ENGINEERS IRELAND CORK REGION Annual … EI_cork MM_JMcI...ENGINEERS IRELAND CORK REGION Annual...
Transcript of ENGINEERS IRELAND CORK REGION Annual … EI_cork MM_JMcI...ENGINEERS IRELAND CORK REGION Annual...
ENGINEERS IRELAND CORK REGION
Annual Seminar 2016
BIM – Practical Examples & Learnings
24th February 2016
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney, B.Eng, M.Eng, MEI.
Mott MacDonald
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region – Seminar 24-2-2016
• Introduction to Bergen Tram Project
• Project Narrative & Initial view of BIM results, video.
• Key Decisions in BIM Project development
• Useful Findings
• Construction Images
Agenda
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE
INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region
Seminar 24-2-2016
Introduction to BIM on Bergen Tram Project
• Mott MacDonald Ireland delivered worlds First Complete 3D Tramway Design for Construction (2013) in Norway (7.5km Line and 40 tram Depot)
• 2014 FIATECH Celebration of Engineering & Technology Innovation (CETI) Award Winning “Design Automation”
• Large Project Design Management Office, staff used to overseas projects
• Light Rail; Dublin Luas Tramway 1996-2011, Bergen Tramway 2012-Ongoing
• Other Power & Civils Projects; Bahamas, Abu Dhabi, Mauritania Empower, Roads
• 334 individual 3D models, with 1,913 individual controlled transmittals, over 3 years.
• Collaboration between MM offices with Project Engineering, BIM and Technical expertise
16,000 Employees 180 Offices Worldwide £1.2bn turn-over
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region - Seminar 24-2-2016
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region – Seminar 24-2-2016
Norway
Kingdom of Norway
Total Land Area of 385,000 square km.
(84,000 Square km)
Population 5,109,059
(6,378,000m)
4th highest per capita income in the world
Member of the European Economic Area
Largest per capita producer of oil outside
Middle East
Wage differences - between lowest and
highest
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region – Seminar 24-2-2016
Bergen
BERGEN
2nd biggest city in Norway
Population of 277,000 in the city
412,000 in the Greater Bergen Region
Principal city in Hordaland County
Hordaland Fylkeskommune is the
administrative authority for the county
Bergen Kommune – City Council
Tram is funded through local and national
government
2250mm rainfall pa (Dublin 730mm)
BERGEN
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region - Seminar 24-2-2016
THE PROJECT:
BERGEN TRAM STAGE 3 AND DEPOT
7.5 km of double track
Depot with 3 Buildings
7 Stops
10 bridge structures
Retaining Walls
Cut & Cover Tunnels
6 tunnels – 3.8km
Multi-storey carpark
Roads, public lighting and signalling
Utilities
Landscaping
Power – HV & LV
Control Systems
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region – Seminar 24-2-2016
Stage 1
(2010)
Stage 2 (2013)
Stage 3 (2016)
Depot (2015)
Flesland Terminal (2017)
Bybanen key Dates
BERGEN TRAM KEY DATES
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE
INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region
Seminar 24-2-2016
Project Team Collaboration• Project Team Collaboration
• Dublin : Civils / Elec & Rail Systems
• Cork : Roads, Bridges, Retaining Structures
• London: Tunnels
• Budapest : Tunnels
• Bristol : Geotechnical
• Prague & Brno : Bridges
• Bergen : Client Interface
• PiMS ProjectWise – Key Dates
• 2012 Q1,2 : Bergen Line Setup
• 2012 Q3 : Bergen Depot Setup
• 2013 Q1 : Add Project Stage Controls
• External Collaboration
• Client 3D Workshops
• Contractors / Local AuthoritiesTime - Quarters
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region – Seminar 24-2-2016
Use of BIM Modelling –
Railways
BIM Models Generated
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE
INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region
Seminar 24-2-2016
BIM Models Generated
Railway Depot Buildings
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE
INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region
Seminar 24-2-2016
BIM for Large Infrastructure projects
- video
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE
INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region
Seminar 24-2-2016
BIM for Large Infrastructure projects
- Important Decisions
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE
INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region
Seminar 24-2-2016
Important Decisions
- Software Selection
- Features
- Interoperability
- Staff capability
- Hardware & network requirements
- System Speed and Latency
- Client/Contractor compatibility
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE
INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region
Seminar 24-2-2016
Example of Software Selection (Interoperability)
P:
Revit
NovaPoint
Cads RC
Civil 3D
AECOsim
Bentley MX
Ben. Rebar
1.Engineering/
Modelling 2. Coordination
MicroStation
DGN
DWG
NWD
DWG
3 .Deliverables
Navisworks
NWD
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE
INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region
Seminar 24-2-2016
Important Decisions
- Selecting and Staffing Design Teams
- Work packaging
- Train/Hire
- Timing of Workload
- Design team must buy in to 3D delivery
- New Roles (Information Officer)
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE
INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region
Seminar 24-2-2016
- Important Decisions
- Level of Development & Detail
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE
INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region
Seminar 24-2-2016
Important Decisions
- 3D or 2D
- Depends on design team capabilities
- Project requirements
- Programme
- Budget
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE
INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region
Seminar 24-2-2016
Useful Findings
Useful Findings: Client Benefits of BIM
StakeholderVisualisation Model for Stakeholder
Construction Progress
Reputation
........MMD has produced a
fantastic 3d model which runs
through a very complex
terrain. From what i have
seen on other projects, this is
maybe the most complete and
advanced infrastructure model
you can find today.......
.......A lot of the things
MMD has done in this project
with 3d models will probably
set a benchmark for how
things, are presented in 3d in
future infrastructure projects
in Norway.Stian Veseth VESETH AS
Shared
Understanding
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE
INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region
Seminar 24-2-2016
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE
INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region
Seminar 24-2-2016
Useful Findings – QA & Workflow Tools
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE
INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region
Seminar 24-2-2016
Useful Findings
- BIM Management should allow changes to
plan if beneficial:
- Change to Navisworks in 2013
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE
INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region
Seminar 24-2-2016
Useful Findings
- Virtual walkthrough for Safety Assessments
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE
INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region
Seminar 24-2-2016
Useful Findings
3D in Design
Worked Well
Design appreciation across
disciplines
Access to wider design team
Sharing live information
Design development with
stakeholders
Geospatial coordination
Can Improve
Planning: sequencing and inter-
dependence of assumptions and
deliverables
Cut back on 2D drawings more
Reduce number of software
platforms (if possible)
100% model led designs
Improved awareness on
construction across teams
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region – Seminar 24-2-2016
3D Model - Setting Out
Useful Findings
- Construction Information
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region – Seminar 24-2-2016
3D Model - Setting Out
Useful Findings
- Construction Information
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region – Seminar 24-2-2016
3D Model - Setting Out
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region – Seminar 24-2-2016
• Information Directly from 3D
Model
• Appreciation of Construction
Interfaces
• Maintain Project Controls
3D Model - Setting Out
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region – Seminar 24-2-2016
3D Model - Setting Out
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE
INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region
Seminar 24-2-2016
Useful Findings – working with the models – Risks / Collaboration
Need a shared understanding
and accepted allocation of risk
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE
INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region
Seminar 24-2-2016
Useful Findings - Challenges
Time for changes, updates
Timing of activities
Resource management
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE
INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region
Seminar 24-2-2016
Useful Findings – Summary
Positive Experience,
many parties welcomed this new approach and took advantage of
the project.
Time savings on construction stage compared to traditional
projects
Needs buy in from all parties
Using BIM and a CDE makes the larger projects more
manageable, and can deliver project savings in time and quality.
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region – Seminar 24-2-2016
Construction Images
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region – Seminar 24-2-2016
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region – Seminar 24-2-2016
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region – Seminar 24-2-2016
2013IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE
INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region
Seminar 24-2-2016
2015
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE
INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott
MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region
Seminar 24-2-2016
IMPLEMENTING BIM ON LARGE INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
John McInerney – Mott MacDonald
Engineers Ireland Cork Region – Seminar 24-2-2016
12-2-2016