Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 ·...

66
Efficiency Vermont Efficiency Vermont - - Better Buildings by Design Better Buildings by Design Burlington, V Burlington, V ermont ermont February 11, 2009 February 11, 2009 Kevin Dowling, VP Innovation, Philips Color Kinetics Past-Chair Next Generation Lighting Industry Alliance (NGLIA) Chair IES, Solid-State Lighting Section Chair NEMA Solid-State Lighting Committee

Transcript of Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 ·...

Page 1: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

Efficiency Vermont Efficiency Vermont -- Better Buildings by DesignBetter Buildings by Design

Burlington, VBurlington, VermontermontFebruary 11, 2009February 11, 2009

Kevin Dowling, VP Innovation, Philips Color KineticsPast-Chair Next Generation Lighting Industry Alliance (NGLIA)Chair IES, Solid-State Lighting SectionChair NEMA Solid-State Lighting Committee

Page 2: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

2

Philips Color Kinetics

Shops

HospitalityOutdoor

Entertainment

FocusDesign and market LED-based lighting systems and technologies

LED Lighting Systems

Customers• High performance color• Specialty white light• OEM products• Over 20,000 installations worldwide

Page 3: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

333/3/2009 ©2007 PHILIPS SOLID STATE LIGHTING SOLUTIONS. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. PRIVATE AND CONFIDENTIAL

Page 4: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

4

LED, you’ve come a long way.

Page 5: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

5

‘Fly by wire’Linkages

DVDVHS

ComputerTypewriter

Cell phoneRotary phone

CCDFilm

CDs -> mp3LP records

TransistorVacuum tube

DigitalAnalog

Lighting is the last refuge of analog

Tubes To Transistors All Over Again

Page 6: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

6

A Brief LED History

• 1962 First visible LED (Holonyak@GE– 0.001 lumens

• 1960’s Red LEDs (HP & Monsanto)– 0.01 lumens

• 1970’s-1980’s Green LEDs, Watches, Calculators– 0.1 lumens

• 1990’s Blue LEDs (Nakamura@Nichia)– 1 lumen

• 2000+ – 10-100 lumens

• 2005– 1000 lumens (multichip packages)

©2004 Color Kinetics Incorporated

Page 7: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

7

LED Background

• A semiconductor device that converts electrical energy directly into a discrete color of light

• Made from different materials and substrates• Made in chip fabrication factories. • Not brass, glass and gas• White LEDs are blue LEDs + phosphor

Wire Bond

Anode Lead

Cathode Lead

Epoxy Case

Epoxy LensSemiconductor Diode

Reflective Cup

©2004 Color Kinetics Incorporated

Substrate (Sapphire or SiC)

BaseN-typeP-type +- Yellow phosphor coating

Page 8: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

8

Indication to Illumination

• Monochrome Indicators– Traffic lights, automotive, exit signs etc– Portable appliances, cell phones, PDAs– Signage– Direct view displays; video screens

• Emerging Applications– Transportation: marine, auto, aviation etc– Lighting niches

• Future– General Illumination

Source: Ecolux, nasdaq, Daimler, Gelcorec©2004 Color Kinetics Incorporated

Page 9: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

9

Conventional Lighting Sources

• Incandescent

• Halogen

• Fluorescent

• Gas-discharge (example: neon)

Benefits of SSL• Ultra long source life• Low power consumption• Low maintenance• No moving parts• Vibration resistance• No UV radiation• Cool beam of light• Digitally controllable• Fast Response

SSL Source

• Light emitting diodes (LEDs)

Lighting Sources

Page 10: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

10

0

50

100

150

200

1920 1940 1960 1980 2000 2020

Market Trends:LEDs Eclipsing Traditional Technologies

Incandescent

Fluorescent

Source: Lumileds

Lum

inou

s Ef

ficie

ncy

(lum

ens

/ wat

t)

Halogen

LED

IR Halogen

White LED

Page 11: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

11

Haitz’ Law: LED Output Up/ Cost Down

0.001

0.01

0.1

1

10

100

1000

10000

100000

1965 1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020

Red Flux

Red$/Lumen

White Flux(Projected)

White$/Lumen

Expon.(Red Flux)

Expon.(Red$/Lumen)

Source: Roland Haitz & Lumileds

Ligh

t Out

put /

Pac

kage

(lum

ens)

-20% CAGR

20x Increase/Decade

+35% CAGR

10x Decrease/Decade

Cost / Lum

en ($ / lumen)

Page 12: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

12

Market Trends: Sharply Falling Cost of LED Light

Cost of Light Incorporates• Lifetime• Source efficiency• Energy cost• Replacement cost of

lamp/fixture• Labor cost

Source: Color Kinetics: research w/ only white LEDs

Page 13: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

13

LED Illumination is expanding rapidly

•Green movement

•LED benefits

•Brighter, cheaper LEDs

•General illumination possible

•Standards & legislation

•Product proliferation

• Incentives (beginning)

Global LED Illumination Market

$0

$500

$1,000

$1,500

$2,000

$2,500

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007

Mar

ket S

ize

($ m

illio

n)

5-year CAGR: 32%

Key Market Drivers

Page 14: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

14

Legislation and Guidelines

• US Initiatives– CA Title 24, ‘05, ‘08, & ‘11– US EISA 2007 mandates– ASHRAE 90.1– LEED

• Increasing number of initiatives• Raising efficacy mandates

– Effectively 45 lpw in 2020• Critical need for standards

Page 15: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

15

LEED• Leadership in Energy and

Environmental Design• LEED is the benchmark for the

design, construction, and operation of high performance green buildings

• http://www.usgbc.org/

Page 16: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

16

LEED Continued• The LEED rating system designed by US Green Building Council• Range of points required for Certified, Silver, Gold, or Platinum status• Each LEED rating system has 5 categories and innovation category

• Sustainable Sites• Water Efficiency• Energy & Atmosphere• Materials & Resources• Indoor Environmental Quality• Innovation & Design Process• Innovation in Operation & Upgrades

• LEED scores benefit from controls and sensing such as dimming and daylighting

• Scoring is based on substantial documentation.

Page 17: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

17

California Title 24• California Energy Efficiency

Standards for Residential and Nonresidential Buildings

• Currently using 2005 standards. 2008 standard now available.

• Reduces energy by limiting building lighting power

• http://www.energy.ca.gov/title24/

Page 18: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

18

California Title 24

Page 19: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

19

LEDs in Title 24 2008 Lighting

60 lumens per wattOver 40 watts

50 lumens per watt15 watts to 40 watts

40 lumens per watt15 watts or less

Minimum Lamp Efficacy for Non-LED Lighting, orMinimum Luminaire Efficacy for LED Lighting

Lamp Power Rating for Non-LED Lighting, orLuminaire Power Rating for LED Lighting

Page 20: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

20

Danger of Hyperbole

“Uses almost no energy!”“Lasts Forever!”

Nothing will kill an industry faster than expectations that cannot be met.

Performance must be realistic and factual.Costs must be complete.

Page 21: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

21

X New Record in Efficient LEDs. 116 lm/W

Y achieved 150 lm/W white LED Lamps

Z white LED produces 131 lm/W

X announces LED 86 lumens per Watt

Y develops 100 lm/W White LEDs

Wow!

Uh, Wait a second….

Page 22: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

22

• Marketed LED lamp– Contains 3 ABC 1W LEDs – 120 lumens output

• ABC LED is nominal 40 lumens– Measured for 25msec at 25C

• The whole <> the sum of its parts

Myth and Reality

Page 23: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

23

US Department of Energy Activities•www.ssl.energy.gov

R&D PortfolioSSL Quality AdvocatesEnergy Star for SSLCALiPER testing programStandards DevelopmentGATEWAY DemonstrationsDesign CompetitionsTechnical Information Network for SSL Using LEDs

Page 24: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

24

DoE Caliper Testing Program• ‘Consumer Reports’ for LED

product testing• Objective product

performance• Over 120 Product tests• Support Energy Star• Help guide development of

testing procedures• www.netl.doe.gov/ssl/

Page 25: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

25

DoE Caliper Testing Program

Page 26: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

26

Labeling• Assure better product quality• Provide useful information• Mandate standards testing

Page 27: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

27

Life Cycle Analysis

QuickTime™ and a decompressor

are needed to see this picture.

Precursor Gases

Reactors/EpitaxyEnergy

Wafers Die Package Array Luminaire

Materials

Substrates

Commissioned by NGLIAStarted by DoE, Oct ‘08

Page 28: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

28

• Luminous Flux• Power & Power Factor• Efficacy• Lifetime• CRI• Light Distribution

Energy Star for Luminaires

Page 29: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

29

Active Organization Involvement

Page 30: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

30

Operating Time (Minutes)

420440460480500520

15 30 45 60 75 90 120

Lum

inou

s Flu

x

RGB Fixture

Heat and Light

Page 31: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

31

A Different Story - DoE Product Testing

Page 32: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

32

Technology & Standards Are Evolving Rapidly

• LED Performance– Output increases (100’s of lumens)– Color Quality much improved (80+ CRI)– Efficacy much improved (50-100lpw)– Costs continue to improve

• SSL Standards– Rapidly coming out in 2008– Chromaticity ANSI C78.377– Luminous Flux IES LM-79– Lumen Maintainance IES LM-80– More to come!

• Product availability increasing

Page 33: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

33

• ANSI C78.377• Defines Color Temperature regions• Being adopted by LED manufacturers

Chromaticity

Page 34: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

34

Chromaticity Specification

Page 35: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

35

• IESNA LM-79-2008• Measure light output of Led-based fixtures

Light Output - Lumens

Page 36: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

36

LED Source Life

• Lifetime Definition– Traditional lighting: Time to failure– LEDs: Time to 70%/50% lumen depreciation

• Fluorescent 25% down over their lifetime• Incandescent down 15-20% over their lifetime

– Predicted LED source life between 50-100K hours• Your mileage may vary• 50K to 75K hours is typical for high-flux packages.

• Lifetime Issues– Thermal– Ambient temperature, humidity, ventilation– Control techniques– Electrical drive, other electrical considerations

color kinetics

color kinetics in SSL

color kinetics

Page 37: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

37

• IESNA LM-80-2008• Specifies temperature conditions• Testing equipment• Reporting requirements and more

– Only a testing method and not a predictive method!• Determine LED Lifetime, L70, L50

• Efforts underway to create a predictive model

• Available from the IESNA - iesna.org

Lumen Maintenance

Page 38: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

38

Colour Rendering Index (CRI)

• Relative measure color shift of eight samples between source andreference source of same CT

• CRI value is 1-100 with 100 as closest match to reference• Tells you only about possible color shift with a particular reference

Page 39: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

39

Many Issues with CRI

• Uses obsolete colour space (1964 W*U*V*)– Used now only for CRI!

• Samples are low-moderate saturation • Outdated chromatic adaptation formula• Non-linear in red region

– Helped by seldom-used addition of R9-R14• Penalizes LED lighting scores

Images: NIST

Page 40: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

40

Spectrum Synthesizer - ‘Equalizer’ for Light

Page 41: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

41

Spectrally Tunable Light Source

Page 42: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

42

Page 43: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

43

Dimming and Efficacy

Power vs Efficacy

0.00

2.00

4.00

6.00

8.00

10.00

12.00

020406080100120

Power (W)

Incandescent & Halogen

Lamp Voltage vs Power

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

020406080100120140

Voltage

Lamp Voltage vs Lumens

0

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

020406080100120140

Voltage

LEDs should remain about the same or improve!

Page 44: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

44

Legacy

Page 45: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

4545

Lighting System Architecture: Old and New

TRA

DIT

ION

AL

SOLI

D S

TATE

Page 46: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

4646

New Lamp Form Standards Needed

New generation components allow– Replacements– Upgrades– Mechanical support– Electrical connections– Thermal connection– Communications & networks– Optimized performance– New lighting options

46

Page 47: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

47

New Generations of Sockets and Bases

Patent Pending

Page 48: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

48

More Application Examples

Patent Pending

Page 49: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

49

FAO Schwarz New York, NY

Page 50: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

50

Philadelphia, PAMorimoto Restaurant

Page 51: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

51

Mexico City Residence Mexico City, Mexico

Page 52: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

52

Chicago, ILCrown Fountain at Millennium Park

Page 53: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

53

Boston Ballet – The Nutcracker Boston, MA

Page 54: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

54

Hard Rock Hotel Las Vegas, NV

Page 55: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

55

Philadelphia, PABenjamin Franklin Bridge

Page 56: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

56

Hospitality Rustic Kitchen

Page 57: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

57

Retail Clarks/Bostonian

Page 58: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

58

Office Lighting

• LED-based Linear Pendant• 2000 lumens per foot• Technically possible• Economically viable - not quite yet

Page 59: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

59

Page 60: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

60

Easy Predictions

Solid-state sources are changing the face of lightingAll colored light is in transitionPerformance increasesCosts decrease

Now white LEDs

Page 61: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

61

Interim Solution?

Page 62: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

62

Hard Predictions

What is fixture or lamp?Fixture gives way to form

Integrate into structures, furniture, accessories

The Illuminated becomes illuminating

What happens when-A 1000 lumen source is the size of a quarter-Uses only 10W of energy. -Costs of a few dollars

We do not yet understand the impact

Page 63: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

63

LED Lighting Systems

Page 64: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

64

New mediums imitate predecessorsEarly movies = films of stage playsEarly TV = radio with pictures

Every medium needs time to form its own form and vocabulary

Solid-state lighting will do the same

Solid state lighting is not simply a replacement technology. This approach weakens its capability

A New Medium

Page 65: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

65

The icon will outlive the lamp

Page 66: Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont … · 2020-01-31 · Efficiency Vermont - Better Buildings by Design Burlington, Vermont February 11, 2009 ...

66

Thank You!