Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH [email protected] Bernd Steffen,...

39
Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 [email protected] Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd Steffen, DESY for the EO@FLASH team (Daresbury, DESY, Dundee, FELIX)

Transcript of Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH [email protected] Bernd Steffen,...

Page 1: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements

at FLASH

Bernd Steffen, DESYfor the EO@FLASH team

(Daresbury, DESY, Dundee, FELIX)

Page 2: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

Overview

• Motivation• Basics

– Electro-optic effect – EO measurement principle– Detection schemes

• Measurement schemes and results– Electro-optic sampling using a variable delay– Spectrally resolved detection– Temporally resolved detection

• Applications• Conclusion

Page 3: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

FLASHFree-Electron Laser in Hamburg

Longitudinal Diagnostics

Electron bunches: ≈ 30 fs duration≈ 700 MeV electron energy≈ 0.5 nC charge≈ 1 kA peak current

ACC1 ACC5ACC4ACC3

BC BC

ACC2

Bypass

Undulator

Dump

RF gun

EOSTDS CollimatorTEO

OTR screenfor TDSCTR beamline

BAM(LOLA)

5 - 200 µJ 13 - 47 nm

450 - 700 MeV

All pulse length:σ of a fitted Gaussian

Page 4: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

Bunch compression

magnetic chicane

high energy

low energy

accelerating resonator

char

ge-

dens

ityen

ergy

long. bunchkoordinate

Page 5: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

Courtesy of Martin Dohlus

Injector first BC second BC

Bunch compression

0

20

40

4 2 0 2 4122

123

124

125

126

ζ [mm]

curre

nt [A

]en

ergy

[MeV

]

0

200

400

2 1 0 1122

123

124

125

126

ζ [mm]

0

500

1000

1500

500 0 500376

377

378

379

380

ζ [μm]

Page 6: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

Bunch length measurements using the transverse deflecting structure (TDS)

Resolution: approx. 20 fsat a time window of 2 ps

ee

fast horizontal kicker

vertical streakand horizontal kick

3.66 m

vertical RF field Ey(t)

σz

~σz

t [ps]x

[mm

]0 0.5 1 1.5 2

-4

-2

0

2

0 0.5 1 1.5 20

0.5

1

0

50

100

150

200

t [ps]

ρ/ρ m

ax

σspike 30 fsQspike 0.12 nC (23 %)

∼∼∼∼

head tail

image

charge density

Page 7: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

Overview

• Motivation• Basics

– Electro-optic effect – EO measurement principle– Detection schemes

• Measurement schemes and results– Electro-optic sampling using a variable delay– Spectrally resolved detection– Temporally resolved detection

• Applications• Conclusion

Page 8: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

The Electro-Optic Effect:THz-field induced Birefringence

EO crystal

Elaser

Y=[0,0,1]

X=[-1,1,0]

(1,1,0)-plane

ETHz

n2

n1

Phase retardation(in the small signal limit):

Page 9: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

Electro-Optic Sampling

- Coulomb field of electron bunch induces birefringence in EO-crystal.

- birefringence is sampled by Ti:Sa laser pulse.

EOP

scanning delayfs laser

Pphoto

detector

λ/4 λ/2

Page 10: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

Effect of the wave plates

Page 11: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

Effect of half wave plate

θ=0° θ=2°

-0.2 -0.1 0.1 0.2Γ in rad

0.005

0.01

0.015

0.02

0.025

0.03Idet,v/Ilaser

0

signalθ=2°

signal θ=0bgθ=2°

θ=0 4θ=π/2

-1 1 2 3 4Γ in rad

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1Idet,v/Ilaser

0

Page 12: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

EO coefficient r41(f) and THz phase velocity in GaP

Faust, Henry. PRL 1966Nelson, Turner. J. Appl. P. 1968

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20-10

-5

0

5

10

15

20r 41

[pm

/V]

f [THz]

r41

lattice resonance: 11THz

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 200.0

0.2

0.4

v/c

f [THz]

v /cph

v /copt

0.1

0.3

lattice resonance

Page 13: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

Propagation of the pulses in 100 µm GaP:EO-Sampling

EO-Signal: Product of the effective THz-field and laserintegrated over the thickness of the crystal

0 500 1000 1500time [fs]

0 500 1000 1500time [fs]

THz pulse effective THz and laser pulse

Page 14: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

• Effective THz pulse calculated from electron bunch and EO response function

• Phase retardation Γ from effective THz pulse• Complex electric field of the modulated chirped laser pulse

calculated according to:

• Temporal and spectral intensity in both polarisations can be calculated.

The simulation program

Page 15: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

Response function of the EO crystal

Signal distortion esp. for thick crystals !

EO coeff., transmission, velocity matching

0 5 10 15 200

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.25

frequency [THz]

|G(f)

| [p

V/m

]

d=65 μm175 μm300 μm

Page 16: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

Overview

• Motivation• Basics

– Electro-optic effect – EO measurement principle– Detection schemes

• Measurement schemes and results– Electro-optic sampling using a variable delay– Spectrally resolved detection– Temporally resolved detection

• Applications• Conclusion

Page 17: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

Electro-Optic Samplingusing a variable Delay

- frequently used for THz-spectroscopy- technically simple, high resolution

Problem: - averages over many bunches- sensitive to time jitter

EOS: Electro-Optic Sampling

Page 18: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

Electro-Optic Samplingusing a variable delay

Time jitter: approx. 200 fs,larger than bunch length

Single shot measurements necessary!

0 2 4 6

1

2

3

4

delay [ps]

EO

S s

igna

l

0

Page 19: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

EO Spectral Detection

• Linear relationship between wavelength and long. position in laser pulse (“linear chirp“)

• Bunch profile is transferred to spectral profile of the laser pulse- Problem: Frequency mixing with THz pulse creates new

frequency components:⇒ Distortions at large chirp

(for Gaussian pulses!)min 02.6 200 fscσ σ σ≈ ≈

fs laser opticalstretcher

CCD gratingσ0 σc

EOP A

01/ cα σ σ≈

Page 20: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

EO Spectral Detection

GaP 175 µm, σ0=7 fs, σc=1.5 ps

pixe

l

200 400 600 800 1000 12001

24

200 400 600 800 1000 12000

5

10

15

20

coun

ts/1

000

0 2 4 6 8 100

time [ps]

norm

. EO

sig

nal

camera bgbg at θ=0bg at θ=2°signal at θ=2°

σ = 230 fs

Page 21: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

0 2 40

0.005

0.01

0.015

0.02

Time [ps]

EO

SD

sig

nal

simulationmeasurements

Spectrally resolved detection: Comparison of measured to simulated signals

5 consecutive bunches, corrected for different arrival times

Simulation: EOSD signal of a bunch measured with TDS

GaP 175 µmθ=2°σ0=7 fsσc=1.5ps

1st reflection

Excellent agreement with simulation in shape and amplitude,but much wider than electron bunch due to response function and frequency mixing

σ = 210 fs

Page 22: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

EOSD: Distortions due to frequency mixing for thin crystal and large chirp

GaP 100μm thick

σTHz= 75 fs

Laser σ0=6 fschirped to: σc=1.5 ps

θ=45°

-0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5

0

time [ps]

ΓΓ

TDΓSDE

THz

Page 23: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

EO Temporal Detection

- Cross-correlation with fs pulse in a frequency doubling crystal (BBO)

- approx. 100 µJ pulse energy necessary for 10 ps timewindow

timegate pulse

EO pulse BBO crystal

fs laser CCD opticalstretcher P A

fixed delay

BBOEO

σ0

σc

Page 24: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

4 6 8 10 12 14 160

5

10

time [ps]

EO

TD s

igna

l

σ = 95 fs

4 6 8 10 12 14 160

2

4

6

time [ps]

EO

TD s

igna

lσ = 80 fs

EO Temporal Detection

θ = 0

EO signal � ETHz

θ = 1°

EO signal � ETHz

2

Page 25: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

EO setup at FLASH

mirrormirror

lens (f=4 m)lens (f=4 m)

1.65

m 2.9

m

1 m8.5 m2.65 m

accelerator tunnel

laser laboratory

optical table

optical table

electronbeam pipe

laser beam pipe

- Laser systems in lab outside the accelerator:- 4 nJ, 7 fs Ti:Sa Oscillator- 1 mJ, 15 fs Ti:Sa amplifier

- 20 m evacuated transfer pipe to the tunnel

Page 26: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

e-beam

to laserdiagnostic

laser pulse

λ/4 and λ/2 platepolarizing beamsplitter

EO crystal

mirror

OTR screenvacuum chamber

photo diodeor PM

CCD camera

EO vacuum chamber in the beam pipe

- plane (175 µm) and wedged (30-200 µm) GaP crystal in the beam pipe

- allows spectrally and temporally decoded measurements

Page 27: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

Page 28: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

EO setup in the accelerator tunnel

Wollastonprism

λ/2 λ/4

fiber-couplers peri-

scope

fromlaser lab

to vacuum chamber

from vacuumchamber

polarizer

flipmirror

BBO

gratingstretcher

beam-splitter

polarizer

λ/2 λ/4 ICCDcamera

imaging lensescyl. lenses

peri-scope

peri-scope

peri-scope

fromlaser lab

to vacuum chamber

from vacuumchamber

polarizer

delay line

gate pulse

stretchedpulse

TD

SD

Page 29: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

Comparison of EOTD vs. TDS measurements

- 10th bunch in bunch train: electro-optic detection- 11th bunch: TDS

-0.5 0 0.5 1time [ps]

TDScorrected signal

EOTDcorrected signal

-6 -4 -2 0 2 4time [ps]

EO

TD a

nd T

DS

sig

nal

TDSraw signal

EOTDraw signal

background

Page 30: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

Comparison of EOTD vs. TDS measurements

- Good agreement between measurement and simulation

- close to the resolution limit of GaP

-0.2 0 0.2 0.4Time [ps]

-0.2 0 0.2 0.4Time [ps]

EO

TD s

igna

lTDS signal

THz pulse

EO signalsimulation

simulation

measurement

20 fs

26 fs

43 fs

55 fs

43 fs

Signal due to wake fields?

Page 31: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

TDS and EOTD measurement of overcompressed bunches

-0.5 0 0.5 1Time [ps]

EO

TD a

nd T

DS

sig

nal

EOTD

TDS(a)

In good agreement with the electron bunch shape

Signal due to wake fields?

Page 32: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

Overview

• Motivation• Basics

– Electro-optic effect – EO measurement principle– Detection schemes

• Measurement schemes and results– Electro-optic sampling using a variable delay– Spectrally resolved detection– Temporally resolved detection

• Applications• Conclusion

Page 33: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

Time jitter, measured with EOSD

- Time jitter: 200 fs (rms) incl. slow drift- Slow drift removed: 130 fs (rms)

1 2 3 4 5

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

time [min]

arriv

al ti

me

[ps]

0

measurement resolution (2σ=140 fs)

Page 34: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

Bunch arrival time dependence on the ACC1 phase

Arrival time change: 1.79 ps/Grad

7 7.5 8 8.5 9

-2

-1

0

1

2

ariv

al ti

me

in p

s

φACC1

0 100 200 300 400

-2

-1

0

1

2

Bunch no.

ariv

al ti

me

in p

s

φ AC

C1

10

7

9

8

6ACC1 phasearrival time

Page 35: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

Correlation between arrival time and ACC1 phase

⇒ correlated time jitter due to phase jitter: 103 fs⇒ uncorrelated time jitter due to other sources: 135 fs⇒ uncertainty in the phase measurement: 0.04° or 73 fs

200 400 600 800 1000

-0.2

0

0.2

0.4

Bunch no.

arriv

al ti

me

[ps]

ACC1 phasearrival time

φ AC

C1

7.8°

8.2°

8.0°

Page 36: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

Bunch shape without at maximum compression (without feedback)

0 2 4 6time [ps]

EO

TD s

igna

l

0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3time [ps]

occasionally double pulses

Down to a separation of approx. 130 fsdouble pulses can be separated

Page 37: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

Comparison to other EO experiments

2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 20070

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

EO s

igna

l dur

atio

n (fs

rms)

year

FELIX

FLASH(TEO)

SLACFELIX

Spectral DecodingTemporal DecodingSpatial Decoding

FLASH

limit for ZnTeGaP

Page 38: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

Conclusions

• Benchmarked EO detection against TDS

• Simulations based on published material data consistent in shape and amplitude with measured signals for GaP

• EO signals measured with of 55 fs (rms) length (linear in field and without deconvolution!) are close to the resolution limit of GaP

Page 39: Electro-Optic Longitudinal Bunch Profile Measurements at FLASH Bernd.Steffen@desy.de Bernd Steffen, 18.10.2007 Overview • Motivation •Basics – Electro-optic effect – EO measurement

Bernd Steffen, [email protected]

Thanks to

• G. Berden, A.F.G. van der Meer (FELIX)

• S. Jamison (ASTeC, Daresbury Laboratory)

• P.J. Phillips, W.A. Gillespie (University of Dundee)

• A.M. MacLeod (School of Computing and Advanced Technologies, University of Abertay, Dundee)

• V. Arsov, E.-A. Knabbe, H. Schlarb, B. Schmidt, P. Schmüser (DESY)