Encyclopedias, Dictionaries, Biographical, Geographical Sources, Directories, Almanacs, Yearbooks, &...

8
Encyclopedias, Dictionaries, Biographical, Geographical Sources, Directories, Almanacs, Yearbooks, & Handbooks by Jason W. Dean

description

A table view briefly evaluating many common reference resources used in libraries

Transcript of Encyclopedias, Dictionaries, Biographical, Geographical Sources, Directories, Almanacs, Yearbooks, &...

Page 1: Encyclopedias, Dictionaries, Biographical, Geographical Sources, Directories, Almanacs, Yearbooks, & Handbooks Resource Evaluation

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Encyclopedias,  Dictionaries,  Biographical,  Geographical  Sources,  Directories,  Almanacs,  Yearbooks,  &  Handbooks    

by    

Jason  W.  Dean

Page 2: Encyclopedias, Dictionaries, Biographical, Geographical Sources, Directories, Almanacs, Yearbooks, & Handbooks Resource Evaluation

Encyclopedias,  Dictionaries,  Biographical,  Geographical  Sources,  Directories,  Almanacs,  Yearbooks,  &  Handbooks  Page  2  

 TITLE   EVALUATION   USE     Format   Scope   Authority   Treatment   Relation  to  Similar  

Works  Main  Purposes      

3  Reference  Questions  You  Could  Answer  With  This  Source  

Britannica  Macropaedia,  Micropedia,  Propaedia  

Each  division  (macropaedia,  micropedia,  and  propaedia)  offers  a  “How  to  use”  section.  Organized  alphabetically  within  each  section.  Includes  index.  

Covers  subjects  from  the  entire  known  universe,  written  in  English.  Each  entry  is  covered  briefly.    

Well-­‐respected  encyclopedia,  with  authors  being  experts  in  their  fields.  Contributors  and  authorities  are  listed  for  entire  set  in  propaedia.  

Subjects  are  treated  succinctly,  and  objectively.  

Unique  in  its  reputation  and  role  as  the  most  respected  encyclopedia.  Shares  format  and  information  with  other  encyclopedias.  

The  purpose  of  this  source  is  as  a  form  of  ready  reference  for  patrons  and  librarians.  

“What  is  an  engine?”    “Who  was  Abraham  Lincoln?”    “What  is  a  democracy?”  

Familiar  Quotations  

Does  not  include  a  section  on  usage.    Entries  are  listed  alphabetically  according  to  the  author’s  last  name.  Includes  index  of  quotes  arranged  alphabetically  by  first  word  of  quote.  

Covers  well-­‐known  quotations,  but  does  not  specify  amount  covered.  Includes  ancient  quotes  to  modern  quotes.  Each  entry  lists  quotes  by  the  author,  as  well  as  sources.  

Well-­‐known  quotation  reference  work,  with  list  of  contributors  being  experts  in  their  field.  

Subjects  are  treated  according  to  their  number  of  famous  quotes,  and  all  entries  are  formatted  in  the  same  manner,  regardless  of  length.  

Shares  information  with  other  quotation  reference  works,  and  is  not  unique.  

The  purpose  of  this  source  is  to  provide  an  easy  method  by  which  users  can  discover  the  source  of  common  quotations.  

“What  are  the  famous  quotes  of  Abraham  Lincoln?”    “Who  said  ‘I  think,  therefore  I  am’?”    “What  are  some  good  quotes  about  courage?”  

World  Book  Encyclopedia  

Includes  “How  to  use”  section.”  Well  illustrated  throughout,  entries  listed  alphabetically.  Includes  index.  

Covers  entries  from  the  known  universe,  written  in  English.  Each  entry  is  covered  briefly  in  a  readable  manner.  

Lists  contributors,  but  not  considered  authoritative.  Sources  are  not  listed.  

Subjects  are  treated  succinctly,  in  a  easy  to  read  manner,  with  many  illustrations.  Written  objectively.  

Much  like  other  encyclopedias,  except  for  the  number  of  high-­‐quality  photos  and  illustrations.  

The  purpose  of  this  source  is  to  give  patrons  images  along  with  words  from  entries.  

“What  does  a  Zebra  look  like?”    “What  is  a  skyscraper?”    “What  is  a  peanut?”  

Oxford  English  Dictionary  

Words  listed  alphabetically.    Key  to  definitions  of  words  is  also  available,  as  well  as  a  list  of  abbreviations.  

Covers  only  English  words.  Covers  290,500  words  -­‐  “the  words  that  have  formed  the  English  vocabulary  from  the  time  of  the  earliest  records  to  the  present  day."  Covers  each  word’s  history,  definition,  and  other  pertinent  information  comprehensively.  

Highly  respected  dictionary,  published  by  Oxford  University,  with  a  wide  array  of  authors,  a  majority  of  whom  have  advanced  degrees.  

The  information  is  alphabetically  presented  in  an  objective  style.  

Very  unique  in  its  scope,  authority,  and  treatment.  However,  does  not  include  many  modern  words.  

The  purpose  of  this  source  is  to  provide  exhaustive  information  about  the  words  it  defines.  

“What  does  the  word  _____  mean?”    “Where  did  the  word  ____  come  from?”    “Did  the  word  ____  mean  something  different  in  the  past?”  

Grove  Dictionary  of  Art  

Information  on  usage  is  given  in  the  introduction.  Organized  alphabetically  according  to  topic.  Includes  index,  as  well  as  several  helpful  appendices.  

Covers  topics  from  all  periods  and  areas  of  art,  in  English.  Illustrated.    

Each  entry  is  attributed  to  its  authors,  as  well  as  including  a  bibliography.  Also  includes  cross-­‐reference  suggestions.  No  information  about  the  authors  or  editors  is  

Each  entry  follows  the  same  format,  presented  alphabetically.  Each  entry  is  objectively  discussed.  

Compared  to  other  art  reference  works,  Grove’s  is  unique,  both  for  its  scholarship,  as  well  as  its  scope.  

The  purpose  of  this  source  is  to  provide  an  authoritative  first  look  at  topics  from  all  periods  and  areas  of  art.  

“When  was  Picasso  born?”    “What  is  Pre-­‐Raphaelite  art?”    “Who  painted  the  Mona  

Page 3: Encyclopedias, Dictionaries, Biographical, Geographical Sources, Directories, Almanacs, Yearbooks, & Handbooks Resource Evaluation

Encyclopedias,  Dictionaries,  Biographical,  Geographical  Sources,  Directories,  Almanacs,  Yearbooks,  &  Handbooks  Page  3  

given.   Lisa?”  

Page 4: Encyclopedias, Dictionaries, Biographical, Geographical Sources, Directories, Almanacs, Yearbooks, & Handbooks Resource Evaluation

Encyclopedias,  Dictionaries,  Biographical,  Geographical  Sources,  Directories,  Almanacs,  Yearbooks,  &  Handbooks  Page  4  

 

American  Heritage  Dictionary  of  the  English  Language  

Includes  information  on  usage,  in  the  front  of  the  first  volume.  Organized  alphabetically  according  to  word.    

Covers  many  common  English  words.  Demonstrates  pronunciation,  parts  of  speech,  as  well  as  usage  and  the  heritage  of  the  word.  

Contributors  and  editors  are  listed,  and  appear  to  be  authoritative.  Each  entry  is  not  signed,  nor  are  sources  given  for  the  information  contained  within  the  dictionary.  

Each  entry  follows  the  same  format,  with  the  same  information  presented  in  the  same  order.  Presented  objectively,  and  includes  some  illustrations.  

The  work  is  very  similar  to  other  works,  but  is  presented  in  an  easy  to  manage  format.  

The  purpose  of  this  source  is  to  provide  word  usage  assistance,  in  one  easy  to  use  volume.  

“What  does  the  word  fibrosis  mean?”    “Is  do  a  verb?”    “How  do  you  pronounce  onomotopeia?”  

Dictionary  of  American  Biography  

Does  not  include  information  on  usage.  Includes  helpful  indices.  Entries  are  listed  alphabetically,  according  to  last  name.  

Does  not  include  information  about  scope  of  dictionary,  however  all  subjects  are  American,  from  all  time  periods  pertinent  to  the  United  States.  

More  authoritative  biographical  dictionary,  due  to  the  association  with  the  American  Council  of  Learned  Socities.  Each  entry  cites  sources,  as  well  as  being  signed  by  the  author  of  that  entry.  

Each  entry  follows  the  same  format,  listed  alphabetically.  Each  entry  is  discussed  objectively.  

Unique  only  for  its  more  authoritative  nature  than  more  current  biographical  resources.  

The  purpose  of  this  work  is  to  give  an  authoritative  treatment  of  important  Americans.  

“What  did  John  Adams  do?”    “What  famous  Americans  attended  Syracuse  University?”    “What  does  Louis  Comfort  Tiffany  have  to  do  with  Tiffany’s?”  

Who’s  Who  in  America  

Information  on  usage  is  not  given.  However,  several  helpful  keys  to  abbreviations  and  other  items  help  the  user  to  better  understand  entries.  Listed  alphabetically,  and  includes  geographic,  as  well  as  professional  indices.  

Covers  “important”  Americans.  Criteria  for  admission  is  listed  in  beginning  of  first  volume.  

Respected  as  an  important  biographical  resource.  For  each  entry,  sources  are  not  given,  nor  are  authors.  

Each  entry  follows  the  same  format,  with  consistent  abbreviations  and  style.  Objectivity  can  be  doubted,  as  presumably  subjects  write  their  own  entries.  

Unique  from  other  biographical  reference  sources  because  of  the  current  nature  of  the  subjects.  

The  purpose  of  this  source  is  to  provide  basic  biographical  and  contact  information  for  the  subjects  listed  within.  

“Where  did  Joe  Biden  go  for  law  school?    “How  can  I  contact  Jesse  Jackson?”    “What  are  some  well  known  physicians  in  our  geographic  area?”  

Times  Atlas  of  the  World  

Information  on  usage  is  not  given.  However,  keys  to  symbols,  as  well  as  several  helpful  geographical  comparison  charts  are  provided.  Listed  according  to  the  key  shown  inside  the  front  cover.  Includes  index.  

Covers  all  nations  and  major  cities  of  the  world,  with  reasonable  detail  in  the  maps  –  depending  upon  their  scale.  

Authors  and  editorial  board  are  authorities.  Maps  are  not  cites,  nor  are  authors  given.  

Each  map  has  full  color,  as  well  as  consistent  symbols  and  markings.  Scale  is  not  constant,  and  is  adjusted  according  to  the  size  of  the  geographical  area  illustrated.  

Similar  to  other  works  in  its  content  and  presentation,  but  is  unique  due  to  the  authority  of  the  authors  and  editors.  

The  purpose  of  this  source  is  to  provide  a  single-­‐volume  atlas  of  the  world,  with  helpful  additional  geographical  information.  

“Where  is  Vladivostok,  Russia?”    “Is  Seattle,  Washington  near  Mt.  St.  Helens?”    “How  far  is  it  from  Dallas  to  El  Paso?”  

Times  Atlas  of  World  History  

Information  on  usage  is  not  given.  However,  keys  to  symbols  are  given.  Maps  are  organized  chronologically.  Includes  index.  

Covers  all  major  events  in  world  history,  with  good  detail  in  full-­‐color  maps.  

Contributors  are  experts  in  their  field,  and  The  Times  is  well-­‐respected  as  a  commonly  used  geographic  source.  Sources  used  are  not  given,  nor  are  authors  names  attached  to  their  work.  

Each  map  is  in  full  color,  using  consistent  symbols  and  markings.  Scale  is  adjusted  according  to  the  geographical  area  illustrated.  

Unique  in  its  blend  of  history  and  geography.  Is  an  excellent  melding  of  two  not  dissimilar  fields.  

The  purpose  of  this  work  is  to  give  a  geographical  representation  of  major  events  in  world  history.  

“How  did  MacArthur  land  at  Inchon?”    “How  did  early  man  move  about  the  world?”    “Where  did  the  Mayans  live?”  

Page 5: Encyclopedias, Dictionaries, Biographical, Geographical Sources, Directories, Almanacs, Yearbooks, & Handbooks Resource Evaluation

Encyclopedias,  Dictionaries,  Biographical,  Geographical  Sources,  Directories,  Almanacs,  Yearbooks,  &  Handbooks  Page  5  

 

Historical  Atlas  of  the  United  States  

Information  on  usage  is  not  provided.  Keys  for  each  map  are  given  in  the  map  and  are  not  necessarily  consistent  through  the  work.  Maps  are  arranged  chronologically.  Includes  index.  

Covers  important  events  from  American  history,  from  the  revolution  to  modern  times  with  full  color  maps.  

The  author  is  an  expert  in  American  history.  Sources  are  not  given  for  the  information  provided  in  the  book.  

All  maps  are  in  full  color,  but  with  changing  symbols  requiring  consultation  of  key  in  each  map.  Scale  is  adjusted  according  to  the  geographical  area  illustrated.  

Unique  in  the  geographic  illustration  of  important  American  historical  events.  

The  purpose  of  this  work  is  to  illustrate  the  changing  nature  of  America,  as  well  as  illustrate  important  events.  

“How  has  the  size  of  the  US  changed  over  time?”    “Where  were  important  landmarks  in  Harlem  in  the  1920’s?”    “Where  was  the  lost  colony  of  Roanoke  located?”  

 

Page 6: Encyclopedias, Dictionaries, Biographical, Geographical Sources, Directories, Almanacs, Yearbooks, & Handbooks Resource Evaluation

Encyclopedias,  Dictionaries,  Biographical,  Geographical  Sources,  Directories,  Almanacs,  Yearbooks,  &  Handbooks  Page  6  

 TITLE   EVALUATION   USE  

  Format   Scope    

Authority   Treatment    

Relation  to  Similar  Works    

Main  Purposes     3  Reference  Questions  You  Could  Answer  With  This  Source  

Old  Farmer’s  Almanac  

Includes  “How  to  use”  section.  Well  illustrated,  with  information  divided  into  several  sections,  as  described  in  the  table  of  contents.  

Covers  key  agricultural  and  rural  information  for  the  year  stated  in  title.    

Generally,  sources  are  not  cited.  However,  individuals  working  in  agriculture  regard  the  information  in  the  Almanac  very  highy.  

Each  area’s  important  points  are  covered  concisely,  and  with  many  illustrations.  

Unique  in  its  comprehensiveness,  an  important  first  reference  source  for  agricultural  and  meteorological  questions.  

The  main  purpose  of  this  work  is  to  help  readers  to  improve  their  farming  and  gardening  skills  with  good  information.  

“When  is  the  best  time  to  plant  my  squash?”    “What  kind  of  weather  can  we  expect  this  year?”    “When  will  we  have  a  full  moon  in  October?”  

World  Almanac  and  Book  of  Facts  

Does  not  include  section  on  usage.  However,  two  helpful  indices  are  included,  as  well  as  a  table  of  contents  demonstrating  the  organization  of  topics  covered.  Within  each  section,  entries  are  listed  alphabetically.  

Covers  key  events  of  the  year  stated  on  the  cover,  as  well  as  provides  helpful  general  statistical  information.  

Some  sections  are  credited,  while  others  are  not.  Sources  are  generally  not  listed.  

Each  topic  is  covered  well,  but  briefly.  

Compiles  in  a  convenient  form  information  available  elsewhere.  Unique  in  that  convenience,  could  be  used  as  a  good  first  reference  tool  for  statistical  information.  

The  main  purpose  of  this  work  is  as  a  convenient  reference  for  statistics  and  key  events  in  a  calendar  year.  

“How  many  births  were  there  in  New  Mexico  last  year?”    “What  is  the  largest  city  in  the  world?    “How  many  American  troops  are  stationed  in  Japan?”  

Occupational  Outlook  Handbook  Statistical  Abstracts  of  the  United  States  

Jobs  are  organized  alphabetically,  with  information  presented  in  a  consistent  format.  

Covers  all  major  career  fields.  

Published  by  the  US  government,  with  statistics  compiled  by  that  institution.    

Each  entry  is  covered  in  the  same  format,  with  a  description  of  the  job  itself,  and  an  outlook.  

Unique  in  its  authority  and  scope.  An  excellent  occupational  reference.  

The  main  purpose  of  this  work  is  to  provide  authoritative  career  information.  

“What  is  the  job  outlook  for  teachers?”    “What  is  a  doctor’s  day  like?”    “What  does  it  take  to  become  a  librarian?”  

Books  in  Print   Provides  several  helpful  indices,  with  entries  listed  alphabetically.  

Covers  all  books  in  print.   Considered  the  authority  on  availability  of  books.  

Each  entry  is  covered  in  a  standard  format  describing  each  book.  Does  not  list  sources.  

Unique  both  in  its  comprehensiveness,  as  well  as  the  topic.  

The  main  purpose  of  this  work  is  to  provide  an  easy  reference  to  determine  the  in  print  status  of  a  given  book.  

“Is  The  Power  Broker  still  in  print?    “What  books  by  Chaim  Potok  are  in  print?”    “Can  I  find  this  book  in  a  large  print  format?”  

Statesman’s  Yearbook  

Does  not  include  section  on  usage.  However,  a  table  of  contents  and  index  is  provided.  Entries  are  broken  down  alphabetically,  in  two  major  sections  –  

Includes  all  major  organizations  in  the  world,  as  well  as  all  of  the  nations  of  the  world.  

Considered  authoritative.  Sources  are  not  listed,  nor  are  authors  attributed.  

Each  entry  is  covered  in  the  same  format,  with  maps,  and  key  information  broken  down  in  a  consistent  fashion,  and  succinctly.  

Unique  in  its  governmental  information.  

The  main  purpose  of  this  source  is  to  be  a  ready  reference  for  key  governmental  information  for  all  nations  of  the  world.  

“What  kind  of    government  does  Lesotho  have?”    “Who  is  the  leader  of  Azerbaijan?”  

Page 7: Encyclopedias, Dictionaries, Biographical, Geographical Sources, Directories, Almanacs, Yearbooks, & Handbooks Resource Evaluation

Encyclopedias,  Dictionaries,  Biographical,  Geographical  Sources,  Directories,  Almanacs,  Yearbooks,  &  Handbooks  Page  7  

organizations  and  nations.  

Facts  on  File   Each  topic  is  presented  in  its  own  volume,  each  with  a  table  of  contents  and  an  index.  Does  not  include  a  section  on  usage.  

Covers  many  major  topics  in  more  depth  than  an  encyclopedia.  

Each  volume  has  a  stated  author,  which  is  generally  an  expert  in  the  subject  area.  Generally  does  not  include  sources.  

Each  volume  is  presented  in  a  different  format.  

Only  unique  for  the  depth  of  general  information  given.  

The  main  purpose  of  this  source  is  to  provide  more  in-­‐depth  information  about  broad  topics  than  is  available  in  an  encyclopedia.  

“What  are  some  general  themes  in  chemistry?”    “What  are  some  fields  in  science?”    “I’d  like  to  know  a  bit  more  about  this  topic,  where  should  I  look?”  

Famous  First  Facts  

Lacks  section  on  usage,  hindering  the  usefulness  of  this  source.  However,  similar  entries  are  grouped  together,  and  several  indices  are  included.  

Covers  major  “firsts”  in  American  history.  

Lacks  references  and  author  statements.    Could  be  an  authority  in  the  “firsts”  area.  

Each  entry  is  covered  with  varying  depth,  and  with  differing  formats.  

Unique  only  for  the  format  in  which  the  information  is  presented.  

The  main  purpose  of  this  source  is  to  provide  a  convenient  resource  for  “firsts”  in  many  areas.  

“Who  was  the  first  Pope  to  visit  the  White  House?”    “Who  was  the  first  man  to  walk  on  the  moon”    “Who  was  the  first  president  to  live  in  the  White  House?”  

Emily  Post’s  Etiquette  

Includes  table  of  contents  and  index,  but  lacks  section  on  usage.  Each  topic  is  listed  under  a  general  heading  of  different  social  situations.  

Includes  many  important  social  occasions,  from  personal  to  general.  

Considered  the  authoritative  source  for  standards  of  polite  behavior.  

Each  topic  is  covered  with  varying  length.  Important  concepts  are  illustrated.  

Unique  in  its  authority  and  scope.  

The  main  purpose  of  this  source  is  to  provide  readers  information  about  how  to  behave  and  conduct  themselves  in  a  “polite”  manner.  

“When  should  I  send  out  invitations  for  my  wedding?”    “What  does  RSVP  stand  for?”    “What  should  be  the  text  on  a  dinner  party  invitation?”  

Robert’s  Rules  of  Order  

Includes  helpful  information  on  usage  in  the  introduction.  Also  includes  table  of  contents,  where  organization  of  topics  and  information  in  the  work  is  described.  

Covers  all  areas  of  rules  for  running  official  meetings.  

Considered  the  authoritative  source  for  rules  for  running  meetings.  

Each  general  topic  is  covered  objectively,  in  differing  formats.  The  topics  are  then  broken  down  into  more  specific  areas.  

Unique  for  the  information  it  presents,  as  well  as  the  format  of  that  presentation.  

The  main  purpose  of  this  source  is  to  provide  readers  with  the  tools  they  require  to  run  efficient,  productive  meetings.  

“What  is  a  quorum?”    “Why  do  we  read  minutes  during  meetings?”    “How  do  I  hold  the  floor  during  a  debate  in  a  meeting?”  

Guinness  Book  of  World  Records/Guinness  World  Records  

Does  not  include  section  on  usage.  Does  include  table  of  contents,  describing  the  breakdown  of  information  in  the  book.  

Covers  many  areas  of  records,  including  space,  and  personal  achievement.  

Considered  the  authority  on  world  records  for  size,  etc.  

Well  illustrated,  with  each  record  and  topic  described  differently.  

Unique  for  the  information  it  contains.  

The  main  purpose  of  this  work  is  to  provide  readers  information  about  impressive  human  and  natural  feats.  

“How  long  are  the  world’s  longest  fingernails?”    “How  heavy  is  the  world’s  largest  ball  of  twine?”    How  big  is  the  biggest  pizza  ever?”  

Page 8: Encyclopedias, Dictionaries, Biographical, Geographical Sources, Directories, Almanacs, Yearbooks, & Handbooks Resource Evaluation

Encyclopedias,  Dictionaries,  Biographical,  Geographical  Sources,  Directories,  Almanacs,  Yearbooks,  &  Handbooks  Page  8