�042SuPREmE CouRT OF FLORIDA

FI'rzAoy ELLtS, E7AL,4pdind

vs. 5c 3 STgMzcHAEL CRE¼!s,Surchtry,kd bEPA KTMEtti O f COKRECTIOtVs, E7&L

Appelhefs

EAL FRoNi 7HE D.7s7~KICT Coux7F1xsrMs7xrcy L Eo^/ Lowvry EL o ipAT

Pko-SE �576N71st àRTEOF RPPELLANT ON TURLSD1L.TroN

i t-royA -%Ilà 6 6uf o9LrBE£1y Lottg£KrzosinL

ST170710%WDKK CA

||O fo // /\/.(Ah D&n1PSEY B¼ton Kb,

S Yo Ah/

PROVIDED BYLIBERTY C1

20 3

ORMAILING - - ----

~ïABLE OF �254_OWTEAI Ts 7%E kloTABLE of CouT6strs s'

'TABLE of ofnTious [ [

AR/.-lu»,6NT 2

BAst s fol :rnMolu r¼ ~Tu R.i s D iCTtoxi i

66MToN¥. MAPa/LAwa 89 5. C:7. 24>F/:, 3

buRFEE V. bu k E 845' $�042CT L//2. 3

F£D2RA L A Lt.. W&tvs Acrzg tJ.s. c, A 14r;

�254?FKE^L_Vr STKt Lk L ER '173 Sa ad 17.[ 97 1 s-MAK15]4065 V Ól4Ayc N2ss y342 l/$Sfo,72S Cf 5/z i

. EWgS V MbLso4 6(, Soej34 k(/9ti

l^26 V 7 Roi.t To T' lo o 5 S

Mnerm g. Gisso wE rré //S f5 D ß?/, î7/ 1987 5

touFEE PETirtolv Fog w£rr of Hnegas to Pus

Dracs V. was twiur,scr 3 ¤ $~ 5°¤d i

L.b WflYM�254MuT.L. ASSOC,V. N2LbeNoci i 2r

T2 .9.C T 234.

Ü(BY d ÜÑBY (,$'t $osÞ /K97 i X

Kos'EofowbV. LAM8sar 144,9 hb /t4 3

$01-/E/D&tLMAN V L(WirgÞ STATEs·}zoMS //1ir 43 $.CT /333

$ÝM7£µ¡g41 <o p�042TH£ 69s£ Ado fac7s fî, $'

$9MMA AV DF A&CvuNt&MTS

/4UÛOÑÔ. É . SE6SiOW44d(hnKN ób) S~S�254PTa_7,_J1?SCosicLus i on C,

£ATi ft Ca7£ o F TRw14fqLs/Ess 'lhiá·rùKE of Kscl�254f $0ucäir

TIFiCAT�254Df�041�254RViLÁ

A PP 5et..gn, app×. s

D l$oHLETilGAh0VKEfDLIVLOLT Of '99�570_�570ÞK2.Pü9. L-,A/c ie4-13y $EC for-¶ëoS rn7-13.11-t.,4, Arpx 3

Lok (MCOMsflJyf/ON_ÅѶîLt.�254/ $6 49 Afi3 40PK sq9 . n. Cw. R «utes 4.o 6) aò nbp>L 5

rà. A msh)3 & App>L 1,_s-r's yA Ss 5,.ogy A-PP 7

wesrs és.a m q».. so D up14¥rs _LSA 99¥ a

AFf/DAV/7

/ i /

9i O¡OI i3, s-; 12-· l

1 /513

APPEA L To THE SuMEME CouRT' of FLORzM1N'iNE SuPKEME C-ounT CF FY oKIbn

case Wo

SC 13-SM

/\/oA) FEE )°ET.zT30W GOK ¼!Rz7 0F HesEasC0KP45.G£FFKEN V· STRic k.LE R ^773Soa.ol 97�254977

&A5I.5 FOR TWVOK1Nå TuRLsDIcT1o^/Thi.s Coe-tet 1,«ve-- TuÃ�576shtc7towpa.rsand

o A r�570V S t S e-c. . ÚÛÚ> ..) 77/u- F7or/O-on8Ñ < ! a Ür v Orl>y (oSi Sozd /295

ks y, ta wcipt sos Son.d 1,

( Fir. 1974) ! tori air strtu fe. s.u.·79.o s;, S e e. a /s( L b wAYN E /VlüT. L . Í�570$50C..V. MC . 1)OWous

S·C7

UMN A R.y Of 198c.u IV4E N TP e fr«sc4s orAt ¤"÷ issu

uR15hrWro^t .ke%«cfh-c pd?hener wa_.sfried aufsendemd by

e ouz�570wifÉoÁ J^^Lris didion ctA vfo- ve idsudnti,

wo Lonets, 6ok k y ^Í'wc1sdu:liony-A ce r«4use.s

rn Acc±s s To C_ o Lnd dî�541m iss el for alad Qu."w dar'compo a cap Hbc ordez rølA 11

o vc /o a2e s 6 spedirely .he r"Sce"wa-s d rez a d ther was

a- p p a der �040¾

Did thx_ e i joncr y/on on'ÉÈ�254_/S£ue.- of

ARGUMENTTrà I CoezrfLacked -Tu_risd ion over

Pditione ri e«s es.

u d,--th;in g c 6), r 4didaed,o,. ièpr.,,A K

1 o p_rycessin< coNicer of the court.Tt,&g co¯p 544 ÀÏfo x ecise kis

pri vi ]cq<- * A*1 I pro±e ss è « tripune/ must be

calicef ando c ried by "Suc en ~T~ed,momy '¥¡lzd byTlw W1 adcrål custn essQs) bo th e- offer.se�254L

Tke c-Jy aoe_a n,«J + L>ear th« #ew/s or the

VÈØ o nz c'c l' er..s« s is h is (Ara b aA>Ìr dause th¾cla#î 6

a s e ete y 18 c/wÊs cLe.e -n o�570s coo r- o

Áf n eo �540rbie fida.À¼) u»ùÁd! w at orià Mdà -5

.Si3E ificde. re

r o. Á no . / meÅs S o ld bc astóe

açhi e p e so« + k,8y eradm nis4er i 7ts.

Lishd s o??icA <× p<rsy s¿LtLMor d o aÅm rú.sícr Ôaihs u.si n L ,,

Niu nel-aÃyùe,,Ätted pf '%,. berse l o Hiú4 s ert: 'iL_ users or

art 'J uf7e4 C/ce/c. */ _ot4rf-

ss. s C / k c4Cw9 Com missuners Assis6J

STA TEtrlENT OF THE <C AsE /tND l~Acrs( kWON'OL OG Y

n Apri l lR 20 /o appr«r«»a, ik �040knn #

7 4 ,¼_I Get d af 13r·cæ ard Coady, ffo riek

s Pdikon er /4ppdlæd wedfro- c<.JaJ e+ 'ro br6 l<... C' sr (ker«s .. Coads t¼ thenhoisk

k ,- - Tari.s'atüt-¿A coa'ds 14 7e r.es

ukd cl Irn d <ceaÃs 1-à rkn 6Releasa "om «// c auxf.s i-T a s e.,. a

la- sa to Fad W of Ceir È 4//e oCr Co)

s Bro a Coa-dy T is 4n i d

- , u o d provt4~ïLeiz / tize/

o o L.

Jh'.e»xa, edih~r/4brellaJ, <»L6 ßpr är be etpµaran«.. h|cL n 7'MoÀ �040L!LGrte

e.f Coad on PR&Bf '6·S �042ï7M2T&Ten.(y-is-vo)- 4Þ©X-, & °×nNAr*4ThLN-T^t rite fusr

ð< g rer . LQan bl÷t,1¼e- '7" ~T r ad wu+aq'ir«d +o prove As -ihetsdéhó - o waukt

·As'N'½ e- 1/·74Ácdd /Co S T

.5exeisdähon onee_ e_/ ile>$·<da ss a m.rd, a_-4 m e.isH,-r d«cid-d, 7he 'Warde- s /«r/

I l'k prov÷~3aris dù£o£ Ger Rose eno d

V La hed 4C#9 Fad Mil·.LL s ad c erf.>|> e 4-, coads �042>.-C

Worr- ndd±d Tads o i ndthw pedrys('mar-froom e.»kdx Proe F sd Jarts dà+on <.-azu

demand«d brusk«d æsib c l ryd <µ¡fA

C,rs-J Tkx·Ál l'A! Tk+ F~rs f D-ey r«<. odt94. C_oads a-c. rs moa bk operely

(.» rsaned-to U.£.& Armd 5. S 6-donbdre

wue ? -·

lo r o e é i Car u

I n Ano Tc Bro a oC C F o rîti

Dt <lee v. b 14 5 C r 11/2 A C A n

a d make vord (>r--ce aliny vale T

is cl< <· a_A c .e/l cht,1ùJ | w �040kJ e o

Lorel cr e æn b«. cka(Íeyed y Loccr

()l_ b MAYNE I luT. L - A ssV C_. \/ M C. bo^t o uGx, S . C_T. 1%.

A ddôWnrLe>g N l e s C o rpu s 7-n a casdas

rern u/L uaà creA o s5 c4erysf /s »d e-o¼e

w±ter t¼ L a / SL�040e97 fL o VEcE

PoS 5 E SSioN).Se L wis_V. Netsagga ysj,LP�041&_lÑ~II,e F ru

the-syproper-h etexrty d Advun asses i

Wittat Cefev ¤F Tdl<- i s a a

law f4 prçc e s «Jowed e F/w d

tws and rs wd/ks / s4 1 <LinÜ e NpI!

14/ifL 4c�042rof ? sid n T -Sche dezma-m / o J/ows /4yp,he t i d

yeded n_qids ella<_tn t vo a-nol n ncrÄy yaa

, or AsLvern fossession71Dn L Å r 8 �040)'>cS t (Lr

e_n_// 4 u_pom c_learpe vec-_l:Janyoo-F, F~ etherenaec N7crtin 6 ßissene f «. //8Fs

doe-.s a 9/y te Sta_-fe prise ner,s .

of // b s . �042A+f-rx s-fr k e r r

cd 975 971 /w/___£¿«y__dód sud -uda)ENfÀ OF ACCEss -Tò GOURT¯ a U e 1

Pe.¼i�040Á> >rdesfi e on¯vic_�040n or s

Ax on e Olsofhe_ N// CONG.

E 55 /O /8 (dr e_d. Se_jd .Ti im)s4desPc , s A is eA4/ists /«w,

wu e_,,akot &J4 ndnyly to /L.1««s procea, s

Tk Pris on d 5-id u e-n--chd do dùcour

Jil4 - r to 1 Ja«1s As t>«Job t° pr- N

. S 7· 085

og fen.. Nc ly confen 'Tu s d L a ,b ad 4 we Ce rchioks �042--4/7 Tudûá/

re al Bro« a ' ('au.cly flor,da_ w/w fåey/wd

k coy -na~_ us.n.. ++ L unaA>rn,

C n e + c 6 47 F->~, «A u scax,Pi d- Far L Ca< A R«k bo Hu o

I /0 Ti c E. Son e.. er+//pÂs of p-.n s-·7 r e du..e_4t> /oss of

w d»ûss +& F/-àr Caud o+>,p on er ghor i d

N h þ<~J4k-«.., w.«« 4-r*k stxyd s

5

Pehitione_e 6s 1kd 3kos diLhom c64 c AL//c y on, On d /,y%

7 <-is dúbbn e eé be æssamzd 2en,..c4

pc e-r, e-x vo id Tud_qm<nt ¿Á on<... uttu! k uJ s o -npfede ya_/lity,

ns t t e.s Tudà<h be. The fdriben e.

Wrouyn % a r·e.zaphre±d rz>m mun

h Lo.ss µea>.rk ad/cc s«A nr

F' forrà Ça r mc Cou_rt. Any o miss.ie n ar-

dddio is avat ajü/fu_/ -fk._ þ s pr«s.edr% wou_id þç �040ke_ s r«g«cd less ,

È E(Z·1*/ F/ CA 7'E Of ?XuTHFulMEsseÅ�040ione-r ch-<_la_ces a der Annay a,e år

Þte_ k±s reA thr.s rios FsE Pd7/7/oM F'm

W rr or l¼BEAs Co&Pu2 U f1wt thc /ads ar

A c-o cd cc-ordance._ u.ii/A F

1793 (no«Ü n¼e 454 . 5cdrán4 , Lhswon 1)e r Ata'ns t-L«der fz«L

ry-

JVATugE Of RE¿pEg Soya yrs sMfù h act law 4 qßa.ppza_,-s to

e 4 o nþd±J ~1 råolL¼n thnj a is

e fly reste al of his liberk # asr p i y cof -the_ Cou_rt

n 11Ý1 s 4 tisca_ s .

prepn 4 ed es «_s ahlt d

EKTIFIC ATE OF SERVICE.L eedi+y triJ «+ræc -d c»m+ »py y

-�040f,e_-fore_oikey u)æs sod by ll_S.7rt.ü/h·.

/-)d A -G Bond¡_ 2hde M+erny Gen 2,

~7'/u. Cc<½'del '77//dLss F'/(32399.

~ï¯:e-Mke Puker C J Caus&

D.cp etmeÄ e4' �254_o�041ree-}s È®t So |k CÉlko S

~T¯ e-c c't_ . 5.239

&h41 ner

Fi cogEllrì Ñ-t> Se, Dc46259o

EXcc-ahA ath Bris I Lib r$ÿ CoaJry, f~/e

4/rt/ 23, 2_o/3.

* Sidt M C'for,k z =f .4 afCorrec e

Libthy o l 7n om //obò 4/·a.+Âg s N L p K:L i g

ects6 usar

APPL41 D K EG

A FæNb1x iE (_E R PTS F'R o en -7-siE #4){A

b E F1N1 T10 h/S

1%ll.S SE criON 342 (6} be4 hänsf..(htKeÅerm "cúsl CLtÅon utdk resp.ed depri.sen

op d iWon s rn eans cLoy ti li.at rv e-«dî 4 ctriunder feder / Jaw wi1L resped Kn_ tondehk s

n¼med ¤<Mv·EGhds af «cfrasa by.ogwwe_d· a#iètÅÁs n Nip ¿�570�254A VÊ �040·ers�042ons

ad¼eA_ tò pn'so n bd does n o/róclude habeas

Loepas proceedinpjk«lleny,÷y the Ac«d toe

cherrhon of c_onfîhx_mud in prison;

(3) % L fedpóse ner mears a~y perm su¾Já

to LarcerrÍión d·eÁeÁton eradmission Ét> An

fw/,G æl s ceas.a ß c_onvid<.4 o-r s teremex; or ad 4,¼dd deli a_ed for; viá/à,o s of

Leii>,,h ! tax oc·-ftiebms adcondihor eo

parcic prol>dron, pr.dn«'l r:chrs.e, or

hers y prcy±~, ;[~Je-rr prison" meæ~s æ~y fã&JÁtd e

loca ï lik /Ad uharcerdc.s or ald«�041ms

les é ce4r lds æccuszd cQ-nväha o

srd d bç oraA'j d d ed-f

viot of cen», I t

A PPEN DJ X .2 3FEbERA L. STA¯TU7Ê5

EDERA L PAIS ON L.17L C, A -rron REFoKM Ac¯T

U6. L . ÍYO /O(d'~/34 6 EL%D/-ßtO //O TA T.

/3a/ --¼6.

�042

/0

A PPENM× 4'�042 FLom a Cortsn Tti 77o

FL OR1D R CONSTInLTro^/ AR TI c. LE SEc riod/3.

....s_................,...... ....-. . . ..s _ s . .. . . .. ___ ... _ ..,_ __ __,. . ,. , ..., .. ,_.. ., _ s..s _....... ,._ _ . ._,_. ____ . ,,,,,_ _ _ . _, ..,,. . . _,,,,.. ,, _ .._,,. _ . , ,_, , _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _

_........__. .,., .s . ., ....... , .....,, ..._ ...., ,s. . ..m .. _.. ,,s. . _.....,__. ..._ .. .. . . __ _. . ._, ,.. _ . .. ... .,_... . , _ . .. . ,_,_,_ . _ ... . .._ _. _ _ . . _ . _ _ _ __ ... _ _ __

........_........ . ..........,s, m._..........,. ,s..._s _ . _._._ .. _ ,, ___ _ .._, ,,.,_.,..,.... . s , .. .. ,,... ..__..,._.... . _ . _ . _ __,._ . _ .,. _, _ ,.,_,, __ __, _ .. _ _ _ __ _ _

. ,s.,,_,. ,. ............ ,._.......,. . __ .. .. ___ _ _ . .. ._. _ .. .._. ,_ . ___ m. . ,, , . ,. .. _ . . _,_ _.. _ _ . .. _ _ , _ _ _ , _ ,,_,, _ _ . ,,, , _ _ _

s . .. . . _ ,.., , ..,-... ,. , , . . . . , . . . . _. . . . . . . _ . .. _ ._ . . ,.... , . ,, . . __ . _ .. _ __ __ . __ _ __ . . ,_

.......... ..,,s.,m.,..._m._. s .. . ....... . _ _. _ _ ___ ,_,. . . . ,_........_... _,. . .., . _ . ..__ __.___ _ _ _ . _ _,.. , . ,_ __

AffE^/ D!l E 3

&o. &. C w. P ÑuL E Éso(8%6.)U .$. C· A�042A WI�254^I.D5

APPE N'D]ïEs 7 Z,

W Gs'T'S Ks. A. G E c-, 57· c 15

w&s T'S f.s. A. $6c 99 .05

yJEs~Ps R$ A.. $�254C.93·50G)

12

APPENDix to

ESTS K5. A. 5EC T¥(d' A 1

/2-

Preu<> w'A -g >nWotKupsi

AFflòAVITJURAT

STATE of F¯LORIDACouNTY OF LIBERTY

S' £4)ôw 7'o A tvo Su8s c A t 6Eo baor« n,ron 16 i's by_Fi±�523gf_V/Su> ko d,bl p ro chae»1 E--made- .T£c-dîtådán

-rdlechrhy -CD -rücmber (o 2s 909 æs ge-oep

den ;LC.fåecfron. $e.e_ Sec. 9.2�042So(Ò Fla. S .

Plæu~tJf rise dalece itJ /ke bAs --

e wA ca--ced ud is d.n.e_ ye oet

+a. A ca sJ«y, -ws

. Rs

ec+r+1o

/3

Tn 77a_ cùaut Cnud e ,L.... rPC-r

d_g, -z~,., 4.A f 8 ,.. e,,,,q p6 a ef., F~-4 , p.bah, Ca..u_-4 to-3sysa:·ton, 4/

.hù !°'4/13cføoA /©-yf42.cssoA/ ©.·6:ss7cr toa,' !©-C.2s-scr ton '

è+z.,- ert,:s, e.+aL '' ''"·"'_.'°®po~ó.~+- N°~7u&- bgf-»1 /--�042<7r)J übed ©rdo--T~w-~ped:<-:~1 2kg«s·d

o ~Í| bd.AA._ .¿.x_mA1e.41.. / .LO/2., ~lä 6« U..r..y aA

a»A VoK Mads a...u..nu 7 tra;. gaa.be TliayA a.«A ud.

4.w,,~J +kce,,,e A bg.Cims .us yrs.crsr.y

I. 'LUhe<.æ, aA«dûy.å £4-£ a×4ar u..> a...n

Gder te wL.r.,. 2kgm.,.za.«.½ b> Liba±y &v.-Jî�042~£

<dio~ tiosy 4.u). bampss-y

64, FL . 3232/, ,,.'.a x..,./ Bo ud«.. ,..,._

. e /«..aùaAy. Sa.a.. S-. µ v.Dá5Øfad44ytn2 . f64 7. s a.ùL LA.edy Cav.u_-fio~A

.t. Oh , sL....«..L<. a.....uptue_ ¼

..uu% u- a_- / .4.e.. ác~:. 5.e. ..p u- eaa++a~g_-.._)a+ . . os7- 4.:2. ½4_ <7._ r s-1

3. 'Tju-. D... J o 7 -. 21uà eg Cau-,-d~sG« d ø . C - .«_+ fa, .

It wù'L b . d«±y y a.kr. C e - c 2aJ

Cmhs - s o .. .

. er fiùL p ... n -r o a d -r-wh . . n

b 4 y . os,_-39s Du_31 ¡qs-,.77u b i etJe.r . +1 e

�040to#ionD.e_c_] O 'Tha«a po

/~o dowd, D d) 1©/% o e I//xgdA.,4 Vouc . 411a ch usq f 7 0 . ...a

Abs.e 2'46 L a AVo<L. pay.c 2..

."r+.

p. Mty. c . oss-tss1957.

4. (4~l Edite w a .a

lu.. a_e.z: ou e d is

-4, e, s

f._ojuz.e.<.. - a-+ur e3 -a (..e.uns>f Co.m m . Op Att<q Ôe_n .

os,- ass- u u ins-,.

5. A-nd (4%ewt» o<st h.wt..»;..y 5.a. u . d -r..

... a. 4 a exy <>g L 21<Msio

n..d u /aw/A ts(,.x. 6 L sa

. s o- o-n_Önkn e

Lb2.o d a n /nu.~..b á> Cude -

ek a.«d t _-nu-Ju.u a

d --«d 3.ul 4. ,L �042

e.a a.£L Dw( sa ow

7L«1A 4.«A ¼¿¿ do.... -»<.nd I h<..

dL aftea½d:s to é o. .e c/ +4io

o T-pad hep... .7o Coud u 3 u..19 2ctr -To &_ rt/

L veu all a-ds 4 tr�042-Ifl - x_r«£VoLL. s

wu .. b oL A r..uaa44 fu 3

ru -s qu, cjtwh, to ft a o .

. o éy «.«-c ntya d -6 p p«h s4dk h ha

o e4 4 w2µ og ar..«.d 44,4o ö e . r +sg 4zws.

x.u o u wär bz. Qwk'ul

J o 6 e LawAw<p aAouaAy,

o A p hkup*d

. e- -d-<-w es _ b. .

. T dfaui , - ß «

u e.. .. a .b 1

o a <u a

a e p .. n dødt ouJ ou . owej.y s.Jda p«x. ! S

LO shax v. K64 shtu 99s.crs4; s,s-

unzuâ ^ owr

-ra cá, a5ZL~u înea~< v.at . an as

'rLlo7& a.~¶ VoûtP r

p_fä¢ 6a«.,Lt

u 5 v 5+& 4p.i Dù+. n45 o 4 it35 (aco é ) u»La -.t..,_ udd K d A .e

bp oc b A 6 er.ux, o

sî - L, - au

1 a s .,

î s

® TI . a. a z

e_Le

G) NL 77u_ ~~ d

t· 7tus au a

.- d s o . L . e.

7rt. 6 o 7 au.

s- ru. - FaA C .u y .d oc ,

e ...«d AA pur44 k6 7 ou

Chau T pad y h. . da 7 6ud

b r o 7 rt

o A e és & Ou -

z . v

ou'44 5Ác -52s- QLoco') a--.

u.s . c_. 1-144, LL+csu 1kJ

P ty »g e,1¿

/fc..o- 5.4._ 2) L %:L3 tov

ER7tf/CATE O SEKvicE

E N +m a..«d co^^-<-d

C k 8 .oeux Cs< .A'y CowdM~.w..2»t & E.( 5 a d-b, FL 3530/.

e- A 6t.au wL ØeadÄm

or sé. s*s+ r L , fr.ssaci.

I . .I

K 6u'stoA- Luhuty �042¯¶F k, $-Åù lo day og 7KasA, z.o /L

e 6f.otL ola_ a.dt,<.a...d- doutatim

LJuty P_.a.a.m.<..bM --~ gc4&i¿~ //o @ N u3 .

Duußs.a -.36 L, 6to..elo( FL 3 2

E CIR OFFICE OF THE . �042

CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURTSECOND JUDICIAL CIRCUIT �042LIBERTY COUNTY

KATHLEEN E. BROWN

ClÈay 10, 2013

Florida Supreme Court Clerk's Office

500 South Duval St.

Tallahassee, FL 32399

Please find the attached document which was received in our office on May 9, 2013. It is styled

with the Supreme Court heading and case number and was evidentially meant to be filed in your

court. I am therefore forwarding this document to you and will instruct the defendant to

address further filings to your court.

Sincerely,

Vanell B Summers

Deputy Clerk

Liberty County Clerk of Court

Cc: Fitzroy A Ellis #623904

Liberty Correctional Institution

Work Camp

11064 NW Dempsey Barron Rd.

Bristol, FL 32321

10818 NW SR 20 �042REPLY TO: P.O. BOX 399�042BRISTOL, FLORIDA 32321(850) 643-2215 �042FAX (850) 643-2866