EC6012 Tutorial 3

Peer Review

Turnitin

Peer review rules

ArranArran

BettyBetty

CillianCillian

11

1133

22

33

22

Turnitit.com

1111

3333

2222

Peer review rules

40% Data project / or market report:

30% your actual submitted project

10% your assessment to other students.

If you leave any identification in the softcopy on turnitin then you will not receive the 10%!!

Organisation (10%)

• Rate this paper's overall readability (From very readable to unreadable)• Were the basic sections (Introduction, Conclusion, Literature Cited, etc.)

adequate? If not, what is missing?• Does each paragraph of this paper logically progress from the former ones?

Why or why not? • Could the writer of this paper have omitted certain passages to make this

paper more concise? If yes, which ones?

Referencing (20%)

• Did the writer cite sources adequately and appropriately? Note any incorrect formatting.

• Were all the citations in the text listed in the Literature Cited section? Note any discrepancies.

Peer review rules: Side Panel

Peer review rules: Side Panel

Grammar/Style (20%)

• Were there any grammatical or spelling problems?• Could the readability, clarity, or style of this paper be improved? How? • Does this paper sustain a coherent point of view? Why or why not?

Content (50%)

• Did the data used make sense to you? Was it well explained? Did it contribute to the argument the writer was making?

• Do you feel this paper relies on evidence, or on opinion or intuition? If the latter, cite examples of where this paper relies on opinion and intuition and give suggestions as to how the writer can write more objectively.

• Does the logic of this paper's argument ever fall flat? Where? What might be done to correct this?

• Additional remarks - Organisation, Referencing, Style, & Content • Recommended grade? A1/A2/B1/B2/B3/C1/C2/C3/D1/D2/F

Turnitin

• Turnitin instructions11th March 2011– Submit softcopy to turnitin, no identification– Submit hardcopy to KBS, with cover page12th March (12:00 am) – 19th March (11:59 pm)3. Begin reviews4. 2 papers will be automatically assigned to you to

review5. Follow questions on the side panel26th March (12:00 am)6. Access reviews of your paper7. Final overall grade on stephenkinsella.net

Turnitin Instructions

• Where to go for guidance….

• Pdfs on Stephen’s website or available through Turnitin

– Student Guide– Chapter 3 PeerMark

Turnitin Instructions

• Example– How to create an account– How to submit a paper– How to conduct the peer review

Turnitin – Create an account

• How to create an account; – click Create Account on the Turnitin

homepage.

Turnitin – Create an account

• Under Create a New Account, click Student

• Introduce the class id and enrollment password, which are:– Class ID 3824938– Enrollment password EC6012

Turnitin – Create an account

• Now introduce your complete student email address;

IDnumber@studentmail.ul.ie

• Password

6-12 characters (at least 1 letter & 1 number)

N.B. write down password

Turnitin – Create an account

• Secret question

• Name and surname and confirm you are over 13 years of age

• Click “I agree…”

Turnitin – Submitting an assignment

• Log in using email address & password• Click on name of the class

– Assignment 1 'Country Project' – Click on the submit icon next to the assignment paper– Select file upload

• Browse and attach your report• Enter name & title for submission (Country Project)

– Click Submit– Go to portfolio

Turnitin - PeerMark

• Log in using email address & password

• Click on name of the class – Assignment 1 'Country Project' – Click on the “show details” icon on the

PeerMark row– Click on “start review” icon below the

PeerMark row– PeerMark will open

Turnitin - PeerMark

• Right side of the peer review screen;– Free response– Scale questions

• Submit

• N.B. 2 REVIEWS TO BE COMPLETED!!

Group Presentation

• Group submission to mary.carey@ul.ie

• By February 25th

• Size of group; minimum 3, maximum 4

• No submission of group?– Randomly assigned to a group