EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF...

28
EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF MULTIELEMENT APPARATUSES Norman M. Savage Geological Sciences, University of Oregon, Eugene, Oregon 97403, USA Michael J. Orchard Geological Survey of Canada, Vancouver, BC, V6B 5J3, Canada Apsorn Sardsud Department of Mineral Resources, Bangkok, Thailand 10400 Petra Lutat Palaeontological Research Centre, Mahasarakham University, Thailand 44150

Transcript of EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF...

Page 1: EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF MULTIELEMENT APPARATUSES Norman M. Savage Geological.

EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN

THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF

MULTIELEMENT APPARATUSES

Norman M. SavageGeological Sciences, University of Oregon, Eugene, Oregon 97403, USA

Michael J. OrchardGeological Survey of Canada, Vancouver, BC, V6B 5J3, Canada

Apsorn SardsudDepartment of Mineral Resources, Bangkok, Thailand 10400

Petra LutatPalaeontological Research Centre, Mahasarakham University, Thailand 44150

Page 2: EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF MULTIELEMENT APPARATUSES Norman M. Savage Geological.

Location of the Phrao field area in northwest Thailand

Page 3: EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF MULTIELEMENT APPARATUSES Norman M. Savage Geological.

Fossil locality west of Phrao, northwest Thailand

Page 4: EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF MULTIELEMENT APPARATUSES Norman M. Savage Geological.

Narong and Supatta in their garden

Page 5: EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF MULTIELEMENT APPARATUSES Norman M. Savage Geological.

Narong and Supatta’s very full garden with almost no remaining exposure

Page 6: EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF MULTIELEMENT APPARATUSES Norman M. Savage Geological.

Bed PR-48 at the Phrao locality

PR-48

Page 7: EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF MULTIELEMENT APPARATUSES Norman M. Savage Geological.

Beds 50, 51 and 52 at the Phrao locality

PR-50PR-51

PR-52

Page 8: EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF MULTIELEMENT APPARATUSES Norman M. Savage Geological.

Spec.

1a1a

1b

1c

2a

2b

2c

3a

3b

3c

4a

4b

4c

P1 elements from Bed PR-48, Phrao section, northwest Thailand.

a, lateral, b, aboral, c, oral views

Page 9: EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF MULTIELEMENT APPARATUSES Norman M. Savage Geological.

5a

5b

5c

6a

6b

6c

7a

7b

7c

8a

8b

8c

P1 elements from Bed PR-48, Phrao section, northwest Thailand

a, lateral, b, aboral, c, oral views

Page 10: EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF MULTIELEMENT APPARATUSES Norman M. Savage Geological.

9a

9b

9c

10a

10c

10b

11a

11b

11c

12a

12b

12c

P1 elements from Bed PR-48, Phrao section, northwest Thailand a, lateral, b, aboral, c, oral views

Page 11: EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF MULTIELEMENT APPARATUSES Norman M. Savage Geological.

Neospathodus sp. A. Bed PR-50, Phrao section, northwest Thailand, possible apparatus.

Page 12: EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF MULTIELEMENT APPARATUSES Norman M. Savage Geological.

Neospathodus sp. B. Bed PR-50, Phrao section, northwest Thailand, possible apparatus.

P1

P2

M

S1

S2S3

S4S0

Page 13: EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF MULTIELEMENT APPARATUSES Norman M. Savage Geological.

Fused cluster from Bed PR-51, upper and lower views.

Consisting of ?S3, S4, S1, plus an S2 and a P1.

Page 14: EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF MULTIELEMENT APPARATUSES Norman M. Savage Geological.

Representative P1 elements

Page 15: EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF MULTIELEMENT APPARATUSES Norman M. Savage Geological.

Bed PR-51. Neospathodus concavus

Page 16: EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF MULTIELEMENT APPARATUSES Norman M. Savage Geological.

Bed PR-51. Neospathodus aff. concavus

Page 17: EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF MULTIELEMENT APPARATUSES Norman M. Savage Geological.

Bed PR-51 Neospathodus chaohuensis

Page 18: EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF MULTIELEMENT APPARATUSES Norman M. Savage Geological.

Bed PR-51. Neospathodus ex gr. chii

Page 19: EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF MULTIELEMENT APPARATUSES Norman M. Savage Geological.

aaaaaaaaaa

A B

Neospathodus dieneri A, Morphotype 1, B, Morphotype 2

Page 20: EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF MULTIELEMENT APPARATUSES Norman M. Savage Geological.

A B

Bed PR-48. Hindeodus parvus A, Side view B, Oral view

Page 21: EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF MULTIELEMENT APPARATUSES Norman M. Savage Geological.

DMR Field Group: Chan, Dr. Apsorn Sardsud, New, and Oan

Page 22: EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF MULTIELEMENT APPARATUSES Norman M. Savage Geological.

ConclusionsPreliminary work suggests this Phrao locality comprises several horizons with important Dienerian apparatuses.

The key to understanding the evolution of multielement Lower Triassic conodonts lies in Dienerian collections.

The Neospathodus dieneri Sweet 1970 group were amongst the first species from Neogondolella ancestors in the early Induan and represent the major rootstock for many Olenekian conodonts.

The faunas include two morphotypes of N. dieneri, plus fewer specimens of N. chii, N. concavus, and ?N. chaohuensis, all recently described from Induan-Olenekian boundary beds at Chaohu, China (Zhao et al., in press).

The faunas also contain rare specimens of Neogondolella carinata and Hindeodus parvus, species that have been regarded as casualties of the end-Griesbachian extinction.

The abundant Thailand material adds to our understanding of the evolving apparatuses of the Early Triassic but at this preliminary stage in the work it is difficult to confidently differentiate the apparatuses.

Page 23: EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF MULTIELEMENT APPARATUSES Norman M. Savage Geological.

Thanks are extended to:

Narong and Supatta for allowing access to their garden and permitting us to collect rock samples,

and

The Geological Survey Division of the Thailand Department of Mineral Resources, Bangkok, and the Palaeontological Research Institute, Mahasarakham University for financial and logistic support,

and

the drivers, field assistants, and technicians.

Page 24: EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF MULTIELEMENT APPARATUSES Norman M. Savage Geological.
Page 25: EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF MULTIELEMENT APPARATUSES Norman M. Savage Geological.
Page 26: EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF MULTIELEMENT APPARATUSES Norman M. Savage Geological.
Page 27: EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF MULTIELEMENT APPARATUSES Norman M. Savage Geological.
Page 28: EARLY TRIASSIC (DIENERIAN) CONODONTS FROM NORTHERN THAILAND AND THEIR BEARING ON THE EVOLUTION OF MULTIELEMENT APPARATUSES Norman M. Savage Geological.