E-mail Marketing: Beating The Deliverability Crisis Brian S. Klais VP eBusiness Netconcepts Sunday,...
-
Upload
sybil-shelton -
Category
Documents
-
view
214 -
download
0
Transcript of E-mail Marketing: Beating The Deliverability Crisis Brian S. Klais VP eBusiness Netconcepts Sunday,...
E-mail Marketing:
Beating The Deliverability Crisis
Brian S. Klais
VP eBusiness
Netconcepts
Sunday, October 17, 2004
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
State of the Inbox
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
Agenda
• State of the Industry– Spam thresholds
• Optimizing Deliverability– Network reputation
– Filter-friendly design
– Deployment timing
• Name that SPAM game
• The Road Ahead– Sender authentication
– RSS
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
Email Marketing Benefits
• Critical mass– Reaches 93% of internet users
• Response rates– 10x greater than direct mail
• Lower costs– 1/10 the cost per communication
• Still effective and targeted retention vehicle
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
The Resulting Deluge
• 76% of global email is spam (MessageLabs, 2004)
• 90% of all US email is spam• 12 billion per day 2005 (IDC)• Average consumer received 3,920 unwanted
emails in 2003 (Jupiter)• Spam has made 52% of consumers less
trusting of email (Pew)• Most marketers plan to increase in 2005!
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
Legislating & Regulating
• CANSPAM took effect January 1, 2004– Places burden on recipients to opt out
– Allows you to send unsolicited emails if you:• Provide valid postal address• Clearly indicate advertisement in subject line • Provide functional opt out mechanism
– Fines $200 per email, up to $2MM per incident
– Remove un-subscribers immediately from master list
• EU opt-in legislation
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
CAN-ning SPAM?
• 56% of spam originates in US (Commtouch)
• Forecast >95% of all email is spam in 2006
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
Filtered But Not Pure
• 20% of legitimate emails are being blocked as spam (Return Path, 2004)
• 38% of consumers report wanted emails being blocked by filters (RoperASW, 2003)
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
The New Face of Email Marketing
• The consumer is deluged and jaded– Reach and attention is made more difficult
– Relevancy and trustworthiness more important
• The medium is much more complex – Deliverability is uncertain
– Format control is lost
– Regulation increases filtration risks
• How to optimize reach and effectiveness?
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
The Email Funnel
Deliverability Blacklists, Whitelists, Filters
Open-abilitySubject, From, Frequency
Readability Design, Content,
Organization
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
Network Blacklisting• Either your vendor or your own network • Major symptoms
– Bounce rates > 10%– Open rates < 30%
• Blacklist monitoring– SpamCop, SpamHaus, MAPS, etc.– Check multiple blacklists simultaneously: SenderBase.org
• Halls of Shame– NANAS (news.admin.net-abuse.sightings Usenet newsgroup)
• http://groups.google.com/groups?q=yourname+group:news.admin.net-abuse.sightings
• Clean network gets more emails through– May cost more, but likely worth it
• Guilt by association
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
Maps
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
maps
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
spamcop
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
spamhaus
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
senderbase
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
White listing
• Ask customers to add you to their white list:– AOL 9.0, Yahoo and Hotmail filter unknown emails to
junk folders, but let known senders in.– On your site and in emails (for forwards)– Email address or domain name - choose carefully!
• Earn white-list status with ISPs– Manage directly if deploying email in-house– Only outsource to a vendors white listed with AOL,
Yahoo, MSN, Hotmail
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
Request white-listing
BEFORE sending the
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
Achieving AOL Whitelist Status
• AOL Criteria– Submit IP for monitoring– Setup feedback looks to monitor spam complaints – Dynamically blocks if 10% bounce
• Remove repeat bounces immediately and automatically
– Or if 1/10 of 1% complain• Can suspend white list status
• You receive the complaint but NOT the complainer
– Embed tracking codes to simplify auto removal
• http://postmaster.info.aol.com– AOL policies, guidelines and bounce thresholds
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
Yahoo Whitelist Status
• Yahoo Process– Thresholds not as clearly defined as AOL
– Must complete application process• Describe list source/ownership• Describe permission verification• Bounce/unsubscribe handling policies
– IP activity is monitored for 3-5 weeks
• Contact: [email protected]
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
Other Forms of Whitelisting
• 3rd party white listing services– Bonded Sender: Post a financial bond. Every spam
complaint costs you $$
• Throttle your sending– Hashcash: CPU-intensive to calculate a single-use,
recipient-specific “postage stamp”. 2 emails per second
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
Spam Filters
• Lots of spam filters & email firewalls– SpamAssassin
– MailWasher
– Yahoo! SpamGuard
– BrightMail
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
SpamAssassin
• One of the most popular spam filters for ISPs
• Open source
• Predicts whether a message is spam using:– Scoring content based filters (rules-based)
– Bayesian filtering (adaptive message content analysis)
– Sender Policy Framework (for sender authentication)
– Hashcash (for proof of message intent)
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
Bayesian Filtering
• Analyzes your legit email and your spam (e.g. that you’ve already separated) to calculate the probability of various characteristics appearing in spam vs. in legit email
• Learns to differentiate spam from legit email
• Gets better over time
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
• Best rates OUCH! “Negotiate The Best Rates on
Local Advertising Media”
Got High Bounce Rates?
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
Test Deliverability
• Seed list with 100 – 200 hotmail & yahoo addresses. Check for delivery on each of those accounts.
• Check your ‘spam score’ before sending– Free version available at:
www.gravitymail.com/spamscore.php
– Aim for < 5 SpamAssassin points
– Note: This tool is only indicative. Not everyone’s using SpamAssassin to filter spam. Other filters will interpret your campaign differently.
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
Name that SPAM!
• The Prize:– A Crunchie bar… from New Zealand!
• The Rules:– Point out things in the email campaign that caused it to
be unceremoniously junked by SpamAssassin
– Must be something that’s displayed on the slide
– The thing must be worth at least 0.4 points
– Be the first one to find it, then raise your hand (no yelling out before I call on you!)
– One bar per person
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected] things
Work from Home
6.2 / 5.0
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
4 things
Link: mailto:[email protected]?subject=REMOVE
7.4 / 5.0
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected] things
5.8 / 5.0
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
5.2 / 5.0
1 thing
MS Internet Explorer adds this tag when
you “Save As”
(Peeking under the hood at the HTML of this campaign…)
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
5.0 / 5.0
2 things
A thick HTML table
border
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
http://66.38.189.161/maestro/link/1497084910/2/17517/13123909/2/167362/1/1377/1382/lnk.htm?lc2
3 things
5.2 / 5.0
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
9.0 / 5.02 things
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
6.4 / 5.0
1 thing
base-64 encoding
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
Best Practices
• Custom content
• Timing matters
• From line
• To line
• Subject line
• Other headers
• Body copy
• HTML code
• Words to avoid
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
Customizing Content
• Generic = greater blockage
• Custom = greater penetration
• Integrate email and website into one channel– Website should personalize around email click history
– Email offers personalized around purchase/click history• HP email offers enhancements to desktop you
purchased• Click-through increased 32%; email sales increased 30%
– Abandoned-cart reminder emails• Petco reminder emails with cross sell promotions• 850% click-thru rate; Conversion 171%
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
Early Birds Get Through
• Early week (Mon – Tues) and early morning (2 am – 6 am) yield better deliverability
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
Optimizing Your Envelope• In the “from” line:
– Include a real name, not just an e-mail address– Include lower-case characters– Don't end it with a number
• In the “to” line:– Make sure the recipient's e-mail address is listed– Never use “CC” or “BCC”
• In the “subject” line, do not:– include the recipient's e-mail user name– include “Now Only” or “Hello” or “Free” or “Buy” – use all caps. (Retailers are notorious for this) – pad it with extra “gappy” white space — anywhere– include a unique ID or exclamation marks
• If it's a regularly scheduled newsletter, include the date or month of the issue (e.g. Oct 2004) and “newsletter,” “news,” or frequency (“daily,” “monthly”)
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
The Envelope (cont’d)
• Regarding attachments:– no attachments!
• The spam filter or firewall may consider your e-mail personal communication with:– An “In Reply To” line in the e-mail header– A long signature in the message body– An attribution in the message body (e.g. “On Tues Jan 1,
2003 John Smith wrote:”)– “Quoted” e-mail text (e.g. with a “>” in front of certain lines)
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
Copy Practices to Avoid
• Greeting recipient with a “Dear” salutation • Claiming that:
– the recipient was on a list– the recipient registered at your site – your message is not spam– you obtained the recipient's address legitimately – the recipient gave you permission or opted in– the recipient was registered with one of your marketing partners– you respect all removal requests– you comply with various regulations/House bills/Senate bills
• Explaining why the recipient is receiving your offer • Suggesting the recipient might have received the e-mail by mistake. • Using “click here” links• Linking “remove me” to an e-mail address• Linking your opt-out to a page that contains the word “remove” in the URL• Including “spammy” words and phrases
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
Spammy Words to Avoid
100% * amazing * best rates * big savings * breakthrough * call now * checks * completely free * consolidate (bills) * coupons * credit card * discounts * for free * forward to a
friend * free consultation / free access * freedom * full refund * great offer * guarantee / guaranteed * income * increase * incredible * Investment * limited-time only * marketing solutions * mobile phones * money back * money order * no cost * now only * one-time mailing *
opportunity * opt in * please forward * quote (no obligation) * refund * remove / removed / removal * risk free
satisfaction * save up to * special promotion * this is not spam * urgent * win * your own * etc etc etc
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
HTML Best Practices• Don't use Frontpage to create the message HTML• Make sure the title tag doesn't contain the word “Untitled”• Don't use thick table borders• Don't include a form that sends an e-mail (a “mailto form”) • Don't define the content type as “TEXT/HTML” in all caps• Don't have a low ratio of text to image area. Especially don't have image-only
e-mails – the #1 tactic spammers use to bypass filters• Pay careful attention to the percentage of HTML contained in the message.
The assumption is that HTML = spam• Never use scripts of any kind (Javascripts etc.)• Don't include any Javascript statements that open new windows• Avoid incorporating tracking ID numbers as much as possible• Do specify a character set• Use a white background, not a colored background• Do not use “invisible” text• Avoid red or blue textual colors — spammers' colors of choice• Don’t disguise key words, like spacing out the letters or placing punctuation in
odd places in the words
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
Designed Filter Friendly
• Case study makeovers– Redesigned the look-and-feel, layout
– Lowered file size
– Lowered spam score
• A Wisconsin industry association
• A New Zealand bank
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
Case Study:Wisconsin Manuf. Association
• Poor usability
• Broken hyperlinks or image links
• Graphic/design appears amateur
• Poor font selections
• Difficult to read
• Horizontal scrolling
• HTML breaks in Lotus notes
• Text vs HTML
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
Clicker increase:
37%
Size decrease:
50%
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
Case Study:New Zealand Bank
• Poor use of screen real estate– Too much white space
– Too much administrivia above the main content
– Main content “below the fold”
• Horizontal scrolling
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
Size decrease:
50%
Unique opens
increase: 200%
Spam score: 0
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
New Vendor RequirementsWEIGHT CRITERION SCORE
0-10 Few complaints in news.admin.net-abuse.sightings
0-10 Not on any blacklists according to SenderBase.org
0-10 Customization and personalization abilities
0-15 Whitelisted by ISPs – eg Yahoo AOL MSN
0-15 On MarketingSherpa's top 50 email vendors list
0-20 Bounce handling & master suppression compliance
0-20 Bounce and open rates beat the average
0-25 Ability to design filter-friendly layouts and content
0-25 Built-in predictive spam analyzer
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
Looking Ahead
• Other forms of filters• Closing the spam loop• Writing for machines• RSS feeds
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
Other Forms of Filters• Disposable emails
– Mailinator• Make up email address on the spot. Retrieve via web. No password required.
Deleted after 3 hrs.• The first message will probably get to the intended recipient, but probably not
subsequent ones.
– Yahoo! AddressGuard• 500 free disposable addresses per yahoo.com email account• Used to obfuscate your real yahoo.com email address and to see if you are
sharing addresses w/ 3rd parties
• Challenge-response– Major barrier to bulk permission emailers– Unrecognized senders have to answer an autoresponder
before mail gets delivered• MailBlocks (just bought by AOL)• SpamArrest
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
Closing the Spam Loop
• Verification solutions provide missing link– DomainKeys and Sender Policy Framework– Addresses SMTP “spoofing” vulnerability – Mail server can authenticate domain– Eliminate spammer anonymity– Enable law enforcement– Being submitted to Internet standards committees
and backed by AOL, Yahoo, MSN, etc– AOL is near requiring SPF to remain whitelisted
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
Writing for “Machines”
• When email copy will be published on the web (e.g. archive of e-newsletters), write it for search engines too
• When web page copy will be repurposed for email campaigns (e.g. online catalog copy for promotional emails), write for spam filters too
• Google factor: desktop/inbox search – new campaign life• Writing for Search Engines encompasses:
– Keyword research– Making pages “sing” for particular keyword themes– Keyword-rich title tags, H1 tags, hyperlink text– Keywords placed high up in the HTML– Penalties for search engine spamming
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
RSS Feeds
• Really Simple Syndication– Syndicate to someone’s PC or to someone’s website– Late-breaking news/articles/blog posts in an XML file at a
web URL
• May turn email marketing on its head• Spammers can’t infiltrate peoples’ RSS readers• RSS readers
– Standalone software (e.g. FeedReader)– Web-based ASP (e.g. My.Yahoo.com)– Integrated into your web browser (e.g. Sage plug-in for
Firefox)– Integrated into your email client (e.g. NewsGator for
Outlook)
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
An RSS feed - Looks a lot like HTML, doesn’t it?
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
RSS
• Are you ready for RSS? Start today!
• Make RSS feeds out of your…– E-newsletter
– New arrivals
– Best sellers
– Close-outs
– Sale items
– Special offers, discounts, coupons
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
Beating the Game
• Spam and blacklist/filter reliance is increasing
• Opportunities still exist for email marketing – More relationship development then selling
• Optimize your deliverability:– Properly time deployment
– Test and adapt to filter algorithms
– Secure network reputation (blacklist/whitelist)
• Prepare for change– Experiment with RSS as a hedge
– Apply SEO to email campaigns
6400 Gisholt Drive, Suite 203 Madison WI 53713 608-285-6600 [email protected]
Questions?
For a copy of this presentation
request on back of your card
or email [email protected]
or call (608) 285-6600
netconcepts: integrated web design and e-marketing
specialists in natural search engine optimization &
e-mail marketing for 400 clients around the globe