Effects of the Landscape on Gene Flow and Connectivity of Boreal Toads Jennifer Moore, Julie...

21
Effects of the Landscape on Gene Flow and Connectivity of Boreal Toads Jennifer Moore, Julie Nielsen, David Tallmon, Sanjay Pyare University of Alaska Southeast
  • date post

    19-Dec-2015
  • Category

    Documents

  • view

    217
  • download

    0

Transcript of Effects of the Landscape on Gene Flow and Connectivity of Boreal Toads Jennifer Moore, Julie...

Page 1: Effects of the Landscape on Gene Flow and Connectivity of Boreal Toads Jennifer Moore, Julie Nielsen, David Tallmon, Sanjay Pyare University of Alaska.

Effects of the Landscape on Gene Flow and Connectivity of Boreal Toads

Jennifer Moore, Julie Nielsen, David Tallmon, Sanjay PyareUniversity of Alaska Southeast

Page 2: Effects of the Landscape on Gene Flow and Connectivity of Boreal Toads Jennifer Moore, Julie Nielsen, David Tallmon, Sanjay Pyare University of Alaska.

Landscapes have profound effects on species ecology

Colonization

Movement

DispersalPopulation dynamics

Geographic distributions

Page 3: Effects of the Landscape on Gene Flow and Connectivity of Boreal Toads Jennifer Moore, Julie Nielsen, David Tallmon, Sanjay Pyare University of Alaska.

Landscape genetics

Landscape ecology + population genetics

• Aims to quantify the effects of the landscape on microevolutionary processes– Cryptic boundaries– Secondary contact among previously isolated pops

• Hypothesis driven• Novel individual-based methods

Page 4: Effects of the Landscape on Gene Flow and Connectivity of Boreal Toads Jennifer Moore, Julie Nielsen, David Tallmon, Sanjay Pyare University of Alaska.

Landscape genetics

Two key steps:1. Detect genetic discontinuities2. Correlate these with landscape and

environmental features

Page 5: Effects of the Landscape on Gene Flow and Connectivity of Boreal Toads Jennifer Moore, Julie Nielsen, David Tallmon, Sanjay Pyare University of Alaska.

Amphibians

• Good models for studies of connectivity– Function as metapopulations– Patchy distributions = limited connectivity

• Population dynamics difficult to understand with traditional ecological methods– High population stochasticity

Page 6: Effects of the Landscape on Gene Flow and Connectivity of Boreal Toads Jennifer Moore, Julie Nielsen, David Tallmon, Sanjay Pyare University of Alaska.

Boreal toads

• Widespread• IUCN listed as near

threatened• Status in Alaska?– northern range

margin

Page 7: Effects of the Landscape on Gene Flow and Connectivity of Boreal Toads Jennifer Moore, Julie Nielsen, David Tallmon, Sanjay Pyare University of Alaska.

Boreal toads

• Pond breeding, but variable habitat and climate tolerance

• Capable of long distance movements• High breeding site fidelity

Highly differentiated?Strongly affected by the landscape?

Page 8: Effects of the Landscape on Gene Flow and Connectivity of Boreal Toads Jennifer Moore, Julie Nielsen, David Tallmon, Sanjay Pyare University of Alaska.

Study sitesAdmiralty Island Haines

Page 9: Effects of the Landscape on Gene Flow and Connectivity of Boreal Toads Jennifer Moore, Julie Nielsen, David Tallmon, Sanjay Pyare University of Alaska.

Hypotheses• H1: Isolation by distance– Euclidean distance

• H2-n: Isolation by landscape resistance– Habitat structure (x 5)– Insolation– Rugosity– Saltwater– Permanent snow and ice– Roads (Haines only)G

eneti

c di

stan

ceGeographic distance

Page 10: Effects of the Landscape on Gene Flow and Connectivity of Boreal Toads Jennifer Moore, Julie Nielsen, David Tallmon, Sanjay Pyare University of Alaska.

Methods

1. Sample breeding populations2. Amplify microsatellites3. Calculate genetic distance (Fst)4. Generate GIS models, calculate

geographic distances5. Correlate pairwise genetic with

pairwise geographic distance (Mantel tests)

Page 11: Effects of the Landscape on Gene Flow and Connectivity of Boreal Toads Jennifer Moore, Julie Nielsen, David Tallmon, Sanjay Pyare University of Alaska.

Geographic distance

Least cost paths Circuit theory• Distance that incorporates

multiple potential paths of least resistance

• Single path of least resistance

Mcrae et al. 2008

Page 12: Effects of the Landscape on Gene Flow and Connectivity of Boreal Toads Jennifer Moore, Julie Nielsen, David Tallmon, Sanjay Pyare University of Alaska.

Wolverine gene flowMcRae and Beir 2007, PNAS

Circuit theory outperforms traditional methods

Circuitscape software

Page 13: Effects of the Landscape on Gene Flow and Connectivity of Boreal Toads Jennifer Moore, Julie Nielsen, David Tallmon, Sanjay Pyare University of Alaska.

Sample locations + resistance surface

Circuitscape current map=

Page 14: Effects of the Landscape on Gene Flow and Connectivity of Boreal Toads Jennifer Moore, Julie Nielsen, David Tallmon, Sanjay Pyare University of Alaska.

Results

Toad populations moderately differentiated on a small scale

• Mean pairwise FstANM = 0.061, 0.008 - 0.122HNS = 0.053, 0.006 – 0.143

• Mean pairwise Euclidean distanceANM = 14.5 km, 0.33-45 kmHNS = 11.4 km, 0.11-50 km

Page 15: Effects of the Landscape on Gene Flow and Connectivity of Boreal Toads Jennifer Moore, Julie Nielsen, David Tallmon, Sanjay Pyare University of Alaska.

Small effective population sizes (Ne)

0 2 4 6 8 10 120

50

100

150

200

250HNSANM

Population

Effec

tive

Popu

latio

n Si

ze

Page 16: Effects of the Landscape on Gene Flow and Connectivity of Boreal Toads Jennifer Moore, Julie Nielsen, David Tallmon, Sanjay Pyare University of Alaska.

Permanent snow/ice strongest single factor model

euclid ice ru

gg salt

solar

struct1

struct2

struct3

struct4

struct5

road

s-0.10

0.00

0.10

0.20

0.30

0.40

0.50

0.60ANM

HNS

Model

r

Page 17: Effects of the Landscape on Gene Flow and Connectivity of Boreal Toads Jennifer Moore, Julie Nielsen, David Tallmon, Sanjay Pyare University of Alaska.

Permanent snow and ice affects genetic connectivity

0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.250

1

2

3

4

5

6

Pairwise Fst

Pair

wis

e Re

sist

ance

- Ic

e

R = 0.59

Page 18: Effects of the Landscape on Gene Flow and Connectivity of Boreal Toads Jennifer Moore, Julie Nielsen, David Tallmon, Sanjay Pyare University of Alaska.

Summary and conclusions

• Limited gene flow, small scale differentiation• Small Ne for many populations• Gene flow strongly affected by permanent

snow/ice– Differs from other parts of range– Barrier due to physiological/thermal limits

Page 19: Effects of the Landscape on Gene Flow and Connectivity of Boreal Toads Jennifer Moore, Julie Nielsen, David Tallmon, Sanjay Pyare University of Alaska.

Summary and conclusions

• Impacts of climate change?

Glaciers, permanent snow and ice

= Toad connectivity?

Page 20: Effects of the Landscape on Gene Flow and Connectivity of Boreal Toads Jennifer Moore, Julie Nielsen, David Tallmon, Sanjay Pyare University of Alaska.

Future directions

• Improve model fit– Combine surfaces, multiple parameters

• Compare methods: least cost path vs. circuit theory

• Broad-scale phylogeographic analysis– Do patterns hold true at different scales?

Page 21: Effects of the Landscape on Gene Flow and Connectivity of Boreal Toads Jennifer Moore, Julie Nielsen, David Tallmon, Sanjay Pyare University of Alaska.

Thanks

• NSF Alaska EPSCoR• ADF&G Non Game program• USFS• USGS• Emma Caragano, Ray Slayton, Tim Shields, Kim

Obermeyer, Karin McCoy, Colin Shanley, Iris Shields, Robbie Piehl, Lance Lerum, Brett Addis, Cat Frock, Dave Moore