Orkestra: Comparative Baseline study - Comparative Baseline study: preliminary results
EFA BASELINE DESIGNS LIGHTING STRATEGY - … BASELINE DESIGNS LIGHTING STRATEGY ... guides. In...
Transcript of EFA BASELINE DESIGNS LIGHTING STRATEGY - … BASELINE DESIGNS LIGHTING STRATEGY ... guides. In...
EF
And
a.b
A PSBP– Base
drew Bissell – L
bissell@cundall.
Con
B1.
T2.
© This repoconfidentialupon or useLLP. If any Cundall acc
line Designs on
Lighting Director
.com
ntents
Baseline De
The baseline
ort is the copl use of the Eed by any thithird party w
cepts no duty
n Lighting
r
sign – Dayl
e design so
pyright of CunEducation Fuird party with
whatsoever cy or respons
ight Strateg
lutions .......
ndall Johnstounding Agenchout the expromes into poibility (includ
gy ...............
..................
on & Partnercy and cannoress written aossession of ding in neglig
..................
..................
s LLP. It hasot be reproduauthorisationf this report, tence) to any
..................
..................
s been prepauced in whol of Cundall Jthey rely on iy such third p
..................
..................
ared for the sle or in part oJohnston & Pit at their owparty.
Page 2 o
..................
..................
sole and or relied Partners n risk and
of 9
.. 3
.. 6
EF
And
a.b
A PSBP– Base
drew Bissell – L
bissell@cundall.
1.
1 The cobuildingsLighting
line Designs on
Lighting Director
.com
Baseli
Good quality
was to ensu
Climate Bas
schools1
The PSBP O
previous bui
the learning
ambition wa
achieve a de
Daylight Mod
Using CBDM
intensity whi
daylight. Re
relative to us
For the PSB
and Daylight
UDI is define
range consid
UDI
need
pred
UDI
of g
UDI
light
oncept of CBs, the concepfor Learning
n Lighting
r
ne Des
y daylight wit
re sufficient
sed Dayligh
Output Speci
ilding progra
environmen
s to deliver a
egree of unif
delling (CBD
M in place of
ich allows th
eal weather d
ser needs.
BP Output Sp
t Autonomy (
ed as the an
dered “usefu
-a (x to y lux
ded for the m
dominantly d
-e (above y l
lare and the
-s (below x
ting.
DM has beept was also ig.
sign – D
thin the learn
levels of bala
t Modelling
fication has
mmes and s
t has been a
a certain perc
ormity. The B
DM) which tak
daylight fact
e building de
data are used
pecification tw
(DA).
nual occurre
l” by occupa
x) where elec
majority of the
aylit through
lux) where th
blinds would
lux) where th
n around forintroduced in
Daylig
ning environm
anced glare-
(CBDM) – a
a very differe
school design
a numerical p
centage of d
Baseline sch
kes account
tors provides
esign to be a
d to calculate
wo criteria ha
ence of illumi
ants – 100 to
ctric lighting i
e day. Achie
hout and glar
he amount of
d be closed.
he light woul
r a number on the Society
ht Stra
ment is esse
-free light to
a different a
ent approach
n guides. In
process base
iffuse light in
hools have be
of the quality
s far greater
adjusted to m
e lux levels a
ave been est
nances acro
2000 lux. Th
s acceptable
eving a high U
re is controlle
f light would
d be conside
f years and hy of Light and
ategy
ntial. The ai
all teaching s
pproach to
h to daylight
the past, des
ed on a static
nto the space
een designed
y and quanti
detail about
maximise the
and targets c
tablished, Us
oss the work-
his is subdivi
e and electric
UDI-a percen
ed.
be considere
ered insufficie
has been used Lighting (SL
im of the bas
spaces.
daylight des
design comp
signing for d
c overcast sk
e (daylight fa
d using Clim
ity of sunligh
light distribu
use of sunlig
can be set wh
seful Dayligh
-plane that is
ided:
c lighting wo
ntage signifie
ed excessive
ent without e
ed on other tLL), Lighting
Page 3 o
seline design
sign in
pared with
aylight within
ky. The
actors) and
mate Based
t and dayligh
tion and
ght and
hich are
ht Index (UDI
s within a
uldn’t be
es the space
e and a sourc
electric
types of Guide 5 –
of 9
ns
n
ht.
I)
e is
ce
EF
And
a.b
A PSBP– Base
drew Bissell – L
bissell@cundall.
Daylig
The reith
valueroom
DAgrap
infoaid uof th
rsy
secon
Samp
The secondat the ba
classrooincreased t
auton
line Designs on
Lighting Director
.com
The output s
and exam ar
DA is the am
plane. This
a minimum t
When under
and where k
that. Where
perimeter zo
The graphs
ht Analy
results can bher a single e to show the
m satisfies thA criteria or a ph which canbe more
ormative andunderstandinhe benefits o
the light redirecting ystems and ndary glazing
ple Clas
dary glazing ck of the om has he daylight
nomy.
n Lighting
r
specification
rea.
mount of time
criterion is a
target DA of
rtaking UDI a
known the fur
e it is known t
one in each r
below show
ysis Res
be
e e
n
g
of
g
sroom D
sets a minim
e a space ca
aimed at deliv
50% for eac
and DA analy
rniture layou
that desks o
room can be
the modellin
ults
Daylight
mum target o
an expect to r
vering an en
ch learning sp
ysis, the calc
ut. If a space
r working are
eliminated f
ng results obt
t Auton
At this the Dayapproa
min
of 80% UDI-a
reach a targe
ergy efficien
pace, sports
culation grids
e is flexible th
eas will not b
from the calc
tained for the
nomy Di
point in the rylight Autonoaching the taimum of 50%
a for each lea
et illuminance
t space. The
hall and exa
s must relate
hen the calcu
be directly ag
ulation area.
e baseline de
40
46
52
58
64
7
7
stributi
room my is
arget %.
arning space
e level on th
e output spe
am area.
e to the use o
ulation grid m
gainst walls t
.
esign classro
2
8
4
70
76
ion
76
70
64
58
52
46
40
A re
perimdistrito th
c
Page 4 o
e, sports hall
e working
cification set
of the space
must reflect
then a 500m
ooms.
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
‐
lightshelf is educing the meter DA anbuting the lighe back of thclassroom.
of 9
ts
m
nd ght e
EF
And
a.b
A PSBP– Base
drew Bissell – L
bissell@cundall.
1
Secondwill im
UDI 10reduc
<10
cladow
Usef
line Designs on
Lighting Director
.com
1620
81 79
3 1
2
Sa
dary glazing mprove the 0-2000 as it es the UDI
00 figure.
The sampssroom. E
wn the cent
ful Dayl
n Lighting
r
0 22
9 77
1
3
ample C
UDI <100
ple graph hEach line retre of the ro
3D gra
ight Ind
23
76
1
4
Classroo
[%]
here showsepresents oom from t
aph would p
dex
15
80
5
5 6
om Usef
UDI 100‐3000
The targ100-200for the
sp
s the resultthe resultsthe externaprovide fur
11 10
8689
3 1
7
ul Dayli
0 [%]
et is a UDI 00 of 80% learning
pace.
ts of a UDIs as if a lineal window rther detail
0 8
9 89
3
8
ght Inde
UDI >3000 [%
U
exeq
I analysis fe had beento the back..
6
85
9
9
ex
%]
UDI >2000 walways riseadjacent to
xternal glazinqually UDI <1
for a n drawn k wall. A
Page 5 o
2
76
22
10
will
ng, 100
of 9
EF
And
a.b
A PSBP– Base
drew Bissell – L
bissell@cundall.
2.
line Designs on
Lighting Director
.com
The ba
The aim of t
balanced an
below.
Sec
side
Prim
in th
Tall
ther
peri
The
dee
Ligh
high
A m
assu
Bec
day-
The
rest
The images
n Lighting
r
aseline
he baseline
nd visually co
ondary scho
es of the room
mary school
he Output Sp
window ope
re to be no st
meter and sm
floor to ceili
p Primary cla
ht shelves or
h levels of da
inimum of 30
umes no exte
ause CBDM
-lighting solu
lighting des
rict the distri
below show
e desig
designs was
omfortable da
ool teaching s
m.
classrooms
pecification.
enings ensure
tructural elem
mall profile w
ng heights re
assrooms an
r other light r
aylight adjace
0% external
ernal obstruc
takes into a
utions are pro
ign is co-ord
bution of day
w these featur
n solut
s to provide n
ay lit space.
spaces are ty
are 7.2m de
e light travels
ments protrud
window frame
elate to the d
nd 3.3m high
redirection sy
ent to the ext
glazing is pr
ction.
account the s
ovided for the
inated with o
ylight within t
res applied t
tions
not only suffic
Key feature
ypically 7.8m
ep; the dayli
s deep into t
ding below th
es are used.
depth of the s
in the 7.8m
ystems distri
ternal window
rovided to ac
sun and sky i
e different fa
other building
the space.
o the baselin
cient function
s of the day-
m deep with li
ght is adequ
he room. To
he structural
space to be d
deep second
bute light wit
ws.
hieve the CB
ntensity and
cades.
g elements a
ne designs.
nal light but a
-lighting desi
ight entering
uate and mee
o achieve this
slab along t
daylit. 3m h
dary teachin
thin the spac
BDM criteria.
the sun ang
and services
Page 6 o
also a well-
gn are given
g from two
ets the criteri
s requires
the building
igh in the 7.2
g spaces.
ce and contro
. This
gle, different
so as not to
of 9
n
a
2m
ol
EF
And
a.b
A PSBP– Base
drew Bissell – L
bissell@cundall.
Baseli
Façade Gl30% of the
wall wheexter
line Designs on
Lighting Director
.com
ne Primar
lazing is e internal ere no nal
Souglazinlight s
re
n Lighting
r
ry School
uth façade ng requires ashelf or light
edirecting
Internmust
as a
Design –
a
al reflectionsbe 70/50/20
a minimum.
Section th
pcor
Floor to ceheight is 3
where no exobstructions
s 0
hrough cla
Roof lights aplaced over trridor openinmaximise th
eiling 3.0m xternal s exist.
assrooms
Theglazinappro
7.2m d
are the
ngs to he
s
e external ng at 30% is opriate for a deep space.
The acbaffles ar
away frwindow o
Page 7 o
coustic e located rom the openings.
of 9
EF
And
a.b
Southgla
incorpolight sredire
into th
A PSBP– Base
drew Bissell – L
bissell@cundall.
Baseli
façade azing orates a shelf to ect light e room.
line Designs on
Lighting Director
.com
ne Second
Roof lprov
daylighthe largand prsecon
lighlearnspac
n Lighting
r
dary scho
lights vide ht into ge halls rovide ndary t to ning ces.
ool (superb
25% glarequirethe inte
walls to dsecond
daylight classro
space
Optransbalus
designligh
distribthe
flo
block) – s
azing ed on ernal deliver dary to the oom es.
pen / slucent strade n allows ht to bute to lower
oors.
section thr
Intereflecmus
70/50/2minim
rough dini
ernal ctions st be 20 as a mum.
ing hall
Floor to height isassumi
exterobstruc
exis
Page 8 o
ceiling s 3.3m ng no rnal ctions st.
of 9
EF
And
a.b
NortGlazinthe in
whereobstru
Thebaffles
awawindow
Interna25% owall fa
providelight int
The gopen
corridwide daylgro
Flooheiass
eobs
A PSBP– Base
drew Bissell – L
bissell@cundall.
Baseli
th Façade ng is 30% of nternal wall no external ctions exist.
e acoustic s are located y from the w openings.
al Glazing is f the internalaçade. This es secondaryto the space
ground floor ning in the dor is 1.2m to provide ight to the
ound floor
or to ceiling ght is 3m
suming no external structions.
line Designs on
Lighting Director
.com
ne Second
l
y .
n Lighting
r
dary schoool (finger r block) – ssection through teaaching spa
Page 9 o
aces
The firstopening
corridor iswide to daylight lower flo
Open / tranbalustradeallows ligh
lower flo
South faglazi
incorporateshelf to re
light into th
Roof lighplaced ov
corridor opto maximinternal d
Internal refmust be 7
as a min
of 9
t floor in the s 1.8m allow to the oors.
nslucent e design ht to the oors.
açade ng es a light edirect he room.
hts are ver the penings ise the aylight.
flections 70/50/20
imum.