Emergency Services for IEEE 802 Tutorial March 2007 S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. GuptaSlide 1...

57
March 2 007 S. Mc Cann, D. S Slide 1 Emergency Services for IEEE 802 Tutorial Emergency Services for 802 Date: 2007-03-13 N am e C om pany A ddress Phone em ail Stephen M cCann Siem ensRoke M anor R oke M anorR esearch Ltd O ld Salisbury Lane, Rom sey H am pshire, SO 51 0ZN , U K +44 1794 833341 stephen.mccann@ roke.co. uk D ave Stephenson Cisco 170 W Tasm an D r. San Jose, CA 95134 +1 408 527 7991 daves@ cisco.com V ivek G upta Intel M ailstop JF3-206, 2111, N E 25th A venue, H illsboro, O R 97124 +1 503 712 1754 [email protected] G aborBajko Nokia Palo A lto, CA +1 972 894 5000 G abor.Bajko@ nokia.com Srinivas Sreem anthula Nokia Irving, TX +1 972 894 5000 Srinivas.Sreemanthula@ n okia.com Authors:

Transcript of Emergency Services for IEEE 802 Tutorial March 2007 S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. GuptaSlide 1...

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 1

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

Emergency Services for 802

Date: 2007-03-13

Name Company Address Phone email

Stephen McCann Siemens Roke Manor Roke Manor Research Ltd Old Salisbury Lane, Romsey Hampshire, SO51 0ZN, UK

+44 1794 833341 [email protected]

Dave Stephenson Cisco 170 W Tasman Dr. San Jose, CA 95134

+1 408 527 7991 [email protected]

Vivek Gupta Intel Mailstop JF3-206, 2111, NE 25th Avenue,

Hillsboro, OR 97124

+1 503 712 1754 [email protected]

Gabor Bajko Nokia Palo Alto, CA +1 972 894 5000 [email protected]

Srinivas Sreemanthula

Nokia Irving, TX +1 972 894 5000 [email protected]

Authors:

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 2

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

Content

• Scope & Motive

• Introduction

• Regulations

• Media types

• 802 technologies

• Other SDOs

• What next?

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 3

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

Introduction

• This tutorial reflects work in progress. Its intention is to inform members about ongoing efforts to standardise emergency services within IEEE 802.

• It does not attempt to provide definitive solutions to all problems.

• It hopefully will encourage all projects and members to consider whether their technology will meet the future requirements of regulatory bodies for emergency service provision.

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 4

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

Scope

• Within this tutorial we define Emergency Services as:– Suitable for IEEE 802 Wireless technologies

– Emergency voice calls

– Network push alerts (e.g. Emergency Alert System – EAS)

– Vehicle communication

– non-VoIP calls (e.g. multi-media)

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 5

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

Motive

• There is an overarching concern for a consistent approach by standards development organizations (SDOs – see later) to address social policy expectations, such as full Emergency Service capability, in relation to emerging access technologies.

• Location identification and callback capability represent baseline requirements for emergency service.

• Call integrity is of prime concern

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 6

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

Motive• Organizations, within the US, such as the National Emergency

Number Association (NENA), the ATIS Emergency Service Interconnection Forum (ESIF) and the FCC's Network Reliability and Interoperability Council (NRIC) have created considerable documentation identifying requirements and technical needs that must be addressed to support emergency services (i.e. E911) through emerging access technologies.

• Should IEEE 802 working groups consider including in their standards whatever is needed for the generation and delivery of location identification and callback capability for individuals trying to gain access to emergency services ??

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 7

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

Regulations

(I am not a lawyer)

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 8

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

FCC Wireless Enhanced 911

• Wireless Enhanced 911 (E911) rules seek to improve the effectiveness and reliability of wireless 911 service by providing 911 dispatchers with additional information on wireless 911 calls.

• The wireless E911 program is divided into two parts - Phase I and Phase II. Phase I requires carriers, upon valid request by a local Public Safety Answering Point (PSAP), to report the telephone number of a wireless 911 caller and the location of the antenna that received the call. Phase II requires wireless carriers to provide far more precise location information, within 50 to 300 meters in most cases.

• The deployment of E911 requires the development of new technologies and upgrades to local 911 PSAPs, as well as coordination among public safety agencies, wireless carriers, technology vendors, equipment manufacturers, and local wireline carriers.

• http://www.fcc.gov/911/enhanced/

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 9

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

112 in the EU

• Member States shall ensure that, in addition to any other national emergency call numbers specified by the national regulatory authorities, all end-users of publicly available telephone services, including users of public pay telephones, are able to call the emergency services free of charge, by using the single European emergency call number "112".

• Member States shall ensure that calls to the single European emergency call number "112" are appropriately answered and handled in a manner best suited to the national organisation of emergency systems and within the technological possibilities of the networks.

• Member States shall ensure that undertakings which operate public telephone networks make caller location information available to authorities handling emergencies, to the extent technically feasible, for all calls to the single European emergency call number "112".

• http://www.eena.org/view/en/citizen/112_in_eu.html

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 10

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

Emergency Calls in Japan

• Emergency call (“notification”) regulation is being discussed in Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications. In operation from 1st April 2007.

• For analog telecommunication facilities or equivalent analog fixed telecommunication facilities

1. Emergency call must connect to the local emergency center2. User device sends its number and location to the emergency center that is nearest

the user device.3. Emergency call maintains a circuit connection or callback function (or equivalent

functions)• For other voice transmission facilities

– 1 and 2– Emergency call maintains a circuit connection unless the call termination signal is

transmitted from the emergency center

• Location information (one or more of ZIP, Address Code, Address, Subscriber ID etc) of user must be provided to the emergency center.

• 11-06-0460-01-000u-japanese-emergency-call-regulation.ppt

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 11

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

Emergency Calls in Other Countries• Philippines: 112 or 911; police 117• Singapore: fire and medical 995; police 999; 112 and 911 can be

dialed from mobile phones• South Korea: police 112; fire and medical 119• Sri Lanka: police emergency 119 accident service 11-2691111• Lithuania: 112; fire 01, 101, or 011; police 02, 102, or 022; medical

03, 103, or 033. Note: the non-112 numbers are for separate emergency services differ in distinct telecommunications networks, whereas 112 available on all networks.

• Vietnam: 115; police 113; fire 114• Switzerland: fire 118; police 117; medical 144; poison 145; road

emergency 140; psychological support (free and anonymous) 143; psychological support for teens and children (free and anonymous) 147; helicopter air-rescue (Rega) 1414 or by radio on 161.300 MHz.

• http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergency_telephone_number#Emergency_numbers_by_country

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 12

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

Emergency Alert System (EAS)

http://wonkette.com/politics/television/emergency-alert-system-actually-used-183830.php

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 13

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

Media Types

(I am not a journalist)

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 14

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

Media Types

• One Way– VoIP– SMS/Text/IM– Video– TTY/TDD (speech impaired)

• Interactive– Instant messaging and video could improve the ability to

communicate and evaluate the situation and to provide appropriate instruction prior to arrival of emergency crews.

• ...and others as defined in http://tools.ietf.org/wg/ecrit/draft-ietf-ecrit-framework/draft-ietf-ecrit-framework-00.txt section 12.

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 15

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

IEEE 802 technologies

(am I not an engineer ?)

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 16

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

Generalized Emergency Call procedure

• Location determination ( in cellular networks, this might be done by the network on behalf of the mobile phone) with Location Configuration Protocols (LCP)

• Location representation (geo, civic: cell-id for cellular)

• Mapping database discovery

• Location to Service Translation (LoST)

• Location conveyance

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 17

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

Issues to be solved for IEEE 802

• ES identification

• Location information– Some procedure to fetch the location information by higher layers

when initializing the call may be required.

– Mobile terminal

– Network edge device (e.g. Access Point, Base Station)

• Unauthenticated Network Access (e.g. IEEE 802.11)

• Admission Control– QoS – dedicated bandwidth

– preemption

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 18

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

Issues to be solved for IEEE 802

• ES identification

• Location information– Some procedure to fetch the location information by higher layers

when initializing the call may be required.

– Mobile terminal

– Network edge device (e.g. Access Point, Base Station)

• Unauthenticated Network Access (e.g. IEEE 802.11)

• Admission Control– QoS – dedicated bandwidth

– preemption

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 19

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

IEEE 802.1

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 20

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

IEEE 802.1AB

Link Layer Discovery Protocol (LLDP)

• A standard and extensible multi-vendor protocol and management elements to support network topology discovery and exchange device configuration and capabilities

• Developed and maintained by IEEE 802.1, planned for revision (for wireless purposes)

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 21

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

IEEE 802.11

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 22

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

Introduction

• Why does IEEE 802.11 need to address Emergency Services provision at all?– Emergency Service Identification

– Location

– Unauthenticated Network Access

– Vehicular Emergency Communications

– Network Push Alert

• IEEE 802.11 must be able to open an 802.1X port to proceed, if 802.1X is the required authentication procedure (i.e. not open authentication)

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 23

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

AP(11u-capable)

STA(11u-capable)

Configured by Hotspot owner / administrator

Beacon (ESN)Association request (SSID : Foo)

Association Response (…)

EAP Success (include PMK)

dela

y

IEEE 802.11 Emergency Call Setup

EAPOL/EAP-Response/Identity (e.g. anonymous@ESN)

EAPOL/EAP-Request/Identity

4-Way Handshake

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 24

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

Location

• Location information is being developed by IEEE 802.11k and IEEE 802.11v (RFC 3825)

• Request/Response paradigm– Client may request from the access point

• it’s own location

• the location of the access point

• GeoPriv (RFC 4119) used to wrap location information– Location standard formats supported include GEO and CIVIC

• Control and Measurement mechanisms to enable tracking continuously

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 25

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

Unauthenticated Network Access • Public user credentials. In this situation, a client uses the defined network

selection method to query candidate networks to determine which one (or several) supports VoIP, end-to-end QoS and emergency services. Once this has been determined, the client associates to the SSID corresponding to the chosen network using public user credentials.

• Use an SSID configured for Open Authentication, that is only suitable for obtaining emergency service (i.e., and not suited for obtaining other hotspot services such as internet access). Network elements necessary to complete an emergency call are reachable via this SSID. How to reach these network elements (e.g., a Call Manager) and which protocol to use (e.g., SIP) are outside the scope of IEEE 802.11.

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 26

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

Admission Control • A QoS enabled client requests bandwidth using a TSPEC

Request in an action frame.

• Currently a TSPEC Request includes parameters describing the characteristics of the traffic stream, but no information on the actual use of the traffic stream.

• To indicate emergency call initiation, it is proposed that a new “Expedited Bandwidth Request” element is used. It is the responsibility of the client to transmit this element.

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 27

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

Public Safety Band (4.9 GHz) • In 2003, the FCC allocated 50 MHz of spectrum in the 4.9 GHz

band to public safety services. Public safety agencies can use this 4.9 GHz band to implement wireless networks such as IEEE 802.11 for the transmission of mission-critical information such as streaming video, data access, maps, and missing person images.

• IEEE 802.11 has now been amended to operate within this band and is able to provide emergency facilitator communications such as: police, fire and rescue, disaster relief.

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 28

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

IEEE 802.15

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 29

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

IEEE 802.15

• IEEE802.15.4a has built in a position measurement capability (<1m), but it appears that they are not dealing with emergency services.

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 30

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

IEEE 802.16

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 31

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

IEEE 802.16 • In IEEE 802.16g there are several elements for Device

Localization and Location Based Services (LBS) - which may be used for Emergency Services.

• Examples in location sensitized applications, emergency call origination tracking, equipment tracking etc.

• IEEE 802.16e utilises RFC 3825

• Is it useful consider civic location issues, when cell/hotspot sizes are so high.

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 32

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

IEEE 802.20

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 33

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

IEEE 802.20 • There is no distinct description within current draft for

emergency service.

• However the draft indicates that the system can get the terminal location, and obviously the system can support QoS classes, that might be used as emergency service location identification and provide preferential resource for emergency call.

• The SectorParameters message is used to convey sector specific information from the serving sector to the access terminals, including the Latitude, Longitude, RegistrationRadius, etc.

• The terminal may possibly initialize a emergency call in "connected" states with an open session using ConnectionOpenRequest ?

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 34

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

IEEE 802.21

March 2007

Matthew Gast, Dave Stephenson

Slide 35

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

AP(11u-capable)

STA(11u-capable)

Carrier Network

VLAN #5

Note: There does NOT need to be a 1-to-1 mapping between this and SSID #5.

Architecture

IEEE 802.21Information Server

AAA

DHCP

SSID #5

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 36

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

Emergency Call with 802.21 IS802.11u STA 802.11u AP

(MIH-aware)802.21 IS

Beacon (GAS: MIH)

Pre-configAdvertising protocol =

IS (APID)Length limitation req

from 11u to 21

Probe REQ

Probe RSP (GAS: MIH)

GAS init req (MIH IE: e911 req)MIH frame (e911 req)

GAS init resp (Query ID, comeback_delay)

Out of scope

802.11

802.21

MIH frame rsp (e911 accepted + IS Location)

GAS comeback req (Query ID)

GAS comeback rsp (Query ID, e911 accepted)

comeback_delay

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 37

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

IEEE 802.21 Information Server • Networks may support means to determine, help in

determining or provide the location to the clients at various layers– Link layer specific ones: LLDP[-MED], U-TDoA, D-TDoA

– Link layer agnostic ones: DHCP, OMA SUPL, RELO, HELD (HTTP based)

– Other SDOs defined different LCPs

• Service providers need flexibility on how location services are offered in their network

• IEEE 802.21 provides a logical place to support a comprehensive list of all support options using IS

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 38

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

IEEE 802.22

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 39

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

IEEE 802.22

• IEEE 802.22 has defined a Location Configuration Measurement Report

• A Location Configuration report as described in IETF RFC 3825 (“Dynamic Host Configuration Protocol Option for Coordinate-based Location Configuration Information”), includes latitude, longitude and altitude. The report format shall be as described in RFC 3825, and the length shall be 16 octets.

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 40

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

Vehicular Communications

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 41

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

Vehicular Communications • Emergency communications is a major focus of ITS (Intelligent

Transport Systems) activity, and it was a significant topic at the March 2005 ITU Workshop.

• Project MESA is also helping to call attention to this area and providing high-level direction.

• Two distinct areas for wireless communications:– MBW: New work item in ISO/TC204/WG16: “Specific Mobile Broadband

Wireless Access Communications Systems”, e.g. IEEE 806.16e, IEEE 802.20

– DSRC : IEEE 1609 continues work on application layer standards for IEEE 802.11p

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 42

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

Vehicular Communications • DSRC/WAVE. Dedicated short-range communications (DSRC)

at 5.9 GHz using an IEEE 802.11p base is now called WAVE (Wireless Access in Vehicular Environments).

• The U.S. FCC has allocated 75 MHz of bandwidth for ITS applications in this band, with emphasis on public safety and, in the U.S., WAVE may become a U.S. federally funded vehicle-data network separate from the cellular network.

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 43

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

Vehicular Communications • Mobile wireless broadband (MWB) represents an important part

of a public sector (particularly public safety) solution. MWB can provide a consistent and robust capacity that can serve routine operations, but provide priority for emergencies.

• MWB is useful for commercial applications of ITS as well as to support public agency and public safety applications, due to its ability to function well over large distances and at high travel speeds. It is vitally important for commercial and public uses of MWB to remain consistent with one another, including the ability to prioritise messages, especially in case of emergencies.

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 44

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

Standard Development Organizations

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 45

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

Standard Development Organizations (SDOs)

• ES in IEEE 802 technologies do not provide the whole solution.

• What do we expect from other SDOs– signaling protocol SIP (new variant – USIP)

• Note: SIP requires an IP address of an SIP agent. This can not be used by 802.11 in state 1, unless a SIP agent discovery protocol exists?)

– codec (e.g. G711)

– network connection (authentication at layer 2)

– application authentication (e.g. https)

– internationalization of emergency dialing codes

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 46

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

Other SDOs• 3GPP & 3GPP2• TIA TR-45• IETF ECRIT• NENA• OMA• ITU-T• ETSI EMTEL• OCG• EU Commission• ComCare• ESIF NGES• ANSI HSSP• US DoT

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 47

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

• 3GPP– Service requirements from 3GPP TS 22.101http://www.ietf-ecrit.org/EmergencyWorkshop2006/slides/

Service_requirements-ESW06.ppt

– Architecture = IMS (centralised)http://www.ietf-ecrit.org/EmergencyWorkshop2006/slides/

3GPP IP Based Emergency Calls.pdf

– Protocol Details from 3GPP TS 24.229http://www.ietf-ecrit.org/EmergencyWorkshop2006/slides/

3GPP-Protocol_details.ppt

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 48

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

• 3GPP2– S.R0115 “All IP-Network Emergency Call Support” -

Stage 1 requirements, produced by TSG-S; recommended for publication on Sept. 14, 2006

– http://www.ietf-ecrit.org/EmergencyWorkshop2006/slides/3GPP2 IP Based Emergency Calls.ppt

• TIA TR-45– Develops performance, compatibility, interoperability and service

standards for mobile and personal communications systems– Joint effort between TIA TR-45.2 AHES and ATIS WTSC

(formerly T1P1) to develop Emergency Services Standards– Requirementshttp://www.ietf-ecrit.org/EmergencyWorkshop2006/slides/TIA TR-

45.pdf

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 49

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

• IETF ECRIT– ECRIT working since 2004– Building off of the GEOPRIV work and architecture– And the ‘sipping-emergency’ design team of SIPPING– Initial focus on using location information to learn how to direct emergency

calls on the Internet – architecture = localised

– IETF ECRIT Architecture• http://www.ietf-ecrit.org/EmergencyWorkshop2006/slides/IETF-Overview.ppt

– SIP Location Conveyance: • http://www.ietf-ecrit.org/EmergencyWorkshop2006/slides/SIP_Location_Conveyance.ppt

– Emergency Services Identifiers• http://www.ietf-ecrit.org/EmergencyWorkshop2006/slides/ESW06-service-urn.ppt

– LoST and LoST Architecture• http://www.ietf-ecrit.org/EmergencyWorkshop2006/slides/ESW06-LoST.ppt

– DHCP Civic & Geo• http://www.ietf-ecrit.org/EmergencyWorkshop2006/slides/ESW06-civic.ppt • http://www.ietf-ecrit.org/EmergencyWorkshop2006/slides/Geo DHCP Option 123 for LCI.ppt

– Geopriv L7 LCP• http://www.ietf-ecrit.org/EmergencyWorkshop2006/slides/L7LCP-ESW06.ppt

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 50

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

• NENA = North American Emergency Number Association– Sets standards (among many other things) for emergency calls in

U.S./Canada

– Next Generation 9-1-1 project (NG911)• Complete overhaul of the entire 9-1-1 system

• Based on IP

• Includes changes to processes, funding, training, etc, etc

• The initial version of the technical standards part is known as “i3”

– Architecture and solutions based on IETF protocols

http://www.ietf-ecrit.org/EmergencyWorkshop2006/slides/NENA NG911 arch for SDO workshop.ppt

– NENA sent an liaison to IEEE 802, regarding location issues. IEEE 802.11u are currently addressing this liaison.

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 51

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

• OMA– Mentioning of Mobile Location Services, Secure User

Plane for Location, Mobile Location Protocol, Roaming Location Protocol, Privacy Control Protocolhttp://www.ietf-ecrit.org/EmergencyWorkshop2006/slides/OMA-LOC ES Coordination WorkshopR01.ppt

• ITU-T

– Work focused on Telecommunications for Disaster Relief and Early Warning

http://www.ietf-ecrit.org/EmergencyWorkshop2006/slides/TDR in ITU-T Oct 06.ppt

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 52

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

• ETSI EMTEL– Special Committee on Emergency Communications

– Act as a key coordinator in getting requirements on Emergency Communications, outside ETSI (i.e. from different stakeholders) and inside ETSI (i.e. ETSI Bodies).

– Provide requirements on issues of network security, network integrity, network behaviour in emergency situations, and emergency telecommunications needs in networkshttp://www.ietf-ecrit.org/EmergencyWorkshop2006/slides/ EMTEL Presentation_ECRIT 200.ppt

• OCG– The Open Geospatial Consortium, Inc. (OGC) is a non-profit,

international voluntary consensus standards organization that is leading the development of standards for geospatial and location based services.

– http://www.ietf-ecrit.org/EmergencyWorkshop2006/slides/2006 OGC GML Info for October SDO Coordination Meeting.ppt

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 53

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

• EU Commission– Presentation on the EU Regulatory Framework– Discussion on establishment of document outlining responsibilities

of different market playershttp://www.ietf-ecrit.org/EmergencyWorkshop2006/slides/EU-Commission.ppt

• COMCARE– US Organization Overview and pointers to OASIS standards for

authority-to-authority communication.http://www.ietf-ecrit.org/EmergencyWorkshop2006/slides/

Emergency Services SDO Workshop Architecture.ppt

– Agency Locator Service Prototypehttp://www.ietf-ecrit.org/EmergencyWorkshop2006/slides/Emergency Services SDO Workshop Agency Locator Services.ppt

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 54

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

• ESIF NGES– Next Generation Emergency Services (NGES) Subcommittee created at

ESIF 17 in Las Vegas– Provide liaison with global SDOs for the standards development

coordination– Plans to develop stage 2/3 standards based on NENA’s i3 requirements

and to – would like to act as SDO coordinator on emergency services– The goal is to ensure other Standards are aware of NG9-1-1 work being

done at NENA and ESIFhttp://www.ietf-ecrit.org/EmergencyWorkshop2006/slides/ESIF NGES Update.ppt

• ANSI HSSP– The ANSI Homeland Security Standards Panel (HSSP)– Plans to offer a forum for standards and coordination– Aims to produce a white paper to outline key issues, emergency

communications standards, identified gaps, and resources for further information/possible partnerships

http://www.ietf-ecrit.org/EmergencyWorkshop2006/slides/ANSI-HSSP - SDO Emergency Services Coordination Workshop.ppt

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 55

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

• US DoT

– Report about NG911 projects

http://www.ietf-ecrit.org/EmergencyWorkshop2006/slides/ USDOT.ppt

• Emergency Services Project in Austria

– Emergency service project based on IETF protocols

http://www.ietf-ecrit.org/EmergencyWorkshop2006/slides/ AT_PROTOTYP_FIELDTEST.ppt

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 56

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

2nd SDO emergency services coordination workshop

• Washington DC, USA, on the 10, 11 and 12 April 2007.

• More details about the workshop via this webpage:– http://www.emergency-services-coordination.info/

March 2007

S. McCann, D. Stephenson and V. Gupta

Slide 57

Emergency Services for IEEE 802

Tutorial

Concluding Issues

• Don’t assume that IEEE 802 technologies can already support all ES requirements:– callback facility ?

– terminal location ? geospatial or civic?

– does Civic location, make sense, for large scale systems?

• How far do we want to pre-empt upcoming regulations?– 2 years?

– 10 years?

• What does the market require?– Similar issues to Legal Intercept?

• Do we want closer liaisons with other SDOs

• Comments welcome