Engagement Brief FINAL
Transcript of Engagement Brief FINAL
-
8/9/2019 Engagement Brief FINAL
1/23
Adol
ConscentEitionsa
gageme
dPolicie
ntforAcsinWas
Hila
Maya
Lori
ademicington
Ju
ryLoeb
agarati
Pfingst
uccess:tate
ly2010
-
8/9/2019 Engagement Brief FINAL
2/23
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
WashingtonKidsCount(WKC)isaprojectoftheHumanServicesPolicyCenterattheUniversityof
WashingtonsEvansSchoolofPublicAffairs.ThemissionofWKCistoimprovethewellbeingofchildren
andfamiliesinWashingtonStateby:
Providingcomprehensivedataandinformationonthestateschildrenandfamiliesinthefollowingareas:economicsecurity,education,health,family&community,andsafety&
security;
Objectivelyanalyzingdataandconductingpolicyanalysistoinfluencepublicpolicyandprogramsthataffectchildrenandfamilies;
Workingincollaborationwithnational,state,andlocalpartnerstodevelopsolutionsandstrategiesthatimprovethelivesofchildrenandfamilies;and
ConductingoutreachwithkeyplayersinthepolicycommunitytobuildawarenessandunderstandingoftheissuesfacingchildrenandfamiliesinWashingtonState.
Wewould
like
to
thank
the
following
individuals
for
their
thoughtful
comments
and
assistance
in
preparingthispolicyreport:
LindaBecker
WashingtonStateDepartmentofSocialandHealthServices
KimBobby
UniversityofPugetSound
PeterBylsma
IndependentConsultant
JuliaDilley
MultnomahCountyHealthDepartment/OregonDepartmentofHumanServices
RobinFleming
FranklinHighSchoolandSchmitzParkElementary,SeattlePublicSchools
MariOffenbecher
SchoolsOutWashington
AntonySmith
UniversityofWashington,Bothell
Wewouldliketothankthefollowinggroupsandindividualsfortheirassistanceinprovidingdatafor
thispolicyreport:
LillianBensley
WashingtonStateDepartmentofHealth
DennisJones,
Patrick
Kelly
NationalCenterforHigherEducationManagementSystems
DavidPrince
WashingtonStateBoardofCommunityandTechnicalColleges
ThisreportwasmadepossiblebygeneroussupportfromtheAnnieE.CaseyFoundationandtheBill&
MelindaGatesFoundation.
-
8/9/2019 Engagement Brief FINAL
3/23
1
Introduction
Manyofusprobablyrememberatimewhen,asstudents,weweredeeplyengagedinwhatwe
werelearning.Maybeitwasthemomentwhenwefinallyunderstoodadifficultmathconcept.
Orperhapsitwaswhenwelearnedtoplaythatfirstsongonaninstrument,orthedaywefelt
inspiredby
alively
book
discussion
in
an
English
class,
or
the
time
our
soccer
team
won
a
pivotalmatch.Wemayfondlyrecalltheinfluenceofacaringteacherwhonoticedourtalents.A
commonthreadacrosstheseexperiencesistheattentionandpurposethatwebroughtto
thesetasks.Whenstudentsareengagedtheyaremorelikelytolearn,whichimprovestheir
chancesforsuccessinschoolandinlife.
PoliciesandprogramsaimedatimprovingstudentengagementcancontributetoPresident
ObamasgoalforallAmericanstoattendatleastoneyearofcollege. Studentswhoaredeeply
engagedinhighschoolhavehigherachievementrates,greatercommitmenttolearning,and
areless
likely
to
drop
out
than
students
with
low
engagement.
Most
importantly,
students
who
areengagedinschoolaremorelikelytoattendcollege,anincreasinglycriticalcomponentto
futureeconomicsecurity.
Forevery100studentsentering9thgradeinWashington,just17willgoonto
obtainacollegedegreewithinsixyearsofgraduatingfromhighschool.
BothnationallyandinWashingtonState,currenttrendssuggestthateffortstoimprovestudent
engagementcouldhaveasignificantimpact. Currently,lessthanthreequarters(73percent)of
9thgradersintheU.S.graduateinfouryears.1Only35percentofournations12
thgraders
scoreatoraboveproficiencyontheNationalAssessmentofEducationalProgressinreading.2
Further,theachievementlevelsofU.S.studentsofallageslagbehindmanyoftheirpeers
aroundtheworld.ComparingeducationstatisticsfromtheOrganisationforEconomicCo
operationandDevelopment3nations,15yearoldsintheUnitedStatesareranked15
thof29
countriesforreadingandinthebottomsixnationsinmathematicsperformanceonthe
Program
for
International
Student
Assessment.
4
DataonWashingtonshighschoolstudentsparallelnationaltrendsinachievementand
attainment,butWashingtonisdoingworsethanmanystatesinsupportingstudentsthrough
theeducationalpipeline.Figure1illustratesthatasizableproportionofourstudentsexit
schoolpriortocompletinghighschoolorcollege.Forevery1009thgradersenteringhigh
schoolin1996,only69earnedadiploma,and33enrolledincollege.Ofthose33students,just
-
8/9/2019 Engagement Brief FINAL
4/23
2
24enrolledintheirsecondyearofcollege,and17ultimatelygraduatedwitheitheran
associatesorbachelorsdegree.WashingtonStateisranked33rd
lowestinthecountryfor
supportinghighschoolstudentsthroughtheeducationalpipeline.Inhighlyrankedstateslike
Massachusetts,NewHampshire,andSouthDakota,closeto30percentof9thgradersearnan
AAwithinthreeyearsoraBAwithinsixyears.5
Figure1:WashingtonsLeakyEducationalPipeline
Forevery100studentsentering9th
gradeinWashington
WashingtonStateismakingaconcertedefforttoinvestinprogramsthatmayinfluence
adolescentengagementandimprovehighschoolgraduationandcollegeenrollment.For
example,BasicEducationlegislationpassedin2009authorizedanincreaseinhighschool
graduationrequirements.Recentpublic,private,andphilanthropicpartnershipswillbroaden
accesstoNavigation101andAdvancementviaIndividualDetermination(AVID),twoprograms
aimedatenhancingacademicguidanceandstudentstudyskills.ThroughtheBuildingBridges
Program,school
districts
have
piloted
the
use
of
early
warning
systems
in
order
to
identify
studentsatriskofdroppingoutandreengagetheminschool.SchoolsOutWashingtonisinthe
processofimplementinganumberofinitiativestoimproveoutofschooltimeandafterschool
programsacrossthestate.
ThispolicyreportshareswhatweknowaboutstudentengagementinWashingtonState.To
contributetodiscussionsaboutstateleveleducationalreformefforts,wefirstdiscussthe
Source:NationalCenterforHigherEducationManagementSystems2009
-
8/9/2019 Engagement Brief FINAL
5/23
3
conceptofschoolengagementandidentifythefactorsassociatedwithit.Wethenshare
evidencefromWashingtonStatesHealthyYouthSurvey(HYS),adatasetthatcaptures
studentsperceptionsoftheconditionsinfluencingengagementinlearninginsideandoutside
ofschool.Wesummarizecurrentandemergingstatepoliciesandprogramsthatwillinfluence
adolescentschoolengagementintheyearstocome.Finally,weconcludewithadiscussionof
howafocus
on
student
engagement
can
improve
learning
opportunities,
performance,
and
attainment.
Whiledroppingoutofschoolisthemostextremeformofdisengagement,itis
oftenthefinalstageofalongprocessofdisconnectingfromschoolthatbegins
intheearliestyearsoflearning.
WhatisEngagement?
Schoolengagementcomprisesthebeliefsandbehaviorsthatdemonstratethatstudentsvalue
learninginsidetheclassroom.Engagementhasbeenfoundtoimprovestudentsacademic
performance,6promoteschoolattendance,andinhibitriskyadolescentbehavior.7Theconcept
helpsillustratethecomplexityoftherelationshipthatstudentshavewiththeireducation.By
exploringstudentengagement,wecanbetterunderstandadolescentsspecificactions,values,
andinvestmentsinlearning.Nurturingstudentengagementisalsocompellingbecause
researchpoints
to
numerous
effective
approaches
in
schools
and
communities
to
improve
this
condition.
DimensionsofEngagement
Therearethreeinterrelateddimensionsofschoolengagement(Figure2).8Behavioral
engagementreflectsstudentsinvolvementinacademicandextracurricularactivities.Examples
ofbehavioralengagementincludestudentsschoolattendanceandwhetherstudents
participatein
school
clubs
or
teams.
Emotional
engagement
includes
positive
and
negative
reactionstoteachers,peers,academicsubjects,andschooloverall.Indicatorsofemotional
engagementincludethewaysthatstudentsseetheirschoolsascaring,safeenvironmentsor
thewaystheyhaveavoiceinimportantschoolmatters.Whilebehavioralengagementis
viewedascriticalforfosteringpositiveacademicoutcomes,emotionalengagementcan
strengthenschooltiesandinfluencestudentswillingnesstodotheirwork.Cognitive
-
8/9/2019 Engagement Brief FINAL
6/23
4
engagement,whichrepresentsstudentsmotivationtoexerttheeffortnecessarytomaster
difficultskills,mayincludemeasuresofparticipationinrigorousprograms.
Figure2:DimensionsandKeyInfluencesofEngagement
Whileschoolengagementiscriticalforallstudents,theconsequencesofdisengagementvarya
greatdealacrossdifferentgroupsofstudents.9Disadvantagedstudentsarelesslikelytogetthe
secondchancesthattheiradvantagedpeersreceivewhentheybecomedisengaged.When
disadvantagedstudentsfailtoearnbasiccredentialsordeveloptheskillsrequiredtoflourishin
thelabormarket,theyhaveanincreasedriskofpoverty,poorhealth,andinvolvementwiththe
criminaljusticesystem.Whiledroppingoutofschoolisthemostextremeformof
disengagement,itisoftenthefinalstageofalongprocessofdisconnectingfromschoolthat
beginsintheearliestyearsoflearning.10
KeyInfluencesofEngagement
Thesenseofpurposethatcomeswithschoolengagementispresentwhenthreecritical
psychologicalneedsamongadolescentsaremet.Adolescentsbeliefsaboutcompetenceand
controlreflectwhethertheyseethemselvesasabletomasterchallengingintellectualtasks.
Studentsvaluesandgoalsaretiedtowhethertheyaremotivatedtocompleteschoolwork.
Lastly,socialconnectednessillustratestheirsenseofbelonginginschool.11
Families,peersand
communitiescanallhelpmeettheseneeds.
-
8/9/2019 Engagement Brief FINAL
7/23
5
Familiesplayacriticalroleinhelpingadolescentsthriveinschool.12
Warm,responsive
parenting,13parentalattemptstotakeresponsibilityfortheirchildrenslearning,andeffortsto
bringparentstotheschoolphysically,14
15arerelatedtoacademicsuccess.Parentingstylesvary
byincomelevel16
andracial/ethnicbackground,17
requiringschoolstodevelopculturally
competentapproachestooutreach.
Likeparents,peerscanbothpositivelyandnegativelyinfluenceadolescents'school
engagement.Highschoolstudentsfrequentlydevelopfriendshipswithintheiracademictrack
orgroupofcourses.18
Onestudythatfollowedhighschoolstudentsovertimeconcludedthat
thepositiveeffectsofhighachievingandlowachievingfriendswereofsimilarmagnitude.19
In
somecases,however,thenegativeinfluencesofpeerrelationshipsmaybereinforcedwhen
groupsofdisengagedstudentsspendalotoftimetogether.20
Emergingevidencehighlightsthe
importanceofsocialmediatechnologiesliketexting,Facebook,andTwitterinadolescents
lives. Socialmediamayofferuniqueopportunitiestoengagepeersincultivatingschool
engagement.21
Thelargercommunitieswherestudentsattendschoolalsoexertanimportanteffectonschool
engagement.Whiledisengagementisachallengeinallsettings,theproblemisgreatestin
communitiesthatareeconomicallyandsociallymarginalized.22
Arangeofapproaches,
includingoutofschooltimeprograms,23
schoolcommunityconnections,andservicelearning24
arepromisingwaystoimprovestudentengagement.Notonlycantheseprogramsdecreasethe
unsupervisedactivitieswhereadolescentsmaydevelopnegativeattitudesaboutschool,they
canofferopportunitiesforadolescentstodemonstratecompetenceandfeelasenseof
belonging.25
StudentEngagementinWashingtonState
Tobetterunderstandadolescentsschoolengagement,werevieweddataabout(a)how
studentscharacterizetheircommitmenttoschooland(b)theaspectsoftheirschools,families
andcommunitiesthatarelinkedtoschoolengagement.iTable1providesasummaryofthe
itemswereviewedandhowtheyarelinkedtokeyschoolengagementconcepts.We
summarizeresponses
from
all
participating
grades,
but
focus
specifically
on
10th
graders
when
makingcomparisonsbasedongender,race,ethnicity,homelanguage,andsocioeconomic
status.Inaddition,wereportonschoolengagement,familyinvolvement,andcommunity
supports.26
iFortechnicalnotesontheanalysis,pleasevisithttp://www.hspc.org/topics/TechAppendixI_HYSData.pdfand
http://www.hspc.org/topics/TechAppendixII_HYSVariableCodes.pdf.ThesenotesprovidedetailsoftheHYSsample,theitemsweselectedfor
analysis,andthestatisticaltechniquesweusedtoexplorethedata.
-
8/9/2019 Engagement Brief FINAL
8/23
6
DespitetherichnessoftheHYS,therearetwolimitationstotheanalysisinthisreport.
First,lessthanhalfof12th
gradestudentseligibletoparticipateinthesurveyresponded,
limitingthereliabilityofdataforthisgroup. Therefore,weinterpretthedataon12th
graders
withcaution. Second,the10th
and12th
gradesamplesdonotincludetheperspectivesof
studentswhohavealreadydroppedout,sotheperspectivesofourmostdisengagedstudents
fromlearning
are
not
included.
Table1:EngagementConceptsIncludedintheHealthyYouthSurvey
DimensionofEngagement HYSTopic
Behavioral DaysofschoolstudentmissedinlastmonthWhetherstudenttriedbestinschoollastyear
Emotional HowmuchstudentenjoysbeinginschoolHowmuchstudenthatesbeinginschool ImportanceofschoolworkforfutureMeaningfulnessandimportanceofschoolwork
Cognitive Gradeslastyear Levelofinterestinschoolcourses
InfluencesofEngagement
Peers QuestionsaboutfourbestfriendsFamilies Parentstellstudentstheyaredoingagoodjob
ParentswouldcatchstudentskippingschoolParentsaskstudentiftheycompletedhomework
Schools SchoolletsparentsknowwhenstudentisdoingwellOpportunitiesforextracurricularactivities Teacherletsstudentknowhe/sheisdoingagoodjobOpportunitiesforoneononetimewithteachers
Communities Opportunitiesforcommunityactivities
Findings:Behavioral,
Emotional,
and
Cognitive
Engagement
in
School
TheWashingtonStateHealthyYouthSurvey(HYS)
Studentperspectivesareavaluableandunderutilizedwaytogainanunderstandingof
conditionsin
schools.i
The
Washington
HYS
is
the
richest
source
of
statewide
data
capturing
thevoicesofstudentsinthe6th,8th,10th,and12thgrades.Administeredbiannually,the
surveyasksstudentsaboutarangeofriskandprotectivefactors,includingschool
engagement.TheHYSisusedforarangeofpurposes,includinglocalandstateplanning,
schoolandcommunityimprovementefforts,preventionprograms,andresearch.
-
8/9/2019 Engagement Brief FINAL
9/23
7
Nearly40percentofstudentsin6th,8th,10th,and12thgradesinWashington
areathighriskofdisengagementfromschool.
Findings:Behavioral,Emotional,andCognitiveEngagementinSchool
Adolescentsschoolengagementdecreasesinthehighergrades. Nearly40percentof
studentsin6th,8th,10th,and12thgradesareathighriskofdisengagementfromschool.This
riskisdefinedthroughaseriesofHYSquestionsaboutbehavioral,emotional,andcognitive
engagementthatindicatehowstudentsvaluetheirexperiencesinschool.Reinforcing
conclusionsfromotherstudies,27
Chart1illustratesthatafewcriticalaspectsofschool
engagementdecreaseinthehighergrades.Forexample,while81percentofsixthgraders
reportthattheybelievewhattheyarelearninginschoolwillbeimportantlaterinlife,just53
percentof10thgradersand46percentof12thgradersreportthisbelief.Similarly,declining
percentageofstudentsagreethatassignedschoolworkisusuallymeaningfulandimportant.
Tenthand12thgradersarealsomorelikelytoreporttheyhavecutschoolinthelastmonth
thanstudentsinlowergrades.
Chart1
PercentofStudentsResponding"Yes"toSelectEngagementIndicatorsbyGrade
Washington2008
57%
81%
92%
45%
66%
79%
38%
53%
73%
33%
46%
69%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
SchoolworkUsually
Meaningful
LearningImportantforFuture TryBestinSchoolMostof
Time
6th 8th 10th 12th
Source:HealthyYouthSurvey2008
-
8/9/2019 Engagement Brief FINAL
10/23
8
Black,Latino,NativeHawaiian,andNativeAmericanstudentshaveamoretenuous
connectiontoschoolthantheirWhiteandAsiancounterparts.Overonethird(38percent)of
10thgradestudentsreportlowengagementinschool,butstudentsfromcertainracialand
ethnicbackgroundsareespeciallyatrisk.28,29
Over40percentofBlack,Latino,NativeHawaiian,
andNative
American
students
reported
that
their
grades
last
year
were
mostly
Cs,
Ds,
and
Fs,
comparedto29and14percentofWhiteandAsianstudents,respectively.Inaddition,closeto
onethirdofBlack(33percent),andLatinostudents(31percent)andoveronequarterof
NativeHawaiian(29percent)andNativeAmericanstudents(26percent)reportedskipping
schoolatleastonceinthepreviousmonth,ascomparedwith20percentofWhitestudentsand
17percentofAsianstudents.30
NativeAmerican(27percent),Black(25percent),andLatino(23
percent)studentsaremorelikelytoreportfeelingunsafeinschoolthanAsian(20percent)and
White(16percent)students.
Childrenin
immigrant
families
see
greater
purpose
in
what
they
are
learning
in
school.
By
comparingtheresponsesofstudentswhospeakEnglishathometotheresponsesofthosewho
speakanotherlanguage,Chart2suggeststhatchildreninimmigrantfamiliesmayseegreater
purposeinwhattheyarelearninginschool.
Chart2
Percentof10th
GradeStudentsReporting"Yes"onSelectEngagementIndicators
byLanguageSpokeninHome,Washington2008
36%
51%47%
67%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
SchoolworkUsuallyMeaningful LearningImportantforFuture
EnglishSpokeninHome OtherLanguageSpokeninHome
Source:HealthyYouthSurvey2008
-
8/9/2019 Engagement Brief FINAL
11/23
9
Forexample,overtwothirds(67percent)ofstudentswhospeakalanguageotherthanEnglish
athomereportedthatlearningisimportantforthefutureascomparedwithhalf(51percent)
ofstudentswhospeakEnglishathome.However,studentswhodidnotspeakEnglishathome
alsohavehigherratesoftruancythanstudentslivinginEnglishspeakinghouseholds(33
percentvs.21percent). MoreresearchisneededonwhythismightbethecaseinWashington,
butnational
studies
suggest
that
parental
behaviors
supporting
childrens
education
differ
by
racialandethnicbackground. Inaddition,studentsofcertainracial/ethnicbackgroundsare
morelikelytoworkgreaterthan20hoursperweek. AmongWashington10th
graders,for
example,9percentofstudentsfromnonEnglishspeakinghouseholdsworkmorethan20
hoursperweek,comparedtojust2percentofthosefromEnglishspeakinghouseholds.
Studentslivinginfamilieswithlowersocioeconomicstatus(SES)aremorelikelytoreport
poorgradesandskippingschoolthanhigherSESstudents. Whilestudentsfrombothlowand
highSESfamiliesreportedsimilarlevelsofschoolengagement,surveyresponsesshow
differencesbetween
these
groups
in
school
achievement.
Chart
3illustrates
that
students
from
lowSESfamiliesweremorelikelytoreportlowgradesandskippingschoolduringtheprevious
month,keyriskfactorsfordroppingoutofschool.31
Chart3
Percentof10th
GradeStudentsReportingLowGradesandSkippingSchoolbyMothersEducation
Washington2008
40%
29%28%
18%19%
22%
0%
20%
40%
MostlyCs,
Ds,
Fs
Last
Year Skipped/Cut
At
Least
One
Day
Last
Month
LessthanHighS chool S omeCollege BAorHigher
Adolescentboysarelesslikelytobeengagedthangirls. Consistentwithnationalconcerns
abouteducationaldisparitiesbetweenboysandgirls,32
ourfindingssuggestthatmale10th
Source:HealthyYouthSurvey2008
-
8/9/2019 Engagement Brief FINAL
12/23
10
gradersarelesslikelytobeengagedinschoolthantheirfemalecounterparts.Overall,girlshad
higherratesofschoolengagement,withthemostpronounceddifferenceshowninstudents
reportsoftryingtheirbestinschool. Seventyninepercent(79percent)offemale10th
graders
reportedtheytriedtheirbestinschoollastyearcomparedto66percentofmale10th
graders
(Chart4).Inaddition,agreaterpercentageofgirls(73percent)thanboys(63percent)reported
goodgrades
(mostly
As
and
Bs)
in
the
previous
year.
Chart4
Percentof10th
GradeStudentsReportingTheyTriedTheirBestinSchoolMostoftheTimeLastYear
bySex,Washington2008
66%
79%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
Male Female
Findings:SchoolandParentSupportsforEngagement
Parentandschoolsupportsdeclineasstudentsgetolder. Parallelingschoolengagement
trends,parentengagementandschoolsupportalsodecreaseinlatergrades(Chart5).For
example,whilecloseto80percentof6thgradersreportthatteacherstellthemwhentheyare
doingagood
job,
this
is
only
the
case
for
70
percent
of
10th
and
12th
graders.
Furthermore,
studentsexpressthatschoolsarenotsharinggoodnewswiththeirfamilies.Fiftyonepercent
of6thgradersreportthattheirschoolletstheirparentsknowwhentheyhavedonewell
comparedwith28percentof12thgraders.Comparedto12th
gradestudents,studentsin8th
gradearealsomorelikelytoreportthattheirparentsaskiftheyhavedonetheirhomework(90
percentand75percent,respectively)orwouldcatchthemiftheyskippedschool(85percent
and62percent,respectively).
Source:HealthyYouthSurvey2008
-
8/9/2019 Engagement Brief FINAL
13/23
11
Chart5
Percent
of
Students
Reporting
School
Lets
Parents
Know
When
They
Have
Done
Well
by
Grade
Level,
Washington2008
51%
39%
29% 28%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
6th 8th 10th 12th
Studentsof
color,
low
SES
students,
and
female
students
are
least
likely
to
have
parents
monitoringschoolwork. Disparitiesinparentalmonitoringbehaviorwerepresentfordifferent
racialandethnicgroups,SESgroups,aswellasforgirlsandboys.While58percentofBlack
studentsand67percentofNativeAmericanstudentsreportedtheirparentswouldcatchthem
iftheyskippedschool,nearlythreequarters(74percent)ofstudentsfromothergroupsnoted
thiswasthecase.Black(72percent)andLatino(77percent)studentswerelesslikelytoreport
thattheirparentswouldaskiftheirhomeworkwasdonethantheapproximately8in10
studentsfromothergroupsnotingthisparentalbehavior.
Economically
disadvantaged
students
also
reported
lower
levels
of
parental
monitoring
of
their
schoolattendanceandschoolwork.Forexample,studentsfromlowSESfamiliesnotedthat
theirparentswerelesslikelytocatchthemwhentheyskippedschool(68percentlowSESvs.
77percenthighSESstudents)oraskiftheirhomeworkwasdone(79percentlowSESvs.88
percenthighSESstudents).Whilenearly70percentofhighSESstudentsreportedtheirparents
noticedgoodwork,thiswastrueforonly56percentoflowSESstudents.Whilegirlsreported
Source:HealthyYouthSurvey2008
-
8/9/2019 Engagement Brief FINAL
14/23
12
higherlevelsofschoolengagement,boysnotedmorefrequentlythattheirparentswereproud
andnoticedgoodworkmoreoften(bothquestions:63percentboysvs.57percentgirls).
Findings:School
and
Community
Involvement
Lessthantwothirdsofstudentsreportparticipatinginsupervisedafterschoolactivitieseither
atschoolorawayfromschool. Whileotheraspectsofengagementdecreaseinthehigher
grades,opportunitiesforschoolandcommunityinvolvementappeartobesimilaracrossgrade
levels.Chart6illustratesthatamajorityofstudents(84percent)reportthatsportsand
recreationalopportunitiesareavailableintheircommunities.Otheroutofschooltime
opportunitiesareavailabletoalesserdegree71percentofstudentsreportthepresenceof
activityclubs(e.g.,BoysandGirlsClubsorYMCA)67percentofstudentsreportopportunities
toparticipate
in
service
clubs
(e.g.,
4H
or
Girl
Scouts).
Despite
these
opportunities,
less
than
twothirdsofstudents(61percent,64percent,and65percentof12th,10th,and8thgraders,
respectively)reportparticipatinginsupervisedafterschoolactivitieseitheratschooloraway
fromschool.
Chart6
PercentofStudentsinGrades6,8,10,and12ReportingOpportunitiesforActivitiesinthe
Community,Washington2008
84%
67%71%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
Sports&Recreation CommunityServiceClubs(4H,
Scouts)
CommunityActivityClubs
(YMCA,Boys&Girls)
Source:HealthyYouthSurvey2008
-
8/9/2019 Engagement Brief FINAL
15/23
13
Latinostudentsarelesslikelytoparticipateinextracurricularactivitiescomparedtostudents
fromotherracialandethnicgroups.Tenthgradersfromcertainracialandethnicbackgrounds
weremorelikelytoreportalackofopportunityforcommunityservice.Approximately50
percentofBlack,Latino,andNativeAmericanstudentsreportedthepresenceofcommunity
serviceopportunitiescomparedwithapproximately70percentofAsianandWhitestudents,
and60
percent
of
Native
Hawaiian
and
Pacific
Islanders.
While
there
were
slightly
lower
participationratesinsupervisedafterschoolactivitiesamongunderservedracialandethnic
groups,thelackofparticipationamongLatinoswasstriking.Justoverhalf(53percent)ofLatino
studentsreportedparticipationinextracurricularactivitiescomparedwithroughlytwothirds
(between63percentand70percent)ofstudentsfromotherracialandethnicgroups(see
Chart7).
TwootherdemographicgroupslowSESstudentsandmalestudentsalsonotedfewer
communityopportunitiesandlessextracurricularparticipation.Threequarters(76percent)of
highSES
students
reported
participation
in
weekly
supervised
after
school
activities,
this
was
thecaseforonly56percentoflowSESstudents.Girlswerenotonlymorelikelytoreport
opportunitiesintheircommunitiesforathletics,service,andactivityclubsbutalsotonote
participatinginsupervisedafterschoolactivitiesingreaternumbers(67percentvs.61percent).
Chart7
Percentof10th
GradeStudentsReportingTheyParticipatedinSupervisedAfterschoolActivitiesAt
LeastOneDayaWeek,Washington2008
70% 69% 68% 66% 63%
53%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
Asian NativeHawaiianorPacific
Islander
AfricanAmerican White Nativ eAmerican LatinoorHispanic
Source:HealthyYouthSurvey2008
-
8/9/2019 Engagement Brief FINAL
16/23
14
KeyReformsAffectingAdolescentsinWashingtonState
In2008,morethanoneinfour(27percent)ninthgradersinWashingtonStatedidnotgraduate
withinfouryears.33
Toaddressthisconcerningtrend,WashingtonStatehasimplementeda
numberofthereformslistedbelowtoimproveadolescentsengagement,achievement,and
postsecondary
opportunities.
The
goals
of
these
policies
and
programs
are
threefold
(a)
to
increasetherigorofinstruction;(b)topersonalizethelearningexperienceforyouthandensure
thateachhasaccesstoaconsistent,caringadult;and(c)toseektoimprovethesystemof
providingsupporttoyouththroughprofessionaldevelopmentandtechnicalassistancefor
instructors.
AnumberofK12reformsalsoholdpromiseforimprovingadolescentengagement.For
example,theAchievementGapOversightandAccountabilityCommitteehasputforward
promisingstrategiesforaddressingtheachievementgapforhistoricallyunderserved
students.34Recent
legislation
was
passed
to
intervene
in
the
states
lowest
performing
schools.
ImprovementstoWashingtonStateseducationaldatasystemwillenableanalysisofcourse
takingpatterns,linkagesacrosssecondaryandpostsecondarysettings,andtheuseofdatain
earlywarningsystemstoidentifystudentsatriskfordroppingoutofschool.
AdvancementviaIndividualDetermination(AVID).In2008,OSPIandCollegeSparkannounced
anineyear,$9.5millionCollegeReadinessInitiativethatwillsupportwidespread
implementationofAVIDandNavigation101(seebelow).AVIDaimstoincreasestudents
abilitiestosucceedincollegepreparatorycourses.Inadditiontoelectivecourses,students
attendpeer
tutorials
with
atrained
tutor
facilitator,
and
participate
in
time
management,
study,andorganizationalskills.AVIDteachersalsoaccessprofessionaldevelopmentactivities
thatenablethembettersupporttheirstudentsinrigorouscoursework.35
BuildingBridgesProgram.Between20092010,BuildingBridgesmadegrantsthroughOSPIto
partnershipsofschools,families,andcommunitiestosupportdropoutprevention,
intervention,andretrievalsystemsthatidentifystudentswhoareatatriskforleavingschool
beforegraduationandtoprovidetimelyinventionsandsupports.BuildingBridgesserved36
schooldistrictsin85identifiedbuildingsandprograms.36
Beginninginthesummerof2010,
BuildingBridges
will
convene
aworkgroup
to
make
recommendations
to
develop
astate
school
improvementmodelthatfocusesonintegratedstudentsupportsandinterventionsthat
improvestudentachievementbylinkingstudentstocommunityresourcestomeettheir
academicandsocialserviceneeds.
-
8/9/2019 Engagement Brief FINAL
17/23
15
CollegeSuccessFoundation(CSF).CSFworkstoexpandeducationalopportunitiesbygrowing
thenumberofcollegegraduatesamonglowincomeyouth.InWashingtonState,CSFprovides
academic,informational,andfinancialsupportstostudentsandtheirfamilies,andadvocates
forincreased
college
readiness
and
college
access.
In
2010,
CSF
launched
Washington
College
AccessNetwork(WCAN),whichwasdevelopedtoimprovepreparationandaccesstohigher
educationthroughsupportingbestpractices,trainingopportunities,andpublicpolicies.37
CORE24.Core24isasetofnewhighschoolgraduationrequirementsthatisdesignedto
providestudentswithasolidacademicfoundationtopreparethemforarangeofpost
secondarypaths.PartoftheWashingtonStateBoardofEducationsMeaningfulHighSchool
DiplomaInitiative,CORE24willincreasethenumberofcoursesthatstudentswillneedtotake
inmanyschooldistrictstograduate,alteringrequirementsthathavenotchangedsince1985.
Currently,the
CORE
24
Task
Force
of
educators
across
the
state
is
working
on
an
implementationstrategyfortheprograms2013phasein.38
Navigation101.Navigation101offerspersonalizedsupporttohighschoolstudentsandtheir
familiesandhelpsthemexploretheirpostsecondaryopportunities.ComponentsofNavigation
101includecurriculumdrivenadvisorycourses,studentplanningportfoliosthatsetgoalsand
monitorprogress,studentledconferenceswithfamilymembersandtheiradvisoryleader,and
studentdrivenscheduling,inwhichstudentsarepromptedtoselectchallengingcoursesand
schoolwork.EvaluationoftheCollegeReadinessInitiative,criticaltoprogramoptimization,will
informthe
integration
of
Navigation
101
within
acomprehensive
guidance
and
counseling
program.39
SchoolsOutWashington(SOWA).SOWAworkstoincreasethenumberofaffordableand
qualityafterschoolandyouthdevelopment(AYD)programsfor518yearoldsinthestate
throughtraining,advocacyandleadership. SOWAcurrentlysupportsarangeofreform
projects. Theseincludeeffortstoimprovethequalityofcarethroughrevisingtheminimum
licensingrequirementsforschoolagechildcare,effortstoimplementandevaluate
professionaldevelopmentforAYDprovidersthroughthePathwaytoExcellence,andthe
ImprovingProgram
Quality
projects
that
offer
on
site
coaching
support.
The
Feed
Your
Brain
projectsupportsthestateshighpoverty,ruralcommunitiesthroughprovidingliteracy
activitiesandnutritiousmealsduringthesummermonths.40
SOWAworkswith12school
districtsthroughtheRefugeeSchoolImpactProjecttosupporttheacademicperformanceof
refugeestudents.41
-
8/9/2019 Engagement Brief FINAL
18/23
16
ThreePrioritiesforIncreasingStudentEngagementinWashingtonState
ThefindingspresentedinthisbriefhighlighttheschoolengagementneedsofWashingtonState
adolescents.Asizableproportionofyouthinourstateareatgreatriskofdisengagementfrom
school,andthisriskincreasesinthehighergrades.Ourcomparisonsacrossincome,race,
ethnicity,and
sex
highlight
noteworthy
disparities
in
engagement
and
related
parent
and
communitysupports.ButthelowlevelsofschoolengagementamongbothhighandlowSES
10thgradersindicatethatdisengagementisaproblemacrosstheboardforthestatesschools
andcommunities.
WashingtonStatespoliciesandprogramssupportingschoolengagementareunderfunded.
Currently,certainpromisingeffortsarenotpresentinschooldistrictsorregions,andwould
benefitmorestudentsiftheywerebroughttoscale.Forexample,duringthe200910school
year,Navigation101isbeingimplementedin82ofthestatesschool295schooldistricts.42
Fortyone
school
districts
and
128
sites
are
using
the
AVID
program.43
Due
to
the
economic
downturn,fundingforsupportingprogramsthroughBuildingBridgesisuncertainafterthe
summerof2010.DespitecutstoanumberofprogramsintheStateEducationbudgetduring
thelastlegislativesession,boththefederalRacetotheTopandInvestinginInnovation
applicationscouldbringnewresourcesintothestatethatwouldsupportschoolengagement
initiatives.
ThelowlevelsofschoolengagementamongbothhighandlowSES10thgraders
indicatethatdisengagementisaproblemacrosstheboardforschoolsand
communitiesinWashingtonState.
Boththeeconomicdownturnandpossibilityofnewfederalfundingineducationreflectan
evolvingpolicyagendaaroundschoolengagement.Weputforwardthreeprioritiesforcurrent
andfuturepoliciesandprogramsinWashingtonStatethatemergedfromourstudyfindings.
Together,thesereflectacomprehensiveapproachwhichdrawsontheresourcesofschools,
families,and
communities
to
meet
adolescents
needs.
First,
students
need
academic
supports
tobesuccessfulinrigorousacademicwork.Second,studentsneedindividualizedattention
fromcaringadultsinarangeofsettings.Third,coordinationbetweenK12,postsecondary,and
outofschooltimeprogramscanenhanceschoolengagement.
-
8/9/2019 Engagement Brief FINAL
19/23
17
Priority1:Studentsneedacademicsupportstobesuccessfulinrigorousacademicwork.
Whileincreasingrigorcanhelpaddressconcernsaboutboredomamongadolescents,many
highschoolstudentsareunderpreparedforchallengingwork.44
InWashingtonState,10th
grade
boys,studentsofcolor,andlowSESstudentsreportedbothhigherlevelsofCs,Ds,andFsand
skippingschool,
raising
serious
concern
about
the
risk
of
disengagement
and
dropping
out
amongthesegroups.Thismaybepartiallytheresultoflowlevelsofparentalengagementin
school,communityopportunities,andextracurricularparticipation.Aschildrenofimmigrants
nowcompriseclosetoonefourth(22percent)ofthestatespopulationunder18,45
thegreater
purposeinschoolingseenbychildrenwithahomelanguageotherthanEnglishreflectsan
opportunityforschoolsandoutofschooltimeprogramstorespondtotheiroptimism.
Statewidepoliciesandprogramsincludearangeofapproachesaimedatimprovingstudent
achievementandpreparationforpostsecondarysuccess.However,someinvolveonlyafraction
ofthe
students
who
can
benefit
from
supports.
Black,
Latino,
and
American
Indian/Alaskan
NativestudentsaresignificantlyunderrepresentedinAPcourses,suggestingthatequitable
accesstorigorisaprobleminWashingtonState.46
Torespondtothisissue,AVIDincludes
classesandtutoringdesignedtoimprovestudentsperformanceincollegepreparatory
coursework.
Whenimplemented,CORE24willbepoisedtoincreasetherigorininstructionacrossthestate.
However,theAchievementGapOversightandAccountabilityCommitteeraisesconcernsabout
theimplicationsofthispolicybecauseahighpercentageofhistoricallyunderservedstudentsof
colorare
either
dropping
out
or
not
meeting
current
graduation
requirements.
The
Committee
alsorecommendsareviewofthecomponentsofthehighschoolgraduationpolicy,including
thepotentialimpactonstudents,funding,andschoolanddistrictcapacity.47
TheCORE24
ImplementationTaskForcehasalsorespondedtoconcernsaboutstudentsworkingbelow
gradelevel,andhasrecommendedthatthephaseinofCORE24includeapproachestoprovide
strategiestoassiststrugglingstudentssotheycanretrieveacademiccreditsandworktoward
reachinggradelevelintheirskills.48
Priority2:Studentsneedindividualizedattentionfromcaringadultsinarangeofsettings.
Youthneedgreaterautonomyastheygetolder,buttheguidanceofadultsiscriticalwhenthey
arefacedwithchoicesthatcanpotentiallyaffecttheirsubsequentopportunities.Ourstudy
findingscallforacloserlookathowhighschoolsinWashingtonStatecaneffectivelyreachout
tofamilies,especiallyinthehighergrades.Fewerthan3in10highschoolsophomoresreport
thattheirschoolshareswiththeirparentswhentheyhavedoneagoodjob.Responsestothis
onequestionaboutschoolcommunicationtoparentshighlightthatschoolsanddistrictscould
-
8/9/2019 Engagement Brief FINAL
20/23
18
benefitfromfurtherinvestigationoftheeffectivenessoftheirbroadereffortstocommunicate
andengagefamilies.
Anumberofpoliciesandprogramsincludefeaturesthataredesignedtoenhanceadultsrolein
schoolengagement.Forexample,Navigation101fosterspersonalrelationshipsbetween
studentsand
adults
in
schools.
Building
Bridges
has
supported
programs
that
provide
individualizedhealth,mentalhealth,andacademicinterventionswhenstudentswithhigh
probabilityofdroppingouthavebeenidentified.Evidenceofthepositiveeffectsofadolescent
participationinoutofschooltimeprograms49
underscorestheimportantrolethatprogram
leaderscanplayinprovidingstudentswithopportunitiestodiscovertheiracademicand
nonacademicstrengths.
Priority3:CoordinationbetweenK12,postsecondary,andoutofschooltimeprogramscan
enhanceschoolengagement.
Researchdemonstratesthatschoolscannotworkinisolationtonurtureengagement.50
PartnershipsbetweenK12,postsecondary,andoutofschooltimeprogramsrepresenta
strategytocapitalizeontheexpertiseofeducatorsandyouthdevelopmentprofessionalsand
tocultivateanawarenessofopportunitiesafterhighschoolgraduation.Evidencefromthis
studyraisesurgentneedtofosterandsustainpartnershipsamongschools,parents,
communitybasedorganizations,andreligiousinstitutions.Supervisedextracurricularactivities
canprotectstudentsagainstdisengagementfromschoolandotherriskybehaviors,butone
thirdof8th,10th,and12thgradersdonotparticipate.SchoolsOutWashingtonsprofessional
networksand
projects
aim
to
further
professionalize
the
field
of
out
of
school
time
programs
andbroadenaccesstotheyouthwhoareinthegreatestneed.TheCollegeSuccessFoundation
providesinformationandsupportthroughschools,colleges,andnonprofitstotargetsupports
foreconomicallydisadvantagedstudents.Theimpactoftheseprogramscanbeamplifiedby
strongpartnershipswithschoolsanddistrictswhichmaybedevelopedthroughstaterequired
SchoolImprovementPlans.51
-
8/9/2019 Engagement Brief FINAL
21/23
19
Conclusion
PresidentObamaschallengeforallAmericanstoattendatleastoneyearofcollegewillrequire
educators,parents,andcommunitiestoconsidercreativesolutionsthataddressstudent
performance,andtomakeprogressonlongstandinggapsinachievementandattainment.Such
anambitiousgoalbringsneededattentiontoimprovingeducationforhighschoolstudents.As
theconnectionbetweenschoolengagementandachievementhasbeenproveninmultiple
studies,focusingonschoolengagementpromisestoencourageprogresstowardsthisnational
goal.Increasingsupports,caring,andcoordinationacrossorganizationsservingyouthare
criticalstepstonurturethesenseofpurposethatadolescentsmustbringtoschool.
SourcesandNotes
1Planty,M.,Hussar,W.,Snyder,T.,Kena,G.,KewalRamani,A.,Kemp,J.,Bianco,K.,Dinkes,R.(2009).The
ConditionofEducation2009(NCES2009081).NationalCenterforEducationStatistics,InstituteofEducation
Sciences,U.S.DepartmentofEducation.Washington,DC.2Planty,M.,Hussar,W.,Snyder,T.,Kena,G.,KewalRamani,A.,Kemp,J.,Bianco,K.,Dinkes,R.(2009).3OECDnationsincludeAustralia,Austria,Belgium,Canada,CzechRepublic,Denmark,Finland,France,Germany,
Greece,Hungary,Iceland,Ireland,Italy,Japan,Korea,Luxembourg,Mexico,theNetherlands,NewZealand,
Norway,Poland,Portugal,SlovakRepublic,Spain,Sweden,Switzerland,Turkey,UnitedKingdom,andtheUnited
States.4Provasnik,S.,Gonzales,P.,andMiller,D.(2009).U.S.PerformanceAcrossInternationalAssessmentsofStudent
Achievement:SpecialSupplementtoTheConditionofEducation2009(NCES2009083).NationalCenterfor
EducationStatistics,InstituteofEducationSciences,U.S.DepartmentofEducation.Washington,DC.Retrieved
April5,
2010,
from
http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2009/2009083.pdfSee
Tables
3and
6.
5NationalCenterforHigherEducationManagementSystems.(2009).[WashingtonStateandnationalpipeline
data].Unpublishedrawdata.Note:StaffatNCHEMSclaimthatacaveatofthepipelinedataisthatRunningStart
(astateprogramwhichenableseleventhandtwelfthgradestudentstotakecommunitycollegecourses)arenot
includedinthecountofstudentswhoimmediatelyenrollinpostsecondaryeducation,whichleadstoan
underreportingofstudentsatthismilestoneintheeducationpipeline.Approximatelysevenpercentofeligible
juniorsandseniorsparticipatedinRunningStartduringthe19967schoolyear.
SeeEwell,P.T.,Jones,D.P.,&Kelly,P.J.(2003).ConceptualizingandResearchingtheEducationalPipeline.
RetrievedDecember,15,2009,fromhttp://www.nchems.org/pubs/docs/Pipeline%20Article.pdfforadiscussionof
educationalpipelinepolicies6Fredricks,J.A.,Blumenfeld,P.C.,&Paris,A.(2004).Schoolengagement:potentialoftheconcept:stateofthe
evidence.ReviewofEducationalResearch,74,59119.
7National
Research
Council
and
the
Institute
of
Medicine.
(2004).
Engaging
schools.
Washington,
D.C.:
The
NationalAcademiesPress.8Fredricks,J.A.,Blumenfeld,P.C.,&Paris,A.(2004).9NationalResearchCouncilandtheInstituteofMedicine(2004)10
Rumberger,R.W.&Lim,S.A.(2008).Whystudentsdropoutofschool:Areviewof25Yearsofresearch.Santa
Barbara:CaliforniaDropoutResearchProjectReport#15,UniversityofCalifornia,SantaBarbara.RetrievedApril1,
2010,fromhttp://cdrp.ucsb.edu/dropouts/pubs_reports.htm11
NationalResearchCouncilandtheInstituteofMedicine(2004)
-
8/9/2019 Engagement Brief FINAL
22/23
20
12Kreider,H.,Caspe,M.,Kennedy,S.,Weiss,H.(2007).Familyinvolvementinmiddleandhighschoolstudents'
education.Cambridge:HarvardFamilyResearchProject.RetrievedApril4,2010,from
http://www.hfrp.org/publicationsresources/publicationsseries/familyinvolvementmakesadifference/family
involvementinmiddleandhighschoolstudentseducation13
Moore,K.A.,Guzman,L.,Hair,E.,Lippman,L.,&Garrett,S.(2004).Parentteenrelationshipsandinteractions:
Far
more
positive
than
not
(Research
Brief,
Publication
No.
2004
25).
Washington,
DC:
Child
Trends
Wong,E.,Wiest,D.,&Cusick,L.(2002).Perceptionsofautonomysupport,parentinvolvement,competenceand
selfworthaspredictorsofmotivationalorientationandacademicachievement:Anexaminationofsixth and
ninthgraderegulareducationstudents.Adolescence,37(146),255266.14
NationalResearchCouncilandtheInstituteofMedicine(2004)15
Patrikakou,E.N.(2004).Adolescence:Areparentsrelevanttostudentshighschoolachievementandpost
secondaryattainment?Cambridge,MA:HarvardFamilyResearchProject,HarvardUniversity.RetrievedApril5,
2010,fromhttp://www.gse.harvard.edu/hfrp/projects/fine/resources/digest/adolescence.html16
Lareau,A.(2003).Unequalchildhoods:Class,raceandfamilylife.Berkeley,CA:UniversityofCaliforniaPress.17
Spera,C.(2005).Areviewoftherelationshipamongparentingpractices,parentingstyles,andadolescentschool
achievement.EducationalPsychologyReview,17(2),125146.18
Oakes,J.,Gamoran,A.,&Page,R.N.(1992).Curriculumdifferentiation:Opportunities,
outcomes,andmeanings.InP.W.Jackson(Ed.),Handbookofresearchoncurriculum(pp.570608).NewYork:
Macmillan.19
Epstein,J.L.(1983).Theinfluenceoffriendsonachievementandaffectiveoutcomes.InJ.L.Epstein&N.Karweit
(Eds.),Friendsinschool:Patternsofselectionandinfluenceinsecondaryschools(pp.177200).NewYork:
AcademicPress.20
Dishion,T.J.,McCord,J.,&Poulin,F.(1999).Wheninterventionsharm:Peergroupsandproblembehavior,
AmericanPsychologist,54,755764.21
Alvermann,D.,&Eakle,A.J.(2007).Dissolvinglearningboundaries:Thedoing,redoing,andundoingofschool.
InA.CookSather&D.Thiessen(Eds.),Internationalhandbookofstudentexperienceinelementaryandsecondary
school(pp.143166).TheNetherlands:Springer.22
Balfanz,R.(2000).Whydosomanyurbanpublicschoolstudentsdemonstratesolittleacademicachievement?
InM.
G.
Sanders
(Ed.),
Schooling
at
risk:
Research,
policy,
and
practice
in
the
education
of
poor
and
minority
adolescents(pp.3050).Mahwah,NJ:ErlbaumAssociates.23
Dotterer,A.M.,McHale,S.M.,&Crouter,A.C.(2007).Implicationsofoutofschoolactivitiesforschool
engagementinAfricanAmericanadolescents.JournalofYouthAdolescence,36,391401.24
Melchior,A.(2000).CostsandBenefitsofServiceLearning.SchoolAdministrator,57(7),2631.25
NationalResearchCouncilandInstituteofMedicine,200226
Weoptedtoexcludefindingsaboutpeersasthesewerelesslikelytobeshapedbystatepoliciesandprograms.
ResponsestotheseandotherHYSmaybefoundathttp://www.askhys.net/layout.asp?page=analyzer27
Stipek,D.J.(2002).Motivationtolearn:Integratingtheoryandpractice.Boston:AllynandBacon.28
Amongchildren,parentseducationisacriticaldeterminantofhealthoutcomes,butmotherseducationis
especiallypredictive.Morehighlyeducatedmothersaremorelikelytohavehigherincomeandhaveapartner
withahigher
income,
providing
greater
economic
security
for
children
than
lower
educated
mothers.
As
mothers
educationincreases,achildslanguageskillsandhomeenvironmenthavebeendemonstratedtoimprove
(Magnuson2007).See:Magnuson,K.(2007).Maternaleducationandchildrensacademicachievementduring
middlechildhood.DevelopmentalPsychology,43,14971512.29
Reflectingresearchthatindicatesthatstudentsdonotprovidevalidreportsoffamilyincome,theDepartmentof
HealthrecommendsmotherseducationasaproxyforSES.Studentswithmotherswithoutahighschooldiploma
arethemostlikelytobelowSESwhilethosewithaBAorhigherarelikelytobehighSES.30
However,whencontrollingforsocioeconomicstatus,HispanicorLatinostudentswerelesslikelythanwhitesto
reportskippingschoolinthepreviousmonth.
-
8/9/2019 Engagement Brief FINAL
23/23
21
31Neild,R.C.,Balfanz,R.,&Herzog,L.(2007).Anearlywarningsystem.EducationalLeadership,65(2),2833.
32Mead,S.(2006).Thetruthaboutboysandgirls.Washington,DC:TheEducationSector.RetrievedApril7,2010,
fromhttp://www.educationsector.org/usr_doc/ESO_BoysAndGirls.pdf
Note:TheEducationSectorreportaimstodebunkthemythofaboycrisisthatwasprevalentinthemedia.It
providesananalysisofnumerouseducationaloutcomes,notingsexbaseddisparitiesinachievementandcollege
enrollment.It
highlights
the
concern
about
the
underachievement
of
African
American
and
Hispanic
or
Latino
males.33
While73percentofninthgradersgraduatedontime,77percenttookgreaterthanfouryearstograduate.There
aresignificantdisparitiesingraduationratesbasedonrace,ethnicity,sexandsocioeconomicstatus.Ireland,L.
(2009).GraduationandDropoutStatisticsforWashingtonin200708.OfficeofSuperintendentofPublic
Instruction.Olympia,WA34
Studentsfromhistoricallyunderservedracialandethnicandgroupshavehadlessaccesstohighqualitypublic
educationintheUnitedStatesthantheirpeers.ThesepopulationsincludestudentswhoareAfricanAmerican,
Latino,NativeAmerican,NativeHawaiianorAsianPacificIslanders,SoutheastAsianandmixedraceorethnic
heritage.35
Seehttp://www.avid.org/formoreinformation36
SeeBuildingBridgesWorkgroupReporttotheLegislature(December2009)formoreinformation
http://www.k12.wa.us/BuildingBridges/pubdocs/BBWrkGrp.pdf37
Seehttp://www.collegesuccessfoundation.org/formoreinformation38
SeeCORE24FrequentlyAskedQuestionsathttp://www.sbe.wa.gov/default.html?tab=4&panel=2#core2and
Flyer,OpeningDoorswithCore24http://www.sbe.wa.gov/documents/CORE24FinalGraphic_000.pdf formore
information.39
SeeNavigation101FrequentlyAskedQuestionshttp://www.k12.wa.us/navigation101/FAQs.aspxand
Navigation101Multimediahttp://www.k12.wa.us/navigation101/Multimedia.aspx formoreinformation40
Seehttp://schoolsoutwashington.org/formoreinformation.
41Seehttp://schoolsoutwashington.org/formoreinformation.
42PersonalcommunicationwithMikeHubert,Navigation101Supervisor,OfficeoftheSuperintendentofPublic
Instruction.43
AVID200910WashingtonFactsheet.(2009,November).RetrievedMay15,2010from
http://www.avid.org/dl/wd/wd_qg_washington.pdf44
Neild,R.C.,Balfanz,R.,&Herzog,L.(2007).45
TheCenterforSocialandDemographicAnalysis.(2009,September).ChildreninImmigrantFamiliesin
WashingtonFactsheet.Baltimore,MD:AnnieE.CaseyFoundation.46
AchievementGapOversightandAccountabilityCommittee(2010a).Closingopportunityandachievementgaps
inWashingtonseducationsystem.RetrievedApril6,2010,from
http://www.capaa.wa.gov/documents/AgapLegReportFinal.pdf47
AchievementGapOversightandAccountabilityCommittee(2010b).Recommendations:Memorandumtothe
StateBoardofEducation.RetrievedApril6,2010,from
http://www.k12.wa.us/cisl/pubdocs/StateBoardMemo1.10.pdf48
WashingtonStateBoardofEducation.(2010).Core24ImplementationTaskForceFinalReporttotheWashingtonStateBoardofEducation.RetrievedMay14,2010,from
http://www.sbe.wa.gov/documents/Core%2024%20ITF%20Final%20Rpt%20April%202010.pdf 49
Jordan,W.J.&Nettles,S.M.(1999).Howstudentsinvesttheirtimeoutofschool:Effectsonschoolengagement,
perceptionsoflifechances,andachievement.Baltimore:CenterforResearchontheStudentsPlacedatRisk.
RetrievedApril5,2010,fromhttp://www.csos.jhu.edu/crespar/techReports/Report29.pdf50
NationalResearchCouncilandtheInstituteofMedicine.(2004).51
AchievementGapOversightandAccountabilityCommittee(2010b).