Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized...

30
Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized Intersections Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil Engineering University of Nebraska-Lincoln

description

Nebraska Department of Roads Conference 2012 Presented by Dr. Anuj Sharma, University of Nebraska-Lincoln

Transcript of Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized...

Page 1: Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized Intersections Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil Engineering University of Nebraska-Lincoln

Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at

Signalized Intersections

Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil EngineeringUniversity of Nebraska-Lincoln

Page 2: Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized Intersections Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil Engineering University of Nebraska-Lincoln

Objective of Research

• Evaluate the effects a countdown timer has on safety and efficiency of operations at an intersection and public view.

Page 3: Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized Intersections Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil Engineering University of Nebraska-Lincoln

Past Literature: Pedestrians

Page 4: Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized Intersections Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil Engineering University of Nebraska-Lincoln

Intersection Selection

• Two intersections chosen: – S 17th St & G St (Pedestrian and Drivers)

• Northbound Approach • Speed Limit 35 mph

– N 27th St & Cornhusker Highway (Drivers) • Eastbound Approach • Speed Limit 40 mph

Page 5: Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized Intersections Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil Engineering University of Nebraska-Lincoln

Pedestrian Data

Page 6: Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized Intersections Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil Engineering University of Nebraska-Lincoln

Driver Data

Page 7: Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized Intersections Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil Engineering University of Nebraska-Lincoln

Performance Measures

• Pedestrian Compliance

• Pedestrian Walking Speed

• Probability of Stopping

• Speed Gain at Stopbar during Yellow Phase

• Change in Queue Discharge

Page 8: Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized Intersections Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil Engineering University of Nebraska-Lincoln

Pedestrian Analysis (Only for 17th and G)• 861 pedestrians before installation (April-March)

(Mean temp 56 F) • 495 pedestrians after installation (Oct-end) (Mean

temp 56 F) • Clear weather conditions

Page 9: Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized Intersections Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil Engineering University of Nebraska-Lincoln

Compliance Results

Page 10: Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized Intersections Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil Engineering University of Nebraska-Lincoln
Page 11: Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized Intersections Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil Engineering University of Nebraska-Lincoln

Performance Measures

• Pedestrian Compliance

• Pedestrian Walking Speed

• Probability of Stopping

• Speed Gain at Stopbar during Yellow Phase

• Change in Queue Discharge

Page 12: Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized Intersections Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil Engineering University of Nebraska-Lincoln

Performance Measures

• Pedestrian Compliance • Pedestrian Walking Speed • Probability of Stopping • Speed Gain at Stopbar during Yellow Phase • Change in Queue Discharge

Page 13: Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized Intersections Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil Engineering University of Nebraska-Lincoln

Performance Measures

• Pedestrian Compliance • Pedestrian Walking Speed (4.7 ft/s 4.9 ft/s) • Probability of Stopping • Speed Gain at Stopbar during Yellow Phase • Change in Queue Discharge

Page 14: Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized Intersections Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil Engineering University of Nebraska-Lincoln
Page 15: Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized Intersections Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil Engineering University of Nebraska-Lincoln

Probability of Stopping at 27th and Cornhusker

Page 16: Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized Intersections Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil Engineering University of Nebraska-Lincoln

Important Results

• RLR (17 & G): – Before 10 of 429 vehicles ran the red light

(2.3%) – After 3 of 422 vehicles ran the red light (0.7%)

• RLR (27 & Cornhusker): – Before 7 of 525 vehicles ran the red light (1.3%) – After 8 of 482 vehicles ran the red light (1.6%)

Page 17: Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized Intersections Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil Engineering University of Nebraska-Lincoln

Performance Measures

• Pedestrian Compliance

• Pedestrian Walking Speed (4.7 ft/s 4.9 ft/s)

• Probability of Stopping: 17th and G

• Speed Gain at Stopbar during Yellow Phase

• Change in Queue Discharge

Page 18: Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized Intersections Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil Engineering University of Nebraska-Lincoln

Performance Measures

• Pedestrian Compliance

• Pedestrian Walking Speed (4.7 ft/s 4.9 ft/s)

• Probability of Stopping: 17th and G 27th

and Cornhusker

• Speed Gain at Stopbar during Yellow Phase

• Change in Queue Discharge

Page 19: Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized Intersections Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil Engineering University of Nebraska-Lincoln

17th and G

Page 20: Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized Intersections Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil Engineering University of Nebraska-Lincoln

27th and Cornhusker

Page 21: Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized Intersections Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil Engineering University of Nebraska-Lincoln

Performance Measures

• Pedestrian Compliance

• Pedestrian Walking Speed (4.7 ft/s 4.9 ft/s)

• Probability of Stopping: 17th and G 27th

and Cornhusker

• Speed Gain at Stopbar during Yellow Phase

• Change in Queue Discharge

Page 22: Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized Intersections Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil Engineering University of Nebraska-Lincoln

Performance Measures

• Pedestrian Compliance

• Pedestrian Walking Speed (4.7 ft/s 4.9 ft/s)

• Probability of Stopping: 17th and G 27th

and Cornhusker

• Speed Gain at Stopbar during Yellow Phase

• Change in Queue Discharge

Page 23: Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized Intersections Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil Engineering University of Nebraska-Lincoln

Queue Discharge: 27th and Cornhusker

Page 24: Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized Intersections Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil Engineering University of Nebraska-Lincoln

Performance Measures

• Pedestrian Compliance

• Pedestrian Walking Speed (4.7 ft/s 4.9 ft/s)

• Probability of Stopping: 17th and G 27th

and Cornhusker

• Speed Gain at Stopbar during Yellow Phase

• Change in Queue Discharge

Page 25: Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized Intersections Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil Engineering University of Nebraska-Lincoln

Survey: NASIS

• 2,032 responses collected

Page 26: Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized Intersections Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil Engineering University of Nebraska-Lincoln

Pedestrian Impact (2032)

Page 27: Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized Intersections Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil Engineering University of Nebraska-Lincoln

Driver Impact (2018)

Page 28: Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized Intersections Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil Engineering University of Nebraska-Lincoln

Conclusions

• The empirical evidence in this study support the use of PCT and have found no negative impact at the two sites.

• The impact of PCT on the two sites were different implying the interaction of site-specific parameter can influence the results.

Page 29: Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized Intersections Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil Engineering University of Nebraska-Lincoln
Page 30: Effect of Pedestrian Countdown Timer on Safety and Efficiency of Operations at Signalized Intersections Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Department of Civil Engineering University of Nebraska-Lincoln

Slide design © 2009, Mid-America Transportation Center. All rights reserved.

Dr. Anuj Sharma, Ph.D. Assistant Professor

Department of Civil EngineeringUniversity of Nebraska-Lincoln

CREDITS