Emails 1

45
1 Johnson, Mike (OP) From: Richard deC HINDS <[email protected]> Sent: Friday, April 22, 2011 1:26 PM To: Mordfin, Stephen (OP) Subject: Fw: Final edits to Report Attachments: George H.F. Oberlander.vcf; Oberlander Report Final to RHinds APRIL 17.doc Stephen, enclosed is the final version of George Oberlander's report for your information. We plan to file it with the Commission next week and will provide you with hard copy at that time. The only significant changes to the Report relate to the Burleith maps and Appendices D-1-D-2. Review of the data underlying the 2000 map revealed that it reflects solely undergraduate group houses, grad houses were not counted. Both were counted in 2010, but the grad houses are colored a different color so you can see the growth in undergrad group houses. According to GU Grad growth in Burleith has been 36 students, a 22% increase from 2000-2010. April 26, 2010 Community Meeting Presentation at p. 14. Lenore redid her spreadsheets at D-1-D-2 to assume 3 grad students per house to estimate future growth in grad houses to take into account GU's claim that graduates prefer not to live in group houses of 4 or more. However, those spreadsheets have to some extent been rendered obsolete by GU's last minute conditional amendment to the Plan. The Appendices are too large to email. I look forward to receiving your report by email next week. Regards, Richard Final edits to Report George H. F. Oberlander to: Richard deC HINDS 04/17/2011 04:25 PM This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information. If you are not the intended recipient, please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy.

Transcript of Emails 1

Page 1: Emails 1

1

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Friday April 22 2011 126 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject Fw Final edits to ReportAttachments George HF Oberlandervcf Oberlander Report Final to RHinds APRIL 17doc

Stephen enclosed is the final version of George Oberlanders report for your information We plan to file it with the Commission next week and will provide you with hard copy at that time The only significant changes to the Report relate to the Burleith maps and Appendices D-1-D-2 Review of the data underlying the 2000 map revealed that it reflects solely undergraduate group houses grad houses were not counted Both were counted in 2010 but the grad houses are colored a different color so you can see the growth in undergrad group houses According to GU Grad growth in Burleith has been 36 students a 22 increase from 2000-2010 April 26 2010 Community Meeting Presentation at p 14 Lenore redid her spreadsheets at D-1-D-2 to assume 3 grad students per house to estimate future growth in grad houses to take into account GUs claim that graduates prefer not to live in group houses of 4 or more However those spreadsheets have to some extent been rendered obsolete by GUs last minute conditional amendment to the Plan The Appendices are too large to email I look forward to receiving your report by email next week Regards Richard

Final edits to Report George H F Oberlander to Richard deC HINDS 04172011 0425 PM

This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

2

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Luca ltlucapivatocomgtSent Friday April 15 2011 1217 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject Re ZC GU Hearing MPD DataAttachments ATT00002png 911Calls2000-2010-3500-O-3500-Pxlsx

911Calls2000-2010-1400-36TH-1400-35THxlsx 911Calls2000-2010-O-ByBlockxlsx 911Calls2000-2010-Prospect-ByBlockxlsx 911Calls2000-2010-BlocksWithStudentsxlsx

Hi Stephen As an update to the MPD calls data that I have provided a couple of weeks ago when I didnt have the 2010 calls yet Id like to send you some attachments now with the latest 2010 MPD calls for service I have updated some charts with data that will be part of many more chars that we will show The data shows a picture that is exactly the opposite of what GU said Their data was misleading because they mixed students and residents blocks Our data shows that all of their programs including the new ones (implemented 1 year ago) have not made any measurable difference whatsoever In fact 911 calls are up and trending up in all studentified blocks See attachments Feel free to contact me at any time if you need clarification on the data Best Luca 301-221-8983 c On 472011 326 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) wrote The Office of Planning has requested an extension to file its report to give more time to review the submittal by the applicant on March 31 2011 OP has requested that the first hearing be held on May 12 which was originally scheduled to be the first continuation date Steve

Stephen J Mordfin AICP Development Review Specialist DC Office of Planning 1100 4th Street SW Suite E650 Washington DC 20024 Office 202‐442‐8810 FAX 202‐442‐7638 stephenmordfindcgov httpplanningdcgov

3

From Luca [mailtolucapivatocom] Sent Thursday April 07 2011 104 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject Re ZC GU Hearing MPD Data Hi Stephen are you filing today On 442011 1113 AM Mordfin Stephen (OP) wrote Thank you

Stephen J Mordfin AICP Development Review Specialist DC Office of Planning 1100 4th Street SW Suite E650 Washington DC 20024 Office 202‐442‐8810 FAX 202‐442‐7638 stephenmordfindcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Luca [mailtolucapivatocom] Sent Monday April 04 2011 1107 AM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject ZC GU Hearing MPD Data Hi Stephen I have attached some of the charts and maps that we have Ill be happy to come to your office tomorrow at 1pm and bring the raw data on a pen drive as well as our analysis of the data Thank you Luca 301-221-8983 c

4

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Tuesday April 12 2011 1043 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject RE OP Report on 2000 PlanAttachments ATT00002png

Thanks Please email me you Report when you get it approved Richard ___________________________________________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom From Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt To Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgt Date 04122011 1040 AM Subject RE OP Report on 2000 Plan

As requested

Stephen J Mordfin AICP Development Review Specialist DC Office of Planning 1100 4th Street SW Suite E650 Washington DC 20024 Office 202‐442‐8810 FAX 202‐442‐7638 stephenmordfindcgov httpplanningdcgov From Richard deC HINDS [mailtorhindscgshcom] Sent Tuesday April 12 2011 1036 AM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject OP Report on 2000 Plan Hi Steve Glad to hear you have some breathing room OP issued a report on Georgetown University Campus Plan 200-2010 BZA Application No 16566 dated June 12 2000 P 28 contains data on where undergrads live at p 28 that I would like to use at the hearing but I do not have a good copy of it and would like to see the entire report Can you email

5

or fax it to me Thanks Richard ___________________________________________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999 wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy[attachment 16566 GU Campus Plan Report 06-12-00pdf deleted by Richard deC HINDSDCCgsh] This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

6

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Tuesday April 12 2011 1036 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject OP Report on 2000 Plan

Hi Steve Glad to hear you have some breathing room OP issued a report on Georgetown University Campus Plan 200-2010 BZA Application No 16566 dated June 12 2000 P 28 contains data on where undergrads live at p 28 that I would like to use at the hearing but I do not have a good copy of it and would like to see the entire report Can you email or fax it to me Thanks Richard ___________________________________________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

7

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Betsy Cooley ltbetsycooleycagtownorggtSent Thursday April 07 2011 549 PMTo Hawkinson Colleen (DDOT) Hanousek Donna (DCOZ) Schellin Sharon (DCOZ) Ricks

Karina (DDOT) Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP) DCOZ - ZC Submissions (DCOZ) Bill Starrells Ed Solomon tmfsmithstarpowernet Ron Lewis Jones Jeffrey (ANC 2E03)

Cc Jennifer Altemus Lenore RubinoSubject CAG + BCA request re order of presentation regarding GU Campus PlanAttachments CAG BCA LTR RE GU PLAN HEARINGJPG

Please see the attached letter from the Citizens Association of Georgetown and the Burleith Citizens Association

8

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Luca ltlucapivatocomgtSent Thursday April 07 2011 104 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject Re ZC GU Hearing MPD DataAttachments ATT00002png

Hi Stephen are you filing today On 442011 1113 AM Mordfin Stephen (OP) wrote Thank you

Stephen J Mordfin AICP Development Review Specialist DC Office of Planning 1100 4th Street SW Suite E650 Washington DC 20024 Office 202‐442‐8810 FAX 202‐442‐7638 stephenmordfindcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Luca [mailtolucapivatocom] Sent Monday April 04 2011 1107 AM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject ZC GU Hearing MPD Data Hi Stephen I have attached some of the charts and maps that we have Ill be happy to come to your office tomorrow at 1pm and bring the raw data on a pen drive as well as our analysis of the data Thank you Luca 301-221-8983 c

9

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Monday April 04 2011 314 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject OP Report on GU Campus Plan

Importance High

Stephen when the OP Report is made available can you send me a copy by email Thanks Richard ___________________________________________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

10

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Luca ltlucapivatocomgtSent Monday April 04 2011 1107 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject ZC GU Hearing MPD DataAttachments Calls By Street for 3500 Block 2000-2009xlsx Calls for O Street 2000-2009xlsx GU

Grad Addresses 2009xls GU Undergrad Addresses 2009xls GMap All Addresses 2009jpg Top10 Calls Residential 2009xlsx Aggregated Geocoded 911 calls - 2009png

Categories Red Category

Hi Stephen I have attached some of the charts and maps that we have Ill be happy to come to your office tomorrow at 1pm and bring the raw data on a pen drive as well as our analysis of the data Thank you Luca 301-221-8983 c

11

Johnson Mike (OP)

From rhindscgshcomSent Monday February 07 2011 335 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Subject Fw Info from Charles DeSantisAttachments Response to Ron Lewis Request_20101117adoc

Steve enclosed is the source of some of the other GU numbers we provided you today Note in particular the growth in non-traditional undergraduates and despite that growth the large reduction in number living in zip 20007 That number needs to be verified However if it were accurate and if the undergraduate cap includes non-traditional students as proposed by GU a decrease in enrollment of non-traditional students would permit a potentially large increase in traditional undergraduates seeking housing in the community which is the opposite of what the community wants to see happen Ditto for students studying abroad if for some unclear to me reason they were included in calculating the base cap Accordingly if total undergraduate enrollment is capped there still needs to be some control on the enrollment of traditional undergraduates in excess of the number of beds provided by the University on campus Requiring the University to take action if the number of undergraduates living in zip 20007 exceeds some number (which should be well below the current number) would provide that control and get to the heart of the communitys concerns Richard ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Charles DeSantis ltced33georgetownedugt Date Wed Nov 17 2010 at 607 PM Subject Re Setting up time to meet To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Cc Dan Porterfield ltporterfdgeorgetownedugt Linda greenan ltgreenanlgeorgetownedugt Margaret Elizabeth Moore ltmem95georgetownedugt Ron As you know we have had a flurry of activity with the news of Dans new presidential appointment at Franklin and Marshall College We are very excited and proud of him and we are also experiencing the loss of a great leader amongst us This has presented some conflicts for meeting with you to discuss answers to your questions this week In the interest of getting you these responses we wanted to provide you with the attacehd document outlining our responses that you can look over and if you have follow up questions you can either get them to us or we can schedule a meeting time in the near future I hope that this holiday season finds you well Happy Thanksgiving to you and Anne Charles

12

Charles DeSantis Associate Vice President of Faculty and Staff Benefits Chief Benefits Officer Office of Faculty and Staff Benefits Georgetown University Direct Line 2026871787 Cell Phone 2022947434 Fax 2026872389 Benefits 2026872500 Email ced33georgetownedu This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

13

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Tuesday January 25 2011 436 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus lucapivatocom

Ronald Lewis Lenore RubinoSubject UK Article

I thought the attached article might be of interest since it makes clear that the same problems facing Georgetown and Burleith have surfaced throughout England httphmolobbyorguk39articlespdf Richard ______________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

14

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday November 02 2010 418 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Ronald LewisSubject Original GU presentations

Sorry for the delay in sending the links I forgot to look at my notes These are the links to the full original presentations from GU httpsgusharegeorgetowneduOfficeOfCommunicationscampus_plan20090529_May30CampusPlanOptions_AMpdf httpsgusharegeorgetowneduOfficeOfCommunicationscampus_plan20090529_May30CampusPlanOptions_PMpdf Regards Gianluca Pivato

15

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Thursday August 26 2010 1001 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Ron LewisSubject Re RE

Oh OK So GUs practice of averaging is still acceptable Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 407 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

Your welcome One change I meant to say that the student counting may NOT be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

Steve

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202‐442‐8810

FAX 202‐442‐7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

16

From Jennifer Altemus [mailtocag-presidentcagtownorg] Sent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer

On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

17

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

18

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

19

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

20

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday May 18 2010 1129 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP)Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meetingAttachments Georgetowner Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on the Georgetowner I meant to attach it to the previous email The editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning for longer than 10 years and being geographically limited by the west and south boundaries Unfortunately unless the trend is reversed and GU complies with the DC Comprehensive Plan the long term result of turning Georgetown and Burleith into college towns is a very real possibility GU under De Gioia is planning to expand enormously in the next decades and this is only the first step I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the adjacent neighborhoods They just need a little push Best regards Luca Pivato On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your time today Please find attached selected data slides from this morning presentation I will be glad to answer any question you may have about the numbers our sources and references or our calculation methods The easiest way to contact me is on my cell at 301-221-8983 or via email at cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg Best regards Luca Pivato

21

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Monday May 17 2010 501 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich

Hinds Lenore Rubino DCtuxedoaolcomSubject Fw 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

This is the incident that was mentioned today involving (1) a graduate student living in Burleith who has repeatedly engaged in loud late night partying (2) whom GU was unaware was living in Burleith Stephen Brown is a resident of Burleith who has created his own website to protest GU student misconduct in his neighborhood It has generated much attention httpwwwdrunkengeorgetownstudentscom Richard ----- Forwarded by Richard deC HINDSDCCgsh on 05172010 0445 PM ----- Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt

17 May 2010 0954 AM

To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Ed Soloman ltdctuxedoaolcomgt Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgt Altemus Jennifer ltcag-presidentcagtownorggt Gianluca Pivato ltlucapivatocomgt

cc

Subject Fwd FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

It is confirmed This is a good example of where GU does not know where all its students live For those jumping in on the email stream Lt Hedgecock MPD reported there was a noise disturbance and Anne Koester (GU) relayed it wasnt a GU student house ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Mon May 17 2010 at 834 AM Subject FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT To Bonnie Hardy lthardybonniehotmailcomgt Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt Dear BonnieLenore This is a medical student whorsquos family was visiting and decided that an open fire and a musical tribute were appropriate I felt otherwise and we ended up having quite a fracas in the alley The police were called twice SNAP came byetcand the letter that follows is to Dean Jeanne Lord We have at least two to three 911rsquos per year from that house Regards

22

Stephen Stephen R Brown Photography 3715 T Street NW Washington DC 20007 202‐667‐1965 202‐255‐8635(cell) httpwwwsrbphotocom httpwwwdcphotobookcom httpwwwjewelofthemallcom mailtosrbsrbphotocom

‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded Message From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Sun 16 May 2010 132049 ‐0400 To Jeanne Lord ltlordjgeorgetownedugt Conversation 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Subject 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Jeanne I can assure you I am quite as tired of this as you and am going out today to buy a quality pair of headphones I wil be doing a composite sketch of all the pictures I have taken and thatrsquos all that will be on the website other than general information to the neighbors It is getting 19000 hits per day and as you may or may not have noticed I have taken out advertising I will be happy to ressurect the site in a more popular format if things continue as they are as I fully expect them to Obviously I donrsquot think you have a handle on your current student population so I will be working in other ways to block GUrsquos growth Last night3713 broke into Florida version of Swiss Family Robinson and three neighbors called the police As they went into the house they began yelling out my name At 217 they began a phone marathon to my studio and fortunately not to my house I have the voice recordings and they are not particularly ldquomedicalrdquo I have to question this womanrsquos competency to get a license as her drunken tirades and now phone marathons are stunningly nasty Herersquos a photo of my phone with the ldquoblocked callsrdquo from her family member who was visiting and her number which she wasnrsquot clever enough to block If yoursquod like to hear what Georgetownrsquos finest has to say on the phone Irsquoll be happy to put it up on the web Otherwise I expect some disciplinary actionsome examination of this womenrsquos competence to get a medical license and a letter of apology to my family ‐‐‐‐‐‐ End of Forwarded Message -- Lenore G Rubino Realtor Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage wwwlenorerubinocom

23

202-262-1261 (best way to reach me) 202-471-5262 (e-fax) Washington Harbour - Georgetown 3000 K Street NW Suite 101 Washington DC 20007

This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

24

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Thursday January 14 2010 301 PMTo Jennings Jeffrey (DDOT) Ziemann Christopher (DDOT)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) billstarrelsgmailcom dctuxedoaolcom

billskelseyancaolcom cag-presidentcagtownorg lenorerubiongmailcomSubject Friday meeting re transportation aspects of GUs 10-year planAttachments Impacts of GU transportation issues and draft 10-year plandoc

Dear Jeff and Chris In case this might be helpful for our meeting Friday morning an outline is attached of what we see as some key transportation issues in the Georgetown University draft 10-year campus plan Our group will include - From ANC 2E - Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Ed Solomon (possibly) and Bill Skelsey (possibly) From the Citizens Association of Georgetown Jennifer Altemus president From the Burleith Citizens Association Lenore Rubino president We look forward to seeing you on Friday (tomorrow) at DDOT at 930 am Best regards Ron

25

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Tuesday January 12 2010 947 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc billstarrelsgmailcom billskelseyancaolcom dctuxedoaolcom cag-

presidentcagtownorg lucapivatocom rhindscgshcom lenorerubinogmailcom

Subject Meeting re Georgetown University 10-year plan with community representatives Jan 13

Attachments Outline of some key impacts on the community of the GU draft 10-year plan-1doc

Dear Jennifer Joel and Steve An outline is attached in case it might be helpful of some key issues in the Georgetown University draft 10‐year plan that wed like to discuss with you at tomorrows meeting Out group tomorrow will include ‐ ANC 2E (Georgetown and Burleith) Commissioners Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Bill Skelsey and Ed Solomon Citizens Association of Georgetown President Jennifer Altemus Vice President Luca Pivato and advisor Richard Hinds Burleith Citizens Association President Lenore Rubino and advisor Mark Gisler We look forward very much to seeing you and continuing the productive dialogue Best regards Ron Ron Lewis Chair ANC 2E

26

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Friday January 08 2010 1057 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer AltemusSubject RE Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image001gif image002gif CAG letter to GU re campus planpdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan Best Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia

27

Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar

28

See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

29

B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

30

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Thursday December 31 2009 406 PMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP)Subject Re Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image002gif image001gif

Jennifer Thanks for providing this information Happy New Year Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Sent Thu Dec 31 144709 2009 Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

31

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 2: Emails 1

2

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Luca ltlucapivatocomgtSent Friday April 15 2011 1217 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject Re ZC GU Hearing MPD DataAttachments ATT00002png 911Calls2000-2010-3500-O-3500-Pxlsx

911Calls2000-2010-1400-36TH-1400-35THxlsx 911Calls2000-2010-O-ByBlockxlsx 911Calls2000-2010-Prospect-ByBlockxlsx 911Calls2000-2010-BlocksWithStudentsxlsx

Hi Stephen As an update to the MPD calls data that I have provided a couple of weeks ago when I didnt have the 2010 calls yet Id like to send you some attachments now with the latest 2010 MPD calls for service I have updated some charts with data that will be part of many more chars that we will show The data shows a picture that is exactly the opposite of what GU said Their data was misleading because they mixed students and residents blocks Our data shows that all of their programs including the new ones (implemented 1 year ago) have not made any measurable difference whatsoever In fact 911 calls are up and trending up in all studentified blocks See attachments Feel free to contact me at any time if you need clarification on the data Best Luca 301-221-8983 c On 472011 326 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) wrote The Office of Planning has requested an extension to file its report to give more time to review the submittal by the applicant on March 31 2011 OP has requested that the first hearing be held on May 12 which was originally scheduled to be the first continuation date Steve

Stephen J Mordfin AICP Development Review Specialist DC Office of Planning 1100 4th Street SW Suite E650 Washington DC 20024 Office 202‐442‐8810 FAX 202‐442‐7638 stephenmordfindcgov httpplanningdcgov

3

From Luca [mailtolucapivatocom] Sent Thursday April 07 2011 104 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject Re ZC GU Hearing MPD Data Hi Stephen are you filing today On 442011 1113 AM Mordfin Stephen (OP) wrote Thank you

Stephen J Mordfin AICP Development Review Specialist DC Office of Planning 1100 4th Street SW Suite E650 Washington DC 20024 Office 202‐442‐8810 FAX 202‐442‐7638 stephenmordfindcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Luca [mailtolucapivatocom] Sent Monday April 04 2011 1107 AM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject ZC GU Hearing MPD Data Hi Stephen I have attached some of the charts and maps that we have Ill be happy to come to your office tomorrow at 1pm and bring the raw data on a pen drive as well as our analysis of the data Thank you Luca 301-221-8983 c

4

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Tuesday April 12 2011 1043 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject RE OP Report on 2000 PlanAttachments ATT00002png

Thanks Please email me you Report when you get it approved Richard ___________________________________________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom From Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt To Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgt Date 04122011 1040 AM Subject RE OP Report on 2000 Plan

As requested

Stephen J Mordfin AICP Development Review Specialist DC Office of Planning 1100 4th Street SW Suite E650 Washington DC 20024 Office 202‐442‐8810 FAX 202‐442‐7638 stephenmordfindcgov httpplanningdcgov From Richard deC HINDS [mailtorhindscgshcom] Sent Tuesday April 12 2011 1036 AM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject OP Report on 2000 Plan Hi Steve Glad to hear you have some breathing room OP issued a report on Georgetown University Campus Plan 200-2010 BZA Application No 16566 dated June 12 2000 P 28 contains data on where undergrads live at p 28 that I would like to use at the hearing but I do not have a good copy of it and would like to see the entire report Can you email

5

or fax it to me Thanks Richard ___________________________________________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999 wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy[attachment 16566 GU Campus Plan Report 06-12-00pdf deleted by Richard deC HINDSDCCgsh] This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

6

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Tuesday April 12 2011 1036 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject OP Report on 2000 Plan

Hi Steve Glad to hear you have some breathing room OP issued a report on Georgetown University Campus Plan 200-2010 BZA Application No 16566 dated June 12 2000 P 28 contains data on where undergrads live at p 28 that I would like to use at the hearing but I do not have a good copy of it and would like to see the entire report Can you email or fax it to me Thanks Richard ___________________________________________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

7

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Betsy Cooley ltbetsycooleycagtownorggtSent Thursday April 07 2011 549 PMTo Hawkinson Colleen (DDOT) Hanousek Donna (DCOZ) Schellin Sharon (DCOZ) Ricks

Karina (DDOT) Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP) DCOZ - ZC Submissions (DCOZ) Bill Starrells Ed Solomon tmfsmithstarpowernet Ron Lewis Jones Jeffrey (ANC 2E03)

Cc Jennifer Altemus Lenore RubinoSubject CAG + BCA request re order of presentation regarding GU Campus PlanAttachments CAG BCA LTR RE GU PLAN HEARINGJPG

Please see the attached letter from the Citizens Association of Georgetown and the Burleith Citizens Association

8

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Luca ltlucapivatocomgtSent Thursday April 07 2011 104 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject Re ZC GU Hearing MPD DataAttachments ATT00002png

Hi Stephen are you filing today On 442011 1113 AM Mordfin Stephen (OP) wrote Thank you

Stephen J Mordfin AICP Development Review Specialist DC Office of Planning 1100 4th Street SW Suite E650 Washington DC 20024 Office 202‐442‐8810 FAX 202‐442‐7638 stephenmordfindcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Luca [mailtolucapivatocom] Sent Monday April 04 2011 1107 AM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject ZC GU Hearing MPD Data Hi Stephen I have attached some of the charts and maps that we have Ill be happy to come to your office tomorrow at 1pm and bring the raw data on a pen drive as well as our analysis of the data Thank you Luca 301-221-8983 c

9

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Monday April 04 2011 314 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject OP Report on GU Campus Plan

Importance High

Stephen when the OP Report is made available can you send me a copy by email Thanks Richard ___________________________________________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

10

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Luca ltlucapivatocomgtSent Monday April 04 2011 1107 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject ZC GU Hearing MPD DataAttachments Calls By Street for 3500 Block 2000-2009xlsx Calls for O Street 2000-2009xlsx GU

Grad Addresses 2009xls GU Undergrad Addresses 2009xls GMap All Addresses 2009jpg Top10 Calls Residential 2009xlsx Aggregated Geocoded 911 calls - 2009png

Categories Red Category

Hi Stephen I have attached some of the charts and maps that we have Ill be happy to come to your office tomorrow at 1pm and bring the raw data on a pen drive as well as our analysis of the data Thank you Luca 301-221-8983 c

11

Johnson Mike (OP)

From rhindscgshcomSent Monday February 07 2011 335 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Subject Fw Info from Charles DeSantisAttachments Response to Ron Lewis Request_20101117adoc

Steve enclosed is the source of some of the other GU numbers we provided you today Note in particular the growth in non-traditional undergraduates and despite that growth the large reduction in number living in zip 20007 That number needs to be verified However if it were accurate and if the undergraduate cap includes non-traditional students as proposed by GU a decrease in enrollment of non-traditional students would permit a potentially large increase in traditional undergraduates seeking housing in the community which is the opposite of what the community wants to see happen Ditto for students studying abroad if for some unclear to me reason they were included in calculating the base cap Accordingly if total undergraduate enrollment is capped there still needs to be some control on the enrollment of traditional undergraduates in excess of the number of beds provided by the University on campus Requiring the University to take action if the number of undergraduates living in zip 20007 exceeds some number (which should be well below the current number) would provide that control and get to the heart of the communitys concerns Richard ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Charles DeSantis ltced33georgetownedugt Date Wed Nov 17 2010 at 607 PM Subject Re Setting up time to meet To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Cc Dan Porterfield ltporterfdgeorgetownedugt Linda greenan ltgreenanlgeorgetownedugt Margaret Elizabeth Moore ltmem95georgetownedugt Ron As you know we have had a flurry of activity with the news of Dans new presidential appointment at Franklin and Marshall College We are very excited and proud of him and we are also experiencing the loss of a great leader amongst us This has presented some conflicts for meeting with you to discuss answers to your questions this week In the interest of getting you these responses we wanted to provide you with the attacehd document outlining our responses that you can look over and if you have follow up questions you can either get them to us or we can schedule a meeting time in the near future I hope that this holiday season finds you well Happy Thanksgiving to you and Anne Charles

12

Charles DeSantis Associate Vice President of Faculty and Staff Benefits Chief Benefits Officer Office of Faculty and Staff Benefits Georgetown University Direct Line 2026871787 Cell Phone 2022947434 Fax 2026872389 Benefits 2026872500 Email ced33georgetownedu This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

13

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Tuesday January 25 2011 436 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus lucapivatocom

Ronald Lewis Lenore RubinoSubject UK Article

I thought the attached article might be of interest since it makes clear that the same problems facing Georgetown and Burleith have surfaced throughout England httphmolobbyorguk39articlespdf Richard ______________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

14

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday November 02 2010 418 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Ronald LewisSubject Original GU presentations

Sorry for the delay in sending the links I forgot to look at my notes These are the links to the full original presentations from GU httpsgusharegeorgetowneduOfficeOfCommunicationscampus_plan20090529_May30CampusPlanOptions_AMpdf httpsgusharegeorgetowneduOfficeOfCommunicationscampus_plan20090529_May30CampusPlanOptions_PMpdf Regards Gianluca Pivato

15

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Thursday August 26 2010 1001 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Ron LewisSubject Re RE

Oh OK So GUs practice of averaging is still acceptable Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 407 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

Your welcome One change I meant to say that the student counting may NOT be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

Steve

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202‐442‐8810

FAX 202‐442‐7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

16

From Jennifer Altemus [mailtocag-presidentcagtownorg] Sent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer

On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

17

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

18

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

19

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

20

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday May 18 2010 1129 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP)Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meetingAttachments Georgetowner Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on the Georgetowner I meant to attach it to the previous email The editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning for longer than 10 years and being geographically limited by the west and south boundaries Unfortunately unless the trend is reversed and GU complies with the DC Comprehensive Plan the long term result of turning Georgetown and Burleith into college towns is a very real possibility GU under De Gioia is planning to expand enormously in the next decades and this is only the first step I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the adjacent neighborhoods They just need a little push Best regards Luca Pivato On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your time today Please find attached selected data slides from this morning presentation I will be glad to answer any question you may have about the numbers our sources and references or our calculation methods The easiest way to contact me is on my cell at 301-221-8983 or via email at cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg Best regards Luca Pivato

21

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Monday May 17 2010 501 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich

Hinds Lenore Rubino DCtuxedoaolcomSubject Fw 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

This is the incident that was mentioned today involving (1) a graduate student living in Burleith who has repeatedly engaged in loud late night partying (2) whom GU was unaware was living in Burleith Stephen Brown is a resident of Burleith who has created his own website to protest GU student misconduct in his neighborhood It has generated much attention httpwwwdrunkengeorgetownstudentscom Richard ----- Forwarded by Richard deC HINDSDCCgsh on 05172010 0445 PM ----- Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt

17 May 2010 0954 AM

To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Ed Soloman ltdctuxedoaolcomgt Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgt Altemus Jennifer ltcag-presidentcagtownorggt Gianluca Pivato ltlucapivatocomgt

cc

Subject Fwd FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

It is confirmed This is a good example of where GU does not know where all its students live For those jumping in on the email stream Lt Hedgecock MPD reported there was a noise disturbance and Anne Koester (GU) relayed it wasnt a GU student house ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Mon May 17 2010 at 834 AM Subject FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT To Bonnie Hardy lthardybonniehotmailcomgt Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt Dear BonnieLenore This is a medical student whorsquos family was visiting and decided that an open fire and a musical tribute were appropriate I felt otherwise and we ended up having quite a fracas in the alley The police were called twice SNAP came byetcand the letter that follows is to Dean Jeanne Lord We have at least two to three 911rsquos per year from that house Regards

22

Stephen Stephen R Brown Photography 3715 T Street NW Washington DC 20007 202‐667‐1965 202‐255‐8635(cell) httpwwwsrbphotocom httpwwwdcphotobookcom httpwwwjewelofthemallcom mailtosrbsrbphotocom

‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded Message From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Sun 16 May 2010 132049 ‐0400 To Jeanne Lord ltlordjgeorgetownedugt Conversation 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Subject 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Jeanne I can assure you I am quite as tired of this as you and am going out today to buy a quality pair of headphones I wil be doing a composite sketch of all the pictures I have taken and thatrsquos all that will be on the website other than general information to the neighbors It is getting 19000 hits per day and as you may or may not have noticed I have taken out advertising I will be happy to ressurect the site in a more popular format if things continue as they are as I fully expect them to Obviously I donrsquot think you have a handle on your current student population so I will be working in other ways to block GUrsquos growth Last night3713 broke into Florida version of Swiss Family Robinson and three neighbors called the police As they went into the house they began yelling out my name At 217 they began a phone marathon to my studio and fortunately not to my house I have the voice recordings and they are not particularly ldquomedicalrdquo I have to question this womanrsquos competency to get a license as her drunken tirades and now phone marathons are stunningly nasty Herersquos a photo of my phone with the ldquoblocked callsrdquo from her family member who was visiting and her number which she wasnrsquot clever enough to block If yoursquod like to hear what Georgetownrsquos finest has to say on the phone Irsquoll be happy to put it up on the web Otherwise I expect some disciplinary actionsome examination of this womenrsquos competence to get a medical license and a letter of apology to my family ‐‐‐‐‐‐ End of Forwarded Message -- Lenore G Rubino Realtor Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage wwwlenorerubinocom

23

202-262-1261 (best way to reach me) 202-471-5262 (e-fax) Washington Harbour - Georgetown 3000 K Street NW Suite 101 Washington DC 20007

This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

24

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Thursday January 14 2010 301 PMTo Jennings Jeffrey (DDOT) Ziemann Christopher (DDOT)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) billstarrelsgmailcom dctuxedoaolcom

billskelseyancaolcom cag-presidentcagtownorg lenorerubiongmailcomSubject Friday meeting re transportation aspects of GUs 10-year planAttachments Impacts of GU transportation issues and draft 10-year plandoc

Dear Jeff and Chris In case this might be helpful for our meeting Friday morning an outline is attached of what we see as some key transportation issues in the Georgetown University draft 10-year campus plan Our group will include - From ANC 2E - Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Ed Solomon (possibly) and Bill Skelsey (possibly) From the Citizens Association of Georgetown Jennifer Altemus president From the Burleith Citizens Association Lenore Rubino president We look forward to seeing you on Friday (tomorrow) at DDOT at 930 am Best regards Ron

25

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Tuesday January 12 2010 947 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc billstarrelsgmailcom billskelseyancaolcom dctuxedoaolcom cag-

presidentcagtownorg lucapivatocom rhindscgshcom lenorerubinogmailcom

Subject Meeting re Georgetown University 10-year plan with community representatives Jan 13

Attachments Outline of some key impacts on the community of the GU draft 10-year plan-1doc

Dear Jennifer Joel and Steve An outline is attached in case it might be helpful of some key issues in the Georgetown University draft 10‐year plan that wed like to discuss with you at tomorrows meeting Out group tomorrow will include ‐ ANC 2E (Georgetown and Burleith) Commissioners Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Bill Skelsey and Ed Solomon Citizens Association of Georgetown President Jennifer Altemus Vice President Luca Pivato and advisor Richard Hinds Burleith Citizens Association President Lenore Rubino and advisor Mark Gisler We look forward very much to seeing you and continuing the productive dialogue Best regards Ron Ron Lewis Chair ANC 2E

26

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Friday January 08 2010 1057 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer AltemusSubject RE Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image001gif image002gif CAG letter to GU re campus planpdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan Best Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia

27

Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar

28

See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

29

B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

30

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Thursday December 31 2009 406 PMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP)Subject Re Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image002gif image001gif

Jennifer Thanks for providing this information Happy New Year Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Sent Thu Dec 31 144709 2009 Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

31

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 3: Emails 1

3

From Luca [mailtolucapivatocom] Sent Thursday April 07 2011 104 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject Re ZC GU Hearing MPD Data Hi Stephen are you filing today On 442011 1113 AM Mordfin Stephen (OP) wrote Thank you

Stephen J Mordfin AICP Development Review Specialist DC Office of Planning 1100 4th Street SW Suite E650 Washington DC 20024 Office 202‐442‐8810 FAX 202‐442‐7638 stephenmordfindcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Luca [mailtolucapivatocom] Sent Monday April 04 2011 1107 AM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject ZC GU Hearing MPD Data Hi Stephen I have attached some of the charts and maps that we have Ill be happy to come to your office tomorrow at 1pm and bring the raw data on a pen drive as well as our analysis of the data Thank you Luca 301-221-8983 c

4

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Tuesday April 12 2011 1043 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject RE OP Report on 2000 PlanAttachments ATT00002png

Thanks Please email me you Report when you get it approved Richard ___________________________________________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom From Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt To Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgt Date 04122011 1040 AM Subject RE OP Report on 2000 Plan

As requested

Stephen J Mordfin AICP Development Review Specialist DC Office of Planning 1100 4th Street SW Suite E650 Washington DC 20024 Office 202‐442‐8810 FAX 202‐442‐7638 stephenmordfindcgov httpplanningdcgov From Richard deC HINDS [mailtorhindscgshcom] Sent Tuesday April 12 2011 1036 AM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject OP Report on 2000 Plan Hi Steve Glad to hear you have some breathing room OP issued a report on Georgetown University Campus Plan 200-2010 BZA Application No 16566 dated June 12 2000 P 28 contains data on where undergrads live at p 28 that I would like to use at the hearing but I do not have a good copy of it and would like to see the entire report Can you email

5

or fax it to me Thanks Richard ___________________________________________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999 wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy[attachment 16566 GU Campus Plan Report 06-12-00pdf deleted by Richard deC HINDSDCCgsh] This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

6

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Tuesday April 12 2011 1036 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject OP Report on 2000 Plan

Hi Steve Glad to hear you have some breathing room OP issued a report on Georgetown University Campus Plan 200-2010 BZA Application No 16566 dated June 12 2000 P 28 contains data on where undergrads live at p 28 that I would like to use at the hearing but I do not have a good copy of it and would like to see the entire report Can you email or fax it to me Thanks Richard ___________________________________________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

7

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Betsy Cooley ltbetsycooleycagtownorggtSent Thursday April 07 2011 549 PMTo Hawkinson Colleen (DDOT) Hanousek Donna (DCOZ) Schellin Sharon (DCOZ) Ricks

Karina (DDOT) Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP) DCOZ - ZC Submissions (DCOZ) Bill Starrells Ed Solomon tmfsmithstarpowernet Ron Lewis Jones Jeffrey (ANC 2E03)

Cc Jennifer Altemus Lenore RubinoSubject CAG + BCA request re order of presentation regarding GU Campus PlanAttachments CAG BCA LTR RE GU PLAN HEARINGJPG

Please see the attached letter from the Citizens Association of Georgetown and the Burleith Citizens Association

8

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Luca ltlucapivatocomgtSent Thursday April 07 2011 104 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject Re ZC GU Hearing MPD DataAttachments ATT00002png

Hi Stephen are you filing today On 442011 1113 AM Mordfin Stephen (OP) wrote Thank you

Stephen J Mordfin AICP Development Review Specialist DC Office of Planning 1100 4th Street SW Suite E650 Washington DC 20024 Office 202‐442‐8810 FAX 202‐442‐7638 stephenmordfindcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Luca [mailtolucapivatocom] Sent Monday April 04 2011 1107 AM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject ZC GU Hearing MPD Data Hi Stephen I have attached some of the charts and maps that we have Ill be happy to come to your office tomorrow at 1pm and bring the raw data on a pen drive as well as our analysis of the data Thank you Luca 301-221-8983 c

9

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Monday April 04 2011 314 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject OP Report on GU Campus Plan

Importance High

Stephen when the OP Report is made available can you send me a copy by email Thanks Richard ___________________________________________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

10

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Luca ltlucapivatocomgtSent Monday April 04 2011 1107 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject ZC GU Hearing MPD DataAttachments Calls By Street for 3500 Block 2000-2009xlsx Calls for O Street 2000-2009xlsx GU

Grad Addresses 2009xls GU Undergrad Addresses 2009xls GMap All Addresses 2009jpg Top10 Calls Residential 2009xlsx Aggregated Geocoded 911 calls - 2009png

Categories Red Category

Hi Stephen I have attached some of the charts and maps that we have Ill be happy to come to your office tomorrow at 1pm and bring the raw data on a pen drive as well as our analysis of the data Thank you Luca 301-221-8983 c

11

Johnson Mike (OP)

From rhindscgshcomSent Monday February 07 2011 335 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Subject Fw Info from Charles DeSantisAttachments Response to Ron Lewis Request_20101117adoc

Steve enclosed is the source of some of the other GU numbers we provided you today Note in particular the growth in non-traditional undergraduates and despite that growth the large reduction in number living in zip 20007 That number needs to be verified However if it were accurate and if the undergraduate cap includes non-traditional students as proposed by GU a decrease in enrollment of non-traditional students would permit a potentially large increase in traditional undergraduates seeking housing in the community which is the opposite of what the community wants to see happen Ditto for students studying abroad if for some unclear to me reason they were included in calculating the base cap Accordingly if total undergraduate enrollment is capped there still needs to be some control on the enrollment of traditional undergraduates in excess of the number of beds provided by the University on campus Requiring the University to take action if the number of undergraduates living in zip 20007 exceeds some number (which should be well below the current number) would provide that control and get to the heart of the communitys concerns Richard ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Charles DeSantis ltced33georgetownedugt Date Wed Nov 17 2010 at 607 PM Subject Re Setting up time to meet To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Cc Dan Porterfield ltporterfdgeorgetownedugt Linda greenan ltgreenanlgeorgetownedugt Margaret Elizabeth Moore ltmem95georgetownedugt Ron As you know we have had a flurry of activity with the news of Dans new presidential appointment at Franklin and Marshall College We are very excited and proud of him and we are also experiencing the loss of a great leader amongst us This has presented some conflicts for meeting with you to discuss answers to your questions this week In the interest of getting you these responses we wanted to provide you with the attacehd document outlining our responses that you can look over and if you have follow up questions you can either get them to us or we can schedule a meeting time in the near future I hope that this holiday season finds you well Happy Thanksgiving to you and Anne Charles

12

Charles DeSantis Associate Vice President of Faculty and Staff Benefits Chief Benefits Officer Office of Faculty and Staff Benefits Georgetown University Direct Line 2026871787 Cell Phone 2022947434 Fax 2026872389 Benefits 2026872500 Email ced33georgetownedu This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

13

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Tuesday January 25 2011 436 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus lucapivatocom

Ronald Lewis Lenore RubinoSubject UK Article

I thought the attached article might be of interest since it makes clear that the same problems facing Georgetown and Burleith have surfaced throughout England httphmolobbyorguk39articlespdf Richard ______________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

14

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday November 02 2010 418 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Ronald LewisSubject Original GU presentations

Sorry for the delay in sending the links I forgot to look at my notes These are the links to the full original presentations from GU httpsgusharegeorgetowneduOfficeOfCommunicationscampus_plan20090529_May30CampusPlanOptions_AMpdf httpsgusharegeorgetowneduOfficeOfCommunicationscampus_plan20090529_May30CampusPlanOptions_PMpdf Regards Gianluca Pivato

15

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Thursday August 26 2010 1001 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Ron LewisSubject Re RE

Oh OK So GUs practice of averaging is still acceptable Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 407 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

Your welcome One change I meant to say that the student counting may NOT be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

Steve

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202‐442‐8810

FAX 202‐442‐7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

16

From Jennifer Altemus [mailtocag-presidentcagtownorg] Sent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer

On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

17

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

18

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

19

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

20

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday May 18 2010 1129 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP)Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meetingAttachments Georgetowner Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on the Georgetowner I meant to attach it to the previous email The editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning for longer than 10 years and being geographically limited by the west and south boundaries Unfortunately unless the trend is reversed and GU complies with the DC Comprehensive Plan the long term result of turning Georgetown and Burleith into college towns is a very real possibility GU under De Gioia is planning to expand enormously in the next decades and this is only the first step I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the adjacent neighborhoods They just need a little push Best regards Luca Pivato On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your time today Please find attached selected data slides from this morning presentation I will be glad to answer any question you may have about the numbers our sources and references or our calculation methods The easiest way to contact me is on my cell at 301-221-8983 or via email at cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg Best regards Luca Pivato

21

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Monday May 17 2010 501 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich

Hinds Lenore Rubino DCtuxedoaolcomSubject Fw 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

This is the incident that was mentioned today involving (1) a graduate student living in Burleith who has repeatedly engaged in loud late night partying (2) whom GU was unaware was living in Burleith Stephen Brown is a resident of Burleith who has created his own website to protest GU student misconduct in his neighborhood It has generated much attention httpwwwdrunkengeorgetownstudentscom Richard ----- Forwarded by Richard deC HINDSDCCgsh on 05172010 0445 PM ----- Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt

17 May 2010 0954 AM

To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Ed Soloman ltdctuxedoaolcomgt Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgt Altemus Jennifer ltcag-presidentcagtownorggt Gianluca Pivato ltlucapivatocomgt

cc

Subject Fwd FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

It is confirmed This is a good example of where GU does not know where all its students live For those jumping in on the email stream Lt Hedgecock MPD reported there was a noise disturbance and Anne Koester (GU) relayed it wasnt a GU student house ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Mon May 17 2010 at 834 AM Subject FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT To Bonnie Hardy lthardybonniehotmailcomgt Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt Dear BonnieLenore This is a medical student whorsquos family was visiting and decided that an open fire and a musical tribute were appropriate I felt otherwise and we ended up having quite a fracas in the alley The police were called twice SNAP came byetcand the letter that follows is to Dean Jeanne Lord We have at least two to three 911rsquos per year from that house Regards

22

Stephen Stephen R Brown Photography 3715 T Street NW Washington DC 20007 202‐667‐1965 202‐255‐8635(cell) httpwwwsrbphotocom httpwwwdcphotobookcom httpwwwjewelofthemallcom mailtosrbsrbphotocom

‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded Message From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Sun 16 May 2010 132049 ‐0400 To Jeanne Lord ltlordjgeorgetownedugt Conversation 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Subject 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Jeanne I can assure you I am quite as tired of this as you and am going out today to buy a quality pair of headphones I wil be doing a composite sketch of all the pictures I have taken and thatrsquos all that will be on the website other than general information to the neighbors It is getting 19000 hits per day and as you may or may not have noticed I have taken out advertising I will be happy to ressurect the site in a more popular format if things continue as they are as I fully expect them to Obviously I donrsquot think you have a handle on your current student population so I will be working in other ways to block GUrsquos growth Last night3713 broke into Florida version of Swiss Family Robinson and three neighbors called the police As they went into the house they began yelling out my name At 217 they began a phone marathon to my studio and fortunately not to my house I have the voice recordings and they are not particularly ldquomedicalrdquo I have to question this womanrsquos competency to get a license as her drunken tirades and now phone marathons are stunningly nasty Herersquos a photo of my phone with the ldquoblocked callsrdquo from her family member who was visiting and her number which she wasnrsquot clever enough to block If yoursquod like to hear what Georgetownrsquos finest has to say on the phone Irsquoll be happy to put it up on the web Otherwise I expect some disciplinary actionsome examination of this womenrsquos competence to get a medical license and a letter of apology to my family ‐‐‐‐‐‐ End of Forwarded Message -- Lenore G Rubino Realtor Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage wwwlenorerubinocom

23

202-262-1261 (best way to reach me) 202-471-5262 (e-fax) Washington Harbour - Georgetown 3000 K Street NW Suite 101 Washington DC 20007

This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

24

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Thursday January 14 2010 301 PMTo Jennings Jeffrey (DDOT) Ziemann Christopher (DDOT)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) billstarrelsgmailcom dctuxedoaolcom

billskelseyancaolcom cag-presidentcagtownorg lenorerubiongmailcomSubject Friday meeting re transportation aspects of GUs 10-year planAttachments Impacts of GU transportation issues and draft 10-year plandoc

Dear Jeff and Chris In case this might be helpful for our meeting Friday morning an outline is attached of what we see as some key transportation issues in the Georgetown University draft 10-year campus plan Our group will include - From ANC 2E - Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Ed Solomon (possibly) and Bill Skelsey (possibly) From the Citizens Association of Georgetown Jennifer Altemus president From the Burleith Citizens Association Lenore Rubino president We look forward to seeing you on Friday (tomorrow) at DDOT at 930 am Best regards Ron

25

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Tuesday January 12 2010 947 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc billstarrelsgmailcom billskelseyancaolcom dctuxedoaolcom cag-

presidentcagtownorg lucapivatocom rhindscgshcom lenorerubinogmailcom

Subject Meeting re Georgetown University 10-year plan with community representatives Jan 13

Attachments Outline of some key impacts on the community of the GU draft 10-year plan-1doc

Dear Jennifer Joel and Steve An outline is attached in case it might be helpful of some key issues in the Georgetown University draft 10‐year plan that wed like to discuss with you at tomorrows meeting Out group tomorrow will include ‐ ANC 2E (Georgetown and Burleith) Commissioners Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Bill Skelsey and Ed Solomon Citizens Association of Georgetown President Jennifer Altemus Vice President Luca Pivato and advisor Richard Hinds Burleith Citizens Association President Lenore Rubino and advisor Mark Gisler We look forward very much to seeing you and continuing the productive dialogue Best regards Ron Ron Lewis Chair ANC 2E

26

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Friday January 08 2010 1057 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer AltemusSubject RE Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image001gif image002gif CAG letter to GU re campus planpdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan Best Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia

27

Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar

28

See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

29

B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

30

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Thursday December 31 2009 406 PMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP)Subject Re Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image002gif image001gif

Jennifer Thanks for providing this information Happy New Year Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Sent Thu Dec 31 144709 2009 Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

31

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 4: Emails 1

4

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Tuesday April 12 2011 1043 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject RE OP Report on 2000 PlanAttachments ATT00002png

Thanks Please email me you Report when you get it approved Richard ___________________________________________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom From Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt To Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgt Date 04122011 1040 AM Subject RE OP Report on 2000 Plan

As requested

Stephen J Mordfin AICP Development Review Specialist DC Office of Planning 1100 4th Street SW Suite E650 Washington DC 20024 Office 202‐442‐8810 FAX 202‐442‐7638 stephenmordfindcgov httpplanningdcgov From Richard deC HINDS [mailtorhindscgshcom] Sent Tuesday April 12 2011 1036 AM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject OP Report on 2000 Plan Hi Steve Glad to hear you have some breathing room OP issued a report on Georgetown University Campus Plan 200-2010 BZA Application No 16566 dated June 12 2000 P 28 contains data on where undergrads live at p 28 that I would like to use at the hearing but I do not have a good copy of it and would like to see the entire report Can you email

5

or fax it to me Thanks Richard ___________________________________________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999 wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy[attachment 16566 GU Campus Plan Report 06-12-00pdf deleted by Richard deC HINDSDCCgsh] This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

6

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Tuesday April 12 2011 1036 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject OP Report on 2000 Plan

Hi Steve Glad to hear you have some breathing room OP issued a report on Georgetown University Campus Plan 200-2010 BZA Application No 16566 dated June 12 2000 P 28 contains data on where undergrads live at p 28 that I would like to use at the hearing but I do not have a good copy of it and would like to see the entire report Can you email or fax it to me Thanks Richard ___________________________________________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

7

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Betsy Cooley ltbetsycooleycagtownorggtSent Thursday April 07 2011 549 PMTo Hawkinson Colleen (DDOT) Hanousek Donna (DCOZ) Schellin Sharon (DCOZ) Ricks

Karina (DDOT) Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP) DCOZ - ZC Submissions (DCOZ) Bill Starrells Ed Solomon tmfsmithstarpowernet Ron Lewis Jones Jeffrey (ANC 2E03)

Cc Jennifer Altemus Lenore RubinoSubject CAG + BCA request re order of presentation regarding GU Campus PlanAttachments CAG BCA LTR RE GU PLAN HEARINGJPG

Please see the attached letter from the Citizens Association of Georgetown and the Burleith Citizens Association

8

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Luca ltlucapivatocomgtSent Thursday April 07 2011 104 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject Re ZC GU Hearing MPD DataAttachments ATT00002png

Hi Stephen are you filing today On 442011 1113 AM Mordfin Stephen (OP) wrote Thank you

Stephen J Mordfin AICP Development Review Specialist DC Office of Planning 1100 4th Street SW Suite E650 Washington DC 20024 Office 202‐442‐8810 FAX 202‐442‐7638 stephenmordfindcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Luca [mailtolucapivatocom] Sent Monday April 04 2011 1107 AM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject ZC GU Hearing MPD Data Hi Stephen I have attached some of the charts and maps that we have Ill be happy to come to your office tomorrow at 1pm and bring the raw data on a pen drive as well as our analysis of the data Thank you Luca 301-221-8983 c

9

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Monday April 04 2011 314 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject OP Report on GU Campus Plan

Importance High

Stephen when the OP Report is made available can you send me a copy by email Thanks Richard ___________________________________________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

10

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Luca ltlucapivatocomgtSent Monday April 04 2011 1107 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject ZC GU Hearing MPD DataAttachments Calls By Street for 3500 Block 2000-2009xlsx Calls for O Street 2000-2009xlsx GU

Grad Addresses 2009xls GU Undergrad Addresses 2009xls GMap All Addresses 2009jpg Top10 Calls Residential 2009xlsx Aggregated Geocoded 911 calls - 2009png

Categories Red Category

Hi Stephen I have attached some of the charts and maps that we have Ill be happy to come to your office tomorrow at 1pm and bring the raw data on a pen drive as well as our analysis of the data Thank you Luca 301-221-8983 c

11

Johnson Mike (OP)

From rhindscgshcomSent Monday February 07 2011 335 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Subject Fw Info from Charles DeSantisAttachments Response to Ron Lewis Request_20101117adoc

Steve enclosed is the source of some of the other GU numbers we provided you today Note in particular the growth in non-traditional undergraduates and despite that growth the large reduction in number living in zip 20007 That number needs to be verified However if it were accurate and if the undergraduate cap includes non-traditional students as proposed by GU a decrease in enrollment of non-traditional students would permit a potentially large increase in traditional undergraduates seeking housing in the community which is the opposite of what the community wants to see happen Ditto for students studying abroad if for some unclear to me reason they were included in calculating the base cap Accordingly if total undergraduate enrollment is capped there still needs to be some control on the enrollment of traditional undergraduates in excess of the number of beds provided by the University on campus Requiring the University to take action if the number of undergraduates living in zip 20007 exceeds some number (which should be well below the current number) would provide that control and get to the heart of the communitys concerns Richard ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Charles DeSantis ltced33georgetownedugt Date Wed Nov 17 2010 at 607 PM Subject Re Setting up time to meet To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Cc Dan Porterfield ltporterfdgeorgetownedugt Linda greenan ltgreenanlgeorgetownedugt Margaret Elizabeth Moore ltmem95georgetownedugt Ron As you know we have had a flurry of activity with the news of Dans new presidential appointment at Franklin and Marshall College We are very excited and proud of him and we are also experiencing the loss of a great leader amongst us This has presented some conflicts for meeting with you to discuss answers to your questions this week In the interest of getting you these responses we wanted to provide you with the attacehd document outlining our responses that you can look over and if you have follow up questions you can either get them to us or we can schedule a meeting time in the near future I hope that this holiday season finds you well Happy Thanksgiving to you and Anne Charles

12

Charles DeSantis Associate Vice President of Faculty and Staff Benefits Chief Benefits Officer Office of Faculty and Staff Benefits Georgetown University Direct Line 2026871787 Cell Phone 2022947434 Fax 2026872389 Benefits 2026872500 Email ced33georgetownedu This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

13

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Tuesday January 25 2011 436 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus lucapivatocom

Ronald Lewis Lenore RubinoSubject UK Article

I thought the attached article might be of interest since it makes clear that the same problems facing Georgetown and Burleith have surfaced throughout England httphmolobbyorguk39articlespdf Richard ______________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

14

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday November 02 2010 418 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Ronald LewisSubject Original GU presentations

Sorry for the delay in sending the links I forgot to look at my notes These are the links to the full original presentations from GU httpsgusharegeorgetowneduOfficeOfCommunicationscampus_plan20090529_May30CampusPlanOptions_AMpdf httpsgusharegeorgetowneduOfficeOfCommunicationscampus_plan20090529_May30CampusPlanOptions_PMpdf Regards Gianluca Pivato

15

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Thursday August 26 2010 1001 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Ron LewisSubject Re RE

Oh OK So GUs practice of averaging is still acceptable Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 407 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

Your welcome One change I meant to say that the student counting may NOT be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

Steve

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202‐442‐8810

FAX 202‐442‐7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

16

From Jennifer Altemus [mailtocag-presidentcagtownorg] Sent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer

On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

17

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

18

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

19

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

20

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday May 18 2010 1129 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP)Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meetingAttachments Georgetowner Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on the Georgetowner I meant to attach it to the previous email The editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning for longer than 10 years and being geographically limited by the west and south boundaries Unfortunately unless the trend is reversed and GU complies with the DC Comprehensive Plan the long term result of turning Georgetown and Burleith into college towns is a very real possibility GU under De Gioia is planning to expand enormously in the next decades and this is only the first step I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the adjacent neighborhoods They just need a little push Best regards Luca Pivato On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your time today Please find attached selected data slides from this morning presentation I will be glad to answer any question you may have about the numbers our sources and references or our calculation methods The easiest way to contact me is on my cell at 301-221-8983 or via email at cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg Best regards Luca Pivato

21

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Monday May 17 2010 501 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich

Hinds Lenore Rubino DCtuxedoaolcomSubject Fw 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

This is the incident that was mentioned today involving (1) a graduate student living in Burleith who has repeatedly engaged in loud late night partying (2) whom GU was unaware was living in Burleith Stephen Brown is a resident of Burleith who has created his own website to protest GU student misconduct in his neighborhood It has generated much attention httpwwwdrunkengeorgetownstudentscom Richard ----- Forwarded by Richard deC HINDSDCCgsh on 05172010 0445 PM ----- Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt

17 May 2010 0954 AM

To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Ed Soloman ltdctuxedoaolcomgt Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgt Altemus Jennifer ltcag-presidentcagtownorggt Gianluca Pivato ltlucapivatocomgt

cc

Subject Fwd FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

It is confirmed This is a good example of where GU does not know where all its students live For those jumping in on the email stream Lt Hedgecock MPD reported there was a noise disturbance and Anne Koester (GU) relayed it wasnt a GU student house ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Mon May 17 2010 at 834 AM Subject FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT To Bonnie Hardy lthardybonniehotmailcomgt Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt Dear BonnieLenore This is a medical student whorsquos family was visiting and decided that an open fire and a musical tribute were appropriate I felt otherwise and we ended up having quite a fracas in the alley The police were called twice SNAP came byetcand the letter that follows is to Dean Jeanne Lord We have at least two to three 911rsquos per year from that house Regards

22

Stephen Stephen R Brown Photography 3715 T Street NW Washington DC 20007 202‐667‐1965 202‐255‐8635(cell) httpwwwsrbphotocom httpwwwdcphotobookcom httpwwwjewelofthemallcom mailtosrbsrbphotocom

‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded Message From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Sun 16 May 2010 132049 ‐0400 To Jeanne Lord ltlordjgeorgetownedugt Conversation 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Subject 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Jeanne I can assure you I am quite as tired of this as you and am going out today to buy a quality pair of headphones I wil be doing a composite sketch of all the pictures I have taken and thatrsquos all that will be on the website other than general information to the neighbors It is getting 19000 hits per day and as you may or may not have noticed I have taken out advertising I will be happy to ressurect the site in a more popular format if things continue as they are as I fully expect them to Obviously I donrsquot think you have a handle on your current student population so I will be working in other ways to block GUrsquos growth Last night3713 broke into Florida version of Swiss Family Robinson and three neighbors called the police As they went into the house they began yelling out my name At 217 they began a phone marathon to my studio and fortunately not to my house I have the voice recordings and they are not particularly ldquomedicalrdquo I have to question this womanrsquos competency to get a license as her drunken tirades and now phone marathons are stunningly nasty Herersquos a photo of my phone with the ldquoblocked callsrdquo from her family member who was visiting and her number which she wasnrsquot clever enough to block If yoursquod like to hear what Georgetownrsquos finest has to say on the phone Irsquoll be happy to put it up on the web Otherwise I expect some disciplinary actionsome examination of this womenrsquos competence to get a medical license and a letter of apology to my family ‐‐‐‐‐‐ End of Forwarded Message -- Lenore G Rubino Realtor Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage wwwlenorerubinocom

23

202-262-1261 (best way to reach me) 202-471-5262 (e-fax) Washington Harbour - Georgetown 3000 K Street NW Suite 101 Washington DC 20007

This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

24

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Thursday January 14 2010 301 PMTo Jennings Jeffrey (DDOT) Ziemann Christopher (DDOT)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) billstarrelsgmailcom dctuxedoaolcom

billskelseyancaolcom cag-presidentcagtownorg lenorerubiongmailcomSubject Friday meeting re transportation aspects of GUs 10-year planAttachments Impacts of GU transportation issues and draft 10-year plandoc

Dear Jeff and Chris In case this might be helpful for our meeting Friday morning an outline is attached of what we see as some key transportation issues in the Georgetown University draft 10-year campus plan Our group will include - From ANC 2E - Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Ed Solomon (possibly) and Bill Skelsey (possibly) From the Citizens Association of Georgetown Jennifer Altemus president From the Burleith Citizens Association Lenore Rubino president We look forward to seeing you on Friday (tomorrow) at DDOT at 930 am Best regards Ron

25

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Tuesday January 12 2010 947 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc billstarrelsgmailcom billskelseyancaolcom dctuxedoaolcom cag-

presidentcagtownorg lucapivatocom rhindscgshcom lenorerubinogmailcom

Subject Meeting re Georgetown University 10-year plan with community representatives Jan 13

Attachments Outline of some key impacts on the community of the GU draft 10-year plan-1doc

Dear Jennifer Joel and Steve An outline is attached in case it might be helpful of some key issues in the Georgetown University draft 10‐year plan that wed like to discuss with you at tomorrows meeting Out group tomorrow will include ‐ ANC 2E (Georgetown and Burleith) Commissioners Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Bill Skelsey and Ed Solomon Citizens Association of Georgetown President Jennifer Altemus Vice President Luca Pivato and advisor Richard Hinds Burleith Citizens Association President Lenore Rubino and advisor Mark Gisler We look forward very much to seeing you and continuing the productive dialogue Best regards Ron Ron Lewis Chair ANC 2E

26

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Friday January 08 2010 1057 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer AltemusSubject RE Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image001gif image002gif CAG letter to GU re campus planpdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan Best Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia

27

Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar

28

See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

29

B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

30

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Thursday December 31 2009 406 PMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP)Subject Re Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image002gif image001gif

Jennifer Thanks for providing this information Happy New Year Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Sent Thu Dec 31 144709 2009 Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

31

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 5: Emails 1

5

or fax it to me Thanks Richard ___________________________________________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999 wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy[attachment 16566 GU Campus Plan Report 06-12-00pdf deleted by Richard deC HINDSDCCgsh] This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

6

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Tuesday April 12 2011 1036 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject OP Report on 2000 Plan

Hi Steve Glad to hear you have some breathing room OP issued a report on Georgetown University Campus Plan 200-2010 BZA Application No 16566 dated June 12 2000 P 28 contains data on where undergrads live at p 28 that I would like to use at the hearing but I do not have a good copy of it and would like to see the entire report Can you email or fax it to me Thanks Richard ___________________________________________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

7

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Betsy Cooley ltbetsycooleycagtownorggtSent Thursday April 07 2011 549 PMTo Hawkinson Colleen (DDOT) Hanousek Donna (DCOZ) Schellin Sharon (DCOZ) Ricks

Karina (DDOT) Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP) DCOZ - ZC Submissions (DCOZ) Bill Starrells Ed Solomon tmfsmithstarpowernet Ron Lewis Jones Jeffrey (ANC 2E03)

Cc Jennifer Altemus Lenore RubinoSubject CAG + BCA request re order of presentation regarding GU Campus PlanAttachments CAG BCA LTR RE GU PLAN HEARINGJPG

Please see the attached letter from the Citizens Association of Georgetown and the Burleith Citizens Association

8

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Luca ltlucapivatocomgtSent Thursday April 07 2011 104 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject Re ZC GU Hearing MPD DataAttachments ATT00002png

Hi Stephen are you filing today On 442011 1113 AM Mordfin Stephen (OP) wrote Thank you

Stephen J Mordfin AICP Development Review Specialist DC Office of Planning 1100 4th Street SW Suite E650 Washington DC 20024 Office 202‐442‐8810 FAX 202‐442‐7638 stephenmordfindcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Luca [mailtolucapivatocom] Sent Monday April 04 2011 1107 AM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject ZC GU Hearing MPD Data Hi Stephen I have attached some of the charts and maps that we have Ill be happy to come to your office tomorrow at 1pm and bring the raw data on a pen drive as well as our analysis of the data Thank you Luca 301-221-8983 c

9

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Monday April 04 2011 314 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject OP Report on GU Campus Plan

Importance High

Stephen when the OP Report is made available can you send me a copy by email Thanks Richard ___________________________________________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

10

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Luca ltlucapivatocomgtSent Monday April 04 2011 1107 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject ZC GU Hearing MPD DataAttachments Calls By Street for 3500 Block 2000-2009xlsx Calls for O Street 2000-2009xlsx GU

Grad Addresses 2009xls GU Undergrad Addresses 2009xls GMap All Addresses 2009jpg Top10 Calls Residential 2009xlsx Aggregated Geocoded 911 calls - 2009png

Categories Red Category

Hi Stephen I have attached some of the charts and maps that we have Ill be happy to come to your office tomorrow at 1pm and bring the raw data on a pen drive as well as our analysis of the data Thank you Luca 301-221-8983 c

11

Johnson Mike (OP)

From rhindscgshcomSent Monday February 07 2011 335 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Subject Fw Info from Charles DeSantisAttachments Response to Ron Lewis Request_20101117adoc

Steve enclosed is the source of some of the other GU numbers we provided you today Note in particular the growth in non-traditional undergraduates and despite that growth the large reduction in number living in zip 20007 That number needs to be verified However if it were accurate and if the undergraduate cap includes non-traditional students as proposed by GU a decrease in enrollment of non-traditional students would permit a potentially large increase in traditional undergraduates seeking housing in the community which is the opposite of what the community wants to see happen Ditto for students studying abroad if for some unclear to me reason they were included in calculating the base cap Accordingly if total undergraduate enrollment is capped there still needs to be some control on the enrollment of traditional undergraduates in excess of the number of beds provided by the University on campus Requiring the University to take action if the number of undergraduates living in zip 20007 exceeds some number (which should be well below the current number) would provide that control and get to the heart of the communitys concerns Richard ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Charles DeSantis ltced33georgetownedugt Date Wed Nov 17 2010 at 607 PM Subject Re Setting up time to meet To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Cc Dan Porterfield ltporterfdgeorgetownedugt Linda greenan ltgreenanlgeorgetownedugt Margaret Elizabeth Moore ltmem95georgetownedugt Ron As you know we have had a flurry of activity with the news of Dans new presidential appointment at Franklin and Marshall College We are very excited and proud of him and we are also experiencing the loss of a great leader amongst us This has presented some conflicts for meeting with you to discuss answers to your questions this week In the interest of getting you these responses we wanted to provide you with the attacehd document outlining our responses that you can look over and if you have follow up questions you can either get them to us or we can schedule a meeting time in the near future I hope that this holiday season finds you well Happy Thanksgiving to you and Anne Charles

12

Charles DeSantis Associate Vice President of Faculty and Staff Benefits Chief Benefits Officer Office of Faculty and Staff Benefits Georgetown University Direct Line 2026871787 Cell Phone 2022947434 Fax 2026872389 Benefits 2026872500 Email ced33georgetownedu This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

13

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Tuesday January 25 2011 436 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus lucapivatocom

Ronald Lewis Lenore RubinoSubject UK Article

I thought the attached article might be of interest since it makes clear that the same problems facing Georgetown and Burleith have surfaced throughout England httphmolobbyorguk39articlespdf Richard ______________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

14

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday November 02 2010 418 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Ronald LewisSubject Original GU presentations

Sorry for the delay in sending the links I forgot to look at my notes These are the links to the full original presentations from GU httpsgusharegeorgetowneduOfficeOfCommunicationscampus_plan20090529_May30CampusPlanOptions_AMpdf httpsgusharegeorgetowneduOfficeOfCommunicationscampus_plan20090529_May30CampusPlanOptions_PMpdf Regards Gianluca Pivato

15

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Thursday August 26 2010 1001 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Ron LewisSubject Re RE

Oh OK So GUs practice of averaging is still acceptable Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 407 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

Your welcome One change I meant to say that the student counting may NOT be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

Steve

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202‐442‐8810

FAX 202‐442‐7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

16

From Jennifer Altemus [mailtocag-presidentcagtownorg] Sent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer

On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

17

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

18

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

19

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

20

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday May 18 2010 1129 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP)Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meetingAttachments Georgetowner Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on the Georgetowner I meant to attach it to the previous email The editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning for longer than 10 years and being geographically limited by the west and south boundaries Unfortunately unless the trend is reversed and GU complies with the DC Comprehensive Plan the long term result of turning Georgetown and Burleith into college towns is a very real possibility GU under De Gioia is planning to expand enormously in the next decades and this is only the first step I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the adjacent neighborhoods They just need a little push Best regards Luca Pivato On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your time today Please find attached selected data slides from this morning presentation I will be glad to answer any question you may have about the numbers our sources and references or our calculation methods The easiest way to contact me is on my cell at 301-221-8983 or via email at cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg Best regards Luca Pivato

21

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Monday May 17 2010 501 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich

Hinds Lenore Rubino DCtuxedoaolcomSubject Fw 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

This is the incident that was mentioned today involving (1) a graduate student living in Burleith who has repeatedly engaged in loud late night partying (2) whom GU was unaware was living in Burleith Stephen Brown is a resident of Burleith who has created his own website to protest GU student misconduct in his neighborhood It has generated much attention httpwwwdrunkengeorgetownstudentscom Richard ----- Forwarded by Richard deC HINDSDCCgsh on 05172010 0445 PM ----- Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt

17 May 2010 0954 AM

To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Ed Soloman ltdctuxedoaolcomgt Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgt Altemus Jennifer ltcag-presidentcagtownorggt Gianluca Pivato ltlucapivatocomgt

cc

Subject Fwd FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

It is confirmed This is a good example of where GU does not know where all its students live For those jumping in on the email stream Lt Hedgecock MPD reported there was a noise disturbance and Anne Koester (GU) relayed it wasnt a GU student house ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Mon May 17 2010 at 834 AM Subject FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT To Bonnie Hardy lthardybonniehotmailcomgt Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt Dear BonnieLenore This is a medical student whorsquos family was visiting and decided that an open fire and a musical tribute were appropriate I felt otherwise and we ended up having quite a fracas in the alley The police were called twice SNAP came byetcand the letter that follows is to Dean Jeanne Lord We have at least two to three 911rsquos per year from that house Regards

22

Stephen Stephen R Brown Photography 3715 T Street NW Washington DC 20007 202‐667‐1965 202‐255‐8635(cell) httpwwwsrbphotocom httpwwwdcphotobookcom httpwwwjewelofthemallcom mailtosrbsrbphotocom

‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded Message From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Sun 16 May 2010 132049 ‐0400 To Jeanne Lord ltlordjgeorgetownedugt Conversation 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Subject 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Jeanne I can assure you I am quite as tired of this as you and am going out today to buy a quality pair of headphones I wil be doing a composite sketch of all the pictures I have taken and thatrsquos all that will be on the website other than general information to the neighbors It is getting 19000 hits per day and as you may or may not have noticed I have taken out advertising I will be happy to ressurect the site in a more popular format if things continue as they are as I fully expect them to Obviously I donrsquot think you have a handle on your current student population so I will be working in other ways to block GUrsquos growth Last night3713 broke into Florida version of Swiss Family Robinson and three neighbors called the police As they went into the house they began yelling out my name At 217 they began a phone marathon to my studio and fortunately not to my house I have the voice recordings and they are not particularly ldquomedicalrdquo I have to question this womanrsquos competency to get a license as her drunken tirades and now phone marathons are stunningly nasty Herersquos a photo of my phone with the ldquoblocked callsrdquo from her family member who was visiting and her number which she wasnrsquot clever enough to block If yoursquod like to hear what Georgetownrsquos finest has to say on the phone Irsquoll be happy to put it up on the web Otherwise I expect some disciplinary actionsome examination of this womenrsquos competence to get a medical license and a letter of apology to my family ‐‐‐‐‐‐ End of Forwarded Message -- Lenore G Rubino Realtor Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage wwwlenorerubinocom

23

202-262-1261 (best way to reach me) 202-471-5262 (e-fax) Washington Harbour - Georgetown 3000 K Street NW Suite 101 Washington DC 20007

This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

24

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Thursday January 14 2010 301 PMTo Jennings Jeffrey (DDOT) Ziemann Christopher (DDOT)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) billstarrelsgmailcom dctuxedoaolcom

billskelseyancaolcom cag-presidentcagtownorg lenorerubiongmailcomSubject Friday meeting re transportation aspects of GUs 10-year planAttachments Impacts of GU transportation issues and draft 10-year plandoc

Dear Jeff and Chris In case this might be helpful for our meeting Friday morning an outline is attached of what we see as some key transportation issues in the Georgetown University draft 10-year campus plan Our group will include - From ANC 2E - Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Ed Solomon (possibly) and Bill Skelsey (possibly) From the Citizens Association of Georgetown Jennifer Altemus president From the Burleith Citizens Association Lenore Rubino president We look forward to seeing you on Friday (tomorrow) at DDOT at 930 am Best regards Ron

25

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Tuesday January 12 2010 947 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc billstarrelsgmailcom billskelseyancaolcom dctuxedoaolcom cag-

presidentcagtownorg lucapivatocom rhindscgshcom lenorerubinogmailcom

Subject Meeting re Georgetown University 10-year plan with community representatives Jan 13

Attachments Outline of some key impacts on the community of the GU draft 10-year plan-1doc

Dear Jennifer Joel and Steve An outline is attached in case it might be helpful of some key issues in the Georgetown University draft 10‐year plan that wed like to discuss with you at tomorrows meeting Out group tomorrow will include ‐ ANC 2E (Georgetown and Burleith) Commissioners Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Bill Skelsey and Ed Solomon Citizens Association of Georgetown President Jennifer Altemus Vice President Luca Pivato and advisor Richard Hinds Burleith Citizens Association President Lenore Rubino and advisor Mark Gisler We look forward very much to seeing you and continuing the productive dialogue Best regards Ron Ron Lewis Chair ANC 2E

26

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Friday January 08 2010 1057 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer AltemusSubject RE Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image001gif image002gif CAG letter to GU re campus planpdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan Best Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia

27

Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar

28

See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

29

B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

30

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Thursday December 31 2009 406 PMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP)Subject Re Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image002gif image001gif

Jennifer Thanks for providing this information Happy New Year Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Sent Thu Dec 31 144709 2009 Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

31

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 6: Emails 1

6

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Tuesday April 12 2011 1036 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject OP Report on 2000 Plan

Hi Steve Glad to hear you have some breathing room OP issued a report on Georgetown University Campus Plan 200-2010 BZA Application No 16566 dated June 12 2000 P 28 contains data on where undergrads live at p 28 that I would like to use at the hearing but I do not have a good copy of it and would like to see the entire report Can you email or fax it to me Thanks Richard ___________________________________________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

7

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Betsy Cooley ltbetsycooleycagtownorggtSent Thursday April 07 2011 549 PMTo Hawkinson Colleen (DDOT) Hanousek Donna (DCOZ) Schellin Sharon (DCOZ) Ricks

Karina (DDOT) Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP) DCOZ - ZC Submissions (DCOZ) Bill Starrells Ed Solomon tmfsmithstarpowernet Ron Lewis Jones Jeffrey (ANC 2E03)

Cc Jennifer Altemus Lenore RubinoSubject CAG + BCA request re order of presentation regarding GU Campus PlanAttachments CAG BCA LTR RE GU PLAN HEARINGJPG

Please see the attached letter from the Citizens Association of Georgetown and the Burleith Citizens Association

8

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Luca ltlucapivatocomgtSent Thursday April 07 2011 104 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject Re ZC GU Hearing MPD DataAttachments ATT00002png

Hi Stephen are you filing today On 442011 1113 AM Mordfin Stephen (OP) wrote Thank you

Stephen J Mordfin AICP Development Review Specialist DC Office of Planning 1100 4th Street SW Suite E650 Washington DC 20024 Office 202‐442‐8810 FAX 202‐442‐7638 stephenmordfindcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Luca [mailtolucapivatocom] Sent Monday April 04 2011 1107 AM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject ZC GU Hearing MPD Data Hi Stephen I have attached some of the charts and maps that we have Ill be happy to come to your office tomorrow at 1pm and bring the raw data on a pen drive as well as our analysis of the data Thank you Luca 301-221-8983 c

9

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Monday April 04 2011 314 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject OP Report on GU Campus Plan

Importance High

Stephen when the OP Report is made available can you send me a copy by email Thanks Richard ___________________________________________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

10

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Luca ltlucapivatocomgtSent Monday April 04 2011 1107 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject ZC GU Hearing MPD DataAttachments Calls By Street for 3500 Block 2000-2009xlsx Calls for O Street 2000-2009xlsx GU

Grad Addresses 2009xls GU Undergrad Addresses 2009xls GMap All Addresses 2009jpg Top10 Calls Residential 2009xlsx Aggregated Geocoded 911 calls - 2009png

Categories Red Category

Hi Stephen I have attached some of the charts and maps that we have Ill be happy to come to your office tomorrow at 1pm and bring the raw data on a pen drive as well as our analysis of the data Thank you Luca 301-221-8983 c

11

Johnson Mike (OP)

From rhindscgshcomSent Monday February 07 2011 335 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Subject Fw Info from Charles DeSantisAttachments Response to Ron Lewis Request_20101117adoc

Steve enclosed is the source of some of the other GU numbers we provided you today Note in particular the growth in non-traditional undergraduates and despite that growth the large reduction in number living in zip 20007 That number needs to be verified However if it were accurate and if the undergraduate cap includes non-traditional students as proposed by GU a decrease in enrollment of non-traditional students would permit a potentially large increase in traditional undergraduates seeking housing in the community which is the opposite of what the community wants to see happen Ditto for students studying abroad if for some unclear to me reason they were included in calculating the base cap Accordingly if total undergraduate enrollment is capped there still needs to be some control on the enrollment of traditional undergraduates in excess of the number of beds provided by the University on campus Requiring the University to take action if the number of undergraduates living in zip 20007 exceeds some number (which should be well below the current number) would provide that control and get to the heart of the communitys concerns Richard ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Charles DeSantis ltced33georgetownedugt Date Wed Nov 17 2010 at 607 PM Subject Re Setting up time to meet To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Cc Dan Porterfield ltporterfdgeorgetownedugt Linda greenan ltgreenanlgeorgetownedugt Margaret Elizabeth Moore ltmem95georgetownedugt Ron As you know we have had a flurry of activity with the news of Dans new presidential appointment at Franklin and Marshall College We are very excited and proud of him and we are also experiencing the loss of a great leader amongst us This has presented some conflicts for meeting with you to discuss answers to your questions this week In the interest of getting you these responses we wanted to provide you with the attacehd document outlining our responses that you can look over and if you have follow up questions you can either get them to us or we can schedule a meeting time in the near future I hope that this holiday season finds you well Happy Thanksgiving to you and Anne Charles

12

Charles DeSantis Associate Vice President of Faculty and Staff Benefits Chief Benefits Officer Office of Faculty and Staff Benefits Georgetown University Direct Line 2026871787 Cell Phone 2022947434 Fax 2026872389 Benefits 2026872500 Email ced33georgetownedu This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

13

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Tuesday January 25 2011 436 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus lucapivatocom

Ronald Lewis Lenore RubinoSubject UK Article

I thought the attached article might be of interest since it makes clear that the same problems facing Georgetown and Burleith have surfaced throughout England httphmolobbyorguk39articlespdf Richard ______________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

14

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday November 02 2010 418 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Ronald LewisSubject Original GU presentations

Sorry for the delay in sending the links I forgot to look at my notes These are the links to the full original presentations from GU httpsgusharegeorgetowneduOfficeOfCommunicationscampus_plan20090529_May30CampusPlanOptions_AMpdf httpsgusharegeorgetowneduOfficeOfCommunicationscampus_plan20090529_May30CampusPlanOptions_PMpdf Regards Gianluca Pivato

15

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Thursday August 26 2010 1001 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Ron LewisSubject Re RE

Oh OK So GUs practice of averaging is still acceptable Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 407 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

Your welcome One change I meant to say that the student counting may NOT be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

Steve

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202‐442‐8810

FAX 202‐442‐7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

16

From Jennifer Altemus [mailtocag-presidentcagtownorg] Sent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer

On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

17

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

18

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

19

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

20

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday May 18 2010 1129 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP)Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meetingAttachments Georgetowner Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on the Georgetowner I meant to attach it to the previous email The editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning for longer than 10 years and being geographically limited by the west and south boundaries Unfortunately unless the trend is reversed and GU complies with the DC Comprehensive Plan the long term result of turning Georgetown and Burleith into college towns is a very real possibility GU under De Gioia is planning to expand enormously in the next decades and this is only the first step I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the adjacent neighborhoods They just need a little push Best regards Luca Pivato On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your time today Please find attached selected data slides from this morning presentation I will be glad to answer any question you may have about the numbers our sources and references or our calculation methods The easiest way to contact me is on my cell at 301-221-8983 or via email at cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg Best regards Luca Pivato

21

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Monday May 17 2010 501 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich

Hinds Lenore Rubino DCtuxedoaolcomSubject Fw 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

This is the incident that was mentioned today involving (1) a graduate student living in Burleith who has repeatedly engaged in loud late night partying (2) whom GU was unaware was living in Burleith Stephen Brown is a resident of Burleith who has created his own website to protest GU student misconduct in his neighborhood It has generated much attention httpwwwdrunkengeorgetownstudentscom Richard ----- Forwarded by Richard deC HINDSDCCgsh on 05172010 0445 PM ----- Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt

17 May 2010 0954 AM

To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Ed Soloman ltdctuxedoaolcomgt Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgt Altemus Jennifer ltcag-presidentcagtownorggt Gianluca Pivato ltlucapivatocomgt

cc

Subject Fwd FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

It is confirmed This is a good example of where GU does not know where all its students live For those jumping in on the email stream Lt Hedgecock MPD reported there was a noise disturbance and Anne Koester (GU) relayed it wasnt a GU student house ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Mon May 17 2010 at 834 AM Subject FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT To Bonnie Hardy lthardybonniehotmailcomgt Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt Dear BonnieLenore This is a medical student whorsquos family was visiting and decided that an open fire and a musical tribute were appropriate I felt otherwise and we ended up having quite a fracas in the alley The police were called twice SNAP came byetcand the letter that follows is to Dean Jeanne Lord We have at least two to three 911rsquos per year from that house Regards

22

Stephen Stephen R Brown Photography 3715 T Street NW Washington DC 20007 202‐667‐1965 202‐255‐8635(cell) httpwwwsrbphotocom httpwwwdcphotobookcom httpwwwjewelofthemallcom mailtosrbsrbphotocom

‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded Message From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Sun 16 May 2010 132049 ‐0400 To Jeanne Lord ltlordjgeorgetownedugt Conversation 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Subject 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Jeanne I can assure you I am quite as tired of this as you and am going out today to buy a quality pair of headphones I wil be doing a composite sketch of all the pictures I have taken and thatrsquos all that will be on the website other than general information to the neighbors It is getting 19000 hits per day and as you may or may not have noticed I have taken out advertising I will be happy to ressurect the site in a more popular format if things continue as they are as I fully expect them to Obviously I donrsquot think you have a handle on your current student population so I will be working in other ways to block GUrsquos growth Last night3713 broke into Florida version of Swiss Family Robinson and three neighbors called the police As they went into the house they began yelling out my name At 217 they began a phone marathon to my studio and fortunately not to my house I have the voice recordings and they are not particularly ldquomedicalrdquo I have to question this womanrsquos competency to get a license as her drunken tirades and now phone marathons are stunningly nasty Herersquos a photo of my phone with the ldquoblocked callsrdquo from her family member who was visiting and her number which she wasnrsquot clever enough to block If yoursquod like to hear what Georgetownrsquos finest has to say on the phone Irsquoll be happy to put it up on the web Otherwise I expect some disciplinary actionsome examination of this womenrsquos competence to get a medical license and a letter of apology to my family ‐‐‐‐‐‐ End of Forwarded Message -- Lenore G Rubino Realtor Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage wwwlenorerubinocom

23

202-262-1261 (best way to reach me) 202-471-5262 (e-fax) Washington Harbour - Georgetown 3000 K Street NW Suite 101 Washington DC 20007

This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

24

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Thursday January 14 2010 301 PMTo Jennings Jeffrey (DDOT) Ziemann Christopher (DDOT)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) billstarrelsgmailcom dctuxedoaolcom

billskelseyancaolcom cag-presidentcagtownorg lenorerubiongmailcomSubject Friday meeting re transportation aspects of GUs 10-year planAttachments Impacts of GU transportation issues and draft 10-year plandoc

Dear Jeff and Chris In case this might be helpful for our meeting Friday morning an outline is attached of what we see as some key transportation issues in the Georgetown University draft 10-year campus plan Our group will include - From ANC 2E - Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Ed Solomon (possibly) and Bill Skelsey (possibly) From the Citizens Association of Georgetown Jennifer Altemus president From the Burleith Citizens Association Lenore Rubino president We look forward to seeing you on Friday (tomorrow) at DDOT at 930 am Best regards Ron

25

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Tuesday January 12 2010 947 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc billstarrelsgmailcom billskelseyancaolcom dctuxedoaolcom cag-

presidentcagtownorg lucapivatocom rhindscgshcom lenorerubinogmailcom

Subject Meeting re Georgetown University 10-year plan with community representatives Jan 13

Attachments Outline of some key impacts on the community of the GU draft 10-year plan-1doc

Dear Jennifer Joel and Steve An outline is attached in case it might be helpful of some key issues in the Georgetown University draft 10‐year plan that wed like to discuss with you at tomorrows meeting Out group tomorrow will include ‐ ANC 2E (Georgetown and Burleith) Commissioners Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Bill Skelsey and Ed Solomon Citizens Association of Georgetown President Jennifer Altemus Vice President Luca Pivato and advisor Richard Hinds Burleith Citizens Association President Lenore Rubino and advisor Mark Gisler We look forward very much to seeing you and continuing the productive dialogue Best regards Ron Ron Lewis Chair ANC 2E

26

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Friday January 08 2010 1057 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer AltemusSubject RE Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image001gif image002gif CAG letter to GU re campus planpdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan Best Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia

27

Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar

28

See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

29

B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

30

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Thursday December 31 2009 406 PMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP)Subject Re Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image002gif image001gif

Jennifer Thanks for providing this information Happy New Year Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Sent Thu Dec 31 144709 2009 Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

31

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 7: Emails 1

7

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Betsy Cooley ltbetsycooleycagtownorggtSent Thursday April 07 2011 549 PMTo Hawkinson Colleen (DDOT) Hanousek Donna (DCOZ) Schellin Sharon (DCOZ) Ricks

Karina (DDOT) Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP) DCOZ - ZC Submissions (DCOZ) Bill Starrells Ed Solomon tmfsmithstarpowernet Ron Lewis Jones Jeffrey (ANC 2E03)

Cc Jennifer Altemus Lenore RubinoSubject CAG + BCA request re order of presentation regarding GU Campus PlanAttachments CAG BCA LTR RE GU PLAN HEARINGJPG

Please see the attached letter from the Citizens Association of Georgetown and the Burleith Citizens Association

8

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Luca ltlucapivatocomgtSent Thursday April 07 2011 104 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject Re ZC GU Hearing MPD DataAttachments ATT00002png

Hi Stephen are you filing today On 442011 1113 AM Mordfin Stephen (OP) wrote Thank you

Stephen J Mordfin AICP Development Review Specialist DC Office of Planning 1100 4th Street SW Suite E650 Washington DC 20024 Office 202‐442‐8810 FAX 202‐442‐7638 stephenmordfindcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Luca [mailtolucapivatocom] Sent Monday April 04 2011 1107 AM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject ZC GU Hearing MPD Data Hi Stephen I have attached some of the charts and maps that we have Ill be happy to come to your office tomorrow at 1pm and bring the raw data on a pen drive as well as our analysis of the data Thank you Luca 301-221-8983 c

9

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Monday April 04 2011 314 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject OP Report on GU Campus Plan

Importance High

Stephen when the OP Report is made available can you send me a copy by email Thanks Richard ___________________________________________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

10

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Luca ltlucapivatocomgtSent Monday April 04 2011 1107 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject ZC GU Hearing MPD DataAttachments Calls By Street for 3500 Block 2000-2009xlsx Calls for O Street 2000-2009xlsx GU

Grad Addresses 2009xls GU Undergrad Addresses 2009xls GMap All Addresses 2009jpg Top10 Calls Residential 2009xlsx Aggregated Geocoded 911 calls - 2009png

Categories Red Category

Hi Stephen I have attached some of the charts and maps that we have Ill be happy to come to your office tomorrow at 1pm and bring the raw data on a pen drive as well as our analysis of the data Thank you Luca 301-221-8983 c

11

Johnson Mike (OP)

From rhindscgshcomSent Monday February 07 2011 335 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Subject Fw Info from Charles DeSantisAttachments Response to Ron Lewis Request_20101117adoc

Steve enclosed is the source of some of the other GU numbers we provided you today Note in particular the growth in non-traditional undergraduates and despite that growth the large reduction in number living in zip 20007 That number needs to be verified However if it were accurate and if the undergraduate cap includes non-traditional students as proposed by GU a decrease in enrollment of non-traditional students would permit a potentially large increase in traditional undergraduates seeking housing in the community which is the opposite of what the community wants to see happen Ditto for students studying abroad if for some unclear to me reason they were included in calculating the base cap Accordingly if total undergraduate enrollment is capped there still needs to be some control on the enrollment of traditional undergraduates in excess of the number of beds provided by the University on campus Requiring the University to take action if the number of undergraduates living in zip 20007 exceeds some number (which should be well below the current number) would provide that control and get to the heart of the communitys concerns Richard ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Charles DeSantis ltced33georgetownedugt Date Wed Nov 17 2010 at 607 PM Subject Re Setting up time to meet To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Cc Dan Porterfield ltporterfdgeorgetownedugt Linda greenan ltgreenanlgeorgetownedugt Margaret Elizabeth Moore ltmem95georgetownedugt Ron As you know we have had a flurry of activity with the news of Dans new presidential appointment at Franklin and Marshall College We are very excited and proud of him and we are also experiencing the loss of a great leader amongst us This has presented some conflicts for meeting with you to discuss answers to your questions this week In the interest of getting you these responses we wanted to provide you with the attacehd document outlining our responses that you can look over and if you have follow up questions you can either get them to us or we can schedule a meeting time in the near future I hope that this holiday season finds you well Happy Thanksgiving to you and Anne Charles

12

Charles DeSantis Associate Vice President of Faculty and Staff Benefits Chief Benefits Officer Office of Faculty and Staff Benefits Georgetown University Direct Line 2026871787 Cell Phone 2022947434 Fax 2026872389 Benefits 2026872500 Email ced33georgetownedu This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

13

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Tuesday January 25 2011 436 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus lucapivatocom

Ronald Lewis Lenore RubinoSubject UK Article

I thought the attached article might be of interest since it makes clear that the same problems facing Georgetown and Burleith have surfaced throughout England httphmolobbyorguk39articlespdf Richard ______________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

14

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday November 02 2010 418 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Ronald LewisSubject Original GU presentations

Sorry for the delay in sending the links I forgot to look at my notes These are the links to the full original presentations from GU httpsgusharegeorgetowneduOfficeOfCommunicationscampus_plan20090529_May30CampusPlanOptions_AMpdf httpsgusharegeorgetowneduOfficeOfCommunicationscampus_plan20090529_May30CampusPlanOptions_PMpdf Regards Gianluca Pivato

15

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Thursday August 26 2010 1001 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Ron LewisSubject Re RE

Oh OK So GUs practice of averaging is still acceptable Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 407 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

Your welcome One change I meant to say that the student counting may NOT be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

Steve

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202‐442‐8810

FAX 202‐442‐7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

16

From Jennifer Altemus [mailtocag-presidentcagtownorg] Sent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer

On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

17

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

18

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

19

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

20

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday May 18 2010 1129 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP)Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meetingAttachments Georgetowner Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on the Georgetowner I meant to attach it to the previous email The editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning for longer than 10 years and being geographically limited by the west and south boundaries Unfortunately unless the trend is reversed and GU complies with the DC Comprehensive Plan the long term result of turning Georgetown and Burleith into college towns is a very real possibility GU under De Gioia is planning to expand enormously in the next decades and this is only the first step I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the adjacent neighborhoods They just need a little push Best regards Luca Pivato On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your time today Please find attached selected data slides from this morning presentation I will be glad to answer any question you may have about the numbers our sources and references or our calculation methods The easiest way to contact me is on my cell at 301-221-8983 or via email at cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg Best regards Luca Pivato

21

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Monday May 17 2010 501 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich

Hinds Lenore Rubino DCtuxedoaolcomSubject Fw 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

This is the incident that was mentioned today involving (1) a graduate student living in Burleith who has repeatedly engaged in loud late night partying (2) whom GU was unaware was living in Burleith Stephen Brown is a resident of Burleith who has created his own website to protest GU student misconduct in his neighborhood It has generated much attention httpwwwdrunkengeorgetownstudentscom Richard ----- Forwarded by Richard deC HINDSDCCgsh on 05172010 0445 PM ----- Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt

17 May 2010 0954 AM

To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Ed Soloman ltdctuxedoaolcomgt Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgt Altemus Jennifer ltcag-presidentcagtownorggt Gianluca Pivato ltlucapivatocomgt

cc

Subject Fwd FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

It is confirmed This is a good example of where GU does not know where all its students live For those jumping in on the email stream Lt Hedgecock MPD reported there was a noise disturbance and Anne Koester (GU) relayed it wasnt a GU student house ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Mon May 17 2010 at 834 AM Subject FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT To Bonnie Hardy lthardybonniehotmailcomgt Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt Dear BonnieLenore This is a medical student whorsquos family was visiting and decided that an open fire and a musical tribute were appropriate I felt otherwise and we ended up having quite a fracas in the alley The police were called twice SNAP came byetcand the letter that follows is to Dean Jeanne Lord We have at least two to three 911rsquos per year from that house Regards

22

Stephen Stephen R Brown Photography 3715 T Street NW Washington DC 20007 202‐667‐1965 202‐255‐8635(cell) httpwwwsrbphotocom httpwwwdcphotobookcom httpwwwjewelofthemallcom mailtosrbsrbphotocom

‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded Message From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Sun 16 May 2010 132049 ‐0400 To Jeanne Lord ltlordjgeorgetownedugt Conversation 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Subject 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Jeanne I can assure you I am quite as tired of this as you and am going out today to buy a quality pair of headphones I wil be doing a composite sketch of all the pictures I have taken and thatrsquos all that will be on the website other than general information to the neighbors It is getting 19000 hits per day and as you may or may not have noticed I have taken out advertising I will be happy to ressurect the site in a more popular format if things continue as they are as I fully expect them to Obviously I donrsquot think you have a handle on your current student population so I will be working in other ways to block GUrsquos growth Last night3713 broke into Florida version of Swiss Family Robinson and three neighbors called the police As they went into the house they began yelling out my name At 217 they began a phone marathon to my studio and fortunately not to my house I have the voice recordings and they are not particularly ldquomedicalrdquo I have to question this womanrsquos competency to get a license as her drunken tirades and now phone marathons are stunningly nasty Herersquos a photo of my phone with the ldquoblocked callsrdquo from her family member who was visiting and her number which she wasnrsquot clever enough to block If yoursquod like to hear what Georgetownrsquos finest has to say on the phone Irsquoll be happy to put it up on the web Otherwise I expect some disciplinary actionsome examination of this womenrsquos competence to get a medical license and a letter of apology to my family ‐‐‐‐‐‐ End of Forwarded Message -- Lenore G Rubino Realtor Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage wwwlenorerubinocom

23

202-262-1261 (best way to reach me) 202-471-5262 (e-fax) Washington Harbour - Georgetown 3000 K Street NW Suite 101 Washington DC 20007

This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

24

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Thursday January 14 2010 301 PMTo Jennings Jeffrey (DDOT) Ziemann Christopher (DDOT)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) billstarrelsgmailcom dctuxedoaolcom

billskelseyancaolcom cag-presidentcagtownorg lenorerubiongmailcomSubject Friday meeting re transportation aspects of GUs 10-year planAttachments Impacts of GU transportation issues and draft 10-year plandoc

Dear Jeff and Chris In case this might be helpful for our meeting Friday morning an outline is attached of what we see as some key transportation issues in the Georgetown University draft 10-year campus plan Our group will include - From ANC 2E - Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Ed Solomon (possibly) and Bill Skelsey (possibly) From the Citizens Association of Georgetown Jennifer Altemus president From the Burleith Citizens Association Lenore Rubino president We look forward to seeing you on Friday (tomorrow) at DDOT at 930 am Best regards Ron

25

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Tuesday January 12 2010 947 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc billstarrelsgmailcom billskelseyancaolcom dctuxedoaolcom cag-

presidentcagtownorg lucapivatocom rhindscgshcom lenorerubinogmailcom

Subject Meeting re Georgetown University 10-year plan with community representatives Jan 13

Attachments Outline of some key impacts on the community of the GU draft 10-year plan-1doc

Dear Jennifer Joel and Steve An outline is attached in case it might be helpful of some key issues in the Georgetown University draft 10‐year plan that wed like to discuss with you at tomorrows meeting Out group tomorrow will include ‐ ANC 2E (Georgetown and Burleith) Commissioners Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Bill Skelsey and Ed Solomon Citizens Association of Georgetown President Jennifer Altemus Vice President Luca Pivato and advisor Richard Hinds Burleith Citizens Association President Lenore Rubino and advisor Mark Gisler We look forward very much to seeing you and continuing the productive dialogue Best regards Ron Ron Lewis Chair ANC 2E

26

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Friday January 08 2010 1057 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer AltemusSubject RE Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image001gif image002gif CAG letter to GU re campus planpdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan Best Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia

27

Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar

28

See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

29

B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

30

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Thursday December 31 2009 406 PMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP)Subject Re Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image002gif image001gif

Jennifer Thanks for providing this information Happy New Year Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Sent Thu Dec 31 144709 2009 Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

31

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 8: Emails 1

8

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Luca ltlucapivatocomgtSent Thursday April 07 2011 104 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject Re ZC GU Hearing MPD DataAttachments ATT00002png

Hi Stephen are you filing today On 442011 1113 AM Mordfin Stephen (OP) wrote Thank you

Stephen J Mordfin AICP Development Review Specialist DC Office of Planning 1100 4th Street SW Suite E650 Washington DC 20024 Office 202‐442‐8810 FAX 202‐442‐7638 stephenmordfindcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Luca [mailtolucapivatocom] Sent Monday April 04 2011 1107 AM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject ZC GU Hearing MPD Data Hi Stephen I have attached some of the charts and maps that we have Ill be happy to come to your office tomorrow at 1pm and bring the raw data on a pen drive as well as our analysis of the data Thank you Luca 301-221-8983 c

9

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Monday April 04 2011 314 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject OP Report on GU Campus Plan

Importance High

Stephen when the OP Report is made available can you send me a copy by email Thanks Richard ___________________________________________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

10

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Luca ltlucapivatocomgtSent Monday April 04 2011 1107 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject ZC GU Hearing MPD DataAttachments Calls By Street for 3500 Block 2000-2009xlsx Calls for O Street 2000-2009xlsx GU

Grad Addresses 2009xls GU Undergrad Addresses 2009xls GMap All Addresses 2009jpg Top10 Calls Residential 2009xlsx Aggregated Geocoded 911 calls - 2009png

Categories Red Category

Hi Stephen I have attached some of the charts and maps that we have Ill be happy to come to your office tomorrow at 1pm and bring the raw data on a pen drive as well as our analysis of the data Thank you Luca 301-221-8983 c

11

Johnson Mike (OP)

From rhindscgshcomSent Monday February 07 2011 335 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Subject Fw Info from Charles DeSantisAttachments Response to Ron Lewis Request_20101117adoc

Steve enclosed is the source of some of the other GU numbers we provided you today Note in particular the growth in non-traditional undergraduates and despite that growth the large reduction in number living in zip 20007 That number needs to be verified However if it were accurate and if the undergraduate cap includes non-traditional students as proposed by GU a decrease in enrollment of non-traditional students would permit a potentially large increase in traditional undergraduates seeking housing in the community which is the opposite of what the community wants to see happen Ditto for students studying abroad if for some unclear to me reason they were included in calculating the base cap Accordingly if total undergraduate enrollment is capped there still needs to be some control on the enrollment of traditional undergraduates in excess of the number of beds provided by the University on campus Requiring the University to take action if the number of undergraduates living in zip 20007 exceeds some number (which should be well below the current number) would provide that control and get to the heart of the communitys concerns Richard ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Charles DeSantis ltced33georgetownedugt Date Wed Nov 17 2010 at 607 PM Subject Re Setting up time to meet To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Cc Dan Porterfield ltporterfdgeorgetownedugt Linda greenan ltgreenanlgeorgetownedugt Margaret Elizabeth Moore ltmem95georgetownedugt Ron As you know we have had a flurry of activity with the news of Dans new presidential appointment at Franklin and Marshall College We are very excited and proud of him and we are also experiencing the loss of a great leader amongst us This has presented some conflicts for meeting with you to discuss answers to your questions this week In the interest of getting you these responses we wanted to provide you with the attacehd document outlining our responses that you can look over and if you have follow up questions you can either get them to us or we can schedule a meeting time in the near future I hope that this holiday season finds you well Happy Thanksgiving to you and Anne Charles

12

Charles DeSantis Associate Vice President of Faculty and Staff Benefits Chief Benefits Officer Office of Faculty and Staff Benefits Georgetown University Direct Line 2026871787 Cell Phone 2022947434 Fax 2026872389 Benefits 2026872500 Email ced33georgetownedu This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

13

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Tuesday January 25 2011 436 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus lucapivatocom

Ronald Lewis Lenore RubinoSubject UK Article

I thought the attached article might be of interest since it makes clear that the same problems facing Georgetown and Burleith have surfaced throughout England httphmolobbyorguk39articlespdf Richard ______________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

14

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday November 02 2010 418 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Ronald LewisSubject Original GU presentations

Sorry for the delay in sending the links I forgot to look at my notes These are the links to the full original presentations from GU httpsgusharegeorgetowneduOfficeOfCommunicationscampus_plan20090529_May30CampusPlanOptions_AMpdf httpsgusharegeorgetowneduOfficeOfCommunicationscampus_plan20090529_May30CampusPlanOptions_PMpdf Regards Gianluca Pivato

15

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Thursday August 26 2010 1001 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Ron LewisSubject Re RE

Oh OK So GUs practice of averaging is still acceptable Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 407 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

Your welcome One change I meant to say that the student counting may NOT be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

Steve

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202‐442‐8810

FAX 202‐442‐7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

16

From Jennifer Altemus [mailtocag-presidentcagtownorg] Sent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer

On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

17

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

18

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

19

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

20

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday May 18 2010 1129 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP)Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meetingAttachments Georgetowner Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on the Georgetowner I meant to attach it to the previous email The editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning for longer than 10 years and being geographically limited by the west and south boundaries Unfortunately unless the trend is reversed and GU complies with the DC Comprehensive Plan the long term result of turning Georgetown and Burleith into college towns is a very real possibility GU under De Gioia is planning to expand enormously in the next decades and this is only the first step I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the adjacent neighborhoods They just need a little push Best regards Luca Pivato On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your time today Please find attached selected data slides from this morning presentation I will be glad to answer any question you may have about the numbers our sources and references or our calculation methods The easiest way to contact me is on my cell at 301-221-8983 or via email at cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg Best regards Luca Pivato

21

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Monday May 17 2010 501 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich

Hinds Lenore Rubino DCtuxedoaolcomSubject Fw 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

This is the incident that was mentioned today involving (1) a graduate student living in Burleith who has repeatedly engaged in loud late night partying (2) whom GU was unaware was living in Burleith Stephen Brown is a resident of Burleith who has created his own website to protest GU student misconduct in his neighborhood It has generated much attention httpwwwdrunkengeorgetownstudentscom Richard ----- Forwarded by Richard deC HINDSDCCgsh on 05172010 0445 PM ----- Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt

17 May 2010 0954 AM

To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Ed Soloman ltdctuxedoaolcomgt Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgt Altemus Jennifer ltcag-presidentcagtownorggt Gianluca Pivato ltlucapivatocomgt

cc

Subject Fwd FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

It is confirmed This is a good example of where GU does not know where all its students live For those jumping in on the email stream Lt Hedgecock MPD reported there was a noise disturbance and Anne Koester (GU) relayed it wasnt a GU student house ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Mon May 17 2010 at 834 AM Subject FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT To Bonnie Hardy lthardybonniehotmailcomgt Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt Dear BonnieLenore This is a medical student whorsquos family was visiting and decided that an open fire and a musical tribute were appropriate I felt otherwise and we ended up having quite a fracas in the alley The police were called twice SNAP came byetcand the letter that follows is to Dean Jeanne Lord We have at least two to three 911rsquos per year from that house Regards

22

Stephen Stephen R Brown Photography 3715 T Street NW Washington DC 20007 202‐667‐1965 202‐255‐8635(cell) httpwwwsrbphotocom httpwwwdcphotobookcom httpwwwjewelofthemallcom mailtosrbsrbphotocom

‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded Message From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Sun 16 May 2010 132049 ‐0400 To Jeanne Lord ltlordjgeorgetownedugt Conversation 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Subject 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Jeanne I can assure you I am quite as tired of this as you and am going out today to buy a quality pair of headphones I wil be doing a composite sketch of all the pictures I have taken and thatrsquos all that will be on the website other than general information to the neighbors It is getting 19000 hits per day and as you may or may not have noticed I have taken out advertising I will be happy to ressurect the site in a more popular format if things continue as they are as I fully expect them to Obviously I donrsquot think you have a handle on your current student population so I will be working in other ways to block GUrsquos growth Last night3713 broke into Florida version of Swiss Family Robinson and three neighbors called the police As they went into the house they began yelling out my name At 217 they began a phone marathon to my studio and fortunately not to my house I have the voice recordings and they are not particularly ldquomedicalrdquo I have to question this womanrsquos competency to get a license as her drunken tirades and now phone marathons are stunningly nasty Herersquos a photo of my phone with the ldquoblocked callsrdquo from her family member who was visiting and her number which she wasnrsquot clever enough to block If yoursquod like to hear what Georgetownrsquos finest has to say on the phone Irsquoll be happy to put it up on the web Otherwise I expect some disciplinary actionsome examination of this womenrsquos competence to get a medical license and a letter of apology to my family ‐‐‐‐‐‐ End of Forwarded Message -- Lenore G Rubino Realtor Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage wwwlenorerubinocom

23

202-262-1261 (best way to reach me) 202-471-5262 (e-fax) Washington Harbour - Georgetown 3000 K Street NW Suite 101 Washington DC 20007

This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

24

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Thursday January 14 2010 301 PMTo Jennings Jeffrey (DDOT) Ziemann Christopher (DDOT)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) billstarrelsgmailcom dctuxedoaolcom

billskelseyancaolcom cag-presidentcagtownorg lenorerubiongmailcomSubject Friday meeting re transportation aspects of GUs 10-year planAttachments Impacts of GU transportation issues and draft 10-year plandoc

Dear Jeff and Chris In case this might be helpful for our meeting Friday morning an outline is attached of what we see as some key transportation issues in the Georgetown University draft 10-year campus plan Our group will include - From ANC 2E - Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Ed Solomon (possibly) and Bill Skelsey (possibly) From the Citizens Association of Georgetown Jennifer Altemus president From the Burleith Citizens Association Lenore Rubino president We look forward to seeing you on Friday (tomorrow) at DDOT at 930 am Best regards Ron

25

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Tuesday January 12 2010 947 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc billstarrelsgmailcom billskelseyancaolcom dctuxedoaolcom cag-

presidentcagtownorg lucapivatocom rhindscgshcom lenorerubinogmailcom

Subject Meeting re Georgetown University 10-year plan with community representatives Jan 13

Attachments Outline of some key impacts on the community of the GU draft 10-year plan-1doc

Dear Jennifer Joel and Steve An outline is attached in case it might be helpful of some key issues in the Georgetown University draft 10‐year plan that wed like to discuss with you at tomorrows meeting Out group tomorrow will include ‐ ANC 2E (Georgetown and Burleith) Commissioners Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Bill Skelsey and Ed Solomon Citizens Association of Georgetown President Jennifer Altemus Vice President Luca Pivato and advisor Richard Hinds Burleith Citizens Association President Lenore Rubino and advisor Mark Gisler We look forward very much to seeing you and continuing the productive dialogue Best regards Ron Ron Lewis Chair ANC 2E

26

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Friday January 08 2010 1057 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer AltemusSubject RE Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image001gif image002gif CAG letter to GU re campus planpdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan Best Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia

27

Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar

28

See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

29

B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

30

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Thursday December 31 2009 406 PMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP)Subject Re Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image002gif image001gif

Jennifer Thanks for providing this information Happy New Year Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Sent Thu Dec 31 144709 2009 Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

31

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 9: Emails 1

9

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Monday April 04 2011 314 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject OP Report on GU Campus Plan

Importance High

Stephen when the OP Report is made available can you send me a copy by email Thanks Richard ___________________________________________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

10

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Luca ltlucapivatocomgtSent Monday April 04 2011 1107 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject ZC GU Hearing MPD DataAttachments Calls By Street for 3500 Block 2000-2009xlsx Calls for O Street 2000-2009xlsx GU

Grad Addresses 2009xls GU Undergrad Addresses 2009xls GMap All Addresses 2009jpg Top10 Calls Residential 2009xlsx Aggregated Geocoded 911 calls - 2009png

Categories Red Category

Hi Stephen I have attached some of the charts and maps that we have Ill be happy to come to your office tomorrow at 1pm and bring the raw data on a pen drive as well as our analysis of the data Thank you Luca 301-221-8983 c

11

Johnson Mike (OP)

From rhindscgshcomSent Monday February 07 2011 335 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Subject Fw Info from Charles DeSantisAttachments Response to Ron Lewis Request_20101117adoc

Steve enclosed is the source of some of the other GU numbers we provided you today Note in particular the growth in non-traditional undergraduates and despite that growth the large reduction in number living in zip 20007 That number needs to be verified However if it were accurate and if the undergraduate cap includes non-traditional students as proposed by GU a decrease in enrollment of non-traditional students would permit a potentially large increase in traditional undergraduates seeking housing in the community which is the opposite of what the community wants to see happen Ditto for students studying abroad if for some unclear to me reason they were included in calculating the base cap Accordingly if total undergraduate enrollment is capped there still needs to be some control on the enrollment of traditional undergraduates in excess of the number of beds provided by the University on campus Requiring the University to take action if the number of undergraduates living in zip 20007 exceeds some number (which should be well below the current number) would provide that control and get to the heart of the communitys concerns Richard ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Charles DeSantis ltced33georgetownedugt Date Wed Nov 17 2010 at 607 PM Subject Re Setting up time to meet To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Cc Dan Porterfield ltporterfdgeorgetownedugt Linda greenan ltgreenanlgeorgetownedugt Margaret Elizabeth Moore ltmem95georgetownedugt Ron As you know we have had a flurry of activity with the news of Dans new presidential appointment at Franklin and Marshall College We are very excited and proud of him and we are also experiencing the loss of a great leader amongst us This has presented some conflicts for meeting with you to discuss answers to your questions this week In the interest of getting you these responses we wanted to provide you with the attacehd document outlining our responses that you can look over and if you have follow up questions you can either get them to us or we can schedule a meeting time in the near future I hope that this holiday season finds you well Happy Thanksgiving to you and Anne Charles

12

Charles DeSantis Associate Vice President of Faculty and Staff Benefits Chief Benefits Officer Office of Faculty and Staff Benefits Georgetown University Direct Line 2026871787 Cell Phone 2022947434 Fax 2026872389 Benefits 2026872500 Email ced33georgetownedu This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

13

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Tuesday January 25 2011 436 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus lucapivatocom

Ronald Lewis Lenore RubinoSubject UK Article

I thought the attached article might be of interest since it makes clear that the same problems facing Georgetown and Burleith have surfaced throughout England httphmolobbyorguk39articlespdf Richard ______________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

14

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday November 02 2010 418 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Ronald LewisSubject Original GU presentations

Sorry for the delay in sending the links I forgot to look at my notes These are the links to the full original presentations from GU httpsgusharegeorgetowneduOfficeOfCommunicationscampus_plan20090529_May30CampusPlanOptions_AMpdf httpsgusharegeorgetowneduOfficeOfCommunicationscampus_plan20090529_May30CampusPlanOptions_PMpdf Regards Gianluca Pivato

15

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Thursday August 26 2010 1001 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Ron LewisSubject Re RE

Oh OK So GUs practice of averaging is still acceptable Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 407 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

Your welcome One change I meant to say that the student counting may NOT be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

Steve

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202‐442‐8810

FAX 202‐442‐7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

16

From Jennifer Altemus [mailtocag-presidentcagtownorg] Sent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer

On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

17

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

18

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

19

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

20

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday May 18 2010 1129 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP)Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meetingAttachments Georgetowner Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on the Georgetowner I meant to attach it to the previous email The editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning for longer than 10 years and being geographically limited by the west and south boundaries Unfortunately unless the trend is reversed and GU complies with the DC Comprehensive Plan the long term result of turning Georgetown and Burleith into college towns is a very real possibility GU under De Gioia is planning to expand enormously in the next decades and this is only the first step I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the adjacent neighborhoods They just need a little push Best regards Luca Pivato On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your time today Please find attached selected data slides from this morning presentation I will be glad to answer any question you may have about the numbers our sources and references or our calculation methods The easiest way to contact me is on my cell at 301-221-8983 or via email at cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg Best regards Luca Pivato

21

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Monday May 17 2010 501 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich

Hinds Lenore Rubino DCtuxedoaolcomSubject Fw 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

This is the incident that was mentioned today involving (1) a graduate student living in Burleith who has repeatedly engaged in loud late night partying (2) whom GU was unaware was living in Burleith Stephen Brown is a resident of Burleith who has created his own website to protest GU student misconduct in his neighborhood It has generated much attention httpwwwdrunkengeorgetownstudentscom Richard ----- Forwarded by Richard deC HINDSDCCgsh on 05172010 0445 PM ----- Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt

17 May 2010 0954 AM

To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Ed Soloman ltdctuxedoaolcomgt Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgt Altemus Jennifer ltcag-presidentcagtownorggt Gianluca Pivato ltlucapivatocomgt

cc

Subject Fwd FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

It is confirmed This is a good example of where GU does not know where all its students live For those jumping in on the email stream Lt Hedgecock MPD reported there was a noise disturbance and Anne Koester (GU) relayed it wasnt a GU student house ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Mon May 17 2010 at 834 AM Subject FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT To Bonnie Hardy lthardybonniehotmailcomgt Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt Dear BonnieLenore This is a medical student whorsquos family was visiting and decided that an open fire and a musical tribute were appropriate I felt otherwise and we ended up having quite a fracas in the alley The police were called twice SNAP came byetcand the letter that follows is to Dean Jeanne Lord We have at least two to three 911rsquos per year from that house Regards

22

Stephen Stephen R Brown Photography 3715 T Street NW Washington DC 20007 202‐667‐1965 202‐255‐8635(cell) httpwwwsrbphotocom httpwwwdcphotobookcom httpwwwjewelofthemallcom mailtosrbsrbphotocom

‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded Message From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Sun 16 May 2010 132049 ‐0400 To Jeanne Lord ltlordjgeorgetownedugt Conversation 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Subject 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Jeanne I can assure you I am quite as tired of this as you and am going out today to buy a quality pair of headphones I wil be doing a composite sketch of all the pictures I have taken and thatrsquos all that will be on the website other than general information to the neighbors It is getting 19000 hits per day and as you may or may not have noticed I have taken out advertising I will be happy to ressurect the site in a more popular format if things continue as they are as I fully expect them to Obviously I donrsquot think you have a handle on your current student population so I will be working in other ways to block GUrsquos growth Last night3713 broke into Florida version of Swiss Family Robinson and three neighbors called the police As they went into the house they began yelling out my name At 217 they began a phone marathon to my studio and fortunately not to my house I have the voice recordings and they are not particularly ldquomedicalrdquo I have to question this womanrsquos competency to get a license as her drunken tirades and now phone marathons are stunningly nasty Herersquos a photo of my phone with the ldquoblocked callsrdquo from her family member who was visiting and her number which she wasnrsquot clever enough to block If yoursquod like to hear what Georgetownrsquos finest has to say on the phone Irsquoll be happy to put it up on the web Otherwise I expect some disciplinary actionsome examination of this womenrsquos competence to get a medical license and a letter of apology to my family ‐‐‐‐‐‐ End of Forwarded Message -- Lenore G Rubino Realtor Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage wwwlenorerubinocom

23

202-262-1261 (best way to reach me) 202-471-5262 (e-fax) Washington Harbour - Georgetown 3000 K Street NW Suite 101 Washington DC 20007

This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

24

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Thursday January 14 2010 301 PMTo Jennings Jeffrey (DDOT) Ziemann Christopher (DDOT)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) billstarrelsgmailcom dctuxedoaolcom

billskelseyancaolcom cag-presidentcagtownorg lenorerubiongmailcomSubject Friday meeting re transportation aspects of GUs 10-year planAttachments Impacts of GU transportation issues and draft 10-year plandoc

Dear Jeff and Chris In case this might be helpful for our meeting Friday morning an outline is attached of what we see as some key transportation issues in the Georgetown University draft 10-year campus plan Our group will include - From ANC 2E - Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Ed Solomon (possibly) and Bill Skelsey (possibly) From the Citizens Association of Georgetown Jennifer Altemus president From the Burleith Citizens Association Lenore Rubino president We look forward to seeing you on Friday (tomorrow) at DDOT at 930 am Best regards Ron

25

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Tuesday January 12 2010 947 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc billstarrelsgmailcom billskelseyancaolcom dctuxedoaolcom cag-

presidentcagtownorg lucapivatocom rhindscgshcom lenorerubinogmailcom

Subject Meeting re Georgetown University 10-year plan with community representatives Jan 13

Attachments Outline of some key impacts on the community of the GU draft 10-year plan-1doc

Dear Jennifer Joel and Steve An outline is attached in case it might be helpful of some key issues in the Georgetown University draft 10‐year plan that wed like to discuss with you at tomorrows meeting Out group tomorrow will include ‐ ANC 2E (Georgetown and Burleith) Commissioners Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Bill Skelsey and Ed Solomon Citizens Association of Georgetown President Jennifer Altemus Vice President Luca Pivato and advisor Richard Hinds Burleith Citizens Association President Lenore Rubino and advisor Mark Gisler We look forward very much to seeing you and continuing the productive dialogue Best regards Ron Ron Lewis Chair ANC 2E

26

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Friday January 08 2010 1057 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer AltemusSubject RE Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image001gif image002gif CAG letter to GU re campus planpdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan Best Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia

27

Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar

28

See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

29

B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

30

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Thursday December 31 2009 406 PMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP)Subject Re Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image002gif image001gif

Jennifer Thanks for providing this information Happy New Year Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Sent Thu Dec 31 144709 2009 Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

31

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 10: Emails 1

10

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Luca ltlucapivatocomgtSent Monday April 04 2011 1107 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject ZC GU Hearing MPD DataAttachments Calls By Street for 3500 Block 2000-2009xlsx Calls for O Street 2000-2009xlsx GU

Grad Addresses 2009xls GU Undergrad Addresses 2009xls GMap All Addresses 2009jpg Top10 Calls Residential 2009xlsx Aggregated Geocoded 911 calls - 2009png

Categories Red Category

Hi Stephen I have attached some of the charts and maps that we have Ill be happy to come to your office tomorrow at 1pm and bring the raw data on a pen drive as well as our analysis of the data Thank you Luca 301-221-8983 c

11

Johnson Mike (OP)

From rhindscgshcomSent Monday February 07 2011 335 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Subject Fw Info from Charles DeSantisAttachments Response to Ron Lewis Request_20101117adoc

Steve enclosed is the source of some of the other GU numbers we provided you today Note in particular the growth in non-traditional undergraduates and despite that growth the large reduction in number living in zip 20007 That number needs to be verified However if it were accurate and if the undergraduate cap includes non-traditional students as proposed by GU a decrease in enrollment of non-traditional students would permit a potentially large increase in traditional undergraduates seeking housing in the community which is the opposite of what the community wants to see happen Ditto for students studying abroad if for some unclear to me reason they were included in calculating the base cap Accordingly if total undergraduate enrollment is capped there still needs to be some control on the enrollment of traditional undergraduates in excess of the number of beds provided by the University on campus Requiring the University to take action if the number of undergraduates living in zip 20007 exceeds some number (which should be well below the current number) would provide that control and get to the heart of the communitys concerns Richard ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Charles DeSantis ltced33georgetownedugt Date Wed Nov 17 2010 at 607 PM Subject Re Setting up time to meet To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Cc Dan Porterfield ltporterfdgeorgetownedugt Linda greenan ltgreenanlgeorgetownedugt Margaret Elizabeth Moore ltmem95georgetownedugt Ron As you know we have had a flurry of activity with the news of Dans new presidential appointment at Franklin and Marshall College We are very excited and proud of him and we are also experiencing the loss of a great leader amongst us This has presented some conflicts for meeting with you to discuss answers to your questions this week In the interest of getting you these responses we wanted to provide you with the attacehd document outlining our responses that you can look over and if you have follow up questions you can either get them to us or we can schedule a meeting time in the near future I hope that this holiday season finds you well Happy Thanksgiving to you and Anne Charles

12

Charles DeSantis Associate Vice President of Faculty and Staff Benefits Chief Benefits Officer Office of Faculty and Staff Benefits Georgetown University Direct Line 2026871787 Cell Phone 2022947434 Fax 2026872389 Benefits 2026872500 Email ced33georgetownedu This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

13

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Tuesday January 25 2011 436 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus lucapivatocom

Ronald Lewis Lenore RubinoSubject UK Article

I thought the attached article might be of interest since it makes clear that the same problems facing Georgetown and Burleith have surfaced throughout England httphmolobbyorguk39articlespdf Richard ______________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

14

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday November 02 2010 418 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Ronald LewisSubject Original GU presentations

Sorry for the delay in sending the links I forgot to look at my notes These are the links to the full original presentations from GU httpsgusharegeorgetowneduOfficeOfCommunicationscampus_plan20090529_May30CampusPlanOptions_AMpdf httpsgusharegeorgetowneduOfficeOfCommunicationscampus_plan20090529_May30CampusPlanOptions_PMpdf Regards Gianluca Pivato

15

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Thursday August 26 2010 1001 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Ron LewisSubject Re RE

Oh OK So GUs practice of averaging is still acceptable Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 407 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

Your welcome One change I meant to say that the student counting may NOT be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

Steve

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202‐442‐8810

FAX 202‐442‐7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

16

From Jennifer Altemus [mailtocag-presidentcagtownorg] Sent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer

On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

17

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

18

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

19

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

20

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday May 18 2010 1129 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP)Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meetingAttachments Georgetowner Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on the Georgetowner I meant to attach it to the previous email The editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning for longer than 10 years and being geographically limited by the west and south boundaries Unfortunately unless the trend is reversed and GU complies with the DC Comprehensive Plan the long term result of turning Georgetown and Burleith into college towns is a very real possibility GU under De Gioia is planning to expand enormously in the next decades and this is only the first step I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the adjacent neighborhoods They just need a little push Best regards Luca Pivato On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your time today Please find attached selected data slides from this morning presentation I will be glad to answer any question you may have about the numbers our sources and references or our calculation methods The easiest way to contact me is on my cell at 301-221-8983 or via email at cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg Best regards Luca Pivato

21

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Monday May 17 2010 501 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich

Hinds Lenore Rubino DCtuxedoaolcomSubject Fw 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

This is the incident that was mentioned today involving (1) a graduate student living in Burleith who has repeatedly engaged in loud late night partying (2) whom GU was unaware was living in Burleith Stephen Brown is a resident of Burleith who has created his own website to protest GU student misconduct in his neighborhood It has generated much attention httpwwwdrunkengeorgetownstudentscom Richard ----- Forwarded by Richard deC HINDSDCCgsh on 05172010 0445 PM ----- Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt

17 May 2010 0954 AM

To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Ed Soloman ltdctuxedoaolcomgt Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgt Altemus Jennifer ltcag-presidentcagtownorggt Gianluca Pivato ltlucapivatocomgt

cc

Subject Fwd FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

It is confirmed This is a good example of where GU does not know where all its students live For those jumping in on the email stream Lt Hedgecock MPD reported there was a noise disturbance and Anne Koester (GU) relayed it wasnt a GU student house ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Mon May 17 2010 at 834 AM Subject FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT To Bonnie Hardy lthardybonniehotmailcomgt Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt Dear BonnieLenore This is a medical student whorsquos family was visiting and decided that an open fire and a musical tribute were appropriate I felt otherwise and we ended up having quite a fracas in the alley The police were called twice SNAP came byetcand the letter that follows is to Dean Jeanne Lord We have at least two to three 911rsquos per year from that house Regards

22

Stephen Stephen R Brown Photography 3715 T Street NW Washington DC 20007 202‐667‐1965 202‐255‐8635(cell) httpwwwsrbphotocom httpwwwdcphotobookcom httpwwwjewelofthemallcom mailtosrbsrbphotocom

‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded Message From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Sun 16 May 2010 132049 ‐0400 To Jeanne Lord ltlordjgeorgetownedugt Conversation 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Subject 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Jeanne I can assure you I am quite as tired of this as you and am going out today to buy a quality pair of headphones I wil be doing a composite sketch of all the pictures I have taken and thatrsquos all that will be on the website other than general information to the neighbors It is getting 19000 hits per day and as you may or may not have noticed I have taken out advertising I will be happy to ressurect the site in a more popular format if things continue as they are as I fully expect them to Obviously I donrsquot think you have a handle on your current student population so I will be working in other ways to block GUrsquos growth Last night3713 broke into Florida version of Swiss Family Robinson and three neighbors called the police As they went into the house they began yelling out my name At 217 they began a phone marathon to my studio and fortunately not to my house I have the voice recordings and they are not particularly ldquomedicalrdquo I have to question this womanrsquos competency to get a license as her drunken tirades and now phone marathons are stunningly nasty Herersquos a photo of my phone with the ldquoblocked callsrdquo from her family member who was visiting and her number which she wasnrsquot clever enough to block If yoursquod like to hear what Georgetownrsquos finest has to say on the phone Irsquoll be happy to put it up on the web Otherwise I expect some disciplinary actionsome examination of this womenrsquos competence to get a medical license and a letter of apology to my family ‐‐‐‐‐‐ End of Forwarded Message -- Lenore G Rubino Realtor Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage wwwlenorerubinocom

23

202-262-1261 (best way to reach me) 202-471-5262 (e-fax) Washington Harbour - Georgetown 3000 K Street NW Suite 101 Washington DC 20007

This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

24

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Thursday January 14 2010 301 PMTo Jennings Jeffrey (DDOT) Ziemann Christopher (DDOT)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) billstarrelsgmailcom dctuxedoaolcom

billskelseyancaolcom cag-presidentcagtownorg lenorerubiongmailcomSubject Friday meeting re transportation aspects of GUs 10-year planAttachments Impacts of GU transportation issues and draft 10-year plandoc

Dear Jeff and Chris In case this might be helpful for our meeting Friday morning an outline is attached of what we see as some key transportation issues in the Georgetown University draft 10-year campus plan Our group will include - From ANC 2E - Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Ed Solomon (possibly) and Bill Skelsey (possibly) From the Citizens Association of Georgetown Jennifer Altemus president From the Burleith Citizens Association Lenore Rubino president We look forward to seeing you on Friday (tomorrow) at DDOT at 930 am Best regards Ron

25

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Tuesday January 12 2010 947 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc billstarrelsgmailcom billskelseyancaolcom dctuxedoaolcom cag-

presidentcagtownorg lucapivatocom rhindscgshcom lenorerubinogmailcom

Subject Meeting re Georgetown University 10-year plan with community representatives Jan 13

Attachments Outline of some key impacts on the community of the GU draft 10-year plan-1doc

Dear Jennifer Joel and Steve An outline is attached in case it might be helpful of some key issues in the Georgetown University draft 10‐year plan that wed like to discuss with you at tomorrows meeting Out group tomorrow will include ‐ ANC 2E (Georgetown and Burleith) Commissioners Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Bill Skelsey and Ed Solomon Citizens Association of Georgetown President Jennifer Altemus Vice President Luca Pivato and advisor Richard Hinds Burleith Citizens Association President Lenore Rubino and advisor Mark Gisler We look forward very much to seeing you and continuing the productive dialogue Best regards Ron Ron Lewis Chair ANC 2E

26

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Friday January 08 2010 1057 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer AltemusSubject RE Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image001gif image002gif CAG letter to GU re campus planpdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan Best Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia

27

Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar

28

See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

29

B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

30

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Thursday December 31 2009 406 PMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP)Subject Re Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image002gif image001gif

Jennifer Thanks for providing this information Happy New Year Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Sent Thu Dec 31 144709 2009 Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

31

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 11: Emails 1

11

Johnson Mike (OP)

From rhindscgshcomSent Monday February 07 2011 335 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Subject Fw Info from Charles DeSantisAttachments Response to Ron Lewis Request_20101117adoc

Steve enclosed is the source of some of the other GU numbers we provided you today Note in particular the growth in non-traditional undergraduates and despite that growth the large reduction in number living in zip 20007 That number needs to be verified However if it were accurate and if the undergraduate cap includes non-traditional students as proposed by GU a decrease in enrollment of non-traditional students would permit a potentially large increase in traditional undergraduates seeking housing in the community which is the opposite of what the community wants to see happen Ditto for students studying abroad if for some unclear to me reason they were included in calculating the base cap Accordingly if total undergraduate enrollment is capped there still needs to be some control on the enrollment of traditional undergraduates in excess of the number of beds provided by the University on campus Requiring the University to take action if the number of undergraduates living in zip 20007 exceeds some number (which should be well below the current number) would provide that control and get to the heart of the communitys concerns Richard ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Charles DeSantis ltced33georgetownedugt Date Wed Nov 17 2010 at 607 PM Subject Re Setting up time to meet To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Cc Dan Porterfield ltporterfdgeorgetownedugt Linda greenan ltgreenanlgeorgetownedugt Margaret Elizabeth Moore ltmem95georgetownedugt Ron As you know we have had a flurry of activity with the news of Dans new presidential appointment at Franklin and Marshall College We are very excited and proud of him and we are also experiencing the loss of a great leader amongst us This has presented some conflicts for meeting with you to discuss answers to your questions this week In the interest of getting you these responses we wanted to provide you with the attacehd document outlining our responses that you can look over and if you have follow up questions you can either get them to us or we can schedule a meeting time in the near future I hope that this holiday season finds you well Happy Thanksgiving to you and Anne Charles

12

Charles DeSantis Associate Vice President of Faculty and Staff Benefits Chief Benefits Officer Office of Faculty and Staff Benefits Georgetown University Direct Line 2026871787 Cell Phone 2022947434 Fax 2026872389 Benefits 2026872500 Email ced33georgetownedu This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

13

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Tuesday January 25 2011 436 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus lucapivatocom

Ronald Lewis Lenore RubinoSubject UK Article

I thought the attached article might be of interest since it makes clear that the same problems facing Georgetown and Burleith have surfaced throughout England httphmolobbyorguk39articlespdf Richard ______________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

14

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday November 02 2010 418 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Ronald LewisSubject Original GU presentations

Sorry for the delay in sending the links I forgot to look at my notes These are the links to the full original presentations from GU httpsgusharegeorgetowneduOfficeOfCommunicationscampus_plan20090529_May30CampusPlanOptions_AMpdf httpsgusharegeorgetowneduOfficeOfCommunicationscampus_plan20090529_May30CampusPlanOptions_PMpdf Regards Gianluca Pivato

15

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Thursday August 26 2010 1001 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Ron LewisSubject Re RE

Oh OK So GUs practice of averaging is still acceptable Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 407 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

Your welcome One change I meant to say that the student counting may NOT be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

Steve

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202‐442‐8810

FAX 202‐442‐7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

16

From Jennifer Altemus [mailtocag-presidentcagtownorg] Sent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer

On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

17

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

18

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

19

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

20

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday May 18 2010 1129 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP)Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meetingAttachments Georgetowner Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on the Georgetowner I meant to attach it to the previous email The editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning for longer than 10 years and being geographically limited by the west and south boundaries Unfortunately unless the trend is reversed and GU complies with the DC Comprehensive Plan the long term result of turning Georgetown and Burleith into college towns is a very real possibility GU under De Gioia is planning to expand enormously in the next decades and this is only the first step I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the adjacent neighborhoods They just need a little push Best regards Luca Pivato On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your time today Please find attached selected data slides from this morning presentation I will be glad to answer any question you may have about the numbers our sources and references or our calculation methods The easiest way to contact me is on my cell at 301-221-8983 or via email at cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg Best regards Luca Pivato

21

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Monday May 17 2010 501 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich

Hinds Lenore Rubino DCtuxedoaolcomSubject Fw 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

This is the incident that was mentioned today involving (1) a graduate student living in Burleith who has repeatedly engaged in loud late night partying (2) whom GU was unaware was living in Burleith Stephen Brown is a resident of Burleith who has created his own website to protest GU student misconduct in his neighborhood It has generated much attention httpwwwdrunkengeorgetownstudentscom Richard ----- Forwarded by Richard deC HINDSDCCgsh on 05172010 0445 PM ----- Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt

17 May 2010 0954 AM

To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Ed Soloman ltdctuxedoaolcomgt Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgt Altemus Jennifer ltcag-presidentcagtownorggt Gianluca Pivato ltlucapivatocomgt

cc

Subject Fwd FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

It is confirmed This is a good example of where GU does not know where all its students live For those jumping in on the email stream Lt Hedgecock MPD reported there was a noise disturbance and Anne Koester (GU) relayed it wasnt a GU student house ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Mon May 17 2010 at 834 AM Subject FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT To Bonnie Hardy lthardybonniehotmailcomgt Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt Dear BonnieLenore This is a medical student whorsquos family was visiting and decided that an open fire and a musical tribute were appropriate I felt otherwise and we ended up having quite a fracas in the alley The police were called twice SNAP came byetcand the letter that follows is to Dean Jeanne Lord We have at least two to three 911rsquos per year from that house Regards

22

Stephen Stephen R Brown Photography 3715 T Street NW Washington DC 20007 202‐667‐1965 202‐255‐8635(cell) httpwwwsrbphotocom httpwwwdcphotobookcom httpwwwjewelofthemallcom mailtosrbsrbphotocom

‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded Message From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Sun 16 May 2010 132049 ‐0400 To Jeanne Lord ltlordjgeorgetownedugt Conversation 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Subject 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Jeanne I can assure you I am quite as tired of this as you and am going out today to buy a quality pair of headphones I wil be doing a composite sketch of all the pictures I have taken and thatrsquos all that will be on the website other than general information to the neighbors It is getting 19000 hits per day and as you may or may not have noticed I have taken out advertising I will be happy to ressurect the site in a more popular format if things continue as they are as I fully expect them to Obviously I donrsquot think you have a handle on your current student population so I will be working in other ways to block GUrsquos growth Last night3713 broke into Florida version of Swiss Family Robinson and three neighbors called the police As they went into the house they began yelling out my name At 217 they began a phone marathon to my studio and fortunately not to my house I have the voice recordings and they are not particularly ldquomedicalrdquo I have to question this womanrsquos competency to get a license as her drunken tirades and now phone marathons are stunningly nasty Herersquos a photo of my phone with the ldquoblocked callsrdquo from her family member who was visiting and her number which she wasnrsquot clever enough to block If yoursquod like to hear what Georgetownrsquos finest has to say on the phone Irsquoll be happy to put it up on the web Otherwise I expect some disciplinary actionsome examination of this womenrsquos competence to get a medical license and a letter of apology to my family ‐‐‐‐‐‐ End of Forwarded Message -- Lenore G Rubino Realtor Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage wwwlenorerubinocom

23

202-262-1261 (best way to reach me) 202-471-5262 (e-fax) Washington Harbour - Georgetown 3000 K Street NW Suite 101 Washington DC 20007

This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

24

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Thursday January 14 2010 301 PMTo Jennings Jeffrey (DDOT) Ziemann Christopher (DDOT)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) billstarrelsgmailcom dctuxedoaolcom

billskelseyancaolcom cag-presidentcagtownorg lenorerubiongmailcomSubject Friday meeting re transportation aspects of GUs 10-year planAttachments Impacts of GU transportation issues and draft 10-year plandoc

Dear Jeff and Chris In case this might be helpful for our meeting Friday morning an outline is attached of what we see as some key transportation issues in the Georgetown University draft 10-year campus plan Our group will include - From ANC 2E - Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Ed Solomon (possibly) and Bill Skelsey (possibly) From the Citizens Association of Georgetown Jennifer Altemus president From the Burleith Citizens Association Lenore Rubino president We look forward to seeing you on Friday (tomorrow) at DDOT at 930 am Best regards Ron

25

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Tuesday January 12 2010 947 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc billstarrelsgmailcom billskelseyancaolcom dctuxedoaolcom cag-

presidentcagtownorg lucapivatocom rhindscgshcom lenorerubinogmailcom

Subject Meeting re Georgetown University 10-year plan with community representatives Jan 13

Attachments Outline of some key impacts on the community of the GU draft 10-year plan-1doc

Dear Jennifer Joel and Steve An outline is attached in case it might be helpful of some key issues in the Georgetown University draft 10‐year plan that wed like to discuss with you at tomorrows meeting Out group tomorrow will include ‐ ANC 2E (Georgetown and Burleith) Commissioners Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Bill Skelsey and Ed Solomon Citizens Association of Georgetown President Jennifer Altemus Vice President Luca Pivato and advisor Richard Hinds Burleith Citizens Association President Lenore Rubino and advisor Mark Gisler We look forward very much to seeing you and continuing the productive dialogue Best regards Ron Ron Lewis Chair ANC 2E

26

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Friday January 08 2010 1057 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer AltemusSubject RE Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image001gif image002gif CAG letter to GU re campus planpdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan Best Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia

27

Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar

28

See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

29

B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

30

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Thursday December 31 2009 406 PMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP)Subject Re Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image002gif image001gif

Jennifer Thanks for providing this information Happy New Year Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Sent Thu Dec 31 144709 2009 Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

31

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 12: Emails 1

12

Charles DeSantis Associate Vice President of Faculty and Staff Benefits Chief Benefits Officer Office of Faculty and Staff Benefits Georgetown University Direct Line 2026871787 Cell Phone 2022947434 Fax 2026872389 Benefits 2026872500 Email ced33georgetownedu This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

13

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Tuesday January 25 2011 436 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus lucapivatocom

Ronald Lewis Lenore RubinoSubject UK Article

I thought the attached article might be of interest since it makes clear that the same problems facing Georgetown and Burleith have surfaced throughout England httphmolobbyorguk39articlespdf Richard ______________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

14

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday November 02 2010 418 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Ronald LewisSubject Original GU presentations

Sorry for the delay in sending the links I forgot to look at my notes These are the links to the full original presentations from GU httpsgusharegeorgetowneduOfficeOfCommunicationscampus_plan20090529_May30CampusPlanOptions_AMpdf httpsgusharegeorgetowneduOfficeOfCommunicationscampus_plan20090529_May30CampusPlanOptions_PMpdf Regards Gianluca Pivato

15

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Thursday August 26 2010 1001 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Ron LewisSubject Re RE

Oh OK So GUs practice of averaging is still acceptable Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 407 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

Your welcome One change I meant to say that the student counting may NOT be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

Steve

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202‐442‐8810

FAX 202‐442‐7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

16

From Jennifer Altemus [mailtocag-presidentcagtownorg] Sent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer

On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

17

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

18

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

19

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

20

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday May 18 2010 1129 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP)Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meetingAttachments Georgetowner Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on the Georgetowner I meant to attach it to the previous email The editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning for longer than 10 years and being geographically limited by the west and south boundaries Unfortunately unless the trend is reversed and GU complies with the DC Comprehensive Plan the long term result of turning Georgetown and Burleith into college towns is a very real possibility GU under De Gioia is planning to expand enormously in the next decades and this is only the first step I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the adjacent neighborhoods They just need a little push Best regards Luca Pivato On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your time today Please find attached selected data slides from this morning presentation I will be glad to answer any question you may have about the numbers our sources and references or our calculation methods The easiest way to contact me is on my cell at 301-221-8983 or via email at cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg Best regards Luca Pivato

21

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Monday May 17 2010 501 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich

Hinds Lenore Rubino DCtuxedoaolcomSubject Fw 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

This is the incident that was mentioned today involving (1) a graduate student living in Burleith who has repeatedly engaged in loud late night partying (2) whom GU was unaware was living in Burleith Stephen Brown is a resident of Burleith who has created his own website to protest GU student misconduct in his neighborhood It has generated much attention httpwwwdrunkengeorgetownstudentscom Richard ----- Forwarded by Richard deC HINDSDCCgsh on 05172010 0445 PM ----- Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt

17 May 2010 0954 AM

To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Ed Soloman ltdctuxedoaolcomgt Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgt Altemus Jennifer ltcag-presidentcagtownorggt Gianluca Pivato ltlucapivatocomgt

cc

Subject Fwd FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

It is confirmed This is a good example of where GU does not know where all its students live For those jumping in on the email stream Lt Hedgecock MPD reported there was a noise disturbance and Anne Koester (GU) relayed it wasnt a GU student house ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Mon May 17 2010 at 834 AM Subject FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT To Bonnie Hardy lthardybonniehotmailcomgt Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt Dear BonnieLenore This is a medical student whorsquos family was visiting and decided that an open fire and a musical tribute were appropriate I felt otherwise and we ended up having quite a fracas in the alley The police were called twice SNAP came byetcand the letter that follows is to Dean Jeanne Lord We have at least two to three 911rsquos per year from that house Regards

22

Stephen Stephen R Brown Photography 3715 T Street NW Washington DC 20007 202‐667‐1965 202‐255‐8635(cell) httpwwwsrbphotocom httpwwwdcphotobookcom httpwwwjewelofthemallcom mailtosrbsrbphotocom

‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded Message From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Sun 16 May 2010 132049 ‐0400 To Jeanne Lord ltlordjgeorgetownedugt Conversation 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Subject 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Jeanne I can assure you I am quite as tired of this as you and am going out today to buy a quality pair of headphones I wil be doing a composite sketch of all the pictures I have taken and thatrsquos all that will be on the website other than general information to the neighbors It is getting 19000 hits per day and as you may or may not have noticed I have taken out advertising I will be happy to ressurect the site in a more popular format if things continue as they are as I fully expect them to Obviously I donrsquot think you have a handle on your current student population so I will be working in other ways to block GUrsquos growth Last night3713 broke into Florida version of Swiss Family Robinson and three neighbors called the police As they went into the house they began yelling out my name At 217 they began a phone marathon to my studio and fortunately not to my house I have the voice recordings and they are not particularly ldquomedicalrdquo I have to question this womanrsquos competency to get a license as her drunken tirades and now phone marathons are stunningly nasty Herersquos a photo of my phone with the ldquoblocked callsrdquo from her family member who was visiting and her number which she wasnrsquot clever enough to block If yoursquod like to hear what Georgetownrsquos finest has to say on the phone Irsquoll be happy to put it up on the web Otherwise I expect some disciplinary actionsome examination of this womenrsquos competence to get a medical license and a letter of apology to my family ‐‐‐‐‐‐ End of Forwarded Message -- Lenore G Rubino Realtor Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage wwwlenorerubinocom

23

202-262-1261 (best way to reach me) 202-471-5262 (e-fax) Washington Harbour - Georgetown 3000 K Street NW Suite 101 Washington DC 20007

This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

24

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Thursday January 14 2010 301 PMTo Jennings Jeffrey (DDOT) Ziemann Christopher (DDOT)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) billstarrelsgmailcom dctuxedoaolcom

billskelseyancaolcom cag-presidentcagtownorg lenorerubiongmailcomSubject Friday meeting re transportation aspects of GUs 10-year planAttachments Impacts of GU transportation issues and draft 10-year plandoc

Dear Jeff and Chris In case this might be helpful for our meeting Friday morning an outline is attached of what we see as some key transportation issues in the Georgetown University draft 10-year campus plan Our group will include - From ANC 2E - Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Ed Solomon (possibly) and Bill Skelsey (possibly) From the Citizens Association of Georgetown Jennifer Altemus president From the Burleith Citizens Association Lenore Rubino president We look forward to seeing you on Friday (tomorrow) at DDOT at 930 am Best regards Ron

25

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Tuesday January 12 2010 947 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc billstarrelsgmailcom billskelseyancaolcom dctuxedoaolcom cag-

presidentcagtownorg lucapivatocom rhindscgshcom lenorerubinogmailcom

Subject Meeting re Georgetown University 10-year plan with community representatives Jan 13

Attachments Outline of some key impacts on the community of the GU draft 10-year plan-1doc

Dear Jennifer Joel and Steve An outline is attached in case it might be helpful of some key issues in the Georgetown University draft 10‐year plan that wed like to discuss with you at tomorrows meeting Out group tomorrow will include ‐ ANC 2E (Georgetown and Burleith) Commissioners Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Bill Skelsey and Ed Solomon Citizens Association of Georgetown President Jennifer Altemus Vice President Luca Pivato and advisor Richard Hinds Burleith Citizens Association President Lenore Rubino and advisor Mark Gisler We look forward very much to seeing you and continuing the productive dialogue Best regards Ron Ron Lewis Chair ANC 2E

26

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Friday January 08 2010 1057 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer AltemusSubject RE Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image001gif image002gif CAG letter to GU re campus planpdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan Best Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia

27

Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar

28

See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

29

B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

30

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Thursday December 31 2009 406 PMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP)Subject Re Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image002gif image001gif

Jennifer Thanks for providing this information Happy New Year Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Sent Thu Dec 31 144709 2009 Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

31

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 13: Emails 1

13

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Tuesday January 25 2011 436 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus lucapivatocom

Ronald Lewis Lenore RubinoSubject UK Article

I thought the attached article might be of interest since it makes clear that the same problems facing Georgetown and Burleith have surfaced throughout England httphmolobbyorguk39articlespdf Richard ______________________________ Richard deC Hinds Cleary Gottlieb Steen amp Hamilton LLP 2000 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington DC 20006 t +1 202 974 1540 | f +1 202 974 1999

wwwclearygottliebcom | rhindscgshcom This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

14

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday November 02 2010 418 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Ronald LewisSubject Original GU presentations

Sorry for the delay in sending the links I forgot to look at my notes These are the links to the full original presentations from GU httpsgusharegeorgetowneduOfficeOfCommunicationscampus_plan20090529_May30CampusPlanOptions_AMpdf httpsgusharegeorgetowneduOfficeOfCommunicationscampus_plan20090529_May30CampusPlanOptions_PMpdf Regards Gianluca Pivato

15

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Thursday August 26 2010 1001 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Ron LewisSubject Re RE

Oh OK So GUs practice of averaging is still acceptable Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 407 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

Your welcome One change I meant to say that the student counting may NOT be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

Steve

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202‐442‐8810

FAX 202‐442‐7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

16

From Jennifer Altemus [mailtocag-presidentcagtownorg] Sent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer

On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

17

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

18

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

19

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

20

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday May 18 2010 1129 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP)Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meetingAttachments Georgetowner Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on the Georgetowner I meant to attach it to the previous email The editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning for longer than 10 years and being geographically limited by the west and south boundaries Unfortunately unless the trend is reversed and GU complies with the DC Comprehensive Plan the long term result of turning Georgetown and Burleith into college towns is a very real possibility GU under De Gioia is planning to expand enormously in the next decades and this is only the first step I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the adjacent neighborhoods They just need a little push Best regards Luca Pivato On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your time today Please find attached selected data slides from this morning presentation I will be glad to answer any question you may have about the numbers our sources and references or our calculation methods The easiest way to contact me is on my cell at 301-221-8983 or via email at cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg Best regards Luca Pivato

21

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Monday May 17 2010 501 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich

Hinds Lenore Rubino DCtuxedoaolcomSubject Fw 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

This is the incident that was mentioned today involving (1) a graduate student living in Burleith who has repeatedly engaged in loud late night partying (2) whom GU was unaware was living in Burleith Stephen Brown is a resident of Burleith who has created his own website to protest GU student misconduct in his neighborhood It has generated much attention httpwwwdrunkengeorgetownstudentscom Richard ----- Forwarded by Richard deC HINDSDCCgsh on 05172010 0445 PM ----- Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt

17 May 2010 0954 AM

To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Ed Soloman ltdctuxedoaolcomgt Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgt Altemus Jennifer ltcag-presidentcagtownorggt Gianluca Pivato ltlucapivatocomgt

cc

Subject Fwd FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

It is confirmed This is a good example of where GU does not know where all its students live For those jumping in on the email stream Lt Hedgecock MPD reported there was a noise disturbance and Anne Koester (GU) relayed it wasnt a GU student house ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Mon May 17 2010 at 834 AM Subject FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT To Bonnie Hardy lthardybonniehotmailcomgt Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt Dear BonnieLenore This is a medical student whorsquos family was visiting and decided that an open fire and a musical tribute were appropriate I felt otherwise and we ended up having quite a fracas in the alley The police were called twice SNAP came byetcand the letter that follows is to Dean Jeanne Lord We have at least two to three 911rsquos per year from that house Regards

22

Stephen Stephen R Brown Photography 3715 T Street NW Washington DC 20007 202‐667‐1965 202‐255‐8635(cell) httpwwwsrbphotocom httpwwwdcphotobookcom httpwwwjewelofthemallcom mailtosrbsrbphotocom

‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded Message From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Sun 16 May 2010 132049 ‐0400 To Jeanne Lord ltlordjgeorgetownedugt Conversation 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Subject 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Jeanne I can assure you I am quite as tired of this as you and am going out today to buy a quality pair of headphones I wil be doing a composite sketch of all the pictures I have taken and thatrsquos all that will be on the website other than general information to the neighbors It is getting 19000 hits per day and as you may or may not have noticed I have taken out advertising I will be happy to ressurect the site in a more popular format if things continue as they are as I fully expect them to Obviously I donrsquot think you have a handle on your current student population so I will be working in other ways to block GUrsquos growth Last night3713 broke into Florida version of Swiss Family Robinson and three neighbors called the police As they went into the house they began yelling out my name At 217 they began a phone marathon to my studio and fortunately not to my house I have the voice recordings and they are not particularly ldquomedicalrdquo I have to question this womanrsquos competency to get a license as her drunken tirades and now phone marathons are stunningly nasty Herersquos a photo of my phone with the ldquoblocked callsrdquo from her family member who was visiting and her number which she wasnrsquot clever enough to block If yoursquod like to hear what Georgetownrsquos finest has to say on the phone Irsquoll be happy to put it up on the web Otherwise I expect some disciplinary actionsome examination of this womenrsquos competence to get a medical license and a letter of apology to my family ‐‐‐‐‐‐ End of Forwarded Message -- Lenore G Rubino Realtor Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage wwwlenorerubinocom

23

202-262-1261 (best way to reach me) 202-471-5262 (e-fax) Washington Harbour - Georgetown 3000 K Street NW Suite 101 Washington DC 20007

This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

24

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Thursday January 14 2010 301 PMTo Jennings Jeffrey (DDOT) Ziemann Christopher (DDOT)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) billstarrelsgmailcom dctuxedoaolcom

billskelseyancaolcom cag-presidentcagtownorg lenorerubiongmailcomSubject Friday meeting re transportation aspects of GUs 10-year planAttachments Impacts of GU transportation issues and draft 10-year plandoc

Dear Jeff and Chris In case this might be helpful for our meeting Friday morning an outline is attached of what we see as some key transportation issues in the Georgetown University draft 10-year campus plan Our group will include - From ANC 2E - Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Ed Solomon (possibly) and Bill Skelsey (possibly) From the Citizens Association of Georgetown Jennifer Altemus president From the Burleith Citizens Association Lenore Rubino president We look forward to seeing you on Friday (tomorrow) at DDOT at 930 am Best regards Ron

25

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Tuesday January 12 2010 947 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc billstarrelsgmailcom billskelseyancaolcom dctuxedoaolcom cag-

presidentcagtownorg lucapivatocom rhindscgshcom lenorerubinogmailcom

Subject Meeting re Georgetown University 10-year plan with community representatives Jan 13

Attachments Outline of some key impacts on the community of the GU draft 10-year plan-1doc

Dear Jennifer Joel and Steve An outline is attached in case it might be helpful of some key issues in the Georgetown University draft 10‐year plan that wed like to discuss with you at tomorrows meeting Out group tomorrow will include ‐ ANC 2E (Georgetown and Burleith) Commissioners Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Bill Skelsey and Ed Solomon Citizens Association of Georgetown President Jennifer Altemus Vice President Luca Pivato and advisor Richard Hinds Burleith Citizens Association President Lenore Rubino and advisor Mark Gisler We look forward very much to seeing you and continuing the productive dialogue Best regards Ron Ron Lewis Chair ANC 2E

26

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Friday January 08 2010 1057 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer AltemusSubject RE Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image001gif image002gif CAG letter to GU re campus planpdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan Best Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia

27

Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar

28

See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

29

B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

30

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Thursday December 31 2009 406 PMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP)Subject Re Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image002gif image001gif

Jennifer Thanks for providing this information Happy New Year Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Sent Thu Dec 31 144709 2009 Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

31

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 14: Emails 1

14

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday November 02 2010 418 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Ronald LewisSubject Original GU presentations

Sorry for the delay in sending the links I forgot to look at my notes These are the links to the full original presentations from GU httpsgusharegeorgetowneduOfficeOfCommunicationscampus_plan20090529_May30CampusPlanOptions_AMpdf httpsgusharegeorgetowneduOfficeOfCommunicationscampus_plan20090529_May30CampusPlanOptions_PMpdf Regards Gianluca Pivato

15

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Thursday August 26 2010 1001 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Ron LewisSubject Re RE

Oh OK So GUs practice of averaging is still acceptable Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 407 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

Your welcome One change I meant to say that the student counting may NOT be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

Steve

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202‐442‐8810

FAX 202‐442‐7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

16

From Jennifer Altemus [mailtocag-presidentcagtownorg] Sent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer

On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

17

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

18

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

19

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

20

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday May 18 2010 1129 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP)Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meetingAttachments Georgetowner Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on the Georgetowner I meant to attach it to the previous email The editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning for longer than 10 years and being geographically limited by the west and south boundaries Unfortunately unless the trend is reversed and GU complies with the DC Comprehensive Plan the long term result of turning Georgetown and Burleith into college towns is a very real possibility GU under De Gioia is planning to expand enormously in the next decades and this is only the first step I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the adjacent neighborhoods They just need a little push Best regards Luca Pivato On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your time today Please find attached selected data slides from this morning presentation I will be glad to answer any question you may have about the numbers our sources and references or our calculation methods The easiest way to contact me is on my cell at 301-221-8983 or via email at cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg Best regards Luca Pivato

21

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Monday May 17 2010 501 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich

Hinds Lenore Rubino DCtuxedoaolcomSubject Fw 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

This is the incident that was mentioned today involving (1) a graduate student living in Burleith who has repeatedly engaged in loud late night partying (2) whom GU was unaware was living in Burleith Stephen Brown is a resident of Burleith who has created his own website to protest GU student misconduct in his neighborhood It has generated much attention httpwwwdrunkengeorgetownstudentscom Richard ----- Forwarded by Richard deC HINDSDCCgsh on 05172010 0445 PM ----- Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt

17 May 2010 0954 AM

To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Ed Soloman ltdctuxedoaolcomgt Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgt Altemus Jennifer ltcag-presidentcagtownorggt Gianluca Pivato ltlucapivatocomgt

cc

Subject Fwd FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

It is confirmed This is a good example of where GU does not know where all its students live For those jumping in on the email stream Lt Hedgecock MPD reported there was a noise disturbance and Anne Koester (GU) relayed it wasnt a GU student house ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Mon May 17 2010 at 834 AM Subject FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT To Bonnie Hardy lthardybonniehotmailcomgt Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt Dear BonnieLenore This is a medical student whorsquos family was visiting and decided that an open fire and a musical tribute were appropriate I felt otherwise and we ended up having quite a fracas in the alley The police were called twice SNAP came byetcand the letter that follows is to Dean Jeanne Lord We have at least two to three 911rsquos per year from that house Regards

22

Stephen Stephen R Brown Photography 3715 T Street NW Washington DC 20007 202‐667‐1965 202‐255‐8635(cell) httpwwwsrbphotocom httpwwwdcphotobookcom httpwwwjewelofthemallcom mailtosrbsrbphotocom

‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded Message From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Sun 16 May 2010 132049 ‐0400 To Jeanne Lord ltlordjgeorgetownedugt Conversation 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Subject 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Jeanne I can assure you I am quite as tired of this as you and am going out today to buy a quality pair of headphones I wil be doing a composite sketch of all the pictures I have taken and thatrsquos all that will be on the website other than general information to the neighbors It is getting 19000 hits per day and as you may or may not have noticed I have taken out advertising I will be happy to ressurect the site in a more popular format if things continue as they are as I fully expect them to Obviously I donrsquot think you have a handle on your current student population so I will be working in other ways to block GUrsquos growth Last night3713 broke into Florida version of Swiss Family Robinson and three neighbors called the police As they went into the house they began yelling out my name At 217 they began a phone marathon to my studio and fortunately not to my house I have the voice recordings and they are not particularly ldquomedicalrdquo I have to question this womanrsquos competency to get a license as her drunken tirades and now phone marathons are stunningly nasty Herersquos a photo of my phone with the ldquoblocked callsrdquo from her family member who was visiting and her number which she wasnrsquot clever enough to block If yoursquod like to hear what Georgetownrsquos finest has to say on the phone Irsquoll be happy to put it up on the web Otherwise I expect some disciplinary actionsome examination of this womenrsquos competence to get a medical license and a letter of apology to my family ‐‐‐‐‐‐ End of Forwarded Message -- Lenore G Rubino Realtor Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage wwwlenorerubinocom

23

202-262-1261 (best way to reach me) 202-471-5262 (e-fax) Washington Harbour - Georgetown 3000 K Street NW Suite 101 Washington DC 20007

This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

24

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Thursday January 14 2010 301 PMTo Jennings Jeffrey (DDOT) Ziemann Christopher (DDOT)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) billstarrelsgmailcom dctuxedoaolcom

billskelseyancaolcom cag-presidentcagtownorg lenorerubiongmailcomSubject Friday meeting re transportation aspects of GUs 10-year planAttachments Impacts of GU transportation issues and draft 10-year plandoc

Dear Jeff and Chris In case this might be helpful for our meeting Friday morning an outline is attached of what we see as some key transportation issues in the Georgetown University draft 10-year campus plan Our group will include - From ANC 2E - Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Ed Solomon (possibly) and Bill Skelsey (possibly) From the Citizens Association of Georgetown Jennifer Altemus president From the Burleith Citizens Association Lenore Rubino president We look forward to seeing you on Friday (tomorrow) at DDOT at 930 am Best regards Ron

25

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Tuesday January 12 2010 947 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc billstarrelsgmailcom billskelseyancaolcom dctuxedoaolcom cag-

presidentcagtownorg lucapivatocom rhindscgshcom lenorerubinogmailcom

Subject Meeting re Georgetown University 10-year plan with community representatives Jan 13

Attachments Outline of some key impacts on the community of the GU draft 10-year plan-1doc

Dear Jennifer Joel and Steve An outline is attached in case it might be helpful of some key issues in the Georgetown University draft 10‐year plan that wed like to discuss with you at tomorrows meeting Out group tomorrow will include ‐ ANC 2E (Georgetown and Burleith) Commissioners Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Bill Skelsey and Ed Solomon Citizens Association of Georgetown President Jennifer Altemus Vice President Luca Pivato and advisor Richard Hinds Burleith Citizens Association President Lenore Rubino and advisor Mark Gisler We look forward very much to seeing you and continuing the productive dialogue Best regards Ron Ron Lewis Chair ANC 2E

26

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Friday January 08 2010 1057 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer AltemusSubject RE Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image001gif image002gif CAG letter to GU re campus planpdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan Best Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia

27

Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar

28

See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

29

B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

30

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Thursday December 31 2009 406 PMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP)Subject Re Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image002gif image001gif

Jennifer Thanks for providing this information Happy New Year Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Sent Thu Dec 31 144709 2009 Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

31

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 15: Emails 1

15

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Thursday August 26 2010 1001 AMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Ron LewisSubject Re RE

Oh OK So GUs practice of averaging is still acceptable Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 407 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

Your welcome One change I meant to say that the student counting may NOT be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

Steve

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202‐442‐8810

FAX 202‐442‐7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

16

From Jennifer Altemus [mailtocag-presidentcagtownorg] Sent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer

On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

17

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

18

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

19

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

20

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday May 18 2010 1129 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP)Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meetingAttachments Georgetowner Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on the Georgetowner I meant to attach it to the previous email The editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning for longer than 10 years and being geographically limited by the west and south boundaries Unfortunately unless the trend is reversed and GU complies with the DC Comprehensive Plan the long term result of turning Georgetown and Burleith into college towns is a very real possibility GU under De Gioia is planning to expand enormously in the next decades and this is only the first step I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the adjacent neighborhoods They just need a little push Best regards Luca Pivato On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your time today Please find attached selected data slides from this morning presentation I will be glad to answer any question you may have about the numbers our sources and references or our calculation methods The easiest way to contact me is on my cell at 301-221-8983 or via email at cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg Best regards Luca Pivato

21

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Monday May 17 2010 501 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich

Hinds Lenore Rubino DCtuxedoaolcomSubject Fw 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

This is the incident that was mentioned today involving (1) a graduate student living in Burleith who has repeatedly engaged in loud late night partying (2) whom GU was unaware was living in Burleith Stephen Brown is a resident of Burleith who has created his own website to protest GU student misconduct in his neighborhood It has generated much attention httpwwwdrunkengeorgetownstudentscom Richard ----- Forwarded by Richard deC HINDSDCCgsh on 05172010 0445 PM ----- Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt

17 May 2010 0954 AM

To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Ed Soloman ltdctuxedoaolcomgt Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgt Altemus Jennifer ltcag-presidentcagtownorggt Gianluca Pivato ltlucapivatocomgt

cc

Subject Fwd FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

It is confirmed This is a good example of where GU does not know where all its students live For those jumping in on the email stream Lt Hedgecock MPD reported there was a noise disturbance and Anne Koester (GU) relayed it wasnt a GU student house ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Mon May 17 2010 at 834 AM Subject FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT To Bonnie Hardy lthardybonniehotmailcomgt Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt Dear BonnieLenore This is a medical student whorsquos family was visiting and decided that an open fire and a musical tribute were appropriate I felt otherwise and we ended up having quite a fracas in the alley The police were called twice SNAP came byetcand the letter that follows is to Dean Jeanne Lord We have at least two to three 911rsquos per year from that house Regards

22

Stephen Stephen R Brown Photography 3715 T Street NW Washington DC 20007 202‐667‐1965 202‐255‐8635(cell) httpwwwsrbphotocom httpwwwdcphotobookcom httpwwwjewelofthemallcom mailtosrbsrbphotocom

‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded Message From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Sun 16 May 2010 132049 ‐0400 To Jeanne Lord ltlordjgeorgetownedugt Conversation 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Subject 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Jeanne I can assure you I am quite as tired of this as you and am going out today to buy a quality pair of headphones I wil be doing a composite sketch of all the pictures I have taken and thatrsquos all that will be on the website other than general information to the neighbors It is getting 19000 hits per day and as you may or may not have noticed I have taken out advertising I will be happy to ressurect the site in a more popular format if things continue as they are as I fully expect them to Obviously I donrsquot think you have a handle on your current student population so I will be working in other ways to block GUrsquos growth Last night3713 broke into Florida version of Swiss Family Robinson and three neighbors called the police As they went into the house they began yelling out my name At 217 they began a phone marathon to my studio and fortunately not to my house I have the voice recordings and they are not particularly ldquomedicalrdquo I have to question this womanrsquos competency to get a license as her drunken tirades and now phone marathons are stunningly nasty Herersquos a photo of my phone with the ldquoblocked callsrdquo from her family member who was visiting and her number which she wasnrsquot clever enough to block If yoursquod like to hear what Georgetownrsquos finest has to say on the phone Irsquoll be happy to put it up on the web Otherwise I expect some disciplinary actionsome examination of this womenrsquos competence to get a medical license and a letter of apology to my family ‐‐‐‐‐‐ End of Forwarded Message -- Lenore G Rubino Realtor Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage wwwlenorerubinocom

23

202-262-1261 (best way to reach me) 202-471-5262 (e-fax) Washington Harbour - Georgetown 3000 K Street NW Suite 101 Washington DC 20007

This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

24

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Thursday January 14 2010 301 PMTo Jennings Jeffrey (DDOT) Ziemann Christopher (DDOT)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) billstarrelsgmailcom dctuxedoaolcom

billskelseyancaolcom cag-presidentcagtownorg lenorerubiongmailcomSubject Friday meeting re transportation aspects of GUs 10-year planAttachments Impacts of GU transportation issues and draft 10-year plandoc

Dear Jeff and Chris In case this might be helpful for our meeting Friday morning an outline is attached of what we see as some key transportation issues in the Georgetown University draft 10-year campus plan Our group will include - From ANC 2E - Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Ed Solomon (possibly) and Bill Skelsey (possibly) From the Citizens Association of Georgetown Jennifer Altemus president From the Burleith Citizens Association Lenore Rubino president We look forward to seeing you on Friday (tomorrow) at DDOT at 930 am Best regards Ron

25

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Tuesday January 12 2010 947 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc billstarrelsgmailcom billskelseyancaolcom dctuxedoaolcom cag-

presidentcagtownorg lucapivatocom rhindscgshcom lenorerubinogmailcom

Subject Meeting re Georgetown University 10-year plan with community representatives Jan 13

Attachments Outline of some key impacts on the community of the GU draft 10-year plan-1doc

Dear Jennifer Joel and Steve An outline is attached in case it might be helpful of some key issues in the Georgetown University draft 10‐year plan that wed like to discuss with you at tomorrows meeting Out group tomorrow will include ‐ ANC 2E (Georgetown and Burleith) Commissioners Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Bill Skelsey and Ed Solomon Citizens Association of Georgetown President Jennifer Altemus Vice President Luca Pivato and advisor Richard Hinds Burleith Citizens Association President Lenore Rubino and advisor Mark Gisler We look forward very much to seeing you and continuing the productive dialogue Best regards Ron Ron Lewis Chair ANC 2E

26

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Friday January 08 2010 1057 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer AltemusSubject RE Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image001gif image002gif CAG letter to GU re campus planpdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan Best Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia

27

Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar

28

See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

29

B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

30

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Thursday December 31 2009 406 PMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP)Subject Re Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image002gif image001gif

Jennifer Thanks for providing this information Happy New Year Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Sent Thu Dec 31 144709 2009 Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

31

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 16: Emails 1

16

From Jennifer Altemus [mailtocag-presidentcagtownorg] Sent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer

On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

17

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

18

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

19

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

20

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday May 18 2010 1129 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP)Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meetingAttachments Georgetowner Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on the Georgetowner I meant to attach it to the previous email The editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning for longer than 10 years and being geographically limited by the west and south boundaries Unfortunately unless the trend is reversed and GU complies with the DC Comprehensive Plan the long term result of turning Georgetown and Burleith into college towns is a very real possibility GU under De Gioia is planning to expand enormously in the next decades and this is only the first step I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the adjacent neighborhoods They just need a little push Best regards Luca Pivato On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your time today Please find attached selected data slides from this morning presentation I will be glad to answer any question you may have about the numbers our sources and references or our calculation methods The easiest way to contact me is on my cell at 301-221-8983 or via email at cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg Best regards Luca Pivato

21

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Monday May 17 2010 501 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich

Hinds Lenore Rubino DCtuxedoaolcomSubject Fw 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

This is the incident that was mentioned today involving (1) a graduate student living in Burleith who has repeatedly engaged in loud late night partying (2) whom GU was unaware was living in Burleith Stephen Brown is a resident of Burleith who has created his own website to protest GU student misconduct in his neighborhood It has generated much attention httpwwwdrunkengeorgetownstudentscom Richard ----- Forwarded by Richard deC HINDSDCCgsh on 05172010 0445 PM ----- Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt

17 May 2010 0954 AM

To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Ed Soloman ltdctuxedoaolcomgt Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgt Altemus Jennifer ltcag-presidentcagtownorggt Gianluca Pivato ltlucapivatocomgt

cc

Subject Fwd FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

It is confirmed This is a good example of where GU does not know where all its students live For those jumping in on the email stream Lt Hedgecock MPD reported there was a noise disturbance and Anne Koester (GU) relayed it wasnt a GU student house ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Mon May 17 2010 at 834 AM Subject FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT To Bonnie Hardy lthardybonniehotmailcomgt Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt Dear BonnieLenore This is a medical student whorsquos family was visiting and decided that an open fire and a musical tribute were appropriate I felt otherwise and we ended up having quite a fracas in the alley The police were called twice SNAP came byetcand the letter that follows is to Dean Jeanne Lord We have at least two to three 911rsquos per year from that house Regards

22

Stephen Stephen R Brown Photography 3715 T Street NW Washington DC 20007 202‐667‐1965 202‐255‐8635(cell) httpwwwsrbphotocom httpwwwdcphotobookcom httpwwwjewelofthemallcom mailtosrbsrbphotocom

‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded Message From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Sun 16 May 2010 132049 ‐0400 To Jeanne Lord ltlordjgeorgetownedugt Conversation 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Subject 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Jeanne I can assure you I am quite as tired of this as you and am going out today to buy a quality pair of headphones I wil be doing a composite sketch of all the pictures I have taken and thatrsquos all that will be on the website other than general information to the neighbors It is getting 19000 hits per day and as you may or may not have noticed I have taken out advertising I will be happy to ressurect the site in a more popular format if things continue as they are as I fully expect them to Obviously I donrsquot think you have a handle on your current student population so I will be working in other ways to block GUrsquos growth Last night3713 broke into Florida version of Swiss Family Robinson and three neighbors called the police As they went into the house they began yelling out my name At 217 they began a phone marathon to my studio and fortunately not to my house I have the voice recordings and they are not particularly ldquomedicalrdquo I have to question this womanrsquos competency to get a license as her drunken tirades and now phone marathons are stunningly nasty Herersquos a photo of my phone with the ldquoblocked callsrdquo from her family member who was visiting and her number which she wasnrsquot clever enough to block If yoursquod like to hear what Georgetownrsquos finest has to say on the phone Irsquoll be happy to put it up on the web Otherwise I expect some disciplinary actionsome examination of this womenrsquos competence to get a medical license and a letter of apology to my family ‐‐‐‐‐‐ End of Forwarded Message -- Lenore G Rubino Realtor Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage wwwlenorerubinocom

23

202-262-1261 (best way to reach me) 202-471-5262 (e-fax) Washington Harbour - Georgetown 3000 K Street NW Suite 101 Washington DC 20007

This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

24

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Thursday January 14 2010 301 PMTo Jennings Jeffrey (DDOT) Ziemann Christopher (DDOT)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) billstarrelsgmailcom dctuxedoaolcom

billskelseyancaolcom cag-presidentcagtownorg lenorerubiongmailcomSubject Friday meeting re transportation aspects of GUs 10-year planAttachments Impacts of GU transportation issues and draft 10-year plandoc

Dear Jeff and Chris In case this might be helpful for our meeting Friday morning an outline is attached of what we see as some key transportation issues in the Georgetown University draft 10-year campus plan Our group will include - From ANC 2E - Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Ed Solomon (possibly) and Bill Skelsey (possibly) From the Citizens Association of Georgetown Jennifer Altemus president From the Burleith Citizens Association Lenore Rubino president We look forward to seeing you on Friday (tomorrow) at DDOT at 930 am Best regards Ron

25

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Tuesday January 12 2010 947 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc billstarrelsgmailcom billskelseyancaolcom dctuxedoaolcom cag-

presidentcagtownorg lucapivatocom rhindscgshcom lenorerubinogmailcom

Subject Meeting re Georgetown University 10-year plan with community representatives Jan 13

Attachments Outline of some key impacts on the community of the GU draft 10-year plan-1doc

Dear Jennifer Joel and Steve An outline is attached in case it might be helpful of some key issues in the Georgetown University draft 10‐year plan that wed like to discuss with you at tomorrows meeting Out group tomorrow will include ‐ ANC 2E (Georgetown and Burleith) Commissioners Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Bill Skelsey and Ed Solomon Citizens Association of Georgetown President Jennifer Altemus Vice President Luca Pivato and advisor Richard Hinds Burleith Citizens Association President Lenore Rubino and advisor Mark Gisler We look forward very much to seeing you and continuing the productive dialogue Best regards Ron Ron Lewis Chair ANC 2E

26

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Friday January 08 2010 1057 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer AltemusSubject RE Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image001gif image002gif CAG letter to GU re campus planpdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan Best Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia

27

Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar

28

See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

29

B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

30

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Thursday December 31 2009 406 PMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP)Subject Re Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image002gif image001gif

Jennifer Thanks for providing this information Happy New Year Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Sent Thu Dec 31 144709 2009 Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

31

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 17: Emails 1

17

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

18

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

19

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

20

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday May 18 2010 1129 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP)Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meetingAttachments Georgetowner Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on the Georgetowner I meant to attach it to the previous email The editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning for longer than 10 years and being geographically limited by the west and south boundaries Unfortunately unless the trend is reversed and GU complies with the DC Comprehensive Plan the long term result of turning Georgetown and Burleith into college towns is a very real possibility GU under De Gioia is planning to expand enormously in the next decades and this is only the first step I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the adjacent neighborhoods They just need a little push Best regards Luca Pivato On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your time today Please find attached selected data slides from this morning presentation I will be glad to answer any question you may have about the numbers our sources and references or our calculation methods The easiest way to contact me is on my cell at 301-221-8983 or via email at cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg Best regards Luca Pivato

21

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Monday May 17 2010 501 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich

Hinds Lenore Rubino DCtuxedoaolcomSubject Fw 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

This is the incident that was mentioned today involving (1) a graduate student living in Burleith who has repeatedly engaged in loud late night partying (2) whom GU was unaware was living in Burleith Stephen Brown is a resident of Burleith who has created his own website to protest GU student misconduct in his neighborhood It has generated much attention httpwwwdrunkengeorgetownstudentscom Richard ----- Forwarded by Richard deC HINDSDCCgsh on 05172010 0445 PM ----- Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt

17 May 2010 0954 AM

To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Ed Soloman ltdctuxedoaolcomgt Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgt Altemus Jennifer ltcag-presidentcagtownorggt Gianluca Pivato ltlucapivatocomgt

cc

Subject Fwd FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

It is confirmed This is a good example of where GU does not know where all its students live For those jumping in on the email stream Lt Hedgecock MPD reported there was a noise disturbance and Anne Koester (GU) relayed it wasnt a GU student house ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Mon May 17 2010 at 834 AM Subject FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT To Bonnie Hardy lthardybonniehotmailcomgt Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt Dear BonnieLenore This is a medical student whorsquos family was visiting and decided that an open fire and a musical tribute were appropriate I felt otherwise and we ended up having quite a fracas in the alley The police were called twice SNAP came byetcand the letter that follows is to Dean Jeanne Lord We have at least two to three 911rsquos per year from that house Regards

22

Stephen Stephen R Brown Photography 3715 T Street NW Washington DC 20007 202‐667‐1965 202‐255‐8635(cell) httpwwwsrbphotocom httpwwwdcphotobookcom httpwwwjewelofthemallcom mailtosrbsrbphotocom

‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded Message From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Sun 16 May 2010 132049 ‐0400 To Jeanne Lord ltlordjgeorgetownedugt Conversation 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Subject 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Jeanne I can assure you I am quite as tired of this as you and am going out today to buy a quality pair of headphones I wil be doing a composite sketch of all the pictures I have taken and thatrsquos all that will be on the website other than general information to the neighbors It is getting 19000 hits per day and as you may or may not have noticed I have taken out advertising I will be happy to ressurect the site in a more popular format if things continue as they are as I fully expect them to Obviously I donrsquot think you have a handle on your current student population so I will be working in other ways to block GUrsquos growth Last night3713 broke into Florida version of Swiss Family Robinson and three neighbors called the police As they went into the house they began yelling out my name At 217 they began a phone marathon to my studio and fortunately not to my house I have the voice recordings and they are not particularly ldquomedicalrdquo I have to question this womanrsquos competency to get a license as her drunken tirades and now phone marathons are stunningly nasty Herersquos a photo of my phone with the ldquoblocked callsrdquo from her family member who was visiting and her number which she wasnrsquot clever enough to block If yoursquod like to hear what Georgetownrsquos finest has to say on the phone Irsquoll be happy to put it up on the web Otherwise I expect some disciplinary actionsome examination of this womenrsquos competence to get a medical license and a letter of apology to my family ‐‐‐‐‐‐ End of Forwarded Message -- Lenore G Rubino Realtor Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage wwwlenorerubinocom

23

202-262-1261 (best way to reach me) 202-471-5262 (e-fax) Washington Harbour - Georgetown 3000 K Street NW Suite 101 Washington DC 20007

This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

24

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Thursday January 14 2010 301 PMTo Jennings Jeffrey (DDOT) Ziemann Christopher (DDOT)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) billstarrelsgmailcom dctuxedoaolcom

billskelseyancaolcom cag-presidentcagtownorg lenorerubiongmailcomSubject Friday meeting re transportation aspects of GUs 10-year planAttachments Impacts of GU transportation issues and draft 10-year plandoc

Dear Jeff and Chris In case this might be helpful for our meeting Friday morning an outline is attached of what we see as some key transportation issues in the Georgetown University draft 10-year campus plan Our group will include - From ANC 2E - Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Ed Solomon (possibly) and Bill Skelsey (possibly) From the Citizens Association of Georgetown Jennifer Altemus president From the Burleith Citizens Association Lenore Rubino president We look forward to seeing you on Friday (tomorrow) at DDOT at 930 am Best regards Ron

25

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Tuesday January 12 2010 947 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc billstarrelsgmailcom billskelseyancaolcom dctuxedoaolcom cag-

presidentcagtownorg lucapivatocom rhindscgshcom lenorerubinogmailcom

Subject Meeting re Georgetown University 10-year plan with community representatives Jan 13

Attachments Outline of some key impacts on the community of the GU draft 10-year plan-1doc

Dear Jennifer Joel and Steve An outline is attached in case it might be helpful of some key issues in the Georgetown University draft 10‐year plan that wed like to discuss with you at tomorrows meeting Out group tomorrow will include ‐ ANC 2E (Georgetown and Burleith) Commissioners Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Bill Skelsey and Ed Solomon Citizens Association of Georgetown President Jennifer Altemus Vice President Luca Pivato and advisor Richard Hinds Burleith Citizens Association President Lenore Rubino and advisor Mark Gisler We look forward very much to seeing you and continuing the productive dialogue Best regards Ron Ron Lewis Chair ANC 2E

26

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Friday January 08 2010 1057 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer AltemusSubject RE Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image001gif image002gif CAG letter to GU re campus planpdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan Best Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia

27

Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar

28

See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

29

B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

30

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Thursday December 31 2009 406 PMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP)Subject Re Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image002gif image001gif

Jennifer Thanks for providing this information Happy New Year Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Sent Thu Dec 31 144709 2009 Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

31

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 18: Emails 1

18

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Jennifer Altemus ltcag-presidentcagtownorggtSent Wednesday August 25 2010 406 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Subject Re

Thanks Steve Jennifer On Aug 25 2010 at 351 PM Mordfin Stephen (OP) ltstephenmordfindcgovgt wrote

httpdcozdcgovorders06-11pdf

Jennifer

I know I was supposed to send this to Ron Lewis but I am unable to locate his email address Please forward this

Attached is the order approving the GW Foggy Bottom campus plan See the bottom of page 39 for student counting Please note that this is a baseline for future campus plans and may be used identically for all campus plans coming forward

I did tell you I had an EPA letter regarding the smokestack I am unable to locate it and am beginning to think that I may have misspoken I will let you know

Thanks

Steve

19

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

20

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday May 18 2010 1129 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP)Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meetingAttachments Georgetowner Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on the Georgetowner I meant to attach it to the previous email The editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning for longer than 10 years and being geographically limited by the west and south boundaries Unfortunately unless the trend is reversed and GU complies with the DC Comprehensive Plan the long term result of turning Georgetown and Burleith into college towns is a very real possibility GU under De Gioia is planning to expand enormously in the next decades and this is only the first step I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the adjacent neighborhoods They just need a little push Best regards Luca Pivato On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your time today Please find attached selected data slides from this morning presentation I will be glad to answer any question you may have about the numbers our sources and references or our calculation methods The easiest way to contact me is on my cell at 301-221-8983 or via email at cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg Best regards Luca Pivato

21

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Monday May 17 2010 501 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich

Hinds Lenore Rubino DCtuxedoaolcomSubject Fw 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

This is the incident that was mentioned today involving (1) a graduate student living in Burleith who has repeatedly engaged in loud late night partying (2) whom GU was unaware was living in Burleith Stephen Brown is a resident of Burleith who has created his own website to protest GU student misconduct in his neighborhood It has generated much attention httpwwwdrunkengeorgetownstudentscom Richard ----- Forwarded by Richard deC HINDSDCCgsh on 05172010 0445 PM ----- Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt

17 May 2010 0954 AM

To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Ed Soloman ltdctuxedoaolcomgt Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgt Altemus Jennifer ltcag-presidentcagtownorggt Gianluca Pivato ltlucapivatocomgt

cc

Subject Fwd FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

It is confirmed This is a good example of where GU does not know where all its students live For those jumping in on the email stream Lt Hedgecock MPD reported there was a noise disturbance and Anne Koester (GU) relayed it wasnt a GU student house ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Mon May 17 2010 at 834 AM Subject FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT To Bonnie Hardy lthardybonniehotmailcomgt Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt Dear BonnieLenore This is a medical student whorsquos family was visiting and decided that an open fire and a musical tribute were appropriate I felt otherwise and we ended up having quite a fracas in the alley The police were called twice SNAP came byetcand the letter that follows is to Dean Jeanne Lord We have at least two to three 911rsquos per year from that house Regards

22

Stephen Stephen R Brown Photography 3715 T Street NW Washington DC 20007 202‐667‐1965 202‐255‐8635(cell) httpwwwsrbphotocom httpwwwdcphotobookcom httpwwwjewelofthemallcom mailtosrbsrbphotocom

‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded Message From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Sun 16 May 2010 132049 ‐0400 To Jeanne Lord ltlordjgeorgetownedugt Conversation 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Subject 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Jeanne I can assure you I am quite as tired of this as you and am going out today to buy a quality pair of headphones I wil be doing a composite sketch of all the pictures I have taken and thatrsquos all that will be on the website other than general information to the neighbors It is getting 19000 hits per day and as you may or may not have noticed I have taken out advertising I will be happy to ressurect the site in a more popular format if things continue as they are as I fully expect them to Obviously I donrsquot think you have a handle on your current student population so I will be working in other ways to block GUrsquos growth Last night3713 broke into Florida version of Swiss Family Robinson and three neighbors called the police As they went into the house they began yelling out my name At 217 they began a phone marathon to my studio and fortunately not to my house I have the voice recordings and they are not particularly ldquomedicalrdquo I have to question this womanrsquos competency to get a license as her drunken tirades and now phone marathons are stunningly nasty Herersquos a photo of my phone with the ldquoblocked callsrdquo from her family member who was visiting and her number which she wasnrsquot clever enough to block If yoursquod like to hear what Georgetownrsquos finest has to say on the phone Irsquoll be happy to put it up on the web Otherwise I expect some disciplinary actionsome examination of this womenrsquos competence to get a medical license and a letter of apology to my family ‐‐‐‐‐‐ End of Forwarded Message -- Lenore G Rubino Realtor Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage wwwlenorerubinocom

23

202-262-1261 (best way to reach me) 202-471-5262 (e-fax) Washington Harbour - Georgetown 3000 K Street NW Suite 101 Washington DC 20007

This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

24

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Thursday January 14 2010 301 PMTo Jennings Jeffrey (DDOT) Ziemann Christopher (DDOT)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) billstarrelsgmailcom dctuxedoaolcom

billskelseyancaolcom cag-presidentcagtownorg lenorerubiongmailcomSubject Friday meeting re transportation aspects of GUs 10-year planAttachments Impacts of GU transportation issues and draft 10-year plandoc

Dear Jeff and Chris In case this might be helpful for our meeting Friday morning an outline is attached of what we see as some key transportation issues in the Georgetown University draft 10-year campus plan Our group will include - From ANC 2E - Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Ed Solomon (possibly) and Bill Skelsey (possibly) From the Citizens Association of Georgetown Jennifer Altemus president From the Burleith Citizens Association Lenore Rubino president We look forward to seeing you on Friday (tomorrow) at DDOT at 930 am Best regards Ron

25

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Tuesday January 12 2010 947 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc billstarrelsgmailcom billskelseyancaolcom dctuxedoaolcom cag-

presidentcagtownorg lucapivatocom rhindscgshcom lenorerubinogmailcom

Subject Meeting re Georgetown University 10-year plan with community representatives Jan 13

Attachments Outline of some key impacts on the community of the GU draft 10-year plan-1doc

Dear Jennifer Joel and Steve An outline is attached in case it might be helpful of some key issues in the Georgetown University draft 10‐year plan that wed like to discuss with you at tomorrows meeting Out group tomorrow will include ‐ ANC 2E (Georgetown and Burleith) Commissioners Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Bill Skelsey and Ed Solomon Citizens Association of Georgetown President Jennifer Altemus Vice President Luca Pivato and advisor Richard Hinds Burleith Citizens Association President Lenore Rubino and advisor Mark Gisler We look forward very much to seeing you and continuing the productive dialogue Best regards Ron Ron Lewis Chair ANC 2E

26

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Friday January 08 2010 1057 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer AltemusSubject RE Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image001gif image002gif CAG letter to GU re campus planpdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan Best Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia

27

Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar

28

See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

29

B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

30

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Thursday December 31 2009 406 PMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP)Subject Re Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image002gif image001gif

Jennifer Thanks for providing this information Happy New Year Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Sent Thu Dec 31 144709 2009 Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

31

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 19: Emails 1

19

Stephen J Mordfin AICPltimage001pnggt

Development Review Specialist

DC Office of Planning

1100 4th Street SW Suite E650

Washington DC 20024

Office 202-442-8810

FAX 202-442-7638

stephenmordfindcgov

httpplanningdcgov

20

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday May 18 2010 1129 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP)Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meetingAttachments Georgetowner Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on the Georgetowner I meant to attach it to the previous email The editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning for longer than 10 years and being geographically limited by the west and south boundaries Unfortunately unless the trend is reversed and GU complies with the DC Comprehensive Plan the long term result of turning Georgetown and Burleith into college towns is a very real possibility GU under De Gioia is planning to expand enormously in the next decades and this is only the first step I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the adjacent neighborhoods They just need a little push Best regards Luca Pivato On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your time today Please find attached selected data slides from this morning presentation I will be glad to answer any question you may have about the numbers our sources and references or our calculation methods The easiest way to contact me is on my cell at 301-221-8983 or via email at cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg Best regards Luca Pivato

21

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Monday May 17 2010 501 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich

Hinds Lenore Rubino DCtuxedoaolcomSubject Fw 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

This is the incident that was mentioned today involving (1) a graduate student living in Burleith who has repeatedly engaged in loud late night partying (2) whom GU was unaware was living in Burleith Stephen Brown is a resident of Burleith who has created his own website to protest GU student misconduct in his neighborhood It has generated much attention httpwwwdrunkengeorgetownstudentscom Richard ----- Forwarded by Richard deC HINDSDCCgsh on 05172010 0445 PM ----- Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt

17 May 2010 0954 AM

To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Ed Soloman ltdctuxedoaolcomgt Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgt Altemus Jennifer ltcag-presidentcagtownorggt Gianluca Pivato ltlucapivatocomgt

cc

Subject Fwd FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

It is confirmed This is a good example of where GU does not know where all its students live For those jumping in on the email stream Lt Hedgecock MPD reported there was a noise disturbance and Anne Koester (GU) relayed it wasnt a GU student house ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Mon May 17 2010 at 834 AM Subject FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT To Bonnie Hardy lthardybonniehotmailcomgt Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt Dear BonnieLenore This is a medical student whorsquos family was visiting and decided that an open fire and a musical tribute were appropriate I felt otherwise and we ended up having quite a fracas in the alley The police were called twice SNAP came byetcand the letter that follows is to Dean Jeanne Lord We have at least two to three 911rsquos per year from that house Regards

22

Stephen Stephen R Brown Photography 3715 T Street NW Washington DC 20007 202‐667‐1965 202‐255‐8635(cell) httpwwwsrbphotocom httpwwwdcphotobookcom httpwwwjewelofthemallcom mailtosrbsrbphotocom

‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded Message From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Sun 16 May 2010 132049 ‐0400 To Jeanne Lord ltlordjgeorgetownedugt Conversation 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Subject 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Jeanne I can assure you I am quite as tired of this as you and am going out today to buy a quality pair of headphones I wil be doing a composite sketch of all the pictures I have taken and thatrsquos all that will be on the website other than general information to the neighbors It is getting 19000 hits per day and as you may or may not have noticed I have taken out advertising I will be happy to ressurect the site in a more popular format if things continue as they are as I fully expect them to Obviously I donrsquot think you have a handle on your current student population so I will be working in other ways to block GUrsquos growth Last night3713 broke into Florida version of Swiss Family Robinson and three neighbors called the police As they went into the house they began yelling out my name At 217 they began a phone marathon to my studio and fortunately not to my house I have the voice recordings and they are not particularly ldquomedicalrdquo I have to question this womanrsquos competency to get a license as her drunken tirades and now phone marathons are stunningly nasty Herersquos a photo of my phone with the ldquoblocked callsrdquo from her family member who was visiting and her number which she wasnrsquot clever enough to block If yoursquod like to hear what Georgetownrsquos finest has to say on the phone Irsquoll be happy to put it up on the web Otherwise I expect some disciplinary actionsome examination of this womenrsquos competence to get a medical license and a letter of apology to my family ‐‐‐‐‐‐ End of Forwarded Message -- Lenore G Rubino Realtor Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage wwwlenorerubinocom

23

202-262-1261 (best way to reach me) 202-471-5262 (e-fax) Washington Harbour - Georgetown 3000 K Street NW Suite 101 Washington DC 20007

This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

24

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Thursday January 14 2010 301 PMTo Jennings Jeffrey (DDOT) Ziemann Christopher (DDOT)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) billstarrelsgmailcom dctuxedoaolcom

billskelseyancaolcom cag-presidentcagtownorg lenorerubiongmailcomSubject Friday meeting re transportation aspects of GUs 10-year planAttachments Impacts of GU transportation issues and draft 10-year plandoc

Dear Jeff and Chris In case this might be helpful for our meeting Friday morning an outline is attached of what we see as some key transportation issues in the Georgetown University draft 10-year campus plan Our group will include - From ANC 2E - Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Ed Solomon (possibly) and Bill Skelsey (possibly) From the Citizens Association of Georgetown Jennifer Altemus president From the Burleith Citizens Association Lenore Rubino president We look forward to seeing you on Friday (tomorrow) at DDOT at 930 am Best regards Ron

25

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Tuesday January 12 2010 947 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc billstarrelsgmailcom billskelseyancaolcom dctuxedoaolcom cag-

presidentcagtownorg lucapivatocom rhindscgshcom lenorerubinogmailcom

Subject Meeting re Georgetown University 10-year plan with community representatives Jan 13

Attachments Outline of some key impacts on the community of the GU draft 10-year plan-1doc

Dear Jennifer Joel and Steve An outline is attached in case it might be helpful of some key issues in the Georgetown University draft 10‐year plan that wed like to discuss with you at tomorrows meeting Out group tomorrow will include ‐ ANC 2E (Georgetown and Burleith) Commissioners Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Bill Skelsey and Ed Solomon Citizens Association of Georgetown President Jennifer Altemus Vice President Luca Pivato and advisor Richard Hinds Burleith Citizens Association President Lenore Rubino and advisor Mark Gisler We look forward very much to seeing you and continuing the productive dialogue Best regards Ron Ron Lewis Chair ANC 2E

26

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Friday January 08 2010 1057 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer AltemusSubject RE Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image001gif image002gif CAG letter to GU re campus planpdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan Best Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia

27

Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar

28

See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

29

B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

30

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Thursday December 31 2009 406 PMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP)Subject Re Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image002gif image001gif

Jennifer Thanks for providing this information Happy New Year Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Sent Thu Dec 31 144709 2009 Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

31

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 20: Emails 1

20

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato ltcag-vicepresidentcagtownorggtSent Tuesday May 18 2010 1129 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP)Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meetingAttachments Georgetowner Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on the Georgetowner I meant to attach it to the previous email The editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning for longer than 10 years and being geographically limited by the west and south boundaries Unfortunately unless the trend is reversed and GU complies with the DC Comprehensive Plan the long term result of turning Georgetown and Burleith into college towns is a very real possibility GU under De Gioia is planning to expand enormously in the next decades and this is only the first step I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the adjacent neighborhoods They just need a little push Best regards Luca Pivato On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your time today Please find attached selected data slides from this morning presentation I will be glad to answer any question you may have about the numbers our sources and references or our calculation methods The easiest way to contact me is on my cell at 301-221-8983 or via email at cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg Best regards Luca Pivato

21

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Monday May 17 2010 501 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich

Hinds Lenore Rubino DCtuxedoaolcomSubject Fw 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

This is the incident that was mentioned today involving (1) a graduate student living in Burleith who has repeatedly engaged in loud late night partying (2) whom GU was unaware was living in Burleith Stephen Brown is a resident of Burleith who has created his own website to protest GU student misconduct in his neighborhood It has generated much attention httpwwwdrunkengeorgetownstudentscom Richard ----- Forwarded by Richard deC HINDSDCCgsh on 05172010 0445 PM ----- Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt

17 May 2010 0954 AM

To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Ed Soloman ltdctuxedoaolcomgt Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgt Altemus Jennifer ltcag-presidentcagtownorggt Gianluca Pivato ltlucapivatocomgt

cc

Subject Fwd FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

It is confirmed This is a good example of where GU does not know where all its students live For those jumping in on the email stream Lt Hedgecock MPD reported there was a noise disturbance and Anne Koester (GU) relayed it wasnt a GU student house ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Mon May 17 2010 at 834 AM Subject FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT To Bonnie Hardy lthardybonniehotmailcomgt Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt Dear BonnieLenore This is a medical student whorsquos family was visiting and decided that an open fire and a musical tribute were appropriate I felt otherwise and we ended up having quite a fracas in the alley The police were called twice SNAP came byetcand the letter that follows is to Dean Jeanne Lord We have at least two to three 911rsquos per year from that house Regards

22

Stephen Stephen R Brown Photography 3715 T Street NW Washington DC 20007 202‐667‐1965 202‐255‐8635(cell) httpwwwsrbphotocom httpwwwdcphotobookcom httpwwwjewelofthemallcom mailtosrbsrbphotocom

‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded Message From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Sun 16 May 2010 132049 ‐0400 To Jeanne Lord ltlordjgeorgetownedugt Conversation 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Subject 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Jeanne I can assure you I am quite as tired of this as you and am going out today to buy a quality pair of headphones I wil be doing a composite sketch of all the pictures I have taken and thatrsquos all that will be on the website other than general information to the neighbors It is getting 19000 hits per day and as you may or may not have noticed I have taken out advertising I will be happy to ressurect the site in a more popular format if things continue as they are as I fully expect them to Obviously I donrsquot think you have a handle on your current student population so I will be working in other ways to block GUrsquos growth Last night3713 broke into Florida version of Swiss Family Robinson and three neighbors called the police As they went into the house they began yelling out my name At 217 they began a phone marathon to my studio and fortunately not to my house I have the voice recordings and they are not particularly ldquomedicalrdquo I have to question this womanrsquos competency to get a license as her drunken tirades and now phone marathons are stunningly nasty Herersquos a photo of my phone with the ldquoblocked callsrdquo from her family member who was visiting and her number which she wasnrsquot clever enough to block If yoursquod like to hear what Georgetownrsquos finest has to say on the phone Irsquoll be happy to put it up on the web Otherwise I expect some disciplinary actionsome examination of this womenrsquos competence to get a medical license and a letter of apology to my family ‐‐‐‐‐‐ End of Forwarded Message -- Lenore G Rubino Realtor Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage wwwlenorerubinocom

23

202-262-1261 (best way to reach me) 202-471-5262 (e-fax) Washington Harbour - Georgetown 3000 K Street NW Suite 101 Washington DC 20007

This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

24

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Thursday January 14 2010 301 PMTo Jennings Jeffrey (DDOT) Ziemann Christopher (DDOT)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) billstarrelsgmailcom dctuxedoaolcom

billskelseyancaolcom cag-presidentcagtownorg lenorerubiongmailcomSubject Friday meeting re transportation aspects of GUs 10-year planAttachments Impacts of GU transportation issues and draft 10-year plandoc

Dear Jeff and Chris In case this might be helpful for our meeting Friday morning an outline is attached of what we see as some key transportation issues in the Georgetown University draft 10-year campus plan Our group will include - From ANC 2E - Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Ed Solomon (possibly) and Bill Skelsey (possibly) From the Citizens Association of Georgetown Jennifer Altemus president From the Burleith Citizens Association Lenore Rubino president We look forward to seeing you on Friday (tomorrow) at DDOT at 930 am Best regards Ron

25

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Tuesday January 12 2010 947 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc billstarrelsgmailcom billskelseyancaolcom dctuxedoaolcom cag-

presidentcagtownorg lucapivatocom rhindscgshcom lenorerubinogmailcom

Subject Meeting re Georgetown University 10-year plan with community representatives Jan 13

Attachments Outline of some key impacts on the community of the GU draft 10-year plan-1doc

Dear Jennifer Joel and Steve An outline is attached in case it might be helpful of some key issues in the Georgetown University draft 10‐year plan that wed like to discuss with you at tomorrows meeting Out group tomorrow will include ‐ ANC 2E (Georgetown and Burleith) Commissioners Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Bill Skelsey and Ed Solomon Citizens Association of Georgetown President Jennifer Altemus Vice President Luca Pivato and advisor Richard Hinds Burleith Citizens Association President Lenore Rubino and advisor Mark Gisler We look forward very much to seeing you and continuing the productive dialogue Best regards Ron Ron Lewis Chair ANC 2E

26

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Friday January 08 2010 1057 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer AltemusSubject RE Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image001gif image002gif CAG letter to GU re campus planpdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan Best Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia

27

Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar

28

See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

29

B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

30

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Thursday December 31 2009 406 PMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP)Subject Re Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image002gif image001gif

Jennifer Thanks for providing this information Happy New Year Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Sent Thu Dec 31 144709 2009 Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

31

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 21: Emails 1

21

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgtSent Monday May 17 2010 501 PMTo Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich

Hinds Lenore Rubino DCtuxedoaolcomSubject Fw 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

This is the incident that was mentioned today involving (1) a graduate student living in Burleith who has repeatedly engaged in loud late night partying (2) whom GU was unaware was living in Burleith Stephen Brown is a resident of Burleith who has created his own website to protest GU student misconduct in his neighborhood It has generated much attention httpwwwdrunkengeorgetownstudentscom Richard ----- Forwarded by Richard deC HINDSDCCgsh on 05172010 0445 PM ----- Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt

17 May 2010 0954 AM

To Ronald Lewis ltronaldblewisgmailcomgt Ed Soloman ltdctuxedoaolcomgt Richard deC HINDS ltrhindscgshcomgt Altemus Jennifer ltcag-presidentcagtownorggt Gianluca Pivato ltlucapivatocomgt

cc

Subject Fwd FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT

It is confirmed This is a good example of where GU does not know where all its students live For those jumping in on the email stream Lt Hedgecock MPD reported there was a noise disturbance and Anne Koester (GU) relayed it wasnt a GU student house ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Mon May 17 2010 at 834 AM Subject FW 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT To Bonnie Hardy lthardybonniehotmailcomgt Lenore Rubino ltlenorerubinogmailcomgt Dear BonnieLenore This is a medical student whorsquos family was visiting and decided that an open fire and a musical tribute were appropriate I felt otherwise and we ended up having quite a fracas in the alley The police were called twice SNAP came byetcand the letter that follows is to Dean Jeanne Lord We have at least two to three 911rsquos per year from that house Regards

22

Stephen Stephen R Brown Photography 3715 T Street NW Washington DC 20007 202‐667‐1965 202‐255‐8635(cell) httpwwwsrbphotocom httpwwwdcphotobookcom httpwwwjewelofthemallcom mailtosrbsrbphotocom

‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded Message From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Sun 16 May 2010 132049 ‐0400 To Jeanne Lord ltlordjgeorgetownedugt Conversation 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Subject 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Jeanne I can assure you I am quite as tired of this as you and am going out today to buy a quality pair of headphones I wil be doing a composite sketch of all the pictures I have taken and thatrsquos all that will be on the website other than general information to the neighbors It is getting 19000 hits per day and as you may or may not have noticed I have taken out advertising I will be happy to ressurect the site in a more popular format if things continue as they are as I fully expect them to Obviously I donrsquot think you have a handle on your current student population so I will be working in other ways to block GUrsquos growth Last night3713 broke into Florida version of Swiss Family Robinson and three neighbors called the police As they went into the house they began yelling out my name At 217 they began a phone marathon to my studio and fortunately not to my house I have the voice recordings and they are not particularly ldquomedicalrdquo I have to question this womanrsquos competency to get a license as her drunken tirades and now phone marathons are stunningly nasty Herersquos a photo of my phone with the ldquoblocked callsrdquo from her family member who was visiting and her number which she wasnrsquot clever enough to block If yoursquod like to hear what Georgetownrsquos finest has to say on the phone Irsquoll be happy to put it up on the web Otherwise I expect some disciplinary actionsome examination of this womenrsquos competence to get a medical license and a letter of apology to my family ‐‐‐‐‐‐ End of Forwarded Message -- Lenore G Rubino Realtor Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage wwwlenorerubinocom

23

202-262-1261 (best way to reach me) 202-471-5262 (e-fax) Washington Harbour - Georgetown 3000 K Street NW Suite 101 Washington DC 20007

This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

24

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Thursday January 14 2010 301 PMTo Jennings Jeffrey (DDOT) Ziemann Christopher (DDOT)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) billstarrelsgmailcom dctuxedoaolcom

billskelseyancaolcom cag-presidentcagtownorg lenorerubiongmailcomSubject Friday meeting re transportation aspects of GUs 10-year planAttachments Impacts of GU transportation issues and draft 10-year plandoc

Dear Jeff and Chris In case this might be helpful for our meeting Friday morning an outline is attached of what we see as some key transportation issues in the Georgetown University draft 10-year campus plan Our group will include - From ANC 2E - Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Ed Solomon (possibly) and Bill Skelsey (possibly) From the Citizens Association of Georgetown Jennifer Altemus president From the Burleith Citizens Association Lenore Rubino president We look forward to seeing you on Friday (tomorrow) at DDOT at 930 am Best regards Ron

25

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Tuesday January 12 2010 947 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc billstarrelsgmailcom billskelseyancaolcom dctuxedoaolcom cag-

presidentcagtownorg lucapivatocom rhindscgshcom lenorerubinogmailcom

Subject Meeting re Georgetown University 10-year plan with community representatives Jan 13

Attachments Outline of some key impacts on the community of the GU draft 10-year plan-1doc

Dear Jennifer Joel and Steve An outline is attached in case it might be helpful of some key issues in the Georgetown University draft 10‐year plan that wed like to discuss with you at tomorrows meeting Out group tomorrow will include ‐ ANC 2E (Georgetown and Burleith) Commissioners Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Bill Skelsey and Ed Solomon Citizens Association of Georgetown President Jennifer Altemus Vice President Luca Pivato and advisor Richard Hinds Burleith Citizens Association President Lenore Rubino and advisor Mark Gisler We look forward very much to seeing you and continuing the productive dialogue Best regards Ron Ron Lewis Chair ANC 2E

26

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Friday January 08 2010 1057 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer AltemusSubject RE Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image001gif image002gif CAG letter to GU re campus planpdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan Best Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia

27

Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar

28

See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

29

B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

30

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Thursday December 31 2009 406 PMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP)Subject Re Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image002gif image001gif

Jennifer Thanks for providing this information Happy New Year Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Sent Thu Dec 31 144709 2009 Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

31

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 22: Emails 1

22

Stephen Stephen R Brown Photography 3715 T Street NW Washington DC 20007 202‐667‐1965 202‐255‐8635(cell) httpwwwsrbphotocom httpwwwdcphotobookcom httpwwwjewelofthemallcom mailtosrbsrbphotocom

‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded Message From Stephen Brown ltsrbsrbphotocomgt Date Sun 16 May 2010 132049 ‐0400 To Jeanne Lord ltlordjgeorgetownedugt Conversation 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Subject 3713 T STREET NW MEDICAL STUDENT Jeanne I can assure you I am quite as tired of this as you and am going out today to buy a quality pair of headphones I wil be doing a composite sketch of all the pictures I have taken and thatrsquos all that will be on the website other than general information to the neighbors It is getting 19000 hits per day and as you may or may not have noticed I have taken out advertising I will be happy to ressurect the site in a more popular format if things continue as they are as I fully expect them to Obviously I donrsquot think you have a handle on your current student population so I will be working in other ways to block GUrsquos growth Last night3713 broke into Florida version of Swiss Family Robinson and three neighbors called the police As they went into the house they began yelling out my name At 217 they began a phone marathon to my studio and fortunately not to my house I have the voice recordings and they are not particularly ldquomedicalrdquo I have to question this womanrsquos competency to get a license as her drunken tirades and now phone marathons are stunningly nasty Herersquos a photo of my phone with the ldquoblocked callsrdquo from her family member who was visiting and her number which she wasnrsquot clever enough to block If yoursquod like to hear what Georgetownrsquos finest has to say on the phone Irsquoll be happy to put it up on the web Otherwise I expect some disciplinary actionsome examination of this womenrsquos competence to get a medical license and a letter of apology to my family ‐‐‐‐‐‐ End of Forwarded Message -- Lenore G Rubino Realtor Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage wwwlenorerubinocom

23

202-262-1261 (best way to reach me) 202-471-5262 (e-fax) Washington Harbour - Georgetown 3000 K Street NW Suite 101 Washington DC 20007

This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

24

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Thursday January 14 2010 301 PMTo Jennings Jeffrey (DDOT) Ziemann Christopher (DDOT)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) billstarrelsgmailcom dctuxedoaolcom

billskelseyancaolcom cag-presidentcagtownorg lenorerubiongmailcomSubject Friday meeting re transportation aspects of GUs 10-year planAttachments Impacts of GU transportation issues and draft 10-year plandoc

Dear Jeff and Chris In case this might be helpful for our meeting Friday morning an outline is attached of what we see as some key transportation issues in the Georgetown University draft 10-year campus plan Our group will include - From ANC 2E - Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Ed Solomon (possibly) and Bill Skelsey (possibly) From the Citizens Association of Georgetown Jennifer Altemus president From the Burleith Citizens Association Lenore Rubino president We look forward to seeing you on Friday (tomorrow) at DDOT at 930 am Best regards Ron

25

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Tuesday January 12 2010 947 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc billstarrelsgmailcom billskelseyancaolcom dctuxedoaolcom cag-

presidentcagtownorg lucapivatocom rhindscgshcom lenorerubinogmailcom

Subject Meeting re Georgetown University 10-year plan with community representatives Jan 13

Attachments Outline of some key impacts on the community of the GU draft 10-year plan-1doc

Dear Jennifer Joel and Steve An outline is attached in case it might be helpful of some key issues in the Georgetown University draft 10‐year plan that wed like to discuss with you at tomorrows meeting Out group tomorrow will include ‐ ANC 2E (Georgetown and Burleith) Commissioners Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Bill Skelsey and Ed Solomon Citizens Association of Georgetown President Jennifer Altemus Vice President Luca Pivato and advisor Richard Hinds Burleith Citizens Association President Lenore Rubino and advisor Mark Gisler We look forward very much to seeing you and continuing the productive dialogue Best regards Ron Ron Lewis Chair ANC 2E

26

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Friday January 08 2010 1057 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer AltemusSubject RE Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image001gif image002gif CAG letter to GU re campus planpdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan Best Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia

27

Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar

28

See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

29

B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

30

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Thursday December 31 2009 406 PMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP)Subject Re Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image002gif image001gif

Jennifer Thanks for providing this information Happy New Year Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Sent Thu Dec 31 144709 2009 Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

31

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 23: Emails 1

23

202-262-1261 (best way to reach me) 202-471-5262 (e-fax) Washington Harbour - Georgetown 3000 K Street NW Suite 101 Washington DC 20007

This message is being sent from a law firm and may contain confidential or privileged information If you are not the intended recipient please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy

24

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Thursday January 14 2010 301 PMTo Jennings Jeffrey (DDOT) Ziemann Christopher (DDOT)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) billstarrelsgmailcom dctuxedoaolcom

billskelseyancaolcom cag-presidentcagtownorg lenorerubiongmailcomSubject Friday meeting re transportation aspects of GUs 10-year planAttachments Impacts of GU transportation issues and draft 10-year plandoc

Dear Jeff and Chris In case this might be helpful for our meeting Friday morning an outline is attached of what we see as some key transportation issues in the Georgetown University draft 10-year campus plan Our group will include - From ANC 2E - Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Ed Solomon (possibly) and Bill Skelsey (possibly) From the Citizens Association of Georgetown Jennifer Altemus president From the Burleith Citizens Association Lenore Rubino president We look forward to seeing you on Friday (tomorrow) at DDOT at 930 am Best regards Ron

25

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Tuesday January 12 2010 947 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc billstarrelsgmailcom billskelseyancaolcom dctuxedoaolcom cag-

presidentcagtownorg lucapivatocom rhindscgshcom lenorerubinogmailcom

Subject Meeting re Georgetown University 10-year plan with community representatives Jan 13

Attachments Outline of some key impacts on the community of the GU draft 10-year plan-1doc

Dear Jennifer Joel and Steve An outline is attached in case it might be helpful of some key issues in the Georgetown University draft 10‐year plan that wed like to discuss with you at tomorrows meeting Out group tomorrow will include ‐ ANC 2E (Georgetown and Burleith) Commissioners Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Bill Skelsey and Ed Solomon Citizens Association of Georgetown President Jennifer Altemus Vice President Luca Pivato and advisor Richard Hinds Burleith Citizens Association President Lenore Rubino and advisor Mark Gisler We look forward very much to seeing you and continuing the productive dialogue Best regards Ron Ron Lewis Chair ANC 2E

26

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Friday January 08 2010 1057 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer AltemusSubject RE Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image001gif image002gif CAG letter to GU re campus planpdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan Best Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia

27

Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar

28

See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

29

B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

30

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Thursday December 31 2009 406 PMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP)Subject Re Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image002gif image001gif

Jennifer Thanks for providing this information Happy New Year Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Sent Thu Dec 31 144709 2009 Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

31

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 24: Emails 1

24

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Thursday January 14 2010 301 PMTo Jennings Jeffrey (DDOT) Ziemann Christopher (DDOT)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) billstarrelsgmailcom dctuxedoaolcom

billskelseyancaolcom cag-presidentcagtownorg lenorerubiongmailcomSubject Friday meeting re transportation aspects of GUs 10-year planAttachments Impacts of GU transportation issues and draft 10-year plandoc

Dear Jeff and Chris In case this might be helpful for our meeting Friday morning an outline is attached of what we see as some key transportation issues in the Georgetown University draft 10-year campus plan Our group will include - From ANC 2E - Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Ed Solomon (possibly) and Bill Skelsey (possibly) From the Citizens Association of Georgetown Jennifer Altemus president From the Burleith Citizens Association Lenore Rubino president We look forward to seeing you on Friday (tomorrow) at DDOT at 930 am Best regards Ron

25

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Tuesday January 12 2010 947 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc billstarrelsgmailcom billskelseyancaolcom dctuxedoaolcom cag-

presidentcagtownorg lucapivatocom rhindscgshcom lenorerubinogmailcom

Subject Meeting re Georgetown University 10-year plan with community representatives Jan 13

Attachments Outline of some key impacts on the community of the GU draft 10-year plan-1doc

Dear Jennifer Joel and Steve An outline is attached in case it might be helpful of some key issues in the Georgetown University draft 10‐year plan that wed like to discuss with you at tomorrows meeting Out group tomorrow will include ‐ ANC 2E (Georgetown and Burleith) Commissioners Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Bill Skelsey and Ed Solomon Citizens Association of Georgetown President Jennifer Altemus Vice President Luca Pivato and advisor Richard Hinds Burleith Citizens Association President Lenore Rubino and advisor Mark Gisler We look forward very much to seeing you and continuing the productive dialogue Best regards Ron Ron Lewis Chair ANC 2E

26

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Friday January 08 2010 1057 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer AltemusSubject RE Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image001gif image002gif CAG letter to GU re campus planpdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan Best Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia

27

Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar

28

See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

29

B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

30

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Thursday December 31 2009 406 PMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP)Subject Re Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image002gif image001gif

Jennifer Thanks for providing this information Happy New Year Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Sent Thu Dec 31 144709 2009 Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

31

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 25: Emails 1

25

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Lewis Ron (ANC 2E02)Sent Tuesday January 12 2010 947 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Mordfin Stephen (OP)Cc billstarrelsgmailcom billskelseyancaolcom dctuxedoaolcom cag-

presidentcagtownorg lucapivatocom rhindscgshcom lenorerubinogmailcom

Subject Meeting re Georgetown University 10-year plan with community representatives Jan 13

Attachments Outline of some key impacts on the community of the GU draft 10-year plan-1doc

Dear Jennifer Joel and Steve An outline is attached in case it might be helpful of some key issues in the Georgetown University draft 10‐year plan that wed like to discuss with you at tomorrows meeting Out group tomorrow will include ‐ ANC 2E (Georgetown and Burleith) Commissioners Ron Lewis Bill Starrels Bill Skelsey and Ed Solomon Citizens Association of Georgetown President Jennifer Altemus Vice President Luca Pivato and advisor Richard Hinds Burleith Citizens Association President Lenore Rubino and advisor Mark Gisler We look forward very much to seeing you and continuing the productive dialogue Best regards Ron Ron Lewis Chair ANC 2E

26

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Friday January 08 2010 1057 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer AltemusSubject RE Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image001gif image002gif CAG letter to GU re campus planpdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan Best Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia

27

Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar

28

See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

29

B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

30

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Thursday December 31 2009 406 PMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP)Subject Re Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image002gif image001gif

Jennifer Thanks for providing this information Happy New Year Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Sent Thu Dec 31 144709 2009 Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

31

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 26: Emails 1

26

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Friday January 08 2010 1057 AMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer AltemusSubject RE Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image001gif image002gif CAG letter to GU re campus planpdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan Best Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia

27

Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar

28

See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

29

B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

30

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Thursday December 31 2009 406 PMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP)Subject Re Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image002gif image001gif

Jennifer Thanks for providing this information Happy New Year Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Sent Thu Dec 31 144709 2009 Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

31

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 27: Emails 1

27

Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar

28

See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

29

B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

30

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Thursday December 31 2009 406 PMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP)Subject Re Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image002gif image001gif

Jennifer Thanks for providing this information Happy New Year Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Sent Thu Dec 31 144709 2009 Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

31

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 28: Emails 1

28

See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

29

B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

30

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Thursday December 31 2009 406 PMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP)Subject Re Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image002gif image001gif

Jennifer Thanks for providing this information Happy New Year Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Sent Thu Dec 31 144709 2009 Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

31

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 29: Emails 1

29

B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

30

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Thursday December 31 2009 406 PMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP)Subject Re Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image002gif image001gif

Jennifer Thanks for providing this information Happy New Year Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Sent Thu Dec 31 144709 2009 Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

31

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 30: Emails 1

30

Johnson Mike (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia ltcynthiapantazisbinghamcomgtSent Thursday December 31 2009 406 PMTo Steingasser Jennifer (OP)Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP)Subject Re Georgetown community - zoningAttachments image002gif image001gif

Jennifer Thanks for providing this information Happy New Year Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Sent Thu Dec 31 144709 2009 Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise Happy New Year Jennifer Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009 921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

31

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 31: Emails 1

31

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December 08 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team Best Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday Jennifer Steingasser AICP

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 32: Emails 1

32

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 914 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best Cynthia Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom B I N G H A M Bingham McCutchen LLP

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 33: Emails 1

33

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (o) 202-442-8808 (f) 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

wwwcensusdcgov

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning How about 300 on Dec 7 Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 34: Emails 1

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Pantazis Cynthia [cynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday January 0820101057 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning Attachments CAG letter to GU re campus plan pdf

Jennifer I have a attached is a courtesy copy of the letter that the Citizens Association of Georgetown sent to John DeGioa summarizing the communitys leading concerns about the draft campus plan

Best

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 31 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia Attached is our preliminary list of preliminary issues regarding the Gtwn Campus Plan We have only had one meeting of substance with the university about the 2010 plan so the issues are identified as preliminary at this time The list should not be considered comprehensive or complete - it is only our quick take on what was presented As we continue to meet with the university and the community I expect issues to be resolved and others to arise

Happy New Year Jennifer

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Friday December 11 2009 1004 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer Sounds good Thank you for the update

Cynthia

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Friday December 11 2009921 AM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis COP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 35: Emails 1

Cynthia We are still compiling our list of issues but should have something to share by Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanningdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Tuesday December OB 2009 602 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Jennifer Altemus Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I want to thank you and your team for taking the time to meet with us yesterday The discussion was informative and helpful providing us with a better understanding of the process and opportunities to constructively participate

As a follow-up it would be helpful to receive what Georgetown submitted for your meeting and the questions raised We hope to stay as informed as possible

Thank you again We look forward to working with you and the team

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

B IN GH AM Bingham McCutchen LLP 2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 550 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Cynthia- it is still on the calendar See you Monday

Jennifer Steingasser AICP

2

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 36: Emails 1

II Transportation Parking and tbe Hospital

A Transportation Parking

The Campus should contain a transportation management plan that includes rerouting GUTS busses and those seeking to use any in parking spaces through the Canal entrance Plan should include a loop road within campus boundaries to transport people the spaces accessed through the Canal Road entrance to the campus and hospital The Plan should not include additional parking spaces accessed

Road The Prospect Street should closed as committed to do Plan but failed to implement

B Hospital

CAG is in favor of a new enlarged hospital on the Georgetown University Campus However the proposed plan for rebuilding and enlarging the existing hospital on the current hospital site is unacceptable The proposed structure would too large the site objectionable bulk and density conditions Piecemeal construction of a new hospital on current without closing hospital would involve a decade of construction traffic on Reservoir Road that would impose an unreasonable and objectionable burden on surrounding neighborhood When finally completed the in traffic to the hospital would overwhelm the capabilities Road and surrounding streets The increase in and for I-gt~fgt by employees patients would create objectionable conditions for local residents We agree with MedStar representatives that piecemeal construction on current is not desirable Relocating the hospital to another site on University campus accessed from Canal Road would avoid objectionable impacts and create a space the construction

new student housing

would like to these with you in detail We look forward to working with you to address our concerns and identify solutions will positively impact relations between community and the University and the overall quality of life for all residents West Georgetown Burleith and neighboring communities

Sincerely ~

~m President

4

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 37: Emails 1

students or none ofwhom are provided housing Finally it is proposing to its nontraditional undergraduate enrollment (which is not subject to the cap on undergraduate enrollment) from 885 to 1055 an of 170 students

While majority ofresident complaints about noise and student misconduct have involved undergraduates graduate student campus group houses create of the same as undergraduate houses At present University provides little if any graduate and professional student housing no housing for Studies In its Campus Plan

npTV is only to build townhouses in the 1789 block of Street that could house about 120 graduate students and faculty No main campus graduate housing is proposed

insufficient supply of on-campus housing for graduate students combined with the proposed increases in graduate enrollment are likely to an already intolerable situation A

percentage new and professional students will West which could cause a predominantly owner tVU1lllPti

neighborhood to change to a predominantly rental student group house neighborhood which has very negative implications for livability property values West Georgetown In addition the student demand for housing is likely to lead to more houses and an increase in tenants per house in response all of which would have a negative impact on this area

The proposed huge increase in graduate and Continuing Studies enrollment combined with the proposed increase in non-traditional undergraduates many ofwhom are commuters would also

intolerable on an overloaded system and more on than the 500 Georgetown is proposing to add for University use Furthermore the

total increase proposed for parking-lOOOspaces with 500 for Medstar-represents an almost 25 increase in parking spaces a large parking availability will simply exacerbate the already Reservoir Road objectionable and parking availability conditions for adjoining communities

C Continuing Studies EnroUment-The proposed huge increase in enrollment on campus would overwhelm the existing transportation infrastructure

There is already excessive no parking available in West Georgetown to accommodate current Continuing Education students many of whom are

UniversityS satellite campus in Clarendon VA The proposed 1825 in Continuing Studies enrollment (a increase) on campus would overwhelm the transportation

in West Any expansion Studies enrollment should in a satellite campus outside 20007 but in the District of Columbia Section 12145 Districts Comprehensive Plan future development directs

District the University and residents to [p ]romote development of satellite campuses to accommodate university growth [and] growth on neighborhoods adjacent to 1gt campuses Universitys to potentially move the Clarendon to the main goes in the opposite direction from that recommended in the Comprehensive Plan and simply ignores the impact of the traffic and parking problems that the University has created for the surrounding with its current enrollment

3

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 38: Emails 1

Summary of Issues

I Enrollment and Housing

A Undergraduate Enrollment and Housing - The University needs to mitigate the adverse impacts it has caused on adjoining neighborhoods by increasing enrollment without providing any new housing on campus

The continuing viability of West Georgetown as a residential neighborhood is threatened by the large number of students currently living in that neighborhood in group houses several of which are owned by the University In the Fall of 2008 Georgetown provided only 5053 undergraduate beds for its 6247 traditional undergraduates who required housing However III of those undergraduate beds are located in University owned townhouses in West Georgetown so only 4942 or 79 of its Fall 2008 undergraduates could be housed in dormitories on campus As a reswt 1305 undergraduates were forced to find housing off campus-primarily in rental group houses in West Georgetown and Burleith

In the Spring of2008 nine hundred traditional undergraduates were living in zip code 20007 in privately owned homes with 498 residing in West Georgetown To that number must be added the 111 students living in University owned townhouses for a total of609 students in West Georgetown In addition there is a substantial number of graduate students living in West Georgetown The UniversityS graduate enrollment is about 4770 and the University currently provides no housing for them As a reswt a significant number of students are living in the small residential communities of single family homes adjoining the University primarily West Georgetown and Burleith FUrthermore a large number of the Universitys on campus undergraduate beds are located in University owned dormitories in Nevi1s and LXR Halls the so-caUed East Campus expansion of the University Those dormitories are immediately adjacent to residential housing in West Georgetown Students returning to those Halls late at night have been a source of numerous complaints by residents over the last twenty years

During the early meetings held by the University on its proposed Campus Plan Cooper Robertson the Universitys architectural conswtant identified locations on campus for buildings housing an additional 800 students The community uniformly demanded at those meetings that Georgetown house most of its undergraduates on campus and move the undergraduates in off campus University owned townhouses on campus However in its current draft Campus Plan the University states that because it is not seeking any increase in the existing cap on undergraduate enrollment it is proposing no new student housing on campus It also proposes to continue using its townhouses in West Georgetown for undergraduate housing and to continue purchasing properties for student housing in West Georgetown

B Graduate and Professional EnrolJment - The proposed increases in enrollment would have a serious adverse impact on the surrounding community

In its draft Campus Plan the University is also proposing to increase graduate and professional student enrollment from 4770 to 6150 students an increase of 1380 or 29 It is also proposing to increase Continuing Studies enrollment from 775 to 2600 an increase of 1825

2

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 39: Emails 1

January 7 2010

Mr Jolm J DeGioia President Georgetom University 204 Healy Hall 37th amp 0 Streets NW Washington DC 20057-1789

Dear Mr DeGioia

On behalfof the Citizens Association of Georgetom (CAG) I am writing to highlight the primary concerns of District residents to the proposed draft Georgetown University latnptlS

OFFICERS We are extremely disappointed with the process thtlS community input at the GU sponsored has

CAG seeks to ensure that Georgetown Universitys Gianlu(J expansion do not adversely impact RJn ~ RSldlenlts

T 501lt11111 impacted by excessive noise traffic Or(U O ~U~IuilUUU

conditions Rbrr uY The issues disctJSSed below

onjlOllllJ( and seriotlS concerns This list is no means COlmClretlenlSl TIlJllrf

OlRECTORS but these issues represent the priority concerns of the

-mi BJnir Oint CImo be the plan review approval proces~s

Rnec EbnJitv Cruri Oni R Cunnil1~ham

Kren Cruse disproportionately bigh number of students located a HI DenIM residential community of single-family bomes

Barbra Of SnnJa Mrmall Bbra J ZOrlmon Intolerable nOBe caused by students off campus at aU bours of tbe

nigbtLEGAL AD1S0R Rihanl J C HinJ Objedionable bebavior of unsupervised students Jiving off campus in

EXEClJTIVE DlRECTOR University and privately owned student group bouses (vandalism tbreats sanitation trasb~ mamtenance safety issues)

Increased traffic congestion and lack of parking

Land use wbicb tbreatens tbe bistoric fabric of tbe community

In addition we have requested but have yet to il1llo11mlticin about variOtlS aspects of the plan For example we have not specifics about the power plant and the implications smokestackSuire 200

Wahingron DC 2t1()7

liJlmm h Z02m1088

(a~milcalll(ln1j(

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 40: Emails 1

2020 K Street NW Washington DC 20006-1806

From Steingasser Jennifer (OP) [mailtojennifersteingasserdcgov] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 247 PM To Pantazis Cynthia Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

That works well I have put it on our calendars

Jenn ifer Steingasser AICP Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Wash ington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808

wwwcensusdcgoy

DC Counts - Watch your mail for your 2010 US Census

(0202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanning dcgov

-I

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Wednesday October 21 2009 153 PM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

How about 300 on Dec 7

Thanks

Confidentiality Notice The information in this e-mail (including attachments if any) is considered confidential and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above Any review use disclosure distribution or copying of this e-mail is prohibited except by or on behalf of the intended recipient If you have received this email in error please notify me immediately by reply email delete this email and do not disclose its contents to anyone

Bingham McCutchen LLP Circular 230 Notice To ensure compliance with IRS requirements we inform you that any US federal tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties Any legal advice expressed in this message is being delivered to you solely for your use in connection with the matters addressed herein and may not be relied upon by any other person or entity or used for any other purpose without our prior written consent

4

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 41: Emails 1

Deputy Director Development Review and Historic Preservation DC Office of Planning 2000 14th Street NW 4th Floor Washington DC 20009 (0) 202-442-8808 (D 202-442-7637 JennniferSteingasserdcgov httpplanninqdcqov

Make a difference in your community Watch your US mail for your 2010 Census Form wwwcensusdcgov

From Pantazis Cynthia [mailtocynthiapantazisbinghamcom] Sent Thursday December 03 2009 9 14 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Parker Travis (OP) Subject RE Georgetown community - zoning

Jennifer I wanted to touch base to reconfirm our meeting on December 7 at 300 and to let you know that we will have 6 participants In addition to me (I chair the Georgetown University Relations Committee for the Citizens Association of Georgetown (CAG)) the following people all of whom serve on the committee will attend

Jennifer Altemus President of CAG Seth Kirshenberg former CAG Board member Luca Pivato CAG Board member Jeff Jones CAG Georgetown University Relations Committee Barbara Zartman Chair of CAG Zoning Committee

If you need any additional information please let me know

We appreciate everyone taking the time for this meeting

Best

Cynthia

Cynthia Pantazis Bingham Consulting Group LLC T 2023736105 F 2023736405 cynthiapantazisbinghamcom

BINGHAM Bingham McCutchen LLP

3

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 42: Emails 1

Stein

From Sent To Cc

Gianluca Pivato ca~I-VIICetre~laEntouclt~at()wn Tuesday November 02 Mordfin Stephen (OP)

ngclssEar Jennifer (OP) Ronald Lewis Original GU presentations

delay in sending I forgot to look at notes

to the

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 43: Emails 1

Steingasser Jennifer (OP)

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent Monday May 17 2010418 PM To Mordfin Stephen (OP) Cc Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Ronald Lewis Rich Hinds Subject ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 meeting Attachments CAG OP May 17 (DRAFTpdf

Thank you for your time today find attached ~~v v data slides from this morning presentation

I will be to answer any question you may about our sources or our calculation methods way to contact me is on my at 301-221-8983 or via email at

Luca Pivato

1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 44: Emails 1

Stein asser Jennifer

From Gianluca Pivato [cag-vicepresidentcagtownorg] Sent May 18 2010 11 29 AM To Steingasser Jennifer (OP) Cc Mordfin Stephen (OP) Lawson Joel (OP) Bolden Tarek (OP) Subject Re ANCCAGBCA Data Slides from May 17 Attachments otrllAlnr Editorial - May 3pdf

Please find attached an editorial that was published on Georgetowner I meant to attach it to emaiL editorial raises an interesting point about GU planning longer than 10 years and geographically limited by west and south boundaries Unfortunately the trend is reversed and GU complies with DC Comprehensive the term result of Georgetown college towns is a possibility GU Gioia is to enormously in the next -uu_) and this is only the

I truly hope that the city has the strength to stand up to such a powerful organization There are many ways they can achieve the same results with the community support and without destroying the neighborhoods

just need a little push

On 5172010 418 PM Gianluca Pivato wrote Thank you for your today Please find attached selected slides from this morning presentation

I will be glad to answer any question you have the numbers our sources references or our calculation methods The way to contact me is on my cell at 301 1-8983 or via email at cagshy

regards Luca Pivato

1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown

Page 45: Emails 1

On Monday April 26th Georgetown University presented their plan for 2010-2020

Without substantive changes plan is bad for the community and the District of Columbia

GUs 2010-2020 Campus Plan doesnt resolve existing objectionable conditions and will continue to negatively impact the surrounding communities Specifically GU states it plans to add 3205 additional students from 2009 to 2020 reaching a total enrollment of8750 approximately 1130 graduate students rent in ZIP 20007 and using GUs

we can project that at least 465 more students will seek housing in the nearby communities This enrollment increase is likely to result in an increase of rental group homes and further compromise the housing stock and of Georgetown Burleith We also have concerns about the Universitys enrollment projections since GU has greatly exceeded the enrollment numbers that it presented to the community and to the Office of Planning back in 2000 when it predicted a graduate total of 3873 in 20 I 0 vs 6275 actual today Nothing in the addresses of wrong set forth by GU in the 2000-20 I 0 Campus Plan submissions

Community improvements and neighborhood conservation are nowhere to be seen in the plan Instead GU is to build 80 and townhomes on 1789 block This block was in 1973 Finally most by community have been

or by palliative solutions

DC City Council adopted a new Plan in December 2006 it became in March 2007 to the Comprehensive Plan the growth of universities in a manner that 1) supports community improvement and neighborhood conservation 2) discourages university actions that would adversely affect the character or quality life in surrounding residential areas 3) campus plans to by the surrounding communities 4) nro

housing stock in adjacent communities 5) promotes to relieve growth pressure on neighborhoods

Georgetown University has an integral of for many years Its an important reputable academic institution They plan longer than 10 years The question for to consider is how we as and voters GU the Council and Mayor envision future of our neighborhoods

cannot grow to the west or south and they are left with two options Comply with the Comprehensives Plan and help improve our neighborhoods or keep increasing growth on adjacent communities which ultimately tum Burleith and Georgetown into college towns

GU should reduce the number students in the residential areas (starting with GU-owned homes outside of campus) re-adopt their goal housing 100 undergraduates on campus not houses on the 1789 block and limit new construction to administrative offices commit not to from their the traffic and parking impact on the neighborhood and link all enrollment increases to University owned housing availability on campus

Visit ---==~=-igt to learn how you can help ensure responsible growth for our neighborhood

-- GU Relations Committee Citizens Association of Georgetown