EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century...

34
eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi Ojeda 2 João Costa 1 Rogério Costa 1 1 Polytechnic Institute of Leiria (IPL) - Portugal 2 Polytechnic University of Catalonia (UPC) - Spain THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Transcript of EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century...

Page 1: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

Pedro Gaspar1 Josep Monguet2 Jordi Ojeda2

João Costa1 Rogério Costa1

1Polytechnic Institute of Leiria (IPL) - Portugal2Polytechnic University of Catalonia (UPC) - Spain

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Page 2: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Introduction

pre

vale

nc

e &

inci

de

nc

e

eco

no

mic

bu

rden

… 2.3 and 3.1 billion pounds (2005-2006 prices) per year in the UK (Posnett & Franks, 2008)

… 7 billion dollars in the USA, in 2007 (in dressing materials alone) …

… 20 billion if other costs (salaries, hospitalization, infection control…) are taken into consideration (Zaleski, 2008)

Page 3: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Introduction

diagnosis and treatment

new materials

tech

nolo

gica

l

adva

nces

new equipment

evidence based

practice

trai

nin

g

Page 4: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Introduction

Lifelong Learning Competences Performance

INFORMATION and COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGIES

HEALTH COSTS

In a context of fast-moving scientific and technological advances, knowledge acquired at school soon becomes outdated (Kokol, 2006).

Page 5: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

general hypothesis

costs vary according to the training of health professionals involved in the diagnosis and treatment of

chronic wounds.

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Introduction

Page 6: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

Web Based Learning (e-fer)

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Materials and methods

Page 7: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.
Page 8: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

Mathematical model to estimate the costs of chronic wounds

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Materials and methods

PLPPLFCETCphTChsLCWDCWETTTC Where: TC – Total Costs ETT – Expected Treatment Time (weeks)

APIHrADIHrDIHrWWIHrHTETT

HT - Healing Time WWIHr - Wound Washing Impact in healing rate DIHr - Dressing Impact in healing rate ADIHr - Additional Dressing Impact in healing rate APIHr - Additional Procedure Impact in healing rate DCW – Dressing Costs per Week

DCPDCDCW DCP- Dressing Change periodicity, per week DC- Dressing (materials) Costs, per week LCW –Labour (nursing) Costs per Week

DCPSmobLCLCW 125,0120min

Smob –Mobility status (1 if the patient is autonomous ; 0 if the patient is not autonomous) LCmin – Labour Costs per minute TChs – Travel costs from patient home to Health Service – per week

SmobDCPTChs 4,9

TCph – Travel costs from Health Service to patient home – per week

SmobDCPLCSmobTCph 1min20125,014,46,10

CE – Costs of Equipment for pressure relieving support

PRCErgCPRMCE

PRM – Pressure relieving Mattress ErgC – Ergonomic Chair PRC – Pressure Relieving Cushion PLF – Productivity losses by familiar that support patient.

ETTDCPDPV

PLF 2

DPV – Daily production value PLP – Productivity losses by patient (if the patient is a worker) Age2 – 0 if ? 65 years old 1 if < 65 years old

27 AgeSmobETTDPVPLP

Page 9: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

Materials and methods

PLPPLFCETCphTChsLCWDCWETTTotalCosts

Page 10: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

Materials and methods

PLPPLFCETCphTChsLCWDCWETTTotalCosts

ETT – Expected Treatment Time (weeks)

Page 11: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

Materials and methods

PLPPLFCETCphTChsLCWDCWETTTotalCosts

DCW – Dressing Costs per Week

Page 12: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

Materials and methods

PLPPLFCETCphTChsLCWDCWETTTotalCosts

LCW –Labour (nursing) Costs per Week

Page 13: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

Materials and methods

PLPPLFCETCphTChsLCWDCWETTTotalCosts

TChs – Travel costs from patient home to Health Service – per week

TCph – Travel costs from Health Service to patient home – per week

Page 14: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

Materials and methods

PLPPLFCETCphTChsLCWDCWETTTotalCosts

CE – Costs of Equipment for pressure relieving support

Page 15: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

Materials and methods

PLPPLFCETCphTChsLCWDCWETTTotalCosts

PLF – Productivity losses by familiar that support patient.

PLP – Productivity losses by patient (if the patient is a worker)

Page 16: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

Web Based System (e-fer Simulator)

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Materials and methods

Page 17: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.
Page 18: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

Optimum Cost matrices

…by applying the mathematical model to the virtual cases validated.

Cost of Decision matrices

…by applying the mathematical model to the options chosen by the users in the e-fer Simulator

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Materials and methods

Page 19: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Experimental

group

(n=12)

Control

group

(n=12)

Pre-test Post-test

TRAINING

Prevention andTreatment of

ChronicWounds

35h

XData pre-test Data post-test

Time (two weeks)

e-fer Simulator

e-fer Simulator

e-fer Simulator

e-fer Simulator

Page 20: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Experimental

group

(n=12)

Control

group

(n=12)

Pre-test Post-test

TRAINING

Prevention andTreatment of

ChronicWounds

35h

XData pre-test Data post-test

Time (two weeks)

e-fer Simulator

e-fer Simulator

e-fer Simulator

e-fer Simulator

Page 21: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Experimental

group

(n=12)

Control

group

(n=12)

Pre-test Post-test

TRAINING

Prevention andTreatment of

ChronicWounds

35h

XData pre-test Data post-test

Time (two weeks)

e-fer Simulator

e-fer Simulator

e-fer Simulator

e-fer Simulator

Page 22: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Experimental

group

(n=12)

Control

group

(n=12)

Pre-test Post-test

TRAINING

Prevention andTreatment of

ChronicWounds

35h

XData pre-test Data post-test

Time (two weeks)

e-fer Simulator

e-fer Simulator

e-fer Simulator

e-fer Simulator

Page 23: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Experimental

group

(n=12)

Control

group

(n=12)

Pre-test Post-test

TRAINING

Prevention andTreatment of

ChronicWounds

35h

XData pre-test Data post-test

Time (two weeks)

e-fer Simulator

e-fer Simulator

e-fer Simulator

e-fer Simulator

Page 24: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Results

The results were analysed with the Mann-Whitney and Wilcoxon nonparametric test, with 95% confidence interval.

The results reflect the difference between Optimum Costs and the Costs of Decision observed in the groups.

Page 25: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Results

The groups were homogeneous with regard to the Cost of Decision in the pre-test

(U = 64; p= 0.641)

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Results

The groups were homogeneous with regard to the Cost of Decision in the pre-test

0,00 €

2.000,00 €

4.000,00 €

6.000,00 €

8.000,00 €

10.000,00 €

12.000,00 €

14.000,00 €

16.000,00 €

18.000,00 €

20.000,00 €

CMP CSE CDSS CDEdd TCD PSF PSDta TCI CT

1º momento de avaliação 2º momento de avaliação

0,00 €

2.000,00 €

4.000,00 €

6.000,00 €

8.000,00 €

10.000,00 €

12.000,00 €

14.000,00 €

16.000,00 €

18.000,00 €

20.000,00 €

CMP CSE CDSS CDEdd TCD PSF PSDta TCI CT

Control Group

Experimental Group

(U = 64; p= 0.641)

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Results

The groups were homogeneous with regard to the Cost of Decision in the pre-test

Control Group

Experimental Group

(U = 64; p= 0.641)To

tal

Co

sts

Pre test

Page 26: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Results

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Results

The groups were homogeneous with regard to the Cost of Decision in the pre-test

0,00 €

2.000,00 €

4.000,00 €

6.000,00 €

8.000,00 €

10.000,00 €

12.000,00 €

14.000,00 €

16.000,00 €

18.000,00 €

20.000,00 €

CMP CSE CDSS CDEdd TCD PSF PSDta TCI CT

1º momento de avaliação 2º momento de avaliação

0,00 €

2.000,00 €

4.000,00 €

6.000,00 €

8.000,00 €

10.000,00 €

12.000,00 €

14.000,00 €

16.000,00 €

18.000,00 €

20.000,00 €

CMP CSE CDSS CDEdd TCD PSF PSDta TCI CT

Control Group

Experimental Group

(U = 64; p= 0.641)

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Results

The groups were homogeneous with regard to the Cost of Decision in the pre-test

Control Group

Experimental Group

(U = 64; p= 0.641)To

tal

Co

sts

Pre test

Pos test

Pre test

Pos test

Z= -3.059 p= 0.002

Z= -0,314 p= 0.753

Difference between Optimal Costs and Costs of Decision observed in Groups (before and after training)

Page 27: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Results O

pti

mu

m

cost

Co

st

of

de

cis

ion

119.

19%

ab

ove

th

e O

C

Co

st

of

de

cis

ion

58.9

0% a

bo

ve t

he

OC

Control Group

Experimental Group

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Results

no

n-t

rain

ing

co

sts

(89

0.0

7 €

for

eac

h w

ou

nd

)

Ind

irec

t co

sts

(428

.08

€)d

irec

t co

sts

(461

.99

€)

(salary losses of the reference family member and/or patient)

(dressing materials) 97.09 €

(patient’s travel expenses ) 171.28 €

(nurse’s salaries and travel expenses) 196.90 €

non-training costs(890.07 € for each wound)

Page 28: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Results

no

n-t

rain

ing

co

sts

(890

.07

€ fo

r ea

ch w

ou

nd

)

Ind

ire

ct

co

sts

(428

.08

€)

dir

ect

co

sts

(461

.99

€)

(dressing materials) 97.09 €

(patient’s travel expenses ) 171.28 €

(nurse’s salaries and travel expenses) 196.90 €

(salary losses of patient and/or familiar) 428.08 €48%

19%

22%

11%

Page 29: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

eco

no

mic

bu

rden

Conclusion

How mutch € can we save through

training ?

Page 30: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Conclusion

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Conclusion

Based on real experiences Relevant data to the Diagnosis & Treatment Correct choices for the Diagnosis & Treatment

Construction of Virtual Cases

(Web based tool)

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Peer review

Diagnosis Decision Treatment Decision

Diagnosis & Treatment Simulator

of Virtual Cases (Web based tool)

EXPERTS TRAINEES

Optimum Cost

Cost of Decision

COSTS OF NON-TRAINING = Cost of decision – Optimum Cost

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Based on real experiences Relevant data to the Diagnosis & Treatment Correct choices for the Diagnosis & Treatment

Construction of Virtual Cases

(Web based tool)

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Peer review

Diagnosis Decision Treatment Decision

Diagnosis & Treatment Simulator

of Virtual Cases (Web based tool)

EXPERTS TRAINEES

Optimum Cost

Cost of Decision

COSTS OF NON-TRAINING = Cost of decision – Optimum Cost

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Based on real experiences Relevant data to the Diagnosis & Treatment Correct choices for the Diagnosis & Treatment

Construction of Virtual Cases

(Web based tool)

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Peer review

Diagnosis Decision Treatment Decision

Diagnosis & Treatment Simulator

of Virtual Cases (Web based tool)

EXPERTS TRAINEES

Optimum Cost

Cost of Decision

COSTS OF NON-TRAINING = Cost of decision – Optimum Cost

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Based on real experiences Relevant data to the Diagnosis & Treatment Correct choices for the Diagnosis & Treatment

Construction of Virtual Cases

(Web based tool)

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Peer review

Diagnosis Decision Treatment Decision

Diagnosis & Treatment Simulator

of Virtual Cases (Web based tool)

EXPERTS TRAINEES

Optimum Cost

Cost of Decision

COSTS OF NON-TRAINING = Cost of decision – Optimum Cost

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Page 31: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Conclusion

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Conclusion

Based on real experiences Relevant data to the Diagnosis & Treatment Correct choices for the Diagnosis & Treatment

Construction of Virtual Cases

(Web based tool)

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Peer review

Diagnosis Decision Treatment Decision

Diagnosis & Treatment Simulator

of Virtual Cases (Web based tool)

EXPERTS TRAINEES

Optimum Cost

Cost of Decision

COSTS OF NON-TRAINING = Cost of decision – Optimum Cost

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Based on real experiences Relevant data to the Diagnosis & Treatment Correct choices for the Diagnosis & Treatment

Construction of Virtual Cases

(Web based tool)

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Peer review

Diagnosis Decision Treatment Decision

Diagnosis & Treatment Simulator

of Virtual Cases (Web based tool)

EXPERTS TRAINEES

Optimum Cost

Cost of Decision

COSTS OF NON-TRAINING = Cost of decision – Optimum Cost

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Based on real experiences Relevant data to the Diagnosis & Treatment Correct choices for the Diagnosis & Treatment

Construction of Virtual Cases

(Web based tool)

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Peer review

Diagnosis Decision Treatment Decision

Diagnosis & Treatment Simulator

of Virtual Cases (Web based tool)

EXPERTS TRAINEES

Optimum Cost

Cost of Decision

COSTS OF NON-TRAINING = Cost of decision – Optimum Cost

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Based on real experiences Relevant data to the Diagnosis & Treatment Correct choices for the Diagnosis & Treatment

Construction of Virtual Cases

(Web based tool)

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Peer review

Diagnosis Decision Treatment Decision

Diagnosis & Treatment Simulator

of Virtual Cases (Web based tool)

EXPERTS TRAINEES

Optimum Cost

Cost of Decision

COSTS OF NON-TRAINING = Cost of decision – Optimum Cost

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Page 32: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Conclusion

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Conclusion

Based on real experiences Relevant data to the Diagnosis & Treatment Correct choices for the Diagnosis & Treatment

Construction of Virtual Cases

(Web based tool)

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Peer review

Diagnosis Decision Treatment Decision

Diagnosis & Treatment Simulator

of Virtual Cases (Web based tool)

EXPERTS TRAINEES

Optimum Cost

Cost of Decision

COSTS OF NON-TRAINING = Cost of decision – Optimum Cost

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Based on real experiences Relevant data to the Diagnosis & Treatment Correct choices for the Diagnosis & Treatment

Construction of Virtual Cases

(Web based tool)

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Peer review

Diagnosis Decision Treatment Decision

Diagnosis & Treatment Simulator

of Virtual Cases (Web based tool)

EXPERTS TRAINEES

Optimum Cost

Cost of Decision

COSTS OF NON-TRAINING = Cost of decision – Optimum Cost

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Based on real experiences Relevant data to the Diagnosis & Treatment Correct choices for the Diagnosis & Treatment

Construction of Virtual Cases

(Web based tool)

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Peer review

Diagnosis Decision Treatment Decision

Diagnosis & Treatment Simulator

of Virtual Cases (Web based tool)

EXPERTS TRAINEES

Optimum Cost

Cost of Decision

COSTS OF NON-TRAINING = Cost of decision – Optimum Cost

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Based on real experiences Relevant data to the Diagnosis & Treatment Correct choices for the Diagnosis & Treatment

Construction of Virtual Cases

(Web based tool)

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Peer review

Diagnosis Decision Treatment Decision

Diagnosis & Treatment Simulator

of Virtual Cases (Web based tool)

EXPERTS TRAINEES

Optimum Cost

Cost of Decision

COSTS OF NON-TRAINING = Cost of decision – Optimum Cost

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Page 33: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Conclusion

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

Conclusion

Based on real experiences Relevant data to the Diagnosis & Treatment Correct choices for the Diagnosis & Treatment

Construction of Virtual Cases

(Web based tool)

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Peer review

Diagnosis Decision Treatment Decision

Diagnosis & Treatment Simulator

of Virtual Cases (Web based tool)

EXPERTS TRAINEES

Optimum Cost

Cost of Decision

COSTS OF NON-TRAINING = Cost of decision – Optimum Cost

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Based on real experiences Relevant data to the Diagnosis & Treatment Correct choices for the Diagnosis & Treatment

Construction of Virtual Cases

(Web based tool)

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Peer review

Diagnosis Decision Treatment Decision

Diagnosis & Treatment Simulator

of Virtual Cases (Web based tool)

EXPERTS TRAINEES

Optimum Cost

Cost of Decision

COSTS OF NON-TRAINING = Cost of decision – Optimum Cost

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Based on real experiences Relevant data to the Diagnosis & Treatment Correct choices for the Diagnosis & Treatment

Construction of Virtual Cases

(Web based tool)

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Peer review

Diagnosis Decision Treatment Decision

Diagnosis & Treatment Simulator

of Virtual Cases (Web based tool)

EXPERTS TRAINEES

Optimum Cost

Cost of Decision

COSTS OF NON-TRAINING = Cost of decision – Optimum Cost

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Based on real experiences Relevant data to the Diagnosis & Treatment Correct choices for the Diagnosis & Treatment

Construction of Virtual Cases

(Web based tool)

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Peer review

Diagnosis Decision Treatment Decision

Diagnosis & Treatment Simulator

of Virtual Cases (Web based tool)

EXPERTS TRAINEES

Optimum Cost

Cost of Decision

COSTS OF NON-TRAINING = Cost of decision – Optimum Cost

MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR COSTS ESTIMATION

TC = CDC+CIC+IC

TC – Total costs CDC – Clinical Direct Costs CIC – Clinical Indirect Costs IC – Indirect Costs

Page 34: EHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century Istanbul, Turkey Pedro Gaspar 1 Josep Monguet 2 Jordi.

eHealth 2009 - Second International ICST Conference on Electronic Healthcare for the 21st century

Istanbul, Turkey

Pedro Gaspar1 Josep Monguet2 Jordi Ojeda2

João Costa1 Rogério Costa1

1Polytechnic Institute of Leiria (IPL) - Portugal2Polytechnic University of Catalonia (UPC) - Spain

THE COSTS OF NON-TRAINING IN CHRONIC WOUNDS: Estimates through practice simulation

thank you for your attention