considering the violent history of the sports
spectatorship.
For many years hooliganism pervaded the football landscape. Fans
would gather in gangs outside football grounds with the sole purpose of
fighting opposing fans. While this behavior demonstrated an immense amount
of loyalty towards their football clubs, it was obviously detrimental to English
society. Fortunately through the addition of seated grounds and evolving police
control, hooliganism has abated in recent years.
But even without manifest violence nowadays, football spectatorship still
serves as an excellent method of venting aggression. Now is a good time to
note that the majority of football supporters are male. 56% of English men, as
opposed to 26% of English women, consider themselves football fans (Barclays
2009 Global Fan Report). That being said, because of a combination of
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
13/54
13
psychological and social reasons, men are statistically more likely to partake in
violence. So if we consider Oakleys theory of therapeutic delirium, football is
in essence targeting the most violent demographic and creating a less
destructive outlet of expression.
George Orwell once said that sport is war minus the shooting. He may
not have been far from the truth. Much like the Marxist perspective, this anti-
violence conception further supports the idea that sports, and football in
particular, serve as a form of social control. In a time when religious wars run
rampant in our world, the institution of football functions as a much more
civilized version of religious competition.
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
14/54
14
4. Identity
a.Material Symbolism
After watching the match it was time to retire to Josephs house. Hewas
a devout follower of the Jewish faith, but first and foremost he was an Arsenal
fan. Be that as it may, it was not until I entered his bedroom that I realized the
extent of his obsession. Lining every inch of every wall were pictures, tickets,
newspaper clippings, jerseys, autographs, practically anything and everything
associated with the Arsenal football club. This was a shrine.
It is amazing how important memorabilia becomes
to people, as if each item is a means to stay connected
to a team even when separated. The idea of using
symbols to represent deeper beliefs, also known as the symbolic interactionist
perspective, permeates countless aspects of our lives today. This could range
from the commercial icons we encounter daily, such as the Apple insignia or
the golden arches of McDonalds, to religious emblems. As Prebish adeptly
points out, the sport symbol may not be the Cross, Rosary, or Mezuzah, but it
is no less valuable to the owner (Prebish 67).
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
15/54
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
16/54
16
from the passion of the sport. On the contrary, it can fuel even deeper
connections with the fans.
After watching the Arsenal match on the laptop, I witnessed a very
interesting conversation between Joseph and his friend Dan:
There came a time when I realized that football was not my life, but just a
hobby. (Joseph)
- Well mate, that realization has not come to me yet. (Dan)Maybe because youve spent thousands of dollars on games and
memorabilia. (Joseph)
- Maybe. (Dan)
Because of Danssubstantial investment in the Arsenal football club he
consequently developed a very strong attachment to the team. By investing
time and money into football, fans are in turn investing parts of themselves
into the sport as well. It is this notion of self sacrifice that deeply links fans
with their clubs.
On the other hand, the importance of money in modern sport severely
limits the potential attachment of many fans. Lower class citizens cannot
attend as many games or own as much memorabilia as those in the upper
echelon of society. This evolving rift between supporters may sadly be one of
the negatives of the modernization of football.
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
17/54
17
5.Community
On to the next leg of my trip: Manchester. Of course my first stop was
Old Trafford, home of Manchester United, the most followed football club in the
world. I had a ticket to the match versus Stoke
City, but this was not all I wanted to see.
Throughout England there is a tradition to
meet in a pub before and after the games, and
tradition I would keep.
With game time fast approaching I made my way to the local supporter
pub. I was tentative at first being the only American around for miles, but
once they saw my Man U scarf I was immediately accepted. After a few pints
with the lads it became apparent that this was more than a simple pub, it was
a community. These fans all knew each other, they reminisced on past
experiences, they swapped strongly held opinions, they deftly analyzed the
current team and players, and they gazed starry eyed together into the future
of MUFC. They shared a passion and a faith which united them all. They were
a family.
Many of the communal ties exhibited at a supporter pub are extremely
reminiscent of organized religion. A sense of community remains one of the
most integral elements of modern day religions. Churches or Synagogues or
Mosques bring together congregations of like minded people. While prayer is
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
18/54
18
often the focus, the social benefits are as, if not more, essential. These
institutions have realized the importance of cohesion and have thus further
instituted extracurricular gatherings including education, music, and yes, even
sports.
People tend to dwell on the extremely competitive nature of football and
the rifts that it creates between its fans. However, amongst each fan base is a
unique sense of unity that is difficult to replicate. What was once restricted to
organized religions has now seeped into other facets of culture. Especially in
England, one can see that the bonds between a clubs fans are tremendously
stronger than those between a churchs members.
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
19/54
19
6. Tribal
Location is the fundamental connector of a clubs fan base. As one can
see in the map below, even within the city limits of London, supporters are
geographically tied to particular teams.
In one sense it is obvious that people will follow the team that plays closest to
them. But what makes these regional ties so important to football club
affiliation?
The Bedouin Syndrome suggests that in the same way that rival
neighborhood groups coalesce to defend their home territory against visiting
fans, so too is community solidarity of this type manifested on a regional scale
and a national scale (Frosdick388). In a way, this theory exhibits the true
tribal nature of sports. Teams and individuals first and foremost represent
their home towns or countries in their competitions. However in the modern
times, with advances in transportation and travel, the lines separating specific
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
20/54
20
regions are becoming blurred. In most professional sports players are drafted
to teams all around the world, even if they have absolutely no association with
that particular city. So why do we continue to separate our teams with regards
to location?
According to the Bedouin theory, we divide ourselves due to our inherent
human need to congregate in communities and tribes. Much like the hunters
and gatherers in the past, each clan must compete to survive in a world where
success is limited. Sports provide a structured format in which we can fulfill
our intrinsic yearning for competition in a somewhat safe environment.
In the past, religion was the common glue that held neighborhoods and
communities together. Now, in England at least, the strength of this religious
glue has decayed. What remains are communities built around their iconic
cathedrals: stadiums.
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
21/54
21
7. Sanctuary
Finally it was time, time for me to enter Old Trafford stadium, also
known as the Theater of Dreams. This stadium is recognized as one of the
most renowned and historic football grounds
in England, if not the world. As I stood within
that fortress of fame I could hear the whispers
of its celebrated past. I could see where
players the likes of Gary Neville, Ryan Giggs,
and George Best once stunned the football world. I could see where Sir Alex
Ferguson won all his titles. This was not simply a building, this was a sacred
sanctuary.
Much like a cathedral, the architectural marvel of a stadium showcases
human potential at its finest. The massive grandeur of these buildings puts
the infinitesimal nature of a human into perspective; one is humbled as a mere
component of the grand scheme. The majority of religious structures are built
with a lofty hope of reaching towards the sky, grasping towards their elusive
God. While stadiums were not necessarily built with this intention in mind,
they inadvertently evoke a similar spiritual reaction.
For the most part churches, mosques and synagogues, as with stadia,
are simultaneously places of awe and dazzlement. Rising high above the
surrounding landscape they operate as a constant reminder of the hallowed
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
22/54
22
ground that lies beneath them (Oakley 162). Certain places on our Earth have
been deemed holy because of the events which have graced their location. The
Dome of the Rock for instance is sacred to the Islamic tradition because it is
the site where Mohammad ascended to heaven. Similarly in football terms, the
legendary and miraculous events that occurred in Old Trafford sanctify the site
as a holy temple of memories to Manchester United and football fans alike.
Furthermore, fans from around England and all over the world travel to
consecrated stadiums such as Old Trafford in order to experience firsthand the
fateful histories of the grounds. This journey is not much different than the
pilgrimages which many religions partake in. For centuries people of similar
faith have flocked to holy sites to worship their God in the presence of
greatness, both present and past. As football lore continues to inflate, so does
the significance of football stadiums in the lives of their fans.
Upon surveying Old Trafford there were two banners that caught my eye.
One read MUFC the Religion and the other stated Manchester is my
Heaven. Sitting beneath the beaming spotlights,
surrounded by 75,000 devoted followers, and witnessing
the greatest athletes on earth, I clearly realized why
stadiums in England are often considered cathedrals.
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
23/54
23
8. Crowd
a.Transformative Misconduct
Game time. There was a buzz in the air, an arousing mist of
anticipation. I purposefully sat next to the away section, the notoriously
loudest section of any stadium. These were the diehard fans, the ones who
traveled miles upon miles to support their club, their livelihood. They stood in
unison, chanted in unison, reacted in unison; it was as if they were a single
entity, a distinct organism.
Sitting next to that away section in Old Trafford stadium I decided to
pinpoint one fan and observe his behavior. What ensued was shocking to say
the least. He was drunk beyond reason; he was screaming obscenities at the
opposing fans (jokingly); he sang chants at the top of his lungs; he grabbed his
friend and shook him in both frustration and elation. Somehow though, this
mans actions were completely acceptable within the confines of the stadium.
Why can people behave so differently at a football match than in everyday life?
For the answer, we must look to the power of thecrowd.
In 1852 a British journalist named Charles Mackay first mentioned the
concept of herd mentality,which denotes that members of a crowd will often
act the same way. This notion challenged the paradigm of individualism and
brought about a whole new field of crowd studies. At the core of crowd
research is the idea of collective behavior, which is defined as actions by a
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
24/54
24
group of people who bypass the usual norms governing their behavior and do
something unusual (Turner and Killian). But why only in a group will people
blatantly disregard social conventions? Gustave Le Bon, the founder of crowd
psychology, theorizes that by being part of the crowd, individuals lose all
sense of self and all sense of responsibility. Yet, at the same time, they gain a
sentiment of invincible power due to their numbers (Reicher 186).
In the unique forum of football grounds, fans can cast aside their
individual constraints and release their often restrained desires without
judgment or ridicule. The frustrations and struggles of work and family
cascade to oblivion as animalistic fervor is embraced. Buried within the depths
of the crowd resides humanity in its purest form.
b. UnityBeyond the individual benefits of immersing oneself in a crowd, the
power of shared experience should not be overlooked. Certain ritualistic
traditions such as clapping, chanting, and the wave help link a crowd as a
single unit. This bond evokes a sense of oneness and connectivity that many
gurus, shamans, and spiritual leaders seek their entire lives. It is not simply a
coincidence that religious practices such as minyan and communionrequire the
presence of a congregation. By connecting with those around us we can in
turn connect with God, the connector of all. Football is no different.
In Jungian terms perhaps football will enable us to be in touch with the
Collective Unconscious, however briefly(Oakley 172). Maybe football is
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
25/54
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
26/54
26
9. Music
a.Temptress Muse
I continued to watch the away section in Old Trafford stadium and their
behavior never ceased to amaze me. In a single booming voice they sang
without a moments rest. It seemed as if they had an endless repertoire of
songs at their disposal. This was not just a crowd, this was a choir.
The phenomenon of crowd chanting at professional football games is
hardly a rare occurrence. Fans all around the world use song to motivate their
teams as well as themselves. I asked Liverpool legend Jimmy Melia how
cheering affected him and he replied, when I hear Liverpool supporters singing
You Never Walk Alone, that brings tears to my eyes. Evidently music can
rouse deep emotions, even for the most masculine athletes.
You Never Walk Alone was originally a show tune from the 1945 Rodgers
and Hammerstein musical, Carousel. In the early 1960s the song was
adopted as Liverpools anthem, and it has stuck ever since. Before every
Liverpool match fans sing this song in unison. The lyrics are as follows:
When you walk through a storm hold your head up highAnd dont be afraid of the dark.
At the end of a storm is a golden sky
And the sweet silver song of a lark.
Walk on through the wind,
Walk on through the rain,
Tho your dreams be tossed and blown.
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
27/54
27
Walk on, walk on with hope in your heart
And youll never walk alone,
Youll never, ever walk alone.
Walk on, walk on with hope in your heartAnd youll never walk alone,
Youll never, ever walk alone.
These song lyrics serve as an inspiration to fans and players alike. Upon
deeper interpretation one can recognize that the meaning behind these words
stretch beyond football and into the existential. Though we face adversity,
together with faith we can eventually reach the light in the sky, or shall we call
it heaven.
It is difficult not to classify this traditional song as a religious ritual.
Through the art of music the Liverpool fan base can express their
overwhelming sense of solidarity. Beneath the transient spotlights, nestled in
their house of worship, outstretching their symbolic scarves towards the
firmament, these fans come together to pray to their God, the Liverpool
Football Club.
b. Siren from AfarBut the uniting force of music extends beyond the football grounds. I
was fortunate enough to be in London to bring in the new year of 2011. I
decided to make my way to the Themes River to see the renowned fireworks
display. Needless to say, thousands of other people had the same idea. On the
train into the city I witnessed a fascinating event; a large group of High School
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
28/54
28
boys caught up in the revelry of the night began chanting what I soon realized
was an Arsenal song. It went as such:
Woke up this morning,
from the strangest dream.
I was in the biggest army,
The world has ever seen.
We were marching as one,
on the road to the holy grail.
Firstly, it was incredible to see that on this day of celebration these
English teenagers chose football as their primary means of expression.
Through the memory tool of music they were transported back to ecstatic
moments within their short-lived history involving Arsenal. In this ritual of
reflection and expectation, they seemed, happy.
Secondly, the lyrics of this song carry obvious religious connotations.
The Holy Grail (the wine cup used by Jesus Christ at the Last Supper) is
arguably the most sought after religious relic on Earth. Similarly, the FA cup
is arguably the most sought after trophy in England. It is only fitting that
these fans were singing about ultimate triumph in a religious context.
Both the Liverpool and Arsenal songs that have been mentioned share an
extremely similar undertone; via the unity of their fans, clubs can reach victory
of religious proportions. Accordingly, music serves as a brilliant unifier of fans.
It is interesting to note that many football songs draw their tunes from
religious hymns. The chanting of crowds in football grounds is highly
comparable to the choral prayer seen in churches. Whether a Christian or a
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
29/54
29
football supporter, the communal singing of shared beliefs has the potential to
bring about an exceptional sense of spirituality beyond the profane.
c. BeatlemaniaBesides musics involvement in religion and football, popular music
deeply impacts culture. As a side note to my research we should note that
bands can attract followings very similar to those of football clubs. The Beatles
in particular provide a spectacular example of how bands come to be adored.
Beginning at a small venue called the Cavern in Liverpool in the 1960s,
Beatlemaniaspread throughout England and then across the world.
Much like football matches, Beatles concerts would ignite their fans into
an indescribable frenzy. The crowd would scream and sing in unison, jump
around in rapture, and thrust their arms up in a statement of faith and
reverence. Indeed the Beatles opened the worlds eyes to the possibility of
worshiping aspects of culture other than religion.
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
30/54
30
10. Idolization
In Manchester I had the privilege of visiting the Manchester United
museum. As if I did not already realize the clubs prodigious history, it was
soon very clear to me. What first caught my eye was an influx of tributes to
past athletes, or shall we call them celebrities.
Here is a shrine to David Beckham, an athlete who transcended the realm of
football and established himself as a worldwide icon. It is quite fitting that his
stance in this picture closely resembles that of Jesus on the cross, because in
many ways Beckham can be viewed as a savior and a prophet.
While not many athletes (if any) have reached the monumental status of
David Beckham, celebrity has and continues to permeate the football world.
With the progression of media such as newspapers, television, and the internet,
teams now perform on a larger stage than ever before. Elite players with
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
31/54
31
exceptional talent often get thrown into the limelight and amidst this spotlight
they have the power to influence immense amounts of people.
Indeed this spotlight of fame is dangerously powerful. It can radiate an
aura of divinity, casting an icon as an idol before his/her adoring fans. The
bible directly warns us in Exodus 32 about the perils of idolatry when the
Israelites are reprimanded for worshiping a golden calf. Nevertheless, I will
venture to suggest that idolatry remains rampant in modern day society. In his
book Sacred Matters, Gary Laderman discusses in depth the religious nature of
fame:
Celebrity icons arouse the religious passions of followers in modern
society who find spiritual meaning, personal fulfillment, and awe-
inspiring motivation in the presence of these idols. The early decades of
the twentieth century witnessed the dawn of these new gods worshipped
in celebrity culture, when fame and stardom in public and popular
cultures could, in some instances, translate into religious categories with
sacred implications in [peoples] lives. The sacred implications of
worshipping at the altar of celebrity might include invigorating new forms
of ritual commitment and devotional practice, or investing in mythologies
that promise immortality and spiritual rather than material rewards, or
even instigating a reformation of personal moral values and ultimate
concerns.
(Laderman 64)
Professional athletes are given the amazing opportunity to have a positive effect
on massive amounts of people simultaneously. Through an athletes
professional accolades he/she can lead the public through example.
Formulated around a base of talent these athletes can showcase hard work,
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
32/54
32
determination, execution, and a good attitude in order to inspire people now
and for generations to come.
With this exposure comes great responsibility. Under such a potent
magnifying glass of scrutiny, every action and gesture is important. For
instance, let us examine the occasion when Kak, an AC Milan legend, revealed
a shirt stating I belong to Jesus after winning the Champions League.
Here we see an instance in which an athlete
utilizes his fame as a platform to propagate
religion. His shirt represents a statement that
his success should be attributed to his lord
and savior Jesus Christ. Further, if his fans
wish to achieve similar success they too
should turn to Jesus Christ. This action is quite reminiscent of the Ancient
Olympians who thanked their gods for each triumph. Who knows, maybe
Athena still roams the football grounds. Regardless, this event shines a light
upon the fact that many modern day athletes still look to religion as a source of
inspiration for athletic performance.
Another example of the public construing athletic prowess as spiritual
enlightenment can be seen in the career of Diego Maradona. His goal in the
1986 World Cup for Argentina was widely regarded as the hand of god. Ever
since then he has been a legend. Maradona is a mere mortal, a mere football
player, yet for many of his fans he is viewed as a conduit of god, a messenger,
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
33/54
33
an inspiration. So if religion is simply a conglomeration of symbols used to give
meaning to our lives, who is to say that Maradonas career cannot provide
similar meaning?
Religion is largely based upon the influence of certain people, namely
their belief system and character. People often ask, why has there not been a
prophet since the days of the bible? Maybe we are just too blind to look at
what has been right in front of our eyes this whole time. The world is filled
with inspirational people, people who seem to embody the godliness for which
we strive. Maybe it is time we recognize that prophets do exist today, even if
they reside in the so called secular realm of society.
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
34/54
34
11. Afterlife
Upon entering the imposing halls of the Manchester United museum, one
is immediately blinded by a throng of trophies and medals.
While Man U is the most decorated football club in England, the notion of
flaunting success is not new to the sport. But these trophies represent more
than simply the act of winning; they symbolize the actualization of dreams, the
fulfillment of determination, and ultimately the attainment of perfection. In
many ways it can be argued that winning the Premier League or the FA cup for
an athlete, or even a fan, is much like reaching heaven on earth.
By winning footballs highest honors, athletes and coaches alike have the
capability to solidify themselves in football lore. Much like the ancient Greek
athletes who strived for immortality through distinction and fame, modern
athletes still yearn for their name to live on. Once the gods have vanished
from Mount Olympus or from Dantes paradise, we can no longer run to
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
35/54
35
appease them or save our souls, but we can set a new record. It is a uniquely
modern form of immortality (Guttmann 55).
Some athletes have the potential to go down in the history books, to not
only be an icon in this generation, but for generations to come. While they may
not survive for the next 300 years, their identity will forever be imprinted upon
the aging face of civilization. Their achievements, though secular, can prove to
hold influence of religious proportions.
a. Life and DeathIn professional football, a win or a loss has huge implications. Jimmy
Melia even ventured to say, Ifyou were to ask a Liverpool or Manchester
United supporter if winning is like life and death to you, they would say no, its
more important than that.
From a religious perspective, if football can actually simulate life and
death experiences, the subsequent gains hold profound possibility. When our
society progressed into an age of increased civility, defeat in an athletic
contest was thus the symbolic substitute for sacrificial death (Guttman 22).
So unlike the Mayan and Aztec ball games in which men were slaughtered on
behalf of the gods, our modern conception of sports allows us to sacrifice our
emotions rather than our bodies. Through the metaphorical experience of
death in sports we no longer must partake in the barbaric rituals which once
pervaded religion.
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
36/54
36
12. Heredity
On my way to the Everton vs. Tottenham match in Liverpool it was only
fitting that I stop off at a pub to talk to some of the local fans. Right away a
man in his 60s kindly motioned me over and offered me a pint. Him and his
brother were season ticket holders and it was soon clear how loyal they were to
the Everton football club. Over the last 40 years they had managed to attend
almost every home game and even some away ones. Their father and their
fathers father were Everton supporters. Rightfully so, they carried on the
tradition.
Whenever I met a fan along my trip I asked them why they chose to
support their respective teams. Each answered with one of two responses: one,
they were raised in that suburb; two, their parents rooted for that team. The
first response relates to the tribal power of football which we previously
discussed. The second unveils a very important aspect of football fandom;
heredity.
Children are exposed to football at a very young age and are thus
instilled with certain experiences and partialities which tend to dictate their
future associations with particular clubs. Once a club is chosen, these ties
can last a lifetime. Further, the more a fan watches games, enshrouds himself
with memorabilia, and learns about a team, the more connected he becomes.
What is amazing is that these ties can be passed down from generation to
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
37/54
37
generation, and thus a fans unique devotion for his club can live on through
his children and his childrens children.
The deep rooted ties which connect a fan to his club are much like those
which bind people to their respective religions. Most of us affiliate with the
religion of our parents. We are brought up with a certain moral code which will
optimistically stick with us for a lifetime. This system of beliefs will expectedly
be passed down to our children and our childrens children. It is this cyclical
process of heredity which makes religion, and also football, so beautiful.
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
38/54
38
13. Catharsis
a.Everton vs. Tottenham: the climax
Finally, I made my way into Goodison Park (Evertons stadium), the last
leg of my journey. I didnt know it at the time, but this would be the
culmination of my research, or even my life.
I found my seat by a group of teenagers who spoke with a heavy scouse
accent. Apparently they were speaking English, but I could not understand a
word they said. Regardless, we all shared the universal language of football.
The matchup was an extraordinary challenge against the highly favored
Tottenham Hotspurs. As the game began the anxiety amidst the stands was
evident, but this unease was soon to be transformed.
Within the first 3 minutes of the game
Everton striker Louis Saha shocked the crowd
with a spectacular goal. Suddenly, the
impossible seemed possible. 5 minutes later
the game was tied, but the Evertonians
maintained faith. The 75thminute came along and oh how significant that
minute was. Everton drove up the sideline, a cross, a header, a swoosh of the
net.
Boom! Euphoria
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
39/54
39
An explosion of ecstasy, a wave of passion, a whirlwind of the surreal.
This was happiness in its purest form. A crowd of thousands jumping in
contentment, hugging strangers like family, and reaching towards the heavens
with gratitude.
Emile Durkheim, one of the most prominent sociologists in history,
would describe this experience as collective effervescence.
Swept away, the participants experience a force external to them, which
seems to be moving them, and by which their very nature is transformed.
They experience themselves as grander than at ordinary times; they dothings they would not do at other times; they feel, and at that moment
really are, joined with each other and with the totemic being. They come
to experience themselves as sharing one and the same essence.
(Durkheim xli)
According to Durkheim, it is through the ritualistic assembly of people by
which the phenomenon of collective effervescencecan be reached. In this
sense, a sporting event serves as a perfect medium for sacredactivity. Yet this
does not necessarily mean that such a ritual is religious. Actually in
Durkheim's view, the god and the society are one and the same (Durkheim
208). Ah, finally, this is the answer I have been searching for.
Society in general, simply by its effect on mens minds, undoubtedly has
all that is required to arouse the sensation of the divine. A society is to its
members what a god is to its faithful (Durkheim 208). Football, being an
institution within the bounds of society, can arouse the divine akin to religion.
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
40/54
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
41/54
41
14. Secularization
a.Secularization Theory at large
In the field of sociology, Secularization Theory states that as society
advances into modernity, religion will retreat. After the Age of Enlightenment
in the 18thCentury human intellect and scientific prowess began to expunge
much of the mystery that religions relied upon. In fact, the three 'classical'
sociological theorists, Marx, Durkheim and Weber [all] thought that the
significance of religion would decrease in modern times (Crabtree).
Society was swarming with thousands of different religions and beliefs
systems; consequently it was difficult to view this cultural entity as anything
but an illusion. Especially now in our globally connected society there are few
communities who solely share the same religion. In this age of pluralism it
seems almost irrational to make claims on a single set of objective beliefs when
there is an infinite amount of options.
Once again looking back on ancient tradition, the study of various
Greek religious ceremonies teaches us that one can always please the gods by
offering themmusic, dance, poetry, drama and athletic contests (Guttmann
23). Interestingly though, all of these facets of culture are now considered
secular. Have our traditions changed tremendously since the Greeks took part
in them? No, not really. All of these mores remain extremely important to
modern culture. What have changed are the motives and intentions behind
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
42/54
42
them. People still play music, dance, write poetry, produce drama, and take
part in athletic contests, the only difference now is that we no longer implicitly
dedicate these activities to gods.
What we can draw from this cultural evolution is not that our traditions
and customs have been revolutionized, but rather that the religiosity of our
culture has vastly diminished. Here is the question that we must ask: is this
religious downfall indicative of the collapse of religion, or has our modern
concept of religion simply shifted?
The absence of gods does not necessitate the absence of spirituality. As
our cultural ideals continue to evolve and adapt, it is ludicrous to think that
our perceptions and expressions of spirituality have not transformed as well.
Why as everything changes must we assume that religion must forever stay
stagnant?
People throughout history have harbored innate yearnings for
connection, ritual, competition, community, and the list goes on. That being
said, people have not lost the need for these elemental attributes of life.
Rather, they have lost the need to classify these elements beneath the umbrella
of God. G.K. Chesterton, a devout Catholic, thought that when people stop
believing in God it is not that they start to believe in nothing. Rather theyll
believe in anything (Oakley 148). Beneath the guise of our secular world we
continue to satisfy our spiritual fix, beyond the realm of religion as we know it.
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
43/54
43
b. Secularization in EnglandNow let us take a look at England. Here we have a country which holds
a deep historical link with religious ideals. The English Reformation, which
occurred in the 16thcentury, allowed for the Church of England to finally break
off from the Roman Catholic Church. The Act of Supremacy was passed in
1534 and this granted the king divine rule and leadership of the Church of
England, ultimately coalescing religion and government. To this day England
still adheres to this concept and the royal family is said to harness the
authority of God.
Surprisingly, while England boasts an extremely religious past, the
English population is currently one of the least religious populaces in the
world. Below is a graph of the religious attendance trends from 1964 to 2005:
As one can clearly see, religious association has plummeted in recent decades.
Here are the numbers for each of the main Christian sects:
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
44/54
44
Sunday Attendance
1989Annual
Change1998
Annual
Change2005
1989-
2005
Total
Change
Roman
Catholics (England)1,703,800 -3.2% 1,217,800 -4.2% 875,600 -49%
Church of England 1,260,800 -2.6% 975,900 -1.6% 867,400 -31%
Pentecostals 236,700 -0.1% 214,600 +4.9% 287,600 +22%
Methodists 512,300 -2.9% 379,700 -3.4% 289,400 -44%
Baptists 270,900 +0.2% 277,600 -1.2% 254,800 -6%
New Churches 167,000 +2.2% 200,500 -1.2% 183,600 +10%
Independent
Churches298,500 -4% 191,600 -0.2% 190,500 -36%
United Reformed 149,300 -2% 121,700 -6.2% 69,900 -53%
Total of above: 4,599,300 3,579,400 3,018 800 -34%
The Christian Research English Church Census, 2005And the chart below shows how general religious attendance has about halved
in the last 30 years:
Not only has the institution of religion been in freefall,
but it is showing no signs of slowing down. Religion in
Britain has suffered an immense decline since the 1950s,
and all indicators show a continued secularization of
British society in line with other European countries
such as France (Crabtree).
National Attendance
1979 12%
1989 10%
1998 07.5%
2005 06.3%
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
45/54
45
Below are two more graphs which show the projected decline of religion in the
UK:
Ultimately, the absolute, institutionalized and symbolic strength of the Church
of England has disappeared (Crabtree).
c. The Rise of FootballWhile religion in England has plummeted, football attendance has
contrastingly increased in recent years:
Football Trend in England
Additionally, many statistics have been released indicating football as a socially
beneficial institution. Here are just a few:
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
46/54
46
'Happy Families are 24% more likely to be found in the football nationthan the general population.
Ties of community are 11% more likely to be found in the football nationthan the general population.
Symbols of success are 27% more likely to be found among fans whoattend matches than the football nation.
(Barclays 2009 Global Fan Report)
Taken even further, the importance of the sport to its spectators is striking.
81 per cent of fans highlighted football as their most regular topic of
conversation, ahead of relationships, family and the economy, while 49 per
cent said that football was the most important thing in their lives ahead of
everything, even family and partners (Barclays 2008 Global Fan Report).
At one point in my trip I asked a fan if he was religious and he replied,
religion? Thats a load of bollocks. I like football more. The more I talked to
fans the more I recognized how widespread this mentality shift truly was. So
many Englishmen have lost patience and faith in their respective religions.
And this trend has already begun to indoctrinate new generations who are
being raised atheist.
So what can we realize from this discrepancy between religious followers
and football supporters in England? Is there any way the nation of England
can take these trends into consideration and use them as leverage?
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
47/54
47
15. The Changing of the Guard
On Christmas in 2010 Queen Elizabeth II addressed the nation as she
does every year on what is considered the most important day of the Christian
calendar. This particular year, in a serendipitous storm of timing and
relevance, the Queen decided to discuss the significance of sport in England.
Her speech went as follows:
Over four hundred years ago, King James the Sixth of Scotland inheritedthe throne of England at a time when the Christian Church was deeply
divided. Here at Hampton Court in 1604, he convened a conference of
churchmen of all shades of opinion to discuss the future of Christianity
in this country. The King agreed to commission a new translation of the
Bible that was acceptable to all parties. This was to become the King
James or Authorized Bible, which next year will be exactly four centuries
old.
Acknowledged as a masterpiece of English prose and the most vivid
translation of the scriptures, the glorious language of this Bible hassurvived the turbulence of history and given many of us the most widely-
recognised and beautiful descriptions of the birth of Jesus Christ which
we celebrate today.
The King James Bible was a major cooperative endeavour that required
the efforts of dozens of the days leading scholars. The whole enterprise
was guided by an interest in reaching agreement for the wider benefit of
the Christian Church, and to bring harmony to the Kingdoms of England
and Scotland.
Four hundred years later, it is as important as ever to build communities
and create harmony, and one of the most powerful ways of doing this is
through sport and games. During this past year of abundant sporting
events, I have seen for myself just how important sport is in bringing
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
48/54
48
people together from all backgrounds, from all walks of life and from all
age-groups.
In the parks of towns and cities, and on village greens up and down the
country, countless thousands of people every week give up their time to
participate in sport and exercise of all sorts, or simply encourage others
to do so. These kinds of activity are common throughout the world and
play a part in providing a different perspective on life.
Apart from developing physical fitness, sport and games can also teach
vital social skills. None can be enjoyed without abiding by the rules, and
no team can hope to succeed without cooperation between the players.
This sort of positive team spirit can benefit communities, companies and
enterprises of all kinds.
As the success of recent Paralympics bears witness, a love of sport also
has the power to help rehabilitate. One only has to think of the injured
men and women of the Armed Forces to see how an interest in games
and sport can speed recovery and renew a sense of purpose, enjoyment
and comradeship.
Right around the world, people gather to compete under standard rules
and, in most cases, in a spirit of friendly rivalry. Competitors know that,
to succeed, they must respect their opponents; very often, they like each
other too.
Sportsmen and women often speak of the enormous pride they have in
representing their country, a sense of belonging to a wider family. We see
this vividly at the Commonwealth Games, for example, which is known to
many as the Friendly Games and where I am sure you have noticed that
it is always the competitors from the smallest countries who receive the
loudest cheers.
People are capable of belonging to many communities, including a
religious faith. King James may not have anticipated quite how
important sport and games were to become in promoting harmony and
common interests. But from the scriptures in the Bible which bears his
name, we know that nothing is more satisfying than the feeling of
belonging to a group who are dedicated to helping each other:
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
49/54
49
Therefore all things whatsoever ye would that men should to do to you,
do ye even so to them.
I wish you, and all those whom you love and care for, a very happy
Christmas."
(HM. Queen Elizabeth II)
From the mouth of the symbolic leader of England herself, we must
reassess what is important in our society today. While religion once served as
the quintessential uniting force of our culture, the times are changing. As we
now approach this seemingly eminent secular age, shall we resist adaptation or
shall we embrace change?
Initially even I had doubts concerning the legitimacy of my thesis, but
here we have direct evidence that England hopes to use sport as a potential
substitute for religion. In a land of jaded spirituality and disparate fervent
fandom, football may truly be the superior opium of the masses.
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
50/54
50
16. Conclusion: The Final Whistle
So many aspects of the modern world can be explained by science or
logic, but the unpredictable and fateful nature of sports still has the capability
to incite religious reactions much like those which were sought in ancient
sports rituals. In a sense, football is simply a simulation, a system that has
been set in place to tempt fate, challenge the expected, and provoke the
miraculous. One thing is for sure: uncertainty and the unknown will
inevitably give rise to the metaphysical (Oakley 158). In a world defined,
football could be our last beacon of God, the mysterious force which binds us
all.
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
51/54
51
Bibliography
Baker, William J. Playing with God: Religion and Modern Sport. Cambridge:
Harvard University Press, 2007. Print.
Barclays Premier League. Barclays Global Fans Report 2008 results. Premier
League. N.p., 11 Dec. 2008. Web. 3 Dec. 2010.
.
The Church of England. Latest figures show changing trends in church-going.
The Church of England. The Archbishops Council, 31 Jan. 2008. Web. 2
Dec. 2010. .
Coakley, Jay. Sports in Society: Issues and Controversies. 10th ed. Boston:
McGraw Hill Higher Education, 2009. Print.
Crabtree, Vexen. Religion in the United Kingdom: Diversity, Trends and
Decline. Vexen. N.p., 4 Aug. 2009. Web. 2 Dec. 2010.
.
Durkheim, Emile. The Elementary Forms of Religious Life.New York, NY: The
Free Press, 1995. Print.
Frosdick, S. and Marsh, P. (2005). Football Hooliganism. London: Willian
Publishing.
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
52/54
52
Guttman, Allen. From Ritual to Record. New York, NY: Columbia University
Press, 1978. Print.
Laderman, Gary. Sacred Matters: Celebrity Worship, Sexual Ecstasies, the Living
Dead, and Other Signs of Religious Life in the United States. New York:
The New Press, 2009. Print.
Mcdonald, Ian. 2011. Interview conducted at the University of Brighton,
January 10.
Melia, Jimmy. 2011. Interview conducted at the University of Brighton,
January 9.
Oakley, Chris. Football Delirium. London, England: Karnac Books Ltd, 2007.
Print.
Prebish, Charles. Football Delirium. Westport, Ct: Greenwood Press, 1993.
Print.
Reicher, S. (2003). The Psychology of crowd dynamics. In M. Hogg, S. Tindale
(Eds.), Blackwell handbook of social psychology: group processes (pp.
182-208). Oxford: Blackwell publishing.
Turner, Ralph H., and Lewis M. Killian. Collective Behavior, 2nded. Engleswood
Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice Hall, 1987.
-
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
53/54
53
WhyChurch. How many people go to church in the UK? Trends in UK Church
attendance. Web. 8 Jul. 2011.
.
http://www.whychurch.org.uk/trends.phphttp://www.whychurch.org.uk/trends.php -
8/13/2019 English Football, The Rise of Secular Religion
54/54
BIOGRAPHY
Benji Hill was born in Dallas Texas on January 17th, 1989. He
graduated from the University of Texas in 2011 with a major in Plan II Honors
and a Certificate in Business Foundations. As an active student he was theVice President of Phi Chi Theta Coed Business Fraternity as well as the co-
founder of the UT Disc Golf Club. Benji is an avid traveler and hopes to
postpone his career for the time being in order to explore the world.